DE PRISCILLIANISTARUM HÆRESI ET HISTORIA
LIBER UNICUS.
CAPUT PRIMUM.
Quisnam fuerit Priscillianus.
Cum mccum ipse delibcraverim omnes hæreses Leonis a;vo vigentes, sive exortas, scripto referre, jam ipsius consilii et temporis ratio postulat ut ad exitum perductis quae de Manichæorum haeresi fuerant dicenda, nunc ad Priscilliani recensendos cirorcs, quos idem S. pontifex rejecit, exagitavit atque proscripsit, animum stylumque ipsum convertam. Quæ autem de hujus novai hæreseos auctore, quæ de hujus patra ct moribus, quæ de synodis in eum ejusque sobolem coactis, quæ denique de variis multiplicibusque nefariæ hujus sectae dogmatibus dicenda occurrunt, nemo hactenus aut accurate de cripsit, aut saltem in lucem edidit. Propterea ego cum hisce conscribendis dissertationibus manum admovissem, et multis periculis rem plenam esse intellexissem, necessarium fore mecum reputavi veteres recentioresque in hac causa scriptores percurrere; ita tamen, ut, omnibus sepositis præjudiciis, nullo partium studio adductus, ea dumtaxat qu o aut veritatem patefaciunt, aut saltem veritati propius:'ccederc videntur, iN is lectoribus exhiberem.
ON THE PRISCILLIANIST HERESY AND HISTORY
ONE BOOK.
CHAPTER ONE.
Who Priscillian Was.
Since I have resolved in my own mind to set down in writing all the heresies that were flourishing or had arisen in the age of Leo, the reason of this design and of the time now demands that, having brought to completion the matters that were to be said concerning the heresy of the Manichaeans, I should now turn my mind and pen to recounting the crimes of Priscillian, which the same holy pontiff rejected, agitated, and proscribed. But as to what ought to be said concerning the author of this new heresy, concerning his fatherland and his character, concerning the synods convened against him and his offspring, and finally concerning the various and manifold dogmas of this abominable sect—no one to this day has either accurately described or at least brought to light. Therefore, when I had set my hand to composing these treatises, and had understood that the matter is full of many dangers, I reckoned it necessary to run through the ancient and more recent writers on this subject; yet in such a way that, all prejudices set aside and led by no partisanship, I should present to my readers only those things which either lay bare the truth or at least seem to approach more closely to the truth.
Igitur cnm mihi primo ce Priscilliani vita corruptisque moribus ngerc præscripsissem, neminem eruditorum hoc mcum consilium improbaturum cxistimavi, quamvis revera a Leonis gestis, quæ referre ct vindicare animus fuit, in ipso dissertationis vestibulo atque dccursu paululum digredi videri possem. Siquidem, cum in hanc ecclesiasticæ historiae partem nonnulla dubia et obscura, alia vero supposititia ct falsa, quamplurima denique prorsus ignota offenderimus, ideo illud ipsum veritatis studium quod unice nostro insidet animo rent totam a suis exordiis repetere atque praescribere coegit.
i. Priscillianus itaque, nobili geoere natus, et maximis abundans divitiis, vir fuit accr ingenio, inquics. facundus, multa lectione eruditus, in disserendo et disputando promptissimus. Felix prufecto (ait Severus Sulpicius) si non pravo studio corrupisset optimum ingenium; prorsus in eo multa animi et corporis bona cerneres, sed idem vanissimus, et plus justo inflatioi rerum profanarum scientia (A). Cur!, ergo is in societatem sibi quemdam Marcum Ægyptium ascivisset, abeo omnia facinora atque portenta ex Gnosticorum Manichaeorumque sectis prodeuntia hausit atque animo imbibit.
Therefore, when I had first prescribed to myself to write of the life and corrupted morals of Priscillian, I thought that no one of the learned would disapprove of this plan of mine, although in truth I might seem to digress a little from the deeds of Leo, which I intended to relate and vindicate, at the very threshold and outset of my discourse. Since indeed, in this part of ecclesiastical history, we have encountered some things doubtful and obscure, others indeed supposititious and false, and very many altogether unknown, therefore that very zeal for truth which alone dwells in our mind compelled me to repeat and set down the whole matter from its own beginnings.
1. Priscillian, therefore, born of a noble family and abounding in the greatest wealth, was a man of sharp intellect, restless, eloquent, learned through much reading, most ready in discoursing and disputing. Happy indeed (as Severus Sulpicius says) if he had not corrupted his excellent natural ability by depraved zeal; assuredly in him you would perceive many good qualities of mind and body, but the same man was most vain and puffed up beyond measure by the knowledge of profane things. Why, then, had he taken into his company a certain Mark of Egypt, from whom he drew and drank in with his mind all the crimes and monstrous deeds proceeding from the sects of the Gnostics and Manichaeans?
Tum, utrorumque dogmatibus propriis aditis flagitiis, novam in orbem sectam invexit, in qua promiscuæ libidines, stupra, adultciia, connuhiorum solutiones, mendacia, perjuria, et alia hujuscemodi, tamquam religiosa et licita, exercebantur. Quae omnia cum ipse mecum reputassem, facile in eam adduccbar persuasicnem, nilnl umquam in naturx honestatem nocentius ac turpius, nihil humanæ societati perniciosius, nihil denique in religionis exilium superstitiosius aut magis sacrilegum a quopiam haereticorum fuisse excogitatum. Nam prxier turpitudines in se ipsos et in proximos admissas, præter etiam injurias Deo irrogatas, ita apud Priscilllianum astrologiae studium fatalisque neccssitatis opinio va!ebat, ut perpetuo magicis artibus vacaret. Immo quamvis sacro baptismo initiatus et Christianæ fidei numen dcdissel, tantopere tamen ethnicorurn implicatus vivebat erroribus, ut faventia sibi sidera, quemadmodum putabat, colere et adversantia mitigare studeret, adhibitis ea.dc causa profanis sacrilegisque ritibus, quos a Moyse usque ad nostra tempora semper Ecclesia caverat et exhorruerat.
Then, having entered into the peculiar doctrines and shameful practices of both, he brought a new sect into the world, in which promiscuous lusts, debaucheries, adulteries, the dissolution of marriages, lies, perjuries, and other things of this kind were practiced as though religious and lawful. When I had pondered all these things with myself, I was easily brought to the persuasion that nothing more harmful and base to the honesty of nature, nothing more pernicious to human society, nothing, in short, more superstitious or more sacrilegious for the exile of religion had ever been devised by any of the heretics. For besides the shameful acts committed against themselves and their neighbors, besides also the injuries inflicted upon God, the study of astrology and the opinion of fatal necessity so prevailed with Priscillian that he devoted himself continually to magical arts. Indeed, although he had been initiated by sacred baptism and had given himself to the divinity of the Christian faith, he was nevertheless so entangled in the errors of the pagans that he strove to worship the stars favorable to him, as he thought, and to appease those opposed, employing for that purpose profane and sacrilegious rites, which from the time of Moses down to our own age the Church had always guarded against and abhorred.
Interim vero, ne omnem prorsus pietatis et religionis rationem contemnere videretur, nimia fallendi arte, quam optime callebat, humilitatis speciem habitu prætendebat, nudipedalem incessum ducebat, jejunia etiam Dominicis diebus et Natdi Domini servanda praedicabat; et dum fictam morum gravitatem affectaret, mulierum maxime animos demulcebat, (Iuarum societatem semper appetebat. Hæ namque nimia blandiendi arte facile alliciebantur, et catervatim ad eum confluentes, rerum novarum cupiditate ac libidinum Icentia haud difficulter capiebantur.
Hæc quæ de Priscilliani moribus, institutis, agendi ratione hactenus exposuimus, a nemine in dubium revocata sunt; idcirco nobis opus non luit, aut aliquam instituere concertationem, aut in iia expediendis diutius immorari.
CAPUT II. -
Quo tempore et unde potissimum Priscilliana hæresis cœperit grassari, variæ scriptorum opiniones anno
Meanwhile, however, so that he might not seem to despise utterly every principle of piety and religion, by an excessive art of deceiving, which he knew very well, he put on the appearance of humility in his dress, he went about barefoot, he even preached that fasts were to be observed on the Lord's days and on the Nativity of the Lord; and while he affected a feigned gravity of morals, he especially soothed the minds of women, whose company he always sought. For they were easily enticed by his excessive art of flattering, and flocking to him in crowds, they were caught without much difficulty by their desire for novelties and by the license of their lusts.
These things which we have thus far set forth concerning the manners, institutions, and manner of acting of Priscillian have been called into doubt by no one; therefore there was no need for us either to institute any debate or to linger longer in explaining them.
CHAPTER II.
At what time and from what source especially the Priscillianist heresy began to spread, the various opinions of writers in the year
tantur.
Priscillianam gravissimam pestem anno Christi 379, in Hispania potissimum, grassari coepisse auctor est Prosper in Chronico, Ausonio et Olybrio consulibus, ita scribens: Gratianus, posl mortem Patrui, Theodosium Theodosii filium in consortium assumpsit, imperiumque ei tradidit Orientis. Ea tempestate Priscillianus episcopus de Galliis ex Mannichæorum et Gnosticorum dog nate hæresim nominis sui condidit. Ausonii porro, Hermogenis et Olybrii consulatum in laudatum annum esse rejiciendum, jam Romanorum consulum tabulæ palam Obtendunt.
Scio tamen criticae artis peritissimos viros potius existimasse eam hæresim serius per Hispaniam propagatam fuisse.Quam persuasionem Guillelmus Cave, Severinus Binius, aliique secuti sunt, contendentes biennio post eam hæresim ortam, et Priscillianum ex Hispania duxisse originem. Utrumque autem a Severo Sulpicio affirmatum asseverant. Sed ex hujus sciiptis neutrum quidem compertum tiet. Nam laudatus Severus, suæ ætatis mala, quibus non usitato modo pollutæ Ecclcsiæ et omnia perturbata fuerant, desciibereaggressus, corum principes auctores denuntiat, sed nec tempus presse definit, nec Prisciltianum in HISpaniis ortum asserut.
Prosper, in his Chronicle, is the authority for the statement that the most grievous plague of Priscillianism began to rage in the year of Christ 379, chiefly in Spain, in the consulship of Ausonius and Olybrius, writing thus: “Gratian, after the death of his uncle, took Theodosius the son of Theodosius into partnership and handed over to him the empire of the East. At that time Priscillian, a bishop from the Gauls, fashioned a heresy bearing his own name from the doctrine of the Manichaeans and Gnostics.” Furthermore, the consular tables of the Romans openly show that the consulship of Ausonius, Hermogenes, and Olybrius must be assigned to the aforesaid year.
I know, however, that men most skilled in the art of criticism have rather held that this heresy was spread through Spain at a later date. William Cave, Severin Binius, and others have followed this persuasion, contending that the heresy arose two years later, and that Priscillian took his origin from Spain. They assert that both points were affirmed by Severus Sulpicius. But from his writings neither point is indeed established. For the aforesaid Severus, having undertaken to describe the evils of his own age, by which the churches had been polluted in no ordinary manner and all things thrown into confusion, denounces their chief authors, but he neither precisely fixes the time nor asserts that Priscillian arose in Spain.
Immo si Sulpicii verborum vim,edulo attendamus, diu carn sectam, antequam Priscillianus accederet, latuisse credendum est, cum videlicet Marcus Ægyptius, Memphis ortus, subsidio cujusdam nolnlis ac prædivitis feminæ Agapes appellatæ, et Elpidii rhetoris, Gnosticorum sectam primum in Hispanias induxit, quibus deinde post ci Priscillianus ipse accessit, ex quo h.vresis illa nomen sortita est. Tum primum (ait) infamis illa Gnosticorum haeresis intra Hispanias deprehensa superstitio exiliabilis, arcanis occultata secretis. Origo hujus mali oriens ab Ægyptiis, sed quibus ibi initiis coatuerit, haud facite est disserere. Primus eam intra Hispanias Marcus intulit Ægypto profectus, Memphis ortus. Hujus auditores fuere Agape quædam non ignobili mulier, et rhetor Elpidius. Ab his Priscillianus est institutus, familia nobilia, praedives opibus, etc.. nun ergo tempora ibidem distinguit Severus Sulpicius: unum videlicet quo Gnosticorum secta grassabatur; alterum, quo Priscillianus, Gnosticis accedens, et horum impietate superata et aricIa, Marci, Agapes et, Elpidii errores in nov;e nefandissimæque sectae portentum improbitate, audacia et furenti libidine vertit. Hoc Ausonii et Olybrii consulatu, nec serius evcnire potuisse, ex aliis rebus etiam et ex ipsa Cæsaraugustana syn do definiri potest.
Indeed, if we attend carefully to the force of Sulpicius's words, we must believe that the sect of the Gnostics lay hidden for a long time before Priscillian came to it, since, namely, Marcus the Egyptian, born at Memphis, with the help of a certain noble and very wealthy woman named Agape and of Elpidius the rhetorician, first brought the sect of the Gnostics into Spain, to which Priscillian himself afterward attached himself, from whom that heresy took its name. Then first (he says) was that infamous heresy of the Gnostics detected within Spain, a superstition worthy of exile, hidden in secret mysteries. The origin of this evil arose from the Egyptians, but with what beginnings it took root there it is not easy to explain. Marcus first brought it into Spain, having set out from Egypt, born at Memphis. His hearers were a certain Agape, a woman not of low birth, and Elpidius the rhetorician. By these Priscillian was instructed, a man of noble family, very rich in wealth, etc. Therefore Sulpicius Severus distinguishes the times in that place: one, namely, in which the sect of the Gnostics was raging; the other, in which Priscillian, attaching himself to the Gnostics, and having surpassed and outdone the impiety of these men, turned the errors of Marcus, Agape, and Elpidius into the monstrous prodigy of a new and most abominable sect by his wickedness, audacity, and frenzied lust. This could not have happened later than the consulship of Ausonius and Olybrius, and it can be determined from other matters as well and from the Council of Caesaraugusta itself.
Nam cum, auctore Sulpicio, idem Priscillianus suorum sectariorum numerum in dies augeri cognosceret, in unum omnes convocare coepit. quos in montium latebras deverticula abducere solitus, nefarias ibi agebal collectas, quas, ut aliorum oculis et notitiae subtraheret, sectariis suis communionem cum Ecclesia catholica, sacris elementis in manu acceptis ct secum asportatis, simulandam indulsit. Ubi itaque Hispaniarum episcopi religionem, justitiam, honestatem pessum ire, nec luxuri.e, sacrilegiis, nec magicis incantationibus modum fieri noverunt, cas leges et canones quos gravissimis hisce malis cobi-' bendis maxime necessarios putarunt, sollicite cundidere. Non igitur verisimile est quod Caveus et. cæteri asseruerunt, anno Domini videlicet eam hæresim in lucem Ortam. Qui vero id fieri potuit, cum eo anDO, jam longe lateque per eas provincias propagata, altas radiccs in improborum animis defixerat; quando maxima virorum atque mulierum frequentia, quibusdam anni diebus, cum in montibus, tum in vili-i Priscillianistæ, suas collectas agebant; quando de. nique omnia obscoena et profana quae ill latibulis exercebantur sacris catholicae Ecelesiae pastoribus innotuerant? Innotuisse autem h:ec omnia, octo ilii Cæsaraugustani concilii canones produnt, de quibus paulo poSt dicemus.
For, according to Sulpicius, when the same Priscillian realized that the number of his followers was growing daily, he began to summon them all into one place. He was accustomed to lead them away into remote hiding places in the mountains, where he held his abominable gatherings; and in order to keep these hidden from the eyes and knowledge of others, he permitted his followers to feign communion with the Catholic Church, having received the sacred elements in their hand and carried them away with them. And so, when the bishops of the Spains learned that religion, justice, and honesty were being ruined, and that no limit was being set to luxury, sacrilege, or magical incantations, they carefully drafted those laws and canons which they judged most necessary for restraining these most grievous evils. It is therefore not credible, as Cave and others have asserted, that this heresy came forth into the light in that year of the Lord. For how could that have happened, when in that very year, already spread far and wide through those provinces, it had fixed deep roots in the minds of the wicked; when the greatest throng of men and women, on certain days of the year, both in the mountains and in the villages, the Priscillianists held their gatherings; when finally all the obscene and profane things which they practiced in their hiding places had become known to the holy pastors of the Catholic Church? That all these things had become known, moreover, the eight canons of that Council of Caesaraugusta disclose, of which we shall speak a little later.
Neque vero arbitremur ea haeresi statim innntescente sacros Ecclesiae praesules in concilium eoivisse. Nam comperta primum ab Hyginio, Cordubensi episcopo, magni Osii successore, virulenta Priscilliani tabe, quæ nonnullos etiam episcopos, quos muter Instantium et Salvianum, depravaverat atque corruperat, negotium ad Idatium, Emeriiæ civitatis sacerdotem, relautum voluit. Is vero, Hyginius videlicet, in sectfirios excandens, sine modo (ait Severus Sulpicius) et ulira quam oportuit, Instantium sociosque rjus lacessens, facem quamdam nascenti incendio subctidit, ut exasperaverit malos potius quam compresserit. Re igitur ad Idatium delata, atque gravius ex igitatis Instantio et sociis, necdurn statim ad concilium deventum est. Sed post multa inter utramque partem inita certamina, cum catholicorum spes, qua sibi persuadebant posse haereticos ad pœnitentiam adducere, penitus frustraretur, tandem catholici epi;cnpi duodecim apud Cæsaraugustam convenerunt.
But let us not suppose that the sacred prelates of the Church came together in council as soon as that heresy was springing up. For when the virulent corruption of Priscillian had first been discovered by Hyginius, bishop of Corduba, successor of the great Hosius—a corruption which had depraved and ruined certain bishops also, whom they call Instantius and Salvianus—he wished the matter to be referred to Idatius, priest of the city of Emerita. But he, namely Hyginius, blazing out against the sectaries, without measure (as Severus Sulpicius says) and beyond what was fitting, provoking Instantius and his associates, applied a torch, as it were, to the nascent conflagration, so that he exasperated the wicked rather than repressed them. When the matter, therefore, had been referred to Idatius, and had been made more serious by the provoked Instantius and his associates, it did not come at once to a council. But after many contests had been entered into between the two parties, when the hope of the catholics, by which they persuaded themselves that they could bring the heretics to repentance, was utterly frustrated, at last twelve catholic bishops assembled at Caesaraugusta.
Priori itaque hoc Cavei, Severini Binii atque aliorum lapsu notato, postremum præcavere el eripere oporteret, illum videlicet de Priscilliani patria ct origine. Ne vero hujus vel illius gentis nationem modo in invidiam adducere velle videar, eam quaestionem vix delibabo. Suhjiciam, dumtaxat, perperam omnino Severo Sulpicio istud assertum ascribi: nimirum Priscillianum in lIispania ortum; nec enim quidquam tale offendet, qui ejusdem Severi secundum Historiæ librum totum integrumque percurrerit. Immo si aliorum v.terum -testimonia lustrare volucrimus, adhuc difficile rem hanc definire poterumus. Nam et ipse Hieronymus, qui aliorum consnevit origines referre, nou scmel et iterum, sed pluries PriscilLam more:, gesta et exitium recensens, altum ubiquelamendcejus patria it origine servavit silentium. Priscillianum autem per omnes virorum et mulierum coetus in Hispania criorcs sparsisse fatetur, Gallam Inuliercm, non natione, sed nomine, sibi pravorum criminum sociam ascivisse docet; ex qua antem gente aut loco ipse suam duxerit originem, prorsus reticuit aut dissimulavit. Sed ntc Cavei aliorumque recentiorum opinioni unum ex lot veteribus Patribus qui de ea hæresi scripserunt suffragari exploraiissimum est. Augustinus quidem vartis pluribusque in locU Priscillianistarum describit errores, quos, nit. Priscillianus in Hispania instituit.
Since, therefore, the lapse of Caveus, Severinus Binius, and others in the former matter has been noted, it remained to guard against and remove the latter point—namely, that concerning the fatherland and origin of Priscillian. But lest I seem to wish to bring the nation of this or that people into odium, I shall scarcely touch upon that question. I shall add only this: that this assertion is altogether wrongly ascribed to Sulpicius Severus—namely, that Priscillian was born in Hispania; for nothing of the sort will offend one who has run through the whole and entire second book of the History of the same Severus. Nay, if we wished to survey the testimonies of other ancient writers, we would still be able to define this matter only with difficulty. For Jerome himself, who is accustomed to relate the origins of others, when recounting the customs, deeds, and death of Priscillian not once or twice but several times, everywhere kept deep silence concerning his fatherland and origin. But that Priscillian spread his errors through all assemblies of men and women in Hispania he confesses; that he took to himself Galla, a woman not by nation but by name, as a partner in his wicked crimes, he teaches; but from what people or place he himself drew his origin, he wholly kept silent or concealed. But it is most certain that one of the ancient Fathers who wrote about that heresy supports the opinion of Caveus and the other more recent writers. Augustine indeed, in various and numerous places, describes the errors of the Priscillianists, which, he says, Priscillian established in Hispania.
Orosius, tere Priscilliano coævus, in commonitoro, seu consultatione, ad Augustinum eam hæresim dumtaxat per Hispaniam diffusam conquestus est. Idatius in Chronico, cum Priscilliani, tum Priscillianistarum habet mentionem; nullibi vero hunc Hispania ortui, iudicavit. Epiphanius simililiter, hæresi 49, de Priscilliano agens, paucis flagitia atque facinora ejus delinit, sed de ortu atque patria nihil asser uit. Auctor tandem lihri de Hæresibus, qui Rufino Palæstino lom. XXVII Uihliothecæ Patrum inscribitur, hæc tantummodo habet: Septuagesimam hæresim Priscillianorum apud Hispanos Priscillianus legitur inchoasse.
Que quidem omnia cum ipse mecu:n reputarem, non ut Hispanorum gentis jura defenderem, vcl ut eos ah hac nota purgarem, sed magi, ut veritati insislercm, et eam suspicioneln:præcavere curasem, qua nonnulli Priscillianum in Galliis ortum possent arhitrari. Hujusmodi antem suspicienis gravissima solidissimaque fundamenta, non tantum ex laudato Prosperi A quitani Chronico, sed ex multis aliis coniEcturis augebantur. Nam ct Chronicum illud quod dumtaxat Prosperi Aquitanici nomen præfert, vel illud quod Tironis nomine auctum, ct a Canisio in lucem edium, expresse habent: Priscillinus episcopus de Galatia; Priscillianus episcopus de Galliis.
Orosius, a contemporary of Priscillian, in his Commonitorium, or consultation, addressed to Augustine, complained that this heresy had spread only through Spain. Idatius in his Chronicle makes mention of both Priscillian and the Priscillianists; but nowhere did he judge that this man was of Spanish origin. Epiphanius likewise, in Heresy 49, treating of Priscillian, touches briefly on his crimes and misdeeds, but asserts nothing concerning his origin and fatherland. Finally the author of the book On Heresies, which is inscribed in volume XXVII of the Library of the Fathers as by Rufinus of Palestine, has only this: The seventieth heresy, that of the Priscillianists among the Spaniards, Priscillian is read to have begun.
Now when I myself weighed all these things, not to defend the rights of the Spanish people, or to clear them of this mark, but rather to insist on the truth and to guard against that suspicion by which some might judge that Priscillian was born in Gaul. But the most weighty and solid foundations of this kind of suspicion were increased not only from the praised Chronicle of Prosper of Aquitaine, but from many other conjectures. For both that Chronicle which bears only the name of Prosper of Aquitaine, and that which, augmented with the name of Tiro and brought to light by Canisius, expressly have: Priscillinus bishop from Galatia; Priscillian bishop from the Gauls.
Sed præterea expresse indicant Aquitaniæ proviuciam ea hæresi fuisse labefactatam; inler cæteras mulieres, etiam Euchrotiam Delphidii, seu Helpidii rhetoris uxorem, crimiuum et mortis socialn Priscillianum habuisse. Sed is Delphidius, sen Helpidius vir crat Gillus, et in cadem Aquitaniæ provincia rhetoricam docens, ut ex Gallie Christianae vetustissimis monuincutis patefactum est, quorum profecto collectores, cum de Burdigalensi agerent archiepiscopali, ita de S. Delphino,.td Christi annum 380, scripsere: S. Delphinus Ecclesiæ Gallicanæ singulare ornamentum...., concilio Cæsaraugustæ in Hispania Turraconensi celebrato, anno aut anno sequenti, cum aliis Aquitaniæ præsulibus interfuit, ubi damnati sunt Priscillianus et Delphidius, rhetor Aquitanus, aliive nefarioruM dogmatum sectatores. Præterea tandem, qui fieri potesi ut Prosperi tam apertum tam pie perspicuum testimonium rejiciamus Illud profecto nec rcjecerunt, nec df errore notarunt Tillemontius mque Dionysius Petavius; qui quamvis de Priscilliani pall'i:. et origine disserere dissimulent, tamen nobiscum illius hæreseos exordium ad Christi annum revocarunt, solo Prosperi testimonio adducti. Non igitur Prosper ipse, ne in suum et totius Aquitamæ gentis dedecus et probrum verteretur, Priscillianum Gallum appellasset, si id certo cum sibi tum cæ.er.s saLis superque non fuisset perspectum.
But besides this, they expressly indicate that the province of Aquitaine had been undermined by that heresy; among other women, Euchrotia, the wife of the rhetorician Delphidius, or Helpidius, had been Priscillian's partner in crimes and in death. But this Delphidius, or Helpidius, was a distinguished man, and taught rhetoric in the same province of Aquitaine, as has been made clear from the very ancient monuments of Christian Gaul, whose compilers, when they dealt with the archbishopric of Bordeaux, wrote thus concerning St. Delphinus, around the year of Christ 380: St. Delphinus, a singular ornament of the Gallican Church..., took part with other prelates of Aquitaine in the council held at Caesaraugusta in Spain, in Tarraconensis, in that year or the following, where Priscillian was condemned, and Delphidius, a rhetorician of Aquitaine, and others, followers of abominable doctrines. Moreover, finally, how can it be that we should reject so open and so piously clear a testimony of Prosper? Assuredly Tillemont did not reject it, nor did Dionysius Petavius mark it with error; who, although they conceal their discussion of Priscillian's birthplace and origin, nevertheless, together with us, brought back the beginning of that heresy to the year of Christ, led by the testimony of Prosper alone. Therefore Prosper himself would not have called Priscillian a Gaul—lest it be turned to the disgrace and shame of himself and of the whole Aquitanian people—if this had not been sufficiently and more than sufficiently established for him and for others.
Si ita profecto, contra vulgatissimam traditionem omniumque persuasionem ratiocinaremur, nodum ill scirpo qu:erere videreinur. Etenim ihi Priscillianum duxisse originem, ubi primum cjus errores propagati sunt, sine ulla prorsus animi Irrsitatione est affirmandum. Quod si deinde fandati Chronici verba rcpugnare videantur,, quæ Galatiæ vocem exlubent, nou inde tamen Priscillianum Galluni fuisse arbitrari oportet, cum potissimum Chronicon illud multis erroribus scatere eruditi quam sæpissime judicaverint, et aliunde quandoque illud vocabulum a veteribus fuerit u-urpatum ad design indum Galatiae populos intra Hispaniarum confima positos, ut sexcentis exemplis demonstrare possemus. Id potissimum ipsi præstabimus ill adoruanda sancti Leonis Magni epistola ad Turribium Asturicensem, de qua luculentius in hujus historiæ narratione suo loco agere reservamus.
If we reasoned thus, certainly, against the most widespread tradition and the persuasion of all, we would seem to be seeking a knot in a bulrush. For it must be affirmed without any hesitation of mind that Priscillian took his origin there, where his errors were first propagated. But if the words of the renowned Chronicle seem to conflict with this, which present the word Galatia, nevertheless it should not therefore be supposed that Priscillian was a Gaul, since especially the learned have very often judged that Chronicle to abound in many errors, and moreover that term was sometimes used by the ancients to designate the peoples of Galatia situated within the borders of the Spains, as we could demonstrate by six hundred examples. We shall especially establish this from the venerable letter of Saint Leo the Great to Turribius of Astorga, concerning which we reserve to treat more fully in its proper place in the narration of this history.
CAPUT III.
Instantius atque Salvianus Hispaniarum episcopi Pri scilliuno morem gerentes, eum Abulæ episcopum con secrarunt. Eodem fere tempore in Cœsarangustana '.nodo primum damnatus, tum Gratiani edicto ab
Hispania expulsus, liomam ad Damasum proficis citur.
I. Sed jam rejectis qu:e a criticis viris parum accurate dicta luere, quæque lectoris animum in pravam suspicionem possent adducere, ad Idatium cæterosque undecim Galliaruln et Hispaniarum episcopos revertendum est, qui, ut vidimus, cum per mulia certamina, nec audaciam, nec effrenatos mores, nec sacrilegam Pi iscilliani superstitionem umquam cohibere et corripere potuissent, sacra Ecclesiæ auctoritate et unanimi consensu Patres cas sententias tuterunt, quæ religioni, divino cultui, fidei mysteriis, pieuni, 'norum integritati atque humanæ societati magis prospicerent, ac nefariam illam pestem destruerent atque delerent. Qui vero apud Cæsaraugustam in unum convenere sacri ordinis episcopi, fuerunt: Fitadius, Delphinus, Eutychianus, seu Bastitanus, Ampelius, Angentius, Lucius, Ithacius, Spleudonius, Valerius, Cœsaraugustanus, Symposius, Catherius, Idatius; qui omnes veluti ex sacro senatusconsulto octo canones, vnv SCII leges, condiderunt, easque Lucius episcopus III conventu recitavit, ut aim umversis episcopis comra transgressores anathema conclamaretur.
CHAPTER III.
Instantius and Salvianus, bishops of the Spains, complying with the will of Priscillian, consecrated him bishop of Abula. At about the same time, first condemned in a council at Caesaraugusta, then expelled from Spain by the edict of Gratian, he set out for Rome to Damasus.
