ት Tergwame Greek · Coptic · Ethiopic · Syriac · Armenian · Georgian · Latin

Latin · Letters ·

Epistolae Et Decreta

Vigilius · ogl-pl

BothSourceEnglish
JSON Dossier
machine-draft · no human review 296 passages · 68,888 words translation only — commentary and dossier not yet generated

Sources and records

About this work

Apparatus · what the pipeline recorded

Annotation and terms

0 commentary units 39 derived notes 0 open questions 296 narrative
What the kinds mean

Pipeline notes

  • coverageNo English translation could be identified: a language model asked twice could not name one, though it could not rule one out either. That is not proof that none exists — translations in dissertations, recent books and other modern languages are easily missed.
  • limitThe English is a machine draft produced passage by passage from the transcribed Latin; no human has verified it. The commentary is model-written and cites only keys the pipeline could resolve.
  • registerRegister: letter in Latin; the English keeps the liturgical formulae and the vocatives rather than normalising them.
  • structurePassages: 296 narrative.
  • caution38 passage(s) are fragmentary in the source; the English bridges each break and says so in the note.
  • scripture1 scriptural phrase match(es) noted: John 1:1.
  • sourceSource edition: ogl-pl.
  • sourceLicence: Available under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License

Term index

SourceRenderingCountFirst
no glossary terms recorded
tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:101 · narrative
Source · Latin

Illud quoque magnopere nobis cum clementissimo principe, præsentibus etiam Menna Constantinopolitanæ civitatis, et Dacio Mediolanensis urbis antistite, aliisque tam Græcis quam Latinis episcopis, cum quibus omnibus, etiam tu Theodore pater adfuisti, nec non et praesentibus judicibus atque proceribus universoque senatu convenit, ne usque ad memoratam concilii diffinitionem quidquam de præfatis tribus capitulis ab aliquo fieri intentaretur a. Ac deinde tuis ex consuetudine incitamentis libcr condemnationem capitulorum ipsorum continens, in palatio, te assistente et instruente, coram quibusdam Græcis episcopis est relectus, a quibus assentationum favorem tuis vocibus exigebas. Ex quo facto tam tu, quam tibi consentientes episcopi, mitius licet a nobis quam oportuit increpati, ad promerendam ficta satisfactione veniam convolastis. Quis autem commemorare sufficiat quæ te incitante atque exsequente mala commissa sunt? Nam ut de magnis excessibus tuis parva narremus, totius scandali incitamentum fuisti atque seditio; qui domi tuæ sedens, antiquarios pretio caro conducens, ea quæ jurata voce te non esse facturum usque ad constitutum tempus frequentius firmaveras, conscripsisti; et sub prætextu religionis, ea quæ Dei Ecclesiam dividerent, sicut etiam rebus ipsius agnoscitur, perpetrasti.

English

That too was agreed upon by us with the most clement prince, with Menna, bishop of the city of Constantinople, and Dacius, bishop of the city of Milan, also present, and with other bishops both Greek and Latin, with all of whom—including you also, father Theodore, who were present—and likewise with the judges and nobles and the entire senate present, that nothing concerning the aforesaid three chapters should be attempted by anyone up to the aforementioned definition of the council. And then, by your customary incitements, a book containing the condemnation of those same chapters was read in the palace, with you assisting and instructing, in the presence of certain Greek bishops, from whom you demanded the favor of flatteries by your words. From this act, both you and the bishops consenting with you, though rebuked by us more gently than was fitting, hastened to earn pardon by a feigned satisfaction. But who could suffice to recount the evils committed with you inciting and executing them? For, to relate small things concerning your great excesses, you were the incitement and sedition of the whole scandal; who, sitting in your house, hiring copyists at a dear price, wrote out those things which you had frequently confirmed with a sworn voice that you would not do up to the appointed time; and under the pretext of religion, you perpetrated those things which would divide the Church of God, as is also recognized in its own affairs.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:102 · narrative
Source · Latin

Nam usque ad hoc animum Christianissimi principis falsis suggestionibus perduxisti, ut clementia ejus, quæ in suis hostibus pia semper apparuit, contra nos graviter moveretur. Sed haec omnia bona desideria nostra, quæ pro pace Ecclesiae procul dubio militabant, ita animus tuus quietis impatiens dissipavit, ut illa quae fraterna collatione et tranquilla episcoporum fuerant reservanda judicio, subito contra ecclesiasticum morem, et contra paternas traditiones, contraque omnem auctoritatem evangelicæ aposto. licaeque doctrinae, edictis propositis, secundum tuum damnarentur arbitrium, dum fidelium nullus ignoret, per quos Dominus ac Deus noster doctrinis cælestibus plebem suam jusserit erudiri, vel quibus ligandi solvendique super terram dederit potestatem. Deinde in domo Placidiana cum Graecarum vel Latinarum partium episcopis, qui in urbe regia aderant, et presbyteris ac diaconibus Constantinopolitanae Ecclesiae convenisti: ibique sub magnæ vociferationis contestatione, tam nos quam frater noster Mediolanensis episcopus prohibuimus, ne aliquis vestrum prævaricationi communis constituti, contempta fraternitate, praeberet assensum.

English

For you have brought the mind of the most Christian prince to such a point by false suggestions that his clemency, which has always appeared pious toward his own enemies, was gravely moved against us. But your mind, impatient of quiet, so scattered all these good desires of ours, which were undoubtedly fighting for the peace of the Church, that those matters which should have been reserved for fraternal conference and the tranquil judgment of bishops were suddenly condemned according to your own arbitrary will, by published edicts, contrary to ecclesiastical custom, contrary to the traditions of the fathers, and contrary to all the authority of the evangelical and apostolic doctrine—though none of the faithful is ignorant through whom the Lord and our God has commanded his people to be instructed in heavenly doctrines, or to whom he has given the power of binding and loosing on earth. Then in the house of Placidia you met with the bishops of the Greek and Latin parties who were present in the royal city, and with the presbyters and deacons of the Church of Constantinople; and there, with the protestation of great outcry, both we and our brother the bishop of Milan forbade that any of you should give assent to the prevarication of the common constitution, having despised fraternity.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:103 · narrative
Source · Latin

Tu autcm, sedis apostolicae interdicentis per nos auctoritate despecla, ad Ecclesiam in qua edicta ipsa pendebant, reliquos tecum attrahens, perrexisti, ibique aliis adjectis prævaricatienibus, missarum solemnia celebrasti: et quasi nihil tibi esset primæ sedis antistitem praesentem et contradicentem contempsisse, pontificem etiam Alexandrinae Ecclesiae sacerdotem fratrem nostrum Zoilum, cujus nomen usque ad memoratum diem communicatum vobis fuerat diptycbis eximentes, Apollinarem quemdam perversorem atque Ecclesiæ ipsius adulterum vobis sociastis, ut vestra iniquitas non solum in removendo simplicissimo sacerdote, sed etiam in recipiendo patefieret perversore. Reticemus interim alia, quae eodem die a vobis in apostolicae sedis et in canonum perpetrata probantur injuriam, ne detenti enumeratione culparum, quarum inventor a ostenderis, quod tibi competit diutius differamus.

English

But you, having despised the authority of the apostolic see interposing through us, proceeded to the church in which those edicts were hanging, drawing the rest along with you, and there, with other acts of prevarication added, you celebrated the solemnities of the mass; and as though it were nothing to you to have despised the bishop of the first see present and contradicting you, you also removed from the diptychs the name of Zoilus, priest and bishop of the Alexandrian Church, our brother, whose name had been communicated to you up to the aforementioned day, and you joined to yourselves a certain Apollinaris, a perverter and adulterer of that same Church, so that your iniquity might be made manifest not only in removing a most simple priest, but also in receiving a perverter. We pass over for now the other things which are proven to have been perpetrated by you on that same day against the apostolic see and the canons, lest, detained by the enumeration of faults of which you have been shown to be the inventor, we delay longer what is fitting for you.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:104 · narrative
Source · Latin

Et licet ante triginta dies pro memoratis excessibus vestris ab apostolicæ vos commnnionis removissemus consortio, credentes quod sacerdotali proposito facilius quæ male gesta fueran satisfactione congrua curaretis: ideoque ex persona et auctoritate beati Petri apostoli, cujus, licet exigui, not locum gerimus, cum Dacio Mediolanensi, Joanne Marsicano, Zacchaeo Scyllaceno, Vatentino SilvaeCandidæ, Florentio Matellicatensi, Juliano Signino, Romulo Numanatensi, Dominico de Calliopoli, Primasio Adrumetino, Vereeundo Lunensi f, Stephano Ariminensi, Paschasio Aletrino, atque Jordane Crotonensi, fratribus et coepiscopis nostris, hac Theodorum, Caesareæ Cappadociæ civitatis quondam episcopum, sententiae promulgatione, tam sacerdotali honore et communione catholica, quam omni officio episcopali seu potestate spoliatum esse decernimus; nullis te vacare ulterius rebus, nisi pœnitentiæ lacrymis censentes, quibus percepta remissione culparum, locum communionemque tuam aut a me, aut post obitum meum a successore meo (si merueris) indulgentiae recipias.

English

And although thirty days earlier, on account of your aforementioned offenses, we had removed you from the fellowship of apostolic communion, believing that you would more easily, in accordance with your priestly purpose, remedy by suitable satisfaction the things that had been done wrongly: and therefore, in the person and authority of the blessed apostle Peter, whose place, though unworthy, we hold, together with Dacius of Milan, John of Marcianopolis, Zacchaeus of Scyllacium, Valentinus of Silva Candida, Florentius of Matellica, Julian of Signia, Romulus of Numanatia, Dominicus of Calliopolis, Primasius of Adrumetum, Verecundus of Luna, Stephen of Ariminum, Paschasius of Aletrium, and Jordan of Croton, our brothers and fellow bishops, we decree by the promulgation of this sentence that Theodore, formerly bishop of the city of Caesarea in Cappadocia, is deprived both of priestly honor and catholic communion, and of every episcopal office and power; judging that you should occupy yourself with no further matters except the tears of penance, by which, having received remission of your sins, you may receive your place and communion, either from me or, after my death, from my successor, if you have merited it.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:105 · narrative
Source · Latin

Teque Mennam Constantinopolitanæ civitatis episcopum, qui non dissimili culpa constringeris, cum omnibus metropolitanis et micropolitanis episcopis, ad tuam diœcesim pertinentibus, sed et tuos Orientales, vel diversarum provinciarum majorum minorumque civitatum episcopos, qui his excessibus, pro quibus Theodorum Caesareae Cappadociae quondam episcopum condemnavimus, praebuistis assensum, humaniore sententia, pro Dei consideratione, tandiu a sacra communioDe suspendimus, donec unusquisque vestrum errorem suae prævaricationis agnoscens, culpam apud nos propriam competenti satisfactione diluerit. Hæc eat subscriptio sancti papæ. Deo juvante, et ipsius gratia, Vigilius episcopus sanctae Ecclesiæ catholicae urbis Romæ, huic damnationi atque excommunicationi Tbeodori Cæsareæ Cappadociae, et huic communicantis Mennæ Constantinopolitanae urbis episcopi, vel aliorum praefectorum, subscripsi. Data xix calendas Septembris, imperante domino Justiniano perpetuo Augusto anno 25, post consulatum Basilii viri clarissimi anno [10] (Anno CAritH 551).

English

And you, Mennas, bishop of the city of Constantinople, who are bound by no dissimilar fault, together with all the metropolitan and micropolitan bishops belonging to your diocese, and also your Eastern bishops, and the bishops of the greater and lesser cities of various provinces, who have given assent to those excesses for which we once condemned Theodore, former bishop of Caesarea in Cappadocia—by a more humane sentence, out of consideration for God, we have suspended from sacred communion for as long as each of you, recognizing the error of his own transgression, shall wash away his own guilt before us by suitable satisfaction. This is the subscription of the holy pope. With God's help and by his grace, I, Vigilius, bishop of the holy Catholic Church of the city of Rome, have subscribed to this condemnation and excommunication of Theodore of Caesarea in Cappadocia, and to this suspension of communion of Mennas, bishop of the city of Constantinople, and of the others mentioned. Given on the nineteenth day before the calends of September, in the twenty-fifth year of the reign of our lord Justinian, perpetual Augustus, in the tenth year after the consulship of the most illustrious man Basilius (in the year of Christ 551).

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:106 · narrative
Source · Latin

EPISTOLA EUTYCHII AD VIGILIUM.

Profitetur fidem catholicam, et petit ut quæstio de tribus capitulis in concilio terminetur.

Sanctissimo et beatissimo domino et consacerdoti Vigilio Eutychius.

Scientes quantorum bonorum causa est pax Dei, custodiens corda et sensus fidelium, et colligens eos ut unum idemque sapiant in recta fidei confessione, et ad perficienda divina mandata, et propitium Deum faciens in his quae recta sunt concordantibus: ideo festinantes unitatem conservare ad apostolicam sedem vestræ beatitudinis manifestum facimus, quod nos semper et servavimus et servamus fidem ab initio traditam a magno Deo et Salvatore nostro Jesu Christo sanctis apostolis, et ab illis in omni mundo praedicatam, et sanctis Patribus explanatam, et maxime ab his qui in sanctis quatuor synodis congregati sunt, quos per omnia et in omnibus amplectimur et suscipimus, id est, trecentos decem et octo sanctos Patres qui Nicaeæ congregati sunt, et sanctum symbolum sive mathema fidei exposuerunt, et Arianam impietatem anathematizaverunt, et eos qui similia a eis sapuerunt vel sapiunt. Suscipimus autem et centum quinquaginta sanctos Patres Constantinopoli congregatos, qui idem sanctum mathema explanaverunt, et de deitate sancti Spiritus dilucidaverunt, et hæresim Macedonianam, sanctum Spiritum impugnantem, et impinm Apollinarium condemnaverunt, cum his qui similia illis sapuerunt vel sapiunt.

English

LETTER OF EUTYCHIUS TO VIGILIUS.

He professes the catholic faith, and asks that the question concerning the Three Chapters be settled in a council.

To the most holy and most blessed lord and fellow priest Vigilius, Eutychius.

Knowing of how many goods the peace of God is the cause, guarding the hearts and minds of the faithful, and gathering them so that they may think one and the same thing in the right confession of the faith, and for fulfilling the divine commandments, and making God propitious toward those who are of one mind in what is right: therefore, hastening to preserve unity with the apostolic see of your blessedness, we make manifest that we have always preserved and do preserve the faith handed down from the beginning by our great God and Savior Jesus Christ to the holy apostles, and preached by them throughout the whole world, and expounded by the holy Fathers, and especially by those who were gathered in the four holy synods, whom in all things and in all respects we embrace and receive, that is, the three hundred and eighteen holy Fathers who were gathered at Nicaea, and set forth the holy symbol or confession of faith, and anathematized the Arian impiety, and those who have thought or do think similar things to them. We also receive the one hundred and fifty holy Fathers gathered at Constantinople, who expounded the same holy confession, and clarified concerning the divinity of the Holy Spirit, and condemned the Macedonian heresy, which attacks the Holy Spirit, and the impious Apollinarius, together with those who have thought or do think similar things to them.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:107 · narrative
Source · Latin

Suscipimus autem et sanctos ducentos Patres in Ephesina prima synodo congregatos, qui per omnia secuti sunt idem sanctum symbolum sive mathema, et condemnaverunt Nestorium impium, et impia ejus dogmata, et eos qui similia ei aliquando sapuerunt vel sapiunt. Ad haec autem suscipimus et sexcentos triginta sanctos Patres Chalcedone congregatos, qui etiam ipsi per omnia consenserunt praedictis tribus synodis b, et secuti sunt praedictum symbolum sive mathema a trecentis decem et octo sanctis Patribus expositum, et a centum quinquaginta sanctis Patribus explanatum, et anathematizaverunt eos qui aliud præter prædictum symbolum praesumunt docere, aut exponere, aut tradere sanctis ecclesiis Dei c. Condemnaverunt autem et anathematizaverunt et Eutychem, et Nestorium, et impia eorum dogmata, et eos qui similia eis sapuerunt vel sapiunt. His ita se habentibus, certum facimus, quod omnia quae a prædictis sanctis quatuor synodis judicata et definita sunt, et servavimus, et servamus; quia etsi per diversa tempora prædictæ sanctae quatuor synodi factae sunt, tamen unam eamdemque confessionem iidei servaverunt et praedicaverunt. Suscipimus autem et amplectimur et epistolas praesulum Romanae sedis apostolicae e tam aliorum, quam Leonis sanctae memoriæ de recta fide scriptas, et de quatuor sanctis conciliis, vel uno eorum.

English

We also receive the two hundred holy Fathers assembled in the first council at Ephesus, who in all things followed the same holy symbol or doctrine, and condemned the impious Nestorius, and his impious dogmas, and those who at any time have thought or now think similar things to him. In addition to these, we also receive the six hundred and thirty holy Fathers assembled at Chalcedon, who themselves also in all things agreed with the aforementioned three councils, and followed the aforementioned symbol or doctrine set forth by the three hundred and eighteen holy Fathers, and explained by the one hundred and fifty holy Fathers, and they anathematized those who presume to teach, or expound, or hand down to the holy churches of God anything other than the aforementioned symbol. They also condemned and anathematized Eutyches, and Nestorius, and their impious dogmas, and those who have thought or now think similar things to them. These things being so, we make it certain that all things which have been judged and defined by the aforementioned four holy councils, we have both preserved and do preserve; because even though the aforementioned four holy councils were held at different times, nevertheless they preserved and preached one and the same confession of faith. We also receive and embrace the letters of the bishops of the Roman apostolic see, both of others and of Leo of holy memory, written concerning the right faith, and concerning the four holy councils, or one of them.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:108 · narrative
Source · Latin

Cum igitur praedicta omnia et servavimus et servamus, et si in his a nobis ipsis invicem consentimus, necessarium est conferri de tribus capitulis, unde quibusdam quaestio nata est. Et ideo petimus, præsidente nobis vestra beatitudine, sub tranquillitate et sacerdotali mansuetudine propositis sanctis evangeliis, communi tractatu eadem capitula in medio proponenda, quaeri et conservari b, et finem quæstioni imponi Deo placitum c, et convenientem his quae a sanctis quatuor conciliis definita sunt: quoniam ad augmentum pacis et concordiam Ecclesiarum pertinet, ut omni de medio dissensione sublata, quæ a prædictis quatuor sanctis conciliis definita sunt, inconcussa serventur, sanctarum synodorum reverentia in omnibus custodita. His autem et subscripsi incolumis in Domino. Ora pro nobis, sanctissime et beatissime frater.

Ego Eutychius, misericordia Dei episcopus Constantinopolis novæ Romæ omnibus suprascriptis subscripsi.

English

Since, therefore, we have both observed and do observe all the things aforesaid, and if in these things we are mutually in agreement among ourselves, it is necessary that a conference be held concerning the three chapters, from which a question has arisen for certain persons. And therefore we ask that, with your Beatitude presiding over us, in tranquility and priestly gentleness, with the holy Gospels set forth, these same chapters be brought forward in the midst of a common discussion, be examined and preserved, and that an end pleasing to God be put to the question, and one consonant with those things which have been defined by the four holy councils: since it pertains to the increase of peace and the concord of the Churches that, with all dissension removed from the midst, those things which have been defined by the aforesaid four holy councils be preserved unshaken, with reverence for the holy synods maintained in all things. To these things I too have subscribed, in soundness in the Lord. Pray for us, most holy and most blessed brother.

I, Eutychius, by the mercy of God bishop of Constantinople, the new Rome, have subscribed to all the things written above.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:109 · narrative
Source · Latin

Idem libellus scriptus est et ab Apollinario sanctissimo archiepiscopo magnæ civitatis Alexandriæ, et a Domnino sanctissimo archiepiscopo Theopoleos, et a Dco amantissimis episcopis qui sub ipsis sunt, qui et prcesentes erant in hac regia civitate, ad eumdem sanctissimum Vigilium.

EPISTOLA (olim) XVI. VIGILII PAPÆ AD EUTYCHIUM.

Commendat ejus fidem, et annuit ut de tribus capitulis in concilio agatur.

Dilectissimo fratri Eutychio et episcopis sub te constitutis Vigilius.

Repletum est gaudio os nostrum, et lingua nostra exsultatione (Psal. CXXV), quod discordiæ confusione submota, pacem Deus suae reformavit Ecclesiae, ut impleretur quod dictum est e: Ecce quam bonum et quam jucundum habitare fratres in unum (Psal. CXXXII). Valde enim nos in Domino exsultare convenit, quod charitatis vestrae scripto nobis est oblata professio, cujos tenor ita sese habet: Scientes quantorum bonorum causa est pax Dei, custodiens corda et sensus fidelium, et colligens eos ut unum idemque sapiant in recta fidei confessione, etc.

English

The same document was also written by Apollinarius, most holy archbishop of the great city of Alexandria, and by Domninus, most holy archbishop of Theopolis, and by the bishops most beloved of God who are under them, who were also present in this royal city, to the same most holy Vigilius.

LETTER (formerly) XVI. OF POPE VIGILIUS TO EUTYCHIUS.

He commends his faith, and agrees that the three chapters be dealt with in council.

Vigilius to his most beloved brother Eutychius and the bishops constituted under you.

Our mouth has been filled with joy, and our tongue with exultation, because, with the confusion of discord set aside, God has restored peace to his Church, so that what was said might be fulfilled: Behold how good and how pleasant it is for brothers to dwell in unity. For it is very fitting that we exult in the Lord, because by the writing of your charity a profession has been offered to us, the tenor of which is as follows: Knowing of how many good things the peace of God is the cause, guarding the hearts and minds of the faithful, and gathering them so that they may think one and the same thing in the right confession of faith, etc.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:110 · narrative
Source · Latin

His autem et subscripsimus, hujus professionis orthodoxæ claritatem libenter amplexi, eadem nos per omnia et in omnibus approbantes, custodituros atque inviolabiliter servaturos Deo nostro profiteremur [profitemur] auctore. Omnibus igitur, quæ professio vestra continet, in sua pereuniter firmitate durantibus, poposcit vestra fraternitas, ut nobis praesidentibus de tribus capitulis, ex quibus quæstio nata est, sub tranquillitate et sacerdotali mansuetudine sanctis propositis Evangeliis conferatur, et finis quaestioni ipsi Deo plaeitus et conveniens iis i quae a memoratis sanctis quatuor conciliis definita sunt, imponatur; ut omni de medio dissensione sublata,

CONSTITUTUM YIGILIl PAPÆ DE TRIBUS CAPITULIS.

Gloriosissimo et clementissimo filio Justiniano Augusto Vigilius episcopus.

English

To these things we also have subscribed, having willingly embraced the clarity of this orthodox profession, approving the same things in all respects and in all things, and we profess, with God as our author, that we will keep and inviolably preserve them. Therefore, while all the things that your profession contains remain firmly established in their own permanence, your fraternity has requested that, with us presiding, concerning the three chapters from which the question has arisen, in tranquility and priestly gentleness, with the holy Gospels placed before us, it be discussed, and that an end be put to the question itself, pleasing to God and in accordance with those things which have been defined by the aforementioned four holy councils; so that, with all dissension removed from the midst,

THE CONSTITUTION OF POPE VIGILIUS CONCERNING THE THREE CHAPTERS.

Vigilius, bishop, to his most glorious and most clement son Justinian Augustus.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:111 · narrative
Source · Latin

Inter innumeras sollicitudines quibus oneratur imperiale fastigium, laudabile clementiæ vestræ cognovimus esse propositum, per quod submotis omnibus discordie seminibus, quæ in agro Domini humani generis inimicus asperserat, universos Domini sacerdoles præmissis ad testimonium conscientiæ suae professionibus, per quas sanctorum Patrum et venerabilium quatuor synodorum ac præsulum sedis apostolicæ inhærere definitionibus atque judiciis monstrarentur, ad unitatem atque concordiam restituero properastis: quarum professionum formam, ut ecclesiasticæ pacis amplectendum posteris tradatur exemplum, praesenti, quemadmodum se habet, inserta pagina declaramus.

Exemplum primæ professionis quam ad Sanctæ Eu phemiæ templum fecerunt. i.

Omnes quidem fideles, maxime vero Dei sacerdotes, pacem et sanctificationem sequi cum omnibus oportet, sine quibus nemo, secundum Apostolum (I Thess. iv), videbit Dominum. Nos igitur apostolicam sequentes doctrinam, et festinantes concordiam quae ab eisdem quatuor sanctis synodis definita sunt, inconcussa serventur, earumdem synodorum reverentia in omnibus custodita. Quam professionem paternarum traditionum memorem et sequacem, tam in fraternitate vestra quam in omnibus similia confessis atque confitentibus, omni laude plenissimam judicavimus. et nostros ex ea re vere fratres agnoscimus.

English

Among the countless cares by which the imperial height is burdened, we have learned that it is the praiseworthy purpose of your Clemency that, with all the seeds of discord removed which the enemy of the human race had scattered in the field of the Lord, you have hastened to restore all the priests of the Lord to unity and concord, after professions had been brought forward as a testimony of their conscience, by which they might show themselves to adhere to the definitions and judgments of the holy Fathers and of the four venerable synods and of the bishops of the apostolic see; and we declare the form of these professions, as it stands, inserted in the present page, so that it may be handed down to posterity as an example of ecclesiastical peace to be embraced.

Copy of the first profession which they made at the church of Saint Euphemia. i.

Indeed all the faithful, but especially the priests of God, ought to pursue peace and sanctification with all, without which no one, according to the Apostle (1 Thess. 4), will see the Lord. We therefore, following the apostolic doctrine and hastening that the concord which has been defined by the same four holy synods be preserved unshaken, with reverence for the same synods guarded in all things. This profession, mindful and observant of the traditions of the Fathers, both in your brotherhood and in all who confess and have confessed similar things, we have judged most fully worthy of all praise, and we recognize our true brothers from this matter.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:112 · narrative
Source · Latin

Unde divinae clementiæ supplicamus, ut omnes nos in hac confessione et paternis e traditionibus permanentes, nostro digni reperiamur onicio, et in die divini judicii nulli prævaricationi paternarum constitutionum inveniamur obnoxii. Quibus ita prædictis postulationibus vestrum [ postulationis vestræ] desiderium cognoscentes annuimus, ut de tribus capitulis, ex quibus quæstio nata est, facto regulari conventu, servata aequitate, mediis sacrosanctis evangeliis, collationem cum unitis fratribus babeamus [for. habeatis], et finis detur placitus Deo, et conveniens his quae a sanctis quatuor sunt definita couciliis: scientes utique, sicut et communis professionis testimonio declaratur, memoratarum synodorum in omnibus reverentiam custodiri. Deus te incolumem custodiat, frater charissime. Datum VIII [VII] idus Januarias, imperii domini Justiniani perpetui Augusti anno 27, post consulatum Basilii viri clarissimi anno 12.

