{"slug":"tmp761.tmp761.opp-lat1","id":"latin:ogl-pl:tmp761.tmp761.opp-lat1","title":"Sermones Inediti Admixtis Quibusdam Dubiis","title_source":"Sermones Inediti Admixtis Quibusdam Dubiis","author":"Augustinus","genre":"homily","date":"","tradition":"latin","coverage":"not-located","coverage_claim":{"status":"not-located","text":"No English translation could be identified: a language model asked twice could not name one, though it could not rule one out either. That is not proof that none exists — translations in dissertations, recent books and other modern languages are easily missed."},"publication":{"status":"machine-draft","reviewed_by":null,"model":"deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash:floor","provider":"Baidu","generated":"2026-11-15T23:26:03Z","cost_usd":0.026799},"source":{"registry_id":"latin:ogl-pl:tmp761.tmp761.opp-lat1","work_id":"tmp761.tmp761.opp-lat1","edition":"ogl-pl","language":"","license":"Available under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License","url":"https://github.com/OpenGreekAndLatin/patrologia_latina-dev/blob/master/data/tmp761/tmp761/tmp761.tmp761.opp-lat1.xml"},"stats":{"passages":262,"english_words":74137,"coptic_letters":0,"source_letters":266998,"commentary_units":0,"commentary_kinds":0,"derived_notes":3,"ambiguities":0,"work_notes":0,"external_links":0,"timeline":0},"summary":{},"links":[{"kind":"source","label":"Open Greek and Latin Patrologia Latina","url":"https://github.com/OpenGreekAndLatin/patrologia_latina-dev/blob/master/data/tmp761/tmp761/tmp761.tmp761.opp-lat1.xml"}],"checks":{"work":"tmp761.tmp761.opp-lat1","status":"pass","blocking":[],"warnings":[],"stats":{"passages":262,"translated":262,"commentary_passages":0,"commentary_units":0,"english_words":74137,"source_letters":266998,"commentary_kinds":0},"model":"deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash:floor"},"work_notes":[],"derived_work_notes":[{"kind":"coverage","severity":"info","text":"No English translation could be identified: a language model asked twice could not name one, though it could not rule one out either. That is not proof that none exists — translations in dissertations, recent books and other modern languages are easily missed."},{"kind":"limit","severity":"caution","text":"The English is a machine draft produced passage by passage from the transcribed Latin; no human has verified it. The commentary is model-written and cites only keys the pipeline could resolve."},{"kind":"register","severity":"info","text":"Register: homily in Latin; the English keeps the liturgical formulae and the vocatives rather than normalising them."},{"kind":"structure","severity":"info","text":"Passages: 262 narrative."},{"kind":"caution","severity":"caution","text":"1 passage(s) are fragmentary in the source; the English bridges each break and says so in the note."},{"kind":"scripture","severity":"info","text":"2 scriptural phrase match(es) noted: John 1:1; Luke 2:14."},{"kind":"source","severity":"info","text":"Source edition: ogl-pl."},{"kind":"source","severity":"info","text":"Licence: Available under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License"}],"derived_structure":{"narrative":262},"term_index":[],"citations":{},"segments":[{"i":1,"ref":"p1","source":"SANCTI AURELII AUGUSTINI HIPPONENSIS EPISCOPI Sermones inediti.\n\nSERMONES ADMIXTIS QUIBUSDAM DUBIIS.\n\nSERMO I.\n\nDe Cereo Paschali.\n\nSYNOPSIS.\n\nI. Attentos reddit. II, Cereus imago Justi, et Christi. III. Apis imago Justi, Favus Scripturarum. IV. Samson leonem trucidans Figura Christi.\n\nDeo et Domino nostro omnipotenti, visibilium atque invisibilium creatori honorem deferens oratinibus vestris juvandum me credo, ut, quod in laudem et gloriam indulgentissimi creatoris dicere suscepi, non tam meis viribus, quam ipsius Domini misericordia adjuvante explicare sufficiam. Adeste itaque nunc intenti, dil(??)issimi fratres, ut primo de cordibus vestris carnalibus cogitationibus, quasi nocturnis tenebris, discussis, et in cubiculis conscientiarum Christi lumine accenso ea, quae· vobis Dominus per nostrum famulatum ministrare dignabitur, non solum aure percipere, verum etiam mente possitis.","english":"THE UNPUBLISHED SERMONS OF SAINT AURELIUS AUGUSTINE, BISHOP OF HIPPO.\n\nSERMONS WITH CERTAIN DOUBTFUL ONES MIXED IN.\n\nSERMON I.\n\nOn the Paschal Candle.\n\nSYNOPSIS.\n\nI. He makes his hearers attentive. II. The candle is a figure of the righteous man, and of Christ. III. The bee is a figure of the righteous man, the honeycomb of the Scriptures. IV. Samson slaying the lion is a figure of Christ.\n\nDeferring honor to God, our almighty Lord, the creator of things visible and invisible, I believe that I must be helped by your prayers, so that what I have undertaken to speak in praise and glory of our most indulgent creator, I may be able to set forth not so much by my own strength as with the mercy of the Lord himself assisting. Be present, then, now with attention, most beloved brothers, so that, first having shaken off from your hearts carnal thoughts, as it were the darkness of night, and with the light of Christ kindled in the chambers of your consciences, you may be able to receive not only with the ear but also with the mind those things which the Lord will deign to minister to you through our service.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":2,"ref":"p2","source":"Cereus nocturnum lumen est, et homo justus tenebrosi hujus mundi lumen est. Dicit Dominus ad eos, quos ipse justificat: Vos estis lumen mundi (Matth. v. 14). Tria conspiciuntur in Cereo: Cera, Papyrus et Flamma. Et in homine justo tria sunt: Caro, Anima et Sapientia. Flamma illuminat, papyrus accenditur, cerae tenacitas solvitur. Sapientiae doctrina animum tenet, carnis duritia superatur. Flamma urit, papyrus uritur, guttas cera distillat. Sapientia docet, anima dolet, caro lacrymas fundit. Flamma fulget superius, papyrus commutatur interius, cera currit exterius. Sapientia sublimiter praedicatur, anima latenter convertitur, caro visibiliter cooperatur. Cerei laudatur pulchritudo per diem, honoratur claritudo per noctem. Sic ostendit nobis columnae illius imaginem, qua duce populus Israel ambulans per desertum non permittebatur errare. Apparebat enim eis nubis columna per diem, ignis columna per noctem (Exod. xiii, 21. et Num. xiv, 14). Dies significat securitatem in hoc saeculo, et nox tribulationem in hoc saeculo. Hic est dies, de quo Propheta cantat et dicit: Per diem mandavit Dominus misericordiam suam, et nocte declaravit (Psal. xli, 9). In hac carnali vita Dominus Christus veniens non ostendit claritatem suam, sed mortali carne velatus, tanquam nubis columna, in eremo apparuit.","english":"The wax candle is a light by night, and the righteous man is a light of this dark world. The Lord says to those whom he himself justifies: You are the light of the world (Matt. 5:14). Three things are seen in the candle: the wax, the wick, and the flame. And in the righteous man there are three things: the flesh, the soul, and wisdom. The flame gives light, the wick is set alight, the wax's firmness is melted. The teaching of wisdom holds the mind, the hardness of the flesh is overcome. The flame burns, the wick is burned, the wax drips in drops. Wisdom teaches, the soul grieves, the flesh pours out tears. The flame shines above, the wick is changed within, the wax runs without. Wisdom is preached on high, the soul is converted in secret, the flesh cooperates visibly. The candle's beauty is praised by day, its brightness is honored by night. Thus it shows us the image of that column by whose guidance the people of Israel, walking through the desert, were not allowed to go astray. For there appeared to them a column of cloud by day, a column of fire by night (Exod. 13:21; Num. 14:14). Day signifies security in this world, and night tribulation in this world. This is the day of which the Prophet sings and says: By day the Lord commanded his mercy, and by night he declared it (Ps. 41:9). Coming into this carnal life, the Lord Christ did not show his brightness, but, veiled in mortal flesh, appeared in the desert like a column of cloud.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":3,"ref":"p3","source":"Cum autem finis saeculi venerit, quo omnium visibilium gaudia subtrahentur, tunc ipse Dominus sine mortalitatis aliquo velamento clarus et splendidus, tanquam ignis columna, fulgebit. Columna ignis ardet, et lucet. Quod ardet, potestatis est: quod lucet, honoris. Quod ardet, judicat; quod lucet, illuminat. Quod ardet, poena est impiorum; quod lucet, beatitudo justorum.\n\nSed nos proprie Cerei nomen oportet edicere, quod ad sacramentum tantae hujus celebritatis pertinet. Manu gerimus, oculis intuemur, corde conspicimus, ore laudamus. Cerae artifex apis est, de qua Scriptura sic dicit: Vade ad apem, o piger, et disce, quam operatrix sit. Opus autem quam sanctum habet, cujus labores reges et mediocres ad sanitatem assumunt sibi. Grata est illa omnibus, et gloriosa, et, cum sit viribus infirma, sapientiam honorans provecta est. Quid nos, Christe, memoras? Quid in ape jubes intueri? breve animal est, et volatile. Quia humilitas exaltatur. Duabus lucidissimis pennis volat. Et quid luminosius charitate? Et duo sunt praecepta charitatis, ut diligamus Dominum, diligamus et proximum, per quae, veluti duas alas, ad coelum justus attollitur. Operatur illa dulcedinem, habet justus in ore veritatem, quoniam clamat Dominus: Ego sum via, et veritas, et vita (Joan. xiv, 6). Clamat et Propheta: Gustate et videte, quoniam suavis est Dominus (Psal. xxxiii, 9).","english":"But when the end of the world has come, when the joys of all things visible are taken away, then the Lord himself, without any veil of mortality, bright and splendid, will shine like a pillar of fire. A pillar of fire burns and gives light. That it burns belongs to power; that it gives light, to honor. That it burns, he judges; that it gives light, he illumines. That it burns is the punishment of the wicked; that it gives light, the blessedness of the righteous.