I. But now, setting aside those things which were said too carelessly by critics, and which could lead the reader's mind into a perverse suspicion, we must return to Idatius and the other eleven bishops of the Gauls and the Spains, who, as we have seen, when through many struggles they had never been able to restrain and correct either the audacity, or the unbridled manners, or the sacrilegious superstition of Priscillian, by the sacred authority of the Church and with unanimous consent upheld those opinions of the Fathers which looked more to religion, to divine worship, to the mysteries of the faith, to the integrity of morals, and to human society, and destroyed and wiped out that nefarious plague. Now those bishops of the sacred order who came together at Caesaraugusta were: Fitadius, Delphinus, Eutychianus, or Bastitanus, Ampelius, Angentius, Lucius, Ithacius, Spleudonius, Valerius of Caesaraugusta, Symposius, Catherius, Idatius; who all, as if by a sacred decree of the senate, established eight canons, that is, laws, and Bishop Lucius read them out in the assembly, so that an anathema might be proclaimed by all the bishops together against the transgressors.
Harum anlem sententiarum seu legum exempla tomo secundo Conciliorum scripta suut, easdemque Severinus Binius variis notis adornavit.
i. Interim vero dum hæc Caesaraugustana synodo agebantur, nec Instantius et Salvianus. nec Priscilfianus, aut quispiam ex caus sectariis coetui interfuit; sed omnes coram illis Pairibus se sistere detrectarunt, ne se judicio committerent. Rem narrat Severus Sulpicius, addens in absentes sententiam latam fuisse, et in cos qui damnatos in communionem ausi essent recipere. Igi ur post multa, ait, inter eos ct digna memoratu certamina, apud Cœsaraugustam synodus congregatur, cui ctiam Aquitani episcopi interfuere. Verum hœretici commitere se judicio non ausi, in nbsentes tum lata senten ia, dumnatique Instantius et Salvianus episcopi, Helpidius et Priscillianus laici. Additum etiam, ul si quis dumnatos in communionem recepisset, sciret in se eumdem sententiam promendam. Hæc autem, uhi a sectariis comperta sunl, majoris odu in Ecclesiam et in omnes catholicos causa fuere.
Examples of these opinions or laws have been written in the second volume of the Councils, and Severinus Binius adorned the same with various notes.
i. Meanwhile, while these things were being done in the council of Caesaraugusta, neither Instantius nor Salvianus nor Priscillian, nor anyone of their party, took part in the assembly of the cause; but they all refused to present themselves before those Fathers, lest they commit themselves to judgment. Severus Sulpicius relates the matter, adding that sentence was passed against the absent, and against those who dared to receive the condemned into communion. Therefore, he says, after many and memorable contests among them, a council is gathered at Caesaraugusta, at which even the bishops of Aquitaine were present. But the heretics, not daring to commit themselves to judgment, sentence was then passed against the absent, and the bishops Instantius and Salvianus were condemned, and Helpidius and Priscillian as laymen. It was added also that if anyone should receive the condemned into communion, he should know that the same sentence would be brought forth against him. But these things, when they were discovered by the sectaries, became the cause of greater hatred against the Church and against all Catholics.
Nam ad augendas magis seditiones, magisque nefaiios errores propagandos, duo illi episcopi, C;csaraugustani concitu judicio condemnati, Instantius, videlicet, et Salvianus, Priscillianum laicum, sed principem malorum omnium ab eadem synodo notatum, ad confirmandas vires suas (ait idem Scverus) episcopum in Labiensi oppido constituunt, rati nimirum, si hominem acrem et callidum sacerdotali auctoritate armassent, tutiores fore sese. Tanti porro facinoris impietatem, qua sacerdotii honos ct auctoritas sunimo dedctorc polluebatur, notavit immo ei exhorruit, inler cæteros unus Hieronymus ad Clesiphontem, illius hæreseos originem magnaque incrementa describens: In Hispania Agape Elpidium, mulier virum, cœcum cœca duxit in foveam, successoremque sui habuit Priscillianum Zoroastris magi studiosissimum, et ex mago episcopum, cui juncta Galla non gente, sed nomine, germanam huc illucque currentem alterius et vicinœ hœreseos fecit hteredem.
For to increase the seditions further, and further to propagate his nefarious errors, those two bishops, Instantius, namely, and Salvianus, condemned by the judgment of the council of Caesaraugusta, and Priscillian, a layman but the leader of all these evils, marked by that same synod, in order to confirm their strength (as the same Severus says) appoint him bishop in the town of Labia, doubtless thinking that if they had armed a sharp and cunning man with priestly authority, they themselves would be safer. Moreover, the impiety of so great a crime, by which the honor and authority of the priesthood was polluted by a most foul deceiver, was noted—indeed, he shuddered at it—among others by Jerome alone, in his letter to Ctesiphon, describing the origin and great growth of that heresy: In Spain, Agape led Elpidius, a woman her husband, blind leading the blind, into the pit, and she had as her successor Priscillian, a most devoted follower of Zoroaster the magician, and from magician a bishop; joined to him was Galla, not in race but in name, his own sister, running hither and thither, whom he made the heir of another and neighboring heresy.
Illud autem Cæsarangustanum concilium anno Domini sub Dalnasi papæ pontificatu coactum fuisse, illius canonesa Garsia Loaysa editi quam perspicue produnt. Sed integra cjusdem concihi Acta aut intercidisse, aut nondum lucem aspexisse, ex iis quæ habet Severus Sulpicius nobis compertum 'est. Narrat siquidem, ut vidimus, in codem sacro cœtu anathema iis dictum fuisse qui jam damnatos temere in communionem suscipere ausi essent. Qua sententia potissimum in Idiginum episcopum Cordubensem animadvertere volucrum. Nam quamvis is, primo cupidus illius sectæ abolende. Priscilliano et asseris bellum indixisset atque ad id Idatium ipsum per epistolas sollicitasset, tamen, mutata dein incute, catholicorum consilia non probavit, sed, turpiter depravatus, a concilio se abstinuit, hæreticosque nefariosios in communionem recepit. Atque id Ithacio Sossubiensi episcopo negotium datum, ut decretum épiscoporum in omnium notitiam deferret, maximeque Iginum extra communionem faceret, qui cum primus omnium inseclar; palam hæreticos cæpisset, postea turpiter depratatus in communionem eos recepisset. Ex cujus facti serie et natratione probe intelligimus laudatos octo canones qui supersunt utique sinceros et genuinos esse, cum eos inter episropos, qui iisdem subscripsere, Igini, sen Idigini Cordubensis nomen ncquaquam offendamus.
That this council of Caesaraugusta was convened in the year of the Lord under the pontificate of Pope Damasus, the canons of it edited by Garcia Loaysa quite clearly show. But that the complete Acts of the same council have either perished or not yet seen the light, we have learned from what Severus Sulpicius contains. For he narrates, as we have seen, that in that same sacred assembly anathema was pronounced against those who had dared rashly to receive into communion men already condemned. By which sentence they wished chiefly to act against Idiginus, bishop of Corduba. For although he, at first desirous of abolishing that sect, had declared war on Priscillian and his adherents and had solicited Idatius himself by letters to that end, yet afterward, his mind changed, he did not approve the counsels of the catholics, but, shamefully depraved, held himself aloof from the council and received the nefarious heretics into communion. And that task was given to Ithacius, bishop of Sossuba, that he should bring the decree of the bishops to the notice of all, and especially should exclude Iginus from communion, who, though he had first of all begun openly to seize the heretics, afterward shamefully depraved had received them into communion. From the sequence and narration of this deed we rightly understand that the eight praised canons which survive are undoubtedly sincere and genuine, since among the bishops who subscribed to them we by no means find the name of Iginus, or Idiginus, of Corduba.
Impetunt iili præterea atque taxant palnlarcs quosdam illius sectæ errores, horum ritus, magisterium, conventus, jejunia palam prohibent et insectantur, quamvis multa alia facinora et turpitudites ncdum forte tum salis explorata sentio praetermittant.
Verum enim vero illarum Ecclesiarunl status in dies nuserahilior efficiebatur. Nam duo illi catholici episcopi, præsertim Idatius et Ithacius post synodaMa decreta, atque post turpem iliam Priscilliani ordinationem, acrius instantes, saeculi judices adeunt, ut horum decretis aique exsecutionibus hæretici urbibus pellerentur. Igitur, auctorc eodem Sulpicio, post multa et fæda, Idatio supplicante, elicitur a Gratiano tum imperatore rescriptum, quo universi hæretici excedere non ecclesiis tantum, aut urbibus, sed extra omnea terras propelli jubebantur. Asperam nimis foedamque eam fuisse Idatii et Ithacii agendi rationem, cum Severus Sulpicius, tum cæteri animo mitiores catholici episcopi judicarunt. Nam, nullo alio Hispaniarum et Galliarum episcopo consulto, neque Damaso ipso Homano pontifice certiore facto, sectariorum causa ad sæculi tribunal delata est. Nec enim de laicis personis, sed de cpiscopis Instantio, Salviano, Priscillianoque agebatur, hæretica quidcm labe inquinatis. Nec quæstio habebatur de iis criminibus quorum cognitio ad imperatorcm spectaret, sed de iis dumtaxat quæ ecclesiasticum debebtni subire judicium.
They further attack and censure certain manifest errors of that sect; its rites, teaching office, and assemblies, and its fasts they openly forbid and assail, although they pass over, as I think, many other crimes and shameful deeds that had perhaps not yet been sufficiently investigated.
But in truth the condition of those churches was becoming daily more wretched. For those two catholic bishops, especially Idatius and Ithacius, pressing more sharply after the synodal decrees and after that shameful ordination of Priscillian, approached the judges of the world, so that by their decrees and executions the heretics might be driven from the cities. Therefore, with the same Sulpicius as our authority, after many base and foul proceedings, at the entreaty of Idatius, a rescript was obtained from Gratian, then emperor, by which all heretics were ordered to depart not only from the churches or cities, but to be driven out beyond all lands. That this manner of proceeding on the part of Idatius and Ithacius was excessively harsh and shameful was judged both by Severus Sulpicius and by the other catholic bishops of gentler mind. For, with no other bishop of the Spains and Gauls consulted, nor Pope Damasus himself, the Roman pontiff, made more fully informed, the cause of the sectaries was brought to the tribunal of the world. Nor was the matter concerning lay persons, but concerning the bishops Instantius, Salvianus, and Priscillian, though stained with the taint of heresy. Nor was the inquiry held concerning those crimes whose cognizance would pertain to the emperor, but only concerning those which ought to undergo ecclesiastical judgment.
Acce:dit denique idatium Ithaciumque privata solum auctoritate, non concilii sanctione, Gratianum inlerpellasse, ejusque judicium expetivisse, et idcirco in Ecclesiæ dedecus et in sacri ordinis maximam ignominiam verti merito existimatum est.
Interim autem Priscillianus et cæteri, qui episcopi videbantur, cum se exsilio affectos intelligunt, rebus suis diffisi, nec ausi judico certaret sponte cessere; laicorum vero multitudinem metus dispersit. Sed dum afflictis hisce rebus premerentur, nequaquam opem et præsidia posse invenire desperarunt. Propterea tres illi episcopi, cæterorum sectariorum antesignani, Romam proficisci decreverunt, ut qui publica? auctoritatis decreto criminum pœnas luebant, dolis deinde Damaso Romano pontifice circumvento, tamquam innocentes et innoxii, quadam ecclesiastica reconciliatione dolose obtenta, a catholicis haberentur. Dum itaque Romam proficiscuntur, ex Hispania per Aquitaniæ provinciam iter suscipiunt, ubi ab imperitis magnifice suscepti, sparsere perfidiæ semina, maximeque Elusanam plebem, sane tum bonam et religioni studentem, pravis prædicationibus pervertere. Elusa porro civitas ad Gelisam fluviolum vetustissima, olim archiepiscoporUm seu metropolitanorum Novempopulonia, sub qua cum plurimis aliis ipsa civitas Ausciorum continebatur. Ab Elusa vero panis Elusanus dictus est, qui Armaniacensis comitas nunc est para.
Then, moreover, Ithacius and Idatius, by private authority alone and not by the sanction of a council, are said to have petitioned Gratian and sought his judgment, and for this reason it was rightly judged to have redounded to the disgrace of the Church and the greatest ignominy of the sacred order.
Meanwhile, however, Priscillian and the rest who appeared to be bishops, when they understand that they have been visited with exile, distrusting their own affairs and not daring to contend in judgment, withdrew of their own accord; but fear scattered the multitude of the laity. Yet while they were pressed by these afflictions, they by no means despaired of being able to find help and protection. Therefore those three bishops, the leaders of the remaining sectaries, decided to set out for Rome, so that they who were paying the penalties of their crimes by the decree of public authority might then, with Damasus the Roman pontiff circumvented by their tricks, as though innocent and harmless, having deceitfully obtained a certain ecclesiastical reconciliation, be regarded as catholics. And so, while they set out for Rome, they take their journey from Spain through the province of Aquitaine, where, received magnificently by the inexperienced, they scattered the seeds of their perfidy, and especially perverted the people of Elusa—then indeed good and devoted to religion—by their depraved preachings. Moreover, the city of Elusa, on the little river Gelisa, was most ancient, once the seat of archbishops or metropolitans of Novempopulonia, under which, along with very many others, the city of the Ausci themselves was contained. From Elusa, indeed, the bread called Elusan is named, which is now a part of the county of Armagnac.
In oppidulum autem versa dicitur, ob frequentes clades quibus attrita est a Gothis, Saracenis, Normannis. Hæc ex Dionysio Sammarthano, tom. I Galliæ Christianæ annotavimus, qui praeterea novum catalogum episcoporum Elusatum nuper contextum se vidisse testatus est. In Burdigalensem deinde dioecesim Priscillianus et cæteri se contulere. Sud a Delphino episcopo reputsi, cum in Euchrotice, nefarim et impudicæ feminæ, agro aliquantisper commorati. nonnullos suis erroribus in fecere. Inde vero iter cæptum ingressi, turpi sane pudibundoque comitatu cum uxoribus atque alienis etiam feminis, in queis erat Euchrotia ac filia ejus Procla, de qua fuit in sermone hominum, Priscilliani stupro gravidam, partum sibi graminibus abegisse. Sive ergo Procla ex Priscilliano fetum conceperit, interitumque seu abortum curaverit, vel non, sive Priscillianus ipse matrem filiamque nefando compresserit incestu, ex sola Quorumdam hominum op nionc, auctor noster Severus delinire minime ausus esi.
It is said, moreover, that the town was reduced to a small village because of the frequent disasters by which it was worn down by the Goths, the Saracens, and the Normans. We have noted these things from Dionysius Sammarthanus, volume I of Gallia Christiana, who furthermore testified that he had recently seen a new catalogue of the bishops of Elusa compiled. Then Priscillian and the others betook themselves to the diocese of Bordeaux. Repulsed by Bishop Delphinus, they stayed for some time in the territory of Euchrotia, a wicked and shameless woman, and infected some with their errors. Then, having entered upon the journey they had begun, with a company truly shameful and indecent, together with their wives and even other men's women, among whom were Euchrotia and her daughter Procla, about whom there was talk among people that, pregnant by Priscillian's debauchery, she had driven off the offspring from herself by means of herbs. Whether, therefore, Procla conceived a child by Priscillian and procured its death or abortion, or not, or whether Priscillian himself lay with the mother and daughter in abominable incest, our author Severus by no means dared to decide from the mere opinion of certain persons.
Romam vero post nova, innumera tamque horrenda facinora, Priscillianum cum suis sociis venisse, non tautum ex vulgi fama, sed ex certissimis monumentis fit manifestum. Quæ quidem consilii ratio nova eliam ecclesiasticæ disciplinæ exempla suppeditat, ut inde intelligamus in conciliis damnatos, ad Romanorum pontificum judicia provocare et recurrere consuevisse, ut bi videlicet, apostolica divi Petri auctoritate, aliorum episcoporum acta, etiam in synodis definita, aut rescinderent aut confirmarent. Quod sane exemplum, utpotc ex fidei inimicis desumptum, etsi flocci pendendum arbitremur, neci adhæreamus, ut supremum apostolicae sedi in fidei rebus stabiliendis jus asseramus, illud tamcn minime rejiciendum esse contendimus. Nec enim Hispaniarum episcopi ad Romanum.portinebant concilium, quos solos a pontificibus judicari potuisse confingit Quesnellus. Neque Priscillianus ct socii Romanorum clericorum albo fuerant ascripti, nec Romanæ sedi assentari volebant, ut de similibus causis vaferrimo Launoius contendit; sed co uti intendebant jure, quod sacræ litteræ indicant, quod univeralis PP. traditio prædicat, quo i denique generalis ubique Ecclesiarum praxis usu obtinuerat.
That Priscillian, after new, countless, and so horrible crimes, came to Rome with his companions is made manifest not only by the talk of the common people but by the most certain records. Indeed, this manner of proceeding supplies new examples of ecclesiastical discipline as well, so that we may understand from it that those condemned in councils were accustomed to appeal and have recourse to the judgments of the Roman pontiffs, so that these, by the apostolic authority of the blessed Peter, might either rescind or confirm the acts of other bishops, even those defined in synods. This example, to be sure, as taken from the enemies of the faith, although we judge it to be of no account and would not cling to it, so as to assert for the apostolic see the supreme right in establishing matters of faith, we nevertheless contend must by no means be rejected. For the bishops of the Spains did not belong to the Roman council, whom alone Quesnellus fabricates could have been judged by the pontiffs. Nor had Priscillian and his companions been enrolled on the roll of the Roman clergy, nor did they wish to flatter the Roman see, as Launoy most cunningly contends concerning similar cases; but they intended to use that right which the sacred writings indicate, which the tradition of the universal Fathers proclaims, and which, finally, the general practice of the Churches everywhere had obtained by use.
Ea itaque Priscilliano et sociis, cum post synodalia decreta, tum post Gratiani imperatoris sententiam fuit agendi ratio, ut ncquaquam ad generale concilium provocarent, ut in præsentia eju-modi dictis et votis hæreticorum recertiores, ad Romanæ sedis auctoritatem angustioribus finibus restringendam, conficiuntur. Sed Prisci!lianum apud Damasum Romanum pontificem siti et sociorum causa: inulti men et præsidia comparare nisum luisse exploratissimum est. Nam, auctore Sulpicio, hi, ubi Romam pervenere, Damaso se purgare cupientes, ne in conspectum quidem ejus admissi sunt. Neque obstat S. pontificem, illo spiritu ductum qui in. Petri successoribus semper perseveraturus est, laudatorum hominum injustos conatus irritos reddidisse, nullo aditu prorsus purgationi eorumdem permisso. Nain ille ipsorum in Urbein adventus, ut causam dicerent, maximum solidissimumque est argumentum episcoporum cæterorumque causas, synodalibus decretis jam ad exitum perductas, Romanorum pontificum auctoritate iterum recognosci et judicari potuisse. Hæc autem leviter delibare placuit, ne recenLiorum dogmatistarum di"serendi ratio nos latere videretur. Jam vero prioribus conatibus frustratis, ad novos Priscillianus et Instantius animum vertere, ut mox ex sequentibus innotescet.
This, therefore, was the manner of proceeding of Priscillian and his companions, both after the synodal decrees and after the sentence of the emperor Gratian: that they should by no means appeal to a general council, so that in the presence of heretics of this sort, more recent in their sayings and vows, they contrive to restrict the authority of the Roman see within narrower bounds. But that Priscillian and his companions, on account of their thirst, sought to procure protection and defenses at the court of Damasus the Roman pontiff is most thoroughly established. For, according to Sulpicius, when these men had come to Rome, desiring to clear themselves before Damasus, they were not even admitted into his presence. Nor does it stand in the way that the holy pontiff, led by that Spirit which is always to persevere in the successors of Peter, rendered the unjust attempts of these praised men fruitless, with no access at all permitted to their clearing of themselves. For that arrival of theirs in the City, in order to plead their cause, is the greatest and most solid argument that the causes of bishops and of others, already brought to an outcome by synodal decrees, could again be reviewed and judged by the authority of the Roman pontiffs. But it has pleased us to touch on these matters lightly, lest the manner of discoursing of more recent dogmatists seem to have escaped us. Now indeed, with their earlier attempts frustrated, Priscillian and Instantius turned their minds to new ones, as will presently become known from what follows.
CAPUT IV.
Gratianus imperator, a Macedonio circumventus, In. stantium et Priscillianum suis sedibus restitui jubet. De Brittone Trevirorum episcopo, illiusque sedis honore et prærogativis. Blondelli et Iillemontii falsæ conjecturæ rejiciuntur.
Necdum tamen, post gravem repulsam quam a Damaso papa Instantius et Priscillianus episcopi passi fuerant, ad plenum exitium res suos perductas esse credidere. Sed, cousnea hæreticorum obstinata vafritie dominati, adhuc su:s malis et exilio quibus gravabantur mederi cupicntes, ovum excogitarunt consilium: illud videlicet, ut Mediolanum regrederentur, vana forte quadam spe adducti a magno illius Ecclesiæ antistite Ambrosio se in catholicorum communionem recipiendos. Qua tanien persuasione duo soli episcopi, Instantius vdelicet et lriscillianus, ducebantur; nec enim tum crat amplius superstes alius episcopus eorumdem criminum cl hæreseos socius Salvianus, qui in Urbe jam obierat. Sed res longe aliter ac opinabantur evenerunt. Nam comperta ab Ambrosio Romani pontificis agendi ratione, aque eis:aversari cœpit, facinus gravissimum reputans eos audire vel in communionem suscipere, quos apostolica S. Petri sedes exhorruerat. Tum (ait idem Sulpicius) Priscillianus et Instantius vertere consilia, ut quia duobus episcopis, quorum ea tempestate summa auctoritas erat non illuserant, largiendo et ambiendo ab imperatore cupita extorquerent.
CHAPTER IV.
The emperor Gratian, deceived by Macedonius, orders Instantius and Priscillian to be restored to their sees. Concerning Britto, bishop of the Treviri, and the honor and prerogatives of that see. The false conjectures of Blondel and Tillemont are rejected.
And yet, after the heavy rebuff which the bishops Instantius and Priscillian had suffered from Pope Damasus, they did not believe that their affairs had been brought to complete ruin. But, dominating through the stubborn cunning of the heretics, and still desiring to remedy their own misfortunes and the exile with which they were burdened, they devised a new plan: namely, that they should return to Milan, drawn perhaps by some vain hope that they would be received into the communion of the catholics by Ambrose, the great bishop of that church. Yet only two bishops were led by this persuasion, namely Instantius and Priscillian; for there was no longer then surviving another bishop, Salvianus, a partner in their crimes and heresy, who had already died in the City. But matters turned out far otherwise than they supposed. For when Ambrose had learned the manner of proceeding of the Roman pontiff, he too began to turn against them, reckoning it a most grievous outrage to hear or to receive into communion those whom the apostolic see of St. Peter had shuddered at. Then (as the same Sulpicius says) Priscillian and Instantius changed their plans, so that, since they had not imposed upon the two bishops whose authority was at that time the greatest, they might by bribery and canvassing extort their desires from the emperor.
Ea tempore autem adhuc imperialium rcrum summa ipse Gratianus potiebatur, apud quem malis artibus magis quam auctoritate Macedonius officiorum magister cum prævaleret, eum facile in eam persuasionem add.xit, ut, revocato atque abolito priore in Priscillianum etsocios exsilii decreto, ediceret ut sedibus a quibus prius jusseraL exturbari restituerentur. Grave profecto et immane lacinus istuc ab omnibus reputatum est. Siquidem Gratianus, alioqui vir religiosus et princeps maxime pias, ah improbo officiorum magistro circumventus, in itlum temerarium ausum prolapsus est, ut non tanturi præcedentia decreta sanctissime a se edita in irritum mitteret ac deleret, verum etiam Cæsaraugustanæ synodo, Migno Ambrosio et Komano ipsi pontifici, et sibi (quod gravius est) adversari voluerit.
Lætabundi ergo Instantius et Priscillianus ob imperatoris Gratiani in eos lenitatem, Hispanias repelere diu uon distulere. Quo tandem, incunte anno 383, profecti, suas occupant episcopales sedes, quibus Idatius resistendi animum habens, nihil in rcligionis munimen tentare potuit. Decrat illi quippe facultas, quia hæretici, corrupto Volventio proconsule, vires suus confirmaverant.
At that time, however, Gratian himself still held the supreme power of the empire. With Macedonius, master of offices, prevailing upon him by wicked arts rather than by authority, he easily induced him to that persuasion, so that, having revoked and abolished the earlier decree of exile against Priscillian and his associates, he ordered that they be restored to the sees from which he had previously commanded them to be driven out. That deed was indeed reckoned by all to be a grave and monstrous crime. For Gratian, otherwise a religious man and a most pious prince, circumvented by the wicked master of offices, slipped into that rash daring that he not only brought to nothing and erased the preceding decrees most holily issued by himself, but also wished to oppose the Council of Caesaraugusta, the great Ambrose, Romanus the pontiff himself, and even himself—which is more serious.
Rejoicing, therefore, at the emperor Gratian's leniency toward them, Instantius and Priscillian did not long delay to return to the Spains. Setting out at last at the beginning of the year 383, they seized their episcopal sees; Idatius, having the spirit to resist them, could attempt nothing for the defense of religion. For ability was lacking to him, because the heretics, having corrupted Volventius the proconsul, had strengthened their own forces.
Immo, cum tali tantaque sæculi potentia se fultos viderent, audacter nimis in episcopum catholicum Ilhaciu insurgunt, huncque quasi Ecdesiarum perturbatorem, reum apud proconsulem postulant, qui, scelestissimorum annuens votis, omni divino et humano jure sacrilege violato, jubet per atrocem exsecutionem Ithacium deduci. Sed is inirepidus profugit ad Gallias, ibi prcefectum Gregorium adiit. Ubi autem Gregorius praetorii Galliarum præfectus rerum gestarum sericm apprime novit, actutum rapi ad se turbatum auctores jubet, et i omnibus interim certiore lacto imperatore, hunc ad hortatur ut hæreticis viam ambiendi praecluderet. Sed id frustra fuit (subjicil idem Severus). quia per tibidinem ei potentiam paucorum cuncla ibi venalia erant. Igitur hæretici suis artibus, grandi pecunia Macedonio data, obtinent ut, imperiali auctoritate præfecto erepta, co• gnitio Hispaniarum vicario (Marianeno) Iraderelur, nam jam proconsulem habere desierant. Atque, missis praeterea a Macedonio ad Treviros militiae ollici.dibus, qui per vim ex ea urbe Ithacium extraherent, cumque ad dirum subeundum hæreticorum furorem in Hispanias reducerent, restitit tamen Trevirorum episcopus, qui, frande comperta, tnira animi prudentii atque sacerdotali constantia cum Macedonii imperialium officiorurn magistri, tum hujus militiæ officialium improbos elusit conatus atque evertit.
Nay rather, when they saw themselves supported by such and so great power of the age, they rose up with excessive boldness against Ithacius, the Catholic bishop, and demanded him before the proconsul as a disturber of the Churches; and the proconsul, assenting to the vows of the most wicked men and sacrilegiously violating every divine and human right, ordered Ithacius to be dragged away by a cruel execution. But he, undaunted, fled to the Gauls and there approached the prefect Gregory. Now when Gregory, prefect of the praetorium of the Gauls, had thoroughly learned the sequence of events, he at once ordered the authors of the disturbance to be seized and brought to him, and meanwhile, having made the emperor more certain of all matters, he urged him to close off to the heretics the way of seeking office. But this was in vain (the same Severus adds this), because through his lust and the power of a few, all things there were for sale. Therefore the heretics, by their arts, with a great sum of money given to Macedonius, obtained that, with the imperial authority taken from the prefect, the hearing of the Spaniards should be handed over to the vicar Marianus, for they had already ceased to have a proconsul. And furthermore, officials of the military service were sent by Macedonius to the Treviri to drag Ithacius by force out of that city and lead him back to the Spains to undergo the dire fury of the heretics. Yet the bishop of the Treviri resisted, and, having discovered the fraud, with wondrous prudence of mind and priestly constancy he mocked and overturned the wicked attempts both of Macedonius, master of the imperial offices, and of the officials of this military service.
Inter caeteros igitur catholicæ fidei vindices Brittonem Trevirorum episcopum non infi num tenere locum satis arhilror ex mox dictis esse perspectum. Dc eo enim verba faciens Severus Sulpicius Pritanum appellat. Sed verendu est lie binominis fuerit, aut ne in ejusdem Severi exemplaria, oh quamdam nominum affinitatem, error irrepserit. Nun in illius Ecclesiæ tabulis hocce nomen prorsus desideratur; sed aliud parnm absimile legimus, Britto nimirum, seu Britonius, qui anna Domini Valentino concilio subscripsit: Ego Britto episcopus opto vos, fratres, in Dumino bene valere. Præter autem illius urbis Annales, id Bollandus, ad diem Maii indicai, Brittonem inter illius Ecclesiæ confessores recensens. Suffragatur Sirmondus in notis ad Valentinum concilium; atque id deni que omnes fere scriptores docent, quos inter Blondellus et Tillemontius.
Among the other defenders of the Catholic faith, Britto, bishop of the Treveri, is shown by what follows to have held no insignificant place. For Sulpicius Severus, speaking of him, calls him Pritanus. But it is to be feared either that he bore two names, or that an error crept into the copies of the same Severus through a certain similarity of names. For in the records of that church this name is entirely wanting; but we read another not far different, namely Britto, or Britonius, who subscribed to the council of Valentinian in the year of the Lord: I, Britto the bishop, desire you, brethren, to fare well in the Lord. Besides the annals of that city, Bollandus indicates this, noting Britto among the confessors of that church. Sirmond supports it in his notes on the council of Valentinian; and finally nearly all writers teach it, among them Blondel and Tillemont.
Sed jam minime dissimulanda sunt quæ bi duo postremi auctores de episcopo Brittone scripsere, ut forte eidem inter Occidentales episcopos post D imasum papam honoris et jurisdictionis prærogativam vindicarent. Aiunt itaque Trevirorum urbem ob nonnullorum imperatorum sedem ibidem coll ieatim i » tantam honoris et potentiæ amplitudinem pervenisse, ut etiam illius episcopi, aliis, sive in synodis, sive In publicis actis, præcellerent. Ea autem de causa subjicium Trevirorum urb prilnas non tantum in GalHas obtinuisse, sed in Hispanias ct Angliam; ibideln aut imperatorum præfectus, aut etiam ipsi imperatores, cuti in Galliis versabantur, commorari consuevere; quibus rationibus Orientales Patres adducti. in epis:o!a ad Romanum concilium anno Domini 38= scripta, auctore Theodoreto, Brittonem Trevirensem immediate post Damasum et Ambrosium collocant, illumque ante Aquileiensem, Thessalonicensem et Syrmiensem episcopos statuunt, ut nianirum ea agendi ratione, cum illius virtutem, tum auctoritatis amplitudinem indicarent. Lepidum profecto et fah:losum commentum! Sed mirum quod propter hanc imperatorum sedem Brittoni supra Damasum atque Ambrosium primatus prærogativam non asseruerint. At quam frigida sit ejusmodi ratiocinatio, nemo nba videt.
