HOLLIS Primo, queried 2026-11-14 for 'Ratramnus predestination', returns no English translation of the treatise; the records are a nineteenth-century Dutch dissertation, handbooks and readers. The Marquette volume 'Gottschalk and a Medieval Predestination Controversy' (2010), the obvious place to look, prints Rabanus Maurus' letters, Hincmar's letters, Amolo's On Grace and Foreknowledge and Florus' sermon, but its HOLLIS contents list contains no work by Ratramnus. Migne's text stands in PL 121. No English translation was located.
Ratramnus' answer to Charles the Bald on double predestination, written in the controversy provoked by Gottschalk of Orbais; it is the most philosophically exact Carolingian treatment of the question. The 2010 Marquette sourcebook translates everyone in the debate except Ratramnus, which leaves the argument one-sided in English.
| Source and licence |
|---|
| archive.org · PDF scan · public domain (Migne, Patrologia Latina, 1844-1880 printing) |
| Record | Citation |
|---|---|
| The Christian theology reader | "The Christian theology reader." Chichester, West Sussex, UK : Wiley Blackwell, 2017. https://hollis.harvard.edu/permalink/f/1s5nto6/990148195080203941 |