De conveniendis Donatistis Decretum Carthaginenlis ex tota Africa concilii, habiti Theodosio Augusto et Rumorido V. C. con sulibus, VIII cal. septemb..
Aurelius episcopus dixit: Quod in tractatum venit Charitatis vestrae, puto hoc ecclesiasticis gestis esse firmandum. Professio enim vestrum omnium hoc deprompsit, debere unumquemque nostrum in civitate sua per se convenire Donatistarum praepositos, aut adjungere sibi vicinum collegam, ut pariter eos in singulis quibusque civitatibus vel locis, per magistratus vel seniores locorum conveniant. Hoc si omnibus placet, edicatur. Ab universis episcopis dictum est: Omnibus placet, et omnes hoc subscriptione nostra firmavimus. Petimus eliam, ut epistolis ad judices de concilio mittendis pro omnibus subscribat Sanctitas tua. Aurelius episcopus dixit: Si videtur Charitati vestra, forma conventionis eorum recitetur, ut hunc tenorem prosecutionis omnes, si placuerit, teneamus. Ab universis episcopis dictum est: Recitetur. Laetus notarius recitavit.
Decree of the Council of Carthage, held from all Africa, concerning the summoning of the Donatists, in the consulship of Theodosius Augustus and Rumoridus, most illustrious man, on the eighth day before the Kalends of September.
Bishop Aurelius said: What has come up for discussion before your Charity, I think ought to be confirmed in the ecclesiastical acts. For the declaration of all of you has brought this forth, that each of us ought in his own city personally to meet with the leaders of the Donatists, or join to himself a neighboring colleague, so that together they may summon them in each and every city or place, through the magistrates or the elders of the places. If this pleases all, let it be decreed. All the bishops said: It pleases all, and we have all confirmed this by our subscription. We also ask that your Holiness subscribe on behalf of all to the letters to be sent from the council to the judges. Bishop Aurelius said: If it seems good to your Charity, let the form of their summons be read out, so that we may all, if it pleases, hold to this tenor of procedure. All the bishops said: Let it be read out. Laetus the notary read it out.
Forma conventionis Donatistarum. I
Ille episcopus ecclesiae catholicæ dixit: Quid de auctoritate illius amplissimae sedis impetraveri-. mus, petimus Gravitatem vestram recitari, et gestis innecti, atque in effectum deduci jubeatis. Recitata autem jussione atque actis innexa, dicat ille episcopus Eccle sici! catholicæ': Mandalum ad Donatistas pcr vestram Gravitatem perferendum audire, et actis inserere, ct ad cos perferre dignemini, eorumque responsionem rursus apud acta vestra nobis insinuare. Convenimus vos ex concilii nostri catholici auctoritate missi, de vestra correctione gaudere cupientes, considerantes Domini charitatem, qui dixit, Beati pacifici, quia ipsi filii Dei vocabuntur (Hail/h v, 9): ct admonuit per prophetam, etiam his qui dicunt se fratres nostros non esse, dicere nos debere, Fratre. nostri estis (Isai. LXVI, a, sec. LXX).
Form of the agreement of the Donatists. I
That bishop of the catholic church said: What we have obtained concerning the authority of that most ample see, we ask your Gravity to have recited, and inserted into the proceedings, and to order to be put into effect. But when the order has been recited and inserted into the proceedings, let that bishop of the catholic church say: Deign to hear the mandate to be carried to the Donatists through your Gravity, and to insert it into the proceedings, and to carry it to them, and to make known to us their response again in your proceedings. We have come to you, sent by the authority of our catholic council, desiring to rejoice in your correction, considering the charity of the Lord, who said, Blessed are the peacemakers, for they shall be called sons of God (Matt. 5:9): and he admonished through the prophet that even to those who say they are not our brothers, we ought to say, You are our brothers (Isa. 66:5, according to the LXX).
nanc ergo pacificati ex charitate venientem commonitionem nostram contemnerenou debetis, ut si quid veritatis hahere vos arbitramini, non dubitetis asserere: id est, ut congregato vestro concilio deligatis ex vobis, quibus caussam assertionis vestræ committatis; ut et nos possimus hoc facere, ut ctiam de nostro concilio deligantur, qui cun cis quos delegeritis, constituto loco et lempore, quidquid quæstionis est, quod vestram a nobis separat communionem, cum pace discutiant; et tandem aliquando adjuvante Domino Deo nostro finem velernosus crror accipiat, ne propter animositatem hominum infirmæanimæ ct iguari populi sacrilega dissensione dispereant. Si cnim hoc fraterne acceperitis, veritas facile dilucescet: si autem hoc facere nolueritis, diffidentia vestra facile irinotescet.
Libellus a. eodem Carthaginensi totius Africæ concito datus Septimino proconsuli,
Therefore, having been made peaceable, you ought not to despise our admonition coming from charity, so that if you think you hold any of the truth, you do not hesitate to assert it: that is, that having gathered your council, you choose from among you those to whom you may entrust the cause of your assertion; so that we too may be able to do this, that from our council as well there may be chosen those who, with those whom you have chosen, at an appointed place and time, may discuss in peace whatever question it is that separates your communion from us; and so that at last, with the help of our Lord God, that wretched error may receive an end, lest on account of the animosity of men, weak souls and the ignorant populace perish in sacrilegious dissension. For if you receive this in a brotherly spirit, the truth will easily shine forth; but if you are unwilling to do this, your lack of confidence will easily become known.
A little book given by the same council of Carthage of all Africa, assembled, to Septiminus the proconsul,
Æquitatem tuam petimus, Septimine vir clarissime, proconsulum summc sublimis. Multa contra divinas humanasque leges ab hærceticis de partc Donati Ecclesia catholica sustinct, quæ si vel anterioribus vel recentioribus imperialibua jussis prohibenda ct tollenda postulanda veliemus, nequaquam audere debe rent de nostris actionibus conqueri, scientes se, cum nulla tali legc adjuvarentur, schismaticos tamen suos Maximianistas per judicum jussa locis ac scdibuseorum pellendos exturbandosque curasse. Verumtamen nos saluti corum et nostrae existimationi pacifice consuicntes, propter charitatem qua christiani sumus, lcnitcr eos volumus admonere, ut errorem suum cogitando et agnoscendo non negligant: aut si pulant sc hahere aliquid veritatis, non cam furiosis Circumcellionum violentiis contra publicam quietem, sed tranquilla rationis redditione defendant. Unde pctimus Sublimitatem luam, ut cum eos de bac rc per magistratus sivc in civilatibus, sivc in pertinenlibus territoriis admonere voluerimus, copiam nobis præberi gestorum, ct cos ex allegntione nostra honeste conveniri præcipias: quod consecuti agamus Excellentiæ tuæ apud Deum uheres gratias. Dat. ab univcrsis episcopis catholicis ex concilio Carthaginensi D. N. Theodosio PP. Augusto ct Rumorido V. C. consulibus, idibus septembris, Carthagine.
We ask your fairness, Septiminus, most distinguished man, exalted in the office of proconsul. The Catholic Church endures many things from the heretics of the party of Donatus contrary to divine and human laws; and if we wished to demand that these be prohibited and abolished by either earlier or more recent imperial orders, they should by no means dare to complain about our actions, knowing that they, when they were aided by no such law, nevertheless took care that their own schismatics, the Maximianists, be driven out and expelled from their places and seats by the orders of judges. Yet we, peacefully consulting for their salvation and our own good repute, on account of the charity by which we are Christians, wish gently to admonish them, that by thinking upon and acknowledging their error they not neglect it; or if they think they hold any of the truth, let them defend it not by the frenzied violence of the Circumcellions against the public peace, but by the calm rendering of reason. Wherefore we ask Your Sublimity, that when we wish to admonish them concerning this matter through the magistrates either in the cities or in the dependent territories, you provide us the opportunity of official records, and order that they be courteously summoned by our allegation; having obtained this, we will give abundant thanks to Your Excellency before God. Given by all the Catholic bishops from the Council of Carthage, in the consulship of our lord Theodosius, perpetual Augustus, and of Rumoricus, most illustrious man, on the Ides of September, at Carthage.
Septiminus vir clarissimus proconsul dixit: In quolibet loco antistitibus legis venerabilis ob quietis imperium gestor uni collidendorum tribuitur facultas: hoc etiam tenore hujus præceptionis limitato, ut intelligant se deviæ plebis niagislris I salubriter petentibus propriæ persuasionis ratiocinia persolvere; ut rebus in medio prolatis amica legis moderatio servetur, superstiti one supplosa.
C onrilii Carthaginensis adversus Donatistas ad Honorium imperatorem legatio, et Com monitorium legatis datum.
Cloriosissimo Imperatore Honorio Augusto vi consule, xvi 'alendas julias, Carthagine in basilica regionis secundæ. In hoc concilio legationem susceperunt Theasius et Evodius contra Donatistas: in quo concilio insertum est Commonitorium quod ita se continet.
Commonitorium fratribus Theasio et Evodio legalis ex Carthaginensi concilio ad gloriosissimos religiosissimosque principes missis.
Septiminus, most distinguished man, proconsul, said: In whatever place, to the presiding officers of the venerable law, for the sake of the command of peace, the power of bringing parties into conflict is granted to the agent; and this too with the tenor of this precept limited, so that they may understand that they are to pay back the reasonings of their own persuasion to the teachers of the straying people when these request it salubriously; so that, with matters brought into the open, the friendly moderation of the law may be preserved, superstition having been trampled down.
The embassy of the Council of Carthage against the Donatists to the Emperor Honorius, and the Commonitorium given to the legates.
In the consulship of the most glorious Emperor Honorius Augustus, consul for the sixth time, on the sixteenth day before the Kalends of July, at Carthage in the basilica of the second region. In this council Theasius and Evodius undertook the embassy against the Donatists; and in this council the Commonitorium was inserted, which is contained as follows.
Commonitorium to the brothers Theasius and Evodius, legates sent from the Council of Carthage to the most glorious and most religious princes.
Cum Domini auxilio piissimos imperatores adierint, eis insinuent, quemadmodum plena fiducia secundum supcrioris anni concilium Donatistarum praepositi actis municipalibus sunt conventi, ut si confiderent de assertionibus suis, eleetis ex suo numero aliquibus idoncis, nobiscum pacifice conferrent, et mansuetudine christiana, si quid veritatis tenerent, non ambigerent demonstrare; quo ita sinceritas catholica, quæ jampridem superioribus temporibus claruit, nunc quoque per imperitiam vel pertinaciam resistentibus innotesceret. Sed quia diffidentia premebantur, nihil pene ausi sunt respondere. Unde quia impletum est erga eos episcopale ac pacificum officium, et illi qui veritati respondcre nequiverunt, ad immanes violentias sunt conversi, ita ut inultos episcopos multosque clericos, ut de laicis taceamus, insidiis oppresserint, ecclesias etiam aliquas invaserint, aliquas invadcre pertentavcriut: ipsorum jam clementiæ est consulere, ut Ecclesia catholica, quæ eos religioso utero in Christo genuit, pt fidei firmitate nutrivit, eorum etiam prospectione muniatur, IIC temerarii homines religiosis temporibus infirmos populos terrendo praevaleant, quoniam seducendo depravare non possunt.
With the Lord's help, let them approach the most pious emperors and inform them how, with full confidence according to the council of the previous year, the leaders of the Donatists were summoned by municipal records, so that if they trusted in their own assertions, they might choose certain suitable men from their number and confer peacefully with us, and with Christian gentleness, if they held any truth, they would not hesitate to demonstrate it; whereby the sincerity of the catholic faith, which has long been clear in former times, might now also become known to those resisting through ignorance or stubbornness. But because they were weighed down by distrust, they scarcely dared to respond at all. Therefore, since the episcopal and peaceable duty has been fulfilled toward them, and those who were unable to respond to the truth have turned to monstrous violence, so that they have oppressed many bishops and many clerics by ambushes—to say nothing of the laity—and have even invaded certain churches and attempted to invade others, it is now for their clemency to take counsel that the catholic Church, which brought them forth in Christ from a religious womb and nourished them with firmness of faith, may also be protected by their foresight, lest rash men in religious times prevail by terrifying weak peoples, since by seducing they cannot corrupt them.
Nota est enim, cl sæpe legibus conclamata Circumcellionum, qua furunt, detestabilis manus, quoe etiam ipsorum religiosissimorum supra principum frequentibus sanctionibus condemnata est; adversus quorum furorcm possemus non insolita, nee a Scripturis sanctis aliena inipetrarc præsidia, quando apostolus Paulus, sicut in Apostolorum Actibus fidelibus notum est, lactiosorum conspirationem militari ciiam submovit auxilio (Act. XXIII, 12-33). Sed nos illud poscimus, ut catholicis Ecclesiarum ordinibus I per civitates siugulas et vicinorum quorumque possessorum per diversa loca sine ulla dissimulatione tuitio præbcatur. Simul etiam petendum, ut illam legem quæ a religiosæ memoriæ eorum patre Theodosio dc auri libris decem in ordinatores vel ordinatos hæreticos, scu cliam in possessores ubi eorum congregatio deprehendilur, promulgata est, ita deinceps confinnari præcipiant. ut in cas valeat, contra quos propter coruui insidias Catholici provocati contestationem deposuerint: ut Inc saltem terrore a schismatica vel hæretica pravitate desistant, qui consideratione æterni supplicii emendari corrigique dissimulant.
For the detestable band of the Circumcellions is well known, so often denounced by laws, in the madness with which they rage, and it has even been condemned by the frequent sanctions of those most religious emperors above; against whose fury we could obtain no unusual protections, nor ones foreign to the Holy Scriptures, since the apostle Paul, as is known to the faithful in the Acts of the Apostles, even removed the conspiracy of the riotous by military aid (Acts 23:12-33). But we ask this: that protection be provided without any dissimulation to the catholic orders of the churches throughout individual cities and to the neighboring landowners in various places. At the same time it must also be asked that they order that law which was promulgated by their father of religious memory, Theodosius, concerning ten pounds of gold against those who ordain or are ordained as heretics, or even against landowners where their congregation is discovered, to be confirmed henceforth in such a way that it be valid against those against whom catholics, provoked by their plots, have lodged a formal complaint; so that at least by this terror those may desist from schismatic or heretical depravity who, out of consideration for eternal punishment, dissemble to be amended and corrected.
Petendum etiam, ut lex quæ hæreticis vel ex donationibus vel ex testamentis aliquid capiendi vel rclinquendi denegat facultatem, ab corum quoque pietate haetenus repetatur, ut eis relinquendi vel sumendi jus adimat, qui pertinaciæ furore cæcati in Donatislarum crrorc perseverare voluerint. Cæterum illis qni consideratione unitatis ct pacis se corrigcre volucrint, absque interdicto hujus Icgis, capicudæ hæreditatis aditus pateat, si adhuc in errore hæretico constitutis aliquid ante donationis vcl hæreditatis obvenit: his sane cxcoptis, qui lite pulsati putaverint ad Catholicam transeundum; quia de talibus credibile est, non metu cælestis ju licii potius quam terreni commodi aviditate unitatem catholicam præoptasse. Ad hæc autem omnia, præsidio opus cst potestatum suarum quarumcumque provinciarum. Sane pro utilitalibus Ecclesiæ quidquid intellxerint prodesse, agendi ct imperandi liberam decernimus legationem. Illud præterea cuuctis nohis placuit. ut litteræ de coctu nostro ad gloriosissimos Imperatores et emientissimas potestates dirigantur, quibus instruantur nostro omnium consensu ad beatissimum comitatum legatos a nobis esse dirccios. Sed quia iisdem litteris ab omnibus subscribit Ardissimum est, ne singulorum subscriptionibus eædem epistolæ onerentur; petimus, frater Aureli, ut iisdem tua charitas nostro omnium nomino subscribere dignetur. Et subscripscrunt.
It must also be sought that the law which denies to heretics the capacity to receive or leave anything by way of donations or testaments be requested from their Piety, in the same manner as hitherto, so that it take away the right of leaving or receiving from those who, blinded by the fury of pertinacity, have wished to persevere in the error of the Donatists. Otherwise, for those who by consideration of unity and peace have wished to correct themselves, let the approach to receiving an inheritance lie open without the interdict of this law, if while still established in heretical error something came to them by way of donation or inheritance: with those, of course, excepted who, having been assailed by lawsuit, have thought of passing over to the Catholic Church; because concerning such persons it is credible that they preferred the Catholic unity not from fear of heavenly judgment but rather from greed for earthly advantage. But for all these things there is need of the protection of their powers in whatever provinces. Indeed, for the utilities of the Church, whatever they understand to be advantageous, we decree that they have free legation to act and to command. Moreover, it has pleased all of us that letters from our assembly be directed to the most glorious Emperors and the most eminent powers, by which they may be instructed that by the consent of all of us legates have been directed by us to the most blessed court. But because it is most arduous for the same letters to be subscribed by all, lest those same epistles be burdened by the subscriptions of individuals, we ask, brother Aurelius, that your Charity deign to subscribe to the same in the name of all of us. And they subscribed.
Aurelius episcopus ecclesiic Carthaginensis huic decreto consensi et subscripsi. Similiter et cæteri episcopi subscripserunt. Litteræ etiam ad judices miuendæ sunt, ut donec Dominus legatos ad nos redire permittat, tuitiones per ordines civitatum et posses.sores praediorum Ecclesiæ catholicæ impertiant.
Honorii lex in rebaptizantes.
Impp. AaCADltS, HONORIUS et THEODOSIUS AAA. Hadriano PF. P.
Adversarios catholicae fidei exstirpare hujus decreti auctoritate prospeximus. Ideoque intercidendam specialiler eam sectam nova constitutione censuimus, quae ne haeresis vocaretur, appellationem schismatis, praeferebat. In tantum enim sceleris progressi dicuntur ii quos Donatistas vocant, ut Baptisma sacrosanctum, mysteriis recalcalis, temeritale noxia iterent; et homines semel, ut traditum est, munere divinitatis ablulos, contagione profanæ repctitionis infecerint. Ita contigit ut hæresis ex schismate nasceretur. Inde,Male credulas mentes ad spem secundæ indulgentiæ blandus error invitat. Facilc est enim persuader e peceantibus, veniani prius præstitam denuo posse præstari; quæ si concedi iterum codern modo potest, non intelligimus cur tertio denegetur. Ili vero et servos vei homines juri proprio subditos iterati Baptismatis polluunt sacrilegio.
Aurelius, bishop of the church of Carthage, consented to this decree and subscribed. Similarly the other bishops also subscribed. Letters are also to be sent to the judges, so that, until the Lord permits the legates to return to us, they may grant protections through the orders of the cities and the possessors of the estates to the catholic Church.
The law of Honorius against those who rebaptize.
Emperors Arcadius, Honorius, and Theodosius, Augusti, to Hadrianus, Praetorian Prefect.
We have seen fit by the authority of this decree to extirpate the adversaries of the catholic faith. And therefore we have judged that that sect especially must be cut off by a new constitution, which, so that it not be called a heresy, put forward the name of schism. For those whom they call Donatists are said to have advanced to such a degree of wickedness that they repeat the most sacred Baptism, with the mysteries trampled underfoot, by harmful temerity; and men once washed, as has been handed down, by the gift of divinity, they have infected with the contagion of profane repetition. Thus it has come about that a heresy was born from schism. Hence, a flattering error invites poorly believing minds to the hope of a second indulgence. For it is easy to persuade sinners that pardon, once granted, can be granted again; which if it can be conceded a second time in the same manner, we do not understand why it should be denied a third time. But they also pollute slaves or men subject to their own right with the sacrilege of repeated Baptism.
Quare hac lege sancimus, ut quisquis posthac fuerit rebaptizasse detectus, judici qui provincias praesidet offeratur, ut facultatum omnium publicatione mulctatus, inopiæ poenam, qua in perpetuum alliciatur expendat. lta ut filiis corum, si a palernae societatis pravitate dissenliunt, ca quæ fuerint paterna non pereant; ut si ipsos forsitan sævitas paternæ depravitatjs implicavit, nc reverti jam ad catholitam religionem malunt, adipiscendorum his bonorum, copia non negetur. Ea præterea Joe:. seu j rædia, quæ feralibus sacrilegiis deinceps constiterit præbuisse secretum, fisci viribus applicentur; si tamen ominus aut domina, ant præsens fortc fuisse, aut consensum praestitisse probetur: quos quidem inusta etiam per sententiam notabit infamia. Si vero his nesciis per conduelorem, procuratoremve corum in dono agitatum hujusmodi facinus comprobatur, præjudicio a praediorum publicatione suspenso, impliciti sceleris auetores eoerciti plumbo exsilium, in quo omni vitae suæ tempore afficiantur accipient.
Therefore by this law we sanction that whoever hereafter is detected to have rebaptized shall be handed over to the judge who presides over the provinces, so that, mulcted by the confiscation of all his property, he may undergo the penalty of want, by which he is to be held fast forever. So that their children, if they dissent from the depravity of their father's society, may not lose those things which were their father's; and if perhaps the savagery of their father's depravity has entangled them, so that they no longer wish to return to the catholic religion, the abundance of obtaining these goods is not to be denied them. Moreover, those estates or properties which it is established have hereafter given concealment to the deadly sacrileges shall be applied to the strength of the fisc; if however the master or mistress is proven either to have been present or to have given consent; whom indeed a sentence shall also brand with infamy. But if, with these unaware, through their conductor or procurator such a crime is proven to have been carried out on the estate, with the prejudice suspended from the confiscation of the estates, the authors implicated in the crime, having been coerced, shall receive exile with lead, in which they are to be afflicted for the whole time of their life.
Ac nc forsitam sit liberum conscientiam piacularis perpetrati intra domesticos parietes silentio cclarc secreto, his qui forsitan ad rebaptizandum cogentur, refugiendi ad Ecclesiam catholicam sil facultas, ut cjus præsidio adversus hujus criminis et societatis auctores, attributæ libertatis præsidio defendautur, liceatque his sub hac conditione fidem tueri, quam extorquere ab invitis domini tenlaverint. Nec assertorcs dogmatis catholici, ea qua cæteros qui in potestate sunt positi, oporlet ad facinus lege constringi; et maxime conveniL mncs homines sine ullo discrimine conditionis ant status infusæ cælitus sanctitatis esse custodes. Sciant ii vero qui a supradictis iterare Baptisma non timuerint, aut qui consentiendo hoc facinus propria hujus societatis permixtione damnaverint, non solum testandi sibi, verum adipiscendi aliquid sub specie donationis vel agitandorum contractuum in perpetuum copiamdenegatam, nisi pravæ mentis errorem revcrtendo ad veram fidcm consilii emendatione correxerint. Illos quoque par nihilominus poena constringat, qui memoratorum interdictis coetibus seu ministeriis præbuerint conniventiam: ita ut moderatores provinciarum, si in contemptum sanctionis hujusmodi consensam putaverim commodandum, sciant se viginti librarum auri poena esse muletandos. Officia etiam sua simili condemnatione subjuganda.
And lest perchance it be free for the consciousness of an atrocious crime to be concealed in secret silence within private walls, let there be the opportunity of fleeing to the Catholic Church for those who perchance are compelled to rebaptize, so that by her protection they may be defended against the authors of this crime and society, by the protection of the liberty attributed to them, and let it be permitted them under this condition to guard the faith which the lords have attempted to extort from the unwilling. Nor should the assertors of the catholic dogma be constrained by law to a crime in the same manner as the others who are placed in power; and it is especially fitting that all men, without any distinction of condition or status, be guardians of the holiness infused from heaven. But let those know who have not feared to repeat Baptism after the aforesaid persons, or who by consenting have condemned this crime by their own mingling in this society, that not only the power of testifying is denied them in perpetuity, but also of acquiring anything under the appearance of a donation or of conducting contracts, unless by returning to the true faith they correct the error of a depraved mind by amendment of counsel. Let the same penalty likewise constrain those also who have given connivance to the forbidden assemblies or ministries of the aforementioned: so that the governors of the provinces, if they should think that consent is to be lent in contempt of a sanction of this kind, may know that they are to be mulcted by a penalty of twenty pounds of gold. Let their offices also be subjected to similar condemnation.
Principales vel defensores civitatum, nisi id quod præcipimus fuerint exsecuti, vel his præsentibus Ecclesiæ catholicae vis fuerit illata, eadem mulcta sc noverint attinendos. Dat. prid. idus febr. Raven. Stilichone II ei Anthemio Coss.
Aliae leges Honorii in Donatistas eodem anno datæ, exstant supra aute libros contra cresconium, col. 445-446.
Decretum Concilii habiti Stilichone iterum et Anthemio viris clarissimis consulibus, cal. septembris, Carthagine in basilica Regio nis secundæ.
Ut quia apud Carthaginem tanturi unitas facta esf, dentur etiani littoræ ad judices, ut et in aliis provincii; et civitatihus operam impendi jubeant unitati. Ut gratiarum actiones de Carthaginensi Ec clesia pro universa Africa, de exclusione Donatistarum, cum episcoporum litteris ad comitatum mittantur. Recitatæ sunt litteræ papa; Innocentii: ut episcopi ad transmarina pergere facile non debeant; quod hoc ipsam episcoporum sententiis confirmatur. Ut propter gratiarum actionem et exelusionem Donatistarum duo clerici Ecclesiæ Carthaginensis ad comitatum mitlanlur.
The leading men or defenders of cities, unless they shall have carried out what we command, or unless, in their presence, force has been inflicted on the Catholic Church, let them know that they are liable to the same penalty. Given on the day before the ides of February at Ravenna, in the consulship of Stilicho for the second time and of Anthemius.
Other laws of Honorius against the Donatists given in the same year stand above, before the books against Cresconius, col. 445-446.
Decree of the council held in the consulship of Stilicho for the second time and of Anthemius, most illustrious men, on the kalends of September, at Carthage in the basilica of the Second Region.
That, since unity has been brought about at Carthage, letters be also given to the judges, so that in other provinces and cities as well they may be ordered to devote effort to unity. That thanksgivings be sent to the court, together with the letters of the bishops, concerning the Carthaginian Church on behalf of all Africa and concerning the exclusion of the Donatists. The letters of Pope Innocentius were read: that bishops ought not easily to set out for overseas regions; and this same thing is confirmed by the judgments of the bishops. That, on account of the thanksgiving and the exclusion of the Donatists, two clerics of the Church of Carthage be sent to the court.
Decretum Concilii habiti Honorio VII et Theo dosio II Augustis Coss. idibus juniis Car thagine in basilica regionis secundm.
Ut illæ plebes quæ conversæ sunt a Donatistis et habuerunt episcopos, sine dubio, inconsulto concilio habere mercantur. Quæ autem plebes habuerunt episcopum, et eo defuncto voluerint non episcopum preprium habere, sed ad alicujus episcopi dioecesim per. tinere, nun eis esse denegandum. Necnon et illud suggestum est, quod plebes ante legem Imperatorum de unitate latam, quicumque converterunt episcopi ad Catholicam, ipsi cas obtinere debeant. Veram a lege unitatis et deinceps, oporteat universas Ecclesias vindicare sibi episcopos catholicos eorum locorum, ad quos loca sub hæreticis pertinebant, vel conversorum ad Catholicam, vel non conversorum hæreticorum, et diæceses, et si qua forte sunt instrumenta Ecclesiæ, vel ad ejus jus pertinentia. Qni vero aliqua usurpaverunt post legem, usurpata conventi restituant.
The decree of the council held in the consulship of the Augusti Honorius VII and Theodosius II, on the Ides of June, at Carthage in the basilica of the second region.
That those congregations which have been converted from the Donatists and had bishops should without doubt, with the council not consulted, deserve to have them. But those congregations which had a bishop, and, he being dead, wished not to have a bishop of their own, but to belong to the diocese of some bishop, this is not to be denied them. Moreover, it was also suggested that congregations which, before the law of the Emperors concerning unity was passed, were converted by bishops to the Catholic [Church], should themselves obtain them. But from the law of unity onward, it should be that all churches claim for themselves the Catholic bishops of those places to which the places under the heretics belonged, whether of those converted to the Catholic [Church] or of heretics not converted, both the dioceses and whatever instruments of the Church there may happen to be, or things pertaining to its right. But those who have usurped anything after the law, let them restore what they have usurped when summoned.
In concilio Carthaginensi subsequentis anni die junii legationem iterum suscepit Fortunatianus episcopus contra Paganos et ha'reticos. III altero item concilio ejusdem anni 408. habito Carthagine die i;; octob. legationem contra Paganos et hæreticos susceperunt Restitutus et Florentius episcopi, eo tempore quo Severus et Macarius occisi sunt: et propter eorum causam Evodius et Theasius et Victor episcopi cæsi sunt.
Legationis causam discere licet ex Augustini ad Olympium epistola 97, n. i, quo nimirum per novum Imperatoris edictum noverint inimici Ecclesiæ, leges illus quæ de idolis confringendis et hæreticis corrigendis vivo Stilichone missæ sunt, ex voluntate Imperatoris piissimi constitutas: quo nesciente vel nolente factas, sive dolose jactant, sive libenter putant; atque hinc animos imperitorum turbulentissimos reddunt, et (Catholicis) periculose ac vehementer infestos. Ilinc vero subsequentium legum occasio.
In the Carthaginian council of the following year, on the day of June, Fortunatianus the bishop again undertook a legation against the pagans and heretics. III. At another council likewise of the same year 408, held at Carthage on the day of October, the bishops Restitutus and Florentius undertook a legation against the pagans and heretics, at the time when Severus and Macarius were killed; and on their account the bishops Evodius, Theasius, and Victor were beaten.