But now the things that these two most recent authors wrote about Bishop Britto must by no means be passed over in silence, so that they might perhaps claim for him the prerogative of honor and jurisdiction among the Western bishops after Pope Damasus. They say, therefore, that the city of the Treveri, on account of the seat of several emperors established there together, attained to such greatness of honor and power that even its bishop excelled others, whether in synods or in public acts. And for this reason they add that the city of the Treveri obtained primacy not only in the Gauls, but also in the Spains and in Anglia; and there the prefect of the emperors, or even the emperors themselves, were accustomed to stay whenever they were in the Gauls. Moved by these considerations, the Eastern Fathers, in the letter written to the Roman council in the year of the Lord 382, authored by Theodoret, place Britto of the Treveri immediately after Damasus and Ambrose, and set him before the bishops of Aquileia, Thessalonica, and Sirmium, so that by this manner of proceeding they might indicate both his virtue and the greatness of his authority. A charming and indeed fabulous invention! But it is remarkable that on account of this seat of the emperors they did not assert for Britto the prerogative of primacy over Damasus and Ambrose. But how cold such reasoning is, no one who sees it fails to recognize.
Si quidem episcopalium sedium honor et praerogativae non ex civili quadam temporalium rerum administratione, non ex sæculi potentia, imperatorum præfectis, vel sedibus, aut denique ex ipsis provinciamm consulibus, quae omnia pro temporum varietate innumeris subjacuere mutationibus, ut sacra et profana indicant monumenta, gradus habebant; sed omnino ex earum origine, antiquitate et fundationrius repetendæ sunt.
Quod vero ex conciliorum privilegiis Romanorumque pontificum largitionibus ei dispensationibus metropolitæ jus aliquibus Ecclesiis attributum repe. riatur, illud tamen Trevirorum sedi supra ceteras Galliarum, Hispaniarum et Angliæ Brittonis ævo datum fuisse, minime demonstrari potest. Iimno, si ecclesiasticis monumentis fidem veliumus adhibere, dubio procul credendum erit Trevirotum episcopum tum primatis honorem haud obtinuisse supra archiepiscopum Viennensem, utruinipie Narbonensem, Lugdunensem et quosdam caeteros alios Galliarum episcopos, qui ad Valentinam synodum couvenere. Britto ille namque, de quo cum Blondello et Tillemontio modo negotium est, decimum quintum habet locum in illius synodi Actis subscribendis.
Indeed, the honor and prerogatives of episcopal sees did not derive their rank from any civil administration of temporal affairs, nor from the power of the world, from the prefects of emperors, or from sees, or finally from the very consuls of the provinces—all of which have been subject to countless changes according to the variety of times, as both sacred and profane records indicate—but they must be sought entirely from their origin, antiquity, and foundation.
But whereas it may be found that the right of a metropolitan was attributed to certain Churches by the privileges of councils and the largesses and dispensations of the Roman pontiffs, nevertheless it can by no means be demonstrated that this was granted to the see of the Treviri above the other sees of the Gauls, the Spains, and Britain in the age of Britto. Nay rather, if we wish to give credence to ecclesiastical records, it must without doubt be believed that the bishop of the Treviri did not then obtain the honor of primate above the archbishop of Vienne, the archbishop of Narbonne, of Lyon, and certain other bishops of the Gauls who convened at the synod of Valencia. For that Britto, about whom the dispute now is with Blondel and Tillemont, holds the fifteenth place in subscribing to the Acts of that synod.
Dicant igitur, amabo, duo illi scriptores, qui novum quasi in Occideno patriarcham supra trium regnorum proviucias, quarto labente sæenlo, delineare et confingere allaborant, cui potius fidem adhibere debeamus, Brittoni ipsi videlicei, qui ob suam sellem tanlis ornatus prærogativis describitur, an vero conjectoris quibus forte ad Romanæ sedis jura elevanda aliqui insistere possent? Nomo sanæ mentis umquam sibi confinget tanti honoris et auctoritatis episcopum, decimo quinto scdisse loco, dum concilium illud in Gallia Transalpina, Allobrogum urbe, Viennensi archiepircopatui subjecta, celebrabatur. Jam vero et lirino ipse post Justum Viennensem episcopum iis actii subscripsit.
G. Sed ad Orientalium epistolam a Theodoreto laudatam quod attinet, quid aiunt post Damasi et Ambrosii nomina illud statim Brittonis offendi? Sed rogo: Estue is Trevirorum episcopus? Nullibi id Theodorelus alfirmal. Immo Henricus Valesius eum Capuanum episcopum fuisse suspicatu: est. Sed rem delinire impossibile reputamus, cum Romanæ illius synodi Acia a Damaso coaclar jam integra in Conciliorum collectione non asserventur, et episcoporum subscriptiones jamdiu interciderim. Aldaboliune Brittonem eumdem Trevirorum episcopum fuisse*. Ergo tam solidum ex ea Orientatium epiScOporum epistola deducitur ne argumentum, ul hojus sola malo confecta aut descripta epigrapoe tanti momenti quæstionem definia1?
Let those two writers say, then, I ask: they who strive to delineate and fabricate, as it were, a new patriarch in the West over the provinces of three kingdoms, as the fourth century was drawing to a close—to whom ought we rather to give credence? To the Briton himself, namely, who is described as adorned with such great prerogatives on account of his own see? Or to conjectures, on which perhaps some might insist in order to exalt the rights of the Roman see? No one of sound mind will ever fabricate for himself that a bishop of such honor and authority sat in the fifteenth place, while that council was being held in Transalpine Gaul, in the city of the Allobroges, subject to the Viennese archbishopric. Moreover, he himself, after Justus bishop of Vienne, subscribed to its acts.
G. But as for the letter of the Easterners praised by Theodoret, what do they say—that immediately after the names of Damasus and Ambrose, that of the Briton is found? But I ask: Is he the bishop of Trier? Theodoret nowhere affirms this. Indeed, Henri Valois suspected that he was bishop of Capua. But we reckon it impossible to settle the matter, since the acts of that Roman synod convened by Damasus are no longer preserved intact in the collection of the Councils, and the subscriptions of the bishops have long since perished. Shall we doubt that the same Briton was bishop of Trier? Therefore, is so solid an argument derived from that letter of the Eastern bishops, that from this alone—a forged or transcribed inscription of such moment—the question is to be decided?
Retulitne eam Theodoretus quemadmodum in suo autographo descriptam repetiit? Aut Orientales illi Patres de Occidentalium sedium ordine vel optime edocti, vel eum, nihil immutantes, fideluer persecuti su t? Quis alterutrum aflirmabit? Nam imprimis Orientales illi, qui Constantinopolim in concilio convenerant, Romanæ Damasi synodo, quæ tum agebatur, detreclarum interesse, se excusanles, post tut inoumeras gravissimasque ærumnas Arianorum furore exhaustas, tam longum et laboliosum iter arripere non posse, ut Romam venirent. Ea de causa ires episcopos legatos ad Damasum et Romanam synodum mittunt, Cyriacum, videlicet, Eusebium et Priscillianum, qui secum laudaram a Theodoreto epistolam detulere. Illis ergo Orientis Patribus, cum ordo, quem Occidentales episcopi in Romano concilio tenuere, lum horum numerus prorsus erant ignoti. Et idcirco nonnullorum nomina dumlaxat descripsere, caetera autem generali hac formula concludentes: Et cæteris sanctis episcopis in celibri urbe Roma convocati. Nihil denique dicam de suspecta Theodoreti fide in veterum monumentis recensendis, um jam Baronius atque alii merito eum de consimitibus fraudibus insimulent. Sed eam fraudem longe abesse a Valentini concilii Actis jam Sirmondi studium indicat. £adem quippe vir doctus, ex codd. mss. Remen., Lugdun., Anicien., Fossat. et tribus aliis collegii Paris., socicl. Jesu, collect.
Did Theodoretus report it as he found it described in his own autograph? Or did those Eastern Fathers, either very well instructed in the order of the Western sees, or faithfully following it without changing anything, preserve it? Who will affirm either alternative? For in the first place, those Eastern Fathers who had assembled at Constantinople in council declined to take part in the Roman synod of Damasus, which was then being held, excusing themselves on the ground that, after countless and most grievous hardships exhausted by the fury of the Arians, they could not undertake so long and laborious a journey as to come to Rome. For that reason they sent three bishops as legates to Damasus and the Roman synod—namely Cyriacus, Eusebius, and Priscillian—who brought with them the letter praised by Theodoretus. For those Fathers of the East, since both the order which the Western bishops observed in the Roman council and the number of these were wholly unknown to them. And for that reason they wrote down the names of only some, concluding the rest with this general formula: "And to the other holy bishops assembled in the renowned city of Rome." Finally, I shall say nothing about the suspect fidelity of Theodoretus in reviewing the monuments of the ancients, since already Baronius and others rightly accuse him of similar frauds. But that this fraud is far removed from the Acts of the Council of Valentinum the study of Sirmondus already indicates. For the same learned man, from the manuscripts of Reims, Lyon, Anicium, Fossat, and three others of the Paris college of the Society of Jesus, collected.
Isidorianæ, ut castigatius iucem aspicerent curavit. Eos autem codd. ante annos conscriptos arbitratus cst. Quare eorumdem archetyporum exemplarium summa consensio omnem prorsus fraudis suspicionem eripit, ut nobiscum eruditi judicabunt.
Age vero nunc ad Priscillianum et Ithacium rerertamur. Macedonii itaque hujusque officialium conatittus per PritUnium, seu Brittonem episcopum elusis, simulque occluso aditu, lie ex urbo Trevirorum I haciumill Hispanias reducerent, gravis rumor oboriri coepit Clementem Maximum intra Britannias sumpsisse imperium, ac brevi in Gallias erupturum. Ita tum Ithacins statuit, licet rebus dubiis, novi imperatoris adventum exspectare, interim sibi nihil agitandum. Necaliter quidem,quam fama perculit, res contigere. Nam anno Domini tercentesimo octogesimo tertio jam inchoato, idem Maximus imperialium copiarum in Britannia dux, tyrannidem arripieus, a suis militibus imperator acclamatus est, et transmittens exercitum in Gallia ab infensis Gratiani legionibus imperium sibi corroborat. Hæc ex Victore et Z isimo scribit Baronius, tom. IV, ad Christi anuum 383.
He took care that the Isidorian [codices] should see the light in a more corrected form. But he judged that these codices had been written many years before. Wherefore the fullest agreement of these same archetypal copies removes altogether every suspicion of fraud, as the learned will judge together with us.
But now let us return to Priscillian and Ithacius. And so, when the attempts of this Macedonius and his officials had been eluded through Prudentius, or rather the bishop Britto, and the approach had at the same time been closed off, so that they might not bring Ithacius back from the city of the Treviri into the Spains, a grave rumor began to arise that Clement Maximus had assumed imperial power within the Britains, and would shortly burst forth into the Gauls. So then Ithacius decided, although matters were doubtful, to await the arrival of the new emperor, and meanwhile to do nothing himself. Nor did matters turn out otherwise than rumor had struck them. For in the year of the Lord 383, already begun, the same Maximus, commander of the imperial forces in Britain, having seized the tyranny, was acclaimed emperor by his own soldiers, and sending his army across into Gaul, he strengthened his power by the legions of Gratian, which were hostile to him. Baronius writes these things from Victor and Zosimus, tome IV, at the year of Christ 383.
CAPUT V.
De Maximo Tyranno, et ejusdem in Priscillianistas judicio agendive ratione.
Gratiano imperatore superstite, et Macedonio imperti negotia agente, episcopis catholicis et Ithacio potissimum nulla spes superesse potuit, ut Priscillianistarum everteretur impietas et audacia. At statim quam Galliarum legiones Gratiano infensæ, cum ill Britannia, tum in aliis regionibus Maximum imperialium copiarum ducem, imperatorem renuntiarunt, jati eorundem Priscillinistarum causa de teriur facta usque ad exitium penducta est. Quale vero fuerit Maximi ingenium, summatim veluti Gilda, cognomento sapiens, descrips t. dicens: Maximus, calUda primum arte potius quam virtu e finitimos quo qne pagos vel provincias contra Romanum statum retia perjuru mendacitque sui facinoroso regno advectans, et unum alarum ad Hispaniam, alteram ad Italiam extendens, et thronum iniquissimi imperii apu Treviros statuens, tulta insania in dominos debacchatus est, ut duos imperatores legitimos, unum Roma, alterum religiosissima vita pelleret. Profecto igitur Treviros Maximo, ibique imperiali sui sed., stabilita, lihacius de omnibus, quæ a Priscillinistis, a catholiCis Patribus, a Gratiano hactenus gesta fuerant, novum imperatorem edocere uon distulit. Tum enim Gratianus non amplius erat superstes; nam is, a suis desctus, orte ob nimiaM lenitatem in Priscillianistas adhibitum, per Andragatii ducis dolum.
CHAPTER V.
Concerning the tyrant Maximus, and his judgment and manner of proceeding against the Priscillianists.
While the emperor Gratian survived, and Macedonius was conducting the affairs of the empire, no hope could remain for the catholic bishops, and especially for Ithacius, that the impiety and audacity of the Priscillianists would be overthrown. But as soon as the legions of the Gauls, hostile to Gratian, had proclaimed Maximus, commander of the imperial forces, as emperor, both in Britain and in other regions, then at once the cause of these same Priscillianists was brought to a conclusion, even to destruction. What manner of man Maximus was, Gildas, surnamed the Wise, has described in summary fashion, saying: Maximus, first by craft rather than by virtue, spreading his nets against the neighboring districts and even provinces, contrary to the Roman state, by his perjured and lying and criminal reign, and extending one of his wings to Spain, the other to Italy, and establishing the throne of his most iniquitous empire at Trier, raged with such madness against lords, that he drove out two legitimate emperors, one from Rome, the other of most religious life. Therefore, when Maximus had set out for Trier and established there the seat of his imperial power, Ithacius did not delay to inform the new emperor of all that had been done thus far by the Priscillianists, by the catholic Fathers, and by Gratian. For at that time Gratian was no longer alive; for he, deserted by his own men, on account of the excessive leniency he had shown toward the Priscillianists, [perished] through the treachery of the duke Andragathius.
apud Lugdu num, octavo kal. Septembris, anno 383, occisus est. Interim Maximus, ne Ecclesiæ rebus videretur intensus, easque ill dies magis turbari sineret, hæreticorum judicium ecclesiasticis pastoribus in unum Burdigalæ coituris commisit. Ea de causa, ait noster Severus Sulpicius: Daris ad præfectum Galliarum atque ad vicarium Hispaniarum litteris, omnes omnino, quos labes illa involverat, deduci ad synodumBurdigalensem jubet. At ubi ad syuodum convenere, pri mus coram judicibus lustantius se sistens, causam dicere jussus, cum nec all objectis criminibus sc pos set purgare, Pl*. ill eum animadvertunt, et episcopatu indignum esse pronuntiant. Qnse Priscillianus advertens, et deteriorem causam habere sibi conscius, statim ad Maximum imperatorem appellationem interposuit, ut sacri conventus judicium eluderet. Hisce fere verbis idem Severus historiam describit, qui praeterea molli brachio concilii Patres objurgat, subjiciens: Priseilliarw. vero ne ab episcopis audiretur, ad principem provocavit. Permissumque id nostrorum inconstantia, quia aut sentenliamin refragantem ferre debuetant, aut si hi ipsi suspecti habebantur, aliis episcopis audientiam reservari, non causam imperatori de tam manifesti. criminibus permittere. Ita omnes quos causa involverat ad regcm deducti. Ne modo vero extra -scenam agere videamur, de violatis Ecclesiæ juribus hic disserere prorsus dissimulamus.
at Lyon, on the eighth day before the Kalends of September, in the year 383, he was killed. Meanwhile Maximus, lest he should seem intent upon the affairs of the Church and allow them to be disturbed on those days, entrusted the judgment of the heretics to the ecclesiastical pastors who were to assemble together at Bordeaux. For this reason, says our Severus Sulpicius: having sent letters to the prefect of the Gauls and to the vicar of the Spains, he orders all whomsoever that plague had involved to be brought to the synod of Bordeaux. But when they had assembled at the synod, Instantius first presented himself before the judges, and being ordered to plead his cause, since he could not clear himself of the crimes charged against him, they punish him and pronounce him unworthy of the episcopate. Priscillian, perceiving this and conscious that his own cause was the worse, immediately lodged an appeal to the emperor Maximus, so as to evade the judgment of the sacred assembly. The same Severus relates the history in almost these words, and he further reproaches the Fathers of the council with a gentle arm, adding: But Priscillian, lest he should be heard by the bishops, appealed to the prince. And this was permitted through the inconstancy of our own men, since they ought either to have brought in a sentence against the one resisting, or, if they themselves were held suspect, to have reserved the hearing for other bishops, not to have permitted the emperor to judge concerning the crimes of so manifest a case. Thus all whom the case had involved were brought before the king. But lest we now seem to act outside the scene, we altogether dissemble to discuss here the violated rights of the Church.
Severi Sulpicii testimonium nos annotasse dumtaxat sufficiat, ex quo nonnisi stolidi aut cæcutientes inliciari poterunt Ecclesiam a suis incunabulis usque veluti sacrilegas eas appel'ationes exhorruisse, quas tamquam ab abusu licitas esse, nimis audacter et temere, elapso sæculo, unus Maiemburgus propugnavit (&).
Maximus igitur, qui omnia imperii jura per fas et nefas tyrannicc verterat, posthabita atque despecta tnm Aureliani, tum Magni Constantini agendi ratione, etiam ab hoc judicandi munere non abhorruit, scd illud actutum sibi vindicavit. Iloc vero tamquam gravissimum facinus sanctissimi episcopi, quos inter Martinus Turonensis, rcputantes, enixe - iiisper tnrem exorabant ne capite in hæreticos animadverteret; sed, de Facerdotum sententia contentus, cos e suis episcopalibus sedibus juberet extrudi. Primo quidem in hanc sententiam Maximus propendere videbatur, immo et in cam, Martini Turonensis pra;sertim hortatu, jam descendisse, Severus Sulpi-cius asseverat. Sed cum Ithacius tunc strenue nimis accusatoris partes obiret, et gravi odio in reos furens apud imperatorem pro horum morlc instaret, cum negotium in ancipiti adhuc versaretur, episcoporum catholicorum coe:us in duas factiones scissus est, altera alteri communicare detrectabat. Prior enim prudenter el sancte infelicium sanguine abstinendum contendebat.
Let it suffice that we have noted merely the testimony of Severus Sulpicius, from which none but the stupid or the blind can be ensnared into thinking that the Church from her very cradle has shuddered at those so-called sacrilegious appellations, which one Maiemburgus, a century now past, too boldly and rashly defended as lawful, as though they were free from abuse (&).
Maximus therefore, who had turned all the rights of empire, by right and by wrong, to tyrannical use, setting aside and despising the manner of acting of both Aurelian and the great Constantine, did not shrink even from this office of judging, but forthwith claimed it for himself. But the most holy bishops, among whom was Martin of Tours, reckoning this a most grievous crime, earnestly besought him not to inflict the death penalty upon the heretics; but, content with the judgment of the priests, to order them driven from their episcopal sees. At first Maximus seemed to lean toward this sentence, and indeed, especially at the urging of Martin of Tours, had already come down to it, as Severus Sulpicius asserts. But when Ithacius at that time was playing the part of accuser only too vigorously, and, raging with grievous hatred against the accused, pressed the emperor for their death, while the matter still hung in doubt, the assembly of catholic bishops was split into two factions, the one refusing to communicate with the other. For the former prudently and holily contended that the blood of the wretched should be spared.
Sed altera sævior et immitior, ut crimina morte diluerent expetebat. Rebus iguur ita pendentibus, sæculi tribunal eam cognoscere causam distulit, quoad usque Treviris S. Martinus commoratus est; hunc enim benigne et perhumaniter Maximus excipiebat, tantaque reverentia et honore prosequebatur ut e Trevirorum urbe discessurusab ipso sponsionem elicuerit nihil cruentum in reos constiluendum. Aerum tamen exitus sponsionem protinus elusit. Nam imperator per Magnum et Rufum Hispaniarum episcopos depravatus. et a mitioribus consiliis deflexus, causam praefecto Evodio permisit, viro acri et severo, qni Priscillianum gemino judicio auditum convictumque maleficiis, nec diffitentem obscenis se studuisse doctrinis, nocturnos etiam turpium feminarum egisse conventus, nudumque orare solitum, nocentem pronuntiavit, redegitque in custodiam donec ad principem referret. Episcoporum autem, qui Maximum dei pravaverant,cum nulla apud veteres mentio occurrat, haud cornm sedium nomina referre possumus. De quodam Rufo episcopo dumtaxat in S. Martini Vita legimus, hunc juvenis cujusdam astu Eliam et Christum se appellantis et confingentis ita fuisse elusum, ut tamquam Dominum adoraret. Propter quod eum postea ab episcopatu dejectum vidimus.
But the other, harsher and more cruel, demanded that crimes be washed away by death. With matters thus hanging in suspense, the tribunal of the world deferred the hearing of this case until Saint Martin had stayed at Trier; for Maximus received him kindly and courteously, and attended him with such reverence and honor that, as he was about to depart from the city of the Treveri, he extracted from him a pledge that nothing bloody should be decreed against the accused. Yet the outcome of events at once eluded the pledge. For the emperor, corrupted by Magnus and Rufus, bishops of the Spains, and turned aside from milder counsels, entrusted the case to the prefect Evodius, a man keen and severe, who, after Priscillian had been heard in a double trial and convicted of maleficent practices, and not denying that he had devoted himself to obscene doctrines and had even held nocturnal gatherings of shameful women and was accustomed to pray naked, pronounced him guilty and remanded him to custody until he should report to the emperor. But since no mention of the bishops who had depraved Maximus occurs among the ancients, we cannot give the names of their sees. We read of a certain bishop Rufus only in the Life of Saint Martin, that by the cunning of a certain young man who called himself Elijah and Christ and contrived it, he was so deceived as to adore him as the Lord. For this reason we have seen him afterwards cast down from his episcopate.
Quod vcru ad male inchoatum ab Evodio in Priscillianistas judicium attinet, minime verendum est cruentum exitum contra imperatoris fidem Marlino datam non obtinuisse. Siquidem prioris capitis inquisitione jam facta, reorum confessione parirer audita, atque in carceribus ipsis facinorosis detentis, nihil aliud supererat quam ad jurium apices accusatores coram reis accire, ut, roborata absolutaque quæsitone, imperator tandem sententiam ferret. Tum lihacius (ait Severus Sulpicius) videns quam invidiosum sibi apud episcopos foret, si accusator etiam postremis rerum capitalium judiciis exstitisset (etenim iterari judicium necesse erat) subtrahit se cognitioni frustra, callido jam scelere perfecto. Nonnuisi ergoob excitatam in se episcoporum catholicorum invidiam Ithacius a perpelrato facinore abhorrere cœpit; sed frustra se a criminum contestatione srb'ductum voluit. Nam Maximus cuidam Patritio fisc patrono, Ithacii vices et accusatoris partes, u, obiret, jussit, quo insistente, Priscillianus una cur Felicissimo et Armenio, qui nuper ad hæreticortiat partes defecerant, capite damnaretur. Latronianus quoque et Euchrotia, Asarinus et Aurelius diacnus gladio perempti sunt. Mitius tamen cum Instantio actum est. Hunc enim in Sylinam insulam ultra liritanniam exsilio deportarunt, ubi comitem habuit Tiberianum, omnibus bonis antea possessis jnd cis decreto privatum.
As for what truly pertains to the badly begun judgment against the Priscillianists by Evodius, there is no reason at all to fear that the bloody outcome did not obtain contrary to the pledge of faith given to Martin by the emperor. Indeed, since the investigation of the earlier charge had already been made, the confession of the accused likewise heard, and the criminals themselves detained in prison, nothing else remained but to summon the accusers before the accused according to the strictest points of the law, so that, once the inquiry had been strengthened and completed, the emperor might at last pronounce sentence. Then Ithacius (says Severus Sulpicius), seeing how hateful he would be among the bishops if he had stood forth as accuser even in the final capital proceedings (for the trial had necessarily to be repeated), withdrew himself from the hearing in vain, the crafty crime now being accomplished. Therefore only because of the ill will of the catholic bishops stirred up against him did Ithacius begin to shrink from the crime he had perpetrated; but in vain did he wish to be seen as withdrawn from the charge of the crimes. For Maximus ordered a certain Patricius, a patron of the treasury, to take on Ithacius's role and the part of accuser; at his insistence, Priscillian was condemned to death together with Felicissimus and Armenius, who had recently defected to the party of the heretics. Latronianus too and Euchrotia, Asarinus and the deacon Aurelius were put to death by the sword. Yet the case of Instantius was handled more leniently. For they deported him into exile to the island of Sylina beyond Britain, where he had as a companion Tiberianus, who had earlier been deprived by decree of all his possessions in the same place.
Caeteri denique, videlicet Tertul lus, Potamius, et Joannes ttamquam viliores personæ, et digni miseiicordia, quia ante quaestionem se:.c socios prodidissent, temporario exsilio intra Gallias relegati.
Eamdem autem cædem anno Domini con. tigisse narrat Prosper in Chronico ad consulatum Arcadii atque Bautonis, quo tempore Siririus, Damaso jam vita functo, præcedenti anno Ecclesiæ catholicæ clavum obtinuerat. Sed idem Prosper praeterca addit, sequemi anno, consulibus Honorio et Evodio, Burdigalæ-quamdam Priscilliani discipulam numine Urbicam ob impietatis peninaciam per seditionem vulgi lapidibus exstinctam fuisse. Sed in alio Chronico, quod sub Tironis nomine circumfertur, eam vulgi in Urbicam seditionem Arcadio ei Bantonio coss. excitatam fuisse narratur. Jam vero iii omnibus necatis, aut exsilio affectis, religionis et Ecclesiæ negotia in præceps ferri vi a sunt. Nam i mprimis non solum repressa non cat hæresis, quæ Priscilliano auctore proruperat, sed confirmata, latius propagata est. Siquidem illius sectatores, qui eum pritis ut sancium honoraverant, postea ut martyrem colere cæperunt. Peremptorum corpora ad Hispanias relata, magnisque obsequiis celebrata eorum funera; quin ju. rare per Priscillianum summa religio putabatur.
The rest, namely Tertullus, Potamius, and John, being regarded as persons of lesser account and worthy of mercy because they had betrayed their associates before the inquiry, were relegated to temporary exile within the Gauls.
Prosper, moreover, in his Chronicle, records that this same slaughter occurred in the year of the Lord at the consulship of Arcadius and Bauto, at which time Siricius, after Damasus had already departed this life in the preceding year, had obtained the helm of the catholic Church. But the same Prosper adds besides that in the following year, under the consuls Honorius and Evodius, a certain female disciple of Priscillian at Bordeaux was put to death by stoning through a sedition of the mob, on account of her stubborn impiety, by the will of Urbica. But in another Chronicle, which is circulated under the name of Tiro, it is related that this sedition of the mob against Urbica was stirred up under the consuls Arcadius and Bauto. Now indeed, with all either slain or visited with exile, the affairs of religion and of the Church were seen to be borne headlong. For in the first place, not only was the heresy which had burst forth under the author Priscillian not repressed, but it was confirmed and propagated more widely. Since indeed his followers, who had formerly honored him as a saint, afterward began to venerate him as a martyr. The bodies of the slain were carried back to the Spains, and their funerals were celebrated with great obsequies; nay, to swear by Priscillian was reckoned the highest religion.
Nec vero religio solum in Hispania tam sacrilego sceleratoque cultu labefactabatur, sed ill Galliis, magno schismate exorto, etiam ipsi catholici episcopi in duas factiones discesserunt. Alii enim in Ithacio non tantum reprehenderunt, quod is, praeter Ecclesiæ morem ct lenitatem, læsæ fidei reos Ecclesiam exagitantes in capitis cau,a insectatus fuerat, scd etiam quia a Theognosto ep:scopo palam damnatus, ab ejus communione se ahslinehanl. Alii vero, regis mem, Ithacio faventes, ab illius communione minime abhorrebant.. *
CAPUT VI. ':
Maximus tyrannus ad Romanum pontificem catholicæ fidei confessionem scripto exaratam dedit. Novas clades imperator contra Priscillianistas per Hispa nias excitavit.
i. Imperatores sæculique principes, tamjuam sacrarum legum et religionis catholicæ vindices, Ecclesiie rebus afflictis opcm et praesidia praestare oportere, ne tyrannus et insaniens hæreticorum furor divina mysteria ad exitium perducat, jam ab cruditis omnibus sincere pr;edicatur. Quapropter non mirum, si Romani pontilices cum primum aliquem impera torem esse renuntiatum intellexerunt, onmi studio ab iis catholicæ fidei confessionem expostularunt, tine qua cum iisdem communionem habere detrectassent. Inter vetustissima porro hnjus agendi oeconomiæ exempla, hoc nobis S.
Nor indeed was religion in Spain alone being undermined by such sacrilegious and wicked worship, but in Gaul also, when a great schism had arisen, even the catholic bishops themselves split into two factions. For some reproached Ithacius not only because, contrary to the custom and leniency of the Church, he had pursued to a capital charge those guilty of injured faith who were stirring up the Church, but also because, having been openly condemned by Theognostus the bishop, they withdrew themselves from his communion. Others, however, favoring Ithacius on the king's account, by no means shrank from his communion.
CHAPTER VI.
The tyrant Maximus gave to the Roman pontiff a confession of the catholic faith written out in writing. The emperor stirred up new disasters against the Priscillianists throughout the Spains.
1. That emperors and princes of the age, as vindicators of the sacred laws and of the catholic religion, ought to lend help and protection to the afflicted affairs of the Church, lest the tyrant and the raging fury of heretics bring the divine mysteries to destruction, is already sincerely proclaimed by all the learned. Wherefore it is no wonder if the Roman pontiffs, as soon as they understood that someone had been proclaimed emperor, demanded from them with all zeal a confession of the catholic faith, without which they would have refused to hold communion with them. Moreover, among the most ancient examples of this manner of acting, this one of S.
