ት Tergwame Greek · Coptic · Ethiopic · Syriac · Armenian · Georgian · Latin

Latin · Letters ·

Epistolae Et Decreta

SS Gelasius I · ogl-pl

BothSourceEnglish
JSON Dossier
machine-draft · no human review 284 passages · 70,500 words translation only — commentary and dossier not yet generated

Sources and records

About this work

Apparatus · what the pipeline recorded

Annotation and terms

0 commentary units 81 derived notes 0 open questions 284 narrative
What the kinds mean

Pipeline notes

  • coverageNo English translation could be identified: a language model asked twice could not name one, though it could not rule one out either. That is not proof that none exists — translations in dissertations, recent books and other modern languages are easily missed.
  • limitThe English is a machine draft produced passage by passage from the transcribed Latin; no human has verified it. The commentary is model-written and cites only keys the pipeline could resolve.
  • registerRegister: letter in Latin; the English keeps the liturgical formulae and the vocatives rather than normalising them.
  • structurePassages: 284 narrative.
  • caution81 passage(s) are fragmentary in the source; the English bridges each break and says so in the note.
  • sourceSource edition: ogl-pl.
  • sourceLicence: Available under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License

Term index

SourceRenderingCountFirst
no glossary terms recorded
tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:1 · narrative
Source · Latin

GELASII PAPÆ I EPISTOLÆ ET DECRETA.

a EPISTOLA PRIMA.

GELASII PAPAS I AD ELPHEMIANUM.

Scribit neminem ad sedis apostolicæ communionem se potae admittere qui Acacii nomen non damnaverit. Quare eum hortatur ut quemadmodum Eutychetem reliquosque haereticos, sic quoque Acacium anathe matizet.

Dilectissimo fratri Euphemiano Gelasius.

Quod plene cupimus, alque sincera fidei communionisque catholicæ redintegratione firmari, asserit tua dilectio, quod alteri solus non sufficiat auditus, nisi per litteras spectaverit significantiam provocantem de bis quae circa nos dispensatio divina perficit, ut sic in secundis vicem salutionis impenderem. Non arbitramur vel dilectionem tuam, vel aliquem sic hoc sperare potuisse, ut putaret nos, vel aliquempiam potiorem, quæ sunt gesta referentes, debuisse responsa promereri; quia nimis judicaretur arrogans, si de prima sede taliter existimasset. Quod si, ut magis opinamur, quasi sociis, quibus præesse Cbristi munere delegatum est, apostolicam sedem institutum sibi noviter sacerdotem præeuntibus oportuisse dixisti litteris indicare. Fuit quondam ecclesiastica vetus haec regula apud patres nostros, quibus una caUtolica apostolicaque communio ab omni prævaricatorum libera pollutione constabat.

English

THE LETTERS AND DECREES OF POPE GELASIUS I.

LETTER ONE.

GELASIUS I TO EUPHEMIUS.

He writes that he admits no one to communion with the apostolic see who has not condemned the name of Acacius. Wherefore he urges him that, just as he anathematized Eutyches and the other heretics, so too he should anathematize Acacius.

To his most beloved brother Euphemius, Gelasius.

Your belovedness asserts that what we fully desire, and what must be confirmed by the sincere reintegration of faith and catholic communion, is this: that hearing alone is not sufficient for another unless he has looked upon the meaning conveyed by letters, prompting him concerning those things which the divine dispensation accomplishes around us, so that thus in favorable circumstances I might bestow the office of a greeting. We do not believe that either your belovedness or anyone else could have hoped for this, as to think that we, or anyone of higher rank, reporting what has been done, ought to have earned replies; because it would be judged far too arrogant if anyone had thought such a thing concerning the first see. But if, as we rather suppose, you have said that the apostolic see ought to have indicated by preceding letters to those who are, as it were, allies, over whom it has been delegated to preside by the gift of Christ, the priest newly appointed to them — there once existed this ancient ecclesiastical rule among our fathers, for whom the one catholic and apostolic communion stood free from every pollution of the treacherous.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:2 · narrative
Source · Latin

Nunc autem cum societatem preferre malitis extraneam, quam ad beati Petri purum redire illibatumque consortium: Quomodo cantabimus canticum Domini in terra aliena (Psal. CXXXVI)? Quomodo dispositionis apostolicæ antiqua foedera præbeamus hominibus communionis extraneæ? Quemadmodum vobis ordinationem renuntiatura est, cui vestro etiam testimonio I haereticos damnatos præponitis? Dicet forsitan tua dilectio, hæreticos damnatos dici Acacium et Petmm. Cur «/. Quod] si fas non est, praesentibus saltem litteris colloquamur Quia aliter appellamus dominicxmensæ participes, aliter qui in ejus nobiscum socie'ate dissentiunt: quia ipse Dominus alio modo verba faciebat, a sua prædicatione discretis; alio discipulis regni coelestis secreta pandebat. Consequcner quoque apostoli non ita a suo collegio separatis, quemadmodum fidei domesticis, consortibusque loquebantur. Sed ait dilectio tua, tantum circa me sese caritatis habuisse, ut non solum ad scribendum fueris contentus, sed affatus audire. Legisti sententiam: Fides ex auditu, auditus autem per verbum Dei (Rom. x); illud scilicet verbum, quod confessioni beati apostoli Pelri portas inferni nunquam praevaliluras esse promisit (Matth. XVI). Atque ideo rationobiliter existimasti, quia fidelis Deus in verbis suis, non nisi aliquid tale promisisset instituere, veram sponsionis suæ promissionem impleret.

English

But now, since you prefer to maintain an alien fellowship rather than to return to the pure and unblemished consortium of blessed Peter: How shall we sing the song of the Lord in a strange land? How shall we extend the ancient covenants of the apostolic ordinance to men of alien communion? In what manner will she renounce ordination for you, when even by your own testimony you set condemned heretics before her? Perhaps your Belovedness will say that Acacius and Peter are called condemned heretics. Why so? If it is not lawful, let us at least converse by the present letter. For we address the partakers of the Lord's table in one way, and those who dissent from us in His fellowship in another; because the Lord Himself spoke in one way to those separated from His preaching, and in another way revealed the secrets of the heavenly kingdom to His disciples. Consequently the apostles also did not speak in the same manner to those separated from their college as to the household of the faith and their associates. But your Belovedness says that you had such charity toward me that you were content not only to write, but to hear an address. You have read the sentence: Faith comes by hearing, and hearing through the word of God; that is, the word which He promised to the confession of the blessed apostle Peter, that the gates of hell would never prevail against it. And therefore you reasonably supposed that, since God is faithful in His words, He would fulfill the true promise of His pledge only if He had promised to establish something of that kind.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:3 · narrative
Source · Latin

Ait denique tua dilectio, nos divinae providentiae gratia, quod ille monstraverit, sanctarum ecclesiarum non deserere caritatem, quia me in pontificali sede locaverit non indigentem, sicut ait, doceri; sed intendentem omnia necessaria ad ecclesiastici corporis unitatem. Ego quidem sum omnium hominum minimus, satis immeritus ad tantae sedis officium, nisi quod superna gratia semper operatur magna de parvis. Quid enim de me sentiam cum hoc ipse de se magister gentium testetur, qui se ultimum et non dignum vocari apostolum profitetur (I Cor. xv)? Verumtamen, ut ad dilectionis tuæ verba redeamus, si veraciter assecutus es haec divinitus mihi fuisse collata, quae et profecto quaecunque sunt bona, dona sunt Dei: sequere ergo hortamenta non indigentis doceri, et se. cundum supernam dispositionem universa cunctaque inspicientis quæ ad Ecclesiarum pertinent unitatem, et ad versus diabo!um conturbatorem veræ pacis atque compagis, ut asseris fortiter resistentis. Si ergo de me tsta pronuntias, aut sectanda tibi sunt quæ a Christo, ut perhibes, constituta sunt; aut palam te, quod absit, Christi dispositionibus obviare depromis, aut ad veniam [al. venam] luxuriæ de me cognosceris ista jactare. Sed consequenter adnectis, condescendibilem me et optima dispositione revocare posse c( ncordiam. Proinde, quoniam isto verbo frequenter utimini, quid sibi velil, explorem.

English

Finally, your Belovedness says that I, by the grace of divine providence, do not abandon the love of the holy churches, because he who placed me in the pontifical see placed me there as one not needing, as he says, to be taught, but as one attending to all things necessary for the unity of the ecclesiastical body. I indeed am the least of all men, quite undeserving of the office of so great a see, except that heavenly grace ever works great things from small. For what should I think of myself, when the very teacher of the Gentiles testifies this of himself, who professes himself to be called the last and unworthy apostle (I Cor. 15)? Nevertheless, to return to the words of your Belovedness: if you have truly grasped that these things were divinely conferred upon me—and indeed whatever good things there are, they are the gifts of God—then follow the exhortations of one who does not need to be taught, and according to the heavenly disposition of him who inspects all and every thing, [follow] those things which pertain to the unity of the Churches, and [stand] against the devil, the disturber of true peace and concord, as you assert, resisting bravely. If, therefore, you pronounce these things concerning me, then either the things which, as you maintain, were established by Christ must be followed by you; or you openly declare—which God forbid—that you oppose the ordinances of Christ; or you are known to boast these things concerning me to obtain pardon for self-indulgence. But you go on to add that I am condescending and can, by the best arrangement, restore concord. Therefore, since you frequently use this word, let me examine what it means.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:4 · narrative
Source · Latin

Optima enim illa est Ecclesiæ catholicæ atque apostolicæ dispositio, ad meliora proficiendo condescendere, non ad inferiora descendendo deficere. Cum autem dicis condescendere nos dcbere vobiscum, interim jam vos autdescenderc, aut descendisse monstratis. Undc,quaeso, vel quo is a descensio est? Utique ex superiori quodam loco ad in'eriora quæque deposilo, a catholica [al. depositio. A catholica] apostolicaque communione ad hæreticam damnatamque prolapsos vos videtis, cognosci. tis, non negatis: et non solum vos in infimis jacere dclectat, sed etiam in superiore manentes sede vultis impelli. Condescendere nos vobiscum invitatis ad ima de summis, nos coascendere vos nobiscum rogamus ad summa de imis. Nunc igitur sub conspectu illius excelsæ justitiæ judicet genus humanum, quis nostrum debeat alteri obedire. I An dicis, ut caetera nunc omittam, descendit Dominus ipse de cœlo. Descendit plane, sed ut hominem ab errore liberaret, non ut ejus misceretur errori. Nonne ip præmonuit ut qui in tecto consisterent, non descenderent, nec de ea quæ in domo videntur esse tollenda (Matth. XXIV)? Nonne pro omnibus Apostolus (/ Cor. I, 5) lamat unus, qui plus omnibus laboravit, cum de castodia veritatis ageretur, quibus nec ad horam cessimus subjeclionis gratia, ut veritas Evangelii permaneret apud vos? Videtis cœlestem magistrum condescendere noxiis recusantem?

English

For that is the best arrangement of the catholic and apostolic Church: to condescend by advancing toward better things, not to fail by descending to lower things. But when you say that we ought to condescend with you, you show that you have already either condescended or descended. Whence, I ask, or whither is this descent? Surely it is a lowering from some higher place to the lowest things, a falling from catholic and apostolic communion to heretical and condemned communion. You see yourselves, you recognize it, you do not deny it; and it does not merely please you to lie in the depths, but you even wish those remaining in the higher seat to be driven down. You invite us to condescend with you from the heights to the depths; we ask that you ascend with us from the depths to the heights. Now therefore, under the gaze of that exalted justice, let the human race judge which of us ought to obey the other. Or do you say—to omit other matters for now—that the Lord himself descended from heaven? He descended indeed, but to free man from error, not to be mingled in his error. Did he not warn that those who were on the housetop should not descend, nor take anything from the house? Did not the Apostle, that one who labored more than all, cry out on behalf of all, when the guarding of the truth was at stake, that we did not yield to them even for an hour, so that the truth of the Gospel might remain with you? Do you see the heavenly Master refusing to condescend to the guilty?

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:5 · narrative
Source · Latin

Postremo faciamus aliquem corruisse, ad quem benignissime sublevandum paululum quispiam velit inflecti. Ergo, ut erigatur jacens, miserantem convenit inclinari, non ut cum eodem præcipitetur in foveam. Igitur per litteras quas Ner Sinclitium diaconem destinastis, de his quos baptizavit, quos ordinavit Acacius, majorum traditione confectam et veram, praecipue religiosæ sollicitudini congruam prabemus sine difficultate medicinam. Quo nos vultis ultra descendere? Quid taceii,? Quid verecundamini verbis exprimere quod corde gestatis? Ipsa vos saltem verecundia, quod nonnunquam fit, debuit commonere. Au forsitan, ut hæreticorum damnatorumque et his vel eorum successoribus communicantium nomina consentiamus admitti? Hoc non est condescendere ad subveniendum, sed evidenter in inferna demergi. Parcite, quæso, et nabis cl vobis. Quod si curam ves ri adeo non habev:. date veniam nobis. Dolcre et flere possumus et debemus: in hæc abrupta deduci nec possumus, nec debemus, qui, præstante Deo nostro, sinceram puramque paternæ traditionis fidem communionemque retinere, et ab omni praevaricatorum contagione discretam, etiam inlentato pericu'o mortis, optamus, eligentes (si velit Deus) quaelibet illa perreti, quam causas incidere damnationis æternæ.

English

Finally, let us suppose that someone has fallen, and that someone wishes to bend a little to raise him up most kindly. Therefore, to lift up the fallen, it is fitting for the merciful to stoop down, not to be hurled with him into the pit. Therefore, through the letter which you sent by the deacon Ner Sinclitius, concerning those whom Acacius baptized and those whom he ordained, we offer without difficulty the true remedy prepared by the tradition of the ancients, and especially suited to religious solicitude. To what further point do you wish us to descend? Why do you keep silent? Why are you ashamed to express in words what you carry in your heart? Shame itself, at least, as sometimes happens, ought to have reminded you. Or perhaps you wish us to agree that the names of heretics and of the condemned, and of those in communion with them or with their successors, be admitted? This is not to condescend in order to help, but manifestly to be plunged into hell. Spare, I beg, both us and yourselves. But if you have so little care for yourselves, grant us pardon. We can and ought to grieve and weep: we can and ought not to be led into these precipices, who, with our God's help, desire to retain the sincere and pure faith and communion of the paternal tradition, and to keep it separated from every contagion of the prevaricators, even at the threat of death, choosing (if God wills) to endure any dangers whatever rather than to incur the causes of eternal damnation.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:6 · narrative
Source · Latin

Date, inquam, veniam, si tamen cum vos propter amorem cujuslibet hominis vel timorem haec libenter incurritis, nos prop:er amorem Dei et timorem gebennæ talia refutamus. Nec vos credatis, dissimulando causas atque personas, cujuslibet amiciliis posse subrepcre? quia neque vos ita subtiles estis, qui non possitis ittelligi: et nos, praestante Deo nostro, non reperiiis incautos. Nonne missis huc sæpe litteris indicastis, cum cæteris hæreticis vos Eutychen quoque respuere? Hoc si verum est, aut eos qui communicaverunt Eutychetis successoribus pariter ahdicate, aut aliorum quoque hæreticorum successoribus communicantes, admittite. Sed Acacius, inquis, nihil contra fidem, sicut Eutyches, et successor ejus, legitur ubicutique dixisse; quasi non sit deterius, et non ignorasse veritatem et tamen communicasse veritatis inimicis. Si enim, cum aliquis recte sapiens de fide catholica communicet illis hæreticis, inter quos Eutychetem posuistis, vel successoribus eorum, non est fas eos uter catholicorum altaria no.m;nare: ita ergone illius Eutychetis successoribus communicando, simili serte tenetur obnoxius? De talibus qnippe convenienter dicitur: Descendant in infernum viventes (Psal. LIV), qui dum illa vita qua justus vivit (Rom. i), vera atque catholica putantur vivere, repeute aut in prona pravitatis, aut in hæreticæ communionis inferna vergunt.

English

Give, I say, pardon, if indeed, when you willingly incur these things for the love or fear of any man, we refuse such things for the love of God and fear of Gehenna. And do not believe that by dissembling causes and persons you can creep into anyone's friendships, since neither are you so subtle that you cannot be understood, nor are we, by the help of our God, found off guard. Did you not, by letters often sent here, indicate that along with the other heretics you reject Eutyches also? If this is true, either equally condemn those who communicated with the successors of Eutyches, or admit those who communicate with the successors of other heretics as well. But Acacius, you say, is read everywhere to have said nothing against the faith, as Eutyches and his successor did; as if it were not worse both to have known the truth and yet to have communicated with the enemies of the truth. For if, when someone rightly wise concerning the catholic faith communicates with those heretics among whom you have placed Eutyches, or with their successors, it is not lawful for any of the catholics to name their altars, is he then, by communicating with the successors of that Eutyches, bound by a like guilt? For concerning such it is fittingly said: Let them go down alive into hell, who, while they are thought to live that life by which the just man lives, suddenly sink either into the downward path of depravity or into the hell of heretical communion.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:7 · narrative
Source · Latin

Eccc quales Christo dicilis esse praeponendos, cum ille ec animas nostras sibimet praecipiat anteponi. Imo et adhuc quæritis quando fuerit damnatus Acacius, quasi revcra, etiamsi eum nullus ante damnasset, non debuerit orthodoxæ ct apostolicæ communionis, cujus praevaricator exstitit ct deserlor, participatione secludi; sicut eliam quilibet qui fuerit ante catholicus, cuicunque hæresi communicans, merito judicatur a nostra societate removendus; aut in tali orte defunctus, inter catholieorum nomina nullatenus computari. Miramur tamen quomodo ista profertis. hoc est et synodum Chalcedonensem vos suc;pere pro fide catholica profiteamiui; et eos quos damnavit, sectantium communicatores, non particulariter generaliterque putetis fuisse damnatos. Ostendite ergo quæ synodus in unaquaque hæresi cum erroribus successores eorum his communicantes simulque omnes non damnet et complices. Itaque ille vester Acacius, qui Eutychianis hæreticis detestabili communione factus est particeps, ab eadem synodo sine dubitatione damnatus est, quae et Eutychen Dioscoi umque cum sue essoribus eorum bisque communicantessy. nodico tenore prostravit.

English

Behold what sort of men you say are to be preferred to Christ, when He bids our own souls be preferred to Himself. Nay, you even still ask when Acacius was condemned, as though in truth, even if no one had condemned him beforehand, he ought not to have been excluded from participation in the orthodox and apostolic communion, of which he proved himself a betrayer and deserter; just as anyone who was previously catholic, by communicating with any heresy whatsoever, is rightly judged to be removed from our fellowship; or if he dies in such a beginning, he is by no means to be counted among the names of catholics. Yet we wonder how you put these things forward: that is, you profess to accept the synod of Chalcedon for the catholic faith, and yet you think that those whom it condemned, and the communicators of those who follow them, were not condemned both individually and generally. Show, therefore, which synod does not at once condemn, in each heresy, their successors who communicate with the errors, and all their accomplices together. And so that Acacius of yours, who by a detestable communion became a partaker with the Eutychian heretics, was without doubt condemned by the same synod, which also laid low Eutyches and Dioscorus with their authors and those who communicated with them by the tenor of its judgment.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:8 · narrative
Source · Latin

Sic sequaces quoque eorum, Timotheum Petrum-. que simili definitione dejecit. Proinde si ea quae in synodo Chalcedonensi pro fide et communione catholica lege apostolica definita sunt, vere certeque sectamini, sicut vestra professione mulliplici continetur; aut successores ab illa synodo damnatorum hisque communicantes abjicite; aut, si istos admittilis, ea quae in illa synodo pro fide et communione catholica et apostolica sunt peracta, non solum falso vos retinere perpenditis, sed insuper tabefactare conamini, et in Eutychianam haeresim sine retractatione reciditis, meritoque a catholicis probamini esse vitandi: quia ut talem pestilentiam perpetuo possemus evadere, ea. quæ contra ipsam ab ea congregatione sanctorum Patrum salubriter decreta leguntur, nullatenus mutilanda, non solum sedis apostolicae præsules, sed etiam Orientalium regionum catholici censuere pontifices. An Petrum dicitis fuisse purgatum, cui communicavit Acacius? Veris assertionibus edocete, hoc ostendite, hoc probate, quibus ille modis, quibus ille regulis ab Eutychiana fuerit professione vel communione mundatus: ut cum id nihilominus evidenti rerum claruerit demonstratione convictum, palam aperteque possitis advertere, aut vos debere cedere veritati, aut adversus hanc manifesta dimicatione confligere.

English

Thus he also cast down their followers, Timothy and Peter, by a similar definition. Therefore, if you truly and certainly follow what was defined in the Council of Chalcedon for the faith and catholic communion by apostolic law, as is contained in your manifold profession; either reject the successors of those condemned by that council and those who communicate with them; or, if you admit these men, you perceive that you not only falsely retain what was enacted in that council for the catholic and apostolic faith and communion, but you even attempt to corrupt it, and you fall back without retraction into the Eutychian heresy, and you are deservedly judged by catholics to be avoided: because, in order that we might forever escape such a pestilence, the decrees which are read as having been salutarily enacted against it by that assembly of holy Fathers must in no way be mutilated—so judged not only the prelates of the apostolic see, but also the catholic pontiffs of the Eastern regions. Or do you say that Peter was purified, with whom Acacius communicated? Teach us with true assertions, show this, prove this, by what methods, by what rules he was cleansed from the Eutychian profession or communion: so that, when this has nevertheless been made clear and convicted by evident demonstration of the facts, you may be able openly and clearly to perceive that you must either yield to the truth, or fight against it in manifest combat.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:9 · narrative
Source · Latin

Nec vobis blandiamini, quia fidem catholicam profitemini vos tenere, quia Eutychetis nomen ademistis, quia ea veluti prædicare videamini, quae orthodoxa prædicavit antiquitas. Clamat enim nobis illa evangelica sententia: Aut facite arborem bonam, et fructus ejus bonos; aut facite arborem malam et fruclus ejus malos: a fructibus enim arbor cognosdtur (Matth. xn): id est, si voce, si fide, si professione catholica et apostolica fideliter veraciterque gloriamini, hujus et communionem recipite. Si vero hæreticorum, scilicet a.mnatorum, vel his aut successoribus eorum communicantium, communio vobis placet, quid statis? quid circumspicitis? sinui et eorum aperte manifesteque, remotis obstaculis dogma defendite. Quid enim juvat? imo et satis gravai, dictis polliceri quod factis negatur, ut non solum ipsa per se hæresis Eutychiana, quam sit funesta Christiano sacramento, possitis agnoscere, quanta et quam gravia hxresis ista in sui delini. tione contineat. Ecce ad quæ nos præc pitia condescendere provocatis, atque ad quæ nos vitæ aeternae pericula cupitis inclinare. Hoc descensu salvare est ægrotante r, an cum languente consumi? Hæc erit o. lima dispositio illius quam memoras reparandæ concordiæ, an illa potius, ut rejectis contagiis perfidorum, integra fide, sincera sui.

English

Do not flatter yourselves because you profess to hold the catholic faith, because you have removed the name of Eutyches, because you seem to preach those things which orthodox antiquity preached. For that Gospel sentence cries out to us: Either make the tree good and its fruit good, or make the tree bad and its fruit bad, for by its fruits the tree is known (Matt. 12): that is, if in voice, in faith, in catholic and apostolic profession you glory faithfully and truly, then receive his communion as well. But if the communion of heretics, namely of the condemned, or of those communicating with them or their successors, pleases you, why do you stand? Why do you look around? Defend their dogma openly and manifestly, with obstacles removed. For what does it profit—indeed it is grievous enough—to promise in words what is denied in deeds, so that you may be able to recognize not only how deadly the Eutychian heresy itself is to the Christian sacrament, but also how great and how grave a heresy this contains in its own definition. Behold, to what precipices you provoke us to condescend, and to what dangers of eternal life you desire to incline us. Is this descent to save the sick, or to be consumed with the languishing? Will this be the former arrangement of that restoration of concord which you mention, or rather that, with the contagions of the faithless rejected, in integrity of faith, sincere in its own.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:10 · narrative
Source · Latin

communione pot aiur communio catholica atque apostolica, ne haereticorum labe deputsa, intemeratam suae Olei confessionem nitatur astruere, atque invicem sibimet congruentis orthodoxæ professionis communionisque sii unitas? Hanc (sicut dilectionis tuæ litterae cohortantur) meis quoque temporibus custodiri, qua valeo preces deposco, quae per tot annos ab illis Pamibus gloriosis, illibata intactaque servata est. Hæc enim est, sicut ipse dicis, quam Deus noster de omnibus bene futuram, et secundum suam veritatem et regulam gubernandam, et præscius ante constituit, et singalis quibusque temporibus sua dispositione convenienter aptavit. Hæc est voluntas Dei, cujus tu ingeris meotionem, quam ego quoque pro meo modulo, quem Dominus donare dignatur, cupio prersus implere, ut non reus de hujus talenti cœlestis diminutione reperiar: sed in hoc talento (sicut ipse quoque nos admonet) incrementum Christi gratia postulo consequi, et nutlum prorsus incidere detrimentum. Hinc est quod prioribus dilectionis tuae litteris, sicut tua quoque paginadesignavit, pro vestra sumpsi salute tristitiam, ubi comperi quod erat vobis noxium, et quod verse paci contrarium reperi. Contristatur enim Aposlolus (II Cor. vn) de crrore deviantium, et lætitiam recipit de eisdem sua prædicatione correctis.

English

in the catholic and apostolic communion, lest, having been reckoned as stained by the corruption of heretics, it strive to build up an undefiled confession of its own faith, and the unity of an orthodox profession and communion agreeing with one another in turn? This unity (as the letters of your Belovedness urge) I beseech with prayers, as far as I am able, to be guarded also in my times, which for so many years has been preserved unblemished and untouched by those glorious Fathers. For this is, as you yourself say, what our God, foreknowing that it would be well concerning all things and would be governed according to his truth and rule, both established beforehand and fitted in due measure to each several time by his own disposition. This is the will of God, of which you bring mention to me, which I also, according to my own measure, which the Lord deigns to grant, desire wholly to fulfill, so that I may not be found guilty of diminishing this heavenly talent; but in this talent (as he himself also admonishes us) I ask to obtain an increase through the grace of Christ, and to incur no loss at all. Hence it is that from your earlier letters of Belovedness, as your page also indicated, I took up sorrow for your salvation, where I discovered what was harmful to you, and what I found contrary to true peace. For the Apostle grieves (II Cor. 7) over the error of those who go astray, and receives joy concerning the same when corrected by his preaching.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:11 · narrative
Source · Latin

Si autem tua cantas, ut dixit, nescio quorum necessitate constringitur, quod (pace tua dixerim) sacerdos pro veritate promenda nec facere deberet omnino nec dicere; ignoscat nobis hominibus timidissimis, si coarctante nos terribili et divini judicii grandi necessitate constringimur, sicut qualescunque ministros Christi decet, I nos animas. nostras ponere pro veritate salvandas, quam eas lucrari velle veritatis diminutione perdendas, ut non dicam, contra fidem libiti. cujuslibet abdicandas. Istæ mihi sunt (quas dilectio tua commendat) certae Mei perpetuae cum eo, quicunque voluerit, in Christi visceribus amicitiæ. IIic non tam optamus praeponi aliis, sicut prædicas, quam cum fidelibus cunctis sanctum et Deo placitum habere consortium. Hæc mihi (quam mandat dilectio toa) pax solida, inconvulsa, et perennis; hoc unum vinculum (sicut etiam ipse desideras) salutare qu o cuncta uniri possit Ecclesia. Hoc quibus est creditum (sicut et ipse deprecaris) protectio divina perficiat. Hæc est, quæ Deus est, caritas (I Joan. IV), quam poscis de corde puro, et conscientia bona, et fide non ficta (I Tim. i). Quomodo ergo de corde puro, si haereticorum fuerit participatine polluta? Quomodo conscientia bona, si malorum fuerit confusione pcrmixta? Quomodo fide non ficta, si fuerit mixta cum perfidis?

English

If, however, your Holiness, as he said, is constrained by the necessity of I know not whom, which (with your pardon let me say it) a priest ought neither to do nor to say at all for the sake of bringing forth the truth, may he forgive us most timid men if, pressed by the terrible and great necessity of divine judgment, we are constrained, as it befits whatever sort of ministers of Christ, to lay down our souls to be saved for the truth, rather than to wish to gain them by a diminution of the truth to be lost—not to say, to be renounced against the faith at anyone's pleasure. These are (which your Beloved commends) the sure bonds of my perpetual friendship with him, whoever he may wish, in the bowels of Christ. Here we do not so much desire to be preferred to others, as you preach, as to have a holy and God-pleasing fellowship with all the faithful. This is (which your Beloved enjoins) solid, unshaken, and perpetual peace for me; this one saving bond (as you yourself also desire) by which the whole Church can be united. May divine protection bring this to pass for those to whom it has been entrusted (as you yourself also entreat). This is the charity, which is God (1 John 4), which you require from a pure heart, and a good conscience, and faith unfeigned (1 Tim 1). How then from a pure heart, if it has been polluted by participation with heretics? How a good conscience, if it has been mixed with the confusion of evil men? How faith unfeigned, if it has been mixed with the faithless?

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:12 · narrative
Source · Latin

Quas si prudentia tua (sicut eam precamut) diligenter advertat, perspicit apostolicam sedem non vitare pacem, sed hæreticorum damnatorumque vitare vestigia [al. contagia]. Quae ctiam vos rationabiliter intuentes, creditis commonenduum populum Constantinopolitanum, non permittere submoveri nomine perfidorum. Quisnam hoc ia. Ecclesia Dei, quæso te, possit audire, cum utique pastorem sequi grex debeat ad pascua salutaria revocantem, non per devia gregem pastor errantem? Die mihi, rogo te, grex pro te, an tu pro grege redditurus es rationem? Certe si vobis hoc placet, multo. magis causa est nubis justior, qui populum Romanum a fide illa sua, laudabili majorum traditione percepta, declinare non sinentem nos penitus libenter audivimus, si vos Constantinopolitanam plebem, ab hæretica communione discedere recusantem, non vultis offendere.