The reason for the legation may be learned from Augustine's letter 97 to Olympius, n. 1, namely that through a new edict of the Emperor the enemies of the Church knew that those laws which had been sent, while Stilicho was alive, concerning the breaking of idols and the correction of heretics, were established by the will of the most pious Emperor; and that, made without his knowledge or against his will, they either boast of deceitfully or willingly believe; and from this they render the minds of the ignorant most turbulent, and dangerously and vehemently hostile to the Catholics. Hence, moreover, the occasion of the subsequent laws.
Lex Honorii confirmans ante latas constitui tiones in hæreticos.
Impp. HONORIUS et THEODOSIUS AA. Curtio PF. P.
Omnia quae in Donatistas, qui et Montenses vocantar, Manichæos, sive Priscillianistas, vel in Gentiles, a nobis generalium legum auctoritate decreta sunt, non solum manere decernimus, verum in exsecutionem plenissimam effectumque deduci; ita ut aedificia quoque vel horum, vel Coelicolarum eliam, quae nescio cujus dogmatis novi conventus habent, Ecclesiis vindicentur. Poena vero lege proposita veluti convictos tenere debebit eos, qui Donatistas se confessi fuerint, vel Catholicorum communionem refugerint scaevae religionis obtentu, quamvis christianos esse se simulent, etc. Dat. vu cal. decemb. Romae, Basso et Phi. lippo Coss..
iidem AA. Ave, Donate, x. Na.
Donatistarum haereticorum Judæorumque nova atque inusitata detexit audacia, quod catholicae fidei velint bacramenla turbare: quæ pestis atque contagionis latius emanet ac profluat. In eos igitur, qui aliquid quod sit catholicæ sectae contrarium adversumque tentaverint, supplicium justæ animadversionis expromi præcipimus. Dat. VIII cal. decemb. Raven. Basso et Philippo Coss..
Law of Honorius confirming the constitutions previously issued against heretics.
Emperors Honorius and Theodosius Augusti to Curtius, Praetorian Prefect.
We decree that all things which by the authority of general laws have been decreed by us against the Donatists, who are also called Montenses, the Manichaeans, or the Priscillianists, or against the Gentiles, are not only to remain in force, but are to be carried out to fullest execution and effect; so that even the buildings of these, or likewise of the Coelicolae, which—I know not of what new dogma—hold assemblies, are to be claimed for the Churches. Moreover, the penalty set forth by law shall hold as though convicted those who have confessed themselves to be Donatists, or who have shunned the communion of the Catholics under the pretext of a depraved religion, even though they pretend to be Christians, etc. Given on the seventh day before the Kalends of December at Rome, in the consulship of Bassus and Philippus.
The same Augusti to Ave, Donatus, ten years.
The new and unheard-of audacity of the Donatist heretics and of the Jews has been exposed, in that they wish to disturb the sacraments of the catholic faith: which plague and contagion spreads and flows more widely abroad. Against those, therefore, who shall have attempted anything contrary and opposed to the catholic sect, we command that the punishment of just animadversion be exacted. Given on the eighth day before the Kalends of December at Ravenna, in the consulship of Bassus and Philippus.
Impp. HONORIUS et THEODOSIUS AA. Theodoro pre P.
Ne Donatistae, vel cæterorum vanitas hæreticorum aliorumque error, quibus catholicae communionis cultus non potest persuaderi, Judae! atque Gentiles, quos vulgo Paganos appellant, arbitrentur legum ante adversum se datarum constituta tepuisse, noverint judices universi praeceptis eorum fideli devotione parendum: et inter præcipua quidquid adversus eos decrevimus, non ambigant exsequendum. Quod si quisquam judicum, loco conniventiae, exsecutionem praesentis legis omiserit, noverit amissa dignitate graviorem motum se nostræ Clementiæ subiturum. Officium quoque suum, quod saluti propriæ contenta suggestione defuerit, punitis tribus primatibus, condemnatione vigintilibrarum auri plectendum. Ordinis quoque viri, si in propriis civitatibus vel territoriis commissum tale aliquid siluerint in gratiam noxiorum deportationis poenam et propriarum amissionem facultatum se noverint subituros. Dat. XVII cal. febr. Raven. Honor. vu et Theod. III AA. Coss..
Emperors Honorius and Theodosius Augusti to Theodore, Praetorian Prefect.
Lest the Donatists, or the vanity of the other heretics and the error of others, to whom the worship of the catholic communion cannot be persuaded, should think that the provisions of the laws previously issued against them have grown cold—[and lest] the Jews and the Gentiles, whom the common people call Pagans, [should think the same]—let all judges know that they must obey their precepts with faithful devotion, and let them not doubt that whatever we have decreed against them is to be carried out among the foremost matters. But if any judge, by way of connivance, shall omit the execution of the present law, let him know that, having lost his rank, he will undergo a more severe motion of Our Clemency. His office also, which, content with its own suggestion, shall have failed its own safety, shall be punished, after the punishment of its three chief officials, by a condemnation of twenty pounds of gold. Men of the order also, if in their own cities or territories they shall have kept silent about any such deed committed, in favor of the guilty, let them know that they will undergo the penalty of deportation and the loss of their own property. Given the seventeenth day before the Kalends of February at Ravenna, in the consulship of Honorius for the eighth time and Theodosius for the third time, Augusti.
In concilio apud Carthaginem habito die junii anni 410, legationem susceperunt contra Donatistas Florentius, Possidius, Præsidius, et Benenatus episcopi, eo tempore quo lex data est, ut libera voluntate quis cultum Christianitatis exciperet. Ea occasione datum est ab Honorio sequens istud edictum.
Honorii edictum abrogans eqm legem, qua hæreticis concessa fuerat libertas arbi trii,
Impp. HONORIUS et THEODOSIUS. lleracliano comiti Africæ.
Oraculo penitus remoto, quoad ritus suos haereticae superstitiones obrepscrant, sciant omnes sanctae legis inimici, plectendos se pæna et proscriptionis et sanguinis, si ultra convenire per publicum, exsecranda sceleris sui temeritate tentaverint. Dat. VIII cal. sept. Varane V. C. Cons..
COLLATIONIS CARTHAGINENSIS DIES PRIMA.
Exordium.
Post consulatum Varanis V. C. calendis juniis Carthagine in secretario thermarum Gargilianarum, præsentibus Sebastiano, Maximiano et Petro viris devotissimis protectoribus domesticis; astantibus Urso, Petronio, et Liboso ducenariis, Bonifacio et Evasio apparitoribus illustrium atque eminentium potestatum, Fileto apparitore illustris comitivae sedis, Exitioso adjutore corniculari, Possidio, Quodvultdeo, et Colonico adjutoribus commentariorum officii D. N. V. C. et spectabilis proconsulis, Navigio adjutore numerorum officii D. N. V. C. et spectabilis vicarii, Nampio scriba officii V. C.
In the council held at Carthage on the day of the Ides of June in the year 410, the bishops Florentius, Possidius, Praesidius, and Benenatus undertook a legation against the Donatists, at the time when the law was given that anyone might receive the Christian worship of his own free will. On that occasion the following edict was issued by Honorius.
Edict of Honorius abrogating the law by which freedom of choice had been granted to heretics.
Emperors HONORIUS and THEODOSIUS to Heraclianus, Count of Africa.
With the oracle utterly removed, to the extent that heretical superstitions had crept in with their own rites, let all the enemies of the holy law know that they are to be punished with the penalty both of proscription and of blood, if with the accursed rashness of their own crime they shall attempt to assemble publicly any further. Given on the eighth day before the Kalends of September, in the consulship of Varanes, a most illustrious man.
THE FIRST DAY OF THE CARTHAGE COLLATION.
Preface.
After the consulship of Varanes, a most illustrious man, on the Kalends of June at Carthage in the secretarium of the Gargilian baths, in the presence of Sebastian, Maximian, and Peter, most devoted men, domestic protectors; with Urso, Petronius, and Libosus, ducenarii, standing by, and Boniface and Evasius, apparitors of the illustrious and eminent powers, Filetus, apparitor of the illustrious count's seat, Exitiosus, assistant cornicularius, Possidius, Quodvultdeus, and Colonius, assistants of the record office of our lord, a most illustrious man and spectabilis proconsul, Navigius, assistant of the numeri of the office of our lord, a most illustrious man and spectabilis vicarius, and Nampius, scribe of the office of the most illustrious man.
legali almae Carthaginis, Rufiniano scriba V. C. curatoris celsae Cartbaginis; excipientibus eliam Hilaro et Praetextato exceptoribus D. N.V. C. et spectabilis proconsulis, Fabio exceptore D. N. V. C. et spectabilis vicarii, et Romulo exceptore V. C. legati almae Carthaginis; excipientibus quoque Januario et Vitale nolariis Ecclesiae catholicae, Victore et Cresconio notariis Ecclesiae Donatistarum, Ursus ducenarius illustrium alqueeminentium potestatumdixit:
Dudum vestra Sublimitas secundum imperiale præceptum et nos et cæteros qui tam de sacratissimo comitatu, quam etiam de Africanis ofliciis Sublimitatis tuae sunt actibus deputati, ad singulas provincias destinavit, et edicta etiam per universam Africam direxit, ut tam Catholici quam Donatistae episcopi, intra quartum mensem Collationi cuncti adesse deberent: quae tempora hodierna die videntur impleri. Et quia praesto sunt universi, de omnibus scilicet provinciis Africanis, id est de provincia Proconsulari, de provincia Censi Byzacena, de Numidia, de Mauritaniis Sitifensiet Caesareensi, sed etiam et de Tripolitana provincia, si praecipit Nobilitas tua, adsint iidem venerabiles viri, ut omnia suo ordine peragantur.
...of the legal [court] of beloved Carthage, with Rufinianus, vir clarissimus, scribe of the curator of lofty Carthage; receiving [them] also were Hilarius and Praetextatus, recorders of our lord, vir clarissimus and spectabilis, the proconsul, and Fabius, recorder of our lord, vir clarissimus and spectabilis, the vicar, and Romulus, recorder of the vir clarissimus, the legate of beloved Carthage; receiving [them] also were Januarius and Vitalis, notaries of the Catholic Church, and Victor and Cresconius, notaries of the Donatist Church. Ursus, ducenarius of the illustrious and most eminent powers, said:
Some time ago your Sublimity, in accordance with the imperial command, sent both us and the others who have been assigned to your Sublimity's duties, as much from the most sacred retinue as also from the African offices, to the individual provinces, and also dispatched edicts throughout all Africa, that bishops both Catholic and Donatist should all be present at the Collation within the fourth month; which times appear to be fulfilled on the present day. And since all are at hand, namely from all the African provinces—that is, from the Proconsular province, from the province of Byzacena the Censi, from Numidia, from the two Mauretanias, Sitifensis and Caesariensis, but also from the Tripolitan province—if your Nobility so orders, let these same venerable men be present, that all things may be carried out in their proper order.
Flavius Marcellinus V. C. tribunus et notarius dixit: Adsint vencrabiles viri, quos praesentes esse suggeritis. Et ingressis universis episcopis partis Donati; ingressis etiam Aurelio, Alypio, Augustino, Vincentio, Fortunato, Fortunatiano et Possidio episcopis Ecclesiae catholicae, cum Novato, Florentio, Maurentio, Bonifacio, Prisco, Sereniano, et Scyilacio coepiscopis sais, Deuterio, Leone, Asterio, et Restituto, æque episcopis et custodibus gestorum, Marcellinus vir clarissimus tribunus et notarius dixit: Optarem quidem tantae hujus multitudinis sanctitatem, quae sub unius Cbristi Dei religione censetur, nulia a se dissensione sejungi. Sed quia id quod dodum error antiqui hostis immisit, Deum certum est velle nunc corrigi, ne diutius germana religio concertatione sua spectaculum Genlibus faciat, licet supra meritum meum boc cognoscam esse judicium, ut inter eos videar judicare, a quibus me potiusdecuerat judicari; taincn quia certum est hanc causam spectante Deo ct Augelis testibus agitandam, quae sub fidei coelestis examine vel probata praemium afferat vel laesa judicium, ut tandem praesentium disceptationibus cpiscoporum manifestius veritas elucescat, imperialis primitus sanctio recitetur, ut in quem modum atque formam sit suscipienda cognitio ab omnibus possit adverti, licet eam cunctis innotuisse sat clarum sit.
Flavius Marcellinus, vir clarissimus, tribune and notary, said: Let the venerable men whom you report to be present be admitted. And when all the bishops of the party of Donatus had entered, and there had also entered Aurelius, Alypius, Augustine, Vincentius, Fortunatus, Fortunatianus, and Possidius, bishops of the catholic Church, together with their fellow bishops Novatus, Florentius, Maurentius, Bonifacius, Priscus, Serenianus, and Scyllacius, and likewise Deuterius, Leo, Asterius, and Restitutus, bishops and custodians of the proceedings, Marcellinus, vir clarissimus, tribune and notary, said: I would indeed have wished that the holiness of so great a multitude, which is reckoned under the religion of the one Christ God, should not be divided from itself by any dissension. But since it is certain that God wills that which the error of the ancient enemy introduced long ago to be now corrected, lest the true religion make a spectacle for the Gentiles any longer by its strife, although I know that this judgment is beyond my merit, so that I seem to judge between those by whom I ought rather to be judged; nevertheless, since it is certain that this case is to be conducted with God as spectator and the angels as witnesses, a case which under the examination of heavenly faith will either, if approved, bring a reward, or, if impaired, a judgment, so that at last the truth may shine forth more clearly through the disputations of the bishops here present, let the imperial sanction first be read aloud, so that all may perceive in what manner and form the inquiry is to be undertaken, although it is clear enough that it has become known to all.
Præceptum Honorii de habenda Collatione, recitatum die Collationis primo.
Imperatores, Caesares, Flavii, HONORIUS et THEODOSIUS, pii, felices, victores ac triumphatores, semper Augusti, Flavio MARCELLINO suo, salutem.
Inter imperii nostri maximas curas, catholicae legis reverentia aut prima semper aut sola est. Neque enim aliud aut belli laboribus agimus, aut pacis consiliis ordinamus, nisi ut verum Dei cultum orbis nostri plebs devota custodiat, ut etiam Donatistas vel terrore vel monitu olim implere convenerat, qui Africam, hoc est, regni nostri maximam partem et saecularibus officiis fideliter servientem, vanO errore et dissensione superflua decolorant. Nos tamen eadem fr equentius non piget replicare, quae omnium retro principum devota in Deum definivit auctorilas: ne nostris temporibus si quid forte in injuriam legis catholicæ fuerit generatum, justo judicio hoc nohis pos. sit imputare posteritas. Nec sane latet conscientiam nostram sermo coelestis oraculi, quem errori suo posse proiicere scæva Donatistarum interpretatio profitetur: qui quamvis depravatos animos ad correctionem mitius invitaret, aboleri eum tamen etiam ante jussimus, ne* qua superstitionibus præstaretur occasio.
The decree of Honorius concerning the holding of the Conference, read on the first day of the Conference.
The Emperors, Caesars, Flavii, Honorius and Theodosius, pious, fortunate, victorious and triumphant, forever Augusti, to their Flavius Marcellinus, greeting.
Among the greatest cares of our empire, reverence for the catholic law is always either the first or the only one. For we neither pursue anything else in the labors of war, nor ordain anything else in the counsels of peace, except that the devoted people of our world keep the true worship of God, so that even the Donatists may at last fulfill what they were once bound to do, whether by terror or by admonition—they who discolor Africa, that is, the greatest part of our kingdom and one faithfully serving even in secular offices, with vain error and superfluous dissension. Nevertheless, it does not weary us to repeat more frequently those same things which the devoted authority of all former emperors has defined in favor of God: lest in our times, if perchance anything has been begotten to the injury of the catholic law, posterity should with just judgment impute this to us. Nor indeed does the utterance of the heavenly oracle escape our conscience, which the crooked interpretation of the Donatists professes that their error can cast forth; although it more gently invited depraved minds to correction, we have nevertheless ordered it to be abolished even beforehand, lest any occasion be given to superstitions.
Nunc quoque excludendam subreptionem simili auctoritate censemus, illudque merito profitemur, libenter nos ea quæ Statuta fuerant submovere, ne in divinum cultum nobis se quisquam auctoribus aestimet posse peccarc. Et quamvis una sit omnium et manifesta sententia catholicæ legis plenam veritatem recto hominum cultu et cælesti sententia comprobatam, studio pacis et gratiæ venerabilium virorum episcoporum legationem libenter admisimus, quae congregari Donatistas episcopos ad caetum celeberrimæ desiderat civitatis, ut electis etiam sacerdotibus quos pars utraque delegerit, habitis disputationibus, superstitionem ratio manifesta confutet. Quam rem intra quatuor menses præcipimus explicari, ut conversos animos populorum etiam nostra clementia, sicut desiderat, celerius possit cognoscere. Quod si intra præstitutum tempus studiose Donatistarum episcopi declinaverint convenire, trini edicti vocatione contumacium tempora concludantur; quibus emensis atque transactis, si provocati adesse contempserint, cedat cum ecclesiis populus qui doctores suos silentio cognoverit superatos, et victum se aliquando gratuletur, sciatque, si non præceptis nostris, vel catbolicæ legis veris imperus serviendum.
Now too we decree that surreption must be excluded by similar authority, and we rightly profess that we willingly remove those things which had been established, lest anyone should think that, with us as authors, he can sin against the divine worship. And although there is one and manifest sentence of all, that the full truth of the catholic law has been approved by the right worship of men and by heavenly judgment, for the sake of peace and grace we have willingly admitted the embassy of the venerable bishops, which desires that the Donatist bishops be gathered to the assembly of the most celebrated city, so that, with priests also chosen whom each side shall have selected, and with disputations held, manifest reason may confute superstition. We command that this matter be completed within four months, so that our clemency also may be able, as it desires, more quickly to know the converted minds of the peoples. But if within the appointed time the Donatist bishops shall studiously decline to assemble, let the times of the contumacious be concluded by the summons of a triple edict; when these have been passed and completed, if, having been summoned, they disdain to be present, let the people yield with their churches, who shall have known that their teachers have been overcome by silence, and let them congratulate themselves that they have at some time been conquered, and let them know that, if not by our precepts, yet by the true commands of the catholic law, they must be served.
Cui quidem disputationi principe loco te judicem volumus rcsidere (quidquid eliam ante in mandalis acceperis plenissime meministi), omnemque vel in congregandis episcopis, vel evocandis, si adesse contempserint, curam te volumus sustinere: ut et ea quæ ante mandata sunt, et quae nunc statuta cognoscis, probata possis implere solertia; id ante omma servaturus, ut ea quæ circa catholicam legem vcl olim ordinavit antiquitas, vel parentum nostrorum auctoritas religiosa constituit, vel nostra serenitas roboravit, novella subreptione submota, integra et inviolata custodias. Ut sane adminicula competentia actibus tuis dcesse non possint, viros spectabiles Proconsulem atque Vicarium serenitas nostra commonuit, ut si propriarum dignitatum statum cupiunt retinere, si apparitionem suam extrema declinare supplicia, tam ex propriis officiis quam ex omnium judicum apparitione abunde necessarios faciant deputari. Erit jam sollicitudinis tuæ, si quid ulla cognoveris arte differri, missis relationibus indicare, ut negligentes puniat digna correctio. Omnia sane, quæ vei in unum episcopis con. gregatis disputatio completa firmavcrit, vel desistenlibus forte statuerit circa contumaces lata sententia, te referre conveniet; ut quid ad confirmandam catholicam fidem præceptio nostra profecerit, cclerius possimus agnoscere. Ei divina manu: Vale, Marcelline charissime nobis.
In this dispute, indeed, we wish you to preside as judge in the first place (you have most fully remembered whatever you also received earlier in the mandates), and we wish you to bear every care both in gathering the bishops and in summoning them, if they have scorned to be present: so that you may be able to fulfill with proven diligence both those things which were commanded before and those which you now know to have been decreed; above all, you are to keep this, that those things which either the antiquity of old ordained concerning the catholic law, or the religious authority of our parents established, or our serenity strengthened, with novel surreption removed, you guard whole and inviolate. So that, of course, the competent aids for your acts cannot be lacking, our serenity has warned the spectable men, the Proconsul and the Vicar, that if they desire to retain the status of their own dignities, if they wish to avoid the ultimate punishments for their apparition, they are to make abundantly necessary men assigned both from their own offices and from the apparition of all judges. It will now be your concern, if you learn that anything is being delayed by any art, to indicate it by sending reports, so that worthy correction may punish the negligent. All things, indeed, which either the completed disputation has confirmed when the bishops are gathered into one, or, if they perhaps withdraw, the sentence brought against the contumacious has decreed, it will be fitting for you to report; so that we may more quickly learn what our precept has accomplished for confirming the catholic faith. And by the divine hand: Farewell, Marcellinus, most dear to us.
Dala pridie idus octobris Ravennae, Varane V. C. consule.
Edictum Marcellini primum, quo per provin cias misso utriusque partis episcopi convo cantur.
Quid clementissimus princeps dominus noster Honorius pro catholicæ fidei confirmatione decreverit ante latorum apicum tenore monstratur. Legationem siquidem venerabilium episcoporum libenter acciiens, Africam suo devotam semper imperio vario religionum genere diutius inquietari dccolorarique non passus est. Studio namque pacis, et fidei tan. torum discidia populorum ex antiqua persuasione venientia veritatis voluit manifestatione sedari, ut quas sedare principalibus a se sanctionibus prorogatis ac trahi ad unam fidei sententiam non posse pervidit, habita utrarumque partium disceptatione revocaret. Cunctos etenim, tam Catholicae quam Donatianae partis episcopos, in unum voluit congregari, ut electis ab utraque parte peritioribus viris, certae fidei veritate discussa, superstitionem ratio manifesta convincat: quatenus quidquid illud est quod pro suis partibus æstimat unusquisque posse competere, proferatur in medium, et sic germanae vel sero fidei lux clarescat. Consona siquidem utriusque partis petitio ad hanc principcm sententiam provocavit.
Given at Ravenna on the day before the Ides of October, in the consulship of the most illustrious Varanes.
The first edict of Marcellinus, by which, sent throughout the provinces, the bishops of both parties are convened.
What the most clement prince our lord Honorius has decreed for the confirmation of the catholic faith is shown by the tenor of the letters brought forward. For gladly receiving the embassy of the venerable bishops, he did not suffer Africa, always devoted to his empire, to be disturbed and dishonored any longer by the various kinds of religions. For in his zeal for peace and faith, he wished the dissensions of so many peoples, arising from ancient persuasion, to be calmed by the manifestation of the truth, so that those whom he perceived could not be calmed by the imperial sanctions issued by him nor drawn to one judgment of faith, he might recall by a hearing held of the disputation of both parties. For he wished all the bishops, both of the Catholic and of the Donatian party, to be gathered into one, so that, with the more learned men chosen from each party, the truth of the certain faith having been discussed, manifest reason might convict superstition: in order that whatever it is that each one thinks can avail for his own party might be brought forward into the open, and thus the light of the true faith might shine forth, even if late. For the harmonious petition of both parties provoked this prince to this decision.
Nam sicut a Catholicis nuper Collatio postulata est; sic ante brevissimum tempus Donatistarum episcopos in judicio illustrium potestatum Collationem postulasse non dubium est: et quoniam libenter assensum tribuit clementia principalis, et concilium fieri intra Africam universale decrevit, utriusque partis justa poscentibus, huic me disputationi principe loco judicem voluit residere. Unde cunctos per Africam tam Catholicæ quam partis Donatianae episcopos hujus edicti tenore commoneo, ut intra tempus lege præscriptum, id est, intra quatuor menses, qui dies intra diem calendarum juniarum sine dubio concludetur, ad civitatem splendidam Carthaginensem concilii faciendi gratia convenire non differant: ne eam partem de memo propriæ fidei appareat judicasse quam defuisse constiterit. Universos etiam cunctarum provinciarum curatores, magistratus, et ordinis viros, necnon et actores, procuratores, vel seniores: singulorum locorum, pari admonitione convenio, sub propriae existimationis dignitatis reatu salutisque: periculo, quatenus in civilatibus locisque in quibus consistunt, utriusque partis episcopos convenire, vel sub gestorum confectione, vcl sub cujuslibet acripturac documento exstante, festinent.
For just as a Collation was recently requested by the Catholics, so it is beyond doubt that a short time before, the bishops of the Donatists requested a Collation in the judgment of the illustrious powers; and since the imperial clemency readily gave its assent, and decreed that a universal council be held within Africa, to both parties making just requests, it wished me to preside as judge in the first place in this disputation. Wherefore I remind all the bishops throughout Africa, both of the Catholic and of the Donatist party, by the tenor of this edict, that within the time prescribed by law, that is, within four months, which period will without doubt be concluded by the day before the Kalends of June, they not delay to assemble in the splendid city of Carthage for the purpose of holding a council; lest that party appear to have judged itself, by its own confession, to be of its own faith, which it is established was absent. I also summon all the curators of all the provinces, the magistrates, and men of the order, as well as the agents, procurators, or elders of individual places, by an equal admonition, under the charge against their own reputation and dignity and at the peril of their safety, that in the cities and places in which they reside, they hasten to bring together the bishops of both parties, either by the drawing up of records or by the standing evidence of any written document.
Et si ipso in tempore in civitatibus non potuerint inveniri, per rura ctiam perquisitis lam imperialis praecepti forma, qnam tenor hujus innotescat cdicti, quatenus intra: hos quatuor menses ordinum relatione cognoscam singularum partium voluntatem. lllud etiam scirer Donatianæ partis episcopos volo, si quis eorum affuturum se esse responderit, ecclesiam sibi primitus cum omni jure suo, quae forte a Catholicis juxta praeceptum imperiale retinetur, sine aliqua dilatione per viros ordinis mox tradendam; si vero omnes vel sin-, gulis' in locis suis positi sc adfuturos esse responderint, et ecclesias et ea loca quae corum fuisse vel eos: tenuisse constiterit, per supradictorum ordinum instantiam eorum juri dominioque reddenda; ut reformato iisdem primitus statu, disputationis inchoetur initium. Et quoniam tanti mihi negotii summam committere voluit augustissimus Princeps; illud me quoque fatcor libenter accipere, ut si de mea persona aliquid cunctationis affertur, alium mecum judicem, quein ipsi delegerint Donatianisa partis et fidei, vel supcrioris vel similis dignitatis, residcre non abnuam.
And if at that very time they cannot be found in the cities, let the form of the imperial command be sought out even through the countryside, so that the tenor of this edict may become known, to the end that within these four months I may learn from the report of the officials the will of each party. I wish the bishops of the Donatist party to know this also: that if any of them shall answer that he will be present, the church with all its rights, which perhaps is held by the Catholics according to the imperial command, must first be handed over to him without any delay through the men of the order; but if all, or those placed in their own several places, shall answer that they will be present, both the churches and those places which are established to have been theirs or to have been held by them are to be restored to their right and ownership through the insistence of the aforesaid officials; so that, when their status has first been restored to them, the beginning of the disputation may be undertaken. And since the most august Prince has wished to entrust to me the sum of so great a matter, I confess that I also willingly accept this: that if any hesitation is brought forward concerning my person, I shall not refuse that another judge, whom they of the Donatist party and faith shall themselves choose, of superior or similar rank, sit with me.
Sive autem cum alio, sive solus in hoc negotio judicaturus interero, nihil aliud me, nisi quod allegationes partium examinatæ potuerint demonstrare, et quod veri invenerit fides, per admirabile mysterium Trinitatis, per incarnationis Dominicæ sacramentum, ct per salutem supra memoratorum Principum, judicaturum me esse promitto. Nec illam sane partem potui reticere, quatenus noverint, sive pro Donatistis, sive pro Catholicis fuerit lata sententia, in nullo se Donatistarum cpiscopos aliquam molestiam esse passuros, sed liberos et ab omni injuriæ genere alienos ad propria redituros: quod me et per tremendum judicii diem, et per sacramenta superius memorata ita facturum esse polliceor. Omnes autem qui ad singulas provincias fucraot destinati, noverint in nullo se quemquam deinceps Donatistarum aliquatenus couveuire delere, vel aliquam iisdcm superioris exsecutionis molestiam generare, ni malunt pro contemptu recentioris praecepti subjacere vindictae. Erit autem omnibus Donatianæ partis hominibus, de eorum qui missi sunt concussionibus et depraidalionibus, si quas forte admissas esse noverunt, liherum conqueri; ut in cos probata criminum qualitate, ultio digna procedat. Et alia manu: Proponatur.
But whether I shall be present in this business judging with another or alone, I promise that I shall judge nothing other than what the allegations of the parties, once examined, will have been able to demonstrate and what the truth will have found, through the wondrous mystery of the Trinity, through the sacrament of the Lord's incarnation, and through the salvation of the aforementioned Princes. Nor, indeed, could I keep silent on that point, so that they may know: whether the sentence is delivered for the Donatists or for the Catholics, the bishops of the Donatists will suffer no molestation in any respect, but will return to their own places free and untouched by any kind of injury; and I promise that I will do this both by the fearsome day of judgment and by the sacraments mentioned above. But let all those who have been sent to the individual provinces know that they must not henceforth in any way destroy anyone of the Donatists, or generate any molestation of the aforesaid execution against the same, unless they prefer to be subject to punishment for contempt of the more recent precept. But it will be open to all men of the Donatist party freely to complain concerning the extortions and plunderings of those who have been sent, if perchance they know any such things to have been committed, so that, once the nature of the crimes has been proven, worthy vengeance may proceed against them. And in another hand: Let it be proposed.
Edictum Marcellini secundum, præsentibus apud Carthaginem episcopis propositum, de loco et modo Collatonis.