\n\nBut we ought properly to declare the name of the Candle, which pertains to the sacrament of so great a celebration. We carry it in our hand, we behold it with our eyes, we look upon it with our heart, we praise it with our mouth. The maker of the wax is the bee, of which Scripture says: Go to the bee, O sluggard, and learn how great a worker she is. And how holy is the work she has, whose labors kings and common folk take up for their health. She is pleasing to all, and glorious, and, though she is weak in strength, honoring wisdom she has been advanced. Why, O Christ, do you remind us? What do you bid us behold in the bee? She is a small creature, and winged. Because humility is exalted. She flies on two most bright wings. And what is more luminous than charity? And there are two precepts of charity, that we love the Lord, and that we love our neighbor, through which, as by two wings, the righteous man is raised to heaven. She works sweetness; the righteous man has truth in his mouth, since the Lord cries out: I am the way, and the truth, and the life (John 14:6). The Prophet also cries out: Taste and see, for the Lord is sweet (Ps. 33:9).","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":4,"ref":"p4","source":"Amant apes regem suum, amant justi Christum suum. Apes fabricant favos, justi operantur Ecclesias. De floribus illae colligunt divitias suas, sic omnes justi pulchritudines Scripturarum, per quas intelligitur et honoratur Deus; ipsa sunt florentia prata justorum. Sine libidine apes generant filios, generant et justi casta Evangelii praedicatione Christianos. Paulus enim filios suos alloquebatur, cum diceret: Si decem millia paedagogorum habeatis in Christo, sed non multos patres; nam in Christo Jesu per Evangelium ego vos genui (1 Cor. iv, 15). In favo tria sunt: Cera, Mel, et Pullus. Et ir Ecclesia tria sunt: Scriptura, Intellectus, Auditus. Sicut mel cera concludit, sic intellectum Scriptura custodit. Sicut pulli nidus in cera est, sic in Scriptura pectus auditoris. Sicut foramina favorum, qui adhuc pullos habent, mel nondum habent, sic secreta Scripturarum, prius quam intelligantur, fidem continent parvulorum. Sicut apis pullus, posteaquam volaverit, melle implet receptacula cerae, in quibus nutritus est, sic fideles parvuli, cum in fide creverunt, et pennis charitatis se regere coeperint, munimenta Scripturarum, quarum veneratione custoditi sunt, pleniora efficiunt, et majori veneratione custodiunt. Sicut, favi dum exprimuntur, mella fluunt, vasa suscipiunt, sic Legis et Prophetarum scripta passio Domini expressit, cognitio manavit, corda spiritualium susceperunt.","english":"The bees love their king; the just love their Christ. The bees build honeycombs; the just build churches. From the flowers the bees gather their riches; so all the just gather the beauties of the Scriptures, through which God is understood and honored; these very things are the flowering meadows of the just. Without lust the bees beget their offspring; the just also beget Christians by the chaste preaching of the Gospel. For Paul was addressing his own sons when he said: If you have ten thousand tutors in Christ, yet not many fathers; for in Christ Jesus I begot you through the Gospel (1 Cor. 4:15). In a honeycomb there are three things: wax, honey, and brood. And in the Church there are three things: Scripture, understanding, and hearing. As the wax encloses the honey, so Scripture guards the understanding. As the nest of the brood is in the wax, so the breast of the hearer is in Scripture. As the openings of the combs that still hold brood do not yet hold honey, so the secrets of the Scriptures, before they are understood, hold the faith of the little ones. As the bee's brood, after it has flown, fills with honey the cells of wax in which it was nourished, so faithful little ones, when they have grown in the faith and have begun to guide themselves with the wings of charity, make fuller the strongholds of the Scriptures, by reverence for which they were kept safe, and they guard them with greater reverence. As, when the combs are pressed, the honeys flow and vessels receive them, so the passion of the Lord pressed out the writings of the Law and the Prophets, the knowledge flowed, and the hearts of spiritual people received it.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":5,"ref":"p5","source":"Sicut post mellis expressionem signis imprimendis aptior est cera sine sapore gustantis, sic populi Judaici regentes in lege et prophetis Sabbata et Circumcisionem, Neomenias et Azyma, et caetera horum similia, velut amissa legis dulcedine, sola signorum vestigia, tanquam ceram sine melle tenuerunt.\n\nSed favus multo evidentior, cera, mel et examen Ecclesiae sacramenta, foecunditatisque bona opera significant. Quapropter admonet me Scriptura, ex libro Judicum, aliquid etiam de illo favo dicere, qui in ore leonis mortui inventus est. Cum enim Samson ille fortissimus ad desponsandam iret uxorem, catulus leonis obviam illi factus est itinere, quem tanquam haedum arreptum necavit, et in nihilum facta est in manibus ejus tantae bestiae fortitudo (Judic. xiv). Perrexit quo intenderat, desponsavit uxorem, discessit. Rediens divertit cadaver leonis inspicere. Tunc invenit congregatas apes favum mellis in ore leonis mortui fabricasse. Sacramentum hoc magnum est; res autem breviter a nobis huc usque narrata pro qualitate temporis suffecerit. Jam nunc, fratres, quantum potestis, attendite. Quid Samson, quid leo, quid favus ille significat? Quantum Dominus suggesserit, explicabo. Ipse namque Dominus Jesus Christus pulchritudine mirabilis, fortitudine potentissimus Ecclesiam scilicet ex gentibus convocatam tanquam alienigenarum filiam, venit, ut desponsaret uxorem.","english":"Just as after the honey has been pressed out, the wax is more suitable for stamping impressions, being without taste to the one who tastes it, so the rulers of the Jewish people, in the Law and the Prophets, held the Sabbaths and Circumcision, the New Moons and the Unleavened Bread, and other things similar to these, as though the sweetness of the Law had been lost, only the traces of signs, like wax without honey.\n\nBut the honeycomb, far more evident—wax, honey, and the swarm—signifies the sacraments of the Church and the good works of fruitfulness. Therefore Scripture admonishes me, from the book of Judges, to say something also about that honeycomb which was found in the mouth of a dead lion. For when that most mighty Samson went to marry a wife, a young lion met him on the way, which he seized like a kid and killed, and the strength of so great a beast was brought to nothing in his hands (Judg. 14). He went on to where he intended, married the wife, and departed. Returning, he turned aside to inspect the carcass of the lion. Then he found that bees had gathered and made a honeycomb in the mouth of the dead lion. This is a great mystery; but the matter, briefly narrated by us up to this point, will have sufficed according to the quality of the time. Now, brothers, attend as much as you can. What does Samson signify, what the lion, what that honeycomb? As the Lord has suggested, I will explain. For the Lord Jesus Christ himself, wonderful in beauty, most powerful in strength, came to marry a wife—namely the Church called together from the Gentiles, as though the daughter of foreigners.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":6,"ref":"p6","source":"Cui Ecclesiae loquebatur Apostolus, cum diceret: Desponsavi vos uni viro, virginem castam exhibere Christo (2 Cor. xi, 2). Catulus leonis hic mundus est, dilectores hujus saeculi, filius diaboli, populus impiorum, cujus furor ausus est obviam ire, et resistere Domino, quoad salutem credentium, evangelicam praedicationem praepediret. Fremebat enim gentilis furor per reges, et potentes hujus saeculi, et veluti a patre diabolo inflammatus contra Evangelium Dei, quasi catulus leonis, ardebat, sed tam diu fremuit, donec ad manus viri fortis veniret. Perseverans autem Martyrum fides totam saevitiam gentium, et acerrimos persecutionis impetus fregit. Talibus enim vere fortissimis membris Dominus Christus saeculum vicit, cujus immanem superbiam cum per omnem orbem terrarum nunc videamus extinctam, quis non laetus aspiciat jacere super terram catulum leonis occisum?","english":"To which Church was the Apostle speaking when he said, \"I have espoused you to one husband, to present you as a chaste virgin to Christ\" (2 Cor 11:2)? This lion's cub is the world—the lovers of this age, the son of the devil, the people of the ungodly—whose fury dared to go against and resist the Lord, so far as to hinder the preaching of the Gospel for the salvation of believers. For the fury of the Gentiles was raging through kings and the powerful of this age, and, as if inflamed by the devil their father against the Gospel of God, it burned like a lion's cub; but it raged only so long until it came into the hands of a strong man. Yet the faith of the martyrs, persevering, broke the whole savagery of the nations and the fiercest assaults of persecution. For with such truly most valiant members the Lord Christ conquered the world; and since we now see its monstrous pride extinguished throughout the whole world, who would not look with joy upon the lion's cub lying slain upon the earth?","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":7,"ref":"p7","source":"SERMO II.\n\nIn Sabbato sancto\n\nSYNOPSIS.\n\nI. Deus creavit omnia per Filium. II. Manifestatio Filii per incarnationem. III. Trinitatis Mysterium. IV. Mentis humanae existentia demonstrat existentiam Dei. V. Genuina Dei notio, et in ea spes immortalitatis nostrae.\n\nMultas divinas lectiones audivimus, quarum prolixitati parem sermonem nec nos valemus, nec vos capitis, si valeamus. Quantum ergo Dominus donat, loqui volumus Charitati Vestrae de ipso capite Scripturarum, ubi cum legeretur, audivimus, quia In principio fecit Deus coelum et terram (Gen. I. 1). Attendite et cogitate, quis fecerit; sed scio non posse vos cogitare, quis fecerit. Cogitate, quid fecerit, et laudate, qui fecit. In principio fecit Deus coelum et terram. Ecce, quae facta sunt, in promptu sunt, cernuntur, delectant. Opus patet. Artifex latet, quia et, unde videtur, patet, et unde amatur, latet. Quando ergo mundum videmus, et Deum amamus, melius est utique, unde amamus, quam unde videmus. Oculis videmus, mente amamus. Ergo mentem oculis praeponamus, quia et melior est, quem de occulto amamus, quam opus ejus, quod de aperto videmus. Quaeramus ergo, si placet, quando Deus tantam molem fecit, quibus machinis fecit? Machina facientis verbum est jubentis. Quid miraris? Opus est Omnipotentia. Si ergo quaeris, qui fecit? Deus fecit. Si quaeris, quid fecit? Coelum et terram fecit. Si quaeris, per quid fecit?","english":"SERMON II.\n\nOn Holy Saturday\n\nSYNOPSIS.\n\nI. God created all things through the Son. II. The manifestation of the Son through the incarnation. III. The mystery of the Trinity. IV. The existence of the human mind demonstrates the existence of God. V. The genuine notion of God, and in it the hope of our immortality.