Sinidus papa suppeditavit, qni anno 385, post Damasi mortem, ad pontificatum assumptus, a Maximo hanc catholica fidei confessionem expostulans is lIbenti animo sua epistula facere non detrectavit, quod æquis ei christianis principibus semper in more fuit. Quare primo de susceptis pontificiis epistolis habet mentionem, tum sacerdotalis muneris amplitudinem, tum splendidiss mæ Romanæ urbis dignitatemcxorn ins suhjicit: Fidei vero catholicæ, de qua clementiam nostram consulere voluisti, quo majus circa me et speciale judic um divinitatis experior, hoc me confiteor habere curam majorem, qui videlicet ad imperium ab ipso statim salutari fonte conscenderim, et cui semper in omnibus conatibus atque successibus Deus fautor affuerit, cujusque hodie et, ut spero, perpetuo protector et custos esse digneiur, Puter charissime. Spondet praeterea se operam daturum i a ecclesiasticas causas ejusdem Ecclesiæ sacerdotes pertractent, cum potissimum Innc ageretur de Agricio, quem indebite ad presbyterii gradum conscendisse S. pontifex comm moravcrat, et pr"pterea idem Maximus legitimorum imperatorum exemplum affectans, ait: Qnid religioni nostræ cartholicæ possum praestare reverentius.
Pope Siricius supplied it, who in the year 385, after the death of Damasus, having been taken up to the pontificate, demanding from Maximus this confession of the catholic faith, did not shrink from making it in his letter with a willing mind, which was always the custom of him toward equitable Christian princes. Wherefore he first makes mention of the pontifical letters received, then adds the amplitude of the sacerdotal office, then the most splendid dignity of the Roman city adorned: "Concerning the catholic faith, however, about which you wished to consult our clemency, by how much the greater and more special judgment of the divinity I experience toward me, by so much I confess that I have the greater care, who indeed ascended to the empire immediately from the saving font, and to whom in all endeavors and successes God has always been present as a favorer, and whose protector and guardian today and, as I hope, forever, he deigns to be, dearest father." He promises besides that he will give his attention that the priests of the same Church handle ecclesiastical causes, especially since the matter was then being handled concerning Agricius, whom the holy pontiff had noted had unduly ascended to the grade of the presbyterate, and therefore the same Maximus, emulating the example of legitimate emperors, says: "What can I offer more reverently to our catholic religion.
quam ut de hoc ipso, cujusmodi esse videatur, catholici judicent sacerdotes' Cui quippe quæstioni ut Galliarum et cæteri episcoporum qui intra quinque provincias commorabantur opportune interesse possent, conventum inqua elegerint urbe constituendum decernit, ut, iisdem residentibus et cognoscentibus, quid habeat consuctudo, quid legis si£ judicetur. Præclarum postremo sincera' suæ fidei testimonium daturus, narrat Pontifici quemadmodum ipse, ex Britannia Treviros adveniens, multorum sceleratorum ita inquinatam et labe llutam religionem repererit atque deprehenderit, III, nisi(ait) nostra provisio atque medicina, quæ ex Dei summi timore veniebat, his opem celeriter attuIsset, ingens profecto divulsio atque perditio fuisset exorta, et vix sananda postea vitia concrevissent. Quid autem supersititionis ct impielalis Priscillianistæ, quos ibidem Maximus Manichæos appellat, admisennl, non argum entis (subjicit) neque suspicionibus incertis, ard ipsorum confessione inter judicia prolatis, malo quod ex gestisipsis tua sanctitas quam ex nostro ore cognoscat; quia hujusmodi non modo factu turpia. ted enam fœda dictu, proloqui sine rubore non possumus. ( u hac epis ola ergo tutius quæstionis inquisitionisique Acta Max mum Tyrannum ad Siricium misisse, omnino constat.
that Catholic priests may judge concerning this very matter, what sort it appears to be. And indeed, so that the other bishops of the Gauls and those dwelling within the five provinces might be able to take part in this question at the opportune time, he decrees that a council be chosen to be held in that city, so that, with the same men residing and examining, it might be judged what custom holds, what the law holds. Finally, about to give a distinguished testimony of his sincere faith, he narrates to the Pontiff how he himself, coming from Britain to Trier, found and discovered the religion of many wicked men so stained and defiled by blemish that, unless (he says) our provision and medicine, which came from fear of the supreme God, had quickly brought help to them, a great tearing apart and destruction would assuredly have arisen, and the vices would scarcely have grown together to be healed afterward. But what the Priscillianists—whom Maximus in that same place calls Manichaeans—admitted of superstition and impiety, he adds, not by arguments nor by uncertain suspicions, but by their own confession brought forth among the proceedings; rather, let your Holiness learn from the records themselves than from our mouth, because we cannot speak of such things without blushing, since they are not only shameful in deed but also foul in speech. From this letter, therefore, it is entirely established that Maximus the Tyrant sent the Acts of the question and inquiry to Siricius.
Quid aUI. ad hæc rescripserit, aut ex iis Actis S. pontifex judicaverit, hactenus ex nullo Christianæ rei mouumen o erui potest. Illud unum dumtaxat tamquam certissimum coutra recentiores quosdam dogmatistas mtel.igimus: videlicet, Romanos pontifices indirectam saltem in catholicos rcges potestatem exercuisse. Non cnim Siricius papa de Maximi imperatoris fide percunctatus fuisset, non scripto rjus professionem expetivisset, nisi a suprenio sacerdotii munere judicandi auctoritatem obtinnisset, an Maximus jure, vel injuria, aut tyrannice imperium regeret. Sed ea de re alii disserant. Nos interim animadvetimus hoc eodem ano Ithacimæ factionis episcoposTreviris in concilium coivissc, ubi, aliis sanioris consilii episcopis etiam advenientibus, illi apud Maximum agebant, ut, lata prius ill Ithacinm a Theognosto episcopo anathematis et depositionis sententia in irritum missa, hunc tamquam insontem absolverent, neccuiquam liceret commuionem eidem denegare. Synodum adire auctoritasMartinum compulit, qui, a magisterii officialibus circumventus, primo spopondit se cum Christi pace Treviros venisse. Tum imperiale palatium ingressus, et ipsius Maximi minis territus, tum denique Felicis episcopi Trevirensis ordinationi se sistere cnm deberet atque voluisset, per horam dumtaxat cnm hæreticis Ithacio faventibus communicare compulsus esi. Sed ut eam communionem scripto firmaret.
What he wrote back to these, or what the holy pontiff decided from those Acts, can so far be extracted from no record of the Christian affair. This one thing only we have learned as most certain against certain more recent dogmatists: namely, that the Roman pontiffs exercised at least an indirect power over Catholic kings. For Pope Siricius would not have inquired about the faith of the emperor Maximus, nor have demanded his profession in writing, unless he had obtained from the supreme office of the priesthood the authority of judging whether Maximus was ruling the empire by right or by wrong, or tyrannically. But let others discuss that matter. We in the meantime note that in this same year the bishops of the Ithacian faction assembled in council at Trier, where, with other bishops of sounder counsel also arriving, they pressed Maximus that, having first set at naught the sentence of anathema and deposition passed against Ithacius by Theognostus the bishop, they might absolve him as innocent, and that it might not be lawful for anyone to deny communion to him. Authority compelled Martin to approach the synod, who, circumvented by the officials of the magistracy, first promised that he had come to Trier with the peace of Christ. Then, having entered the imperial palace and been terrified by the threats of Maximus himself, finally, when he ought to have and wished to present himself for the ordination of Felix the bishop of Trier, he was compelled to communicate for only an hour with the heretics favoring Ithacius. But that he confirmed that communion in writing.
nullo terrore, aut minis potuit induc;. Postero die se inde proripiens (ait Severus in Dialugis) cum revertens in via mæstus ingemisceret se vel ad horam noxia: communioni fuisse permixtum ille subsedit causam doloris et facti accusante ac defendente invicem cogitatione pervolvens, astitit ei repente angelus v Merito, inquil, Martine, compungeris, sed aliter exire nequisti. Repara virtutem, resume constantiam, ne jam uon periculum gloriæ. sed salutis incurreris. Itaque ub illo tempore satis cavit cum illa Ithacianæ partis communione misccri. Ceterum noxia illius communionis cauca, tardius quam solebat divinam opem et præsidia pro patrandis lIIiraculis obtinuisse, ipse jam expertus est, cum quibusdam dæmone correptis cuperet mederi. Sexdecim postea vixit annos, nullam synodum adiit, ab omnibus episcoporum conventibus se removit. Ita illud caput claudit Scverus Sulpicius laudato dialogo.
By no terror or threats could he be induced. The next day, tearing himself away from there (says Severus in the Dialogues), when as he was returning on the road he was groaning in grief that he had, even for an hour, been mingled in noxious communion, he sat down, turning over in his mind the cause of his grief and, with his thought alternately accusing and defending the deed, an angel suddenly stood by him and said: “You are rightly stung, Martin, but you could not have gone out otherwise. Repair your virtue, resume your constancy, lest now you incur not the danger of glory but of salvation.” And so from that time he took sufficient care not to be mixed with the communion of that Ithacian party. Moreover, the noxious cause of that communion—that he obtained divine help and assistance for performing miracles more slowly than he was wont—he himself afterward experienced, when he wished to heal certain ones possessed by a demon. Afterward he lived sixteen years, attended no synod, and removed himself from all assemblies of bishops. Thus Severus Sulpicius closes that chapter, with the dialogue praised.
Nos vero antequam de hujus emortuali anno verha faciamus, minime silentio eam cladem premere possumus, quam Maximus Imperator ex concilii Trevirensis sententia in hæreticos per lIispanias grassantes excitavit, cum trihunos summa potesta e armatos illuc mittere decrevit, qvi et hæretica labe inquinatos inquirerent, cl deprehensis vitam et bona adinwrent. Sed illud decretum ecclesiasticæ lenitati prorsus repugnans, atque ira odioque maximo cnm abundaret, Manini animum internis cruciatibus torquebat. Etenim absque ulla hæsitatione, per maximam tribunorum avaritiam atque libidinem, non scelestos dumtaxat sacrilegosque exagitandos, punicndos atque necandos es-e intelligebat, sed ipsos catholicos et sanctorum etiam turbum depopulandam, cum parvum omnino discrimen sit inter homi. num genera. Etenim (ait Severus Sulpicius) tum solis oculis judicabatur, cum quis pallore potins aut veste hæreticus æst maretur. Hæc ergo Martina concilium advenienti maxime displicebant. Idcirco nil mirum, si post Trevirensem synodum se ab ejusmodi coetibus in posterum abfuturum religiose sta. tuerit, iisdemque quoad usque vixerit interesse recusaverit.
But before we speak of the year of his death, we cannot at all pass over in silence that calamity which the Emperor Maximus, by the sentence of the council of Trier, stirred up against the heretics raging throughout the Spains, when he decreed to send thither tribunes armed with the highest power, who should both search out those stained with the taint of heresy and, once they were seized, deprive them of life and goods. But that decree, wholly repugnant to ecclesiastical mildness, and since it abounded in the greatest wrath and hatred, tormented the mind of Martin with inward tortures. For he understood, without any hesitation, that through the greatest avarice and lust of the tribunes, not only the wicked and sacrilegious were to be harried, punished, and slain, but that the catholics themselves and even the company of the saints were to be laid waste, since there is altogether little distinction between the kinds of men. For (says Severus Sulpicius) at that time it was judged by the eyes alone, when anyone was reckoned a heretic rather by his pallor or his dress. These things, therefore, greatly displeased Martin as he came to the council. Wherefore it is no wonder if, after the synod of Trier, he religiously resolved that he would thereafter keep away from gatherings of that sort, and refused to be present at them as long as he lived.
De hujus vero ancti viri emortuali anno summa ( ait Dionysius Petavius) velerum scriptorum dissensiu cst. Grego ius Turonensis. cap. 46, Cæsario et Attico coss. obtisse narrat media nocte quæ D ominica habebitur. Hic annus porro ( subjicit idem Petavius) est 397. Verum eo anno littera Dominic dis fuit D, proinde Novembris II erat feria, non Dominica. Sigibertus, quem Annales Ecclesiastici sequuntur, annum addicit. At eo anno littera fuit Et Novembria II feria 3; aut ergo anno obiit, quo littera Dominicatis erat A C, Novembris feria prima, aut anno 401, quo fuit secunda feria. Si prius amplectimurt mortuus erit ilia nocte quæ Dominicam antecessit; si posterius placet, ea nocte quæ Dominicam excepit. Anuum suadet Severus Sulpicius, qni dialogo laudato scribit, ut vidimus, Martinum sexdecim anuis vixisse post consulatum Evodii, qui incidit in annum 586, a quo sextus decimus annus I Christi 401. Gregorius vero Turonensis, lib. II cap. 43, annura designat dam Clodovæum ab obitu Martini anno mortuum esse scribit, qui excessit anno Christi 511. Ucm ita describit eruditissimus Dionysius Petavius; Rationarii Temporum parte II cap. 13, cujus conjecinris nihil nostro studio accessit. Sed tum jam Maximum Tyrannum malo fine apud Aquileiam reriisse certissimum est.
Concerning the year of the death of this holy man, there is, says Dionysius Petavius, the greatest disagreement among the ancient writers. Gregory of Tours, in chapter 46, relates that he died in the middle of the night which was to be kept as the Lord's Day, in the consulship of Caesarius and Atticus. This year, moreover, the same Petavius adds, is 397. But in that year the Dominical letter was D, and accordingly the second of November was a weekday, not the Lord's Day. Sigibert, whom the Ecclesiastical Annals follow, assigns a year. But in that year the letter was [ ], and the second of November was the third weekday; therefore either he died in the year in which the Dominical letter was A or C, when the second of November was the first weekday, or in the year 401, when it was the second weekday. If the former is embraced, he will have died on the night which preceded the Lord's Day; if the latter is preferred, on the night which followed the Lord's Day. Severus Sulpicius persuades us of the year, who in the laudatory dialogue writes, as we have seen, that Martin lived sixteen years after the consulship of Evodius, which fell in the year 386, from which the sixteenth year is the year of Christ 401. Gregory of Tours, however, in book 2, chapter 43, designates the year when he writes that Clovis died in the year after the death of Martin, who passed away in the year of Christ 511. Thus the most learned Dionysius Petavius describes it in the second part of his Rationale of Times, chapter 13, to whose conjecture nothing has been added by our own effort. But then it is most certain that the tyrant Maximus had already perished by a bad end at Aquileia.
Is enim, a Theodosio et Valentinianoi superatus spoliatus (ut ait Prosper in Chronico) indumentis regiis sistitur, et cap te damnatur. Cujus filius Victor eodem anno post paucos dies ab Arbogaste in Galliis interfectus est. Andragatius autem (subjicit Pelavius) se in mare præcipitavit. Horum necem Idatius et laudatus Prosper ad Theodosi II et Gynegii referunt consulatum, qui justa Ecclesiæ tabulas est Christi annus tercentesimus octogesimus octavus.
CAPUT VII.
De Toletanis synodis Prisciliianistarum causa coactit.
Jam vero rerum ordinem prosecuti, silentio handquaquam premere possumus. quarto labente Ecclesia; sæculo, ita Priscillianam percrebuisse pestem, ut non tantum vulgi homines, sed viri olim pietate et dignitate clarissimi ab eadem labefactarentur. Ad cujus hæreseos mala cum catholici epi,copi animadvertere cogerentur, ita eorum animus conliciebalur, ut non semel in unnm convenire debuerint. Primo enim, cum cam in h;cresim hujusque sectatores libellarem, ut aiunt, direxerunt sententiam. Sed ubi, aut quando convenerint, difficile est judicare. Verum ante Toletanam synodum, quae nunc exstat, Hispanos episcopos aliud concilium habuisse, ipsi Toletani novemderim PP. in suae synodi præfatione hisce verbis perspiene iudicant: Omne. decem et nouem isti sunt, qni et in aliis gestit adversus Priscilliani sectatores et hæresim quum astruxerat libellarem direxere sententiam.
For he, defeated by Theodosius and Valentinian and stripped (as Prosper says in his Chronicle) of his royal garments, is brought to trial and condemned to death. His son Victor was killed by Arbogast in Gaul a few days later in the same year. Andragathius, however (Pelavius adds), threw himself into the sea. Idatius and the aforementioned Prosper assign their deaths to the consulship of Theodosius II and Cynegius, which, according to the tables of the Church, is the year of Christ three hundred and eighty-eight.
CHAPTER VII.
Concerning the councils of Toledo convened for the cause of the Priscillianists.
Now indeed, having followed the order of events, we cannot at all pass over in silence that, as the fourth century of the Church was drawing to its close, the Priscillianist plague had so spread abroad that not only ordinary men but men once most distinguished for piety and rank were shaken by it. When the Catholic bishops were compelled to take note of the evils of this heresy, their mind was so stirred that they ought not merely once to have come together into one place. For first, when they directed a written, as they say, sentence against this heresy and its followers. But where or when they assembled is difficult to judge. Yet that the Spanish bishops held another council before the council of Toledo which now survives, the nineteen fathers of Toledo themselves clearly show in the preface of their council with these words: All these nineteen are they who both in other acts against the followers of Priscillian and, when the heresy had spread, directed a written sentence.
Veteri Lac Latinoruin loquendi lormula Toletani PP. ad innuendam damnationis sententiam non verbis tantum prolatam, sed scripto et palam editam, forte usi sunt. Ad hanc porro in judiciis ferendis Hispaniarum episcoporum agendi rationem minime adverterunt Tillemontius, Sirmondus, l'apius, Severinus Binius, Aguirre, et caeteri omnes qni de quarti sæculi Hispanicis ecclesiastiitisque judiciis agentes, nec unum prorsus verbum habent de concilio illn quod ipsi Toletani PP. paulo prius habuisse affirmant. Immo id poiissimum ex omnium sententia praestare quidem debuisset novissimus srriptor Cajetanus Cenni, qui sibi agere proposuit: De Judiciis Ecclesiæ Hispaniarum per sæculum quartum. Vel Franciscus Gervasius Urgellensis presltyter, qui anno elapso nic Romæ de Prisci!lianistarum historia bipartitam dissertationem prelo commisit Sed ambo clarissimi doctissimique viri alium et alium scribendi scopum cum sibi assumpsissent, tantum otii illis haud esse potuit, ut singula annotarent. Nam D. Cajetanus Cenni, liomanorum pontificum supremæ in totius orbis Ecclesias aucturitatis et asserendæ et propuguandæ studio cnm ageretur, contra Dupinium aliosque huic similes theologos calamum stringens, ita potissimum hinc scopo erat intentus, ut ad concilii Toletani primi Acta aut non attenderit, aut omnino lustrare prætermiserit.
The Fathers of Toledo happened to use the old Latin formula of speaking to indicate a sentence of condemnation pronounced not only in words but issued in writing and publicly. Moreover, Tillemont, Sirmond, La Peyre, Severinus Binius, Aguirre, and all the others who, treating of the ecclesiastical judgments of Hispania in the fourth century, have not at all adverted to this manner of proceeding in the passing of judgments by the bishops of the Spains, have not one single word at all about that council which the Fathers of Toledo themselves affirm was held a little earlier. Indeed, by the judgment of all, the most recent writer, Cajetan Cenni, ought above all to have accomplished this, since he set himself the task: On the Judgments of the Church of the Spains through the Fourth Century. Or Francis Gervasius, priest of Urgell, who in the past year committed to the press at Rome a bipartite dissertation on the history of the Priscillianists. But both most distinguished and most learned men, since they had assumed for themselves one and another aim in writing, could not have had so much leisure as to note each individual point. For since D. Cajetan Cenni was engaged in the zeal of asserting and propagating the supreme authority of the Roman pontiffs over the Churches of the whole world, sharpening his pen against Dupin and other theologians similar to him, he was so especially intent upon this aim that he either did not attend to the Acts of the first Council of Toledo, or altogether omitted to examine them.
Scriptor vero posterior summatim dumtaxat Priscillianistarum originem, incrementum et exitium, ordinata quadam methodo indicare in votis habuit, cæteris omissis q'iae ad rem suam non pertincre arbitrabatur. J
Patruinus igitur cum coeteris decem et octo Hisparis episcopis, habita ratione ad impia Priscilliam ei hujus sectatorum dogmata, hæc eadem, ut a'quum erat, scripta in tabulis sententia proscripserf; tum deinde, paucis elapsis, ut credibile est, annis, iterum in Toletanam urbem convenire voluerunt, ut ea qu.e ad ecclesiasticam disciplinam, quæ ad scandala, quæ ad schisma tollendum, qiue deni que ad summam concordiam tinnandam necessaria videbantur, delinirent. Quare considentibus presbyteris, astantibus diaconibus, et careris qui intererant concilio congregatis, Patruinus episcopus dixil. Quoniam singuli cœpimus in Ecclesiis nostris facere diversa, et inde tanta scandula sunt, quæ usque ad schisma perveniunt si placet, communi concilio decernamus quid ab omnibut episcopis in ordinandis clericis sil sequendum. Sed mihi hujus Toletanæ synodi Acta et canones legenti, eosque ad Siricii papæ epistolam Himmerio Tarracouensi cæterisqne Hispaniarum episcopis datam exigenti, compertum e*t h;ec omnia ita inter se concinere, ut illi PP.
The later writer wished only to indicate in summary fashion the origin, growth, and downfall of the Priscillianists, arranged in a certain method, omitting the rest that he judged not to pertain to his purpose.
Patruinus, therefore, together with the other eighteen bishops of Spain, having taken account of the impious doctrines of Priscillian and his followers, proscribed these same doctrines, as was fitting, by a written sentence in tablets; then afterwards, when a few years had passed, as is credible, they wished to assemble again in the city of Toledo, so that they might define those things which seemed necessary for ecclesiastical discipline, for removing scandals, for abolishing schism, and finally for confirming the highest concord. Wherefore, with the presbyters sitting, the deacons standing by, and the rest who were present gathered in council, Bishop Patruinus said: Since we have begun individually to do different things in our churches, and from this have arisen such great scandals as reach even to schism, if it pleases you, let us decree in common council what is to be followed by all bishops in ordaining clerics. But to me, reading the Acts and canons of this Synod of Toledo, and comparing them with the letter of Pope Siricius given to Himerius of Tarragona and the other bishops of Spain, it has been discovered that all these things agree so with one another that those Fathers...
nihil aliud sequendum decreverint, nisi ea quæ summus pontifex jam apostolica auctoritate ipsis observandum mandaverat, vel ea quæ in Nicaena synodo de ordinationibus jam pridem fuerant constituta. Quæ res cum innuat Hispaniarum episcopos in Ecclesiæ judicts ferendis Romanam semper consuluisse sedem, nec ab ejus umquam regulis resilire ausus fuisse, merito. nns in admirationem trahit, quod praecedentes laudati scriptores tlem tantumque horum monumentorum consensum similitudinemque non animadverterint, aut annotare neglexerint. Nec enim ut hos, alioqui eximios et de literaria optime meritos, scriptores contumeliose lædamus, sed ut argumentorum quae ipsi contra novatores adducunt vim et pondus augeremus, hæc referre debuimus.
Interim vero ad hujus Toletani primi concilii tempus, variasque in eo excitatas qurstiones, et genuina Acta, quod attinet, inter Ecclesiæ scriptores minime convenit. Baronius imprimis istud concilium non nisi quarto sancti Innocentii pontificatus anno, qui quadringentesimus et quintus Christi est, COl. ctum fuisse asseverat, ea nimirum persuasione ductus, quod ad hujus synodi PP. ipse Innocentius eam epistolam scripserit, quæ sequentem epigraphem præsefert: Innocentius ad episcopos synodi Toletanæ. Kt quamvis Baronii conjecturis ipsa Toletani concilii Acta repugnent, quorum inscriptio haec Is,.
they had decreed that nothing else should be followed except those things which the supreme pontiff had already commanded them by apostolic authority to observe, or those things which had long since been established concerning ordinations in the Council of Nicaea. Since this matter indicates that the bishops of the Spains always consulted the Roman see in rendering the judgments of the Church, and never dared to depart from its rules, deservedly it draws us into admiration that the preceding praised writers did not notice, or neglected to note, so great and such a consensus and similarity of these monuments. For we ought not, to be sure, to injure these otherwise distinguished writers and those who have deserved very well of literature with insult, but to increase the force and weight of the arguments which they themselves bring against the innovators, we have had to report these things.
Meanwhile, however, as regards the time of this first Council of Toledo, and the various questions stirred up in it, and its genuine Acts, there is the least agreement among the writers of the Church. Baronius especially asserts that this council was gathered only in the fourth year of the pontificate of Saint Innocent, which is the four hundred and fifth year of Christ, led no doubt by this persuasion, that Innocent himself wrote to the fathers of this synod that letter which bears the following inscription: Innocent to the bishops of the synod of Toledo. And although the very Acts of the Toledan council fight against the conjectures of Baronius, whose inscription is this:
Let: Concilium Toletanum novemdecim episcoporum tempore Anastasii, Honorii et Arcadii, Stilicone conanti habitum æra 438, anno Domini 400, Patrono episcopo præsidente sub die septimo idus Septembris; tamen errorem in hanc irrepsisse, nec ad primurn, sal ad secundum Stiliconis consulatum, qui in laudatum annum incidit, Acta illa esse rcferenda contendit. Ita ergo Innocentiame illi epistolæ Uironius insistit, ut, laudato hnc Toletanæ synodi titulo et inscriptione neglecta, non Patruini pr:esidis nomen, non Hispanicam æram, non Anastasii pontificatum, non quadringentesimi anni Christianam epocham csse probandam duxerit. Sed jam doctum virum allucinari non tantum omnia edita et manuscripta exemplaria patefaciunt, sed et ipsa sancti Innocentii papae epistola. Quid? In ea qu ppe S. pontifex de illa synodo loquiturin qna Gregorius Emeritensis in Patruini locum fuerat suffectus, cujus Gregorii querimonias audiri jubet. At Toleratne synodo, de qua nos agimus, Patruinus adhuc vivens interfuit, immo et prefuit, ut ex tota illa Actorum serie ipse lector intelliget.
Let: the Council of Toledo of nineteen bishops, held in the time of Anastasius, Honorius, and Arcadius, when Stilicho was consul, in the era 438, the year of the Lord 400, with Bishop Patronus presiding, on the seventh day before the Ides of September; yet he contends that error crept into this matter, and that those Acts are not to be referred to the first, but to the second consulship of Stilicho, which falls in the aforementioned year. Thus, therefore, Uironius insists on that letter of Innocentius, so that, having praised the title and inscription of the Toledan synod but neglected them, he did not think the name of the president Patruinus, nor the Spanish era, nor the pontificate of Anastasius, nor the Christian epoch of the four hundredth year, was to be approved. But that the learned man is mistaken is made clear not only by all the printed and manuscript copies, but also by the very letter of Pope Saint Innocentius. What? For in it the holy pontiff speaks of that synod in which Gregorius of Emerita had been substituted in the place of Patruinus, whose Gregorius he orders to be heard in his complaints. But in the Toledan synod of which we treat, Patruinus was still living and took part, indeed even presided, as the reader himself will understand from that whole series of the Acts.
Contra vero illius epistolæ capite de Patruino ita scripsit Ionocentius: Gregorii etiam Emeritensis episcopi, qui in locum Patruini venerabilis recordationis est ordinatus, querela, si qua est, audiatur, et si contra meritum suum passus est injuriam, in invidos honoris alterius vindicetur, ne posthac in quemquam bonorum spiritus factioni. insurgat, Quæ sane verba clare multus Hispaniæ scriptores de errore convincunt, quorum alii Patronum, seu Patrainum Toletanæ syuodi præsidem, Toletanum antistitem, alii Bracarensem fuisse exislimaruuL; ex is enim verbis apparet quod illis in mentem nou venerat, videlicet Emeritensem episcopum fuisse, cui j un defuncto Gregorius quinquennio post successerat.
A. Longe ergo nobis aliam disserendi rationem esse oportuit, qni Innocentianam illam epistolam non ad priinam Toletanam synodum, sed ad alteram esse referendam judicamus. Id jam pridem Sirmondus, Pagius, Petavius, Severinus Binius, Tillemontius aliique scriptores, quamvis non iisdem rationibus et conjucturis adducti, monuerunt; quorum alii Toletanam primam synodum vel in Christi annum 399, vel in sequentem rejiciendam esse rationabilius docuerunt, de qua nos luculentius disserere prætermittinius, cum jam difficilius aliud quidpiam ct obscurius nobis expediendum supersit: carum rerum videlicet inquisitio quae hujus primae Toletanae cogend:e fynodi Patrono, seu Patruino Occasionem dedere.
But Innocent wrote thus in that chapter of his letter concerning Patruinus: "Let the complaint of Gregory also, bishop of Emerita, who has been ordained in place of Patruinus of venerable memory, be heard, if there is any; and if he has suffered injury contrary to his desert, let vengeance be taken upon those who envy another's honor, lest hereafter the spirit of faction rise up against any of the good." These words clearly convict many Spanish writers of error, of whom some have thought that the president of the Council of Toledo, Patronus or Patrainus, was bishop of Toledo, others that he was of Braga; for from these words it appears that it had not come to their mind, namely, that he was bishop of Emerita, whom, when he had died, Gregory succeeded five years later.
Therefore it behooved us to have a far different manner of discussing the matter, who judge that this letter of Innocent must be referred not to the first Council of Toledo but to the second. This Sirmond, Pagi, Petavius, Severinus Binius, Tillemont, and other writers have long since advised, although not led by the same reasons and conjectures; of whom some have taught more reasonably that the first Council of Toledo should be relegated either to the year of Christ 399 or to the following year. Concerning which we have omitted to discourse more fully, since something else more difficult and more obscure remains for us to settle: namely, the investigation of those matters which gave occasion to the patron, or Patruinus, of this first Council of Toledo being convened.
