FELICIS PAPÆ III EPISTOLÆ ET DECRETA.
a EPISTOLA PRIMA.
FELICIS PAPÆ III AD ACACIUM CONSTANTINOPOLITANUM.
Op at sancla synodus Romana ut Zenonem imperatorcm inducat ad emendandum sedulo studio ea quæ adversus catholicam fidem hactenus perperam egisset.
Felicis ad Acaciura episcopum per Vitalem et Misenum episcopos.
Postquam sanctæ memoriæ decessore meo papa Simpliciodevitæ cursu superna præceptione migrante, ministerii quod regebat ad meae humililalis officium gubernacula pervenerunt; in diversas generalis Ecclesiae curas, quas ubique terrarum cunctis populis Christianis, summi pastoris voce delegante, beatissimus Petrus apostolus pervigili moderatione dispensat, continuo me sollicitudo maxima, quae et praedecessorem meum incessanter urgebat, tam Alexandrinæ urbis, quam status fidei totius Orientalis regionis excepit. Hæc nos diebus noctibusque perstringens, ad dominum filium nostrum Christianissi mum prineipem per Vilalem et Misenum fratres et coepiscopos nostros!egationem compulit destinare: qua vice mea pietati ejus et debita præsentaret officia (et pro fide catholica) majorumque nostrorum servandis constitutionibus supplicarct.
THE LETTERS AND DECREES OF POPE FELIX III.
a THE FIRST LETTER.
OF POPE FELIX III TO ACACIUS OF CONSTANTINOPLE.
That the holy Roman synod may induce the emperor Zeno to correct with diligent effort those things which he has hitherto wrongly done against the catholic faith.
Of Felix to Acacius the bishop, through Vitalis and Misenus, bishops.
After my predecessor of holy memory, Pope Simplicius, departed from the course of this life by a summons from on high, the helm of the ministry which he guided came to the office of my lowliness; and among the various cares of the universal Church, which throughout all the lands the most blessed apostle Peter, by the voice of the supreme Shepherd committing them to him, dispenses to all Christian peoples with ever-watchful governance, there immediately fell to me the greatest anxiety—the same anxiety that also ceaselessly pressed upon my predecessor—concerning both the city of Alexandria and the state of the faith of the whole Eastern region. This anxiety, besetting us day and night, compelled us to send a legation to my lord and son, the most Christian prince, through Vitalis and Misenus, our brothers and fellow bishops; that in my stead it might present to his piety both the offices due to him and, on behalf of the catholic faith, might entreat him to preserve the constitutions of our forefathers.
Hac igitur, illo pergenle, par fuit dilectionem tuam dilectis pariter salutare colloquiis, et consequenter horlari ut aliquando tandem patrocinium causæ Domini communis impendas, nec despiciendum putes, Christi confessione veridica, et universalis ejus Ecclesiæ definitione.... vel de pace concorditer.... si illius et honorecupis esse clarus et nomine. Fatemur enim secundum apostolicam vocem, magnam nobis inesse tristitiam et dolorem cordis nostri continuum (Rom. IX) cogitationibus qdas in die procedenlibus [propellentibus] negotiis sustinemus. Imprimis illud, quod dudum ante oculos fere omnium vertebatur, occurrit: cujusnam rei causa videlicet intercessit, indica nobis, quod dilectio tua non modo tantis opportunitatibus indesinenter exortis, verum etiam sæpenumero a decessoribus meis litteris invitata [incitata], velut obstinato silentio, nunquam super hanc partem aut consulere quidquam voluerit, aut referre. Cumque nos aliquid temere sinistrum (quod absit) de tua mente conveniat opinari, tamen quia venerabilium virorum qui Ecclesiam cui praesides ante rexerunt, morem formamquc destituas, ullo modo possis non esse suspectus.
Since he was therefore setting out, it was fitting to greet your beloved self with equally affectionate conversation, and consequently to urge that at long last you lend your patronage to the common cause of the Lord, and not think it something to be despised, by a truthful confession of Christ and the definition of his universal Church.... or concerning peace in concord.... if you desire to be distinguished both in his honor and in his name. For we confess, according to the apostolic voice, that great sorrow is in us and continual grief of our heart (Rom. 9), in the thoughts which we endure as the day's business presses on. First of all, that matter which for some time has been turned about before almost everyone's eyes comes to mind: namely, tell us for what reason it has intervened, that your beloved self, not only when so many opportunities had continually arisen, but also often invited by letters of my predecessors, as if in stubborn silence, has never wished either to consult or to report anything on this matter. And although it is fitting for us not rashly to form any sinister opinion (which God forbid) about your mind, yet because you abandon the custom and pattern of the venerable men who previously governed the Church over which you preside, you cannot in any way avoid being suspected.
Certe si (quod non credimus) dedignaris B. apostoli victoriis reverentiam tuis dcferrc astuosis affectibus, memor saltem officii pro fidei integritate catholicæ, pro paternarum custodia sanctionum, pro synodi Chalcedonensis constitutione servanda, quæ Nicxni conventus penitus probat articulos; atque pro eis ubiquc hostibus comprimendis, sicut orthodoxorum urbis illius imitator antistitum, constanter exsurgere debuisses: quoniam te aliter inter membra corporis Christi monstrare non possis, nisi nullatenus providere desisteres illis quæ per totum mundam dicuntur obrepsisse contagiis.
Proinde adire debes sæpius Christianae mentis Augustum, et causas eidem salutis suae atque etiam imperii redditurus, et conservandi ejus auxilium frequenter ingerere, unde inimici illius corruerint, et qua via idem surrexerit, nihilominus intimare ei; scripta illa sensibus pietatis ejus offerre, quibus decessorem meum eximia laude extulit, eo quod haereticam catholicae tyrannidem veritatis assertione confoderit. Item illa quoque quibus Petrum Alexandrinum ab Alexandrinæ cervicibus excussit Ecclesiae, et sanctae memoriæ Timotheum revocavit orthodoxum.
Certainly, if (which we do not believe) you disdain to show reverence to the victories of the blessed apostle through your crafty affections, you should at least, mindful of your office, have risen up constantly for the integrity of the catholic faith, for the guarding of the fathers' sanctions, for the preserving of the constitution of the synod of Chalcedon, which thoroughly approves the articles of the council of Nicaea, and for the suppressing everywhere of those enemies—just as, an imitator of the orthodox bishops of that city, you ought to have done: since you cannot otherwise show yourself among the members of the body of Christ, unless you cease not at all to provide for those things which are said to have crept in throughout the whole world by contagions.
Therefore you ought more often to approach the Augustus of the Christian mind, both to render to him the causes of his salvation and also of his empire, and frequently to bring before him the aid of preserving it, whence his enemies have fallen, and by what way he himself has risen, and nonetheless to intimate it to him; to offer to his pious senses those writings in which he extolled my predecessor with outstanding praise, because he struck down the heretical tyranny against the catholic [faith] by the assertion of truth. Likewise also those [writings] in which he shook off Peter of Alexandria from the neck of the Alexandrian Church, and recalled Timothy, of holy memory, the orthodox.
Nec illa præterire quibus episcopis et clericis, laicisque per omnem Ægyptum constitutis, quod a divina Cbristiana professione deviassent, sicut catholicus imperator obtestans, nisi intra duos menses ad communionem Timothei redirent, honoribus, ecclesiis, omnibusque in illa regione denuntiavit esse privandos. Simul etiam quibus Petri, quem illicite se Alexandrinae Ecclesiae injecisse perhibuit, ac Timothei haeretici jam defuncti ordinationes, vel ea quae secreto per modos dicebant, ita recassavit. Nec non etiam illud adnectere, quod cum Timotheus sanctae memoriae catholicus fungeretur extremis, divinæ inspirationis instinctu, tam ad ejus pontificis consulta rescribens, quam ad urbis Alexandrinæ clerum, omni providentia mandavit præccavendum, ut si praefatum dominus sacerdotem transire jusserit, non nisi deca. tholicorum corpore clericorum, et qui orthodoxæ fidei probaretur esse discipulus, omnibusque communicaret Ecclesiis, atque a catholicis ordinatus succederet defuncto pontifici: nimirum sapienter intendens, Petrum, qui aut a nullis, aut ab hæreticis falsi nominis bujus honore jactaretur, super petram [unde Petrum] catholicæ Ecclesiae, e qua ejus temeraria fuerat præsumptione depulsus, nunquam posse penitus præsidere.
Nor should those matters be passed over in which he, as a catholic emperor, adjured the bishops and clerics and laymen established throughout all Egypt, because they had deviated from the divine Christian profession, declaring that unless within two months they returned to communion with Timothy, they would be deprived of their honors, churches, and all their possessions in that region. At the same time he also rejected the ordinations of Peter, whom he asserted had unlawfully thrust himself into the Church of Alexandria, and of the heretic Timothy, now deceased, as well as the things they were said to utter secretly in various ways. He further added this also: that when Timothy, of holy memory, a catholic, was at the point of death, by the instinct of divine inspiration, writing back both to the consultations of that pontiff and to the clergy of the city of Alexandria, he charged with all foresight that it be guarded against, that if the Lord should order the aforesaid priest to pass away, no one should communicate with all the churches except a body of catholic clerics, and one who was proved to be a disciple of the orthodox faith, and that one ordained by catholics should succeed the deceased pontiff: wisely indeed intending that Peter, who was vaunted for this honor either by no one or by heretics of a false name, could never fully preside over the rock of the catholic Church, from which by his rash presumption he had been driven out.
Hæc hujusmodi quae gesta sunt, et dilectionis tuae conscientiam non latent, convenerat saepius impertiri: praecipue cum in his Christianissimo principi promulgandis, quando ad regiam potestatem Deo comitante remeavit, operam tuam missis huc litteris non tacueris vehementer impensam esse, dignam catholico pontifice; gloriareris omnes qui contra sedem vestram [nostram], contraque Chalcedonensem synodum, et contra prædicationem sedis apostolicæ venire tentaverint, fuisse prostratos: quo magis te. pro tua salute et professione ferventius apud clementiæ ejus aures oportuerat talia incessabiliter allegare, ac magnopere deprecari, quo nec suam, quam catholica mente deprompserat, violari ullatenus pateretur cujuslibet subreptione sententiam; nec adversus universalis Ecclesiae sanctionem per hæreticorum furias, quas, Deo inspirante, pietas ejus eliserat, sineret denuo pullulare, quam manifestissime pervideres; ac tua modis omnibus praedicatione rursum in ea quæ exstiterant ei adversa consurgeres, atque eadem sine dubitatione firmares: quando huic reluctantia, sicut dudum fuerant subversa, jacuissent; ne vel tuæ (quod absit) fidei destitutor, vel perfidiæ dicereris fautor alienae. Error enim cui non resistitur approbatur, et veritas quae minime defensalur opprimitur.
Matters of this kind which have been done, and which are not hidden from your loving awareness, it would have been fitting to share more often; especially since, in promulgating these things to the most Christian prince, when with God's guidance he returned to royal power, you did not keep silent in the letters sent here that your effort had been vehemently expended, worthy of a catholic pontiff; you would glory that all who had attempted to come against your [our] see, against the Council of Chalcedon, and against the preaching of the apostolic see, had been laid low: the more, therefore, ought you, for your own salvation and profession, more fervently in the ears of his clemency to allege such things unceasingly, and greatly to entreat, that he should not permit his own sentence, which he had brought forth with a catholic mind, to be violated in any way by anyone's surreption; nor should he allow, through the furies of heretics, that to sprout again against the sanction of the universal Church which his piety, by God's inspiration, had crushed, as you most manifestly perceived; and by your preaching in every way you should rise up again against those things which had stood opposed to it, and without doubt strengthen the same: since those resisting it, just as they had long since been overthrown, lay prostrate; lest you be called (God forbid) either a deserter of your faith or a favorer of another's perfidy. For error which is not resisted is approved, and truth which is not defended is oppressed.
Deinde cum tibi, Domino praestante, apud dominum filium nostrum religiosum principem familiaritatem esse noverimus, nullus unquam potuit suaderi dilectionem tuam nequivisse gerere, quin potius noluisse. Et ideo quia non impossibilitatis esset, quod taceretur: ipse quoque non ambigis, quid hinc universalis judicare possit Ecclesia.
Ubi est, frater Acaci, labor tuus, quo tyrannidis haereticae tempore desudasti? Patieris hoc damno conscientiæ tuæ ejusmodi perire mercedem? Respice Apostoli verba, quæ testantur: Currebatis bene; quis vos confascinavit (Galat. v)?Cur eorum, frater, quaerere semitas veteres nunc relinquis? Cur irruentibus in ovile dominicum lupis, nulla vigilantia ministerii pastoralis obsistis, sed aequanimiter atque sccurus commissum gregem aut laniari perspicis, aut necari? Non dicentem recolis Dominum, et animam suam quidem pro ovibus ponere pios pro devotione pastores; mercenarium autem de his curam penitus non habentem, mox ut bestiam forte conspexerit, sine ulla diffugere consideratione testantem? Verum cum tibi fugiendi nulla sit causa (nam nulla formido est), metuo ne septa dominica non tam pavore deserere, quam (quod est detestabilius) sponte videaris sævis dentibus objecisse [dejecisse].
Then, since we know that, with the Lord's help, you have familiarity with our lord and son, the religious prince, no one could ever be persuaded that your beloved self was unable to act—rather, that you were unwilling. And therefore, since what was kept silent was not a matter of impossibility, you too do not doubt what the universal Church can judge concerning this.
Where is your labor, brother Acacius, in which you toiled during the time of heretical tyranny? Will you allow the reward of such a conscience to perish by this loss? Consider the words of the Apostle, which testify: You were running well; who hindered you? Why, brother, do you now abandon the ancient paths of these men and seek them no longer? Why, when wolves rush into the Lord's sheepfold, do you resist with no vigilance of pastoral ministry, but calmly and securely watch the flock entrusted to you either be torn apart or killed? Do you not recall the Lord saying that devoted shepherds indeed lay down their own soul for the sheep, but that the hireling, having no care at all for them, as soon as he perhaps catches sight of the beast, flees without any consideration—as he testifies? But since you have no cause for fleeing (for there is no fear), I fear that you may seem to have abandoned the Lord's enclosures not so much out of dread as—what is more detestable—to have cast them willingly to savage teeth.
Ausculta vocem ejusdem Domini praemonentis: Qui mecum non est, colera me est; et qui mecum non colligit, dispergit (Luc. xi). Et diligenter attende nihil aliud esse non procurare quæ Christi sunt, nisi se palam profiteri ejus inimicum. Non desperemus facere, frater, veram Salvatoris nostri sententiam, qua se usque ad finem saeculi Ecclesiae suae non defuturum esse pollicitus est ( Matth. XXVIII ), nec ab inferi portis eam dixit esse superandam (Matth. xvi), et quae omnia per aposlolicæ scita doctrinae ligarentur in terris, nec in coelestibus memoravit absolvi ( Matth. xvi, ). Neque putemus, quod quibuslibet sit vallata periculis, unquam pondus vigoris sui, vel censura beatissimi Petri, vel auctoritas universalis amittat Ecclesiae: quae quanto magis cavet ne mundi prosperitatibus intepescat, tanto non frangitur, sed potius erudita divinitus, creecit1 adversus.
Hear the voice of the same Lord giving warning: "Whoever is not with me is against me; and whoever does not gather with me scatters" (Luke 11). And attend diligently: to fail to care for the things that are Christ's is nothing other than to openly profess oneself his enemy. Let us not despair, brother, of fulfilling the true sentence of our Savior, by which he promised that he would not be absent from his Church even to the end of the age (Matthew 28), and he said that it would not be overcome by the gates of hell (Matthew 16), and he declared that whatever things were bound on earth by the decrees of apostolic teaching would not be loosed in heaven (Matthew 16). Nor let us think that, however it may be hedged about by any dangers whatsoever, it ever loses the weight of its strength, either through the judgment of the most blessed Peter or through the authority of the universal Church: which, the more it takes care not to grow lukewarm amid the prosperities of the world, the more it is not broken, but rather, taught by God, grows against them.
Unde [ubi] perspiciendum est ne eam, quae nullis potest obrui motibus [molibus] procellarum, quicunque eam submergerc nititur in ipso saeculi pelago fluctuantis, ipse potius a gubernatione salutari in profunda dejectus, illa praevalente, mergatur.
Atque ideo, cum ita sit, moneo, hortor et suadeo, ut quæ commissa sunt corrigas, et sequentibus studiis de te facias meliora sentiri: Negligere quippe, cum possis deturbare perversos, nihil est aliud quam fovere. Non [Nec] caret scrupulo societatis occultæ, qui evidenter [evidenti ] facinori desinit obviare. Unde si contra synodi instituta Chalcedonensis tendere hostilia corda perspicis, quiescis: mihi crede, nescio quemadmodum te Ecclesiæ totius asseris esse participem. Ad te oculos praeterea non reducis, quia non solum in hac causa adversus omnem catholici dogmatis tendatur unitatem, sed etiam cunctis haeresibus, quae vel se nobis melius sentire praetendunt, resumendi vires, atque inter usus pristinos resurgendi, latus campus aperitur, si semel quod a nostris majoribus est depositum, qualibet occasione pulsetur.
Hence it must be seen to that, whoever strives to sink her whom no storms of tempests can overwhelm, in the very sea of this fluctuating world, may himself rather be cast down from the helm of salvation into the depths, and, with her prevailing, be drowned.
And therefore, since this is so, I warn, exhort, and persuade you to correct what has been entrusted to you, and by your subsequent efforts to make better things be thought of you. For to neglect, when you can drive out the perverse, is nothing other than to foster them. He does not lack the scruple of a hidden fellowship who ceases to oppose an evident crime. Therefore, if you perceive hostile hearts striving against the decrees of the synod of Chalcedon, and you remain quiet: believe me, I do not know how you claim to be a partaker of the whole Church. Moreover, you do not turn your eyes back to this, that not only in this matter is war being waged against the whole unity of the catholic faith, but also for all heresies, which either claim that they think better than we do, a broad field is opened for recovering their strength and rising again among their former practices, if once what has been deposited by our forefathers is struck at on any occasion.
Unde iterum atque iterum proteslamur, ne in ab. ruptum totius Ecclesiae statuta per andaciam contra synodum catholicam insurgere molientium sinatur abduei. In quo quidem certamine firmum fundamentum Deus statuet, sicut de eo nobis licet sperare; et novit Dominus qui sunt ejus (II Tim. II, 19). Verumtamen, salvo eo, quod in die judicii talem a nobis Ecclesiam, certum est, qualem a patribus accipimus, exigendam; etiam in hac vita se ad eam non pertinere cognoscat, qui non solum plenitudini ejus noxia conatur inferre, sed etiam qui ea quæ eidem congruentia sunt dissimulat providere. Absit ut de tua dilectione taliter nos credamus, quem et dudum pro catholica fide viriliter stetisse reminiscimur, ct a totius Ecclesiae corpore nolumus discrepare. Quapropter instantius (qui te sincero diligimus caritatis intuitu ) crebro repetitis hortationibus incitamus, ut ipse vicissim ea post haec devites quae te ab omni domo Christi ostendant esse disjunctum; nec magis illa secteris quae ab eadem te faciant esse divisum.
Therefore we protest again and again that no one who strives with audacity against the catholic synod to rise up against the statutes of the whole Church be allowed to be led away to their destruction. In this contest, indeed, God will set a firm foundation, as we may hope concerning him; and the Lord knows those who are his (II Tim. 2:19). Nevertheless, saving this, that on the day of judgment such a Church will be required of us, as is certain, as we received from the fathers; even in this life let him know that he does not belong to it, who not only attempts to bring harm to its fullness, but also who neglects to provide for the things that are fitting for it. Far be it that we should believe such things of your belovedness, whom we remember to have stood manfully for the catholic faith some time ago, and whom we do not wish to be separated from the body of the whole Church. Wherefore more urgently (we who love you with the sincere regard of charity) we stir you up with frequently repeated exhortations, that you in turn, after these things, avoid those things which show you to be cut off from every house of Christ; and that you pursue not rather those things which make you to be divided from it.
Multa vero (quia non opus fuit litteris universa congerere) quaeque utilitas negotii praesentis efflagitat, fratribus ct coepiscopis apostolicae sedis legatione fungentibus, vel cum domino filio nostro clementissimo principe, vel cum tua dilectione colloquenda mandavimus: quod aequum est et pro catholicæ fidei observatione prompta mente suscipere, et pro tuae æstimationis intuitu necessariam apud augustæ mentis benevolentiam suggestionibus adjuvari.
EPISTOLA II.
a AD ZENONEM IMPERATOREM.
Pro Ecclesia Alexandrina supplicat: quidquid antehac pro defensione ejusdem Ecclesiæ dixit aut fecit, commemorat, ad posteriorem Joannis Alexandrini episcopi ejectionem, et Petri Moggi restitutionem reprehendat.
lucipit epistola exemplum beatissimi papæ Felicis urbis Romæ ad Zenonem Augustum per Vitalem et Misenum episcopos.
Decebat profecto, venerabilis imperator, post sanctæ memoriæ decessoris mei transitum, meque in ejus locum divina gratia subrogatum, clementiæ tuæ litterarum munus offerre: quod vel ea, sicut rerum poscebat ratio, nuntiarem, vel officiositatis meæ primitias exhiberem: quibas tamen rite depensis, etiam illa pariter necterentur quæ ad vestri munimea imperii, prosperitatisque ejus suffragia pertinerent; quantoque essent studio majore curanda, tanto dignioribus internuntiis explerentur.
But since it was not necessary to gather everything in a letter, we have entrusted to the brothers and fellow bishops performing the legation of the apostolic see those matters which the utility of the present business demands, to be discussed either with our lord and son, the most clement prince, or with your beloved self; and it is right both to undertake these things with a ready mind for the observance of the catholic faith, and, in view of your esteemed position, to be aided by your suggestions with the necessary favor of the august mind.
EPISTLE II.
TO THE EMPEROR ZENO.
He pleads for the Church of Alexandria: he recalls whatever he has previously said or done for the defense of that same Church; he reproves the later ejection of John, bishop of Alexandria, and the restoration of Peter Mongus.
Here begins the copy of the letter of the most blessed pope Felix of the city of Rome to Zeno Augustus, sent through Vitalis and Misenus, bishops.
It was fitting indeed, venerable emperor, after the passing of my predecessor of holy memory, and my own substitution in his place by divine grace, that I should offer to your clemency the gift of a letter: either to announce those things which the nature of the matter demanded, or to display the firstfruits of my dutifulness; and when these had been duly paid, those matters also should be joined with them which pertain to the protection of your empire and the support of its prosperity; and by how much greater zeal they must be attended to, by so much more worthy messengers should they be carried out.
Itaque conveniens fuit ut Vitalis et Miseni fratrum et coepiscoporum meorum, et femuli vestri Felicis Ecclesiæ defensoris ad vos necessariam Eegationem mitterem, qui non tam hojuli specie ista deferrent, quam meam vicem peragenes, me quodammodo vobis facerent esse praesentem. Per hanc igitur, velut cominas lionorificentiæ tuæ junctus colloquiis, precor ut supplicationem meam benignis auribus, sicut princeps Christianus, accipias. Mee existimet pietas tua, quod quisquam magis sincera mente te diligat, quam qui te pacem in Deo vult habere perpetuam: quando Mei mente non ambigas, et temporalis culminis potestatem et æternæ vita commercia de superna propitiatione pendere.
Ecce jamdiu est quod beati apostoli sedes, datis per beatae memoriæ decessorem meum ad serenitatem 'nam litteris, exspectans, et nullum recepit pro catholica Me, pro Occidentalium [Orientalium] tranquillitate responsum; præsertim cum tuam conseientiam, gloriosissime princeps, metuendis obstrinxerit iUa sacramentis, ne sedes beati evangelistae Marei a doctrina magistri sui vel eommunione permitteres separari. Sed quoniam praefati decessoris mei studium, longa incommoditate faciente, hæc eadem crebrius iterare non potuit; per meae nunc humili tatis officium sollicitius repetere non quiescit.
And so it was fitting that I send to you the necessary legation of my brothers and fellow bishops Vitalis and Misenus, and of your servant Felix, defender of the Church, who would not so much deliver these matters in the guise of bearers as, acting in my place, make me in some manner present to you. Through them, therefore, as though joined in conversation with your Honor, I beseech you to receive my supplication with kindly ears, as a Christian prince. Let your Piety consider that no one loves you with a more sincere mind than he who wishes you to have peace in God forever, since you do not doubt in my mind that both the power of temporal eminence and the commerce of eternal life depend upon heavenly propitiation.
Behold, it is now long since the see of the blessed apostle, having sent letters through my predecessor of blessed memory to your Serenity, has been waiting and has received no response for the catholic faith, for the tranquility of the Western [Eastern] regions; especially since that oath, to be feared, has bound your conscience, most glorious prince, not to permit the see of the blessed evangelist Mark to be separated from the doctrine of its master or from his communion. But since the zeal of my aforementioned predecessor, because of long inconvenience, could not repeat these same things more frequently, it does not now cease, through the office of my humility, to repeat them more diligently.
Rursus ergo apostoli Pelvi veneranda confessio materna instant vocibus, et suorum praecipue filiorum eompellere non desinens confidentiam tuae pietatis, exclamat: Christiane princeps, cur me a curriculo caritatis, quo Ecclesia universalis astringitur, permittis incidi? Cur in me rumpis totius orbis assensum?
Quæso te, fili piissime, ne tunica Domini desuper contexta per totum, qua in unum corpus sancto Spiritu ubique regente, individuam fore Christi figuravit Ecclesiam, ulla patiaris sorte violari; neve cujus inter ipsos qui crucifixeront Salvatorem, mansit integritas, tuis videatur temporibus esse divisa. Nonne mea fides est, quam solam esse unam, et nulla adversitate superandam Dominus ipse monstravit, qui Ecclesiæ suæ in mea confessione fundatae portas inferi nunquam prævalituras esse promisit? Haec te renatum ad regiam sustulit dignitatem, atque ab nas impugnatoribus potestate extrusa, prevalendi tibi denuo viam in ipsius defensione patefecit.
Again, therefore, the venerable confession of the apostle Peter cries out to you with a mother's voice, and ceaselessly urging the confidence of your piety, especially that of his own sons, it exclaims: Christian prince, why do you allow me to be cut off from the course of charity by which the universal Church is bound together? Why do you break in me the consent of the whole world?
I beseech you, most dutiful son, do not permit the tunic of the Lord, woven from above throughout, by which, with the Holy Spirit ruling everywhere, he prefigured the Church of Christ to be indivisible, to be violated by any lot; nor let that integrity, which remained even among those who crucified the Savior, be seen in your times to be divided. Is it not my faith, which the Lord himself showed to be one only and to be overcome by no adversity, when he promised that the gates of hell would never prevail against his Church founded upon my confession? This faith raised you, reborn, to royal dignity, and, having thrust out your attackers by its power, opened for you again the way of prevailing in its defense.
Verum, qnaeso, propone etiam exempla gestorum, et hanc vicem meis repende beneOciis, ut quae per rerum eXamina comprobasti, et periculosa præca-. veas, et subsidia recuperatæ a te dignitatis affectes. Hae rogo, quae dicta Deus esse voluit per dictæ sedis antistitem, vel per mei ordinis parvitatem, qui tuæ I securitatis intuitu, hujuscemodi ideo promenda ju. dieavit, at non tam per ejus qualemcunque vicarium, sed praesentis apostoli velut auctoritate commonitus, aftius vias ei divinae reverentiae et humanae conditionis aspiciens (quod absit) non ingratus existere videaris collatae felicitatis auctori. Redeat, obsecro, in animi tui integra deliberatione conspectum, quae inimicos tuos facta dejecerunt, quæ te ad imperiale fastigium Deo comitante revexerint; qualiter illi cum nefanda dogmatis receptione conciderunt; et quemadmodum gloria tua in haereticorum fuerit depufsione reparata: ut illi contra Chalcedonensis synodi venerabilia constituta, et beatissimi papæ Leonis scripta venientes, ipsa sui molitione collapsi sunt; et quibus modis eorum reformationes, ad pristinum remearunt tuarum reverentiam principatum.
But I ask you, set before yourself also the examples of what has been done, and repay this favor for my benefits, so that you may both guard against the dangerous things that you have verified through the tests of events, and strive after the supports of the dignity you have recovered. These things I ask, which God willed to be spoken through the bishop of the said see, or through the lowliness of my order, who, with a view to your security, judged that such things should therefore be brought forward, so that—not so much as through his own vicar, of whatever sort he is, but as though admonished by the authority of the present apostle, looking more closely at the ways of divine reverence and of the human condition—you may not appear (which God forbid) ungrateful to the author of the felicity conferred upon you. Let there return, I beseech you, into the whole deliberation of your mind the sight of the deeds that cast down your enemies, that brought you back to the imperial height with God as your companion; how they fell with the abominable reception of the doctrine; and how your glory was restored in the driving out of the heretics: so that those who came against the venerable decrees of the synod of Chalcedon and the writings of the most blessed Pope Leo were themselves collapsed by their own machination; and in what ways their reformations returned to the former reverence of your principate.
Liceat, oro, apud te fidenter exponere [exercere] quem convenit non tacere. Unicum in te superest prisci nomen imperatoris. Ne, quaeso, nobis salutem tuam, pie imperator, invideas, ne fiduciam pro te minuas supplicandi. Causae quibus Dominus sit propitius inquirendae sunt, non quibus ejus indignatio provocetur. Convenio, contestor, obtestor; quoniam metuo, horresco, formido, ne mutatione causarum (quod absit) mutetur eventus. Respice propitius ad decessores tuos augustae memoriæ Marcianum scilicet et Leonem, et tantorum principum fidem, legitimus eorum successor: amplecti debes illorum in religione consensum, quorum debes memoriae reverentiam. Absit a tua devotione, absit a tua potestate, ut talium credaris respuisse judicium.