\n\nWe have heard many divine readings, to whose length neither are we able to produce a matching sermon, nor would you be able to take it in, even if we were able. Therefore, as much as the Lord grants, we wish to speak to Your Charity concerning the very head of the Scriptures, where, when it was read, we heard, \"In the beginning God made heaven and earth\" (Gen 1:1). Attend and consider who made it; but I know that you cannot consider who made it. Consider what He made, and praise the One who made it. In the beginning God made heaven and earth. Behold, the things that were made are at hand; they are seen, they delight. The work lies open. The craftsman lies hidden, because both that by which He is seen lies open, and that by which He is loved lies hidden. When therefore we see the world and love God, that by which we love is certainly better than that by which we see. With the eyes we see, with the mind we love. Therefore let us set the mind before the eyes, because even the One whom we love from what is hidden is better than His work, which we see from what is open. Let us ask, then, if it pleases you, when God made so great a mass, by what devices He made it. The device of the maker is the word of the one who commands. Why do you marvel? The work belongs to Omnipotence. If therefore you ask who made it? God made it. If you ask what He made? He made heaven and earth. If you ask through what He made it?","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":8,"ref":"p8","source":"Per verbum fecit, quod non fecit. Verbum, per quod factum est coelum et terra, ipsum verbum non est factum. Si enim factum est, per quid factum est? Omnia per ipsum facta sunt (Joan. i, 3). Si quaecumque facta sunt, per Verbum facta sunt, procul dubio Verbum factum non est, per quod omnia facta sunt. Denique narrator operum famulus Dei Moyses: In principio, inquit, fecit Deus coelum et terram. Per quid fecit? Per verbum. Numquid et verbum fecit? Non. Sed quid? In principio erat Verbum (Ibid. 1). Jam erat, per quod fecit; ideo, quod non erat, fecit. Possumus intelligere, et recte intelligimus in ipso unigenito Verbo factum esse coelum et terram. Per quod enim facta sunt, in ipso facta sunt.· Potest hoc esse et intelligi principium, in quo fecit Deus coelum et terram. Ipsum enim verbum est et sapientia Dei, cui dicitur: Omnia in sapientia fecisti (Psal. ciii, 24). Si in sapientia Deus fecit omnia, et unigenitus ejus Filius procul dubio est Dei sapientia, non dubitemus in Filio facta esse, quae per Filium facta esse didicimus. Nam ipse Filius est profecto principium. Interrogantibus quippe Judaeis, et dicentibus: Tu quis es? Respondit: Principium (Joan. viii 25). Ecce In principio fecit Deus coelum et terram.","english":"Through the Word he made what he did not make. The Word, through which heaven and earth were made, is not itself made. For if it was made, through what was it made? All things were made through him (John 1:3). If whatever things were made were made through the Word, then without doubt the Word was not made, since all things were made through it. Finally, Moses, the servant of God, the narrator of the works: In the beginning, he says, God made heaven and earth. Through what did he make them? Through the Word. Did he also make the Word? No. But what? In the beginning was the Word (Ibid. 1). It already was, through which he made; therefore, what was not, he made. We can understand, and we rightly understand, that heaven and earth were made in the only-begotten Word himself. For that through which they were made, in it they were made. This can be, and can be understood as, the beginning in which God made heaven and earth. For it is the very Word and Wisdom of God, to which it is said: All things you have made in wisdom (Ps. 104:24). If God made all things in wisdom, and his only-begotten Son is without doubt the Wisdom of God, let us not doubt that those things were made in the Son which we have learned were made through the Son. For the Son himself is assuredly the beginning. For when the Jews asked and said: Who are you? He answered: The beginning (John 8:25). Behold, In the beginning God made heaven and earth.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[{"kind":"scripture","severity":"info","ref":"John 1:1","text":"The English carries the scriptural phrase “in the beginning was the word”, which matches John 1:1. The match is on the English draft; check the Coptic before quoting the verse."}]},{"i":9,"ref":"p9","source":"Jam vero caetera, sive cum digeruntur et disponuntur, sive cum ornantur, sive cum ea quae facta non erant in coelo et in terra, creantur, dicit Deus et fiunt. Et dixit Deus: Fiat, et factum est (Gen. i, saepius). Et sic per singula opera: Dixit et factum est; Ipse dixit et facta sunt (Pal. xxxii, 9). Qua lingua dixit? Ut quis audiret, dixit? Non semper lacte nutriamur. Erigite nobiscum mentes ad solidum cibum. Nemo Deum cogitet sicut corpus, nemo Deum cogitet sicut hominem, nemo Deum cogitet sicut Angelum, quamvis patribus sic apparere dignatus sit, non per ipsam substantiam suam, sed per subjectam sibi creaturam suam: non enim aliter humanis visibus invisibilis appareret. Quaeramus, quid in nobis est melius, et inde conemur attingere, quod est melius omnibus. Quod est in nobis melius, mens est. Quod est omnibus melius, Deus est. Rem meliorem quid quaeris re deteriore? In te corpus in ferius est, quam mens; in rebus nihil melius, quam Deus. Erige, quod est in te melius, ut attingas, si potueris, ad eum, qui est omnibus melius. Nam et ego, cum loquor, mentibus loquor. Visibiles quidem facies et ipse corpore visibilis cerno; sed per id, quod video, alloquor, quod non video. Gero intus verbum corde conceptum, et volo in auribus tuis parere. Quod corde concepi, volo tibi dicere, quod (??)us est, proferre ad te. Quod latet, quaero, quomodo pervenire ad mentem tuam possit.","english":"Now the rest—whether when they are arranged and ordered, or when they are adorned, or when those things which had not been made are created in heaven and on earth—God says, and they are made. And God said: Let it be made, and it was made (Gen. 1, repeatedly). And so through each individual work: He spoke, and it was made; He himself spoke, and they were made (Ps. 32:9). In what tongue did he speak? Did he speak so that someone might hear? Let us not always be fed on milk. Raise your minds with us to solid food. Let no one think of God as a body, let no one think of God as a man, let no one think of God as an angel—although he deigned to appear thus to the fathers, not through his own substance, but through his creation subject to him; for otherwise he, being invisible, would not appear to human sight. Let us ask what is better in us, and from there let us strive to reach what is better than all things. What is better in us is the mind. What is better than all things is God. Why do you seek a better thing from a lesser thing? In you the body is lower than the mind; in things there is nothing better than God. Raise up what is better in you, that you may reach, if you can, him who is better than all things. For I too, when I speak, speak to minds. I myself, visible in body, behold visible faces; but through what I see, I address what I do not see. I carry within me the word conceived in the heart, and I wish it to be brought forth in your ears. What I have conceived in the heart, I wish to say to you, to bring forth to you what is hidden. I seek how what lies hidden can reach your mind.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":10,"ref":"p10","source":"Convenio primum, quasi januam mentis tuae, aures tuas, et quoniam invisibile verbum, quod corde concepi, trahere ad te non possum, provideo illi, quasi vehiculum, sonum. Ecce verbum latet, sonus patet. Impono latentem super patentem, et pervenio ad audientem, ac sic verbum exit a me, venit ad te, et non recessit a me. Si ergo licet magnis exigua comparare, infima summis, humana divinis, fecit hoc et Deus. Verbum latebat apud Patrem. Ut veniret ad nos, assumpsit quasi vehiculum, carnem suscepit, ad nos processit, et a Patre non recessit, sed ante incarnationem suam, ante ipsum Adam patrem generis humani, ante coelum et terram, et omnia, quae in eis sunt, In principio erat Verbum, et in principio fecit Deus coelum et terram.\n\nTerram autem fecit Deus adhuc antequam ornaretur, antequam ejus species nudaretur. Invisibilis erat, et incomposita, et tenebrae erant super abyssum. Tenebrae erant, ubi lex non erat; nondum enim lux facta erat. Spiritus Dei superferebatur super aquas (Gen. I, 2), et ipse opifex, nec a Patre et unigenito Verbo sejunctus. Nam ecce, diligenter attendamus, Trinitas nobis insinuatur. Ubi enim dicitur: In principio fecit, Usia intelligitur Patris et Filii, in principio Filio Deus Pater. Restat Spiritus, ut Trinitas impleatur. Spiritus Dei superferebatur super aquas. Et dixit Deus. Cui dixit Deus? Antequam creatura fieret, erat, qui audiret? Erat, inquit.","english":"I first approach your ears as a kind of door to your mind; and since I cannot draw to you the invisible word that I have conceived in my heart, I provide sound for it as a kind of vehicle. Behold, the word lies hidden; the sound lies open. I place the hidden thing upon the open thing, and so I reach the hearer; and thus the word goes out from me, comes to you, and has not departed from me. If, then, it is permitted to compare small things with great, the lowest with the highest, human things with divine, God has done this too. The Word lay hidden with the Father. In order to come to us, he took to himself, as it were, a vehicle; he took up flesh, he came forth to us, and he did not depart from the Father. But before his incarnation, before Adam himself, the father of the human race, before heaven and earth and all things that are in them, In the beginning was the Word, and in the beginning God made heaven and earth.\n\nBut God made the earth even before he adorned it, before its form was unveiled. It was invisible and unformed, and darkness was over the abyss. There was darkness where the law was not; for the light had not yet been made. The Spirit of God was moving over the waters (Gen. 1:2), and he himself is the craftsman, nor is he separated from the Father and the only-begotten Word. For behold, let us attend carefully: the Trinity is made known to us. For where it is said, In the beginning God made, the substance of the Father and of the Son is understood—God the Father in the beginning, that is, in the Son. The Spirit remains, that the Trinity may be complete. The Spirit of God was moving over the waters. And God said. To whom did God say it? Before the creature was made, was there anyone who could hear? There was, he says.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":11,"ref":"p11","source":"Quaero, quis? ipse Filius. Filio ergo dixit Deus. Quo verbo locutus est Verbo? Si enim jam erat Filius, ut dubitat nemo Christianus, utique hoc etiam erat. Filius Verbum erat, et Verbo Pater dicebat. Ergo inter Deum et Verbum verba currebant? Absit! Impedimenta, fratres, carnalis cogitationis auferte, invisibilia invisibiliter cogitate, non vobis versentur ante oculos mentis similitudines corporis. Transi, quidquid in te cernitur. Transcende, quidquid in te etiam non cernitur; corpus enim cernitur, anima non cernitur, sed tamen mutatur. Modo vult, modo non vult; modo scit, modo nescit; modo meminit, modo obliviscitur; modo proficit, modo deficit. Non est hoc Deus, non est Deus ista natura, non est anima portio de substantia Dei. Quidquid enim Deus est, immutabile Bonum est, incorruptibile Bonum est. Etsi invisibilis Deus, invisibilis anima, sed tamen mutabilis anima, immutabilis Deus. Transcende ergo non solum, quod cernitur in te, sed etiam illud, quod mutatur in te. Totum transcende, te ipsum transcende.","english":"I ask, who? The Son himself. Therefore God spoke to the Son. By what word did he speak to the Word? For if the Son already existed, as no Christian doubts, then this also already existed. The Son was the Word, and the Father was speaking to the Word. So were words running between God and the Word? Far be it! Brothers, remove the hindrances of carnal thought, think invisible things invisibly, and let no likenesses of a body turn about before the eyes of your mind. Pass beyond whatever is seen in you. Transcend whatever in you is not even seen; for the body is seen, the soul is not seen, yet it is changed. Now it wills, now it does not will; now it knows, now it does not know; now it remembers, now it forgets; now it advances, now it fails. This is not God; this is not God's nature; the soul is not a portion of God's substance. For whatever God is, he is unchangeable Good, incorruptible Good. Though God is invisible and the soul is invisible, yet the soul is changeable, God unchangeable. Transcend, therefore, not only what is seen in you, but also that which is changed in you. Transcend the whole, transcend yourself.