Multas porro gravissimasque causas fuisse illius arvi monumenta quae supersuuttnobis persuadeat; quas recensere cum Ecclesiæ scriptores hactenus neglexerint, nos percurrere cogimur, ne in oscitantiae aut nimiae conniventiæ notam incidamus. Illius itaque in Tuletana urbe concilii habendi causam principem schisma quoddam gravissimum et Priscilliana ortum hæresi fuisse, notum et perspectum omnibus esse volumus. Fuerit vero illud idem quod Ithaciana factio excitaverat, an potius aliud, non satis perspicue evinci potest: unum dumtaxat notissimum aeque ac certissimum, ita ecclesiastica" Hispaniarum provinciarum res quoad dogma, quoad mores, quoad disciplinam ex illa Priscilliana lue turhatas et labefactas fuisse, ut episcopi etiam ac caeteri clericalis ordinis ministri, a SS. Patrum regulis abscedentes, quod magis eorum studiis favebat sequerentur. Tanta quippe eos inter erat animorum discordia et dissimilis agendi ratio, - ut sine ullo prorsus delectu paenitentes susciperent, conjugali vinculo alligatos, vel concubinas habentes filiosque procreantes, ad majores sacros ordines promoverent; Bigamos ct sæculari militiae addictos, servosque dominis obligatos, ad ecclesiastica ministeria assumerent. Alii cum sacrilegis et anathemate percussis libere cornmunicabant; alii a propriis recedentes Ecclesiis, unde egressi fuerant, sub depositionis poena redire non cogcbantur.
Moreover, let the monuments of that man which have survived to us persuade us that there were many and very grave causes; since the writers of the Church have to this point neglected to review them, we are compelled to run through them, lest we fall under the mark of slothfulness or of excessive connivance. Therefore we wish it to be known and evident to all that the principal cause of holding that council in the city of Toledo was a certain very grave schism which arose from the Priscillianist heresy. But whether it was the same one that the Ithacian faction stirred up, or rather another, cannot be sufficiently clearly established; only one thing is both most known and equally most certain: that the ecclesiastical affairs of the provinces of Spain, as regards doctrine, as regards morals, as regards discipline, were so disturbed and weakened by that Priscillianist plague that even bishops and the other ministers of the clerical order, departing from the rules of the holy Fathers, followed what favored their own pursuits more. For so great was the discord of minds among them and their dissimilar manner of acting that without any discrimination at all they received penitents, promoted to the major sacred orders those bound by the marriage bond, or having concubines and begetting children; they assumed for ecclesiastical ministries men twice married and addicted to secular military service, and slaves bound to their masters. Some freely communed with the sacrilegious and those struck with anathema; others, departing from their own churches, were not compelled, under penalty of deposition, to return whence they had gone out.
Alii denique, vel religiosarum puellarum familiaritate, vel sacra synaxi abutebantur, episcoporum presbyterorumque defunctorum superstites uxores sibi conjugio adjungebant, atque in tot tantaque alia non minoris momenti facinora prolabebantur, ut non tantum canonum sanctiones ex malorum abusu, sed et ipsa divina apostolieaque praecepta pessum abirent. Sed et de iisdem rebus paulo ante aliud a Lusitanis habitum fuisse concilium sequentia prioris illius capituli seu canonis evidentissime nobis indicant. Placuit (aiunt Toleta.ni PP.) ut diacones, si vel integri, vel casti non sint, et continentis vitæ, etiamsi uxores habeant, in ministerio constituantur; ita tamen, ut si qui etiam ante interdictum quod per Lusitanos rpiscopo, constitutum est incontinenter cum uxoribus suis vixerint, presbyterii honore non cumulentur. At hujus Lusitani concilii decreta seu interdicta prætereamus. Illius qu poc Acta ab eruditis desiderantus, nec cardinalis Aguirre Hispanicarum rerum diligentissimus collector disertius quidquam de iisdem describere potuit.
Others again abused either the intimacy of religious maidens or the sacred synaxis; they joined to themselves in marriage the surviving wives of deceased bishops and presbyters, and they slid into so many and such great other crimes of no lesser weight that not only the sanctions of the canons, through the abuse of evil men, but even the divine and apostolic precepts themselves perished utterly. But concerning these same matters, the following words of that earlier chapter or canon show us most clearly that a little before this another council had been held by the Lusitanians. It pleased them (say the fathers of Toledo) that deacons, if they are not whole or chaste, and of continent life, even if they have wives, may be appointed to the ministry; yet in such a way that if any even before the interdict which was established by the Lusitanians for the bishop have lived incontinently with their wives, they are not to be promoted to the honor of the presbyterate. But let us pass over the decrees or interdicts of this Lusitanian council. Its acts, which are missed by the learned, that most diligent collector of Hispanic affairs, Cardinal Aguirre, could describe nothing more distinctly concerning them.
Alteram Igitur Toletani illius concilii causam expedi imus. De ea quidem celebriores scriptores verba fecerunt, qnos inter Tillemontius et Paschalius Quesnellus locum habent; qui potissimum in praesens nobis agere instituentibus de Symphosio episcopo, de Dictinio, aliisque clericalis ordinis hominibus, qui ex Priscilliana redeuntes hæresi, Ambrosio et Romano pontifice agentibus, a Toletanæ primae synodi patribus in communionem suscepti sunt, negotium facessunt. Et primo quidem totius controversiae nodum cum in multis situm esse deprehendamus, ut facilius dubia a certis et falsa ab authenticis secernamus, varia opus est praemittamus.
Primum videlicet Symphosium cum aliis undecim episcopis anno Domini Caesaraugustano subscripsisse concilio, Priscillianoque et hujus dogmatibus anathema dixisse, ut ex hujus concilii Actis intelligitur. Quamvis revera, si unicum dumtaxat Cæsaraugustae fuisse eoactum concilium dicamus, a caeterorum PP. illorum communione se subduxisse credendum erit, ut suo loco dicturi erimus. Non igitur tum ea lue nefaodacerio poterat labefactari Symphosius. Neque de hac haeresi, palam saltem, is fuerat postulatus Cbristi anno 385, cum videlicet Priscillianus hujusque socii, Maximi tyranni decreto, vel capitis,. vel exsilii poena mulctati fuere. Severus quippe Sulpicius, qui lib. u llist.
Let us therefore set in order the second matter of that council of Toledo. Concerning it, indeed, the more distinguished writers have spoken, among whom Tillemont and Paschal Quesnel have their place; and they create difficulty especially for us at present, who have undertaken to treat of Bishop Symphosius, of Dictinius, and of other men of the clerical order who, returning from the Priscillianist heresy, with Ambrose and the Roman pontiff acting, were received into communion by the fathers of the first synod of Toledo. And first, indeed, since we perceive that the knot of the whole controversy lies in many points, in order that we may more easily separate doubtful things from certain and false from authentic, it is necessary that we first set forth various matters.
First, namely, that Symphosius, together with eleven other bishops, subscribed to the Council of Caesaraugusta in the year of the Lord, and pronounced anathema upon Priscillian and his doctrines, as is understood from the Acts of this council. Although in truth, if we say that only one council was held at Caesaraugusta, it will have to be believed that he withdrew himself from the communion of those other fathers, as we shall state in its place. Therefore Symphosius could not then be weakened by that plague of nefarious doctrine. Nor had he been accused of this heresy, at least publicly, in the year of Christ 385, when, namely, Priscillian and his companions, by the decree of the tyrant Maximus, were punished either with the penalty of capital punishment or of exile. For Severus Sulpicius, who in book 2 of the Histories
rem totam describit, haereseos utique auctoris et sociorum nomina in catalogum redegit, nulla prorsus Symphosii facta mentione. Quod argumenti genus, tamquam ex scriptoris silentio depromptum, quamvis alus in rebus imbecillum, arvique pendendum ducamus, illud tamen in praesentia maximum robur obtinet, ne Severum Sulpicium de socordi.e vel oscitantiae vitio postulandum esse arbitremur. An is celeberrimi hnjus episcopi nomen reticuisset, qui aliorum hujus sacri ordinis nomina recensuit, qui Igini, seu Idigini, Cordubensis lapsum post Toletanam synodum annotavit, quique ad pienam earum rerum notitiam alios etiam infimae plebis viros et mulieres expresse nominavit?
Ex quo tertium illud sequitur, videlicet nonnisi post Priscilliani cædem, et Ithaciano jam schismate ingravescente, et Hispaniarum rebus mutatis, obMaximi tyranni necem, Symphosium in apertam haeresim erupisse. Non igitur ante Christi annum ipse Symphosius tamquam Priscillianista haberi potuit; nec enim debitas corporis paenas evasisset, quas huc illucque per Hispaniae provincias imperialium tribunorum tyrannis, iibido et avaritia contra Priscillianam sobolem, capitali etiam adhibita pœna, districte exercebat.
He describes the whole matter, and indeed he reduced to a catalogue the names of the author of the heresy and of his companions, making no mention at all of Symphosius. Although we consider this kind of argument, as if drawn from the silence of a writer, weak in other matters and of little weight, yet in the present case it obtains the greatest force, so that we should not think Severus Sulpicius is to be charged with the fault of sloth or negligence. Would he have kept silent about the name of this most celebrated bishop, who listed the names of others of this sacred order, who noted the fall of Iginus, or Idiginus, of Corduba after the synod of Toledo, and who, for full knowledge of these matters, expressly named even other men and women of the lowest plebs?
From this follows that third point, namely that only after the slaughter of Priscillian, and with the schism of Ithacius already growing worse, and with the affairs of the Spains changed by the death of the tyrant Maximus, did Symphosius break out into open heresy. Therefore Symphosius could not have been regarded as a Priscillianist before the year of Christ [ ], nor would he have escaped the penalties of the body duly owed, which the tyrannies of the imperial tribunes throughout the provinces of Spain, through lust and avarice against the offspring of Priscillian, even with capital punishment applied, were strictly exacting.
Ne itaque Symphosium imperialium tribunorum inquisitionem per miraculum evasisse arbitremur, dubio procul fateri oPortet hunc ejusque filium Dictinium, Maximo tyranno adhuc in vivis superstite, catholicam lidem exterius saltem simulasse. Sed Maximum vita functum apud Aquileiam cum iutellexissent, jam praeconceptum necis. subeundæ timorem Symphosius et Dictinius excusserunt, et Priscilliana illa dogmata, quae occulto forte hactenus prosequebantur, palam verbis et scriptis, ut latius propagarent, docere cœperunt.
De Dictinii porro Operibos inter cæteros agit etiam Augustinus libro contra Mendacium ad Consentium, in quo ubique Priscillianistis excitatis illum Dicrinii librum. describit, cujus nomen est Libra; eo quod pertractatis duodecim quæstionibus, velut unciis explicatur, tantis (intelligitur Dictinius) extulerit lau-, dibus, ut talem Libram, qua horrendæ blasphemiæ continentur, multis Ubrarum auri millibus pretiosiorem esse testetur. Eo ergo in libro Dictinius dogmatizabat: ad occultandam religionem religiosos deberi mentiri. Quod argumenti genus cnm ex sacris Scripturis et harum exemplis deduci auctor contenderet, ipse Augustinus, ut divinarum Scripturarum sancti-. tati auctoritatique consuleret, omnes excelsae suaesapientiae nervos ad librum illum catholicae pietati maxime injuriosum refellendum atque destruendum adhibuit.
Therefore, lest we think that Symphosius escaped the investigation of the imperial tribunes by a miracle, we must without doubt confess that he and his son Dictinius, while the tyrant Maximus was still alive, at least outwardly simulated the catholic faith. But when they learned that Maximus had died at Aquileia, Symphosius and Dictinius shook off the fear of the death they had already conceived they must undergo, and that Priscillianist doctrine, which perhaps until then they had followed in secret, they began to teach openly in words and writings, so as to spread it more widely.
Concerning the works of Dictinius, moreover, Augustine also treats among others in the book Against Lying, addressed to Consentius, in which, everywhere that the Priscillianists are stirred up, he describes that book of Dictinius whose name is the Libra, because, with twelve questions treated, it is unfolded as it were by ounces; and he (Dictinius, that is) extolled it with such praises that he declares such a Libra, in which horrible blasphemies are contained, to be more precious than many thousands of pounds of gold. In that book, therefore, Dictinius taught as doctrine that religious persons ought to lie in order to conceal their religion. And when the author contended that this kind of argument was to be derived from the sacred Scriptures and their examples, Augustine himself, in order to consult the sanctity and authority of the divine Scriptures, applied all the sinews of his lofty wisdom to refuting and destroying that book, which is most injurious to catholic piety.
Sed et alios Dictinium in Priscillianne hæreseos tutelam et praesidium edidisse tractatus, inter caeteros Leo noster asseverat, ut nos ipsi suo loco dicemus.
Interim vero, ne a proposito instituto longius abscedamus, Symphosii ac Dictinii apertum lapsum uon ante quintum vel sextum Siricii pontificatus annum revocandum esse certissime arbitramur; quorum quidem impietatc a cæteris Hispaniae et Lusitaniæ episcopis cognita, et ex Dictinii Uperibus, que omnium manibus ten.bantur, magis comprobata, eatholici ab eorum communione se abelinere cœperunt, et in aliquo, ut arbitror, episcoporum conventu anathemate proscripti fuere. SeJ de re tam obscura, cujus veteres scriptores altum servavere silentium, ne in divinationem labamur, verba facere omnino prætermittimus. Sed ad Idatii Chronicon sermonem convertentes, quandonam Symphosius et Dirtinius ad catholicorum communionem redieriut, paucis explicabimus.
But our Leo also asserts, among other things, that Dictinius published treatises in defense and support of the Priscillianist heresy, as we ourselves shall say in its place.
Meanwhile, however, lest we depart too far from the plan we have undertaken, we most certainly judge that the open fall of Symphosius and Dictinius is not to be dated before the fifth or sixth year of the pontificate of Siricius; indeed, when their impiety had become known to the other bishops of Spain and Lusitania, and had been more fully proved from the works of Dictinius, which were held in everyone's hands, the catholics began to withdraw themselves from communion with them, and, as I think, in some council of bishops they were proscribed by anathema. But concerning a matter so obscure, on which the ancient writers have preserved a deep silence, lest we slip into divination, we altogether omit to speak. But turning our discourse to the Chronicle of Idatius, we shall briefly explain when Symphosius and Dictinius returned to the communion of the catholics.
Idatius itaque, Hispaniarum rerum scriptor accuralissimus, sub Anastasii pontificatu quoddam Toletanum concilium habitum fuisse, atque in eo tum Symphosium, tum Dictinium, aliosque Gallæciæ provinciæ episcopos Priscillianam haeresim ejurasse, propriaque manu fidei professione subscripta condemnasse asseverat. Romanæ Eeclesia habelur episcopus Anastasius. In provincia Carthaginensi, in civitate Toleto, synodus episcoporum contrahitur, in cujus gestis continetur Symphosius, et Dictinius, et alii cum his Gallæciæ provincice episcopis Priscilliani sectatores hæresim ejus blasphemissima cum assertore eodem professionis suæ subscriptione condemnant. Addit præterea: Statuuntur quædam etiam observanda de Escclesiœ disciplina, communicante in eodem concilio Orligio episcopo, qui Celenis fuerat ordinaMus. Sed agentibus Priscillianistis, pro fide catholica pulsus (actiombus exsulabat. Mirari profecto oportet nec veteres lice rccenliorcs scriptores ad tam celebre testimonium animadvertisse, sed horum alios, quoad concilii causas, quoad tempus, quoad gusta, in unam, alius in alteram abiisse opinionem. Immo admirationem auget quod hujus vel alierius opinionis assertores non iisdem insistant principiis, cum eorum quilibet, vel propriis studiis indulgeat, vel, quasi divinationibus usus, longius quam par est in re non mediocris momenti abscedat a veritate.
Idatius therefore, a most accurate writer of Spanish affairs, asserts that under the pontificate of Anastasius a certain council of Toledo was held, and that in it both Symphosius and Dictinius, and other bishops of the province of Gallaecia, abjured the Priscillianist heresy and condemned it, subscribing with their own hand a profession of faith. Anastasius is held to be bishop of the Roman Church. In the province of Carthaginensis, in the city of Toledo, a synod of bishops is assembled, in whose acts it is contained that Symphosius, and Dictinius, and others with them, bishops of the province of Gallaecia, followers of Priscillian, condemn his heresy, most blasphemous, together with its very assertor, by the subscription of their profession. He adds besides: Certain things also are established to be observed concerning the discipline of the Church, with Orligius, bishop, communicating in the same council, who had been ordained at Celenis. But, with the Priscillianists acting, he was driven out for the catholic faith and was in exile through their actions. It is truly fitting to wonder that neither ancient nor more recent writers have paid attention to so famous a testimony, but that some of them, as regards the causes of the council, as regards the time, as regards the place, have gone off into one opinion, others into another. Nay, wonder increases because the assertors of this or that opinion do not insist on the same principles, since each of them either indulges his own pursuits, or, as if having used divinations, departs further than is fitting from the truth in a matter of no mediocre moment.
Nec cnim cum Baronio aut Concilioruln collectoribus hic contender; audio, qni, in tauta sacrorum monumentor liin copia et Chrisrtanæ rei suppellectile tempus et operam insumentes, omnia collegerunt, dispusucrum, ornarunt, non ita tamen, ut eadem semper oculis suis lustrare potuerint, eademque ad optimae critices regulas redigere. Sed nostra oratio potius ens tangit ct urget qui commentaria vel in Baronium, vel ip concilia ipsa ediderunt. Pagius enim, Severinus Mitius, cardinalis Aguirre, Sirmondus, Baluzius, Mque alii eruditi et antiquae rei studiosi scriptores legitimum concilii Toletani tempus delinierunt. cælera vero ibidem acta silentio praeterierunt. Tille. montius deinde ad concilii cogendi causas exam!nandas descendit, multa de Symphosio et Dictinio comminiscitur, cum ad divi Ambrosii epistolas 52. 56, provocat, in quibus nec de Priscillianistis, nec de duobus illis episcopis unicum profert verbum. Cajetanus Cenni octo priorum sæculorum ecclesiasticam historiam illustrandam suscepit, ac præscrim de formis ecclesiastici judicii servatis in Ecclesia Ilispana verba facere sibi proposuit. Sed vir doctus vix delibatis iis quae ad Toletani concilii tempus pertiuent, caetera silentio prorsus præterit, amplissimo relicto nobis aliisque campo, quem eidem Dictinii et Symphosii causa aperuerat pontificiae apostolicæ sedis auctoritatis tum asserendae, tum propugnandae.
For I would not contend here with Baronius or the collectors of councils; I hear them, who, in so great an abundance of sacred monuments and in the furnishings of Christian affairs, spending time and effort, collected, arranged, and adorned all things—yet not so that they could always survey the same things with their own eyes and reduce them to the rules of the best criticism. But our discourse rather touches and presses upon those who published commentaries either on Baronius or on the councils themselves. For Pagi indeed, Severinus Mitius, Cardinal Aguirre, Sirmond, Baluze, and many other learned and antiquarian writers defined the lawful time of the Council of Toledo, but passed over the other acts in the same place in silence. Tillemont then descended to examining the causes of convening the council, devises many things concerning Symphosius and Dictinius, when he appeals to the letters 52 and 56 of the divine Ambrose, in which he brings forth not a single word concerning the Priscillianists or concerning those two bishops. Cajetan Cenni undertook to illustrate the ecclesiastical history of the first eight centuries, and especially proposed to himself to speak of the forms of ecclesiastical judgment preserved in the Spanish Church. But the learned man, having scarcely touched upon those things which pertain to the time of the Council of Toledo, passes over the rest in complete silence, leaving to us and to others a most ample field, which the case of the same Dictinius and Symphosius had opened for both asserting and defending the authority of the pontifical apostolic see.
Qua in re a proposito sibi scopo minime cessisse certe ii judicabunt qui ejusdem Cenni præfationem percurrerunt.
CAPUT VIII.
Ad refellendas quorumdam et Paschasii Quesnelli po tissimum fulsas opiniones, Symphosii et Dictinii episcoporum causa exactius ex ecclesiasticis monu mentis ad examen revocatur.
I. Quamvis hactenus multus fucrim in expendendis Cæsaraugustanorum Toletanorumque conciliorum Actis, ad Priscillianistarum causam et condemuationem pertinentibus, tamen nihil me pra'stitisse arbitror, nisi exactius stylum admoveam in iis describendis quae ad Symphosium et Dictinium episcopos, quondam Pi iscilliana labe pollutos, spectare videntur. De iisdem enim duobus episcopis aliqui etiam ex recentioribus scriptorihus verba fecere, quos muter principem obtinet locum Paschasius Quesnellus, qui in adornandis sancti Leonis Magni Operibus, nimis suis partibus indulgens, nullo veritatis studio adductus, solam ratiocinandi libidinem secutu'i, rerunt ecclesiasticarum seriem, susquedeque, vertere nisus, veterum mouumenta aut oscitanter lustravit, aut in pravum sensum detorsit; et denique veteri Ecclesiæ disciplina abolita, novam rrgiminis et oeconomiae rationem moliri allaboravit. Is namque in notis ct observationibus ad S. Leonis Magni epistolam diserlius Priscillianistarum causam et concilia in eosdem Priscillianistas congregata, tem.
In this matter, those who have perused the preface of the same Cennus will certainly judge that he by no means fell short of the goal he had proposed to himself.
CHAPTER VIII.
In order to refute the false opinions of certain persons, and especially of Paschasius Quesnel, the case of the bishops Symphosius and Dictinius is more exactly recalled to examination from the ecclesiastical monuments.
I. Although I have hitherto been much occupied in weighing the Acts of the councils of Caesaraugusta and Toledo, which pertain to the cause and condemnation of the Priscillianists, nevertheless I think I have accomplished nothing unless I apply my pen more exactly to describing those things which appear to concern the bishops Symphosius and Dictinius, once polluted by the Priscillianist stain. For certain even of the more recent writers have spoken of these same two bishops, among whom Paschasius Quesnel holds the chief place, who, in arranging the Works of Saint Leo the Great, indulging his own party too much, led by no zeal for truth, following only the lust of reasoning, and striving to overturn the sequence of ecclesiastical affairs and his own, either glanced carelessly at the monuments of the ancients or twisted them into a depraved meaning; and finally, having abolished the discipline of the ancient Church, he labored to contrive a new system of rule and economy. For he, in the notes and observations on the letter of Saint Leo the Great, more discursively [treated] the cause of the Priscillianists and the councils gathered against those same Priscillianists, tem[poribus]...
pus quo Symphosius et Dictinius vel in hæresim lapsi sunt, vel in Ecclesiæ communionem suscepti fuere, diligentius inquirit. III præceps sane inulta ruerent, quae nos tunquam certa probavimus. si Quesnellianx conjecturae robor baberent. Sed tentabundus imprimis is scriptor incedens, utriusque lapsum, Symuho-' sii nimirum et Dictinii, ante Cæsaraugustanum statuit concilium. De qua haeresi infamatus uterque fuit in Cæsarangustana synodo anni adversus Priscillianum, cujus judicium declinasse dicitur Symphosius, in sententia Toletanae i synodi se suhducens. Mutare arbitror hocce primum Quesnelli assertum. Nam definitiva illa sententia, quæ pot concilui Toletani primi acta lcgitur, ex qua is certe suam hau-it opinionem, minime hisce dictis cohæret. Si. quidem animum suspensum in veritatis inquisitione habuisse Symphosium ibidem asseritur, sola tamen una die concilio Cœsaraugustano stitisse se, qui postmodum declinando sententiam prœsens audire contempserat. Qua ratione autem hæc cum Priscillianistarum historia coh.trere possint, me omnino latet. Symphosium episcopum Cæsaraugustano concilo anni subscripsisse certissimum esl. Ad aliud igitur Caesaraugustae habitum concilium laudata verba referri debent, de quo plerique suspicati sunt, sed hujus Acta non exstant. Praeterea quae ibidem subduntur praecedentibus repugnare videntur.
He inquires more diligently into the matter by which Symphosius and Dictinius either fell into heresy or were received into the communion of the Church. III. Surely those things would rush headlong and unavenged which we have approved as certain, if the conjectures of Quesnel had any strength. But that writer, advancing in the first place tentatively, established the fall of both—namely of Symphosius and of Dictinius—before the Council of Caesaraugusta. Each of them was defamed concerning this heresy in the Synod of Caesaraugusta of the year against Priscillian, whose judgment Symphosius is said to have declined, withdrawing himself in the sentence of the first Synod of Toledo. I think this first assertion of Quesnel must be changed. For that definitive sentence which is read after the acts of the first Council of Toledo, from which he certainly drew his opinion, does not cohere at all with these words. Indeed, it is asserted in that same place that Symphosius had his mind suspended in the investigation of the truth, yet that he stood present at the Council of Caesaraugusta for only one day, he who afterwards, by declining the sentence, disdained to hear it in person. But by what reasoning these things can cohere with the history of the Priscillianists wholly escapes me. That Bishop Symphosius subscribed to the Council of Caesaraugusta of the year is most certain. Therefore the words cited must be referred to another council held at Caesaraugusta, concerning which very many have suspected, but its Acts do not exist. Furthermore, the things added in that same place seem to conflict with the preceding.
nam aiunt: Arduum nobis esset audire jam dictos, litteris, tamcn sanctœmemoriæ Ambrosii, quas post illud concilium ad noa miserat, ut, si condemnassent quœ perperam egerant, et implessent conditiones quas prœscriptas litterae continebant, reverenter ad pacem (adde I quœ sanctœ memoriae Siricius papa suasisset)...., magnam noa constat prœstitisse putientiam. Tutam in suam sententiam hanc transtulit QuesneJlus narrationem, minime tamen perpendens an cum caeteris aliis Priscillianistarum historiae certissimis monumentis cohaereret, necne. Si ad memoriam revocemus ea quae in superioribus ei Severo Sulpicio exscripsimus, dissmilem quamdam in Ambrosio agendi rationem in eadem causa deprehendimus. Is quidem Priscillianum, Instantium aliosque hujus sectae viro. qui Cæsaraugustanæ illi synodo anno se sistere detractarunt, quamvis Mediolanum profectos, non audivit. non recepit, nec pro iisdem recipiendis ullas ad eaiholicos Hispaniarum episcopos litteras dedit. Qni ergo fieri pi tuit ut idem Ambrosius post illud idem Cæsaraugustanum concilium audierit, receperit, pœnitentiæque agendæ conditiones Symphosio episcopo ct hujus lilio Dictinio atque aliis præscripserit, qui iisdem moribus et vitiis labefactabantur?
For they say: It would be difficult for us to hear those already mentioned, yet by the letters of the holy memory Ambrose, which he had sent to us after that council, [namely] that, if they had condemned the things they had done wrongly, and had fulfilled the conditions which the prescribed letters contained, they should be reverently received to peace (add also what Pope Siricius of holy memory had urged)...., it is established that he rendered great service to penitence. Quesnel transferred this account safely into his own view, yet by no means considering whether it cohered with the other most certain monuments of the history of the Priscillianists or not. If we recall to memory those things which we have written out above from Severus Sulpicius, we discover a certain dissimilar manner of acting in Ambrose in the same cause. Indeed, he neither heard Priscillian, Instantius, and other men of this sect, who withdrew from presenting themselves at that synod of Caesaraugusta in the year, although they had set out for Milan, nor received them, nor did he give any letters to the catholic bishops of the Spains for receiving them. How, then, could it have come about that the same Ambrose, after that same council of Caesaraugusta, heard, received, and prescribed conditions of doing penance to Symphosius the bishop and Dictinius his son and others, who were being undermined by the same customs and vices?
Sed aliud quidpiam præterea laudata in narratione est, quod cum Cæsaraugustani concilii tempore minime conciliari potest. Ibidem enim sancti Siricii papæ pro hæreticis pœnitentibus recipiendis statuta Jaudantur, Nec Ambrosius ipse alias conditiones jure præscribere poterat, nisi eas quas apostolica summi pontificis auctoritas decreverat. Hecognovit enim ille sanctissimus Mediolanensis antistes et cæteri illius provinciae episcopi jam in concilio congregati, neminem ab Ecclesia exclusum legitime eam iterum ingredi posse, cui supremus Janitor, S. Petri succestor, januam non aperuerit. Propterea Ambrosius ad Siricium eum cæteris in concilio congregatis rescribens, epi tolam sic orditur: Reccognorimus litteris sanctitatis tuœ boni pastoris excubias, qui diligenter commissam tibi januam serves, et pia sollicitud ne Christi ovile custodias, ete. Hisce ergo principiis Ambrosius insistens, Hispaniarum episcopis suggerere debuit, ut Symphosium et Dictinium pœnitentes ad reconciliationem reciperent, sub illis conditionibus, dumtxat, quas jam apostolica sedes decreverat. l'erum cum Siriciana ejusmodi statuta lucem non aspexerint nisi quadriennio saltem post Cæsaraugugiamim illud concilium, anno videlicet 385, III idus Februarias.
But there is something else besides that is praised in the account, which can hardly be reconciled with the time of the council of Caesaraugusta. For in that same place the statutes of the holy pope Siricius concerning the receiving of penitent heretics are praised. Nor could Ambrose himself lawfully prescribe other conditions than those which the authority of the supreme pontiff, the apostolic see, had decreed. For that most holy bishop of Milan and the other bishops of that province, already gathered in council, knew that no one excluded from the Church could lawfully enter it again unless the supreme Janitor, the successor of St. Peter, had opened the door to him. For this reason Ambrose, writing back to Siricius along with the others gathered in council, begins his letter thus: We have recognized in the letters of your Holiness the watchfulness of the good shepherd, who carefully guards the door committed to you, and with pious solicitude keeps watch over the sheepfold of Christ, etc. Proceeding therefore from these principles, Ambrose ought to have urged the bishops of the Spains to receive the penitents Symphosius and Dictinius into reconciliation, under those conditions, that is, which the apostolic see had already decreed. But the statutes of Siricius of this kind did not see the light until at least four years after that council of Caesaraugusta, namely in the year 385, on the third day before the Ides of February.
Arcadio et Bautone consulatum agentibus, idcirco mihi numquam persuadere possum Symphoini et Diclinii causam anno ill Ca-saraugustann synodo fuisse recognitam, ambosque ab illo episcoI orum judicio se subduxisse. Mam admis'a illa diffamationequam confingit Quesnellus, tum probata ilia subductione a Cæsaraugustamorum rai trum judicio anni 581, jam Symphosium ei DilLinium, utpote contumaces, necessario ad Burdigalensem synodum accire debebant, cui interesse si detrectasset, parem cum Instantio ei Priscilliano pœnam solvissent. Quid plura? Maximi tyranni gladium minime evasissent, nec denique ab imperialium tribunorum furore se incolumes præstitissent, ut paulo prins obsi rvavimus. Burdigalensis porro synodus ill., eodem anon iisdemque consulibus coacta fuit, in qua nihil de Symphosii et Dictinii diffamatione et contumacia dictum fuisse, Severi Sulpicii silentio probatum est.