Postremo professionem tuam, conscientiamque recolendam sensibus tuae pietatis insinuo. Palatii tui facilo scrinia recenseri, et scripta illa diligenter investigari, quæ ad apicem summæ regrediens potestatis ad decessorem meum pietas tua pro communi gratulatione direxit: his cum semper magna laude prosequeris, quod haeretieam tyrannidem praedieationis catholicæ vigore contriveris, qua utique istius veritatis prædicatione nihil aliud quam de Eutychiano labores errore prorsus abolendo, ejusque sequacibus excludendis. Hæc pro synodi Chalcedonensis defini. tione servanda, reducendoque sanctae memoriæ Ti. motheo rectae Me!
Allow me, I pray, to set forth confidently before you what it is fitting for one not to keep silent about. There remains in you the unique name of the emperor of old. Do not, I beseech you, pious emperor, begrudge us your safety, do not diminish the confidence of supplicating on your behalf. The causes for which the Lord may be propitious are to be sought, not those by which His indignation is provoked. I approach, I appeal, I implore; because I fear, I shudder, I dread lest by a change of causes (which God forbid) the outcome be changed. Look propitiously upon your predecessors of august memory, namely Marcian and Leo, and, as the lawful successor of such great princes, you ought to embrace their consensus in religion, whose memory you owe reverence. Far be it from your devotion, far be it from your power, that you should be believed to have rejected the judgment of such men.
Finally, I insinuate to the senses of your piety that your profession and conscience must be recalled. Let the scrinia of your palace be easily reviewed, and let those writings be diligently investigated which, when your piety was returning to the summit of the highest power, it sent to my predecessor for common congratulation: since you always pursue these with great praise, in that you crushed the heretical tyranny by the vigor of catholic preaching, in which, by the preaching of this truth, you labor for nothing other than the Eutychian error to be utterly abolished and its followers excluded. These things are for the definition of the synod of Chalcedon to be preserved, and for the restoration of Timothy of holy memory to the right faith
sacerdote, tota sua texius serie pie locuta est. Haee certe tua mansuetudo cognovit: nec res incognitas tua dementia proferre potuisset, et palam aperteque professa, quod laudum tuarum testificatione firmasti.
Requirantur illa quoque, quae ad sanctae memoriae Timotheum orthodoxum Alexandrinum episcopum serenitatis tuæ paginae sunt locutae, atque ei ipsis actibus intuere, nisi Petro ex ea memorata urbe secluso, qui ei Ecclesiae tunc temporis incubabat, supradictum Timotheum non fuisse revocatum. Vos ad eumdem venerandæ recordationis pontificem jam reductum sacras venerabiles mox dedistis, quibus fideli pectore gloriabamini, quod sanctæ Ecclesiae magnae civitatis Alexandrinae providens orthodoxæ fidei, Dominus noster ac Salvator verum restituerit sacerdotem. Ubi manifestum est, quia cum verum dicitis, illum fuisse falsum qui pulsus est, ostenditis; et cum in venerando Timotheo orthodoxo fidem dominum testamini reduxisse, perversam in omnibus in Petro perhibetis refutasse doctrinam, non ob aliud, nisi quia et ille qui orthodoxus pronuntiatur et verus, Chalcedonensi synodo (sicut ejus tunc missa tenet. professio) consentiebat; et iste qui falsus et perversus ejicitur, ab ejusdem synodi tramite discrepabat.
Your gentleness has certainly learned this: neither could your discernment have brought forward unknown matters, nor things openly and plainly professed, which you confirmed by the testimony of your praises.
Let those things also be examined which the pages of your Serenity spoke to Timothy, the orthodox bishop of Alexandria of holy memory, and look at the very acts themselves, whether, with Peter shut out from that same remembered city, who at that time was presiding over that church, the aforementioned Timothy was not recalled. To that same pontiff of venerable memory, now restored, you soon gave your sacred and venerable letters, in which you gloried with a faithful heart that our Lord and Savior, providing for the holy Church of the great city of Alexandria in the orthodox faith, had restored the true priest. Where it is manifest that, when you speak the truth, you show that he who was driven out was false; and when you testify that the Lord has restored the faith in the venerable orthodox Timothy, you declare that in Peter he has refuted a doctrine perverse in all things, for no other reason than that both he who is pronounced orthodox and true consented to the synod of Chalcedon (as his profession then sent holds), and this one who is cast out as false and perverse disagreed with the path of that same synod.
Denique cunctos episcopos.Egypti, universosque cleros [forte clericos] increpastis, vestris generaliter apicibus sancientes, ut nisi intra duos menses ab his quæ a principio contra canones, eontra Ecclesias Dei, contra orthodoxam fidem cogitaverunt, abstinerent, atque beati Timothei communione, quam impie reliquerunt, dignae pœnitentiæ satisfactione remearent; non solum despoliandos honoribus, verum etiam et Alexandrina urbe et omni Ægyptiaca regione carituros: injuslum enim videri, sicut Christianus imperator affirmans, ut qui se1 ad Ecclesiam, quæ ubique terrarum est, segregarent, haberent sacerdotes, ulle sacro ministerii nomine censerentur. Vos indigne ferentes ab Alexandrinis seditiones concitatan, eos qui propter ordinem clericalem simili deceptione tenebantur, nisi salutaribus monitis obedirent, tali poena dignos arbitrabamini.
Finally, you rebuked all the bishops of Egypt and all the clergy, sanctioning generally by your letters that, unless within two months they should abstain from the things which from the beginning they had devised against the canons, against the Churches of God, and against the orthodox faith, and should return by the satisfaction of worthy penance to the communion of blessed Timothy, which they had impiously abandoned, they would not only be stripped of their honors but would also be deprived of the city of Alexandria and the whole region of Egypt; for it seemed unjust, as the Christian emperor affirmed, that those who separated themselves from the Church which is throughout the whole world should have priests or be reckoned under any name of sacred ministry. You, deeming it unworthy that seditions were stirred up by the Alexandrians, judged those who were held by a similar deception on account of clerical order, unless they obeyed salutary warnings, worthy of such punishment.
Vos Petrum speciali notantes elogio, quod illicite se Alexandrinæ injecisses Ecclesiæ, omnes qui tam ab eo quam haeretico Timotheo jam defuncto fuerant ordinati, si infra finita tempera resipiscerent, ad. communienem catholici Timothei mandastis recipi (non etiam ad male praesumpti gradus privilegia decreveratis admitti), consequenter addentes caeteros deteriora subituros, si eligere meliora noluissent. Vos cujuslibet post has varias satisfactionis causas canetis penitus abstulistis, quibus ipses ab unitatis consortio discedentes, recensuistis tulisse juditium. Vos de ipsius persona Petri quidquam denuo defrieandi, sapienti consideratione tacuistis: quippe quem Eeclesiae arce dejeetom, simul pervasi pontificii videretis honore nudatum; nec ullo modo fieri posse, ut unquam vel orthodoxis præsideret, qui aut a nullis, aut ab haereticis fuerat institutus, vel tecidiva toties temeritate violentas ovile dominicum subdolus et invidiosus intraret.
You, marking Peter with a special distinction because he had unlawfully thrust himself into the church of Alexandria, commanded that all who had been ordained either by him or by the heretic Timothy, now dead, be received into the communion of the catholic Timothy, if within the appointed times they should repent (though you had decreed that they were not even to be admitted to the privileges of the degree they had wrongly presumed), adding consequently that the rest would undergo worse things if they were unwilling to choose the better course. You, after these various causes of satisfaction, wholly removed the caution of any further excommunication from those whom you recounted had brought judgment upon themselves by departing from the fellowship of unity. Concerning the person of Peter himself, you kept silent, in wise consideration, from condemning him again: namely, since you saw him cast down from the citadel of the church and at the same time stripped of the honor of the pontificate he had usurped; and that it could in no way happen that he should ever preside over the orthodox, who had been appointed either by no one or by heretics, or that, cunning and malicious, he should so often enter the Lord's fold by the violence of his repeated rashness.
Atque ideo quod corrigendis ejus prætendebatis sectatoribus irrogandum, huic jam quasi magistro seeteris rationabiliter duputabatis inflictum: ut quibus fratres merserat ad ruinam, fieret ipse metuendæ damnationis exemplum: quodque adeo verum est, ut superstare venerando Timotheo legionem sollicite jusseritis, si eidem humanitus aliquid evenisset. Vos non nisi de catholicorum collegio clericorum et a catholicis consecratum subiistis videre pastorem: quia ubique nullo ritu sub vestræ serenitatis obtutibus haeresis ipse praeCipuus Eutychianæ dementiæ potuit esse vel dici orthodoxi suecessor antistilis. Quo igitur animo bestiam quam a gregibus Christi duxistis abigendam in eorum denuo patimini sævire perniciem? Certe legibus quas universis imponitis, magis vultis vinci quam promulgare contraria; quanto satius fuerit, intemerata persistere quae heri pro integritate retinenda totius Ecclesiæ protulistis, quo et tui catholici imperii aucloritas inconvulsa permaneat, et nihil accedat quod actibus apud Dominum vestræ felicitati obsistat.
And therefore, what you were claiming ought to be imposed as a correction upon his followers, you reasonably reckoned had already been inflicted upon him as their leader: so that for those whom he had plunged into ruin, he himself might become an example of dreaded condemnation. And this is so true that, while the venerable Timothy still survived, you earnestly ordered a legion to be provided, should anything happen to him by human chance. You have not undertaken to see as pastor anyone except one from the college of catholic clerics and consecrated by catholics, since nowhere, under any rite, in the sight of your Serenity, could that chief heresiarch of Eutychian madness either be or be called the successor of an orthodox bishop. With what mind, then, do you suffer the beast, which you have drawn out from the flocks of Christ to be driven away, to rage again to their destruction? Surely, by the laws which you impose upon all, you wish rather to be conquered than to promulgate contrary things; how much better it would have been to persist in the inviolate things which you brought forth yesterday for preserving the integrity of the whole Church, so that both the authority of your catholic empire may remain unshaken, and nothing may be added that stands in the way of your felicity in your acts before the Lord.
Cernis enim, venerabilis imperator, quia ut Chalcedonensis synodi indubilata defensio, inimicorum ejus elisiu est, sic vicissim manifesta illius impugnatione comprobatur hostium venerandæ ipsius cognitionis [protectionis] cveclio. Meministis quemadmodum verba 'divina nos instruant, Neque in dextrum neque in sinistrum limitem rectæ dispositionis excedere, sed via (ut scriptum est) regia mediuque gradiendo (Deut. xxv), hinc atque inde Nestorii Eutychetisque J sacrilegia condemnata detestans, ita magnæ pietatis praedicans sacramentum, ut omnipotentis Dei Patris consubstantiale sempiteruumque Verbum, quod incommutabili deitate et incarnatum est, et ab ipso ineffabilis conceptionis exordio.
For you see, venerable emperor, that just as the undoubted defense of the Council of Chalcedon has crushed its enemies, so in turn by its manifest attack the destruction of its enemies is proven to be the protection of that revered knowledge. You remember how the divine words instruct us not to turn aside to the right hand or to the left from the boundary of right order, but to walk by the royal road, as it is written, and in the middle way, condemning and detesting on this side and on that the sacrileges of Nestorius and Eutyches, and so proclaiming the mystery of great piety, that the eternal Word, consubstantial with God the almighty Father, who in unchanging deity was also incarnate, and from the very beginning of his ineffable conception.
quam sibi in utero Virginis matris potentes instruxit unum eumdemque Jesum Christum Dominum nostrum, unum cumdemque et Dei et hominis Filium, unum eumdemque inconfuse, indivise Deum hominemque veraciter permanentem intermerata Patris lege prolatum, in hoc mundo Mise conspicuum [perspicuum], divina* simul humanaque gessisse; mortuum, atque ex mortuis exsurgentem, in Patris dextera residere; [temque, inde venturum, ut est visus ire in coelos, eatenus profiterentur, quatenus Librorum memorat traditio divinorum, etNicaeni concilii forma, sicuti cuncti retro praedicavere pontifices: sic eorum tam Ephesino primo competenter inserta conventui, quo beati papæ Cœlestini temporibus Nestoriana pestis exstincta est, quam datis augustae memoriæ Leoni sanctae memoriae Leonis papæ epistolis capitula subjecta testantur: quibus vir ille consulens etiam totius Orientis I episcopis, eorumque responsa, subscriptionesque super synodi Chalcedonensis approbatione suscipiens, ea nullatenus passus est mutari; quo magis Christiana mente perpendit, et hoc esse verum, quod cum divinis assertionibus catholicorum de toto orbe doctorum longe antequam hujusmodi quæstio nasceretur, consonantia ubique dicta concinuerant; et ideo nulla iteratione refodienda, quae constarent jure damnata: ne non solum causa praesens in omne catholici nominis extendat exilium, sed etiam cunctis residuis publica bella resumendi
whom he prepared for himself in the womb of the Virgin his mother, mighty, one and the same Jesus Christ our Lord, one and the same Son of both God and man, one and the same, unconfusedly, indivisibly, truly remaining God and man, brought forth by the undefiled law of the Father, in this world, visible to the humble, to have done both divine and human things; to have died and risen from the dead, to sit at the right hand of the Father; and from there to be about to come, as he was seen to go into the heavens, to that extent they should profess it, as far as the tradition of the divine Books records, and the form of the Council of Nicaea, just as all the pontiffs beforehand preached: as both the chapters inserted fittingly into their first Council of Ephesus, by which in the times of the blessed Pope Celestinus the Nestorian plague was extinguished, and the chapters appended to the letters given to Leo of august memory by the holy memory of Pope Leo, testify: consulting that man also with the bishops of the whole East, and receiving their responses and subscriptions concerning the approval of the Council of Chalcedon, he by no means suffered those things to be changed; whereby he more greatly considered with a Christian mind that this also is true, which had harmonized everywhere with the divine assertions of the catholic teachers of the whole world, said in agreement long before a question of this kind arose; and therefore that those things which stood condemned by right must not be dug up again by any repetition: lest not only the present cause extend into the exile of the whole catholic name, but also [give occasion] to all the rest of resuming public wars
pandatur occasio, si quolibet modo, quod semel a veteribus universaliter decisum est, retractetur: uti esse jam pervidetis Alexandrinae Ecclesiae perversorem, funesta diu impunitate grassantem, vestris praeceptionibus, quibus merito dudum probatur ejectus, esse nihilominus abigendum.
An non ipse est per triginta annos catholicae desertor Ecclesiae, inimicorumque ejus sectator et doctor, et ad fundendum sanguinem semper velox fuit et promptus? Nunquid ad hanc istam dissimulationem sumus quadam ex conviventia [conniventia] praeceptoris? In quo revera non est opus discussione subtili; quia ejus aperta sunt crimina. Dolet certe pietas tua, quod per diuturnos partis alternae gravesque conflictus multi ex hoc sæculo videantur ablati aut baptismatis aut communionis expertes. Sub hoc ergo praesule ne sint baptizati, et efficiantur hæretici, et sine communione transeant, ne in perditorum pravitate deficiant: ut quemadmodum scriptum est: Cæcus cæco ducatum præbens cum eodem mergatur in foveam (Matth. xv).
An occasion must be opened up, if in any way what has once been universally decided by the ancients is reconsidered, so that, as you now clearly see, the perverter of the Alexandrian Church, who has long rampaged with deadly impunity, may nonetheless be driven out by your precepts, by which he is proved long since to have been rightly expelled.
Is he not himself the deserter of the Catholic Church for thirty years, the follower and teacher of her enemies, and always swift and ready to shed blood? Was it not through a certain connivance of the instructor that we came to this dissimulation? In this matter there is truly no need of subtle discussion, because his crimes are manifest. Your piety surely grieves that through the long-standing and grave conflicts of the opposing party many seem to have been taken from this world without baptism or communion. Therefore, under this prelate, let them not be baptized and become heretics, and pass away without communion, lest they fail in the depravity of the lost; so that, as it is written: The blind man giving guidance to the blind is plunged with him into the pit (Matthew 15).
Non est hoc, oro te, acerrimum decrevisse periculum, quando nec sauciis adhibetur firma curalio, et sanis ingeritur miseranda contagio? Nam quomodo aiunt sedari posse, si in futuro furores suos patiantur? Quid est illud dicere jam causam nullam superesse certaminis, nisi hæreticis victoria tribuatur? Proinde quibus inferri castigationis aliquid etiam corporalis, ut pater benignus, horrescis; multo clementius eorum animas non patiaris intercipi, sed pia depositione compressos tandem subdi facias catholico sacerdoti, ut veræ generationis cOetum et securum sibimet profuturae communionis auxilium consequantur. Suhjecit vobis divina providentia facultatem qua itidem effringatis opera perfidorum. Depulit ille nostrae religionis vastatorem; vos ab ejus Ecclesiae cervicibus irruptionem deturbate prædonum. Pacavit ille rempublicam (sicut vester quoque sermo testatur) a tyrannide hæretica; libertatem vos ab ipsis hæreseos præceptoribus populos eruentes Christianis restituite. Ille vos aulæ legitimae restituit imperatoris j'ire suffultos; reddite vos magistro discipulum; sedem beati Marci evangelistæ ad communionem beatissimi Petri, de vitae eorum meritis devotione reducite: ut ipso in vobis opus bonum perficiente, qui coeperit, secure audire mereamini: Qui perseveraverit usque in finem, hic salvus erit (Matth.
Is this not, I beg you, a most bitter danger to have decreed, when no firm cure is applied to the wounded, and a pitiable contagion is thrust upon the healthy? For how, they say, can matters be calmed, if in the future they suffer their own frenzies? What is it to say that no cause for struggle now remains, unless victory is granted to the heretics? Therefore, since as a kind father you shrink from having any chastisement, even bodily, inflicted on them, far more mercifully do not allow their souls to be destroyed, but, having restrained them by a pious deposition, at last cause them to be subjected to the catholic priest, so that they may obtain the assembly of true generation and the safe help of communion that will profit them. Divine providence has subjected to you the means by which you may likewise break down the works of the faithless. He has driven off the ravager of our religion; do you beat back the incursion of robbers from the necks of that Church. He has pacified the state (as your own speech also testifies) from heretical tyranny; do you restore liberty to the Christian peoples, snatching them from the very teachers of heresy. He restored you to the right of the lawful imperial court, supported by law; do you render the disciple to the master; bring back the see of the blessed evangelist Mark to communion with the most blessed Peter, by devotion according to the merits of their lives: so that, with him perfecting the good work in you who began it, you may deserve to hear securely: He who perseveres to the end, this one shall be saved (Matt.
x, 24); et ad tuæ gloriae cumulum, ita vice Dei praesideas, verendus veraciter existens Divinitatis imitator, atque adhuc in rebns lemporalibus constitutus, jam experiaris et munus in aeternam tibi beatitudinem praeparatum.
Quod vero cuncta litteris non potuerunt comprehendi quæ negotii qualitas non sinit praeteriri, quædam venerabilibus nostris fratribus et coepiscopis meis, quibus cura legationis injuncta est, proprio apud vos agenda sermone commissa sunt. Precor ut ea quaeque et audire benignus, et indifficulter annuerc, tum pro catholicae observantia veritatis, tum etiam pro regni vestri incolumitate, dignemini.
a EPISTOLA III.
AD PETRUM FULLONEM, EX SYNODO ROMANA.
Ostendit Petrum Fullonem, alias Cnapheum, non solum in Valentini, Marrichæi, Arii, Sabellii, Apollinaris et Eulychetis hæreses, verum etiam in errores gentilitatis plures deos asserentis incidisse. Deinde monet ut resipiscat9 et quod in Trisagio, Crucifixus propter nos, addere non oporteat, " ov.
and, to the sum of your glory, so preside in God's stead, truly being one to be revered, an imitator of the Godhead, and while still established in temporal things, may you already experience the gift prepared for you unto eternal blessedness.
But as for the fact that all matters could not be comprehended in letters, which the nature of the business does not allow to be passed over, certain things have been entrusted to my venerable brothers and fellow bishops, upon whom the charge of the legation has been enjoined, to be conducted before you in their own words. I pray that you deign both to hear each of these things kindly and to grant them without difficulty, both for the observance of the catholic truth and also for the safety of your kingdom.
EPISTLE III.
TO PETER THE FULLER, FROM THE ROMAN SYNOD.
He shows that Peter the Fuller, otherwise called Cnapheus, has fallen not only into the heresies of Valentinus, Marrichaeus, Arius, Sabellius, Apollinaris, and Eutyches, but also into the errors of the gentiles who assert many gods. Then he warns him to repent and that in the Trisagion it is not proper to add "Crucified for us.
I Felix episcopus Petro episcopo Antiochiæ.
Quis dabit capiti meo aquam, et oculis meis fontem lacrymarum (Ier. IX)? Qualem autem et dignum fletum adducam animæ meae, condolens Domini Salvaloris nostri Christi sanctae catholicae et apostolicae Ecclesiae? Ipsa enim plorans ploravit super filios et filias suas, et non est qui consoletur eam, ex omnibus qui diligunt eam (Thren. I). Universi tyranni et haeresiarchæ persequentes ipsam, apprehenderunt eam per te, frater honoralissime, et affligentes ipsam, facti sunt in caput ejus. Omnis decor ipsius, quantum in te est, factus est ad nihilum. Videntes inimici ejus, gavisi sunt super perditione filiorum ejus. Quos enim foverat, quos enutrierat, quos ad mensuram aetatis produxerat, lacteque paverat, propheticis et apostolicis doctrinis, hos tu uno temporis momento veneno necasti. Quemadmodum enim qui piscationem sectantur, hamum esca contegunt, et ex improviso capiunt pisces: sic et tu angelicae laudationi additionem induxisti, et trisagiae deprecationi, quasi pietatis obtentu, diram impietatem excogitasti. Ex pluribus enim Orientalibus provinciis litteras suscepimus, significantes nobis quomodo veneratio tua dudum sopitum Valentiniani dogma resumpsit, et irritatur a vobis Salvatoris incarnatio; quodque in Manichæorum dogma et Arii, et Apollinaris, Paulique Samosateni incidistis.
I, Felix, bishop, to Peter, bishop of Antioch.
Who will give water to my head, and a fountain of tears to my eyes? But what kind of lament, and one worthy of it, shall I bring to my soul, grieving for the holy catholic and apostolic Church of our Lord and Savior Christ? For she herself has wept and wept over her sons and daughters, and there is no one to console her, from among all who love her. All the tyrants and heresiarchs who persecute her have laid hold of her through you, most honorable brother, and afflicting her, they have become her head. All her beauty, as far as lies in you, has been brought to nothing. Her enemies, seeing this, have rejoiced over the destruction of her children. For those whom she had cherished, whom she had nourished, whom she had brought up to the measure of maturity, and fed with milk—with the teachings of the prophets and apostles—these you have slain in a single moment of time with poison. For just as those who pursue fishing cover the hook with bait and catch fish unexpectedly, so too you have introduced an addition to the angelic praise, and to the Thrice-Holy supplication, under the guise, as it were, of piety, you have devised a dreadful impiety. For from many Eastern provinces we have received letters, informing us how your Reverence has revived the long-dormant dogma of Valentinian, and the incarnation of the Savior is being provoked by you; and that you have fallen into the dogma of the Manichaeans, and of Arius, and of Apollinaris, and of Paul of Samosata.
Dicere enim unigenitum Filium et Dominum nostrum Christum Jesum perfectum non esse in deitate, atque in humanitate perrectum, nec ipsum subisse passionem crucis, sed unam Verbi Dei naturam incarnatam, corpusque Domini sine anima et mente, Apollinaris hæresim roborat. Ille enim ignoravit, quod ab ipsis mundi nascentis exordiis primum anima primi parentis nostri mortua est, vel in mortem praecipitata est, atque ita demum corpus. Dictum quippe illi est a Deo: In quacunque die comederitis de ligno scientiæ boni et mali, morte moriemini (Gen. II). Itaque juxta latam in illum a Deo sententiam, in ipsa secundum animam mortuus est. Nam ipsius corporis mors post nongentos et triginta annos contigit. Itaque donum non dimidiatum fecit, sed totum simul Adam ex utero Virginis sumpsit, ut etiam perditum, totum salvum faceret. Idcirco et Dominus ipse dicebat: Ego animam meam pro ovibus pono (loan. x). Valentini item et Marcionis, Manichæorumque ac I gentilium innovare vis dogmata. Si enim Deus est, qui divisibiliter atque substantialiter est mortuus, similiter sanctus Spiritus Deus, et ipse divisibiliter ac substantialiter invenietur; sicque juxla tuam at illorum rationem, tres dii erunt, ac per hoc plurium deorum invalescet error: quantumque in te est, evacuabitur illud: Audi Israel, Dominus Deus tuus, Dominus unus est (Deut. iv).
For to say that the only-begotten Son and our Lord Christ Jesus was not perfect in deity and complete in humanity, and that he himself did not undergo the passion of the cross, but that there is one incarnate nature of the Word of God, and that the body of the Lord was without soul and mind, strengthens the heresy of Apollinaris. For he did not know that from the very first beginnings of the world being born, the soul of our first parent first died, or was cast down into death, and only then the body. For it was said to him by God: On whatever day you eat of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil, you shall die the death (Gen. 2). And so, according to the sentence passed upon him by God, he died in that very moment according to the soul. For the death of his body came to pass after nine hundred and thirty years. Therefore he did not make a gift that was half-measured, but Adam took the whole at once from the womb of the Virgin, so that he might save the whole, even that which was lost. For this reason the Lord himself also said: I lay down my soul for the sheep (John 10). You wish to renew the dogmas of Valentinus likewise, and of Marcion, and of the Manichaeans and the Gentiles. For if God is he who died divisibly and substantially, similarly the Holy Spirit is God, and he too will be found to be divisible and substantial; and thus according to your reasoning and theirs, there will be three gods, and by this the error of many gods will prevail; and as much as lies in you, that saying will be made void: Hear, Israel, the Lord your God, the Lord is one (Deut. 4).
Item quod ait Jeremias: Hic Deus noster, non reputabitur alius ad eum (Baruch. m). Similiter et Dominus: Ut cognoscant te solum verum Deum (Joan. XVII). Cumque Scriptura unum Deum, sanctam et individuam Trinitatem praedicet, tu et bi qui ante te fuerunt haeresiarchae, tres Deos dogmatizare ausi estis, alium quidem dicentes Deum Patrem præter Filium, et alium Deum Filium praeter Patrem; rursusque alium Deum Spiritum sanctum præter Patrem et Filium. Atque atium quidem morlalem et noviter genitum, i olium vero æternum atquc immortalem. In his autem noxiis verbis tuis, contraria sentire vis Patribus qui in Nicæa, et qui in Constantinopoli atque Chalcedone convenerunt, qui et consubstantialem roborarunt, et unam deitatem Patris et Filii sanciique Spiritus prædicarunt, atque Arii amentiam confuderunt. At vero tu in ecclesia ausus es dicere, quod unus increatæ atque individuæ Trinitatis passionem subiit: et per hoc consubstantialem quoque solvere niteris, ac Deum subjicere numero. Si enim unus sanctæ Trinitatis et coæternus, qui crucifixus cst Deus, hoc [hic] est Filius: sunt autem duo S. Trinitalis, Pater ct Spiritus sanctus: dicuntur autem dii, et non (ut habet vera ratio) Dens, sicut tradiderunt nobis, qui ipsi inspexerunt, et ministri fuerunt verbi (Actor. I), inveniris quoque consubstantialem solvere.
Likewise, what Jeremiah says: "This is our God, no other will be reckoned beside him." Similarly also the Lord: "That they may know you, the only true God." And since Scripture proclaims one God, the holy and undivided Trinity, you and those who were heresiarchs before you have dared to dogmatize three Gods, saying indeed that God the Father is one apart from the Son, and that God the Son is another apart from the Father; and again that God the Holy Spirit is another apart from the Father and the Son. And that one is mortal and newly begotten, while the other is eternal and immortal. But in these harmful words of yours you wish to hold a view contrary to the Fathers who assembled at Nicaea, and at Constantinople, and at Chalcedon, who both confirmed the consubstantial and proclaimed one deity of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit, and confounded the madness of Arius. But you in the church have dared to say that one of the uncreated and undivided Trinity underwent the passion: and by this you also strive to dissolve the consubstantial, and to subject God to number. For if the one who was crucified, God, is one of the holy Trinity and coeternal, this is the Son; but there are two of the holy Trinity, the Father and the Holy Spirit: yet they are called gods, and not (as true reason holds) God, as those handed down to us who themselves beheld and were ministers of the word. You are found also to dissolve the consubstantial.
Quippe mortale ct immortale consubstantialia jam esse non possunt: roborabitur autem sic plura. litas dcorum, dum tres dii Christianis auribus ingeruntur. Cum itaque scriptum sit, Verbum caro factum est, et Deus erat Verbum (Joan. I); non alius Deus Verbum praeter Patrem invenietur: Verbum non simpliciter, sed Verbum substantiale; et Deus Filius invenietur, ut ex vilitate nostra, identitatem substantiæ Patris et Verbi et sancti Spiritus agnoscamus. Non enim nos alii praeter verbum nostrum inveniemur. Quoniam igitur unigcnitus Dei Filius, qua ratione Verbum est, in propria substantia non poterit pati, ne ad omnipotentis Dei Patris substantiam passio referatur ( est enim una Patris et Filii et sancii Spiritus deitas); patutur autem proprium animatum corpus, quod ipsum substantiale Dei Verbum ex ipsa sanctae et intemeratæ Virginis vulva sibi conjungens, ex muliere processit, de qua sancto Spiritu afflati prophetæ cecinerunt: Deus virtutum convertere, respice de cœlo, et vide, et visita vitem istam; et perfice eam, quam plantavit dextera tua; et super filiutn hominis, quem confirmasti tibi (Psal. LXXIX): vitem et filium hominis, quem confirmavit Verbum, ut inferni claustra contereret, et vivificaret eo! qui a sæculo mortui sunt, salutarem Verbi incarnationem vocans. Idcirco et Dominus dicebat discipulis suis i Ego sum vitis, vos autem palmites, et Pater meus agricola est (Joan.