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":12,"ref":"p12","source":"IV. Amator quidam invisibilis bonitatis, amator quidam invisibilis aeternitatis ait in suspiriis suis, et gemitibus amoris sui: Factae sunt mihi lacrymae meae panis die et nocte, dum dicitur mihi quotidie: Ubi est Deus tuus (Psal. xli, 4). Quomodo non fiant vere gemitus amanti lacrymae suae panis, ut eis quodam modo tanquam ex cibi voluptate vescatur, et libenter ploret, quandiu non videt quod amat, cum dicitur ei quotidie: Ubi est Deus tuus? Si dixero Pagano: «Ubi est Deus tuus? ostendet mihi idola. Si fregero idolum, ostendet montem, ostendet arborem, ostendet vilem de flumine lapidem. Quod enim de multis lapidibus tulerit, et in loco honoratiore collocaverit, et incurvatus adoraverit, hoc est Deus ipsius. Ecce, inquit digitum intendens: Ecce Deus meus. Cum irrisero lapidem, cum abstulero, cum fregero, cum projecero, cum contempsero, intendit digitum ad solem, ad lunam, intendit ad quamlibet stellam. Illam vocat Saturnum, illam Mercurium, illam Jovem, illam Venerem. Quaero, quid voluerit, quocumque digitum intenderit. Respondet mihi: Ecce est Deus meus. Et quia video solem, et frangere non possum, sidera non possum dejicere, coelum non possum evertere, quasi superior sibi videtur visibilia demonstrando, et digitum extendendo, ad quod voluerit, et dicendo: Ecce est Deus meus, et ad me se convertit dicens: Ubi est Deus tuus? Cum audio: Ubi est Deus tuus?","english":"IV. A certain lover of invisible goodness, a certain lover of invisible eternity, said in his sighs and in the groans of his love: My tears have been my bread day and night, while it is said to me daily: Where is your God? How is it that his tears do not truly become bread to one who loves, so that in some manner he feeds on them as on the pleasure of food, and willingly weeps as long as he does not see what he loves, while it is said to him daily: Where is your God? If I say to a pagan: \"Where is your God?\" he will show me idols. If I break the idol, he will show me a mountain, he will show me a tree, he will show me a worthless stone from the river. For whatever he has taken from many stones, and placed in a more honored place, and bowed down and adored, that is his God. Behold, he says, pointing his finger: Behold my God. When I have mocked the stone, when I have taken it away, when I have broken it, when I have thrown it down, when I have despised it, he points his finger at the sun, at the moon, he points at any star at all. That one he calls Saturn, that one Mercury, that one Jove, that one Venus. I ask what he meant, wherever he pointed his finger. He answers me: Behold, he is my God. And because I see the sun and cannot break it, I cannot cast down the stars, I cannot overturn the heaven, he seems to himself as it were superior by pointing out visible things, and extending his finger at whatever he wishes, and saying: Behold, he is my God, and he turns to me saying: Where is your God? When I hear: Where is your God?","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":13,"ref":"p13","source":"quid oculis ostendam, non habeo, mentes oblatrantes caecas invenio. Oculis, quos habet, unde videat, ego non habeo, quod ostendam. Cum vere habeo, quem ostendam, ille non habet oculos, unde videat. Libet flere, tanquam in lacrymis pane vesci! invisibilis est enim Deus meus, ille, qui mihi loquitur, visibilia requirit, cum dicit: Ubi est Deus tuus? Ego autem, ut pervenirem ad Deum meum, sicut dicit in ipso Psalmo: Haec meditatus sum, et effudi super me animam meam (Psal. xli, 5). Deus meus non est infra animam meam, sed est supra animam meam. Unde attingo ad id, quod est supra animam meam, nisi effundam super me animam meam? Et tamen huic protervo, visibilia requirenti, visibilia demonstranti, de visibilibus exultanti utcumque adjuvante Deo meo respondere conabor. Hoc certe mihi dicis: Ubi est Deus tuus? Respondeo tibi: Ubi es ipse tu? Respondeo, inquam; puto, quia non importune. Tu quaesisti, ubi sit Deus; ego vero, ubi sit ipse interrogator meus. Dicturus est: Ecce, ubi sum. Vides me, tibi loquor. Et ego illi: Interrogatorem meum quaero. Faciem ejus video, corpus ejus video, vocem ejus audio, linguam ejus inspicio. Ipsum quaero, qui in me oculos intendit, qui linguam movet, qui vocem emittit, qui interrogando scire desiderat. H(??)c totum, de quo loquor, anima est. Non ergo tecum diutius agam. Tu dicis: Ostende mihi Deum tuum. Ego dico: Ostende mihi animum tuum.","english":"What I am to show to the eyes, I do not have; I find minds that bark against me, blind. For the eyes that a man has, whereby he may see, I do not have what I may show. But when I truly have one whom I may show, he does not have eyes whereby he may see. It is a pleasure to weep, as if to eat bread in tears! For my God is invisible, he who speaks to me; whereas the man demands visible things when he says: Where is your God? But I, that I might reach my God, as it is said in that same Psalm: These things I have meditated, and I have poured out my soul upon myself (Ps. 41:5). My God is not beneath my soul, but above my soul. How then do I reach that which is above my soul, unless I pour out my soul upon myself? And yet to this shameless one, demanding visible things, pointing to visible things, exulting in visible things, with the help of my God as I can, I shall try to respond. This at least you say to me: Where is your God? I answer you: Where are you yourself? I answer, I say; I think, because not out of place. You asked where God is; but I ask where my questioner himself is. He is about to say: Behold, here I am. You see me, I am speaking to you. And I say to him: I seek my questioner. I see his face, I see his body, I hear his voice, I examine his tongue. I seek the very one who fixes his eyes upon me, who moves his tongue, who emits his voice, who by questioning desires to know. All this of which I speak is the soul. Therefore I will not deal with you any longer. You say: Show me your God. I say: Show me your soul.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":14,"ref":"p14","source":"Laboras, fatigaris, figeris, cum dico: Ostende mihi animum tuum. Scio, quia non potes. Quare non potes? Quia invisibilis est animus tuus. Et tamen melior est in te, quam corpus tuum. Deus autem meus melior est, quam animus tuus. Quomodo ergo ostendam Deum meum, cum mihi non ostendas animum tuum, quo meliorem ostendo Deum meum? Ecce, si dicis mihi ex opere agnosce animum meum. Quia oculos intendo ad videndum, aures ad audiendum, linguam moveo ad loquendum, vocem promo ad sonandum ex hoc intelligo et cognosce animum meum. Vides, quia ipsum non potes ostendere, sed me jubes eum ex operibus nosse. Ecce, et ego ex operibus ostendam tibi Deum meum. Nec pergo longius, nec mitto forte infidelitatem tuam ad ea, quae non capis. Opera Dei mei non sic commemoro: Fecit invisibilia, fecit visibilia, id est, Coelum et terram, mare et omnia, quae in eis sunt. Non te mitto per multa. Ad te ipsum redeo. Tu certe vivis. Habes corpus, habes animum. Visibile est corpus, invisibilis est animus. Corpus habitaculum, animus habitator. Corpus vehiculum, quod regatur, animus auriga corporis tui. Ecce manifesti sunt sensus tui, tanquam januae in corpore tuo, per quas nuntietur aliquid interius habitanti animo tuo: oculi, aures, olfactus, gustus, tactus, membra disposita. Quid illud intus, unde cogitas, unde ista vivificas? Hoc totum, quod miraris in te, qui hoc fecit, ipse est Deus meus.","english":"You labor, you grow weary, you are fixed fast when I say: Show me your mind. I know that you cannot. Why can you not? Because your mind is invisible. And yet it is better in you than your body. But my God is better than your mind. How, then, shall I show my God, when you do not show me your mind, than which I show my God to be better? Behold, if you say to me, Know my mind from its works—because I direct my eyes to see, my ears to hear, I move my tongue to speak, I bring forth my voice to sound—from this understand and know my mind. You see that you cannot show it itself, but you bid me know it from its works. Behold, I too will show you my God from his works. Nor do I go further, nor do I perhaps send your unbelief to those things which you do not grasp. I do not so recount the works of my God: He made invisible things, he made visible things, that is, heaven and earth, the sea and all things that are in them. I do not send you through many things. I return to you yourself. You certainly live. You have a body, you have a mind. The body is visible, the mind is invisible. The body is the dwelling, the mind the dweller. The body is the vehicle that is to be steered, the mind the charioteer of your body. Behold, your senses are manifest, like doors in your body, through which something within is announced to the mind that dwells in your body: eyes, ears, smell, taste, touch, members arranged. What is that within, whence you think, whence you give life to these things? All this that you marvel at in yourself—he who made it is my God himself.