English

If your prudence (as we pray it may) diligently attends to these things, it perceives that the apostolic see does not avoid peace, but avoids the footsteps of heretics and the condemned. Reasonably considering these things also, you believe that the Constantinopolitan people should be admonished, not to permit themselves to be removed under the name of the faithless. Who, I ask you, could hear this? Since surely the flock ought to follow the shepherd recalling it to wholesome pastures, not the shepherd wandering through trackless ways after the flock. Tell me, I ask you, will the flock render an account for you, or you for the flock? Certainly if this pleases you, there is a much more just cause for us, who have willingly heard the Roman people not permitting itself to decline from that faith of theirs, received by the praiseworthy tradition of their ancestors, if you are unwilling to offend the Constantinopolitan people, who refuse to depart from heretical communion.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:13 · narrative
Source · Latin

Sed nos dicitis debere dirigere qui eam valeant mitigare. Quomodo me auditura est, quem videtur habere suspectum, si praesules suos despicit admo. nentes? Nonne ipsis apostolis est praeceptum in aliquibus regionibus verbi prædicatione non uti, his quippe in quibus non fuerant audiendi? Veniemus, frater Euphemiane, sine dubitatione, veniemus ad illud pavendum tribunal Christi (ut taceam quæ ex hoc sit metuenda vindicta), circumstantibus iHis a quibus fides ipsa est. Non illic inficiationibus, non dilationibus, non a inclusionibus est agendum; sed manifestissime eomprobandum utrum beati Petri cloriosa confessio cuiquam eorum quos regendos accepit, quidquam subtraxerit ad salutem; an eam auscultare nolens, etiam cum suo periculo rebellis, exstiterit obstinata pernicies? Ibi certe dilucidabitur utrum ego (sicut putatis) acerbus, asper, et nimis durns, difficilisque sim vobis, qui cum ratione vestram salutem parturio, qui clamo: Etiamsi austerum videtur antidotum, accipite, quæso, bibite, vivite, nolo moriamini; an vos, qui a noxiis prohibiti, medicos ducitis exsecrandos, imo qui vultis vobiscum medicos ægrotare, quam vos recipere 5sanitatem. Et alia manu: Dominus te incolumem custodiat.

English

But you say that I ought to send men who can mitigate her. How will she listen to me, whom she seems to hold suspect, if she despises her own prelates when they admonish her? Was it not commanded to the apostles themselves not to use the preaching of the word in certain regions—namely, in those in which they were not to be heard? We shall come, brother Euphemianus, without doubt we shall come to that fearful tribunal of Christ (to say nothing of the vengeance that is to be feared from this), with those standing by from whom the faith itself comes. There we must not deal in denials, in delays, in excuses; but it must be most manifestly proved whether the glorious confession of blessed Peter has withdrawn anything for the salvation of any of those whom he received to be governed; or whether, refusing to listen to it and rebellious even at her own peril, she has stood as an obstinate destruction. There certainly it will be made clear whether I (as you think) am harsh, rough, and too severe and difficult for you, who with reason travail for your salvation, who cry out: Even if the remedy seems bitter, take it, I beg you, drink, live, I do not wish you to die; or whether it is you, who, forbidden from harmful things, consider the physicians execrable—indeed, who wish the physicians to be sick along with you, rather than that you receive health. And in another hand: May the Lord keep you safe.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:14 · narrative
Source · Latin

aEPISTOLA II.

AD LAURENTIUM DE LIGNIDO EPISCOPUM.

Ad pontificatum assumptus de more Romanæ Ecclesiæ fidei formulam, quam omnes profiteri teneantur, præscribit.

In prolixitate epistolae dilectionis tuæ magno nos gaudio replesti in ea parte in qua dictum est quod in Thessalonicensi Ecclesia, vel in aliis similiter recitata epistola prædecessoris nostri de excessibus Acacii, cuncti eidem anathema dixerint, nec quisquam communioni prævaricatori sese miscuerit. Unde quia nos admones dilectione fraterna, ut velut medicinam quamdam fidei episcopis per Illyricum, vel aliis ministrare debeamus, quanquam hoc copiosissime factum sit a beatae recordationis prædecessore nostro; et quia mos est Romanæ Ecclesiae sacerdoti noviter constituto formam fidei suæ ad sanctas Ecclesias prærogare, hæc eadem compendiosa nimis brevitate studui renovare, ut sub qua fide vivendum sit, secundum statuta Patrum, in hanc nostram epistolam propter brevitatem sine fastidio lector agnoscat.

English

LETTER II.

TO LAURENTIUS, BISHOP OF LIGNIDO.

Having been assumed to the pontificate, he prescribes, according to the custom of the Roman Church, the formula of faith which all are bound to profess.

In the length of your letter, you have filled us with great joy in that part in which it was stated that in the Church of Thessalonica, and in others likewise, when the letter of our predecessor concerning the excesses of Acacius was read out, all pronounced anathema upon him, and no one mingled himself with the communion of the prevaricator. Wherefore, since you admonish us with brotherly love that we ought to administer, as it were, a kind of medicine of faith to the bishops throughout Illyricum and to others—although this was most abundantly done by our predecessor of blessed memory—and since it is the custom of the Roman Church that a newly appointed priest set forth the formula of his faith to the holy Churches, I have taken care to renew these same things in a very brief compendium, so that under what faith one must live, according to the statutes of the Fathers, the reader may learn in this our letter, on account of its brevity, without weariness.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:15 · narrative
Source · Latin

Confitemur ergo Dominum nostrum Jesum Christum Filium Dei unigenitum ante omnia quidem sæcula, sine principio, ex Patre natum secundum deitaiem; in novissimis autem diebus de sanctissima Virgine Maria eumdem incarnatum et perfectum hominem ex anima rationali et corporis susceptione homousion Patri secundum deitatem, et bomousion nobis secundum humanitatem. Duarum enim naturarum -perfectarum unitas facta est ineffabiliter, propter quod unum Christum eumdem Filium Dei et hominis unfgenitum. a Patre, et primogenitnm et mortuis confitemur; scientes quod quidem coæternus sit suo Patri secundum divinitatem, secundum quam opifex est omnium, et dignatus est post consensionem sanctissimæ Virginis, cuti dixit ad angelum: Ecce ancilla Domini, fiat mihi secundum verbum tuum (Luc. I). Ineffabiliter sibi ex ipsa aedificavit templum, et sibi univit, quod non coæternum de sua substantia e coelo detulit corpus, sed ex massa nostræ substantiæ, hoc est ex virgine hoc accipiens, et sibi uniens, non Deus Verbum in carnem versus est; neque ut pbantasma apparens, sed inconvertibiliter et incommutabililcr suam conservavit essentiam primitias naturae nostræ suscipiens, sibi univit.

English

We confess, therefore, our Lord Jesus Christ, the only-begotten Son of God, before all ages indeed, without beginning, born of the Father according to divinity; but in the last days incarnate of the most holy Virgin Mary, and perfect man from a rational soul and the assumption of a body, consubstantial with the Father according to divinity, and consubstantial with us according to humanity. For the unity of two perfect natures was made ineffably, on account of which we confess one Christ, the same Son of God and of man, only-begotten from the Father, and firstborn from the dead; knowing that He is indeed coeternal with His Father according to divinity, according to which He is the maker of all things, and He deigned, after the consent of the most holy Virgin, to whom He said through the angel: Behold the handmaid of the Lord, let it be done to me according to your word (Luke 1). Ineffably for Himself from her He built a temple, and united it to Himself, because He did not bring down from heaven a body coeternal from His own substance, but from the mass of our substance, that is, receiving this from the virgin, and uniting it to Himself, not that God the Word was turned into flesh; nor as appearing as a phantom, but inconvertibly and immutably He preserved His own essence, receiving the firstfruits of our nature, and united it to Himself.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:16 · narrative
Source · Latin

Nam principium Deus Verbum has nostræ naturæ primitias multa sibi bonitate unire dignatus est, qui non permixtus, sed in utriusque substantia unus et ipse visus, secundum quod scriptum est: Solvite templum istud, et in tribus diebus resuscitabo illud (Joan. n). Solvitur enim Christus Jesus, secundum meram snbstantiam quam suscepit, et solutum suscitat proprium templum: hoc ipse secundum divinam substantiam, secundum quam et omnium artifex est. Nunquam autem post resurrectionem unitionis nostræ naturæ discessit a proprio templo, nec discedere potest propter ineffabilem suam benignitatem, sed est ipse Dominus Jesus Christus et passibilis, et impassibilis: passibilis secundum humanitatem, impassibilis secundum divinitatem. Suscitavit igitur suum templum Deus Verbum, et in se naturae nostrae resurrectionem et renovationem operatus est, et hanc Dominus Christus noster Deus, postquam resurrexit a mortuis, discipulis suis ostendebat dicens: Palpate me, et videte quoniam spiritus carnem et ossa non habet, quemadmodum me videtis habere (Luc. xxiv); non die xit, quemadmodum me dicitis esse, sed habere, ut et qui habet, et qui habetur considerans, non permixtionem, non conversionem, non mutationem, sed unitatem factam respicias.

English

For God the Word, the beginning, deigned in his great goodness to unite to himself these firstfruits of our nature, he who is not mixed but one and the same seen in the substance of both, according to what is written: Destroy this temple, and in three days I will raise it up. For Christ Jesus is dissolved according to the mere substance which he took up, and having been dissolved he raises up his own temple: this he does according to the divine substance, according to which he is also the artificer of all things. But never after the resurrection did he depart from his own temple, nor can he depart, on account of his ineffable goodness, but the same Lord Jesus Christ is both passible and impassible: passible according to humanity, impassible according to divinity. God the Word, therefore, raised up his own temple, and in himself worked the resurrection and renewal of our nature, and this our Lord Christ God, after he rose from the dead, showed to his disciples, saying: Handle me, and see that a spirit does not have flesh and bones, as you see me have; he did not say, as you say I am, but have, so that you, considering both him who has and that which is had, may regard not a mixture, not a conversion, not a change, but a unity that has been made.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:17 · narrative
Source · Latin

Propterea, et fixuris clavorum, et fixionem lanceae demonstravit, et cum discipulis manducavit, ut per omnia resurrectionem nostræ naturæin se renovatam doceret: et quia secundum beatam diviuitatis substantiam inconvertibilis, incommutabilis » impassibilis, immortalis, nullius indigens, perficiens omnes passiones, se permisit proprio inferri templo, quod virtute propria suscitavit, et per propriam perfectionem templi sui renovationem nostræ naturæ operatus est. Qui autem dicunt subtilem hominem Christum, aut passibilem Deum, aut in carne versum, aut non cognituin habuisse corpus, aut de coelo hoc detulisse, aut phantasma esse, aut mortalem dicentes, Deum Verbum indiguisse ut a Patre suscitaretur, aut sine anima corpus, aut sine sensu hominem suscepisse, aut duas substantias Christi, secundum permixtionem confusas, unam factam fuisse substantiam, et non confitentes Dominum nostrum Jesum Cbristum duas esse naturas inconfusas, unam autem personam, secundum quod unus Christus, unus idem Filius, istos anathematizat catholica et apostolica Ecclesia.

English

Therefore he showed both the piercings of the nails and the wound of the lance, and he ate with his disciples, so that in all things he might teach that the resurrection of our nature was renewed in himself; and because according to the blessed substance of his divinity he is unchangeable, immutable, impassible, immortal, lacking nothing, perfecting all sufferings, he permitted himself to be brought into his own temple, which he raised up by his own power, and through his own perfection accomplished the renewal of our nature in his temple. But those who say that Christ was a subtle man, or that God was passible, or that he was turned into flesh, or that he did not have a body capable of being known, or that he brought this down from heaven, or that he was a phantom, or who say that he was mortal, that God the Word needed to be raised by the Father, or that his body was without a soul, or that he assumed a man without sensation, or that the two substances of Christ, confused by mixture, became one substance, and who do not confess that our Lord Jesus Christ is two natures without confusion, but one person, according as he is one Christ, one and the same Son—these the catholic and apostolic Church anathematizes.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:18 · narrative
Source · Latin

Hec ergo sunt, frater dilectissime, quæ pro antidoto nos debere mittere flagitasti, quod nullum amarum, neque dulce noxium videndum refugite, nam et de nostro conventu disposueramus quosdam dirigere, si ratio id temporis fieri permisisset: quod facere credimus opportune, cum illarum partium correctio ad nos, juvante Domino, legatione plenissima, sicut confidimus fuerit nundata. Sperantes etiam de Dei nostri misericordia, ut huic praedicationi nostræ c'e. mentissimus et Christianissimus imperator unanimitatem suam auxiliumque conjungat, quatenus pro fide qua pollet, in illis regionibus coerceat, quin suis quæstiunculis, et secundum elementa mundi, sicut vas electionis ante praedixit, superflua vanaque concinant, nolentes contineri salutaribus disciplinis: sed MOx, siCut nil idcin apostolus, non ita didicistis, Christum (Coloss. II), si tamen illum audistis, et in illo docti eftis, sicut est veritas in Jeaum, quam utique ile apprehendere poterit qui orthodoxorum Patrum, sicut jam sæpe dictum est, observaverit instituta. Deus te incolumem custodiat, frater carissime.

English

These therefore are the things, most beloved brother, which you urged me to send as an antidote, since he who has regard for neither bitter nor sweet things that are harmful has refused them. For we had also arranged to send certain men from our assembly, if the reason of the time had permitted it to be done; which we believe will be done opportunely, when the correction of those regions, with the Lord's help, has been made known to us through a most full legation, as we trust. Hoping also in the mercy of our God, that the most clement and most Christian emperor may join his unanimity and aid to this preaching of ours, so that for the faith in which he prevails, he may restrain them in those regions from murmuring their petty questions and, according to the elements of the world, as the vessel of election foretold, superfluous and vain things, unwilling to be contained by wholesome disciplines: but soon, as the same apostle says, "Not so did you learn Christ" (Col. 2), if indeed you heard him and were taught in him, as the truth is in Jesus, which he will certainly be able to grasp who has observed the institutes of the orthodox Fathers, as has already often been said. May God keep you safe, dearest brother.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:19 · narrative
Source · Latin

RESCRIPTUM

EPISCOPORUM DARDANIÆ AD CEIASlUM PAPAM.

Gratias agunt quod ipsos monuerit a quibus cavendum sit; II cupeve ipsos ab apostolica sede visitari scri-

bunt.

Domino sancto apostolo [al. apostołico] et beatissimo patri patrum Gelasio papæurbis Romae, humiIcs episcopi Dardaniae.

Saluberrima apostolatus vestri præcepta Tryphone viro relig oso filio nostro deferente, qua oportet devotione suscepimus, et maximas Deo omnipotenti, et beatitudini vestræ referimus gratias, quod nos pastorali admnitione et evangelica doctrina visitare Ji. gnatus es, domine sancte apostolice et beatissime pater patrum. Desiderii enim et voti nostri est jussionibus vestris in omnibus obcdire, et quemadmodum a patribus nostris accepimus, sedis apostolicæ, quæ vitæ et meritis vestris delata est, præcepta intemerate servare, atque religionem orthodoxam, cujus estis prædicatores, fideli et inculpata devotione, prout nostrae rusticitatis sensus patitur, custodire.

English

RESCRIPT

OF THE BISHOPS OF DARDANIA TO POPE GELASIUS.

They give thanks that he has warned them against whom they must be on guard; and they write that they desire to be visited by the apostolic see.

To the holy lord and apostle, and most blessed father of fathers, Gelasius, pope of the city of Rome, the humble bishops of Dardania.

The most wholesome precepts of your apostolate, brought to us by Tryphon, a religious man, our son, we have received with the devotion with which we ought, and we give the greatest thanks to almighty God and to your blessedness, because you have deigned to visit us with pastoral admonition and evangelical teaching, holy lord and apostolic, and most blessed father of fathers. For it is our desire and vow to obey your commands in all things, and, just as we have received from our fathers, to preserve inviolate the precepts of the apostolic see, which has been conferred upon you by your life and merits, and to guard the orthodox religion, of which you are the preachers, with faithful and blameless devotion, so far as the understanding of our rusticity allows.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:20 · narrative
Source · Latin

Eutychis enim vel Petri Acaciique et omnium sectatorum ejus atque consortium, velut quaedam pestifera contagia, ante vestram quoque vitavimus jussionem, et mulio mogis nunc post admonitionem sedis apostolicæ,et ab eadem nos pollutione nece sseest abstinere: et si qui alii ejusdem Eutychetis sectam, vel Petri et Acacii, aut secuti sunt aut sequentur, vel eorumdem sese complicibus atque consortibus a stimant immiscendos, et a nobis, qui sedi ap stol cæ secundum divina præcepta et Patrum statrita inculpati servire desidcramus, omni ratione vitandi sunt. Et si qui forte prava intentione (quod neque arbiramur neque optamus a sede apostolica se crdiderint segregandos, ab eorum nos alienos esse consortio profitemur; quoniam, ut dictum est, Patrum in omnibus custodientes præcepta. et inviolabilia sacrosanctorum canonnm instituta sectantes, apostolicæ et singulari illi sedi vestræ communi fide et devotione parere contendimus. Et quoniam suggerendi fomitem nobis pro insita sibi benignitate beatitudo vestra concessit, aliqua memor to Tryphoni viro religioso filio nostro, preceptorum vestrorum portitori, suggerenda mandavimus. Et ut suggestionem ejus, quantum arbitramur justam et rationabilem pro supplicatione no.

English

For Eutyches and Peter and Acacius and all their followers and associates, like certain pestilential contagions, we have avoided even before your command, and much more now after the admonition of the apostolic see must we abstain from that same pollution; and if any others have followed or shall follow the sect of the same Eutyches, or of Peter and Acacius, or think that they must mingle themselves with their accomplices and associates, they are also to be avoided by us in every way, who desire to serve the apostolic see blamelessly according to the divine precepts and the statutes of the Fathers. And if any perchance with depraved intention (which we neither believe nor desire) should think themselves separated from the apostolic see, we profess that we are alien from their fellowship; since, as has been said, guarding the precepts of the Fathers in all things and following the inviolable institutions of the sacred canons, we strive to obey your apostolic and singular see with common faith and devotion. And since your blessedness, out of the kindness innate to it, has granted us the fuel for making suggestions, we have entrusted certain things to be suggested to the aforementioned Tryphon, a religious man, our son, the bearer of your precepts. And that his suggestion, insofar as we judge it just and reasonable, according to the supplication of no...

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:21 · narrative
Source · Latin

stra libenti animo aposlolalus vester dignelur admirtere, justis precibus exoramus (quod supplicatio nostra meretur effectum) unum ex angelica sede vestra cum sæpe dicto viro religioso ad nos, usque præcipite destinare, ut sub ejus præsentia quæ fides orthodoxa, et vestræ jussionis sinceritas postulat, ordinentur. Et subscriptio.

Joannos episcopus sacrosanctæ Ecclesiæ Scopinæ metropolitanæ civitatis huic rescripto a nobis dato consentiens, ad omnia quae superius continentur manu propria subscripsi.

Bonosus episco, us ut supra subscripsi.

Samuel episcopus ut supra subscripsi.

Verianus episcopus per Valentinum archidiaconum ut supra subscripsi.

Faustinus episcopus ut supra subscripsi.

Ursinus episcopus ut supra subscripsi.

a EPISTOLA III.

AD EPISCOPOS DARDANIÆ.

Nuntiut se pontificem electum; catholicæ fidei libelium

transmittit, hortaturque ut cum Eutychianistis non communicent, el muneri pastorati invigilent.

English

your apostolic legate deign to admit with a willing mind, we entreat with just prayers (that our supplication may obtain its effect) that you send to us from your angelic see, together with the often-mentioned religious man, one [envoy] without delay, so that in his presence matters may be ordered as the orthodox faith and the sincerity of your command require. And the subscription.

I, John, bishop of the sacrosanct Church of Scopina, a metropolitan city, consenting to this rescript given by us, have subscribed with my own hand to all that is contained above.

I, Bonosus, bishop, have subscribed as above.

I, Samuel, bishop, have subscribed as above.

I, Verianus, bishop, through Valentinus the archdeacon, have subscribed as above.

I, Faustinus, bishop, have subscribed as above.

I, Ursinus, bishop, have subscribed as above.

LETTER III.

TO THE BISHOPS OF DARDANIA.

He announces that he has been elected pontiff; he transmits a libellus of the catholic faith, and exhorts them not to communicate with the Eutychianists, and to be vigilant in the office of pastoral care.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:22 · narrative
Source · Latin

Dilectissimis fratribus universis episcopis per Dardaniam constitutis Gelasius episcopus.

Ubi primum respirare fas est a continuorum tempestate bellorum, quæ in illis provinciis, vel in istis temporibus qualitas incessanter exercuit, cunctos per Dardaniam Domini sacerdoles fraternae sollicitudin caritate duximus alloquendos: primum quia regimen apostolicæ sedis adepti, strepitu publico, sicut dictum est, retardante, commissum nobis sacrae dispensationis officium, propriis, ut mos erat, litteris nequimus indicare, quo vestra fraternitas de communionis Domini nobiscum inunere gratuletur. Deinde, ut post tantas acerbitates incommoditatesque mundanas, qualiter invicem valeremus, mutuus sermo depromeret; postremo si qua de ecclesiasticis referenda sunt causis, quæ propter insidias perpetui hostis, pastorali sunt jugiier circumspicienda vigilantia, significationibus panderemus alternis. His igitur incitati per fratrem et coepiscopum nostrum Ursicinum præsentia dirigere scripta curavimus, præeunte gratia salutationis, orantes ut magnanimiter auxilio Domini tolerando rerum transeuntium vastitatem, magis esse debeamus autenti, ne, quod absit, perpetuæ subeamus vitæ dispendium. Proindeque catholicae veritatis poscit utilitas præcavenda, dilectio vestra paulisper advertat.

English

To the most beloved brothers, all the bishops established throughout Dardania, Bishop Gelasius.

As soon as it is permitted to breathe after the storm of continual wars, which the state of affairs in those provinces, or in these times, has incessantly exercised, we have deemed it right to address all the priests of the Lord throughout Dardania with the charity of brotherly solicitude: first, because, having obtained the governance of the apostolic see, with public turmoil, as has been said, holding us back, we were unable to make known the office of sacred stewardship committed to us by our own letters, as was the custom, so that your brotherhood might rejoice in the burden of the Lord's communion shared with us. Then, so that after such great hardships and worldly troubles, mutual conversation might set forth how we fare with one another; and finally, if any matters concerning ecclesiastical causes must be reported, which on account of the snares of the perpetual enemy must always be watched over with pastoral vigilance, we might disclose them through mutual communications. Stirred by these considerations, we have taken care to send the present writings through our brother and fellow bishop Ursicinus, with the grace of salutation going before, praying that, by the help of the Lord, we may endure with great courage the desolation of passing things, and that we ought rather to be genuine, lest, which God forbid, we undergo the loss of eternal life. And therefore, since the welfare of catholic truth demands that this be guarded against, let your belovedness attend to it for a little while.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:23 · narrative
Source · Latin

Apud Græcos, quibus multas hxreses abundare non dubium est, jam ante annos fere quadraginta et quinque de Domini nostri etSalvatoris incarnatione nata conquæstio est: Euiyche qundam presbytero Constantinopolitano in blasphemias prorucute, per quas diceret unam tantummodo, id esi, solam Divinitatis naturam, sive substantiam in D mino Jesu Christo credere nos debere, susceptae carnis veritate prorsus abolita: quod utique improbum commentum Marcionistis, Manichæisque conjunctum, totum sine dubio salutis nostrae solveret sacramentum; siquidem quantum et Scripturæ vencrabilis dicit auctoritas, et majorum testatur doctrina nostrorum, redemptorem mundi Deum, totum simul Deum, totumque hominem ci Maria Yirgine fuisse progenitum. Et huic mundo certum est exstitisse conspicuum, sic passum, atque resurrexisse constat a mortuis. Itaque quadraginta diebus fuisse cum discipulis conversatum, in cœlum ascendisse, plena luce sit clarum, coque modo dictum, ad judicium, angelo testante, venlurum, ut et Filius hominis, quem beatus Stephanus martyr a dextris virtutis Dei vidit astantem, mani. festus appareat, et quem compunxerunt persecutores ejus, aspiciant: quod nimirum sine carnis humanæ non potest constare materia, cujus assumptio glorificata est deitate, non prorsus absumpta. Unde et beatus apostolus Joannes dicit: Qui negat Christum in carne venisse, hic est antichristus (Joan.

English

Among the Greeks, who are undoubtedly abounding in many heresies, a dispute arose almost forty-five years ago concerning the incarnation of our Lord and Savior. A certain Eutyches, a presbyter of Constantinople, burst forth into blasphemies, by which he said that we ought to believe in only one nature, that is, solely the nature or substance of Divinity, in the Lord Jesus Christ, with the truth of the assumed flesh utterly abolished. This wicked fabrication, joined to the Marcionists and Manichaeans, would without doubt dissolve the entire mystery of our salvation. For as both the authority of venerable Scripture declares and the doctrine of our forefathers testifies, the Redeemer of the world, God, was born of the Virgin Mary as wholly God and wholly man at the same time. And it is certain that he was visible to this world, that he so suffered, and it is established that he rose from the dead. Thus it is clear in full light that he conversed with his disciples for forty days, ascended into heaven, and in that manner, as the angel testified, will come to judgment, so that both the Son of Man, whom the blessed martyr Stephen saw standing at the right hand of the power of God, may appear manifest, and those who pierced him may look upon him. This certainly cannot stand without the substance of human flesh, whose assumption was glorified by divinity, not entirely consumed. Therefore the blessed apostle John also says: Whoever denies that Christ has come in the flesh, this is the antichrist (John).

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:24 · narrative
Source · Latin

n); et gloriosus apostolus Paulus qualem hodie credere debeamus Dominum nostrum Jesum Christum palam professus est, dicens: ln quo habitat omnis plenitudo divinitatis corporaliter (Coloss. II), quod brevi capitulo simul Arianam pestem, et hanc quain diximus Eutychianam coelesti prædicatione subvertit, quia et homo nihilominus est, ubi omnis plenaque Divinitas habitare perhibetur, et corporaliter exprimendo, in veritne persistere nostri corporis approbatur.

Super autem his frequenter ab apostolica sede, et per beatæ memoriæ sanctum Leonem, et per succes. sores ejus certum est, Graecos fuisse convictos, sicut ipsorum chartis quas apud nos habemus, sine ambiguitate monstratur. Nunc vero quamvis ipsam pestilentiam non audeant profiteri, eos tamen qui talibrus communicaverint, meritoque secundum Chalcedonensis decret a concilii ab aposlolica sede damnati sunt, obstinatique in eadem damnatione defuncti, pernicioso furore defendunt, et eorum recitationem Ecclesiae catholicæ moliuntur ingerere. Quod utique, quod absit, receptis, etiam contagium pravitatis, cui se communione sociarunt, consequenter incurritur, quemadmodum (quod Dominus avertat!) si Arii vel cujuslibet hæretici ad ecclesiasticam recitationem nomen admittitur, simul et consortium detestabilis erroris assumitur.

English

and the glorious apostle Paul openly professed what sort of Lord Jesus Christ we ought today to believe in, saying: In whom dwells all the fullness of the Godhead bodily (Colossians 2), which in a brief passage at once overturns both the Arian plague and this Eutychian one we have mentioned by heavenly preaching, because he is nonetheless man, where all the full Divinity is said to dwell, and by expressing it bodily, he is shown to persist in the truth of our body.

Moreover, concerning these matters it is certain that the Greeks were frequently convicted by the apostolic see, both through the holy Leo of blessed memory and through his successors, as is shown without ambiguity by their own documents which we have. But now, although they do not dare to profess that pestilence itself, they nevertheless defend with pernicious fury those who communicated in such things and who were rightly condemned by the apostolic see according to the decree of the Council of Chalcedon, and who persisted and died in that same condemnation, and they attempt to force the reading of their names upon the catholic Church. If this is accepted—which God forbid—the contagion of depravity, to which they joined themselves by communion, is consequently incurred, just as (may the Lord avert it!) if the name of Arius or of any heretic is admitted to ecclesiastical reading, at the same time partnership in the detestable error is assumed.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:25 · narrative
Source · Latin

Unde quia errorem quidem fatentur, sed ea sibi putant communonem catholicam conditione laxandam, ut nomina eorum qui prævaricati sunt illis in ecclesia recitare sit licitum, et non tam ipsi corrigerc quam sinceritatem catholicam inficere nitantur contagio perfidorum; dilectionem vestram fraternæ caritatis affectu non destitimus admonere, ut si qui talia seminantes ad vn s'ras regiones forte pervenerint, modis omnibus excludantur, vobisque cum sede beati apostoli Petri, sicut a patribus nostris est tradita illibata communio atque ex omni pirte inconvulsa perduret. Certe si quis aures vestras de hac crediderit subreptione pulsandas, Ilicitudine pastorali ad nos quam citius referre properetis, ut communi studio, catholicoque tractatu, pro domo unius Domini cuncti catholici conferant sacerdotes; ut quæ orthodoxæ definitioni competunt, intemerata serventur; et quatenus errantibus debeat subveniri, rationabili deliberatione noscatur. Hæc autem vestra dilectio etiam ad contiguas si hi quasque provincias vicinosque pontifices prudenter faciat pervenire, ut Ecclesiarum præsules, universæ veritatis instructione percepta, mortiferam declinare valeant falsitatem. Et subscriptio: Deus vos iucolu. mes custodiat, fratres carissimi.