For mortal and immortal cannot now be consubstantial; but in this way the plurality of gods will be strengthened, while three gods are dinned into Christian ears. And so, since it is written, "The Word was made flesh, and God was the Word" (John 1), the Word will not be found to be another God besides the Father: the Word not simply, but the substantial Word; and the Son will be found to be God, so that from our lowliness we may recognize the identity of the substance of the Father and of the Word and of the Holy Spirit. For we too will not be found to be other than our word. Since, therefore, the only-begotten Son of God, insofar as he is the Word, cannot suffer in his own substance—lest the passion be referred to the substance of God the Father almighty (for the Godhead of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit is one)—yet he suffers his own animate body, which the substantial Word of God himself, joining it to himself from the very womb of the holy and undefiled Virgin, brought forth from a woman, of whom the prophets, inspired by the Holy Spirit, sang: "O God of hosts, turn, look down from heaven, and see, and visit this vine; and perfect it, which your right hand has planted; and upon the son of man, whom you have confirmed for yourself" (Psalm 79): the vine and the son of man, whom the Word confirmed, that he might shatter the bars of hell and give life to those who have been dead from the beginning of the world, calling this the saving incarnation of the Word. Therefore the Lord also said to his disciples: "I am the vine, you are the branches, and my Father is the husbandman" (John
XV); et, Tradetur Filius hominis in manibus peccatorum (Matth. xxvi). Patris enim intimum substantiale Verbum ac Deus, per sanctae Virginis aures illapsum, conceptionem ineffabiliter operatum est. Qua igitur parte uuigenitus Filius est consubstanlialis Patri, et unus individuæ Trinitatis, increatus atque invisibilis, impassibilis et immortalis permansit. Quod ergo increatum atque immortale est, creaturæ ne applices, nequc deorum pluralitatem confirmare pergas, dicens unum S. Trinitatis mortuum esse. Rursus, qua parte ex muliere natum est, et substantiae nostræ ac generationis est particeps absque peccato, subtinuit passionem. Porro, quod non modo consubstantialis, verum etiam cognatus secundum carnem sit nobis Filius Dei, docet ipse Dominus, nunc quidem in Evangelio his qui in se crediderant dicens: Ego sum vitis, vos palmites (Joan. xv); nunc autem in Psalmis: Annuntiabo Momen tuum fratribus meis (Psal. xxi). Unde autem libi tam pessima superhia subrepere potuit, ut te ipsis quoque sanctis angelis intelligentiorem sapientioremque putares? Super his ingemisco, in his plango inimicos crucis Christi, quorum finis perditio, et quorum Deus venter est, et gloria in confusione ipsorum (Philip. III). Non cogitasti quod scandalizare vel unum solum ex his qui credunt in Domiuum nostrum Jesum Christum, quam gravi crucialui facit obnoxium?
and, The Son of man shall be delivered into the hands of sinners. For the inmost substantial Word of the Father and God, having slipped in through the ears of the holy Virgin, wrought conception ineffably. Therefore, in that part wherein the only-begotten Son is consubstantial with the Father and one of the undivided Trinity, He remained uncreated and invisible, impassible and immortal. What therefore is uncreated and immortal, do not apply to a creature, nor continue to confirm the plurality of gods by saying that one of the Holy Trinity died. Again, in that part wherein He was born of a woman and is a partaker of our substance and generation without sin, He underwent suffering. Moreover, that the Son of God is not only consubstantial but also akin to us according to the flesh, the Lord Himself teaches, now indeed in the Gospel to those who had believed in Him, saying: I am the vine, you are the branches; now in the Psalms: I will declare Your name to my brethren. But whence could such a most wicked pride creep upon you, that you should think yourself more understanding and wiser even than the holy angels themselves? Over these things I groan, over these I weep for the enemies of the cross of Christ, whose end is destruction, and whose God is their belly, and whose glory is in their confusion. Did you not consider that to scandalize even one single one of those who believe in our Lord Jesus Christ makes one liable to how heavy a torment?
Sed incaute, ut serpens Evæ, tu ipse quoque erroris venena mullitudini fidelium atque auribus infudisti, traditamque ab augelis sanctissimam laudationis formam corrupisti, inserens illi: Qui crucifixus es pro nobis. Ergone non advertisti Quod Paulum Samosatenum, Photinumque et Ariemium impietate transcenais, qui duos Dei filios posuerunt, unum quidem ante sæcula, alterum vero novitcr natum, cum ipse quoque Trinitati invexeris pluralitatem, duos Dei filios dicens, unum fortem, alterum crucifixum Adbaec fidelissimum Christi gregem in Manichaei opinionem præcipitare contendis, qui1 Spiritum sanctum asserii crucifixum. Nain quod post illud, sanctus immortalis, quod est Spiritus sanctus, tunc infers, Qui pro nobis crucifixus es, miserere nobis; qualernitalemque, non Trinitatem, populo insinuare videris. Nempe si ex humana traditione manasset haec laus, non ita incaute ct ucem insereres laudi, in qua filii appellatio, fortis scilicet, ponitur. Quoniam vero ab angelis nobis laus ista profluxit, qui ante crucem dicebant, Sanctus, sanctus, sanctus (Isai. VI); sicut respicere lsaias meruit; post crucem vero cum laude clamabant: Sanctus Deus, sanctus fortis, sanctus immortalis.
But you too, like the serpent to Eve, have heedlessly poured the poisons of error into the multitude of the faithful and into their ears, and have corrupted the most holy form of praise handed down by the angels, inserting into it: Who was crucified for us. Did you not then notice that you surpass in impiety Paul of Samosata, Photinus, and Arius, who posited two sons of God, one indeed before the ages, but the other newly born, since you yourself also have introduced a plurality into the Trinity, saying there are two sons of God, one strong, the other crucified? And now you strive to cast down the most faithful flock of Christ into the opinion of Manichaeus, who asserts that the Holy Spirit was crucified. For in that after this, Holy, immortal, which is the Holy Spirit, you then add, Who was crucified for us, have mercy on us, you seem to instill into the people a quaternity, not a Trinity. Surely if this praise had come from human tradition, you would not have so heedlessly inserted into the praise that phrase in which the appellation of Son, namely the strong one, is placed. But since this praise flowed to us from the angels, who before the cross were saying, Holy, holy, holy (Isa. 6), as Isaiah was worthy to behold; after the cross indeed they were crying out with praise: Holy God, holy strong, holy immortal.
a Denique cum terræmotu Constantinopolis quateretur, populusque in campo oraret, infantulus, toto populo spectante cum Proclo civitatis episcopo, in coelum per unam horam raptus est, ibique hujusmodi didicit bymnum. Rursumque descendens, nuntiavit quae in æthere audierat, diceos de coelo quasi de multitudine psallentium, hujusmodi laudes insonuisse auribus suis, dictumque sibi ut eam laudationem poputo indicaret. Quam ubi populi incoeperant, civitatem receperunt; Dcoque per hujusmodi laudem propitio facto, ab imminenti ira liberali sunt. At tu quam temere, ut Scripturas divinas reliquas, ita et angelorum laudem pervertere praesumpsisti? Quis igitur in hujusmodi non ingemiscat? quis non lamentetur? quis dolor sinatis invenietur, sicut dolor Ecclesiae Domini et Salvatoris nostri Christi? Conspice te constitutum, ut sis lumen his qui in tenebris sunt, et eruj ditor insipientium (Rom. II, 5): imo insipienlia praeceptor es, lucem in tenebras transferens. Vide a te populos semel illuminatos, qui bona gustaverunt Dei verba, Dei mandata, Dei propbetias, prædicationes Dei, apostolicas evangelicasque doctrinas, abs te perverti magis, ac doceri non solum crucifigere Filium Dei et ostentui habere, verum et contraria sentire Scripturis divinis, et pacta abnegare quae acce. dentes ad sanctum baptisma fecerunt.
Finally, when Constantinople was shaken by an earthquake and the people were praying in the field, a little child, in the sight of the whole people and with Proclus the bishop of the city present, was caught up into heaven for one hour, and there learned a hymn of this kind. And descending again, he reported what he had heard in the ether, saying that from heaven, as if from a multitude singing psalms, praises of this kind had sounded in his ears, and that he had been told to make that praise known to the people. And when the people had begun it, they recovered the city; and God, being made propitious by praise of this kind, they were freed from the imminent wrath. But you, how rashly have you presumed to pervert, like the other divine Scriptures, so also the praise of the angels? Who, then, would not groan over such things? Who would not lament? What grief will be found like the grief of the Church of the Lord and of our Savior Christ? Consider that you have been appointed to be a light to those who are in darkness, and an instructor of the foolish (Rom. 2:5): nay rather, you are a teacher of folly, transferring light into darkness. See that the peoples once enlightened by you, who tasted the good words of God, the commandments of God, the prophecies of God, the preachings of God, the apostolic and evangelical doctrines, are by you rather perverted, and taught not only to crucify the Son of God and hold him up to contempt, but also to think things contrary to the divine Scriptures, and to deny the covenants which they made when they came to holy baptism.
Nam cum coram coelestibus virtutibus omnibus, coram apostolicis evangelicisque ordinibus, sancti baptismatis tempore promiserint credere in unum Deum omnipotentem, nunc illos in tres deos credere docuisti. Rursum, cum polliciti sint credere in unum Dominum Jesum Christum Filium Dei incarnatum, et hominem factum de Spiritu sancto et Maria Virgine; tu eos doces ne dicant Dominum Jesum Christum Filium Dei cruccm perpessum esse, qui Deus est secundum sempiternam et impassibilem ex parte generationem, et idem homo secundum eam qua in novissimis diebus ex matre prodiit, secundum quam etiam sustinuit passionem: sed unum Trinitatis mortuum esse, qui est ipsum Dei Verbum. Confessi sunt rursus Spiritum sanctum, vivilicum et immortalem, dicentes credere in Spiritum sanctum, dominum et vivificantem; et mortalem esse ponis Spiritum sanctum, cum dicis: Sanctus immortalis, qui crucifixus es pro nobis. Fuge, obsecro, hujusmodi errorem. Corruisti, noli in ruina persistere. Peccasti, jam peccare noli. ExspecLat te sancta Dei Ecclesia, cupit amplecti pœnitentem in vanis propositionibus tuis, et secum de Christo divina praedicantem, neque negantem ipsius animatam incarnationem: secundum quam etiam passus esse memoratur, clamatque tibi per nos: Venite ad me, omnes, qui laboratis, et ego reficiam vos (Matth. XI).
For when, in the presence of all the heavenly powers, in the presence of the apostolic and evangelical orders, at the time of holy baptism they promised to believe in one God almighty, you have now taught them to believe in three gods. Again, when they promised to believe in one Lord Jesus Christ, the Son of God incarnate and made man of the Holy Spirit and the Virgin Mary, you teach them not to say that the Lord Jesus Christ, the Son of God, suffered the cross—he who is God according to his eternal and impassible generation from the Father, and the same is man according to that by which in the last days he came forth from his mother, according to which he also endured the passion—but that one of the Trinity died, who is the very Word of God. Again, they confessed the Holy Spirit, life-giving and immortal, saying that they believe in the Holy Spirit, the Lord and giver of life; and you set forth the Holy Spirit as mortal, when you say: Holy, immortal, who was crucified for us. Flee, I beseech you, from this kind of error. You have fallen, do not persist in ruin. You have sinned, sin no more. The holy Church of God awaits you, desires to embrace you when you repent of your vain propositions, and to have you proclaim divine things with her concerning Christ, and not deny his animated incarnation, according to which he is also remembered to have suffered; and she cries to you through us: Come to me, all you who labor, and I will refresh you (Matthew 11).
Non vult Deus, frater carissime, mortem peccatoris; sed ut convertatur, et vivat (Ezech. XVIII). Memor esto, Jesum Christum rusurrexisse a mortuis (II Tim. II), secundum Evangelium. Memento beati Matthæi scribentis: Liber generationis Jesu Christi filii David, filii Abraham (Matth. I). Recordare quid Paulus scribat: Segregatus in Evangelium Dei, quod promiserat ipse Deus in Scripturis sanctis de Filio suo, qui fuctus eat ei ex semine David secundum carnem, qui prædestinatus est Filius Dei (Rom. I). Memento etiam Joannis clamantis: In principio erat Verbum, et Verbum erat apud Deum, sicut enim est, et Deus erat Verbum (Joan. I); quodque caro factum est, homine assumpto, et quod Deum nemo vidit unquam (Joan. I, 18).Hæc tibi scripsi una cum praesente synodo, conveniens te coram
Deo et sanctis angelis, ut ea doceas, ea nobiscum senlias; ut illibata fides nostra permaneat in gloriam Dei.
God does not will the death of the sinner, dearest brother, but that he be converted and live (Ezek. XVIII). Remember that Jesus Christ rose from the dead (II Tim. II), according to the Gospel. Remember what the blessed Matthew wrote: The book of the generation of Jesus Christ, the son of David, the son of Abraham (Matt. I). Recall what Paul writes: Set apart for the Gospel of God, which God himself had promised in the holy Scriptures concerning his Son, who was made for him of the seed of David according to the flesh, who was predestined the Son of God (Rom. I). Remember also John crying out: In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, as indeed he is, and the Word was God (John I); and that the Word was made flesh, man having been assumed, and that no one has ever seen God (John I, 18). I have written these things to you together with the present synod, admonishing you before God and the holy angels, that you teach these things and hold them with us, so that our faith may remain unblemished to the glory of God.
EPISTOLA IV.
AD EUMDEM.
etrus Fullo I.deponitur et anathematizatur.
Quoniam importabilibus verbis impie garrulasti, et non judicasti cedere praedictis sanctis Patribus, qui ornarunt sedem beatæ memoriæ multum triumphantis Ignalii martyris, cujus tu indignus existens, nescio. quomodo insiluisti inchoare novitatem in catholica Ecclesia tuis profanis legibus et impiis dogmatibus, et judicasti non oportere dicere Christum crucifixum propter nos sed passionem ideo impassibili impie induxisti, et immortali Patri mortem imponere, et non horruisti ea quae non suscepisti ex divinis Evangeliis et apostolis, probatissimisque et gloriosis Patribus, pessime sophisticatus ipsa intorquere, et propriam pestem sensus imponere simplicioribus, scandatum hujuscemodi haeresis, non ut æqualiter prioribus haeresibusvigeat, sed magis multipliciter excellat; et non statuisti credere veritati, et [Supple binis] litteris nostris ad te scriptis, nunc incœpi senlenliare contra te: imo ille qui vertex est omnium pastoralium sedium, in sanctis laudibus florens, apostolorum vere optimus Petrus, cujus tu nomine æqualis es, sed non opinione, neque fide, quoniam ab istius recta intentione, et immaculata fide valdc declinasti.
EPISTLE IV.
TO THE SAME.
And Peter the Fuller is deposed and anathematized.
Because with intolerable words you have impiously babbled, and have not judged it right to yield to the aforesaid holy Fathers, who adorned the see of the blessed memory of the much-triumphant martyr Ignatius, of whom, being unworthy, I know not how you have leapt in to begin a novelty in the catholic Church by your profane laws and impious dogmas, and have judged that one ought not to say that Christ was crucified for our sake, but on that account you have impiously introduced a passion into the impassible one, and imposed death upon the immortal Father, and you have not shuddered to twist most wickedly, by your sophistry, those things which you did not receive from the divine Gospels and the apostles and the most approved and glorious Fathers, and to impose the plague of your own understanding upon the simpler sort, a scandal of this kind of heresy, not that it might flourish equally with the former heresies, but that it might abound all the more manifoldly; and you have not stood firm to believe the truth, and by our letters written to you, now I have begun to write against you: nay rather, he who is the summit of all pastoral sees, flourishing in holy praises, the truly best of the apostles, Peter, whose name you are equal to, but not in repute, nor in faith, since from his right intention and immaculate faith you have greatly declined.
Et non solum contra te sententio, sed et contra eos qui non erubuerunt characteres venerabilium evangelistarum, et npostolorum eos sequentium, ac perfectorum doctorum sermones: et instabili sententia ex tua iniqua expositione firmati sunt: tanquam dulcissima circumsequendi in mala opinione, quod vere amarissimum est, et non averterunt hujusmodi impietatem. Dicemus ergo tibi, sicut et contra illos: Quoniam dilexisti iniquitatem magis loqui quam justitiam, dilexisti super omnia prœcipitationis linguam dolosam [Juxta Græc., omnia verba præcipitationis, linguam dolosam: propter hoc Deus destrue' te in finem (Psal. LI); et non solum ab Antiochena Ecclesia, sed ab omni civitate deponet: et firma sit haec tua depositio a me, et ab his qui una mecum apostolicum thronum regunt, et ab Acacio Constantinopolitanæ Ecclesiae pastore, et a venerabilibus episcopis sibi subjectis, quoniam ipsorum monimenta non sustinuisti. Quandoque enim dicis Trinitatem propter nos crucifixam, non Christum; quandoque autem immortalem Spiritum, manichaizans; quandoque ab istis diffugiens, meis argumentis reprehensus et sermonibus. dixisti Christum, post immor. talem Spiritum, passionem sustinuisse, sicut Samosatenus et Nestorius, unum Filium dividentes in dualitatem filiorum.
And I have passed sentence not only against you, but also against those who have not blushed to set up the characters of the venerable evangelists and of the apostles who followed them, and the discourses of the perfect teachers, and who have been confirmed by unstable judgment from your iniquitous exposition, as though most sweetly following after in evil opinion—which is truly most bitter—and have not turned away from such impiety. We shall therefore say to you, as also against them: Because you have loved iniquity more than to speak righteousness, you have loved above all things a precipitating and deceitful tongue. For this cause God shall destroy you unto the end; and he shall remove you not only from the Church of Antioch, but from every city; and let this your deposition be firm from me, and from those who with me govern the apostolic throne, and from Acacius, pastor of the Church of Constantinople, and from the venerable bishops subject to him, because you have not endured their records. For at one time you say that the Trinity was crucified for us, not Christ; at another time the immortal Spirit, playing the Manichaean; at another time, fleeing from these things and refuted by my arguments and words, you have said that Christ, after the immortal Spirit, suffered passion, like Samosatenus and Nestorius, dividing the one Son into a duality of sons.
Quandoque autem et his cessisti non detrectando, et venisti ad pejus, non glorificando cherubicum hymnum, ad Filium referre præstolanti tremore venerabiliter similiter Trinitatem, # sed totum bymnum ad Filium referre, volens firmare morbum cancri rodentis, quem innocentibns intulisti; et inde omnis generis hæresium laqueis circumpræcipitatus, a veritate exiens, non praedicas Christum pro nobis crucifixum, nec unigenitum Filium Dei, qui in medio Patris et Spiritus sancti est, pie gloriOcas. Quid enim isto magis interdictum, Patre a vobis et sancto Spiritu non glorificato? Nam calumniam seraphim vos infertis, qui Trinitatem non dicitis glurificandam, Sanctus, sanctus, sanctus, sed solum personaliter Filium. Et quae præcipitatio hæresium ita confundit, id est impudenter egit, sicut vos? Verumtamen et in isto percurrens adhuc novius [AI., nocentius] ascendistis, et strangulandas infamias a Deo adjicitis, Filium videlicet, Patrem, et sanctum Spiritum, sabellianizantes, simul conjungere judicantes. Trinitatem confiteri negatis, in qua baptizamur, et credimus, et confitemur.
At some point, however, you yielded to these things too, not by refusing, and you came to something worse, not by glorifying the cherubic hymn, which awaits reverently with trembling to refer the Trinity equally to the Son, but by referring the whole hymn to the Son, wishing to confirm the disease of the gnawing cancer that you inflicted on the innocent; and from there, hurled headlong by the snares of every kind of heresy, departing from the truth, you do not preach Christ crucified for us, nor do you piously glorify the only-begotten Son of God, who is in the midst of the Father and the Holy Spirit. For what is more forbidden than this, when the Father and the Holy Spirit are not glorified by you? For you bring a false accusation against the seraphim, since you do not say that the Trinity is to be glorified—Holy, holy, holy—but only the Son in person. And what headlong plunge of heresies so confounds, that is, has so shamelessly acted, as you do? Yet even in this, running on, you have ascended to something still newer, and you add to God infamies that must be strangled, namely, joining together the Son, the Father, and the Holy Spirit in Sabellian fashion, judging that they are to be confessed as one. You refuse to confess the Trinity, in which we are baptized, and believe, and confess.
Quis ergo non defleret sic dicentes de intemerato trisagio, quod mihi valde convenit refulare, et fletum merito dare in hos animarum simplicium cavillatorcs, ac impium facinus fingentes: quos et alienos putavimus ab orthodoxa fide et catholica Ecclesia, et a communione ducis nostri gloriosi præcessoris Petri, qui claves regni a Salvatore nostro recepit? Qui autem participes aposloli esse volunt, ducuntur et doctrina ipsius, qui Christum dicit et credit propter nos crucifixum, et hoc non negat, sicut et modo depositus Petrus, ex eo quod non legitime et inclementer in trisagio adinnovavit: Qui crucifixus est propter nos; scientes quia Lon Trinitatem crucifixam ab apostolis suscepistis, non Patrem, non Spiritum sanctum, nisi carne Filium Dei unigenitum solum. Fugite ergo ab hac inclementi communione, et ero vobis communicans, in quantum et vos mihi, dolosa fallacia longe a nostra orthodoxia expulsa. Custodite, Christi discipuli, mei autem filii, traditiones quas a diviuis Scripturis accepistis.
Who, then, would not weep over those who speak thus about the undefiled Trisagion—a matter that it greatly behooves me to expose—and rightly give tears to these mockers of simple souls, who invent an impious deed? We have reckoned them alien from the orthodox faith and the catholic Church, and from communion with our glorious leader and predecessor Peter, who received the keys of the kingdom from our Savior. But those who wish to be partakers with the apostle are also led by his teaching—he who says and believes that Christ was crucified for us, and does not deny this, just as Peter has now been deposed for this reason: that he unlawfully and harshly added to the Trisagion, "Who was crucified for us"—knowing that you have received from the apostles that the Trinity was crucified, not the Father, not the Holy Spirit, but only the only-begotten Son of God in the flesh. Flee, therefore, from this harsh communion, and I will be in communion with you, insofar as you also are with me, with deceitful falsehood driven far from our orthodoxy. Keep, disciples of Christ—and my sons—the traditions which you have received from the divine Scriptures.
a EPISTOLA
EJUSDEM FELICIS PAPÆ III AD PETRUM EPISCOPUM ANTIOCHENUM, VERSIO ANTIQUA.
Petrus Antiochenus deponitur et anathematizatur.
Quoniam pesliferis doctrinis imbulus et impietate verborum non curasti sequi præordinatos sanctos Patres qui sedem beatæ memoriæ Ignatii gloriosi martyris ordinaverunt, quo etiam cum sis indignus, nescio quemadmodum adeptus fueris principatum, et sceleribus tuis profanis, impiisque dogmatibus inferre putaveris Ecclesiae catholicæ novitatem, ut non propter nos Christum crucifixum dicas, sed passionem impassibili Deo iniquissime intulisti, et immortali spiritui mortem apponere praesumpsisti. Nec exterritus es, quae tibi a sanctis Evangeliis et apestolis et viris beatissimis ac probatissimis Patribus tradita non sunt, sed callidis haec commentis astruere, et sensum proprii languoris, et hujus haereseos scandalum simplicioribus inculcare, ita ut nec similis prioribus videatur haeresibus, sed multipliciter potius hæc transcendant: nec ambulare in veritate; nec nostris duanus epistolis aurem voluisti commodare.
LETTER OF THE SAME FELIX, POPE III, TO PETER, BISHOP OF ANTIOCH, OLD VERSION.
Peter of Antioch is deposed and anathematized.
Because, imbued with pestilential doctrines and with the impiety of your words, you have not taken care to follow the holy Fathers preordained, who established the see of the blessed memory of Ignatius, the glorious martyr—although you are unworthy even of it, I do not know how you obtained the primacy—and you have thought to bring novelty to the catholic Church by your profane crimes and impious dogmas, so that you do not say that Christ was crucified on our account, but most iniquitously you have imputed the passion to the impassible God, and you have presumed to attach death to the immortal Spirit. Nor were you terrified that these things were not handed down to you by the holy Gospels and apostles and the most blessed and most approved Fathers, but you have sought to build them up with cunning fabrications, and to press upon simpler souls the sense of your own sickness and the scandal of this heresy, so that it does not even seem like the earlier heresies, but rather transcends them in many ways; nor to walk in the truth; nor have you wished to lend your ear to our letters.
Nunc igitur sum exorsus adversum te proferre sententiam (magis autem summus princeps apostolorum Petrus, qui inter sanctorum apostolorum praeconia veridicus est), et non solum adversum te (qui ejus nominis, non sententiae neque fidei parem te esse cognoscens, quoniam ultra modum ab ejus intentione recta inviolabill fide deviasti), sed etiam adversus eos qui, non erubescentes Evangeliorum venerabiles characteres, neque horum sequacium apostolornm praefectorumque virorum doctorumque sermones, inconstanti sententia iniquis traditionibus Luis incumbunt. Ita ut malae sectæ deleciabiliter revcra sequantur amaritudinen, nec hujusmodi exsecrabilem aversantur impietatem. Dicimus ergo tibi sicut etiam illis; quoniam dilexisti malitiam super benignitatem, iniquitatem magis quam loqui aequitatem. Dilexisti omnia verba præcipitationis, et linguam dolosam; propterea destruet te Deus in finem, non solum ab Antiochenæ Ecclesiae sede, sed etiam ab omni civitate.
Now therefore I have begun to pronounce sentence against you (or rather the chief prince of the apostles, Peter, who among the heralds of the holy apostles is truthful), and not only against you (who, knowing yourself to be equal to his name but not to his mind or faith, since beyond measure you have deviated from his upright intention and inviolable faith), but also against those who, not blushing at the venerable characters of the Gospels, nor at the words of these following apostles and prelates and learned men, with inconstant judgment cling to iniquitous traditions. So that in truth they delightfully follow the bitterness of an evil sect, and do not turn away from this kind of execrable impiety. We say therefore to you as also to them: because you have loved malice more than goodness, and iniquity more than to speak equity. You have loved all words of precipitation, and a deceitful tongue; therefore God will destroy you in the end, not only from the see of the Church of Antioch, but also from every city.
Etenim sit in te hæc fixa damnatio, a me et ab bis qui sub me constituti episcopales sedes gubernare noscuntur, et Acacio Constantinopolitanae Ecclesiæ paslore, et venerabilibus episcopis cjus juri subjectis tanquam et ipsis minime consentientibus tuis commentis, sic aliquando siquidem dixisti, Trinitatem propter nos crucifixam et non Cbristum, aliquando vero immortalem spiritum Manicbxi secutus errorum, aliquando autem hæc fugiens, nostrorum sermonum pignoribus increpatus, Christum post immortalem spiritum passionem sustinuisse dixisti, sicut Paulus Samosatenus, et Nestorius unum filium dividentes in dualitate filiorum, et cum bic putasti non immorandum, ad pejora venisti, ut hymni, quos Cherubim cum tremore Trinitatis incessanler emittunt, ad Trinitatem glorificandam non referantur. Sed ut totus hymnus ad Filium dedicatur, confirmare volens sententiam, velut cancer serpentem, quam adversus simplices extulisti, et binc omnium hæresum laqueis præcipitatus es, a veritate declinando, nec prædicando propter nos Christum crucifixum unigenitum Dei Filium, qui est in medio Patris et sancii Spiritus, qui glorificatur. Quid enim hoc erit damnabilius quam cum a vobis Pater et Spiritus sanctus fiat inglorius, et calumnia seraphin inferatur, quam cum non Trinitatem glorificare credatur, cum dicunt Sanctus, Sanctus, Sanctus, sed solam personam?
For let this condemnation be fixed upon you by me and by those who are known to govern episcopal sees under me, and by Acacius, pastor of the Church of Constantinople, and by the venerable bishops subject to his jurisdiction, as also by them who in no way consent to your inventions—since at one time you said that the Trinity was crucified for us and not Christ, at another time, following the error of Manichaeus, that the immortal Spirit suffered, and at another time, fleeing these things and rebuked by the pledges of our words, you said that Christ suffered after the immortal Spirit, like Paul of Samosata and Nestorius, dividing the one Son into a duality of sons. And when you thought this was not to be dwelt upon, you came to worse things, so that the hymns which the Cherubim with trembling ceaselessly utter to the Trinity are not referred to the Trinity for glorification. But as though the whole hymn is dedicated to the Son, wishing to confirm the sentence—like a serpent's cancer—which you brought forth against the simple, and from this you have been cast headlong into the snares of all heresies, by turning aside from the truth and not preaching Christ crucified for us, the only-begotten Son of God, who is in the midst of the Father and the Holy Spirit, who is glorified. For what will be more damnable than this, that by you the Father and the Holy Spirit are made inglorious, and calumny is brought upon the Seraphim, than that the Trinity is not believed to be glorified when they say Holy, Holy, Holy, but only a single person?