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":15,"ref":"p15","source":"Ergo, fratres mei, si mentes vestras, si interiores animos vestros aliqua, ut potui, congrua collocutione conveni, si ad eos, qui intus morantur in domibus luteis, id est, ad animos vestros habitantes in corporibus vestris loquendo perveni, nolite de eis, quae nostis, Divina conjicere. Superat omnia Deus. coelum et terram. Nolite vobis ante oculos ponere quasi fabrum aliquem magnum aliquid componentem. disponentem, machinantem, tornantem, vertentem, aut certe tanquam Imperatorem in sella regia, lucida, ornata sedentem, et jubendo creantem. Frangite idola in cordibus vestris. Attendite, quod dictum est ad Moysen, cum Dei nomen inquireret. Ego sum (Exod. iii. 14) Quaere, quid aliud Est. Illius comparatione nec Est. Nescit ulla ex parte mutari, quod veraciter Est. Omne, quidquid mutatur et fluitat, et quodam tempore mutari non cessat, fuit, et erit Non in eo comprehendis Est. Deus autem non habet fuit, et erit. Quod autem fuit, jam non est. Quod erit, nondum est. Et quod sic venit, ut transeat ideo erit, ut non sit. Cogitate, si potestis: Ego sum, qui sum. Nolite voluntatibus volvi, nolite voluntariis et temporalibus cogitationibus agitari. State ad Est. State ad ipsum Est. Quo itis? State, ut et vos esse possitis. Sed quando tenemus volaticam cogitationem, et ad id, quod manet, affigere. quando possumus?","english":"Therefore, my brothers, if I have reached your minds, if I have come to your inner souls by some fitting address, as I was able, if by speaking I have come to those who dwell within houses of clay—that is, to your souls dwelling in your bodies—do not form your ideas of God from the things you know. God surpasses all things: heaven and earth. Do not set before your eyes something like some great craftsman composing, arranging, devising, turning, and rotating some great work, or at least like an Emperor seated on a royal throne, bright and adorned, creating by command. Break the idols in your hearts. Attend to what was said to Moses when he inquired after God's name: I am who am. Ask what else \"is\" means. Compared with Him, it is not. That which truly is knows no change in any part. Everything that changes and flows and at some time does not cease to change, was and will be; in it you do not grasp \"is.\" But God has no \"was\" and \"will be.\" For what was, now is not; what will be, is not yet. And what comes in such a way as to pass away, therefore will be so that it may not be. Think, if you can: I am who am. Do not be rolled about by your wills, do not be tossed about by voluntary and temporal thoughts. Stand at \"is.\" Stand at \"is\" itself. Where are you going? Stand, so that you too may be able to be. But when do we hold a fleeting thought and fix it to that which remains? When can we?","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":16,"ref":"p16","source":"Ergo misertus Deus, et ille, qui Est, et ille, qui dixit: Hoc dices filiis Israel: Qui est, misit me ad vos, dicto nomine substantiae suae, dicit postea nomen misericordiae suae. Quod nomen substantiae ejus? Ego sum, qui sum, dices filiis Israel: Qui est, misit me ad vos (ibid.). Sed Moyses homo erat, et in his, quae in illius comparatione non sunt, erat. In terra erat, in carne erat, et in ipsa carne anima erat, natura mutabilis erat, sub sarcina fragilitatis humanae erat. Nam Illud, quod dictum est: Ego sum, qui sum, quando capiebat? Etenim per id, quod videbatur oculis ejus, ad eum loquebatur, qui non videbatur, et illo, qui videbatur, tanquam instrumento latens Deus utebatur. Non enim, quod videbat Moyses, hoc erat totum Deus: quia nec tu, quod a me ipso, quod homo sim, sonat, hoc est totum verbum. Habeo in corde verbum quod non sonat. Sonus transit, verbum manet!. Ergo cum diceret Deus ad hominem invisibilis, per id, quod apparere dignatus est, visibilis, loqueretur aeternus temporalia, incommutabilis fragilia, cum diceret: Ego sum, qui sum, et Dices filiis Israel: Qui est, misit me ad vos, tanquam illo non valente comprehendere, quid sit: Ego sum, qui sum, et: Qui est, misit me ad vos, aut forte, si ipse comprehendebat, nobis legendum erat, qui comprehendere non valemus, continuo post nomen substantiae dixit nomen misericordiae.","english":"Therefore God took pity, and he who Is, and he who said, \"Thus shall you say to the children of Israel: He who is has sent me to you,\" having first spoken the name of his substance, afterward speaks the name of his mercy. What is the name of his substance? \"I am who I am; thus shall you say to the children of Israel: He who is has sent me to you.\" But Moses was a man, and he was among those things which are not, in comparison with him. He was on earth, he was in the flesh, and in that flesh was a soul, he was a mutable nature, he was under the burden of human frailty. For that which was said, \"I am who I am,\" when could he grasp it? For indeed, through that which appeared to his eyes, he was speaking to him who was not seen, and God, hidden, was using that which was seen as an instrument. For what Moses saw was not the whole of God—just as neither is the sound that comes from me, insofar as I am a man, the whole of the word. I have in my heart a word that makes no sound. The sound passes away, the word remains. Therefore, when God, invisible, was speaking to a man through that which he deigned to make visible, the eternal speaking to temporal things, the unchangeable to fragile things, when he said, \"I am who I am,\" and \"Thus shall you say to the children of Israel: He who is has sent me to you\"—as though Moses could not grasp what \"I am who I am\" means, and \"He who is has sent me to you,\" or perhaps, if he did grasp it, it was for us to read who cannot grasp it—immediately after the name of his substance he spoke the name of his mercy.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":17,"ref":"p17","source":"Tanquam diceret Moysi; Quod dixi: Ego sum, qui sum, non capis, non stat cor tuum, non es immutabilis mecum, nec incommutabilis mens tua. Audisti, quod sum. Audi, quod capias; audi, quod speres. Dixit iterum Deus ad Moysen: Ego sum Deus Abraham, et Deus Isaac, et Deus Jacob. Non potes capere nomen substantiae meae, cape nomen misericordiae meae. Ego sum Deus Abraham, et Deus Isaac, et Deus Jacob (Ibid. 6). Sed quod sum, aeternum est. Abraham, Isaac et Jacob quidem aeterni, imo non dico aeterni, sed ab illo facti aeterni. Denique sic etiam calumniantes Sadducaeos Dominus ipse convincit, qui cum resurrectionem negarent, hinc ille dedit testimonium sanctae Scripturae. Legite quod dixit Dominus in rubo ad Moysen: Ego sum Deus Abraham, et Deus Isaac, et Deus Jacob. Non est Deus mortuorum, sed vivorum (Matth. xxii, 32; et Marc. xii, 26, 27); omnes enim illi vivunt. Proinde et hic non addidit Deus, cum dixisset: Ego sum, qui sum, Hoc mihi nomen est aeternum (Exod. iii, 15). Hic enim nemo dubitat; quia id, quod est, ideo est, quia aeternum est. Sed ubi ait: Ego sum, Deus Abraham, et Deus Isaac, et Deus Jacob, ibi addidit: Hoc mihi nomen est in aeternum. Tanquam diceret: Quid times de mortalitate generis humani? Quid fortasse trepidas, ne, cum mortuus fueris, ultra non sis? Hoc mihi nomen est in aeternum.","english":"As if he were saying to Moses: What I said, \"I am who am,\" you do not grasp; your heart does not stand firm; you are not immutable with me, nor is your mind unchangeable. You have heard that I am. Hear what you may grasp; hear what you may hope for. God said again to Moses: \"I am the God of Abraham, and the God of Isaac, and the God of Jacob.\" You cannot grasp the name of my substance; grasp the name of my mercy. \"I am the God of Abraham, and the God of Isaac, and the God of Jacob.\" But what I am is eternal. Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob are indeed eternal—no, I do not say eternal, but made eternal by him. Finally, the Lord himself also refutes the slanderous Sadducees in this way; when they denied the resurrection, he gave testimony from this passage of holy Scripture. Read what the Lord said in the bush to Moses: \"I am the God of Abraham, and the God of Isaac, and the God of Jacob. He is not the God of the dead, but of the living\"; for all those men live. Accordingly, here too God did not add, when he had said, \"I am who am,\" \"This is my name forever.\" For here no one doubts it, because that which is, is for this reason, because it is eternal. But where he said, \"I am the God of Abraham, and the God of Isaac, and the God of Jacob,\" there he added: \"This is my name forever.\" As if he were saying: Why do you fear concerning the mortality of the human race? Why do you perhaps tremble lest, when you have died, you be no more? This is my name forever.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":18,"ref":"p18","source":"Aeternum nomen esse non posset Deus Abraham, et Deus Isaac, et Deus Jacob, nisi in aeternum viverent Abraham, Isaac et Jacob. Conversi ad Dominum, etc.\n\nSERMO III.\n\nDe Sacramento altaris ad infantes.\n\nSYNOPSIS.\n\nI Sacrificii novae Legis Commendatio. II. Sacrificium istud Christus est. III. Vere et realiter in Eucharistia praesens. IV. Eucharistiae Effectus. V. Conditiones dignae Sumptionis.\n\nI. Reddendi sermonis officium, et cura, qua vos parturivimus, ut Christus formaretur in vobis, compellit nos admonere infantiam vestram, qui ex aqua et Spiritu nunc renati cibum et potum istum super hanc dominicam mensam nova luce conspicitis, et novella pietate percipitis, quid sibi velit tam magnum, divinumque Sacramentum, tam clarum et nobile medicamentum, tam mundum et facile sacrificium, quod nec in una civitate terrena Jerusalem, nec in tabernaculo illo quod per Moysen, nec in templo illo, quod per Salomonem fabricatum est, quae fuerunt umbrae futurorum, sed a solis ortu usque ad occasum, sicut a Prophetis praedictum est, immolatur, et secundum Novi Testamenti gratiam Deo victima laudis offertur. Non adhuc de gregibus pecorum hostia cruenta conquiritur, non nunc ovis aut hircus divinis altaribus admovetur, sed sacrificium jam nostri temporis Corpus et Sanguis est ipsius Sacerdotis.","english":"God could not be the eternal name \"God of Abraham, and God of Isaac, and God of Jacob\" unless Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob lived forever. Turned to the Lord, etc.\n\nSERMON III.\n\nOn the Sacrament of the Altar, to the infants.\n\nSYNOPSIS.\n\nI. The commendation of the sacrifice of the New Law. II. This sacrifice is Christ. III. Truly and really present in the Eucharist. IV. The effects of the Eucharist. V. The conditions of worthy reception.\n\nI. The duty of rendering our sermon, and the care with which we have labored for you, that Christ might be formed in you, compels us to admonish your infancy—you who, now reborn of water and the Spirit, behold with new light this food and drink upon the Lord's table, and receive it with new devotion—as to what is meant by so great and divine a Sacrament, so clear and noble a remedy, so pure and easy a sacrifice, which is not offered in that one earthly city Jerusalem, nor in that tabernacle which was built through Moses, nor in that temple which was built through Solomon—which were shadows of things to come—but from the rising of the sun to its setting, as was foretold by the Prophets, is immolated, and according to the grace of the New Testament a victim of praise is offered to God. No longer is a bloody victim sought from the flocks of sheep; no longer is a sheep or a goat brought to the divine altars, but the sacrifice of our time is now the Body and Blood of the Priest himself.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":19,"ref":"p19","source":"De illo quippe tanto ante praedictum est in Psalmis: Tu es Sacerdos in aeternum secundum ordinem Melchisedech (1 Psal. cix, 4) Quod autem panem et vinum Melchisedech sacerdos Dei excelsi protulerit, quando patrem nostrum Abraham benedixit, in libro Genesis legimus et tenemus (Gen. xiv, 18).