Magnitudo hujusce negotii, quod de veritatis ac religionis agnitione suscipitur, etiamsi parum momenti sui libraretur examine; convenerat tamen ipsa disceptantium gravitate atque auctoritate pensari. Nulli enim babetur ambiguum, quanti sit ponderis causa. quæ inter episcoporum est discutienda personas. Sed cum mibi cognitionem disceptationis hujusce crediderii augusta dignatio, eisque judicem dederit, quibu3 inferiorem me esse pro tanti nominis veneratione cognosco; fidei sollicitudinis meae hac consideratione prospexi, ut de meo vellem judicio fudicari. Hujus igitur auctoritate propositi ornos utriusque partis episcopos censui commonendos, ut ante cognoscant, non amplius quam septenos ambarum episcopos partium mutuae inter se disceptationis habituros esse colloquium, quos in officium disputandi suarum parlium subrogarit clectio: siquidem certum deliri ex partibus numerum præceperit imperialis auctoritas.
The second edict of Marcellinus, issued in the presence of the bishops at Carthage, concerning the place and manner of the Collation.
The magnitude of this matter, which is undertaken for the acknowledgment of truth and religion, even if it were weighed by an examination of little importance, would nevertheless have been fitting to be assessed by the very gravity and authority of those disputing. For it is held doubtful by no one of how great weight the cause is, which must be discussed among the persons of bishops. But since the august dignity has entrusted to me the cognizance of this disputation, and has given me as judge to those to whom I recognize myself to be inferior out of reverence for so great a name, I have provided for the faith of my solicitude by this consideration, that I wished to be judged by my own judgment. By the authority, therefore, of this proposal, I have judged that the bishops of both parties should be admonished, that they may know beforehand that no more than seven bishops of each of the two parties are to hold the conference of mutual disputation between themselves, whom the election of their own parties shall have substituted for the duty of disputing; since indeed the imperial authority has prescribed a fixed number from the parties.
Aderunt alii quoque septeni, delecti judicio suæ cujusque partis episcopi, qui servata primitus per omine colloquium moderatione silentii, ad hoc se tantum intelligant interesse, ut si qui ex disputantibus utrinque septenis conferre consilium cum suorum quoque voluerit, cum eodem illic seccdat in partem, atque ibi communicata patienter ratione tractandi I proprium revertatur ad locum, fidem servaturus officii, ut alter cui id necesse est tacendo audienda commendet, alter cui id munus est loquendo suscepta confirmet. Erit autem Collationi aptissimus locus Thermarum Gargilianarum, in quem die calendarum juniarum eosdem episeopos solos qui designati sunt oporteat convenire. Ex quo illud profecto perspicuum est, eo nullum penitus populi fieri debere conventum, auo ncc ipsos univetsos confluere sinatur episcopos. Nam cum patientia disputandi, qua; soli amica est silentio, omnem catervatim agminis strepitum perhorrescat; nibil interesl utrum eam congestio populorum, an episcoporum turba præpediat.
There will also be present seven others, bishops chosen by the judgment of each side, who, having first preserved the moderation of silence throughout the entire conference, should understand that they are present only for this purpose: that if any of the disputants on either side of the seven wishes to confer in counsel with his own men as well, he may withdraw there with him to one side, and there, having patiently communicated the method of discussion, may return to his proper place, about to preserve the fidelity of his office, so that the one for whom this is necessary may commend what is to be heard by keeping silent, and the other for whom this is the duty may confirm what he has undertaken by speaking. But the most suitable place for the Collation will be the Baths of Gargilianus, to which on the day of the Kalends of June those same bishops alone who have been designated ought to assemble. From this it is assuredly clear that absolutely no gathering of the people should be held there, since not even all the bishops themselves are permitted to flock together there. For since the patience of disputation, which is a friend only to silence, dreads every noise of a crowd in a mass, it makes no difference whether a heaping together of peoples or a crowd of bishops hinders it.
Igitur episcopi memorali soli in prædictum locum tempusque conveniant; ita tamen ut reliqui omnes utriusque partis episcopi ante diem qui prædestinatus examini est, ratum se habituros quidquid a septenis utrinque coepiscopis suis fuerit actitatum, epistolis ad meam dicationem currentibus utrinque designent: quibus epistolis tamen etiam testimonium omnes apud me propriæ subscriptionis adiungant. Æquissimum namque est, ut eorum universa Collatio rata futura promittatur ab omnibus. qui eliguntur ab omnibus. Nullus ergo vel laicus vel episcopus ultra numerum præstitutum in illum tranquillissimum concilii locum contra prohibitum moliatur accedere: quin potius ctiam plebcs suas pia quietis ac modestiæ commonitione conveniant, boc per ecclesias proprias ante tractantes, quatenus a dic disputationis ac loco omnis se multitudo contineat, ut religioso patientiæ magisterio delinitum christianae paci populum parent. Non solum enim episcopi, verum euam rationabilis in hanc sententiam populus consentit, disputantibus supradictis, et ubi major occupatio mentium delixa constitit, de veritate quærentibus, nibil turbidum, nihil tumultuosum, nihil denique intempestivum debere prorsus obrepere. Nam ut quod omnium saluti proficiat, fiat postea publicum, debet discutientibus veritatem præstare ante secretum.
Therefore let the bishops of the memorial alone assemble in the aforesaid place and at the appointed time; yet in such a way that all the other bishops of both sides, before the day which is set for the examination, by letters dispatched to my dictation from each side, designate that they will hold ratified whatever has been transacted by the seven co-bishops from each side; to which letters, however, let all also join the testimony of their own subscription before me. For it is most just that the whole conference of those who are chosen by all should be promised as ratified by all. Let no one, therefore, whether layman or bishop, beyond the established number, attempt to approach that most tranquil place of the council against the prohibition; but rather let them also assemble their own peoples by a pious admonition of quiet and modesty, treating of this beforehand through their own churches, so that the whole multitude may keep itself away from the day and place of the disputation, and thus, soothed by the religious teaching of patience, they may prepare the people for Christian peace. For not only the bishops, but also the reasonable people consent to this opinion, that while the aforesaid men dispute, and where the greater occupation of minds has settled, seeking the truth, nothing turbulent, nothing tumultuous, nothing in short untimely ought by any means to creep in. For in order that what profits the salvation of all may afterward be made public, the secret ought first to be given to those discussing the truth.
A me vero ita per omnia promulganda sententia est, ut in publicam dimissa notitiam, toto splendidæ Carthaginis populo judice ponderetur. Ita quippe oculis, non solum urbis bujusce, verum elian universæ provinciae totus emensa disputationis ordo pandetur, ut tam prosecutiones disptantium episcuporum, quam pronuntiationum mearam series subseruta. digestis in publico voluminibus explicetur, hæc eniti in judice securitas fidei est, ut de se non timeat judicari. Ut igitur in eliciendæ veritatis examen non inserpat aliquatenus calumniosa suspicio, lucemque perspicuam quam mentibus publicis probationum cvidenlium fides absoluta purgabit, nullis penita. nebulis cansalio cujuslibet partis obdocat: id etiam contra suspicionum fucos ct commenta fallendi necessario provisum noverint omnes, non solum oponere, verum etiam expedire servari, scilicet at imerfatibus meis me primitus per omnia subscribente, etiam omnes disputantes episcopi suis in seheda prosecutionibus universis absque ulla promte excusatione subscribant. Exigit cnim meritum fidei, ut adversus eum qui assertionibus suis perfidom forte subducere tentarit assensum et inficiari quae dixerit, etiam testimonii sui consistat auctoritas, ubi soli proficit victoria veritati.
But my sentence must be promulgated in all respects in such a way that, once released into public notice, it may be weighed by the judgment of the whole people of splendid Carthage. For in this way the entire order of the debate will be laid open to the eyes not only of this city but even of the whole province, so that both the presentations of the disputing bishops and the series of my pronouncements, set down in order, may be unfolded in volumes published publicly. This is the confidence of faith resting in a judge, that he does not fear to be judged concerning himself. Therefore, so that no calumnious suspicion may in any way creep into the examination by which the truth is drawn out, and so that the clear light, which the unencumbered faith of evident proofs will cleanse for public minds, may not be obscured by any dark clouds of the quibbling of either party: let all know that this too has been necessarily provided against the disguises of suspicions and the fabrications of deception—namely, that not only to oppose but also to carry out is to be observed: that is, with me first subscribing in all respects to my own statements, all the disputing bishops also shall subscribe on their own sheet to all their presentations without any ready excuse. For the merit of faith demands that, against one who has perhaps attempted to withdraw assent from his assertions and to deny what he has said, the authority of his own testimony should also stand, since victory profits only the truth.
Hi antem qui excipiendi funguntur officio, pr;rter eos qai dicationi meae de publicis præstolantur officiis, etiam quaterni de singulis partibus ecclesiastici alternis debebunt astare notarii, quorum ftdes nequa vacilleiambage, quaterni episcopi partium singularum delecti suorum judicio praeponantur, ut eosdem exceptoresacnotarios pervigili ac sollicita observatione cusiodiant; quatenus cum eisdem exceptoribus ac notariis egressi per vices, subinde faciant perspicua digert descriptione quæ dicta sunt; ut nihilominus adhuc episcopis supradictis in disceptatione versantilms, transeai in apices evidentes profligatæ pars aliqua quæstionis, ut confestim ea cum a septenis episcopis subnexa subscriptione, celerem exspectationi publica tribuant notionem. Post primum antem Collationis diem, descriptioni subsenptionique gestorum locum diei subsequentis efficiet procrastinata cognhio: ita ut si quid forte præcedenti Collationi saperent, in diem tertium recurrat examen. Omne igitur spatium conferendi vicissim diei unius intercapedo distinguet, quo possint in medio gesta subinde subscribenda describi, memoratorum præstolante custodia, qui hoc fine suam metiantur officium, non ut aliquid dicant, sed ut dicta custodiant.
But those who serve in the office of recording, besides those who await my pronouncement concerning public duties, shall also have four notaries from each side of the church stand alternately, whose fidelity may not waver in any ambiguity; and four bishops chosen from each of the several parties shall be placed over the judgment of their own men, that they may guard those same recorders and notaries with vigilant and careful observation; so that, having gone out in turns with those same recorders and notaries, they may then make clear by orderly description what has been said; so that nevertheless, while the aforesaid bishops are still engaged in the dispute, some part of the question that has been settled may pass into evident records, so that forthwith, when it has been appended with the subscription of seven bishops, they may give swift notice to the public expectation. But after the first day of the Conference, the deferred examination shall make the place of the day following available for the description and subscription of the proceedings: so that if anything perhaps remains over from the preceding Conference, the examination may recur to the third day. Therefore the interval of one day shall separate every period of conferring in turn, so that the proceedings may be able to be described in the meantime, to be subscribed in succession, with the guard of the said men waiting, who measure their office by this end, not that they may say anything, but that they may guard what has been said.
Donec autem emenso exitu quæstionum, omnes expedita veritas enodct ambages, schedas subinde scriptas pariter atqne subscriptas, tam mici sigilli, quam illorum octo custodom signabit impressio. Maximianistis etiam edicti hujus innotescet auctoritas, qua sibi ab illo concilio intelligant temperandum I quod I inter Catholicos Donatistasque distingui I omnem dijudicarique conflictum dementium Principum praeceptio religiosa constiluif; nec eis opitulari aliquatenus potest, quod sibi Donatistarum nomine blandiuntur, cum a Donatistis dicantur esse damnati. Si quis ex istis, quæ adversas omnes multifarie suspicionis insidias provisa sollicite, constituta fideliter, ordinata diligenter, tener hujus propositionis amplectitur, quodlibet observave noluerit; non solum quid de causa sua sentiat confitelur, verum ctiam quid moliatur ostendit. Sufficit interim Cognitori talis praerogativa justitiae, hujus commonitionis circa universos episcopos fecisse populum sibi plebis Carthaginensis testem, quem mox est habiturus judicem. Superest ut ante concilii diem universam hujusce ordinationis tenorem utriusque partis episcopi, amputata penitus mora, missis ad dicationem meam litteris suis impleturos se esse promittant hoc præcipuc maturato, ut eædem quibus ad omnia hujusce edicti se consensisse profitebuntur epistolae, primatium tantummodo episcoporum subscriptione signentur.
But when the outcome of the questions has been traversed and the plain truth has unraveled all the tangles, the schedules then written and likewise subscribed shall be sealed both by the impression of my seal and by the mark of those eight custodians. The authority of this edict shall also become known to the Maximianists, so that they may understand that they must restrain themselves from that council, since the religious ordinance of the most clement Princes has established that every conflict between Catholics and Donatists be distinguished and adjudged; nor can it help them in any way that they flatter themselves with the name of Donatists, since they are said to have been condemned by the Donatists. If anyone of these things, which have been provided with solicitude against all the manifold snares of suspicion, faithfully established, and diligently ordered, embraces the tenor of this proposition, but is unwilling to observe any one of them, he not only confesses what he thinks about his own cause, but also shows what he is attempting. For the present, such a prerogative of justice suffices for the Cognitor: that concerning this admonition he has made the people of the Carthaginian plebs a witness for himself, whom he will soon have as judge. It remains that before the day of the council the bishops of both parties, with delay utterly cut off, by letters sent to my dictation, promise that they will fulfill the entire tenor of this ordination, and this especially hastened, that the same letters by which they will profess that they have consented to all things of this edict be signed only by the subscription of the primate bishops.
Sufficit enim illis epistolis universalem, ut ita dixerim, subscriptionem episcoporum omnium cohaerere, quibus totum disputationis ordinem conferentium septenorum ratum se habituros esse promiserint.
Notoria Donatistarum, Marcellini edicto respondentium.
Post consulatum viri clarissimi Varanis, VIII cal. Jun. Flavio Marcellino viro clarissimo et spectabili tribuno et notario, Januarius, Primianus, et eæteri sinceræ Christianitatis episcopi et catholicae veritatis.
Notum facimus Sinceritati tuae, nos edicto tuo conventos, ex diversis partibus Africæ convolantes, ingressos fuisse Carthaginem xv die calendarum juniarum: cujus nostri adventus et omnes quos Carthago continet testes sunt, et tua Sinceritas non ignorat. Tanta enim vis jurisjurandi tui edicto tuo expressa est, ut exceptis his quos adversæ valetudines cotporum in sedibus retinent, aut aegritudo In via con rehendit, nec gravissimos senes annositas, nec prolixi itineris labor potuerit prohibere. Quod cum solum edictum ante causam sufficeret; alterum quoque dignatus es edere, in quo cum multa nos moveant, tam præcipue magnam sollicitudinem tacit, quod nos ipsos edicto tuo epistolis nostris astipulari oportere censuisti; cum hoc nec mos publicus habeat, nec jadhcum consuetudo.
For it is sufficient for them that there cohere, so to speak, a universal subscription of all the bishops to those letters, by which they promised that they would hold as ratified the entire order of the disputation of the seven delegates on each side.
The declaration of the Donatists, responding to the edict of Marcellinus.
After the consulship of the most illustrious man Varanes, on the eighth day before the Kalends of June, to Flavius Marcellinus, most illustrious man and spectabilis tribune and notary, Januarius, Primianus, and the other bishops of sincere Christianity and of the catholic truth.
We make known to Your Sincerity that we, summoned by your edict, having flown together from diverse parts of Africa, entered Carthage on the fifteenth day before the Kalends of June: of this our arrival both all whom Carthage contains are witnesses, and Your Sincerity is not ignorant. For so great a force of your oath has been expressed in your edict that, except for those whom adverse bodily illnesses keep in their seats, or illness has seized on the way, neither the great age of the most grievous old men nor the labor of a long journey could hinder them. And whereas that edict alone would have sufficed before the case, you also deigned to issue a second, in which—although many things in it move us—you have especially caused us great anxiety in that you judged that we ourselves ought to assent to your edict by our letters; whereas neither public custom has this, nor has the practice hitherto.
Qua de re Sinceritatem tuam plurimum exhortamur, ut prioris edicti fide servata, cunctos nos ad te venire præcipias; ut quam primam de numero nostro constet, quos adversarii paucos esse s.rpe mentiti sunt: ut rite omnibus ordinatis quæ nostris partibus competunt, disceptatio subsequatur; ne aut edicta se tuas Sinceritatis impugnent, aut nobis quidquam præjudicet, ut cum omnes venire praeceperis, paucos nune adesse velle videaris. noc enim decet et expedit, ut cunctis præsentibus commune negotium pauci loqaantur. Hujus Notoriae parem apud nos retinuimus. Et alia manu: Januarianus episcopus sub. scripsi. Et alia manu: Primianus episcopus subscripsi.
Litteræ Catholicorum, edicto Marcellini re spondentium.
Honorabili ac dilectissimo filio viro clarissimo et spectabili tribuno et notario Marcellino, Aurelius, Silvanus et universi episcopi catholici.
Wherefore we exhort your Sincerity most earnestly that, keeping the faith of the former edict, you command all of us to come to you, so that it may be established first of all how many we are in number, whom the adversaries have often falsely claimed to be few; so that, when all things have been duly ordered which pertain to our side, the disputation may follow; lest either your Sincerity's edicts be assailed, or anything prejudice us, so that when you have ordered all to come, you may seem to wish only a few to be present now. For it is neither fitting nor expedient that, when all are present, a few should speak on a common matter. We have retained a copy of this Notice with us. And in another hand: I, Januarianus, bishop, have subscribed. And in another hand: I, Primianus, bishop, have subscribed.
Letter of the Catholics, responding to the edict of Marcellinus.
To the honorable and most beloved son, the most illustrious man and the spectable tribune and notary Marcellinus, Aurelius, Silvanus, and all the Catholic bishops.
Edicto Spectabilitatis tuæ, quo nostræ Collationis tranquillitati quietique servandæ, et veritati manifestandæ muniendaeque consultum est, in omnibus nos consentire, sicut admonere dignatus es, per has litteras intimamus, etc.
Exstant inter Epistolas Augustinianas, tom. 2, epistola 128.
Litteræ Catholicorum ad Marcellinum datæ, quibus Notorioe Donatistarum respondent.
Honorabili ac dilectissimo filio viro clarissimo et spectabili tribuno et notario Marcellino, Aurelius, Silvanus, et universi episcopi Catholici.
Malam nos sollicitos reddidit Notoria vel litterae fratrum nostrorum, quos cupimus ad catholicam pacem a perniciosa dissensione converti, quod edicto Nobilitatis tuae, quo ipsius disputationis nostrae tranquillitati quietique providisti, consentire noluerunt, etc.
Exstant hae Ulterae tom. 2, epistola 229.
Mandatum Catholicorum, quo tota causa com prehensa est, et electis ad disputandum septem episcopis injuncta est Catholicæ de fensio.
By the edict of your Spectability, by which provision has been made for preserving the tranquility and quiet of our Conference and for making manifest and defending the truth, we intimate through these letters that we consent in all things, as you have deigned to admonish, etc.
These are extant among the Augustinian Letters, volume 2, letter 128.
A letter of the Catholics given to Marcellinus, in which they respond to the Notoria of the Donatists.
To the honorable and most beloved son, the most illustrious man and spectable tribune and notary Marcellinus, Aurelius, Silvanus, and all the Catholic bishops.
The Notoria, or the letter of our brethren, whom we desire to be converted from pernicious dissension to the Catholic peace, has made us badly anxious, because they were unwilling to consent to the edict of your Nobility, by which you provided for the tranquility and quiet of that disputation of ours, etc.
These are extant in the same place, volume 2, letter 229.
The mandate of the Catholics, in which the whole cause is comprehended, and the defense of the Catholics was enjoined upon the seven bishops elected to dispute.
Post consulatum Varanis viri clarissimi, III calendas Junias,. Mandatum factum in Ecclesia Carthaginensi ab Universo concilio episcoporum Catholicorum, præsidente Aurelio episcopo Ecclesiæ Carthaginensis, et Silvano primate Numidiae.
i. Quamvia cansa Ecclesiae catholicæ adversus omnes falsas criminationes, quibus eam usquequaque diffusam schismatici et baeretici per suas quasque regiones vel provincias vel divisi atque separati vaniloquis et sacrilegis insectantur erroribus, satis superque divinis testimoniis defendatur; in Africa vero adversus Donatistas etiam ecclesiasticis atque imperiali judicio, sicut oportebat vel necesse fuerat, terminata sit: tamen quia idipsum hominibus qui ista nesciunt quo eos ad aeternam salutem christianae eharitatis1 acquiramus, instantius manifestandum atque declarandum est; placuit uobis ex Dei Domini voluntate in hanc Carthaginensis civitatis convenire ecclesiam, et eligere idoneos fratres collegasque nostros, ad gerendam hujos causae defensionem, qui crimina falsissima Ecclesiae catholicae, quæ toto, sicut de illa divina testantur eloquia, terrarum orbe diffunditur, a parte Donati objecta redarguant.
After the consulate of Varanes, vir clarissimus, on the third day before the Kalends of June. A mandate made in the Church of Carthage by the entire council of Catholic bishops, with Aurelius, bishop of the Church of Carthage, presiding, and Silvanus, primate of Numidia.
i. Although the cause of the Catholic Church against all false accusations, with which schismatics and heretics, scattered and separated throughout their various regions or provinces, assail her far and wide with vain and sacrilegious errors, is defended sufficiently and more than sufficiently by divine testimonies; and in Africa indeed against the Donatists it has been settled even by ecclesiastical and imperial judgment, as was fitting and necessary; nevertheless, because this very matter must be more earnestly made manifest and declared to men who do not know these things, so that we may win them to eternal salvation through Christian love, it has pleased you, by the will of God the Lord, to assemble in this church of the city of Carthage and to choose suitable brothers and our colleagues to undertake the defense of this cause, who may refute the most false accusations brought by the party of Donatus against the Catholic Church, which is spread throughout the whole world, as the divine oracles testify concerning her.
i. Ecclesia quippe Christi, Sanctis patribus nostris Abrahae, Isaac et Jacob, et populis omnibus per imitationem fidei posteris et filiis eorum, ita divina et veridica voce promissa est, ut nulla humana et malediea possit tace convinci. Ad Abraham namque ita locutus est Deus: Per me juravi, dicit Dominus, propter qnod fecisti verbum hoc, et non pepercisti filio tuo amantissimo propter me, nisi benedicens benedicam te, et implendo implebo semen luum, tanquam stellas cæli, et tanquam arenam qum secus oram maris est; et hæreditatem pessidebit semen tuum civitates adversariorum, et benedicentur in semine tuo omnes gentes terræ, quia obaudisti vocem meam ( Gen. XXII, 16-18). Ad Isaac quoqne ista de hac re verba sunt Domini: Statuam jusjurandum meum quod juravi Abrahnrn patri tuo, et ampliabo semen tuum tanquam stellas cæli, et dabo tibi et semini tue omnem terram hanc, et benedicentur in nomine tuo omnes gentes terræ, pro his quæ obaudivit Abraham pater tuus meam vocem, et servavit præcepta mea et justitias meas et legitima mea (Id. XXVI, 3-5). Ad Jacob etiam loquens, hoc idem attestatione praeclarissima pollicetur: Et erit semen tuum sicut arena terræ. et multiplicabitur supra mare et in africum et in aquilo • nem et ad orientem, et benedicentur in te omnes tribus terras ei In semine tuo ( Id. XXVIII, 14).
For the Church of Christ was promised by the divine and truthful voice to our holy fathers Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob, and to all peoples who would follow them as descendants and children through imitation of their faith, in such a way that it cannot be shown false by any human and accursed voice. For God spoke thus to Abraham: By myself I have sworn, says the Lord, because you have done this word, and have not spared your most beloved son for my sake, blessing I will bless you, and multiplying I will multiply your seed as the stars of heaven, and as the sand which is by the shore of the sea; and your seed shall possess the inheritance of the cities of their adversaries, and in your seed all the nations of the earth shall be blessed, because you have obeyed my voice (Gen. 22:16-18). To Isaac also these words of the Lord concerning this matter are: I will establish my oath which I swore to Abraham your father, and I will multiply your seed as the stars of heaven, and I will give to you and to your seed all this land, and in your name all the nations of the earth shall be blessed, for the things which Abraham your father obeyed my voice, and kept my precepts and my judgments and my statutes (ibid. 26:3-5). Speaking also to Jacob, he promises this same thing with a most illustrious attestation: And your seed shall be as the sand of the earth, and shall be multiplied above the sea and to the west and to the north and to the east, and in you all the tribes of the earth shall be blessed, and in your seed (ibid. 28:14).
Unde propheta Isaias his vocibus consonans, istam Ecclesiam in Spiritu sancto futuram prævidens, sic alloquilur: Lætare, sterilis, qum non paris; erumpe et exclama, quæ non parturis, quoniam tutti filii desertæ, magis quam ejus quæ habet virum. Dixit enim Dominus: Dilata /ocum tabernaculi tui, et aularum tuarum: fige palos, noti parcere, longos fac funiculos tuos, et palos tuos confirma; adhuc in dexteram et sinistram extenderis, et semen tuum gentes possidebit, et civitutes desertas inhabitabis. Ne timeas, quoniam prævalebis: neque verearis quod detestabilis fueris; confusionem enim in æternum, oblivisceris, ignominiæ viduitatis tuæ non eris memor: quomam ego Dominus qui facio te, Dominus nomen llli; et qui liberavit te Deus Israel, universæ terræ vocabitur (Isai. LIV, 1-5). Item alio loco: Et patefaciet Dominus brachium suum sanctum in conspectu universarum gentium, et videbunt omnes gentes usque ad intima terræ salutem quæ a Deo est (Id. LII, 10). Item dicit: Posui te in testamentum generis, lucem gentibus, ut sit salus usque in fines terræ ( Id. XLIX, U).
Hence the prophet Isaiah, echoing these words and foreseeing in the Holy Spirit that this Church would come to be, addresses her thus: Rejoice, O barren woman who does not bear; break forth and cry aloud, you who do not travail, for the children of the desolate are more numerous than those of her who has a husband. For the Lord has said: Enlarge the place of your tent and the curtains of your dwellings; fix your stakes, do not spare, make your cords long and strengthen your stakes; you shall yet spread out to the right and to the left, and your seed shall possess the nations, and you shall inhabit the desolate cities. Do not fear, for you shall prevail; do not be afraid that you were detestable, for you shall forget your confusion forever, and you shall not remember the disgrace of your widowhood; for I am the Lord who made you, the Lord is his name; and he who redeemed you, the God of Israel, shall be called the God of the whole earth (Isa. 54:1-5). Likewise in another place: And the Lord shall reveal his holy arm in the sight of all the nations, and all the nations shall see, even to the ends of the earth, the salvation that is from God (Isa. 52:10). Likewise he says: I have set you as a covenant of the race, a light to the nations, that salvation may reach to the ends of the earth (Isa. 49:6).
Malachias etiam propheta prævidens sacrificium primi populi cessaturum, et toto orbe terrarum, id est, a solis ortu usque ad occasum, æternum sacrificium glorificato in gentibus nomine Domini celebrandum, ita loquitur ad Judaeos: Non eat mihi voluntas in vobis, dicit Dominus omnipotens, et sacrificium nen accipiam de manibus vestris: quoniam ab ortu solis usque ad occasum clarificatum est nomen meum in gentibus, et in omni loco incensum offertur nomini meo, et sacrificium mundum; quoniam magnum eat nomen meum in gentibus, dicit Dominus omnipotens ( Malach. I, 10, 11). Jeremias quoque gentes ab extremo terræ venturas ad Dominum, damnatis simulacrorum superstitionibus, sic praedicit: Domine, virtus mea et adjutorium meum et refugium meum in die malorum; ad te gentes venient ab extremo terræ, et dicent: Quam falsa possederunt patres nostri idola, et non eat in eis utilitas (Jerem. XVI. 19). Quia vero non in unum aliquen) terrae locum ex aliis locis ad Deum gentes venturas esse prædictum est,sed in locis suis eum adoraturas, in quem damnatis simulacris fuerant credi. tune, sic Sophonias propheta testatur: Prævalebit Dominus adversus eos, et disperdet omnes deos gentium terree, et adorabunt eum unusquisque de loco suo omnes insulæ gentium (Sophon. II,11).
The prophet Malachi as well, foreseeing that the sacrifice of the first people would cease, and that an eternal sacrifice would be celebrated throughout the whole world—that is, from the rising of the sun to its setting—with the name of the Lord glorified among the nations, speaks thus to the Jews: I have no pleasure in you, says the Lord Almighty, and I will not accept a sacrifice from your hands; for from the rising of the sun to its setting my name is glorified among the nations, and in every place incense is offered to my name, and a pure sacrifice; for my name is great among the nations, says the Lord Almighty (Malachi 1:10–11). Jeremiah also foretells that the nations will come to the Lord from the ends of the earth, once the superstitions of idols have been condemned, saying: O Lord, my strength and my help and my refuge in the day of evils; to you the nations will come from the ends of the earth, and they will say: How false are the idols our fathers possessed, and there is no profit in them (Jeremiah 16:19). But because it was foretold that the nations would come to God not into some one place of the earth from other places, but would worship him in their own places—him in whom, once the idols were condemned, they had come to believe—then Sophonias the prophet likewise testifies: The Lord will prevail against them, and he will destroy all the gods of the nations of the earth, and all the islands of the nations shall worship him, each one from his own place (Sophonias 2:11).
His atque aliis multo pluribus testimoniis Legis et Prophetarum asserentibus Ecclesiam toto terrarum orbe diffundi, Psalmi etiam divini ita concinunt: Domnus dixit ad me: Filius meus es tu, ego hodie genui te. Postula a me, et dabo tibi gentes hæreditatem tuam, et possessionem tuam terminos terræ ( Psal. II, 7, 8). Item in alio psalmo de Domino Christo in figura Salomonis: Dominabitur a mari usque ad mare, et a flumine usque ad terminos finis terræ. Coram illo decident Æthiopes, et inimici ejus terram lingent. Reges Tharsis ei insulæ munera offerent, rcges Arabum et Saba dona adducent; et adorabunt eum omnes rcges terræ, omnes gentes servient illi ( Psat. LXXI, 8-11). Item in alio psalmo: Deus deorum Dominus locutus est, et vocavit terram a solis ortu usque ad occasum: ex Sion species decoris ejus (Psal. XLIX, 1,2).