Quae infernalis hæresis ita crudedeliter ut vos inverecunda fuit. Verumtamen adhuc in ista discurrentes novitate usque ad fundamenta blasphemiarum Dei pertingitis Filium, Patrem et Spiritum sanctum dicentes, Sabellium sectamini, et confusionem inducitis, et Trinitatis codfessionem pariter abnegatis, in qua baptizati sumus, et credimus et fatemur. Quis ergo DOR lugeat talia dicentes de sancta et inviolabili Trinitate? boc mihi valde convenit allegare, et planctum sufficienter effundere, cum in hoc simpliciun animae fuerint captivatæ, quæ tunc rem impiam velut piam divilgaverunt, quos etiam judicamus extraneos ab orthoduxa fide, Ecclesiaque catholica, et communione gturiosi nostri principis Petri, qui c'aves regni coelorum a nostro Salvatore percepit.
What infernal heresy was so cruelly shameless toward you? Nevertheless, still running about in this newness, you reach even to the foundations of the blasphemies against God, saying that the Son, the Father, and the Holy Spirit are [one], you follow Sabellius, and you introduce confusion, and you equally deny the confession of the Trinity, in which we were baptized, and which we believe and confess. Who, then, could mourn over those saying such things about the holy and inviolable Trinity? It is very fitting for me to bring this forward and to pour out lamentation sufficiently, since the souls of the simple have been taken captive in this matter, who then spread abroad an impious thing as if pious, whom we also judge to be strangers from the orthodox faith and the catholic Church and from the communion of our glorious prince Peter, who received the keys of the kingdom of heaven from our Savior.
Qui ergo voluerint esse communicatorei npos oli, ejus quoque doctrinam sequantur, dicendo et credendo Christum propter nos crucifixum, neque eum negando, sicut Petrus, qui nuper damnatus est eo quod prave et nefarie in hymno trisagion noviter introduxit, qui crucifixus est propter nos, scientes quia non Trinitatem crucifixam ab apostolis accep siis, neque Patrem, neque Spiritum sanctum, nisi carnem Christi, Filium Dei unigenitum solum, Igitur fugite ab hnjus communione sacrilega, et ero vester socius, utque communicator, et vos quoque mei, peste dolosa a vestra rectitudine procul expulsa: custodite, Christi discipuli, mei autem filii, traditiones quas a sacris voluminibus accepistis.
Explicit epistola papae Felicis ad Petrum Antiocbenum damnans eum: quae epistola ante damnationem Acacii quantum ejus textus indicat comprehenditur scripta; sed quia cum aliorum Litteris ad eumdem Petrum directis in Græco volumine reperimus de Latino translatas, quas nunc iterum de Græco in Latinum necessitate compulsi transferentes deseri' psimns propter hæreticorum insidias, et supradictis epistolis ejusdem papæ connectimus.
Therefore let those who wish to be in communion with him also follow his doctrine, saying and believing that Christ was crucified for our sake, and not denying him, as Peter did—who was recently condemned because he wickedly and impiously newly introduced into the Trisagion hymn that he who was crucified for us, knowing that you did not receive from the apostles a crucified Trinity, nor the Father, nor the Holy Spirit, but only the flesh of Christ, the only-begotten Son of God. Therefore flee from his sacrilegious communion, and I will be your partner and fellow-communicant, and you also mine, with the deceitful plague driven far from your uprightness. Keep, disciples of Christ, but my sons, the traditions which you have received from the sacred volumes.
Here ends the letter of Pope Felix to Peter of Antioch, condemning him; which letter, as its text indicates, is understood to have been written before the condemnation of Acacius; but because we found it, together with the letters of others directed to the same Peter, translated from Greek in a Greek volume, which now again, compelled by necessity to translate them from Greek into Latin, we have left aside on account of the snares of the heretics, we join them to the above-mentioned letters of the same pope.
EPISTOLA V.
AD ZENONEM IMPERATOREM.
Nuntiat imperatori Petrum Fullonem synodali judicio sententia anathematis condemnatum, ideoque ab ejus communione abstinendum esse. Hortatur eumdem imperatorem ut Petrum depositum ex Antiochena Ecclesia expellat.
Gloriosissimo ac serenissimo filio Zenoni Augusto Felix episcopus in Domino salutem
Convenit clementiae tuae rerum ordinem nuntiare gestarum pro tranquillitate imperii serenitatis tuao, et ora suscipias precem meam ac si ipse praesens essem, benignis auribus tuis, ut Christianissimus imperat; et ncquaquam arbitretur pietas tua illum puro nos corde diligere, quicunque te pacem cum Deo habere non vult. Quoniam vero fideli mente credidisti, nec ambigis et temporalis solii potestatem, et æternæ vitæ retributionem superno ex momento pendere, per nostram etiam parvitatem dignare suscipere venerabilem ac divinam beatissimi Petri confessionem, apostolorum scilicet principis, cui et regni claves a Salvatore traditae sunt, qui etiam præparabit Christianissimo Imperio vestro locum in coelo cum sanctis angelis; quique immutabilem et immaculatam fidem in. Dominum nostrum Jesum Christum, Dei Filium unigenitum, primus exponens, a Salvatore ipso beatus est dictus. Nam cum ipse dixisset ad Dominum, Tu es Christus Filius Dei vivi (Matth.
EPISTLE V.
TO THE EMPEROR ZENO.
He announces to the emperor that Peter the Fuller has been condemned by the judgment of the synod with the sentence of anathema, and that therefore communion with him must be avoided. He urges the same emperor to expel the deposed Peter from the Church of Antioch.
To the most glorious and most serene son Zeno Augustus, Bishop Felix, greeting in the Lord.
It is fitting for your Clemency to be informed of the order of events that have taken place for the tranquility of your Serenity's empire, and may you receive my prayer with kindly ears, as if I were myself present, as a most Christian emperor does; and let not your Piety think that we love with a pure heart anyone who does not wish you to have peace with God. Since indeed you have believed with a faithful mind, and do not doubt that both the power of a temporal throne and the reward of eternal life depend upon a heavenly moment, deign also through our lowliness to receive the venerable and divine confession of the most blessed Peter, namely the prince of the apostles, to whom the keys of the kingdom were also handed by the Savior, who will also prepare a place in heaven with the holy angels for your most Christian Empire; and who, first setting forth the unchangeable and immaculate faith in our Lord Jesus Christ, the only-begotten Son of God, was himself called blessed by the Savior. For when he had said to the Lord, You are the Christ, the Son of the living God (Matt.
XVI), ab ipso audire meruit, Beatus es, Simon Bar Jona, quia caro et sanguis non revelavit tibi, sed Pater meus, qui in cœlis est: et super ista confessione ædificabo Ecclesiam meam, et portæ inferi non prævalebunt adversus eam (Ibidem). Cum ergo Salvator dixerit quod portae inferi non prævalebunt adversus ipsius Ecclesiam, ut ab ea ipsius denominationem tollant, quae dicitur Christus Jesus, et Dei omnipotentis Filius; Petrus primogenitus diaboli filius, et qui sanctæ Antiochenæ Ecclesiæ indignissime se ingessit, sanctamque sedem pontificatus Ignatii martyris pollnit, qui Petri dextra episcopus ordinatus est, Eustathiique confessoris ac praesidentis trecentorum decem et octo Patrum qui in Nicaea convenerunt, ausus est dicere non oportere Christum etiam Dei Filium nominare secundum divinam Salvatoris sanctionem et traditionem divinarum Scripturarum, Patrumque expositionem; sed unum de Trinitate passionem pro nobis pertulisse in substantia deitatis, juxta Arii, Apollinaris, Eunomiique blasphemiam, volens hac voce evacuare salutarem Domini incarnationem, secundum quam Christus et passionem subiit. Dicitur autem et unus ex nobis, ut qui Abrahæ semen apprehendit (Hebr. II); augere quoque deorum pluralitatem nititur. Quippe sensus ejus tres introducit deos, unum mortuum, ct duos viventes.
he deserved to hear from him, "Blessed are you, Simon Bar Jona, because flesh and blood did not reveal it to you, but my Father who is in heaven; and upon this confession I will build my Church, and the gates of hell shall not prevail against it" (Ibidem). Since, therefore, the Savior said that the gates of hell shall not prevail against his Church—so that they may take away from it the name of him by whom it is called, Christ Jesus, and the Son of God almighty—Peter, the firstborn son of the devil, who most unworthily thrust himself into the holy Church of Antioch and defiled the holy see of the pontificate of Ignatius the martyr, who was ordained bishop by the right hand of Peter, and of Eustathius the confessor and president of the three hundred and eighteen Fathers who assembled at Nicaea, has dared to say that Christ should not even be named the Son of God according to the divine ordinance of the Savior and the tradition of the divine Scriptures and the exposition of the Fathers; but that one of the Trinity suffered the passion for us in the substance of the Godhead, according to the blasphemy of Arius, Apollinaris, and Eunomius, wishing by this word to empty out the saving incarnation of the Lord, according to which Christ also underwent the passion. But he is also called one of us, as he who took hold of the seed of Abraham (Hebr. 2); he also strives to increase the plurality of gods. Indeed, his understanding introduces three gods: one dead, and two living.
Solvit etiam consubstantialis nomen sacrasque abjicit synodos, Nicaenam, Constantinopolitanam, et Chalcedonensem; sanctam quoque Mariam Yirginem nequaquam admittere deprehenditur. Si enim non ex ea incarnalum Verbum homo factum est, quæ necessitas virginis et quare ad eam dixisset Gabriel Quod ex te nascetur sanctum, vocabitur Filius Dei; et dabit illi Dominus Deus sedem David patris ejus (Luc. II)? Post hæc autem omnia impia et blasphemiae suæ pracsumpta, et depravationem trisagiæ deprecationis, cum illi addere voluit, Qui crucifixus est pro nobis, multa inconvenientia effecit. Multumque a nobis et in Christo dilectis fratribus nostris qui in Oriente sunt, et a venerabili Acacio vestrae regalis et a Deo amatae civitatis archiepiscopo admonitus, converti noluit. Quapropter nunc sancta Dei Ecclesia matenis te vocibus, utpote excellentem ipsius filium, alloqui noo tessat: a Christo amate imperator, meæ venerabilitatis vinculum, in quo multitudines fidelium circumstringuntur, dissolvi non permiuas; Domini autem Christi et unigeniti Filii Dei laudationem transgredi non permittas, et quae vestram civitatein periclitantem salvavit: sed tanquam angelorum traditionem indepravatam conserva. Petrum Arianae superstitionis sequacem, ab Ecclesia Antiochena expelle. Qua ex causa Petrus scindit vestem meam desuper contextam (Matth. XVI)?
He also dissolves the name of consubstantial and rejects the sacred synods, the Nicene, the Constantinopolitan, and the Chalcedonian; and he is found in no way to admit the holy Mary as Virgin. For if the Word was not made man incarnate from her, what was the necessity of the virgin, and why would Gabriel have said to her, "That which is born of you is holy, he shall be called the Son of God; and the Lord God shall give him the throne of David his father" (Luke 2)? But after all these impious things and the presumptions of his blasphemy, and the corruption of the Trisagion prayer, when he wished to add to it, "Who was crucified for us," he brought about many incongruities. And though much admonished by us and by our brothers beloved in Christ who are in the East, and by the venerable Acacius, archbishop of your royal and God-beloved city, he refused to be converted. Wherefore now the holy Church of God does not cease to address you with morning cries, as her excellent son: O emperor beloved of Christ, bond of my venerability, in whom the multitudes of the faithful are bound together, do not permit it to be dissolved; do not permit the praise of the Lord Christ and only-begotten Son of God to be transgressed, and of that which saved your city when in peril; but preserve it undefiled as the tradition of the angels. Expel Peter, follower of the Arian superstition, from the Church of Antioch. For what reason does Peter rend my garment woven from above (Matt. 16)?
Deus et Pater mandavit principi apostolorum quid vocarent Filium. Ejus unigenilus Filius in confessione primi apostolorum fundavit me, sanctus Spiritus quotidie testatus mihi, dicens: Non judica te scire aliquid, nisi Jesum Christum, et hunc crucifixum (Joan. XIX). Si autem inimici, increduli, insidiatores, qui extra vitem sunt, et qui unigenitum Filium Dei mactaverunt, lapidaverunt, vestem illius non diviserunt et Petrus fidei meæ. vestem dirupit' Portæ inferi non prævalebunt adversus me (Matth. xix), et Petrus tentat muros meos demoliri? Ego, piissime imperator, te de imperio expulsum rursus introduxi, et malignos ac inobedientes meis divinis dogmatibus dedi pro sepultura tua, viamque potentiae aperui ante te, inimicos tuos percussi una cum iniquo eorum dogmate, antiquam potentiam exquisivi tibi a Deo in altis regnante, ex quo et regnante sumpsisti. Respice ad prædecessorem tuum piissimum imperatorem Marcianum, et illius fidem libenter amplectere: hæreticam tyrannidem Petri quam citissime eradica, Valentini et Eutychetis discipulum expelle a civitate simul et ecclesiastico regimine, et a dignitate hierarchica dejectum esse sancito.
God and the Father commanded the prince of the apostles what they should call the Son. His only-begotten Son established me in the confession of the first of the apostles, the Holy Spirit testifying to me daily, saying: Do not judge yourself to know anything except Jesus Christ, and him crucified (John XIX). But if the enemies, unbelievers, ambushers, who are outside the vine, and who killed the only-begotten Son of God, stoned him, did not divide his garment, and Peter tore the garment of my faith—the gates of hell shall not prevail against me (Matthew XIX), and does Peter attempt to demolish my walls? I, most pious emperor, brought you back in after you had been expelled from the empire, and I gave the malignant and disobedient to my divine doctrines in place of your burial, and I opened the way of power before you, I struck your enemies together with their wicked dogma, I sought out for you the ancient power from God who reigns on high, from whom you also, reigning, received it. Look to your predecessor, the most pious emperor Marcian, and gladly embrace his faith: uproot the heretical tyranny of Peter as quickly as possible, expel the disciple of Valentinus and Eutyches from the city and at the same time from ecclesiastical rule, and decree that he be cast down from the hierarchical dignity.
Conspice, sanctissime fili et imperator invictissime, qualis in Chalcedonensi synodo indubitabilis defensio facta fuit, et quibus expugnavit Æschinum [juxta Græc., quæ vindicta in hostem tuum a ]; et divulgationes hæreticæ doctrinae Petri expedias. Hæc legat sancta Dei apostolica et catholica Ecclesia, ut ab ipsa propter praedictas causas depositum, ad communionem non suscipias: sed per divinos apices vestræ serenitatis ab Antiochiæ confinio propellite. Pro ipso autem constituite virum operibus sacerdolium ornantem, custodemque diligentem sanctæ Cbalcedonensis synodi, et eorum quæ in ea firmata sunt. Omnipotens Deus custodiat vestram potentiam in pace semper.
EPISTOLA VI.
AD ACACIUM.
I Acacium munere sacerdotali et fidelium communione privat.
i Felix episcopus sanctæ Ecclesiæ catholicae urbis Romae, Acacio.
Multarum transgressionum reperiris obnoxius, et in venerabilis concilii Nicæni contumelia sæpe versatus, alienarum tibi provinciarum jura temerarie vindicasti. Haereticos [supple et] pervasores, atque ab hæreticis ordinatos, et quos ipse damnaveras, atque ab apostolica institisti [id est, petisti] sede damnari, non modo communioni tuæ recipiendos putasti, verum etiam aliis Ecclesiis, quod nec de catbolicis fieri poterat praesidere fecisti; autem [lege atque] etiam honoribus, quos non merebantur,auxisti.
Behold, most holy son and most invincible emperor, what an unshakeable defense was made in the Council of Chalcedon, and by what means it vanquished Aeschinus [according to the Greek: what vengeance upon your enemy], and you may disentangle the spread of heretical doctrine from Peter. Let the holy, apostolic, and catholic Church of God read these things, so that on account of the aforesaid causes you do not receive the deposit from it into communion; but by the divine letters of your Serenity drive them away from the territory of Antioch. In his place, however, appoint a man adorning the priesthood with works, and a diligent guardian of the holy Council of Chalcedon and of the things that were confirmed in it. May Almighty God keep your power always in peace.
Letter VI.
To Acacius.
He deprives Acacius of the priestly office and the communion of the faithful.
Felix, bishop of the holy catholic Church of the city of Rome, to Acacius.
You are found liable for many transgressions, and having often engaged in insult against the venerable Council of Nicaea, you have rashly claimed for yourself the rights of provinces belonging to others. Heretics and usurpers, and those ordained by heretics, and those whom you yourself had condemned and whom you urged to be condemned by the apostolic see, you not only thought should be received into your communion, but you even caused them to preside over other churches—which could not be done even by catholics—and you also advanced them with honors that they did not deserve.
Testatur hoc Joannes, quem a catholicis Apameæ non receptum, pulsumque de Anliochia, Tyriis perfecisti: et a Humerius, tunc de diaconio dejectus, atque Christiani nominis appellatione privatus, a te etiam in presbyterii provectus officium. Etquasi hæc minora tibi viderentur, in ipsam doctrina apostolicæ vcritatem ausu superbiæ tuae [lege ausus tuos et superbiam] tetendisti: ut Petrus, quem damnatum a sanctae memoriae decessoremeo ipse retuleras, sicut testantur annexa, beati evangelistae Marci sedem te connivente (lege jubente], rursus invaderet, et fugatis orthodoxis episcopis et clericis, sui procul dubio similas ordinaret; pulsoque eo qui illic fueral regulariter constitutus, captivam teneret Ecclesiam. Cujus tibi adeo grata persona est, et ministri ejus accepti [lege ministerium ejus acceptum], ut episcopos et clericos plurimos orthodoxos, nunc [lege tunc] Constantinopolim venientes, detegaris affligere, et apocrisarios ejus confovere, atque anathematizantem eumdem Petrum Chalcedonensis decreta concilii, et violantem sanctæ memoriae Timothei sepulturam, sicut ad nos certiores nunc quoque nuntii detulerunt, per Misenum et Vitalem credideris [ lege crederes J excusandum: nec eum laudare desieris [ lege desineres], et multis efferre praeconiis, ita ut damnalionem ipsius, quam ante retuleras, veram non fuissc jactaris [lege jactares].
John testifies to this, whom you drove out from Apamea, not received by the Catholics, and expelled from Antioch among the Tyrians; and Humerius, then cast down from the diaconate and deprived of the name of Christian, was even advanced by you to the office of presbyter. And as if these things seemed too small to you, you stretched out the audacity of your pride against the very truth of the apostolic doctrine: so that Peter, whom you yourself had reported as condemned by my predecessor of holy memory, as the attached documents testify, with you conniving (read: commanding), might again invade the see of the blessed evangelist Mark, and with the orthodox bishops and clerics driven out, might ordain men undoubtedly like himself; and with him who had been regularly established there having been expelled, he might hold the Church captive. His person is so pleasing to you, and his ministry accepted, that you are revealed to be afflicting very many orthodox bishops and clerics now coming to Constantinople, and to be favoring his apocrisiarii, and you would have believed that the one anathematizing this same Peter, the decrees of the Council of Chalcedon, and violating the burial place of Timothy of holy memory—as more certain messengers have now also brought to us—was to be excused through Misenus and Vitalis; nor did you cease to praise him, and to extol him with many praises, so that you boasted that his condemnation, which you had previously reported, was not true.
Tantum autem perseveras in hominis defensione perversi, ut quondam episcopos, nunc vero honore et communione privatos, Vitalem atque Misenum, quos ad ejus expulsionem specialiter miscramus, sublatis chartis, custodiæ passus fueris mancipari; et ad processionem quae tibi cum hæreticis habetur, exinde productos, sicut eorum professione [lege professionibus] patefaclum est, ad hæreticorum tuamque communionem, contempta, quæ vel gentium jure servari debuit, legatione, pertraxeris, præliisque corruperis, et in laesionem beati Petri apostoli, a cujus sede profecti fuerant, nOli solum inefficaces redire feceris, sed etiam impugnatores omnium quæ fuerant mandata, monstraris. In quorum deceptione tuam nequitiam prodidisti, et ad libellum [lege a libello fratris et coepiscopi mei Joannis, qui te gra. vissimis objectioDibus impetivit, in apostolica sede I secundum canones respondere diffidens, objecta firmasli. Felicem quoque dcfensorem fidelissimum nobis, necessitate faciente serius subsecutum, iudignum tuis censuisti oculis. Eos quoque tecum litteris tuis communicare testatus es, quos constat hæreticos. Quid enim sunt aliud, qui post obitum sanctae memoriæ Timothei ad Ecclesiam sub Petro redeunt, vel qui se ex catholicis eidem tradiderunt, nisi quod Petrus ab universa Ecclesia, atque a te fuerat judica. tus?
You persist so far in the defense of a perverse man that you have allowed bishops—once bishops, but now deprived of honor and communion—Vitalis and Misenus, whom we had sent specifically for his expulsion, to be handed over into custody with their documents taken away; and having brought them out from there to the procession which you hold with heretics, as has been made clear by their own profession, you dragged them, with contempt for the legation which ought to have been preserved even by the law of nations, into communion with the heretics and with yourself, and you corrupted them by battles, and to the injury of the blessed apostle Peter, from whose see they had set out, you have not only made them return ineffective, but you are shown to be an attacker of all the things that had been commanded. In their deception you have betrayed your own wickedness, and against the libellus of my brother and fellow bishop John, who assailed you with very grave accusations, distrusting to respond in the apostolic see according to the canons, you strengthened the accusations. Felix also, a most faithful defender of ours, who followed later than necessity required, you judged unworthy of your eyes. You have also testified in your letters that you communicate with those whom it is established are heretics. For what else are they—those who after the death of Timothy of holy memory return to the Church under Peter, or those who from Catholics handed themselves over to him—except what Peter was judged to be by the whole Church and by you?
Habe ergo cum his, quos libenter amplecteris, portionem ex sententia praesenti, quam per tuæ tibi direximus Ecclesiæ defensorem: sacerdotali bonore, et communione catholica, nec non etiam a fidelium numero segregatus, sublatum tibi nomen et munus ] ministerii sacerdotalis agnosce, sancti Spiritus judicio et apostolica [supple per nos ] auctoritate damnatus, nunquamque [lege nec jam unquamj anathematis vinculis exuendus. Cælius Felix episcopus sanctae Ecclesiae catholicae urbis Romae subscripsi. Data v calend. Augusti (an. Christi 484), Venantio viro darissimo consule. Simul episcopi absque papa subscripserunt.
a EPISTOLA VII.
AD UNIVERSOS EPISCOPOS.
Statuit quomodo qui rebaptizati sunt ad Ecclesiam ca tholicam admitti debeant.
Rebaptizatus per pœnitentiam recipiatur.
II, Episcopus, presbyter, diaconus, si rebaptizatus fuerit, laicam communionem accipiat in mortem.
Therefore have a portion, according to the present sentence, with those whom you gladly embrace—the sentence which we have directed to you through the defender of your Church: know that you are separated from the priestly honor and catholic communion, and also from the number of the faithful; recognize that the name and office of priestly ministry have been taken from you, condemned by the judgment of the Holy Spirit and by apostolic authority [supplied through us], and never [read: nor ever henceforth] to be released from the bonds of anathema. I, Caelius Felix, bishop of the holy catholic Church of the city of Rome, have subscribed. Given on the fifth day before the Kalends of August (in the year of Christ 484), in the consulship of Venantius, a most illustrious man. At the same time, bishops subscribed without the pope.
a EPISTLE VII.
TO ALL BISHOPS.
It is decreed how those who have been rebaptized ought to be admitted to the catholic Church.
Let one who has been rebaptized be received through penance.
II. A bishop, presbyter, or deacon, if he has been rebaptized, is to receive lay communion unto death.
III. Clericus, monachus, puella Dei, laicus, si rebaptizatus fuerit, Nicæni concilii sententia teneat.
IV. Ætatiores utroque sexu per manus impositionem transeant.
V. Qui rebaptizatus fuerit in clero non recipiatur.
VI. Pœnitentem alterius episcopus non absolvat nec accipiat.
Dilectissimis in Christo Jesu fratribus, universis episcopis per diversas provincias constitutis V
Qualiter in Africanis regionibus astutia diaboli sævierit in populum Christianum, atque id in multiplici deceptione proruperit, ut non modo vulgus incautum, sed ipsos quoque in mortis profunda demerserit sacerdotes, nullus non orbis gemuit, nulla terra nescivit. UnUe in gravi [lege grandi] mœrore positi, dissimulare non possumus pereuntium atque a nobis exigendarum discrimen animarum. Quapropter competens adhibenda est talibus medicina [lege medela] vulneribus, ne immatura curandi facilitas mortifera captis peste nihil prosit, sed segnius tracta pernicies, reatu non legitimæ curationis involvat paritcr saucios et medentes.
III. A cleric, a monk, a virgin of God, a layman, if he has been rebaptized, let the sentence of the Council of Nicaea hold.
IV. Let the older, of either sex, pass through the laying on of hands.
V. Whoever has been rebaptized is not to be received into the clergy.
VI. Let the bishop of another not absolve or receive a penitent.
To the most beloved brothers in Christ Jesus, to all bishops constituted throughout the various provinces, V.
How the cunning of the devil has raged among the Christian people in the African regions, and has burst forth in manifold deception, so that it has plunged into the depths of death not only the incautious common folk but even the priests themselves, no part of the world has failed to groan over, no land has been ignorant of. Hence, placed in grave grief, we cannot dissemble the peril of those who are perishing and of the souls that are to be required at our hands. Wherefore a fitting remedy must be applied to such wounds, lest the premature ease of healing, deadly to those seized by the plague, profit nothing, but the destruction, handled too sluggishly, involve alike the wounded and the healers in the guilt of an illegitimate cure.
Imprimis itaque venientis ad vos et remedium postulantis, solticite discutienda est professio et persona decepti, ut medela possit congruens exhiberi. Et qui satisfacturus Deo per pœnitentiam, se rebaptizatum legitime doluerit; utrum ad hoc facinus concurrerit [lege cucurrerit, vel occurrerit], an impulsus accesserit, requiratur: sciens quod se decipiat ipse, qui fallit (/ Petr. v), nihilque per nostram facilitatem tribunalis excelsi judicio derogari, cui illa sunt rata [lege recta], quæ pia, quæ vera, quæ justa sunt; et aliter necessitatis, aliter tractanda est ratio voluntatis. Deterior est autem causa illius, qui forte pretio sollicitatus est ut periret. Nihil enim intentatum relinquit inimicus, cui ne de sua liceat gaudere captura, succurrendum est irretitis; et contendendus [lege conterendus est] venantis laqueus, infucatum lamentantibus tam justitiae moderatione quam compunctione pietatis ad I aulam quam reliquerant sit regressus. Nec pudeat forsitan aut pigeat indictis jejuniorum gemituumque temporibus obedire, aut aliis observantiae salubrioris obtemperare praeceptis: quia humilibus datur gratia, non superbis.
First of all, therefore, the profession and the person of the deceived one who comes to you and seeks a remedy must be carefully examined, so that a fitting cure can be provided. And he who is to make satisfaction to God through penance should grieve that he was lawfully rebaptized; let it be asked whether he ran together to this crime, or came under compulsion: knowing that he deceives himself who deceives, and that nothing is derogated from the judgment of the exalted tribunal by our leniency, for whom those things are ratified which are pious, which are true, which are just; and the account of necessity must be treated one way, that of the will another. But worse is the case of him who perhaps was solicited by a bribe so that he might perish. For the enemy leaves nothing untried, and since he is not permitted to rejoice over his own capture, help must be given to those ensnared; and the snare of the hunter must be crushed, and an unfeigned return to the court which they had left must be made for those lamenting, as much by the moderation of justice as by the compunction of piety. Nor let it perhaps shame or grieve them to obey the appointed times of fastings and groanings, or to submit to other precepts of a more healthful observance: because grace is given to the humble, not to the proud.
Sit ergo ruinæ suæ dolore prostratus quisquis in Christo fieri quaerit erectus, et per dispositionis nostrae ministerium, quod vestram sequi convenit caritatem, nec alicui fas est velle vel posse transcendere causas ejus, qui contra apostolicam doctrinam, ad iterationem se baptismatis nimis infaustam dedidit; vel ejus qui aliquibus argumentis excusandum callide p. oprium putaverit esse consensum, sacerdotali vigore, et humanitate tractemus, ut in eis fides, quæ nisi est una, jam nulla est, adjutorio Domini Judicis, ad salutem sine nostrae a operationis offensione reparetur: quia cum peccatoris a nobis satisfaclio protrahitur, non præter laudem nostram atque lætitiam, mens ejus ad veniam purgatior invenitur. Et ideo memineritis, hanc super bis nos habere sententiam, ut servata discretione peccantium, non eadem cuncti qui lapsi sunt, lance pensentur: quoniam majoris casiigationis i exigendus est usura [usuras], cui domus Domini commissa fuerit disciplina.
Let anyone who seeks to be raised up in Christ, therefore, lie prostrate in grief over his own ruin; and through the ministry of our arrangement, which it befits your charity to follow, it is not lawful for anyone to wish or to be able to override the cases of him who, contrary to apostolic doctrine, has too disastrously given himself over to the repetition of baptism, or of him who by some arguments has cunningly thought that the consent of the opposing party should be excused. Let us treat them with priestly vigor and humanity, so that in them the faith, which, unless it is one, is now none, may by the help of the Lord, the Judge, be restored to salvation without offense on the part of our action; because when the satisfaction of a sinner is prolonged by us, not without our praise and joy is his mind found more purified for pardon. And therefore you should remember that we hold this judgment concerning these matters, that, with discretion preserved regarding sinners, not all who have fallen are weighed with the same scale; since the interest of a greater punishment is to be exacted from him to whom the discipline of the house of the Lord has been entrusted.