\n\nChristus ergo Dominus noster, qui obtulit patiendo pro nobis, quod nascendo accepit ex nobis, princeps Sacerdotum factus in aeternum sacrificandi dedit ordinem, quem videtis. Corporis utique et Sanguinis sui. Nam percussum lancea Corpus ejus aquam et sanguinem emisit, quo peccata nostra dimisit. Hujus gratiae memores, vestram ipsorum salutem operantes, quoniam Deus est, qui operatur in vobis, cum timore et tremore ad participationem hujus altaris accedite. Hoc agnoscite in pane, quod pependit in cruce; hoc in calice, quod manavit ex latere. Nam et illa vetera sacrificia populi Dei hoc unum venturum multiplici varietate figurabant. Ipse enim Christus et ovis est propter innocentiam simplicis animi, et hircus propter similitudinem carnis peccati. Et quidquid aliud multis et diversis modis in sacrificiis Testamenti Veteris praenunciatum est, ad hoc unum pertinet, quod novo Testamento revelatum est.","english":"For of him it was foretold so long before in the Psalms: You are a Priest forever according to the order of Melchizedek. And that Melchizedek, priest of God Most High, brought forth bread and wine when he blessed our father Abraham, we read in the book of Genesis and hold fast.\n\nChrist, therefore, our Lord, who offered by suffering for us what he received from us by being born, having been made the chief of Priests forever, gave the order of sacrificing which you see—namely, of his Body and Blood. For his Body, struck by the lance, gave forth water and blood, by which he forgave our sins. Mindful of this grace, working out your own salvation—since it is God who works in you—approach the partaking of this altar with fear and trembling. Recognize in the bread what hung on the cross; recognize in the cup what flowed from his side. For those ancient sacrifices of the people of God also prefigured by manifold variety this one thing that was to come. For Christ himself is both a sheep, on account of the innocence of a simple soul, and a goat, on account of the likeness of sinful flesh. And whatever else was foretold in many and various ways in the sacrifices of the Old Testament pertains to this one thing, which has been revealed in the New Testament.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":20,"ref":"p20","source":"Accipite itaque, et edite Corpus Christi, etiam Ipsi in Corpore Christi facti jam membra Christi. Accipite, et potate Sanguinem Christi. Ne dissolvamini, manducate vinculum vestrum. Ne vobis viles videamini, bibite pretium vestrum. Sicut hoc in vos convertitur, cum id manducatis et bibitis, sic et vos in Corpus Christi convertimini, cum obedienter et pie vivitis. Ipse namque sua jam propinquante passione, cum Pascha faceret cum Discipulis suis, acceptum panem benedixit, et ait: Hoc est Corpus meum, quod pro vobis tradetur (Luc. xxii, 19). Similiter benedictum calicem dedit dicens: Hic est Sanguis meus Novi Testamenti, qui pro multis effundetur in remissionem peccatorum (Matth. xxvi, 28). Hoc in Evangelio vel legabatis, vel audiebatis, sed hanc Eucharistiam esse Filium nesciebatis. Nunc vero aspersi corde in conscientia pura, et loti corpore aqua munda Accedite ad eum, et illuminamini, et vultus vestri non erubescent (Psal. xxxiii, 6). Hoc enim si digne accipitis, quod pertinet ad Testamentum Novum, per quod aeternam haereditatem speratis, tenentes mandatum novum, ut vos invicem diligatis, habetis in vobis vitam. Illam enim carnem sumitis, de qua dicit ipsa Vita: Panis, quem ego dedero, caro mea est pro saeculi vita, et: Nisi quis manducaverit carnem meam, et biberit sanguinem meum, non habebit in se vitam (Joan. vi, 52-54).","english":"Receive therefore and eat the Body of Christ, you who have already been made members of Christ in the Body of Christ. Receive and drink the Blood of Christ. Lest you be dissolved, eat your bond. Lest you seem worthless to yourselves, drink your price. Just as this is turned into you when you eat and drink it, so also are you turned into the Body of Christ when you live obediently and piously. For he himself, when his passion was already near, when he was making the Passover with his disciples, blessed the bread he had received and said: This is my Body, which shall be delivered for you (Luke 22:19). Likewise he gave the blessed cup, saying: This is my Blood of the New Testament, which shall be poured out for many for the remission of sins (Matthew 26:28). You used to read or hear this in the Gospel, but you did not know that this Eucharist is the Son. But now, sprinkled in heart in a pure conscience, and washed in body with clean water, Draw near to him and be enlightened, and your faces shall not be put to shame (Psalm 33:6). For if you receive this worthily, which belongs to the New Testament, through which you hope for an eternal inheritance, keeping the new commandment that you love one another, you have life in you. For you take that flesh of which Life itself says: The bread that I shall give is my flesh for the life of the world, and: Unless one eats my flesh and drinks my blood, he will not have life in himself (John 6:52-54).","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":21,"ref":"p21","source":"Habentes ergo vitam in illo in carne una eritis cum illo. Neque enim hoc Sacramentum Christi corpus ita commendat, ut nos inde sejungat. Hoc namque Apostolus in Scriptura sancta praedictum esse commemorat: Erunt Duo in carne una. Sacramentum hoc, inquit, magnum est; ego autem dico in Christo et in Ecclesia (Ephes. v. 52). Et alio loco de hac ipsa Eucharistia a dicit: Unus panis, unum corpus multi sumus (1 Cor. x, 17). Accipere ergo incipitis, quod et esse coepistis, si non indigne accipiatis, ne judicium vobis manducetis, et bibatis. Sic enim dicit: Quicumque manducaverit panem aut biberit calicem Domini indigne, reus erit Corporis et Sanguinis Domini. Probet autem se ipsum homo, et sic de pane illo edat, et de calice bibat. Qui enim manducat et bibit indigne, judicium sibi manducat et bibit (1 Cor. xi, 27-29).\n\nDigne autem accipitis, si a malae doctrinae fermento caveatis, ut sitis Azymi sinceritatis, et veritatis (Id. v. 3). Aut si fermentum illud charitatis teneatis, Quod abscondit mulier in farinae mensuris tribus, donec fermentaretur totum (Matth. xiii, 33). Haec enim mulier est sapientia Dei, facta per Virginem in carne mortali, quae in toto orbe terrarum, quem de tribus Noe filiis post diluvium reparavit, tanquam in mensuris tribus suum disseminat Evangelium, Donec fermentaretur totum.","english":"Having therefore life in him, you will be one flesh with him. For this sacrament does not so commend the body of Christ as to separate us from it. For the Apostle recalls that this was foretold in Holy Scripture: The two shall be one flesh. This sacrament, he says, is great; but I speak concerning Christ and the Church (Eph. 5:32). And in another place he says of this very Eucharist: We many are one bread, one body (1 Cor. 10:17). You therefore begin to receive what you have also begun to be, if you do not receive it unworthily, lest you eat and drink judgment to yourselves. For so he says: Whoever shall eat the bread or drink the cup of the Lord unworthily shall be guilty of the body and blood of the Lord. But let a man prove himself, and so let him eat of that bread and drink of the cup. For he who eats and drinks unworthily eats and drinks judgment to himself (1 Cor. 11:27-29).\n\nBut you receive worthily if you guard against the leaven of evil doctrine, so that you may be unleavened bread of sincerity and truth (1 Cor. 5:8). Or if you hold that leaven of charity, which a woman hid in three measures of flour until the whole was leavened (Matt. 13:33). For this woman is the wisdom of God, made through the Virgin in mortal flesh, who throughout the whole world, which he restored from the three sons of Noah after the flood, as it were in three measures sows her Gospel, until the whole is leavened.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":22,"ref":"p22","source":"Hoc est illud Totum, quod graece dicitur Holon, ubi custodientes vinculum pacis eritis secundum totum, quod Catholon vocatur, et unde Catholica nominatur.\n\nSERMO IV.\n\nDe Paschate. SYNOPSIS.\n\nChristus agnus et Leo.\n\nSicut veritas per Apostolos sonuit, et In omnem terram exivit sonus eorum, atque in fines orbis terrae verba eorum (Psal. xviii, 5); Pascha nostrum immolatus est Christus(Rom. x, 18). De quo ante Propheta praedixerat: Sicut ovis ad immolandum ductus est, et ut agnus coram, qui se tonderet, fuit sine voce, sic non aperuit os suum (Isai, liii, 7). Quis est iste? Nempe ille, de quo sequitur, et dicit: In humilitate judicium ejus sublutum est. Generationem ipsius quis enarrabit (Isai. Ibid. 7). Video exemplum tantae humilitatis in Rege tantae potestatis. Nam iste sicut agnus coram tondente non aperiens os suum ipse est Leo de tribu Juda (Apoc, v, 5). Quis est iste agnus et leo? Mortem pertulit, ut agnus; consumpsit, ut leo. Quis est iste agnus et leo? Mitis et fortis, amabilis et terribilis, innocens et potens, tacens judicatus, fremens judicaturus. Quis est iste agnus et leo? In passione agnus in resurrectione leo, an potius et in passione agnus, et leo, et in resurrectione agnus et leo? Agnum in passione videamus. Modo jam dictus est. Sicut agnus coram tondente se fuit sine voce, sic non aperuit os suum. Leonem in passione videamus.","english":"This is that Whole which in Greek is called Holon, where you will be keeping the bond of peace according to the whole, which is called Catholon, and from which the Catholic Church is named.\n\nSERMON IV.\n\nOn the Passover. SYNOPSIS.\n\nChrist the lamb and the Lion.\n\nAs the truth sounded forth through the Apostles, and Their sound went out into all the earth, and their words to the ends of the world (Ps. 18:5); Christ our Passover has been sacrificed (Rom. 10:18). Concerning whom the Prophet had foretold: As a sheep he was led to the slaughter, and as a lamb before the one who shears it was silent without voice, so he did not open his mouth (Isa. 53:7). Who is this? Surely the one of whom it follows, and says: In his humiliation his judgment was taken away. Who shall declare his generation (Isa. ibid. 7). I see an example of such great humility in a King of such great power. For this one, as a lamb before its shearer not opening his mouth, is himself the Lion of the tribe of Judah (Rev. 5:5). Who is this lamb and lion? He endured death as a lamb; he consumed it as a lion. Who is this lamb and lion? Gentle and strong, lovable and terrible, innocent and powerful, silent when judged, roaring when he will judge. Who is this lamb and lion? In his passion a lamb, in his resurrection a lion—or rather both in his passion a lamb and a lion, and in his resurrection a lamb and a lion? Let us see the lamb in the passion. It has just now been said. As a lamb before its shearer was silent without voice, so he did not open his mouth. Let us see the lion in the passion.