Propterea ipse quoque Dominus Jesus, qui locutus fuerat ante per ora Prophetarum, posteaquam resurrexit a mortuis, jam per os proprium sic promisit Ecclesiam: Oportebat, inquit, impleri omnia quæ scripta sunt in Lege, et Prophetis, ct Psalmis deme. Tunc aperuit illis sensum, nt intelligerent Scripturas, et dixit eis: Quia sic scriptum est, et sic oportebat Christum pati, et resurgere a mortuis tertia die, et prædicari in nomine ejus pænitentiam et remissionem peccatorum per omnes gentes, incipientibus ab Jerusalem (Luc.
By these and many other far more numerous testimonies of the Law and the Prophets asserting that the Church is spread throughout the whole world, the divine Psalms also sing in harmony: The Lord said to me: You are my Son, today I have begotten you. Ask of me, and I will give you the nations as your inheritance, and the ends of the earth as your possession (Ps. 2:7-8). Likewise in another psalm concerning the Lord Christ in the figure of Solomon: He shall rule from sea to sea, and from the river to the ends of the earth. Before him the Ethiopians shall fall down, and his enemies shall lick the earth. The kings of Tarshish and the islands shall offer him gifts; the kings of the Arabs and of Saba shall bring presents; and all the kings of the earth shall adore him, all nations shall serve him (Ps. 71:8-11). Likewise in another psalm: God, the God of gods, the Lord has spoken, and he has called the earth from the rising of the sun to its setting: out of Zion is the beauty of his comeliness (Ps. 49:1-2).
Therefore the Lord Jesus himself also, who had spoken before through the mouths of the Prophets, after he rose from the dead, now through his own mouth promised the Church thus: It was necessary, he said, that all things be fulfilled which are written in the Law, and the Prophets, and the Psalms concerning me. Then he opened their understanding, that they might understand the Scriptures, and said to them: For so it is written, and so it was necessary that Christ suffer, and rise from the dead on the third day, and that repentance and remission of sins be preached in his name among all nations, beginning from Jerusalem (Luke.
xxiv, 44-47): tanquam illud testimonium Psalmi, quod recentissimum posuimus, verbis aliis exponercl. Nam quod ibi positum cst, vocavit terram a solis ortu usque ad occasum; hoc Dominus nit, per omnes gentes: ct quod ibi positum est, ex Sion species decoris ejus; hoc Dominus ait, incipienlibus ab Jerusalem. Quis enin nesciat Sion et Jerusalem unam esse civitatem, unde cæpit passio et resurrectio Domini Jesu Christi per orbem terrarum populis mundandis atque salvandis illustrissimo præconio prædicari? Proinde et ascensurus in cælum, providens uude fuissent carnales homines pro suis divisionibus et se. parationibus liligaiuri, cum quæsiissent discipuli andire ab eo aliquid dc fine sæculi: Non eat, inquit, vestrum scire tempora quæ Pater posuit in sua potestate; aed accipietis virtutem Spiritus sancti, et eritis mihi testes in Jerusalem et in totam Judæam et Samariam, et usque in totam terram (Act. I, 7, 8). Manc auctoritatem magisterii cælestis secuti Apostoli Ecclesiam commendant in tuto mundo fructificantem atque crescentem (Coloss. I, G): ct ne se in partes membra Christi per hominum nomina dividant, ita carnales, qui jam hoc facere coeperant, Apostolus alloquitur: Obsecro vos, fratres, per nomen Domini nostri Jesu Christi, ut idipsum dicatis omnes, et non sint in vobis schismata, sitis autem perfecti in eodem sensu et in eadem sententia.
(24:44-47): as if I were expounding in other words that testimony of the Psalm which we have most recently cited. For what is there stated, "He called the earth from the rising of the sun to its setting," this the Lord says, "through all nations"; and what is there stated, "out of Zion the beauty of his comeliness," this the Lord says, "beginning from Jerusalem." For who does not know that Zion and Jerusalem are one city, from which the passion and resurrection of the Lord Jesus Christ began to be proclaimed throughout the whole world to peoples to be cleansed and saved, by a most illustrious proclamation? Accordingly, also when about to ascend into heaven, foreseeing whence carnal men would be stirred up on account of their divisions and separations, when the disciples had asked to hear from him something concerning the end of the world, he said: "It is not for you to know the times which the Father has placed in his own power; but you shall receive the power of the Holy Spirit, and you shall be my witnesses in Jerusalem and in all Judea and Samaria, and to the whole earth" (Acts 1:7-8). Following this authority of heavenly teaching, the Apostles commend the Church as bearing fruit and increasing in the whole world (Colossians 1:6); and lest they divide the members of Christ into factions under the names of men, the Apostle thus addresses the carnal, who had already begun to do this: "I beseech you, brethren, through the name of our Lord Jesus Christ, that you all say the same thing, and that there be no schisms among you, but that you be perfect in the same mind and in the same judgment.
Nuntiatum enim est mihi, fratres, ab his qui sunt Chloes, quia contentiones sunt in vobis, et unusquisque vestrum dicit, Ego quidem sum Pauli; ego autem Apollo; ego vero Cephæ; ego autem Christi. Divisus est Christus? Numquid Paulus pro vobis crucifixus est? aut in nomine Pauli estis baptizati (I Cor. i, 13)? Unde et istos, contra quorum errorjem et pro quorum salute nomine Christi elegimus qui eorum criminationibus falsis vanisque respondeant, in Sacramentis Christi fratres nostros agnoscimus, nec eorum detestamur perversitatem, sed ipsa Christi Sacrementa in cis approbamus, et rescindere non audemus. Meminimus enim per prophetam esse præceptum: Audite, qui navetis, verbum Domini, dicite, Fratres nostri estis, his qui vos oderunt, et qui vos detestantur; ut nomen Domini honorificetur; et appareat illis in jucunditate (Isai. LXVI, 5, sec. LXX). Jamquod sequitur, ipsi sibi salubriter dicant, vel a Propheta potius quam a nobis hoc audiant. Nos Icviora dicimus, ut pacem potius cum correctis, quam litem cum perversis habeamus. Fratres nostros esse dicimus, ut nomen Domini honorincelur; qui idco nos oderunt et detestantur, ct esse fratres nostros negant, quia nomen hominum ab cis magis quam Domini honorilicatur.
For it has been reported to me, brothers, by those who are of Chloe, that there are contentions among you, and each one of you says, "I indeed am of Paul; but I of Apollos; but I of Cephas; but I of Christ. Is Christ divided? Was Paul crucified for you? Or were you baptized in the name of Paul?" Hence also these men, against whose error and for whose salvation we have chosen to answer in the name of Christ, who reply to their false and empty accusations—we recognize them as our brothers in the sacraments of Christ, and we do not detest their perversity, but we approve in them the very sacraments of Christ, and we do not dare to rescind them. For we remember that it was commanded through the prophet: "Hear the word of the Lord, you who tremble at his word; say, 'Your brothers are those who hate you and detest you,' that the name of the Lord may be honored, and may appear to them in joy." And what follows, let them say it to themselves for their health, or rather let them hear it from the prophet than from us. We say more joyful things, so that we may have peace rather than strife with the corrected, and with the perverse. We say that they are our brothers, so that the name of the Lord may be honored; they who therefore hate us and detest us, and deny that they are our brothers, because the name of men is honored by them more than that of the Lord.
Ac per hoc fratres ct coepiscopi nostri, quos ad eorum criminationes rcdargucndas elegimus, in hac Collatione quæ cum eis habenda csl, Ecclesiam sanclam adversus eorum objecta defendant. Dicunt enim quod hæc Ecclesia, quam in Lege ct Prophetis ct Psalmis accepimus prænuntiatam, opcra I Salvatoris expressant ct sanguine redemptam, Apostolorum laboribus disseminatam atque plantatam, incipicutibus ab Jcrusalcm, ubi in centum viginti animas simul congregatas sanctus Spiritus venit, cosque in quos venit linguis omnibus, gentium loqui facicns, evidentissimo signo docuit Ecelcsiam pcr omnes gentes futuram, et linguis omnium gcutium locuturam: hanc ergo Ecclesiam, quæ isto modo, ut prædictum et implcium cst, ab Jcrusalcm sumpsit exordium, atque inde se in Judæam et Samariam aliasque orbis terræ partes Apostolorum prædicatione diffudit, in quorum Litteris atque Actibus civitatcs ct provincias invenimus longe latcquc distentas, in quas cam suis speciosis pedibus invexerunt, unde et in Africam crescereI; hanc, ut diximus, Ecclesiam dicunt isti, contra quorum crrorcm collegis nostris Collationem defensionemque mandamus, Cæciliani episcopi quondam Carthaginensis Ecclesiae et. sociorum cjus nescio quibus peccatis periisse pollutam, alque in parte Donati cjus reliquias remansisse.
And therefore our brothers and fellow bishops, whom we have chosen to refute their accusations, defend the holy Church against their charges in this Conference which is to be held with them. For they say that this Church, which we have received as foretold in the Law and the Prophets and the Psalms, and which was brought forth by the works of the Savior and redeemed by his blood, disseminated and planted by the labors of the Apostles, beginning from Jerusalem, where the Holy Spirit came upon one hundred and twenty souls gathered together, and by making those upon whom he came speak in all tongues, taught with a most evident sign that the Church would be throughout all nations and would speak in the tongues of all nations—this Church, then, which in this manner, as was foretold and fulfilled, took its beginning from Jerusalem, and from there spread through the preaching of the Apostles into Judea and Samaria and other parts of the world, in whose Letters and Acts we find cities and provinces far and wide, into which they brought it with their beautiful feet, whence it also grew into Africa—this Church, as we have said, these men against whose error we entrust to our colleagues the Conference and defense, say has perished, polluted by I know not what sins of Caecilianus, once bishop of the Church of Carthage, and of his companions, and that its remnants have remained in the party of Donatus.
Hanc vanam et sacrilegam criminationem hi, quibus mandamus, ila redarguant ct refellant, ut prianilus Ecclesiæ cnusaln a causa quorumdam hominum disliuguant alquc discernant. Quoniam Ecclesia permixtos malos habitura prædicta est, quousque messis tempore a tritico zizania segrcgenlur, vel a frumentis palea ventilata discedat, vel oves ad dexteram, hædi ad sinistram, qui nunc cisdem pascuis permixti sun!, segregentur; vel mali pisces a bonis, qui nunc intra cadem retia simul trahunturad liltus, in eodem littore, hoc est in fine sæculi, dirimantur. Homines autem quilibet in Ecclesia, si boni sunt, triticum vel frumenta ejus sunt, ovcs ejus sunt, pi sces ejus boni sunt: sin autem mali sunt, zizania, palea, hædi, pisces mali cjus sunt. Non ergo propter eos tota inessis, tola area, grex tolus, piscatio tola damnata csl: nc cum ante tempus audcmus quasi de malis temere judicare, et aliis aliorum objectare peccata, bonos propter malos sacrilega scparatione deseramus; cnm potius malos propler bonos pia unitate tolerare debcamus.
Let those to whom we give this charge so refute and rebut this vain and sacrilegious accusation that they distinguish and discern the cause of the whole Church from the cause of certain men. For it was foretold that the Church would have the wicked mingled within it, until at the time of harvest the tares are separated from the wheat, or the chaff is parted by winnowing from the grain, or the sheep at the right hand and the goats at the left, which now feed together in the same pastures, are separated; or the bad fish are divided from the good, which now are dragged together in the same nets to the shore, and on that same shore, that is, at the end of the world, are set apart. But whatever men are in the Church, if they are good, they are its wheat or grain, they are its sheep, they are its good fish; but if they are evil, they are its tares, chaff, goats, and bad fish. Not therefore on account of them is the whole harvest, the whole threshing floor, the whole flock, the whole fishing condemned; lest, while we dare to judge rashly, as it were, of the wicked before the time, and to cast the sins of some in the teeth of others, we abandon the good on account of the wicked by a sacrilegious separation, when rather we ought to tolerate the wicked on account of the good in pious unity.
Urgendi ergo sunt isti harum evangelicarum similitudinum, et tam perspicuæ veritatis inimici, ul docrant quod intendunt, ac prius ostendant, si valuerint, quomodo Ecclesia, quam incipientem ab Jerusalem in Scripturis sanctis per propinqua el longinqua fructificantem atque crescentem accepimus et tenemus, quorumlibet quos accusant contagione pcricrit, et in Donati parte remanserit. Si enim hoc fieri potuisse monstravcriut, tunc utique ad causam Ecclesiæ pertinebit, aliam fortasse suscipere atque discutcre quæstionem: utrum Cæcilianus ejusque collegne vel tales fuerint quales ah istis fuisse dicuntur, sic a innotescere potuerint christianæ quæ jam tunc erat unitati usquequaque diffusæ, ut cam usque ad ultimas terras ipsius notionis contagione macularent et perderent. Fatentur quippe etiam ipsi neminem peccatis alienis maculari posse quae ignorat. Unde si demonstrare voluerint, tam latam per tantas terras communionem gentium christianarum peccatis Cxciliani et sociorum ejus contaminari ac perire potuisse; non suflicit ut ostendant, tales eos fuissequales acensando criminaniur, nisi etiam ostendant vera crimina eorum omnibus innotuisse, quos ipsa contagione periisse contendunt.
Therefore those enemies of these gospel similitudes and of truth so clear must be pressed, so that they may prove what they intend, and first show, if they can, how the Church—which we have received and hold in the Holy Scriptures as beginning from Jerusalem and bearing fruit and growing through things near and far—perished by the contagion of any persons whom they accuse, and remained in the party of Donatus. For if they show that this could have happened, then indeed it will pertain to the cause of the Church perhaps to take up and discuss another question: whether Caecilian and his colleagues were such as these men say they were, and whether they could have become so known to the Christian unity already then spread everywhere, as to stain and destroy it even to the farthest lands by the contagion of that notoriety. For even they themselves admit that no one can be stained by the sins of others which he does not know. Hence, if they wish to demonstrate that the communion of Christian peoples, so wide through so many lands, could have been contaminated and destroyed by the sins of Caecilian and his associates, it is not enough for them to show that these men were such as they charge them with being by their accusation, unless they also show that their true crimes became known to all those whom they contend perished by that contagion itself.
Si autem non potuerint demonstrare, catholicam Ecclesiam per omnes gentes, in quibus eam divina commendant eloquia, ullis alienis peccatis destrui potuisse; sequcstrata paululum causa Cæciliani et corum quos cum illo accusandos esse putaverunt, quae ad Ecclesiæ causam omnino non pertinet, quoniam etsi mala fuisset, cam contaminare non posset; quod nos dicimus ad corum crimina repellenda ab eis quibus officium defensionis hujus imponimus, evidentissime et exemplis cumulatius ostendatur, id est, Ecclesiam Christi nullorum malorum usque in linem sibimct permixtorum, non solum ignotorum, verum eliam cognitorum, quasi corruptione pestifera posse inquinari atque deleri, primum exemplis propheticis, qui populum peccatorem et Deum multis exsecrabilibus abominationibus offendentem tam severis vocibus arguebant, et flagellis correptionis duros atque indomilos animos usque ad inimicitias adversum se horribiles excitabant, nec tamcn se ab eo populo, in quo utique etiam boni incr malos erant, corporali discrimiue dividebant, melius judicantes per patientiam ferre malos, quam per calmnniam relinquere bonos. Ipse Dominus Jesus Christus exemplum singulare patientiæ traditorem suum, utique pessimum, non solum cognitum in discipuli numero perlulil, verum etiam præcognitum in discipulorum numerum assumpsit. Dixit eliam discipulis suis, Et vos mundi estis, sed non omnes (Joan.
But if they cannot demonstrate that the catholic Church throughout all the nations, in which the divine oracles commend her, could have been destroyed by the sins of any outsiders, then, setting aside for a little while the case of Caecilian and of those whom they thought should be accused along with him—a case that has no bearing at all on the Church's cause, since even if it had been bad, it could not have contaminated her—what we say in order to repel their charges, by those on whom we impose the duty of this defense, should be shown most evidently and more abundantly by examples: namely, that the Church of Christ cannot be defiled and destroyed, as if by a pestilential corruption, by any wicked persons mixed in with her until the end, not only unknown persons but even known ones. First, by the examples of the prophets, who rebuked a sinful people offending God with many detestable abominations in such severe words, and by the lashes of correction stirred up hard and untamed minds even to horrible hostility against themselves, and yet did not separate themselves bodily from that people, in which surely even good people were among the bad, judging it better to endure the bad through patience than to abandon the good through calumny. The Lord Jesus Christ himself handed down a singular example of patience: he not only endured his betrayer, certainly the worst of men, though known, in the number of his disciples, but even foreknew him and took him into the number of his disciples. He also said to his disciples, "And you are clean, but not all" (John.
XIII, 10): ut eo modo scirent munditiam suam aliena immunditia non posse sordescere. Apostolorum temporibus testis est apostolus Paulus, inter falsos fratres gemens (II Cor. XI, 26), et quosdam per invidiam, quod ulique vitium diabolicum est, Christum annuntiantes in Epistola sua nolaus (Philipp. I, 15), quemadmodum boni malos, propter unitatem Christi pictate sollicita conscrvandam, sine ulla sua perditione in Sacramentorum communione tolerabant, a quorum malitia longe abhorrcbant. Post Apostolos etiam episcopi boni, quemadmodum propter unitatem Christi, non solum quoslibet laicos, verum etiam coepiscopos toleraverunt malos, testes sunt litteras martyris Cypriani, ubi gemit avaritiam quorumdam collegarum usque ad crudelitatem fenoris, rapinasque fundorum; nec tamen malorum contagione factus est talis, sed bonorum die lectione pertulit tales; non tantum id exemplo admonens, verum etiam præcepto instruens. Nam in quadam epistola sua dicit: Et si videntur in Ecclesia esse zizania, non tamen impediri debet aut fides aut charitas nostra; ut quoniam esse zizania in Ecclesia cernimus, ipsi de Ecclesia recedamus (Epist. ad Maximum, nunc 54).
so that in this way they might know that their own purity cannot be defiled by another's impurity. In the times of the apostles, the apostle Paul is a witness, groaning among false brothers (2 Cor 11:26), and [he speaks of] certain ones proclaiming Christ out of envy, which is surely a diabolical vice, in his Epistle (Phil 1:15), [showing] how the good tolerated the bad, for the sake of preserving with solicitous devotion the unity of Christ, without any loss to themselves, in the communion of the sacraments, though they utterly abhorred the malice of those men. After the apostles, also good bishops—for the sake of the unity of Christ—tolerated not only any laypeople but even their fellow bishops who were wicked; the letters of the martyr Cyprian are witnesses, where he groans over the greed of certain of his colleagues, extending even to the cruelty of usury and the plundering of estates; and yet he was not made such a man by the contagion of the wicked, but bore with such men for the sake of the good, being admonished by example and also instructed by precept. For in a certain letter of his he says: And if the tares seem to be in the Church, nevertheless our faith or our love ought not to be hindered, so that because we see tares in the Church, we ourselves should withdraw from the Church (Epistle to Maximus, now 54).
Ipsorum etiam qui huic veritati adversantur judicio probandum est, quam sit hoc verum; qui cum Maximianum damnassent merito sacrilegi schismatis, sociis ejus qui cum illo ab istis foras exierant, seque ab eorum communione separaverant, dilationem ad redeundum dederunt, dicentes eos illius sacrilegi surculi plantariis non esse pollutos. Quod quidem cum omnes unius schismatis societas connexos teneret, quemadmodum recte dici potuerit non invenimus. Sed tamen vel sero hinc intelligere cogantur, multo potius in unitate catholica malos bonis tanquam paleam frumentis obesse non posse, si in concisione scbismatica, ubi palea sola est, putatus est Maximianus ejusdem concisionis suae socios, tantum quia ordinalioni ejus praesentes non fuerunt, non potuisse. maculare: et videant qnam inconsiderate dicant, Cæcilianum, qualiscumque ille fuerit, et ejus quoscumque collegas, in tot longinquis gentibus unitatem christianam perdere potuisse; cum Maximianum arbitrentur nec Afros participes sui schismatis perdidisse. Sic apparebit, ad Ecclesiæ causam cujus injungimus defensionem, non pertinere Cæciliani causam, qualemlibet haheat quxstionem.
It must be proved even by the judgment of those who oppose this truth how true this is: when they had condemned Maximianus, deservedly, for the sacrilegious schism, they gave his associates, who had gone out with him from them, and had separated themselves from their communion, a period of delay to return, saying that they were not polluted by the plantings of that sacrilegious offshoot. But since the fellowship of one schism held them all bound together, we do not find how this could rightly be said. Yet at least, though late, let them be forced to understand from this that much more in the Catholic unity the wicked cannot harm the good, like chaff to the wheat, if in the schismatic cut, where there is only chaff, Maximianus was thought unable to stain the associates of his own cut, merely because they were not present at his ordination; and let them see how rashly they say that Caecilianus, whatever sort of man he was, and whatever colleagues of his, could destroy Christian unity in so many distant nations, when they judge that Maximianus did not destroy even the Africans who were partakers of his schism. Thus it will appear that the case of Caecilianus, whatever question it may involve, does not pertain to the cause of the Church, for whose defense we are arguing.
Quod autem accusant Baptismum nostrum, vel potius Baptismum Christi, quem habemus et ministramus, eumque in eis quos deceperint ingemiscendo errore rescindunt, sic ferendum1 est, quemadmodum ipsa Ecclesia cujus donum est. Non enim audebunt amplius Baptismum accusare quem damus, si ab eorum criminibus Ecclesia purgabitur quam tenemus. Sed si illud, ut assolent, objiciendum putaverint, quod Baptismum Christi etiam foris a nostra communione traditum agnoscimus potius quam improbamus, nec reseindere audemus: respondeatur eis quantiscumque rationibus et testimoniis responderi potuerit, divina Ecclesia; dona et apud fures vel usurpatores vel etiam raptores inventa, agnoscenda esse potius quam neganda. Nam sicut Apostolus de quibusdam dicit, quia veritatem in iniquitate detinent ( Rom, i, 18): ila omnes qui extra Ecclesiam Christi hahent vel ministrant Baptismum Christi, veritatem Sacramenti divini in iniquitate detinent erroris humani; unde humana iniquitate correcta, non est veritas divina violanda. Qui autem putant negandum esse Baptismum Christi, quia eum ethaeretici tradunt; possunt putare negandum esse etiam ipsum Christum, quia cum et d;emones confitentur. Et ideo ad Ecclesiam venire debent, qui extra ejus communionem Baptismum ejus babent; non ut quod deerat adsit, sed ut quod inerat prosit.
But as for their accusing our baptism—or rather the baptism of Christ, which we have and administer—and as for their canceling it in those whom they have deceived by their lamentable error, it must be borne as the Church herself is borne, whose gift it is. For they will not dare to accuse any further the baptism that we give, if the Church that we hold is cleared of their crimes. But if, as they are accustomed, they think this should be objected—that we acknowledge rather than reject the baptism of Christ even when it has been administered outside our communion, and do not dare to cancel it—let the answer be given to them, by whatever arguments and testimonies it can be given, that the divine Church's gifts, even when found among thieves or usurpers or even robbers, are to be acknowledged rather than denied. For just as the Apostle says of certain people that they hold the truth in iniquity (Romans 1:18), so all who outside the Church of Christ have or administer the baptism of Christ hold the truth of the divine sacrament in the iniquity of human error; therefore, when human iniquity has been corrected, the divine truth is not to be violated. But those who think that the baptism of Christ must be denied because heretics administer it could also think that Christ himself must be denied, because even demons confess him. And therefore those who outside her communion have his baptism ought to come to the Church—not so that what was lacking may be present, but so that what was already in them may benefit them.
Neque putandum cst illos hinc jam diuturnum habituros esse conflictum; quandoquidem etiam de hac re suo judicio et exemplo po. terunt admoneri. Baptismum quippe Christi extra suam communionem in Maximiani schismate datum, in eis. quos inde cum illis quos damnaverant susceperunt, agnoscere quam rescindere maluerunt. Proindo et illud quod non recte intelligenles solent dicere, Ne communices peccatis alienis ( I Tim. v, 22) (neque enim hoc corporum segregatione, sed morum diss!militudine faciendum cst); in eis coguntur attendere quemadmodum intelligendum sit, quos cum Maximiano damnato sacramenta communicantes impollutos fuisse dixcrunt. Et quod de Baptismo solent accipere, quod dictum est, Qui baptizatur a mortuo ( Eccli. xxxiv, 50), et exetera hujusmodi, in eis ipsis nosse coguntur quomodo accipienda sint, quando ab illis, quos cum damnarent mortuos esse dixerunt, Baptismum in schismate datum improbare atque iterare non ausi sunt. Et quod nobis objicere consueverunt, quod ad eos corrigendos pro unitate Christi apud terrenas potestates aliquid agere cogimur, in ipsis ideotidem Maximianistis compellendi sunt approbare, quos cum apudjudicesterrenos tanquam schismaticos suos vel hæreticos accusarent, ut de basilicis pellerent, etiam Bagaiense concilium, quo eos damnaverunt, aliquoties allegarunt.
Nor should it be thought that they will now have a long-lasting conflict over this matter, since even on this point they can be admonished by their own judgment and example. For they preferred to acknowledge rather than to cancel the baptism of Christ given outside their communion in the schism of Maximianus, in those whom they received from that schism together with those whom they had condemned. Therefore also that saying which, understanding it incorrectly, they are accustomed to use—"Do not share in the sins of others" (1 Tim 5:22)—for this is to be done not by separation of bodies but by dissimilarity of conduct—they are forced to consider in the case of those very people how it should be understood, since they said that those who shared the sacraments with the condemned Maximianus were undefiled. And what they are accustomed to take regarding baptism, namely what was said, "He who is baptized by a dead man" (Sirach 34:30), and other such sayings, they are forced to learn in the case of those very people how they should be taken, since they did not dare to reject and repeat the baptism given in schism by those whom, when they condemned them, they said were dead. And what they have been accustomed to object against us—that for correcting them for the unity of Christ we are compelled to do something before earthly powers—they are compelled to approve in the very same Maximianists, whom, when they accused them before earthly judges as their schismatics or heretics, so that they might be driven from the basilicas, they also cited several times the Council of Bagai, by which they condemned them.
Quae omnia ideo dicenda sunt, ut et suo judicio commoneantur dissensionem tandem deponere, et consumpta vel abjecta falsarum et vanarum animositate criminalionum, diligere catholicam pacem, amplecti individuam charitatem, sine qua nullus hominum bonus esse poterit, quidquid boni aliud habere potuerit.
Quibus peractis, nec ipsam Cæciliani causam volumus deserant; sed eam non tanquam Ecclesiae matris, sed tanquam episcopi fratris suscipiant; nec sic ut iterum discutiatur finienda, sed ut demonstretur jam olim esse finita ecclesiasticis et publicis documentis: quorum nonnulla sufficient, si eis cum a nobis proferuntur fidem habere voluerint; potuerunt archivis eliam contestantibus declarari 1, quibus appareat, et causam Cæciliani eos per Anulinum proconsulem ad imperatorem Constantinum accusando misisso, ot enmdem imperatorem post ecclesiastica judicia quibus Cæciliabus fuerat absolutus, causaln totam partibus præsentibus cognovisse, atque innocentem Cæcilianum, illos autem calumniosissimos judicasse Felicis quoquo Aptugnensis ordinatoris Cæciliani innocentiam. AEliano proconsule cx pr;ccepio ejusdem imperatoris cognoscente claruisse, quem malorem fontem in concilio suo ipsi dixerunt.
All these things must be said so that by their own judgment they may be admonished to lay aside their dissension at last, and, having consumed and cast away the animosity of false and empty accusations, to love catholic peace and embrace undivided charity, without which no man can be good, whatever other good he may have been able to possess.
With these matters settled, we do not wish them to abandon even the case of Caecilian himself; but let them take it up not as the case of the mother Church, but as that of a brother bishop; and not in such a way that it must be ended by being discussed again, but so that it may be shown to have been ended long ago by ecclesiastical and public documents. Some of these will suffice, if they are willing to give credence to them when they are produced by us; they could also be made clear by the archives themselves bearing witness, from which it appears both that they sent the case of Caecilian to the emperor Constantine by accusing him through the proconsul Anulinus, and that the same emperor, after the ecclesiastical judgments by which Caecilian had been absolved, heard the whole case with the parties present, and judged Caecilian innocent, but them most slanderous; and also the innocence of Caecilian's ordainer Felix of Aptunga. When Aelianus the proconsul, by the command of the same emperor, heard the case, it became clear—whom they themselves in their council called the chief source of the evil.
Quæcumque autem crimina quibuslibet collegis nostris, non jam more conferentium vel disputantium, sed maledicentium et litigantium, objicienda putaverint; respondendum cst cis, nee corum causas ad Ecclesiæ causam quam nunc defendendam injungimus pertinerc, nec ipsas tamen cis discutiendas auferri, sed pro temporis quod nunc instat necessitate differri; ut cum Ecclesiæ causam, quam nunc clementissimus Imperator cognoscendam et demonstrandam recenti præceptione curavit, fuerit terminata, quæcumque quibuscumque nostris objiciendaarbitrantur, apud quos voluerint judites et nostros et suos, cum jam catholicæ unitati fucrint sociali, vel purgata monstrentur, vel convicta puniantur.