English

Wherefore, since they indeed confess the error, but think that communion with the catholic Church should be relaxed for them on this condition, that it be permitted to recite in the church the names of those who have prevaricated, and they strive not so much to correct themselves as to infect catholic sincerity with the contagion of the faithless, we have not ceased to admonish your Beloved with the affection of brotherly charity, that if any who sow such things should perhaps reach your regions, they be excluded by all means, and that for you the unblemished communion with the see of the blessed apostle Peter, as it was handed down by our fathers, and unshaken in every part, may endure. Certainly, if anyone should believe that your ears are to be assailed by this stealthy intrusion, you should hasten to report it to us as quickly as possible with pastoral solicitude, so that by common study and catholic discussion all catholic priests may confer together for the house of the one Lord; that the things that belong to the orthodox definition may be preserved inviolate; and that it may be known by reasonable deliberation to what extent aid ought to be given to those who err. Moreover, let your Beloved prudently cause these things to reach also the neighboring provinces and neighboring pontiffs, if any such persons are there, so that the prelates of the Churches, having received instruction in the whole truth, may be able to avoid deadly falsehood. And the subscription: God keep you safe, dearest brothers.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:26 · narrative
Source · Latin

EPISTOLA III bis.

BEATI PAPf GELASII AD NATALEM ABBATEM.

Dilectissimo filio Natali abbati Gelasius episcopus. Quamvis pro beati Petri apostoli moderamine divinitus instituto. QUO sedis ejus vicarii cunctis sunt ecclesiis debitores, ad fratres cl coepiscopos meos per Dardaniam constitutos competentia scripta delerimus, antiquæ fidei communionis que tramitem subsequentes, ut cavere valeant contagia perfidorum, al nohiscum illibatum tenere consortium; tamen dilec tionem quoque tuam non destitimus desiderantes affari, cujus sollicitudinem de noxiis quibus' que vitandis, et in retinendis quæ ad utilitatem pertinent Christianam, laudabilem perspeximus esse fervorem, ex litteris scilicet quas ad fratrem et coepiscopum meum Serenum tua caritas destinavit. a Proinde collaborandum sibi tua dilectio perpendit Evangelio Dei, et æternæ salutis intuitum etiam adversantia quaeque tolerando constanter; ut nullum lubeas quod abit, cælestis regni dispendium, ad quod ut'que nisi legitime certaveris, non potes pervenire. Tanto enin, præstante Domino, nobis est instandum vigilandumque, quanto sub ipso fine jam mundi vehementior humani generis hostis insistere non quiescit. Nihil significamus omissum, a quod aut correctioni rerum quas in Ecclesias Orientis seminavit inimicus, Patrum regulis congruentem possit adhibere medicinam. Sed quid facimus?

English

LETTER III bis.

OF BLESSED POPE GELASIUS TO NATALIS THE ABBOT.

Gelasius, bishop, to his most beloved son Natalis the abbot. Although, by the divinely instituted authority of the blessed apostle Peter, inasmuch as the vicars of his see are debtors to all the churches, we have dispatched fitting writings to my brothers and fellow bishops established throughout Dardania, following the path of the ancient faith and communion, so that they may be able to guard against the contagions of the faithless and to keep undefiled fellowship with us; nevertheless we have not failed to address your belovedness also, desiring it, whose solicitude for avoiding harmful things and whose praiseworthy fervor in retaining what pertains to Christian advantage we have perceived from the letters, namely, which your charity sent to my brother and fellow bishop Serenus. Accordingly, your belovedness considers that it must labor together for the Gospel of God, and, with a view to eternal salvation, must endure steadfastly even whatever things are opposed; so that you may not have to undergo any loss of the heavenly kingdom—to which, unless you have striven lawfully, you cannot attain. For, with the Lord granting it, we must press on and keep watch all the more, inasmuch as already under the very end of the world the enemy of the human race does not cease to press more violently. We signify that nothing has been omitted which could apply, in accordance with the rules of the Fathers, a remedy for the correction of the things which the enemy has sown in the churches of the East. But what are we to do?

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:27 · narrative
Source · Latin

quia obduratis auribus vocem refugiunt veritatis audire, lantaque vis morbi sævientis incubuit, ut secum malint salvos quosque lethaliter ægrotare, quam ipsi recipere sanitatem; nunc inficiantes universa quae ipsorum chartis, ipsorum subscriptionibus approbamus; nunc cum manifesta rerum fuerint luce convicti, palam aperteque fatentes errorem, nolle se tamen reverti ad viam puræ confessionis communionisque 3testantur; sed nos potius exspectant suis praevaricatoribus implicari. Quapropter, largiente Christi gratia, magnis studiis est agendum, ut quia de vita perpetua vel amittenda res agitur vel tenenda demus operam quidem, si aliquos ex illis, operant Domino, salvare possimus: alioquin, sicut ait Apostolus, te ipsum castum custodi (I Tim. v, 22). Perire vo'entium nitamur declinare perniciem; et, quod lum facere debeamus, divinam pro illis exorare clementiam, ut resipiscant a diaboli laqueis a quo capli detinentur ab ipsius voluntate: ut ab obstinatione mortifera respirantes, pestem quam se humanitus incidisse etiam ipsi sentiunt, inutili verccundiæ languore deposito, ad recuperandi remedia sempitern i libero corde resipiscant. His ergo cognitis quae sicut diximus ad regionum vestrarum sunt directa pontifices, et ipsi protegente vos Domino debetis esse convenienter instructi, et provinciis cadem quibusque contiguis fiducialiter prædicare.

English

because with hardened ears they shrink from hearing the voice of truth, and such is the force of the raging disease that they would rather that all the sound be lethally sick along with them than that they themselves receive healing; now denying all the things that we prove by their own documents, their own signatures; now, when they have been convicted by the manifest light of facts, openly and plainly confessing the error, yet they testify that they are unwilling to return to the way of pure confession and communion; but they expect us rather to be entangled with their own prevaricators. Wherefore, by the bounty of Christ's grace, we must strive with great zeal, since the matter at stake is either the loss or the keeping of eternal life, to labor, if by the Lord's working we can save some of them; otherwise, as the Apostle says, keep thyself chaste. Let us strive to avoid the destruction of those who wish to perish; and, as we ought to do, to entreat the divine clemency on their behalf, that they may recover their senses from the snares of the devil, by whom they are held captive at his will; so that, breathing again from their deadly obstinacy, they may lay aside the useless languor of shame and with a free heart recover their senses for the remedies of eternal salvation, recognizing the plague that they themselves feel they have incurred in a human manner. Therefore, when these things are known which, as we have said, have been directed to the pontiffs of your regions, you also, with the Lord protecting you, ought to be suitably instructed and confidently proclaim the same things to each of the neighboring provinces.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:28 · narrative
Source · Latin

Nihil est enim quod pavere debeamus, cum certum sit a cœlesti Præsule non derelinqui quos suae vernalis præstitit arma tractare; nec quidquam videamus ci ullatenus præferendum, cum ipsas animas nostras pro earum nos voluerit salute cuntemnere. Qualiter autem vel proficiat ibidem religionis integritas, vel quid forsitan asseratur, saepius nobis vestra dilectio non omittat ostendere; ut necessaria, Christo tribuente, subsidia responsis congruentibus ministremus.

Subscriptio papæ.

Deus te incolumem custodiat, fili dilectissime.

EPISTOLA IV SEU COMMONITORIUM AL FAUSTUM MAGISTUUM FUNGENTEM LEGATIONIS

OFFICIO CONSTASTINOPOLI.

Acacium jure a sede apostolica damnatum, et in excom. municatione mortuum non posse absolvi, et cum illo non communicandum.

Ego quo que mente percepi [al. præcepi] Graecos in sua obstinatione mansuros, nec cui velut insperatum videri potest, quod esl ante [al. in ante] præcognitum. Quapropter non jam propter religionis cauBas student dispositionibus publicis obviare, sed potius per occasionem legationis regiae catholicam fidem moliuntur evertere, et tali commento [al. commercio] nituntur sperata præstare.

English

For there is nothing that we ought to fear, since it is certain that those whom he has granted to wield the arms of his springtime are not abandoned by the heavenly Prelate; nor do we see anything that is in any way to be preferred, since he has willed that we despise our own souls for their salvation. But how the integrity of religion may prosper there, or what perhaps may be asserted, let your belovedness not cease to show us rather often, so that, with Christ granting it, we may minister the necessary aids with fitting responses.

Subscription of the pope.

May God keep you safe, most beloved son.

LETTER IV, OR THE COMMONITORIUM TO FAUSTUS, MAGISTER, SERVING THE OFFICE OF LEGATE AT CONSTANTINOPLE.

That Acacius, rightly condemned by the apostolic see and dead in excommunication, cannot be absolved, and that there is to be no communion with him.

I too have perceived in my mind that the Greeks will remain in their obstinacy, nor can it seem to anyone as unexpected, since it was known beforehand. Wherefore they are no longer eager to oppose public dispositions on account of the cause of religion, but rather through the occasion of the royal legation they strive to overthrow the catholic faith, and by such a device they endeavor to bring about what they hope for.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:29 · narrative
Source · Latin

Quid sibi vult autem quod dixerit imperator, a nobis se in religione damnatum, cum super hac parte et decessor meus non solum minime nomen ejus attigerit, sed insuper quando p: incipia adeptus regiæ potestatis exercuit, in ejus se rescripsit imperii promotione gaudere: et ego nulla ipsius unquam scripta percipiens, honorificis (ut nostis) eum litteris salutare curaverim? Decessores mei, sacerdotes qui prævaricatoribus se commuricasse propria voce confessi sunt, a communione apostolica submoverunt. Si isti [al. ita] placet se miscere damnatis, nobis non potest imputari; si ab eis velit abscedere, tanto magis a nobis non potest esse damnatus, sed pOlitis ad gratiam sinceræ communionis admissus. Ad senatum vero pertinet Romanum, ut memor fidei quam a parentibus se suscepisse meminit, contagia vitet communionis externæ, ne a communione hujus sedis apostolicæ (quod absit) reddatur externus. Veniam sibi dari [al. addit debere] proponunt. Legatur, ex quo est religio Christiana, vel cerie detur eXemplum, in Ecclesia Dei, a quibuslibet pontificibus, ab ipsis apostolis, ab ipso demque Salvatore veniam nisi corrigentibus se fuisse concessam. Auditum autem sub isto cælo nec legitur nmninn, nec dicitur, quod eorum voce depromitur: Date nobis veniam, dum tamen nos in errore duremus. Id quoque pariter [forte leg.

English

But what does it mean that the emperor said he was condemned by us in religion, when in this matter not only did my predecessor not even mention his name, but furthermore, when he had obtained the beginnings of royal power and exercised it, he wrote back that he rejoiced in the promotion of his rule; and I, never having received any writings of his, took care to greet him with honorific letters, as you know? My predecessors removed from apostolic communion those priests who confessed with their own voice that they had communicated with prevaricators. If it pleases these men to mingle with the condemned, it cannot be imputed to us; if he wishes to depart from them, all the more he cannot have been condemned by us, but rather, having been cleansed, admitted to the grace of sincere communion. But it pertains to the Roman senate, mindful of the faith which it remembers it received from its parents, to avoid the contagion of external communion, lest it be made an outsider from the communion of this apostolic see (which God forbid). They propose that pardon should be granted to them. Let it be read, from the time the Christian religion began, or at least let an example be given, in the Church of God, by any pontiffs whatsoever, by the apostles themselves, by the Savior himself finally, that pardon was granted except to those correcting themselves. But under this heaven it is neither read nor said—what is uttered by their voice: Give us pardon, provided that we remain in error. This also likewise...

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:30 · narrative
Source · Latin

par est] osiendant, qui nobis canones nituntur opponcre, quibus hoc canonibus, quibus regulis, qua lectione, quove do. umento, sive majoribus nostris, sive ab ipsis apostolis (quos potiores merito fuisse non dubium est), seu ab ipso Domino Salvatore, qui judicaturus creditur vivos et mortuos, sivc factum est unquam, vel faciendum esse mandatur. Mortuos suscitasse tegimus Christum, in errore mortuos absolvisse non legimus. Et qui certe hoc faciendi solus habuit potestatem, beato Petro principaliter mandat apostolo: Quce ligaveris super terram, ligata erunt et in cælis; et quæ solveris super terram, erunt soluta et in coelis (Matth. XVI). Super terram, inquit; nam in hac ligatione' defunctum nusquan dixit absolvi [al. absolvendum]. Quod ergo nunquam factum est, vel mente concipere formidamus, scientes in divino judicio non posse penitus excusari. Si autem, quod nunc prætendunt, a Romana Ecclesia se sunt divisuri, id jim dudum fecisse monstrantur. a Euphemium vero miror, si ignorantiam suam ipse non perspicit, qui dicit Acacium ab uno non potuisse damnari. Itane non perspicit, secundum formam synodi Chalcedonensis, Acacium fuisse damnatum?

English

It is fitting that they show us, who try to oppose the canons to us, by what canons, by what rules, by what reading, or by what document, whether by our forebears or by the apostles themselves (who beyond doubt were deservedly of greater authority), or by the Lord Savior himself, who is believed to be about to judge the living and the dead, this was ever done, or is commanded to be done. We read that Christ raised the dead; we do not read that he absolved the dead in error. And he who certainly alone had the power to do this, chiefly commanded the blessed apostle Peter: Whatever you bind on earth will be bound also in heaven; and whatever you loose on earth will be loosed also in heaven. On earth, he says; for in this binding he nowhere said that a dead man is absolved. Therefore what was never done, we tremble even to conceive in the mind, knowing that in the divine judgment it cannot be excused at all. But if, as they now pretend, they are going to divide themselves from the Roman Church, they are shown to have already done so long ago. But I am amazed at Euphemius, if he himself does not perceive his own ignorance, who says that Acacius could not be condemned by one man. Does he not perceive that, according to the form of the synod of Chalcedon, Acacius was condemned?

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:31 · narrative
Source · Latin

nec novit eam, aut se nosse dissimulat, in qua utique per numerosam se ntentiam sacerdotum erroris hujus auctores constat fuisse damnatos; sicut in unaquaque hær si a principio Christianæ religionis et factum fuisse, et fieri, manifesta rernm ratione monstratur, decess remque meum exseculorem fuisse veteris constitui, non novæ constitutionis auctorem? Quod non solum præsuli apostolico facere licet, sed cuicunque pont fici, ut quoslibet et quemlibet locum, secundum regulam hæreseos ipsius ante damnatae, a catholica communionc discernant. Acacius quippe non fuitnovi vel proprii inventor crroris, ut in eum nova scita prodirent [al. procederent], sed alieno facinori sua communione se miscuit. Itaque necese est ut in illam recideret justa lance sententiam, quam cum suis successoribus per convenientiam synodalem susceperat auctor erroris. Nobis opponunt canones, dum nesciunt quid loquantur. Contra quos hoc ip o venire se produnt, quod prime sedi, sana rectaque suadenti, parere fugiunt. Ipsi sunt canones, qui appellationes totius Ecclesiæ ad bujus sedis examen voluere deferri. Ab ipsa vero nusquam prorsus appellari debere sanxerunt; ac per hoc illam de tota Ecclesia judicare, ipsam ad nullius commeare judicium, nec de ejus unquam praeceperunt judicio judicari, sententiamque illius constituerunt non oportere dissolvi, cujus potius decreta sequenda mandarunt.

English

Nor does he know it, or he pretends not to know it, in which it is established by the numerous sentence of priests that the authors of this error were condemned; just as in each and every heresy from the beginning of the Christian religion it is shown by clear reasoning that it both was done and is done, that my predecessor was a follower of the old constitution, not the author of a new one? Which not only is it permitted to the apostolic prelate to do, but to any pontiff whatsoever, that they may separate any persons and any place whatsoever from catholic communion, according to the rule of that heresy already condemned. For Acacius was not the inventor of a new or peculiar error, so that new decrees might issue forth against him, but he mixed himself by his communion with another's crime. And so it is necessary that he fall under that justly balanced sentence which the author of the error had received together with his successors through synodal agreement. They oppose the canons to us, while they do not know what they are saying. Against these very canons they betray that they themselves come, in that they flee from obeying the first see, which persuades sound and right things. These are the canons which willed that the appeals of the whole Church be brought to the examination of this see. But they sanctioned that from it no appeal should ever be made at all; and through this, that it judge concerning the whole Church, that it come before no one's judgment, nor did they ever order that it be judged concerning its own judgment, and they established that the sentence of that see ought not to be dissolved, whose decrees rather they commanded to be followed.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:32 · narrative
Source · Latin

In hac ipsa causa Timotheus Alexandrinus, et Pe. trus Antiochenus, Petrus, Paulus, Joannes, et cæteri, non solum unus, sed plures utique nomen sacerdotii præferentes, sola sedis apostolicæ sunt auctoritate dejecti, cujus rei testis etiam ipse docetur Acacius, qui præceptionis hujus exstitit exsecutor. Quod utique sicut apostolicam sedem juxta formam synodicam fecisse manifestum est, sic neminem resultare potuisse certissimum. Hoc igitur modo recidens in consortium damnatorum, est damnatus Acacius, qui eorum damnationem, antequam prævaricator existeret, fuerat exsecutUs. Nobis ausi sunt facere canonum mentionem, contra quos semper ambitionibus illicitis fecisse monstrantur. Qua ipsi synodo, vel secundum cujns synodi formam Alexandrinum Joannem de ecclesia cui ordinatus fuerat expulerunt? qui nullis causis evidentibus nec ante convinci, nec postea provocans, etiam in judicio competenti potuit nccusari. Quod si dicunt: Imperator hoc fecit: hoc i;sum quibus canonibus; quibus regulis est præceptum? Cur huic tam pravo facto consensit Acacius, cum auctoritas divina dicat: Non solum qui faciunt prava reos esse, sed etiam qui consentiunt facientibus (Rom. II). Quibus canonibus quibusve regulis Calendion exclusus est, vel primi urbium diversarum catholici sacerdotes? Qua traditione majorum apo. stolicam dem in judicium vocant?

English

In this very cause Timothy of Alexandria, and Peter of Antioch, Peter, Paul, John, and the rest—not only one, but indeed several bearing the name of priesthood—were deposed by the sole authority of the apostolic see. Of this matter Acacius himself is also shown to be a witness, who was the executor of this decree. And just as it is manifest that the apostolic see did this according to the synodal form, so it is most certain that no one could resist. Therefore in this way, falling back into the fellowship of the condemned, Acacius was condemned, who had been the executor of their condemnation before he became a prevaricator. They have dared to make mention of the canons to us, against which they are shown always to have acted through unlawful ambitions. By what synod, or according to the form of what synod, did they expel John of Alexandria from the church over which he had been ordained? He who, with no evident causes, could neither be convicted beforehand nor afterward, even when appealing, be accused in a competent judgment. But if they say: The emperor did this—by what canons, by what rules was this very thing commanded? Why did Acacius consent to so depraved a deed, when divine authority says: Not only those who do evil are guilty, but also those who consent to those doing it (Rom. 2). By what canons or by what rules was Calendion excluded, or the catholic priests of the first cities of various regions? By what tradition of the ancestors do they summon the apostolic see to judgment?

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:33 · narrative
Source · Latin

An secundae sedis antistites, et tertiæ, cæterique bene sibi concii sacerdotes depelli debuerunt, et qui religionis exstitit inimicus, depelli non debuit? Viderint ergo si alios habent canones quibus suas ineptias exsequantur. Cæterum isti, qui sacri, qui ecclesiastici, qui legi'imi celebrantur, sedem apostolicam ad judicium vocare non possunt; et Constantinopolitanae civitatis episcopus, quæ utique per canones inter sedes nullum nomen accepit, in communionem recidens perfidorum, non debuit submoveri? An, qui homini mentitus dicitur imperatori, et qui imperatorem læsisse perhibentur, depelli debuerunt: et in Deum, qui summus et verus est imperator, Acacium delinquentem, sinceramque communionem divini sacramenti studentem miscere. cum perfidis, secundum synodum, qua hæc est damnata perfidia, non oportebat excludi? Sed verint, nolnt, ipsius judicio antiquæ canonum constitutio. nes firmabuntur.

English

Or should the bishops of the second see, and of the third, and the other priests who rightly agreed with him have been deposed, and he who proved himself an enemy of religion should not have been deposed? Let them see, then, whether they have other canons by which to carry out their absurdities. But those who are celebrated as sacred, ecclesiastical, and legitimate cannot summon the apostolic see to judgment; and should the bishop of the city of Constantinople, which by the canons certainly received no name among the sees, having fallen back into communion with the faithless, not have been removed? Or should those who are said to have lied to the emperor as a man, and those who are reported to have harmed the emperor, have been deposed; and should Acacius, who sinned against God, who is the supreme and true emperor, and who sought to mingle the sincere communion of the divine sacrament with the faithless, not have been excluded according to the synod by which this perfidy was condemned? But whether they wish it or not, the ancient constitution of the canons will be confirmed by his own judgment.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:34 · narrative
Source · Latin

Sed religiosi viri atqne perfecti, secundum canones ncessam sedi apostolicx potestatem nimirum conantur eripere, et sibimet eam contra canones usurpare contendunt. canonum magistros atque cu* stodes! Nobis nullum fas est inire certamen cum hominibus communionis alienae, divina Scriptura prædicante: Hominem hæreticum post primam et secundam correptionem devola,.rien. quod hujusmodi delinquat, proprio judicio condemnatus (Tit. III). Ecce cognoscant quia non solum ab alio, sed a se quoque ipso damnetur [al. prædamnetur] hæreticus. Illud autem nimis est impudens, quod Acacium veniam postulasse confingunt, et nos exstitisse difficiles. Testis est frater vester, filius meus vir illustris Andromachus, qui a nobis abundanter instructus est, ut cohortaretur Acacium deposita obstinatione res!piscere, et ad sedis apostolicae remrare consortium, quique se sub jurejurando magnis cum eodem molitionibus egisse testator, nec ad ea quae recta sunt potuisse deflecti, sicut rerum probatur effectu. Certe proferatur judicium, quando miserit, quando vcniam jostularit, correctionemque suam nobis promiserit exhibendam: nisi forte hunc animum gessit quem success res ejus habere perspicimus, ut tamen si veniam postularet, sic sibi vellet impendi, ut nihilominus in errore persisteret: ubi utique non tam a hobis recipi videretur, quam nos potius in suam traduceret pravitatem.

English

But religious and perfect men, according to the canons, are undoubtedly attempting to snatch away the necessary power of the apostolic see, and they strive to usurp it for themselves against the canons—these masters and guardians of the canons! It is not lawful for us to enter into any contest with men of alien communion, since divine Scripture proclaims: "After a first and second admonition, avoid a heretic, knowing that such a one is condemned by his own judgment" (Tit. 3). Behold, let them recognize that a heretic is condemned not only by another but also by himself. But that is excessively shameless, that they fabricate that Acacius sought pardon and that we proved difficult. Your brother, my son the illustrious Andromachus, is a witness, who was abundantly instructed by us to urge Acacius to lay aside his obstinacy, recover his senses, and return to the fellowship of the apostolic see; and he testifies that he labored with him under oath with great efforts, and that he could not be bent toward what is right, as is proven by the outcome of events. Certainly let the judgment be produced—when he sent, when he sought pardon, and when he promised that he would exhibit his correction to us—unless perhaps he harbored the intention that we perceive his successors to have, namely that if he sought pardon, he would wish it granted to him in such a way that he would nonetheless persist in his error; in which case he would evidently not so much be received by us as rather drag us over into his own depravity.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:35 · narrative
Source · Latin

Quem reatum se confessuros asserunt ante certamen? Si reatus est, otique corrigendus esi. Si corrigendum non putant, fallaciter se reatum perhibent profiteri; nsi, quod est infeHcius, cum et fatentur reatum, et non æstimant corrigendum. Illud quoque me ridere libuit, quod ait: Si necesse fuerit veniam postulare, existitnans nimirum tunc se peccati veniam cessario postulare, si ei concedamus ne peccare desistat; imo etiam (quod absit) com eodem consentiamus nos quoqne peccare. Nescio inter qua mundi prodigia hæc vox possit admitti. Remitti culpa de præterito potest, correctone sine dubio subsequente. Nam si deinceps finitur [al. fingitur] mansura perversitas, non est benignitas remittentis, sed consentientis I assensio [al. assentatio]. Non est mirum, si isti sedem beati Petri apostoli blasphemare præsumunt, qui talia portenta vel corde gerunt, vel ore diffundunt, et nos insuper superbos esse pronuntiant, cum eis prima sedes, quidquid est pietatis, non resistat [al. desinat, vel desistatj offerre, illi eam ipso protervo spiritu subjugare se posse confidant. Sed captos mente facere ista non mirum est. Sic phrenetici solent medicantes quosque [al. quoquej velut hostes putare vel cædere. * Quæro tamen ab his, judicium quod prætendunt, ubinam possit agitari: an apud ipsos, ut iidem sint inimici, et testes, et judices?

English

What guilt do they claim they will confess before the contest? If it is guilt, it must be corrected at once. If they do not think it must be corrected, they falsely claim to profess their guilt—unless, which is more wretched, they both admit the guilt and do not consider it must be corrected. That too I was pleased to laugh at, where he says: If it should be necessary, to ask pardon—thinking, no doubt, that he would then necessarily ask pardon for sin if we grant him that he may cease to sin; indeed even (which God forbid) that we too consent with him to sin. I do not know among what monstrosities of the world this utterance could be admitted. A fault can be remitted for the past, with correction undoubtedly following. For if the perversity is henceforth to continue [or: be feigned] and remain, it is not the kindness of one remitting but the assent [or: flattery] of one consenting. It is no wonder if these men presume to blaspheme the see of the blessed apostle Peter, who bear such portents either in their heart or pour them out with their mouth, and moreover pronounce us proud, when the first see does not resist [or: cease, or desist from] offering them whatever is of piety, while they trust that by their own shameless spirit they can subjugate it to themselves. But it is no wonder that men captured in mind do these things. So the delirious are accustomed to think of or strike at any who treat them as enemies. However, I ask of them: the judgment they pretend, where can it be conducted? Among themselves, so that the same men may be enemies, and witnesses, and judges?

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:36 · narrative
Source · Latin

Sed tali judicio nec humana debent committi negotia, nedum divinae legis integritas. Si quantulA ad religionem pertinet, non nisi apostolicæ sedi juxta canones debetur summa judicii totius; si quantum ad sæculi potestatem, illa a pontificibus, et praecipue a beati Petri vicario, debet cognosci [al. cognoscere], quae divina sunt, non ipsa eadem judicare [al. dijudicare]. Nec sibi hoc quisquam potentissimus saeculi (qui tamen Christianus est) vindicare presumit, nisi religionem forsitan persequens. Quid tamen dicerent, si non chartis suis in omnibus vincerentur? Ineptias itaque suas sibi servent, nisi resipiscant, no. tius cogitantes Christi vocem non esse superfluam, quae confessioni beati Petri apostoli inferni portas nunquam prævalituras asseruit (Matth. XVI). Quapropter non reremur ne apostolica sententia resol. vatur, quam et vox Christi, et majorutn traditio, et canonum fulcit auctoritas, at totam potius Ecclesiam semper ipsa dijudicet. Sed cogitent magis, si quis in eis religionis est sensus, ne pravilatem suamnullatenus deponentes, apud Deum hominesque sedis apostolicæ perpetua constitutione dainuentur. Sic autem dicitur fuisse definitum, ut deinceps de negotio nihil dicatur, quasi vel nunc eos (quemadmodum nostis) meo duxerim nomine specialiter alloquendos. Neque plane cum istis non corrigentibus ineunda congressio, quemadmodum cum aliarum quoque hæ..

English

But neither human affairs ought to be committed to such a judgment, much less the integrity of the divine law. If it pertains in any measure to religion, the supreme judgment of the whole matter is due to the apostolic see alone, according to the canons; if it pertains to the power of the world, those things which are divine ought to be known by the pontiffs, and especially by the vicar of blessed Peter, not for him to judge those same things. Nor does anyone, however powerful in the world (who is nonetheless a Christian), presume to claim this for himself, unless perhaps he is persecuting religion. Yet what would they say, if they were not in all respects to be convicted by their own documents? So let them keep their absurdities to themselves, unless they come to their senses, thinking more carefully that the voice of Christ is not superfluous, which declared that the gates of hell would never prevail against the confession of the blessed apostle Peter (Matthew 16). Wherefore we do not fear that the apostolic sentence may be dissolved, which both the voice of Christ and the tradition of the elders and the authority of the canons support, but rather that it itself always judges the whole Church. But let them consider rather, if there is any sense of religion in them, that by in no way laying aside their depravity, they are condemned before God and men by the perpetual constitution of the apostolic see. But it is said to have been so defined, that hereafter nothing be said about the matter, as if even now I had thought them (as you know) to be addressed specially in my name. Nor, plainly, is a confrontation to be entered into with these men who do not correct themselves, just as with the others also who...

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:37 · narrative
Source · Latin

resum sectatoribus dimicatio renuenda. Vos autem salvos et sospites quautocius huc reverti, continuis Divinitatem votis expetimus

EPISTOLA V.

AD HONORIUM DALMATIÆ EPISCOPUM.

Monet ne Pelagianam hæresim a tot pontificibus detestatam reviviscere sinat.

Dilectissimo fratri Honorio Gelasius.

Licet inter varias temporum difficultates continuis occupationibus implicati, vix respirare valeamus; pro sedis tamen apostolicae moderamine totius ovilis dominici curam sine cessatione tractantes, quae beato Petro Salvatoris ipsius nostri voce delegata est: Et tu conversus confirma fratres tuos (Lue. XXII). Et item: Petre, amas me? face oves meas (Joan. XXI). Dissimulare nec possumus nec debemus, quæ nostram sollicitudinem forma perstringat, cum beato Paulo apostolo sentientes atque dicentes: Quis infirmatur, et ego non infirmor? Quis scandalizatur, et ego non uror (11 Cor. xi)? Ita quippe nos repente tristis, horrenda et vix credibilis confecit opinio, ut mentem nostram confunderet, sauciaret, affligeret. Nuntiatum nobis est enim in regionibus Dalmatiarum, quosdam recidiva Pelagianæ j estis zizania ceuinasse, tantumque i lic eorum prævalere blasphemiam, ut simplices quosque mortiferi furoris insinuatione decipiant.

English

the contest must be refused by the followers of the resumption. But as for you, safe and sound, we beseech the Divinity with unceasing vows that you return hither as quickly as possible.

LETTER V.

TO HONORIUS, BISHOP OF DALMATIA.

He warns him not to allow the Pelagian heresy, detested by so many pontiffs, to revive.