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":23,"ref":"p23","source":"Jacob dixit: Ascendisti recumbens, dormisti sicut leo(Gen. xlix, 9). Agnum in resurrectione videamus. Apocalypsis, cum de gloria sempiterna virginum loqueretur: Sequuntur, inquit. Agnum, quocumque ierit (Apoc. xiv, 4). Leonem in resurrectione videamus. Eadem Apocalypsis dicit, quod supra jam posui. Vicit leo de tribu Juda aperire librum (Ibid. 5). Quare agnus in passione? Quia mortem sine iniquitate suscepit. Quare leo in passione? Quia mortem occisus occidit. Quare agnus in resurrectione? Quia sempiterna est illi innocentia. Quare leo in resurrectione? Quia sempiterna est illi potentia. Quis est iste agnus et leo? Quomodo quaeris, quisnam sit? Si autem, quid erat? In principio erat Verbum. Si, ubi erat? Et verbum erat apud Deum. Si, quale Verbum erat? Et Deus erat Verbum. » Si, quantae patientiae sit? Omnia per ipsum facta sunt. Si, et ipse quid factus est? Et Verbum caro factum est (Joan. i, 1, et 14). Si, quemadmodum vel de patre sine matre, vel de matre sine patre natus sit? Generationem ejus quis enarrabit? Ab altero genitus, gignenti, coaeternus. Verbum permanens caro fac(??) est. Omnium temporum creator, opportuno tempore creatus. Praeda mortis, praedator mortis. Deformis positione prae filiis hominum, infirmitatem sciens ferre, excelsus facere humilia, humilis excelsa. Deus homo, et homo Deus. Et primogenitus, et creator primogenitorum. Unicus, et frater cunctorum.","english":"Jacob said: You have gone up, you have lain down, you have slept like a lion (Gen 49:9). Let us see the Lamb in the resurrection. The Apocalypse, when it spoke of the eternal glory of virgins, says: They follow the Lamb wherever he goes (Rev 14:4). Let us see the Lion in the resurrection. The same Apocalypse says what I have already set down above: The Lion of the tribe of Judah has conquered, to open the book (Rev 5:5). Why the Lamb in the passion? Because he took up death without iniquity. Why the Lion in the passion? Because, being slain, he slew death. Why the Lamb in the resurrection? Because his innocence is eternal. Why the Lion in the resurrection? Because his power is eternal. Who is this Lamb and Lion? How do you ask who he is? But if you ask what he was: In the beginning was the Word. If you ask where he was: And the Word was with God. If you ask what kind of Word he was: And God was the Word. If you ask of what patience he is: All things were made through him. If you ask what he himself became: And the Word was made flesh (Jn 1:1, 14). If you ask how he was born either of the Father without a mother, or of the mother without a father: Who shall declare his generation? Begotten of the other, coeternal with the begetter. The Word abiding was made flesh. Creator of all times, created at the fitting time. Prey of death, plunderer of death. Deformed in appearance beyond the sons of men, knowing how to bear infirmity, exalted to do humble things, humble to do exalted things. God man, and man God. Both firstborn, and creator of the firstborn. Only-begotten, and brother of all.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":24,"ref":"p24","source":"De substantia patris natus, et particeps factus adoptatorum. Et Dominus omnium, et servus plurimorum. Hic est agnus. Qui tollit peccata mundi (Ibid. 29), hic est leo, qui vincit regna mundi. Quaerebam, quis est iste. Quaeramus, qui sunt, pro quibus mortuus est iste. Forte pro justis et sanctis? Non hoc dicit Apostolus, sed potius, quia Christus pro impiis mortuus est (Rom. v, 6). Non utique, ut impii permanerent, sed ut morte justi impius justificaretur, et effuso sanguine sine peccato peccati chirographum deleretur.\n\nSERMO V.\n\nIterum de Paschate.\n\nSYNOPSIS.\n\nI. Mors Christi Spes nostra. II. Mors Christi voluntaria. III. Quomodo Christus tristis in morte. IV. Necessitas Incarnationis, ut redimeremur. V. Redemptoris ad Redemptos Verba. VI. Quomodo intelligatur Christus pro nobis mortuus. VII. Errores Apollinaris et Arii refutantur. VIII. Adhortatio.","english":"Born of the substance of the Father, and made a partaker with the adopted. Both Lord of all and servant of many. This is the lamb who takes away the sins of the world (ibid. 29); this is the lion who conquers the kingdoms of the world. I was asking who this is. Let us ask who those are for whom this one died. Perhaps for the just and holy? The Apostle does not say this, but rather that Christ died for the ungodly (Rom 5:6). Not, of course, so that the ungodly might remain so, but so that by the death of the just one the ungodly might be justified, and by the shedding of sinless blood the handwriting of sin might be blotted out.\n\nSermon V.\n\nAgain on the Pasch.\n\nSynopsis.\n\nI. The death of Christ, our hope. II. The death of Christ is voluntary. III. How Christ was sorrowful in death. IV. The necessity of the Incarnation, that we might be redeemed. V. The words of the Redeemer to the redeemed. VI. How it is understood that Christ died for us. VII. The errors of Apollinaris and Arius are refuted. VIII. Exhortation.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":25,"ref":"p25","source":"Audivimus Evangelium. Lecta est Resurrectio Domini nostri Jesu Christi. Resurrexit Christus, ergo mortuus est Christus. Resurrectio testis est mortis; mors autem Christi peremptio timoris. Non timeamus mori. Mortuus est Christus pro nobis. Cum spe vitae aeternae moriamur. Resurrexit Christus, ut resurgamus. Habemus in morte et resurrectione ejus opus indictum, praemium promissum. Opus indictum passio, praemium promissum resurrectio. Opus hoc Martyres impleverunt; non impleamus pietate, si non possumus passione. Non enim omnibus contingit pati pro Christo, et mori pro Christo. Tamen ipsum mori omnibus contingit. Felices, quibus pro Christo factum est, quod necesse erat, ut fieret(??) Necessitas enim erat mori, sed non erat necessitas pro Christo mori. Omnibus ventura est mors, sed non omnibus pro Christo mors. Quibus contigit pro Christo mori, quodam modo illud, quod eis erogatum fuerat, reddiderunt. Erogaverat eis Dominus, ut moreretur pro illis; reddiderunt illi moriendo pro illo. Sed unde redderet miser egenus, si non dedisset felix Dominus? Itaque quod erogaverat Martyribus Christus, dedit eis. unde redderent Christo. Vox enim Martyrum est: Nisi quia Dominus erat in nobis, fortasse vivos absorbuissent nos (Psal. cxxiii, 1, 2). Persecutores, inquit, Fortasse vivos absorbuissent nos. Quid est, Vivos?","english":"We have heard the Gospel. The Resurrection of our Lord Jesus Christ has been read. Christ has risen; therefore Christ died. The Resurrection is a witness to death; but the death of Christ is the destruction of fear. Let us not fear to die. Christ died for us. Let us die with the hope of eternal life. Christ has risen, that we may rise again. In his death and resurrection we have a work enjoined and a reward promised. The work enjoined is his Passion; the reward promised is his Resurrection. This work the Martyrs fulfilled; let us fulfill it by devotion, if we cannot by suffering. For it is not granted to all to suffer for Christ and to die for Christ. Yet to die itself is granted to all. Happy are those for whom what was necessary to happen was done for Christ. For it was necessary to die, but it was not necessary to die for Christ. Death is to come to all, but death for Christ is not for all. Those to whom it was granted to die for Christ in a certain manner returned what had been bestowed upon them. The Lord had bestowed upon them that he should die for them; they returned it to him by dying for him. But how could the poor and needy return it, if the blessed Lord had not given it? Therefore what Christ had bestowed upon the Martyrs, he gave them, that they might return it to Christ. For the voice of the Martyrs is: Unless the Lord had been in us, perhaps they would have swallowed us up alive (Ps. 123:1-2). The persecutors, he says, perhaps would have swallowed us up alive. What is this, \"alive\"?","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":26,"ref":"p26","source":"Scientes, quia male faceremus, si Christum negaremus, tamen tam magnum malum Vivi, id est, scientes faceremus, et sic Absorbuissent nos vivos, non mortuos. Quid est. Vivos? Scientes, non nescientes. Et qua virtute non fecerunt, quod a persecutoribus facere cogebantur? Ipsi interrogentur, ipsi dicant. Ecce respondent: Nisi quia dominus erat in nobis. Ergo ipse dedit, quod ei redderetur. Gratias illi. Dives est. Et quod de illo scriptum est: Pauper factus est, ut nos divites faceret (2 Cor. viii, 9), paupertate ejus ditati, vulneribus ejus sanati, humilitate ejus exaltati, morte ejus vivificati.\n\nDicebat Martyr: Quid retribuam Domino pro omnibus, quae retribuit mihi (Psal. cxv, 12)? Audite, quod sequitur. Attendit enim? et quaesivit, quid retri(??) bueret Domino. Et quid ait? Calicem salutaris accipiam (Ibid. 13). Hoc retribuam Domino: Calicem salutaris, calicem martyrii, calicem passionis, calicem Christi. Hoc est: Calicem salutaris, quia salutare nostrum Christus. Ergo, inquit, accipiam calicem ejus, et retribuam illi. De ipso calice dixit et ipse Patri ante passionem: Pater, si fieri potest, transeat a me calix iste (Matth. xxvi, 39). Pati venerat, mori venerat, in potestate habebat mortem, aut, si mentior, ipsum audite. Potestatem, inquit, habeo ponendi animam meam, et potestatem habeo iterum sumendi eam. Nemo tollit eam a me, sed ego pono eam a me, et iterum sumo eam (Joan.","english":"Knowing that we would be doing evil if we denied Christ, yet we would be doing so great an evil while alive—that is, knowingly—and thus they would have swallowed us alive, not dead. What does \"alive\" mean? Knowing, not ignorant. And by what power did they not do what they were being compelled by persecutors to do? Let them be asked, let them say. Behold, they answer: Unless the Lord had been in us. Therefore he himself gave what was to be rendered back to him. Thanks be to him. He is rich. And what was written of him: He became poor, that he might make us rich (2 Cor. 8:9)—made rich by his poverty, healed by his wounds, exalted by his humility, given life by his death.\n\nThe Martyr was saying: What shall I render to the Lord for all that he has rendered to me (Ps. 115:12)? Hear what follows. For he paid attention and sought what he might render to the Lord. And what does he say? I will take up the cup of salvation (Ibid. 13). This I will render to the Lord: the cup of salvation, the cup of martyrdom, the cup of suffering, the cup of Christ. That is: the cup of salvation, because our salvation is Christ. Therefore, he says, I will take up his cup, and I will render it to him. Of this very cup he also said to the Father before his passion: Father, if it can be done, let this cup pass from me (Matt. 26:39). He had come to suffer, he had come to die; he had death in his power—or, if I lie, hear him yourself. He says: I have power to lay down my life, and I have power to take it up again. No one takes it from me, but I lay it down of myself, and I take it up again (John","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":27,"ref":"p27","source":"x, 18). Audistis potestatem? Nemo tollit, Sine causa gloriantur Judaei. Peccatum inde habent, non potentiam. Christus, quia voluit, mortuus est. Ipse dicit in Psalmo: Ego dormivi, et somnum coepi (Psal. iii, 6). Clamaverunt: Crucifige, crucifige (Luc. xxiii. 