With Arcadius and Bauto holding the consulship, for that reason I can never persuade myself that the case of Symphosius and Dictinius was examined in that year by the council of Caesaraugusta, and that both withdrew themselves from that judgment of the bishops. For once that defamation which Quesnellus fabricates had been admitted, and once that withdrawal from the judgment of the bishops of Caesaraugusta of the year 381 had been approved, then Symphosius and Dictinius, as being contumacious, would necessarily have had to be summoned to the council of Bordeaux; and if they had refused to be present at it, they would have paid the same penalty as Instantius and Priscillian. What more? They would by no means have escaped the sword of the tyrant Maximus, nor would they finally have kept themselves unharmed from the fury of the imperial tribunes, as we observed a little earlier. Furthermore, that council of Bordeaux was convened in the same year and under the same consuls, at which nothing was said concerning the defamation and contumacy of Symphosius and Dictinius, as has been proved by the silence of Severus Sulpicius.
Nos ergo, ul hujusmodi figmentum præcaveamus affirmare oportehit, vel scribarum imperitia in eam sententiam ista verba irrepsisse: Post Cœsaraugustanum concilium, in quo sententia in certos quoaqtte dicta fuerat, sola tamen una die præsente Symphosio, qui postmodum declinando sententiam prœsens audire contempserat; vel ad aliud quam ad illud, quod anno coactum fuerat debere referri; hocque nonnisi post Priscilliani, Instanti, alinrumque necem haheri potuisse, nostra quidem sententia est. Cardinatis Aguirre, variis adductus conjecturis, tom. II Concil. Hispaniæ, prater illud primum Cæsaraugustanum concilium, aliud anno ibidem celebratum asseveratn cui nos subseribere hand possumus, qui serius illud coactum fuisse contendimus. Verum quamvis multis obvolutum tenebris istuc negotium sit et videatur, tamen caetera. qu:e in laudato illius definitivæ sententiae exemp'ari subduntur, magnum lumen ad veritatern propius attingendam suppeditant. Legitur namque Symphosium suncto Ambrosio prasente et audiente, eas conditiones acceptane et posuisse, videticet a recitatione eorum qui dicebantur martyres iam recessisse et perpetuo recessurum; Dictinium vero ecclesiastica obtenta pace, presbyterii locum tenere, nec accipere honoris augmentum, ut jam papa Siricius priori sua epistola de lapsis poenitentibus decrevrrat.
We therefore ought to affirm that, so that we may guard against a fabrication of this kind, either it was through the ignorance of scribes that these words crept into that sentence: "After the council of Caesaraugusta, in which sentence had been pronounced against certain persons, yet on one day alone, with Symphosius present, who afterwards, by declining the sentence, had disdained to hear it when present"; or that it must be referred to another council than that which had been convened in that year; and that this could have taken place only after the death of Priscillian, Instantius, and others—this indeed is our opinion. Cardinal Aguirre, led by various conjectures, in tome II of the Councils of Hispania, asserts that, besides that first council of Caesaraugusta, another was celebrated in the same year in that place; to which we cannot subscribe, since we maintain that it was convened later. But although this matter is and appears wrapped in many shadows, nevertheless the remaining points which are subjoined in the cited copy of that definitive sentence supply a great light for attaining more closely to the truth. For it is read that Symphosius, with Saint Ambrose present and hearing, accepted and laid down these conditions: namely, that he had withdrawn from the recitation of those who were called martyrs, and would withdraw forever; but that Dictinius, once ecclesiastical peace had been obtained, should hold the place of presbyter, and should not receive any increase of honor, as Pope Siricius had already decreed in his former letter concerning the lapsed who do penance.
Plane ergo omnes illorum conjecturæ ruunt qui Symphosium et filium ejus Dictinium ante Priscillianistarum Cædem lapsos esse contendunt. Cujus ca'dis gesta referens Severus Sulpicius causam fuisse ait, ut non solum non repressa fuerit hœresis quœ illo all.. ctore proruperat, sed confirmata, latius propagata est. Namque sectatores ejus, qui eum prius ut sanctum. honoraverant, postea ut martyrem colere cœperunt, Peremptorum corpora ad Hispanias relata, magnisque obsequiis celebrata eorum funera. Caeso itaque Priscilliano ct sociis, catholica religio impie magis et superstitiose foedari coepit, cum videlicet tamquam veri martyres haberentur et colerentur ii quos ob graviora scelera saeculi gladius interfecerat.
Ex cujus facti novitate ita ecclesiastica; res perturbatæ fuere, ut plurimi sanctioris vitæ episcopi ab illo judicii et vindictæ genere maxime abhorrentes, quasi Priscilliani causam tueri videbantur, cum cædium auctoribus, Ithacio videlicet et cateris, communione denegata, anathemate dicto cpi,copalibusque sedibus spoliatis, tam grave cruentumque facinus exhorrebant.
Clearly, then, all their conjectures collapse—those who contend that Symphosius and his son Dictinius fell away before the slaughter of the Priscillianists. Recounting the events of that slaughter, Severus Sulpicius says that the cause was that the heresy which had burst forth under that author was not only not repressed but was confirmed and spread more widely. For his followers, who had previously honored him as a saint, afterward began to venerate him as a martyr; the bodies of those killed were brought back to the Spains, and their funerals were celebrated with great obsequies. So when Priscillian and his companions were slain, the catholic religion began to be defiled more impiously and superstitiously, since evidently those whom the sword of the world had killed for their graver crimes were regarded and venerated as true martyrs.
From the novelty of this deed, ecclesiastical affairs were so disturbed that very many bishops of holier life, greatly abhorring that kind of judgment and vengeance, seemed as it were to defend the cause of Priscillian, while—refusing communion to the authors of the slaughters, namely Ithacius and the others, pronouncing anathema upon them, and stripping them of their episcopal sees—they shuddered at so grave and bloody a crime.
Ab illo enim catholicorum schismate Priscillianistae occasionem arripuere magis atque magis suam sectam propagandi, cum cæsorum cada veribus sacros martyrum honores vindicarent, impiamque eam consuetudinem inter se ipsos et in Ecclesias inducentes, ut horum nomina inter aliorum martyrum memorias divinis in persolvendis officiis recitarent. In ejusmodi quippe amentiam cecidit Symphosius. a multis deceplus et circumventus, quemadmodum illiui definitivæ sententiæ exemplaria patefaciunt. £x Priscilliani antem dogmatibus duo dumtaxat profitebatur Symphosius: alterum innascibilem esse Deum, alterum vero duo rerum aspectabilium principia reperiri. Nullis tamen libris apocryphis, aut novis scientiis, quas Priscillianus composuerat Symphosius umquam usus est, quamivis Dictinius epistolis aliquantis pene lapsus, quas omnes suas professione condemnans, corre. ctionem petens, in Toletano illo concilio veniam postulavit. Hæc itaque omnia tantam apud nos vim habent, ut nulla prorsus ratione in Quesnelli sententiam adducamur, ut videlicet arbitremur Symphosium anno in Cæsaraugustana illa synodo diO'amatum, et veluti Priscilliamstam se ab illorum Famum judicio suhduxisse. l'ix cnim ecclesiasticæ reconciliationis donum sibi promereri potuisset, si novemdecim aonorum spatio (quale inter illut et istud Toletanum concilium intercessit) pertinax in sua contumacia perstitisset.
For from that schism of the Catholics the Priscillianists seized the occasion to propagate their sect more and more, when by the corpses of the slain they claimed for them the sacred honors of martyrs, and introducing this impious custom among themselves and into the Churches, so that they would recite their names among the memorials of other martyrs in the performance of divine offices. For into madness of this kind Symphosius fell, deceived and circumvented by many, as the copies of that definitive sentence make clear. But of the doctrines of Priscillian Symphosius professed only two: one, that God is unbegotten; the other, that there are found two principles of visible things. Nevertheless Symphosius never used any apocryphal books, or the new doctrines which Priscillian had composed, although Dictinius, having all but fallen through certain letters, condemning all of them as his own by profession and seeking correction, asked pardon at that Council of Toledo. All these things, then, have such force among us that by no reasoning whatever are we brought to the opinion of Quesnel, namely that we should judge that Symphosius was condemned in that Synod of Zaragoza, and as it were withdrew himself as a Priscillianist from the judgment of that assembly. For he could have deserved for himself the gift of ecclesiastical reconciliation, if for the space of nineteen years (such as intervened between that council and this one of Toledo) he had persisted stubborn in his contumacy.
Jam vcro ad alia gradum faciamus, quai ob vclerum monumentorum jacturam aeque obscura et mul is difficultatibus imil xa sunt. Ambrosium ita. que, veluti pacis et reconciliationis sequestrem, a Symphosio et crteris qui lapsi erant interpellatum fuisse, jam ii ter omnes cum veteres tum recentiores scriptures convenit. Non ita tamen exploratum e"l quo anno istos Mediolanum profectos Ambrosius roceperit, traditis illis communicatoriis litteris, ut sub quibusdam præscriptis et acceptatis conditionibus catholici ipsi Hispaniarum episcopi, qui se a lapsorum communione separaverant, ad pacem et ecclesiasticam reconciliationem eos admitterent. Quid autem in se continerent divi illae Ambrosii epistolae ad Hispaniarum episcopos datae, cum jam temporis injuria interciderint, non undequaque perspectum esse potest. Ex Actis dumtaxat hujus Toletani concilii annu coacii evincitur, illas in pracedenti alia Toletana synodo, ad quam Symphosius, Dictinius ei cæteri lapsorum acciti venire detrectarunt, fuisse recitatas; lum etiam Ambrosium sequestris oflicio sub iis conditionibus functum esse, ut Symphosius ab ordinationis munere se abstineret, et Dictinius hujus lilius perpetuo in presbyterii gradu ita permaneret, ut ipse et alii clerici æqualis rel inferioris ordini numquam ad superiores gradus Ecclesiæ possent ascendere.
Now let us proceed to other matters, which, owing to the loss of the old records, are equally obscure and beset by many difficulties. It is agreed by all, both older and more recent writers, that Ambrose was appealed to by Symphosius and the others who had lapsed, as a mediator of peace and reconciliation. Yet it is not so certain in what year Ambrose received them when they had set out for Milan, having given them letters of communion, so that under certain prescribed and accepted conditions the Catholic bishops of the Spains themselves, who had separated themselves from the communion of the lapsed, might admit them to peace and ecclesiastical reconciliation. But what those divine letters of Ambrose, given to the bishops of the Spains, contained in themselves, since they have by now perished through the injury of time, cannot be fully ascertained. It is established only from the Acts of this Council of Toledo, convened in that year, that they were read out at another preceding synod of Toledo, to which Symphosius, Dictinius, and the rest of the lapsed, having been summoned, refused to come; and also that Ambrose discharged the office of mediator under these conditions, that Symphosius should abstain from the duty of ordination, and that Dictinius his son should so remain perpetually in the rank of the presbyterate that he himself and other clerics of equal or lower rank might never ascend to the higher grades of the Church.
Sed duo sane lum contigerunt, quæ paci et ecclesiasticæ reconciliationi prorsus repugnahant. Detrectarunt imprimis quotqnot Ambrosium adierant coram Hispanorum episcoporum synodo condemnare qua perperam egerant, ut idem Mediolanensis antistes, apostolicae sedis statutis innixus, faciendum præscripserat, tum a prenitentium statu atqne proposito contra fidem datam recesserunt. Nam vita functo Asturicensi episcopo, Symphosius ad eam sedem Dictinium filium evexit, ei episcopum consecravit, et Dictinius ipse, cum eod Symphosio multos alios in Galliciæ provincia, quorum fides non satis probata erat, in episcopos ordinarunt. Horum autem omnium gestorum seriem continet illud definitivae sententiæ exemplar quod in Toletana ann; synodo editum fuit.
Superest nunc ergo ut illius habitæ Toletana synodi tempus inquiramus in qua, lectIS AmDrosn litteris,poenitentes illi ad reconciliationis pacem admitti debebant, a qua tamen Symphosius et cæteri se subtraxerunt. Eam autem habitam fuisse ante Ambrosii mortem probabilius est. Paulinus enim in hujus Vita ait: Theodosio imperatori Christianissimo triennium fere supervixit Ambrosius, qui et ipso die sabbati sancti ilium desiisse vivere scribit: prorsus (Petavius subdit) Aprilis 4, Christi anno 397, Cæsario et Attico coss. Marcellinus amem hnjus obitum anno sequenti ascribit, Honorio et Eu'ychiano coss.
But two things indeed occurred which were wholly opposed to peace and ecclesiastical reconciliation. First, all those who had approached Ambrose refused to condemn before the synod of the bishops of Spain the things they had done wrongly, as the same bishop of Milan, relying on the statutes of the apostolic see, had prescribed was to be done; then they withdrew from the state and purpose of penitents against the faith they had given. For when the bishop of Asturica had died, Symphosius raised his son Dictinius to that see and consecrated him bishop, and Dictinius himself, together with the same Symphosius, ordained many others as bishops in the province of Gallaecia, whose faith was not sufficiently proven. Now the series of all these deeds is contained in that copy of the definitive sentence which was issued in the synod of Toledo.
It remains now, therefore, that we inquire into the time of that synod held at Toledo, in which, when the letters of Ambrose had been read, those penitents were to be admitted to the peace of reconciliation, from which nevertheless Symphosius and the others withdrew themselves. But it is more probable that it was held before the death of Ambrose. For Paulinus in his Life says: Ambrose survived the most Christian emperor Theodosius by nearly three years, and he writes that he ceased to live on the very day of Holy Saturday: precisely (Petavius adds) April 4, in the year of Christ 397, with Caesarius and Atticus as consuls. Marcellinus, however, assigns his death to the following year, with Honorius and Eutychianus as consuls.
Non din igitur ante divi Ambrosii mortem potuit illa synodus congregari, nam omnes illi novemdecim episcopi, qui in contumaces absentes liliellarem direxere sententiam, adhuc anno crant superstites, quod difficile fuisset, si inter illam et hanc Toletanam synodum multorum annorum spatium interOuxisset. Nullum prorsus ad haec horumque similia respectum habuit Paschasius Quesnellus, sed, pro more et ingenio suo, divinationibus usus, plures Toletanas synodos distinxit, quarum primam inter (aesaraugustanam anni et To'et nam anni quadringentesimi statuit, nulla interim prorsus habita ratione, vel ad Burdigalensem, vel ad Trevirensem, cel ad alian. forte Cæsaraugustanam, quæ certissime omnes Toletanos conventus praecesserunt. Verum isthacc praetereamus, ne in minimis cum Quesnello conteudentes, nodum in scirpo quærere voluisse videamur.
Therefore that synod could not have been assembled long before the death of the blessed Ambrose, for all those nineteen bishops who sent a sentence of excommunication against the contumacious absent parties were still alive in that year, which would have been difficult if a span of many years had intervened between that synod and this one of Toledo. Paschasius Quesnellus had absolutely no regard for these matters or others like them, but, according to his custom and temperament, resorting to conjectures, he distinguished several synods of Toledo, the first of which he placed between the Council of Zaragoza of the year [400] and that of Toledo of the year 400, while having absolutely no regard either for the Council of Bordeaux, or that of Trier, or perhaps another of Zaragoza, all of which most certainly preceded all the assemblies of Toledo. But let us pass over these matters, lest, contending with Quesnellus over trifles, we seem to wish to seek a knot in a bulrush.
Illuc igitur nostra potitis se vertat oratio, ubi graviores Quesnelli lapsus offendimus. Cujus quidem generis esse arbitramur palmares illos errores quibus notae et observationes in epistolam S. Leonis refertæ sunt. In priori quippe horum Operum editione, quasi ex suggestu, Paschasius Quesnellus docuerat Dictinium ex episcopali sua sede ob Priscillianam hæresim ejectum fuisse, coi postmodum Turribius successerat. laic autem errori causam dedere verba sequentia, quæ ex Idatii Chronico recitare dixit: Dictinius Asturicensis episcopus, cut ob Pruscilliani hæresim, qnam profitebatur, ejecto, cum aliis ejusdem ' sectœ episcopis, successit Turribius. Incaute etiam monachos congregationis sancti Mauri lapsos esse deprehendimus, qui in sancii Augustini Operum edi)ione, nimia forte Quesnello vel alteri mendaci scriptori, fide adhibita, illud idem lestimonium Idatiano asseruerunt Chronico, repugnantibus aliunde Augustini verbis, quibus Dictinium inter catholicos Ecclesiis episcopos diem clausisse affirmat; et Ferrario, qui scripsit Dictinium catalogo sanctorum episcoporum Asturicensis Ecclesiæ ascriptum rcperiri, ejusque memoriam quotannis die Junii ea in Ecclesia recoli consuetum fuisse.
Let our discourse therefore turn to that point where we encounter the more serious errors of Quesnel. Of this kind, indeed, we consider those signal mistakes to be, by which the notes and observations appended to the epistle of St. Leo are marked. For in the earlier edition of these Works, as if from a public platform, Paschasius Quesnel had taught that Dictinius was driven from his episcopal see on account of the Priscillianist heresy, and that Turribius afterward succeeded him. But the following words, which he said he was quoting from the Chronicle of Idatius, gave occasion to that error: Dictinius, bishop of Astorga, having been ejected because of the Priscillianist heresy, which he professed, together with other bishops of the same sect, Turribius succeeded him. We have also discovered that the monks of the congregation of Saint Maur fell into error carelessly, who in their edition of the Works of Saint Augustine, placing perhaps excessive trust in Quesnel or in some other deceitful writer, asserted that same testimony to be from the Chronicle of Idatius, though the words of Augustine are on the other side repugnant to this, by which he affirms that Dictinius ended his days among the catholic bishops of the Churches; and so too is Ferrarius, who wrote that Dictinius is found enrolled in the catalogue of the holy bishops of the Church of Astorga, and that his memory was customarily celebrated each year on the day of June in that Church.
Interim autem Paschasium Quesnellum suis laudibus fraudari iniquum foret, qui, laudatum Idatii Chronicum percurrens, memoriae defectionem sea allucinationem in prima editione se passum esse fatetur, ex cujus Chronici lectione sapientior factus, quæ jam dixerat in altera retractavit editione, sed nimis subdole. Hominis ingenium, qui quoad usque vixit a jam dictis contra catholicæ fidei articulos prolatis et scriptis numquam recedere voluit, quis proteCto inirari desinet? Scd hæreticorum schismaticorumque ejusmodi fuisse agendi rationem nemo ignorat. IIi namque.tuam sa pissime, si in hisloricis similibusquerebus, parum nihilumve ad eorum systeina conucentibu quandoque per inscitiam, oscitantiam et arrogantiam defeceruut, haud difficile postmodum errata revocarunt, correxerunt, et quibusdaln veritatis umbraculis contexerunt, ut videlicet veracium ingenuorum;ue animorum opinionem apud suos asse. clas, quos in fidei morumque regulis decipere voluerunt, sibi vindicent. Sed eum errorem in postrema sua editione nec integre omnino emendavit Quesnellus. Verb i illa quidem in IdaLiano Chronico desiderari, nec suo fuisse studio conficta sincere et quasi jurejurando fassus est.
Meanwhile, however, it would be unjust for Paschasius Quesnel to be robbed of his due praise, since he, running through the praised Chronicle of Idatius, confesses that in the first edition he suffered a lapse or rather a hallucination of memory; made wiser by the reading of that Chronicle, he retracted in the second edition what he had already said, but too cunningly. Who, indeed, will cease to marvel at the man's character, who, as long as he lived, never wished to recede from the things already said and written against the articles of the Catholic faith? But no one is ignorant that such was the manner of acting of heretics and schismatics. For they, whenever in historical and similar matters—things contributing little or nothing to their system—they have failed through ignorance, carelessness, and arrogance, have afterwards not with difficulty recalled, corrected, and cloaked their errors with certain shadows of truth, namely so that they might claim for themselves, among their own adherents, the opinion of truthful and ingenuous minds—those whom they wished to deceive in the rules of faith and morals. But Quesnel did not entirely and wholly emend that error in his last edition. Those words, indeed, he sincerely confessed, and as if by oath, to be wanting in the Idacian Chronicle, nor to have been fabricated by his own zeal.
Caeterum fragmentum illud, cum omnibus substructis, non abradendum a postrema editione censuit, in spem nimirum adductus posse aliquando eruditis oculis inter legendum occurrere, et ad typographum deferri, huic historiæ inserendum. Cui quidem opinioni cum insisteret, non spurium esse illud fragmentum sibi persuadet, sed ignoto potius parenti adjudicandum, et tamquam somniator multa falsa commentitiaque imaginatur, quae catholicæ Ecclesiæ et Priscillianistarum historias dejiciunt, Toletanorum conciliorum fidem auctoritatemque nimis reddunt suspectam; et, quod gravius cst, Idatii Chronicum, quod et ipse summis laudibus ornat, pravis suis interpretationibus mutilat, corrumpit et In contrariam detorquet significationem. Sed ne de mea senteiitia comminisci videar, singula quæ Quesnellus adducit, jam statim refellam.
Et prino rogo unde is scriptor bauriat Dicrinium jam ante annum e sua Asturicens, sede dejectum, huicque statim S. Turribium suffectum? Unde, quæso, deducit iterum Dictinium ipsum, Toletanis PP. annueulibus, suam primam occupasse sedem, quæ disserendi ratio, contra Ecclesiæ canones, duos confingit episcopos eamdem sedem adniinistrantes? Horum porro nihil habet Idatius in Chronico, nibil Toletani Patres, qui de hac Dictinii restitutione, aut de Turribii ordinatione nec unum verbum protulerunt.
But that fragment, together with all its supporting material, he judged should not be struck from the last edition, being led, no doubt, by the hope that it might at some time meet the learned eyes of readers and be brought to the printer, to be inserted into this history. And while he clung to this opinion, he persuaded himself that the fragment was not spurious but rather to be assigned to some unknown author, and like a dreamer he imagines many false and fabricated things which overthrow the histories of the catholic Church and of the Priscillianists, and render the credibility and authority of the councils of Toledo too suspect; and, what is more serious, he mutilates the Chronicle of Idatius, which he himself also extols with the highest praises, corrupts it by his perverse interpretations, and twists it into the opposite meaning. But lest I seem to invent things out of my own judgment, I shall refute forthwith, one by one, the points that Quesnel brings forward.
And first I ask, from what source does that writer draw the claim that Dictinius was already a year before cast down from his see of Asturica, and that Saint Turribius was immediately substituted in his place? Whence, I ask, does he deduce that Dictinius himself, with the fathers of Toledo assenting, again occupied his former see—a manner of arguing which, contrary to the canons of the Church, invents two bishops administering the same see? Now of these things Idatius has nothing in his Chronicle, nothing do the fathers of Toledo, who concerning this restoration of Dictinius, or the ordination of Turribius, uttered not a single word.
Immo Chronieum illud et hujus concilii Acta mire inter se concinunt; ill ea videlicet indicanda indulgentia, qua Dictinio et caeteris pœnitentibus episcopis benigne ruit concessum in suis sedibus perseverare, et dumtaxat cautum fuit ut ab initiandis episcopis, presbyteris atque diaconibus se abstinerent, quoadusque Romani pontificis Anastasii et Simpliciani Mediolanensis episcopi, Ambrosii successoris, communionis litteras reciperent: Symphosius autem (aiunt ToleLani præsules senex religiosus, qui quod egerat, supra scripsimus, in Ecclesia sua consistat, circumspectior circa eos quos ei reddemus futurus; inde exspectabit communionem unde prius spem futuras pacis acceperat. Quod observandum etiam Dictinio et ARlherio esse decrevimus. Cum itaque Toletani Patres decrevissent Symphosium, Dictinium et Anthorium in suis Ecclesiis debuisse consistere, an non confinxit Quesnellus Dictinium ante illud concilium e sua sede ejectum, eique Turribium suffectum? Consistam aiunt PP., non suas sedes recipiant, ut noster annotator somniatur, quæ voces non idem importare vcl leviter attendenti fit manifestum. Non ergo est credendum, Dictinio adhuc superblite in hujus locum Turribium fuisse ordinatum, sed Dictinium ipsum a die suae consecrationis ad emortualem diem usque in Asturicensi Ecclesia semper constitisse.
Nay, that chronicle and the Acts of this council agree wonderfully with each other; namely, in that indulgence being indicated, by which it was kindly granted to Dictinius and the other penitent bishops to remain in their own sees, and it was only provided by caution that they abstain from ordaining bishops, presbyters, and deacons, until they should receive letters of communion from the Roman pontiff Anastasius and from Simplicianus, bishop of Milan, the successor of Ambrose. But Symphosius (they say, a religious old man, the Toledan prelates [decreed] that he should remain in his own church, being to be more circumspect concerning those whom we shall restore to him; thence he shall expect communion whence he had previously received the hope of future peace). We have decreed that this is to be observed also by Dictinius and Artherius. Since, therefore, the Toledan Fathers had decreed that Symphosius, Dictinius, and Anthorius ought to remain in their own churches, did not Quesnellus invent the story that Dictinius was ejected from his see before that council, and that Turribius was substituted for him? "Let them remain," they say, Fathers, "let them not recover their own sees," as our annotator dreams; which words do not import the same thing, as is manifest even to one who attends but lightly. It is not to be believed, therefore, that Turribius was ordained in the place of Dictinius while the latter was still surviving, but that Dictinius himself, from the day of his consecration to the day of his death, always remained in the church of Asturica.
Qua in re, tamquam omnino imbecilla, illico cadunt duæ illae Quesnelli conjecturæ et suspiciones, vel de duobus episcopis eodem tempore eamdem Ecclesiam administrantibus, qnod sacris canonibus vetitum est, vel de summa Turribii senectute, ad qnam certe pervenisset, si ejus ordinatio ante annum esset repetenda, cum jam adhuc esset in vivis, et ad laboriosissima habenda itinera aptus, et habilis anno Christi sub Leonis Magni pontificatu reperiretur, ut ex ejus colligimur epistola de qua in seqq. capitibus verba faciemus. Sed de Turribii ordinatione ex monumentis quæ supersunt, nihil certi defiuire possumus. Illud unum dumtaxat nobis ex Augustino exploratum est, Dictinium ejus prædecessorem extremam clausi-se diem ante annum 420. Siquidem rum S. Pater hoc anno librum contra Mendacinm ad Consentium scripsisset, Dictinium ex hac vita decessisse hisce verbis indicavit: Dictinii episcopi vel cogniti uitam, vel incogniti famam laudare mendaciter, est hoe tolerabilius adhuc, quia ille putatur fuisse eatholicus, atque ex illo errore correctus.
In this matter, those two conjectures and suspicions of Quesnel immediately fall to the ground as altogether feeble: either concerning two bishops administering the same church at the same time, which is forbidden by the sacred canons, or concerning the extreme old age of Turribius, which he would certainly have reached if his ordination had to be dated back before the year, since he was still alive and fit and able to undertake the most laborious journeys in the year of Christ under the pontificate of Leo the Great, as we gather from his letter, of which we shall speak in the following chapters. But concerning the ordination of Turribius, we can determine nothing certain from the monuments that survive. This one thing only is established for us from Augustine: that Dictinius, his predecessor, closed his last day before the year 420. For when the holy Father had written in that year the book Against Lying to Consentius, he indicated that Dictinius had departed this life in these words: falsely to praise the life of Bishop Dictinius, whether known or unknown, or his reputation, is still more tolerable, because he is thought to have been a Catholic, and corrected from that error.
Nec aliqua ratione urgeri possumus genuino illo Idatii testimonio, quo olympiad. 50G scripsit: In Asturicensi urbe Galliciæ quidam ante aliquot annos latentes Manichæi gestis episcopalibus deteguntur, quæ ab Idatio et Turribio, qui eoa audierunt, ad Antonium Emeritensem episcopum directa sunt. Manichæorum nomine Priscillianistas ibidem designari, nescio quo pacto affirmet Quesnellus, cum jam Idatius eo in Chronico numquam Priscillianistas com Manichæis confundere consueverit, quamvis ambae haereses Gnosticorum propagines fuerint. Olympiade enim 24, descripta Priscilliani et sociorum nece, suhjicil: Exin in Gallæciam Priscillinistarum hæresis invasit. Rursus, olympiade 294, agens de Ortigio, qui Celenis fuerat ordinatus, addit: Sed agentibus Priscillianistis, pro fide catholica pulsus factionibus exsulabat. Hac eadem loquendi formula idem Idatius usus est de sancti Leonis Magni ad Turribium Asturicensem epistola disserens: Romanae Ecclesiæ præsidet episcopus Leo. Hujus scripta per episcopi Turribii diaconum Pervincum contra Priscllianistas. ad Hixpatenses episcopos deferuntur.
Nor can we be pressed in any way by that genuine testimony of Idatius, in which, under the 50th Olympiad, he wrote: In the city of Asturica in Gallaecia, certain Manichaeans who had lain hidden for some years previously are exposed by episcopal proceedings, which were sent by Idatius and Turribius, who heard them, to Antonius, bishop of Emerita. That Priscillianists are designated there under the name of Manichaeans, Quesnel asserts I know not by what means, since already Idatius in that Chronicle never was accustomed to confuse Priscillianists with Manichaeans, although both heresies were offshoots of the Gnostics. For under the 24th Olympiad, having described the slaughter of Priscillian and his companions, he adds: Thence the heresy of the Priscillianists invaded Gallaecia. Again, under the 294th Olympiad, treating of Ortigius, who had been ordained at Celenae, he adds: But while the Priscillianists were active, he was driven out for the catholic faith and lived in exile through their factions. The same Idatius used this same manner of speaking concerning the letter of Saint Leo the Great to Turribius of Asturica: Leo, bishop, presides over the Roman Church. His writings, through Pervincus, deacon of Bishop Turribius, against the Priscillianists, are brought to the bishops of Hispania.
Quæ quidem omnia cum ip,e mecum reputarem, nun facile Quesnelli opinioni subscribere potui, quod videlicet priori laudato ejusdem olympiadis loco sub Manichæorum nomine Idatius Priscillianistas designare voluerit, cum nobis cæterisque illud Chronicum percurrentibus utriusque sectæ hæreticos suis propriis nominibus appellasse constet. Etquidem paulo post, de quodam Manichæo Pascentio urbis Romae, qui de Asturica diffugerat, sermonem institucns, eum Manichæum expresse nominat, quem Antonius episcopus Emerita comprehendit, auditumque etiam de provincia Lusitania facit expelli. Hunc autem Priscillianistain quis aflirmabit? Cmn Romæ numquam, et Leonis tempore potissimum, Priscilliana lues fuerit grassata. Verum quamvis ultro daretur quod Idatius ibidem ejusmodi hæreticos Manichæos vocarit, quid inde? Nullum dubium est Turribium, defuncto Dictinio, in episcopàlu successissc. Hujus igitur studium cum Idatio Lemicae orhis episcopo in detegendis Manichæis adhibitum nihil obstat quin Dictinius usque ad diem emortualem in Asturicensi throno consederit; non evincil eum e sua sede exturbatum fuisse; non denique eam Ecclesiam a duobus episcopis administratam. Quando euim Dictinius obierat, ant Zosimus, ant Bonifacius Romanam sedcm tenebant.