Hæc eo modo quo conscripta sunt, ct si quid uberius vel firmius eis Dominus dederit, exsequenda mandamus fratribus et coepiscopis nostris, Aurelio, Alypio, Augustino, Vincentio, Fortunato, Fortunatiano et Possidio. Quod mandalum se suscepisse testantur subscriptionibus suis, sicut nos mandasse testamur subscriptionibus nostris, ratum habituri quidquid adjuvante Domino in hac defensione peregerint. Ilis autem adjungimus, cum quibus ubi opus fuerit consilium babeant, Novatum, Florentium, Maurentium, Priscum, Serenianum, Bonifacium, et Scillatium. Ad custodiendam vero conscriptionem gestorum, Deuterium, Leonem, Asterium, ct Restitutum.
But whatever charges they have thought should be brought against any of our colleagues—not now in the manner of those conferring or disputing, but of those slandering and quarreling—it must be answered to them that neither do their cases pertain to the cause of the Church, which we are now charged to defend, nor are the cases themselves to be taken from them so as not to be examined, but rather deferred according to the necessity of the time that now presses; so that when the cause of the Church, which the most merciful Emperor has taken care to have examined and demonstrated by a recent order, has been concluded, whatever they think should be brought against any of our people, before whatever judges they wish—whether ours or their own—once they have been joined to catholic unity, may either be shown to be cleared or, once convicted, be punished.
These things, in the manner in which they have been written, and whatever more abundantly or more firmly the Lord has given them, we command to be carried out by our brothers and fellow bishops Aurelius, Alypius, Augustine, Vincentius, Fortunatus, Fortunatianus, and Possidius. That they have received this mandate they testify by their subscriptions, just as we testify that we have given it by our subscriptions, being about to hold as ratified whatever, with the Lord's help, they shall accomplish in this defense. To these we further join, with whom, where it is needed, they may take counsel: Novatus, Florentius, Maurentius, Priscus, Serenianus, Bonifacius, and Scillatius. For the safeguarding of the written record of the proceedings, however: Deuterius, Leo, Asterius, and Restitutus.
Aurelius episcopus Ecclesias catholicae Carthaginensis Carthagini constitutus præsente viro clarissimo tribuno et notario Marcellino hoc Mandatum suscepi et subscripsi. Item alia manu: Silvanus primæ sedis provinciæ Numidiæ præsente viro clarissimo Marcellino tribuno et notario Carthagini constitutus Mandato a nobis facto consensi et subscripsi. Item alia manu: Valentinus episcopus Ec. clesiæ Vaianensis Carthagini constitutus praesente V. C. Marcellino tribuno et notario mandavi et sui. scripsi, etc.
COLLATIONIS DIES SECUNDA.
Exordium.
Post consulatum Varanis V. C. tertio nonas junias, in secretario Thermarum Gargilianarum Carthagini, astantibus Sebastiano, Maximiano, etc., Libosus ducenarius illustrium potestatum dixit i Quoniam in hodiernum diem comperendinata cognitio est, et præsentes sunt utriusque partis episcopi, si jubet Subli-Illi las tua, intromittentur. Flavius Marcellinus V. C. tribunus et notarius dixit: Venianl. Et ingressis Aurclio, Alypio, Augustino, etc. Marcellinus V. C. tribunus et notarius dixit: Et superiore judicio saepe me obtulisse certissimum est, ct nunc deprecor ut sedere dignemini. Cumque episcopi Catholici consedissent, Petilianus episcopus dixit: Quod priore judicio factum non est, facere non audemus, etc. Marcellinus V. C.
Aurelius, bishop of the catholic church of Carthage, appointed at Carthage, in the presence of the most illustrious man, the tribune and notary Marcellinus, received this Mandate and subscribed it. Likewise in another hand: I, Silvanus of the first see of the province of Numidia, appointed at Carthage, in the presence of the most illustrious man Marcellinus, tribune and notary, consented to the Mandate made by us and subscribed it. Likewise in another hand: I, Valentinus, bishop of the church of Vaia, appointed at Carthage, in the presence of the most illustrious man Marcellinus, tribune and notary, gave my mandate and subscribed it, etc.
THE SECOND DAY OF THE CONFERENCE.
Opening.
After the consulate of the most illustrious man Varanes, on the third day before the nones of June, in the secretarium of the Gargilian Baths at Carthage, with Sebastianus, Maximianus, and others standing by, Libosus, ducenarius of the illustrious powers, said: Since the hearing has been postponed to this day, and the bishops of both parties are present, if your Sublimity orders, let them be brought in. Flavius Marcellinus, most illustrious man, tribune and notary, said: Let them come in. And when Aurelius, Alypius, Augustinus, and others had entered, Marcellinus, most illustrious man, tribune and notary, said: It is most certain that I have often presented myself at the earlier hearing, and now I beg that you deign to be seated. And when the catholic bishops had sat down, Petilianus the bishop said: What was not done at the earlier hearing, we do not dare to do, etc. Marcellinus, most illustrious man.
tribunus ct notarius dixit: Licet et superiore judicio me obtulisse mcminerim, tamen illa arbitror tunc minime factum esse ratione, quia multis sacerdotibus convenientibus locus considendi esse non poterat. Unde quia nunc dcfinilas video convenisse personas, doprecor ut vel nunc sedere dignemini. Petilianus cpiscopus dixit: Patribus nostris absentibus non sedemus, maxime cum lcge divina consessus prohibeatur, ne cum hujusmodi adversariis nostris considere velimus. Marcellinus V. G. tribunus et notarius dixit: Si petitionem meam Sanctitas vestra audire neglexit, ut considere dignaretur, hoc mihi extorqueri non poterit, quominus stando cognoscam, etc.
NOTORIA DONATISTARUM,
Qum recitata est in secunda cognitione.
Post consulatum Varanis viri clarissimi, quarto nonas junii, Flavio Marcellino viro clarissimo et spe. ctabili tribuno ct notario, Primianus, Petilianus, Emeritus, Prothasius, Montanus, Gaudentiusv Adeodatus, episcopi et defensores ecclesiasticae veritatis, per Notoriam hæc dicunt:
The tribune and notary said: Although I remember that I presented myself also at the earlier hearing, nevertheless I judge that at that time nothing was done, for the reason that, when many bishops assembled, there was no place to sit. Therefore, since I now see that the persons defined have assembled, I beg that even now you deign to sit. Petilianus the bishop said: We will not sit while our fathers are absent, especially since sitting together is forbidden by the divine law, lest we wish to sit with adversaries of this kind. Marcellinus, of illustrious rank, tribune and notary, said: If Your Holiness has neglected to hear my petition, that you deign to sit, this cannot be extorted from me so as to prevent me from conducting the inquiry while standing, etc.
NOTICE OF THE DONATISTS,
which was read at the second hearing.
After the consulship of the most illustrious man Varanes, on the fourth day before the Nones of June, in the presence of the most illustrious and distinguished man Flavius Marcellinus, tribune and notary, Primianus, Petilianus, Emeritus, Prothasius, Montanus, Gaudentius, and Adeodatus, bishops and defenders of the ecclesiastical truth, say these things through the Notice:
Hesterna die calend. junii inter nos et adversarios nostros Spectabilitas tua audire dignata est. Et quoniam evoluto pene die partibus patientiam præbens, aliquanta quae principia negotii fuerant audire dignatus es, opusque est ad causam, ut Mandatum quod adversarii nostri obtulerunt, nobis in notitiam perferatur; quoniam series actorum propter sui prolixitatem non potest explicari; ne imparati ad judicium venire vidcamur, id Mandalum quod adversal'ii nostri legendum dcderunt, in exemplarihus nO. bis hodie, quod est quarto die nonarum juniarum, dari praecipias; ut instructi negotio nobis injuncto adesse valeamus. Et alia manu: Primianus episcopus huic Notoriæ subscripsi quarto nonas junias Carthagini.
Prosecutiones quædam Augustini.
Augustinus episcopus Ecclesiæ catholicae dixit: Hoc solum constet, ipsos rem velle differre. Ut con cedat Sublimitas tua, petimus te. numanum est, considerare volunt, discutcre volunt, paratiores volunt venirc: ne nolentes differre prolixiora gesta fa-. ciamus, et ipsa gestorum prolixitas majores nobis moras incutiat.
On the day yesterday, the kalends of June, your Spectability deigned to hear between us and our adversaries. And since, with the day almost spent, showing patience to the parties, you deigned to hear certain things which were the beginnings of the case, and it is necessary for the case that the Mandate which our adversaries presented be brought to our notice; since the series of the acts, on account of its length, cannot be unfolded; lest we seem to come to the judgment unprepared, order that the Mandate which our adversaries gave to be read be given to us today in copies, which is the fourth day before the nones of June; so that, instructed in the business enjoined upon us, we may be able to be present. And in another hand: I, Bishop Primianus, have subscribed to this Notice on the fourth day before the nones of June at Carthage.
Certain prosecutions of Augustine.
Bishop Augustine of the catholic Church said: Let this alone be established, that they wish to delay the matter. That your Sublimity may grant it, we ask you. It is human to consider, they wish to discuss, they wish to come more prepared; lest, unwilling to delay, we make the acts longer, and the very length of the acts bring upon us greater delays.
Marcellinus V, C. tribunus et notarius dixit: Licet jam de professionibus dubietas mihi magna nascatur, tamen denuo,utrum sexto iduum juniarum dic, omnibus ambagibus amputatis, negotium sit principale tractandum, pars utraque designet.
Augustinus episcopus Ecclesiae catholicae dixit: Nos et hodie volumus, et si fieri posset vellemus. Tamen quia humanum fuit, hoc concedere fratribus nostris, quod nobis non injustc videntur postulasse, ad diem sextum iduum juniarum, adjuvante Domino Deo nostro adfuturos nos ad peragendum principale negotium Ecclesiae pollicemur.
COLLATIONIS DIES TERTIA.
Exordium.
Post consulatum Varanis viri clarissimi, sexto idus junias, Carthagini, in secretario Thermarum Gargilianarum, astantibus Sebastiano, Maximiano et Petro viris devotissimis, etc., Ursus ducenarius illustrium potestatum dixit: Præterito judicio Donatianae partis episcopi in hodiernam diem, ut exinde instructi in judicio Sublimitatis tuæ responderent, causa sibi edendorum gestorum inducias postularunt. Nunc utræque partes pro foribus sunt: si præcipis, intromittentur. Flavius Marcellinus V. C. tribunus et notarius dixit: Veniant. Et ingressis episcopis, etc., Marcellinus V. C. tribunus et notarius dixit: Certum est ob hoc dilatum fuisse ucgotium, ut hodierno die gestis editis principalis actio tractaretur, etc.
Marcellinus, of clarissimus rank, tribune and notary, said: Although great doubt now arises in my mind concerning the declarations, nevertheless let both parties state again whether, on the sixth day before the ides of June, with all ambiguities cut away, the principal matter is to be treated.
Augustine, bishop of the catholic Church, said: We wish it both today and, if it could be done, we would have wished it. Nevertheless, because it was humane to grant to our brothers what they are seen not unjustly to have requested of us, we promise that, with the help of our Lord God, we will be present on the sixth day before the ides of June to complete the principal matter of the Church.
THE THIRD DAY OF THE CONFERENCE.
Opening.
After the consulship of the most illustrious man Varanes, on the sixth day before the ides of June, at Carthage, in the secretarium of the Gargilian Baths, with the most devoted men Sebastian, Maximian, and Peter standing by, etc., Ursus, ducenarius of the illustrious powers, said: At the previous judgment, the bishops of the Donatian party requested a postponement for themselves of producing the records, so that, instructed thereby, they might respond on the present day in the judgment of your Sublimity. Now both parties are before the doors: if you order it, they will be admitted. Flavius Marcellinus, of clarissimus rank, tribune and notary, said: Let them come. And when the bishops had entered, etc., Marcellinus, of clarissimus rank, tribune and notary, said: It is certain that the matter was delayed for this reason, that on the present day, with the records produced, the principal action might be treated, etc.
Prosecutiones Augustini.
Augustinus episcopus Ecclesiæ catholica dixit: Principale negotium jam diu est ut cupimus terminari. Proinde, si vel sero conceditur, probent quoniam ex parte adversa esse desiderant, toties objecta Ecclesiæ sanctae catholicæ toto orbe diffusæ crimina et nunquam probata.
(Ctim Donatistæ flagitarent, ut prius exprimerentur qui petissent Collationem fieri, volentes ul constaret Catholicos esse petitores, ut ex' forensi jure possent discutere personas petitorum ) Augustinus episcopus Ecclesiæ catholicæ dixit: Si ad rem judicas pertiucre, prudentiæ ture ost considerare. Catholicis episcopis vel legatis Catholicorum episcoporum concessum esse habendam Collationem, tenor rescripti imperialis ostendit. Venimus, utrique hic surmus; et Deus nus disputatores et collatores magis quam litigatores esse præcepit, et nihil aliud voluit Deum timens et Deo serviens clementissimus Imperator. Astitisse legitimas personas, el confirmata esse mandata primo die conflictus nostri judicavit Sublimitas tua. Non interponantur quæ ad rcm necessaria non sunt. Ecclesia est quam asserimus testimoniis divinarum Scripturarum, omnibus nota, in monte, sicut scriptum est, altissimo constituta, ad quam veniunt omnes gentes (Isai. 11, 2, 3, cl Malth. v, 14). Si cst aliquid contra istam Ecclesiam quod dicaiur, jam dicatur, et nullæ moræ interponantur.
The Proceedings of Augustine.
Augustine, bishop of the Catholic Church, said: It is already long since we have desired that the principal matter be settled. Therefore, if it is granted even at this late hour, let them prove that it is from the opposing party that those desires come, [namely] that the crimes so often charged against the holy Catholic Church spread throughout the whole world, and never proved, [be proved].
(When the Donatists kept demanding that those who had requested that the Conference be held should first be named, wishing it to be established that the Catholics were the petitioners, so that by forensic law they might challenge the persons of the petitioners.) Augustine, bishop of the Catholic Church, said: If you judge that this pertains to the matter, it is for your prudence to consider. That the Conference was granted to the Catholic bishops, or to the legates of the Catholic bishops, the tenor of the imperial rescript shows. We have come; we are both here; and God has commanded us to be disputants and conferrers rather than litigants, and the most clement Emperor, fearing God and serving God, willed nothing else. That legitimate persons have appeared and that the mandates have been confirmed, your Sublimity judged on the first day of our conflict. Let there be no interposition of things that are not necessary to the matter. It is the Church that we assert by the testimonies of the divine Scriptures, known to all, established on the mountain, as it is written, the most high, to which all nations come (Isa. 11:2, 3; cf. Matt. 5:14). If there is anything that is said against this Church, let it now be said, and let no delays be interposed.
Si nihil csl qnod dicatur, cedat vcritati, qui ciiminationem suain affirmare et ostendere et probare hominibus non potest. Quamdiu ista tanta populi exspectatio suspensa est? De anima su omnes cogitant, et nos moratorias præscriptiones ad hoc interponimus, ut ad finem cognoscendae veritatis nunquam veniatur.
(Item post aliquot prosecutioncs Donatistarum et Judicisinterlocutiones Augustinus dixit: Advertat Nobilitas tua quanta aguntur, ut nihil agatur, etc.
Augustinus dixit: Præsentes sunt, utrique convenimus, locus iste episcopis pene refertus est, Mandata recitata atque (ir.nata suni. Non negatur a partibus nostris postulatam esse Collatonem, ut in ca Collatione tandem aliquando vel probent, vel proharc non potuisse monstrentur, quæ solent non nobis, non unicuique nostrum, sed universo orhi christiano objicere crimina: qui christianus orbis non opinione humana, sed divinis testimonus et promissus csi ct impletur. Qnid adhuc nesci i quæ tergiversationes moratoriæ ab cis interponuntur, qui se epises pos Christi dici volunt. Exspectatio, non dico hujus civi. tatis, sed universi pene generis humani suspensa est, aliquid de Ecclesia cu it audire, et uos adhuc ferenscs formulas discutimus etmis rrime litigamus. Jam advertat Nobilitas tua quid agatur. Jam aliquando ims de hoc negotio, amputatis omnibus morulis, adj uvante Deo liberare dignare.
If there is nothing that can be said, let him yield to the truth, since he cannot affirm, demonstrate, and prove his accusation to men. How long is this so great an expectation of the people held in suspense? All are thinking about their own soul, and we interpose these delaying prescriptions, so that it may never come to the end of knowing the truth.
(Item, after several pleadings of the Donatists and interlocutions of the judge, Augustine said: Let your Nobility note how many things are done, so that nothing be done, etc.
Augustine said: They are present; we have both come together; this place is almost filled with bishops; the mandates have been read out and examined. It is not denied by our side that a Conference was requested, so that in that Conference at last they may either prove, or be shown unable to prove, the crimes which they are accustomed to object not to us, not to any one of us, but to the whole Christian world: which Christian world is promised and fulfilled not by human opinion, but by divine testimonies. What do I still not know? What delaying tergiversations are interposed by those who wish to be called bishops of Christ? The expectation, I do not say of this city, but of almost the whole human race, is held in suspense to hear something concerning the Church, and we are still discussing mere formulas of pleading and litigating most triflingly. Now let your Nobility note what is being done. Now at last, with all delays cut off, deign, with God's help, to free us from this business.)
( Et post aliquot prosecutiones pertium cl Judicis interlocutiones) Augustinus divit: Collatio pelita est a legatis nostris. Lex ipsa hoc continel, quæ ad tuam Nobilitatem data cst, ete. Omnes fatemur nos petisse Collationem, quoniam cam recusabatis, utlaudem sic saltem ad hunc locum vel ad hoc tempus Collationis et disputationis et demonstrandæ veritatis gratia vcniremus. Factum est: venimus, ct nihil vultis prodesse quod venimus. Conlitemur nos Collationem petisse. Nihil aliud Imperator quam nos Collationem petisse suis verbis expressit. Jam fiat ipsa Collatio. Videamus quid dicatur contra Ecclesiam ton orbe diffusam, quam demonstramus divinis testimoniis et promissam esse, ct nunc ita cxhiberi, ut cæcorum oculos feriat, surdorum aures irrumpat. Ad hanc demonstrandam nolunt pervenire fratres nostri, ut demonstretur quod latere non potest. Edicant crimina: videamus quibus criminibus periit quod promissum est Abrahæ: In semine tuo benedicentur omnes gentes ( Gen. XXII, 18). Quæ crimina istam promissio, nemjurantis Dei delere potuerunt audiamus, discamus, noverimus. sequamur. Si autem nihil esi, quod contra dici possit, aut pronuntia, nul tolle omnes moras, et aliquando negotium liniatur.
(And after several further arguments and the judge's interlocutory rulings) Augustine said: The conference was requested by our legates. The law itself contains this, which was given to Your Nobility, etc. We all acknowledge that we requested the conference, since you were refusing it, so that at least for this purpose, at this place or at this time, we might come together for the sake of conference and disputation and the demonstration of the truth. It has been done: we have come, and you wish that our coming should profit nothing. We confess that we requested the conference. The Emperor expressed nothing other than that we requested the conference in his own words. Now let the conference itself take place. Let us see what is said against the Church spread throughout the whole world, which we demonstrate by divine testimonies both to have been promised and now to be so exhibited that it strikes the eyes of the blind and bursts into the ears of the deaf. To demonstrate this our brothers do not wish to come, so that what cannot be hidden may be demonstrated. Let them state the crimes: let us see by what crimes perished what was promised to Abraham: In your seed all nations shall be blessed (Gen. 22:18). What crimes could blot out this promise of God, who does not lie? Let us hear, let us learn, let us know, let us follow. But if there is nothing that can be said against it, either pronounce it, or remove all delays, and let the matter at last be brought to a close.
(Item post alias partium prosecutiones et Judicis interlocutiones) Augustinus dixii: Ecclesia, quod audire non vultis, el necesse est audiatis, quoniam tot testimoniis et divinis eloquiis proelamatur toto terrarum orbe diffusa, cujus communionem videmur tenere, falsis criminationibus a vobis appetita est: unde exstitit vestra separatio, quam dolemus. Istæ criminationes quibns insectari soletis Ecclesiam tuto, sicut promissa est, orhe diffusam, hodie audire volumus, an veræ sint. Si enim veræ sunt istæ criminationes, quas Ecclesiæ memoratæ objicere consuestis, si cnm pollutam, maculatam, eversam, destructam, et exstinctam nescio quibus nostris criminibus demonstrare polucritis; supererit ut quæramus uirum apud vos remanscril, quam ubique periisse clamatis. Si autem illa perire non potuit, superest ut eam vos agnoscatis, el litem tandem aliquando finiatis.
(Again, after other pleadings of the parties and interlocutory rulings of the judge) Augustine said: The Church, which you refuse to hear, you must also hear, since by so many testimonies and divine utterances it is proclaimed as spread throughout the whole world, whose communion we appear to hold; it has been attacked by you with false accusations; from this arose your separation, which we grieve over. These accusations with which you are accustomed to assail the Church—safely, as was promised, spread throughout the world—we wish to hear today whether they are true. For if these accusations are true, which you are accustomed to bring against the aforementioned Church—if you can show that it is polluted, stained, overturned, destroyed, and extinguished by I know not what crimes of ours—it will remain for us to ask whether that which you cry out has perished everywhere has remained among you. But if it could not perish, it remains that you recognize it and at last put an end to the dispute.
(Item post prosecutiones aliquot et interlocutiones) Augustinus dixit: Personas primo die judicii esse firmatas et sequenti etiam die interlocutionis tuine forma declaravit. Scd quia dicit cum peregrinis Christi mis nou se habere aliquam rationem, scd hoc totum quod agitur, inter Afros agi, Afrorum Christianorum catholicorum hæc vox cst: Nos universo orbi christiano communione cohæremus. Hanc Ecclesiam elegimus retinendam, qnam in cis Scripturis invenimus, etc. Nos cam Ecclesiam retimemus, quam in illis Sci ipluris invenimus, in quibus etiam cognovimus Christum. Scripturæ quippe nostræ, quarum auctoritati utrique subdimur, Christum et Ecclesiam tanquam sanctum commendiul conjugium, Christum sponsum, illam sponsam. Ubi illum cognoscimus, ibi et iliam invenire dcbemus. Si itaque nunc exorti essemus, ct cogitaremus in Africa cui communioni Christianorum sociari deberemus, procul dubio eam tenere deberemus, quam in Scripturis inveniremus, et criminatrices opiniones hominum repudiare, ad sola eloquia divina, quæ mentiri nesciunt, nos tcnerc. Hoc fecerunt Christiani Afri, et appellantur ct mcrilo sunt catholici, ipsa sua communione nomen testantes. ' enim, Secundum totum dicitur. Qui autem a toto separatus ost, partemque defendit ab universo præ. cisam, non sibi usurpet hoc nomcn, sed nobiscum teneat veritatem.
(Again, after certain pleadings and interlocutory rulings) Augustine said: The persons were established on the first day of the trial, and on the following day of the interlocutory proceeding your own formulation also declared it. But because he says that he has no account to give with the strangers of Christ's mission, but that this whole matter is being conducted among Africans, this is the voice of African catholic Christians: We adhere in communion to the whole Christian world. This Church we have chosen to hold fast, which we find in those Scriptures, etc. We hold fast to that Church which we find in those most holy Scriptures, in which we have also come to know Christ. For our Scriptures, to whose authority both of us submit, present Christ and the Church as a holy and praiseworthy marriage—Christ the bridegroom, she the bride. Where we know him, there we ought also to find her. If, therefore, we had now for the first time come into being, and were considering in Africa to which communion of Christians we ought to join ourselves, without doubt we ought to hold fast to that one which we would find in the Scriptures, and to reject the accusatory opinions of men, and to hold to the divine utterances alone, which cannot lie. This is what the African Christians have done, and they are called and truly are catholic, bearing witness to the name by their very communion. For it is said "according to the whole." But he who is separated from the whole, and defends a part cut off from the universe, let him not usurp this name for himself, but let him hold the truth with us.
Gaudentius episcopus dixit: Catholicum nomen putant ad provincias vel ad gentes referendum; cum hoc sit catholicum nomen, qnod sacramentis pienum est, quod perfectum, quod immaculatum, non ad gentes, etc.
I ht pesi quasdam prosecutiones et interlocutiones) Augustinus dixit: Solent Ecclesiæ quam tenemus, ( i imina traditionis objicere, et nescio quorum peccatis eam contendere esse destructam ct exstinctam; atque his criminationibus fallere corda simplicium, de quorum salute satagimus. Ilis nos permoti, convenimus cos, ut nobiscum conferrent, et quod intendunt, utrum proharc possent in Ecclesiam cui intendunt, ostenderent. Quam conventionem nostram quoniam recusaveranl, cum ntiper in Comitatum venissent quidani illorum, apud acta etiam præfectoria dixerunt audiri se velle et discuti velle; amplectentes nos aliquando corum de Collationc consensum, pee tendum ab hnperatore credidimus, ut Collatio ad hoc fieret, nt ca crimina quæ solent dicere in universam Ecclesiam, aut probarent, ut veritas appareret, aut nun probarent, ut nihilominus veritas appareret. Hæc crimina, si volunt aut possunt ostendere, proferantur ct demonstrentur. Si autem non possunt, aut nolunt; jam tuæ Sublimitatis est de re tota, sicul ratio ipso indicat, judicare.
Bishop Gaudentius said: They think the name "Catholic" is to be referred to provinces or to nations; whereas this name is Catholic which is full in the sacraments, which is perfect, which is immaculate, not [to be referred] to nations, etc.
(Here, after certain pleadings and interlocutory rulings) Augustine said: Those of the Church which we hold are accustomed to throw up the charges of tradition against it, and to contend that it has been destroyed and extinguished by the sins of I know not whom; and by these accusations to deceive the hearts of the simple, for whose salvation we are anxious. Moved by these things, we came together with them, so that they might confer with us, and show whether they could prove against the Church what they intend. Because they had refused this meeting of ours, when certain of them had recently come into the Comitatus, they even said before the prefectorial acts that they wished to be heard and wished the matter to be discussed; embracing at last their consent to a Collation, we believed that it should be sought from the emperor that a Collation be held for this purpose, that those charges which they are accustomed to bring against the whole Church they might either prove, so that the truth might appear, or not prove, so that the truth might nonetheless appear. Let these charges, if they wish or are able, be brought forward and demonstrated. But if they cannot or will not, it is now for Your Sublimity to judge concerning the whole matter, as the nature of the case itself indicates.
(El post prosecutiones quasdam et interlocntiones Augustinus dixit: Nos Collationem poposcimus, ubobjecta diluamus, non ubi objiciamus diluenda; quan. doquidem cum illi objecta probare non potuerint, quid sint, quid remaneant, nobis non dicentibus manifeslum erit omnibus, et a tua Sublimitate judicabitur. Nunc ingressi sumus diluerc criminationes eorum, quas solent Ecclesiæ quam tcnemns objicere. Mandalum quoque ipsorum hoc continet. Adversus tradite;es persecutores nostros. Quondam autem Primianus, si dignatur, frater noster, conventus pro ipsa Collatione respondit: Indignum est ut in unum conveniant filii martyrum et progenies traditorum. Hæc crimina diluenda suscepimus, ut hæc crimina diluantur, istam Collationem poposcimus: concessa est, aut probentur, aut purgentur.
(Et cum Donatistæ quæsiissent, utrum testimoniis Scripturæ divinae, an publicis gestis Catholici agere mallent; dixissentque, ut si Scripturæ testimonia eligerent, facerent omnium legum publicarum gestorumque jacturam; si autem publicis legibus ct gestis agere potius vellent, omitterent Scripturae testimonia Augustinus dixit: Ad ea quæ prosecuta cst modo pars adversa, paucis advertat Sublimitas tua.
And after certain prosecutions and interlocutions, Augustine said: We demanded the Collation so that we might clear away the charges brought against us, not so that we might bring charges that need clearing away; since, when they have been unable to prove the charges they brought, what they are and what they remain will be manifest to all without our saying anything, and it will be judged by your Sublimity. Now we have entered upon the task of clearing away their accusations, which they customarily bring against the Church that we hold. Their mandate also contains this: Against the traditors, our persecutors. But formerly Primianus, if he deigns, our brother, when assembled for the Collation itself, responded: It is unworthy that the sons of martyrs and the offspring of traditors should come together in one place. We have undertaken to clear away these charges, so that these charges may be cleared away; we demanded this Collation: it has been granted, so that they may either be proved or purged.
And when the Donatists had asked whether the Catholics wished to proceed by testimonies of divine Scripture or by public records, and had said that if they chose the testimonies of Scripture they would forfeit all public laws and records, but if they preferred to proceed by public laws and records they should set aside the testimonies of Scripture, Augustine said: Let your Sublimity attend briefly to the points which the opposing party has just set forth.
Nos Ecclesiam catholicam retinere ipsa nostra communionis testificatione monstramus: quam Ecclesiam probare descendimus, si permittant, non rumoribus humanis, neque errantibus opinionibus, sed divinis eloquiis declaratam. Ut autem leges, vel gesta, vel quæcumque de arcbivis prolata offeramus in hac Collatione recitanda, ipsi cogunt, qui talibus agunt. Nam si remotis hujuscemodi omnibus chartis, nollent Ecclesiam nisi in Scripturis adverti, nihil vellemus, nihil aliud optaremus. Crimina dicunt traditionis: ea crimina traditionis aut non probant archivis, et nihil dicunt; aut probant, et archivis nos vicissim agere compellunt. Itaque pervidet Pracstantia tua distinguendas esse causas, quando cogamur publicis legibus agere, quando autem velimus et optemus negotiuin Ecclesiæ nonnisi divinis eloquiis terminari.