English

Wherefore we beseech the divine clemency that we all, remaining in this confession and in the traditions of the fathers, may be found worthy of our office, and on the day of divine judgment may not be found liable to any prevarication against the constitutions of the fathers. Having thus been informed of these things, we grant your desire, as set forth in your requests, that concerning the three chapters, from which the question has arisen, a regular council having been convened, with equity preserved, in the midst of the most holy Gospels, we may hold a conference with the united brethren, and that an end may be given pleasing to God and consonant with those things which have been defined by the four holy councils: knowing, certainly, as is also declared by the testimony of our common profession, that reverence for the aforementioned synods is to be preserved in all things. May God keep you safe, dearest brother. Given on the eighth day before the Ides of January, in the twenty-seventh year of the reign of our lord Justinian, perpetual Augustus, and in the twelfth year after the consulship of Basilius, a man of most illustrious rank.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:113 · narrative
Source · Latin

Eadem forma scripsit et ad Apollinarium sanctissimum, archiepiscopum magnæ civitatis Alexandriæ, ct ad Domninum sanctissimum, archiepiscopum Theopoleos, et ad synodum ipsis subjectam.

ecclesiasticam servare, præsentem facimus libellum. Imprimis quatuor sanctas synodos, Nicænam trecentorum decem et octo, Constantinopolitanam centum quinquaginta, Ephesinam primam ducentorum, in qua in legatis suis atque vicariis, id est beatissimo Cyrillo Alexandrinæ urbis episcopo, Arcadio et Projecto episcopis, et Philippo presbytero, beatissimus Coelestinus papa senioris Romae noscilur præsedisse, et Chalcedonensem sexcentorum triginta sanctorum Patrum suscipimus. Et per omnia et in omnibus, quaecunque in omnibus gestis Chalcedonensis conci-.

English

He wrote in the same form also to Apollinarius, most holy archbishop of the great city of Alexandria, and to Domninus, most holy archbishop of Theopolis, and to the synod subject to them.

We make this present document to preserve the ecclesiastical [faith]. In the first place we receive the four holy synods: Nicaea of the three hundred and eighteen, Constantinople of the one hundred and fifty, the first Ephesus of the two hundred, in which the most blessed Pope Celestinus of elder Rome is known to have presided through his legates and vicars, that is, the most blessed Cyril, bishop of the city of Alexandria, the bishops Arcadius and Projectus, and the presbyter Philip, and Chalcedon of the six hundred and thirty holy Fathers. And in all things and through all things, whatever in all the acts of the Chalcedonian council—

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:114 · narrative
Source · Latin

Iii aliaruiuque praedictarum synodorum, sicut in iisdem quatuor synodis scriptum invenitur, communi consensu curn legatis atque vicariis sedis apostolicae, in quibus juxta tempora sua prædecessores sanctitalis vestræ beatissimi papæ senioris Romæ ipsis synodis præsederunt, tam de fide quam de aliis omnibus causis, judiciis, constitutionibus, aut dispositionibus definita aut judicata, vel constituta, sive disposita sunt, inconcusse, inviolabiliter, irreprehensibiliter, atque irretractabiliter, sine adjectione vel imminutione aliqua nos promittimus secuturos, nec quidquam contrarium quod ad earum reprehensionem et retractationem vel permutationem sive injuriam sub qualibet occasione vel novitate pertineat admiasuros, aut tale aliquid praesumentibus consensuros; sed quæcunque communi consensu cum legatis atque vicariis sedis apostolicæ orthodoxæ ibidem dicta sunt, ea orthodoxa veneramur atque suscipimus.

English

And whatever was defined or judged, or constituted or disposed, by the common consent of these and the other aforementioned synods, as is found written in the same four synods, together with the legates and vicars of the apostolic see, in which, according to their times, the predecessors of your Holiness, the most blessed popes of senior Rome, presided over those same synods, both concerning the faith and concerning all other causes, judgments, constitutions, or dispositions — we promise to follow unshaken, inviolably, irreprehensibly, and irrevocably, without any addition or diminution; nor will we admit anything contrary that pertains to their reprehension and retractation or alteration or injury under any occasion or novelty, nor will we consent to those presuming any such thing; but whatever has been said there in orthodox fashion by common consent with the legates and vicars of the orthodox apostolic see, we venerate and receive as orthodox.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:115 · narrative
Source · Latin

Quæcunque anathematizaverunt vel damnaverunt, anathematizamus et nos atque damnamus; et universa, sicut ab iisdem synodis communi consensu cum vicariis sedis apostolicae judicata, aut definita, vel constituta; sive disposita lecta inveniuntur, irretractabiliter atque impermutabiliter conservamus. Sed et beatae recordationis papæ Lconis epistolas, et sedis apostolicæ constituta, quæ tam de fide quam de firmitate supradictarum quatuor synodorum, processerunt, nos in omnibus secuturos servturosque promittimus. Anathematizantes omnem hominem ad ordines et dignitates ecclesiasticas pertinentem, quicunque contra ea quæ superius promisimus sub qualibet occasione vel altercatione venire tentaverit. Libellum autem in causa trium capitulorum, de quitbus quæstio nata est, contra constitutum piissimi principis et beatitudinis vestræ, ego quidem nullum feci, sed volo atque consentio, ut omnes libenti qui facti sUnt sub hac forma beatitudini vestite reddantur. De injuriis autem, quæcunque beatitudini vel sedi vestrae factæ sunt, eas quidem non feci; sed quia pro pace Ecclesiae modis est omnibus festinandum, velut si eas fecissem, veniam postulo. Quia vero tempore discordiæ excommunicatos vel non receptos a beatitudine vestra in communionem suscepi, pariter veniam postulo.

English

Whatever they anathematized or condemned, we also anathematize and condemn; and all things, as they are found read to have been judged, or defined, or constituted, or disposed by the common consent of the same synods together with the vicars of the apostolic see, we preserve irrevocably and unchangeably. But also the letters of Pope Leo of blessed memory, and the constitutions of the apostolic see, which have proceeded both concerning the faith and concerning the firmness of the aforementioned four synods, we promise in all things to follow and observe. Anathematizing every man belonging to the ecclesiastical orders and dignities, whoever against those things which we have promised above shall attempt to come under any occasion or dispute. But the libellus in the cause of the Three Chapters, concerning which a question has arisen, against the constitution of the most pious prince and of your blessedness, I indeed have made none, but I will and consent that all libelli which have been made under this form be willingly returned to your blessedness. Concerning the injuries, however, whatever have been done to your blessedness or see, I indeed did not do them; but because for the peace of the Church it must be hastened by all means, as if I had done them, I ask pardon. But because in the time of discord I received into communion those excommunicated or not received by your blessedness, I likewise ask pardon.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:116 · narrative
Source · Latin

In hac forma fecerunt Mennas Constantinopolitanus episcopus, Theodorus Cæsareæ Cappadociæ episcopus, Andreas Ephesinus episcopus, Theodorus Antiochiæ Pisidiae episcopus, Petrus Tarsensis episcopus; sed multi alii episcopi idem fecerunt.

Exemplar professionis quam residui episcopi Theopha niorum die nobis fecerunt.

Scientes quantorum bonorum causa est pax Dei, custodiens corda et sensus ftdelium, et colligens eos, ut unum idemque sapiant in recta fidei confessione, et ad perficienda divina mandata, et propitium Deum faciens in his quæ recta sunt concordantibus, ideo festinantes unitatem conservare, ad apostolicam sedem vestræ beatitudinis manifestum facimus, quod nos semper conservavimus et conservamus fidem ab initio traditam a magno Deo et Salvatore nostro Jesu Christo, sanctis apostolis, et ab illis in omni mundo praedicatam, et a sanctis Patribus explanatam, et maxime ab bis qui in sanctis quatuor synodis congregati sunt, quos per omnia et in omnibus sequimur et suscipimus, id est trecentos decem et octo sanctos Patres, qui Nicææ congregati sunt, et sanctum symbolum sive mathema Mei exposuerunt, et Arianam Impietatem anathematizaverunt, et eos qui eadem sapuerunt vel sapiunt.

English

In this form acted Mennas, bishop of Constantinople; Theodore, bishop of Caesarea in Cappadocia; Andrew, bishop of Ephesus; Theodore, bishop of Antioch in Pisidia; Peter, bishop of Tarsus; but many other bishops did the same.

Copy of the profession which the remaining bishops of the Theophaniorum made to us on the day.

Knowing that the peace of God is the cause of how many good things, guarding the hearts and minds of the faithful, and gathering them together so that they may think one and the same thing in the right confession of faith, and for fulfilling the divine commandments, and making God propitious to those who are of one mind in the things that are right, therefore hastening to preserve unity, we make known to the apostolic see of your blessedness that we have always preserved and do preserve the faith handed down from the beginning by the great God and our Savior Jesus Christ, preached by the holy apostles, and by them throughout the whole world, and expounded by the holy Fathers, and especially by those who were gathered in the four holy synods, whom we follow and receive in all things and in every respect, that is, the three hundred and eighteen holy Fathers who were gathered at Nicaea, and who set forth the holy symbol or mathema of the faith, and anathematized the Arian impiety, and those who have held or do hold the same opinions.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:117 · narrative
Source · Latin

Suscipimus autem et centum quinquaginta sanctos patres Constantinopoli congregatos, qui idem sanctum mathema explanaverunt, et de deitate Spiritus sancti dilucidaverunt, et hæresim Macedonianam Spiritum sanctum impugnantem, et impium Apollinarium condemnaverunt, cum his qui eadem cum illis sapuerunt vel sapiunt. Suscipimus autem et sanctos ducentos Patres in Ephesina prima synodo collectos, qui per omnia secuti sunt idem sanctum symbolum sive mathema, et condemnaverunt Nestorium impium et scelerata ejus dogmata, et eos qui similia ei aliquando sapuerunt vel sapiunt.

Ad hæc autem etiam suscipimus sexcentos triginta sanctos Patres Chalcedone congregatos; qui etiam ipsi per omnia consenserunt prædictis sanctis tribus synodis, et secuti sunt prædictum symbolum sive mathema a trecentis decem et octo sanctis Patribus expositum, et a centum quinquaginta sanctis Patribus explanatum, et anathematizaverunt eos qui aliud praeter praedictum symbolum præsumunt docere, aut exponere, et tradere sanctis Dei ecclesiis: condemnaverunt autem et anathematizaverunt et Eutychetem et Nestorium, et impia eorum dogmata, et eos qui similia eis sapuerunt vel sapiunt.

English

We also receive the one hundred fifty holy fathers gathered at Constantinople, who expounded the same holy doctrine and clarified concerning the divinity of the Holy Spirit, and condemned the Macedonian heresy that attacks the Holy Spirit, and the impious Apollinaris, together with those who have held or now hold the same opinions as they did. We also receive the two hundred holy fathers assembled in the first synod at Ephesus, who in all things followed the same holy symbol or doctrine, and condemned the impious Nestorius and his wicked dogmas, and those who at any time have held or now hold opinions similar to his.

In addition to these, we also receive the six hundred thirty holy fathers gathered at Chalcedon, who themselves also in all things agreed with the aforesaid three holy synods, and followed the aforesaid symbol or doctrine set forth by the three hundred eighteen holy fathers and expounded by the one hundred fifty holy fathers, and anathematized those who presume to teach or expound or hand down to the holy churches of God anything other than the aforesaid symbol. They also condemned and anathematized both Eutyches and Nestorius, and their impious dogmas, and those who have held or now hold opinions similar to theirs.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:118 · narrative
Source · Latin

His ita se habentibus, certum facimus quod omnia quæ a praedictis sanctis quatuor synodis judicata et definita sunt servamus; quia etsi per diversa tempora prædictæ sanctae quatuor synodi factae sunt, tamen unam eamdemque confessionem fidei servaverunt et prædicaverunt.

Suscipimus autem et amplectiinur epistolas præsulum Romanæ sedis apostolicæ, tam aliorum, quam Leonis sanctæ memoriæ de recta fide scriptas, et de quatuor Sanctis conciliis, vel de uno eorum. Cum igitur prædicta omnia et servavimus et servamus, et in iisdem nobis invicem consentimus, necessarium est conferri [confiteri] de tribus capitulis, unde qui.. busdam quæstio nata est. Et ideo petimus, præsidente nobis vestra beatitudine, sub tranquillitate et sacerdotali mansuetudine, sanctis propositis Evangeliis, communi tractatu eadem capitula in medio proponenda quæri et conferri, et finem quaestioni imponi Deo placitum et convenientem his quæ a sanctis quatuor conciliis definita sunt; quoniam ad augmentum pacis, et concordiam Ecclesiarum pertinet, ut, omni de medio dissensione sublata, quae a prædictis sanctis quatuor conciliis definita sunt inconcussa serventur, sanctarum synodorum reverentia in omnibus custodita. His autem et subscripsimus in hunc modum fratres et coepiscopi nostri.

English

These things being so, we make it certain that we preserve all things that have been judged and defined by the aforesaid four holy synods; for even if the aforesaid four holy synods were held at different times, nevertheless they preserved and preached one and the same confession of faith.

We also receive and embrace the letters of the bishops of the Roman apostolic see, both of others and of Leo of holy memory, written concerning the right faith, and concerning the four holy councils, or concerning one of them. Since, therefore, we have preserved and do preserve all the aforesaid things, and in them we are mutually in agreement, it is necessary that a conference be held concerning the three chapters, from which a question has arisen among certain people. And therefore we ask that, with your blessedness presiding over us, in tranquility and priestly gentleness, with the holy Gospels placed before us, in common discussion those same chapters be brought forward and examined, and that an end be put to the question, pleasing to God and consistent with those things that have been defined by the four holy councils; since it pertains to the increase of peace and the concord of the Churches that, with all dissension removed from the midst, those things that have been defined by the aforesaid four holy councils be preserved unshaken, with reverence for the holy synods maintained in all things. To these things we have also subscribed in this manner, we your brothers and fellow bishops.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:119 · narrative
Source · Latin

Eutychius episcopus Constantinopolitanus, Apollinaris episcopus Alexandrinus, Domninus [Domnus] Antiochiæ Syriæ episcopus, Elias episcopus Thessalonicensis; sed et cæteri qui primam professionem non fecerunt, et in hac secunda professione aut subscripserunt, aut seorsum eamdem fecerunt.

His igitur dispositis, optavimus quidem, venerabilis imperator (sicut frequentissime supplici prece poposcimus) eundum ad quemlibet Italiae locum, aut certe ad Siciliam, et convocatis ad nos Africanæ et aliarum provinciarum Latinae linguae sacerdotibus, vel Ecclesiæ nostræ sacratis ordinibus, secundum consuetudinem tractaremus, et de quæstionibus trium capitulorum pietati vestrae reddoremus plena deliberatione responsum; quod quia fieri serenitas vestra non annuit, hoc iterum noscitur constitutum, ut oblatis a nobis mansuetudini vestræ nominibus de suprascriptis provinciis, qui nobiscum ad tractandum adhiberentur antistites, clementia vestra faceret advenire; cui dispositioni ilem praebuimus ecclesiasticae pacis amore consensum.

English

Eutychius bishop of Constantinople, Apollinaris bishop of Alexandria, Domninus [Domnus] bishop of Antioch in Syria, Elias bishop of Thessalonica; but also the others who did not make the first profession, and in this second profession either subscribed or made it separately.

These things therefore having been arranged, we desired indeed, venerable emperor (as we have very often requested with suppliant prayer) to go to any place in Italy, or certainly to Sicily, and with the African and other provinces' priests of the Latin language, or the sacred orders of our Church, having been summoned to us, we might, according to custom, discuss and, concerning the questions of the Three Chapters, render to your Piety a full deliberation in answer; because your Serenity did not grant that this be done, it is again known to have been resolved that, with the names of those from the above-written provinces who might be brought in with us for discussion having been offered by us to your Mildness, your Clemency should cause them to come; to which arrangement we likewise gave consent out of love for ecclesiastical peace.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:120 · narrative
Source · Latin

Postea vero hoc magis cum consensu fratrum nostrorum, nostrarum partium episcoporum, nuper ante sanctum Paschae diem pietas vestra constituit, ut exæquato numero his pontificibus, qui in Constantinopolitana urbe præsentes sunt, de tribus capilulis, ex quibus quæstio vertitur, secundum superius designatam fralrum nostrorum episcoporum professionem deberemus inire tractatum.

Sed quia, dum ea quæ pro conservanda Ecclesiarum pace cum fratribus nostris fieri, vestra dispositione convenerant, festinaremus implere, ut adhibita salubri deliberatione communiter, et propter informandam universalem Ecclesiam, cunctis quæ inter nos geruntur in scriptis deductis atque jacentibus, nostrum ex his collectum de tribus capitulis in quæstionem deductis judicium proveniret: continuo pietas vestra a post illud volumen, quod nobis ante multos Paschæ dies per virum magnificum Theodorum decurionem palatii destinavit, in quo vos interim quid de tribus sentiretis capitulis exponentes, nostrum poscitis dari ex eadem causa responsum.

English

Afterwards, however, with the consent of our brothers, the bishops of our side, your Piety recently established, before the holy day of Pascha, that with an equal number of those pontiffs who are present in the city of Constantinople, concerning the three chapters, from which the question arises, we should enter into discussion according to the profession of our brothers the bishops designated above.

But because, while we were hastening to fulfill those things which, for preserving the peace of the Churches, had been agreed with our brothers by your arrangement, so that, with salutary deliberation applied in common, and for the purpose of instructing the universal Church, all things which are done among us having been set down and laid out in writing, our judgment collected from these concerning the three chapters brought into question might come forth: immediately your Piety, after that volume which it sent to us many days before Pascha through the magnificent man Theodore, decurion of the palace, in which you, setting forth in the meantime what you thought concerning the three chapters, ask that our response be given on the same matter.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:121 · narrative
Source · Latin

Ideoque cum fratres nostri, neque exaequato nobiscum numero residere, neque in scriptum quae ageremus vel tractaremus redigi paterentur, tanquam (quod absil) non convenientia rectitudini loqueremur, quae scribere timeremus; et insuper gloriosissimis ad nos proceribus destinatis insisteret vestra clementia, nostrum de trium capitulorum negotio quam celerrime proferre debere responsum, nec sic destitimus vestrae obedire velle clementiæ: hoc solummodo postulantes, ut pro infirmitate corporis nostri, quæ nulli habetur incognita, viginti dierum nobis daretis inducias, quatenus habito nobiscum, Deo auxiliante, tractatu, definitionis nostræ, constituto die scripto, sententiam diceremus: ad fratres et coepiscopos nostros, a quibus similiier de eadem causa responsum vos flagitare dixistis, filium nostrum diaconum Pelagium cum hujusmodi mandato direximus, dicentes. Ut quia constilutus collationis faciendae modus fuerat prætermissus, saltem viginti dies pro antedicta nostri corporis imbecillitate, quam norunt, nostrum deberent definitum de tribus capituUs sustinere responsum, antiquum et regularem custodientes ordinem, ne ante nostræ, hoc est sedis apostolicae, cui per Dei gratiam praesidemus, promulgationem sententiae, quidquam proferre tentarent, unde scandali rursus, quae sopita fuerat, oriri posset occasio.

English

And therefore, since our brothers were unwilling either to sit with us on an equal footing, or to allow what we were doing or discussing to be put in writing, as if (may it be far from us) we were speaking things not in accord with rectitude, which we would fear to write; and furthermore, when your Clemency, through the most glorious nobles sent to us, insisted that we ought to bring forth our response on the matter of the Three Chapters as quickly as possible, not even then did we cease from our willingness to obey your Clemency: asking only this, that on account of the infirmity of our body, which is unknown to no one, you grant us a truce of twenty days, so that, having held a discussion with us, with God's help, we might pronounce the sentence of our definition, put in writing on the appointed day. To our brothers and fellow bishops, from whom you said you were likewise demanding a response on the same matter, we sent our son the deacon Pelagius with a mandate of this kind, saying: that since the established manner of holding a conference had been omitted, they ought at least, for the aforesaid weakness of our body, which they know, to await our definitive response concerning the Three Chapters for twenty days, preserving the ancient and regular order, lest before the promulgation of the sentence of our see—that is, the apostolic see, over which by God's grace we preside—they should attempt to bring forth anything from which an occasion of scandal, which had been lulled to rest, might again arise.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:122 · narrative
Source · Latin

Propositis itaque nobis et diligenter inspectis, inquantum uniuscujusque capituli in quaestionem deducti ratio postulabat, synodalibus codicibus atque gestis prolatis, quae aliis eorumdem Patrum vel in sanctis quatuor synodis, aut in una earum rescripsissc [resedissej monstrantur, synodalibus epistolis inspectis, nihilominus prædecessorum nostrorum sedis apostolicae praesulum constitutis, aliisque probatorum Patrum necessariis instructionibus pertractatis: si qua de his quæ in quaestionem deducta sunt, apud patres nostros examinata fuerint, finita atque disposita, memores superius designatarum professionum, investigare curavimus: inspicientes dogmata quædam in prima chartacei voluminis parte per fratrem nostrum Benignum episcopum Heracleæ Paphlagoniæ a vestra parte transmissi jacentia, quorum tenor secundum intellectum subter expositum ad excludendum totius ambiguitatis errorem præsenti definitioni nostrae tenetur insertus, plena exsecrabilibus blasphemiis, et orthodoxæ fidei (quæ secundum evangelicam apostolicamque doctrinam a sanctis quatuor synodis, Nicæna, Constantinopolitana, Ephesina, atque Chalcedonensi probabiliter atque irreprehensibiliter, sancti Spiritus cooperante præsentia, legitur definita) valde inimica esse perspeximus, et procul a Christianis sensibus repellenda.

English

Therefore, with these matters set before us and carefully examined, insofar as the reasoning of each chapter brought into question demanded, with the synodal books and records produced, which show that some of these same Fathers either in the four holy synods or in one of them resided or wrote, with the synodal letters inspected, and nonetheless with the constitutions of our predecessors, the bishops of the apostolic see, and other necessary instructions of approved Fathers thoroughly treated: if any of these matters that have been brought into question were examined, settled, and disposed of among our fathers, mindful of the professions designated above, we took care to investigate. Inspecting certain doctrines lying in the first part of the paper volume sent by our brother Benignus, bishop of Heraclea in Paphlagonia, on your side, whose tenor, according to the understanding set out below, is to be inserted into our present definition to exclude the error of all ambiguity, we have perceived them to be full of execrable blasphemies and greatly hostile to the orthodox faith (which, according to the evangelical and apostolic teaching, is read to have been defined in a commendable and irreprehensible manner by the four holy synods—Nicaea, Constantinople, Ephesus, and Chalcedon—with the presence of the Holy Spirit cooperating), and to be driven far from Christian minds.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:123 · narrative
Source · Latin

Propterea ergo, ut pote exsecrabilia, atque a sanctis Patribus olim sine dubitatione damnata, nostra quoque sententia anathematizamus atque damnamus, quorum primum capitulum ita se habet:

THEODORI CAPITULUM I.

Quomodo igitur tu, quem super omnes maxime decet animarum regimen, illum eumdem, qui ex virgine natus est, Deum esse, et ex Deo consubstantialem Patri existimari dicis, nisi forte sancto Spiritui imputari illius creationem non jubes? Sed quis est Deus ex Deo et consubstantialis Patri? Is idem qui ex virgine natus erat (o miranduml), et qui per Spiritum sanctum secundum divinas Scripturas plasmatus est, et confictionem in muliebri accepit ventre? Inerat forsitan quia mox quam plasmatus est, et ut templum Dei esset, accepit: non tamen existimandum nobis est, Deum de virgine natum esse, nisi forte idem existimandum nobis est et quod natum est, et quod est in nato templo, et qui in templo est Deus Verbum: non tamen nec secundum tuam vocem pronuntiandum est omnino, ex virgine natum Deum esae et ex Deo consubstantialem Patri. Nam si non homo est (sicut dicis) assumptus, qui natus est ex virgine, Deus vero incarnatus; quomodo qui natus est, Deus ex Deo et consubslantialis dicetur Patri, carne non potente hanc vocem suscipere?

English

Therefore, as being execrable and long ago condemned without doubt by the holy Fathers, we too by our sentence anathematize and condemn them, the first chapter of which reads as follows:

CHAPTER I OF THEODORE.

How then do you, whom above all others it most befits to have the governance of souls, say that that same one who was born of a virgin is God, and is considered God from God and consubstantial with the Father, unless perhaps you do not order his creation to be attributed to the Holy Spirit? But who is God from God and consubstantial with the Father? Is it the same one who was born of the virgin (O wondrous thing!), and who according to the divine Scriptures was formed by the Holy Spirit, and received his fashioning in a woman's womb? Perhaps he was present because as soon as he was formed he also received it, so that he might be a temple of God; yet we must not think that God was born of the virgin, unless perhaps we must think the same both of that which was born and of that which is in the temple that was born, and of God the Word who is in the temple; yet neither, according to your word, is it to be pronounced at all that God was born of the virgin and is God from God and consubstantial with the Father. For if it is not a man (as you say) who was assumed, who was born of the virgin, but God incarnate, how shall he who was born be called God from God and consubstantial with the Father, since the flesh cannot receive this word?

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:124 · narrative
Source · Latin

Nam est quidem dementia Deum ex virgine natum esse dicere; hoc enim nihil aliud est quam ex semine eum dicere David de substantia virginis genitum et in ipsa plasmatum, quia quod ex semine David et de substantia virginia est, in materno ventre consistit, et sancti Spiritus plasmatum virtute, natum fuisse dicimus de virgine. Ut autem aliquis ex hoc concedat dicere ipsis, quod Deus ex Dee et consubstantialis Patri natus est ex virgine, eo quod eat in templo nato, sed non per se natus est Deus Verbum; incarnatus vero, sicut dicit iste sapiens.

English

For it is indeed madness to say that God was born of a virgin; for this is nothing other than to say that he was begotten from the seed of David, from the substance of the virgin, and formed in her, since what is from the seed of David and from the substance of the virgin exists in the maternal womb, and, formed by the power of the Holy Spirit, we say that he was born of the virgin. But that anyone might grant from this to say to them that God was born of God and consubstantial with the Father, born of a virgin, in that he was born in the temple, but God the Word was not born through himself; but was incarnate, as this wise one says.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:125 · narrative
Source · Latin

Si igitur cum carne eum natum esse dicunt; quod autem natum est, Deus ex Deo, et consubstantialis Patri est: necesse est hoc et carnem dicere, quod si non idcirco caro est, quoniam nec Deus ex Deo, nec consubstantialis Patri, sed ex semine David, et consubstantialis ei cujus semen est, et non id quod natum est ex virgine Deus est, et ex Deo, et consubstantialis Patri; nisi forte pars Nati, prout ipse in inferioribus partem Christi nominat deitatem; sed non divina natura ex virgine nata est; natus autem est ex virgine, qui ex substantia virginis constat, non Deus verbum ex Maria natus est: natus est autem ex Maria, qui ex semine est David, non Deus verbum ea; muliere natus est, sed natus ex muliere, qui virtute sancti Spiritus plasmatus est in ea; non ex matre natus est consubstantialis Patri (tine matre enim est, secundum beati Pauli vocem), sed qui in posterioribus temporibus in materno ventre sancti Spiritus virtute plasmatus est, ut pote sine Patre propter hoc dictus.

English

If, therefore, they say that he was born with flesh; but what is born is God from God and consubstantial with the Father: it is necessary to say this also of the flesh. But if it is not for this reason flesh, since it is neither God from God nor consubstantial with the Father, but from the seed of David and consubstantial with him whose seed it is, and what was born of the virgin is not God and from God and consubstantial with the Father—unless perhaps a part of the one born, inasmuch as he himself in what follows names the deity a part of Christ; but the divine nature was not born of the virgin; yet he who consists of the substance of the virgin was born of the virgin, not God the Word born of Mary: but he who is from the seed of David was born of Mary, not God the Word born of a woman, but he who was formed in her by the power of the Holy Spirit was born of a woman; he who is consubstantial with the Father was not born of a mother (for he is without a mother, according to the voice of blessed Paul), but he who in later times was formed in the maternal womb by the power of the Holy Spirit, as being for this reason said to be without a Father.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:126 · narrative
Source · Latin

vigilii responsio.

In suprascripto primo capitulo quoniam per circuitus id videtur astrui, quia homo purus ex sancta virgine Maria natus sit, dicendo: Si fatemur Deum verbum, qui consubstantialis est Patri, carne ex eadem virgine natum, necesse est ut carnem consubstantialem Patri consequenter esse dicamus. Ideoque quicunque hujusmodi intellectus sapit, docet, credit, aut predicat, et non eumdem Verbum ac Filium Dei per secundam nativitatem ex sancta Maria incamatum et natum credit, anathema sit.