Ut ergo ab Ecclesiae summitatibus inchoemus, eos quos episcopos, presbyteros, vel diaconos fuisse constiterit, et seu optantes forsitan, seu coactos lavacri illius unici salutarisque claruerit fecisse jacturam, et Christum, quem non solum dono regenerationis, verum etiam gratia percepti honoris induerant, cxuisse, cum constet neminem ad secundam tinctionem venire potuissc, nisi se palam Christianum negavcrit, et professus fuerit se esse paganum. Quod cum gcneralitcr sit in omnibus cxsecrandum, multo magis in episcopis, presbyteris, diaconibus auditu saltem dictuque probatur horrendum. Sed quia idem Dominus atque Salvator clementissimus est, et neminem vult perire, usque ad exitus sui diem, in poenitentia (si resipiscunt) jacere conveniet; nec orationi non modo fidelium, sed ne catecbumenorum omnimodis interesse, quibus communio laica tantum in morte reddenda esi. Quam rem diligentius explorarc vel facere probatissimi sacerdotis cura debebit.
So then, to begin with the highest ranks of the Church: those who are established to have been bishops, presbyters, or deacons, and who are shown to have suffered the loss of that one saving laver, whether perhaps willingly or under compulsion, and to have stripped off Christ, whom they had put on not only by the gift of regeneration but also by the grace of the honor they had received—since it is certain that no one could come to a second washing unless he had openly denied that he was a Christian and declared himself to be a pagan. And while this is to be detested universally in all, it is proved far more horrible in bishops, presbyters, and deacons, even to hear or speak of. But because the same Lord and Savior is most merciful and wills that no one perish, it will be fitting for them to lie in penitence (if they come to their senses) until the day of their death; and they are by no means to be present at the prayer not only of the faithful but even of the catechumens, to whom lay communion is to be granted only at death. The most approved priest's care ought diligently to investigate or carry out this matter.
De clericis autem et monachis, aut puellis Dei, aut sæcularibus, servari praecipimus hunc tenorem quem Nicæna synodus circa eos qui lapsi sunt vcl fuerint servandum esse constituit; ut scilicet qui nulla necessitate. nullius rei timore aut periculo, se ut rebaptizentur hæreticis impie dediderunt; si tamea eos ex corde poeniteat, tribus annis inter audientes sint; septem autem annis subjaceant inter poenitentes manibus sacerdotum, duobus autem annis oblationes modis omnibus non sinantur offerre, sed tantummodo sæcularibus in oratione socientur. Nec confundatur Deo colla submittere, qui non eum timuit abnegare. Quod si, ut pote mortales, intra metas praescripti temporis cœperit vitæ finis urgere, subveniendum est imploranti, ' et seu ab episcopo qui pœnitentiam dederit, seu ab alio, qui tamen datam esse probaverit, aut similiter a presbylero viaticum abeunti de saeculo non negetur.
But concerning clerics and monks, or the maidens of God, or secular persons, we command that this rule be observed which the Nicene synod established to be observed concerning those who have fallen or shall fall; namely, that those who, with no necessity, no fear or peril of anything, wickedly gave themselves over to heretics to be rebaptized, if only they repent from the heart, shall be among the hearers for three years; but for seven years they shall lie among the penitents under the hands of the priests; and for two years they shall by no means be permitted to offer the oblations, but shall only be joined with the secular faithful in prayer. Nor should he be ashamed to bow his neck to God, who did not fear to deny him. But if, as is the case with mortals, the end of life should begin to press within the bounds of the prescribed time, help must be given to him who implores it, and whether by the bishop who gave the penance, or by another who has proved that it was given, or likewise by a presbyter, the viaticum must not be denied to one departing from the world.
Pueris autem quibus quod adhuc8 impuberes, a pubertate vocabulum est, seu clericis, sive laicis, aut etiam similibus puellis, quibus ignorantia suffragatur ætatis, aliquandiu sub manus impositione detentis, reddenda communio est; nec corum exspectanda poenitentia quos excipit a coerciLione censura. Quod rst a nobis provide constitutum, ne hi quibus in terreni labe contagii plus minusve restat ad vitam, dum adhuc in poenitentia sunt, poenitenda committant [Supple forte]. Quod si ante præfinitum pœnitentiæ tempus desperatus a medicis, aut evidentibus mortis pressus indiciis, recepta quisquam communionis gratia convalescit; servemus in eo quod Nicæni canones ordinaverunt, ut habeatur inter eos qui in oratione sola communicant, donec impleatur spatium temporis eidem præstitutum. Nec catechumenos nostros, qui sub tali professione baptizati sunt, prætermittimus: quia non est causa dissimilis (sicut iidem sancti ca. nones ordinaverunt) ejus qui quolibet modo Christum, quem semel confessus, abjurarit; tribus annis inter audientes sint, et postea cum catechumenis per manus impositionem communionis catholicæ gratiam percepturi, exceptis sane tantUmmodo episcopis, presbyteris et diaconibus, quos solo mortis suæ tempore reconciliandos esse jam diximus.
But for children—who are called "impubes" from the word "pubertas," since they are not yet of age—whether clerics or laypersons, or likewise for girls, whom the ignorance of their age supports, after they have been held for some time under the imposition of hands, communion is to be restored; nor is penitence to be expected from those whom the censure exempts from coercion. This we have provided by our constitution, lest those who have more or less of life remaining amid the contagion of earthly corruption, while they are still in penitence, commit things deserving of penitence. But if, before the predetermined time of penitence, someone, despaired of by the physicians or pressed by evident indications of death, having received the grace of communion, recovers, let us observe in his case what the canons of Nicaea have ordained, that he be reckoned among those who communicate in prayer alone, until the space of time appointed for him is fulfilled. Nor do we pass over our catechumens, who have been baptized under such a profession, because the case is not dissimilar (as the same holy canons have ordained) to that of one who by whatever means has abjured Christ, whom he once confessed: let them be among the hearers for three years, and afterwards, with the catechumens, receive the grace of catholic communion through the imposition of hands—except, of course, only bishops, presbyters, and deacons, whom we have already said are to be reconciled only at the time of their death.
Caeteros, id est, seu clericos, sive monachos, seu laicos, utriusque sexus personas, quos It violentiae pcriculis coactos iterationem baptismatis subiisse constiterit, vel qui aliquo commento, cujus se facinoris piaculo dixerint non teneri, his poenitentiam per triennium durare decrevimus, et per manus impositionem ad societatem tecipi eos sacramenti.
Illo per omnia custodito, ne ex eis unquam qui in qualibet ætate alihi quam in Ecclesia catholica aut baptizati, aut rebaptizati sunt, ad ecclesiasticam militiam prorsus non permittantur accedere. Quibus satis esse debeat quod in catholicorum numero sunt recepti: quoniam de suo, ordine et communione videbitur ferre judicium quisquis hoc violaverit institulum, vel qui non removerit eum quem ex eis ad ministerium clericale obrepsisse cognoverit.
Curandum vero maxime, et omni cautela est proVidendum, ne quis fratrum coepiscoporumque nostrorum, aut etiam presbyterorum, in alterius civitate vel diœcesi poenitentem, vel sub manu positum sacerdotis, aut eum qui reconciliatum se esse dixerit, sine episcopi vel presbyteri testimonio et litteris, I ad cujus pertinet parochiam, presbyter aut episcopus [lege et litteris, aut in parochia presbyter aut episcopus] in civitate suspiciat. Quod si aliqua dissimulatione negligitur, culpa tangit elam clerum [lege clcricum] qui in locis in quibus hoc minus curatum fuerit commoratur.
As for the rest—that is, whether clerics, or monks, or laypersons, persons of both sexes—whom it is established either to have undergone a repetition of baptism under compulsion of the dangers of violence, or who by some contrivance have said that they are not bound by the guilt of the crime they committed, we have decreed that penance for them last for three years, and that through the imposition of hands they be received into the fellowship of the sacrament.
This being guarded in all things, that none of those who at any age have been either baptized or rebaptized anywhere other than in the Catholic Church be permitted at all to approach ecclesiastical service. For it ought to be enough for them that they have been received into the number of Catholics; since whoever violates this institution, or who does not remove one of them whom he knows to have crept into the clerical ministry, will be seen to bring judgment upon his own order and communion.
But it must especially be seen to, and provided for with all caution, that no one of our brothers and fellow bishops, or even of presbyters, in another's city or diocese, should receive a penitent, or one placed under the hand of a priest, or one who has said that he has been reconciled, without the testimony and letters of the bishop or presbyter to whose parish he belongs, as a presbyter or bishop in the city. But if through any dissimulation this is neglected, the blame touches even the clergy who dwell in the places in which this has been less attended to.
His itaque rite dispositis, et ad Ecclesiarum vestrarum notitiam nostra deliberatione perlatis, parerevos convenit |lege convenerat ]: quibus, licet ad animarum reparationem nihil decsse videatur, tamen si cui novi aliquid, et quod praeterire nos potuit, fuerit revelatum, secundum beatum apostolum Paulum, tacente priore, fideliter [ lene fidenter] insinuet: quiaSpiritus sanctus, ubi vult,,,,irae, maxime cum sua, causa tractatur; nec nos pigebit audire, et si quæ sunt omissa, non arroganter abnuere, sed rationabiliter ordinare. Deus custodiat vos, dilectissimi fratres. Data idibus Martii (an. Christi 488), Dynamio et' Siphidio viris clarissimis consulibus.
EPISTOLA VIII.
AD ZENONEM EPISCOPUM
Terentianum commendat.
Dilectissimo fratri Zenoni, Felix episcopus.
Filius meus vir clarissimus Terentianus ad Ilaliam dudum veniens, dilectionis. tuM siugularis exstitit praedicator, talemque te esse vulgavit, qui ita Christi gratia redundares, ut inter mundi turbines gubernator Ecclesiæ praecipuus appareres. Quapropter, frater carissime, cum ad provinciam commearet, seduloque deposceret nostras ad dilectionem tuam litteras destinari, gratanter annuimus, qui etnignum Deo sermone complecti cuperemus antistitem, et per eum maxime vellemus id fieri, cujus nobis fuerat laudibus intimatus. Quamvis ergo sanctis operibus ex omni parte prædictam fraternitatem tuam vir præ.
With these matters therefore duly arranged and brought to the notice of your churches by our deliberation, it is fitting that you obey; for although nothing seems to be lacking for the restoration of souls, yet if anything new, and which could have escaped us, has been revealed to anyone, according to the blessed apostle Paul, while the former speaker is silent, let him faithfully suggest it; because the Holy Spirit, where it wills... especially when His own cause is being treated; nor will it displease us to hear, and if anything has been omitted, not to reject it arrogantly, but to arrange it reasonably. May God keep you, most beloved brothers. Given on the Ides of March (in the year of Christ 488), with Dynamius and Siphidius, most illustrious men, as consuls.
LETTER VIII.
TO ZENO THE BISHOP
He commends Terentianus.
To his most beloved brother Zeno, Felix the bishop.
My son, the most illustrious man Terentianus, having come to Italy some time ago, proved to be a herald of your singular affection, and spread abroad that you are such a man, so overflowing with the grace of Christ, that amid the storms of the world you appeared as a pre-eminent governor of the Church. Wherefore, dearest brother, when he was returning to the province and earnestly requested that our letters be sent to your affection, we gladly agreed, since we desired to embrace in speech a bishop worthy of God, and we especially wished it to be done through him by whose praises your brotherhood had been made known to us. Although therefore by your holy works your aforesaid brotherhood is in every respect...
fatus astruxerit, multumque fiduciæ de tua benevolentia jam teneret, tamen æquum est ut quod desiderabat magnopere consequatur; quatenus qui tuis olim gratus est animis, contemplationenostri reddatur acceptior, simulque maierna et sacerdotali consolatione foveatur, peregrinationisque praesidium pastorali pietate reperiat, ut vestræ dignitatis affectu; appareat apud sincerilatem tuam, nostrum quoque non minimum salutantis valuisse colloquium. Deus te incolumem custodiat, frater carissime.
MONITUM PHILIPPI LABBEI
IN SEQUENTEM BREVICULUM.
Anno 1631, opera et studio ii. P. Jacobi Sirmondi prodiit in lucem appendix codicis Theodosiani novis constitutionibus cumnlatior, cum epistolis aliquot veterum conciliorum, quas tomo II a page ad exhibuimus, necnon trium pontificum Romanorum Felicis III ( cui praemisit breviculum Eutychianistarum sive gesta de nomineAcacii cum edicto sententiæ ejusdem papæ), Gelasii atque Vigilii. Nos ne quid desit amplissimae huic collectioni nostræ, eadem omnia in Luparea editione prætermissa, felicibus auspiciis, suis quæque locis inserta, pro more collocabimus.
...he has built up, and would already hold great confidence from your benevolence, nevertheless it is fitting that what he greatly desired he obtain; so that he who was once pleasing to your soul may, through the contemplation of us, be rendered more acceptable, and at the same time be cherished with maternal and priestly consolation, and by pastoral piety find the protection of his pilgrimage, so that by the affection of your dignity it may appear before your sincerity that our conversation, as we greet you, has availed not a little. May God keep you safe, dearest brother.
NOTE OF PHILIPPE LABBE
ON THE FOLLOWING SHORT DOCUMENT.
In the year 1631, by the labor and study of the eminent Father Jacobus Sirmondus, there came to light an appendix to the Theodosian code, more abundantly supplied with new constitutions, together with certain letters of ancient councils, which we have set forth in volume II at the appropriate place, and also of three Roman pontiffs: Felix III (to which he prefixed a short document of the Eutychianists, or the acts concerning the name of Acacius, with the edict of the same pope's sentence), Gelasius, and Vigilius. We, that nothing may be lacking to this most ample collection of ours, shall place all these same things, omitted in the Lyon edition, each in its own place, under favorable auspices, and arrange them according to custom.
BREVICULUS HIST. EUTYCHIANISTARUM.
Sive,
GESTA DE NOMINE ACACII.
in causa Mel Christianæ, cui ab exordio sui nun. quam defuisse proMantur inimici, nostro quidem sæcolo, sed intervallo temporum, Nestorius et Eutyches non nova dogmata suae perversilatis, sed nomina prodiderunt. Nam Nestorius ante quinquaginta et octo fere annos, Photini et Pauli Samosateni secutus errorem, Oasitano a exsilio meruit relegari, dicendo, sicut ab auctoribus suis didicit, Christum Dominum nostrum hominem tantummodo de Virgine Maria esse progenitum. Contra quemEutyches, post annos non plurimos, aestimans disputandum, rectum trami-' tem tenere nesciens, offendit; et in Apollinaris est raptus insaniam, in hæc verba prorumpens, quibus assereret Christum verum hominem non fuisse, nec in eo duas naturas esse credendas, sed unam tantummodo Dei Verbi, verumtamen incarnatam. Quam quidem non esse hominis perhibuit, sed humanam, ut similitudo magis humani corporis quam ipsa veritas suaderetur. Cum catholica fides verum Deum verumque hominem Christum Dei Filium esse fateatur, non unius naturæ, sed unius essentiæ atque personae.
BRIEF ACCOUNT OF THE HISTORY OF THE EUTYCHIANISTS.
Or,
THE ACTS CONCERNING THE NAME OF ACACIUS.
In the cause of the Christian faith, which from its very beginning is shown never to have lacked enemies, in our own age indeed, but at an interval of time, Nestorius and Eutyches brought forth not new doctrines of their own perversity, but names. For Nestorius, some fifty-eight years ago, following the error of Photinus and Paul of Samosata, deserved to be relegated from his exile in the Oasis, by saying, as he learned from his authorities, that Christ our Lord was a man only, begotten of the Virgin Mary. Against him Eutyches, not many years later, thinking he must dispute, and not knowing how to hold the right path, stumbled; and he was carried away into the madness of Apollinaris, bursting out into these words, by which he asserted that Christ was not a true man, nor were two natures to be believed in him, but only one, of God the Word, yet incarnate. This nature, indeed, he maintained was not of a man, but human, so that a likeness of a human body rather than the truth itself might be urged. Since the catholic faith confesses that Christ the Son of God is true God and true man, not of one nature, but of one essence and person.
Cum ergo Eutychem istum, presbyterum et abbatem Constantinopolitanæ civitatis, Euscbius Dorylilanus episcopus suadere talia reperisset, zelo fidei, quam etiam cum agens in rebus esset ostendit (ipse enim Nestorium quoque in tempore reprehendit in ecclesia res sacrilegas prædicantem), detulit ad Flavianum episcopum, et ad judicium provocavit. Dicta causa est. Cum partes suas Eutyches videret urgeri, per Chrysaphium spaiarium Theodosii praesidium principis expetivit. Cujus praecepto Florentius vir illustris, exconsule, discussioni Eutychis abesse non potuit, et jam in praesentia ipsius convincitur Eutyches atque damnatur. Offenditur imperator, et in Ephesina civilate mandat synodum congregari. Adsunt fere CCCLX [CXL] episcopi, principibus Dioscoro Alexandrino episcopo, Juvenali Hierosolymitano, Tbalassio Caesariensi, Eustathio Berytensi, Eusebio Ancyritano, Basilio Isauriæ. Interfuerunt eliam vicarii ab apostolica sede directi, Julius Puteolanus episcopus, Hilarus archidiaconus, quia presbyter Renatus in Delo insula morte praeventus est. Adfuit etiam Dulcitius notarius. In quo conventurrepudiata est epistola papae Leonis dogmatica ad synodum Flavianumque directa, et penitus non permittitur recenseri. Tota die, id est VI idus Augusti, nihil aliud nisi quondam Nestorii damnati, id est prioris Ephe-,Binae sinæ synodi gesta releguntur.
When therefore Eusebius of Dorylaeum, a bishop, had discovered that this Eutyches, a presbyter and abbot of the city of Constantinople, was persuading such things, out of zeal for the faith—which he had also shown when he was an agent in affairs (for he himself also at that time rebuked Nestorius in the church when he was preaching sacrilegious things)—he reported it to Flavian the bishop and summoned him to judgment. The case was pleaded. When Eutyches saw that his side was being pressed, through Chrysaphius the spatharius he sought the protection of the emperor Theodosius. By whose command Florentius, a man of illustrious rank, an ex-consul, could not be absent from the examination of Eutyches, and even in his presence Eutyches is convicted and condemned. The emperor is offended, and he orders a synod to be assembled in the city of Ephesus. Nearly 360 [140] bishops are present, with as leaders Dioscorus bishop of Alexandria, Juvenal of Jerusalem, Thalassius of Caesarea, Eustathius of Berytus, Eusebius of Ancyra, and Basil of Isauria. The vicars sent directly from the apostolic see were also present: Julius bishop of Puteoli and Hilarus the archdeacon, because the presbyter Renatus had been prevented by death on the island of Delos. Dulcitius the notary was also present. In that assembly the dogmatic letter of Pope Leo directed to the synod and to Flavian was rejected, and it is not permitted at all for it to be read out. All day, that is, on the sixth day before the Ides of August, nothing else is read out except the acts of the once-condemned Nestorius, that is, of the prior synod of Ephesus.
Simul etiam discutitur, lectis omnibus chartis, judicium de Eutyche sanctae memoriæ Flaviani. Interea cum Eutychis a blasphemiae relegerentur, ab omnibus acclamatum est hanc esse veram fidem, hanc ortbodoxam. Dejicitur contradicentibus vicariis Romanis Flavianus, e et recipitur Eutyches. Damnatur etiam Eusebius episcopus accusator ejusdem presbyteri, tanquam Nestorianus, qui ante, dum adhuc esset laicus, Nestorii fuerat accusator. Ita enim nihil volunt isti Eutychianistae inter se esse atque Nestorium, ut quicunque apud eos Eutychianista non fuerit, Nestorianus prorsus habea tur: cum doctrina catholica uniat duas naturas in Christo, non dividat sicut Nestorius fecit. Et isti quidem reperiuntur deteriora garrire. Nam fidentissime dicunt rem ineptam, rem etiam stolidis exsecrandam, ante unitionem, id est incarnationem, duas dici debere naturas; post vero unam Dei Verbi tantum incarnatam: ut si dicamus aliquid cereatum, aut picatum, aut stagnatum [ lege Stannatum ], aut quolibet alio genere coloratum. Jam vero post diem tertium synodi qua dejectus est sanctae memoriæ Flavianus, dejicitur etiam et domnus Antiochenus. Dioscorus repente discessit, solutusque conventus est. Ducitur in exsilium Flavianus apud Epipam, quae est civitas Lydiæ, seu superveniente, seu ingesta morte defunctus « est. Tunc temporis Anatolius quidam presbyter Alexandrinus apud Constantinopolim morabatur.
At the same time, after all the documents had been read, the judgment concerning Eutyches of holy memory Flavian was also discussed. Meanwhile, when the blasphemies of Eutyches were read out, all cried out that this was the true faith, this the orthodox faith. Flavian is cast down, with the Roman vicars objecting, and Eutyches is received. Eusebius also, the bishop who was the accuser of the same presbyter, is condemned as a Nestorian—he who formerly, while he was still a layman, had been the accuser of Nestorius. For these Eutychianists wish nothing to be between themselves and Nestorius, so that whoever among them has not been a Eutychianist is regarded outright as a Nestorian—although the catholic doctrine unites two natures in Christ, and does not divide them as Nestorius did. And these men are found to babble worse things. For they say most confidently a thing absurd, a thing to be execrated even by the dull-witted: that before the union, that is, the incarnation, two natures ought to be spoken of; but after it, only one, the incarnate nature of God the Word—as if we should say something waxed, or pitched, or tinned, or colored with any other kind whatsoever. Now indeed, after the third day of the synod at which Flavian of holy memory was cast down, the lord of Antioch is also cast down. Dioscorus suddenly departed, and the assembly was dissolved. Flavian is led into exile at Epipa, which is a city of Lydia, and died, whether by a death that came upon him or was brought on. At that time a certain Anatolius, a presbyter of Alexandria, was staying at Constantinople.
Hæc enim consuetudo prædictis est ut ad comitatum vicibus clerici dirigantur, ne quid forte causæ vel necessitatis emergat. Fit ergo iste Anatolius Constantinopoli episcopus, homo partium Dioscori. Exemptoanno moritur Theodosius imperator, Chrysaphius punitur i, Marcianus factus est princeps i. r~ Læsam fidem graviter ferens indicit synodum apud Nicæam,in qua et ipse et Pulcheria resedit, et omnis cum eo senatus et potestates. Quam synodum postea transtulit Chalcedona propter palatii vicinitatem. Conveniunt quingenli [630] et ultra episcopi totius Orientis et Ægypti; Dioscorus exhibetur ut facti sui causa in concilio possit asserere. Interfuit etiam imperator ipse conventui; interfuit et senatus, et omnes judices, et omnes aulicae potestates. Eusebius ille Dorylitanus episcopus qui ante annum de exsilio fugiens Romam venerat, etiam et Chalcedonensi synodo interesse properavit. Accusat ipse Dioscorum, et alii Alexandrini. Quid multa? Damnatur Dioscorus, sanctae memoriae Flaviani corpus ofGciosissime Constantinopolim reportatur, apud Alexandriam Proterius catholicus fit sacerdos. Quidam Timotheus cui cognomen erat iturus, presbyter; et Petrus diaconus, qui episcopatum nunc Alexandrinae occupavit Ecclesiae, Dioscori sectatores, se ab Ecclesia Alexandrina separarunt. Quos cum Proterius episcot pus suis monitis ad ministeria sua revocare non pesset, utrumque damnavit.
For this custom of the aforesaid is that clerics be sent in turn to the court, lest perhaps some matter of a case or necessity arise. So this Anatolius is made bishop of Constantinople, a man of the faction of Dioscorus. When the year had passed, the emperor Theodosius dies, Chrysaphius is punished, Marcian is made emperor. Grieving grievously over the wounded faith, he summons a synod at Nicaea, at which both he and Pulcheria sat, and with him the whole senate and the powers. This synod he afterwards transferred to Chalcedon because of its proximity to the palace. Five hundred and thirty bishops and more of the whole East and of Egypt assemble; Dioscorus is brought forward so that he might assert the cause of his deed in the council. The emperor himself also was present at the assembly; the senate was present, and all the judges, and all the palace powers. That Eusebius, bishop of Dorylaeum, who a year before had fled from exile and come to Rome, also hastened to be present at the synod of Chalcedon. He himself accuses Dioscorus, and others of Alexandria. What need of many words? Dioscorus is condemned, the body of Flavian of holy memory is brought back to Constantinople with the greatest honor, at Alexandria Proterius is made catholic priest. A certain Timothy, whose surname was the Weasel, a presbyter, and Peter a deacon, who has now occupied the episcopate of the Church of Alexandria, followers of Dioscorus, separated themselves from the Church of Alexandria. Since Proterius the bishop could not recall them by his admonitions to their ministries, he condemned them both.
Mortuo principe Marciano, a collectis turbis hæreticorum, Timotheus et Petrus veniunt Alexandriam, et ordinatur ab haereticis Timotheus episcopus. Duo igitur apud Alexandriam episcopi esse coeperunt. Ante triduum Paschæ, quo cœna Domini celebratur, collecta multitudine perditorum occupatur ecclesia, ad quam se sanctæ memoriæ Proteriterius de more contulerat. Ibi supradicto die in baptisterio occiditur, laniatur, ejicitur, et funus ejus incenditur, cineresque ipsius sparguntur in ventos. Leo sumit imperium, ad quem tanti faciuoris catholicorum querela pervenit. Contra quos hæretici supplicarunt, petentes ut Cbalcedonensis synodus abolerelur; illi autem vindictam tanti sceleris spectabant. Considerans imperator nimis esse grave vexari tautos iterum sacerdotes, quorum plurimos aut ætas, aut infirmitas, aut etiam paupertas hunc laborem subire prohibebat, dirigit magislrianos per totum Orientem: dirigit etiam Anatolius episcopus Constantinopolitanus Asclepiadem diaconum suum. Per quos et omnes illi episcopi qui Chalcedona fuerant congregati, quidAlexandriaefactum fuisset agnoscunt interrogatique cum suis provincialibus episcopis rescribunt, Chalcedonensem synodum usque ad sanguinem esse defendendam, quia non alteram fidem statuit quam synodus NicænasTimotheum non SOlUM episcopum non haberi, sed etiam Christiani appellatione privari.
When the emperor Marcian died, Timotheus and Petrus came to Alexandria with gathered mobs of heretics, and Timotheus was ordained bishop by the heretics. Thus there began to be two bishops at Alexandria. Before the third day of Pascha, on which the Lord's Supper is celebrated, a multitude of the wicked gathered and seized the church, to which Proterius, of holy memory, had come according to custom. There, on the aforementioned day, he was killed in the baptistery, mangled, cast out, and his corpse was burned, and his ashes were scattered to the winds. Leo took up the empire, and the complaint of the catholics concerning so great a crime reached him. The heretics petitioned against them, asking that the synod of Chalcedon be abolished; but they were looking for vengeance for so great a crime. The emperor, considering it far too grievous that so many priests should again be harassed—most of whom age, or infirmity, or even poverty prevented from undertaking this labor—sent magistrians throughout the whole East; the bishop Anatolius of Constantinople also sent his deacon Asclepiades. Through them all those bishops who had been assembled at Chalcedon learned what had been done at Alexandria, and when questioned, they wrote back together with their provincial bishops that the synod of Chalcedon must be defended even to bloodshed, because it established no other faith than the synod of Nicaea, and that Timotheus was not only not to be held a bishop, but was even to be deprived of the name of Christian.
e Quo deposito, fit alter Timotheus catholicus episcopusAlexandriæ. Vix Timotheus hæreticus depellitur, fugit Petrus, mittitur in essilium Timotheus Chersona, qui locus est in Ponto abditus. Quandiu vixit imperator Leo, vixit Timotbeus episcopus Alexandriæ cum quiete. Sed cum Basiliscus occupasset imperium, i damnare coepit Chalcedonensem synodum, et catholicos persequi. Tunc denique Timotheus ille damnatus accepta libertate venit Constantinopolim, et damnatos hæreticus locis suis reddidit. Vadit Alexandriam, fugiti Timotheus catholicus, et in monasterio latet. Petrus ille itcrum se junxit Timotheo, cum quo fuerat ante damnatus. Redit Zeno imperator ad regnum, Basiliscus opprimitur. Mittitur Alexandriam, ut pulso penvasoreTimotheus catholicus redderetur Ecclesiae. Sed Timotheo damnato morte praevento, Petrus consors ipsius ab uno hæretico Alexandrinis episcopus ordinatur. Quem nihilominus dejici jussit Cbristianissimus imperator, et reduci Timotheum catholicum, sicut Acacii Constantinopolitani litteris continetur. Cum plurimi, seu clerici, seu monachi, seu sæcularis vitæ homines, ad communionem catholici episcopi Timothei nollent penitus convenire, diversis sacris terruit universos clementissimus impcrator.
After he was deposed, another Timotheus, a catholic, was made bishop of Alexandria. Scarcely was the heretical Timotheus driven out when Petrus fled; Timotheus was sent into exile at Chersona, a remote place in Pontus. As long as the emperor Leo lived, Timotheus, bishop of Alexandria, lived in peace. But when Basiliscus had seized the empire, he began to condemn the synod of Chalcedon and to persecute the catholics. Then at last that condemned Timotheus, having received his freedom, came to Constantinople, and restored the condemned heretics to their places. He goes to Alexandria; the catholic Timotheus flees and hides in a monastery. That Petrus joined himself again to Timotheus, with whom he had previously been condemned. The emperor Zeno returns to the throne, and Basiliscus is overthrown. A message is sent to Alexandria, that with the perverse one driven out, the catholic Timotheus might be restored to the Church. But since the condemned Timotheus was prevented by death, Petrus, his associate, was ordained bishop of the Alexandrians by a single heretic. Nevertheless the most Christian emperor ordered him to be cast down and the catholic Timotheus to be brought back, as is contained in the letters of Acacius of Constantinople. Since very many, whether clerics, monks, or men of secular life, were utterly unwilling to come to the communion of the catholic bishop Timotheus, the most merciful emperor terrified them all with various sacred rites.