( Et cum Donatistæ instarent, ut ederetur sibi Catholicorum Mandatum, qnod legatis ad petendam ab Imperatore Collationem directis injunctum fuerat) Augustinus disit: Jam toties conclamavimus. Mandatum quod injunctum est legatis episcoporum ab episcopis, flagitant sibi recitari: hoc est aliena requirere ad causam non pertinentia. Mandatum qnod nobis propter Collationem cum his faciendam injunctum est, hoc recitatum est, hoc eis sufficiat. Quid si enim aliqua legatis mandata sunt, ad causam quidem istam non pertinentia, sed quæ ipsos scire nolumus?
We show that we hold the catholic Church by the very testimony of our communion; and we have come down to prove this Church, if they permit, as declared not by human rumors nor by erring opinions, but by divine utterances. But that we should offer laws, or records, or whatever documents are produced from the archives, to be read out in this Collation, they themselves compel us, who act by such means. For if, with all documents of this kind set aside, they were unwilling for the Church to be understood except in the Scriptures, we would wish nothing, we would desire nothing else. They allege the crimes of tradition: those crimes of tradition they either do not prove by archives, and then they say nothing; or they do prove them, and they compel us in turn to act by archives. Therefore Your Excellency perceives clearly that the causes must be distinguished: when we are compelled to act by public laws, and when we wish and desire that the business of the Church be settled by divine utterances alone.
And when the Donatists insisted that there be given to them the Mandate of the Catholics, which had been enjoined upon the legates sent to seek a Collation from the Emperor, Augustine said: We have already cried out so many times. The Mandate which was enjoined upon the legates of the bishops by the bishops, they demand to have read out to them: this is to demand things alien and not pertaining to the cause. The Mandate which was enjoined upon us for the sake of making this Collation with them, this has been read out; let this suffice them. For what if some things were commanded to the legates that do not indeed pertain to this cause, but which we do not wish them to know?
Sufficit quod Imperator Collationem nos petisse suo testimonio declaravit. Hæc concessa est, ad hanc venimus, hæc aliquando agatur: veritati aures hominum palent.
Adeodatus episcopus dixit: Confessus es quas olim tacuisti. Ostendisti te inulta adversus nos mandasse quae scire non facile debeamus, etc.
Augustinus dixit: Non hoc dixi. Non advertisti, aut dissimulas le audisse quod dixi. Audi: planius hoc dicimns, ne forte culpa mea non intellexeris, dum id obscurius aliquantum dixi, studio brevitatis, quod percipere nequiveris. Notum cst omnibus multas causas habere Ecclesiam, et suam, ct privatarum personarum sibimet commissarum: et potest fieri ut ad episcoporum intercessionem multa pertineant. Secreta nobis committuntur negotiorum et causarum alienarum, in quibus nostra interventio saepe postulatur, propter quae auxilium ab Ecclesia poscitur. Haec prodenda non sunt, ne proditores inveniamur. Sufficit tibi quod Collationem me petiisse in causa tua, ipse testis est clementissimus imperator. Nihil ultra quæras, si negotia aliena non quaeris. Negotio tuo suflicit quod de ipsa Imperatoris lege recitatum est, quod nostro Mandato subscriptionibusque firmatum est.
It is sufficient that the Emperor has declared by his own testimony that we requested the Conference. It has been granted, we have come to it, let it at some time be conducted: the ears of men are open to the truth.
Bishop Adeodatus said: You have confessed the things you once kept silent about. You have shown that you issued unavenged orders against us, things which we ought not easily to know, etc.
Augustine said: I did not say this. You did not notice, or you pretend not to have heard what I said. Listen: we say this more plainly, lest perhaps through my fault you have not understood, since I spoke somewhat too obscurely, out of a desire for brevity, what you were unable to grasp. It is known to all that the Church has many cases, both her own and those of private persons entrusted to her; and it can happen that many matters pertain to the intercession of bishops. Secrets of business and of other people's cases are entrusted to us, in which our intervention is often sought, and on account of which help is requested from the Church. These things must not be betrayed, lest we be found betrayers. It is sufficient for you that the most clement Emperor himself is witness that I requested the Conference in your case. Seek nothing further, if you do not seek other people's business. For your business it is sufficient that what has been read from the Emperor's own law was confirmed by our Mandate and subscriptions.
( Et cum rursum instarent Donatistæ, ut eligerent Catholici utrum publicis legibus agere vellent, an divinis testimoniis, utque illarum jacturam facerent, si his uti cuperent ) Augustinus dixit: Ecclesia: quam tenemus, sicut omnes noverunt, quorum solent animos suis sollicitare criminationibus, et etiam sui Mandati tenore declararunt; Ecclesiæ, inquam, quam tenemus crimina solent traditionis objiccre. Si horum criminum jacturam faciunt, de chartis publicis nibil proferimus. Si autem in eadcm criminatione persisiunt, chartis publicis docemus hanc causam olim esse linitnm, nec tamen eos ab hujusmodi objicicndis criminibus cessavisse. Unde nunc Collationem istam poposcimus, nou ut illam causam traditionis, quam Cæciliano et ejus collegis objiciebant, suscipiamus dinuo finiendam, sed demonstremus olim esse finitam; ut hoc cognoscentes populi qui nesciunt, et istorum adhuc criminationibus commoventur, tandem aliquando cognoscant in qua Ecclesia christianæ salutis viam requirant. Si ergo de Ecclesia quæritur, quæ sit, quanta sit, qualis sit, sola divina testimonia ad eam demonstrandam sufficient.
(And when the Donatists again pressed that the Catholics choose whether they wished to proceed by public laws or by divine testimonies, and that they abandon the former if they wished to use the latter,) Augustine said: The Church which we hold, as all know whose minds they are accustomed to stir up with their accusations—and as they have even declared by the tenor of their own Mandate—the Church, I say, which we hold, they are accustomed to charge with the crimes of tradition. If they abandon these crimes, we produce nothing from the public records. But if they persist in the same accusation, we teach from the public records that this case was long ago settled, and yet that they have not ceased to bring charges of this kind. Wherefore we have now demanded this Conference, not that we should undertake to settle again that case of tradition which they brought against Caecilian and his colleagues, but that we should show that it was long ago settled; so that the peoples who do not know this, and are still stirred by their accusations, may at last come to know in which Church they should seek the way of Christian salvation. If, therefore, the question is about the Church—which she is, how great she is, what she is like—the divine testimonies alone are sufficient to demonstrate her.
Si homines appellant, si hominihus crimina intendunt, quanquam Ecclesiæ causa ab hominum causa distinguenda est, nee in hominibus spes ponenda est Ecclesiæ, si boni sunt; nerne, si mali sunt, jndicandn est Ecclesia Dei periisse: sed tamen etiam ipsorum causam tanquam fratrum nostrorum suscipimus, et si nohis ostendi potuerint criminosi, hodie illos anathemamus; non tamen propter illos Ecclesiam a Deo promissam et exhibitam deserimus aut relinquimus. Ipsi ergo eligant quod volunt: non objiciant crimina hominibus, et chartae cessahunt; sola divina loquetur auctoritas, sola Dei Scriptura, cui utrique subdimur, in medium proferetur.
( Et post plures prosecutiones et interlocutiones, cum Petilianus dixisset, Quis est iste qni agit? Cæciliani filius est, an non? ) Augustinus dixit: Ne vobis dicatis Patrem in terra ( Mallli. XXIII, 9), simul audivimus, simul legimus, simul populis prædicamus. Quid de me quaeris utrum sun filius Cæciliani? Caecilianus si innocens fuit, gaudeat de sua innocentia, me congaudente, non in ejus innocentia me spein meam ponente.
If they appeal to men, if they bring accusations against men—although the cause of the Church must be distinguished from the cause of men, and hope must not be placed in men, lest, if they are good, the Church be thought to stand by them, or, if they are evil, the Church of God be judged to have perished—nevertheless we take up even their cause as that of our brothers, and if they can be shown to us to be criminals, we anathematize them today; yet on their account we do not desert or abandon the Church promised and displayed by God. Let them therefore choose what they wish: let them not cast accusations against men, and the paper will fall silent; the divine authority alone will speak, the Scripture of God alone, to which we both submit, will be brought forward into the midst.
And after many pleadings and interlocutions, when Petilianus had said, Who is this who pleads? Is he a son of Caecilianus, or not? Augustine said: Let you not say to yourselves, Father on earth, we have heard together, we have read together, we preach together to the peoples. Why do you ask of me whether I am a son of Caecilianus? If Caecilianus was innocent, let him rejoice in his innocence, with me rejoicing, not placing my hope in his innocence.
Si autem nocens fuit, quod fortasse discussa causa vel sic vel aliter declarabit, sustinuit eum Ecclesia quam teneo ( ut a similitudinibus dominicis non recedam), sicut paleam in area, sicut in eisdem pascuis hædos, sicut in eisdem retibus pisces malos; non tamen propter malos nos aut aream dominicam deserere debemus, aut retia dominica nefaria animositate dissensionis abrumpere, et in mare ante tempus littoris prosilire.
( Ei post aliquot proscentiones Donatistarum et interlocutiones ) Augustinus dixit: Caeciliani causam vel collegarum ejus solent ipsi Ecclesiæ catholicae objicere, vel, ut sine controversia loqtiar, ipsi Ecclesiae quam tenemus. Proinde, ut video, magnum volunt aflerre compendium: si hanc causam non objiciunt Ecclesiæ quam tenemus, dicant quid ei objiciant. Si enim nihil, quare separamur? Si aliquid prætcr causam Cæciliani, idipsum offerant, id ostendant.
But if he was guilty—something that, once the case has been examined, will perhaps be made clear either this way or that—the Church that I hold (so as not to depart from the Lord's similitudes) endured him as chaff on the threshing floor, as goats in the same pastures, as bad fish in the same nets; yet on account of the wicked we ought not to abandon either the Lord's threshing floor, or with a wicked vehemence of dissension break apart the Lord's nets and leap into the sea before the time of the shore.
(And after several protestations and interlocutions of the Donatists) Augustine said: They are accustomed to object the case of Caecilianus, or of his colleagues, to the Catholic Church itself—or, to speak without controversy, to the Church itself which we hold. Therefore, as I see it, they wish to bring a great shortcut: if they do not object this case to the Church which we hold, let them say what they object to it. For if nothing, why are we separated? But if something besides the case of Caecilianus, let them offer that very thing, let them show it.
Petilianus episcopus dixit: Tu quis es? Filius es Cæciliani, an non? Tenet te crimen Cæciliani, an non, si fucrit?
Augustinus dixit: Ego in Ecclesia sum, in qua Caecilianus fuit.
Petilianus episcopus dixit: Unde ccepisti? Quem habes patrem? Alioquin si patrem tuum damnaveris, hæreticum te esse profiteris, qui nec originem vis habere, nec patrem.
Augustinus dixit: In Ecclesia sumus, in qua Cæcilianus episcopatum gessit et diem obiit. Ejus nomen ad altare recitamus, ejus memoriæ communicamus, tanquam memoriæ fratris, non tanquam patris aut matris. Quaeris autem a me unde communio mea sumat exordium. Dominus ipse Christus asserit exordium communionis meæ, dicens: Oportebat Christum pati, ct resurgere a mortuis tertio die, et prædicari in nomine ejus pænitentiam et remissionem peccatorum per omnes gentes, incipientibus ab Jerusalem ( Luc. XXIV, 46, ). Cæpit ista prædicatio ab Jerusalem: inde se ab illustrissimo exordio diffudit, diffudens Ecclesiam qnam tenemus, primo per vicina, deinde per longinqua, etiam in Africam venit. In hanc oculos aperimus, hanc in divinis eloquiis ct testimoniis, sicut ipsum Dominum Christum et Redemptorem nostrum, comperimus. Ab illo Dco patre, ab hac Ecclesia matre, nullius me hominis crimina, nullius calumniæ separabunt.
Petilianus the bishop said: Who are you? Are you a son of Caecilianus, or not? Does the charge against Caecilianus hold you, or not, if it has been established?
Augustine said: I am in the Church in which Caecilianus was.
Petilianus the bishop said: Where did you begin? Whom do you have as a father? Otherwise, if you condemn your father, you profess yourself to be a heretic, you who wish to have neither an origin nor a father.
Augustine said: We are in the Church in which Caecilianus held the episcopate and died. We recite his name at the altar, we communicate with his memory as with the memory of a brother, not as of a father or a mother. But you ask me where my communion takes its beginning. The Lord Christ himself asserts the beginning of my communion, saying: It was necessary that Christ should suffer and rise from the dead on the third day, and that repentance and remission of sins should be preached in his name among all nations, beginning from Jerusalem. That preaching began from Jerusalem; from there it spread itself abroad from a most illustrious beginning, spreading abroad the Church that we hold, first through neighboring places, then through distant ones, and it came even into Africa. Upon this Church we have opened our eyes; this Church we have found in the divine utterances and testimonies, just as we have found the Lord Christ himself and our Redeemer. From that God the Father, from this Church our mother, no man's crimes, no man's calumnies shall separate me.
( Et post alias quasdam prosecutiones et inlerlocutiones) Augustinus dixit: Ecce dico, quoties voluerint dico: Caecilianus non est pater meus; quia audio Doininum meum dicentem, Ne vobis patrem dicatis in terra; unus eat pater vester Deus. Dico Cæcilianum fratrem, bonum fratrem, si bonus; malum fratrem, si malus est: quoniam propter communia Sacramenta frater meus est. Si autem judicium de illo meum vis audire, ctiam innocentem credo, appetitum falsis criminationibus existimo: sed tanquam homo de homine existimans, non tanquam certum aliquid cre. dens. Tu si objicis Ecclesiae crimina Cæciliani, assisto, defendo tanquam fratris, ostendens non pertinere ad Ecclesiam, ncc ad ejus causam, nee ei præjudicare: et sic demonstro nihil te objicere Ecclesiæ catholicæ, etiamsi vera fortasse, quod nullo modo poteris demonstrare, siut crimina Cæciliani. Si autem nec ipsa vera potucris demonstrare, etiam te judice vides ubi remanscris, et quid rejecta tandem animositate crroris cligerc debeas, ut nobiscum tencas veritatem, nobiscum amplectaris damnato errore charitatem.
Augustine said: Behold, I say it, and I say it as often as they wish: Caecilianus is not my father, because I hear my Lord saying, "Do not call anyone on earth your father; one is your Father, God." I call Caecilianus a brother, a good brother if he is good, a bad brother if he is bad, since on account of the common sacraments he is my brother. But if you wish to hear my judgment concerning him, I even believe him innocent, and I consider that he was assailed by false accusations—but as a man forming an opinion about a man, not as one believing something certain. If you bring against the Church the crimes of Caecilianus, I stand by her, I defend her as a brother's cause, showing that they do not pertain to the Church, nor to her case, nor do they prejudice her; and thus I demonstrate that you bring no charge against the catholic Church, even if those things are perhaps true—which you can in no way demonstrate—as the crimes of Caecilianus. But if you cannot demonstrate that they are even true, you see, even with yourself as judge, where you have remained, and what, once your vehemence of error has at last been cast off, you ought to choose, so that you may hold the truth with us, and with us, error condemned, embrace charity.
( Et cum contenderent Donatistæ, Cæcilianum Catholicis radicem fuisse vel caput) Augustinus dixit: Habeo caput, sed Christus cst, cujus Apostolum audio dicentem, Omnia vestra, vos autem Christi, Christus vero Dei (I Cor. III,, 23). Nam ct uhi se patrem dixit Apostolus, IIC ipsius paternitatis velut basem humanam infirmitatem crederemus, addidit, Per Evangelium ego vos genui ( (Id. IV, ). Semen ergo et vena seminis mei de Evangelio ducitur. Ilonorificentiæ causa patres appellamus cos qui nos vel tempore vel meritis præcesserunt. Aliud est cum. quærimus ad fidem quem habeamus patrem, ad salutem æternam quem habeamus patrem, ad retinendam Ecclesiam et percipienda Dei promissa quem habeamus patrem. Nam illud honoris est, ut quotidie senibus dicamus, Pater. Quotidie etiam. quibusdam non nobiscum in una Ecclesia nee in iisdem Sacramentis constitutis dicimus, Frater. Sodomitis etiam dixit Lot, Fratres: utique ad lcniendum eorum animositatem, non ad cognitam fraternitatem ct quasi unius hæreditate I consortium. Tollantur ergo ista, distinguamus vocabula qu:c hominibus propter honoicm debentur, ct vocabulum quod propter salutem requirimus. Pro salute æterna, pace Apostoli dixerim, imo jubente Apostolo dixerim, non pater meus Apostolus est ad salutem æternam, qui milii dicit, Ego plantavi, Apollo rigavit: sed Deus incrementum dedit.
And when the Donatists were contending that Caecilianus was the root or head of the Catholics, Augustine said: I have a head, but it is Christ, whose Apostle I hear saying, "All things are yours, and you are Christ's, and Christ is God's" (1 Cor 3:23). For even when the Apostle called himself a father, lest we should believe that the very basis of that fatherhood was human weakness, he added, "I begot you through the Gospel" (1 Cor 4:15). Therefore the seed and the channel of my seed is derived from the Gospel. It is for the sake of honor that we call those fathers who have preceded us either in time or in merits. It is one thing when we ask, for the sake of faith, whom we should have as father; for the sake of eternal salvation, whom we should have as father; for the sake of holding fast to the Church and receiving God's promises, whom we should have as father. For that [use of the word] is a matter of honor, so that we daily call old men "father." Daily, too, we call "brother" certain people who are not established with us in one Church or in the same sacraments. Lot even said to the Sodomites, "Brothers"—certainly to soften their hostility, not out of any acknowledged brotherhood or, as it were, partnership in a single inheritance. Let these things, then, be set aside; let us distinguish the terms that are owed to men on account of honor from the term that we require on account of salvation. For eternal salvation's sake—I would say with the Apostle's leave, or rather, at the Apostle's command—the Apostle is not my father for eternal salvation, he who says to me, "I planted, Apollos watered, but God gave the growth.
llaque neque qui plantat est aliquid, neque qui rigat; sed qui incrementum dat Deus (Id. in,, ). De hoc Dominus dixit, Nolite vobis dicere patrem in terra. Utique scivit dicturum Apostolum, Per Evangelium ego vos genui. Non enim Domino dicenti, Ne. vobis dicatis patrem in terra, contrarius futurus crat Apostolus dicens, Etsi multos habeatis patres, per Evangelium ego vos genui. Sed quia distinxit ad quam rem patrem nobis constituerit Dominus, et pro qua honorificentia etiam Apostolum possemus patrem accipere, ideo sic locutus est, ut ejus oratio non esset contraria dominicae vcritati. Patres igitur quoscumque agnosco in terra, honorificentiæ causa agnosco. Patroni salutis meæ non teneo nisi Deum, de quo mihi Dominus dixit, Ne vobis patrem dicatis in terra; et cui quotidie dicimus, Pater noster, qui es in cælis ( Matth. vi, ).
( Et cum Donatistæ quaererent quis ordinaverit Angustinum ) Augustinus dixit: Superflua quæri video a fratribus nostris diverso sistentibus; ct ad ipsa superflua non denego responsionem; dum tamen Ecclesiæ causa, cui responderi nihil potest, in fundamento tutissimo collocetur. Ego, cujus ordinatorem requiris, homo sum christianus, fidelis, quod Deo teste loquor, catholicus, unde adhuc ambigimus quis dignus hoc nomine vocitetur. Ego illam Ecclesiam defendo, hanc assero qualicumque voce; in qua quidquid fuero, illa Ecclesia est.
For neither is he that planteth anything, nor he that watereth; but God that giveth the increase. Concerning this the Lord said, "Call no man your father upon the earth." Surely he knew that the Apostle would say, "I have begotten you through the Gospel." For the Apostle would not be contrary to the Lord saying, "Call no man your father upon the earth," when he says, "Though you have many fathers, I have begotten you through the Gospel." But because the Lord distinguished for what purpose he established a father for us, and for what honor we might also accept the Apostle as a father, he therefore spoke thus, so that his word would not be contrary to the Lord's truth. Therefore whatever fathers I acknowledge on earth, I acknowledge them for the sake of honor. I hold no patrons of my salvation except God, of whom the Lord said to me, "Call no man your father upon the earth"; and to whom we say daily, "Our Father, who art in heaven."
And when the Donatists were asking who ordained Augustine, Augustine said: I see that superfluous questions are being asked by our brothers who stand for a different party; and to these superfluous questions I do not deny an answer; provided nevertheless that the cause of the Church, to which nothing can be answered, be placed on the safest foundation. I, whose ordainer you seek, am a man, a Christian, a believer—as I speak with God as witness—a Catholic, whence we are still in doubt as to who is worthy to be called by this name. I defend that Church, I assert this one with whatever voice I can; in whatever state I may be, that Church is she.
Video quo tendas; humanas calumnias consectaris: et quæ so. leatis jactare et dicere, non alienum est ab auribus vel a cordibus nostris. Megalius me ordinavit, primas Ecclesiæ Numidiæ catholicæ, eo tempore quo ille me potuit ordinare. Ecce respondi: prosequere, profer quæ præparas: ibi etiam calumniosus appareas. Ecce dixi ordinatorem meum: profer jam calumnias tuas.
Donatistarum litteræ, hac tertia die prolatae, guibus Mandato Catholicorum prima die Collationis allegato respondere conantur.
Flavio Marcellino viro clarissimo el spectabili tribuno et notario, Januarianus et cæteri episcopi veritatis catholicæ, quæ persecutionem patitur, non quoe facit.
i. Quia apud acta Nobilitatis tuæ fratribus colle gisque nostris defensionem mandavimus, magnum justi cognitoris indicium est, quod uni parti concesserit, alteri non negare, ne uni parti favere, altcram premere videatur. Quod te pro tua prudentia et longe prospicere, ct longius condecet praecavere: maxime cum populos edictis invites de audientine tuæ libramine judicare. Adversarii igitur, traditores, persecutoresque nostri cum elucubratum volumen sui mandati diuque conceptum et expositum actis ingererent, sine praejudicio equidem nostro libenter audisti: quod ut huic epistolae nostrae concedas, impendio postulamus.
I see where you are going; you pursue human calumnies, and the things you are accustomed to boast of and say are not foreign to our ears or our hearts. Megalius ordained me, primate of the catholic Church of Numidia, at the time when he was able to ordain me. Behold, I have answered: proceed, bring forth what you are preparing; there too let your calumnious nature appear. Behold, I have named my ordainer: now bring forth your calumnies.
The letters of the Donatists, produced on this third day, in which they attempt to respond to the Mandate of the Catholics cited on the first day of the Conference.
To Flavius Marcellinus, most illustrious man and honorable tribune and notary, Januarianus and the other bishops of the catholic truth, which suffers persecution, not which inflicts it.
i. Since before the acts of Your Nobility we have entrusted a defense to our brothers and colleagues, it is a great indication of a just examiner that what he has granted to one party, he does not deny to the other, lest he seem to favor one party and oppress the other. This it befits you, by your prudence, both to foresee far in advance and to guard against still further; especially since by your edicts you invite the peoples to judge from the balance of your hearing. Therefore our adversaries, the traditors and persecutors of us, when they brought into the acts the carefully composed volume of their mandate, long conceived and set forth, you indeed heard them willingly, without prejudice to us; and we earnestly request that you grant this to this letter of ours.
Non quo illorum prava perversaque doctrina nos terreat, sed ne labor sit defensoribus nostris, contra librum illorum prolixum, et contra prosecutiones eorum confligere, cum nec dies totus causæ sufficiat, nec vox aut latera defensioni, tit liber cum libro et defensio cum defensione concertet. Quare igitur hanc epistulam nostram petimus accipi atque inseri jubeas, tunc deinde causam audire digneris.
Adversarii enim nostri decursis testimoniis, quibus Ecclesia cum laude sui ubique diffunditur, id prins mandant suis defensoribus peragendum, ut contra nos qui Ecclesia; defendimus puritatem, isto modo agant, ut camdem Ecclesiam habituram in se permixtos simul bonos et malos usque in finem saeculi dicant esse pricdiclam. Cujus rei causa nos magis ostendimus, Ecclesiam Domini in Scripturis divinis sauctam et immaculatam fore ubique nuntiatam. Per Isaiam: Exsurge, Sion; indue fortitudinem tuam, Jerusalem civitas sancta; non adjiciet transire per te incircumcisus et immundus (Isai. LII, 1). Et iterum: Dic, filia Sion, Ecce tibi salvator adveniet, habens mercedem et opus ante faciem suam, et vocabit illum populum sanctum, redemptum a Domino. Tu autem vocaberis desiderata civitas, et non derelicta (Id. LXII, ii, 12). Et iterum: Confortamini, manus dissolutæ; et genua debilia, confortamini: qui estis pusillanimes, nolite timere.
Not because the depraved and perverse doctrine of those men frightens us, but so that there may be no burden for our defenders to struggle against their lengthy book and against their pleadings, since neither a whole day would suffice for the case, nor voice or lungs for the defense, so that book may contend with book and defense with defense. Therefore we ask that this our letter be accepted and that you order it to be inserted, and then that you deign to hear the case.
For our adversaries, having run through the testimonies by which the Church is spread abroad everywhere with her praise, first command their defenders to accomplish this: that against us who defend the purity of the Church, they should act in this way—that they say the same Church is foretold as having good and evil mixed together within her even to the end of the world. For this reason we rather show that the Church of the Lord is announced everywhere in the divine Scriptures as holy and immaculate. Through Isaiah: Arise, Sion; put on your strength, Jerusalem, holy city; the uncircumcised and the unclean shall no longer pass through you (Isa. 52:1). And again: Say, daughter of Sion, Behold, your savior will come to you, having his reward and his work before his face, and he will call them a holy people, redeemed by the Lord. But you shall be called the desired city, and not forsaken (Isa. 62:11-12). And again: Be strengthened, you hands that are slack, and you feeble knees, be strengthened; you who are faint-hearted, do not fear.
Dominus noster judicium retribuet, et ipse veniet, et salvos faciet nos. Tunc aperientur oculi cæcorum, et aures surdorum audient, planaerit lingua mutorum, et claudus saliet sicut cervus. Quoniam rupta eat in deserto aqua, et fons in terra sitienti. Et adjecit: Illic via munda, et via sancta vocabitur; et non transibit illic immundus, neque erit illic via immunda. Etiam illic non erit leo, neque ex bestiis maiis ascendet in illa, neque invenientiur in illa, sed ambulabunt illic redempti et electi (Id. XXXV, 10). De qua in Canticis canticorum ex persona Domini scriptum est Tota speciosa es, soror meat et reprehensio non eat in te (Cant. IV, 7). Quod Paulus apostolus apertissime demonstravit dicens: Christus dilexit Ecclesiam, et semetipsum tradidit propter eam, ut eam sanctificaret, purgans eam aquæ lavucro in verbo, et adjungens sibi gloriosam Ecclesiam, uon habentem maculam nerne rugam. aut aliquid ejusmodi, sed sanclam et immaculatam (Ephes. v, 25-27). Et iterum: Desponsavi enim vos urti viro virginem sanctam assignare Christo (II Cor. xi, 2).
Our Lord will repay judgment, and he himself will come and save us. Then the eyes of the blind will be opened, and the ears of the deaf will hear, the tongue of the mute will be made plain, and the lame will leap like a deer. For water has broken forth in the desert, and a spring in the thirsty land. And he added: There will be a clean way, and it will be called the holy way; and the unclean will not pass through there, nor will there be an unclean way there. Indeed, there will be no lion there, nor will any of the evil beasts go up on it, nor will they be found on it, but the redeemed and chosen will walk there (Isa. XXXV, 10). Concerning this, in the Song of Songs, in the person of the Lord, it is written: You are entirely beautiful, my sister, and there is no reproach in you (Cant. IV, 7). The apostle Paul demonstrated this most clearly, saying: Christ loved the Church, and gave himself up for her, so that he might sanctify her, cleansing her by the washing of water in the word, and joining to himself a glorious Church, not having spot or wrinkle or anything of the kind, but holy and immaculate (Eph. V, 25-27). And again: For I have betrothed you to one husband, to present you as a holy virgin to Christ (II Cor. XI, 2).
Ilis crgo lot et tantis documentis de Ecclesiae purit te, quæ per Spiritum promittebalur, spretis, atque contemptis, malas in illa inter bonos esse mansuros, per zizaniorum similitudinem incompetenter affirmant, cum ipsam similitudinem Dominus interpretatus sit Apostolis suis dicens: Qui seminat semen bonum. Filius est hominis. Ager autem eat hic mundus; bonum autem semen ii sunt filii regni; zizania autem filii sunt maligni; inimicus autem qui seminat ea, diabolus est; messis autem, consummatio sæculi; messores autem Angdi sunt (Matth. XIII, 37-59), et caera. Ager, inquit, eat mundus: non ergo Ecclesia, sed mundus, III quo boni simul et mali usque ad messem, id est, usque ad divinum judicium reservantur. Quia nec potest a Domino interpretata imo I corrumpere. Quoniam si Apostoli, ipsius Domini comites, in Ecclesia zizania, id est filios diaboli pullulantes, in sanctorum communione dimittendos esse didicissent, nunquam Simonem, Erastum, Filetum, Alexandrum, Deman, Hermogenem, coeterosque consimiles Ecclesia; liminibus ejecissent. Imo si ita esset, vacaret totum præconium Scripturarum divinarum, quo jubcntur polluti e medio sanctorum, sacerdotum diligentia separari, dicente Domino per Moysen: Legitimum inquit, ceterum in progenies vestras, dividere inter aunclos et profanos, inter mundos et immundos (Levit. x, I, 10).