THEODORI CAPITULUM II.

a Mox autem in ipso plasmato Deus Verbum factus est; nec enim in cælum ascendenti solum inerat, sed etiam ex mortuis resurgenti, ut pote et resuscitans eum secundum suam promissionem; nec resurgenti solum inerat, sed etiam crucifixo et baptizato, et evangelicam post baptisma conversionem peragenti, nec non etiam de baptismo legalem adimplenti constitutionem, et praesentato secundum legem, et circumciso, et fetui pannis obvoluto; erat autem forte in ipso et nascente, et cum in utero esset a prima statim plasmatione; dispensationi enim quæ circa eum erat ordinem imponebat, et particulatim ipsum ad perfectionem perducens.

English

The response of Vigilius.

In the above-written first chapter, since it seems to be asserted through circumlocutions that a mere man was born of the holy virgin Mary, by saying: If we confess that God the Word, who is consubstantial with the Father, was born in the flesh from the same virgin, it necessarily follows that we must say the flesh is consubstantial with the Father. And therefore, whoever savors, teaches, believes, or preaches this kind of understanding, and does not believe that the same Word and Son of God was incarnate and born through a second nativity from holy Mary, let him be anathema.

The second chapter of Theodore.

But soon, in that very formed [flesh], God the Word became; for he was not present only in him ascending into heaven, but also in him rising from the dead, as one who also raised him according to his promise; nor was he present only in him rising, but also in him crucified and baptized, and performing the evangelical conversion after baptism, and also fulfilling the legal ordinance concerning baptism, and presented according to the law, and circumcised, and wrapped as a fetus in swaddling clothes; he was perhaps also in him being born, and when he was in the womb from the very first formation; for he was imposing order on the dispensation that concerned him, and leading him part by part to perfection.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:127 · narrative
Source · Latin

TBEODORI CAPITULUM III.

Et per tempus ad baptisma ducens, post illud autem ' ad mortem, deinde secundum suam pronuntiationem resuscitans, ducens in cælum, collocans eum ad dexteram Dei per suam conjunctionem, ex qua sedet et adoratur ab omnibus, et omnes judicabit. Istorum autem omnium finem apud se habebat Deus Verbum, cum in eo erat, et omnia per ordinem complebat; quem ordinem ipse arbitrabatur bene habere per finitionem quidem et roluntatem, quam antea statuit pro bis quæ crentura erant, et bona voluntate, quam circa cum habebat, ab initio similiter inerat ei, per ordinem autem placitum ad perfectionem ducebat ipsum.

Vigilii responsio.

In suprascriptis secundo et tertio capitulis hoc videtur astrui, quia Deus verbum homini plasmalo inerat tanquam alter in altero. Dicendo enim, ut particulatim dispensationi, quæ circa eum erat, ordinem videretur imponere, et eum propter bonam voluntatem, quam circa ipsum habebat, et parabat eum qui assumptus est ad provectum perfectionis adducere, talibus verbis dualitas personarum in Domino uno et Deo nostro Jesu Christo exsecrabiliter videtur induci, et tanquam quemlibet hominem Dei Verbi gratia per spatia temporum profecisse. Ideoque quicunque eo intellectu sapit, docet, credit, aut praedicat, anathema sit.

English

CHAPTER III OF THEODORE.

And through time leading him to baptism, and after that to death, then according to his own pronouncement raising him up, leading him into heaven, placing him at the right hand of God through his conjunction, from which he sits and is adored by all, and will judge all. But God the Word had the end of all these things in himself, when he was in him, and he was fulfilling all things in order; which order he himself judged to be well held through the definition and will which he had previously established for the things that were to come, and by the good will which he had toward him, from the beginning it was similarly in him, and through order he was leading him according to his good pleasure to perfection.

The response of Vigilius.

In the above-written second and third chapters this seems to be asserted, that God the Word was in the formed man as one in another. For by saying that, so as to impose order in detail upon the dispensation that was concerning him, and that on account of the good will which he had toward him, he was also preparing him who was assumed to be brought to the advancement of perfection, by such words a duality of persons in the one Lord and our God Jesus Christ seems abominably to be introduced, and as though he had progressed like any man by the grace of God the Word through spans of time. And therefore whoever understands, teaches, believes, or preaches with that meaning, let him be anathema.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:128 · narrative
Source · Latin

THEODORI CAPITULUM IV.

Suam autem cooperationem ad proposita opera præstabat ei qui assumptus; ubi hoc facit in loco sensus fuisse distantem illi qui assumptus est; nec enim eis quibuscunque donavit cooperationem; sensus locum ejus obtinebat; si autem et modo præcipuam quamdam cooperationem donavit illi qui assumptus est, non hoc faciebat locum sensus deitatem obtinere. Sed si deitas pro sensu fiebat illi qui assumptus est, secundum vestra verba, quomodo timorem in passione suscipiebat? Quid vehementioribus orationibus ad imminentem necessitatem indigebat, quas cum magna quidem et clamorosa voce, cum plurimis etiam lacrymis secundum beatum Paulum (Heb. v) referebat Deo, evangetista aperte dicente (Luc. XIII), quod globis sanguinis simiIi. sudor descendebat? Quid autem angeli adventu et visitatione egebat, animam reficientis in experimento malorum, confortantis ejus alacritatem, exercitantis eum ad imminentem passionis necessitatem, tolerare fortiter mala suadentis, urgentis ad patientiam et toterationem malorum, ostendentis præsentium malorum fructum ex passione, mutationem in gloriam bonam circa eum post passionetn futuram? qui enim secundum evangelistæ vocem (Ibidem) confortabat eum, angelus scilicet, verbis istis fortem eum faciebat, et infirmitati naturæ superiorem fieri hortabatur, et corroborando cogitationes ejus fortem eum faciebat.

English

CHAPTER IV OF THEODORE.

But he who was assumed was receiving his cooperation for the works proposed, where he does this in the place of the sense that was distant from him who was assumed; for he did not grant cooperation to just any whatever persons; the sense was obtaining his place; but if even now he granted a certain principal cooperation to him who was assumed, he was not doing this so that the sense would obtain the place of the deity. But if the deity was becoming a sense for him who was assumed, according to your words, how did he receive fear in the passion? Why did he need more vehement prayers for the imminent necessity, which with a great and clamorous voice, with very many tears as well according to blessed Paul (Heb. 5), he was offering to God, while the evangelist openly says (Luke 13) that his sweat was descending like drops of blood? Why moreover did he need the coming and visitation of an angel, refreshing his soul in the experience of evils, strengthening his eagerness, training him for the imminent necessity of the passion, persuading him to endure evils bravely, urging him to patience and the endurance of evils, showing the fruit of the present evils from the passion, the change into good glory around him that would come after the passion? For he who was strengthening him, namely the angel, according to the voice of the evangelist (Ibidem), was making him strong with these words, and was exhorting him to become superior to the infirmity of nature, and by strengthening his thoughts was making him strong.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:129 · narrative
Source · Latin

Vigilii responsio.

In suprascripto quarto capitulo, quia dici intelligitur, quod sicut aliis hominibus donavit suam cooperationem Deus, ita et ei qui assumptus est, licet praecipuam, tamen similiter ut aliis hominibus dicitur esse donatam, et ita purum atque infirmum homi. nem circa passionem angeli eguisse præsidio, ut ei pro corroborandis cogitationibus ejus futura gloria promitteretur de tolerantia passionis; quæ si quis ita sapit, docet, credit, aut prædicat, anathema sit.

THEODORI CAPITULUM V.

Vade post me, Satana, scandalum mihi es, quod non sapis ea quae Dei sunt, sed ea quæ hominuM (Matth. xvi; Marc. VIII), non est confusio mihi mors, non fugio ipsam ut indecentem ad humanam gloriam respiciens. Sustinebo autem meliori animo experimentum mortis pro plurimis bonis futuris, in quibus et ipse fuero, et per omnes, ne mihi animum lædas atque turbes, tanquam confusione dignum fugere admonet mortis experimentum.

English

The response of Vigilius.

In the above-written fourth chapter, because it is understood to be said that, just as God gave his cooperation to other men, so also to him who was assumed—though a special one—it is nevertheless said to have been given similarly as to other men, and that thus a pure and weak man in regard to his passion needed the aid of an angel, so that for the strengthening of his thoughts the future glory was promised to him from the endurance of his passion: whoever thinks, teaches, believes, or preaches thus, let him be anathema.

CHAPTER V OF THEODORE.

Get behind me, Satan; you are a scandal to me, because you do not savor the things that are of God, but the things that are of men. Death is not a confusion to me; I do not flee it as indecent, looking to human glory. But I shall endure the experience of death with a better mind for the sake of many future goods, in which I myself shall also be, and through all things, lest you harm and disturb my mind, in that you admonish me to flee the experience of death as though it were worthy of confusion.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:130 · narrative
Source · Latin

Vigilii responsio.

In supradicto quinto capitulo dicitur, quod ideo Jesus Christus verba Petri apostoli fuerat aspematus, quando ei dixit: Vade post me, Salana, scandalum mihi es, quia non sapis ea qua Dei sunt (Matth. xvi; Marc. VIII): ne dissuasione ejus animus ipsius perturbatus refugeret passionem, et quia passione sna proiiceret, et pro pluribus bonis exinde adipiscendis. Qui igilur hæc ita sapit, docet, credit, aut prædicat, et, non magis nobis mortem ipsius, quam propria carne suscepit, æternæ credit vitæ praemia contulisse, anathema sit.

THEODORI CAPITULUM VI.

Quod enim dictum est: Ducebatur a Spiritu (Matth. IV), aperte hoc significat, quod ab eo regebatur, ab eo ad virtutem propositorum confortabatur, ab eo ad hæc quæ oportebat ducebatur, ab eo quod decebat docebatur, ab eo cogitationibus corroborabatur, ut intantum certamen sufficeret, sicut et beatus dicit Paulus: Quicunque Spiritu Dei aguntur, hi sunt filii Dei (Rom. VIII); duci Spiritu dicens illos qui ab eo gubernantur, ab eo docentur, ab eo ad melius constituuntur, ab eo competentium doctrinam accipiunt. Cum dixisset autem evangelista, quod Spiritu sancto plenus regressus est ab Jordane, aperte demonstravit quod hujus causa sancti Spiritus habitationem in baptismate suscepit, ut indc propositam caperet virtutem; unde et ad certamen illud quod pro nobis erat ad diabolum effecturus, Spiritu ducebatur.

English

The response of Vigilius.

In the above-written fifth chapter it is said that Jesus Christ had therefore rejected the words of the apostle Peter, when he said to him: Get behind me, Satan, you are a scandal to me, because you do not savor the things that are of God (Matthew 16; Mark 8): lest by his dissuasion his mind be disturbed and shrink from the passion, and lest by his passion he cast himself down, and for the sake of the many good things to be obtained therefrom. Whoever therefore savors, teaches, believes, or preaches these things, and does not believe that he has conferred the rewards of eternal life upon us no less by his death than he took upon himself his own flesh, let him be anathema.

CHAPTER VI OF THEODORE.

For what was said: He was led by the Spirit (Matthew 4), clearly signifies this: that he was governed by him, strengthened by him for the virtue of his purposes, led by him to the things that were fitting, taught by him what was proper, strengthened by him in his thoughts, so that he might suffice for the contest to such a degree, just as the blessed Paul also says: As many as are led by the Spirit of God, these are the sons of God (Romans 8); calling those who are governed by him, taught by him, established by him for the better, and who receive the teaching of those who are competent, "led by the Spirit." But when the evangelist had said that, full of the Holy Spirit, he returned from the Jordan, he clearly demonstrated that for this reason he received the indwelling of the Holy Spirit in baptism, so that from there he might take up the virtue set before him; whence also, for that contest which he was about to wage against the devil on our behalf, he was led by the Spirit.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:131 · narrative
Source · Latin

Vigilii responsio.

In suprascripto sexto capitulo rursus tanquam purus homo a Spiritu, cujus præsentiam post baptisma suscepisse dicitur, ad omnia ductus perhibetur, confortatus et edoctus, sicut cæteri homines, de quibus, ut hic videtur dici, Apostolus ait: Quicunque Spiritu Dei aguntur hi sunt filii Dei (Rom. VIII). Si quis haec ita sapit, docet, credit aut praedicat, et non Deum Verbum incarnalum unum esse credit, et confitetur, et praedicat Christum, anathema sit.

THEODORI CAPITULUM VII.

Dicant igitur nobis omnium sapientissimi, si pro sensu Domino Christo, qui est secundum carnem, deitas facta esset, sicut dicunt, quid sancti Spiritus operatione ad hæc Christus indigebat? Nec enim Unigeniti deitas Spiritu indigebat ad justipeationem, Spiritu indigebat ad vincendum diabolum, Spiritu indigebat ad operanda miracula, Spiritu indigebat ut doceretur ea quæ decebat peragere, Spiritu indigebat ut immacutatus appareret. Si enim pro sensu quidem deitas sufficiebat, ad omnia autem ejus virtus, necesse erat inde omnia fieri, ut superflua esset sancti Spiritus habitatio: sed nunc unctum esse dicit ipsum Spiritu, et habitasse in eo Spiritum, et ad omnia adjuvisse proposita, Et doctrinam inde ipsum accepisse et virtutem, et inde impetrasse justificationem, et inde immaculatum factum esse.

English

The response of Vigilius.

In the above-written sixth chapter he is again presented as a mere man, led, strengthened, and taught in all things by the Spirit, whose presence he is said to have received after baptism, just like other men, of whom, as it seems to be said here, the Apostle says: As many as are led by the Spirit of God, these are the sons of God (Rom. 8). If anyone understands, teaches, believes, or preaches these things in this way, and does not believe, confess, and preach that God the Word incarnate is one Christ, let him be anathema.

CHAPTER VII OF THEODORE.

Let the wisest of all, therefore, tell us: if, as they say, the deity was made in place of the mind of the Lord Christ, who is according to the flesh, why did Christ need the operation of the Holy Spirit for these things? For neither did the deity of the Only-Begotten need the Spirit for justification, need the Spirit for conquering the devil, need the Spirit for working miracles, need the Spirit to be taught what it was fitting to accomplish, need the Spirit to appear immaculate. For if the deity sufficed in place of the mind, and his power sufficed for all things, then everything had necessarily to come from that source, so that the indwelling of the Holy Spirit would be superfluous. But as it is, it says that he was anointed by the Spirit, and that the Spirit dwelt in him, and assisted him in all his purposes, and that he received doctrine and power from that source, and obtained justification from that source, and was made immaculate from that source.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:132 · narrative
Source · Latin

Vigilii responsio.

In suprascripto septimo capitulohocdici intelligitur, quia ut caLLeri homines ad justificationem suam et ad vincendum diabolum, et ad operanda miracula, et ut doceretur ea quæ decebat eum agere, et ut immaculatus appareret, habitatione sancti Spiritus eguisse, et ipso Spiritu eum ad omnia adjutum fuisse propesita. Quicunque haec ita sapit, docet, credit aut prædicat, et non sua deitate Christum, ut pote verum Deum, omnia operatum fuisse quae voluit, et operari quae volet, sed tanquam purum hominem sancti Spiritus eguisse solatio, anathema sit.

THEODORI CAPITULUM VIII.

Hoc quod ante sæcula erat, dicit in ultimis factum esse temporibus, ut pote quibusdam hoc confitentibus; cum nemo ex his qui pietatis curam habent, istum patitur morbum habere dementiæ, ut dicat eum qui ante sæcula est, in ultimis factum esse. Et ex his infert quod necesse est, et hoc quod in ultimis est, ante sæcula esse, et accusat eos qui non omnia similiter cum obversione dicunt; quasi hi qui unum esse Filium confitentur, necessitatem habeant cum obversione omnia dicere. Et quis non beatificet vestram dementiam?

English

The response of Vigilius.

In the above-written seventh chapter this is understood to be said, that like other men he needed the indwelling of the Holy Spirit for his justification and for conquering the devil, and for working miracles, and that he might be taught the things which it was fitting for him to do, and that he might appear spotless, and that he was aided in all things by that same Spirit. Whoever understands, teaches, believes, or preaches these things in this way, and does not hold that Christ, as true God, accomplished all things that he willed and works whatever he wills by his own divinity, but that as a mere man he needed the consolation of the Holy Spirit, let him be anathema.

CHAPTER VIII OF THEODORE.

That which existed before the ages, he says was made in the last times, as though some were confessing this; when no one of those who have a care for piety suffers him to have this disease of madness, so as to say that he who exists before the ages was made in the last times. And from these things he infers that it is necessary that this also which is in the last times exist before the ages, and he accuses those who do not say all things similarly with inversion; as if those who confess that the Son is one had a necessity of saying all things with inversion. And who would not call your madness blessed?

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:133 · narrative
Source · Latin

Quis autem ' non optettales impetrare doctores, tantam confusionem rationi pietatis introducentes, ut dicerent, hoc quod ante sæcula est, factum est in ultimis, et hoc alienarent sua natura, et ad deterius deducerent, deinde everterent, quod et hoc quod est in ultimis, ante sæcula est, cum oporteret forte dicere, quia quod ante sæcula erat, assumpsit hunc qui in ultimis erat secundum beati Pauli vocem (I Tim. IV). Vestras igitur leges sequente., et a tua sapientia constitutam obversionem, imo magis subversionem suscipientes age omnia simul confundamus, et nulla jam sit discretio, nec Dei formæ, nec servi formæ, nec templi sumpti, nec ejus qui in templo habitavit, nec ejus qui solutus est, nec ejus qui suscitavit, nec ejus qui perfectus est in passionibus, nec ejus qui perfecit, nec ejus qui memoriam meritus eat, nec ejus qui meinor factus est, nec ejus qui visitatus est, nec ejus qui visitavit, nec ejus qui paulo minus ab angelis minoratus est, nec ejus qui minoravit, nec ejus qui gloria et honore coronatus eat, nec ejus qui coronavit, nec ejus qui constitutus est super opera manuum Dei, nec ejus qui constituit, nec ejus qui at:cepit ista ad sublevationem, nec ejus qui dedit sublevationem.

English

But who would not wish such teachers to obtain such things, who introduce so great a confusion into the reasoning of piety, as to say that what exists before the ages was made in the last times, and that they alienate this from its own nature and lead it down to something worse, and then overturn it, namely that what exists in the last times also exists before the ages, when perhaps it ought to be said that what existed before the ages assumed this one who was in the last times, according to the word of blessed Paul (1 Tim. 4). Following your laws, therefore, and accepting the inversion—or rather subversion—established by your wisdom, come, let us confound all things together, and let there no longer be any distinction, neither of the form of God nor of the form of a servant, nor of the temple that was taken up nor of him who dwelt in the temple, nor of him who was loosened nor of him who raised up, nor of him who was perfected in sufferings nor of him who perfected, nor of him who merited remembrance nor of him who was made mindful, nor of him who was visited nor of him who visited, nor of him who was made a little lower than the angels nor of him who made lower, nor of him who was crowned with glory and honor nor of him who crowned, nor of him who was set over the works of the hands of God nor of him who set, nor of him who received these things for his uplifting nor of him who gave uplifting.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:134 · narrative
Source · Latin

Vigilii responsio.

In suprascripto octavo capitulo diversis modis videtur induci dualitas personarum per hec quod dicitur: Non ipse qui anle saecula erat, in ultimis dicendus est venisse temporibus; sed quasi altera sii assumentis humanitatem, alLera assumpti persona. Si quis igitur hæc ita sapit, docet, credit aut praedicat, et non eumdem Deum Verbum, qui ante saecula ex Patre natus est, in ultimis temporibus ex beata Virginc Maria incarnatum et natum esse fatetur, ut unus idemque sit Christus in utraqae natura, anathema sit.

THEODORI CAPITULUM IX.

Istum igitur virum, in quo statuit omnium facere judicium ad fidem futurorum, cum resuscitasset eum ex mortuis, et judicem omnium demonstrasset, secundum beati Pauli vocem (Act. xvu), meriti a unitate ad seipsum dignatus est: et per conjunctionem ad se (actam, talium participem fecit, ut et adorationis communionem haberet; omnibus quidem divince naturæ debitam adorationem reddentibus, comprehendentibus autem adoratione et illum quem inseparabiliter scit esse conjunctum. Ex quo manifestum eat, quod ad majora eum perduxerit.

English

The response of Vigilius.

In the above-written eighth chapter, a duality of persons seems to be introduced in various ways, through this statement: "Not he who existed before the ages is to be said to have come in the last times, but as though one person were the one assuming humanity, and another the one assumed." If anyone, therefore, understands, teaches, believes, or preaches these things in this way, and does not confess that the same God the Word, who was born of the Father before the ages, was in the last times incarnate and born of the blessed Virgin Mary, so that Christ is one and the same in both natures, let him be anathema.

CHAPTER IX OF THEODORE.

Therefore this man, in whom he determined to execute judgment over all for faith in things to come, when he had raised him from the dead and shown him to be the judge of all, according to the word of blessed Paul (Acts 17), he deigned to unite to himself by merit: and through the union made to himself, he made him a partaker of such things, so that he might also have communion in adoration; while all render the adoration due to the divine nature, they comprehend in adoration also him whom he knows to be inseparably conjoined. From this it is manifest that he led him on to greater things.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:135 · narrative
Source · Latin

Vigilii responsio.

In sUprascripto nono capitulo conjunctionis et participationis cujusdam vocabulo, quasi Dei ad hominem Christum factæ, divinis Christus asseritur operibus decorari; per quae rursus dualitas inducitur personarum. Si quis igitur ita sapit, docet, credit aut prædicat, et non unum eumdemque Christum Deum ac Dominum nostrum manentibus in suis proprietatibus differentiis naturarum, agnoscit et credit, anathema sit.

THEODORI CAPITULUM X.

Ego quidem, quem videtis, nihil quidem facere possum secundum meam naturam, cum homo sim, operor cutem, quia in me manens Pater omnia facit; quoniam enim et ego in Patre, et Pater in me (Joan. XIV); Deus autem Verbum unigenitus in me est; certum est quod et Pater cum ipso in me manet, et opera facit. Et non est mirandum de Christo hac existimari, cum evidenter ipse de cæteris hominibus dicat: Qui diligit me verbum meum observabit, et Pater meus diliget eum, et ad eum veniemus, et mansionem apud eum faciemus (Ibidem). Si enim apud unumquemque hujusmodi hominum et Pater et Filius mansionem faciunt, quid existimandum est, ut in Domino secundum carIem Christi ambo simu' putarentur manere, communionem eorum secundum substantiam, communionem etiam mansionis forsitan suscipientem?

English

The response of Vigilius.

In the above-written ninth chapter, by the term "conjunction" and a certain "participation," as if made by God to the man Christ, Christ is asserted to be adorned with divine works; through which again a duality of persons is introduced. If anyone therefore thinks, teaches, believes, or preaches in this way, and does not acknowledge and believe that Christ our God and Lord is one and the same, with the differences of natures remaining in their own properties, let him be anathema.

CHAPTER X OF THEODORE.

I indeed, whom you see, can do nothing according to my own nature, since I am a man; I work salvation, because the Father abiding in me does all things; for since I also am in the Father, and the Father in me (John XIV); and the only-begotten God the Word is in me; it is certain that the Father also abides with him in me, and does the works. And it is not to be wondered at that this is thought concerning Christ, since he evidently says concerning other men: "He who loves me will keep my word, and my Father will love him, and we will come to him, and make our dwelling with him" (Ibidem). For if the Father and the Son make their dwelling with each one of men of this sort, what is to be thought, that in the Lord Christ according to the flesh both were supposed to abide together, their communion according to substance perhaps receiving also a communion of dwelling?

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:136 · narrative
Source · Latin

Vigilii responsio.

In suprascripto decimo capitulo ita in homine Christo Deus Verbum inesse dicitur, sicut Pater, ut per hoc aut et Pater incarnatus esse videatur, sicut et Filius; aut nec Filius sit incarnatus, sicut nec Pater, aut magis uterque in tertia persona hominis habitare. Qui igitur ita sapit, docet, credit aut prædicat, anathema sit.

THEODORI CAPITULUM XI.

Ita et animam, ut pote humanam et immortalem consututam, et sensus participem prtus accipiens, et per resurrectionem in immutabilitatem constituens, sic et nobis eorumdem istorum per resurrectionem præbuit communionem. Ideo autem ante resurrectionem ex mortuis increpat quidem Petrum, ut suis cum vocibus sandalizantem; et in magna trepidatione per tempus passionis constitutus, apparitione angeli indiget confortantia eum ad patientiam et tolerantium imminentium malorum. Post resurrectionem autem ex mortuis, et in cælos ascensum, impassibilis factus et immutabilis omnino, et ad dexteram Dei sedens, judex universi est orbis terrarum, ut pote in eo divina natura faciente judicium.

English

The response of Vigilius.

In the above-written tenth chapter, God the Word is said to be in the man Christ just as the Father is, so that through this either the Father also seems to have been incarnate, just as the Son; or neither the Son has been incarnate, just as neither has the Father; or rather both dwell in the third person of the man. Whoever therefore thinks, teaches, believes, or preaches thus, let him be anathema.

CHAPTER XI OF THEODORE.

Thus also the soul, inasmuch as it is human and immortal by nature, and previously receiving a share in understanding, and through the resurrection establishing it in immutability, so also through the resurrection he provided for us a communion in these same things. Therefore, before the resurrection from the dead, he indeed rebukes Peter, as one scandalized by his words; and having been placed in great trembling during the time of his passion, he needs the appearance of an angel strengthening him for patience and the endurance of the imminent evils. But after the resurrection from the dead and the ascension into heaven, having become impassible and altogether immutable, and sitting at the right hand of God, he is the judge of the whole world, since the divine nature in him executes judgment.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:137 · narrative
Source · Latin

Vigilii responsio.

In suprascripto undecimo capitulo eadem repeti videntur quæ superius in quarto jam dicta sunt, quod ante passionem ita infirmus fuerit Christus, ut in magna trepidatione passionis tempore constitutus angeli videretur eguisse solatio. Quod quia velut purum hominem, qui hujusmodi auxiliis egeat, significare videtur, si quis ita sapit, docet, credit aut prædicat, anathema sit.

THEODORI CAPITULUM XII.

Sic igitur et hic sapientissimum [sapientissime] omnium habere nos doces Christi sensum, ut sanctum Spiritum habentem illum qui sensui Christi [habentes illum qui sensus Christo], aliquam virtutem adimplebat, prudentiam ejus [ei] praestans ad omnia quæ agenda erant, sicut et in præcedentibus demonstravimus, quod ab ipso quidem in eremum ad certamina quæ contra diabolum erant ducebatur; unctionem autem illius et scientiam et vim eorum quæ agenda erant accipiebat; et illius particeps factus, non solum miracula faciebat, sed etiam quomodo uti oportebat miraculis, sciebat subtititer, ut notam quidem faceret gentibus pietatem, pateretur autem laborantium infirmitates, et sic ad effcctum suam voluntatem duceret, et justificabatur inde, et immaculatus ostendebatur, sive reparatione pejorum, sive custodia meliorum, sive etiam paulatim ad meliora profectibus.

English

The response of Vigilius.

In the above-written eleventh chapter, the same things seem to be repeated which were already said above in the fourth, that before the passion Christ was so weak that, placed in great trepidation at the time of the passion, he seemed to have needed the solace of an angel. And because this seems to signify him as a mere man, who needs aids of this kind, if anyone thinks, teaches, believes, or preaches thus, let him be anathema.

CHAPTER XII OF THEODORE.