Scripsit ad papam Simplicium Timotheus (dicens Petrum olim in diaconio esse damnatum, nunc etiam Christiana societate semotum: mandans per Esaiam episcopum 1), rogans ut scriberetur imperalori de Petro, qui latebat in Alexandrina civitate, et insidiabatur Ecclesiae, ut, ad longinquum deportaretur exsilium. Per ferme tricnnium sanctae memoriæ papa Simplicius non desiit scribendo ad Acacium episcopum, ut ageret cumimperatore, et fleret de Petro quod Timoiheus episcopus postulabat. Scriptum est etiam principi, sed nunquam inde rescriplum est. Post omnia, Joannem presbyterum œconomum suum Timotheus ad principem misit, rogans ut si quid humanitus sibi forte contingeret, juberet pietas ejus catholicuma catholicis ordinari.Ad cujus petita responsum est, et tam ipsi quam clericis scriptum: atque in iisdem sacris Joannes oeconomus mullis laudibus praedicatur, ut jam pene omnibus Alexandrinus episcopalis putaretur officii candidatus. Defuncto isto Timotheo episcopo Joannes œconomus catholicus a catholicis ordinatur episcopus. Qui cum de consuetudine majorum ad apostolicam sedem synodica (per Isidorum presbyterum et Petrum diaco. num) scripta misisset, superveniente Uranio subadjuva, ct contra Joannem jam episcopum sacra principis deferente, ab episcopatus illius confirmatione papa suspensus est.
Timotheus wrote to Pope Simplicius, saying that Petrus had once been condemned in the diaconate and was now even cut off from Christian fellowship, and instructing him through Esaias the bishop, asking that a letter be written to the emperor concerning Petrus, who was hiding in the city of Alexandria and plotting against the Church, so that he might be deported into distant exile. For nearly three years Pope Simplicius of holy memory did not cease writing to Acacius the bishop, that he should act with the emperor and that there should be done concerning Petrus what Timotheus the bishop demanded. It was written also to the prince, but from there it was never answered. After all this, Timotheus sent John the presbyter, his own steward, to the prince, asking that, if anything should happen to him after the manner of men, his Piety should order a catholic to be ordained by catholics. To his petitions a response was given, and it was written both to him and to the clergy; and in the same sacred letters John the steward is praised with many commendations, so that now he was considered by almost everyone the candidate for the Alexandrian episcopal office. When this Timotheus the bishop had died, John the steward, a catholic, was ordained bishop by catholics. When he, according to the custom of the ancestors, had sent synodical letters to the apostolic see through Isidore the presbyter and Petrus the deacon, Uranius, a subdeacon, arriving afterward and bringing the sacred letters of the prince against John, now already bishop, the pope was suspended from the confirmation of that episcopate.
Et quia in iisdem sacris de restituendo Petro, quem ipse damnavit, fecerat mentionem, haec pars omnino est abnegata. Unde vide... tur clementissimus imperator offensus. Cum. ergo sanctæmemoriae papx Simplicii nihil toties ad Acacium directa, propter Alexandrinae Ecclesiae quie. tem, et catholicæfidei integritatem, scripta proficerent, supervenit idem sanctus Joannes episcopus, qui sicut dccebat, ab apostolica sede susceptus est. Nam et priores ejus similiter Romanæ Ecclesiae tempore persecutionis suffugium poposcerunt. Hujus adventus plenius universa patefecit. Cui dum Acacii scripta legeremus quae de Petro et Juanne P Antiochenis miserat, excessus Acacii cliam in hac causa gravissimos deprehendit. tUo enim tempore quo de Petro Alexandrino damnato retulerat, non longe post etiam de Petro et Joanne scripserat. Petrum apud Constantinopolim monnsterium gubernasse; sed hoc propter crimina derelicto, Antiochiam fugisse. Ibi pulso (Martyrio) catholico episcopo, per hæreticos sedem ipsius occupasse; continuoque damnatum a Leone tunc principe ad Oasitanumexsilium esse directum. De quo lapsum Constantinopolim rediisse, ac dedisse fidem, quod nullas ulterius turbas facere prorsus auderet. Sed sicut superius dictum est, Basilisci temporibus a Timotheo a illo damnato, qui Constantinopolim venerat, ad Antiochiam remissum fuisse, ut iterum illic episcopatum teneret.
And because in the same sacred rites he had made mention of restoring Peter, whom he himself had condemned, this part was entirely refused. Hence it seems that the most clement emperor was offended. Since, therefore, the letters of Pope Simplicius of holy memory, sent so many times to Acacius for the peace of the Alexandrian Church and the integrity of the catholic faith, were accomplishing nothing, the same holy John the bishop arrived, who, as was fitting, was received by the apostolic see. For his predecessors likewise, in the time of persecution, sought refuge from the Roman Church. His arrival laid everything more fully open. And while we were reading to him the letters of Acacius which he had sent concerning Peter and John of Antioch, he detected also the most serious offenses of Acacius in this matter. For at the time when he had reported about Peter of Alexandria being condemned, not long afterward he had also written about Peter and John: that Peter had governed a monastery at Constantinople, but that, having abandoned this on account of crimes, he had fled to Antioch; that there, when the catholic bishop Martyrius had been driven out, he had occupied his see through heretics; and that, condemned at once by Leo, then prince, he had been sent into exile at Oasis. From this exile he had returned to Constantinople and had given assurance that he would by no means dare to cause any further disturbances. But, as was said above, in the times of Basiliscus, having been condemned by that Timotheus who had come to Constantinople, he was sent back to Antioch, so that he might again hold the episcopate there.
Quo facto, idem Petrus Joannem quemdam presbyterum, de quo Acacium diiimus retulisse, ordinat Apamenis episcopum; a quibus non receptus venit Antiochiam, et Petrum episcopatus sui pellit auctorem et invaditejus Ecclesiam. Quos iterum damnatos dicit Acacius, petens ab apostolica sede, ut si forte ad eam confugerent, nec visu dignos haberet; et si jam aliquam indulgentiam forsitan impetrassent, irritam esse debere. nec eorum pœnitentiam recipiendam esse. Quod cum præfatus Joannes Alexandrinus episcopus relegisset, tacere non potuit, quod illum Joannem, quem Acacius damnaverat cum Petro, et sine remedio pœnitentiæ fecit ab apostolica sede damnari, post tot damnationes Tyriorum miserit Ecclesiae praesidere. Postquam ergo non solum nihil profecisse litteras decessoris sui sanctus Felix papa cognovit, et ludibria quaedam Acacio fieri in eversionem totius ecclesiasticae disciplinæ, electis Vitale episcopo Troentinate ex Picena regione, et Miseno Cumanæ Ecclesiae episcopo ex regione Campaniae, sub hac instructione direxit, ut Petrus de Alexandrina pellerelur Ecclesia, et ut libello sancti Joannis episcopi Alexandrini responderet Acacius, atque ipsi denuntiaretur Acacio, ut anathema diceret Petro. Qui quamvis hostili more detrusi in custodiam chartos amiserint, tamen perGdis hæreticis atque damnatis accommodare non debuerant, quae sola negari potuit, voluntatem.
When this had been done, the same Peter ordained as bishop of the Apameans a certain presbyter John, of whom we said that Acacius had reported; and when he was not received by them, he came to Antioch and drove out Peter, the author of his episcopate, and invaded his Church. Acacius declares that these men have again been condemned, asking the apostolic see that if by chance they should flee to it, it should not deem them worthy even of sight; and that if perhaps they had already obtained any indulgence, it should be void, and their penitence should not be received. When the aforesaid John, bishop of Alexandria, had read this, he could not keep silent, because that John whom Acacius had condemned together with Peter and, deprived of the remedy of penitence, had caused to be condemned by the apostolic see, he sent after so many condemnations to preside over the Church of the Tyrians. After therefore the holy Pope Felix learned that the letters of his predecessor had not only accomplished nothing, but that certain mockeries were being made of Acacius to the overthrow of all ecclesiastical discipline, he sent, having chosen Vitalis bishop of Troentina from the Picene region and Misenus bishop of the Cuman Church from the region of Campania, with this instruction: that Peter be driven from the Church of Alexandria, and that Acacius respond to the libellus of the holy John, bishop of Alexandria, and that it be denounced to Acacius himself that he should pronounce anathema upon Peter. Although these men, thrust into custody in hostile fashion, lost their papers, nevertheless they ought not to have accommodated to the reprobate and condemned heretics that will, which alone could be denied.
Non solum ergo non egerunt quæ jussa sunt, aut quæ expedire potcrant; sed etiam haereticis communicaverunt, confirmationem Petri episcopatus, ad quem pellendum missi fuerant, deferentes, atque contumelias in episcopum Joannem Acacio dirigente portantes. Quibus rebus habita synodo conimotus beatissimus papa, Vitalem et Misenum ab of. flcio et communione suspendit b, Acaciumque damnavit. Cujus audacia deteriora committens, etiam Petrum Antiochenum, ejecto catholico a Calendione, quem ipse ordinaverat, ad Antiochenam misit Ecclesiam.
ADDITAMENTUM EX TERTIA EDITIONE DESUMPTUM.
Postquam Joannes supervenit episcopus, quem Romana suscepit Ecclesia, sanctus papa Felix legationem (ut dictum est) sicut oportuit ordinavit, quae apud prædictos omnes quidquid est hostilitatis experta est. Nam detrusa in custodiam prædictis charlis, cum grandi vix remeavit opprobrio, episcopatum Petri, adquem expellendum missa fuerat confirmatum reportans, quem Romana anathematizarat Ecclesia. In Felix papa episcopis per Ægyptum. Thebaidem, Libyam et Pentapolim constitutis post alia; Peti us vero, qui se ab Ecclesiæ unitate sub beatæ recordationis Proterio separavit,et in mortem ipsius parricidæ Timotheo ad persequcndos se junxit orthodoxos, nulla tanti nominis, aut honoris permittimus societate laetari, quanto in creatoribus propriis non dissimilibus ipso sui exordio caducum, quod se æstimat reperitur.
Therefore they not only failed to do what was commanded, or what they could have done to advantage, but they even communicated with heretics, carrying to Peter the confirmation of his episcopate—the very man they had been sent to expel—and bearing insults against bishop John under the direction of Acacius. Moved by these events, the most blessed pope, having held a synod, suspended Vitalis and Misenus from office and communion, and condemned Acacius. In his audacity, committing worse deeds, he even sent the Antiochene Peter to the church of Antioch, after the catholic Calendion, whom he himself had ordained, had been driven out.
ADDITION TAKEN FROM THE THIRD EDITION.
After bishop John arrived, whom the Roman Church received, the holy pope Felix arranged the legation (as has been said) as was fitting, and it experienced every kind of hostility among all the aforementioned. For, thrust into custody with the aforementioned letters, it scarcely returned with great disgrace, reporting that the episcopate of Peter had been confirmed—the very man it had been sent to expel—whom the Roman Church had anathematized. In Felix, pope, to the bishops established throughout Egypt, the Thebaid, Libya, and the Pentapolis, among other things: But we permit Peter, who separated himself from the unity of the Church under Proterius of blessed memory, and joined himself to the parricide Timothy for the persecution of the orthodox, to rejoice in no fellowship of so great a name or honor, inasmuch as in his own beginnings, not unlike his own creators, he is found to be perishable, which he thinks himself to be.
Est ergo præfatus cuneUs anathema, nec ab Ecclesia catholica credatur unquam recipi, qui post cohortationem saepissimam et per tot annorum spatia in perversitate propria perseverans, locum satisfactionis amisit.
EDICTUM SENTENTIÆ FELICIS PAPÆPROPTER ACACII EPISCOPI CP. DAMNATIONEM.
Acacius, qui secundo a nobis admonitus statutorum salubrium non destitit esse contemptor, meque in meis credidit carcerixandum, hunc Deus, cœlitus prolata sententia, de sacerdotio fecit extorrem. Ergo si quis episcopus, clericus, monachus, laicus, post hanc denuntiationem eidem communicaverit, anathema sit, sancto Spiritu exsequente.
EPISTOLA IX.
FELICIS III PAPÆ AD ZENONEM IMPERATOREM.
Conqueritur de violatis ab eo legatis, suadetque at acquiescat damnationi Petri Alexandrini et Acacii. Felix Zenoni Augusto.
Quoniam pietas tua, licet profusiore pagina ad mea scripta responderit, suis auribus diligentius intimatam fastidio dignam credidit veritatem: curandum mihi fuit, ut breviter quæ nou vultis latius publicari definita concluderem. Itaque officiositate premissa timere me fateor regno vesiro pariter et saluti.
That aforementioned assembly is therefore anathema, and let it never be believed that anyone is received by the catholic Church who, after very frequent exhortation and persevering in his own perversity through the span of so many years, has lost the place of satisfaction.
EDICT OF THE SENTENCE OF POPE FELIX ON ACCOUNT OF THE CONDEMNATION OF ACACIUS, BISHOP OF CONSTANTINOPLE.
Acacius, who, when admonished by us a second time, did not cease to be a despiser of salutary statutes, and believed that I was to be imprisoned in my own [see], him God, by a sentence pronounced from heaven, has made an exile from the priesthood. Therefore if any bishop, cleric, monk, or layman, after this denunciation, has communicated with him, let him be anathema, the Holy Spirit executing it.
LETTER IX.
OF POPE FELIX III TO THE EMPEROR ZENO.
He complains of the legates violated by him, and urges that he acquiesce in the condemnation of Peter of Alexandria and of Acacius. Felix to Zeno Augustus.
Since your piety, although it has answered my writings with a more copious page, has deemed the truth, more diligently brought to its ears, worthy of disdain: I have taken care to conclude briefly the things which you do not wish to be published at greater length. Therefore, after the greeting of courtesy, I confess that I fear for your kingdom equally and for your salvation.
Siquidem contra divinam reverentiam probabitur, ut beati apostoli Petri directa legatio, sicut ejus confessio patefecit, tanquam in captivitate redacta teneretur, et chartis quas bajulabat violenter ablatis, ad communicandum hæreticis, hoc est apocrisiariis Alexandrini Petri, adversum quem ierat, de custodia sit producta. Quapropter (Nicolaus / papa, epist. 9) Vitalem quidem et Misenum, cur vel impulsi ad ista consenserint, honore simul et communione apostolica censura privavit. Sed (Ibid.) cum apud barbaras etiam nationes, atque ipsius Deitatis ignaras, pro exscquendis negotiis vel humanis, jure gentium legationis cujuslibet habeatur sacrosancta libertas; notum est omnibus, quanto magis ab imperatore Romano et Christiano principe, in rebus præsertim divinis, oportuerit intemeratam servari. Deindc legatione submota, quae apud vos, ut dictum est, ncc beati Petri apostoli inviolata esse jam potuit, tranquillitas tua litterarum saltim tenore cognoscat, sedum beati apostoli Petri Alexandrino Petro, olim justeque damnato, ac nihilominus per sententiam synodalem nuper eliso, communionis nunquam vel præbuisse, vel præbituram esse consensura. Quia, ut cætera nunc omittam, aD næreticisinstitutus, contra fas omne catholicæ praesidere non possit Ecclesiæ.
For it will be proved contrary to divine reverence that the direct legation of the blessed apostle Peter, as his confession made clear, should be held as though reduced to captivity, and that, with the documents he was carrying violently taken away, it should be brought out of custody to communicate with heretics, that is, with the apocrisiarii of Peter of Alexandria, against whom he had gone. Wherefore (Nicholas, pope, epistle 9) by apostolic censure he deprived both Vitalis and Misenus of honor together with communion, for consenting to these things, even though under compulsion. But (Ibid.) since even among barbarous nations, and those ignorant of the Godhead itself, for the transaction of human affairs, the sacrosanct liberty of any legation is held by the law of nations, it is known to all how much more it ought to have been preserved inviolate by the Roman emperor and Christian prince, especially in divine matters. Then, with the legation removed—which, as has been said, could no longer be inviolate even for the blessed apostle Peter—let your Tranquility know at least by the tenor of letters that it has never given, nor will it ever consent to give, communion to Peter of Alexandria, the blessed apostle Peter's own, long since justly condemned, and nonetheless recently crushed by synodal sentence. Because, to omit other matters now, one appointed by heretics cannot, against all right, preside over the catholic Church.
Unde quoniam adhortationem meam duxistis onerosam, in vestro relinquo deliberationis arbitrio utrum beati apostoli Petri an Alexandrini Petri, cuiquam sit eligenda communio. Qualis autem Alexandrinus exstiterit, vel quemadmodum falsi nominis sacerdotium per unum vix suae complicem pravitatis temerarius usurparit, atque in damnatorum fuerit etiam apud vos dudum sone numeratus, suffragatoris ejus Acacii litteris ad sanctae memoriae decessorem meum datis, quarum exemplaria subdita cernitis, approbatc. Utrum vel episcopus dici valeat, quod nomen etiamsi a pluribus episcopis accepisset, habere non posset, vel orlbodoxis plebibus contra Nicænam synodum, contra observantiam singularem, mereatur imponi, prompta in Deum pietate perpendite. Ubi etiam apparet evidenter Acacium, qui excessus suos sub vestro potius nomine celare voluit quam vobis profutura suggerere, tam saluti vestrae devotionem deferre sinceram, quam fidelem conscientiam circa Patrum regulas, atque ipsum dogma gestaret catholicum.
Wherefore, since you have deemed my exhortation burdensome, I leave it to your own judgment of deliberation whether the communion of the blessed apostle Peter or of the Alexandrian Peter is to be chosen by anyone. But of what sort the Alexandrian was, or how, as a priest of a false name, he recklessly usurped the priesthood through one who was scarcely his accomplice in depravity, and was long since counted among the condemned even among you by the letters of his supporter Acacius, given to my predecessor of holy memory, copies of which you see appended, is approved. Consider with ready piety toward God whether he can even be called a bishop, which name, even if he had received it from many bishops, he could not have, or whether he deserves to be imposed upon orthodox peoples against the Nicene synod, against singular observance. Here it also appears evidently that Acacius, who wished to conceal his own excesses under your name rather than suggest what would profit you, showed as sincere devotion to your salvation as he carried a faithful conscience toward the rules of the Fathers and the catholic dogma itself.
Propterea hunc eumdem, ut pote qui multa conlra scita veterum nefaria perpetrarit, et ejus laudator emerserit, quem asseruit et ipse damnatum, et ab apostolica fecit sede damnari, ac rursus ædificans quae ante destruxerat, ' praevaricatorem se ipse constituit; eorum quos sequi maluit portioni districtionis aposiolicæper Tutum Romanae Ecclesiæ defensorem, justa deputavit auctoritas, atque a commuDione et dignitate apostolica, qua se ipse ejus externis sociando monstravit indignum, legitima severitate discrevit. Puto autem quod pietas tua, quae etiam suis mavult vinci legibus quam reniti, cœlestibus debeat parere decretis: atque ita humanarum sibi rerum fastigium noverit esse commissum, ut tamen ea quae divina sunt per dispensatores divinitus attributos percipienda non ambigat. Puto quod vobis sine ulla dubitatione sit utile, si Ecclesiam catholicam vestri tempore principatus sinatis uti legibus suis; nec libertati ejus quemquam permittatis obsistere, qua: regni vobis restituit potestatem.
Therefore the same man, inasmuch as he has wickedly perpetrated many things against the decrees of the ancients, and has emerged as a praiser of him whom he himself asserted to be condemned and caused to be condemned by the apostolic see, and again building up what he had before destroyed, has made himself a prevaricator; the apostolic authority has justly assigned him to the portion of the apostolic severity through Tutus, defender of the Roman Church, and by legitimate severity has separated him from the communion and apostolic dignity, which he himself showed himself unworthy of by joining himself to its outsiders. But I think that your piety, which prefers even to be conquered by its own laws rather than to resist them, ought to obey the heavenly decrees; and that it should know that the summit of human affairs has been entrusted to it in such a way that it should nevertheless not doubt that the things that are divine are to be received through stewards divinely appointed. I think that it would be useful to you without any doubt if you were to allow the catholic Church in the time of your principate to use its own laws; and you should not permit anyone to resist its liberty, by which it has restored to you the power of your kingdom.
Certum est enim hoc rebus vestris esse salutare, ut cum de causis Dei agitur, et juxla ipsius constitutum, regiam voluntatero sacerdotibus Christi studeatis subdere, non praeferre, et sacrosaucta per eorum praesules discere potius quam docere; Ecclesiae formam sequi, non huic bumanitus sequenda jura præfigere;neque ejus sanctionibus velle dominari, cui Deus voluit clementiam tuam piae devotionis colla submittere: ne dum mensura coelestis dispositionis exceditur, ealur in contumeliam disponentis. Et ex hoc quidem de his omnibus conscientiammeam ante tribunal Christi causam dicturus absolvo. Vestrae mentis intererit magis ac magis cogitare et in rerum praesentium statu sub divina nos examinalione subsistere, ac post hnjus vitæ cursum ad divinum consequenter ventur os esse judicium. Et alia manu. Data calendis Augusti (anuo Christi 484), Venantio V. C. consule.
For it is certain that this is salutary for your affairs: that when the causes of God are at issue, and according to his own ordinance, you should study to subject the royal will to the priests of Christ, not to prefer it before them, and to learn the sacred mysteries through their prelates rather than to teach them; to follow the form of the Church, not to set before it laws to be followed in a human manner; nor to wish to lord it over her sanctions, to which God has willed that your clemency submit the neck of pious devotion: lest, while the measure of the heavenly disposition is exceeded, it be trodden under contempt of the one who disposes. And on this account, indeed, concerning all these things, I absolve my conscience, about to plead my cause before the tribunal of Christ. It will be for your mind to consider more and more, and in the present state of affairs, that we stand under divine examination, and that after the course of this life we are consequently to come to the divine judgment. And in another hand. Given on the Kalends of August (in the year of Christ 484), in the consulship of Venantius, most illustrious.
EPISTOLA X.
FELICIS III PAPÆ AD CLERUM ET PLEBEM CONSTANTI NOPOLITANAM
Ne turbentur ob prævaricationem legatorum, atque ut Acacii a sede apostolica damnati commumonem devitent.
Felix clero et plebi orthodoxis Constantinopoli constitutis dilectissimis filiis salutem.
Probatam cunctis vestrae fidei firmitatem Vitalis atque Miseni non irrationabiliter opinamur praevaricatione turbatam: qui universa quæ illis mandata sunt, non tantum negligendo, verum etiam impugnando, fecerunt ut Ecclesia Romana consentire damnatis hæreticis crederetur; quando contra vetitum his qui a Petro illo [Mongo] hæretico, parricidarum socio, olim justeque dejecto, et toties anathematizato, directi, atque ab Acacio suscepti sunt, nostrorum immemores mandatorum, communicare convicti sunt, nulla contestatione præmissa, quam tamen, sicut his praeceptum fuerat, religio vestræ sanctitatis audiret; actumquc est ut, siculi praediximus, excessus illorum noster [crederetur assensus. Quos et ordinibus suis, et "eneranda divini mysterii perceptione privavimus. Nullus ergo vestrum per tale commissum sit immemor sui, nec nos aestimet in apostolicæ traditionis defensione deficere, quos videt I fidei contumeliam in prodilores et perditos vindicasse. Scire vos quoque decuit Acacii quondam a episcopi varietatem inconstantiamque detectam.
LETTER X.
OF POPE FELIX III TO THE CLERGY AND PEOPLE OF CONSTANTINOPLE
That they be not disturbed by the prevarication of the legates, and that they avoid the communion of Acacius, condemned by the apostolic see.
Felix to the orthodox clergy and people established at Constantinople, his most beloved sons, greeting.
We think, not unreasonably, that the firmness of your faith, approved by all, has been disturbed by the prevarication of Vitalis and Misenus: who, by not only neglecting but even attacking everything that was commanded to them, have caused it to be believed that the Roman Church consented to condemned heretics; since, contrary to the prohibition, having been sent to him who was once justly deposed by that Peter, the heretic, the associate of parricides, and so many times anathematized, and having been received by Acacius, forgetful of our commands, they were convicted of communicating with him, with no protest premised, which nevertheless, as had been commanded them, the religion of your holiness would hear; and it has come about that, as we have said, their transgression was believed to be our assent. We have deprived them both of their ranks and of the venerable perception of the divine mystery. Let none of you, therefore, through such a commission, be forgetful of himself, nor estimate that we fail in the defense of the apostolic tradition, whom he sees to have avenged the insult to the faith upon the betrayers and the lost. It behooved you also to know that the fickleness and inconstancy of Acacius, once bishop, has been detected.
Qui cum do Petro islo, sicut probatur adnexis, non ferenda retulerit, atque olim dixerit fuisse damnatum, per legatos nostros multis laudibus prosecutus, contra conscientiam fecit, utrum ei quidquam credendum sit, omnes qui timorem Dei ante oculos constituunt judicabunt. Alienarum quoque provinciarum sibi jura defendens, sanctorum trecentorum decem et octo Patrum canones illicitarum sibi ordinationum praesumptor est conatus everterc. Quorum etiam ob hoc subjacet ultioni; nec Romanae, id est apostolicæ sedis, qua se ipse privavit, communione jam gaudet. Quando Petri Eutychianistæ socius et susceptor apparens, damnationis ejus se participem indicavit. Quem nostra quoque sententia ministerii episcopalis oflicio, et sancta communione, vestroque numero, id est Christiano, judicavit alienum, sicut reperitur in adnexis. Filio autem nostro Salomoni presbytero, quem Acacius, ut placeret haereticis, suo privare putavit gradu, gradum proprium sententia vestra conservet, vel omnes qui forte a memorato propulsi, in locis suis et in nostra communione manere pronuntiet. Quamvis autem zelum vestrae fidei noverimus, monemus tamen ut omnes qui catholicae fidei volunt esse participes, ab illius se communione abstineant, ne, quod absit, simili subjaceant ultioni.
Since he reported from this Peter things not to be borne, as is proved by the attached documents, and since he had once said that he had been condemned, yet honored him with many praises through our legates, he acted against his own conscience; whether anything he says is to be believed, all who set the fear of God before their eyes will judge. Moreover, defending for himself the rights of other provinces, the presumptuous man attempted to overturn the canons of the three hundred and eighteen holy Fathers concerning unlawful ordinations. For this reason he also lies under their punishment; nor does he any longer enjoy the communion of the Roman, that is, the apostolic see, from which he has deprived himself. Since, appearing as the companion and supporter of Peter the Eutychianist, he showed himself a partaker of his condemnation. Our sentence also has judged him alien from the office of the episcopal ministry, from holy communion, and from your number, that is, the Christian number, as is found in the attached documents. But to our son Salomon the presbyter, whom Acacius thought to deprive of his rank, in order to please the heretics, let your sentence preserve his own rank, or declare that all who have perhaps been driven out by the aforementioned man remain in their places and in our communion. Although we know the zeal of your faith, nevertheless we warn that all who wish to be partakers of the catholic faith abstain from his communion, lest, which God forbid, they lie under a similar punishment.
EPISTOLA XI.
FELICIS PAPÆ III AD MONACHOS URBIS CONSTANTINO POLITANÆ ET BITHYNIÆ.
Tutum, Ecclesiæ defensorem. prævaricationis causa fuisse damnatum, et quomodo ipsi in suos qui Acacio adhæserint animadvertere debeant.
Felix, Rufino, Thalasio, presbyteris et archimandritis, et caeteris monachis circa Conslantinopolim et Bitbyniam constitutis.
Diabolicae artis astutias frequentius experimur, sed malignitati ejus, Deo juvante, non cedimus. Nam cum ea quae toties pro constantia fidei disponuntur fraus ejus vacuare molitur, necesse est ut et viribus quas divina gratia subministrat, conatus ipsius exstirpemus. Acceptis itaque litteris dilectionis vestrae, quarum Basilius fuit lator, inter caetera a Tutus, quem ob hoc feceramus defensorem Ecclesiae de provectioribus intra Ecclesiam clericis, ut quam dirigi non Ii. cebat, in Acacium sententiam ipse portaret, se quadam dementia, imo ardore pecuniae, postquam nostris satisfactum est conslitutis, inimicis fidei vendidisse convictus est atque confessus. Lectae sunt enim litterae ipsius in conventu fratrum, qualiter pacta interposita persona, Marone condemnato, ei cui sententiam portarat inhæsisse creditur: quas proprias esse cognoscens, non potuit diffiteri.
EPISTLE XI.
OF POPE FELIX III TO THE MONKS OF THE CITY OF CONSTANTINOPLE AND OF BITHYNIA.
That Tutus, a defender of the Church, was condemned for the crime of prevarication, and how they themselves ought to take action against those who adhered to Acacius.
Felix, to Rufinus, Thalasius, presbyters and archimandrites, and to the other monks established around Constantinople and Bithynia.