Gelasius to his most beloved brother Honorius.

Although, entangled in the continuous occupations of the various difficulties of the times, we are scarcely able to breathe, yet, in accordance with the governance of the apostolic see, we unceasingly attend to the care of the whole Lord's flock, which was delegated to blessed Peter by the voice of our Savior Himself: And thou, being converted, confirm thy brethren (Luke XXII). And again: Peter, lovest thou me? Feed my sheep (John XXI). Nor can we, nor ought we, to dissemble the matters that touch our solicitude, feeling and saying with the blessed apostle Paul: Who is weak, and I am not weak? Who is scandalized, and I am not burned (2 Cor. XI)? For so suddenly has a sad, horrible, and scarcely credible report consumed us that it confounded, wounded, and afflicted our mind. For it has been announced to us that in the regions of Dalmatia certain persons have sown the tares of the Pelagian heresy, revived again, and that their blasphemy prevails to such an extent that they deceive even the simple by the insinuation of their deadly madness.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:38 · narrative
Source · Latin

Est uidem error ipse nefarius tanto perniciosor ad subripiendum, quanto ad fallendum verisimilitudinis colore versutior: praestante Domino, adest fidei catholicæ pura veritas, concordibus universorum Patrum deprompta sententiis, quæ et subtile virus funestæ pravitatis exponat, et humano generi salvando conferat de Scripturarum confectione medicinam. Nullatenus igitur discretionem rerum nondum abundantia corda conturbet, donec et occultum vulnus apparcat, et salvatio singularis eluceat: quoniam quantalibet arte fallaciæ spiritus perditionis armetur, sancto gladio Spiritus principalis et detegitur et necatur. Quapropter per dilectionem tuam cunet ibidem Domini sacerdotes fraterno commonemus affectu; ut qui cin erudiente vos Domino contra novitios pugre:is errores, oliin perversitatem toto o be damnatam ncc ip os recipere debeatis, aut quod temnere putatur, esse faciendum; quæ non hæresis majoribus nostris convenienter exstincta rarsus provocare nos audeat, et palam novis resumptis vir bus aperteque confligat. Nunquidnam licet nobis a venerandis Patribus damnata dissolvere, et ab illis excisa nefaria dogmata retractare? Quid est ergo quod magnopere præcavemus, ne cujuslibet hæresis semel dejecta pernicies ad examen denuo venire contendat?

English

Indeed that nefarious error itself is all the more pernicious for creeping in, the more cunning it is for deceiving under the color of verisimilitude. By the Lord's provision, the pure truth of the catholic faith is at hand, brought forth by the concordant judgments of all the Fathers, which both exposes the subtle poison of deadly depravity and, from the preparation of the Scriptures, brings medicine for the salvation of the human race. Therefore let not hearts not yet abounding in discernment be disturbed by the distinction of matters, until both the hidden wound appears and the singular salvation shines forth, since however great the art of deceit with which the spirit of perdition is armed, by the holy sword of the principal Spirit it is both uncovered and slain. Wherefore through your love we admonish all the priests of the Lord in that place with brotherly affection, that you who, with the Lord instructing you, fight against newly devised errors, should not receive again the perversity once condemned by all, nor do what is thought to be despised; let not that which was fittingly extinguished by our greater forebears, no heresy, dare to provoke us again, and with new strength resumed, contend openly and in the open. Is it indeed permitted us to dissolve what has been condemned by the venerable Fathers, and to retract the nefarious dogmas cut off by them? What then is it that we so greatly guard against, lest the once-cast-down destruction of any heresy whatsoever strive to come again to examination?

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:39 · narrative
Source · Latin

Si quae antiquitus a nostris majoribus cognita, discussa, refutata, sunt, restauranda nitamur; nonne ipsi nos, quod absit, et quod nunquam catholica patietur Ecclesia, adversariis veritatis universis contra nos resurgendi proponimus exemplum? Ubi est quod scriptum est: Terminos patrum tuorum non transgredieris (Deut. XXXII); et: Interroga patres tuos, et annuntiabunt tibi; et seniores tuos, et dicent tibi? Quid ergo tendimus ultra definita majorum, aut cur nobis non sufficit? Si quid ignorantes discere cupiamus, qualiter ab orthodoxis Patribus et senioribus singula quæque vel vitanda precepta sunt, vel aptanda catholicæ veriiati;cur non hi:; probantur esse decreta? Nunquid aut sapientiores illis sumus, aut poterimus firma stabililate constare, si ea quae ab illis constituta sunt subruamus? An fortasse nescitis hanc hæresim de qua loquitnur, ct ab apostolica dudum sede Der beatæ memoriæ Innocentium, ac deinde Zosimum, Bonifacium, Cœlestinum, Sixtum, Leonem, continuis et incessabilibus sententiis fuisse prostratam; nec; tantum Ecclesiæ catholicæ legibus, sed principum quoque Romanorum eo tenore damnatam, ut nec usquam terrarum vivendi locum sectatores ejus habere sinerentur? Qua: omnia tam gestis Ecclesiae per singulas quasque regiones de eorum pravitate conrectis, quam censuræ publicae sanctionibus edocentur.

English

If we strive to restore those things which were known, discussed, and refuted by our forebears long ago, do we not—God forbid, and may the catholic Church never tolerate it—set ourselves up as an example for all the adversaries of the truth to rise up against us? Where is it that is written: You shall not transgress the boundaries of your fathers; and: Ask your fathers, and they will announce to you; and your elders, and they will tell you? Why then do we strain beyond what has been defined by our forebears, or why does it not suffice for us? If, being ignorant, we wish to learn how each and every thing was either to be avoided or to be adapted to catholic truth by the orthodox Fathers and elders, why are these decrees not approved? Are we wiser than they, or shall we be able to stand firm with stable firmness if we overturn what has been established by them? Or perhaps you do not know that this heresy of which we speak was long ago struck down from the apostolic see by Innocent of blessed memory, and then by Zosimus, Boniface, Celestine, Sixtus, and Leo, with continuous and unceasing pronouncements; and was condemned not only by the laws of the catholic Church but also by the decrees of Roman emperors to such an extent that its followers were not permitted to have a place of dwelling anywhere on earth? All these things are made known both by the acts of the Church, drawn up in each and every region concerning their depravity, and by the sanctions of public censure.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:40 · narrative
Source · Latin

Ecce quorumlibet aures catholicas audire doctrinam quaestiones accipere, tractare tendiculas, et blasphemias patienter admittere. O si studerent adversus eos majorum nostrorum libros responsaque cognoscere, illic modis ommibus cerneretur, nihil esse prorsus, quod non et ab istis fuerit ventilatum, et ab illis magnifica veritate contritum. Sicque de cunctis eorum nequitus refutandis fideles quique redderentur instructi, ut nihil amplius quæreretr. Sed si forsitan ineruditos animos quædam de eorum sensibus proposita commoverent, ita venerabilium Patrum do. ctrinis et omnis eorum publicatur insania, et quibus remediis curelur,ostenditur,ut ex his Deo præstante prævisis, cuncta quæ de eorum serie texuerunt, et periculusa sectantibus et stulta deprehendentibus esse videantur; ita ut si quis existimet reluctandum, non tamen veterum sententiis contradictor existat, scd humanæ saluti, catholicæque doctrinae palam se aperteque profiteatur inimicum; quo magis aiten ius pervigil cura pastorum a sacris gregibus luporum tibet arcere sævitiam. Num quidquid ovibus sanctis acciderit detrimenti, praesulum (quod absit) damnet incuriam; sicut a regeneratis agminibus nocentium depulsio bestiarum custodum præmiis perpetuum procuravit augmentum?

English

Behold, whose ears—anyone's Catholic ears—to hear doctrine, to receive questions, to handle snares, and patiently to admit blasphemies. Oh, if they would strive to learn from the books and answers of our forebears against them, there it would be discerned in every way that there is absolutely nothing which has not both been tossed about by these men and crushed by those with magnificent truth. And so, from all their wickedness to be refuted, all the faithful would be rendered so instructed that they would seek nothing further. But if perhaps certain things put forward from their ideas should disturb unlearned minds, thus by the teachings of the venerable Fathers both all their insanity is made public and by what remedies it is cured is shown, so that from these things, with God providing, being foreseen, all that they have woven from their sequence may appear both perilous to those who follow and foolish to those who discern; so that if anyone thinks resistance must be offered, he may nevertheless not stand as a contradictor of the opinions of the ancients, but may openly and plainly profess himself an enemy of human salvation and of Catholic doctrine; and all the more, therefore, by the vigilant care of shepherds, must the savagery of wolves be kept away from the holy flocks. For whatever harm befalls the holy sheep, let it condemn (God forbid) the negligence of the prelates; just as from the reborn flocks the driving off of harmful beasts has procured perpetual increase for the rewards of the guardians?

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:41 · narrative
Source · Latin

Certe si, ut magis optamus, falsis hæc rumoribus sint relata, quantocius desideramus agnoscere, ut qui membrorum Christi velatione trepidamus, multo magis de eorum stabilita e lætemur. Data v kalendas Augusti, a a Fausto [al. Albino] V. C. consule (anno Christi 493).

EPISTOLA VI

AD EUMDEM HONORIUM DALMATIÆ EPISCOPI.

Eum non debuisse mirari scribit quod admonuerit in vigilandum ne iterum Pelagiana hæresis pullularet.

Dilectissimo fratri Honorio Gelasius.

Miramur dilectionem tuam fuisse miratam, curam sedis apostolicæ, quae more majorum cunctis per mundum debetur Ecclesiis, pro vestrae quoque regionis fide fuisse sollicitam. Cumque ad cam per!atum esset quod quidam per Dalmatias integritatem catholicam vitiare niterentur, et divinis humanisque legibus ante damnatum Pelagianæ pestilentiæ denuo virus inferre; non putaverimus ullatenus differendum quominus hæc diligentius inquirentes, aut si fortasse irrepserant, de proximo sanarentur, aUt anxietatem nostram, si f.dso probarentur jactata, relevarent; æstimantes melius nos videri impatientius talia investigare voluisse, quam crescere dissimulando perniciem. Neque enim vel silentio premere causam hujusmodi, vel differendo fovere deberemus. Cum dicente magistro gentium, sollicitudine non pigri (Rom.

English

Certainly, if—as we more greatly desire—these things have been reported on false rumors, we long to know it as soon as possible, so that we who tremble at the veiling of the members of Christ may rejoice much more over their steadfastness. Given on the fifth day before the Kalends of August, in the consulship of Faustus [otherwise Albinus], a most illustrious man (in the year of Christ 493).

EPISTLE VI

TO THE SAME HONORIUS, BISHOP OF DALMATIA.

He writes that he ought not to have been surprised that he had given warning to be vigilant lest the Pelagian heresy sprout again.

Gelasius to his most beloved brother Honorius.

We are surprised that your Belovedness was surprised that the care of the apostolic see, which by the custom of our forebears is owed to all the churches throughout the world, was solicitous also for the faith of your region. And when it had been reported to it that certain persons throughout Dalmatia were striving to corrupt the Catholic integrity, and to introduce anew the poison of the Pelagian pestilence, already condemned by divine and human laws, we did not think it should be deferred in any way, but that, inquiring into these matters more diligently, either—if perhaps they had crept in—they should be healed at once, or—if what was being thrown about proved false—they should relieve our anxiety; judging that we would better appear to have wished to investigate such matters with too little patience than to let the destruction grow by dissembling. For we ought neither to suppress a cause of this kind in silence nor to foster it by delay. Since, as the teacher of the Gentiles says, "not slothful in solicitude" (Rom.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:42 · narrative
Source · Latin

XII); atque iterum, qui præest in sollicitudine, reos procul dubio nos nisi continuo quaereremus, etiamsi inaniter essent vulgata, convincerent. Nec interest per quos ad aures nostras cadem pervenissent, dum quomodo libet ista referentibus, postquam nostram conscientiarn penetrarent, in his veraciter indagandis pastorales excubias esse non oportuerit negligentes, quatenus vel e vestigio posset lupis inhiantibus obviari, vel nullis existentibus feris, ovium custodia secura persisteret. Ab bis qui essent Chloes, Corinthiorum se dissensiones agnovisse testatur Apostolus (ICor. XIV), confestimque scribere non omittit; ut vel nascentibus jurgiis pius medicator occurreret, vel de corum com perla mox incolumitate gauderet: quod nos quoque litteris quae super hac parte dictæ sunt, indicasse reminiscimur, ut scilicet aut irrepentibus obsisteremus insniiis, aut, si nihil horum penitus accidisset, de cathol cae veritatis integritate lætaremur. Quaprop cr non solum dilectio tua nostra non debet vigilantia permoveri, sed præsentis colloquii salutatione percepta nobiscum potius industriam propriae soci re solertiae, quatenus vel sive tentata sint talia, protinus eorrigantur, vel ne qualibet obreptione tententur, attentius præcavendo subintrare non valeant. De quibus autem ii quos tua caritas destinavit, si plenius instrui voluerint, sequentes tituli cum suis responsionibus intimabunt.

English

and again, he who is in charge in solicitude would undoubtedly convict us as guilty unless we investigated immediately, even if the reports had been spread in vain. Nor does it matter through whom these things reached our ears, since, however they were reported, after they penetrated our conscience, it would not have been fitting for pastoral watchfulness to be negligent in truly investigating them, so that either the ravening wolves might be met at once, or, if there were no wild beasts at all, the guarding of the sheep might continue secure. The Apostle testifies that he learned of the dissensions of the Corinthians from those who were of Chloe (1 Cor 14), and he does not delay to write at once, so that the pious physician might either confront the quarrels as they arose, or soon rejoice in their restored soundness. We also recall that we indicated this in the letters which were spoken on this matter, namely that we should either resist the snares creeping in, or, if none of these things had happened at all, rejoice in the integrity of the catholic truth. Wherefore not only ought your belovedness not to be disturbed by our vigilance, but, having received the greeting of the present address, you should rather join with us in the diligence of your own carefulness, so that either, if such things have been attempted, they may be corrected at once, or, lest they be attempted by any stealth, they may not be able to steal in through more attentive precaution. But concerning those matters about which those whom your charity has sent, if they wish to be more fully instructed, the following headings with their responses will make known.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:43 · narrative
Source · Latin

Et quoniam se his acquiescere præfati eatenus suul professi, ut eadem se et primitus tenuisse firmarent, sed ante ullius in quæstionem vocata vellent manifestius expediri, studuimus quantum inter occupationes fieri potuit, quae nos minime respirare patiuntur, largiente Domino, sequentes paterna, vestigia, de tal bus, quae coepimus non silcre: quam regulam sobrie sentiendi quisquis fideli corde sectatur, inter orthodoxos merito debeat æstimari. Quisquis vero putaverit abnuenda, ab apostolicis sese non ambigat exsulare doctrinis. Certe si quid est quod valeat animum permovere, fraternitas tua consulere fiducialiter omittat, ut Domini gratia ministrante, totius discutiat obscuritatis ambiguum fraterna collatio.

a EPISTOLA VII.

AD OMNES EPiSCOPOS PER PICENUM.

Tria præcipua Pelagianæ hæresis capila refe lit. Pri mum, scilicet parvulos sine originali peccato nas i.

English

And since the aforesaid persons had professed that they acquiesced in these things to such an extent as to affirm that they had held them from the first, but wished that, before any of them was called into question, they might be more clearly set forth, we have endeavored, as much as could be done amid the occupations which scarcely allow us to breathe, with the Lord's bounty, following in the footsteps of the fathers, not to be silent concerning such matters as we have begun: whoever with a faithful heart follows this rule of sober understanding should deservedly be reckoned among the orthodox. But whoever thinks it should be rejected should not doubt that he is exiled from the apostolic teachings. Certainly, if there is anything that can move your mind, let your brotherhood not hesitate to consult with confidence, so that, by the ministry of the Lord's grace, brotherly conference may settle every ambiguity of obscurity.

Letter VII.

To all the bishops throughout Picenum.

He refuted the three chief heads of the Pelagian heresy. First, namely, that little children are born without original sin.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:44 · narrative
Source · Latin

Secundum, hos pro solo peccato originali non dam nari. Tertium, gratiam ad salutem non esse necessa riam, illamque secundum hominum merita conferri.

Gelasius episcopus universis episcopis per Picenum in Domino salutem.

Barbaricis hactenus dolebamus incursibus maxime vicinas Urbi provincias, et bellorum sæva tempestate vastari; sed quantum inter ipsa recentium calamitatum ferventia pericula comperimus, perniciosiorem diabolus Christianorum mentibus labem, quam corparibus hostilis feritas, irrogavit: quod lum principaliter illarum regionum respicit sacerdotes, qui tanta segnitie tantaque ministerii dissimulatione suscepti, commissarum sibi negligunt regimen amo arum, ut eas etiam ab exiguis quibusque bestiolis lacerari sub conspectibus suis impune patiantur: quin... imo subrepentes nequitias confovendo, et depravatoribus acquiescendo fidelium, non solum eas minimo retrahant, sed ipsis praebeant propria nutrimenta perditionis exemplo.

English

Second, that they are not condemned for original sin alone. Third, that grace is not necessary for salvation, and that it is conferred according to men's merits.

Gelasius, bishop, to all the bishops throughout Picenum, greeting in the Lord.

We had hitherto been grieving that the provinces especially near to the City were being laid waste by barbarian incursions and by the savage storm of wars; but as much as we have learned amid the very burning perils of recent calamities, the devil has inflicted a more pernicious stain upon the minds of Christians than the ferocity of the enemy upon their bodies: which chiefly concerns the priests of those regions, who, having undertaken so great a sloth and so great a dissimulation of ministry, neglect the governance of the souls committed to them, so that they allow them to be torn even by any petty little beasts under their own eyes with impunity: nay rather, by fostering the creeping wickednesses and acquiescing to the corrupters of the faithful, they not only fail to draw them back in the least, but even provide them with their own nourishment of perdition by their example.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:45 · narrative
Source · Latin

Quid autem tales essent acturi pontifices, si (quod absit) vel aliqua nova pestis, ea primitus ignorata prorumperer, vel ingeniis acrioribus, sensibusque versutis, aut aliqua sæcularium doctrinarum pcritia callidis, sacrilega blasphemiarum dicta promerentur, qui tam veteris erroris detrita commenta, tamque majoribns Ecclesiarum magistris, quam etiam nostra retate convicta non recolunt nec refutant; atque ab imperitis stultisque prolata non respuunt. Gratias omnipotenti Deo agimus, quoniam suorum corda per hujusmodi personas examinat; qui hoc ipsum virus nesciunt quod loquantur. Nam quid facerent populorum praesules sub astutioribus inimicis, qui se subjiciunt libenter indoctis? Quando utique, etiamsi tanta erat in rectoribus dominici gregis prorsus ignavia, ut ne tam vitem hebetemque personam possint vel intelligere vel frenare, potius pastorali cura debuerint a nobis cognoscenda perquirere, quam suasionibus inconsideranter absurdis, facilem suhmittere voluntatem: ob!atus est enim nobis miserabilis senex Seneca nomine, qui non modo totius est eruditionis alienus, sed ipsius quoque intelligentiæ communis prorsus extraneus9 in Pelagianæ voraginis coeno (sicut de quibusdam in Apocalypsi (Cap. XVI) legimus) velut una ranarum impudenter immersus, inque illa faece horribiliter volutatus.

English

But what would such pontiffs be going to do, if (which God forbid) either some new plague, previously unknown, were to burst forth, or sacrilegious words of blasphemy were to be produced by sharper wits and cunning minds, or by those made crafty through some expertise in secular learning—men who neither recall nor refute the worn-out fabrications of so ancient an error, condemned both by the greater teachers of the Churches and even in our own time, and who do not reject what has been brought forth by the ignorant and foolish? We give thanks to almighty God, because He tests the hearts of His people through persons of this sort, who do not even know the very poison that they speak. For what would the leaders of the peoples do under more cunning enemies, who willingly subject themselves to the unlearned? When indeed, even if there were such utter sloth in the rulers of the Lord's flock that they could neither understand nor restrain so vile and dull a person, they ought rather, out of pastoral care, to have sought from us the things that must be known, than to submit their ready will to recklessly absurd persuasions. For there has been brought before us a pitiable old man by the name of Seneca, who is not only a stranger to all learning, but utterly devoid of even common understanding, shamelessly immersed in the mire of the Pelagian abyss (as we read of certain ones in the Apocalypse, chapter 16) like one of the frogs, and horribly wallowing in that dregs.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:46 · narrative
Source · Latin

nullatenus inde qualiter emergerc posset inveniens; quia puritatem relinquens catholicæ veritatis, quanto se per lubri cum falsitatis conatur attollere, tanto magis ejus lu tosis foveis circumclusus obruitur, de illis unus evistens, de quibus Petrus dicitaposlolus: Hi vero velut irra ionabilia pecora, naturaliter in captionem et in perniciem in his quæ ignorant blasphemantes in corruptione sua, peribunt percipientes mercedem injustitiæ (II Petr. n). Uevera enim sic ejns stolidus et obtusus est animus, ut de his venenis, quae male hausit, et vomuit, nullam rationem vel accipere valeat omnino, vel reddere. Sed induratus obcaecatione diabolica, sibique jam traditus, cordis sui funesta sit obslinatione damnatus; nihilque supersit ei, nisi ut Deus noster, qui dixit, quæ hominibus impossibilia videntur, apud se esse facilia (Matth. xix), hujusmodi mentem potenti compunctione transfigat, ut secundum beatum apostolum Paulum, resipiscat a diaboli laqueis, quibus captivus detinetur (II Tim. II) sententia diviui judicii. Multa illi quæ de Pelagianis sensibus nec in somnis omnino contigerant, nos magis patefacta prodidimus ea, quæ dudum convicta fuisse monstravimus.

English

Finding no way at all by which he could emerge from it, because, abandoning the purity of the catholic truth, the more he tries to raise himself up through the slippery mire of falsehood, the more he is overwhelmed, enclosed in its filthy pits, being one of those of whom the apostle Peter says: But these, like irrational beasts, naturally born for capture and destruction, blaspheming in those things which they do not know, will perish in their own corruption, receiving the reward of injustice (2 Peter 2). For truly his mind is so stupid and dull that concerning these poisons, which he has wickedly drunk and vomited forth, he is wholly unable either to receive or to give any account. But hardened by diabolical blindness, and now handed over to himself, he is condemned by the deadly obstinacy of his own heart; and nothing remains for him, except that our God, who said that the things which seem impossible to men are easy with him (Matthew 19), may transform a mind of this sort by a powerful compunction, so that, according to the blessed apostle Paul, he may come to his senses and escape from the snares of the devil, by which he is held captive (2 Timothy 2), by the sentence of divine judgment. Many things concerning the Pelagian opinions which had not come to him even in dreams, we have rather brought forward and made manifest, those things which we have shown were long ago refuted.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:47 · narrative
Source · Latin

Hæc etiam ipsa, quæ idem proferre videbatur, olim et ab hæreticis Pelagianis in medium producta docuimus, et a catholicis praedicatoribus competenter elisa.Pelagium, Coelestium, Julianum, caeterosque complures oratoriæ facundiæ viros in hac assertione probavimus fuisse convictos, et tam ecclesiasticis contitutis quam imperialibus etiam percussos fuisse præcepiis; proinde istum ferre non posse firmavimus, in quibus illi tales tantiq ue prostrati sunt, qui nec ipsa, quæ ab illis sunt disputata, vel intellecta capere, vel eloquio simili possit astruere. Sed, ut dictum est, diabolica mens inspiratione possessa, in profundum veniens jam malorum ad remedia nulla consentit (Prov. XVIII). Quapropter de innumeris blaspbemiarum generibus quas auctores Pelag anæ hæresis addiderunt, tria, quæ sibi præcipue hic senex lugendus ascivit, credidimus non tacenda, ut reserata manifestius panderentur, et Deo destrunte facilius viderentur eversa. lu uter is, inquiunt, matrum opere divino creantur infante, propterea jusium videri non putant qu factura Dei sine ullis propriis actionibus cuiquam peccato gignatur obstricta; injustumque Deum faciunt, si rci efficiantur antequam nati.

English

We have shown that these very things which he seemed to bring forward were long ago produced by the Pelagian heretics and competently struck down by catholic preachers. We have proved that Pelagius, Coelestius, Julianus, and several other men of forceful oratorical eloquence were convicted in this assertion, and we have decreed that they were struck down by both ecclesiastical and imperial ordinances; and accordingly we have affirmed that this man cannot endure the things in which such great men were laid low, since he can neither grasp with understanding the very things that were disputed by them nor set them forth with similar eloquence. But, as has been said, a mind possessed by diabolical inspiration, coming into the depth of evils, now consents to no remedies (Prov. 18). Wherefore, out of the countless kinds of blasphemies that the authors of the Pelagian heresy have added, we believed that three, which this lamentable old man has especially adopted for himself, must not be passed over in silence, so that, once disclosed, they might be set forth more plainly and, with God overthrowing them, might more easily be seen to have been destroyed. For they say that infants are created by the divine work of mothers, and therefore they do not think it seems just that the handiwork of God, without any actions of its own, should be born bound to any sin; and they make God unjust, if they are made guilty before they are born.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:48 · narrative
Source · Latin

lloc velut acutissimum sui dogmatis exerunt argumentum, non advertentes quia primi illi parentes generis humani de nullis utique genitoribus, sed de innoxia limi materia procreati, et pure atque sincere potenter arte divina compacti, factique rationales, propria voluntate seductorem secuti diabolum, pravis cupiditatibus per excessum prævaricationis infecti sunt. In quibus utique humana natura peccavit, et humana est facta natura vitiosa, receptrix sine dubio mali quod ante nescierat, quæ a bono rectoque deiiciens in affectum mali pravique recidere ipso rerum consequentium tramite manifestum est. Tales igitur effecti principes nostræ substantiæ, semetipsos passibiles et corruptibiles reddiderunt; in tantum conditionis divinæ dona violantes, ut mortis fuerint ultione puniti. Hac enim die fuisso mortuos qua mortales effecti sunt, ambiguum non habetur: proinde quidquid isti genitores de sUo ger. mine protulerunt, opus quidem Dei est, secundum institutionem naturae; sed non absque contagio illius mali, quod sua prævaricatione traxerunt: et utique hoc idcm ipsius mali contagium, certum est opus non esse divinum.

English

They put forward this point as though it were the sharpest argument of their dogma, not noticing that those first parents of the human race, begotten certainly from no parents but produced from the harmless matter of clay, and powerfully fashioned by divine art purely and sincerely, and made rational, followed the seducer the devil by their own will, and were infected with depraved desires through the transgression of their sin. In them, certainly, human nature sinned, and human nature was made vicious, undoubtedly a receiver of the evil it had not known before, which, falling away from the good and the right, manifestly sank back into an affection for evil and depravity by the very course of consequent events. Having thus become such, the founders of our substance made themselves passible and corruptible; to such an extent did they violate the gifts of the divine condition that they were punished by the vengeance of death. For there is no doubt that on the day they were made mortal, they died. Accordingly, whatever those parents produced from their own seed is indeed the work of God, according to the institution of nature, but not without the contagion of that evil which they drew upon themselves by their transgression; and certainly this same contagion of evil is assuredly not a divine work.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:49 · narrative
Source · Latin

Itaque non ex creatione Dei est vitium quod voluntario motu natura collegit; sed etiam de vitiata per semetipsam natura Deus institutionem suam quidem suae creationis exsequitur; sed creatio profert vitium, quod non ex Institutione Creatoris accepit, sed quod ipsa per lapsurn transgressionis sua assumpsit. Nam si ipsi primi homines ex nullis, ut dictum est, parentibus nati, et sine ullo formati contagio, per amibitum præsumptionis illicitæ semetipsos depravare potuerunt, et in opere Dei opus diabolicæ fraudis adnectere, quid mirum si iidem depravati protulerunt sobolem depravatam? Nonne etiam cum Deus utique liberam condiderit humanam sua creatione substantiam, etiam apud humanas tamen leges extrinsecus accedens servitus naturaliter eam reddit obstrictam et obnoxiam? Origine generantur obnoxii, et ex conditione servili gignuntur addicti; et nascendo fiunt prius obligati quam geniti: si hoc agitur de rebus extra naturam positis, quanto magis de his provenire non mirum est, quibus ipsa humana substantia depravata cognoscitur? ac per hoc sicut te ipsa humana substantia de institutione sincera actuum reproborum rea fecit voluntate pollutam, sic edidit sobolem atque progenicm naturae suae ex actuum suorum rea voluntate maculosam; quia hujusmodi genuit prolem, cujusmodi se ipsa reddidit prævaricationis excessu.

English

Therefore the fault is not from God's creation, which nature contracted by its own voluntary movement; but even from a nature corrupted through itself, God indeed carries out the institution of His own creation; but the creation brings forth a fault which it did not receive from the Creator's institution, but which it itself assumed through the fall of transgression. For if those first men, born as has been said from no parents, and formed without any contagion, were able by the ambition of unlawful presumption to deprave themselves, and to attach to God's work the work of diabolical fraud, what wonder if the same depraved men brought forth depraved offspring? Is it not also the case that, although God by His creation made human substance free, yet even under human laws an externally imposed servitude naturally renders it bound and liable? By origin they are born liable, and from a servile condition they are begotten as enslaved; and by being born they become obligated before they are begotten: if this is done in matters placed outside nature, how much more is it not wonderful that it comes about in those things in which human substance itself is known to be depraved? And accordingly, just as human substance itself, from its sincere institution, made you guilty by the polluted will of wicked acts, so it brought forth offspring and progeny spotted by the guilty will of its own acts, because it begot a child of the same kind as it made itself through the excess of transgression.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:50 · narrative
Source · Latin

Ideoque non solum de se profert quod bene Deus institut, sed etiam quod male ipsa inconsequenter adjecit. Quemadmodum autem qualitas interior appetendi valet immutare naturam, divinae lectionis auctoritate firmatur. Sic denique pascente Jacob (Genes. xxx), commissus ille grex ovium, supposita canalibus varietate virgarum, dum potat, illectus affectionali delectatione, concepit, quod non habuit in natura, et molitum sensibus transfundit in prolem quod in crcatione non sumpsit. Quod tune utique figuraliter gestum, et in ecclesiasticis significavit gregibus hoc futurum, et Pelagianorum Deus prævidens calumnias, et excitandas fidelibus suis decertationes intelligentiam praeparavit. Docent divina testimonia, et ipsa ecclesiastica sacramenta, ct ab ipso Domino Salvatore catholicorum traditio magistrorum humanæ generationis decolorata primordia. Hinc est quod clamat propheta: Quis gloriabitur castum II habere cor, aut mundum esse a peccatis? nec infans, cujus est unius diei vita super terram (Job xiv). Hi:nc cst quod irem dicit Scriptura: Q uis potest facere mundum de immundo conceptum semine? nonne tu qui solus es? et alibi: Quia semen, inquit, erat malcdictum (Sap. XII); nec non etiam David propheta testatur. In iniquitatibus conceptussum, et in delictis peperit me mater mea (Ps. L). Et si hoc ille dicit, quis aliter se asserat procreatum?