So therefore here too you teach us that he has the most wise mind of all, so that the Holy Spirit, having him who belongs to the mind of Christ, was fulfilling some power for him, furnishing his prudence for all things that were to be done, just as we also demonstrated in the preceding, that he was indeed led by him into the desert for the contests that were against the devil; but he received the anointing of that one and the knowledge and the power of the things that were to be done; and having become a partaker of him, he not only performed miracles, but also knew subtly how it was fitting to use miracles, so that he might make known piety to the nations, and might suffer the infirmities of those who labor, and thus lead his will to effect, and was justified from this, and was shown immaculate, whether by the reparation of worse things, or by the custody of better things, or even by gradual advances toward better things.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:138 · narrative
Source · Latin

Vigilii responsio.

In suprascripto duodecimo capitulo eadem quae in septimo capitulo videntur exponi, asserendo Dominum nostrum Jesum Christum per habitationem sancti Spiritus ad omnia informatum, et per tempora ad perfectionem unctionis ejus auxilio pervenisse. Si quis igitur eum non sua deitate perfectuin esse credens, sed tanquam purum hominem unctione sancLi Spiritus indigentem fuisse adjutum sapit, docet, credit aut prædicat, anathema sit.

THEODORI CAPITULUM XIII.

Quomodo igitur sequentiam habet, eo quod home factus est Deus, justum hominem Deum Verbum esse dicere: si enim homo est Deus Verbum, ut ipsi dicis, omnimode de homine dicemus ea quæ de Deo Verbo evangelista dicit. Quid autem dicit? In principio erat Verbum, et Verbum erat apud Deum, iste erat in principio apud Deum: omnia per it'sum facta sunt, et sine ipso faclum est nihil quod factum est (Joan. i). Ergo si homo est Deus Verbum, dicemus de ipso: In principio erat homo, el homo erat apud Deum, et Deus erat homo, erat homo in principio apud Deum; omnia per ipsum facta sunt, et sine ipso factum eat nihil quod factum est. Si enim homo est Deus Verbum, sicut dicis, convenient omnia ipsi quæ de Deo Verbo dicit evangelista.

English

The response of Vigilius.

In the above-written twelfth chapter, the same things seem to be set forth which were already stated in the seventh chapter, by asserting that our Lord Jesus Christ was, through the indwelling of the Holy Spirit, formed unto all things, and that in the course of time he came to perfection of his anointing with the aid of the Spirit. If therefore anyone, believing that he was not perfect by his own deity but that, as a mere man, he was aided by needing the anointing of the Holy Spirit, understands, teaches, believes, or preaches this, let him be anathema.

CHAPTER XIII OF THEODORE.

How then does it follow, from the fact that a man was made God, that it is right to say that the Word of God is a just man? For if the Word of God is a man, as you yourself say, we shall say of the man, in every way, the things which the evangelist says of God the Word. But what does he say? In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, this one was in the beginning with God: all things were made through him, and without him was made nothing that was made (John 1). Therefore, if the Word of God is a man, we shall say of him: In the beginning was a man, and the man was with God, and God was a man, the man was in the beginning with God; all things were made through him, and without him was made nothing that was made. For if the Word of God is a man, as you say, all the things which the evangelist says of God the Word will apply to him.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:139 · narrative
Source · Latin

Vigilii responsio.

In suprascripto decimo tertio capitulo negari videtur Deum Verbum hominem factum, et rursus hominem Verbum Deum esse, ut per hoc inducatur, sicut superius dictum est, dualitas personarum. Si quia igitur ita sapit, docet, credit aut prædicat, et non potius, manente in Domino Deo nostro Jesu Christo inconvertibiliter atque indivise differentia naturarum, sic una persona, sive subsistentia ejus esse creditur, ut et Deus Verbum sine ulla divinæ naturae suæ convertibilitatc homo esse, et assumpta humanitas propter singularitatem personæ inconvertibiliter Deus esse credatur, anathema sit.

THEODORI CAPITULUM XIV.

a Hoc quidem quid est, Ad Patrem meum et Patrem vestrum, et Deum meum et Deum vestrum (Joan. xx). Nemo sic demens est, ut alii cuidam convenire diceret, nisi templo Dei Verbi assumpto pro nostra salute homini, qui est mortuus, et resurrexit, et ascensurus esset in cælos, et patrem sibi ascribit cum discipulis suis Deum, et ipse gratia adoptionem meritus: et Deum suum appellat, quia cum cæteris hominibus similiter ut esset accepit. Unde propter communitutem quidem naturae, Patrem meum et Patrem vestrum dicit, et Deum meum et Deum vestrum. Divisit autem iterum suam personam ipsis, principium gratiæ significans, propter quam ad Deum Verbum conjunctione in loco veri Filii ab omnibus honoratur hominibus.

English

The response of Vigilius.

In the above-written thirteenth chapter, it seems to be denied that God the Word became man, and again that the man is God the Word, so that by this there is introduced, as was said above, a duality of persons. If therefore anyone so understands, teaches, believes, or preaches, and does not rather—while there remains in our Lord God Jesus Christ, without change and without division, the difference of natures—believe that He is one person, or one subsistence, in such a way that both God the Word is believed to have become man without any change of His divine nature, and the assumed humanity is believed to be God without change because of the singularity of the person, let him be anathema.

CHAPTER XIV OF THEODORE.

Now what is this, "To my Father and your Father, and to my God and your God" (John 20)? No one is so insane as to say that this applies to any other than to the man assumed for our salvation from the temple of God the Word, who died and rose again and was about to ascend into heaven, and who ascribes God as Father to himself along with his disciples, and who himself by grace merited adoption; and he calls Him his God, because he received it that he should be as the other men. Hence, on account of the community of nature, he says, "To my Father and your Father, and to my God and your God." But again he distinguished his own person from them, signifying the beginning of grace, on account of which, through conjunction with God the Word, he is honored by all men in the place of the true Son.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:140 · narrative
Source · Latin

Vigilii responsio.

In suprascripto quarto ceccano capitulo per hoc quod legitur in Evangelio: Ascendo ad Patrem meum et Patrem vestrum, Deum meum et Deum vestrum (Joan. xx), ita intelligitur, quod Jesus Christus Dominus et Deus noster, sicut cæteri homines, gratiam adoptionis, ut Filius Dei diceretur, acceperit, et quasi per conjunctionem ad Deum Verbum in locum veri Filii ab omnibus adoretur. Quod si quis ita sapit, docet, credit aut prædicat, et non magis unum Jesum Christum Filium Dei et Dominum nostrum in duabus inconfusis et inseparabilibus intelligit et credit esse naturis, anathema sit.

TUEODORI CAPITULUM XV.

Hoc quod dictum eat: Accipitc, pro accipietis, dicit. Si enim cum insufflasset, Spiritum dedisset discipulis (quod valde quidem stulte existimaverunt), superfluum erat dicere postea his, et maxime tempore ascensus in cælos non separari ab Jerusalem, sed exspectarent (exspectare) promissionem Spiritus; et in sequentibus: Sed accipietis virtutem, superveniente Spirilu sancto in vos (Act. 1). Adventum autem ipsum sancti Spiritus super discipulos Lucas factum esse dicit quinquagesimo die resurrectionis, post ascensum. Et illud tamen animadvertendum eat, quod si ab insufflatu suscepissent Spiritum, non diceret: Accipite, sed, quoniam accepistis; hoc enim quod dictum est: Accipite, his convenit qui nondum acceperunt.

English

The response of Vigilius.

In the above-written fourth chapter of the Capitula, through what is read in the Gospel: I ascend to my Father and your Father, my God and your God (John 20), it is understood that Jesus Christ our Lord and God, just like other men, received the grace of adoption, so as to be called the Son of God, and as it were through conjunction to God the Word is adored by all in the place of the true Son. But if anyone thinks, teaches, believes, or preaches thus, and does not rather understand and believe that there is one Jesus Christ, the Son of God and our Lord, in two unconfused and inseparable natures, let him be anathema.

The fifteenth chapter of Theodorus.

What was said: Receive, he says instead of you will receive. For if when he had breathed on them he had given the Spirit to the disciples (which they have indeed quite foolishly supposed), it would have been superfluous to say to them afterwards, and especially at the time of his ascent into the heavens, not to depart from Jerusalem, but to await the promise of the Spirit; and in what follows: But you will receive power, when the Holy Spirit comes upon you (Acts 1). But Luke says that the coming of the Holy Spirit upon the disciples took place on the fiftieth day after the resurrection, after the ascension. And yet it must be noted that if they had received the Spirit from his breathing on them, he would not say: Receive, but, since you have received; for what was said: Receive, fits those who have not yet received.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:141 · narrative
Source · Latin

Vigilii responsio.

In suprascripto decimo quinto capitulo dicitur, quia insufflans Dominus noster Jesus Chrislus post resurrectionem suam in facies discipulorum suorum non dederit eis Spiritum sanctum, sed dandum significaverit: ut per hoc aut veritas ipsa ( quod absit ) putetur esse mentita, aut tanquam purum hominem illo flatu non habuisse quod daret, aut dare minime potuisse. Si quis igitur hæc ita sapit, docet aut prædicat, anathema sit.

THEODORI CAPITULUM XVI.

Dicit ad Thomam: Infer digitum tuum huc, et vide manus meas; et porrige manum tuam, et mitte in latus meum, et noli esse incredulus, sed fidelis (Joan. XXVIII). Quoniam, dicit, non credis, et tactum solum sufficere tibi ad credendum putas (hæc enim dicens non me latuisti), tange manu, et cape experimentum, et disce credere, et non diffidere. Thomas quidem cum sic credidisset, Dominus meus et Deus meus, dicit: Non ipsum Dominum et Deum dicens. Non enim resurrectionis scientia docebat etiam Deum esse eum qui resurrexit, sed quasi pro miraculo facto Deum collaudat.

English

The response of Vigilius.

In the above-written fifteenth chapter it is said that our Lord Jesus Christ, breathing after his resurrection upon the faces of his disciples, did not give them the Holy Spirit, but signified that he was to be given: so that by this either the Truth itself (which God forbid) might be thought to have lied, or he might be thought, as a mere man, not to have had what he could give by that breath, or to have been unable to give it at all. If anyone, therefore, understands, teaches, or preaches these things in this way, let him be anathema.

THE CHAPTER XVI OF THEODORE.

He says to Thomas: Put your finger here, and see my hands; and stretch out your hand, and put it into my side, and do not be unbelieving, but believing (John 20). Since, he says, you do not believe, and you think that touch alone is sufficient for you to believe (for in saying these things you did not escape me), touch with your hand, and take the proof, and learn to believe, and not to doubt. When Thomas had thus believed, he says, My Lord and my God: not calling him Lord and God himself. For the knowledge of the resurrection did not teach that the one who rose was also God, but as if for a miracle performed he praises God.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:142 · narrative
Source · Latin

Vigilii responsio.

In suprascripto decimo sexto capitulo de illo loco Evangelii ubi Thomas apostolus palpans figuras clavorum dixit: Dominus meus et Deus meus (Ibidem), asseritur quod Thomas apostolus non ipsum Jesum Christum Dominum Deumque confessus sit, et quia resurrectionis scientiam non doceret, vel quia Deus esset qui rcsurrexit, sed quia magis pro miraculo facto Thomas apostolus Deum laudaverit. Si quis igitur haec ita sapit, docet, credit aut prædicat, et non potius Thomæ confessione et verum Deum esse Jesum Christum et in vera carne eum resurrexisse declaratum credit, anathema sit.

THEODORI CAPITULUM XVII.

Ille autem dixit oportere pænitentiam agere eos pro crucis iniquitate, et agnoscentes Salvatorem. et auctorem bononun omnium Jesum Christum, quoniam propter ista pervenit et assumptus est de divina natura, in ipsum fidem suscipcre, et ejus discipulos fieri, ante omnia autem ad baptisma accedentes; quod ipse tradidit nobis, præformationem quidem habens sperationia futurorum, in nomine autem celebrandum Patris, et Filii, et Spiritus sancti: hoc enim quod eat. Ut ba ptizctur unusquisque in nomine Jesu Christi (Act.

English

The response of Vigilius.

In the above-written sixteenth chapter, concerning that passage of the Gospel where the apostle Thomas, touching the marks of the nails, said, "My Lord and my God," it is asserted that the apostle Thomas did not confess Jesus Christ himself as Lord and God, and that it was not because he was teaching the knowledge of the resurrection, or because it was God who had risen, but rather that the apostle Thomas praised God for a miracle performed. If anyone, therefore, understands, teaches, believes, or preaches these things in this way, and does not rather believe, by Thomas's confession, that Jesus Christ is truly God and that he rose again in true flesh, let him be anathema.

CHAPTER XVII OF THEODORE.

But he said that they ought to do penance for the iniquity of the cross, and, recognizing the Savior and author of all good things, Jesus Christ, that because of these things he came and was assumed from the divine nature, to receive faith in him and become his disciples, and before all things to come to baptism, which he himself handed down to us, having indeed a prefiguration of the hope of future things, but to be celebrated in the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit: for this is that "that each one be baptized in the name of Jesus Christ.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:143 · narrative
Source · Latin

II), non hoc dicit ut vocotionem quæ in nomine Patris, et Filii, et Spiritus sancti est, retinquentes, Jesum Christum in baptismate vocent, sed quale hoc est, quod in Moyse baplizati sunt in nube et in mari, ut diceret, quia sub nube et mari Ægyptiorum aepurati sunt, liberati eorum servitute, ut Moysis leges attenderent: tale hoc est, ut cum ad ipsum accessissent tanquam Salvatorem et omnium bonorum auctorem et doctorem veritatis, ab ipso, ut pote auctore bonorum et doctore veritatis, vocarentur, sicut omnibus hominibus quamque sectam sequentibus consuetudo est ab ipso dogmatis inventore vocarit ut Platonici, Epicurei, Manichæi, et Marcionistæ, et si quidam tales dicuntur: eodem enim modo et nos nominariChristianos judicaverunt apostoli, tanquam per hoc certum facientes, quod istius doctrinum oportet attendere: sic et quod ab ipso datum est susciperent baptisma, in ipso quidem primo constitutum, qui et primus baptizatus est, ab ipso autem et cæteris traditum, ut secundum præformationem futurorum celebretur.

English

it does not say this so that, abandoning the invocation that is in the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit, they should call upon Jesus Christ in baptism, but such as this is what it means that in Moses they were baptized in the cloud and in the sea, so that he might say that under the cloud and the sea they were reckoned with the Egyptians, freed from their servitude, so that they might attend to the laws of Moses: such is this, that when they had come to him as Savior and author of all good things and teacher of truth, they should be called by him, as being the author of good things and teacher of truth, just as it is the custom for all men following any sect to be called by the very founder of the doctrine, as Platonists, Epicureans, Manichaeans, and Marcionists, and if any such are so called: for in the same way the apostles judged that we too should be named Christians, as thereby making certain that his doctrine must be attended to: so also they should receive the baptism given by him, established first in him, who was also the first baptized, but handed down by him and by the others, so that it might be celebrated according to the prefiguration of things to come.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:144 · narrative
Source · Latin

Vigilii responsio.

In supradicto decimo septimo capitulo ex verbis B. Petri, quibus in Actis apostolorum dicit: Baptizetur unusquisque vestrum in nomine Jesu Christi, hoc astruitur, quia in ea invocatione, quæ in nomine Palris et Filii et Spiritus sancti fit, non contineatur et Christus et quod dixit Petrus apostolus, debere eos in Christi nomine baptizari, ut secundum hunc intellectum appareat introducta quaternitas. Adjicitur etiam in eodem capitulo, quia sic a Christo Christiani vocemur, quemadmodum diversarum sectarum et errorum sequaces ab inventoribus et magistris suis sunt sortiti vocabula, ut a Platone Platonici, a Marcione Marcionistac, et a Manichæo [Manete] Manichaei. Si quis haec ita sapit, docet, credit aut praedicat, anathema sit. Nos enim ideo Christiani vocamur et sumus, quia ipsumDominumnostrum Jesuin Christum in baptisma percipientes induimus, ipso nobis existente capite omnes in eodem unum corpus efficimur.

English

The response of Vigilius.

In the above-mentioned seventeenth chapter, from the words of blessed Peter, which he speaks in the Acts of the Apostles: Let every one of you be baptized in the name of Jesus Christ, it is asserted that in that invocation which is made in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit, Christ is not also contained, and that what the apostle Peter said—that they ought to be baptized in the name of Christ—means that according to this understanding a quaternity is introduced. It is added also in the same chapter that we are called Christians from Christ in the same way as the followers of diverse sects and errors received their names from their founders and teachers, as Platonists from Plato, Marcionists from Marcion, and Manichaeans from Manichaeus. If anyone holds, teaches, believes, or preaches these things, let him be anathema. For we are called and are Christians for this reason, that receiving our Lord Jesus Christ himself in baptism we put him on, and with him as our head we all are made one body in him.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:145 · narrative
Source · Latin

THEODORI CAPITULUM XVIII.

Et secundum duas rationes locum imaginis obtinet: qui enim amant quosdam, post mortem eorum sæpius imagines statuentes, hoc sufficiens mortis solatium habere arbitrantur: et eum qui non videtur, nec præsens eat, tanquam in imagine aspicientes, putant videre, ita flammam desiderii et vigurem placantes: sed etiam illi qui per civitates habent imperatorum imagines, tanquam præsentes et videntes honorare videntur eos qui non sunt præsente., cultu et adoratione imaginum. Ista autem utraque per illum adimplentur: omnes enim qui cum illo sunt, et virtutem sequuntur, et debitorum Dei parati redditores, diligunt eum et valde honorant, et charitatem quidem ei, divina natura licet non aspiciatur, adimplent in illo qui ab omnibus videtur, sic omnibus existimantibus, ut ipsum videntibus per illum, et illi semper præsentibus, et honorem vero omnem sic attribuunt tanquam imagini imperiali, cum quasi ipso sit divina natura, et in ipso spectetur.

English

CHAPTER XVIII OF THEODORE.

And according to two reasons it holds the place of an image: for those who love certain people, often setting up images after their death, consider that they have a sufficient consolation for death; and looking as in an image upon him who is not seen and is not present, they think they see him, thus appeasing the flame of desire and grief. But also those who have images of emperors throughout cities seem to honor, as though present and seeing, those who are not present, by the cult and adoration of images. But both of these are fulfilled through him: for all who are with him, and follow virtue, and are ready payers of what is owed to God, love him and greatly honor him, and they fulfill their love for him—although the divine nature is not beheld—in him who is seen by all, with all supposing that they see him himself through him, and are always present to him; and they attribute all honor to him as to an imperial image, since the divine nature is, as it were, in him and is beheld in him.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:146 · narrative
Source · Latin

Si enim et Filius est qui inhabitare dicitur, sed cum eo est etiam Pater, et inseparabiliter omnimodo ad Filium esse ab omni creditur creatura, et Spiritus autem non abest, ut pote etiam in loco unctionis factus ei, et cum eo est semper qui assumptus est; et non mirandum est, cum etiarn in quibuslibet hominibus virtutem sequentibus cum Filio et Patre esse dicitur: Veniemus enim et ego, et Pater, et mansionem apud eum faciemus (Joan. XIV). Quod autem et Spiritus hujusmodi hominum inseparabilis eat, certum est omnibus.

Vigilii responsio.

In suprascripto decimo octavo capitulo ita invisibilis Dei imago asseritur esse Christus, tanquam si absentium principum imagines pro eorum colantur honoribus. Quæ si quis ita sapit, docet, credit aut prædicat, anathema sit..

THEODORI CAPITULUM XIX.

IIoc enim quod, Hic est Filius meus dilectus in quo mihi complacuit (Luc. III), in baptismate adoptionem demonstrat, sed non comparatione [secundum comparationem Judaicæ adoptionis: quia et ad illos dictum erat: Ego dixi: Dii estis, et lilii excelsi omnes, et: Filios genui et exaltavi (Psal. LXXXI): ejus adoptionis præcipuum, eo quod dixit: Dilectus, et in eo mihi complacuit (Isai. II), ostendens.

English

For if it is the Son who is said to dwell in him, yet the Father is also with him, and it is believed by every creature that he is in every way inseparably with the Son, and the Spirit is not absent either, inasmuch as he was also made for him in the place of anointing, and is always with him who was assumed; and it is no wonder, since even in any men who follow virtue he is said to be with the Son and the Father: for we will come, I and the Father, and make our dwelling with him (John XIV). But that the Spirit is also inseparable from such men is certain to all.

The response of Vigilius.

In the above-written eighteenth chapter, Christ is asserted to be the invisible image of God, just as if images of absent princes were worshiped in place of their honors. If anyone thinks, teaches, believes, or preaches this, let him be anathema.

CHAPTER XIX OF THEODORE.

For this, that This is my beloved Son in whom I am well pleased (Luke III), demonstrates adoption in baptism, but not by comparison [according to the comparison of Jewish adoption: for it had also been said to them: I said, You are gods, and all of you sons of the Most High, and: I have begotten sons and exalted them (Psalm LXXXI)]: he shows the preeminence of that adoption, in that he said: Beloved, and in him I am well pleased (Isaiah II).

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:147 · narrative
Source · Latin

Propter hoc et vox Patris fiebat adoptionem confirmans, et Filii nominatione per adoptionem secundum gratiam eum qui vere Filius est demonstrabat: cujus conjunctio ad veram et firmam adoptionem istum constituebat: et Spiritus sanctus in specie columbæe descendens permansit super eum, quatenus in conjunctione ad eum qui vere Filius est, ejus cooperationi intentus maneat, firmam adoptionis habens dignitatem. Per omnia autem i. quo primo adoptionis performabatur baptisma, dico autem Domini Christi ex Patre, et Filio, et Spiritu sancto, hoc quod fiebat complebatur.

Vigilii responsio.

In suprascripto decimo nono capitulo, ubi Evangelium secundum Lucam de baptismo Christi videtur exponi, duæ sunt reprehensiones: una quia dualitas inducitur filiorum, cum per adoptionem videtur dici Chrislus Filius Dei; alia, quia in nomine Trinitatis ipse quoque asseritur baptizatus; per quod quaterni. tas sine dubitatione monstratur. Si quis igitur hæc ita sapit, docet, credit aut prædicat, anathema sit.

English

On account of this, there was also a voice of the Father confirming the adoption, and by the naming of the Son He was pointing out, through adoption according to grace, the one who is truly the Son; whose conjunction established him unto true and firm adoption; and the Holy Spirit, descending in the form of a dove, remained upon him, so that in conjunction with the one who is truly the Son, he might remain intent upon his cooperation, having the firm dignity of adoption. But in all things, that is, in the first baptism of adoption which was being performed—I mean the baptism of the Lord Christ from the Father, and the Son, and the Holy Spirit—what was being done was being completed.

The response of Vigilius.

In the above-written nineteenth chapter, where the Gospel according to Luke seems to be expounded concerning the baptism of Christ, there are two reprehensions: one, because a duality of sons is introduced, since Christ seems to be called the Son of God through adoption; the other, because in the name of the Trinity he himself is also asserted to have been baptized; by which a quaternity is shown without doubt. If anyone, therefore, understands, teaches, believes, or preaches these things in this way, let him be anathema.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:148 · narrative
Source · Latin

THEODORI CAPITULUM XX.

Ideo ergo differentiam quidem Dei Verbi et recepti hominis tantum nobis ostendit psalmus: divisa vero hæc in Novo Testamento reperiuntur, Domino quidem in se accipiente primordia psalmi, in quibus factorem eum dicit esse creaturæ, et elevatam habere super carlo. magnificentiam, et mirificari in omni terra. Apostolo. autem supradicta quæ de homine dicuntur, qui tantum beneficiorum meruit, quomodo non manifestum, quod alterum quidem nos divina Scriptura docet evidenter esse Deum Verbum, alterum vero hominem, et multam eorum esse ostendit nobis differentiam: nam iste quidem memorat, ille autem memoriam meretur: et iste quidem visitat, alter aulem cum visitationem meretur, beatus dicitur: et iste quidem beneficium dando minui' paulo minus ab angelis, ille autem et per tatem minutionem beneficium uccepit: et iste quidem gloria et honore coronat, alter autem coronatur, et pro his beatus dicitur: ct iste quidem constituit ipsum super omnia opera manuum ejus, et omnia sub jccit sub pedibus ejus: alter autem meritus est dominari eis, quorum antea non habebat potestatem.

English

CHAPTER XX OF THEODORE.

Therefore the psalm shows us only the distinction between God the Word and the man who was received: but these things are found divided in the New Testament, since the Lord took to himself the opening words of the psalm, in which it says that he is the maker of creation, and has magnificence exalted above heaven, and is wondrous in all the earth. But as for the Apostle, the things said above concerning the man, who merited such great benefits—how is it not manifest that divine Scripture clearly teaches us that one is God the Word, and the other a man, and shows us that there is a great difference between them? For the one brings to remembrance, while the other merits remembrance; and the one visits, while the other, when he merits visitation, is called blessed; and the one, by giving a benefit, is diminished a little less than the angels, while the other also received a benefit through that diminution; and the one crowns with glory and honor, while the other is crowned, and for these things is called blessed; and the one set him over all the works of his hands, and subjected all things under his feet, while the other merited to rule over those whom he did not previously have power over.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:149 · narrative
Source · Latin

Vigilii responsio.

In suprascripto vigesimo capitulo, ubi octavus psalmus videtur exponi, et nudus homo (sicut et in aliis jam dictum est) Christus asseritur, et divisus a Verbo monstratur, et dualitas inducitur personarum. Quæ si quis ita sapit, docet, credit aut prædicat, et non ita in Christo Domino duas naturas invisibiliter et inconfusc unitas intelligat, ut manente earumdem differentia naturarum, ipse unus atque idem verus sit Dci et vcrus hominis Filius, anathema sit.

THEODORI CAPITULUM XXI.

Sed non volentes ista considerare, voces omnes trahere ad Dominum tenlant Christum, ut ea quæ de populo facta sunt simili modo intelligerent, et risum præstarent Judæis, quando ex scriptorum sequentia nihil ad Dominum Christum pertinentes ostendant voces.

THEODORI CAPITULUM XXII.

Tale eat, et quod non derelicta est anima ejus in inlerno, nec caro ejus vidit corruptionem (Psal. IV): nam propheta quidem supra modum ipsam ponit circa populum providentiam, volens dicere, quoniam infer tentabiles eos ab omnibus conservavit malis. Quoniam autem hoc verum et ex ipsis rebua eventum accepit in Domino Christo, frequentissime de eo loquens beatus Petrus, utitur voce; ostendens quoniam quod de populo supra modum dictum est, ex quadam ratione utente voce propheta, hoc verum eventum in ipsis rebus accepit nunc in Domino Christo.

English

The response of Vigilius.

In the above-written twentieth chapter, where the eighth psalm is seen to be expounded, Christ is asserted to be a mere man (as has already been said in others too), and is shown to be divided from the Word, and a duality of persons is introduced. If anyone understands, teaches, believes, or preaches in this way, and does not understand the two natures in Christ the Lord to be so united invisibly and without confusion that, while the difference of the same natures remains, he himself is one and the same true Son of God and true Son of man, let him be anathema.

CHAPTER XXI OF THEODORE.

But those who are unwilling to consider these things try to drag all the utterances to the Lord Christ, so that they understand in a similar way the things that were done concerning the people, and they provide laughter to the Jews, when from the sequence of the writings they show that the utterances do not pertain at all to the Lord Christ.

CHAPTER XXII OF THEODORE.