We experience the cunning of the devil's art rather often, but by God's help we do not yield to his malice. For since he strives to make void by his fraud those things which are so often ordained for the constancy of the faith, it is necessary that we also, by the strength which divine grace supplies, root out his attempts. Therefore, having received the letters of your beloved selves, of which Basil was the bearer, among other things it has been established and confessed that Tutus, whom for this reason we had made a defender of the Church from among the more advanced clerics within the Church, so that he might carry to Acacius the sentence which could not be directed [otherwise], through a certain madness—nay, rather through greed for money—after our decrees had been satisfied, sold himself to the enemies of the faith. For his letters were read in the assembly of the brethren, showing how, with a pact interposed and Maro condemned, he is believed to have adhered to him to whom he had carried the sentence; and recognizing these letters as his own, he could not deny them.
Unde eum fidei et sedis apostolicæ proditorem, officio defensoris quod ei ad tempus dederamus exuimus, eumque sacrosancti mysterii communione privatum præcipitarique cognitione praecepimus, monentes dilectionem vestram, ut sicut semper fecistis, pro custodia veritatis I jugi observatione vigiletis. Et quia non est dubium nonnullos ex monasteriis vestris esse deceptos, atque ad inimicos Dei, seu sponte, seu necessitate transisse, observandum vobis de talibus hoc esse mandamus, ut quisquis cujuslibet loci apud vos, vel sponte se dedit, vel mercede corruptus, collegii vestri sit prorsus alienus. Quia nisi a fidelibus perfidi sint remoti, rerum discretione sublata, laborabunt suapicionibus innocentes, ut ad vitia facitis hominibus est prolapsus. A probatorum consortio contagia repe!lenda sunt perditorum: quoniam mores bonos colloquia, sicut scriptum est (1 Cor. xv, 53), perversa corrumpunt. Illorum vero aliter causa tractanda est, quos constiterit poenis gravibus ut traducerentur amictos. Circa quos humaniores vos esse convenit, ut ad cellulas sub districtione pœnitentiæ revertantur, et fidelioribus lacrymis eorum quod lapsi sunt expietur, donec exclusis inimicis, et perveraoribus suis catholica purgetur Ecclesia.
Therefore, we have stripped him of the office of defender, which we had given him for a time, as a betrayer of the faith and of the apostolic see, and we have ordered that he be deprived of communion in the most sacred mystery and be cast down from his rank, warning your beloved selves that, as you have always done, you may keep watch for the guarding of the truth with continual observance. And since there is no doubt that some from your monasteries have been deceived and have gone over to the enemies of God, either voluntarily or under compulsion, we command that this be observed by you concerning such persons: that whoever, from whatever place among you, has either given himself over voluntarily or been corrupted by payment, be entirely alien to your community. For unless the faithless are kept apart from the faithful, with all distinction of things removed, the innocent will suffer from suspicions, as men are prone to vices. The contagion of the lost must be driven back from the company of the approved, since, as it is written, evil communications corrupt good manners. But the case of those must be handled otherwise whom it is established were clothed with grave punishments so that they might be led astray. Concerning these it is fitting that you be more humane, so that they may return to their cells under the strict discipline of penance, and what they have fallen into may be atoned for by their more faithful tears, until, with the enemies and their perverters shut out, the catholic Church may be cleansed.
SUPPLEMENTUM ACACIANUM,
Monumenta nunquamediia continens, quæ marehio Scipio Maffeius e vetustissimis Veronensis capitali codd. eruit atque illustravit.
IN FELICIS EPISTOLAM ACACII PROrUGNATORES REFUTANTEM PRÆFATIO.
BibliothecæVeronensi manuscriptæ, quam haud levibus quidem de causis intra demesticos cancellos adhuccontineo,Supplementumhocce Acacianaecausae emittens, particulam aliam demo, ac veluti membro quodam rursus minuo. Cassiodorii complexiones ut ab eo corpore avellerem, paucis abhinc annis concives evicerunt docti atque amicissimi; ut hasce epistolas ab eodem diduci patiar, Nicolai Coleti obtinuit instantia|; praeclarum quoddam ecclesiasticae antiquitatis monumentum a me etiam atque etiam exposcentis, ad instructissimam, quam adornat, Conciliorum collectionem augendam atque exornandam. Ut morem gererem, hunc potissime tractatum selegi, quem anno repertum, exscriptum ac quomodocunque illustratam mihi seposueram. Quanti vero eximum documentum faciendum sit, quoveloco habendum, statim arbitror a doctis omnibus perspectum iri, ubi et a Felice III profectum intelligant, cujus epistolae aliæ eodem prorsus stylo exaratæ inter cloquentissimas quæ a Romanis pontificibus emanarint, recenseri solent; et in ea causa versari, qua paucæ reperiantur in ecclesiastica historia nobiliores, et majonbus studiis agitatæ acdefensæ.
SUPPLEMENT TO THE ACA CIAN AFFAIRS,
containing monuments never before published, which the Marquis Scipio Maffeius extracted from the most ancient manuscripts of the Verona chapter library and illustrated.
PREFACE TO THE LETTER OF FELIX REFUTING THE CHAMPIONS OF ACACIUS.
In publishing this Supplement to the Acacian affair, I again diminish by another portion, and as it were once more cut off a limb from, the manuscript library of Verona, which for no slight reasons I still keep within my domestic confines. A few years ago certain learned and most friendly fellow citizens prevailed upon me to tear the Complexiones of Cassiodorius from that body; and the insistence of Nicolaus Coletus has obtained that I allow these letters to be separated from the same, since he earnestly and repeatedly sought from me a certain distinguished monument of ecclesiastical antiquity, to be added to and adorn the most fully equipped collection of the Councils which he is preparing. To comply with his wish, I selected especially this treatise, which, found, copied out, and in some manner illustrated by me in that year, I had set aside for myself. But how great a value should be placed upon this excellent document, and what place it should hold, I think will at once be perceived by all the learned, when they understand that it also proceeds from Felix III, whose other letters, written in precisely the same style, are customarily numbered among the most eloquent that have ever emanated from the Roman pontiffs; and that it concerns a cause in which few are found more renowned in ecclesiastical history, or more vigorously pursued and defended by our forebears.
Agit siquidem de Acacii Constantinopolitani episcopi damnatione, illamque apostolicæ sedis sententiam tuetur ac propugnat, ex qua tam acre atque diuturnum cum Orientalibus episcopis ortum dissidium est. Neque vero disce ptationis illius, factique omnis historiam pertexere, atque hic praeponere operae pretium duco: quod omnino supervacaneumesset, cum percelebris Annalium pater, ac plures post illum docti viri, specialibus etiam in id adornatis lucubrationibus, rem omnem, amplissime pertractarint.
Epistolam acephalus servat liber in vetustissima canonicorum Veronensium bibliotheca. Majori Romana littera ut inter capitulares quamptures alii non commendatur, solo N calli formam retinente. Etcmenta partim typographicis, vel quas nunc adhibemus, notis, partim antiquæ celeri scriptioni assimitantur; quod scribendi genus proximiori ævo tribui I solet: hunc tamen codicem pervetustumesse, nullus dubito, quod alibi persequar. Ejus figura perfectæ quadratae propior est cæteris, subflavum atramentum, orthographia antiquior, frustumque, quod habet, catalogi pontificalis in Vigilio desinit, qui sedit medio saeculo sexto. Eadem manu scriptus est totus: lignea palmula, quae ab una parte reliqua adhuc est, alterius codicis membrana cooperitur, maximis litteris depicta.
It deals, then, with the condemnation of Acacius, bishop of Constantinople, and it defends and champions that sentence of the apostolic see from which so sharp and long-lasting a dissension with the Eastern bishops arose. Nor indeed do I think it worthwhile to weave together and set forth here the history of that disputation and of the whole affair: for it would be entirely superfluous, since that most renowned father of the Annals, and many learned men after him, in works specially composed for the purpose, have treated the whole matter most copiously.
A book in the most ancient library of the canons of Verona preserves the letter without a beginning. It is recommended rather by the larger Roman script, as several others among the capital letters are not, with only the N retaining the form of a callus. The elements are partly assimilated to typographic notes, or those which we now use, and partly to the ancient rapid writing; which style of writing is usually attributed to a more recent age: yet I have no doubt that this codex is very ancient, which I shall pursue elsewhere. Its shape is closer to the perfect square than the others, the ink is yellowish, the orthography more ancient, and the fragment of the pontifical catalogue which it contains ends in Vigilius, who sat in the middle of the sixth century. It is all written by the same hand: a wooden handle, of which the rest remains on one side, is covered by the membrane of another codex, depicted in the largest letters.
Post alia plura epistolarum ac monumentorum ad Acacii causam spectantium eamdem collectionem hic liber continet, quæ in Codice canonum visitur edito a Paschasio Quesnello in appendicc ad opera S. Leonis: Ecclesiæ Romane Codicem idem scriptor appellat et putat. Præcedit ergo Narrationis ordo, quem Labbeana Conciliorum editio non exhibet, at exhibuit Crabbiana, respondet autem magna ex parte Breviculo historiæ Eutychianiastarum, quem Sirmondo debemus. Sequuntur cætera eodem ordine, consentiente at plurimum cum editis ms. codice, variis quibusdam nonmagni moinenti lectionibus aut verborum transpositionibus exceptis. At insignis diversitas in ea epistola occurrit, quæ in Conciliis Gelasii est, et in canonum Codice capitulo notatur 51. Columna siquidem apud Labbeum (Tom. IV), ubi legitur: Et ab eadem vos proprio judicio separasse videamini; pergunt editiones omnes: et adhuc dicitis, vel, Dicitis etiam synodum in unius hominis persona, etc. At Is. noster, post verbum videamini, duas basce paginas subdit atque interponit:
After many other things, this book contains the same collection of letters and records pertaining to the case of Acacius, which is seen in the Code of canons published by Paschasius Quesnel in the appendix to the works of St. Leo: the same writer calls it and considers it the Code of the Roman Church. Therefore the order of the Narrative comes first, which the Labbe edition of the Councils does not exhibit, but the Crabbe edition did exhibit; and it corresponds in large part to the Brief History of the Eutychianists, which we owe to Sirmond. The rest follow in the same order, agreeing for the most part with the published manuscript codex, with the exception of certain variant readings or transpositions of words of no great importance. But a remarkable diversity occurs in that letter which is in the Councils of Gelasius and is noted in the Code of canons as chapter 51. For at Labbe (Volume IV), where it is read: "And you may be seen to have separated yourselves from the same by your own judgment"; all editions continue: "and you still say," or, "You also say that the synod, in the person of one man," etc. But our Isidore, after the word "you may be seen," adds and inserts these two pages:
Ecce agnoverunt, in corum professione qui constantissime perdurarunt, quid fidei communioque catholicæ deberetur. Ecce agnoverunt quemadmoduma talibus recedendo, imo talibus. cantraria moliendo, a fide et communionecatholicadeviarit Acacius, seque pariter cum eodem errori subdiderint. Ecce agnoverunt quam justis ex causis pro fide et communione catholica atque apostolica, cui et illi qui in ea perstiterant, congrue-, bant, et illi qui perstantibus obviabant, ab eadem docebantur alieni, sedis apostolicæ auctoritate sit remotus Acacius, ejusque pariter quicunque complices exstiterunt; atque ab illa merito cum his communione discretus, a qua se ipse primum cum suis consortibus a catholicis pontificibus discrepando cognoscitur separasse; jureque sententiam ille damnationis excepit, cæteris consortibus promulgandam, qui soluspro omnibus suis consortibus in communionem se recidisse perfidiæ ad apostolicam sedem missis litteris eat professus. Cui si communicarant Orientales episcopi, antequam huc referrent, pari utique reatu sine dubio probabantur involvi; jureque per illum transgressionis sententiam susceperunt, tanquam facti cum eudem communionis externæ; qui utique non consuli tanquam nostræ communionis homines jam deberent, sed tanquam in contrario positi consortio refutari.
Behold, they have recognized, in the confession of those who persevered most steadfastly, what was owed to the faith and the catholic communion. Behold, they have recognized how, by withdrawing from such things—or rather, by attempting things contrary to them—Acacius deviated from the faith and the catholic communion, and they likewise subjected themselves with him to error. Behold, they have recognized by how just causes, for the faith and the catholic and apostolic communion—to which both those who persevered in it were rightly attached, and those who opposed those who persevered were shown to be alien from it—Acacius was removed by the authority of the apostolic see, and likewise all who were his accomplices; and that he was rightly separated in communion from that see from which he himself is known first to have separated himself together with his associates by disagreeing with the catholic bishops; and that he justly received the sentence of condemnation, to be promulgated to his other associates, since he alone, on behalf of all his associates, professed in letters sent to the apostolic see that he had fallen back into the communion of perfidy. If the Eastern bishops had communicated with him before they referred this matter hither, they were undoubtedly shown to be involved in equal guilt; and they justly received through him the sentence of transgression, as having been made partakers with him of an external communion; and they ought no longer to be consulted as men of our communion, but rejected as placed in a contrary fellowship.
Si vero non communicaverant antequam Acacius huc referret, et communicantem notare debuerant, et ipsi de eodem potius huc referre; atque apostolicæ sedis vigore perculsum merito comprobare, cumque sede apostolica tantisque illis catholicis pontificibus magis tenere concordiam. Sed quia ab illorum societate discesserant, et eorum successoribus communicare delegerant, ideo cum sede apostolica minime congruebant; quia in sortem reciderant prævaricatoris Acacit, et illius se sine dubio prævidebant sententia consequenter astringi. Ob hoc eum videri nolebant esse damnatum, quia se cognoscebant in eadem prævaricatione damnatos, in qua hodie manere persistunt. Sed sicut hi simili conditione constricti complicem suum non possunt judicare non jure damnatum, neque rei reum possunt competenler absolvere, sic illo juste prævaricatore damnato, isti quoque pari jacent damnatione prostrati, neque nisi resipiscentes inde poterunt prorsus absolvi. Et adhuc dicitis synodum in unius, etc.
But if they had not been in communion before Acacius reported this matter here, they ought both to have marked the one in communion and to have reported the same matter here themselves; and rightly to have approved him as struck down by the vigor of the apostolic see, and to have held concord more with the apostolic see and with those many catholic pontiffs. But because they had departed from the society of those men, and had chosen to communicate with their successors, therefore they were in no way in accord with the apostolic see; because they had fallen into the lot of the prevaricator Acacius, and they foresaw without doubt that they would consequently be bound by his sentence. For this reason they did not wish him to be seen as condemned, because they recognized that they themselves were condemned in the same prevarication, in which they persist in remaining today. But just as these men, bound by a similar condition, cannot judge their accomplice to be unjustly condemned, nor can the guilty absolve the guilty fittingly, so, when that prevaricator has been justly condemned, these men also lie prostrate under an equal condemnation, nor can they be wholly absolved from it unless they repent. And still you say that the synod of one, etc.
Acacianis actis in memorata editione epistola haec finem imponit; at in Veronensi codice nova, et nunquam hactenus visa subsequitur, quam in præsentia vulgamus. Post quam epistola ad Euphemium seriem claudit, quæ caeteris Gelasii præponi solet: ita ut complementum quodammodo hic appareat ad percelebrem causam pertinentium monumentorum.
Quod ad epistolam nostram attinet, pluribus locis eloquentiae luminibus nilet; quamvis inficiari nemo possit luxuriari auctorem aliquando, acutumque ac, subtile dicendi genus curiose conseCtari. Ordinem mirabitur aliquis quo utitur, sive quo caret, tum inconnexa quandoque membra, et sententias saepius repetitas. At praeterquam quod adversario fortasse insistit, luxato codici, id ex parte tribuendum suspicor. Mirum sane est quot librarii mendis, quanta, ut videtur, sententiarum corruptione ac perturbatione non uno laboret loco: quihus si stylum adjicias quibusdam locis aliquanto implexum, difficultatemque ex interpunctionis atque distictionis defectu scriptionibus antiquis communem, eæ creabantur ambages, ut cum extricari vix posse crederem, poenituerit non semel tam molesto operi manum admovisse, hancque curam abjecturus jam fuerirn non semel.
In the aforementioned edition, this letter brings the Acts of the Acacians to a close; but in the Verona codex a new letter follows, never seen before now, which we publish at present. After this letter, the series closes with the letter to Euphemius, which is customarily placed before the others of Gelasius, so that here there appears, as it were, a completion pertaining to the very celebrated matter of these monuments.
As for our letter, it shines in many places with the lights of eloquence, although no one can deny that the author is sometimes extravagant and curiously pursues a sharp and subtle manner of speaking. One may wonder at the order he uses, or rather lacks, then at the sometimes disconnected members and the sentences repeated rather often. But besides the fact that he perhaps presses hard upon his adversary, I suspect this is partly to be attributed to a corrupt codex. It is truly remarkable with how many errors of copyists, with how great, as it seems, a corruption and disturbance of sentences, he labors in more than one place; to these, if you add a style in certain places somewhat involved, and the difficulty common to ancient writings from the lack of punctuation and distinction, such ambiguities were created that, when I believed they could scarcely be disentangled, I regretted more than once having put my hand to so troublesome a task, and I would already have been about to cast off this care more than once.
Transpositis praecipue deterrebat ac luxatis locis, quod vitium cum alicubi deprehenderem, cogebar et alibi suspicari; sed confirmavit id me tandem, atque in proposito retinuit, cum animadverterem caeteris quoque tum hujus pontificis, tum successoris Gelasii scriptis idem prorsus infortunium veluti fato quodam accidisse: quorum plura monumenta ita perturbata, ni fallor, ad nos pervenerunt, atque intermixta, ut tanquam Sibyllina carmina foHis mandata, rapidis ludibria ventis volitasse aliquando mihi videantur.
A falso titulo epistola nostra rem in manuscripto auspicatur: Exemptum rationis reddendæ beati Gelasii papæ de evitanda communione Acacii, missa ad Urien tales episcopos: habet etiam in fine: Explicit beati Gelasii de evitanda communione Acacii. Quo nomine perspicuum est falso inscribi, cum enim vivente Acado exarata sit, aut nondum certe mortis suae nuntio Romam perlato, Gelasio tribui non potest post annos tres ab Acacii morte inaugurato. Nihilominus Gelasii laudato nomine priores hujus tractatus versus attulit Nicolaus I in epistola ad universos Galliæ episcopos. Sed non hæc tantum Felicis epistola Gelasii nomeu prae se tulit in mss.
It was chiefly the transposed and dislocated passages that deterred me, for when I detected this fault in one place I was compelled to suspect it elsewhere too; but at last it confirmed me in this view and kept me to my purpose, when I observed that the same misfortune had, as it were by a kind of fate, befallen the other writings as well of this pontiff and of his successor Gelasius: many of their records, unless I am mistaken, have come down to us so disordered and intermingled that at times they seem to me to have flitted about like the Sibylline verses consigned to leaves, a mockery to the swift winds.
Our letter begins the matter in the manuscript with a false title: "A statement of the account of blessed Pope Gelasius concerning the avoidance of communion with Acacius, sent to Urial and other bishops"; it also has at the end: "Here ends blessed Gelasius on the avoidance of communion with Acacius." By this name it is plainly falsely inscribed, since, although it was written while Acacius was alive, or at any rate before the report of his death had certainly reached Rome, it cannot be attributed to Gelasius, who was inaugurated three years after the death of Acacius. Nevertheless, Nicholas I, in his letter to all the bishops of Gaul, cited the earlier verses of this treatise under the honored name of Gelasius. But it was not only this letter of Felix that bore the name of Gelasius before it in the manuscripts.
Eodem præfixo nomine inventa est inter alias a Sirmondo, quae in Labbeana editione est, nec ab editis, ut ego puto, hic omnino abest error: iti quem delabi notariis in proclivi fuit, cum ob styli similitudinem ac temporis propinquitatem, tum ob res easdem eademque argumenta ab utroque pontifice pertractata. Principio etiam ac fine carentia ex eorumdem monumentis videmus plura: a quo more nostrum hoc nequaquam deflectere ut pote acephalum conspicimus; etiamsi majori littera, nultaque mutilationis nota in ms. incipiat. Depravationes vero luxationesque quas in nostro deprehendo, quaedam item ex aliis horride deformasse, ex eo maxime credendum est, quod post præstantium editorum studium ac diligentiam squalleant adhuc ac monsirosa sint. Illa auLm paulo attentius inspexisse, magnamque in aliquibus perturbationem detexisse, infimus, ut opinor, laboris hujus nostri fructus non erit. Quorumdam ergo contextum et sententias aliquas summatim expendamus.
Under the same prefixed name, among others, one was found by Sirmond which is in the Labbe edition, and, as I think, the error is not entirely absent here from the published texts: an error into which copyists easily fell, both because of the similarity of style and the closeness of time, and because the same matters and the same arguments were treated by both pontiffs. To begin with, we see that many of their documents lack a beginning and an end; and we observe that this one of ours by no means departs from that custom, inasmuch as it is headless, even though it begins in the manuscript with a larger letter and with no mark of mutilation. But the corruptions and dislocations which I detect in ours, and which have also horribly deformed certain passages from the others, must be believed chiefly for this reason, that after the study and diligence of distinguished editors they still lie neglected and monstrous. To have looked into those matters a little more attentively, and to have detected a great disturbance in some of them, will, I think, be no small fruit of this labor of ours. Let us therefore weigh summarily the context and certain sentences of some of them.
Præmitti posset a prima ipsa Gelasii ad Euphemianum periodo ænigmata jam prænuntiari et ad primae paginæ finem luxationes jam portendi. Prior quoque epistolae sententia ænigmatica est; quæ tamen restituitur modo pro temporibus legas temporum; ila et card. Baronius jam emendaverat; qui etiam Domini sacerdotes probe scripserat. In eadeui pagina: deitate non prorsus assumpta: lege, Deitate non prorsus absumpta. Cum autem Gelasii, quae huic nostræ magis affinis est, in Conciliorum, collectione a ms. valde. recedentem animadverterem, multum laboris insumpseram, cuin ut interpolationes excuicrem, tum ut discrepantias omnes excerperem. Verumtamen ubi Quesnellianam etiam editionem venit in mentem conferre, consentire prorsus cum codice nostro miramus sum; qui eumdem quoque titulum in Thuaneo ms. inventum ad calcem epistolae ostendit. Explicit rationis reddendæ Acacium a sede aposlolica competenter fuisse damnatum, nec posse quemquam sine discrimine animæ suce ejus communionis participem effici.
From the very first period of Gelasius to Euphemianus, riddles could be announced in advance and at the end of the first page the dislocations could already be foretold. The earlier sentence of the letter is also enigmatic; yet it is restored if only you read "for the times" as "of the times"; thus Cardinal Baronius had already corrected it, who had also rightly written "priests of the Lord." On the same page: "the Godhead not wholly assumed": read "the Godhead not wholly taken away." But when I noticed that the letter of Gelasius which is more closely related to this one of ours departs greatly from the manuscript in the collection of the Councils, I expended much labor, both to track down the interpolations and to excerpt all the discrepancies. However, when it came to mind to compare also the Quesnellian edition, we marvel that it agrees entirely with our codex, which also shows the same title, found in the Thuanean manuscript, at the end of the letter. Here ends the account of the reasoning that Acacius was competently condemned by the apostolic see, and that no one can without danger to his own soul become a partaker of his communion.
Ex iis autem, quibus Labbeana editio redundat, frustum illud Gelasii non esse (quamvis in eo iterata interpolatione papa Felix sanctæ memoriæ dicatur) satis patere arbitror, in quo hæc occurrum: Ecce nuper Horonico regi Vandalicæ nationis, vir magnus et egregius sacerdos, Eugenius Carthaginensis episcopus, multique cum eo calliolici sacerdote, constanter restiterunt alevienti, cunctaque extrema toleranles, hodieque persecutoribus resistere non omittunt. Nos quoque Odoacri barbaro hæretico regnum Italiæ tunc tenenti, cum aliqua non fa ienda praeciperet, Deo præstante nullatenus paruisse manifestum est. Si enim anno, quem exhibet, epistola data esset, non video quomodo nuper evenisse dici possent quae aute annos saltem Contigeram; Hunnericus siquidem anno 484, Felicis secundo, decesserat. Neque anno illi ea videntur eompetere: hodieque resistere non omittunt: cum praecedente Gundabundus Hunerici successor episcopos omnes ab exsilio revocasset, suisque Ecclesiis jam reddidisset, ut colligitur ex fragmento Augustano apud Henricum Canisium. Pariter quæ postremo de Odoacre habentur, Gelasio minus commode aptantur: nam Gelasii annua primus Odoacris extremus fuit; quo sane tempore Ravennæ obsessus et a victore Theodorico ad incitas redactus, ne dum Romanum pontificem præceptis suis vexare posset, sed ne regnum quidem tenere amplius videbatur.
But from those things with which the Labbe edition abounds, I think it is sufficiently clear that that fragment is not by Gelasius (although in it, by repeated interpolation, Pope Felix of holy memory is named), in which these things occur: "Behold, recently to Huneric, king of the Vandal nation, a great and distinguished priest, Eugenius bishop of Carthage, and many Catholic priests with him, stood firm against him as he raged, and enduring all extremities, even today they do not cease to resist the persecutors. We also make it manifest that we in no way obeyed the barbarian heretic Odoacer, then holding the kingdom of Italy, when he commanded some things that were not to be done, with God granting it. For if the letter had been given in the year which it displays, I do not see how those things could be said to have happened recently which had occurred at least some years before; for Huneric had died in the year 484, the second of Felix. Nor do these things seem to fit that year: "even today they do not cease to resist," since in the preceding year Gundobad, the successor of Huneric, had recalled all the bishops from exile and had already restored them to their churches, as is gathered from the Augustan fragment in the work of Henricus Canisius. Likewise the things which are had at the end concerning Odoacer are less fittingly applied to Gelasius; for the first year of Gelasius was the last of Odoacer; at which time certainly, besieged at Ravenna and reduced to extremities by the victor Theodoric, he could not only not vex the Roman pontiff with his commands, but did not even seem able to hold the kingdom any longer.
Id quoque non dissimulandum: multa ex iis que ad defensionem pertinent sententiæ in Acacium latae, Gelasio quidem incongruentia dici non possum; Felici tamen, recentibus adhuc atque ferventibus Græcorum querimoniis, multo magis conveninnt. Quae augetur suspicio, cum ejusdem epistolæ plures loci huic nostræ, quae ex toto contextu Felici asseritur, iam similes sint quam qui maxime.
Verum majora consectemur, atque ad tractatum de Analhernale nos conferamus. Conveniunt in hoc tum editiones omnes tum ms. noster; varias enim leciiones, quas ad marginem recensuit Qucsnellus, et in quibus codex ad Labbeanas magis accedit, non magnifacio, ubi tanto potiora animadvertenda eranl. Scilicet scriptum istud, aut ego fallor, aut nihil ferme est aliud, quam cento ex diversis fragmentis librariorum votio contextus. Præmittamus eo dirigi tractatum hunc ut illa verba explicaremur ac purgarentur in Acacii damnatione prolala, nunquamque anathematis vinculis exuendus. At hoc præstare longe magis Felici congruebat, cujus ea verba fuerant, quam Gelasio tot annis jam elapsis: quin superflua fuisset omnino hæc Gelasii cura, postquam Felix ipse abunde in epistola quam nunc edimus id jam præstiterat.
This too must not be overlooked: many of the points in that document which pertain to the defense of the sentence passed against Acacius I cannot say are inconsistent with Gelasius; yet they fit Felix far better, when the complaints of the Greeks were still fresh and burning. And the suspicion is increased when several passages of the same letter are already as similar as can be to this letter of ours, which is asserted from its whole context to be by Felix.
But let us pursue greater matters, and betake ourselves to the treatise On the Anthemale. On this point all the editions agree, and so does our manuscript; for the variant readings which Quesnel collected at the margin, and in which the codex comes closer to the Labbe editions, I do not esteem highly, when matters so much more important were to be observed. For that writing, unless I am mistaken, is almost nothing other than a cento patched together from various fragments of copyists. Let us premise that this treatise is directed to the end that those words uttered in the condemnation of Acacius might be explained and cleared, and that he is never to be released from the bonds of the anathema. But to accomplish this was far more fitting for Felix, whose those words were, than for Gelasius so many years later; indeed, this concern of Gelasius would have been entirely superfluous, since Felix himself had already abundantly accomplished it in the letter which we now publish.
Quis autem credat Gelasium hanc defensionem adornasse, eo validissimo argumento nunquam adducto; scilicet in dubium revocari non posse quin eorum verborum is vere sensus fuisset, cum Felix ipse, qui pronuntiaverat, ita docuisset. Quis credat a Gelasio eosdem sacræ Scripturae locos in eumdem finem adhibitos, nulla unquam Felicis mentione facta? quibus si easdem ferme, ubi agimur de sententia resipiscentem non afficiente, adjicias loquendi formulas, tenoremque orationis ac styli prorsus eumdem, a Felice hæc quoque profecta esse, non immerito conjectabis. At quod magis observandum est, abruptum hujus traciaLus initium ad ejus argumentum non pertinet, cum frustum sit alterius scripii, in quo de Constanlinopolitanis episcopis agebatur, honorem secundæ sedis sibi arrogantibus ex quorumdam Chalcedonensium Petrum decreto, de quo, dum hæc meditor atque adorno, novus ad me Aloysii Andruccii mittitur liber verba faciens. Hanc materiam prima columna prosequitur usque ad ea; Peccator homini, etc., ubi repente, quamvis tanquam continuata afferantur, in propositum insilit, scilicet quo perpetuæ damnationis nota removetur. Per tres columnas idem agitur, distinctione quam col. aspicimus intempestive posita. Col. versus decem perperam interseruntur incipientes, Quod sedes apostolica; spectant enim ad scriptum id, cujus et initium est.