English

And therefore she brings forth not only what God established well, but also what she herself inconsistently added evilly. But that the inner quality of desiring is able to change nature is confirmed by the authority of divine reading. Thus, when Jacob was pasturing (Genesis 30), that flock of sheep entrusted to him, with a variety of rods placed in the channels, while drinking, enticed by an affective delight, conceived what it did not have in nature, and, having brought it forth through the senses, passed on to its offspring what it did not receive in creation. What was then certainly done figuratively both signified that this would happen in the flocks of the Church, and God, foreseeing the calumnies of the Pelagians and the disputes to be stirred up for His faithful, prepared understanding. The divine testimonies and the ecclesiastical sacraments themselves teach, and the tradition of catholic teachers from the Lord Savior Himself teaches, the discolored beginnings of human generation. Hence it is that the prophet cries out: Who will boast that he has a pure heart, or that he is clean from sins? Not even an infant whose life is one day upon the earth (Job 14). Hence it is that Scripture also says: Who can make clean one conceived from unclean seed? Is it not you, who alone are? And elsewhere: Because their seed, it says, was accursed (Wisdom 12); and David the prophet also testifies: In iniquities I was conceived, and in sins my mother bore me (Psalm 50). And if he says this, who would claim he was begotten otherwise?

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:51 · narrative
Source · Latin

Beatus quoque apostolus Paulus asserit: Et nos aliquando eramus natura filii iræ sicut et cæteri (Ephes. VIII). De qua ira in Evangelio dicit: Qui crediderit, et baptizatus fuerit, habebit vitam æternam; qui autem non crediderit, jam judicatus est, et iTa Dei manet super eum (Joan. III). Illa utique, de qua dictum est: Morte morieris (Gen. II), ipsc Dominus Jesus Christus cælesti voce pronuntiat: Qui noti manducaverit carnem Filii hominis et biberit sanguinem ejus, non habebit vitam in semetipsum (Joan. vi), ubi utique neminem videmus exceptum; nec ausus eat aliquis dicere, parvuluin sine hoc sacramento salutari ad æternam vitam posse perduci; sine illa autem vita, in perpetua futurum morte non dubium est. Cur igitur infans hac sorte concluditur, si nullum habet omnino peccatum? magisque videbitur (quod absit) injustus Deus, si illic infligatur poena, ubi nulla sit culpa. Unde cum de propriis actibus nullo reatu teneatur obstrictus, nihil restat nisi ut sola sit vitiosa nativitate pollutus; et si non fuerit mysterii Christiani participatione mundatus, ad vitam non potest pervenire perpetuam. Hinc est quod exsufflantur et catechizantur infantes; et quia in opere Dei, quod in auctore suo bene sunt instituti, opus diabolicæ malignitatis accessit, eruti de potestate tenebrarum (Coloss, I), sicut docet Apostolus, ad Filii Dei sortem, purgationemque legitimam transferuntur.

English

The blessed apostle Paul also asserts: And we were once by nature children of wrath, just as the rest (Eph. 2). Concerning this wrath, the Gospel says: Whoever believes and is baptized will have eternal life; but whoever does not believe is already judged, and the wrath of God remains upon him (John 3). That wrath, certainly, of which it was said: You shall die the death (Gen. 2), the Lord Jesus Christ himself declares with a heavenly voice: Whoever does not eat the flesh of the Son of Man and drink his blood will not have life in himself (John 6), where surely we see no one excepted; nor has anyone dared to say that a little child can be brought to eternal life without this saving sacrament; but without that life, it is beyond doubt that he will be in perpetual death. Why, then, is an infant consigned to this lot, if he has no sin at all? And God would seem (which be far from us) rather unjust, if punishment is inflicted where there is no guilt. Hence, since he is bound by no guilt from his own acts, nothing remains but that he is polluted by his sinful birth alone; and if he has not been cleansed by participation in the Christian mystery, he cannot arrive at eternal life. This is why infants are exsufflated and catechized; and because in God's work—that they were well established in their author—the work of diabolical malice has entered, having been snatched from the power of darkness (Col. 1), as the Apostle teaches, they are transferred to the lot of the Son of God and to legitimate purification.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:52 · narrative
Source · Latin

Nisi autem prima generatio, quam bonam Deus instituit, prævaricatione veuisset iu culpam, et reprobabilis esset effecta; secunda generatio subroganda non fuerat: propter quod dicit beatus Paulus apostolus: Sicut per unum hominem peccatum intravit in mundum, et per peccatum mors: et Ita in omnes homines pertransiit in quo omnes peccaverunt; et paulo post: Igitur sicut pcr unius delictum in omnes homines in condemnationem, sicet per unius justitiam in omnes homines in justificationem vitæ (Rom. V).

Sicut autem omnes in condemnationem dicit, utique qui de Adam parente sunt geniti, sic omnes in justificationem vitæ non nisi illos astruit, qui in Christi mysterio sunt. renati. Innumeris talibus instrumentis hæresis Pelagianæ doctrina mortifera, et a nostris est convicta majoribus, et nunc eorum copiosa potest eruditione convinci; ncc debent simplices animos ista turbare, quibus quae non intelligunt secundum ecclesiasticam formam credidisse sufficiet, aut si quis nosse desiderat, interrogare conveniet.

English

But if the first generation, which God established as good, had not turned aside into fault by transgression and been made reprobate, a second generation would not have had to be substituted. For this reason the blessed apostle Paul says: Just as through one man sin entered into the world, and through sin death, and so it passed into all men, in that all sinned; and a little later: Therefore, just as through the offense of one man it came to all men unto condemnation, so also through the righteousness of one man it comes to all men unto justification of life (Rom. 5).

But just as he says all unto condemnation, namely those born of the parent Adam, so he asserts all unto justification of life to be none other than those who are reborn in the mystery of Christ. By countless testimonies of this kind the deadly doctrine of the Pelagian heresy has been refuted by our forefathers, and can now be refuted by their abundant learning; nor ought these things to disturb simple minds, for whom it will be sufficient to have believed according to the ecclesiastical form those things which they do not understand, or if anyone desires to know, it will be proper for him to ask.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:53 · narrative
Source · Latin

De parvulis autem, quod asserit sine sacro bapt smate pio solo originali peccatu non posse damnari, satis impia, sat profaua propositio est; quamvis enim receutesab ulero matruui iu remissionem peccatorum baptizari nullus Christianus ignorat, quod utique non fallaciter, sed vcraciter catholica celebrat Ecclesia, nein sacramentis coelestibus ( quod absit) mentita videatur; proinde quia propria non habeant ulla peccata, constat ejus [al. cis] sola prorsus originalia relaxari. Itaque omnibus etiam solis rcmissis vitam per baptismum consequuntur æternam; consequens ett ut solis etiam non remissis, ad æternam vitam pervenire non possint, Unde et Dominus, sicut superius diximus, ait (quod utique nisi baptizar a non convenit): Qui non manduca erit carnem Fi ii hominis, et biberit sanguinem ejus, non habebit vitam in semetipso (Joan. VI); sine vita autem esse perpetua quid est nisi in sempiterna morte constituit? quamvis idem sit regnum coelorum quod alterna vita, tamen, ut providentia Dei omnes Pelagianorum nequitias amputaret, non solum dictum est: Qui non fuerit renatus ex aqua et Spiritu sancto non intrabit in regnum coelorum (Joan. III); sed etiam pariter dictum est: Qui non manducaverit carnem Filii hominis, et biberit sanguinem ejus, non habebit vitam in semetipso.

English

But as for infants, the claim that without holy baptism they cannot be condemned on account of original sin alone, is a sufficiently impious and sufficiently profane proposition. For although no Christian is ignorant that infants are baptized for the remission of sins, which the catholic Church certainly celebrates not falsely but truthfully, lest in the heavenly sacraments (which God forbid) she be seen to have lied; therefore, since they have no sins of their own, it is evident that only original sins are wholly remitted to them. And so, when these alone are remitted, they obtain eternal life through baptism; it follows that when these alone are not remitted, they cannot arrive at eternal life. Whence also the Lord, as we said above, says (which certainly does not apply except to the baptized): He who does not eat the flesh of the Son of Man and drink his blood will not have life in himself (John 6). But to be without life is nothing other than to be established in everlasting death. Although the kingdom of heaven is the same as eternal life, nevertheless, so that the providence of God might cut off all the wickedness of the Pelagians, it was not only said: Unless one is born again of water and the Holy Spirit, he will not enter the kingdom of heaven (John 3); but it was likewise also said: He who does not eat the flesh of the Son of Man and drink his blood will not have life in himself.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:54 · narrative
Source · Latin

De vita autem aeterna hoc dictum nullus addubitat; quoniam multi non manducantes hoc sacramentum, vitam habere videantur praesentem.

Nibil est ergo quod dicant, quod non renati infanles, tantummodo in regnum coelorum ire non VIleant; non autem perpetua damnatione puniantur, dum sine baptismate corpus et sanguiucm Christi nec edere valeant, nec potare: sine autem hoc vitam in semclipsis habere non possent, sine vita vero non nisi mortui sint futuri. Dicant [al. Dican ur] igitur in morte perpetua constituti, si non æstimentur esse damnati: tollant ergo de medio nescio quem ipsi tertium, quem decipiendis parvulis faciant locurn. Et quia non nisi dextram partem legimus et sinistram, non illos faciant in sinistra regione sine baptismate remanere, sed baptizatos sinant ad dexteram salutarem sacra regeneratione transferri.

English

But concerning eternal life, no one doubts this statement, since many who do not eat this sacrament appear to have the present life.

There is therefore nothing they can say: that infants who are not reborn only cannot enter the kingdom of heaven, but are not punished with perpetual damnation, since without baptism they can neither eat nor drink the body and blood of Christ; but without this they could not have life in themselves, and without life they can only be destined to death. Let them say, therefore, that those established in perpetual death are not considered damned; let them then remove from the midst that third place of I know not what sort, which they make a place for deceiving little ones. And since we read of no part but the right and the left, let them not make those who remain without baptism in the left region, but let them allow the baptized to be transferred to the right hand of salvation by the sacred regeneration.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:55 · narrative
Source · Latin

Tertio capitulo jam toto mundo cognita, atque convicta Pelagianorum deliramenta circumferre, quibus dicunt, quod homo liberum arbitrium, quod corrupit, foedavit ac perdidit, bono suffragante naturae beatus efficiatur, cum de beatitudine paradisi, ubi na fuerat constituta substantia, nisi suo amisso bono nullatenus potuisset expelli, unde mortalis effecta, quia de bono utique prævaricatione transisset ad malum; et a participatione divina ad diabolica semet facinera contulisset: ideo deceptori suo, cui volens assenserat, competenter addictus, ideo de felicitatis suæ carimate seclusus, atque ad spinas ct tribulos, miseriasque multipl ces cœlesti voce damnatus est; quæ utique poena justi judicii tam gravis et aspera in bono perseveranti nullatenus esset inflicta; et nisi malo non convenienter illata probaretur. Ecce sine divino suffragio, quod in illa beatitudine positus nunquam legitur expetisse: non solum homini naturale bonum prodesse non potuit, non solum non effecit be tum; sed cum hoc solo confidit, atque ad ejus non revertitur largilorem, et beatitudinem potius amisii, et malorum omnium sumpsit exordium. Quod autem libero arbitrio bellitudinem consequantur, quo male usus in perpetuam recidit servitutem, sicut scriptum cst: Qui facit peccatum, servus est peccati (Joan. II, 54): a quo quis superatur, huic et servus addicitur.

English

In the third chapter, the deliriums of the Pelagians, already known and convicted throughout the whole world, are being circulated, in which they say that man, by the good support of nature, is made blessed by the free will that he corrupted, defiled, and lost—since from the blessedness of paradise, where his substance had been established, he could by no means have been expelled unless he had lost his own good; whence he became mortal, because he had passed from good to evil by transgression, and had betaken himself from participation in the divine to diabolical crimes. Therefore he was fittingly consigned to his deceiver, to whom he had willingly assented; therefore he was shut out from the charism of his own felicity, and was condemned by the heavenly voice to thorns and thistles and manifold miseries. Surely such a heavy and harsh penalty of just judgment would by no means have been inflicted on one persevering in good, and it is proven that it was not fittingly imposed except on one who was evil. Behold, without divine support, which, placed in that blessedness, he is never read to have sought: not only could natural good not profit man, not only did it not make him blessed, but when he trusted in this alone and did not return to its more generous giver, he both lost blessedness and took on the beginning of all evils. But that they attain blessedness by free will—which, when he used it badly, fell back into perpetual slavery, as it is written: Whoever commits sin is a slave of sin (John 8:34)—by whatever one is overcome, to that one he is also consigned as a slave.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:56 · narrative
Source · Latin

Nonne hæc esi illa præsumptio naturalis quæ ad detestandæ captivi. tatis jura descendit, quam Scriptura sancta sic memorat: Grave jugum super filio. Adam a die exitus de ventre matris eorum usque in diem sepulturæ in matrem omnium (Eccles. XL); de qua genus humanum non nisi solus Dominus noster Jesus Chritus commercio suae redemit passionis, et mutata nativitate nos eruit? Solus utique venit quærere, et salvare quod perierat (Matth. XVIII), ut libertas, quæ per temerariam fuerat dejecta superbiam, instauretur reparata per gratiam; mutuaque vice humanæ voluntatis arbitrium, sicut sequendo diabolum, captivitatem meruerat sempiternam, sic reformatae subsequendo libertatis auctorem, amissum rediret ad præmium. Hinc est quod ipse Dominus ait: Cum vos Filius Iiveraverit, tunc vere liberi eritis. Et apostolus beatus Paulus exsequitur: Cum servi essetis peccati, liberi fuistis justitiæ, id est alieni a justitia, liberati autem a peccato, servi facti estis justitiæ (Rom. VI); et iterum idem ipse: Libertatem, inquit, qua vos Christus liberavit (Galat. v?. Nonne ipse vas clectionis affirmat, et dicit: Deus est qui operatur in vobis et velle et perficere pro bona volentate (Philip. II)? ne etiam in mala voluntate, et velle et perficere Deus lutaretur operari.

English

Is this not that natural presumption which descends to the laws of a detestable captivity, which Holy Scripture thus records: A heavy yoke upon the son of Adam, from the day of his coming forth from his mother's womb until the day of his burial in the mother of all; from which the human race was redeemed by no one except our Lord Jesus Christ alone through the commerce of His passion, and He rescued us by a changed birth? He alone certainly came to seek and to save what had perished, so that the freedom which had been cast down through reckless pride might be restored, repaired through grace; and in turn the free choice of human will, just as by following the devil it had merited eternal captivity, so by following the author of restored freedom it might return to the reward it had lost. Hence it is that the Lord Himself says: When the Son has set you free, then you will truly be free. And the blessed apostle Paul continues: When you were slaves of sin, you were free from righteousness, that is, strangers to righteousness; but having been freed from sin, you became slaves of righteousness; and again the same man says: The freedom with which Christ has freed you. Does not he who is a vessel of election himself affirm and say: It is God who works in you both to will and to accomplish for good will? lest even in evil will God should be thought to work both to will and to accomplish.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:57 · narrative
Source · Latin

Illud autem Pelagianorum peculiare virus est, olimque detritum, quo putant graliam Dei secundum merita hominum posse conferri, quod absit a mentibus Christianis, cum testetur Apostolus: Gratia est quæ gratis datur; alioquin si ex operibus gratia, jam non est gratia (Rom. XI), quia merces redditur non gratis, unde gratia nomen accepit impenditur. Quis autem audeat dicere Christianus, aliquid habere boni sine gratia, quando magister gentium clamat, cuncta breviter in se dona concludens: Gratia Dei sum id quod sum, et gratia ejus in me vacua non fuit ( I Cor XV); ut oslendereL quia donum gratiæ non ipse præ. cesserit, sed fuerit subsecutus; atque monstraret cooperatotem se esse graiix subsequendo: sed plus omnibus, inquit, illis laboravi (Ibidem). Ac rursus veritus ne de se præsumere videretur, adjunxit: non ego, sed gratia Dei mecum. Non diixit: ego et gratia Dei mecum; sed præposuit gratiam præcedentem se, atque subjunxit. Quid autem haberi possit sine gratia, cum sit fides ipsa per gratiam; eodem apostolo nos docente: Misericordiam consecutus sum, ut fidelis essem (1 Tim. I). Nec aliud est misericordia divina quam gratia. Audiamus etiam quemadmodum informat Ecclesiam: Gratia, inquit, salvi facti estis per fidem (Ephes.

English

But that is the peculiar and long-worn poison of the Pelagians, by which they think that the grace of God can be conferred according to the merits of men—which be far from Christian minds—since the Apostle testifies: Grace is that which is given freely; otherwise if grace is from works, it is now not grace (Rom. 11), because a wage is rendered not freely, whence it receives the name of grace when it is bestowed. But who among Christians would dare to say that he has anything good without grace, when the teacher of the Gentiles cries out, briefly summing up all the gifts in himself: By the grace of God I am what I am, and his grace in me was not in vain (1 Cor. 15); to show that the gift of grace did not come first from himself, but followed after; and to demonstrate that he was a co-worker of grace by following after: but I labored more than all of them, he says (Ibidem). And again, fearing lest he seem to presume of himself, he added: not I, but the grace of God with me. He did not say: I and the grace of God with me; but he placed grace before him as preceding, and then joined himself. But what can be had without grace, when faith itself is through grace, as the same apostle teaches us: I obtained mercy, that I might be faithful (1 Tim. 1). Nor is divine mercy anything other than grace. Let us hear also how he instructs the Church: By grace, he says, you are saved through faith (Eph.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:58 · narrative
Source · Latin

II); ut principium salutis et fidei a gratia coepisse dissereret, sicut secutus adnectit: Et hoc non ex vobis, sed Dei donum est; non ex operibus, ne quis extollatur (Ibid.). Idem ipse alibi generaliter et absolute pronuntiat, dicens: Quid enim habes quod non accepisti? Aut si accepisti, quid gloriaris quasi non acceperis (1 Cor. IV)? Quia sufficiet singula recensere? quibus evidenter apparet, non naturalis libertatis arbitrium gratiam promereri, sed potius gratiam recipere, ut a servitute, quam peccando neruerat, misericorditer absolutum esset, Hujus sacramenti redemptione ante mundi principium sempiterna providentia præparati, sive nondum prolata lege, seu sub observatione legali. figuralibus signis atque sacrificiis omnium sanctorumvirorumfeminarumque sanctarum vetus origo mundata est, universisque justes per gratiae spiritum hoc de longe adorando mysterio salutis æternæ remedia contigerunt, cujus in Christo manifestata gentibus plenitudo, mundum purgat, et renovat, beatitudinisque perpetuae vere facit esse participes. Quapropter nimis incusamus fratres et coepiscopos nostros, maxime per Piceni provincias Ecclesiam Domini gubernantes, qui non solum ineptissimi senis, abjectæque personæ pravum non deterruere colloquium, verum et suo nutrivere consensu. Quis audiat?

English

that the beginning of salvation and of faith came from grace, as he adds next: And this is not from yourselves, but it is the gift of God; not from works, lest anyone be exalted. The same Apostle elsewhere declares universally and absolutely, saying: What do you have that you did not receive? Or if you received it, why do you boast as if you had not received it? For why should I recount each point? From these it clearly appears that it is not the free choice of natural liberty that merits grace, but rather that grace is received, so that one may be mercifully freed from the slavery into which he had bound himself by sinning. By the redemption of this sacrament, prepared by eternal providence before the foundation of the world, whether before the law was brought forth or under legal observance, the ancient origin of all holy men and holy women was cleansed by figurative signs and sacrifices, and to all the righteous, through the Spirit of grace, the remedies of eternal salvation came from this mystery of salvation to be adored from afar, whose fullness, made manifest in Christ to the Gentiles, purifies and renews the world and truly makes it partakers of perpetual blessedness. Therefore we reproach our brothers and fellow bishops too much, especially those governing the Church of the Lord throughout the provinces of Picenum, who not only did not deter the depraved talk of a most foolish old man and contemptible person, but even nourished it with their consent. Who would hear of it?

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:59 · narrative
Source · Latin

quis ferat, passos esse pontifices, ut cadaver nescio quod indignum, presbyterum sibi non acquiescentem audire, communione priva ret? quomodo talis vel susceptus ab aliquo, vel patienter auditus est? qui insuper leges dedit, libenter exceptus, ut 8crvi Dei cum puellis sacris congregatione dedecorissima miscerentur? nam cum spirituales animi, etiam cum desint ista consortia, imaginariis infestentur illecebris, quemadmodum alterni sexus intuitu, I qui illicile nolentes non vehementius incitentur? Adhuc majus scelus accrescit, ut sub conspectu et præsentia sacerdotum, beatæ memoriæ llicronymum atque Augustinum ecclesiasticorum lumina magistrorum, musca moritura, sicut scriptum est, exterminans oleum suavitatis (Eccles. x), lacerare contenderet. Sed quid miremur Ecclesiarum praesules ista negligere, quos sicut a multis audivimus, contra canones omnia gerere, et contra apostolicam (I Cor. XIV) disciplinam passim cuncta miscere, manifestum est; non servatis regulis ordinare, liciteque non solum monachos, sed etiam ministros ecclesiæ cum feminis ad peregrina migrantes remeare rursus, et ab aliis episcopis in militiam provehi clericalem? Quæ cum singula toleranda non sint, quis sustineat tot et talia fat inora perpetrari, quibus speciaculum gentilibus, Judæis, et hæreticis non immerito præbentes, in ipsum (quod absit) tendere videatur religionis excidium?

English

Who could endure that pontiffs have suffered a certain unworthy corpse, unknown to me, to deprive of communion a presbyter who did not consent to hear him? How was such a man either received by anyone or patiently heard? He who furthermore gave laws, willingly accepted, so that servants of God might be mingled with sacred girls in a most shameful gathering? For since spiritual minds, even when such associations are absent, are assailed by imaginary allurements, how are they not more vehemently incited by the sight of the other sex, even against their will? The crime grows still greater, that in the sight and presence of priests, he—a fly about to die, as it is written, destroying the oil of sweetness—strove to tear apart Hieronymus and Augustinus, lights of ecclesiastical teachers, of blessed memory. But why should we wonder that the prelates of the Churches neglect these things, who, as we have heard from many, do everything contrary to the canons and everywhere confound all things contrary to apostolic discipline, as is manifest; who ordain without observing the rules, and allow not only monks but also ministers of the Church who have migrated to foreign parts with women to return again, and to be advanced by other bishops to clerical service? Since these individual things are not to be tolerated, who could bear so many and such great crimes to be perpetrated, by which, providing a spectacle to gentiles, Jews, and heretics not undeservedly, they seem to tend toward the very destruction of religion—which God forbid?

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:60 · narrative
Source · Latin

digneque ista facientibus aptabitur illa sententia dicentis Apostoli: Nomen enim Dei per vos blusphematur in gentibus (Rom. II). Sufficiat igitur hactenus fuisse haec commissa, et ut placetur Deus humanis rebus sollicitius divina curentur. nusquam loci prorsus inveniatur præfatæ pestis assertor, ncc accessum prorsus ecclesiæ vel usqnam participationem catholicæ communionis inveniat qui hæreticorum mavult subsequi nefaria professione consortium; et hi cum quibus antea probabitur noxium miscuisse colloquium, nisi resipiscunt, et ab ejus societate discedunt, ab ecclesiastico remoti servitio, devota ultione plectantur, quo cæteris cavendi ministretur exemplum, nullum adeat, nec usquam loqui damnatæ olim blasphemiæ jam sinantur; disereta suis habilationibus virorum atque feminarum, sicut sanctum propositum decet, exerceatur circumspecta devotio. Contra canonum constituta nullus (Nic. IX, 10) ad ecclesiasticum permittatur [al. promoveatur] officium: non ignoraturis provinciæ uniuscujusque rectoribus, nec de præteritis se veniam reperturos erroribus, si deinceps dissimulaverint vitare patefactos: nec excusationis de caetero relinquetur occasio, si post præcepta præsentia, quae per Romulum diaconum, cujus solertiam pro fide catholica et pro religione vigilantiam gratissime comprobamas, duximus destinanda quisquis super his omnibus aut contemptor aut negligens deprehendetur antistes.

English

And to those who do such things, that sentence of the Apostle who says will deservedly apply: For the name of God is blasphemed among the Gentiles through you (Rom. 2). Let it suffice, therefore, that these things have been committed up to now, and that, so that God may be appeased, divine matters be attended to more diligently than human affairs. Let no defender of the aforementioned plague be found anywhere at all, nor let him who prefers to follow the wicked profession and fellowship of heretics find access to the church or participation in catholic communion anywhere at all; and those with whom he is proven previously to have mixed harmful conversation, unless they repent and depart from his society, removed from ecclesiastical service, let them be punished with devoted vengeance, so that an example of caution may be furnished to the rest. Let him approach no one, nor let them now be permitted anywhere to speak of the blasphemy once condemned; with men and women separated in their dwellings, as befits a holy purpose, let circumspect devotion be practiced. Against the decrees of the canons, let no one be permitted to an ecclesiastical office; the rulers of each province are not to be ignorant, nor will they find pardon for past errors if hereafter they neglect to avoid what has been made manifest; nor will an occasion of excuse be left for the future, if after these present precepts, which we have decided must be sent through Romulus the deacon, whose diligence for the catholic faith and vigilance for religion we have most gratefully approved, any bishop is found to be either contemptuous or negligent in all these matters.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:61 · narrative
Source · Latin

Sicut enim ad sedis apostolicæ moderamina pertinet, cunctis soilicitudinem debitam ministrare congruenter Ecclesiis; ita necesse est, ut in contumaces et desides traditam sibi divinitus non dissimutet potestatem. Data calendis Novembris, Albino viro clarissimo consule (anno Christi 393).

a EPISTOLA VIII.

AD ANASTASIUM IMPF.RATOREM.

Præmissa excusatione cur ad imperatorem non scri pserit, illum hortatur ut apostolicæ sedi obtemperet, et, Acacii nomine damnato, Ecclesiarum pacem re. stituendam curet.

Gelasius episcopus ad Anastasium Augustum. Famuli vestrae pietatis, filii mei, Faustus magister et Irenæus viri illustres, atque eorum comites publica legatione fungentes, ad Urbem reversi, clementiam vestram quæsisse dixerunt [al. dicuntur], cur ad vos meæ salutationis. scripta non miserim. Non meo, fateor, instituto; sed cum directi dudum de partibus Orientis vel videndi me licentiam, sibi vestris præceptionibus abnegalam, tota Urbe disperserint, a litteris credidi temperandum, ne onerosus potius quam officiosus existerem. Videtis igitur non mea dissimulatione provenisse, sed competentis fuisse cautelae, ne respuentibus animis molestias irrogarem. Sed ubi serenitatis tuae benevolentiam comperi, praefatis indicantibus, humilitatis meae clementer expetisse sermonem, jam revera perpendi, imputandum non immerito mihi, si tacerem; quia, gloriose fili, a te sicut Romanus [al.

English

For just as it belongs to the governance of the apostolic see to minister the debt of solicitude to all churches in fitting measure, so it is necessary that it not dissemble the power divinely handed down to it against the rebellious and the slothful. Given on the Kalends of November, in the consulship of Albinus, a most illustrious man (in the year of Christ 393).

a EPISTLE VIII.

TO THE EMPEROR ANASTASIUS.

Having first offered an excuse for why he has not written to the emperor, he exhorts him to obey the apostolic see, and, with the name of Acacius condemned, to take care that the peace of the churches be restored.

Gelasius, bishop, to Anastasius Augustus. The servants of your piety, my sons, Faustus the master and Irenaeus, illustrious men, and their companions, who were performing a public legation, having returned to the City, said that your clemency asked why I had not sent writings of my salutation to you. It was not, I confess, by my own intention; but when those who had recently been sent from the regions of the East, or rather the permission to see me, had been denied them by your commands, they spread this throughout the whole City, and I believed I ought to refrain from letters, lest I prove burdensome rather than dutiful. You see, therefore, that this did not come about through any dissimulation on my part, but was a matter of fitting caution, lest I inflict annoyance on minds that rejected it. But when I learned, through the report of the aforesaid men, that the benevolence of your Serenity had clemently sought the speech of my humility, then truly I considered that it would not undeservedly be imputed to me if I remained silent; because, glorious son, by you as a Roman...

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:62 · narrative
Source · Latin

Romæ] natus, Romanum principem amo, colo,,. suscipio; et sicut Cbristianus, cum eo qui zelum Dei habet, secundum scientiam veritatis habere desidero: et qualiscunque apostolicæ sedis vicarius, quodcunque plenæ fidei catholicæ deesse comperero, pro meo modulo suggestionibus opportunis supplere contendo. Dispensatione etenim mihi divini sermonis injuncta, væ mihi est, si non evangelizavero (/ Cor. IX)! Quod cum vas electionis beatus Paulus apostolus formidet et clamet, multo magis mihi exiguo metuendum cst, si divinitus inspiratum, et paterna devotione transmissum, subtraxero ministerium praedicandi. Pietatem luam precor ne arrogantiam judices divinae rationis officium. Absit, quæso, a Romano principe, ut intimatam suis sensibus veritatem arbitretur injuriam. Duo quippe sunt, imperator Auguste, quibus principaliter mundus hic regitur: auctoritas sacra [al. sacrata] pontificum, et regatis potestas. In quibus tanto gravius est pondus sacerdotum, quanto etiam pro ipsis regibus Domino in divino reddituri sunt examine rationem. Nosti etenim, fili clementissime, quod licet præsideas humano generi dignitate, rerum tamen praesulibus divinarum devotus colla sub. mittis, atque ab eis causas tuae salutis expetis [al. exspectas], inque sumendis coelestibus sacramentis, eisque (ut competit) disponendis, subdi te debere cognoscis religionis ordine potius quam præesse.