Therefore, having spurned and despised these so many and such great proofs concerning the purity of the Church, which was promised through the Spirit, they incompetently assert, by the likeness of the tares, that evil people are to remain in it among the good—although the Lord himself interpreted that very likeness to his Apostles, saying: "He who sows the good seed is the Son of Man. The field is this world; the good seed are the children of the kingdom; the tares are the children of the wicked one; the enemy who sows them is the devil; the harvest is the consummation of the age; the reapers are the Angels," and the rest. The field, he says, is the world—not, therefore, the Church, but the world, in which both good and evil are reserved until the harvest, that is, until the divine judgment. For neither can what has been interpreted by the Lord be corrupted—or rather, [they cannot] corrupt it. For if the Apostles, companions of the Lord himself, had learned that the tares in the Church, that is, the children of the devil sprouting up, were to be left in the communion of the saints, they would never have cast Simon, Erastus, Philetus, Alexander, Demas, Hermogenes, and the rest of their kind out from the thresholds of the Church. Indeed, if it were so, the whole proclamation of the divine Scriptures would be void, by which the polluted are commanded to be separated from the midst of the saints by the diligence of the priests, the Lord saying through Moses: "This is a legitimate statute, moreover, throughout your generations, to divide between the holy and the profane, between the clean and the unclean.
Quod alibi neglectum in persona sacerdotum Spiritus increpat dicens: Sacerdotes ejus repulerunt legem meam; profanabat sancta mea, inter mundum et immundum non dividebant, et inter sanctum et pollutum non separabant (Ezech. XXII, 26). Ad hanc parabolam illud quoque adversarii subjungunt, aleas cum frumentis debere simul in Ecclesia permanere. Quod Jeremias repercutit, dicens, Quid paleis ad frumentum (Jerem. XliII, 2M)? ct Paulus apostolus, Qua: particula eat fideli cum infideli? aut quæ communio luci ad tenebras (II Cor. vi, 15, 14)? el Salomon, St communicabit lupus agno aliquando, sic peccator justo (Eccli. XIII, 21). Pisces etiam bonos et malos uno reticulo usque ad littus, id ea, justos et injustos usque in linem sæculi simul contiueri et protrahi confirmant, non intuentes hoc de reis latentibus dictum; quoniam reticulum in mari positum quid habeat, a piscatoribus, id est, a sacerdotibus ignoratur, donec extractum ad littus ad purffationem boni seu mali prodantur. Ita et latentes et in Ecclesia constituti et a sacerdotibus ignorati, in divino judicio proditi, tanquam pisces mali, a sanctorum consortio separantur, sicut Dominus in Evangelio de latenti reo qui per obreptionem sacerdotes fefellerat, per figuram loquitur dicens: Intrans, inquit, Rex videre recumbentes, vidit illic hominem non habentem vestimentum nuptiale, et ait iili: Amice, quomodo huc venisti?
What is elsewhere neglected, the Spirit reproaches in the person of the priests, saying: "Her priests have rejected my law; they profaned my holy things, they did not divide between the world and the unclean, and they did not separate between the holy and the polluted" (Ezek. 22:26). To this parable the adversaries also add that the tares ought to remain together with the wheat in the Church. Jeremiah strikes this down, saying, "What has chaff to do with wheat?" (Jer. 23:28), and the apostle Paul, "What part has a believer with an unbeliever? Or what fellowship has light with darkness?" (2 Cor. 6:15, 14), and Solomon, "Will the wolf ever share with the lamb? So does the sinner with the just" (Sir. 13:21). They also affirm that the good and the bad fish are held together and drawn in one net even to the shore, that is, that the just and the unjust are kept together and dragged along even to the end of the world, not perceiving that this was said of hidden offenders; since what the net cast into the sea contains is unknown to the fishermen, that is, to the priests, until, drawn to the shore for purification, the good or the bad are made manifest. So also those who are hidden and established in the Church and unknown to the priests, when exposed in the divine judgment, are separated like the bad fish from the company of the saints, just as the Lord in the Gospel speaks in figure concerning the hidden offender who had deceived the priests by stealth, saying: "The King," he says, "entering in to see those reclining at table, saw there a man not having a wedding garment, and said to him: Friend, how did you come in here?
Ille autem obmutuit. Et dixit Rex ministris suis: Auferte illum pedibus et manibus, et mittite illum in tenebras exteriores; illic erit ploratio et stridor dentium (Matth. xxu 11-13). Secundum hanc igitur rationem frustra dixerunt bonos propter malos sacrilega scparatione non deseri, sed malos propter bonos pia unitate tolerari; cum propter hanc profanam permixtionem commoveri et sejunctionem maximam provocare alio loco Dominus indignatus ostendat. Pro eo. inquit, quod facta est mihi omnis domus Israel permixtio, omnes æramentum, argentum, ferrum, stannum et plumbum, in medio camini ardentis permixtum; propterea dicit: Hæc dicit Dominus, Propter quod facti estis omnes in permixtiont una, ideo ego recipio vos in medio Jerusalem, sicut recipitur æramentum, argentum et ferrum et stannum et plumbum in medio camini, ad insufflandum in igni, ut confletur: ita recipiam vos in ira mea, et concremabo, et insufflabo in vos insufflationem ignis iræ meæ; et conflabimini in medio ejus, et scietis qnia ego sum Dominus, qui effudi iram meam super vos (Etech. xxn, 18-22).
But he fell silent. And the King said to his servants: Take him by the feet and hands, and cast him into the outer darkness; there will be weeping and gnashing of teeth (Matt. 22:11-13). According to this reasoning, therefore, they have said in vain that the good are not to be abandoned because of the wicked by sacrilegious separation, but that the wicked are to be tolerated because of the good in pious unity; since the Lord, indignant, shows in another place that because of this profane mixture He is stirred up and provokes the greatest separation. For this reason, he says, because all the house of Israel has become to me a mixture, all bronze, silver, iron, tin, and lead, mixed in the midst of a burning furnace; therefore he says: Thus says the Lord, Because you have all become one mixture, therefore I will gather you into the midst of Jerusalem, as bronze, silver, iron, tin, and lead are gathered into the midst of a furnace, to blow upon the fire, that it may be melted: so will I gather you in my anger, and I will burn you up, and I will blow upon you the blast of the fire of my wrath; and you shall be melted in the midst of it, and you shall know that I am the Lord, who have poured out my wrath upon you (Ezek. 22:18-22).
Contra haec et talia, quibus Ecclesia Dei a contaminatione permixtorum immundorum defenditur, clarum est adversarios qua conscientia patrocinantes erroribus malos nolint a bonorum communione discerni. Sequuntur enim apertissime blasphemantes ut dicant Ecclosiam malorum delictis etiam manifestorum non posse maculari, adhibentes exempla Prophetarum, qui licet eos increparent pro delictis, lamen se ab cis corporaliter non separarunt: cum ostendamus longe ahud fnisse illod tempus, in quo frequentare baptismum toties quoties peccabant permittebatur. Tamen etiam sic, inveniuntur iidem Prophetae a malorum communione se abstinuisse, quando Sophonias propheta, qui ad Jeroboam in schismate positum missus, nec panem nec aquam jubetur accipere: qui circumventus, violato præcepto, a leone confertus est. Elias etiam et Elisaeus altaribus schismatis Samariæ nunquam communicaverint, neque consenserint1; qui magis in solitudine morabantur. Osce quoquo propheta ostenditur non interfuisse mysteriis corum, quorum sacrificia detestatur et damnat, dicens: Sacrificia eorum tanquam vanis tuctus; omnis qui tetigerit ex eis inquinabitur (Osee IX, 4). Amos denique quando potuit Samariae mysteriis misceri, de quo pseudopropheta ita regi invidiam facit, dicens: Conglobationes facit adversum te Amos in medio domus Israel; non potest terra supportare sermones ejus (Amos VII, 10)?
Against these and similar arguments, by which the Church of God is defended from the contamination of the mixed-in unclean, it is clear with what conscience the adversaries, patronizing errors, do not wish the wicked to be separated from the communion of the good. For they follow most openly those who blaspheme, so as to say that the Church cannot be defiled by the sins of the wicked, even manifest ones, adducing the examples of the Prophets, who, although they rebuked them for their sins, nevertheless did not separate themselves from them bodily: whereas we show that that time was far different, in which it was permitted to frequent baptism as often as they sinned. Yet even so, the same Prophets are found to have abstained from the communion of the wicked, when Zephaniah the prophet, who was sent to Jeroboam established in schism, is commanded to receive neither bread nor water: who, having been circumvented, with the command violated, was torn apart by a lion. Elijah also and Elisha never communicated with, nor consented to, the altars of the schism of Samaria; who rather dwelt in solitude. Hosea too the prophet is shown not to have been present at the mysteries of those whose sacrifices he detests and condemns, saying: Their sacrifices are like the bread of mourning; all who eat of them shall be defiled (Hosea 9:4). Finally Amos, when could he have mixed with the mysteries of Samaria, concerning whom the false prophet thus stirs up hatred against the king, saying: Amos makes conspiracies against you in the midst of the house of Israel; the land cannot bear all his words (Amos 7:10)?
Et ob hoc insuper expellitur. Jam vero in ipsa Jerusalem quomodo poterant Prophetæ sacrificiis peccantium hominum communicare, quæ ipsi divino Spiritu pleni damnabant, Isaia dicente, Quo milii multitudinem socrificiorum vestrorum, dicit Duminus? Plenus sum. Holocaustomata arietum et adipem agnorum et sanguinem taurorum et hircorum nolo, nec sic veniatis in conspectu meo. Quis enim exquisivit ista de manibus vestris? Calcare autam meam non adjicietis: si attule itis similaginem, vanum; incensum abominatio est mihi. Neomenias vestras et sabbata et diem magnum non sustineo. Jejunium et feriat et dies festos vestros odit anima mea. Facti enim estis mihi in abundantia multa. Jam nox parcam peccatis vestris. Cum extenderitis manus, avertam oculos meos a vobis: et si multiplicaveritis preces, non exaudiam vos. Manus euim vestræ sanguine plenæ sunt (Isai. I, 1115). Et iterum: Facinorosus autem qui sacrificat mihi vitulum, quasi qui canent occidat; et qui similam offert, quasi sanguinem porcinam; et qui thus in memoriam, quasi blasphemus (Id. LXVI, 3). Aggæus etiam nou modo sacriticia, sed ipsam gentem peccatricem penitus exsecratur, dicens: Sic et populus iste et sic gens ista, et si quis illuc accesserit, inquinabitur (Aggæi II, 15). Et. Malachiel: Vos, o sacerdotes, qui profanatis nomen meum, et dixistis, In quo profanavimus nomen tuum?
And for this reason he is furthermore cast out. But indeed, in Jerusalem itself, how could the prophets have shared in the sacrifices of sinful men, which they themselves, full of the divine Spirit, condemned, as Isaiah says: "To what purpose is the multitude of your sacrifices to me, says the Lord? I am full. I do not want the burnt offerings of rams and the fat of lambs and the blood of bulls and goats, nor shall you come so into my sight. For who has required these things from your hands? You shall not add to trample my courts; if you bring fine flour, it is vain; incense is an abomination to me. I cannot endure your new moons and sabbaths and the great day. My soul hates your fast and your feast and your festival days. For you have become to me in great abundance. Now I will no longer spare your sins. When you stretch out your hands, I will turn my eyes away from you; and if you multiply prayers, I will not hear you. For your hands are full of blood" (Isa. 1:11-15). And again: "But the wicked man who sacrifices a calf to me is as one who kills a dog; and he who offers fine flour is as one who offers swine's blood; and he who offers incense for a memorial is as a blasphemer" (Isa. 66:3). Haggai also execrates not only the sacrifices but the sinful people themselves utterly, saying: "So is this people and so is this nation, and whoever approaches there shall be defiled" (Hag. 2:15). And Malachi: "You, O priests, who profane my name, and you have said, In what have we profaned your name?
Et ponentes a in altari meo panes pollutos; et dixistis, In quo polluimus illos? In eo ut diceretis, Mensa Domini benedicta est, et quæ superponebantur annullastis (Malach. i 6, 7). Et ita in omnibus Prophetis invenies, quoniam si communicassent eis quos tantis vocihus condemn bant, praevaricationis crimen incurrerent. Quod ergo iutcroos crant, commorationis fuit, non communionis.
In defensionem deindc sceleris sui auctoritatem sibi exemplo traditoris Judae assumunt, quo eum dicant a Domino, et praecognitum assumptum, et cogn!tum toleratum: cum utique sine præjudicio praescientiæ suae Dominus Christus Judam in numerum Apostolorum assumpserit; cognitum autem sibi, non hominibus, hac ratione pertulerit, qua et hodie perferre videtur occultos. Scriptum est enim: Qum occulta sunt, mihi; qum manifesta, vobis et filiis vestris (Deut. xxix, 29). In Psalmis: Nonne Deus inquiret ista? Ipse enim scit latentia cordis (Psal. XLIII, 22). In Regnorum prino: Homo videt in facie, Deus au-A tem videt in corde (I Reg. xvi, 7). Et in Apocalypsi: Et scient omnes Ecclesiæ quoniam ego sum scrutator renum el cordis (Apoc. n, 23). Denique Domino cum discipulis rccumbenle et dicente, Unus ex vobis me tradet; atquc respondente codem Juda, Numquid ego sum, Domine? et ah codem Domino audirct, Tu dixisti (Matth.
And placing polluted loaves upon my altar; and you said, In what have we polluted them? In that you said, The table of the Lord is blessed, and the things that were placed upon it you have brought to nothing (Malachi 1:6-7). And so you will find it in all the Prophets, that if they had shared with those whom they condemned with such great voices, they would have incurred the charge of transgression. Therefore, that they were among them was a matter of dwelling, not of communion.
Then, for the defense of their crime, they take to themselves the authority of the traitor Judas as an example, by which they say that he was both foreknown and assumed by the Lord, and known and tolerated; whereas, certainly, without prejudice to His foreknowledge, the Lord Christ assumed Judas into the number of the Apostles; but He tolerated him as known to Himself, not to men, for the same reason by which He is seen to tolerate hidden men even today. For it is written: The hidden things are mine; the manifest things are yours and your children's (Deuteronomy 29:29). In the Psalms: Does not God inquire into these things? For He Himself knows the hidden things of the heart (Psalm 43:22). In the first book of Kings: Man sees in the face, but God sees in the heart (1 Kings 16:7). And in the Apocalypse: And all the Churches shall know that I am the searcher of the reins and the heart (Apocalypse 2:23). Finally, when the Lord was reclining with the disciples and saying, One of you will betray me; and when the same Judas answered, Am I the one, Lord? and heard from the same Lord, You have said it (Matthew
xxvi, 21, 25): dcuctum se protinus videns, confusus abscessil; seu cum ipsa postmodum turba ad tradendum Dominum venit. Vadant ergo cum suo Juda patrono, inimici dominicæ veritatis, qui suo niore dcfenderc I'eos manifestissimos elaborant.
Item ad defensionem pollutæ permixtionis suae verba Apostoli objiciunt, quibus ait, Sive per occasionem, sive per veritatem (Philipp. I, 18)......... miserebor quoniam filii fornicationis sunt, quia fornicata est Muter ipsorum; dedecoravit eos, quæ peperit eoa (Osee II, 4, 5). Et in Isaia: Quomodo vestimentum conspersum in sanguine non erit mundum, ita nec tu eris mundus: quia terram meam perdidisti, ct plebem meam occidisti, non manebis in æternum tempus, semen nequam. Para filios tuos interfici peccatis patris sui, ut non exsurgant (Isai. xiv, 20, sec. LXX). Et in Regnoruin libro tertio: Et deposuit Salomon Abiathar de sacerdotio Domini, ut impleatur verbum Domini quod locutus est de domo Heli in Selom (III Reg. II, 27).
seeing himself straightway led away, he withdrew in confusion; or when afterward he came with that same crowd to betray the Lord. Let them go, then, with their patron Judas, the enemies of the Lord's truth, who strive with all their might to defend those most manifestly guilty.
Likewise, in defense of their polluted mixture, they bring forward the words of the Apostle, in which he says, Whether by occasion or by truth (Philippians 1:18)......... I will have mercy, because they are the children of fornication, for their mother has played the harlot; she who bore them has dishonored them (Hosea 2:4-5). And in Isaiah: As a garment sprinkled with blood shall not be clean, so neither shall you be clean: because you have destroyed my land and killed my people, you shall not remain for eternal time, evil seed. Prepare your sons to be killed for the sins of their father, that they may not rise up (Isaiah 14:20, according to the Septuagint). And in the third book of Kings: And Solomon deposed Abiathar from the priesthood of the Lord, that the word of the Lord might be fulfilled which he spoke concerning the house of Eli in Shiloh (1 Kings 2:27).
Jamvero quod dicunt, Baptismum Chrisli ita defendi, sicut ipsa Catholica defenditur ubique et apud omnes esse, decretis patrum nostrorum martyrum beatissimorum compendio brevilatis excluditur. Illud autem quam incaute immemores sui inimici veritatis oppugnant, apua fures et raptores quoslibet extraneos datum Baptisma suscipi deucrc, adhibito incompetenti ad hanc rem testimonio Pauli apostoli, quod scriptum est, Qui veritatem Dei in injustitia detinent: hoc in loco furtum furtivo voluerunt defendere testimonio. Apostolus enim de Gentilibus agens et incredulos increpans ita loculus est, dicens: Revclabitur enim ira Dei de cælo super Omnem impietatem et injustitiam hominum eorum qui veritatem Dei ii, injustitia detinent; quoniam quud cognoscibile est Dei, manifestum est in illis: Deus enim illis manifestavit. Etenim quæ invisibilia sunt ejus, a constitutione mundi, per ea quas facta sunt, intellecta conspiciuntur; sempiterna quoque virtus ejus et divinitas, ita ut sint inexcusabiles: quia cum cognovissent Deum, non ut Deum honorificaverunt, aut gratias egerunt; sed evanuerunt in cogitationibus suis, et intenebratum est insipiens cor illorum. Dicentes enim se esse sapientes, infatuati sunt; el immutaverunt claritatem Dei incorrupti, in similitudine imaginis corruptibilis hominis et volucrum et quadrupedum et serpentum.
But as for what they say—that the baptism of Christ is to be defended in such a way as the Catholic Church herself is defended, namely that she exists everywhere and among all—this is excluded by the decrees of our fathers, the most blessed martyrs, in a brief summary. But that point, which the enemies of the truth, forgetful of themselves, assail so incautiously—that baptism given among thieves and any outsiders and strangers is to be received—they support with testimony of the apostle Paul that is incompetent for this matter, namely what is written: "Who hold the truth of God in unrighteousness." In this passage they wished to defend theft by a stolen testimony. For the apostle, speaking of the Gentiles and rebuking the unbelieving, spoke thus, saying: "For the wrath of God is revealed from heaven upon all ungodliness and unrighteousness of men who hold the truth of God in unrighteousness; because that which is knowable of God is manifest in them: for God has manifested it to them. For the invisible things of him, from the constitution of the world, are understood and seen through the things which are made; his eternal power also and divinity, so that they are without excuse: because when they knew God, they did not honor him as God, or give thanks; but they became vain in their thoughts, and their foolish heart was darkened. For saying themselves to be wise, they were made foolish; and they changed the glory of the incorruptible God into the likeness of the image of corruptible man and of birds and of four-footed beasts and of serpents.
Propter quod tradidit illos Deus in concupiscentia cordis illorum in immunditiam (Rom. I, 18-24). Unde secundum hunc sensum etiam Gentilium inquinata mysteria sc suscipere profitentur. Seculi autem sunt errorem suum evidentissimis accumulare blasphemiis, quo dicanteos qui hæreticorum Baptisma reprobant, posse Christum reprobare quod cum dsemonia confessa sunt. Hoc loco non solum sanctorum martyrum decretis insultant, sed magis pal'ali sunt dæmoniorum, quia Christum confessi sunt, communioni misceri. Quod autem subtili brevitate ila dixerunt, eum qui loris baptizatus fuerit, suscipi dcbere, non ut quod deest adsit1, sed ut quod inest prosit: iit utroquc se ipsos circumvenisse monstrantur. Omnia enim hæc, ut supra dicum. est, sanctorum martyrum sententiis evacuamur. Unde cnim licri potest, si una est Ecclesia et indivisus est Christus, ut foris positus Baptismum consequatur?
For this reason God handed them over to the desires of their hearts, to impurity (Rom 1:18-24). Hence, according to this understanding, they even profess to receive the polluted mysteries of the Gentiles. But it is characteristic of the world to heap up its error with the most evident blasphemies, by which they say that those who reject the baptism of heretics can have Christ reject what was confessed together with demons. In this passage they not only insult the decrees of the holy martyrs, but are shown all the more plainly to be mingling with demons, because they have confessed Christ. But in what they said with subtle brevity—that one who has been baptized among them ought to be received, not so that what is lacking may be supplied, but so that what is present may benefit—they are shown to have circumvented themselves on both counts. For all these things, as has been said above, are emptied out by the judgments of the holy martyrs. For how can it happen, if the Church is one and Christ is undivided, that one placed outside should obtain baptism?
Quod vero sibi a nobis objici dicunt: Manus cito nemini imposueris, neque communicaveris peccatis alienis (1 Tim. v, 22); ot quasi respondentes occurrunt, moribus potius debere homines quam corpore separari: ad lmc non modo morihus, sed etiam corpore a malis debere disjungi, multis admodum testimoniis legalibus approbamus. In Numeris: Discedite a labernaculis hominum istorum durissimorum, et ne tetigeritis ab omnibus quæ sunt cis, ne simul pereatis et vos in omnibus peccatis eorum (Num. XVI, 26). Item Isaias: Discedite, discedile, exite inde, ct immundum nolite tangere; discedite de medio eorum, qui fertis tusa Domini (Isai. LII, 11). Item Apost olus: Vos enim csiis templum Dei vivi. Dicit enim ipse: Quoniam habitabo in eis, et in eis ambulabo, et ero illorum Deus, et ipsi erunt mihi populus. Propter quod discedite de medio eorum, et separamini, et immundum ne tetigeritis; et cgo recipiam vos, et ero vobis in patrem, et vos eritis mihi in filios et filias, dicit Dominus omnipotens (II Cor. vi, 16-18).
But as for what they say is objected against them by us—"Lay hands hastily on no one, and do not share in the sins of others" (1 Tim 5:22)—and as if in reply they urge that people ought to be separated in conduct rather than in body: we prove by very many legal testimonies that they ought to be separated from evil people not only in conduct but also in body. In Numbers: "Depart from the tents of these most stubborn men, and touch nothing of all that belongs to them, lest you perish together with them in all their sins" (Num 16:26). Likewise Isaiah: "Depart, depart, go out from there, and do not touch what is unclean; depart from the midst of them, you who bear the vessels of the Lord" (Isa 52:11). Likewise the Apostle: "For you are the temple of the living God. For he himself says: I will dwell in them and walk among them, and I will be their God, and they shall be my people. Therefore depart from the midst of them, and be separated, and do not touch what is unclean; and I will receive you, and I will be to you a father, and you shall be to me sons and daughters, says the Lord Almighty" (2 Cor 6:16-18).
Illud vero quale cst, ut cum nos cis objiciamus persecutiones ct immanes crudelitates, quibus ipsi et majores eorum nos patresque nostros per annos centum vel amplius sinc cessatione afflixerint, atque vexaverint, illi islo non erubescant uti suffugio, quod dicant ab aliquibus nostrorum Maximianistis fuisse persecutiones illatas? Cum utique longe aliud sit usurpata ecclesiastica ct compauperum civiliter repetere voluisse, nee ullum ad communionem nostram nolentem invitumque cocgisse; et aliud sit aperto furore per universum populum christianum omnia mala crudeliter exercere. Quis enin nesciat islos traditorcs persecutoresque nostros, ab ipso exordio condemnatæ traditionis commentitiis precibus cunclis in nostram neccm hujus sæculi principibus supplicassc, atque ad suam communionem contra Dei praecepta minis et proscriplionibus coarctasse? Nam ut omittamus quantus sanguis christianus effusus sit per Leontium, Ursacium, Macarium, Paulum, Taurinum, Romanum, cæterosque exsecutores, quos in sanctorum nccem a principibus sæculi meruerunt, quando plurimi venerabiles sacerdotes occisi, alii in exsilium relegaii, Christianitas latc vexata, sacrata stuprata virginitas, proscripti divitcs, spoliati pauperes, ablatæ basilicae, atque acti in fugam profugi sacerdotes: nostro nunc tempore quanta commiserint nullus ignorat.
But what kind of thing is this, that when we object to them the persecutions and inhuman cruelties with which they and their forebears afflicted and harassed us and our fathers without ceasing for a hundred years or more, they are not ashamed to use this refuge, saying that persecutions were inflicted by some of our party, the Maximianists? When surely it is one thing to have wished to reclaim, in a civil manner, an usurped church property and the goods of the poor, and to have compelled no one against his will to our communion; and another thing to exercise every evil cruelly through the whole Christian people in open fury. For who does not know that these traditors and persecutors of ours, from the very beginning of the condemned tradition, supplicated the princes of this world with fabricated prayers for our death, and constrained people to their communion against God's precepts by threats and proscriptions? For to pass over how much Christian blood was shed through Leontius, Ursacius, Macarius, Paulus, Taurinus, Romanus, and the other executioners whom they obtained from the princes of the world for the slaughter of the saints—when very many venerable priests were killed, others relegated into exile, Christianity widely harassed, consecrated virginity violated, the rich proscribed, the poor despoiled, basilicas taken away, and priests driven into flight as fugitives—no one is ignorant of how much they have committed in our own time.
Episcopis ingesserunt cxsilia, Christianis fugienlihus præcipitia: oppresserunt populos, praedati sunt elericos, invaserunt basilicas, intulerunt consentire nolentibus plagas, postremo in uno tantum oppido Bagaiensi eorum causa multorum Christianorum sanguis effusus est; et nec sic satiati in hodiernum cessare contenti sunt. Unde quia ad hoc tantæ immanitatis corum acerbissimos titulos de Scripturis divinis, quibus ista flagitia prohibentur, superlluum sit documenta subnectere, cum talia nec mundanis legibus permittantur; satis sit corum nos errori respondisse, et quæ superfluo responderunt diviois testimoniis eluisse. Et alia manu: Dominus te incolumem conservet; quod optamus.
Augustini responsiones ad litteras Donatista rum.
Augustinus episcopus Ecclesiæ catholicæ dixit: Permitte nos, vir sublimis, pro causa Ecclesia' non diutius superfluis immorari. Atque utinam fratres nostri e diverso sistentes hanc epistolam ante illos omnes moraiorios sermones suos protulissent ut jam de Ecclesia, unde causa vertitur, aliquid ageremus. Animadvcrtit ergo Nobilitas tua in hac epistola, duc quædam genera vel objectionum vel rerum inserta v quibus respondere debeamus: unum de divinis Scri-l pluris ct sanctæ legis eloquiis, alterum de criminationibus humanis, quæ objicienda nescio qui invidio* sius potius quam verius putaverunt.
They inflicted exiles on bishops, precipices on Christians who fled; they oppressed the peoples, plundered the clergy, invaded basilicas, brought blows upon those unwilling to consent, and finally in the single town of Bagai, for their sake, the blood of many Christians was shed; and not even so, being unsated, have they been content to cease to this day. Therefore, since it would be superfluous to append documentary proofs from the divine Scriptures, by which such outrages are forbidden, to the most bitter indictments of their great savagery—especially when such things are not even permitted by worldly laws—it is enough that we have responded to their error, and have washed away with divine testimonies the things they superfluously answered. And in another hand: May the Lord keep you safe; which we pray for.
The responses of Augustine to the letters of the Donatists.
Augustine, bishop of the catholic Church, said: Allow us, eminent man, for the sake of the Church's cause, not to linger longer on superfluous matters. And would that our brothers, standing on the other side, had brought forth this letter before all those lengthy speeches of theirs, so that we might now be doing something about the Church, which is the matter at issue. Your Nobility has therefore observed in this letter that certain kinds of either objections or matters have been inserted, to which we must respond: one concerning the divine utterances of Scripture and the holy law, the other concerning human accusations, which certain people have thought should be objected rather more enviously than truthfully.
Ad hæc duo paucis, si Dominus adjuverit, respondebimus, ne prolixum sermonem tantæ prolixilali reddamus. Quæstio est de Ecclesia, utrum permixtos malos usque in finem habitura prædicta est, an omnino omnes bonos, omnes sanctos atque immaculatos in hoc sæculo isto etiam tempore usquc in finem ultimum sxculi. Utraque testimonia divina sunt, et utique repugnantia. esse non debent, nec omnino possunt, si intellectorem inveniant. Arcam esse Ecclesiam non ego dixi, non quisquam nostrum, sed Evangelium loquitur, ubi scriptum est, venturum qui ventilabrum ferat in manu sua et mundaturum arcam suam, frumenta recondet in horreo.
Emeritus episcopos dixit: Non legis aream.
Augustinus dixit: Joannes dixit, Mundabit aream suam, frumenta recondet in horreo (Matth. III, 42).
Peliliauus dixit: De occultis reis hoc dixit Evangclista, non de evidentibus, quos tu vis tecum esse permixtos.
To these two points we shall respond briefly, if the Lord helps, lest we make a long discourse out of a great prolixity. The question concerns the Church: whether it was foretold that she would have the wicked mixed in with her even to the end, or altogether all good, all holy and immaculate in this world, even in this time up to the final end of the world. Both testimonies are divine, and certainly they must not be contradictory, nor can they be at all, if they find a reader who understands. That the ark is the Church, I did not say, nor did any of us, but the Gospel says it, where it is written that one will come who will carry the winnowing fan in his hand and will cleanse his threshing floor, and will store the grain in the barn.