Such is also the passage that his soul was not left in hell, nor did his flesh see corruption (Ps. 4): for the prophet indeed sets forth his providence concerning the people beyond measure, wishing to say that he preserved them untempted from all evils. But because this is true and received its fulfillment in actual events in the Lord Christ, blessed Peter, speaking very frequently about him, uses the utterance; showing that what was said beyond measure concerning the people, by a certain reason on the part of the prophet using the utterance, has now received its true fulfillment in actual events in the Lord Christ.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:150 · narrative
Source · Latin

Vigilii responsio.

In suprascriptis vigesimo primo et vigesimo secundo capitulis hoc videtur dici, quod prophetiam, quæ ex persona Christi loquens ait: Non derelinques animam meam in infernum, nec dabis Sanctum tuum videre corruptionem (Psal. xv), non de ipso Christo prædictam fuisse, sed de populo Israeliticæ generationis: beatum vero Petrum apostolum ad Christum hanc propheliam per eventum aptare voluisse (Act. II). Et ideo qui hæc ita sapit, docet, credit aut praedicat, anathema sit.

THEODORI CAPITULUM XXIII.

Eumdem intellectum habet et illud: Diviserunt sibi vestimenta mea, ct super vestimentum meum miserunt sortem (Psal. XXI). Quod etenim psalmus nullatenus convenit Domino, certum est: neque enim erat Domini Christi, qui peccatum non fecit, nec inventus est dolus in ore ejus (1 Petr. II), dicere: Longe a salute mea verba delictorum meorum (Psal. xxi). Sed et ipse Dominus, cum secundum communem hominum legem in passione opprimerelur, Deus mcus, Dens meus, quare me dereliquisti (Matth. XXVII)? misit vocem; et avostolis: Diviscrunt sibi vestimenta mea, et super vestimentum meum miserunt sortem (Psal. XXI), ad eum traxerunt manifeste: quoniam quod-supra modum dictum fuerat prius a David, propter illata ei mala, hoc ex operibus evenit in Domino Christo, cuju, et vestimenta diviserunt, et sorti tunicam subjecerunt.

English

The response of Vigilius.

In the above-written twenty-first and twenty-second chapters, this seems to be said: that the prophecy which, speaking in the person of Christ, says, "You will not leave my soul in hell, nor will you give your Holy One to see corruption" (Psalm 15), was not foretold concerning Christ himself, but concerning the people of the Israelite generation; but that the blessed apostle Peter wished to apply this prophecy to Christ by its outcome (Acts 2). And therefore, whoever understands, teaches, believes, or preaches these things in this way, let him be anathema.

CHAPTER XXIII OF THEODORE.

That passage has the same meaning: "They divided my garments among themselves, and upon my vesture they cast lots" (Psalm 21). For it is certain that the psalm in no way fits the Lord: for it was not for the Lord Christ, who committed no sin, nor was deceit found in his mouth (1 Peter 2), to say: "Far from my salvation are the words of my transgressions" (Psalm 21). But even the Lord himself, when according to the common law of men he was overwhelmed in his passion, sent forth the voice, "My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?" (Matthew 27); and the apostles clearly drew to him, "They divided my garments among themselves, and upon my vesture they cast lots" (Psalm 21): since what had been spoken beforehand by David beyond measure, on account of the evils brought upon him, this came about from his works in the Lord Christ, whose garments they divided and whose tunic they subjected to lot.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:151 · narrative
Source · Latin

Vigilii responsio.

In suprascripto vigesimo tertio capitulo exponendo quædam vigesimi primi psalmi verba, quibus dicitur: Diviserunt sibi vestimenta mea, et super vestem meam miserunt sortem, negantur Jesu Christo Domino convenire; sed quod David propter quaedam mala quæ perpessus est, de se dixerit, evangelistam ex eventu ad Christum traxisse, et adjicitur, quia non poterat dicere Dominus Jesus, qui peccatum non fecit: Longe a salute mea verba delictorum meorum (Ibidem): et ideo qui hæc sapit, docet, credit aut prædicat, et non ea in quibus delictorum meminit, ad corpus ipsius, quod est Ecclesia, quæ in hoc mundo sine delicto esse non potest, intelligit pertinere; illa autem de divisione vestimentorum, non specialiter de ipso capite, id est Domino Deo nostro Jesu Christo praedicta, et in ipso credit esse completa, anathema sit.

English

The response of Vigilius.

In the exposition of the above-written twenty-third chapter, certain words of the twenty-first psalm, in which it is said, "They divided my garments among them, and upon my vesture they cast lots," are denied to befit Jesus Christ the Lord; but that David spoke them of himself on account of certain evils which he suffered, and the evangelist drew them to Christ from the outcome. And it is added that the Lord Jesus, who committed no sin, could not say, "Far from my salvation are the words of my transgressions" (Ibidem). And therefore, whoever holds this view, teaches, believes, or preaches it, and does not understand those passages in which he mentions transgressions to pertain to His body, which is the Church, which cannot be in this world without transgression; but those passages concerning the division of the garments, as not specially foretold of the head Himself, that is, our Lord God Jesus Christ, and believed to have been fulfilled in Him—let him be anathema.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:152 · narrative
Source · Latin

THEODORI CAPITULUM XXIV.

Foderunt manus meas et pedes (Psal. XXI), et omnia perscrutabantur, et quæ agebam, et quæ conabar. Nam foderunt, ex translatione dicit eorum qui per fossionem scrutari quæ in profundo sunt tentant. Dinumeraverunt omnia ossa mea (Ibidem): totius meæ fortitudinis et totius meæ substantiæ delentores facti sunt, ut etiam numero mea subjicerent. Istud autem ex consuetudine quam habent hostes dixit, qui quando obtinuerint, numero a et tatis subtilem notitiam inventorum faciunt [Locus corruptus]. Propterea et sequen ter dicens: Ipsi vero consideraverunt, et conspexerunt me, intulit: Diviserunt sibi vestimenta mea, et super vestimentum meum miserunt sortem. Conside rantes enim me, ait, et conspicientes quod omnia eis evenerunt in me desiderata (conspicere enim ita ut apud nos dicitur pro eo quod est: Vidit in eum quæ volebat pati eum) jam, tanquam me omnino malis dedito, sicut hostes, mea post vastationem et captivitatem diviserunt sorte divisionem eorum facientes. Et evangelista quidem in Domino verba ex rebus assumens, eis usus esf, sicut et in aliis diximus. Nam quod non pertineat ad Dominum psalmus, in superioribus evidenter ostendimus.

English

CHAPTER XXIV OF THEODORE.

They pierced my hands and my feet (Psalm 21), and they scrutinized everything, both what I was doing and what I was attempting. For "they pierced" is said, according to the translation, of those who by digging attempt to search out the things that are in the depths. They numbered all my bones (ibid.): they became destroyers of all my strength and all my substance, so that they even subjected my members to number. But he said this from the custom that enemies have, who, when they have prevailed, make a subtle accounting and enumeration of the things found [corrupt passage]. Therefore also, saying next: They themselves have considered, and have looked upon me, he added: They divided my garments among themselves, and upon my garment they cast lots. For considering me, he says, and looking upon me, because all things they desired came to pass in me (for "to look upon" is used among us in the sense of: He saw in him the things he wished him to suffer), now, as though I had been wholly given over to evils, like enemies after devastation and captivity they divided my goods, making their division by lot. And indeed the evangelist, taking the words from the events in the Lord, used them, as we have also said in other places. For that the psalm does not pertain to the Lord, we have shown clearly in the earlier passages.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:153 · narrative
Source · Latin

At vero beatus David supra modum ista magis in his quæ ab Absalom facta sunt, dixit: quoniam dum recessisset David,jure belli metropolim ingressus, omnes quidem obtinuit res regala, non piguit autem patris cubile inquinare.

Vigilii responsio.

In suprascripto vigesimo quarto capitulo de me I morato eodem vigesimo primo psalmo illa verba ubi dicit: Foderunt manus meas et pede, meos, dinumeraverunt omnia ossa mea: ipsi vero consideraverunt et inspexerunt in me (Psal. xxi); asseritur non de Christo esse praedicta, sed David hoc de se dixisse propter tyrannidem Absalom, qui regiam urbem substantiamque pervaserat, atque in terra omnia dinumeraverat patris; sed evangelistam haec ex eventu ad Christi traxisse personam. Qui igitur hæc ita credit, sapit, docet aut praedicat, anathema sit. '

THEODORI CAPITULUM XXV.

Quoniam a cibi et potus suaves quidem fiunt in tempore gaudii, insuavia autem et amara in tristitia; talia erant (inquit) quæ ab illis fiebant, ut ex tristitia et ira esset quidem mihi in locum fellis cibus, esset autem et potio aceto nihil differens. Maxime uutem hoc fit in iracundiis quæ cum tribulatione fiunt, quod verisimile erat pati eos contra suos. Usus est autem evangelista hoc testimonio in Domino, et ipse autem Dominus: Zelusdomus tuæ comedit me (Joan. II), de seipso dicens. Et beatus Paulus de Judæis loquens: Fiat mensa eorum (Rom.

English

But blessed David spoke these things beyond measure rather in those things which were done by Absalom, since when David had withdrawn, Absalom, having entered the capital by the law of war, indeed obtained all the royal possessions, and did not shrink from defiling his father's bed.

The response of Vigilius.

In the above-written twenty-fourth chapter, concerning me, in that same twenty-first psalm, those words where it says: They have pierced my hands and my feet, they have numbered all my bones: they themselves have considered and examined me (Psalm 21); it is asserted that these things were not foretold of Christ, but that David said this of himself on account of the tyranny of Absalom, who had seized the royal city and its substance, and had numbered all things of his father in the land; but that the evangelist drew these things from the event to the person of Christ. Whoever therefore believes, understands, teaches, or preaches these things thus, let him be anathema.

CHAPTER XXV OF THEODORE.

Since foods and drinks become sweet in a time of joy, but unsavory and bitter in sorrow; such were the things (he says) that were done by them, so that from sorrow and anger food became to me in place of gall, and drink was nothing different from vinegar. But this happens especially in fits of anger that come with tribulation, which it was likely they suffered against their own. But the evangelist used this testimony in the Lord, and the Lord himself also: Zeal for your house has consumed me (John 2), saying it of himself. And blessed Paul, speaking of the Jews: Let their table be made (Rom.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:154 · narrative
Source · Latin

xv), etc.; beatus Petrus de Juda: Fiat habitatio ejus deserta (Act. i). Et certe diversis constitutis rebus, non quasi psalmo modo pro his dicto, iterum autem de illo, et iterum de alio: sed quia de Judæis dicta sunt plura, qui se separaverunt de Deo et lege, convincentia illorum devotionem, necessarius est testimoniorum usus simul ex rebus captus, qualis est: Dederunt in escam meam fel, et in siti mea potaverunt me aceto (Psal. LXVIII).

Vigilii responsio.

In suprascripto vigesimo quinto capitulo de eo loco psalmi ubi dicit: Dederunt in escam meam fel. et in siti meapotaverunt me aceto; contra evidentem Evangelii veritatem exponitur, dicendo: quia nec fero aceto potatus est Dominus, sed ad tristitiam et iracundiam offerentium habuerit potationem in aceti loco et escam in fellis; nec de ipso prædictum, sed evangelistam hoc testimonio usum fuisse ex eventu in Domino. Propterea qui Læc ita sapit, docet, credit aut prædicat, anathema sit.

English

and so on; blessed Peter says of Judas: Let his habitation be desolate (Acts 1). And certainly, with various things having been established, not as if the psalm were spoken in this way for these things, and again about that one, and again about another: but because many things were spoken about the Jews, who separated themselves from God and the law, their devotion being convicted, the use of testimonies is necessary, taken together from the events, such as: They gave me gall for my food, and in my thirst they gave me vinegar to drink (Psalm 68).

The response of Vigilius.

In the above-written twenty-fifth chapter, concerning that place of the psalm where it says: They gave me gall for my food, and in my thirst they gave me vinegar to drink; it is expounded contrary to the evident truth of the Gospel, by saying: that the Lord was not actually given vinegar to drink, but that he had a drink in place of vinegar and food in place of gall, unto the sorrow and anger of those offering it; nor was it foretold of him, but the evangelist used this testimony from the event in the Lord. Therefore, whoever savors, teaches, believes, or preaches these things, let him be anathema.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:155 · narrative
Source · Latin

THEODORI CAPITULUM XXVI.

Sicut igitur per hujusmodi confessionem non deitatis Nathanael habens scientiam ostenditur (Judæi et Samaritæ talia sperantes plurimum, quantum Dei verbi ascientia longe erant?), sic et Martha per confessionem illam, non deitatis habens tunc scientiam probatur: manifeste autem nec beatus Petrus: adhuc etenim ipsis sufficiebat tunc revelationem illam suscipientibus præcipuum aliquid majus de ipso præter cœterorum hominum phantasiam accipere: post resurrectionem autem Spiritu perducti ad scientiam, tunc et revelationis perfectam scientiam suscipiebant, ut scirent quia præcipuum ipsi præter cæteros homines non aliquo puro honore ex Deo pervenit, sicut in cæteri. hominibus, sed per unitatem ad Deum Verbum, per quam omnis honoris ei particeps est post in cælos ascensum.

Vigilii responsio.

soprascripto vigesimo sexto capitulo et agnitionem deitatis Chrisli ante resurrectionem ejus Petrus habuisse negatur, phantasiam vero intelligentiae præ cæteris hominibus accepisse dicitur: et rursus dualitas filiorum inducitur: dum hominem participem dicit ad Verbum postquam in coelos ascendit: Qui ergo ita sapit, docet, credit aut prædicat, et non unum eumdemque esse intelligit Christum et Dominam nostrum Dei et hominis Filium, manente in ipso unitarum differentia naturarum, anathema sit.

English

CHAPTER XXVI OF THEODORE.

Just as, therefore, through a confession of this kind Nathanael is shown not to have had knowledge of the deity (did the Jews and Samaritans, hoping for such things, and that in great measure, remain far from knowledge of God the Word?), so also Martha through that confession is proved not to have had knowledge of the deity at that time; and clearly neither did blessed Peter; for at that time it was still enough for those receiving that revelation to accept something preeminent and greater concerning him beyond the imagination of other men; but after the resurrection, led by the Spirit to knowledge, they then also received perfect knowledge of the revelation, so that they knew that what was preeminent in him beyond other men came to him from God not by some mere honor, as in other men, but through unity with God the Word, through which he is a partaker of every honor after his ascension into heaven.

The response of Vigilius.

In the above-written twenty-sixth chapter, Peter is denied to have had knowledge of the deity of Christ before his resurrection, and is said to have received an imagination of understanding beyond other men; and again a duality of sons is introduced, when it says that the man is a partaker with the Word after he ascended into heaven. Whoever therefore thinks, teaches, believes, or preaches thus, and does not understand that Christ our Lord and God and Son of man is one and the same, while the difference of the united natures remains in him, let him be anathema.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:156 · narrative
Source · Latin

TREODORI CAPITILUM XXVII.

Matthæus quidem evangelista post tentationes dicit: quod accedentes angeli ministrabant ei (Matth. IV), scilicet cum eo constituti cooperantes, et omnibus circa eum Deo ministrantes, quod jam per certamina ad diabolum ostensus est clarior; sed et quod passuro ei aderant angeli, ex Evangeliis discimus. Et cum resurreait, in monumento visi sunt (Matth. XXVIII; Luc. XXII): per omnia enim ista monstratur dignitas Christi, quod inseparate ei angeli aderant. omnibus circa eum ministrabant: sicut enim a peccantibus separantur, sic et per meritum honoratis subveniunt. Propterquod bene Dominus ait: Quod majus videbitis, ct quod coelum aperietur omnibus per me, et omnes angeli semper mecum erunt, nunc quidem ascendentes,nunc vero descendentes, sicut ad domesticum Dei et amionm (Joan. I).

Vigilii responsio.

In suprascripto vigesimo septimo capitulo, ubi de Matthaeo evangelista exponitur, quia consummatis tentationibus accesserunt angeli, ut ministrarent Christo, dicitur: Quia sicut et alii per meritum honorato Christo subvenerint angeli, et quia sic ad Christum in coelos ascenderint et descenderint angeli, tanquam ad amicum et domesticum Dei.

English

CHAPTER XXVII OF THEODORE.

Matthew the evangelist indeed says after the temptations: that angels came and ministered to him (Matt. 4), namely, standing with him as co-workers, and ministering to God in all things around him, because he had already been shown more glorious through his contests with the devil; but also that angels were present to him when he was about to suffer, we learn from the Gospels. And when he rose again, they were seen at the tomb (Matt. 28; Luke 22): for through all these things the dignity of Christ is shown, that angels were inseparably present to him. They ministered to him in all things around him: for just as they are separated from sinners, so also they come to the aid of those honored by merit. Wherefore the Lord rightly said: That you will see a greater thing, and that heaven will be opened to all through me, and all the angels will always be with me, now ascending, now descending, as to a friend and domestic of God (John 1).

The response of Vigilius.

In the above-written twenty-seventh chapter, where it is expounded concerning Matthew the evangelist, that when the temptations were completed angels came to minister to Christ, it is said: That just as other angels came to the aid of Christ when he was honored by merit, and that angels thus ascended and descended to Christ into the heavens, as to a friend and domestic of God.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:157 · narrative
Source · Latin

Qui ero haec ita sapit, docet, credit aut praedicat, et non ut vero Deo, veri Dei Filio, uni eidemque cum assumpta ex utero Virginis perfecta humanitate, angeli ut pote Creatori et Domino deservierint atque deserviant, anathema sit.

THEODORI CAPITULUM XXVIII.

Plus inquielabatur Dominus, et certamen habebat ad animae passiones quam corporis, et meliore animo libidines vincebat, mediante ei deitate ad perfectionem; unde et Dominus ad hæc maxime instituens videtur certamen: cupiditate enim pecuniarum non deceptus, et gloriæ desiderio non tentus, carni quidem præbuit nihil, nec enim illius erat talibus vinci: animam autem si non recepisset, sed deitas est quæ ea vinceret, nullatenus eorum quæ facla sunt, ad nos respicit lucrum: quæ enim ad conversationis perfectionem similitudo deitatis et animæ humanos?

English

Whoever therefore understands, teaches, believes, or preaches these things in this way, and does not hold that the angels served and do serve as to true God, to the Son of the true God, one and the same with the perfect humanity assumed from the womb of the Virgin, as to their Creator and Lord, let him be anathema.

CHAPTER XXVIII OF THEODORE.

The Lord was more assailed and had a struggle against the passions of the soul than of the body, and with a better mind he conquered desires, with the deity in him mediating unto perfection; whence also the Lord seems chiefly to have been trained for this struggle: for, not deceived by greed for money, and not held by desire for glory, he indeed yielded nothing to the flesh, for it was not his to be conquered by such things; but if he had not received a soul, but it was the deity that conquered them, the gain from the things that were done in no way pertains to us: for what likeness of deity and of a human soul pertains to us for the perfection of conduct?

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:158 · narrative
Source · Latin

Etiam videntur Domini certamina non ad nos respiciens habere lucrum, sed ostentationis cujusdam gratia fuisse: quod si hoc dicere non est possibile (certum etenim est quod illa propter nos facta sunt, et majus certumen instituit ad animæ passiones, minus autem ad carnis) quanto et amptius et magis inquietare illos contingebat, et magis illa erant, quas et ampliori indigebant medicina9 videlicet quod et carnem et anitnam assumens pro utraque certabas, mortificans quidem in carne peccatum, et mansuetans ejus libidines, et facile capiendas meliori ratione animæ faciens, erudiens autem animam, et exercitans et suas passiones vincere, et carnis refrenare libidines, hæc autem deitas inhabitans operabatur, hæc inhabitans medebatur utrique eorum.

Vigilii responsio.

In suprascripto vigesimo octavo capitulo iterum purus homo Christus inducilur, qui ratione animae, corporis dicitur mansuetas fecisse libidines, et erodisse animam, et exercitasse eam, ut passiones suas vinceret, et carnis in se libidines refrenaret: quæ tamen utraque, mediante deitate, opera tam fuisse dicit animam: ut secundum haec jam nec ipsum unum eumdemque Jesum Christum mediatorem Dei et hominum habeamus, sed carni et animae mediatrix deitas fuisse videatur. Qui igitur hæc ita sapil, docet, credit aut praedicat, anathema sit.

English

Even the Lord's struggles seem to have no benefit with respect to us, but to have been for the sake of a certain display. But if it is not possible to say this (for it is certain that those things were done on our account, and he undertook a greater struggle with respect to the passions of the soul, a lesser one with respect to the flesh), by how much more and more did it befall him to disturb them, and those things were greater which needed even greater medicine—namely, that assuming both flesh and soul, you struggled on behalf of both, mortifying indeed sin in the flesh, and taming its desires, and making the soul's desires easily captured by better reason, instructing the soul and training it both to conquer its own passions and to restrain the desires of the flesh. But the deity dwelling within was working these things, dwelling within was healing both of them.

The response of Vigilius.

In the above-written twenty-eighth chapter, again a mere man Christ is introduced, who by reason of the soul and body is said to have tamed desires, and to have trained the soul and exercised it, so that it might conquer its own passions and restrain in itself the desires of the flesh. Yet he says that both of these works were so much the soul's, with the deity mediating, that according to these things we no longer have the one and the same Jesus Christ as mediator of God and men, but the deity seems to have been the mediator for the flesh and the soul. Whoever therefore understands, teaches, believes, or preaches these things in this way, let him be anathema.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:159 · narrative
Source · Latin

THEODORI CAPITULUM XXIX.

Sed si caro erat, inquit, crucifixa, quomodo sol radios avertit, et tenebræ occupaverunt terram omnem, et terræmotus, et petre dirumpebantur, et mortui surrexerunt? Quid igitur dicant et de tenebris in Ægypto factis temporibus Moysis, non per tres horas, sed per tres dies? quid autem propter alia per Moysem facta miracula? et quæ per Jesum Nave, qui solem stare fecit? qui sol et in temporibus Ezechiæ regis et contra naturam retrorsus est? Et de Elisæi reliquiis quæ mortuum suscitarunt? Si enim Verbum Deum passum demonstrant quas in cruce facta sunt, et propter hominem non concedunt facta esse; et quce in temporibus Moysis, propter genus Abraham non erant, et quæ in temporibus Jesu Nave, et quæ in Ezechiæ regia: quod si illa propter Judæorum populum mirabiliter facta sunt, quomodo non magis quæ in cruce facta sunt, propter Dei Verbi templum?

English

CHAPTER XXIX OF THEODORE.

But if it was flesh, he says, that was crucified, how did it avert the rays of the sun, and darkness cover the whole earth, and there was an earthquake, and rocks were split, and the dead rose? What then will they say also about the darkness brought about in Egypt in the times of Moses, not for three hours, but for three days? What moreover about the other miracles done through Moses? And those through Joshua son of Nun, who made the sun stand still? Which sun also in the times of King Hezekiah turned backward contrary to nature? And about the remains of Elisha which raised a dead man? For if they demonstrate that the Word of God suffered by the things done on the cross, and do not concede that they were done on account of man, then neither were the things in the times of Moses on account of the race of Abraham, nor the things in the times of Joshua son of Nun, nor the things in the reign of Hezekiah. But if those things were done wondrously on account of the Jewish people, how much more were not the things done on the cross on account of the temple of God the Word?

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:160 · narrative
Source · Latin

Vigilii responsio.

In suprascripto vigesimo nono capitulo, dum quasi Apollinari, qui divinam naturam passionihus implicabat, contradicitur, a recto tramite declinatur, et modus assertionis exceditur, ut purus homo pependisse putetur in cruce. Et ideo qui hoc ita sapit, docet, credit aut prædicat, et non Christum Deum verum credens, manente impassibili deitate, eumdem carne propria passum esse confitetur, anathema sit.

THEODORI CAPITULUM XXX.

Manifestum est autem quod unitas convenit: per eam enim naturæ collectæ unam personam secundum unitatem effecerunt. Sicut enim de viro et muliere dicitur, quod jam non sunt duo, sed una caro (Matth. XIX); dicamus ej nos rationabiliter secundum unitatis rationem, quoniam non sunt duce personæ, sed una, scilicet naturis discretis. Sicut enim ibi non nocet numero duorum unam dici carnem (certum est enim secundum quod una dicitur); ita et hic non nocet naturarum differentiæ personæ unitas. Quando etiam et naturas discernimus, perfectam naturam Dei Verbi dicimus, et perfectam personam: ncc enim sine persona est subsistentiam dicere perfectam; perfectam autem et hominis naturam et personam similiter. Quando autem ad conjunctionem, respiciamus, unam personam tunc dicimus.

English

The response of Vigilius.

In the above-written twenty-ninth chapter, while objection is made as it were against Apollinaris, who involved the divine nature in sufferings, one swerves from the straight path, and the manner of assertion is exceeded, so that a mere man is thought to have hung on the cross. And therefore whoever understands, teaches, believes, or preaches this in this way, and not believing Christ to be true God, while the impassible Godhead remains, confesses that the same one suffered in his own flesh, let him be anathema.

CHAPTER XXX OF THEODORE.

But it is manifest that unity is fitting; for through it the natures that were gathered together effected one person according to unity. For just as it is said of a man and a woman that they are no longer two, but one flesh (Matthew XIX), let us also reasonably say, according to the principle of unity, that they are not two persons, but one, namely with the natures distinguished. For just as there it does no harm that, though they are two in number, they are called one flesh (for it is certain according to what is meant that it is called one), so also here the unity of person does no harm to the difference of natures. And when we distinguish the natures, we say that the nature of God the Word is perfect, and his person perfect; for one cannot speak of a perfect subsistence without a person; and similarly also the nature and person of the man are perfect. But when we look to the conjunction, we then say that there is one person.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:161 · narrative
Source · Latin

Vigilii responsio.

In suprascripto trigesimo capitulo pessimo exempia tentatur ostendi, quomodo una persona Christi possit intelligi, id est, sicut de viro et de muliere convenientibus legitur, sic et in Christo discretis naturis quasi unam esse personam: et sequitur perlectam esse naturam Dei VerMi, et perfectam personam, et perfectam hominis naturam atque personam, et similiter: unde apparet quia et de exemplo viri ac mulieris, ubi duae personæ sunt, et de his quæ sequuntur, tametsi tacetur numerus, duæ autem inducuntur unius Christi personae. Quod qui ita sapit, docet, credit aut praedicat, anathema sit.

THEODORI CAPITULUM XXXI.

Sed Christum quidem secundum carnem et assumptam servi formam, eum autem qui eam assumpsit super omnia nominans Deum, intulit tamen hoc secundum conjunctionem; ut per significationem nominum, naturarum manifestam divisionem faciat. Nemo igitur, neque eum qui secundum carnem ex Judæis est, dicat Deuri, nec iterum Deum, qui est super omnia, secundum Carnem ex Judæis.

English

The response of Vigilius.

In the above-written thirtieth chapter, an attempt is made by a very bad example to show how one person of Christ can be understood, that is, just as it is read of a man and a woman coming together, so also in Christ, with the natures distinguished, there is as it were one person; and it follows that the nature of God the Word has been read as perfect, and a perfect person, and the perfect nature and person of a man, and similarly: whence it appears that both from the example of the man and the woman, where there are two persons, and from those things which follow, although the number is passed over in silence, yet two persons are introduced into the one person of Christ. Whoever understands, teaches, believes, or preaches this, let him be anathema.

CHAPTER XXXI OF THEODORE.

But while he names Christ indeed according to the flesh and the assumed form of a servant, and him who assumed it as God over all things, he nevertheless brought this in according to conjunction; so that through the signification of the names he makes a manifest division of the natures. Let no one, therefore, call him who is according to the flesh from the Jews God, nor again call God, who is over all things, [one] according to the flesh from the Jews.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:162 · narrative
Source · Latin

Vigilii responsio.