But who would believe that Gelasius composed this defense, when that most forceful argument was never adduced—namely, that it cannot be called into doubt that the true sense of those words was this, since Felix himself, who had pronounced them, had so taught? Who would believe that Gelasius cited the same passages of Sacred Scripture to the same end, with no mention of Felix ever made? If to these you add nearly the same turns of speech, where we deal with the sentence not affecting one who repents, and an entirely identical tenor of discourse and style, you will not unreasonably conjecture that these too proceeded from Felix. But what is more to be observed is that the abrupt beginning of this treatise does not pertain to its argument, since it is a fragment of another writing, in which the matter concerned the bishops of Constantinople, who arrogated to themselves the honor of the second see by the decree of certain Chalcedonians, Peter among them—concerning which, while I ponder and arrange these matters, a new book of Aloysius Andruccius is sent to me, speaking of it. The first column continues this subject up to the words "Peccator homini," etc., where suddenly, although they are presented as though continuous, it leaps into the proposed topic—namely, that by which the mark of perpetual damnation is removed. The same is treated through three columns, with a distinction untimely placed, as we see in the column. Ten lines of the column are wrongly inserted, beginning "Quod sedes apostolica"; for they belong to that writing whose beginning is also [there].
Verbo hoc tamen ad argumentum redit, periodum Sphingi reservaiam subjiciens, quæ nec manuscriptorum ope salis restituitur: procedit tamen usque ad ea. Quod si hæc tentare formidant: ubi rursus aherrare videmur, et ex abrupto tractatus alterius fragmentum ingredi, quo ab imperatore Petrum Alexandrinum absolvi non potuisse ostendebatur: perstatque usque ad finem, si postremas periodos excipias, quæ rursus alio rcferuntur, inter se etiam inconnexæ. Hæc autem omnia a tot viris doctissimis, qui in bis monumentis vel ut ederent, vel ut expenderent, vel ut adducerent, versati sunt, animadversa non fuisse, vehementer prorecto mirari subit. S. Leonis editor et hujus tractatus caput invenisse, et novis quibusdam lectionibus, novaque partitione reconcinnasse se existimavit ac restituisse; abruptum tamen adhuc initium est, finis mutilus, confusa series atque intermixta: quod patebit, ut puto, statim ac fragmenta ad disparatas causas speciantia in eo contineri constet. Luxationem hujusmodi valde ab antiquo accidisse, tum e codice quem præ manibus habemus, tum ex Anastasio Bi~ bliothecario discere in promptu est, qui in epistola ad Joannem diaconum Collectaneis præfixa sententiam afferens, quæ in priori ejus pagina, alio ut videtur pertinente, visitur, depromptam dicit ex tomo Gelasii de anathematis Vinculo.
Nevertheless, he returns to the argument at this word, appending a period reserved for the Sphinx, which is not sufficiently restored even with the help of manuscripts; yet it proceeds all the way to those matters. But if they dread to attempt these things, where again we seem to wander, and abruptly enter a fragment of another treatise, in which it was shown that Peter of Alexandria could not have been absolved by the emperor; and it continues to the end, if you except the final periods, which are again referred to another matter, being even unconnected with one another. But that all these things were not noticed by so many most learned men, who were occupied with these monuments either to publish them, or to weigh them, or to cite them, truly it comes upon me to marvel vehemently. The editor of St. Leo thought that he had both found the chapter of this treatise and reconciled and restored it with certain new readings and a new division; yet the beginning is still abrupt, the end mutilated, the sequence confused and intermixed: which will be evident, I think, as soon as it is established that fragments pertaining to disparate causes are contained in it. That a dislocation of this kind happened long ago is readily learned both from the codex that we have at hand and from Anastasius the Librarian, who, in the letter prefixed to the Collectanea to John the Deacon, citing a sentence that is seen on its first page, belonging, as it seems, to another matter, says that it was taken from the tome of Gelasius On the Bond of Anathema.
Non deerunt fortasse quibus durus videatur hic sermo, ut in canonicum Ecclesiæ Romanæ codicem cento, ut ita dicam, receplus fuerit. At quamvis monumentum istud antiquitus luxatum, et a libranis male habitum dixerim, non tamen antequam In eum codicem insertum esset, intelligere necesse est. Sed illud insuper animadvertendum, illam canonum collectionem ejusmodi nomine S. Leonis editorem ex proprio judicio douasse; neque in hoc doctorum calculos laturum profecto ' universos si colligantur: multa enim sunt quae contrarium suadeant ac ferme evincant.
Quid de Græcis tribus Felicis epistolis dicemus, quas rejiciunt Valesius, Dupinius, alii, probant Cave, Pagius, aliique? Anastasius quidem secundam videtur laudasse in epistola paulo ante memorata: unde notandum quod nonnulla quæ Latine fuerunt edita, Latinitas funditus mole oblivionis obruta deplorasset, nisi ex Græcorum post fonte librorum hæc hausta sitibundo pectore resumpsisset; sicut epistolam B. papæ Felicis in Petrum sententiam proferentem Antiochenum damnationis. At inlerpolatas saltem quis non videat? Tertiam praecipue, quae sibi non cohæret, neque titulo respondet, nequeprincipio.
Perhaps there will not be lacking some to whom this discourse seems harsh, in that a cento, so to speak, has been received into the canonical code of the Roman Church. But although I would say that this monument was dislocated in antiquity and badly handled by the copyists, it must not be understood before it was inserted into that code. But this besides must be noted, that the editor of that collection of canons marked it with the name of St. Leo by his own judgment; nor in this would he certainly carry the votes of all the learned, if they were gathered together: for there are many things which persuade and almost prove the contrary.
What shall we say about the three Greek letters of Felix, which Valesius, Dupin, and others reject, while Cave, Pagius, and others approve? Anastasius indeed seems to have praised the second in the letter mentioned a little before: whence it is to be noted that certain things which were published in Latin, Latinity, utterly overwhelmed by the mass of oblivion, would have lamented as lost, unless from the later fount of Greek books it had recovered them with thirsty breast; just as the letter of blessed Pope Felix pronouncing the sentence of condemnation against Peter of Antioch. But who at least would not see that they have been interpolated? Especially the third, which does not cohere with itself, nor correspond to its title, nor to its beginning.
In Latina prioris versionesyllaba omissa hæresim creat: dividuam Trinitatem; ut memini, errorem alium hæresim pariter circa Trinitatem facere, ubi legitur de Filio, nec genitus est, sed procedens: iuspecto Graeco textu plures facillime errores abstergi possunt, quos ea de causa memoro, ut in nova Conciliorum collectione animadvertantur. Multi sane cujuscunque generis in anteriores editiones irrepserunt, quorum haud paucos Acaciana monumenta inficientes in hoc prooemio et in annotationibus obiter emendabo.
lis ergo nunc insistendum est, quæ Acacium respiciunt. Gelasii IV seu commonitorium ad Faustum, in quo pariter cum editis consentit ms. codex, non multo depuratius est: ad initium secundæ paginæ labat connexio, ad finem perit. Ab iis, illud autem nimis est impudens, usque ad ea, in suam traduceret pravilatem9 diversa videtur epistola, et quidem Felicis, a quo Andromachus instructus fuérit, ut Acacium cohortaretur. Sequens periodus redit ad anteriora, et subsequens usque ad verba, Non est mirum, rursus Felici tribuenda. Neque doctissimi Baronii sufficit interpretalio, ut nempe ex persona apostolicae sedis Gelasius loquatur: illa enim: quod ait, si necesse fuerit, veniam postulare; existimans nimirum tunc se peccati veniam necessario postulare, si ei concedamus, ne peccare desistat: Acacium adhuc hac aura vescentem manifesto ostendunt.
In the Latin of the earlier version an omitted syllable creates a heresy: a divided Trinity; as I recall, another error likewise makes a heresy concerning the Trinity, where it is read of the Son, "nor was he begotten, but proceeding": with the Greek text examined, many errors can most easily be wiped away, which I mention for this reason, that they may be noted in the new collection of Councils. Many errors of every kind have indeed crept into earlier editions, and not a few of these, infecting the monuments of Acacius, I shall correct in passing in this preface and in the annotations.
We must therefore now insist upon those matters which concern Acacius. The commonitorium of Gelasius IV, or rather to Faustus, in which the manuscript codex likewise agrees with the printed editions, is not much more purified: at the beginning of the second page the connection falters, at the end it perishes. From those words, "But that is too shameless," up to those, "he would traduce into his own depravity," the letter appears to be different, and indeed of Felix, by whom Andromachus was instructed to exhort Acacius. The following period returns to the earlier material, and the one following, up to the words, "It is not wonderful," must again be attributed to Felix. Nor does the interpretation of the most learned Baronius suffice, namely that Gelasius speaks in the person of the apostolic see: for those words, "that he ask pardon, if it should be necessary," thinking namely that then he necessarily asks pardon for sin, if we grant him that he not cease to sin: they manifestly show Acacius still feeding on this breeze.
Cum Græcis deinde, etsi confuse, iterum res est; at ea in fine, neque plane cum istis non corrigentibus ineunda congressio, ad supra posita referuntur, nobis nullum fas est inire certamen cum hominibus communionis alienæ. Nullam in his nobis lucem prætulit liber noster, curn editis mire consentiens, nisi eo loco, ubi in extremo vulgatæ paginae sensus est nullus. Legitur autem in codice: nec novit, aut se nosse dissimulat, per numerosam sententiam sacerdotum, etc.; cui sententiæ si verbum constat demas, vel particulam ut addas, locum habebis integre et mutatione quam minima restitutum. Sed de his satis. '
Temporis notam, quo epistolam hanc Felix III (quibusdam II, alterum nempe tanquam intrusum cum Liberius superstes exsularet, excludentibus) scripserit, is. codex exhibet nullam; verum ex ipso contextu eruitur: scilicet post synodum de lapsi. III Africa, anno Romæ coactam, cujus memmio lit. et ante Acacii mortem, quæ contigit anno 489, Euse bio consule, ut discimus ex Victore Tunonensi. In Labbeana Conciliorum editione ante Felicis epistolam collocanda hæc esset, primam nempe, quæ post obitum Acacii sit data, Ad certos homines non est missa, anonymo enim scripto respondet, in Acacii, Petrique Alexandrini defensionom vulgato, quod etiam an ab uno compactum fuisset, an a pluribus plane ignorasse videtur Felix.
Then the matter is again with the Greeks, though confusedly; but at the end, and plainly not to be entered into with these men who do not correct themselves, the discussions are referred back to the points set out above: it is not lawful for us to enter into any dispute with men of alien communion. Our book has brought no light to bear for us in these matters, agreeing wonderfully with the published texts, except in that place where at the end of the common page there is no sense. But it is read in the codex: "nor does he know, or he pretends not to know, through the numerous sentence of the priests," etc.; and if you remove the word "constat" from this sentence, or add the particle "ut," you will have the place wholly restored with the smallest possible change. But enough of these matters.
The codex shows no note of the time at which Felix III (some reckon him II, excluding the other as an intruder, since Liberius was living in exile) wrote this letter; but it is elicited from the context itself: namely, after the synod concerning the lapsed in Africa III, convened at Rome, mention of which is made in the letter, and before the death of Acacius, which occurred in the year 489, in the consulship of Eusebius, as we learn from Victor of Tununa. In the Labbean edition of the Councils this letter ought to be placed before the letter of Felix—namely the first, which was sent after the death of Acacius. It was not sent to specific men, for it responds to an anonymous writing published in defense of Acacius and Peter of Alexandria, which Felix seems plainly to have been ignorant of, whether it had been put together by one man or by several.
Ex hac vero illius scripti confutatione, cum nova hinc'inde allata argumenta, tum ulteriorem quarumdam rerum notitiam, pluraque iusuper colligere est, quibus, vel quod in ancipiti erat, firmetur, vel quod in obscuro, illustrelur plurimum. Nondum tamen, Ico quidem judicio singula, quæ ob eam controversiam acta sunt, apte. distingui, ac in tuto poni, neque ea omnia quae de hac causa apud antiquos scriptores legimus, satis conciliari possunt: quod corruptis ejus aevi monumentis præcipue imputandum puto.
Verumtamen quod in hac re caput est, quantum Acacius deliquerit, et quam juste exinde Gelasius vel in ejus memoriam invect is sit, abunde hic elucet. Minime profecto intelligo qui fieri potuerit ut Dupinio aliquando exciderit, videri Acacii errorem omnem eo contineri, ut Romano episcopo displicuerit, principique suo nimium adhæserit. Quod enim Felix et Gelasius in Acacium statuerunt, id successores habuerunt ratum, ea quidem constantia, ut post contentiones acerrimas, inter Orientalem et Occidentalem Ecclesiam pax atque concordia obsignata non fuerit ac restituta, nisi eum anno demum 519, Hormisda sedente, nomen Acacii de dyptichis est deletum, ut in Suggestione Dioscori diaconi legitur.
From this refutation of his writing, it is possible to gather both new arguments brought forward from this side and that, and further knowledge of certain matters, and many things besides, by which either what was in doubt may be confirmed, or what was obscure may be greatly illuminated. Yet not even now, in my judgment at least, can the individual acts done on account of that controversy be properly distinguished and placed in safety, nor can all the things which we read concerning this cause in the ancient writers be sufficiently reconciled: which I think is chiefly to be imputed to the corrupted monuments of that age.
But yet, what is the chief point in this matter—how greatly Acacius erred, and how justly Gelasius thereafter inveighed against his memory—is abundantly clear here. Indeed, I do not at all understand how it could have happened that Dupin at some time let slip that the whole of Acacius's error seemed to consist in this, that he displeased the Roman bishop and adhered too much to his own prince. For what Felix and Gelasius decreed against Acacius, their successors held ratified, with such constancy indeed that, after the bitterest contentions, peace and concord between the Eastern and Western Church was not sealed and restored until at last, in the year 519, with Hormisdas presiding, the name of Acacius was deleted from the diptychs, as is read in the Suggestion of Dioscorus the deacon.
Æquitatem autem Romanae postulationis Graeci tandem confessi sunt, Joanne episcopo Constantinopolitano post hæreticum Eutychetem, Dioscorum, Timotheum parricidam, et Petrum Alexandrinum, Acacium quoque Constantinopolitanæ quondam urbis episcopum complicem eorum et sequacem similiter anathematizante. Inspiciatur Græcorum antistitum epistola, quae a Bessarione recitatur, se fatentium Sii, propter Acacn patris nostri prævaricationem. Quin etiam Acacius in decreto de apocryphis Scripturis post hæreticos recensetur: a Felice in ipsam doctrinæ apostolicæ veritatem tetendisse dicitur: ubi in editis profitetur Gelasius eum a communione catholica deviasse, legitur in Veronensi codice a catholica veritate; Hormisda Dioscori et Eutychetis dogmate et communione pollutum vocat; in secunda fidei confessione, quam pontilici Agapeto Justinianus imperator obtulit, post Eutychetem ceterosque, aversamur, inquit, et Acacium cohæreticum et sequacem; ac ad plenum detectum hæreticum scribit Liberatus, quo elogio non semel eum I item mactat Nicolaus I. Quin et Basilius Cilix xov reportasse Acacium tradidit, ut apud Photiun legimus. Nec propterea rem mihi esse volo cum viris doctis iis, qui dissertationibus etiam in hoc adhibitis, episcopum illum, etsi juste damnatum, orthodoxum tame n,, quod fidem spectat, contendunt fuisse.
But the Greeks at last confessed the equity of the Roman demand, when John, bishop of Constantinople, similarly anathematized, after the heretics Eutyches, Dioscorus, Timothy the parricide, and Peter of Alexandria, Acacius also, once bishop of the city of Constantinople, their accomplice and follower. Let the letter of the Greek prelates be examined, which is recited by Bessarion, in which they confess that they are of Sii, on account of the prevarication of Acacius our father. Indeed, Acacius is also reckoned among the heretics in the decree concerning the apocryphal Scriptures: he is said by Felix to have strained against the very truth of the apostolic doctrine: where Gelasius declares in his published writings that he deviated from the catholic communion, it is read in the Veronese codex that he deviated from the catholic truth; Hormisdas calls him polluted by the dogma and communion of Dioscorus and Eutyches; in the second confession of faith, which the emperor Justinian offered to the pontiff Agapetus, he says, after Eutyches and the others, we also abhor Acacius the heretic and his follower; and Liberatus writes that he was fully detected as a heretic, with which eulogy Nicolaus I likewise repeatedly slaughters him. Indeed, Basil of Cilicia also handed down that Acacius had reported xov, as we read in Photius. Nor on that account do I wish to have a dispute with those learned men who, with dissertations even applied to this matter, contend that that bishop, although justly condemned, was nevertheless orthodox, as far as the faith is concerned.
Indicia quidem haud præclara sunt (prætcr communicationem de qua aiebat Symmachus in Apologetica, an communicare non est consentire cum talibus?) quod orthodoxos episcopos ejecerit, et in eorum sedes hæreticos intruserit; quodquecuiu impius Mongus. concilium Chalcedonense anathemate notavit, Acacium habuerit, ut libellus synodicus loquitur. Verum ad apostolicam sedem purgandam id satis superque est, quod Joannes Constantinopolilanus profitebamur: quorum quis communionem complectitur, eorum et similem adjudicationem in condemnatione consequitur. Quin etiam ea ne pro nihilo habenda sint, imperatorem in haereticorum. partes perduxisse; conscribendi et promulgandi Henotici auctorem fuisse; sedis apostolicæ legatos ablatis litteris carcere et pecunia expugnasse, in jurisdictiones alienas tam temere irruisse, catholicisque sacerdotibus per Orientem totum violenter exclusis, perditos ac nefarios homines, et ab ipso antea damnatos subrogasse; sedesque Alexandrinam quidem Petro Mongo parricidii socio, Tyriam Joanne ab Apamenis, et Antiochenis rejecto, Antiochenam Petro Fullone synodali judicio exauctorato, temerasse per fas et nefas, atque infecisse? Quid plura? Nonne etiam Felicis nomen e sacris tabulis ab eo expunctum doCet Theophanes i, quod etiam referunt Nicephorus et Cedrenus. Majus qu ddam hæc omnia profecto sonant quam episcopo Homano displicuisse.
Indeed, the indications are hardly distinguished (except for the communion about which Symmachus spoke in his Apologeticus—or is it not to communicate with such men to consent with them?) that he cast out orthodox bishops and thrust heretics into their sees; and that the impious Mongus, having branded the Council of Chalcedon with anathema, held Acacius, as the synodical libellus states. But to clear the apostolic see, this is more than enough: that John of Constantinople declared—those whose communion one embraces, upon them in condemnation a like judgment follows. Moreover, these things are not to be reckoned as nothing: that he led the emperor into the party of the heretics; that he was the author of composing and promulgating the Henoticon; that he assailed the legates of the apostolic see with imprisonment and money after their letters were taken away; that he so rashly invaded jurisdictions belonging to others; and that, after Catholic priests throughout the whole East had been violently excluded, he substituted for them lost and nefarious men, men already condemned by himself; and that he defiled and infected the sees—the Alexandrian see with Peter Mongus, partner in parricide; the Tyrian with John, rejected by the Apameans and the Antiochenes; the Antiochene with Peter the Fuller, stripped of rank by synodical judgment—by right and by wrong? What more? Does not Theophanes also teach that the name of Felix was erased by him from the sacred tablets, which Nicephorus and Cedrenus likewise report? All these things surely sound like something greater than that they merely displeased the Roman bishop.
Quo consilio seu qua methodo hanc editionem instruxerim, paucis admonebo. Textum quidem purgare adnixus sum, verumtamen transformare noluiHinc etsi partes male inter se cohærescere nonnunquam viderentur, arbitrum non adhibui: eo siquidem uti lemerarium fuisset, praecipue ubi constat auctorem ipsum prosilire aliquando, et ud eadem saepius redire. Semel tantum transpositos sensus aliquos sun loco reddidi, cum reconcinnatio in promptu esset, ac perturbatio in aperto. Lacunas, si quæ sint, quarumve in codice nulla unquam nota nos admonet, non explevi; ubi eni:n eadem reponendi certi non simus, cur nostra auctoribus appiugamus, non video. Emendationum quoque parcum, ac in iis, ni fallor, satis cautum me præstiti: quapropter senteniias quandoque minus integras, dictionesque minus correctas non attigi. Quin ubi insignis quædam aut paulo liberior emendatio contigerit, ms. lectionem in adnotationibus afferam, ut quisquis proprio judicio uti possit. Illa vero, cum dictionis cujusdam inflexione mutata, vel particula addita, aut dempta syllaba sententiam restituimus, quid opus erat admonere? aut quid minuta menda memorare tam frequenter obvis, ex quibus nihil eruatur frugi? Animadversiones ad pompam nequaquam concinnavi: congestiones quidem arrepta cujuscunque verbi occasione cumulatas, et nihil nisi quod millies audivimus afferentes probare ne quaquam soleo.
By what plan or method I have prepared this edition, I will briefly explain. I have indeed endeavored to purify the text, but I was unwilling to transform it. Hence, even if at times parts seemed to cohere badly with one another, I did not bring in an arbiter; for to do so would have been rash, especially where it is evident that the author himself sometimes leaps forth and often returns to the same points. Only once did I restore some transposed senses to their place, when the rearrangement was obvious and the disturbance plain. Gaps, if there are any, and for which no mark in the codex ever warns us, I have not filled; for where we are not certain of restoring the same, I do not see why we should attach our own words to the authors. I have also shown myself sparing in emendations, and in them, unless I am mistaken, sufficiently cautious; therefore I have sometimes left sentences less complete and expressions less correct untouched. Indeed, wherever some notable or somewhat freer emendation has occurred, I will cite the manuscript reading in the notes, so that anyone may use his own judgment. But those cases where, with a change in the inflection of some expression, or a particle added, or a syllable removed, we restored the sense—what need was there to warn? Or what need to record so frequently trivial faults that meet us everywhere, from which nothing useful is extracted? I have by no means composed observations for display; indeed, heaps piled up on the occasion of any word whatever, bringing nothing but what we have heard a thousand times, I am not accustomed to prove.
Jam vero illud reliquum est, ut erratis haud codicis quidem, sed meis mihique tantum imputandis humanus eruditusque lector Ignoscat.
EPISTOLA SIVE TRACTATUS
MELICIS III PAPÆ.
Quæ pro Acacio afferebantur refellit, eumque ut juste ac rite damnatum, iia non nisi canonice restituendum ostendit.
................. " post quingeutos annos constituta Christi eos velle subvertere, cum triginta annorum ''ex hominum non possit abrumpi. Sanctum Athanasium ideo non fuisse damnatum a synodo Orientis, quia sedes ista non consenserit: sanctum Joannem Constantinopolitanum, sanctum Flavianum.... Si ergo ea non consentiente sola, qui damnati sunt a synodo Orientis non potuerunt e;se damnati, consequens est * etiam sine synodo qui eadem sola damnante damnatus fuerit, damnatus sit. Postremo si nulla est ejus sclius sententia, quid tantopere cupiunt, hanc resolvi..... testimonio Acacii ubi confirmat, Timotheum catholicum de damnatione Petri retulisse ad utramque Romam; ubi, ab haeretico fuisse ordinatum, hoc est complicem insaniae suae, ubi dicit, ut propter hoc majoribus suppliciis subderetur. Itaque non ut in sequestris esset, quod nunc prætenditur, sancto, cum obiisset, Timotheo subrogandus; qui pro sceleribus suis, quae retulit Acacius, suppliciis subditus est: nemo autem ad honorem reservatum dignum asserit esse suppliciis.
Now indeed what remains is that the learned and humane reader pardon the errors—not those of the manuscript, but my own, and to be imputed to me alone.
LETTER OR TREATISE
OF MELCHIADES III, POPE.
He refutes the arguments brought forward on behalf of Acacius, and shows that, just as he was justly and rightly condemned, so he is not to be restored except canonically.
................. "after five hundred years, they wish to overturn the ordinances of Christ, when not even thirty years' [custom] can be broken off from among men. Saint Athanasius was therefore not condemned by the synod of the East, because this see did not consent: Saint John of Constantinople, Saint Flavian.... If therefore, with this see alone not consenting, those who were condemned by the synod of the East could not have been condemned, it follows that even without a synod, one who has been condemned by this same see alone condemning him has been condemned. Finally, if its sentence is of no account, why do they so greatly desire that it be dissolved..... by the testimony of Acacius, where he confirms that Timothy the catholic reported the condemnation of Peter to both Romes; where [he says] that he was ordained by a heretic, that is, a accomplice of his madness; where he says that for this reason he was subjected to greater punishments. And so he was not to be substituted for Saint Timothy, when he had died, as though in a sequestrum—which is what is now pretended; he who for his crimes, which Acacius reported, was subjected to punishments: but no one asserts that a man reserved for honor is worthy of punishments.
Imperator Timothei catholici electioni cuncta permisit; necesse est igitur ut sequatur quod ille constituit et dixit catholicum a catholicis ordinatum; falsum est ergo quod in sequestri dicitur constitutus, ut eidem subrogaretur, cui nunquam communicavit; et a quo postulatus est longius debere relegari.
Si juraverat Joannes non se futurum episcopum. quomodo tu mandasti dignum esse cui majora committerentur quae ad gubernationem Ecclesiae pertinerenl? Supra presbyterum quid est majus ad Ecclesiæ gubernationem nisi episcopatus? Si juraverat, quomodo hoc mandas? et si juraverat, cur illum exposuisti ut fieret contra quod juraverat? Aut si factum est quod mandasti, quid irasceris, quid illum tibi dicis pejerasse, cum factam. sit quod se non juraverat esse facturom? cum tu eum hoc fieri debere mandasti, a Apocrisarius erat; omnia ad ipsum pertinebant; omnia Ecclesiæ ipse curavit; potior illo inter clericos Alexandrinos nullus habebatur: honore presbyter erat; supra quid ei adderetur ad gubernationem Ecclesiae? quid ei amplius adjiceretur nisi cpiscopatus? Tu igitur eum episcopum esse voluisti, qui eum supra quam erat (nec aliud restabat, nisi nt esset episcopus) esse debere mandasti.
The emperor left everything to the election of the catholic Timotheus; it is necessary, therefore, that what he established should follow, and that he said a catholic was ordained by catholics. It is false, therefore, that he is said in the sequestration to have been appointed, so that he might be substituted for the same man with whom he never communicated, and by whom it was demanded that he should be relegated further away.
If John had sworn that he would not become bishop, how did you command that he was worthy to whom greater things should be entrusted which pertain to the governance of the Church? What is greater than a presbyter for the governance of the Church except the episcopate? If he had sworn, how do you command this? And if he had sworn, why did you expose him so that he should act against what he had sworn? Or if what you commanded was done, why are you angry, why do you say to me that he perjured himself, when what he had sworn he would not do was done? Since you commanded that this ought to be done by him—he was apocrisiarius; all things pertained to him; he himself took care of all things of the Church; no one among the Alexandrian clergy was held preferable to him; he was in the honor of presbyter; what would be added to him beyond this for the governance of the Church? What more would be added to him except the episcopate? You, therefore, wished him to be bishop, who commanded that he ought to be above what he was—nor was anything else left except that he should be bishop.
Miror autem, si necessitatem patitur in.perator, ne pellat Petrum, et unum hominem necessitatem perpeti non potuisse contendat, ut fieret quod nolebat invitus: nam et ipse imperator, cum necessitatem prætendit, malum esse defioit, quod necessitate facit, docens se hoc nolle facere voluntate, et pati testatur invitus. Si personam Petri excusandam putatis, probamus noxiam, hareticam atque damnatam; si in sequestri fuisse praetenditis propter scandalum, Timotheo catbolico subrogandum; nec Acacii hoc scripta testantur, qui dicit evidenter, cur fuerit exclusus; nec imperatoris, qui et Timotheo catholico, quae statuisset, mansura esse promisit, a cujus fuit Petrus communione diseretus, et a quo postulatus est longius debere relegari, atque huc pariter, et Constantinopolim relatus: sicut etiam testatur Acacius, a sancto Protcrio in diaconio fuisse damnatum, non Pe. trum, qui erat hæreticus, tanquam in sequestri posi. tum subrogandum; a quo ordinati nisi ad communionem sancti Timothei revertissent, jussi sunt sine dilatione damnari. Qui si dicitur postea fuisse correctus, interim hoc ipso in errore hactenus jacuisse monstratur; nec debuisse catholicis præfici post errorem, a quibus est de errore correctus. a Itaque venia dignus fuerat, non honore; et maxime ab hæreticis ordinatus nullam episcopalis dignitatis prorsus habere substantiam.
But I am amazed if the emperor is held to be under compulsion, so as not to expel Peter, and he contends that one man could not have endured compulsion, so that what he did not wish might be done against his will; for even the emperor himself, when he pleads compulsion, has declared that to be evil which he does under compulsion, teaching that he did not wish to do this by his will, and he testifies that he suffered it unwillingly. If you think Peter's person is to be excused, we prove him harmful, heretical, and condemned; if you claim that he was in a position of sequestration on account of scandal, he was to be replaced by the catholic Timotheus; nor do the writings of Acacius testify this, who says evidently why he was excluded; nor do those of the emperor, who also promised to the catholic Timotheus that what he had established would remain, from whose communion Peter was separated, and by whom it was demanded that he ought to be relegated further away, and brought here equally, and to Constantinople: as Acacius also testifies, that he was condemned by the holy Proterius in the diaconate, not Peter, who was a heretic, as though placed in sequestration to be replaced; by whom those ordained, unless they had returned to the communion of the holy Timotheus, were ordered to be condemned without delay. But if he is said to have been corrected afterwards, meanwhile by this very fact he is shown to have lain in error up to this point; nor ought he to have been set over catholics after his error, by whom he was corrected from error. And so he would have been worthy of pardon, not of honor; and especially, having been ordained by heretics, he has absolutely no substance of episcopal dignity.