Emeritus the bishop said: You do not read the threshing floor.
Augustine said: John said, He will cleanse his threshing floor, he will store the grain in the barn (Matthew 3:12).
Pelilianus said: The Evangelist said this about hidden offenders, not about evident ones, whom you wish to be mixed in with you.
Augustinus dixit: Prosecutio nostra pro ipsorum epistola habeatur. Legi coepit, nullas a nobis relatus est strepitus, nulla inlerturbalio, nulla interruptio: permittat ut finiam qnod coepi eloqui, et sic respondeat. Quare non rependitur nobis quod pracrogavimus? Animadvertit Nobilitas tua patientiam nostram, cum tam longa recitaretur epistola.
Emeritus dixit: Nos gravat, cum se dicit esse patientem; ct non debet de se ferre sententiam, dc quo alius judicat.
Augustinus dixit: si esses ct tu paticns donee finiam quod prosequor! Ergo, ut dicere Cæperam, divina sunt testimonia de zizaniis ct tritico ea quæ intelligcre conati. Verumtamen dc rctihus aliquando confessi sunt, quod malos ct bonos habitura est Ecclesia; sed eos dixerunt esse sacerdotibus incognitos, et ideo non præjudicare bonis, quoniam ignorarentur. Ego autem possem qualibuscumque facultatulæ meae assertionibus ostendere illum esse veriorem iutellectum, quod Ecclesia habeat ct bonos et malos, zizania scilicet et triticum, mundumque ipsum appellatum esse pro Ecclesiæ nomine; quandoquidem Dominus ipse dicit, Non til judicet mundum, sed ut salvetur mundus per ipsum (Jonn. III, 17): cum sciamus Dominum non salvare nisi Ecclesiam.
Augustine said: Let our prosecution be counted as [a response] to their letter. It began to be read; no outcry was reported by us, no disturbance, no interruption. Let him permit me to finish what I began to say, and so let him respond. Why is it not repaid to us that we have anticipated? Your Nobility has noticed our patience, when so long a letter was being recited.
Emeritus said: It weighs on us when he says that he is patient; and he ought not to pass judgment on himself, about whom another judges.
Augustine said: If only you too were patient until I finish what I am pursuing! Therefore, as I had begun to say, there are divine testimonies concerning the tares and the wheat—those which we have attempted to understand. And yet concerning the nets they have at some time confessed that the Church will have both bad and good; but they said that these are unknown to the priests, and therefore do not prejudice the good, since they are unknown. I, however, could by whatever assertions of my small ability show that the truer understanding is this: that the Church has both good and bad, namely the tares and the wheat, and that the world itself is called by the name of the Church; since the Lord himself says, Not that he should judge the world, but that the world should be saved through him (John 3:17)—when we know that the Lord saves none but the Church.
Emeritus dixit: Mundus te non cognovit (Id. XVII, 25). Ergo Deum Ecclesia non cognovit, si mundus Ecclesia est. Et iterum dixit: Ut reus fiat totus mundus Dee (Rom. Ill, 19). Et iterum dixit: Si de mundo essetis, mundus quod suum esset amasset; sed nunc, quoniam de mundo non estis, propterea odit et persequitur vos mundus (Joan. xv, 19). Et iterum:Ipsi de mundo sunt, et mundus obaudit eis (I Joan. IV, 5). Et iterum: Si quis dilexerit mundum, non est charitas Patris in illo (Id. II, 15).
Augustinus dixit: Omnia isti possemus et nos dicere, et velnt contraria primo proposita solvere. Itaquc sine causa interrumpunt islo strepitu; quia epistolæ ipsorum potuissemus talia facere, ne recitaretur. Paticnter audiant. Admoneantur a Sublimitate tua facere, quod sponte facere debuerunt. Patienter audiant: non est rus lcvis quæ tractatur a nobis. Suscepimus hodie respondere, si Deus adjuverit, prolixae epistolæ corum. Nee rogamus ut edatur nobis, et consideremus, et postea respondeamus, sicut ipsi de Mandato nostro fecerunt. Praebeant nobis aliquam patieutiam per incolumitatem tuam.
Emeritus said: The world did not know you (John 17:25). Therefore the Church did not know God, if the world is the Church. And again he said: That the whole world may become guilty before God (Rom. 3:19). And again he said: If you were of the world, the world would love what was its own; but now, because you are not of the world, therefore the world hates and persecutes you (John 15:19). And again: They are of the world, and the world hears them (1 John 4:5). And again: If anyone loves the world, the love of the Father is not in him (1 John 2:15).
Augustine said: We too could say all these things, and either solve the contrary propositions first put forward. And so they interrupt with this clamor to no purpose; because we could have done such things with their letter, so that it would not be read out. Let them listen patiently. Let them be admonished by Your Sublimity to do what they should have done of their own accord. Let them listen patiently: the matter that is being treated by us is not a light one. We have undertaken today, if God helps, to respond to their lengthy letter. Nor do we ask that it be given to us, and that we consider it, and afterward respond, as they themselves did concerning our Mandate. Let them grant us some patience through your safety.
(Et post aliquot interlocutiones) Augustinus dixit; Quando legebatur epistola, sic habebamus, tanquam ipsi prosequerentur: prosecutioni ipsorum præbuimus silentium (nolo enim dicere patientiam, quia id calumniantur); præbeant nobis et ipsi silentium.
Montanus episcopus dixit: Quando omnia in animo retinentur. si non ad singula respondeamus?
Augustinus dixit: Ideo et ilia conscripta sunt, et haec excipiuntur: si quid memoriam fallit, et ego possum peterc, ut mibi de epistola recitetur; ct ipsi possunt, ut illis ex codicibus recitetur. Præbeatur silentium, agamus aliquid. Ut ergo dicere coeperam, ipsis admonentibus invenimus in Scripturis, mundi nomen in malo, mundi nomen in bono. Jam mundi nomen in malo, sicut ipsi dlxorunt: Et mundus eum non cognovit (Joan. I, 10); et, Si quis dilexerit mundum, non ese charitas Patris in illo (1 Joan. a, 15): et cætera. Mundi autem nomen in bono: ut credat mundus quoniam tu me misisti (Joan. xvn, 21). Non enim credere malorum est. Mundi nomen in bono: Non venit ut judicet mundum, sed ut salvetur mundus per ipsum (id. III, 17). Non salvabitur nisi Ecclesia in mundo.
(And after several exchanges) Augustinus said: When the epistle was being read, we took it as though they themselves were continuing it; we gave silence to their continuation (for I do not wish to call it patience, since they slander that); let them likewise give us silence.
Montanus the bishop said: When all things are held in the mind, what if we do not respond to each point?
Augustinus said: For that reason both those things were written down and these are being taken down; if anything escapes my memory, I too can ask that the epistle be read to me, and they can ask that it be read to them from the codices. Let silence be given; let us do something. So, as I had begun to say, with them prompting us we find in the Scriptures the name "world" in a bad sense and the name "world" in a good sense. Now the name "world" in a bad sense, as they themselves have said: And the world did not know him (John 1:10); and, If anyone loves the world, the love of the Father is not in him (1 John 2:15); and the rest. But the name "world" in a good sense: that the world may believe that you sent me (John 17:21). For to believe is not the mark of the wicked. The name "world" in a good sense: He did not come to judge the world, but that the world might be saved through him (John 3:17). Only the Church in the world will be saved.
Cum ergo et in bono mundus, et in malo mundus, unde ista Scripturarum rixa, si inlellectore careat; adhibe lumen intelligentiæ: vide mundum in malo omnes dilectores temporalium per uni, versas gentes; vide mundum in bono omnes fideles et spera gerentes æternæ vitae per universas gentes. Deus erat in Christo, inquit, mundum reconcitians sibi ( II cor. v 19). Si reconciliari potest Deo detestatus ille mundus, de quo dictum est quia non est cbaritas Christi in eo qui dilexcrit mundum, judicenl qui loquuntur. Audiat ergo patienter Nobilitas tua. video Scripturam sanctam I cr commixtos bonos et malos, sicut ipsi de retibus jam confessi suut, præsignasse Ecclesiam.
petilianus dixit: Quid sit mundus, quid sit Ecclesia, apertissime definitum est ab ipso auctore mundi atque factore, per quem omnia facta suut, et sinc quo nihil est factum. Ipse enim Dominus dixit: Mundus hic ager (Matth. xm, 38). Potuisset dicere, Mundus Ecclesia est. Quis igitur hominum audet definire quid mundus sit, cum ii se Dominus hujus factor atque opifex jam dignatus fuerit definire?
Since, therefore, the world is both in good and in evil, whence comes this strife over the Scriptures, if it lacks an understanding reader? Apply the light of understanding: see the world in evil as all lovers of temporal things throughout all nations; see the world in good as all the faithful who hope for and bear eternal life throughout all nations. God was in Christ, it says, reconciling the world to himself (2 Cor 5:19). If that detested world can be reconciled to God, of which it was said that the love of Christ is not in him who loves the world, let those who speak judge. Let your Nobility therefore hear patiently. I see that Holy Scripture has prefigured the Church as having good and evil mixed together, just as they themselves have already confessed concerning the nets.
Petilianus said: What the world is and what the Church is has been most openly defined by the very author and maker of the world, through whom all things were made and without whom nothing was made. For the Lord himself said: The world is this field (Matt 13:38). He could have said: The world is the Church. Who, then, among men dares to define what the world is, when the Lord himself, its maker and craftsman, has already deigned to define it?
Marcellinus vir clarissimus tribuous et notarius dixit: Qui mundus sit, qui salvandus dicitur, evidcutcr ostendite.
Petilianus dixit: Homo dictus est mundus, uhi dixit, Mundum rccont ilians sibi. Non euim sibi Deus belluas, sed homines voluit recouciliari.
Augustinus dixit: Mundus ergo (non enim aliter et nobis videri i otuit) in hominibus intelligitur. Nou utique ita stulti simus, ut belluas etiam et quæcumque irrationabilia animantia ad salutem, quam Christus promisit, pertinere dicamus. Prorsus hoc dicimus: Mundus in maligno positus eat ( I Joan. v. 19), homines sunt: Ut credat mundus quia tu me misisti, homines sunt: Mundum reconcilians sibi homines sunt: et caetera quæ in malo diqta suut homincs illi, homines illi. rer totum enim mundum utrique, ma!i mixti bonis Sic et Ecclesia, quam contessi sunt retium nomine declaratam habere malos, sed dixerunt latere i iscatores, constat jam quod habeat bonos et maios: de latendo et de non latendo quaestio est; utrum pertinuerit ad pietatem bonorum etiam malos cognitos tolerare, ne deserereut bonos, an propter malos totum deserere voluerint 1,quibus mali quid in Eclesia apparuerit, ipsa quaestio est: hoc probamus.
Marcellinus, vir clarissimus, tribune and notary, said: Show clearly who this world is that is said to be saved.
Petilianus said: Man is called the world, where it says, Reconciling the world to himself. For God willed not beasts but men to be reconciled to himself.
Augustinus said: The world, therefore (for it could not otherwise seem to us), is understood in men. We are certainly not so foolish as to say that even beasts and whatever irrational living things pertain to the salvation that Christ promised. Plainly this is what we say: The world is placed in the evil one (1 John 5:19)—these are men; That the world may believe that you sent me—these are men; Reconciling the world to himself—these are men; and the other things that are said in an evil sense—those men, those men. For the whole world is both, evil mixed with good. So also the Church, which they have confessed is declared by the name of the net to have evil men, but they said the fishers lie hidden—it is already established that it has both good and evil: the question is about hiding and not hiding; whether it pertained to the piety of the good also to tolerate known evil men, lest they desert the good, or whether on account of the evil men they wished to desert the whole, in which evil men appeared in the Church—this is the very question: this we prove.
Dicimus enim nos, nou neghgeodam quidem ecclesiasticam disciplinam, et ubicumque fuerint proditi mali coercendos eos esse ut corrigantur, non solum sermone correctionis, verum etiam excommunicationibus et degradationibus, ut humilem locum salutis in Ecclesia quærant, ad medicinam ipsorum fieri, non odio, sed studio satutis fraternae: sicut quodam loco etiam Ipse Apostolus evidentissime declarat dicens, si quis non obaudit verbo nostro per epistolam, hunc notate, et notite commisceri cum eo (II Thess. III, 14).....
Desunt reliqua diei tertiae capita.
sententia Cognitoris.
Flavius Marcellinus v. c. tribunus et notarius dixit: Vellem quidem, quod et omni de votorum intentione nunc cupio, ut quanta ex demonstratione veritatis et tandem proditi erroris orta laetitia est, tata ex conversione superstitionis antiquæ et in melius mutatae sententiæ gratulatio nasceretur. Magna enim gaudia esse quis dubitet, cum inveteratae ægritudini provenit insperata curatio?causamque exsultatiouis in talibus majorem facit sanitas restituta, quam semper retenta.
For we say that ecclesiastical discipline is certainly not to be neglected, and that wherever evil men have been exposed they must be restrained so that they may be corrected, not only by the word of correction but also by excommunications and degradations, so that they may seek a humble place of salvation in the Church; this is done for their own healing, not from hatred but from zeal for fraternal salvation, as the Apostle himself declares most clearly in a certain place, saying: If anyone does not obey our word by letter, note that man, and do not associate with him (2 Thess. 3:14)…
The remaining chapters of the third day are missing.
The sentence of the Cognitor.
Flavius Marcellinus, vir clarissimus, tribune and notary, said: I would indeed wish—which is also what I now desire with all the intent of my vows—that, as great as is the joy born from the demonstration of the truth and the error at last exposed, so great a congratulation might arise from the conversion from ancient superstition and from a sentence changed for the better. For who would doubt that great joys exist when an unexpected cure comes to a long-inveterate sickness? And in such cases the restored health makes the cause of exultation greater than health always retained.
sed quia obstinatio menlium perditarum, quas pravae simul persuasionis vincula nexuerant, ad viam salatis ostensæ aut redire dissimulat, aut, quod est deterius imjudentia reformidat; exserenda jam legum est et exercenda sententia, ut quos ad bonam valetudinem leniora, post apertam cominus veritatem, medicamina non revocant, acrior restituat curationis intentio. Cui enim Maio proxima, sicut gestorum series subjecta demonstrat, sicut divinorum quoque voluminum indita exempla testantur, non liquido declaret, alieni, etiamsi probari potuisset, sceleris noxa alium fieri reum omnino non posse, et universalis Ecclesiæ statum Caeciliani insimulatione, de quo nihil reprehensibile potuit approbari, nou debere subverti, nec absentiam eorum qui se a corpore Ecclesiae separarunt, lata adversus eum praejudicare valuisse sententia: sicut nec a Maximianistis recenti tempore in absentem Primianum prolata da. mnatio eiJem nocere praevaluit? cui etiam illud ad corroptionls causam non omni ex parte sufficiat, tut iudiciis patefacta Donato auctore schismatis comprobatio, Cæciliani persolutio atque purgatio, ultimaque sententia triumphabilismemoriae Constantini, qua evidentius docetur expressa et Cæciliani innocentia, et Donati sociorumque ejus calumniosa criminatio, Fclicis quoqne Aptugnensisordinatoris ejus proconsularis sententiæ ducumentis osleusa purgalio?
But because the obstinacy of lost minds, which the chains of a depraved persuasion had bound together, either dissembles to return to the path of salvation that has been shown, or—what is worse—shrinks from it in shamelessness, the sentence of the laws must now be drawn forth and exercised, so that those whom gentler remedies do not recall to good health, after the truth has been openly shown at close quarters, the sharper intent of a cure may restore. For to whom does the series of proceedings, set forth below, so clearly demonstrate—as the examples recorded in the divine volumes also testify—that the guilt of another's crime, even if it could have been proven, cannot make another person a culprit at all, and that the standing of the universal Church ought not to be overturned by the accusation against Caecilian, concerning whom nothing reprehensible could be approved, nor could the absence of those who separated themselves from the body of the Church have been able to prejudice a sentence passed against him: just as neither did the condemnation, in recent times, pronounced by the Maximianists against the absent Primian prevail to harm him? To whom also should that not suffice in every respect as a cause for corruption, namely that the proof, revealed by the judgments, that Donatus was the author of the schism, and the absolution and purgation of Caecilian, and the final sentence of Constantine of triumphant memory, by which the innocence of Caecilian and the calumnious accusation of Donatus and his companions are more evidently shown forth, and also the purgation of Felix of Aptunga, his ordinator, made clear by the documents of the proconsular sentence?
Unde, si hæc tam perspicua atque manifesta inveterato mederi nequeunt morbo, putris est vulneris sanies repr!.. meuda; ut libertate praeclusa, sibi tantum nucere, quia hoc potius elegit, incipiat. Per hæc enim fiet ut velit aliquando sanari. Declaratae igitur veritati detecta falsitas colla submitlat, Uude universos ordinis viros, dominos. eliam fundorum, actores, conductores tam domus divinae, quam etiam privatarum possessionum, senioresquc omnium! locorum, hujus edicti auctoritate commoneo, quatenus memores legum, dignitatum, aestimationis salutisque propria, Donatistarum conventicula in omnibus civitatibus et locis rohibere contendant; ila ut ecclesias, quas eis humanitate mea absque imperiali praecepto usque ad diem sententiae constat indultas, catholicis tradere sinc ulla dilatione festinent, ni matunt tot sanctionum laqueis irretiri: quas quidem, sj unitati catholicae consentire voluerint, eorum esse sat certum est. Majore autem causa atque solertia post dctoclam modis omnibus unitatem superstitionemque conviclam, a proprii debent facinoris intentione depelli. Hi autem qui post vetita legum, eorum se cætibus miscuerint, indubitanter intelligant, pænam se imperiali arbitrio praestitutam ulterius vitare non posse. quos priucipc loco post agnitae catholicae reverentiam legis, ad profanos corum eretus communionemque redisse sat clarum est.
Hence, if these things so clear and manifest cannot heal the inveterate disease, the corrupt pus of the wound must be cut away, so that, with freedom of choice closed off, it may begin to harm only itself, because it has chosen this rather. For through these means it will come about that it wishes at some time to be healed. Therefore let the detected falsehood bow its neck to the truth that has been declared. Wherefore I admonish all men of the order, the lords also of estates, the agents, the tenants both of the divine house and also of private possessions, and the elders of all places, by the authority of this edict, that, mindful of the laws, of their dignities, of their reputation, and of their own salvation, they strive to prohibit the conventicles of the Donatists in all cities and places; so that they hasten without any delay to hand over to the catholics the churches which it is established were granted to them by my humanity without imperial precept up to the day of the sentence, unless they prefer to be entangled in the snares of so many sanctions: which churches, indeed, if they wish to consent to the catholic unity, it is quite certain are theirs. But for a greater cause and with greater skill, after unity has been thoroughly declared and the superstition convicted, they ought to be driven from the intention of their own crime. But those who, after the things forbidden by the laws, have mingled themselves in their assemblies, let them understand without doubt that they cannot further avoid the penalty prescribed by imperial judgment; and it is sufficiently clear that these, in the first place, after the reverence of the catholic law has been acknowledged, have returned to the communion and assembly of their profane rites.
Quod ut ante hon fieret, patientiae tantum considetatione et spe correptionis aliqua ex i arte distuleram. Hactenus igitur iuimicos fidei christianae legibus insultasse sufiiciat: maxime cum eorum notas certum sit esse personas, quid necesse est lot sanctionum, quoniam nulla emendatio subsecuta est, nexibus suhdi? ipsam vero catholicorum episcoporum, etiam post victoriam veritatis, noverinl Donatistae manere sentenliam, ut completis Collationibus, quas cis et ante oblatas publica conscientia retinetur, et nunc oflerri siue dubitatione sat certum est, sese suscip i posse cognoscant. superioris autem edicti fidem in omnibus certum est reservari. Inde unusquisque Donati communionis episcopus ad loca proprja sine ulla debet inquietudine ac molestia rcmeare; quatenus in propriis constitutus, aut ad unam veramque.:eclesiam revertatur, aut satis legibus facere sine dissimulatione non differat. li autem qui in praediis suis Circumcellionumturbas se habere coguoscunt, sciant, nisi eorum insolentiam omnimodis comprimere et relrenare gestierint, maxime ea loca a fisco mox occupanda. siquidem lam catholicæ legi, quam quieti publicæ, ut eorum couquiescat insania, in bac parte consulitur.
That this should not have been done before, I had deferred for a time, partly by reason of patience alone and in hope of correction. To this point, then, let it suffice that the enemies of the Christian faith have insulted the laws: especially since it is certain that their persons are marked out, what need is there of the bonds of so many sanctions, when no amendment has followed? But let the Donatists know that the sentence of the catholic bishops themselves, even after the victory of truth, remains, so that when the Collations are completed—which are retained in the public conscience, both those offered to them before and those which it is certain without doubt are now being offered—they may recognize that they can be received. But it is certain that the force of the earlier edict is preserved in all things. Therefore each bishop of the communion of Donatus ought to return to his own places without any disturbance or trouble; so that, established in his own, he may either return to the one true church, or not delay to satisfy the laws without dissimulation. But those who know that they have crowds of Circumcellions on their estates should know that, unless they desire to suppress and restrain their insolence in every way, those places especially will soon be occupied by the fisc. Since indeed provision is made in this part both for the catholic law and for the public peace, so that their madness may be quieted.
Gestorum autem relectio qua protertur, superius memoralum a Donatistis errorem schismatis exstitisse, atque Caecilianum et caeteros quos improbe crediderant accusandos, luisse purgatos, sanetitatem vestram plenissimc poterit edocere. Proponatur. (Dat. Carthag.) post consulatum varanis v. c. sextocalend. julii. Honorii imperatoris leges in Donatistas, post collationem datæ.
Impp. HONOIUUS et THEODOSIUS loA. Seleuco PF. P.
Cassatis quae pragmatici vel annotatione manus nostrae poterint impetrari, et manentibus his, qua' etiam dudum super hoc definita suut, et veterum principum sanctione servata, nisi ex die prolatae legis omnes Donatillæ, tam sacerdotesquam clerici laicique, catholicæse, a qua sacrilege descivere, reddiderint, tunc illustres singillatim pænæ nomine fisco nostro auri pondo quinquaginta cogantur inferre, spectabiles auri pondo quadraginta, senatorcs auri pondo triginta, clarissimi auri pondo viginti, sacerdotales auri pondo triginta, principales auri pondo viginti, decuriones ' auri pondo quinque, negotiatores auri pondo quinque, pleA ben aun pondo quinque, circumcelliones argenti pondo decem. Qui nisi a conductoribus, subquibus commanent, vel procuratoribus exsecutori exigeudi fuerint præsentati, ipsi teneantur ad poenam, ita ut nec domus nostræ honines ab hujuscemodi censura habeantur immunes. Uxores quoque eorum maritalis segregatim muleta constringat.
But the rereading of the proceedings, by which it is shown that the aforementioned error of schism arose from the Donatists, and that Caecilian and the others whom they had wickedly believed should be accused, had been cleared—your Holiness will be able most fully to be taught. Let it be proposed. Given at Carthage after the consulate of the distinguished man Varanes, on the sixth day before the Kalends of July. The laws of the emperor Honorius against the Donatists, given after the conference.
Emperors Honorius and Theodosius to the illustrious Seleucus, Praetorian Prefect.
With those measures set aside which could be obtained by rescript or by annotation in our own hand, and with those remaining which were also long ago defined concerning this matter, and with the sanction of former emperors preserved, unless from the day of the law's promulgation all the Donatists, both priests and clergy and laity, return themselves to the Catholic Church, from which they have sacrilegiously departed, then the illustrious, one by one, under the name of penalty, shall be compelled to pay into our treasury fifty pounds of gold; the spectabiles, forty pounds of gold; senators, thirty pounds of gold; the clarissimi, twenty pounds of gold; the sacerdotales, thirty pounds of gold; the principales, twenty pounds of gold; decurions, five pounds of gold; merchants, five pounds of gold; the common people, five pounds of gold; the circumcelliones, ten pounds of silver. And unless they shall have been presented for the exaction of the penalty by the conductors under whom they reside, or by the procurators of the executor, they themselves shall be held to the penalty, so that not even the men of our own household are to be held immune from this assessment. Their wives also shall be bound separately by the marital fine.
Eos enim, quos nequaquam illata damna correxerint, facultatum omnium publicatio subsequetur. Servos etiam domiuorum admonitio, vel colonos verberum crebrior ictus a prava religione revocabit: ni malunt ipsi ad praedicta dispendia, etiamsi sunt catholici, retineri. Clerici vero ministrique eorum ac perniciosissimi sacerdolales ablati dc Aricano solo, quod rilu sacrilego polluerunt, in exsilium viritim ad singulas quasque regiones sub idouca prosecutione mittantur: ecclesiis corum vel conventiculis praediisque, si qua in eorum eccles as hæreticorum largitas prava conlulit, proprietati potestatique Catholicae, sicut jamdudum statuimus, vindicatis. Dat. in calend. tebr. Raven. Honor. ix et Theodos. v. AA. Coss..
iidem AA. Juliano proconsuli Africae.
Donatistas atque hxrelicos, quos patientia clementiae nostrae nunc usque servavit, competenti constituimus auctoritate percelli; quatenus evidenti praeceptione se agnoscant et intestabiles et nullam potestatem alicujus ineundi habere, sed perpetua onustos infamia, a cætibus honestis et a conventu publico segregandos. Ea vcro loca in quibus dira superstitio nunc usque servata est, (athoiicae venerabili Ecelesiæsocientur: ita ut episcopi, presbyteri. omnesque antistites eorum et ministri spoliati omnibus facultatibus, ad singulas quasque insulas atque provincias cxsulandi gratia dirigantur.
For those whom the losses inflicted have by no means corrected, the public confiscation of all their property shall follow. As for slaves, moreover, the admonition of their masters, or for tenant farmers the more frequent stroke of beatings, shall recall them from the depraved religion—unless they themselves prefer to be held liable to the aforesaid penalties, even if they are catholic. But their clerics and ministers, and the most pernicious priestlings, removed from the Arican soil, which they have polluted with sacrilegious rite, are to be sent individually into exile, each to his own several regions, under suitable prosecution; their churches or meeting-places and estates, if any depraved largesse of heretics has conferred upon their churches, having been vindicated to the ownership and authority of the Catholic [Church], as we have already long since decreed. Given on the Kalends of February at Ravenna, in the ninth consulship of Honorius and the fifth of Theodosius, Augusti.
The same Augusti to Julianus, proconsul of Africa.
We have determined by fitting authority that the Donatists and heretics, whom the patience of our clemency has until now preserved, be struck down; so that by evident precept they may recognize themselves to be both intestable and to have no power of entering into any [contract], but, burdened with perpetual infamy, to be segregated from honorable assemblies and from public gathering. But those places in which the dire superstition has been preserved until now are to be joined to the venerable Catholic Church: so that their bishops, presbyters, and all their prelates and ministers, despoiled of all their property, are to be directed to their several islands and provinces for the sake of exile.
Quisquis autem hos fugientes propositam ultionem occultandi causa susceperit, sciat et patrimonium suum fisci nostri compendiis aggregandum, et se pænam quæbis proposita est subditurum. Damna quoque patrimonii a-nasque pecuniarias evidenter imponimus viris, mulieribus, personis singulis ot dignitatibus pro qualitate sui quae debeant irrogari. Igitur proconsulari aut vicariano vel comitivæ primi ordinis quisque tucrit honore succinctus, nisi ad observantiam catholicam mentem propositumque converterit, ducentas argenti libras cogetur exsolvere, fisci nostri utilitatibus aggregandas. Ac ne id solum j utetur ad resecandam intentinem posse sufficere, quotiescumque ad communionem talem accessisse fuerit con!utatus, toties mulctam exigatur; et si quinquies eumdem constiterit nec damuis ab errore revocan, tunc ad nostram clementiam reteratur, ut de solida ejus substantia ac de slalu acerbius judicemus. llujusmodi autem couditionibus eliam honoratos reliquos obligamus; scilicet ut senator qui nullo munitus extrinsecus privilegio dignitatis, iuventus iu grege Donatistarum, centum libras solvat argenti, sacerdotales eandem summam cogantur exsolvere, decem primi curiales quinquaginta libras argenti addicantur, reliqui decuriones decem solvant libras argenti, quicumque in haeresi maluerint permanere.
But whoever, for the sake of concealing those fugitives, has taken them in with the intended vengeance in view, let him know that his patrimony is to be added to the revenues of our treasury, and that he himself will be subjected to the penalty which has been set forth. We also evidently impose losses of patrimony and sums of money upon men, women, individual persons, and dignitaries, according to the quality of each, which ought to be inflicted. Therefore, whoever among them has been invested with the honor of proconsul or vicar or count of the first order, unless he converts his mind and purpose to catholic observance, shall be compelled to pay two hundred pounds of silver, to be added to the uses of our treasury. And lest this alone be thought sufficient to cut off their intent, as often as anyone shall have been convicted of having approached such communion, so often let the fine be exacted; and if it is established that the same man has been five times not recalled from his error by these losses, then let it be referred to our clemency, so that we may judge more harshly concerning his entire substance and his status. By conditions of this kind, moreover, we also bind the remaining honorati; namely, that a senator who is protected by no external privilege of dignity, if he is found in the flock of the Donatists, shall pay one hundred pounds of silver; those of priestly rank shall be compelled to pay the same sum; the ten leading curiales shall be assessed fifty pounds of silver; the remaining decuriones shall pay ten pounds of silver, whoever among them shall prefer to remain in the heresy.