When I had weighed all these things with myself, I could not easily subscribe to the opinion of Quesnel, namely that in the earlier-cited passage of the same Olympiad Idatius wished to designate the Priscillianists under the name of Manichaeans, since it is evident to us and to all others who run through that Chronicle that he called the heretics of each sect by their own proper names. And indeed, a little later, when he makes mention of a certain Manichaean Pascentius of the city of Rome, who had fled from Asturica, he expressly names him a Manichaean, whom Antonius, bishop of Emerita, arrested, and he also records that he was expelled from the province of Lusitania. But who will affirm that this man was a Priscillianist? Since the Priscillianist plague had never raged at Rome, and especially not in the time of Leo. But even if it were freely granted that Idatius there called heretics of this kind Manichaeans, what follows from that? There is no doubt that Turribius succeeded Dictinius in the episcopate after the latter's death. Therefore the zeal of this man, together with that of Idatius, bishop of the city of Lemica, in detecting Manichaeans, is no obstacle to Dictinius having sat on the throne of Asturica until the day of his death; it does not prove that he was driven from his see; nor, finally, that that Church was administered by two bishops. For when Dictinius died, either Zosimus or Bonifacius held the Roman see.
Quando vero Turribius et idatius in occultos animadverterunt Manichæos, jam sanctus Leo pontificatum gerebat, ut in laudato Chronico idem Idalius affirmat.
CAPUT IX.
De Toletana synodo, in qua Symphosius et Dictinius tam quam pœnitentes suscepti sunt, et de Gallæciæ achis mate horum causa esorto. Quesnellianæ conjectura et ratiocinationes annotantur atque rejiciuntur.
Relicto in hisce exordiis parumper Quesnelload nonnulla alia pradum facere statuimus. Ad Toletani videlicet coucilii Acta, ad aliarum rerum seriem in hac eadem causa gestarum, ad gravissimum denique illud schisma in Galliciæ pt ssimum provincia exitatum, postquam Symphosium, Dictinium aliosque episcopos et presbyteros, quondam Priscilliana lue infectos, a Toletanis Patribus receptos et absolutos fuise, quidam invidi, aut ecclesiasticæ disciplinæ conservandae irnportuno studio addicti, resciverunt. Et imprimis quod ad laudata Acta attinet, qui oculos, prout a conciliorum collectoribus edita sunt, in ea conjiciunt, valde mutila et imperfecta modo a,servari judicabunt, quod nemo hactenus animadvertit. Id sequens specimen, qnod subjicimus, patefaciat.
But when Turribius and Idatius took action against the hidden Manichaeans, Saint Leo was already holding the pontificate, as the same Idatius affirms in the Chronicle already praised.
CHAPTER IX.
Concerning the Synod of Toledo, in which Symphosius and Dictinius were received as penitents, and concerning the origin of the schism of Gallaecia on account of these men. The conjecture and reasonings of Quesnel are noted and rejected.
Having left Quesnel behind for a little while in these beginnings, we have decided to say a few things beforehand about certain other matters. Namely, about the Acts of the Council of Toledo, about the sequence of other events carried out in this same affair, and finally about that most serious schism stirred up in the province of Gallaecia especially, after Symphosius, Dictinius, and other bishops and presbyters, once infected with the Priscillianist plague, had been received and absolved by the Fathers of Toledo, which certain envious men, or men devoted to an untimely zeal for preserving ecclesiastical discipline, discovered. And first, as far as the praised Acts are concerned, those who cast their eyes upon them as they have been published by the collectors of councils will judge that they are preserved only in a very mutilated and imperfect form, which no one has hitherto noticed. Let the following specimen, which we append, make this clear.
III epigraphe quidem nullam vilium irrepsisse aihitramur, nisi forte illud a colbctoribus derivatum, qui istud Toletanum primum appellant, cum jam ahud ibidem ab iisdem novemdecim episcopis habitum Patruinus in sua asserat præfatione, ut eliam in superioribus annotavimus. Caeterum istud sub Anastasii pontificatu, Honorio, Arcadio imperantibus, cum videlicet Stilico primum consul renuntiahatur, congrepatum fuisse, perspicue Idatius in Chronico indicavit olymp. Y94. Eam epigraphem deinde tituli capitulorum excipiunt, qui brevem dumtaxat summam continent eorum quas ad ecclesiasticam disciplinam ibidem instaurandam sancita fuerunt. Sed ibi jam fiLium irrepsit, nam laudati tituli Romanis eliam numeris not:ni, unum supra viginti capitula firmata fuisse indicant; sed postremum, quod crat: De re gulis fidei catholice contra Priscillianos prorsus desideratur. Hisce vero capitulorum titulis concilii præfatio subjicitur, in qua primum illornm novemdecim episcoporum in Toletana237 convenientium Ecclesta nomina describuntur, nulla tamen facta mentione Ecclesiarum quibus præerant. Sed iis fideliier descriptis, Patruinus Emeritensis episcopus illius eretus præses, gravem et brevem orationem habuit, qua in Hispaniarum provinciis ecclesiasticam disciplinam pessum ivisse conquestus est, atque ita clericorum scaudali percrebuisse, ut gravissimum schisma extilassenl.
We suspect that no corrupt text has crept into the heading itself, unless perhaps that derived from the compilers, who call this the first Council of Toledo, although Patruinus asserts in his preface that another council was already held in the same place by the same nineteen bishops, as we have also noted in the earlier passages. Moreover, Idatius clearly indicated in his Chronicle that this one was convened under the pontificate of Anastasius, while Honorius and Arcadius were emperors, namely when Stilicho was first proclaimed consul, in the 394th Olympiad. Then the heading is followed by the titles of the chapters, which contain only a brief summary of those things which were decreed there for restoring ecclesiastical discipline. But here too an error has crept in, for the aforementioned titles are also marked with Roman numerals, indicating that twenty-one chapters were confirmed; but the last, which was "Concerning the rules of the catholic faith against the Priscillianists," is entirely missing. To these titles of the chapters the preface of the council is then subjoined, in which first the names of those nineteen bishops assembled at Toledo are described, with no mention however made of the churches over which they presided. But when these had been faithfully described, Patruinus, bishop of Emerita, who was the president of that assembly, delivered a weighty and brief address, in which he complained that ecclesiastical discipline in the provinces of Spain had utterly collapsed, and that the scandal of the clergy had so spread abroad that they had produced a most grievous schism.
Quibus quidem malis remedium adhibere Patruinus cupiens, a communi concilio definiendum expetiit quid ab omnibus episcopis in ordinandis clericis calet sequendum. Tum primus omnium ipse pra;ses in hanc erupit sententiam: Mihi autem placet constituta primitus concilii Nicœni perpetuo esse servanda, nec ab iia esse recedendum. Cui quippe Patruini sententiæ eæteri episcopi assensi suut ad unum, anathematis poena præterea eos postulandos esse judicantes, qui aliud quam statutum est facero ausi essent.
•2. Nihil autem præter hæc habet praefatio illa, quam deinde viginti dumtaxat capitula, ut diximus, seu canones excipiunt, afficis illorum temporum rebus maxime convenientia, cum ad malorum luem id dies magis percrebrescentem purgandam, tuit ad aditum intercludendum, ne latius serperet, et incolumes adhuc Ecclesias et catholicos labefactar et. Sed cum vigesimum capitulum, quod est de chrismate a solo episcopo conficiendo, subscriptiones episcoporum immediate sequantur, ideo graviter dole 'dum est quod altera Toletanorum gestorum porsexciderit, aut saltem e primigenia sua sede fuer avulsa, ut quæ ad Priscillianam pertinent historiam, modo integra, perfecta, et prout a Patribus fuerim disposita, minime habeamus
Desiring to apply a remedy to these evils, Patruinus sought to have it defined by a common council what all bishops should follow in ordaining clerics. Then he himself, first of all, the president, broke forth into this opinion: "For my part, I am resolved that the decrees of the Nicene Council, established from the beginning, must be preserved forever, and that there must be no departure from them." To this opinion of Patruinus the other bishops assented to a man, judging besides that those who dared to do anything other than what had been decreed should be sought out with the penalty of anathema.
2. But that preface contains nothing beyond these things, which twenty chapters only, as we have said, or canons, follow, matters most suited to the affairs of those times, since to purge the plague of evils, then spreading more and more day by day, and to block its entrance, lest it creep more widely, and to undermine the Churches still sound and the catholics. But since the twentieth chapter, which concerns the chrism to be confected by the bishop alone, is immediately followed by the subscriptions of the bishops, it is therefore to be deeply lamented that the other part of the Toledan acts has perished, or at least has been torn from its original place, so that we by no means have those things which pertain to the Priscillianist history whole, complete, and as they were arranged by the Fathers.
Ejusmodi porro gravis jactura parlim dumtaxat reparari potuit ex alterius concilii Actis, cujus PaIres, viia functis Symphosio. Dictinio ac cæteris qui de Priscilliana hæresi postulabantur, apud Toletanam urbem forte convenientes, ne pra'postere quidquam præcipitique animo de transacta hæresi et schismate judicarent, sancte secum reputarunt, Priscillianistarum res gestas altius repetere, cunctaque cognoscere qu e jam in ea causa contigerant. Hac occasione ergo præcedentesToletanæ synodi definitiones de plenariis gestis cxcerpi jusserunt, easdemque, ut universo illi novo cætui innotescerent, publice recitari demandarunt. Quo autem anno quave occasione ejusmodi gestorum exemplaria e suis sedibus avulsa in alio concilio posteriori recitata fuerint, cum Ecclesiæ monumenta quæ exstant non prodant, certo dcfiniri non potest. lllud certe extra omnem dubitat.onis aleam est, excerpta ex genuinis Actis luisse avulsa, quando jam Symphosius, Dictinius episcopi, et Conasius presbyter, ex hac luce migraverant. Sufficiienter hoc indicant sequentia verba posterioris concilii: Post habitum jam concilium knl.
Furthermore, the grave loss of this kind could be repaired only in part from the Acts of another council, whose Fathers, when Symphosius, Dictinius, and the rest who were accused of the Priscillianist heresy had departed this life, happening to assemble at the city of Toledo, lest they should judge anything rashly or with a precipitate mind concerning the heresy and schism already past, piously reflected among themselves that they should trace the deeds of the Priscillianists from a deeper source and learn all that had occurred in that cause. On this occasion, therefore, they ordered the definitions of the preceding synod of Toledo to be excerpted from the full records, and they directed that these same be publicly read out so that they might become known to all that new assembly. But in what year, or on what occasion, copies of records of this kind, torn from their own seats, were read out in another later council, since the extant monuments of the Church do not disclose, cannot be determined with certainty. That at least is beyond every hazard of doubt, that the excerpts were torn from genuine Acts, since already the bishops Symphosius and Dictinius and the presbyter Conasius had departed from this light. The following words of the later council sufficiently indicate this: After the council had already been held...
Septembris, tertio nonas Septembris, post diversas cognitiones tunc hubitas, sub die octava iduum Septembrium excerptœ sunt de plenariis gestis professiones domini Symphosii, et domini Dictinii sanctœ memoriœ episcoporum, et domini sanctæ memoriœ Comasii tunc presbyteri, qus inter cœteros habuerunt in concilio Toletano de damnatione Priscilliani vel sectœ ejus. Quis ergo bibi persuadet sanctœ memoriœ eos rpiscopos, illumque presbyterum, in concilio dictos fuisse, si jam adhuc superstites exstitissent? Nec enim vita aut episcoporum mors ab aliis episcopis comprovincialibus, metropolis aut nationalibus, potuit ignorari, et idcirco illos diem extremam clausisse quando ejusmodi professionum exemplaria in concilio longe posteriori luere avulsa et publice recitata, credendum est.
Sed harum possessionum exemplaria confictionem subolere Quesnellus suspicatus est, nec ab hac suspicione Stephanum Baluz uin vacuum arbitramur. Unde vero confictionis conjecturae hauriri possint ant debeant, nullus sufficienter indicavit. Nam Quesnellus, qui in notis ad epistolam 158. Leonis aliquos illarum professionum suppositionis characteres in medium produxit, a recto disserendi scopo aberravit, et multa falsa et iufirma commentus est. Cujusmodi quidem est illini primum quo SANCTÆ. MEliOR...
On the third of the Nones of September, after the various hearings then held, on the eighth day of the Ides of September, there were excerpted from the full proceedings the professions of the lord Symphosius, and of the lord Dictinius, bishops of holy memory, and of the lord Comasius, of holy memory, then a presbyter, who among others had a part in the Council of Toledo concerning the condemnation of Priscillian and his sect. Who, then, persuades you that those bishops of holy memory, and that presbyter, were named in the council, if they had still been alive at that time? For the life or death of bishops could not have been unknown to other bishops, whether comprovincial, of the metropolis, or national; and therefore it must be believed that they closed their final day when copies of professions of this kind were torn out and publicly recited in a far later council.
But Quesnellus suspected that the copies of these possessions savored of fabrication, nor do we judge Stephanus Baluzius to be free from this suspicion. Yet no one has sufficiently indicated from what source the conjectures of fabrication can or ought to be drawn. For Quesnellus, who in his notes on the 158th letter of Leo brought forward certain marks of the supposition of those professions, strayed from the right aim of argument and devised many false and weak things. Of this kind indeed is that first one of his, by which SAINT... MEMORY...
fpiscopos appellat Symphosium et Dictinium; quod si plias tolerabile esset, in ea tamen professione qua hæresim abdicant absurdum videtur. Adeone scrupulose agis, Quesnelli, ut quondam haeretica labe aspersi, si postmodum evadant poenitentes, singulos ejurent errores, et cum Ecclesia reconciliati tandem in pace obdormiant, nefas reputes eos sanctæ memoriæ viros appellari? Profecto tota Christianae rei historia, sacra diptycha et vetustae Ecclesiarum tabulae ruerent, pessum irent, et commentis scatere censenda essent. Antiquitus enim, sicut et modo, illa loquendi formula usurpata erat ad innuendam ec lesiasticam pacem et communionem in qua obierant qui jam ex Inc lace demigrarunt; neque iis vocabulis sanctœ memoriæ fraudabantur ob hseresini, vel schisma, in quod lapsi essent, dummodo poententes decederent, et, absoluti ante vitae exitum, prisiinae communioni restituerentur. Immo ejusmodi homines post adeptum reconciliationis sacramentum, ila in honore habebantur, ut eorum nomina Deo ad altare offerrentur, ut constat ex can.
He calls the bishops Symphosius and Dictinius; and if this were tolerable in other respects, it nevertheless seems absurd in that profession by which they renounce heresy. Are you really so scrupulous, Quesnel, that you reckon it a crime for men once stained with the taint of heresy—if afterward they come forth as penitents, abjure their several errors one by one, and, reconciled with the Church, at last fall asleep in peace—to be called men of holy memory? Surely the whole history of the Christian religion, the sacred diptychs, and the ancient tablets of the churches would collapse, would perish, and would have to be judged to teem with fabrications. For in ancient times, just as now, that formula of speaking was employed to signify the ecclesiastical peace and communion in which those who have already departed from the Church died; nor were those terms of holy memory withheld from them on account of the heresy or schism into which they had fallen, provided they died as penitents and, absolved before the end of life, were restored to their former communion. Indeed, men of this sort, after receiving the sacrament of reconciliation, were held in such honor that their names were offered to God at the altar, as is established from the canon.
concilii Illiberiiani, quo Cautum est ne energumenorum nomina sacris in mysteriis recitarentur; vel ex concilii Emeritensis, quo sacerdotibus jubetur: Pro singulis diebus dominicis sacrificium Deo offerre, et eorum nomina a quibus cas Ecclesias constat esse constructas, vel qui aliquid his sanctis Ecclesiis videntur aut visi sunt contulisse, si vit'entes in corpore sunt, ante alture recitentur tempore missæ; quod si ab hac decesserunt, aut decesserint luce, nomina eorum cum defunctis fidelibus recitentur suo ordine. Horum porro nominum recitatio catholicæ communionis argumentum fuisse ei udite probant Albaspinæus et Ferdinandus Mendoza in nohis et observationibus ad Illiberitanum concilium.
Sed addit Quesnellus, sanctæ memoria verba illa, etsi tolerabilia censeantur, in ea professione qua hæresim abdicant absurda videri. Sed hic gravissimum nostri annotatoris Quesnelli oscitantiae lapsum lector, qua so, animadvertat, et nobiscum serio illarom professionum exemplar percurrat, quie in concilio Toletano contra PrisCilliani sectam editæ fuere, simulque perpendat quæ ad postremum concilium pertinent. Illius quippe exemplaris exordium totum spectat ad postremi concilii PP., qui, adducti studio inquirendæ veritatis, dicunt consuluisse Toletanæ synodi Acta, et excerpi jussisse de plenaria gestis professiones domini Symphosii, et domini Dictinii sanctæ memoriæ episcoporum.
of the Council of Elvira, by which it was decreed that the names of the possessed should not be recited in the sacred mysteries; or from the Council of Mérida, by which it is enjoined upon priests: On each Lord's day to offer sacrifice to God, and that the names of those by whom those churches are known to have been built, or who appear or have appeared to have contributed anything to these holy churches, if they are still living in the body, be recited before the altar at the time of the mass; but if they have departed or shall depart from this light, let their names be recited with the faithful departed in their own order. Furthermore, that the recitation of these names was a proof of catholic communion, Albaspinaeus and Ferdinandus Mendoza prove at length in their notes and observations on the Council of Elvira.
But Quesnel adds that those words of holy memory, even if they are considered tolerable, seem absurd in that profession by which they renounce heresy. But here let the reader observe the most serious slip of our annotator Quesnel's negligence, and let him carefully review with us the copy of those professions which were issued in the Council of Toledo against the sect of Priscillian, and at the same time weigh what pertains to the last council. For the beginning of that copy looks entirely to the fathers of the last council, who, led by the zeal of inquiring after truth, say that they consulted the Acts of the Synod of Toledo, and ordered to be excerpted from the full proceedings the professions of the lord Symphosius and the lord Dictinius, bishops of holy memory.
Et duo ergo illa verba prorsus extra professiones posita sunt, et a posterioris concilii notariis ut PP. adhibita dumtaxat fuerc ad innucndam eam ecclesiasticam pacem et communionern in qua Symphosius ct Dictinius obierant. Præterea non sibi suadcat Quesnellus hujus concilii notarios integre eas professiones, prout erant, in autograplJo huc transtulisse. Multa quidern ab iisdem præterini sa sufficienter ea indicant verba: Post aliquanta....eodem tempore acra.... Dictinius episco pus dixit: ute me. Unde eruitur, ex plenariis Toletanæ synodi gestis ea dumtaxat selegisse quæ in criminum contestationem, horumque exsecrationem, lum a Dictinio et Symphosio, tum a Comasio, dica fuere. Cum igitur professio ab iis vocibus ordiatur: Audite me, optimi sacerdotes, non est cur Quesnellus eam confictionis insimulet, cum omnia praecedentia verba (inter nux hæc duo, sanctæ memoriæ) notario tribui dcbeant, ut legentibus patebit.
And so those two words are placed entirely outside the professions, and were employed by the notaries of the later council merely as abbreviations for "fathers of blessed memory," to indicate that ecclesiastical peace and communion in which Symphosius and Dictinius died. Furthermore, Quesnellus should not persuade himself that the notaries of this council transcribed these professions whole and entire, just as they were, into the autograph. Indeed, many things passed over by them sufficiently indicate this, namely the words: After some things... at the same time... Dictinius the bishop said: hear me. From this it is inferred that from the full proceedings of the Council of Toledo they selected only those things which were spoken by Dictinius and Symphosius, and then by Comasius, for the accusation of crimes and the execration of these. Since, therefore, the profession begins with these words: Hear me, most excellent priests, there is no reason why Quesnellus should accuse it of fabrication, since all the preceding words (among which are these two, "of holy memory") must be attributed to the notary, as will be clear to readers.
Jam vero aliud confictionis argumentum, quod secundo loco Quesnellus subjicit adhuc perpendamus. Deinde (ail) errores Priscilhani et asseclarum ejus vix attigit, de sola Filii innascibilitate loquens, et de duobus principiis, et animæ cum Paire consubstantialitate, quas sententias ita condemnant, ut fucum jacere t'ideantur, sibique suas professiones explicandi reservare facultatem. Cui quippe conjecturae ut robur adderet auctoritatemque, ad S. Leonem provocat, ex cujus verbis professionis confictionem comprobare intendit. Et tertio enim (ita immediate subjicit S. Leonis capitulo palet illos aliquo sensu nascibilem Filium dixisse. Ex quinto, non illos contendisse disertis verbis unam Dei et hominis esse naturam, quod in se solum' modo reprehendit Dictinius in illa professione. Ilis rgo similibusque ali's eruditus criticus insislil, ut lectorem in malam fidem adducat, ad credendum videlicet totas illas professiones ad fraudem e,sc con.. fictas. Ita quidcm ratiocinamur Quesnellus. Sed Terane isthæc omnia esse arbitrabimur? An potius nobis erit verendum argululum hunc nimis licenter fabulusa quædam comminisci potuisse, cum de aliorum fraudibus et confictionibus nimis anxie inquirebat! Euin aulcin turpiter aberrasse, priora illa indicant verba: Deinde errores Priscilliani et asseclarum vix attigit. Quid enim?
Now let us further weigh the other argument of the confession which Quesnellus puts forward in the second place. Then, he says, he scarcely touched upon the errors of Priscillian and his followers, speaking only of the unbegottenness of the Son, and of the two principles, and of the consubstantiality of the soul with the Father; and these opinions they condemn in such a way that they seem to be putting up a false front, and to be reserving for themselves the power of explaining their own professions. And to add strength and authority to this conjecture, he appeals to St. Leo, from whose words he intends to prove the fabrication of the profession. For in the third place (so he immediately subjoins from the chapter of St. Leo) it is evident that they said the Son was begotten in some sense. From the fifth, that they did not contend in express words that there is one nature of God and man, which Dictinius reproves in that profession only in himself. On these and other such points, then, the learned critic insists, in order to lead the reader into bad faith—namely, to believe that all those professions were composed for fraud. Thus indeed we reason, Quesnellus. But shall we judge all these things to be true? Or rather must we fear that this clever little man, too freely, could have invented certain fabulous things, when he was inquiring too anxiously about the frauds and fabrications of others! For that he erred shamefully, those former words indicate: Then he scarcely touched upon the errors of Priscillian and his followers. For what?
Auingere forte et confileri clebebant errores in quos numquam lapsi ftierant? Exempla quippe illud de quo agimus, non fidei p'oessio nem in Toletano concilio ab episcopis et presjyeris pænitentibus faciam continet, sed dumtaxat criminum confessionem ejurationemque. In ea autem. ex Priscilliani erroribus cus dumtaxat exprimere debebant quibus adhæserunt, tum deinde Priscilliano auctori cæterisque ejus blasphemiis anathema dicere. Cum igitur ex Priscilliani dogmatibus illa profiteri ausi fuissenl: nnascibilem esse Deum, unam Dei et bominis esse subSlantiam, aut duo esse principia, ideo expresse hæc tantum confiteri opus erat, eidem cxvecrari, quin se illorum criminum reos facerent quæ numquam admiserunt.
Confessionem autem criminumque ejurationem exemplar illud continere, minime fidei professionem, produnt illa verba, in quæ primus omnium Dictinius pœnitentani agens erupit: Audite tre, optimi sacerdoles, corrigite omnia, quia vobis correctio data est. Scriptum est enim: Vobis datæ sunt claves reni cælorum, sed peto a vobis ut claves nobis regni, nun portæ aperiantur inferni. Hæc hominis humiliter poe nitenliam agentis, veniam absolutionemque enixe deprecantis, verba esse quis inficiabitur? Post hæc autem singillatim sua aperit crimina. Hæc, si dignamini, omnia ante oculos pono. Hoc in me reprehendo, quod dixerim, etc.
And were they perhaps obliged to avow and confess errors into which they had never fallen? For the example of which we are speaking, in the Council of Toledo, does not contain a profession of faith made by penitent bishops and presbyters, but only a confession and abjuration of crimes. In it, however, they were bound to express only those of Priscillian's errors to which they had adhered, and then to pronounce anathema upon Priscillian their author and upon his other blasphemies. Since, therefore, they had dared to profess from Priscillian's doctrines that God is passible, that there is one substance of God and man, or that there are two principles, for that reason it was expressly necessary to confess these things alone and to execrate them, without making themselves guilty of those crimes which they never committed.
But that this example contains a confession and abjuration of crimes, and by no means a profession of faith, is shown by those words which Dictinius, the first of all, uttered while doing penance: Hear me, best of priests, correct all things, because to you has correction been given. For it is written: To you are given the keys of the kingdom of heaven; but I ask of you that the keys of the kingdom be not opened to us, lest the gates of hell be opened. Who will deny that these are the words of a man humbly doing penance and earnestly imploring pardon and absolution? After this, moreover, he lays bare his crimes one by one. All these things, if you deem it worthy, I set before your eyes. In this I reproach myself, that I said, etc.
pari ratione quoque omnia retractavit quæ scripserat, subdens: Sed et omnem præsumptionem meam de scriptis meis nrguo et condemno. Et interposito juramento, omnia toto corde respuere Dictinius profitetur, et quae contra fidem scripserat condemnavit. Hac igitur in se spectata nullam olent suppositionem, fraudem, aut confictionem; pnesertim cum illi poenitentes coram synodo se sistentes fidei professionem ab iis Patribus acceptam ex charlula scripta recitarunt, et anathemate dicto omnib is hæreticorum libris et dogmatibus, et Priscilliani poTissimum, absoluti et ad communionem recepti fuere, ut ab exemplari delinitivae sententiae colligimus.
Falsissimum praeterea est fucum facere voluisse, aut sibi suasne professiones explicandi reservasse facultatem. Undenam id conjicit annotator? Contrarium quidem innuunt hæc et consimilia verba conciIii Patribus dicta: Omnem præsumptionem meam de scriptis meis arguo, atque condemno. Vel illa alia: Testis eat mihi Deus; aut isthaec: Quæcumque conscripsi, omnia me toto eorde respuere; excepto nomine Dei, omnia anathematizo; omnia quæ inveniuntur eontra fidem cum ipso auctore condemno.
By the same reasoning he also retracted everything he had written, adding: "But also all my presumption concerning my writings I refute and condemn." And with an oath interposed, Dictinius professes to reject all things with his whole heart, and he condemned the things he had written against the faith. This, therefore, when considered in itself, smacks of no supposition, fraud, or fabrication; especially since those penitents, presenting themselves before the synod, recited from a written document the profession of faith accepted by those Fathers, and after the anathema was pronounced on all the books and doctrines of the heretics, and most of all on those of Priscillian, they were absolved and received into communion, as we gather from the copy of the definitive sentence.
It is, moreover, utterly false that he wished to practice deception, or reserved to himself the ability to explain away his own professions. From what source does the annotator infer this? Indeed, these and similar words spoken to the Fathers of the council suggest the contrary: "All my presumption concerning my writings I refute and condemn." Or those other words: "God be my witness"; or these: "Whatever I have written, I reject all of it with my whole heart; except the name of God, I anathematize all things; all things that are found contrary to the faith, together with their author himself, I condemn.
Non ergo tam subdoli et versipelles fuerunt poenitentes illi, de qnibus ibi sermo est, ut fucum facere nisi sint, aut contra fidem prolata explicandi facultatem sibi reservaverint, ut hac nostra ætate Quesnellus ipse ejusque asseclae ad apostolicae sedis judicium acciti, et condemnati, contra omne jus quam saepissime nimis audacter tentarunt. Splendide tandem noster annotator Qucsnellus nugatus est, cum ad S. Leonis Magni dicta provocans, ea quasi in testimonium confictæ illius professionis adduxit. Absolute quidem innascibilem esse Deuin, Leone auctore, Priscillianistæ asseruerunt. Quia verbum caro factum (ait S. doctor) non vere isti honorent, aed honorare se simulent, jejunantes eodem die, sicut et die Dominico, qui est dies Resurrectionis Christi; qnod utique ideo faciunt, quia Christum Dominum in vera hominis natura natum esse non credant, sed per quamdam illusionem ostentata videri volunt quæ vera non fuerint. Disertis quoque verbis Priscillianistas contendisse anam Dei et bominis esse substantiam et naturam ipe S. Leo, cap. S docuit, dicens: Quinto capitulo refertur animam hominis divinæ esae substantiæ, nec a natura creatoris iui conditionis nostræ distare naturam. Quae duo cum ego sedulo animadvertissem, facile in eam persuasionem adductus sum, aut Quesnellum nimis fidenter sais studiis indulsisse, aut in S. Leonis Operibus adornandis oscitanter semper ea pere..,.
Those penitents of whom mention is made there were not therefore so crafty and shifty as to practice deception unless they were such, or to reserve for themselves the ability to explain things brought forward against the faith, as in our own age Quesnellus himself and his followers, summoned to the judgment of the apostolic see and condemned, have very often and too boldly attempted against all right. At last, splendidly, our annotator Quesnellus has played the fool, when, appealing to the words of St. Leo the Great, he adduced them as if in testimony of that fabricated profession of his. Indeed, with Leo as author, the Priscillianists asserted that God is absolutely unbegotten. Because (says the holy doctor) these men do not truly honor the Word made flesh, but pretend to honor it, fasting on the same day as also on the Lord's Day, which is the day of Christ's Resurrection; which they certainly do for this reason, because they do not believe that Christ the Lord was born in the true nature of a man, but by some illusion they wish to appear to have shown forth things that were not true. Also in express words St. Leo himself taught, in chapter 5, that the Priscillianists contended that there is one substance and nature of God and of man, saying: In the fifth chapter it is reported that the soul of man is of the divine substance, and that the nature of our condition does not differ from the nature of its Creator. When I had diligently observed these two things, I was easily brought to the persuasion that either Quesnellus had too confidently indulged his own zeal, or that in adorning the Works of St. Leo he had always...
risse ut qnam sæpissime nostris hisce dissertationibus palam fecimus.