In suprascripto trigesimo primo capitulo, in expositione quæ de symbolo trecentorum decem et octo Patrum facta videtur, non solum divisio naturarum asseritur, sed et absolute dicendo, neque eum qui secundum carnem ex Judæis nudus deitate homo, et purus sine carne Deus, quasi seorsum et seorsum duae pronuntiautur esse personae. Si quis ergo hæc ita sapit, docet, credit aut prædicat, et non sic in uno Christo unitas confitetur esse naturas, ut personæ sive subsistentiae singularitas agnoscatur, anathema sit.

THeODORI CAPITULUM XXXII.

Jcsum enim dicit a Nazareth, quem unxit Deus Spiritu sancto et virtute (Act. x): qui autem Dei Spiritu unctus est, omnino aliquid inde assumpsit. Quis autem furens dicat de Spiritu aliquid assumpsisse divinam naturam; nec non et participem? participes enim ejus videlicet vocat qui et ipsi uncti sunt; qui autem uncti sunt, et in hoc participes ejus juste facti, non aliter unctiones communicare dicuntur, nisi ei qui assumptus est: hoc ipsum autem demonstratur, quod mercedem justam accepit: Pro hoc enim, inquit, quod dilexisti justitiam, et odisti iniquitatem, pro his præcipuam unctionem meruisti.

English

The response of Vigilius.

In the above-written thirty-first chapter, in the exposition which appears to have been made concerning the symbol of the three hundred and eighteen Fathers, not only is a division of natures asserted, but also by speaking absolutely, lest he who according to the flesh is from the Jews, a naked man apart from deity, and a pure God without flesh, be pronounced as it were separately and separately to be two persons. If anyone therefore understands, teaches, believes, or preaches these things in this way, and does not confess that the natures are united in one Christ in such a way that the singularity of person or subsistence is recognized, let him be anathema.

THE THIRTY-SECOND CHAPTER OF THEODORE.

For he says Jesus from Nazareth, whom God anointed with the Holy Spirit and with power (Acts 10): but he who has been anointed with the Spirit of God has altogether received something from it. Who, however, being mad, would say that the divine nature has received something from the Spirit; and not also a partaker? For it calls partakers of it evidently those who have themselves also been anointed; but those who have been anointed, and in this have rightly been made partakers of it, are said to communicate in the anointings in no other way than to him who was assumed: but this very thing is demonstrated, that he received a just reward: For this, it says, because you loved righteousness and hated iniquity, for these things you merited the preeminent anointing.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:163 · narrative
Source · Latin

Vigilii responsio.

In suprascripto trigesimo secundo capitulo in com~ mento Epistolae ad Hebræos adhibetur illud Petri, ubi dixit: Jesum a Nazareth, quem unxit Deus Spiritu sancto et virtute, et iufertur: Qui autem Dei Spiritu unctus est, omnimode aliquid inde assumpsit; et additur: Quis autem furens dicat de Spiritu aliquid assumpsisse divinam naturam? per quæ verba purus homo Christus inducitur, qui unctione Spiritus sancti particeps factus sit divinae Daturæ, sicut et alii: et mercedis justæ nomine, quia dilexerit justitiam, et oderit iniquitatem, præcipuam meruerit unctionem. Qui ergo ita sapit, dOcet, credit aut praedicat, anathema sit.

THEODORI CAPITULUM XXXIII.

Rabbi, tu es Filius Dei, tu es rex Israel: hoc eat, tu es ille qui de longe prædicatu. es Christus: hæc enim scilicet de Christo sperabat, sicut domestico constituto præter omnes Deo.

English

The response of Vigilius.

In the above-written thirty-second chapter, in the commentary on the Epistle to the Hebrews, that passage of Peter is adduced, where he said: Jesus of Nazareth, whom God anointed with the Holy Spirit and with power, and there is added: But he who is anointed by the Spirit of God has in every way assumed something from it; and it is added: But who, being mad, would say that the divine nature has assumed anything from the Spirit? Through these words Christ is presented as a mere man, who by the anointing of the Holy Spirit became a partaker of the divine nature, just as others also: and by the name of a just reward, because he loved righteousness and hated iniquity, he merited a preeminent anointing. Whoever therefore thinks, teaches, believes, or preaches thus, let him be anathema.

CHAPTER XXXIII OF THEODORE.

Rabbi, you are the Son of God, you are the king of Israel: that is, you are he who was foretold from afar as the Christ: for she hoped these things, namely, concerning the Christ, as one established in his household beyond all others by God.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:164 · narrative
Source · Latin

IHEODORI CAPITULUM XXXIV.

Certus quidem et ipse erat Filius Dei, non secundum deitatis dicens nativitatem, sed secundum quod domesticus Deo erat, per quod Filii Dei qui per virtutem domestici Deo constituti homines interim vocabantur.

Vigilii responsio.

In suprascriptis trigesimo tertio et trigesimo quarto capitulis de interpretatione Evangelii secundum Joannem adhibentur verba Nathanaelis dicentis Domino: Tu es Filius Dei, tu es rex Israel: et infertur dictum esse Christo tanquam domestico Dei, ut non ipse Christus sit Deus, sed plusquam alii homines sit domesticus Deo; et dicitur, quia sicut alii sancti homines filii Dei dicuntur, sic et Christus per familiaritatem quam ad Deum habet a Nathanaele, cum quo loquebatur, Deus sit nominatus. Quæ qui ita sapit, docet, credit aut prædicat, et non eumdem Christum verum Deum et verum hominem confitetur, unum in utraquo natura perfectum, anathema sit.

English

CHAPTER XXXIV OF THEODORE.

He too was indeed certain that he was the Son of God, not speaking according to the birth of deity, but according to the fact that he was a domestic of God, by which men who were established as domestics of God through the power of the Son of God were for a time called sons of God.

The response of Vigilius.

In the above-written thirty-third and thirty-fourth chapters, on the interpretation of the Gospel according to John, the words of Nathanael are adduced, saying to the Lord: You are the Son of God, you are the king of Israel: and it is inferred that this was said to Christ as to a domestic of God, so that Christ himself is not God, but is more than other men a domestic of God; and it is said that, just as other holy men are called sons of God, so too Christ, through the familiarity which he has with God, was called God by Nathanael, with whom he was speaking. Whoever understands, teaches, believes, or preaches these things in this way, and does not confess the same Christ as true God and true man, one perfect in both natures, let him be anathema.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:165 · narrative
Source · Latin

THEODORI CAPITULUM XXXV.

Quando enim dicit: De Filio suo, qui factus est ex semine David secundum carnem, certum quidem quod filium hic eum qui ex semine David factus est secundum carnem non Deum dicit Verbum, sed assumptam servi formam. Nec enim Deus secundum carnem, nec Deus ex semine factus est David, sed sumptus pro nobis homo, quem Filium beatus Apostolus manifeste vocat.

Vigilii responsio.

In suprascripto capitulo trigesimo quinto cum ex. ponitur locus Apostoli de Epistola ad Romanos, ubi dicit: De Filio suo qui factus est ex semine David secundum carnem, nuda servi forma depromitur, dicendo quod hic Filium eum qui ex semine David factus est secundum carnem, non Deum Verbum dicat, sed sumptum pro nobis hominem, quem Filium beatus Apostolus manifeste vocet: quæ verba ostendunt nudum, sicut dictum est, hominem prædicari. Qui ergo ita sapit, docet, credit aut prædicat, et non eumdem, qui ex semine David secundum camcm natus est: juxta David et Pauli apostoli vocem, ipsum credit esse etiam super omnia Deum, anathema sit.

English

CHAPTER XXXV OF THEODORE.

For when he says: Of his Son, who was made of the seed of David according to the flesh, it is certain indeed that he here calls him who was made of the seed of David according to the flesh a son, not God the Word, but the assumed form of a servant. For neither is God according to the flesh, nor was God made of the seed of David, but the man taken up for us, whom the blessed Apostle manifestly calls Son.

The response of Vigilius.

In the above-written thirty-fifth chapter, when the passage of the Apostle from the Epistle to the Romans is set forth, where he says: Of his Son, who was made of the seed of David according to the flesh, a bare form of a servant is brought forward, by saying that he here calls him who was made of the seed of David according to the flesh a son, not God the Word, but the man taken up for us, whom the blessed Apostle manifestly calls Son: which words show that a bare man, as has been said, is proclaimed. Whoever therefore thinks, teaches, believes, or proclaims thus, and does not believe that the same one who was born of the seed of David according to the flesh, according to the voice of David and of the Apostle Paul, is also God over all things, let him be anathema.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:166 · narrative
Source · Latin

I THEODORI CAPITULUM XXXVI.

Renatus alter factus est pro altero, non jam pars Adam mutubilis et peccatis circumfusi, sed Christi, qui omnino inculpabilis per resurrectionem factus est.

Vigilii responsio.

tu suprascripto trigesimo sexto capitulo ubi ad baptizatum dicitur: Quia renatus alter factus est ex altero, non jam pars Adam mutabilis et peccatis circumfusi, sed Christi, qui omnino ipculpabilis per resurrectionem factus est: quibus verbis Christum ante resurreclionem, quod absit, vult videri fuisse culpabilem. Qui ergo haec sapit, docet aut praedicat, anathema sit.

THEODORI CAPITULUM XXXVII.

Ut multam quidem ejus faceret diligentiam, omnia autem illius propria faceret et toleraret, per omnes conductus passiones, per quas eum secundum suam virtutem perfectum fecit, nec a mortuis secundum suæ natura' legem recedens, sed sua præBentia et operatione et gratia liberans eum quidem de morte et malis quæ inde sunt, resuscitans autem eum de mortuis, et ad meliorem finem perducens.

English

CHAPTER XXXVI OF THEODORE.

He has been made another, reborn in place of another, no longer a part of mutable Adam and of those surrounded by sins, but of Christ, who through the resurrection has been made altogether blameless.

The response of Vigilius.

In the above-written thirty-sixth chapter, where it is said to the baptized: Because he has been reborn and made another from another, no longer a part of mutable Adam and of those surrounded by sins, but of Christ, who through the resurrection has been made altogether blameless: by these words he wishes Christ to appear to have been culpable before the resurrection, which God forbid. Therefore whoever holds, teaches, or preaches these things, let him be anathema.

CHAPTER XXXVII OF THEODORE.

That he might indeed exercise great care concerning him, and make all his own things his and endure them, through all the passions he was led through, by which he made him perfect according to his own virtue, not departing from the dead according to the law of his nature, but by his presence and operation and grace liberating him indeed from death and the evils that come from it, raising him again from the dead, and leading him to a better end.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:167 · narrative
Source · Latin

Vigilii responsio.

In suprascripto trigesimo septimo capitulo dicitur, quia Christo in passionibus et morte Deus verbum præsentia et operatione et ad gratiam adfuerit: quod si ita est, tanquam alter alteri præsens gratiam et operationem impendisse videbitur. Qui ergo hæc ita sapit, docet, credit aut prædicat, et non ipsum Deum Verbum, servata impassibilitate divinitatis suæ in earne anima rationali et intellectuali animata, quam sibi ab ipso conceptu univit ex Virgine, omnia quæ de passione ejus scripta sunt, voluntarie sustinuisse dicit, anathema sit.

THEODORI CAPITULUM XXXVIII.

Deinde ostendens cujus gratia passus est, diminutionem infert: Quatenus circa [citra] Deum pro omnibus gustaret mortem (Hebr. II): quia, divina natura ita volente, separata illa, ipse pro se [per se], pro omnium utilitate gustavit mortem: et ostendens quod deitas separata quidem erat ab illo qui passus est secundum mortis experimentum, quia nec possibile erat illam mortis experimentum accipere, non tameti illi qui passus est abfuerat secundum diligentiam.

English

The response of Vigilius.

In the above-written thirty-seventh chapter it is said that God the Word was present to Christ in his sufferings and death by presence and operation and for grace: but if this is so, one will appear to have bestowed grace and operation upon another as one person upon another. Whoever therefore thinks, teaches, believes, or preaches these things in this way, and does not say that God the Word himself, with the impassibility of his divinity preserved in the flesh animated by a rational and intellectual soul, which he united to himself from the very conception from the Virgin, voluntarily endured all things that are written concerning his passion, let him be anathema.

CHAPTER XXXVIII OF THEODORE.

Then, showing for whose sake he suffered, he introduces a diminution: That he might taste death for all apart from God (Heb. 2): because, the divine nature so willing, that nature having been separated, he himself for himself, for the benefit of all, tasted death: and showing that the deity was indeed separated from him who suffered according to the experience of death, because it was not possible for that deity to receive the experience of death, yet it was not absent from him who suffered according to providence.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:168 · narrative
Source · Latin

Vigilii responsio.

In suprascripto trigesimo octavo capitulo et falsatum testimonium Apostoli agnoscimus, quia ubi legitur: Ut gratia Dei pro omnibus gustaret mortem, hic invenitur: Ut sine Deo pro omnibus gustaret mortem, et hoc quasi astruendo dicitur: quia, divina natura separata, ipse pro se, vel ut purus homo pro omnium utilitate gustaverit mortem. Qui ergo ita sapit, docet, credit, aut prædicat, et non confitetur quia Deus verbum carnem, quam sibi ex ipsa conceptione secundum substantiam adunivit, nec in passionibus ncc in morte unquam deseruerit, anathema sit.

THEODORI CAPITULUM XXXIX.

Jcsum autem ait de Nazareth, quem unxit Deus Spiritu et virtute (Act. x), cujus unctionem meritus, et immaculatus effectus est per omnia, et ad divinam naturam meruit conjunctionem. Neque enim conjunctionem suscepisset illam, nisi prius immaculatus factus fuisset, ut sic condeceat illius unitatem.

English

The response of Vigilius.

In the above-written thirty-eighth chapter we recognize also a falsified testimony of the Apostle, because where it is read: That by the grace of God he might taste death for all, here it is found: That without God he might taste death for all, and this is said as if asserting: that, with the divine nature separated, he himself for himself, or as a pure man, tasted death for the benefit of all. Whoever therefore thinks, teaches, believes, or preaches thus, and does not confess that God the Word never deserted the flesh, which he united to himself according to substance from the very conception, neither in his sufferings nor in death, let him be anathema.

CHAPTER XXXIX OF THEODORE.

But Jesus, he says, of Nazareth, whom God anointed with the Spirit and power (Acts 10), whose anointing he merited, and was made immaculate in all things, and merited conjunction with the divine nature. For he would not have received that conjunction unless he had first been made immaculate, as befits his unity.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:169 · narrative
Source · Latin

Vigilii responsio.

In suprascripto trigesimo nono capitulo rursum illud quod beatus Petrus dixit: Jesum aNazareth, quem luxit Deus Spiritu et virtute: cxponens dicit, per unctionem Spiritus, quod meruit, et immaculatum cum per omnia factum, ct ad divinam naturam meruisse conjunctionem: quæ verba Christum purum hominem aperte signanl. Qui ergo hæc ita sapii, docct, credit aut prædicat, analhema sit.

THEODORI CAPITULUM XL.

Nam et illud: Hic est Filius Incus dilectus, in quo mihi complacuit (Matth. m), insania evidens est de Deo Verbo putare dicere eum. Qui enim dixit: Hic est Filius meus dilectus, et intulit: In quo milii complacuit, significavit quod aperte ad comparationem hoc dicit aliorum filiorum, qui nec dilecti facti sunt, rec placere nimis potuerunt ei.

Vigilii responsio.

In suprascripto capitulo quadragesimo de interpretatione Evangelii secundum Matthæum, ubi dicitur: Hic est Filius meus dilectus, in quo mihi complacuit, subjungitur et dicitur: Insania evidens est de Deo dicere cum. Qui enim dixit: Hic est Filius meus dilectus, ct intulit: In quo mihi complacuit, significavit quod aperte ad comparationcm hoc dicit flliorum, qui no dilecti ei facti sunt, nec placere nimis potuerunt. Quæ verba Christum Jcsum purum rursus hominem et adoptivum filium evidenter ostendunt. Qui igitur hæc ita sapit, docet, credit aut prædicat, anathema sit.

English

The response of Vigilius.

In the above-written thirty-ninth chapter, again, expounding that saying of blessed Peter: Jesus of Nazareth, whom God anointed with the Spirit and power, he says that through the anointing of the Spirit he merited this, and that having been made immaculate in all things, he also merited conjunction with the divine nature. These words openly mark Christ as a mere man. Whoever therefore thinks, teaches, believes, or preaches these things, let him be anathema.

CHAPTER XL OF THEODORE.

For also that saying: This is my beloved Son, in whom I am well pleased (Matthew 3), it is evident madness to think that God the Word says it of him. For he who said: This is my beloved Son, and added: In whom I am well pleased, signified that he says this openly by comparison with other sons, who were neither made beloved nor could please him very much.

The response of Vigilius.

In the above-written fortieth chapter, concerning the interpretation of the Gospel according to Matthew, where it is said: This is my beloved Son, in whom I am well pleased, it is added and said: It is evident madness to say it of God. For he who said: This is my beloved Son, and added: In whom I am well pleased, signified that he says this openly by comparison with sons who were not made beloved to him, nor could please him very much. These words again evidently show Christ Jesus to be a mere man and an adopted son. Whoever therefore thinks, teaches, believes, or preaches these things, let him be anathema.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:170 · narrative
Source · Latin

THEODORI CAPITULUM XLI.

Permanens autem, donec secundum suam creaturam et virtutem solvens mortis dolores, liberavit eum ineffabilibus illius vinculis, et de mortuis resuscitans, transtulit quidem in immortalem vitam: incorruptum autem eum et immortalem et immutabilem efficiens, in cælum duxit.

Vigilii responsio.

In suprascripto quadragesimo primo capitulo dicitur, quod solvens mortis dolores, liberavit Christum ineffabilibus illis vinculis, et de morte resuscitans transtulerit quidem ad immortalem vitam, incorruptum autem eum et immortalem et immutabiIcm efficiens, in coelum eduxerit: per quæ omnia verba declaratur nudum hominem esse Jesum Christum. Qui ergo ita sapit, docet, credit, aut praedicat, anathema sit.

THEODORI CAPITULUM XLII.

Christum justificatum et immaculatum factum secundum virtutem sancti Spiritus [sicut beatus Apostolus modo quidem dicit: Quod justiticatus est in Spiritu (II Tim. m); modo vero: Quod per Spiritum æternum immaculatum se obtulit Deo (Hebr. IX) ] mori quidem fecit secundum legem hominum, ut pote autem impeccabilem virtute sancti Spiritus factum resuscitavit de mortuis, et ad vitam constituit meliorem, immutabilem quidem anima cogitationibus, incorruptum autem et indissolutum ex carne faciens,

English

CHAPTER XLI OF THEODORE.

But he remained, until, according to his own creaturehood and power, dissolving the pangs of death, he freed him from those ineffable bonds, and raising him from the dead, he transferred him indeed into immortal life: making him incorruptible and immortal and immutable, he led him into heaven.

The response of Vigilius.

In the above-written forty-first chapter it is said that, dissolving the pangs of death, he freed Christ from those ineffable bonds, and raising him from death he transferred him indeed to immortal life, and making him incorruptible and immortal and immutable, he led him out into heaven: through all which words it is declared that Jesus Christ is a mere man. Whoever therefore thinks, teaches, believes, or preaches thus, let him be anathema.

CHAPTER XLII OF THEODORE.

That Christ was justified and made immaculate according to the power of the Holy Spirit [as the blessed Apostle says at one time: That he was justified in the Spirit (2 Tim. 3); at another: That through the eternal Spirit he offered himself immaculate to God (Heb. 9)] he indeed caused to die according to the law of men, but as one made impeccable by the power of the Holy Spirit he raised him from the dead, and established him unto a better life, making him immutable indeed in soul with respect to thoughts, but incorruptible and undissolved as regards the flesh,

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:171 · narrative
Source · Latin

Vigilii responsio.

In suprascripto quadragesimo secundo capitulo dicitur Christum juslilicatum et immaculatum factum esse virtute Spiritus sancti; et adjicit: Mori quidem eum fecit secundum legem hominum, ut pote autem impeccabilem virtute Spiritus sancti factum resuscitavit de mortuis: quibus verbis sic separatus a verbo Dei insinuatur homo, ut sancti Spiritus virtute immaculatus et impeccabilis, quasi aliquis justus homo asseratur effectus. Qui ergo hæc ita sapit, docet, credit aut prædicat, anathema sit.

THEODORI CAPITULUM XLIII.

Deo autem gratias, qui nobis dedit victoriam per Dominum nostrum Jesum Christum (I Cor. xv); istorum causam nobis fuisse dicens Deum, qui contra omnes adversarios dedit nobis victoriam sive mortis, sive peccati, sive cujuscunque hinc nascendi mali: qui Dominum nostrum Jesum Christum pro nobis hominem sumens, et ipsum per resurrectionem de mortuis ad meliorem transtulit finem, et in dextera sua sedere fecit, et nobis ad eum donavit communionem

English

The response of Vigilius.

In the above-written forty-second chapter it is said that Christ was justified and made immaculate by the power of the Holy Spirit; and it adds: He indeed caused him to die according to the law of men, but as one who had been made impeccable by the power of the Holy Spirit, he raised him from the dead: by these words the man is so separated from the Word of God, as to be asserted to have been made immaculate and impeccable by the power of the Holy Spirit, as if he were some righteous man. Whoever therefore thinks, teaches, believes, or preaches these things in this way, let him be anathema.

CHAPTER XLIII OF THEODORE.

But thanks be to God, who has given us the victory through our Lord Jesus Christ (1 Cor. 15); saying that God was the cause of these things for us, who against all adversaries gave us victory, whether of death, or of sin, or of whatever evil is born from this: who, taking our Lord Jesus Christ as a man for our sake, and through the resurrection from the dead transferred him to a better end, and made him sit at his right hand, and granted us communion with him

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:172 · narrative
Source · Latin

Vigilii responsio.

In suprascripto quadragesimo tertio capitulo, exponendo verba apostoli Pauli quibus dicit: Deo autem gratias, qui nobis dedit victoriam per Dominum nostrum Jesum Christum. Et post plura subjungitur: Dominus noster Jesus Christus pro nobis hominem sumens, et ipsum per resurrectionem de mortuis ad meliorem transtulit finem, per quæ jam quasi existens homo, a Deo verbo significatur assumptus, ut duo fuisse videantur, et alter alteri praestitisse. Qui ita sapit, docet, credit aut prædicat, anathema sit.

THEODORI CAPITULUM XLIV.

Cum ergo interrogent: Hominis genitrix, aut Dei genitrix Maria dicatur a nobis? Utraque, unum quidem natura, alterum autem relatione: hominis enim genitrix natura, quia homo erat et in ventre Mariae, qui et processit inde; Dei autem genitrix, quia Deus erat in homine nato; non in illo circumscriptus secundum natura,,,, sed quod in eo erat affectu voluntatis.

English

The response of Vigilius.

In the above-written forty-third chapter, in expounding the words of the apostle Paul, in which he says: But thanks be to God, who has given us the victory through our Lord Jesus Christ. And after many things it is added: Our Lord Jesus Christ, taking up man for us, and by the resurrection from the dead transferred him to a better end, through which things, now as if existing as man, he is signified by God the Word to have been assumed, so that they might seem to have been two, and the one to have furnished aid to the other. Whoever thinks, teaches, believes, or preaches thus, let him be anathema.

CHAPTER XLIV OF THEODORE.

When therefore they ask: Is Mary to be called by us the mother of a man, or the mother of God? Both: the one by nature, the other by relation. For she is the mother of a man by nature, because he was a man and was in the womb of Mary, who also came forth from there; but the mother of God, because God was in the man born; not circumscribed in him according to nature, but because he was in him by the disposition of his will.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:173 · narrative
Source · Latin

Vigilii responsio.

In suprascripto quadragesimo quarto capitulo dicitur: Cum ergo interrogent: Hominis genitrix, an Dei genitrix Maria dicatur, quasi ex respondentis persona dicitur, utraque dici, et adjungitur: Unum quidem natura rei, alterum autem relatione; et additur: Hominis enim genitrix natura, quia homo erat et in ventre Mariæ, qui et processit inde: Dei autem genitrix, quia Deus erat in homine nato: et adjicitur: Non ille circumscriptus secundum naturam, sed quod in eo erat affectu voluntatis. Quæ verba item et unum hominem Christum, et duos filios beatæ Mariæ demonstrant. Quod qui ita sapit, docet, credit aut praedicat, et non Deum verbum, qui ante omnia sæcula ex Patre ineflabiliter natos est, eumdem ex sancta Virgine Maria (sicut in primo capitulo diximus) per secundam nativitatem suam incarnatum et natam unum in utraque natura inconfusa inseparabilique cognoscit, anathema sit.

English

The response of Vigilius.

In the above-written forty-fourth chapter it is said: When therefore they ask whether Mary is to be called mother of a man or mother of God, it is said as if from the person of the one responding that she is called both, and it is added: The one indeed by the nature of the matter, the other by relation; and it is added: For she is mother of a man by nature, because he who also came forth from her was a man and in the womb of Mary: but mother of God, because God was in the man born: and it is added: Not that one circumscribed according to nature, but that which was in him by the affection of the will. These words likewise show both one man Christ and two sons of blessed Mary. Whoever understands, teaches, believes, or preaches thus, and does not recognize that the same God the Word, who before all ages was ineffably born from the Father, was incarnate from the holy Virgin Mary (as we said in the first chapter) through his second nativity and born as one in both natures, unconfused and inseparable, let him be anathema.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:174 · narrative
Source · Latin

THEODORI CAPITULUM ILV.

a Gratia filius qui ex Maria est homo, natura autem Deus Verbum: quod autem secundum gratiam, non natura, et quod secundum naturam, non gratia, non duo filii; sufficiat corpori, quod ex nobis est secundum gratiam filiatio, gloria et immortalitas: quia templum Dei Verbi factum est, non supra naturam elevetur: et Deus Verbum pro debita a nobis gratiarum actione non injurietur: et quæ est injuria componere cum cum corpore, et putare indigere corporis ad perfectam filiationem! nec ipse Deus Verbum vult se David filium esse, sed Dominum; corpus autem hoc vocari David filium non solum non invidit, sed et propter hoc adfuit.

Vigilii responsio.

In suprascripto quadragesimo quinto capitulo dicitur, quia per gratiam sit filius qui ex Maria natus est homo, natura autem Deus Verbum: et quasi ratiocinatur dicendo: Quod gratia, non natura, et quod natura, non gratia; et adjungitur: Sufficit corpori quod ex nobis est secundum gratiam flliatio, et non supra naturam elevetur, et Deus Verbum pro debita a nobis gratiarum actione non injurietur; quæ verba nudum hominem ex Virgine Maria significant, qui per gratiam appelletur Filius Dei. Qui ergo hæc ita sapit, docet, credit aut praedicat, anathema sit.

English

CHAPTER ILV OF THEODORE.

a The son by grace who is a man from Mary, but by nature God the Word: and what is by grace, not by nature, and what is by nature, not by grace, are not two sons; let the filiation by grace suffice for the body which is from us, along with glory and immortality: because it has been made a temple of God the Word, let it not be raised above nature: and let not God the Word be injured in return for the thanksgiving due to us from us: and what an injury it is to compound him with the body, and to think that he needs the body for perfect filiation! Nor does God the Word himself wish to be the son of David, but Lord; yet he not only does not begrudge this body being called the son of David, but even for this reason he was present.

The response of Vigilius.

In the above-written forty-fifth chapter it is said that the man who was born from Mary is a son by grace, but God the Word by nature: and he reasons as it were by saying: What is by grace, not by nature, and what is by nature, not by grace; and it is added: The filiation by grace suffices for the body which is from us, and let it not be raised above nature, and let not God the Word be injured in return for the thanksgiving due to us from us; which words signify a bare man from the Virgin Mary, who is called the Son of God by grace. Whoever therefore thinks, teaches, believes, or preaches these things in this way, let him be anathema.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:175 · narrative
Source · Latin

THEODORI CAPITULUM XLVI.