English

Born at Rome, I love, reverence, and embrace the Roman prince; and as a Christian, I desire to have with him who has zeal for God according to the knowledge of truth; and as whatever vicar of the apostolic see I am, whatever I find lacking in the full catholic faith, I strive to supply according to my small measure through fitting suggestions. For since the dispensation of the divine word has been enjoined upon me, woe to me if I do not preach the gospel (1 Cor 9)! And since the blessed apostle Paul, a vessel of election, fears this and cries out, how much more must I, a little one, fear, if I withdraw the ministry of preaching that has been divinely inspired and transmitted by paternal devotion. I beseech your Piety, do not judge the office of divine reason to be arrogance. Far be it, I ask, from the Roman prince, that he should consider the truth made known to his senses to be an injury. For there are two things, emperor Augustus, by which this world is principally ruled: the sacred authority of pontiffs, and the royal power. In these, the weight of priests is all the greater, inasmuch as even for the kings themselves they will render an account to the Lord in the divine examination. For you know, most clement son, that although you preside over the human race by dignity, yet you devoutly submit your neck to the prelates of divine things, and from them you seek the causes of your salvation, and in receiving the heavenly sacraments and disposing of them (as is fitting), you recognize that you ought to be subject to the order of religion rather than to preside over it.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:63 · narrative
Source · Latin

Nosti itaque inter hæc, ex illorum te pendete judicio, non illos ad tuam velle redigi voluntatem. Si cnim, quantum ad ordinem pertinet publicae disciplinæ, cognoscentes imperium tibi superna dispositione collatum, legibus tuis ipsi quoque parent religionis antistites, ne vel in rebus mundanis exclusas videantur obviare sententiae; quo (rogo) te decef affectu cis obedire, qui pro erogandis venerabilibus sunt attributi mysteriis? Proinde sicut non leve discrimcn incumbit pontificibus, siluisse pro Divinitatis cultu, quod congruit; ita his(quod absit) non mediocre periculum est, qui, cum parere debeant, despiciunt. Et si cunctis generaliter sacerdotibus recte divina tractantibus, fidelium convenit corda submitti, quanto potius sedis illius praesuli consensus est adhibendus, quem cunctis sacerdotibus et Divinitas summa voluit prxeminere, et subsequens Ecclesiae generalis jugiter pietas celebravit? Ubi pietas tua evidenter advertit, nunquam quolibet penitus humano consilio elevare se quemquam posse illius privilegio vel confessioni, quem Christi vox praeluiit universis, quem Ecclesia veneranda confessa semper est, et habet devota primatem. Impeti possunt humanis præsumptionibus quae divino sunt judicio coustituta, vinci autem quorumlibet potestate non possunt.

English

You know therefore amid these things that it is from their judgment that you depend, not that they wish to be reduced to your will. For if, as far as pertains to the order of public discipline, recognizing that the empire has been conferred on you by heavenly disposition, the very prelates of religion also obey your laws, lest they be seen to oppose even in worldly matters the sentence that has been excluded; with what feeling, I ask, does it befit you to obey those who have been appointed for dispensing the venerable mysteries? Accordingly, just as no light danger rests upon pontiffs if they have kept silent about what is fitting for the worship of the Divinity, so for those who, when they ought to obey, disdain to do so, there is no moderate peril (which be far from us). And if it is fitting that the hearts of the faithful be submitted to all priests generally who rightly handle divine things, how much more must consent be given to the prelate of that see which the supreme Divinity willed to preside over all priests, and which the subsequent piety of the universal Church has continually celebrated? Where your piety clearly perceives that never by any human counsel can anyone at all raise himself up against the privilege or confession of him whom the voice of Christ set before all, whom the venerable Church has always confessed and devoutly holds as primate. Things that have been established by divine judgment can be attacked by human presumptions, but they cannot be overcome by the power of any persons.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:64 · narrative
Source · Latin

Atque utinam sic contra nitenlibus perniciosa non sit audacia, quemadmodum, quod ab ipso sacræ religionis auctore præfixum est, non potest ulla virtute convelli: Firmamentum enim Dei stat (II Tim. n). Nunquidnam cum aliquibus infestata religio est, quantacunque potuit novitate superari, et non magis hoc invicta pcrmansit, quo aestimata est posse succumbere? Desinant ergo (quæso te) temporibus luis quidam per occasionem perturbationis ecclesiasticæ praecipitanter ambire quae non I licet, ne et illa quae male appetunt nullatenus apprehendant, et modum suum apud Deum et homines non teneant. Quapropter sub conspectu Dei pure ac sincere pietatem tuam deprecor, obtestor et exhortor, ut petitionem meam non indignanler accipias: rogo, inquam, ut me in hac vita potius audias deprecantem, quam (quod absit) in divino judicio sentias accusantem. Nec me latet, imperator Auguste, quod pietatis tuæ studium fuerit in privata vita. Optasli semper fieri particeps promissionis æternæ. Quapropter noli, precor, irasci mihi, si te tantum diligo, ut regnum, quod temporaliter assecutus es, velim te habere perpetuum, et qui imperas sæculo, possis rcgnare cum Christo. Tuis certe legibus, imperator, pateris nihil perire, Romano nomini [al. perirc Romano nomini] nullum admittis ingeri detrimentum.

English

And would that the audacity of those who strive against it were not as pernicious as it is, seeing that what has been fixed by the very author of holy religion cannot be overthrown by any power: For the foundation of God standeth (II Tim. 2). Was religion, when it was assailed by any persons, ever overcome by however great a novelty, and did it not rather remain unconquered precisely in that it was thought it could be brought low? Therefore let certain men cease (I beseech you) in your times, on the occasion of ecclesiastical disturbance, rashly to seek what is not lawful, lest they in no way lay hold of those things they wrongly desire, and lose their proper measure before God and men. Wherefore, in the sight of God, I purely and sincerely entreat, implore, and exhort your Piety, that you not take my petition indignantly: I ask, I say, that you hear me in this life as one entreating, rather than (which God forbid) feel me in the divine judgment as one accusing. Nor does it escape me, Augustus, that the zeal of your Piety was present in your private life. You have always desired to become a partaker of the eternal promise. Wherefore, I pray, do not be angry with me, if I love you so much that I wish you to hold forever the kingdom you have obtained in time, and that you who command the world may be able to reign with Christ. By your laws, certainly, emperor, you suffer nothing to perish, and you admit no detriment to be inflicted on the Roman name.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:65 · narrative
Source · Latin

Itane verum est, princeps egregie, qui non solum praesentia Christi beneficia, sed desideras et futura, ut religioni, ut veritati, ut sinceritati catholicæ communionis et fidei, temporibus luis, patiaris quemquam inferre dispendium? Qua fiducia (rogo le) illic ejus præmia petiturus es, cujus hic damna non prohibes? Non sint gravia, quæso te, quæ pro tuæ salu. lis æternitate dicuntur. Scriptum legisti: Meliora sunt vulnera amici quam oscula inimici (Prov. XXVII). Quæso pietatem tuam, ut quo affectu dicuntur a me, eo tuis sensibus intimentur. Nemo pietatem tuam fallat. Verum est quod figuraliter per prophetam Scriplura testatur? Una est columba meat una esi per. fecta mea (Cant. VI), una cst christiana fides, quæ est calholica. Catholica autem veraciter illa est, quæ ab omnium perfidorum, atque ab corum successoribus atque consortibus sincera, pura, immaculata communione divisa [al. divulsa] est. Alioquin non erit divinilus mandata discretio, sed miseranda con. fusio. Nec ulla causa jam superest, si hoc in quolibet contagio voluerimus admittere, ne cunctis hæresibus aditum januamque pandamus. Qui enim in uno offenderit, omnium reus est (Jacob, II); et: Qui minima spernit, paulatim decidit (Eccles. XIX). Hoc est quod sedes apostolica magnopere cavet [al. prætaxavit], ut quia mundo radix est apostoli gloriosa confessio, nulla rima pravitatis, nulla prorsus contagione maculetur.

English

Is it then true, excellent prince, you who desire not only the present benefits of Christ but also the future, that in your times you would suffer anyone to bring loss upon religion, upon truth, upon the sincerity of the catholic communion and faith? With what confidence, I ask you, will you seek his rewards there, whose losses here you do not prevent? Let not these things, I beseech you, seem burdensome, which are spoken for the sake of your eternal salvation. You have read what is written: Better are the wounds of a friend than the kisses of an enemy. I beseech your Piety, that with the same affection with which they are spoken by me, they may be received into your understanding. Let no one deceive your Piety. Is it true what Scripture testifies figuratively through the prophet? One is my dove, one is my perfect one, one is the Christian faith, which is catholic. But that is truly catholic which is divided, sincere, pure, and immaculate in communion from all the faithless and from their successors and associates. Otherwise there will not be a divinely appointed discernment, but a wretched confusion. Nor does any reason now remain, if we should wish to admit this in any contagion whatsoever, why we should not open the door and entrance to all heresies. For whoever offends in one point is guilty of all; and: Whoever despises the least things falls away little by little. This is what the apostolic see greatly guards against, that since the glorious confession of the apostle is a root for the world, it may be stained by no crack of depravity, by no contagion whatsoever.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:66 · narrative
Source · Latin

Nam si (quod Deus avertat, quod fieri non posse confidimus) late aliquid proveniret, unde cuiquam resistere auderemus errori, vel unde correctionem errantibus posceremus? Proinde si pietas tua unius civitatis populum negat posse pace componi, quid nos de totius orbis terrarum sumus universiiatc facturi, si (quod absit) nostra fuerit prævaricatione deceptus? Si totus correctus est mundus, profana patrum suorum traditione despecta, quomodo non corrigatur unius civitatis populus, si prædicatio fida [al. fidei] succedat? Ergo, gloriose imperator, nolo ego [al. non negligo] Ecclesiarum pacem, quam, cliamsi cum mei sanguinis impendio provenire posset, amplector [al. ampleclar]? Sed (precor te) cujusmodi debeat esse pax ipsi, non utrunque, sed veraciter christiana mente libremus. Quomodo enim potest esse pax vera cui caritas intemerata defuerit? Carilas autem qualiter esse debeat nobis evidenter Apostolus prædicat, qui ait: Caritas de corde, puro, et conscientia bona et fide non ficta (I Tim. I). Quomodo (quaeso te) de corde erit puro, si contagio inficiatur externo? Quomodo de conscientia bona, si pravis fuerit malisque commixta? Quemadmodum fide non fictat si maneat sociata cum per Ii... dis?

English

For if (may God avert it, which we trust cannot happen) anything should spread far and wide, whereby we might dare to resist any error, or whereby we might demand correction for those who err? Accordingly, if your piety denies that the people of one city can be settled in peace, what are we to do concerning the whole community of the entire world, if (which be far from us) it should be deceived by our prevarication? If the whole world has been corrected, having despised the profane tradition of its fathers, how is the people of one city not to be corrected, if faithful preaching succeeds? Therefore, glorious emperor, I do not refuse the peace of the Churches, which, even if it could come about at the cost of my blood, I embrace? But (I beseech you) let us weigh with a truly Christian mind of what sort that peace ought to be, not both kinds, but truly Christian. For how can there be true peace where undefiled charity is lacking? But how charity ought to be is clearly proclaimed to us by the Apostle, who says: Charity from a pure heart, and a good conscience, and faith unfeigned (1 Tim. 1). How (I ask you) will it be from a pure heart, if it is infected by outward contagion? How from a good conscience, if it has been mixed with depraved and evil things? How with faith unfeigned, if it remains associated with the perverse?

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:67 · narrative
Source · Latin

Quae cum a nobis saepe jam dicta sint, necesse est tamen incessabiliter iterari, et tandiu non taceri quandiu nomen pacis obtenditur; ut nostrum non sit (ut invidiose jactatur) facere pacem, sed tamen velle doceamus, qualis, et sola pax csse, et praetcr quam nulla esse monstratur. Eutychianum certe dogma, contra quod apostolicae sedis cautela pervigilat, si creditur salva fidei catholicae posse veritate constare, promatur, asseratur, et qnantislibct viribus astruatur, ut non solum per seipsum, quam inimicum sit fidei Christianæ possit ostendi, sed quantas et quam lethales haereses in sua contineat colluvione monstrari. Si autem ( ut magis confidimus a catholicis judicatis mentibus excludendum, quaeso te, cur non et contagia simul eorum qui hac probantur esse polluti, decernitis refutanda, cum dicat Apostolus: Non solum qui non facienda faciunt, reos videri, sed etiamn qui consentiunt facientibus (Rom. I)? Proinde sicut non notest, perversitatis communicatore suscepto, non pariter perversitas approbari, sic non potest refutari perversitas, complice sectatore perversitati, admisso. Legibus certe vestris, criminum conscii susceptoresque latrocinantium pari judiciorum pœna constringuntur; nec expers lacinoris assUmatur qui, licet ipse non fecerit, facientis tamen familiaritatem foedusque receperit.

English

Since these things have often already been said by us, it is nevertheless necessary that they be repeated without ceasing, and not be kept silent for as long as the name of peace is held out as a pretext; so that it may not be ours (as is invidiously boasted) to make peace, but we may teach that we desire it—what kind of peace it is, and that it alone is peace, and that apart from it there is none. Certainly, if the Eutychian dogma, against which the vigilance of the apostolic see keeps watch, is believed to be able to stand with the truth of the catholic faith safe, let it be brought forward, asserted, and built up with whatever forces, so that it may be shown not only how hostile it is in itself to the Christian faith, but also how many and how deadly heresies it contains in its own filth. But if (as we more confidently trust must be excluded from catholic-judging minds, I ask you, why do you not likewise decree that the contagions of those who are proved to be polluted by this must be rejected, since the Apostle says: not only those who do what must not be done are seen as guilty, but also those who consent to those doing it (Rom. 1)? Accordingly, just as it is not possible, when a communicator of perversity has been received, that the perversity itself is not equally approved, so perversity cannot be rejected if a partner, a follower of the perversity, has been admitted. Certainly by your laws, those who are aware of crimes and those who receive robbers are bound by an equal penalty of judgments; nor is he taken as free of the crime who, although he himself did not do it, has nevertheless received the familiarity and alliance of the one doing it.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:68 · narrative
Source · Latin

Proinde cum Cha!ccdonense concilium, pro fidci catholicæ atque apostolicæ veritate communioneque celebratum, damnaverit Eutychen detestandi furoris auctorem, non satis habuit, nisi ut pariter ejus quoque consortem Dioscorum cæterosque percelleret. Hoc igitur modo, sicut in unaquaque haeresi vel factum semper, vel fieri non habetur ambiguum, successotres eorum Timotheum, Petrum atque alterum Antiochenum Petrum. non viritim propter singulos quosque rursus facto concilio, sed synodi semel acta regula consequenter elisi. Quemadmodum ergo non evidenter apparet etiam cunctos simili tenore constringi, et qui eorum communicato. res et complices exslitcrunt, atque omnes omnino a catholica atque apostolica merito communione discerni: hinc Acacium quoque jure dicimus a nostro consortio submovendum, qui maluit in sortem transire perfidiae, quam in catholicæ atque apostolicæ communionis sinceritate constare, cum fere a per triennium, ne in id veniret, apostolicx sedis epistolis doceatur competenter instructus. Postquam vero communionis cst factus alienæ, non potuit nisi a catholicæ et apostolicae mox societate praecidi, ne per eum, si vel paululum cessaremus, nos quoque videremur subiisse contagia perfidorum. Sed revera vel tali perculsus pœna resipuit, correctionem promisit, emendavit errorem? aut ille tractatus lenius voluerat [al. valuerat coerceri, qui etiam verbera dura nou sensit?

English

Accordingly, since the Council of Chalcedon, convened for the truth and communion of the catholic and apostolic faith, condemned Eutyches, the author of detestable madness, it was not satisfied unless it likewise struck down his partner Dioscorus and the rest. In this way, therefore, as in each heresy it has always been done, or is not doubted to be done, their successors Timothy, Peter, and the other Peter of Antioch were crushed by the rule of the synod once enacted, not by a council held again individually for each one. How then does it not clearly appear that all are bound by a similar tenor, both those who were found to be sharers and accomplices in their communion, and that all are rightly severed from catholic and apostolic communion? Hence we say that Acacius too is justly to be removed from our fellowship, who chose to pass over into the lot of perfidy rather than stand firm in the sincerity of catholic and apostolic communion, although for nearly three years, so that he might not come to this, he was shown to have been duly instructed by the letters of the apostolic see. But after he became a stranger to communion, he could not but be immediately cut off from catholic and apostolic society, lest through him, if we delayed even a little, we too might seem to have undergone the contagion of the perfidious. But in truth, was he brought to his senses by such a punishment, did he promise correction, did he amend his error? Or had that man wished to be restrained more gently, who did not even feel harsh blows?

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:69 · narrative
Source · Latin

Quo in sua perfidia et damnatione moriente [al. manente], tam ejus in ecclesiastica recitatione non potest nomen ascribi, quam externae contagium non debet communicationis admitti. Quapropter aut doceatur ab hæretica participatione sincerus, quorum se ille communioni permiscuit, aut cum eisdem non potest non repelli. Si autem susurrant Orientis episcopi, quod ad eos sedes apostolica non ista conscripserit, quasi vel ip si de recipiendo legitime Petro sedem apostolicam suis litteris fecerint certiorem, vel hujus receptionis inconditæ non jam pariter complices exstitissent, quem sicut vere non possunt docere ah hæretica pravitate fuisse purgatum, ita se hæreticorum nullatenus poterunt excusare consortes. Quod si forlassis astruxerint, quod ad apostolicam sedem de susceptiune Petri per Acacium cuncti consona voce retulerint, per eumdem sibimet omnes pari voce sentiunt fuissc rescriplum. Apostolicæ [al. vice primatus sedis apostolicæ] vero sedis auctoritas, quod cunctis saeculis Christianis Ecclesiæ prælata sit universae, et canonum serie paternorum, et multiplici tradilione firmatur. Sed vel hinc, ' utrum sibi quisquam contra Nicænæ synodi constituta quippiam valeat usurparc, collegio potest unius communionis ostendi, non mentibus externae societatis aperiri. Apud illos si quis confidit, egrediatur in medium, et apostolicam sedem de utraque parte revincat et instruat.

English

Since he dies in his own perfidy and damnation, his name can no more be inscribed in the Church's recitation than the contagion of external communion ought to be admitted. Wherefore, either let him be shown to be clear of heretical participation with those to whose communion he joined himself, or he cannot but be rejected along with them. But if the bishops of the East murmur that the Apostolic See did not write these things to them—as though either they themselves had informed the Apostolic See by their letters concerning the legitimate reception of Peter, or they had not already been equally accomplices in this disorderly reception—then just as they truly cannot show that he was cleansed from heretical depravity, so they will by no means be able to excuse themselves as associates of heretics. But if perhaps they assert that all of them reported to the Apostolic See with one accord concerning the reception of Peter through Acacius, then through the same man they all perceive that the reply was written to them with equal voice. But the authority of the Apostolic See—that it has been set before the whole Church throughout all Christian ages—is confirmed both by the series of the fathers' canons and by manifold tradition. Yet even from this, whether anyone can usurp anything for himself against the decrees of the Council of Nicaea, can be shown to the college of one communion, not laid open to the minds of an external society. If anyone trusts in them, let him come forth into the midst and refute and instruct the Apostolic See concerning either side.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:70 · narrative
Source · Latin

Tollatur ergo nomen e medio, quod ecclesiarum discretionem procul a catholica communione operatur, ut sincera pax fidei communionisque reparetur et unitas: et tunc quis nostrum contra venerandam vel insurrexerit, vel nitatur insurgere vetustatem, co npetenter et legitime perquiratur.Et illic apparebit quis modesto proposito custodiat formam traditionemque majorum, quis supra haec irreverenter insiliens, rapina aequalem posse fieri, arbitretur. Quod si mihi populi Constantinopolitani persona proponitur, per quam dicatur nomen scandali, id est Acacii, non posse removeri; taceo, quia et hæretico quondam Macedonio pulso, et Nestorio nuper ejecto, plehs Constantinopolitana catholica permanere dclegerit potius quam majorum praesulum damnatorum affectione retineri. Taceo, quod qui ab eisdem ipsis damnatis praesulibus, baptizati fuerant, in fide catholica manentes, nulla sint exagitatione turbati. Taceo, quod pro rcbus ludicris populares tumultus nunc etiam vestræ pietatis auctoritas refrenarit; atque ideo multo magis pro salute animarum suarum necessario vobis Constantinopolitanae civitatis obtemperat multitudo, si eam ad catholicam et apostolicam commanionem vos principes reducatis.

English

Let the name therefore be removed from the midst, which brings about a separation of the churches far from catholic communion, so that the sincere peace of faith and communion and unity may be restored; and then, if any of us has risen up or strives to rise up against venerable antiquity, let it be competently and lawfully investigated. And there it will appear who with modest purpose preserves the form and tradition of the ancestors, and who, irreverently leaping upon these things, thinks that by robbery he can become their equal. But if the person of the Constantinopolitan people is put before me, by which it is said that the name of scandal, that is, of Acacius, cannot be removed, I pass over the fact that, when the heretic Macedonius was once driven out and Nestorius recently expelled, the Constantinopolitan plebs chose to remain catholic rather than be held by affection for the condemned prelates of the ancestors. I pass over the fact that those who had been baptized by those same condemned prelates, remaining in the catholic faith, were disturbed by no agitation. I pass over the fact that popular tumults for trifling matters have now even been restrained by the authority of your Piety; and therefore, much more for the salvation of their souls, the multitude of the city of Constantinople necessarily obeys you, if you as princes lead it back to catholic and apostolic communion.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:71 · narrative
Source · Latin

Etenim, imperator Auguste, si contra leges publicas aliquid (quod absit) quispiam fortasse tentaret, nulla pati id ratione potuisses: ad Divinitatis puram sinceramque devotionem, ut tibi plebs subdita redigatur, conscientiae tuae non putas interesse? Postremo, si unius civitatis populi animus non putatur offendi, ne divina (ut res postulat) corrigantur: quanto magis, ne divina offendantur, catholici nominis universis piam fidem nec lædere debemus omnino, nec possumus? Et tameM iidem nostra so poscunt voluntate sanari. Competentibus ergo sinant curari se posse remediis: alioqui (quod absit) in eorum transcundo perniciem, cum illis perire possumus, ipsos vero salvare non possumas, Jam hic quid sit magis sequendum, sub divino judicio vestræ conscientiæ derelinquo: utrum, sicut nos optamus, simul omnes certam redeamus ad vitam; an, sicli illi poscunt, manifestam tendamus ad mortem. Sed adhuc apostolicam sedem, sibi medicinalia suggerentem, superbam vocare arrogantemque contendunt. Habet hoc qualitas sæpe languentium, ut accusent magis medicos congruis observationibus ad salubria revocantes, quam ut ipsi suos noxios appetitus deponere vel reprobare consentiant. Si nos superbi sumus, quia animarurn remedia convenientia ministramus, quid vocandi sunt qui resultant? Si nos superbi sumus, qui obediendum paternis dicimus institutis; qui refragantur, quo appellandi sunt nomine?

English

For indeed, emperor Augustus, if anyone should perhaps attempt something against the public laws (which God forbid), you could by no means have permitted it on any reasonable ground. Do you not think it concerns your conscience that the people subject to you be brought to pure and sincere devotion to the Divinity? Finally, if the mind of the populace of a single city is not thought to be offended when divine matters are corrected (as the situation demands), how much more, lest divine matters be offended, ought we not and indeed cannot we catholics harm the pious faith of the whole catholic name? And yet these same persons demand that their own affairs be healed by our will. Therefore let them allow themselves to be cured by suitable remedies. Otherwise (which God forbid), in their passing over to destruction, we may perish with them, but we cannot save them. Now here what is rather to be followed I leave to your conscience under divine judgment: whether, as we desire, we all together return to certain life; or, as they demand, we hasten toward manifest death. But even now they contend that the apostolic see, which suggests remedies for them, should be called proud and arrogant. It is often the condition of the sick to accuse the doctors who recall them to healthful practices by suitable regimens, rather than to consent themselves to lay aside or reject their harmful appetites. If we are proud because we administer suitable remedies for souls, what are those who resist to be called? If we are proud, who say that paternal institutions must be obeyed, by what name are those who oppose them to be called?

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:72 · narrative
Source · Latin

Si nos elati sumus, qui divinum cultum puro atque illibato cupimus tenore servari; qui contra Divinitatem quoque sentiunt, dicant, qualiter nuncupentur? Sic el nos caeteri, qui in errore sunt, æstimant, quod eorum non consentiamus insaniæ. Ubi lamen spiritus superbiæ veraciter consistat et pugnet veritas ipsa indicat [al. judical].

EPISTOLA IX.

AD EPISCOPOS LUCANIÆ.

Nonnulla ecclesiastica instituta exponuntur.

Dilectissimis fratribus universis episcopis per Lueaniam, et Brutios, et Siciliam constitutis Gelasius.

TITULI DECRETORUM PAPÆ GELASII.

i. De constitutis ecclesiasticis, pro temporibus qualitate moderandis.:

II. Ut ubi nulla perurget necessitas, constituta Patrum inviolata seventur; vel cum defuerint clerici, de monachis eligantur.

III. Ut si qui de laicis eliguntur ad clericum, multo sollicitius in his, ea quæ de monachis dicta sunt inquirantur.

English

If we have been arrogant, we who desire that the divine worship be preserved with a pure and unblemished tenor, let those who also hold opinions against the Divinity say how they are to be named. Thus also the rest of us, who are in error, they think, because we do not consent to their insanity. But where the spirit of pride truly stands, and what it fights, the truth itself indicates.

LETTER IX.

TO THE BISHOPS OF LUCANIA.

Certain ecclesiastical institutions are set forth.

Gelasius to his most beloved brothers, all the bishops established throughout Lucania, and Bruttium, and Sicily.

THE TITLES OF THE DECREES OF POPE GELASIUS.

i. Concerning ecclesiastical institutions, to be moderated according to the quality of the times.

II. That where no necessity presses, the institutions of the Fathers be kept inviolate; or when clerics are lacking, they be chosen from among the monks.

III. That if any are chosen to the clergy from among the laity, those things which were said concerning monks be inquired into much more carefully in their case.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:73 · narrative
Source · Latin

I V. Ut ab episcopis, præceptione papæ, novæ basilicæ dedicentur.

V. Ut nulla prædia [ lege pretia] de baptizandis consignandisque fidelibus exigantur. Quod si qui hoc perpetraverint, honoris sui periculo aubjacebunt.

VI. Ut presbyteri modum debitum servent, non chrisma conficiant, non consignent; nec præsente quolibet episcopo, nisi jubeantur ab ipso, vel orare, vel sedere præsumant, nec acolythum, vel subdiaconum faciant.

VII. Similiter ut diaconi mensuram propriam juxta Patrum decreta custodiant.

VIII. Quod diaconi in presbyterio residere non possint, nec sacri corporis prærogationem, præsentibus debent umrpare presbyteris.

IX. Quod apostolicæ sedes paternos canones pio studio devotoque custodiat.

X. Ut præter paschale tempus et pentecosten nemo baptizare præsumat, nisi eos tantum quos ægritudo extrema compulerit.

X I. Presbyterorum et diaconorum ordinationes certis celebrari posse temporibus.

English

IV. That new basilicas are to be dedicated by bishops at the command of the pope.

V. That no fees be demanded from the faithful for baptizing and confirming them. But if any shall have perpetrated this, they shall be subject to the peril of their honor.

VI. That presbyters observe the due measure: let them not prepare chrism, let them not confirm; nor, in the presence of any bishop, unless ordered by him, let them presume either to pray or to sit, nor let them make an acolyte or a subdeacon.

VII. Likewise that deacons keep their own proper measure according to the decrees of the Fathers.

VIII. That deacons cannot sit in the presbyterium, nor ought they to usurp the prerogative of the sacred body while presbyters are present.

IX. That the apostolic sees guard the paternal canons with pious and devoted zeal.

X. That no one presume to baptize outside the Paschal season and Pentecost, except only those whom extreme illness has compelled.

XI. That the ordinations of presbyters and deacons can be celebrated at fixed times.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:74 · narrative
Source · Latin

XII. Ut præfixis diebus virgines consecrentur. XIII. Ut viduæ non velentur.

XIV. Ut nullus praesul vel ecclesiæ, vel monasterii servum, aut originarium, nolentibus dominis, sub nonine religioso defendat, honoris et communionis periculum subiturus quisquis hoc perpetrare tentaverit.

XV. Ut clerici nullanegotia inhonesta, nec turpia lucra sectentur.

X VI. Ut nemo lilteras nesciens, vel aliqua parte corpori, minutus, provehatur ad clerum.

XVII. De his qui seipsos abscindunt.

XVIII. Quod ad clerum criminosi nequeant promoveri, et in clero positi, si in aliquibus fuerint inventi flagitiis, a suis officiis arceantur.

XIX. Quod dæmonis aliisque passionibus irretitis ministeria sacra tractare non liceat.

X. Quod hi qui se sacris virginibus sociant, et foedera incesta commiscent, communicare non possint, nisi forte publicam pœnitentiam gesserint.

English

XII. That virgins are to be consecrated on appointed days. XIII. That widows are not to be veiled.

XIV. That no prelate is to defend, under the name of religion, a slave of a church or of a monastery, or one bound by birth, against the will of their masters, and whoever attempts to perpetrate this shall undergo the peril of his honor and communion.