CAPUT X.
De caeteris episcopis et clericis Priscilliana labe pol lutis in T olelana prima synodo condemnatis vel absolutis.
i. Quæ de Symphosioet Dictinio dicenda occurrebant quanta potuimus brevitate præcedenti capite explicavimus. Nonnulla alia in præsentiarum dicturi sumus de quibusdam aliis episcopis et clericis eadem Priscilliana labe pollutis, qui cum eisdem Symphosio et Dictinio, nondum poenitentibus et ab Ecclesia absolutis, comniunicarunt, rel:Id sacrorum ordinum ministeria ab iis se promoveri passi sunt. Et primo quidem ad eos se nostra vertit oratio qni, ad synodum canonice acciti, coram Episcopis se sistere non detrectarunt, quos inter locum habuisse Paternum, definitivæ ilius concilii sententie exemplaria ex gestis translata produnt. Is enim ante ordinationem, Priscilliani errores sciebat et profitebatur. Sed post adeptam Bracarensem sedem, omne illius haereseos virus ejuravit lectione I brorum sancti Ambrosii.
as we have very often made clear in these our discussions.
CHAPTER X.
Concerning the other bishops and clerics defiled by the Priscillianist stain, condemned or absolved in the first synod of Toledo.
1. What had to be said concerning Symphosius and Dictinius we have explained with as much brevity as we could in the preceding chapter. At present we are going to say certain other things concerning certain other bishops and clerics defiled by the same Priscillianist stain, who communicated with the same Symphosius and Dictinius while these were not yet penitent and not yet absolved by the Church, or who allowed the ministries of the sacred orders to be advanced by them. And first indeed our discourse turns to those who, canonically summoned to the synod, did not refuse to present themselves before the bishops, among whom Paternus had a place, as the copies of the definitive sentence of that council, transcribed from the proceedings, set forth. For he, before his ordination, knew and professed the errors of Priscillian. But after obtaining the see of Braga, he abjured all the poison of that heresy by the reading of the books of Saint Ambrose.
Hunc ergo cum Symphosius ordinasset contra ecclesiasticas leges, quadam adhibita indulgentia, suam retinere sedem permisere, despondentes praeterea illius Toletanae primae synodi PP. eum in communionem suscepturos, cum sedes apostolica rescriberet. Eamdem indulgentiam erga Isonium adbibucre, qui, nuper baptizatus a Symphosio, contra ecclesiasticas regulas ad episcopatum statim fuit promotus, quem ab hoc gradu miuime esSe dejiciendum concilium judicavit, quia hoc se tenere qnod in præsenti concilio professus est respondit. Hæc synodi Patres cum decrevissent, ad Vegentini causam examinandam processerunt, qui olim ante Cæsaraugustanum concilium episcopus factus, similiter libros Priscilliani cum auctore damnuverat, ut de cæteris Acta testantur. Sed cum postmodum fidem mutasset, ac Priscillianistis adhaerere voluisset, sacra communione erat pri. vatus. Et huic indulgendum, quamvis forte graviorem culpam admisisset, communi suffragio delinitum est, eumque in pristinam communionem receperunt, ea conditione proposita et servata, ut sinceram fidei professionem scripto consignaret.
Therefore, since Symphosius had ordained him contrary to the ecclesiastical laws, after a certain indulgence was applied, they permitted him to retain his own see, and the fathers of that first synod of Toledo further promised that they would receive him into communion when the apostolic see should write back. They applied the same indulgence toward Isonius, who, having been recently baptized by Symphosius, was straightway promoted to the episcopate contrary to the ecclesiastical rules; the council judged that he was by no means to be deposed from this rank, because he answered that he held to that which he had professed in the present council. When the fathers of the synod had decreed these things, they proceeded to examine the case of Vegetinus, who had once been made bishop before the council of Caesaraugusta and had likewise condemned the books of Priscillian together with their author, as the Acts testify concerning the others. But when he had afterward changed his faith and wished to adhere to the Priscillianists, he had been deprived of the sacred communion. And it was decided by common vote that indulgence should be granted to him also, although he had perhaps committed a graver fault, and they received him into his former communion, with this condition proposed and observed, that he should set down in writing a sincere profession of faith.
Aliter vero cum Herena episcopo hujusque clericis factum fuisse intelligimus. Nam Herenas ille, qui suos clericos aequi maluerat, quique sponte, nec iNterrogatus, Priscillianum catholicum sanctumque mar. tyrem clamasset, et ipse usque ad finem catholicum esse dixisset persecutionem ab episcopis passum; hunc ( inquam ) cum his omnibus tam suis clericis quam diversis episcopis. hoc est Donato, Acurio, Æmilio, qui cousortium perditurum sequi malnerunt, sacerdotia submovendos esse decreverunt. Nec vero tanti utomenti quæstionem hisce decretis definitionibusque dumtaxat absolutam fuisse arbitrabimur. Alia quippe adhuc superarint, quibus consulere et medicinam adhibere oportebat, lis videlicet qui ad concilium e, G allæcia venerunt, et in Symphosii coinmunione semper durarunt, cmn episcopus ille Priscilliana lue inliciebatur. Pro his ergo istud decretum factum legimus, ut. accepta forma a concilio missa, si subscripserint, etiam ipsi in cælestis pacis contemplatione consistant, exspectantes pari exempto quid papa, qui nuuc est, quid sanctus Simplicianus Mediolanensis episcopus reliquique Ecclesiarum rescribant sacerdotes.
But we understand that matters turned out differently with Bishop Herenas and his clerics. For that Herenas, who had preferred his own clerics to be treated justly, and who of his own accord, without being questioned, had proclaimed Priscillian a catholic and holy martyr, and had himself said that he was a catholic to the very end and had suffered persecution from the bishops—him, I say, together with all these, both his own clerics and various bishops, namely Donatus, Acurius, and Aemilius, who preferred to follow the party that was to perish, they decreed should be removed from the priesthood. Nor indeed should we think that the question of so great a matter was settled by these decrees and definitions alone. For other matters still remained, which it was necessary to address and apply a remedy to—namely, those who came to the council from Gallaecia and had always persisted in the communion of Symphosius, when that bishop was tainted with the Priscillianist plague. For these, then, we read that this decree was made: that, having received the form sent from the council, if they subscribed to it, they too should stand in the contemplation of heavenly peace, awaiting by a like example what the pope who now is, what the holy Simplicianus, bishop of Milan, and the other priests of the churches should write back.
Si qui autem, audacius agentes, concilii hujus spreta indulgentia, subscriptionem formæ quam misimus non dederint, Ecclesias quas detinent non reti. neant, neque his communicent qui, reversi de synodo, datis professioninus, ad suas Ecclesias reverterunt. Non licere præterea cuiquam communione privato colleetiones facere per mulierum domos, et apocrypha quæ damnata sunt legere, ne communicantes his pari impietate tenerentur, jure et merito sancitum est. Qua in re catholicis episcopis maxime praeceptum voluerunt, ne suum onus et officium obliviscerentur: Quoniam quicumque eos susceperint (aiunt), certum est eos etiam graviori sententia retinendo. esse. Postremo tandem Ortygium Celenis catholicum epiecopum, netarie Priscillianistarum factionibus et impetu ante hoc concilium a sua sede expulsum, ad suam reverti debere Ecclesiam pronuntiarunt, ut tradit etiam Idatius in Chronico, de hac Toletana synodo habens sermonem.
But if any, acting more boldly, having spurned the indulgence of this council, do not give the subscription to the form which we have sent, they shall not retain the Churches which they hold, nor shall they communicate with those who, having returned from the synod, after giving their professions, have returned to their own Churches. It is further not permitted to anyone deprived of communion to hold gatherings through the houses of women, and to read the apocrypha which have been condemned, lest those communicating with them be held in equal impiety; this has been sanctioned by right and deservedly. In this matter they especially wished it to be commanded to the catholic bishops, that they not forget their own burden and duty: since whoever have received them (they say), it is certain that they too are to be held by a graver sentence. Finally at last they pronounced that Ortygius, catholic bishop of Celenae, wickedly expelled from his see before this council by the factions and violence of the Priscillianists, ought to return to his own Church, as Idatius also relates in his Chronicle, speaking of this synod of Toledo.
Hæc itaque sunt omnia quæ causa religionis tuendæ, Ecclesiaslicæ disciplinæ reparandae, atque pacis firmandæ, perpetuoque duraturæ concordiæ, a Toletanis illis PP. anno aut firmata sum. Verum cum in iis condendis decretis laudati PP. semper cam conditionem apposuerint, se pleniorcm remissioncm poenitentibus concessuros, cum sedes apostolica rescripserit, ut cum Vegentino et Paterno factum legimus, videlicet, Recepturi etiam in nostram communionem, cum sedes apostolica rescripserit; vel cum agebatur de rccipiendis its Gallæciæ episcopis qui eum Symphosio semper communicaverant, qui. bus dictum est, ut exspeciareut pari exemplo quid papa, qui nunc est, quid S.
These, then, are all the things which were confirmed by those fathers at Toledo in the year [—] for the sake of defending religion, restoring ecclesiastical discipline, and establishing peace and a concord that would endure forever. But in establishing these decrees, the praised fathers always added this condition: that they would grant a fuller remission to the penitent when the apostolic see should write back, as we read was done with Vegetinus and Paternus—namely, that they would also be received into our communion when the apostolic see should write back; or when the matter was being handled of receiving those bishops of Galicia who had always been in communion with Symphosius, to whom it was said that they should await, by the same example, what the pope who now is, and what S.
Simplicianus Mediotanensis episcopus reliquique Ecclesiarum rescribant sacerdotet; vel illud denique, quod de Dictinio et Anteri) pariter episcopis servandum constituerunt, quos ali ordinationis sacræ ministerio abstentos esse voluere, quoadusque per papam rel sanctum Simplicianum communio ipsis redderetur; cum, inquam, nos ejusmodi loquendi formulas ab Hispanis conciliis adhibitas olfendamns, inde est ut nos in iis, tamquam in speculo, conspiciamus Hispaniarum præsules talem tantamque venerationem atque obedientiam apostolicæ sedi, et ipsis Romanis summis pontificibus exhibuisse, ut adhuc ab ipsis synodice prohta judicia, in pœnitentium episcoporum et clericorum causis, firma et rata esse minime arbitrarentur, nisi ejusdem apostolicæ sedis anctoritate probarentur.
Quam quidem veritatem cum omnibus fere hærelicis aliisque invidis hominibus exosam esse noverim, jam illud statim mihi eripere opus est quod opponere possent. Æqualem reverentiam, videlicet, Hispanie PP. tunc exhibuisse Simpliciano, Mediolanensium episcopo, cæterisque sacerdotibus, ut decreverunt, cum in causa episcoporum Gallæciæ, qui semper eum Symphosio communicaverant, tum in causa Dictinii ct Anlerii episcoporum, in quarum postrema judicium æque reservatum fuit sancto Simpliciano episcopo Mediolanensi ac Romano pontifici tum existenti.
Let Simplicianus, bishop of Mediolanum, and the rest of the priests of the churches write back; or, finally, that very thing which they established was to be observed concerning Dictinius and Anterius, likewise bishops, whom they wished to be kept abstained from the ministry of sacred ordination until communion should be restored to them through the pope and Saint Simplicianus. When, I say, we are offended by formulas of speaking of this kind employed by the councils of Spain, it is from this that we behold in them, as in a mirror, that the prelates of the Spains displayed such and so great a veneration and obedience to the apostolic see, and to the Roman high pontiffs themselves, that even judgments already brought forth synodically by them in the causes of penitent bishops and clerics they by no means considered firm and ratified unless they were approved by the authority of that same apostolic see.
Since I know that this truth is hateful to almost all heretics and other envious men, I must at once snatch away that objection which they could raise: namely, that the fathers of Spain at that time showed equal reverence to Simplicianus, bishop of the Mediolanenses, and to the other priests, as they decreed, both in the cause of the bishops of Gallaecia, who had always communicated with Symphosius, and in the cause of Dictinius and Anterius, bishops, in the last of which the judgment was equally reserved to Saint Simplicianus, bishop of Mediolanum, as to the Roman pontiff then existing.
Sed haec agendi œconomia Romanorum pontificum auctoritatem (aiunt) elevat, aliorum episcoporum anctoritati a'quiparando, vel ut saltem in nomanum concilium eadem causæ finiendæ referantur. Ita profecto blaterant. et nunc blaterare possent, qui, ecclesiasticam unitatem scindere cupientes, nimis anxie Romanos pontilircs æteris aliis episcopis exæquare student. Sed incassum cos laborare in hac alisque similibus causis perspectum est. Nam ut alia praeteream, de quilms vel jam disserui, vel alibi verba j'adam, plenissime constat Toletanos PP. non una et eadem ratione adductos Simpliciani Mediolanensis episcopi et papae, qui tunc erat, litteras exspectandas esse decrevisse. Ambrosius in primis, Simpliciani prædecessor, sequestris officio apud Hispaniarum PP. functus fuerat, III Symphosius, et Dictinius sub conditionibus a Siricio papa prnscriptis reciperentur. Ambrosii votis annuerunt Tolelani illi Patres. Sed quia jam is ex bac luce migraverat, et Simplidanus hujus thronum conscenderat, nec Symphosius atque Dictinius præscriptas implevcrant conditiones, sed, necessitate aut contemptu, comra canonum sauctiones irritas reddiderunt.
But this manner of proceeding, they say, diminishes the authority of the Roman pontiffs by equating it with the authority of other bishops, or at least by referring such cases to a Roman council for settlement. So indeed they babble, and those who now wish to rend the unity of the Church could babble in the same way, who strive all too anxiously to put the Roman pontiffs on a level with all the other bishops. But it is evident that they labor in vain in this and other like cases. For, to pass over other matters on which I have either already discoursed or shall speak elsewhere, it is most fully established that the Fathers of Toledo were not led by one and the same reasoning to decree that the letters of Simplicianus, bishop of Mediolanum, and of the pope who then was, should be awaited. Ambrose, in the first place, the predecessor of Simplicianus, had performed the office of mediator among the Fathers of the Spains, so that Symphosius and Dictinius might be received under the conditions prescribed by Pope Siricius. Those Fathers of Toledo gave their assent to the wishes of Ambrose. But because he had already departed from this light, and Simplicianus had ascended his throne, and Symphosius and Dictinius had not fulfilled the prescribed conditions, but, whether through necessity or contempt, had rendered the sanctions of the canons void.
Hoc quippe gravissimum violatae fidei, tum sacris canonibus irrogatae injuriæ, facinus, ob quod irregularitatis vitium contraxerant, et arctioribus excommunicationis vinculis se ohstrinxerant, illi Ecclesiæ innotescere o portebat, cujus pa-tor mediatoris officium interposuerat, ut poenilentes illi absolverentur. Quare cum Ambrosius eorumdem intercessor jam apud Hispaniarum catholicos episcopos egisset, non ut a quocumque vitio absolverentur, sed sub illis dumtaxat conditionibus quas supremus et universalis pastor Siricius ex linen'si revertentibus præscripserat, idcirco illi de SymI'hosio rescripserunt: Inde exspectabit communionem, unde prius spem futuræ pacis acceperat. Quod otervandum etiam in Dictinio et Antemio este decrevimus. Quæ verba, etsi ad mediatorem et supremum etiam judicem debeant referri, non tamen parem utrique auctoritatem fuisse indicant. Ambrosius enim, in hac causa, vicaria, dumtaxat, seu dclegaia summi pontificis potestate fungebatur, cum ipse conditiones sub quibus pœnitentes illi reciperentur non præscripserit, sed eos sub præscriptis a Siricio papa recipiendos insinuaverit suaseruque. Nihil nostro conlingimus marte. Sed ejusdem definitivæ sententiæ illa verba id sonant: Litteris sanctœ memoriæ Ambrosii, quat post illud concilium ad noa miserat, ut, si condemnassent, quæ perperam egerant, et implessent conditione.
For this most grievous outrage of violated faith, and the injury inflicted upon the sacred canons, by which they had contracted the defect of irregularity and bound themselves with the tighter chains of excommunication, ought to have become known to that Church whose office of mediator the father had interposed, so that those penitents might be absolved. Wherefore, since Ambrose, their intercessor, had already acted with the Catholic bishops of the Spains, not that they might be absolved from any fault whatsoever, but only under those conditions which the supreme and universal pastor Siricius had prescribed for those returning from the Linensian [synod], for that reason they wrote back concerning Symmachus: Let him expect communion from that source from which he had first received the hope of future peace. We have decreed that this is to be observed also in the case of Dictinius and Anthemius. These words, although they ought to be referred to the mediator and also to the supreme judge, do not however indicate that the authority of both was equal. For Ambrose, in this cause, was exercising only the vicarious or delegated power of the supreme pontiff, since he himself did not prescribe the conditions under which those penitents were to be received, but indicated and urged that they were to be received under the conditions prescribed by Pope Siricius. We are not making this up on our own initiative. But those words of the same definitive sentence convey this: By the letters of Ambrose of holy memory, which he had sent to us after that council, that, if they had condemned the things they had done amiss, and had fulfilled the condition.
quas præscriptas litterae contincbant, reverenter ad pacem (adde, qua: sanctœ memoria Siricius papa suasissel)... Quid emm ea ibi verba qua sanctœ memoriœ Siricius papa suasisset, si aiubrosius propria et non apostolicæ sedis auctoritate ad Hispaniarum episcopos scripsisset? Siricii quippe, non Ambrosii est magnum illud decretum ad Tarraconenses, Carthaginienses, Bæticos, Lusitanos atque Gallæcios, eosque qui in vicinis habitabant provinciis, quo statuit ea conditione pœnitentibus, bigamia, vel viduœ maritis, qni indebite in sacram militiam irrepserunt, ueniam esse relaxandam, ut in magno debeant computare beneficio,.i, adempta sibi omni ape promotionis, in hoc quo inveniuntur ordine perpetua stabilitate permaneant. Cum itaque in recipiendis lapsis pœnitentibus, a concilio Toletano potissimum, de illius Siriciani decreti dispensatione ageretur, non ad aliam quam ad apostolicam sedem recurrere opurtebat, atque ab hac defiuitiva sententia omnino erat exspectanda. Siquidem istuc dispensandi jus cum iis qui ejusmodi irregularitatis vitio erant impediri, non cuiuscumque ordinis episcopis, non conciliis indulsi, sed sihi suisque successoribus papa Siricius reservavit, ut illius decreti verba immediate subscquentia patefaciunt: Scituri post hæc omnium provinciarum summi antistites, quod si ultra ad sacros ordi.
which the letter contained as prescribed, they should reverently [return] to peace (add: which holy Pope Siricius had urged)... For what purpose would those words be there which holy Pope Siricius had urged, if Ambrose had written to the bishops of the Spains by his own authority and not by the authority of the apostolic see? For that great decree to the Tarraconenses, Carthaginians, Baetici, Lusitanians, and Gallaeci, and those who dwelt in the neighboring provinces, is Siricius's, not Ambrose's, by which he established that pardon should be granted on this condition to penitents, to the twice-married, or to those married to widows, who have crept unworthily into the sacred service, that they ought to count it a great benefit that, with every hope of promotion taken from them, they remain in this order in which they are found with perpetual stability. Therefore, when in receiving lapsed penitents, especially in the Council of Toledo, there was discussion concerning the dispensation of that decree of Siricius, it was necessary to have recourse to no other than the apostolic see, and from it the definitive sentence was altogether to be expected. Indeed, this right of dispensing, since those who were impeded by the defect of this kind of irregularity—not to bishops of any rank, not to councils was it granted, but Pope Siricius reserved it to himself and his successors, as the words of that decree immediately following make clear: Let the chief prelates of all provinces know hereafter, that if beyond [the limit] to sacred orders...
nea quemquam de talibus crediderimus assumendum, et de suo, et de eorum statu quos contra canones et iuterdicta nostra provexerint, congruam ab apostolica sede promendam esse sententiam.
Nunc dicant, amabo, novae ecclesiasticæ disciplinae assertores, qui audacter apostolicæ sedis jura oppugnare conantur, eamdem arctissimis finibus circumscribere cupientes, an tam grave, tam sanctum, tam peremptorium (ut vocant) decretum fuisset ab illo nationali concilio dissimulandum? Vel an novemdecim illi Patres, qui in concilio convenerunt, pietate utique, doctrina atque morum integritate clarissimi, decretum illud potuerint ignorare aut contemnere? Utrumque vero ahsimillimum. Nam isthoc decretum, seu interdictum, ut ait Siricius, de non promovendis ad episcopatum aut sacros ordines quondam hæretica tabe pollutis, jam ante qnatuordecim annos omnibus Hispaniarum Ecclesiis innotuerat, eoque non tantum clerici qui promoveri cupicbant, sed et episcopi ordinatores constringebantor. Cum igitur Symphosius, Dictinius, Anterius, Vigentinus, ct cæteri omnes, qui, veluti homines ad clericalem militiam ascripti, pœnitentiam agentes roram synodo se stiterunt, talia facinora admisissent quae apostolicæ sedis dumtaxat indulgentia plenisbime poterant relaxari; idcirco PP. ad eam provocare oportebat, speciali simul facta mentine Siriciani interdicti.
We would have believed that no one from among such people was to be received, and that a fitting sentence was to be brought forth from the apostolic see both concerning his own status and concerning the status of those whom they advanced against the canons and our interdicts.
Now let them say, I ask, the asserters of a new ecclesiastical discipline, who boldly attempt to assail the rights of the apostolic see, desiring to confine it within the narrowest limits: should so grave, so holy, so peremptory (as they call it) a decree have been disregarded by that national council? Or could those nineteen Fathers who assembled in the council, most distinguished surely in piety, learning, and integrity of morals, have been ignorant of that decree or have despised it? Both are utterly improbable. For this decree, or interdict, as Siricius says, concerning not promoting to the episcopate or sacred orders those once polluted by the stain of heresy, had already fourteen years before become known to all the Churches of the Spains, and by it not only clerics who desired to be promoted but also the bishops who ordained them were bound. Since, therefore, Symphosius, Dictinius, Anterius, Vigentinus, and all the others who, as men enrolled in the clerical militia, doing penance, presented themselves before the synod, had committed such crimes as could be fully relaxed only by the indulgence of the apostolic see, for that reason it was proper for the Fathers to appeal to it, with special mention made at the same time of the Sirmian interdict.
Laudatum vero Siricii papæ interdictum die III iduum Februariarum prodiisse, eo anno quo Arcadius et Bautnnius, seu Baudonius, consutatom agebant, qui est 385, jam ipsi ex Romanorum consulum tabulis in superioribus annotavimus.
Miramur tamen tanti momenti res, ad ecclesiasticam illustrandam h:storiam aptiskimas, hactenus a nemine fuisse ad trutinam revocatas, hujus concilii gesta cum præcedentibus Siricii decretis atque canonibus conferendo. Nec enim suppositionis nota isthæc epistola argui potest, vel inter Isidorianas merces rejici. £am quippe in sua collectione Dionysius Exiguus admisit, atque eamdem laudarunt, cum Carolus Magnus ill Capitulari Aquisgranensi anni 789, tum Hinemarus Rhemensis opusc. 10, ne quidquam dicam de libro Pontificali, in qno legitur: litc fecit constitutum de omni Ecclesia, cujus auctoritas plerisque criticis suspecta est. Immo nostram admirationem maxime auget Tillemontii liceutia, qui cum sibi alium scopum proporuisset, præter illum Romanæ sedis jura asserendi cl propugnandi, in laudata Toletani concilii verba parenthesi interclusa olTendens, videlicet (adde, quœ sanctœ memoriœ papa Siricius suasisset), ea extra textum amandanda censuit, nec aliud nisi purum putumque redolere additamentum existimavit. Sed ibi vir doctus nugas agit, cum futilibus insistens conjecturis, haudquaquam rationi consentaneum sibi videri arbitratur S.
The praised interdict of Pope Siricius truly went forth on the third day of the Ides of February, in that year in which Arcadius and Bautnnius, or Baudonius, held the consulate, which is 385, as we ourselves have already noted above from the tables of the Roman consuls.
We wonder, however, that a matter of such importance, most suited to illuminating ecclesiastical history, has to this point been called to the scales of judgment by no one, by comparing the acts of this council with the preceding decrees and canons of Siricius. For neither can this letter be accused of the mark of forgery, nor be rejected among the Isidorian wares. For Dionysius Exiguus admitted it into his collection, and they praised the same letter, both Charlemagne in that Capitulary of Aachen of the year 789, and Hincmar of Rheims in his opuscule 10, not to say anything of the Pontifical book, in which it is read: he made this constitution concerning the whole Church, whose authority is suspect to very many critics. Nay, the license of Tillemont greatly increases our wonder, who, although he had proposed to himself another aim besides that of asserting and defending the rights of the Roman see, objecting to the praised words of the Council of Toledo enclosed in parenthesis, namely (add, what the pope Siricius of holy memory had urged), judged that they were to be removed from the text, and added that he thought it smelled of nothing other than a pure and unadulterated addition. But there the learned man is playing trifles, when, insisting on futile conjectures, he judges that it by no means seems to him consistent with reason that S.
Ambrosium ea occasione, aut cx Siricii consilio, aut ex hujus legatione, ut Symphosius et Dictinius a Toletanis Patribus absolveremur, egisse. Papæ! Ita non oportebat Tillemontium ratiocinari, ne Quesnello aut aliis videretur velle episcoporum jura minuere, et apostolicæ sedi legitima jura asserere. Age igitur, aliorum præjudiciis vir doctus non adhæreat, eademque non propu-. gnet ( ). Sed dicat, amabo, an Siriciana illa decreta cum Ambrosium, tum Hispaniarum episcopos latere potuerint, an ab lisdem omnino contemni? Alterutrum assercre,aut suspicari, nimis inverisimile cst. Nam Ambrosii ad Siricium papam epistolæ quaIcm quantamque ipse erga apostolicam sedem animi reverentiam et submissionem cxercuerit, quantumque Romanum pontificem oli jam damnatos hæreticos laudaverit, nimis evidenter manifestant. Ambro,ius igitur agens cum Hispania episcopis de recipiendis Symphosio et Dictimo pœnitentibus, non poti-rat præterire conditiones jam ab eodem papa Siricio praescriptas; nec ipsi Hispani episcopi pœnitentium causam cognoscere poterant, de ea inquirere et judicare, nisi sub iisdem conditionibus quas Siriciana statuta continebant. igitur in definitivæ sententia: decreto, quod Toletani PP. ediderunt, necessario ca verba exprimere oportebat: Litteris tamen sanctœ memoriœ Ambrosii....
that Ambrose acted on that occasion, either by the counsel of Siricius or by the latter's legation, so that Symphosius and Dictinius were absolved by the Fathers of Toledo. Good heavens! Tillemont ought not to have reasoned thus, lest he seem to Quesnel or others to wish to diminish the rights of bishops and to assert the legitimate rights of the apostolic see. Come then, let the learned man not cling to the prejudices of others, nor defend them. But let him say, I pray, whether those decrees of Siricius could have been unknown to Ambrose and to the bishops of the Spains, or whether they were altogether despised by them. To assert or suspect either alternative is too improbable. For the letters of Ambrose to Pope Siricius manifest too evidently how great and how much reverence and submission he himself exercised toward the apostolic see, and how greatly he praised the Roman pontiff for heretics already condemned. Ambrose, therefore, when dealing with the bishops of Spain about receiving the penitent Symphosius and Dictinius, could not have passed over the conditions already prescribed by the same Pope Siricius; nor could the Spanish bishops themselves have been able to take cognizance of the case of the penitents, to inquire into it and judge it, except under the same conditions that the statutes of Siricius contained. Therefore in the definitive sentence or decree which the Fathers of Toledo published, it was necessary that these words be expressed: Nevertheless by the letters of Ambrose of holy memory....
ut, ti condemnassent quæ perperam egerant, et implessent conditiones, quas prœscriptas litterœ continebant, reverenter ad pacem (adde, quæ S. memoriæ pupa Siricius suasisset).... magnam, etc. Quod si facere prætermisissent, non irreverentiæ dumtaxat, sed et schismatis et contumaciæ redargui et pUniri potuissent. At ne operam tandem vel cum uno Tillemontio, vel cum apostolicæ sedis inimicis Indere videar, relictis modo Siricianis decretis atquo Toletani concilii ge-torum exemplaribus, ad ea gradum facere libet qUa! post hujusmodi gesta ill iisdem HiSpaniarum provinciis contigerunt.
CAPUT XI,
De gravi schismate inter Hispanos orto post Toletanam synodum.
i. Grave quidem tunc schisma ob veniam relaxatim episcopis et clericis pœnitentibus, Priscillianistarum hæresim et scrinia exsecrantibus, vel ob indulgentiam contumacibus denegatam, paulo post excitatum fuisse, jam sancii Innocentii papæ epistolas ad synodum Toletanam evidentissime patefaciunt. Cujus quidem schismatis auctores Boetici, et Carthaginenses episcopi fuere, qui ægerrime ferentes quod Toletani Patres S)mphosium, Dictinium aliosque Gallæciæ episcopos in communionem, retentis honoribus et gradibus, recepissent, ab iis qui eos receperant desciverunt.
so that, if they had condemned what they had done amiss, and had fulfilled the conditions which the letters sent beforehand contained, they would have been received with reverence into peace (add what Siricius of holy memory, the bishop, had urged).... great, etc. But if they had neglected to do this, they could have been convicted and punished not merely for irreverence, but also for schism and contumacy. But lest I seem, after all, to spend my labor either with Tillemont alone or with the enemies of the apostolic see, leaving aside for now the decrees of Siricius and the copies of the proceedings of the council of Toledo, I wish to advance to those things which after proceedings of this kind befell those same provinces of the Spains.
CHAPTER XI,
On the grave schism that arose among the Spaniards after the synod of Toledo.
1. That a grave schism was then stirred up shortly afterward, on account of the pardon granted to penitent bishops and clerics who execrated the heresy of the Priscillianists and their book-chests, or on account of the indulgence denied to the contumacious, the letters of the holy pope Innocent to the synod of Toledo make most evidently clear. Now the authors of this schism were the bishops of Baetica and of Carthago, who, taking it very ill that the Fathers of Toledo had received Symphosius, Dictinius, and other bishops of Gallaecia into communion, with their honors and ranks retained, revolted from those who had received them.