Quando erit quæstio de nativilatibus secundum naturam, ne Mariæ filius Verbum Dei existimetur, mortalet enim mortales generant secundum naturam et corpus simile sibi: et duas nativitates Deus Verbum non sustinuit, unam quidem ante sæcula, alteram vero in posterioribus temporibus.

Vigilii responsio.

In supradicto quadragesimo sexto capitulo dicitur, ut Mariae filius Deus Verbum non existimetur, adjiciendo: Quia mortalis mortalem generat secundum naturam, et corpus simile sibi. Quae verba et purum hominem de sancta Virgine Maria significant, et duos filios introducunt. Qui ergo ita sapit, docet, credit aut prædicat, anathema sit.

THEODORI CAPITULUM XLVII.

Ergo jam cessabunt ab impudente pugna, desistent autem a vana contentione, erubescentes evidentiam prædictorum: plurimos enim dicunt filios in gloriam ducentes. Ecce igitur in filiationis ratione Apostolus apparet (1 Tim. III), assumptum hominem cæteris connumerans, non secundum quod tUis [illius] filiationis particeps est, sed secundum quod similiter gratia filiaIi.. assumpsit, deitate sola naturalem filiationem possidente.

English

CHAPTER XLVI OF THEODORE.

When there will be a question about nativities according to nature, let not the Son of Mary be thought to be God the Word, for mortals generate mortals according to nature and a body like themselves: and God the Word did not undergo two nativities, one indeed before the ages, the other in later times.

The response of Vigilius.

In the aforementioned forty-sixth chapter it is said that the Son of Mary is not to be thought to be God the Word, adding: Because a mortal generates a mortal according to nature, and a body like himself. These words signify a mere man from the holy Virgin Mary, and introduce two sons. Whoever therefore thinks, teaches, believes, or preaches thus, let him be anathema.

CHAPTER XLVII OF THEODORE.

Therefore now they will cease from shameless battle, and they will desist from vain contention, blushing at the evidence of the aforesaid things: for they say that very many lead sons into glory. Behold therefore in the reckoning of filiation the Apostle appears (1 Tim. 3), numbering the assumed man with the rest, not according as he is a partaker of that filiation, but according as he similarly assumed filiation by grace, the Godhead alone possessing natural filiation.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:176 · narrative
Source · Latin

Vigilii responsio.

Ia suprascripto quadragesimo septimo capitulo id quod dicit Apostolus, Qui multos filios ad gloriam adduxerat (Hebr. n, 10), exponendo dicitur, quod assumptum hominem cæteris connumeret sanctus Apostolus, eo quod similiter gratiam filiationis acceperit, sola deitate naturalem filiationem possidente: quae quidem verba, sicut superius dictum est, duos introducunt iilios, id est unum per gratiam, alterum per naturam. Quod qui ita sapit, docet, credit aut prædicat, anathema sit.

THEODORI CAPITULUM XLVIII.

Sed ad hoc dicunt, quod Jesus nomen salvatorem significat. Salvator autem si dicitur, quomodo ille homo dicatur? obliti quod Jesus dicebatur etiam filius Nate: et quod mirandum est 1, quia non sit vocatus fortuito in generatione, sed transnominatus a Moyse. Certum autem eat quod non hoc imponere homini patiebatur, si divinam naturam omnimodo significabat.

English

The response of Vigilius.

In the above-written forty-seventh chapter, in expounding what the Apostle says, "Who had brought many sons to glory" (Hebr. 2:10), it is said that the holy Apostle numbers the assumed man among the rest, in that he similarly received the grace of sonship, while the Godhead alone possesses natural sonship. These words, as was said above, introduce two sons, that is, one through grace, the other through nature. Whoever understands, teaches, believes, or preaches this, let him be anathema.

CHAPTER XLVIII OF THEODORE.

But to this they say that the name Jesus signifies Savior. But if he is called Savior, how is that man called so? They forget that even the son of Nun was called Jesus, and—what is to be wondered at—that he was not so named by chance at his birth, but was renamed by Moses. Yet it is certain that he would not have permitted this to be imposed on a man if it signified the divine nature in every way.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:177 · narrative
Source · Latin

Vigilii responsio.

In suprascripto quadragesimo octavo capitulo de nomine Jesu, quod salvatorem significat, argumentando negatur, et dicitur: Quia si salvator divinam naturam significaret, nunquam tale nomen homini imponeretur. Quibus verbis absolute et porus homo Christus ostenditur, et duae personæ intelliguntur. Quae qui ita sapit, credit aut praedicat, anathema sit.

THEODORl CAPITULUM XLIX.

Itaque non solum Filium ipsum vocat a Deo Verbo separans, sed etiam secundum rationem fitiationis communicans cæteri. participibus filiationis convincitur: quoniam gratia et ipse particeps fuit filiationis, non naturaliter ex Patre natus, habens tamen ad cætero. excellentiam, qui unitate ad ipsum filiationem possidet, quod ei firmiorem ipsius rei donat participationem.

Vigilii responsio.

In suprascriptb quadragesimo nono capitulo didtor, quia Christus per gratiam particeps fuit filiationis, habens tamen ad cæteros excellentiam, quod ei firmior ipsius rei donata fuerit participatio. Quod qui ita sapit, docet, credit aut prædicat, et non magis Deus Verbum cum assumpta carne unus atque idem Dominus Jesus Christus et verus Filius Dei et idem ipse verus Filius hominis intelligitur et creditur, anathema sit.

English

The response of Vigilius.

In the above-written forty-eighth chapter, concerning the name of Jesus, which signifies the Savior, it is denied by argument, and it is said: Because if "Savior" signified the divine nature, such a name would never be imposed on a man. By these words Christ is shown to be absolutely and purely a man, and two persons are understood. Whoever holds, believes, or preaches this, let him be anathema.

THEODORE, CHAPTER XLIX.

Therefore he not only calls Him Son while separating Him from God the Word, but he is also convicted of communicating to the rest of the participants in sonship according to the reckoning of sonship: since by grace He too was a partaker of sonship, not born naturally from the Father, yet having excellence over the rest, who possesses sonship by unity with Him, which grants Him a firmer participation in that very reality.

The response of Vigilius.

In the above-written forty-ninth chapter it is said that Christ was a partaker of sonship through grace, yet having excellence over the rest, because a firmer participation in that very reality was granted to Him. Whoever holds, teaches, believes, or preaches this, and does not rather understand and believe that God the Word with the assumed flesh is one and the same Lord Jesus Christ, both the true Son of God and the same true Son of Man, let him be anathema.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:178 · narrative
Source · Latin

THEODORI CAPITULUM L.

Homo Jesus similiter omnibus hominibus, nihil differens connaturalibus hominibus quam quod ipsi gratiam dedit; gratia autem data naturam non mutat; sed post mortis destructionem donavit ei Deus nomen super omne nomen.

Vigilii responsio.

In suprascripto quinquagesimo capitulo dicitur, quod homo Jesus nihil differat ab omnibus connaturalibus hominibus, nisi quod ei gratiam dedit: quae verba Dominum nostrum Jesum Christum velut unum de justis hominibus faciunt æstimari, qui non deitate sua excelsus intelligatur, sed gratia aliquid amplius quam cæteri homines asseratur adeptus. Quod si quis ita sapit, docet, credit aut praedicat, anathema sit.

THEODORI CAPITULUM HI.

Sed mei fratres, qui ejusdem mihi matris sunt filii dicunt mihi. Non separa hominem et Deum, sed unum eumdemque die hominem, dicem: Dico connaturalem mihi, dico Deum. Si dicat connaturalem Deo, dico: Quomodo homo et Deus unum sunt? Nunquid una natura hominis et Dei, domini et servi, factoris et facturæ? Ilomo homini consubstantialis est, Deus autem Deo consubstantialis est: quomodo igitur homo et Deus unus per unitatem esse potest: qui salvificatur, qui salvificat, et qui ante sæcula, et qui ex Maria apparuit?

English

CHAPTER L OF THEODORE.

The man Jesus is like all men, differing in nothing from men of the same nature, except that he gave them grace; but grace given does not change nature; yet after the destruction of death God gave him a name above every name.

The response of Vigilius.

In the above-written fiftieth chapter it is said that the man Jesus differs in nothing from all men of the same nature, except that he gave him grace: which words make our Lord Jesus Christ be esteemed as one of the righteous men, who is not understood as exalted by his deity, but is asserted to have obtained something more than other men by grace. But if anyone thinks, teaches, believes, or preaches thus, let him be anathema.

CHAPTER LI OF THEODORE.

But my brothers, who are sons of the same mother as I, say to me: Do not separate the man and God, but call him one and the same: I call him a man, I call him connatural to me, I call him God. If he calls him connatural to God, I say: How are man and God one? Is there one nature of man and God, of lord and servant, of maker and creature? Man is consubstantial with man, but God is consubstantial with God: how then can man and God be one through unity: he who is saved, and he who saves, and he who was before the ages, and he who appeared from Mary?

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:179 · narrative
Source · Latin

Vigilii responsio.

In suprascripto quinquagesimo primo capitulo negatur quod unus idemque dici possit Deus et homo dicendo: Quomodo homo et Deus unus per unitatem esse potest, qui salvificat, et qui salvificatur, qui ante sæcula est, et qui ex Maria apparuit? Quæ verba duas introducunt in Christo personas. Si quis igitur ita sapit, docet, credit aut praedicat, anathema sit.

THEODORI CAPITULUM LII.

Bene intulit: Namque et ego homo sum (Matth. VIII), ut dicat: Nihil mirandum si hoc potes cum sis homo accipiens a Deo: quoniam et ego cum hoc sim, accipio obedientes, semel habens jubendi potestatem propter datoris indulgentiam.

TUEODORI CAPITULUM LIII.

Quapropter et nec incongruum est et te, accepta ista a Deo potestate, verbo solo jubentem abigere passiones, nec enim tanquam Filio Dei, et ante universam creaturam existenti, et creatori eorum quæ sunt accessit centurio.

English

The response of Vigilius.

In the above-written fifty-first chapter it is denied that one and the same can be called God and man, by saying: How can man and God be one through unity, he who saves and he who is saved, he who is before the ages and he who appeared from Mary? These words introduce two persons in Christ. If anyone therefore thinks, teaches, believes, or preaches thus, let him be anathema.

CHAPTER LII OF THEODORE.

He rightly added: For I also am a man (Matt. 8), so as to say: It is nothing to be wondered at if you can do this, since you are a man receiving from God; for I also, since I am such, receive those who obey, having once for all the power of commanding through the indulgence of the giver.

CHAPTER LIII OF THEODORE.

Wherefore it is neither incongruous that you, having received this power from God, by a word alone command and drive away passions; for the centurion did not come to him as to the Son of God, and as existing before the whole creation, and as the creator of the things that are.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:180 · narrative
Source · Latin

Vigilii responsio.

In suprascriptis quinquagesimo secundo et quinquagesimo tertio capitulis dicitur, quia Christo dixerit centurio, nihil mirandum esse si hoc potes, cum sis homo accipiens a Deo: quoniam et ego cum hoc sim, accipio obedientes, semel habens jubendi potestatem propter datoris indulgentiam. Et quamvis ex eo quod sequitur, centurionem non tanquam Filium Dei adiisse, qui universam condiderit creaturam; videatur quidem esse confiteri eum esse Filium Dei et creaturæ totius opificem. Tamen quia nec de centurionis intellectu bene existimavit, cujus Dominus tidem non laudaret dicendo: Non inveni tantam fidem in Israel (Ibidem), nisi sciret eum intellexisse quia Deus: et ex his et superioribus capitulis ct aliis dictis jam non per unitatem subsistentiæ, sed per gratiam dicitur Christus esse Filius Dei, et ex co Christus purus homo videtur induci, qui pro merito suo acciperet per datoris indulgentiam potestatem. Si quis ergo hæc ita sapit, docet, credit aut prædicat, anathema sit.

English

The response of Vigilius.

In the above-written fifty-second and fifty-third chapters it is said that the centurion said to Christ that it was nothing to be wondered at if he could do this, since he was a man receiving from God, because he also, though he was such, received those who obeyed, having once the power of commanding through the indulgence of the giver. And although from what follows, the centurion did not approach him as the Son of God, who created the whole creation, he nevertheless seems to confess that he is the Son of God and the maker of the whole creation. Yet because he did not think well of the centurion's understanding, whose Lord likewise did not praise him by saying: I have not found so great faith in Israel, unless he knew that he had understood that he was God; and from these and the earlier chapters and other statements, Christ is now said to be the Son of God not through unity of subsistence but through grace, and from this Christ appears to be introduced as a mere man, who by his own merit received power through the indulgence of the giver. If anyone therefore understands, teaches, believes, or preaches these things in this way, let him be anathema.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:181 · narrative
Source · Latin

TBEODORI CAPITULUM LIV.

Consonantia et Apostolus dicit: Et manifeste magnum est pietatis mysterium, quod manifestatum est in carne, justificatum est in Spiritu (/ Tim. iu), justificatum esse in Spiritu dicens ipsum, sive quod ante baptisma cum subtilitate competente legem custodivit, sive quod etiam post illud gratiæ conversationem cooperatione Spiritus cum magna complevit subtilitate.

Vigilii responsio.

In suprascripto quinquagesimo quarto capitulo id quod Apostolus dicit: Quod manifestatum est in carne, justificatum esi in Spiritu, Christus justificatus esse asseritur, sive quod ante baplismum cum subtilitate competenti legem custodivit, sive quod etiam post illud gratiae conversationem coopcratione Spiritus cum magna subtilitate compleverit. Ouæ verba quia item purum hominem Christum justiiicatione eguisse demonstrat, si quis ita sapit, docet, credit aut prædicat, et non magis ipsum ut verum Deum consubstantialem Patri et Spiritui sancto justificare impios per fidem credit, anathema sit.

English

THEODORE, CHAPTER LIV.

The Apostle also says in agreement: And manifestly great is the mystery of godliness, which was manifested in the flesh, was justified in the Spirit (1 Tim. 3), saying that he himself was justified in the Spirit, whether because before baptism he kept the law with fitting subtlety, or because even after it he fulfilled the conduct of grace with great subtlety through the cooperation of the Spirit.

The response of Vigilius.

In the above-written fifty-fourth chapter, what the Apostle says: Which was manifested in the flesh, was justified in the Spirit, is asserted to mean that Christ was justified, whether because before baptism he kept the law with fitting subtlety, or because even after it he fulfilled the conduct of grace with great subtlety through the cooperation of the Spirit. And since these words likewise demonstrate that Christ, as a mere man, needed justification, if anyone so understands, teaches, believes, or preaches, and does not rather believe that he, as true God, consubstantial with the Father and the Holy Spirit, justifies the ungodly through faith, let him be anathema.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:182 · narrative
Source · Latin

THEODORI CAPITULUM LV.

Idem hoc dicimus juste et de Domino, quod Deu verbum sciens ejus virtutem, et secundum præscientiam statim in ipso initio complasmationis cohabitare bene voluit, et uniens eum sibi affectu voluntatis, majorem quamdam præstabat gratiam, ut pote gratia quæ in eum est, et in omnes homines dividenda. Unde et circa bona voluntatem integram ei custodiebat. Non enim hoc dicemus, quod ille homo voluntatem habebat nullam, sed quod volebat quidem bonum, magis autem ci voluntarie plurimum aderat et boni desiderium, et contrarii odium: conservabatur vero a divina gratia illi voluntas integra ab initio, Deo qualis erit subtititer sciente, qui et ad confirmandum eum magnam illi cooperationem habitatione sua præstabat pro omnium nostrum salute: unde nec injustum dicat aliquis esse, quod præter omnes præcipuum aliquid datum est illi homini, qui a Domino assumptus est.

English

THEODORE, CHAPTER LV.

We say this justly also concerning the Lord: that God the Word, knowing his power and according to foreknowledge, willed from the very beginning of his formation to dwell in him, and uniting him to himself by the affection of his will, bestowed on him a certain greater grace, inasmuch as the grace that is in him was also to be divided among all men. Hence he also preserved in him an integrity of good will. For we shall not say that that man had no will, but that he indeed willed the good, and yet more, voluntarily and in the highest degree, both the desire of good and the hatred of its contrary were present in him; but his will was preserved whole from the beginning by divine grace, God knowing beforehand what sort he would be, who also, to confirm him, granted him great cooperation by his indwelling for the salvation of us all. Hence let no one say that it is unjust that something preeminent beyond all others was given to that man who was assumed by the Lord.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:183 · narrative
Source · Latin

Vigilii responsio.

In suprascripto quinquagesimo quinto capitulo dicitur quia Deus verbum secundum præscientiam sciens hominis Christi virtutem, initio complasmationis statim inhabitare in ipso bene voluerit, et uniens eum sibi affcctu volunlatis majorem quamdam ei præstabat gratiam. Ex quibus verbis, et ex aliis quæ sequuntur, duae evidenter inducuntur esse personæ, et quia Filius Dei in filio hominis per affectum et gratiam et relationem habitare videatur. Si quis ergo haec ita sapit, docet, credit aut prædicat, et non unum eumdemque Christum in duabus perfectis et individuis inconfusisque agnoscit et credit naturis, anathema sit.

THEODORI CAPITULUM IVI.

Nam rationalis quidem proprium est diacretio bonorum et malorum: cum vero non sint contraria non erat ei possibile aliquid discernere prinmm: igitur in his quæ creata sunt magnam contrarietatem fecit.

English

The response of Vigilius.

In the above-written fifty-fifth chapter it is said that God the Word, knowing according to foreknowledge the power of the man Christ, willed from the very beginning of his formation to dwell in him, and uniting him to himself by the affection of his will, bestowed upon him a certain greater grace. From these words, and from the others that follow, two persons are evidently shown to exist, and that the Son of God seems to dwell in the son of man through affection and grace and relation. If anyone therefore understands, teaches, believes or preaches these things in this way, and does not acknowledge and believe one and the same Christ in two perfect and indivisible and unconfused natures, let him be anathema.

THE FOURTH CHAPTER OF THEODORE.

For it is proper to the rational being to discern good and evil; but since they were not contrary, it was not possible for it to discern anything at first; therefore in created things it made a great contrariety.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:184 · narrative
Source · Latin

Vigilii responsio.

In suprascripto quinquagesimo sexto capitulo dicitur, rationalis proprium esse discretionem bonorum et malorum; et post pauca sequitur: Primum igitur in his quæ creata sunt magnam contrarietatem fecit. Quae verba si ea intentione dicantur, ut mali natura sicut et boni introducatur, anathema sit.

THEODORI CAPITULUM LVII.

Quoniam autem non obaudit Adam, deinde subditus est morti: et factus est hoc propter inobedientiam, quod et citra inobedientiam propter utilitatem nostram a Creatore factum est, edocti sumus omnes peccatum.

Vigilii responsio.

In suprascripto quinquagesimo septimo capitulo dicitur, quia etsi non fuisset Adam inobediens, tamen propter utilitatem hominum a Creatore factum esse, et edoctos nos esse peccatum: quod absit ut catholica fides credat, a Deo nos, ut peccatores efficeremur, doceri potuisse peccatum. Si quis ergo hoc ita sapit, docet aut prædicat; et non magis prohibente Deo, primi hominis culpa introductum fatetur esse peccatum, et, justo Dei judicio eum atque ejus progeniem propter inobedientiam suam mortis subiisse supplicium, anathema sit.

English

The response of Vigilius.

In the above-written fifty-sixth chapter it is said that it is proper to a rational being to have discernment of good and evil; and after a few words it follows: First, therefore, in those things which were created he made a great contrariety. If these words are spoken with the intention that the nature of evil be introduced just as that of good, let him be anathema.

CHAPTER LVII OF THEODORE.

But because Adam did not obey, he was then subjected to death: and this came about on account of disobedience, which even apart from disobedience was done by the Creator for our benefit, we have all been taught sin.

The response of Vigilius.

In the above-written fifty-seventh chapter it is said that even if Adam had not been disobedient, it was nevertheless done by the Creator for the benefit of men, and that we have been taught sin: which may the catholic faith be far from believing, that we could have been taught sin by God so that we might become sinners. If anyone therefore thinks this, teaches or preaches it; and does not rather confess that sin was introduced by the fault of the first man, with God forbidding it, and that by the just judgment of God he and his offspring underwent the punishment of death on account of his disobedience, let him be anathema.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:185 · narrative
Source · Latin

THEODORI CAPITULUM LVIII.

Nec igitur mortem non sponte et præter judicium suum intulit hominibus, nec peccato aditum ad nullam utilitatem dedit: nec enim hoc fieri, nolente ipso, non poterat: sed quoniam sciebat utile esse nobis, magis autem omnibus rationabilibus prius quidem malorum et deteriorum fieri aditum, postea autem deleri quidem hæc; introduci autem meliora: ideo in duos status divisit Deus creaturam, præsentem, et futurum; in isto quidem ad immortalitatem et immutabilitatem omnia adducturus, in praesenti vero creaturam in mortem et mutabilitatem interim dimittens. Nam siquidem statim ab initio immortales nos fecerit et immutabiles, nullam differentiam ad irrationabilia haberemus, proprium nescientes bonum. lgnorantes enim mutabilitatem, immutabilitatis ignorabamus bonum; nescientes mortem, immortalitatis lucrum nesciebamus; ignorantes corruptionem, non laudabamus incorruptionem; nescientes passionum gravamen, impossibilitatem non mirabamur (compendiose dicam, ne longum sermonem faciam); nescientes malorum experimentum, bonorum illorum non poteramus scientiam mereri.

English

The Chapter LVIII of Theodore.

Therefore he did not bring death upon men unwillingly or apart from his own judgment, nor did he give an entrance to sin for no benefit; for this could not have happened against his will. But since he knew it was useful for us, or rather for all rational beings, that first indeed an entrance to evils and worse things be given, and afterwards these be destroyed, while better things be introduced, for this reason God divided creation into two states, the present and the future: in that one indeed he will bring all things to immortality and immutability, but in the present he meanwhile lets creation go into death and mutability. For if indeed he had made us immortal and immutable from the beginning, we would have had no difference from irrational beings, not knowing the good that is proper to us. For ignorant of mutability, we did not know the good of immutability; not knowing death, we did not know the gain of immortality; ignorant of corruption, we did not praise incorruption; not knowing the burden of passions, we did not marvel at impassibility (to speak briefly, lest I make a long discourse); not knowing the experience of evils, we could not merit the knowledge of those goods.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:186 · narrative
Source · Latin

Vigilii responsio.

In suprascripto quinquagesimo ociavo capitulo dicitur, ideo Deum dedisse peccato aditum, quia utile hoc sciebat esse nobis, magis autem omnibus rationabilibus, ut prius videlicet malis et deterioribus rebus fieret aditus, postea autem his deletis introduci meliora: et adjicitur: Quia si statim ab initio immortales nos fecisset et immutabiles, nullam differentiam ad irrationabilia haberemus, proprium nescientes bonum. Quibus verbis primum contra regulam Mei Deus asseritur tanquam nobis utile introduxisse peccatum. Secundo cum omnia rationabilia complectitur, hoc etiam de angelis et de universa cœlesti militia, quae ratione est praedita, facit intelligi. Tertio quia illud, quod diabolus ad decipiendum primis hominibus persuaserit, quia, si de ligno prohibito manducarent sicut dii a scientes bonum et malum, beneficii loco asseritur profuisse. Quæ si quis ita sapit, docet, credit aut praedicat, anathema sit.

English

The response of Vigilius.

In the above-written fifty-eighth chapter it is said that God therefore gave an entrance to sin, because he knew this to be useful for us, or rather for all rational beings: namely, that first an entrance should be made for evil and worse things, and afterwards, once these had been destroyed, better things should be introduced. And it is added: For if he had made us immortal and immutable from the beginning, we would have no difference from irrational creatures, not knowing the good that is our own. By these words, first, contrary to the rule of "My God," it is asserted that he introduced sin as though it were useful to us. Second, since he includes all rational beings, he makes this understood also of the angels and of the whole heavenly host, which is endowed with reason. Third, because that which the devil persuaded the first humans to do in order to deceive them—that if they ate from the forbidden tree they would be like gods, knowing good and evil—is asserted to have benefited them in the manner of a benefit. Whoever thinks, teaches, believes, or preaches these things, let him be anathema.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:187 · narrative
Source · Latin

THEODORI CAPITULUM LIX.

Necesse est autem omnia simul rationabilia, invisibilia dico, et nos ipso, quibus mortale quidem est corpus, anima autem per omnia ejusdem generis invisibilibus et rationabilibus substantiis, hic quidem præsentem mutabilitatem pati, ut optima erudiamur doctrina religiositatis, et ad benevolentiam constituamur.

Vigilii responsio.

In suprascripto quinquagesimo nono capitulo dicitur: Necesse est omnia simul rationabilia, invisibilia, et nos ipsos, quibus mortale quidem est corpus, anima autem per omnia ejusdem generis invisibilibus et rationabilibus substantiis, hic quidem præsentem mutationem pati, ut optima erudiamur doctrina religiositatis, et ad benevolentiam constituamur. Quibus verbis si angeli lucis, et universae coelestes invisibilesque virtutes sic mutabilitati hactenus subjacere, sicut humanæ animæ asseruntur, auathema sit.

English

CHAPTER LIX OF THEODORE.

But it is necessary that all rational beings together, I mean the invisible ones, and we ourselves, whose body indeed is mortal, but whose soul is in all respects of the same kind as the invisible and rational substances, here indeed undergo the present mutability, so that we may be taught the best doctrine of religion, and be established in benevolence.

The response of Vigilius.

In the above-written fifty-ninth chapter it is said: It is necessary that all rational beings together, the invisible ones, and we ourselves, whose body indeed is mortal, but whose soul is in all respects of the same kind as the invisible and rational substances, here indeed undergo the present change, so that we may be taught the best doctrine of religion, and be established in benevolence. If by these words the angels of light and all the celestial and invisible powers are asserted to be subject to mutability hitherto, just as human souls are, let him be anathema.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:188 · narrative
Source · Latin

THEODORI CAPITULUM LX.

Nam sciebat quidem quod peccabunt omnimodo, concedebat vero hoc fieri, expedire eis cognoscens, quoniam erat impossibile eum, qui cum fecerit non exstantes, et tantorum quidem demonstraverit dominos, tanta vero bona proposuerit, ut eis fruantur, nec prohibere peccati aditum, si expedire eis hoc cognosceret. Sed enim non erat possibile nos aliter discere peccatum, et passionum molestias, et deteriora, et nostram infirmitatem in his demonstrandam, ad ostendeudam magnitudinem immutabilitatis, quam postea nobis easet donaturus, nisi sic ob initio hæc fuissent a Deo dispensata, ut collatione et experimento infinitorum malorum, bonorum possemus scire magnitudinem, et hujus gratia, ut pote profuturum nobis, peccatum intrare dimittens, magnum in ejus bello auxilium invenit.

Vigilii responsio.

In suprascripto sexagesimo capitulo dicitur quia Deus sciens hominem peccaturum, ideo peccare permiserit, quia hoc ei noverat expedire, et propterea non prohibuisse peccati aditum, quia sic ab initio a Deo fuerit dispensatum, ut collatione et experimento. infinitorum malorum, bonorum possemus scire magnitudinem, et hujus rei gratia, ut pote profuturum nobis, peccatum intrare dimittens, magnum in ejus peccali bello auxilium invenerit homo. Quae verba quoniam aliena sunt a sensu divinæ Scripturæ, ut dicatur, quia peccatum a Deo pro utilitate nobis introductum sit.