XV. That clerics are to pursue no dishonest business, nor shameful profits.

XVI. That no one ignorant of letters, or maimed in any part of the body, is to be promoted to the clergy.

XVII. Concerning those who mutilate themselves.

XVIII. That the criminal cannot be promoted to the clergy, and those placed in the clergy, if they are found in any offenses, are to be barred from their offices.

XIX. That it is not permitted for those entangled in demonic and other passions to handle the sacred ministries.

X. That those who join themselves to sacred virgins, and mingle incestuous covenants, cannot communicate, unless perhaps they have performed public penance.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:75 · narrative
Source · Latin

XXI. Quod viduæ, ut supradictum est, non velentur. Et si professam continentiam proposito mutato cat.. caverint, ipsæ pro se rationem sint ideo [al. domino] reddituræ.

XXII. Quod secunda conjugia sæcularibus non negentur, quibus tamen ad clerum minime venire con. ceditur.

XXIII. Ut si quis susceperit ecclesiæ propriae descr. torem, et in aliquam provexerit dignitatem, utique sententiæ subjaceant quam canones addixerunt.

XXIV. Quod si qui ex monachis aut laicis eliguntur c.d clerum, cum nulla cogit necessitas, antiqua in eis debentur instituta servari. Quod si probentur sacram mercalt esse pretto dignitatem, ao officio deponantur, nam dantem et accipientem Simonis magi crimen involvit.

XXV. De sacris locis noviter institutis, quamvis superius dictum sit, hoc nunc tamen adjicitur, ut nulla basilica sub defunctorrum constructa nomine dedicetur.

English

XXI. That widows, as was said above, are not to be veiled. And if women who have professed continence should have changed their purpose and fallen away, they themselves shall therefore render an account for themselves to the Lord.

XXII. That second marriages are not to be denied to secular persons, to whom nevertheless it is by no means permitted to come to the clergy.

XXIII. That if anyone has received the deserter of his own church, and has advanced him to any dignity, they are certainly subject to the sentence which the canons have imposed.

XXIV. That if any are chosen to the clergy from among monks or laymen, when no necessity compels it, the ancient institutions ought to be preserved in their case. But if they are proven to have bought the sacred dignity for a price, they are to be deposed from office, for the crime of Simon Magus involves both the giver and the receiver.

XXV. Concerning sacred places newly established, although it was said above, this nevertheless is now added, that no basilica built under the name of the dead is to be dedicated.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:76 · narrative
Source · Latin

XXVI. Quod nefas sit feminas sacris altaribus ministrare, vel aliquid ex his quæ virorum sunt officiis deputata præsumere.

XXVII. Quod in unaquaque ecclesia cui episcopus præest, tam de redditibus quam de fidelium oblætionibus quatuor debeant fieri portiones: ut una sit episcopi, alia clericorum, tertia pauperum, quarla ecclesiæ fabricis applicetur.

XXVIII, Quod episcopus, presbyter, et diaconus, a quocunque clerico veraciter fuerit accusatus, quod adversus hæc constituta fecerit, potest sine dubita tione percelli, sui etiam honoris periculum episcopus subiturus, si hæc omnia ecclesiæ noscenda tacuerit. I CAPUT PRIMUM. - Necessaria rerum dispensatione [al disputalione vel dispositione] constringimur, et apostolicae sedis moderamine convenimur; sic canonum paternorum decreta librare, et retro præsulum decessorumque nostrorum praecepta metiri, ut quæ praesentium necessitas temporum reslaurandis Ecclesiis relaxanda deposcit, adhibita consideraiifne diligenti, quantum potest fieri, tempercmus; quo nec in totum formam veterum videamur excedere regularum, et reparandis militiæ clericalis officiis [supple consulamusJ quae per diversas Italiæ partes iia belli famisque consumpsit incursio, ut in multis ecclesiis (sicut fratris et coepiscopi nostri Joannis Ravennatis Ecclesiæ sacerdotis, frequenti relatione comperimus) usquequaque deficiente servitio ministrorum [al.

English

XXVI. That it is a sacrilege for women to minister at the sacred altars, or to presume to do anything of those things that are assigned to the offices of men.

XXVII. That in each church over which a bishop presides, four portions ought to be made, both from revenues and from the offerings of the faithful: that one be the bishop's, another the clergy's, a third the poor's, and the fourth be applied to the fabric of the church.

XXVIII. That a bishop, presbyter, and deacon, if accused truthfully by any cleric of having acted against these constitutions, can without doubt be struck down, the bishop even to undergo the risk of his own honor, if he has kept silent about all these things that the church ought to know.

CHAPTER I. — We are constrained by the necessary dispensation of affairs, and convened by the governance of the apostolic see, so to weigh the decrees of the fathers' canons, and to measure the precepts of the bishops who came before and our predecessors, that those things which the necessity of the present times demands to be relaxed for the restoration of the churches, with careful consideration applied, we may temper as far as can be done; so that we may not seem to depart entirely from the form of the ancient rules, and may provide for the restoring of the offices of the clerical militia, which the incursion of war and famine throughout various parts of Italy has so consumed, that in many churches (as we have learned from the frequent report of our brother and fellow bishop John, priest of the church of Ravenna) with the service of ministers failing utterly...

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:77 · narrative
Source · Latin

ministeriorumj nisi remittendo paulisper ecclesiasticis promotionibus antiquitus intervalla praefixa remaneant (sine quibus administrare nequeant) sacris ordinibus Ecclesiae funditus desitutæ atque in plurimis locis per inppiam competenlis auxilii, salutare subsidium redimendarum desit animarum: nosque magno reatu, si tanto coarctante periculo, non aliquatenus videamur innecti.

CAP. II. — Priscis igitur pro sui reverentia manentibus constitutis; quae, ubi nulla vel rerum vel temporum perurget angustia, regulariter convenit custodire, eatenus ecclesiis quæ vel cunctis sunt privatæ ministris, vel sufficientibus usque adeo dispoliatae servitiis, ut plebibus ad se pertinentibus divina munera supplere non valeant, tam I intuendi quam promovendi clericalis obsequii sic spatia dispensanda concedimus.

Ut si quis etiam de religioso proposito, et disciplinis monasterialibus eruditus, ad clericale munus accedat, imprimis ejus vita praeteritis acta temporibus inquiratur, si nullo gravi facinore probatur infectus, si secundam non habuit fortassis uxorem, nec a marilo relictam [al. rejectam] sortitus ostenditur; si pœnitentiam publicam fortassis non gessit, nec ulla corporis parte vitiatus apparet; si servili aut originariae non est conditioni obnoxius; si curiæ jam [al.

English

of ministries, unless the intervals fixed of old for ecclesiastical promotions remain, remitted for a little while (without which they cannot administer), the churches would be utterly destitute of sacred orders, and in very many places, through the wickedness of the assistance required, the salutary remedy of redeeming souls would cease; and we would be involved in great guilt if, with such danger pressing, we did not seem to act in any way.

CAP. II. — Therefore, while the ancient constitutions remain in force by reason of their reverence—which, where no strait of circumstances or times presses, it is fitting to observe regularly—to the extent that we grant to churches that are either deprived of all ministers, or so despoiled of sufficient services that they cannot supply the divine gifts to the peoples belonging to them, the intervals both for ordaining and for promoting clerical service are thus to be dispensed.

That if anyone even from a religious purpose, and instructed in monastic disciplines, should accede to the clerical office, first his life led in past times is to be inquired into: whether he is proved to be infected by no grave crime; whether perhaps he did not have a second wife, nor is shown to have taken one left by a husband; whether perhaps he did not perform public penance, nor appears maimed in any part of the body; whether he is not bound by servile or original condition; whether already of the curia...

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:78 · narrative
Source · Latin

etiam] probatur nexibus ahsolutus; si assecutus est litteras, sine quibus vix fortassis ostiarii possit implere ministerium: utsi his omnibus quæ sunt praedicta fulcitur, continuo lector, vel notarius, aut certe defensor effectus, post tres menses existat acolythus, maxime si huic ætas etiam suffragatur; sexto mense subdiaconi nomen accipiat; ac si modestæ conversationis honestæque voluntatis existit, nono mense diaconus, completoque anno sit presbyter: cui tamen, quod annorum interstitia fueram collatura, sancti propositi sponte suscepta doceatur præstitisse devotio.

I CAP. III. — Si vero de laicis quispiam ecclesiasticis est aggregandus officiis, tanto sollicitius in singulis, quae superius comprehensa sunt, hujusmodi decet examinari personam, quantum inter mundanam religiosamque vitam constat esse discriminis: quia utique convenientia ecclesiæ ministeria reparanda sunt, non inconvenientibus meritis ingerenda; tantoque magis, quod sacris aptum possit esse servitiis, in eorum quærendum est institutis, quantum [al. quanto] de tempore quo fuerant haec assequenda decerpitur: ut morum habere doceatur hoc probitas, quod prolixior consuetudo non contulit; ne per occasionem supplendae penuriae clericalis vitia potius divinis cultibus, intulisse judicemur, non legitimæ familiæ computemur procurasse compendia; quorum promotionibus super anni metas, sex menses nihilo.

English

even is proved to be released from bonds; if he has obtained the letters without which he can perhaps scarcely fulfill the office of doorkeeper: so that if he is supported by all these things which have been stated above, he shall forthwith be made lector, or notary, or certainly defensor, and after three months shall become acolyte, especially if his age also favors this; in the sixth month let him receive the name of subdeacon; and if he proves to be of modest conduct and honorable will, in the ninth month let him be deacon, and when the year is completed let him be presbyter: yet let him be taught that the devotion of a holy purpose, voluntarily undertaken, has supplied for him what the intervals of years would have contributed.

CHAPTER III. — But if any one from the laity is to be joined to ecclesiastical offices, so much the more carefully in each of the things which have been comprehended above ought a person of this kind to be examined, as it is evident that there is a difference between the worldly and the religious life: because, of course, ministries suited to the church are to be restored, not thrust upon unsuitable merits; and so much the more, what can be fit for sacred services is to be sought in their instructions, as time is snatched away from that in which these things were to be attained: so that the probity of his morals may be taught to possess what a longer custom has not conferred; lest through the occasion of supplying the scarcity of clergy we be judged to have brought vices rather than divine worship, and to have procured advantages not for a legitimate household; for whose promotions beyond the bounds of a year, six months are nothing.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:79 · narrative
Source · Latin

minus subrogamus: quoniam, sicut dictum est, distare convenit inter personam, divino cultui deditam et de laicorum conversatione venientem; quae tamen eatenus indulgenda credidimus, ut illis ecclesiis quibus infestatione bellorum vel nulla penitus, vel exigua remanserunt, ministeria renoventur, quatenus his Deo propitio restitutis, in ecclesiasticis gradibus subrogandis canonum paternorum vetus forma servetur. Nec contra eos ulla ratione prævaleat, quod pro accidentis defectus remedio providetur, non adversus scita majorum nova lege proponitur: caeteris ecclesiis ab hac occasione cessantibus, quas non simili clade vastatas, pristinam faciendis ordinationibus convenit tenere sententiam. Quo magis bac opportunitate commoniti, observantiam venerandorum canonum propensius deleganius, singulorum graduum conscientias admonentes, ne in illicitos prorumpere moliantur excessus.

English

we substitute him the less readily, since, as has been said, a distinction ought to be made between a person devoted to the divine worship and one coming from the manner of life of the laity. Nevertheless, we have believed that this should be granted to the extent that in those churches in which, through the ravages of wars, either no ministries at all or only scanty ones remain, they may be renewed, so that, when these have been restored with God's favor, the ancient form of the fathers' canons may be preserved in appointing men to ecclesiastical ranks. Nor should that which is provided as a remedy for an incidental deficiency prevail against them on any grounds, nor is a new law proposed against the decrees of the elders; while the remaining churches abstain from this occasion—churches which, not laid waste by a similar disaster, ought to maintain their former judgment in performing ordinations. Therefore, the more we are admonished by this occasion, the more earnestly should we entrust the observance of the venerable canons, warning the consciences of individuals of every rank not to attempt to break out into illicit excesses.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:80 · narrative
Source · Latin

Nec fas esse confidat quisque pontificum, bigamos, aut conjugia sortientes ab aliis derelicta, sive quoslibet poenitentium [al. post pœnitentiam], vel sine litteris, vcl corpore vitiatos [al. minutos, vel conditionarios, aut curiae publicarumque rerum nexibus implicatos, aut passim nulla temporis congruentis exspectatione discussos, divinisserviturosapplicarc mysteriis; neque pro suo libitu jura studeant aliena pervadere, absque sedis apostolicæ justa dispositione mandante.

CAr. IV. — Basilicas noviter institutas non petitic; ex more praeceptionibus, dedicare non audeant, nec ambiant episcopi sibimet vindicare clericos potestatis alienae.

CAP. V. — Baptizandis consignandisque fidelibus sacerdotes pretia nulla præfigant, nec illationibus quibuslibet impositis exagitare cupiant renascentes: quoniam quod gratis accepimus, gratis dare mandamur (Mallh. x). Et ideo nihil a praedictis prorsus exigere moliantur, quo vel paupertate cogente deterniti, vel indignatione revocati, redemptionis suae causas adire.despiciant; certum habentes quod qui prohibila deprehensi fuerint admisisse, vel commissa non potius sua sponte correxerint, periculum subituri proprii sint honoris.

English

Nor should any pontiff trust that it is lawful to apply to the divine mysteries men who have been twice married, or who have taken in marriage women abandoned by others, or any of the penitents, or those without letters, or those maimed in body, or bound by obligations of the curia and public affairs, or indiscriminately examined without waiting for a fitting time; nor should they strive to usurp the rights of others at their own pleasure, without the just disposition of the apostolic see commanding it.

Chapter IV. — Let them not seek basilicas newly established; let them not dare to dedicate them without instructions according to custom, nor should bishops strive to claim for themselves the clerics of another's authority.

Chapter V. — Let priests set no fees for baptizing and confirming the faithful, nor desire to harass the reborn with any impositions of offerings; since what we have received freely, we are commanded to give freely (Matt. 10). And therefore let them strive to exact nothing at all from the aforesaid, by which either, compelled by poverty and deterred, or recalled by indignation, they might disdain to seek the causes of their redemption; holding it certain that those who are found to have committed forbidden things, or who have not rather corrected their offenses of their own accord, will undergo the danger of their own honor.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:81 · narrative
Source · Latin

CAP. VI. — Nec minus etiam presbyteros ultra modum suum tendere prohibemus; nec episcopali fastigio debita sibimet audacter assumere: non conficiendi chrismalis, non consignationis pontilicalis adhibendæ sibimet arripere facultatem; non praesente quolibet antistite, nisi fortasse jubeantur, vel orationis, vel actionis sacræ supplendae sibi præsumant esse licentiam; neque sub ejus aspectu, nisi jubeantur, aut sedere præsumant, aut' veneranda [al. venerabilia] tractarc mysteria. Nec sibi memincrint ulla ratione concedi, sine summo pontifice, subdiaconum aut acolythum jus habere faciendi; nec prorsus addubitent, si quidquam ad episcopale ministerium specia liter pertinens suo motu putaverint exsequendum, continuo se presbyterii dignitate et sacra communiono privari. Quod fieri necesse est censeamus, si corum praesule defcrente, hujusmodi fuerit prævari catio [al. præsumptio] comprobata, nec ipso eorum episcopo a culpa conniventiae et ultione vacaturo, si immoderata facientem dissimulaverit vindicare.

English

CHAPTER VI. — We also forbid presbyters to overstep their measure, and boldly to assume for themselves what is due to the episcopal rank: they are not to seize for themselves the faculty of confecting chrism, nor of administering episcopal consignation; nor, in the presence of any bishop, unless perhaps they are ordered, are they to presume to have license to supply the prayer or the sacred action; nor in his sight, unless ordered, are they to presume either to sit or to handle the venerable mysteries. Nor should they forget that it is by no means conceded to them, without the supreme pontiff, to have the right of making a subdeacon or an acolyte; nor should they doubt at all that, if they think anything specifically pertaining to the episcopal ministry is to be carried out on their own initiative, they are forthwith to be deprived of the dignity of the presbyterate and of sacred communion. We judge that this must be done if, when their prelate is absent, a transgression of this kind is proven, nor is their own bishop free from the guilt of connivance and from punishment, if he has overlooked vindicating one who does immoderate things.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:82 · narrative
Source · Latin

CAP. VII. — Diaconos quoque propriam constituimus scrvare mensuram, nec ultra tenorem (Nic. XVII) paternis canonibus deputatum quippiam tentare permittimus; nihil eorum penitus suo ministerio applicare, quæ primis ordinibus proprie decrevit antiquitas. Absque episcopo vel presbytero baplizare non audeant, nisi, praedictis fortasse officiis longius (onstitutis, necessitas extrema compellat. Quod et laicis Christianis facere pletumque conceditur.

CAP. VIII. — Non in presbyterio residere, cum divina celebrantur, vel ecclesiasticus habetur [al. celebratur] quicunque tractatus. Sacri corporis prærogationem, sub conspeclu pontificis seu presbyteri, nisi his absentibus, jus non habeant exercendi.

Cum enim decreta venerabilium sanctionum nos quoque magnopere custodire nitamur, ac sine eorum dispendio etiam illa quae pro alicujus utilitatis compendio fortasse videantur laxanda, credamus.

English

CHAPTER VII. — We also decree that deacons observe their proper measure, and we do not permit them to attempt anything beyond the tenor assigned by the paternal canons, nor to apply in any way to their own ministry any of those things which antiquity properly decreed to the first orders. Without a bishop or presbyter they shall not presume to baptize, unless perhaps, with the aforementioned offices established at a distance, extreme necessity compels it. Which is also frequently conceded to Christian laymen to do.

CHAPTER VIII. — That no one, while divine rites are being celebrated or any ecclesiastical treatise is held, is to preside in the presbyterium. They are not to have the right of exercising the prerogative of the sacred body in the sight of the pontiff or presbyter, unless these are absent.

For since we also strive greatly to keep the decrees of the venerable sanctions, we believe that even those things which may perhaps seem to be relaxed for the advantage of someone's benefit should be [kept] without their loss.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:83 · narrative
Source · Latin

CAP. IX. — Cumque nobis contra salutarium revcrendam regularum cupiamus temere nihil licere, et cum sedes aposlolica superior his omnibus, favente nomino, quae paternis canonibus sunt præfixa, pio devotoque studeat tenere proposilo; satis indignum est quemquam vel pontificum, vel ordinum subsequentium, hanc observanliam refutare, quam beati Petri sedem et sequi videat et docere: salisque convcnienssit, ut lotum corpus Ecclesiæ in hac sibimet observatione concordet, quam illic vigere conspiciat, ubi Dominus Ecclesiae totius posuit principatum, dicenle Scriptura: Ordinate in me caritatem (Cant. n). Et item: Omnia cum ordine fiant (/ Cor. XIV). Atque itcrum psalmista praedicante: Circumdate Sion, et complectimini eam, narrate in turribus ejus. Ponite corda vesCra in virtute ejus, et distribuite gradus ejus, ut enarretis in progenies alteras. quoniam hic est Deus, Deus noster in æternum; et ipse reget nos in sæcula (Psal. XLVII).

English

CHAPTER IX. — Since we desire that nothing be rashly permitted to us against the revered salutary rules, and since the Apostolic See, superior to all these things, strives with a pious and devoted purpose, with favorable name, to maintain what has been fixed by the paternal canons, it is quite unworthy that anyone, whether of the pontiffs or of the orders that follow, should reject this observance which he sees the See of blessed Peter both to follow and to teach; and it is quite fitting that the whole body of the Church should be in concord in this observance which it beholds flourishing there where the Lord placed the principate of the whole Church, as the Scripture says: Set in order love in me (Song of Songs 2). And again: Let all things be done with order (1 Corinthians 14). And again, as the psalmist proclaims: Surround Zion, and embrace her, tell in her towers. Set your hearts on her strength, and distribute her steps, that you may tell it to another generation, for this is God, our God forever; and he himself will rule us for ages (Psalm 47).

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:84 · narrative
Source · Latin

Hic procul dubio, qui in ecclesiasticarum narratur altitudine dignitatum, et in cujus virtute bonis operibus corda ponenda sunt, gradibus utique distributis, cunctis Deus noster et rector populis prædicandus est christianis: ubi nemo sibimet aliquid jam existimet imminutum, cum et de uniuscujusque gradus perfectione nihil deperit, et convenienter retinendo, quod coelesti dispensatione collatum est, pariter nobis et cognoscibilem Deum fieri, ct tribuit esse rectorem. Nam et si quid indulgetur de temporum quantitate moribus aggregata strenuitate pensatur: si vitæ jam [al. etiam] proposito continetur, quod protelata fuerat aetate curandum, dummodo illa nullatenus dissimulata subrepant [al. subripiant] quorum quodlibet, si inesse claruerit, merito clericalibus infulis reprobabilem convincatesse personam. Etsi illa nonnunquam sinenda sunt, quæ, si caeterorum constet integritas, sola nocere non valeant, illa tamen sunt magnopere præcavenda, quæ recipi nisi manifesta decoloratione non possint. Ac si ea ipsa, quae nullo detrimento aliquoties indulgenda creduntur, vel rerum temporumque cogit intuitus, vel acceleratae provisionis respectus excusat; quanto magis illa nullatenus mutilanda sunt, quæ nec ulla necessitas, nec ecclesiastica prorsus extorquet utilitas?

English

Here, without doubt, he who is described as being in the height of ecclesiastical dignities, and in whose virtue hearts are to be set upon good works, with ranks duly distributed, is to be proclaimed as our God and ruler to all Christian peoples. In this no one should now think that anything is diminished for himself, since nothing is lost from the perfection of each one's rank, and by fittingly retaining what has been conferred by heavenly dispensation, it is granted to us both that God becomes known to us and that he is our ruler. For even if something is granted in the matter of the quantity of times, it is weighed by the vigor of character that has been accumulated; if it is already contained in the purpose of one's life, what had been deferred for a later age must be attended to, provided that those things by no means steal in unheeded, any one of which, if it becomes clear that it is present, rightly convicts the person of being reprobate for clerical honors. And even if those things are sometimes to be allowed which, if the integrity of the rest is established, cannot harm by themselves, nevertheless those things are greatly to be guarded against which cannot be received except with manifest disgrace. And if those very things which are sometimes believed to be indulged without any detriment are excused either by the consideration of circumstances and times or by regard for hastened provision, how much more are those things by no means to be curtailed which neither any necessity nor any ecclesiastical utility at all extorts?

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:85 · narrative
Source · Latin

CAP. X. - Bapuzandi sibi quisquam passim quocunque tempore nullam credat inesse fiduciam, præter paschale festum et pentecostes venerabile sacramentum, excepto duntaxat gravissimi languoris incursu; in quo verendum est ne, morbi crescente. periculo, sine remedio salutari fortassis aegrotans exilio præventus abscedat.

CAP. XI. — Ordinationes etiam presbyterorum et diaconorum, nisi certis temporibus et diebus, exercere non debent, id est, quarti mensis jejunio, septimi, et decimi, sed et etiam quadragcsimalis iuitii, ac mediana Quadragesimae die, sabbati jejunio circa vesperam noverint celebrandas. Nec cujuslibet utilitatis 3causa, seu presbyterum seu diaconum his praeferre [al. praeferri], qui anle ipsos fuerint ordinati.

CAP. XII. — Devotis quoque Deo virginibus, misi aut in Epiphaniarum [lege Epiphaniorum] die aut in Albis paschalibus, aut in apostolorum natalitiis sacrum minime velamen imponant, nisi forsitan (sicut de baptismate dictum est) gravi languore correptis. ne sine hoc munere de sæculo exeant. implorantibus non negetur.

English

CHAPTER X. Let no one believe that there is any warrant for baptizing anyone indiscriminately at any time whatsoever, apart from the Paschal festival and the venerable sacrament of Pentecost, except only in the case of the onset of most grievous illness; in which it is to be feared that, as the danger of the disease increases, the sick person may perhaps depart, overtaken by death, without the remedy of salvation.

CHAPTER XI. They ought not to carry out ordinations of presbyters and deacons except at fixed times and days, that is, at the fast of the fourth month, the seventh, and the tenth, but also of the Lenten fast, and on the middle day of Lent, and they are to know that the fast of the Sabbath is to be celebrated toward evening. Nor, for the sake of any advantage, is a presbyter or deacon to be preferred to those who were ordained before them.

CHAPTER XII. Also, to virgins devoted to God they are not to impose the sacred veil except on the day of the Epiphany, or on the white garments of Easter, or on the birthdays of the apostles, unless perhaps (as was said concerning baptism) it is not to be denied to those imploring it who have been seized by grave illness, lest they depart from this world without this gift.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:86 · narrative
Source · Latin

CAP. XIII. — Viduas autem velarc pontificum nullus attentet, quod nec auctoritas divina delegat, Dee canonum forma praestiluit. Non est ergo penitus usurpandum, eisque sic ecclesiastica sunt ferenda [forte conferenda vel inferenda] præsidia, ut nihil committatur illicitum.

CAP. XIV. — Generalis etiam querelæ vitanda præsumptio est, qua propemodum causantur universi, passim servos ei originarios, dominorum jura possessionumque [al. possessionem] fugientes, sub religiosæ conversationis obtentu, vel ad monasteria sese conferre, vel ad ecclesiasticum famulatum, conniventibus [al. cohibentibus] quoque præsulibus, indifferenter admitti: quæ modis omnibus est amovenda pernicies, ne per Christiani nominis insumtum, aut aliena pervadi, aut publica videatur disciplina subverti: præcipue cum nec ipsam ministerii clericalis hac obligatione fuscari conveniat dignitatem, cogaturque pro statu militantium sibi conditioneque jurgari, aut videri, quod absit, obnoxia.

English

CHAPTER XIII. — But let no pontiff attempt to veil widows, since neither does divine authority delegate this, nor has the form of the canons provided it. It is therefore not to be usurped at all, and ecclesiastical protections are so to be brought to them that nothing unlawful be committed.

CHAPTER XIV. — The presumption of the general complaint is also to be avoided, by which almost everyone alleges that slaves and those bound by origin to their masters, fleeing the rights of their lords and of their possessions, under the pretext of religious life either betake themselves to monasteries or to ecclesiastical service, and are indiscriminately admitted with the connivance of prelates. This pernicious practice is to be removed by all means, lest under the guise of the Christian name either the property of others be seized or public discipline be seen to be subverted; especially since it is not fitting that the very dignity of the clerical ministry be darkened by this obligation, and that it be forced to litigate for the status and condition of those who serve it, or to appear, which God forbid, liable.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:87 · narrative
Source · Latin

Quibus sollicita competenter interdictione prohibitis, quisquis episcopus, presbyter, aut diaconus, vel corum qui monasteriis præesse noscuntur, bujusmodi personas apud se leneules non restituendas palronis, aut deinceps vel ecclesiasticae servituti, vel religiosis congregationibus pulavcrinl applicandas, nisi voluntate forsitan dominorum, sub Scripturæ testimonio primitus absolutas, vel legitima transactione concessas, I ericulum se hoporis proprii non ambigant communionisque subituros, si super hac re cujusquam verax nos querela pulsaverit. Magnis quippe studiis, secundum beatum Apostolum, præcavendum est ne fides et disciplina Domini blasphemetur (/ Tim. VI).

CAP. XV. — Consequens fuit ut illa quoque quæ de Piceui partibus nuper ad nos missa relatio nuntiavit, non prætereunda putaremus, id est, plurimos cler icorum negotiationibus inhonestis et lucris turpibus imminere, nullo pudore cernentes evangelicam lecHonem, qua ipse Dominus negotiatores e tempto verberatos flagellis asseritur expulissc (Matth. xxi; Joan. u); nec Apostoli verba recolentes, quibus ait: Nemo utilitans Deo implicat se negociis sæcularibus (II Tim. II; Psalmistam quoque David surJa dissimulantes aure cantantem: Quoniam non cognovit negotiationes, introibo in potentias Domini (Psal, LXX).

English

Since these persons have been duly prohibited by a careful interdict, whatever bishop, presbyter, or deacon, or those who are known to preside over monasteries, shall keep such persons with them, not to be restored to their patrons, or shall thereafter see to applying them either to ecclesiastical servitude or to religious congregations, unless perhaps by the will of their masters, first absolved under the testimony of Scripture, or granted by legitimate transaction, let them not doubt that they will undergo danger to their own office and to communion, if a truthful complaint concerning this matter has reached us. For with great zeal, according to the blessed Apostle, we must guard against the faith and discipline of the Lord being blasphemed (1 Tim. 6).

CHAPTER XV. — It followed that we should not think those things also, which the report recently sent to us from the regions of Picenum announced, were to be passed over, that is, that very many of the clergy are intent on dishonorable business dealings and shameful profits, seeing with no shame the Gospel reading in which the Lord Himself is said to have driven out the merchants, beaten with whips after the attempt (Matt. 21; John 2); nor recalling the words of the Apostle, in which he says: No one serving as a soldier of God entangles himself in secular business (2 Tim. 2); and also heedlessly ignoring the Psalmist David singing: For he has not known business dealings, I will enter into the powers of the Lord (Ps. 70).

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:88 · narrative
Source · Latin

Proinde hujusmodi aut ab indgnis posl hac quæstibus noverint asbtinendum, ct ab omni cujuslibet negotiationis ingenio vel cupiditate cessandum; aut in quocunque gradu sint positi, mox a clericalibus officiis I abstinere cogamur: quoniam donnus Dei, domus orationis (Luc. XIX) cl csse debet, et dici, ne officina negotiationis et spelunca potius sit latronum (Isai. L).

CAP. XVI. — illiteratos quoque, et nonnulla parte corporis imminutos, sine ullo respectu ad ecclesiasticum didicimus venire servitium. Quod simul antiqua traditio, et apostolicæ sedis vetus forma non recipit; quia ucc litteris carens sacris esse potest a pIUS officiis et vitiosum nihil prorsus Deo offerri lcgalia præcepta sanxerunt (Levit.xxi; Deut. XVII). Itaque de cætero modis omnibus' hæc vitentur, nec quisquam talis suscipiatur in clerum. Si qui vero vel temeritate propria, vel incuria præsidentium tales ante suscepti sunt, in his quibus constituti sunt locis catcnus perseverent, ut nihil unquam promotionis accipiant; satisque habeant hoc ipsum sibi pro nimia miseratione permissum.

English

Accordingly, let such persons know that they must hereafter abstain from unworthy gains, and must cease from every device and desire of any business whatsoever; or, whatever rank they may hold, we shall be compelled to force them to withdraw immediately from clerical offices, since the house of God must be and be called a house of prayer (Luke 19), lest it be rather a workshop of business and a den of robbers (Isaiah 56).

CHAPTER XVI. — We have learned that illiterate persons also, and those lacking some part of the body, come to ecclesiastical service without any regard. This both ancient tradition and the old form of the apostolic see do not receive, because legal precepts have sanctioned that one lacking letters can be of no use for sacred offices, and that nothing defective may be offered to God (Leviticus 21; Deuteronomy 17). Therefore, henceforth let these things be avoided by all means, and let no such person be received into the clergy. But if any such persons have been received before, whether through their own rashness or through the negligence of those presiding, let them remain in the positions in which they have been placed only to this extent, that they receive no promotion ever; and let them consider it sufficient that this very thing has been permitted them out of excessive compassion.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:89 · narrative
Source · Latin

CAP. XVII. — De his autem qui seipsos abscindunt, paterni canones evidenter sequcuda posuerunt; qutrum tenorem sufficiat iudidissc. Dicunt enim, talia perpetrantes, mox ut aguiti fuerint, a muncre clericali debere secludi. Quod modis omnibus custodire nos convenit, quia fas esse nulli suppeditat quidquam præter illa quæ memorabilis decrcvit forma censere.

CAP. XVIII. — Comperimus etiam horrendis quibusdam criminibus implicatos, tota discretione submota, non solum de factis atrocibus necessariam poenitudinem non habere, sed nec aliqua correctione penitus succedente, ad divinum ministerium hono. remque contendere. Nonnullos autem etiam in ipsis ordinibus constitutos, gravibus delinquentes facinoribus, non repelli, cum et Apostolus clamet: Nemini cito manus imponendas, neque communicandum peccatis alienis (I Tim. v); et majorum veneranda constituta (Nicæni 910) pronuntient, hujusmodi, etiam si forte subrepserint, tam qui ante peccaverunt, detectos oportere repelli, quam sacrae professionis obi! tos, prævaricatoresque sancti propositi, procul dubio submovendos.

English

CHAPTER XVII. — Concerning those who mutilate themselves, the canons of the Fathers have evidently laid down what must be followed; it suffices to have judged their tenor. For they say that those who perpetrate such things, as soon as they are discovered, ought to be excluded from the clerical office. This we must guard in every way, because it is not permitted to anyone to decree anything beyond what that memorable form has decided.

CHAPTER XVIII. — We have learned also that certain persons entangled in horrendous crimes, with all discernment set aside, not only do not have the necessary repentance for their atrocious deeds, but with no correction at all ensuing, strive for the divine ministry and honor. Moreover, certain persons even established in those very orders, offending by grave misdeeds, are not repelled, although the Apostle cries out: Lay hands on no one quickly, nor share in the sins of others (I Tim. 5); and the venerable decrees of the elders (of Nicaea) pronounce that such persons, even if they have perhaps crept in, must be repelled once detected, just as those who have sinned beforehand, and those forgetful of their sacred profession and prevaricators of their holy purpose, must without doubt be removed.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:90 · narrative
Source · Latin

CAP. XIX. — Usque adeo sane comperimus illiciia quæque prorumpere, ut dæmoniacis similibusque [al. dxmone aliisque] passionibus irretitis minisleria [al. mysteria] sacrosancta tractare tribuatur. Quibus si hoc opere positis aliquid propriæ necessitatis occurrat, quis de sua [supple ac] fidelium salute confidet, ubi ministros ipsos curationis humanæ tanta I perspexerit calamitate vexari? Atque ideo necessario removendi sunt, ne quibuslibet, pro quibus Christus est mortuus, scandalum generetur infirmis (Rom. XIV; II Cor. VIII). Postremo, si corpore sauciatum fortassis aut debilem, nequaquam sancta contingere lex divina permittit(Levit. XXI); quanto magis doni cœlestis dispensatores esse non convenit, quod est delerius, mente perculsos [al. percussos]?

CAP. XX. — Virginibus autem sacris temere so quosdam sociare cognovimus, et post dicaLum Deo propositum, incesta foedera sacrilegaque miscere. Quos protinus aequum est a sacra communione detfudi, et nisi per publicam probatamque pœnitentiam, omnino non recipi, II sed tamen viaticum de sæculo transeuntibus, si tamen poenituerint, non negetur.

English

CHAPTER XIX. — We have indeed discovered that unlawful practices break out to such an extent that the sacrosanct mysteries are assigned to be handled by those entangled in demonic and similar passions. If, when such persons are placed in this office, some personal necessity befalls them, who will be confident of his own salvation and that of the faithful, when he perceives that the very ministers of human healing are vexed by such great calamity? And therefore they must necessarily be removed, lest scandal be generated for the weak, for whomsoever Christ died (Rom. XIV; II Cor. VIII). Finally, if one is perhaps wounded or weak in body, the divine law by no means permits him to touch the holy things (Lev. XXI); how much more is it unfitting — which is more grievous — that those stricken in mind should be dispensers of the heavenly gift?

CHAPTER XX. — We have learned that certain persons rashly associate themselves with sacred virgins, and after the vow dedicated to God, contract incestuous and sacrilegious unions. It is right that these be immediately driven from sacred communion, and not received at all unless through public and approved penance, but nevertheless the viaticum at the passage from this world, if they have repented, is not to be denied them.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:91 · narrative
Source · Latin

CAP. XXI. — Nam de viduis sub nulla benedictione velandis, superius' late sufficienterque prædiximus [ forte leg. latius duximus disserendum]. Quæ si propria voluntate professam pristini conjugii castitatem mutabili mente calcavcrint, periculi carum intererit, quali Deum debeant satisfactione placare, R quia (juxta Apostolum) primam fidem irritam fecerunt (I Tim. v). Sicut cnim, si se forsitan continere non poterant, sccundum Apostolum, nullatenus nubere vetabantur (/ Cor. VII); sic habita secum deliberatione, promissam Deo pudiciliae fidem debent [al. debuerunt] custodire. Nos autem talibus nullum laqueum dcbemus injiccre; sed solum adhortationes praemii sempiterni, poenasque proponere divini judicii, ut et nostra sit absoluta conscientia, et illarum pro se rationem Deo reddat intentio. Cavendum est quippe, ut de carum moribus actibusquc beatus Apostolus (I Tim. v) testatur, quod plenius [al. planius; ita in Luc. J exponere praeterimus, ne sexus instabilis non tam deterreri quam admoneri videatur.

English

CHAPTER XXI. — For concerning widows who are to be veiled under no blessing, we have spoken above at length and sufficiently. If by their own will they have professed the chastity of their former marriage and then with a changeable mind have trampled it underfoot, it will be their concern, at their peril, with what satisfaction they ought to appease God, because (according to the Apostle) they have made void their first faith (1 Tim. 5). For just as, if perhaps they could not contain themselves, according to the Apostle they were in no way forbidden to marry (1 Cor. 7), so, having deliberated with themselves, they ought to keep the pledge of purity promised to God. But we ought to cast no snare upon such women, but only to set before them the exhortations of eternal reward and the penalties of divine judgment, so that our conscience may be free and their own intention may render an account to God on their behalf. For it must be guarded against — as the blessed Apostle testifies concerning their morals and actions (1 Tim. 5) — that which we pass over in fuller exposition, lest the unstable sex seem not so much to be deterred as to be admonished.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:92 · narrative
Source · Latin

CAP. XXII. — Secundas nuptias sicut sæcularibus inire conceditur, ita post eas nullus ad clericale sinitur venire collegium. Alia est enim humanæ fragilitati generaliler concessa licentia, alia debet esse vita divinarum rerum servitio dedicata.

CAP. XXIII. — Quisquis propriæ desertor ecclesiae, nullis existentibus causis, ad aliam putaverit transeundum, temereque susceptus fuerit et promotus, reverendorum canonum vel ipse vel receptor [ad quem profectus est] ejus atque provector constituta non effugiet, quæ de hujusmodi præsumptoribus præfixere servanda (Nicæni xv et XVI).

CAP. XXIV. — De monachis laicisqne in prima copiosius præceptionis hujus I parte digestum est, (Vide supra cap. et 3), quae vel quatenus his pro rerum temporumque necessitate concessa sint, vel quemadmodum, ubi nullius necessitatis [forte facti necessitas] interesse probatur, non nisi vetus institutio debeat custodiri. Quos vero constiterit indignos meritis, sacram mercatos esse pretio dignitatem, convictos oportet arceri non sine periculo facinus tale a perpetrantes: quia dantem pariter et accipientem damuatio Simonis, quam sacra lectio (Ad. VIJI) testatur, involvit.

English

CHAPTER XXII. — Just as it is granted to worldly men to enter into second marriages, so after them no one is permitted to come into the clerical college. For one thing is the license generally granted to human frailty, and another must be the life dedicated to the service of divine things.

CHAPTER XXIII. — Whoever, being a deserter of his own church, with no causes existing, thinks he should pass over to another, and has been rashly received and promoted, neither he himself nor his receiver [to whom he went] and promoter shall escape the decrees of the revered canons, which they have fixed to be observed concerning presumptuous men of this kind (Nicene xv and XVI).

CHAPTER XXIV. — Concerning monks and laymen, it has been set forth more copiously in the first part of this precept (See above chap. and 3), what or to what extent has been granted to them according to the necessity of circumstances and times, or in what manner, where the interest of no necessity [perhaps the necessity of fact] is proved, only the ancient institution ought to be preserved. But those who are established to be unworthy in merits, having purchased the sacred dignity for a price, once convicted must be kept away not without danger, committing such a crime: because the condemnation of Simon, which the sacred reading (Ad. VIII) testifies, involves both the giver and the receiver equally.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:93 · narrative
Source · Latin

CAP. XXV. — De locorum consecratione sanctorum, quamvis super ius (Cap. 4) strictim fuerit comprehensum nobis quoque patefactum est, quod absque præcepto sedis apostolicænonnulli factas ecclesias vel oratoria sacrare præsumant: hoc sumus tamen indicio detestabiliore permoti, quod in quocunque [ al. quorumcunque] nomine defunctorum, et (quantum dicitur) nec omnino fidelium, constructiones ædificatas sacris processionibus [AI., professionibus] audacter instituere memorantur: quæ quoniam tam acerba iam dura sunt 4, si revera Christianitatis affe. ctus in illis regionibus certus et fixus est, et districtius ista quærantur, et a quibus fuerint gesta, prodantur: quoniam sicut latentibus in hac atrocitate nominibus non exstat, in quem sententia debita proferatur; ita cum manifestis fuerit documentis expositus, quem [forte quam] tanti scelcris poscit immanitas, non effugiet [forte vitabit ullatenus ultionem.

English

CHAPTER XXV. — Concerning the consecration of holy places, although it was briefly included above in the law (Chapter 4), it has also been made clear to us that some, without the precept of the apostolic see, presume to consecrate churches or oratories that have been built. We are, however, moved by a more detestable indication: that in the name of any dead persons whatsoever, and (as is said) not even altogether of the faithful, they are reported boldly to institute buildings constructed with sacred processions. Since these things are already so harsh and severe, if truly the affection of Christianity in those regions is certain and fixed, let these matters be investigated more strictly, and let those by whom they were done be exposed. For just as, when the names lie hidden in this atrocity, there is no one against whom the due sentence may be pronounced, so when it has been exposed by clear proofs, he whom the enormity of so great a crime demands will not escape punishment.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:94 · narrative
Source · Latin

CAP. XXVI. — Nihilominus impaticnter audivimus tantum divinarum rerum subiisse despectum, ut feminae sacris altaribus ministrare feramur [al. firmentur; ita et in Luc.]; et cuncta quæ non nisi virorum famulatui deputata sunt, sexum cui non competit exhibere.

Viso [al. nisi; ita et in Luc.] quod omnium delictorum quæ sigillatim perstrinximus, noxa omnis [al. noxiorum reatus omnis] et crimen eos respicit sacerdotes qui vel ista committunt, vel committentes minime publicando, pravis cxcessibus se favere significant: si tamen sacerdotum jam sint vocabulo nuncupandi, qui a delegatum sibi religionis officium sc prosternere molium ur, ut in perversa quæque profanaque declives, sine ullo respectu regulae Christianae præcipitia funesta sectentur. Cumque scriptum sit: Minima qui spernit, paulatim decidit (Eccli. XIX, 1): quid est de talibus existimandum qui immensis ac multiplicibus pravitalum molibus occupati, ingentem ruinam multimodis impulsionibus ediderunt, quae non solum ipsos videatur obruere, sed et Ecclesiis universis mortiferam, si non sanentur, inferre perniciem? Nec ambigant qui hæc ausi sunt exercere, sed etiam qui hactenus cognita siluerunt, sub honoris proprii se jacere dispendio, si non quanta possint celeritate festinent, ut lethalia vulnera competenti medicatione curentur.

English

CHAPTER XXVI. — Nevertheless, we have heard with impatience that such great contempt for divine things has been incurred, that women are reported to minister at the sacred altars; and that all things which are assigned only to the service of men, a sex to which it does not belong presumes to exhibit.

Since this has been seen, the guilt of all the offenses which we have enumerated one by one, and the charge, pertains to those priests who either commit these things, or by not making public those who commit them, signify that they favor depraved excesses: if indeed they are now to be called by the name of priests, who strive to cast themselves down from the office of religion delegated to them, so that, sloping toward all perverse and profane things, they pursue deadly precipices without any regard for the Christian rule. And since it is written: He who despises the least things falls little by little (Sirach 19:1): what is to be thought of such men who, occupied with immense and manifold masses of wickedness, have produced a huge ruin by many kinds of impulses, which seems not only to overwhelm them but also, if they are not healed, to bring deadly destruction upon all the churches? Nor should those who have dared to do these things be in doubt, but also those who have until now kept silent about things known, that they lie under the loss of their own honor, if they do not hasten with what speed they can, that the lethal wounds be cured by suitable medication.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:95 · narrative
Source · Latin

Quo enim more teneant jura pontificum, qui pontificalibus excubiis eatenus injuncta dissimulant, ut contraria domui Dei, cui praesident, potius operentur? Qui quantum apud Dominum possent, si non nisi convenientia procurarent, tantum quid mereantur aspiciant, cum cxsecrabili studio sectentur adversa. Et quasi magis hæc regula sit qua Ecclesiæ debeant gubernari, si quidquid est ecclesiasticis inimicum regulis perpetratur, cum et si eognitos habuit canones unusquisque pontificum, inte. merata debuerit tencre custodia. Et si forsilan nesciebat, consulere fidenter oportuerit scicntem [al. ignorantem]. Quo magis excusatio nulla succurrit errantibus: quia nesciens [nec sciens omnino legendum est, ut habet cod. Just. et edit, Canon], proposuit servare quod noverat, nec ignorans curavit nosse quod gereret.

CAP. XXVII. — Quatuor autem tam de reditu quam de oblationc fidclium, prout cujuslibet ecclesiæ facultas admittit, sicut dudum rationabiliter est decretum, convenit fieri portiones. Quarum sit una pontificis, altera clericorum, pauperum tertia, quarta fabricis applicanda. De quibus, sicut sacerdotis intererit, integram ministris ecclesiæ memoratam dependere quantitatem, sic clerus [al. clericus] ultra delegatam sibi summam nihil insolenter noverit expetendum.

English

For in what manner do they uphold the rights of pontiffs, who by their pontifical watchfulness so far dissimulate the duties enjoined upon them that they rather work against the house of God over which they preside? Let them consider how much they could avail with the Lord if they sought only what is fitting, and how much they deserve when with execrable zeal they pursue things contrary. And it is as if this were rather the rule by which the churches ought to be governed, if whatever is hostile to ecclesiastical rules is perpetrated, whereas even if each pontiff had the canons known to him, he ought to have kept them with undiminished custody. And if perhaps he did not know them, he should confidently have consulted one who knew. Hence no excuse comes to the aid of those who err, because one who does not know proposed to preserve what he knew, and one who is not ignorant took care to know what he was doing.

CHAPTER XXVII. — Moreover, four portions, both from the return and from the offering of the faithful, as the means of each church allows, as has long since been reasonably decreed, ought to be made. Of these, let one be the pontiff's, another the clergy's, the third the poor's, and the fourth to be applied to buildings. Concerning these, just as it will be the priest's concern to pay over the entire stated amount to the ministers of the church, so let the clergy know that nothing beyond the sum delegated to them is to be presumptuously sought.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:96 · narrative
Source · Latin

Ea vero quæ ecclesiasticis ædificiis attributa sunt, huic operi veraciler prærogata, locorum doceat instauratio manifesta sanctorum: quia nefas est, si sacris aedibus destitutis, in lucrum suum præsul impendia his designata [al. deputata] convertat. Ipsam nihilominus ascriptam paupcribus portionem, quamvis divinis rationibus se dispensasse monstraturus esse videatur, tamen juxta quod scriptum est: Ut videant opera vestra bona, et glorificent Patrem vestrum, qui in cretis est (Matth. v), oportet etiam praesenti testificatione praedicari, et bonæ famæ præconiis non taceri.

CAP. XXVIII. — Quapropter nec [al. ne] clericorum quispiam se hujus offensæ futurum confudat immunem, si in his quae salubriler sequcnda deprompsimus, sive episcopum, sive presbyterum, sive diaconum viderit excedentem, non protinus ad aures nostras deferre curaverit, probationibus duntaxat competenter exhibitis, ut transgressoris ultio fiat, et caeteris interdictio delinquendi. Sui [ ale Sic] vero modis omnibus erit unusquisque pontificum ordinis et honoris elisor, si cuiquam clericorum, vel Ecclesiae totius auditui hæc putaverit supprimenda. Data v idus Martii (anno Christi 494), Asterio et Praesidio viris clarissimis consulibus. Et alia manu: Deus vos incolumes custodiat, fratres carissimi.

English

But those things which have been assigned to ecclesiastical buildings, truly set apart for this work, let the manifest restoration of the holy places make clear, because it is a sacrilege if, with the sacred buildings left destitute, the bishop turns to his own profit the expenditures designated for them. Likewise, that portion ascribed to the poor, although he may seem about to show that he has dispensed it by divine principles, nevertheless, according to what is written: "That they may see your good works, and glorify your Father who is in heaven" (Matt. 5), it ought also to be proclaimed by present testimony, and not passed over in silence by the heralding of good repute.

CHAPTER XXVIII. — Wherefore let no one of the clergy be confident that he will be free from this offense, if in those things which we have set forth as healthfully to be followed, he sees a bishop, or a presbyter, or a deacon transgressing, and has not immediately taken care to report it to our ears, with suitable proofs at least presented, so that punishment may be inflicted on the transgressor, and a prohibition against offending may be imposed on the rest. But he will in every way be a destroyer of his own rank and honor as a pontiff, if he thinks these things are to be suppressed from any of the clergy, or from the hearing of the whole Church. Given on the fifth day before the Ides of March (in the year of Christ 494), in the consulship of Asterius and Praesidius, most illustrious men. And in another hand: May God keep you safe, dearest brothers.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:97 · narrative
Source · Latin

EPISTOLA X.

AD EPISCOPOS SICILIÆ.

Ecclesiæ facultates ab episcopis, clericis et pauperibus distribui debere; diœceses et bona ecclesiæ ab epi-

copis triginta annos possessa eis non auferenda.

Gelasius Romanæ Ecclesiae episcopus dilectissimis et in Christi carilate unanimiter connexis fratribus episcopis qui in Sicilia sunt constituti.

Præsulum auctoritas nostrorum emanavit, ut facultates ecclesiæ episcopi ad regendum habeant potestatem; ita tamen ut viduarum, pupillorum, atque pauperum, nec non clericorum stipendia distribuere debeant. Hoc eis etiam statuimus dari, quod hactenus decretum est. Reliquum sibi episcopi vindicent, ut (sicut ante diximus) peregrinorum atque captivorum largitores esse possint.

Illud etiam adnecti placuit, ut si (quod absit) facultates ecclesiae,' nec non et diœceses quae ab aliquibus possidentur rpiscopis, jure sibi vindicent, quod tricennalis [al. tricennaria] lex conclusit, quia et filiorum nostrorum principum ita emanavit auctoritas, ut ultra triginta annos nulli liceat pro eo appellare, quod legum tempus [al. tutela, sive regula, aut potius cautela] exclusit. Data idibus Maii, Asterio et Praesidio viris clarissimis consulibus (anno Christi 494)

English

LETTER X.

TO THE BISHOPS OF SICILY.

That the resources of the church ought to be distributed by the bishops to the clergy and the poor; that dioceses and goods of the church possessed by bishops for thirty years are not to be taken from them.

Gelasius, bishop of the Roman Church, to his most beloved brothers and fellow bishops united in the love of Christ who are established in Sicily.

The authority of our predecessors has issued forth, that bishops are to have power to govern the resources of the church; yet in such a way that they ought to distribute the stipends of widows, wards, and the poor, and also of the clergy. We have also decreed that this be given to them, which has been decreed up to now. Let the bishops claim the rest for themselves, so that (as we said before) they may be givers to strangers and captives.

It has also pleased us to add this, that if (which God forbid) the resources of the church, and also the dioceses which are possessed by certain bishops, they claim for themselves by right, which the thirty-year law has concluded, since the authority of our sons the princes has also issued forth, that beyond thirty years it be lawful for no one to appeal on account of that which the time of the laws has excluded. Given on the Ides of May, in the consulship of Asterius and Praesidius, men of clarissimus rank (in the year of Christ 494).

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:98 · narrative
Source · Latin

EPISTOLA XI.

AD EPISCOPOS DARDANIÆ ET ILLYRICI.

Commendat eorum religionem; Thessalonicensem epi scopum, qui hæreticorum nomina damnare recusavit, apostolicæ sedis communione privatum esse, et Aca cium in excommunicatione mortuum non posse ab solvi significat.

Gelasius episcopus universis episcopis per Dardaniam [in qq. codd. leg. et Daciam] sive per Illyricum constitutis.

Audientes orthodoxam vestrae dilectionis in Christo constantiam, atque ita vos antique fidei commu nionisque sincerae traditionibus inhærentes, ut.nentem. Christianæ deditam veritati nullatenus infecerint prævaricatorum vicina contagia, magnificavimus Domiuum, caritatemque vestram missis litteris alloqui er religiosos viros filios nostros Cyprianum atque Macarium diacones tota cordis aviditate curavimus: quoniam pro sedis apostolicae principatu, cujus sollicitudo delegata divinitus cunctis debetur Ecclesiis, nos vivimus, si vos statis in Domino, magnisque gaudiis triumphamus. Cum ubique terrarum Dominum Sabaoth semen purae confessionis reliquisse cognoscimus, quod non in petrosa deveniens, æstu tentationis exaruit, nec viae proximum cecidit vacantibus. inimicis expositum, nec in spinis irruit suffocandum, sed in bonam terram piae devotionis vestrae coelesti factione [al.

English

LETTER XI.

TO THE BISHOPS OF DARDANIA AND ILLYRICUM.

He commends their religion; he signifies that the bishop of Thessalonica, who refused to condemn the names of heretics, is deprived of communion with the apostolic see, and that Acacius, having died in excommunication, cannot be absolved.

Gelasius, bishop, to all bishops established throughout Dardania [in some manuscripts it reads also Dacia] or throughout Illyricum.

Hearing of the orthodox constancy of your belovedness in Christ, and that you so adhere to the traditions of the ancient faith and of sincere communion that the neighboring contagion of the prevaricators has in no way infected you, who are devoted to the truth of the Christian name, we have magnified the Lord, and we have taken care with all the eagerness of our heart to address your charity by letter and to send our sons, the religious men Cyprian and Macarius, deacons: since for the primacy of the apostolic see, whose solicitude is owed by divine delegation to all the Churches, we live, if you stand in the Lord, and we triumph with great joys. When we know that everywhere on earth the Lord of Hosts has left a seed of pure confession, which, not falling upon rocky ground, has not withered in the heat of temptation, nor fallen near the path, exposed to idle enemies, nor rushed into thorns to be choked, but into the good earth of your pious devotion by a heavenly

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:99 · narrative
Source · Latin

sationej dispersum in trigesimum et sexagesimum fructum centenariumque profecit, profectionemque scilicet frumenti dominici mystica locutione designans. Quapropter exsultantibus animis confidentius incitamus, ut ab, Eutychianæ pestis incursu pectora vestra sapienter intemerata servetis: quoniam jam qui perseverat usque in nem, hic salvus erit (Matth. x, Dominus prope est, nihil solliciti sitis (Philip. IV); siquidem major est quod in nobis est quam qui in hoc mundo, regnumque Domini intra nos (etiam Scriptura [Luc. xvn] testante) sit certum. U autem ab eorum qui in errore sunt positi, noxia societate caveatis, nullum talibus communicantem ad vestrum recipiatis qualibet subreptione consortium: quia sicut in unaquaque hæresi cum pravitatis auctore damnato successores ejus et complices atque Hujusmodi sectatoribus polluta communione permixtos catholica vitare debet integritas, ita cum Eutychete Dioscorus simulque Timotheus Ælurus et Petrus Alexandrinus, ejusque communicator Acacius, nec non etiam Antiochenus Petrus, cum suis sunt omnino participibus abdicandi. Nec quisquam, etiamsi pravitatem deponere se promittat, recitandis tamen nominibus consentiens perditorum, vel eadem recitantium minime communione discretus ad immaculata sacrilegiis ovilia quibuscunque modis est permittendtis intrare, ut Ecclesia Dei nostri, quæ maculam rugamque non sustinet (Ephes.

English

by the sowing scattered, it advanced to thirty and sixty and a hundredfold fruit, designating by mystical utterance the going forth of the Lord's grain. Wherefore with exulting minds we more confidently urge you to keep your hearts wisely undefiled from the assault of the Eutychian plague: since already he who perseveres to the end, this one will be saved (Matt. 10); the Lord is near, be anxious for nothing (Phil. 4); since indeed greater is what is in us than what is in this world, and the kingdom of the Lord is within us (as Scripture [Luke 17] also testifies) is certain. But so that you may beware of the harmful fellowship of those who are placed in error, do not receive anyone communicating with such persons into your company under any stealthy pretext: because just as in each heresy, with the author of depravity condemned, his successors and accomplices and followers of this kind, mixed in polluted communion, the catholic integrity ought to avoid, so with Eutyches, Dioscorus, and at the same time Timothy Aelurus and Peter of Alexandria, and his communicator Acacius, and also Peter of Antioch, together with their participants, are altogether to be repudiated. Nor is anyone, even if he promises to lay aside his depravity, yet consenting to the recitation of the names of the lost, or in no way separated in communion from those reciting the same, to be permitted by any means to enter the immaculate sheepfolds of the sacrilegious, so that the Church of our God, which does not endure stain or wrinkle (Eph.

tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:100 · narrative
Source · Latin

v), inviolata permaneat. Absint ergo a fidclibus Christi viperæ capitis dira commercia, et procul a coelestibus pascuis mortifera vcnena pellantur, ut salutaris alimonia panis illius qui de coelo descendit (Joan. VI), fideles hanc sumentes ad vitam perducat aeternam.

Quae ut mutua valeamus exhortatione prospicere, det operam vestra dilectio ut sospitatem vestrae caritatis optatam, et fidei communis instantia nobis crebrius aperire non desinat, quatenus alternis nos instructionibus excitantes, legitimorum Domini sacerdotum possimus invenire mercedem. Per vicinas quoque provincias haec eadem palefacere vestra caritas vigilanter insistat; ut et qui catholicae communionis sinceritate suhsistunt, competentibus roborentur alloquiis; et qui forsitan ab hujus rectitudine deviarunt. ad integritatem dogmatis Christiani salubrihus monitis reducantur. Noverit autem vestra fraternitas Ecclesiæ Thessalonicensis antistitem nostris adhortationibus sepius incitatum, contagia communionis externae nunquam declinare voluisse, nec apud nos nomen Acacii, vel caeterorum similium perfidorum, hisque communicantium congrua profossione damnasse. Quapropter eum communionem sedis apostolicae non recepisse manifestum est, quoniam nisi puris sensibus et ab omni ncfanda societate, beati Petri apostoli nec possumus nec debemus Ecclesiæ praebere commercia.

English

Let it therefore remain inviolate. Let the dire commerce of the viper's head be absent from the faithful of Christ, and let deadly poisons be driven far from the heavenly pastures, so that the saving nourishment of that bread which came down from heaven may lead the faithful who receive it to eternal life.

So that we may be able to provide for these things by mutual exhortation, let your love take care that it not cease to disclose to us more frequently, through the earnestness of our common faith, the desired well-being of your charity, so that, stirring one another up by alternate instructions, we may be able to find the reward of the Lord's lawful priests. Let your charity also vigilantly insist on making these same things known throughout the neighboring provinces, so that both those who stand firm in the sincerity of catholic communion may be strengthened by fitting addresses, and those who perhaps have strayed from the rectitude of this may be brought back to the integrity of Christian doctrine by wholesome warnings. But let your brotherhood know that the bishop of the church of Thessalonica, though often urged by our exhortations, has been unwilling ever to renounce the contagions of external communion, nor has he, as was fitting, condemned by proper profession among us the name of Acacius, or of the other similar faithless men and those in communion with them. Wherefore it is manifest that he has not received the communion of the apostolic see, since, unless with pure minds and free from every wicked association, we neither can nor ought to extend the commerce of the church of the blessed apostle Peter.

Citation. Tergwame, “Epistolae Et Decreta”, tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1:1, machine-draft, 2026. https://naxiai.com/christian/works/tmp943.tmp943.opp-lat1#s1
Colophon. Source: ogl-pl · licence: Available under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License · model: deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash:floor · provider: Wafer · cost: $0.0569 · generated 2026-11-15.