English

CHAPTER LX OF THEODORE.

For he knew indeed that they would sin in every way, but he permitted this to happen, knowing it was expedient for them, since it was impossible for him who had made things that did not exist, and had shown them to be lords of such great things, and had set before them such great goods for them to enjoy, not to prohibit the entrance of sin, if he knew this to be expedient for them. But indeed it was not possible for us to learn sin in any other way, and the troubles of passions, and worse things, and our weakness to be demonstrated in these, to show the greatness of the immutability which he was afterward to grant us, unless from the beginning these things had been so dispensed by God, that by comparison and experience of infinite evils, we might be able to know the greatness of goods, and for this reason, as being going to profit us, allowing sin to enter, he found a great help in its battle.

The response of Vigilius.

In the above-written sixtieth chapter it is said that God, knowing that man would sin, therefore permitted him to sin, because he knew this to be expedient for him, and for that reason did not prohibit the entrance of sin, because it was so dispensed by God from the beginning, that by comparison and experience of infinite evils, we might be able to know the greatness of goods, and for this reason, as being going to profit us, allowing sin to enter, man found a great help in its battle. These words, since they are foreign to the sense of divine Scripture, as it is said that sin was introduced by God for our benefit.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:189 · narrative
Source · Latin

Si quis ita sapit, docet, credit aut prædicat, anathema sit. Sancta enim catholica Ecclesia hoc certum tenet et credit, quia Deus et prohibuerit a peccato primum hominem, et per inobedientiam peccatum punierit justo supplicio; sed bene ulens etiam malis nostris, singulari nos remedio, per unigeniti Filii sui incarnationem, passionem, mortem, et resurrectionem, hoc est Domini nostri Jesu Christi, ab omnium peccatorum nexibus liberavit.

His igitur competenter et per orthodoxæ fidei rectitudinem apostolicæ sententiæ auctoritate damnatis, constituimus, ut ex omnibus istis, quae nos Patrum statutis atque traditionibus inhærentes apostolica auctoritate damnavimus, nulla injuriandi præcedentes Patres vel doctores Ecclesiæ (quæ procul dubio scandala sacrosanctæ Ecclesiæ suscitat) præbeatur occasio: anathematizantes omnem ad ordines ecclesiasticos pertinentem, qui Patribus atque doctoribus Ecclesiae contumeliam ex suprascriptis impietatibus quodammodo ascribere vel irrogare voluerit.

English

If anyone thinks, teaches, believes, or preaches otherwise, let him be anathema. For the holy catholic Church holds and believes this as certain: that God both forbade the first man to sin and punished sin committed through disobedience with just punishment; but using even our evils for good, He freed us by a singular remedy, through the incarnation, passion, death, and resurrection of His only-begotten Son, that is, our Lord Jesus Christ, from the bonds of all sins.

Therefore, since these things have been duly condemned by the authority of the apostolic sentence and according to the rectitude of the orthodox faith, we decree that from all those things which we, adhering to the statutes and traditions of the Fathers, have condemned by apostolic authority, no occasion be given for injuring the Fathers or doctors of the Church who came before (which beyond doubt stirs up scandals for the sacrosanct Church): anathematizing every person belonging to the ecclesiastical orders who, on account of the above-written impieties, wishes in any way to ascribe or inflict insult upon the Fathers and doctors of the Church.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:190 · narrative
Source · Latin

Et quoniam prætata dogmata, quæ secundum intellectum de his expositum anathemati atque damnationi subjecimus in eo volumine quod nobis per fraIrem nostrum Benignum episcopum nuper a pietate vestra transmissum sub Theodori Mopsuesteni episcopi perhibentur nomine praenotata; ad hoc sollicitudinis nostræ animum consequenter admonuimus, ut si quid de persona vel nomine memorati Theodori apnd Patres quaesitum sit, vel si qua super ejus nomine ab eis regulariter fuerint constituta sive disposita, diligentissima indagatione quærere curaremus. Et haec investigantes advertimus beatæ recordationis Cyrillum Alexandrinæ civitatis antistitem de persona jam mortui Theodori episcopi Joanni reterendæ memoriae Antiochenæ civitatis episcopo, vel Orientali synodo ad ejus litteras rescribentem, inter alia ita tradidisse: Quæ prolata est in sancta synodo Ephesina detinitio, veluti a Theodoro disposita, sicut offerentes dicebant, nihil habens sanum, evacuavit quidem eam sancta synodus veluti perversarum plenam intelligentiarum, condemnans item eos qui sic sapiunt. Dispensatim vero mentionem viri non fecit, neque eum nominatim anathemati subdidit, neque alios.

English

And since the aforesaid doctrines, which according to the understanding set forth concerning these matters we have subjected to anathema and damnation in that volume which was recently transmitted to us by your Piety through our brother Benignus the bishop, are recorded under the name of Theodore bishop of Mopsuestia; for this reason we have consequently admonished the attention of our solicitude, that if anything concerning the person or name of the aforementioned Theodore has been questioned among the Fathers, or if anything concerning his name has been regularly established or disposed by them, we should take care to seek it out with most diligent investigation. And investigating these matters, we have noticed that Cyril, of blessed memory, bishop of the city of Alexandria, writing back to John, of revered memory, bishop of the city of Antioch, or to the Eastern synod, in response to their letters, concerning the person of the now-dead Theodore the bishop, handed down among other things as follows: The definition brought forth in the holy synod of Ephesus, as though composed by Theodore, as those presenting it said, having nothing sound, the holy synod indeed set it aside as full of perverse understandings, likewise condemning those who hold such views. But by dispensation it made no mention of the man, nor did it subject him by name to anathema, nor others.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:191 · narrative
Source · Latin

Ipsam vero synodum Ephesinam primam sollicite recensentes, nihil de Theodori Mopsuesteni persona referre comperimus, sed symbolum, quod Charisius presbyter illic prodidit, magis quia ab Athanasio et Photio, qui tunc temporis hæretico Nestorio adhaerebant, per Antonium et Jacobum nomina tantum presbyterorum habentes ad Philadelphiorum ecclesias fuerit destinatum: ex quo claret beatum Cyrillum hoc quod per litteras profitetur a prolatoribus scilicet symboli jam defuncti Theodori episcopi nomen fuisse delatum, sua providentia ecclesiasticam moderationem circa mortuum sapientia sacerdotali servantem, noluisse nomen ejus, ne monumentis quidem synodalibus, propter regulam quae de mortuis in sacerdotio servanda est, contineri. Quomodo autem hoc quod supra dixit beatus Cyrillus dispensative factum, Ut minime anathemati nomen viri subjicere voluisset intelligi, ad ecclesiasticam rcgulam porrigendum, in eadem epistola sua subter adjecit, dicens: Sed juste audient, tametsi nolint, qui hujusmodi causas præbent. Obliviscimini vos ipsos, quando adversus cineres arcus extenditis: non enim superest qui apud eos inscriptus est: et me nullus culpet in haec verba progressum, sed cedant valde, nimirum prædecessori.

English

But carefully reviewing the first Ephesine synod itself, we have found that it reports nothing concerning the person of Theodore of Mopsuestia, but rather the creed which the presbyter Charisius produced there, especially because it had been sent by Athanasius and Photius, who at that time were adhering to the heretic Nestorius, through Antonius and Jacobus, bearing only the names of presbyters, to the churches of the Philadelphians. From this it is clear that the blessed Cyril, in what he professes by letter, namely that the name of the already deceased bishop Theodore had been brought forward by the producers of the creed, did not wish, by his own foresight preserving ecclesiastical moderation concerning the dead with priestly wisdom, for his name to be contained even in the synodal records, on account of the rule which must be observed concerning the dead in the priesthood. But how this which the blessed Cyril said above was done by dispensation—so that it might be understood that he was unwilling to subject the man's name to anathema—is to be extended to the ecclesiastical rule, he added below in the same letter of his, saying: But they will hear justly, even if they are unwilling, who provide causes of this kind. You forget yourselves, when you stretch bows against ashes; for he who is inscribed among them no longer survives; and let no one blame me for having proceeded to these words, but let them yield greatly, namely to their predecessor.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:192 · narrative
Source · Latin

Grave est enim insultare defunctis, vel si laici fuerint, nedum illis qui in episcopatu hanc vitam deposuerunt. Justissimum enim apparet prudentibus viris cedere præscienti, Deo scilicet, uniuscujusque voluntatem; et cognoscenti qualiscunque quisque futurus sit. Beatum quinetiam Proclum hujus regiæ civitatis antistitem ita memorati Joannis Antiocheni episcopi similiter constat respondisse rescriptis, dicentem inter alia: Quando enim scripsi tuae sanctitali, oportere aut Theodorum, aut alios quosdam, qui pridem defuncti sunt, anathemati subdi, aut nominatim alicujus feci mentionem? et post pauca. Et illa capitula quae subjecta sunt repuli, ut pote subtililatem non habenlia pietatis: neque autem de Theodoro, neque de alio quoquam qui jam defuncti sunt scripsi, Deo amantissimi, aut utanathematizaretur, aut ut abdicetur. Sed neque charissimus Theodotus, qui a nobis directus est, diaconus talia mandata suscepit. Item ipse beatus Proclus. in epistola ad Maximum diaconum post alia ita dicit: Quomodo igitur per litteras didici nunc, quia Theodori Mopsuestem, et aliorum quorumdam nomina praeposita sunt capitulis ad anathematizandum, cum illi ad Deum jam migraverint: et eos qui jam vitam reliquerunt supervacuum est injuriari post mortem, quos nec vivos aliquando culpavimus.

English

For it is a grave matter to insult the dead, even if they were laymen, much less those who laid down this life in the episcopate. For it appears most just to prudent men to yield to the foreknowledge of God, that is, and to Him who knows what each one will be. It is also established that the blessed Proclus, bishop of this royal city, responded in like manner in his rescripts to the aforementioned John, bishop of Antioch, saying among other things: For when did I write to your holiness that Theodore, or certain others who died long ago, should be subjected to anathema, or did I make mention of anyone by name? And after a few words: And those chapters which were appended I rejected, as not having the subtlety of piety; nor did I write concerning Theodore, or concerning anyone else who has already died, O most beloved of God, either that he should be anathematized or that he should be repudiated. But neither did the most dear Theodotus, the deacon sent by us, receive such instructions. Likewise the same blessed Proclus, in his letter to the deacon Maximus, says among other things: How then have I now learned through letters that the names of Theodore of Mopsuestia and certain others have been placed at the head of chapters for anathematization, when they have already departed to God? And it is superfluous to injure after death those who have left this life, whom we never blamed while they were alive.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:193 · narrative
Source · Latin

Et post pauca: Post subscriptionem autem tomi, et post abjectionem capitulorum, quæ cujus sint ignoramus, continuo praepara diaconum Theodorum venire ad regiam eivitatem.

Perpendat ergo pietatis vestrae sapientia singularis, quia Proclus eruditissimus sacerdotum, et non longe a Theodori Mopsuesteni vita repertus, mala quæ iibenter damnaverat cujus essent se jam tunc protessus cst ignorare. Sed neque in sancto ac venerando Chalcedonensi concilio aliquid de sæpius designati Mopsuesteni Theodori episcopi nomine invenimus statutum vel dictum esse contrarium, dum in relatione, quam eadem vcneranda synodus piae memoriae Marciano tunc imperatori transmisit, quam vos quoque vestris legibus, dum orthodoxa professione unum de sancta Trinitate Christum Deum ac Dominum nostrum confitendum astruitis, ad testimenium laudabiliter adduxistis, litteræ Antiocheni Joannis cum Orientali synodo ad Theodosium tunc pussimæ recordationis principem destinatæ venerabiliter memorentur, quibus Mopsuesteni Theodori episcopi persona, ne post mortem damnari deberet, excusatur.

English

And after a few words: But after the subscription of the tome, and after the rejection of the chapters, which we do not know whose they are, he immediately prepared the deacon Theodore to come to the royal city.

Let therefore the singular wisdom of your Piety consider, that Proclus, most learned of priests, and found not far from the life of Theodore of Mopsuestia, professed even then that he did not know whose were the evils which he had willingly condemned. But neither in the holy and venerable Council of Chalcedon do we find anything established or said contrary to the name of the often-designated bishop Theodore of Mopsuestia, while in the report which that same venerable synod sent to Marcian, then emperor of pious memory, which you also have laudably adduced by your laws as testimony, when by your orthodox profession you establish that Christ our God and Lord is one of the holy Trinity, the letter of John of Antioch with the Eastern synod, destined to Theodosius, then prince of most pious remembrance, is venerably mentioned, by which the person of Theodore, bishop of Mopsuestia, is excused from being condemned after death.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:194 · narrative
Source · Latin

Post haec ampliori cura prospeximus, si quid in his qui jam defuncti sunt, et minime reperiuntur in vita damnati, etiam sanctae recordationis prædecessores nostri decreverint. Quibus inspectis, agnovimus quod hujus cautelæ providentiæque formam veneranda prædecessorum nostrorum sedis apostolicæ præsulum constituta nobis apertissime tradiderunt. Nam beatissimus papa Leo ad Theodorum episcopum Forojuliensem post alia ita dicit: Non necesse est nos eorum qui sic obierunt merita actusque discurrere; cum Dominus Deus noster, cujus judicia nequeunt comprehendi, quod sacerdotale mysterium implere non poterat, suæ justitiæ reservavit. Item beatus Gelasius papa in epistola quam ad episcopos Dardaniae de causa Acacii scripsit, post alia ita dicit: Qui postquam in collegium recidens pravitatis, jure meruit ab apostolica communione secludi, in hac autem persistens damnatione defunctus est, absolutionem, quam superstes nec quæsivit omnino, nec meruit, mortuus jam non potest impetrare. Siquidem ipsis apostolis Christi voce delegatum est: Quæ ligaveritis super terram, et quæ solveritis super terram (Matth. XVIII). Cæterum jam de eo qui in divino est judicio constitutus nobis fas aliud decernere non est, praeter id in quo eum dies supremus invenit.

English

After these things, with greater care we took provision, in case those who have already died and are not found among the living condemned, even our predecessors of holy memory, had decreed anything. Having examined these, we recognized that the venerable constitutions of the bishops of the apostolic see, our predecessors, have most openly handed down to us the form of this caution and providence. For the most blessed Pope Leo, to Theodore bishop of Forum Julii, among other things says thus: There is no need for us to run through the merits and acts of those who have so died; since our Lord God, whose judgments cannot be comprehended, has reserved to his own justice what he could not fulfill as a priestly mystery. Likewise the blessed Pope Gelasius, in the letter which he wrote to the bishops of Dardania concerning the case of Acacius, among other things says thus: He, after falling back into the fellowship of depravity, rightly deserved to be cut off from apostolic communion, but persisting in this condemnation he died; the absolution, which while alive he neither sought at all nor deserved, now dead he cannot obtain. Indeed, to the apostles themselves it was delegated by the voice of Christ: What you bind on earth, and what you loose on earth (Matt. 18). But concerning him who has already been placed in the divine judgment, it is not lawful for us to decree anything else beyond that in which his final day found him.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:195 · narrative
Source · Latin

a Item memoratus beate recordaLionis papa Celasius in gestis synodalibus de Miseni episcopi CuInani absolutione confectis, hoc evidenter edocuit, dicens: Totum quod supra facultatis est modulum, divino judicio relinquamus: non autem nobis poterunt imputare, cur prævaricationis offensam viventibus remittamus; quod Ecclesiæ, Deo largientc, possibile est: nec nos jam mortuis veniam praestare deposcant: quod nobis non esse possibile manifestum est; quia cum dictum sit: Quæ ligaveritis et solveritis super terram, hos, quos super terram jam non esse constat, non humano, sed suo Deus judicio reservavit: nec audet Ecclesia sibimet vindicare, quod ipsis aposlolis conspicit non fuisse concessum: quia alia est causa superstitum, alia defunctorum. Hanc autem regulam et in sanctorum Joannis Constantinopolitani episcopi, quem Chrysostomum vocant, atque Flaviani ejusdem civitatis episcopi, veneranda memoria constat esse servatam, qui licet violenter exclusi sunt, non tamen pro damnatis sunt habiti, eo quod semper inviolatam eorum communionem Romani pontifices servaverunt, nec abscindi ab Ecclesia dici potuerunt vel poterunt, quos sibi inconvulse unitos apostolica indicavit auctoritas.

English

Likewise the aforementioned Pope Celasius of blessed memory, in the synodal acts drawn up concerning the absolution of Misenus bishop of Cumae, clearly taught this, saying: Everything that is beyond the measure of our authority, let us leave to divine judgment; but they will not be able to impute to us why we remit the offense of transgression to the living, which is possible for the Church, God granting it; nor let them demand that we now grant pardon to the dead, which is manifestly not possible for us; because since it was said: What you bind and loose on earth, those whom it is established are no longer on earth God has reserved for his own judgment, not for human judgment; nor does the Church dare to claim for itself what it sees was not granted to the apostles themselves; because one is the case of the living, another of the dead. Moreover, it is established that this rule was also observed in the venerable memory of the saints John bishop of Constantinople, whom they call Chrysostom, and Flavian bishop of the same city, who although they were violently expelled, were nevertheless not regarded as condemned, in that the Roman pontiffs always preserved their communion inviolate, nor could they be said, nor will they be able, to be cut off from the Church, whom the apostolic authority declared united to itself unshaken.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:196 · narrative
Source · Latin

In Eusebii etiam cognomento Pamphili Historiæ libro septimo legitur, Dionysium Alexandrinae civitatis episcopum, qui longe ante fuerat, de Nepote quodam episcopo Ægypti ita fecisse: hic enim Nepos episcopus de mille annis, quibus post primam resurrectionem sanctos cum Christo regnaturos esse beatus Joannes Apostolus in Apocalypsi dicit, scripsisse asseritur, in quibus Judaicum intellectum habuisse narratur. Post cujus mortem, cum ad Dionysium Alexandriae episcopum pervenisset, quod tota ÆgypLUS ipsos libros, quos Nepos reliquerat, veluti magnum aliquod et occultum mysterium se habere pu taret: et pergens ad eum locum (in Arsinoite enim quxslionem ipsam motam fuisse refert) scribensque destruxit eosdem libros atque evertit: Nepotem vero qui eos scripserat, propter hoc maxime quia jam defuncLus fuerat, nulla sit aggressus injuria.Quae si quis latius agnoscere velit in memorato septimo historiæ ejusdem Eusebii libro reperiet.

English

In the seventh book of the History of Eusebius, also surnamed Pamphilus, it is read that Dionysius, bishop of the city of Alexandria, who had lived long before, acted as follows concerning a certain Nepos, bishop of Egypt: for this Nepos, a bishop, is asserted to have written about the thousand years in which, after the first resurrection, the saints are to reign with Christ, as the blessed John the Apostle says in the Apocalypse, and in these writings he is reported to have held a Jewish understanding. After his death, when it had come to Dionysius, bishop of Alexandria, that all Egypt thought it possessed in those very books which Nepos had left behind something great and a hidden mystery, he set out for that place — for he reports that the question itself had been raised in the Arsinoite district — and by writing he destroyed and overturned those same books; but Nepos, who had written them, he did not attack with any injury, chiefly because he had already died. If anyone wishes to know these things more fully, he will find them in the aforementioned seventh book of the same Eusebius's History.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:197 · narrative
Source · Latin

Quibus omnibus diligenter inspectis, quia licet diverso Patres nostri verborum modo, unius tamen ductu intelligentiae, disserentes, illæsas sacerdotum in pace ecclesiastica defunctorum serva vere personas, idemque regulariter apostolicæ sedis quae supra dixiIDUS definiunt constituta: Nulli licere noviter aliquid de mortuorum judicare personis: sed in hoc relinqui, in quo unumquemque dies supremus invenit, et specialiter de Tbeodori Mopsuesteni nomine, quid sancti Patres nostri disposuerint, soperius evidenter expressum est: eum nostra non audemus damnare sententia, sed nec ab alio quopiam condemnari concedimus: absit tamen ut suprascripta capitula dogmatum, quae secundum subjectos intelligentiae senSUi a nobis constat esse damnata, vel quæcunque dicta cujuslibet sine nomine prænotata, evangelicis tamen et apostolicis, ac quatuor synodorum, Nicænæ, Constantinopolitanæ, Ephesinæ primæ, atque Chalcedonensis, et apostolicae sedis non congruentia consonaque doctrinis, non solum sensu, sed vel etiam aure patiamur admittere.

English

Having carefully examined all these things, since our Fathers, though speaking with a different manner of words, yet with one guiding understanding, preserve inviolate the persons of priests who have died in the peace of the Church, and the same constitutions of the apostolic see which I mentioned above define according to rule: that it is permitted to no one to judge anything newly concerning the persons of the dead, but that this is to be left in that state in which each one's final day found him, and especially concerning the name of Theodore of Mopsuestia, what our holy Fathers decreed has been shown above with evident clarity: we do not presume to condemn him by our sentence, nor do we grant that he be condemned by anyone else. Far be it, however, that we should allow to be admitted, not only in understanding but even in hearing, the above-written chapters of doctrines which are established by us to have been condemned according to the underlying sense of their meaning, or any whatsoever statements of anyone, set down without a name, which are not in agreement and harmony with the evangelical and apostolic doctrines, and those of the four synods—Nicaea, Constantinople, Ephesus the first, and Chalcedon—and of the apostolic see.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:198 · narrative
Source · Latin

De scriptis vero quae sub viri venerabilis Theodoreti quondam episcopi nomine proferuntur, miramur primum, cur necesse sit ejus sacerdotis nomine in obtrectationem quidquam cujuslibet studio devocari: qui ante centum et amplius annos in sanctae ac venerandae Chalcedonensis synodi judicio constitutus sine aliqua cunctatione subscripsit, et beatissimi papæ Leonis epistolis prona devotione consensit. Dehinc cum existerent tunc Dioscorus et Ægyptii episcopi, qui eum dicerent sanctum Cyrillum anathematizasse, et eumdem Theodoretum etiam hæreticum esse, tameo sancti Patres nostri haec audientes, diligentissime eodem Theodoreto posthac examinatione discusso, et praesente a praesentibus inquisito, nihil aliud ab eo exegisse noscuntur, nisi ut statim Nestorium ejusque impia dogmata anathematizaret atque damnaret, hoc sibi tantummodo sufficere judicantes, quod ille coram universo concilio faciens, Nestorium cum dogmatibus suis, universis Patribus audientibus, clara voce damnavit.

English

But concerning the writings which are brought forward under the name of the venerable man Theodoret, formerly bishop, we wonder first why it should be necessary for anything to be brought forth to the disparagement of that priest's name by anyone's zeal; he who, more than a hundred years ago, having been established in the judgment of the holy and venerable synod of Chalcedon, subscribed without any hesitation, and with ready devotion consented to the letters of the most blessed Pope Leo. Then, although Dioscorus and the Egyptian bishops existed at that time, who said that Saint Cyril had anathematized him, and that the same Theodoret was even a heretic, yet our holy Fathers, hearing these things, after the same Theodoret had afterwards been most diligently examined by scrutiny, and questioned in person by those present, are known to have demanded nothing else from him except that he immediately anathematize and condemn Nestorius and his impious doctrines, judging this alone sufficient for themselves, that he, doing so before the whole council, with all the Fathers hearing, condemned Nestorius with his doctrines in a clear voice.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:199 · narrative
Source · Latin

Ex quo evidenter apparet, quia quidquid sit vel fuerit sub cujuslibetprolatum nomine, quod impii Nestorii videatur concordare dogmatibus, hoc tunc in illo sancto concilio a viro venerabili Theodoreto fuerit sine dubitatione damnatum: et sit valde contrarium, et Chalcedonensis synodi judicio indubitabilitcr inimicum, quædam Nestoriana dogmata nunc sub ejus sacerdotis nomine condemnari, qui cum sanctis Patribus eumdem impium Nestorium et cxsecrabilia ejus dogmata (sicut diximus) tunc apertissime anathematizavit. Quid enim aliud est, mendaces aut simulantes professionem rectæ Mei Patres in sancta Chałcedonensi synodo residentes oslendere, quam dicere aliquos ex eis similia sapuisse Nestorio, quorum judicio videas Nestorium ejusque dogmata fuisse damnata.

English

From this it clearly appears that whatever may be or may have been brought forward under anyone's name which seems to agree with the doctrines of the impious Nestorius, was then without doubt condemned in that holy council by the venerable man Theodoret; and it is utterly contrary, and indisputably hostile to the judgment of the synod of Chalcedon, that certain Nestorian doctrines should now be condemned under the name of that priest, who together with the holy Fathers then most openly anathematized the same impious Nestorius and his execrable doctrines, as we have said. For what else is it to show the Fathers residing in the holy synod of Chalcedon as liars or pretenders of a right confession, than to say that some of them held the same opinions as Nestorius, by whose judgment you may see that Nestorius and his doctrines were condemned.

tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:200 · narrative
Source · Latin

Nec illud arbitrandum est, quia sanctæ memoriæ Cyrilli injuriis per duodecim capitulorum ejus reprehensionem a viro venerabili Theodoreto (ut putatur) ingesta beatissimi Patres nostri in sancta synodo Chalcedonensi neglexerint, sed aut (ut pote rebus de proximo gestis cuncta præ oculis habentes Theodorctum nihil tale fecisse probavcrunt, aut exemplum ipsius sanctæ memoriae Cyrilli judicaverunt esse sequendum, qui post multa et gravia contra se ab Orientalibus apud Ephesum scripto gesta, tempore quo cum ipsis in concordiam remeavit, tanquam si acta non fuissent, pacis amore, silentio dereliquit; ut impleret utique illud apostolicum dictum, quo Corinthiis scribit, dicens: Cui enim aliquid donastis, et ego (II Cor. II). Nam et illud sancta synodus Chalcedonensis intendisse credenda est, quia dum doctrinam sancti Cyrilli ea epistolis ejus in eadem synodo reseratis atque receptis memoratus episcopus Theodoretus ita devota mente suscepit, ut doctrinæ quoque ejus ad laudandam bcatissimi papæ Leonis epistolam testimoniis uteretur, etiamsi in cum injurias intulisse constaret, plenissime satisfecisse videretur, illius venerabiliter amplectendo fidem, cujus falso fuerat suspicatus errorem.

English

Nor should it be thought that our most blessed Fathers in the holy synod of Chalcedon disregarded the injuries inflicted upon Cyril of holy memory through the censure of his twelve chapters by the venerable man Theodoret (as is supposed); but either—since the matters had been conducted so recently that everything was before their eyes—they proved that Theodoret had done no such thing, or they judged that the example of Cyril of holy memory himself was to be followed, who, after many grave acts drawn up in writing against him by the Easterners at Ephesus, at the time when he returned to concord with them, left them in silence out of love of peace, as if they had not been done; so that he might fulfill that apostolic saying which he writes to the Corinthians: "For to whom you have forgiven anything, I also forgive" (II Cor. 2). For it must also be believed that the holy synod of Chalcedon had this in view: that when the doctrine of Saint Cyril, in his letters unsealed and received in that same synod, was so devoutly accepted by the aforementioned bishop Theodoret that he even used testimonies from his doctrine to praise the letter of the most blessed Pope Leo, then even if it were established that he had inflicted injuries upon him, he would seem to have made fullest satisfaction by venerably embracing the faith of him whose error he had falsely suspected.

Citation. Tergwame, “Epistolae Et Decreta”, tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1:1, machine-draft, 2026. https://naxiai.com/christian/works/tmp1171.tmp1171.opp-lat1#s1
Colophon. Source: ogl-pl · licence: Available under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License · model: deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash:floor · provider: Baidu · cost: $0.0561 · generated 2026-11-15.