21; et Joan. xix, 6) tenuerunt, suspenderunt. Sic illi juvant, quia aliquid potuerunt. Ego dormivi. Et quid postea? Et somnum coepi. Vere somnus erat triduans. Quid ergo postea? Et resurrexi, quoniam Dominus suscepit me. Secundum formam servi loquitur: Dominus suscepit me (Psal. iii, 6). Sicut et alio loco: Numquid qui dormit, non adjiciet, ut resurgat (Id. xi. 9)? Gloriantur Judaei, quasi vicerint me. Numquid qui dormit, non adjiciet, ut resurgat? Illi, ut occiderent, suspenderunt, sed Ego dormivi, quia quando volui, animam posui, et quando volui, surrexi.\n\nErgo ipse est calix, quem volebat transire, ad quem bibendum venerat. Quid est ergo, Domine, quod dixisti: Pater, si fieri potest, transeat a me calix iste. Dixisti discipulis passurus et moriturus: Tristis est anima mea usque ad mortem (Matth. xxvi, 38). Quaero ergo in his verbis verba illa tua: Potestatem habeo ponendi animam meam, et potestatem habeo iterum sumendi eam. Unde audio: Tristis est anima mea usque ad mortem. Nemo tollit eam. Quare tristis est? Potestatem habes ponendi animam tuam. Quare dicis: Pater, si fieri potest, transeat a me calix iste.","english":"You have heard the power. No one takes it; the Jews boast without cause. From this they have sin, not power. Christ died because he willed it. He himself says in the Psalm: I slept, and I began to sleep. They cried out: Crucify, crucify; they seized him, they hung him up. Thus they rejoice, because they were able to do something. I slept. And what afterward? And I began to sleep. Truly it was a sleep of three days. What then afterward? And I rose again, because the Lord received me. He speaks according to the form of a servant: The Lord received me. As also in another place: Will not he who sleeps add, that he may rise again? The Jews boast as though they had conquered me. Will not he who sleeps add, that he may rise again? They hung him up to kill him, but I slept, because when I willed, I laid down my soul, and when I willed, I rose again.\n\nTherefore he himself is the cup which he wished to pass, which he had come to drink. What is it, then, Lord, that you said: Father, if it can be done, let this cup pass from me. You said to your disciples, about to suffer and die: My soul is sorrowful even unto death. I ask, then, in these words of yours, for those words of yours: I have power to lay down my soul, and I have power to take it up again. Whence do I hear: My soul is sorrowful even unto death. No one takes it. Why is it sorrowful? You have power to lay down your soul. Why do you say: Father, if it can be done, let this cup pass from me.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":28,"ref":"p28","source":"Respondet interroganti et dicit tibi: Homo, in carne mea te suscepi. Numquid ergo, si in carne mea te suscepi, in voce mea non te suscepi? Quando dico: Potestatem habeo ponendi animam meam, et potestatem habeo iterum sumendi eam, sicut factor, me loquor. Quando dico: Tristis est anima mea usque ad mortem, sicut factura, te loquor. Gaude de me in me, agnosce te in me. Quando dico: Potestatem habeo ponendi animam meam,·adjutorium tuum sum. Quando dico: Tristis est anima mea usque ad mortem, speculum tuum sum.\n\nNon legistis, quia mortuus est? Numquid negamus? Si negaverimus mortem, negamus et resurrectionem. Inde mortuus est, unde homo esse dignatus est. Inde resurrexit, unde homo esse dignatus est, quia et nos homines et morituri sumus, et resurrecturi sumus. Numquid Verbum in illo mortuum est? Numquid pati aliquid potuit, quod In principio erat Verbum, et Verbum erat apud Deum, et Deus erat Verbum (Joan. 1, 2.)? Quid potest pati tale Verbum? Et oportebat tamen, ut moreretur pro nobis Verbum, et mori non poterat, et, ut moreretur, oportebat. In principio erat Verbum. et Verbum eun apud Deum, et Deus erat Verbum. Ubi sanguis? Ubi mors? Numquid mors in Verbo? Numquid sanguis in Verbo? Si nec mors in Verbo, nec sanguis in Verbo, ubi pretium nostrum? Annon pretium nostrum sanguis est ejus? Unde ergo daret hoc pretium, si maneret solum Verbum?","english":"He answers the one who questions him and says to you: Man, I have taken you up in my flesh. Therefore, if I have taken you up in my flesh, have I not taken you up in my voice? When I say: I have power to lay down my life, and I have power to take it up again, I speak as the Maker. When I say: My soul is sorrowful even unto death, I speak as the one to be made—I speak you. Rejoice over me in me, recognize yourself in me. When I say: I have power to lay down my life, I am your help. When I say: My soul is sorrowful even unto death, I am your mirror.\n\nHave you not read that he died? Do we deny it? If we deny the death, we deny the resurrection also. He died in that respect in which he deigned to be man. He rose again in that respect in which he deigned to be man, because we too are men and are both to die and to rise again. Was the Word in him dead? Could that suffer anything which was In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and God was the Word? What can such a Word suffer? And yet it was necessary that the Word die for us, and it could not die, and in order to die it was necessary. In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and God was the Word. Where is the blood? Where is the death? Is there death in the Word? Is there blood in the Word? If there is neither death in the Word nor blood in the Word, where is our price? Is not our price his blood? From where, then, would he give this price, if the Word alone remained?","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":29,"ref":"p29","source":"nisi carnem assumeret Verbum; carnem autem de anima humana viventem, ut, quoniam Verbum occidi non poterat, occideretur sola caro, quae de sua anima vivebat? Neque enim vel anima occidi poterat, quae anima Divinitati adhaerendo unus spiritus erat, ipso Domino duntaxat eam se induente, non ipsa in illo credente, sicut de nobis scriptum est: Qui adjungit se Domino, unus spiritus est (1. Cor. vi, 17). Nos enim, cum infideles essemus, indigni eramus, et a Deo alieni; credendo autem adhaesimus Deo. (??)a autem anima adhaesione Dei digna creata est, cum in personae divinae unitatem nova, rudisque assumpta est. Qua unitate hac singularitate duorum spirituum inaequalium discedente caro mortua est, quae de ipsa duorum spirituum unitate novo modo, novoque genere vivens, id est, geminam et admirabilem vitam habens, parvo tantummodo tempore derelicta est. Deus enim spiritus, et imago ejus, humanus spiritus immortales sunt.","english":"unless the Word assumed flesh; and flesh living from a human soul, so that, since the Word could not be killed, only the flesh might be killed, which lived from its own soul? For neither could the soul be killed, which soul, by cleaving to the Divinity, was one spirit, the Lord Himself at any rate putting it on, not it believing in Him, as it is written of us: He who cleaves to the Lord is one spirit (1 Cor 6:17). For we, when we were unbelievers, were unworthy and alien from God; but by believing we have cleaved to God. But that soul was created worthy by its adherence to God, when it was assumed into the unity of the divine person, new and unformed. By this unity, this singularity of two unequal spirits departing, the flesh died, which, living from that very unity of the two spirits in a new mode and a new kind—that is, having a twofold and admirable life—was abandoned for only a short time. For God is spirit, and His image, the human spirit, are immortal.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":30,"ref":"p30","source":"Sic ergo nos alloquitur quodam modo Dominus noster, Salvator noster dicens: O Homines! feci hominem rectum, et fecit se ipse perversum. A me recessistis, in vobis peristis. Ego autem quaesiturus sum, quod perierat. A me recessistis, inquit, vitam perdidistis. Et vita erat lux hominum (Joan. I, 4). Ecce quod reliquistis, quando in Adam omnes peristis Vita erat lux hominum. Quae vita? In principio erat Verbum, et Verbum erat apud Deum, et Deus erat Verbum (Ibid. 1) Vita erat, vos in morte vestra jacebatis. Verbum, unde morerer, non habebam; Homo, unde viveres, non habebas. (Quia dignatur Dominus Christus, suscepi verba ejus. Si ipse mea, quanto magis ego ejus). Quodam modo in silentio, rebus Ipsis loquens Dominus noster Christus dicit: Unde morerer, non habebam: Homo, unde viveres, non habebas. Assumpsi de te, unde morerer pro te. Assume de me, unde vivas mecum. Commercia celebremus. Do tibi, da mihi. Accipio a te mortem, accipe a me vitam. Expergiscere, vide quid dem, quid accipiam. Excelsus in coelo accepi a te super terram humilitatem. Dominus tuus accepi a te formam servi. Sanitas tua accepi a te vulnera. Vita tua accepi a te mortem. Verbum caro factum sum, ut mori possem. Carnem apud patrem non habebam, de massa tua sumpsi, unde tibi erogarem. (Virgo Maria de massa nostra erat; ibi assumpsit Christus carnem a nobis, id est, a genere humano).","english":"Thus, then, our Lord, our Savior, addresses us in a certain manner, saying: O men! I made man upright, and he made himself perverse. You withdrew from me, and you perished in yourselves. But I will seek what had perished. You withdrew from me, he says, and you lost life. And the life was the light of men (John 1:4). Behold what you abandoned when you all perished in Adam: the life was the light of men. What life? In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and God was the Word (ibid. 1). He was life; you lay in your death. As the Word, I had nothing by which I might die; as man, you had nothing by which you might live. (Because the Lord Christ deigns to do so, I have taken up his words. If he takes up mine, how much more do I take up his.) In a certain manner, in silence, speaking through the things themselves, our Lord Christ says: I had nothing by which I might die; O man, you had nothing by which you might live. I took from you that by which I might die for you. Take from me that by which you may live with me. Let us celebrate an exchange. I give to you; give to me. I receive death from you; receive life from me. Awake, see what I give and what I receive. Being exalted in heaven, I received from you humility on earth. I, your Lord, received from you the form of a servant. I, your health, received from you wounds. I, your life, received from you death. I, the Word, was made flesh, so that I might die. I did not have flesh with the Father; I took it from your mass, so that I might bestow it on you. (The Virgin Mary was from our mass; there Christ took flesh from us, that is, from the human race.)","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":31,"ref":"p31","source":"Accepi a te carnem, unde morerer pro te, accipe a me Spiritum vivificatorem, unde vivas mecum. Postremo mortuus sum de tuo, vive de meo.\n\nErgo, fratres, quando auditis: Natus est de Spiritu ex Virgine Maria, passus est, vapulavit, alapas accepit, quando auditis: Passus est haec Christus, nolite putare Verbum illud in principio apud Deum in sua natura, atque in sua substantia aliquid tale potuisse. Sed numquid possumus dicere, quia Verbum Dei, Deus unigenitus non est passus pro nobis? Passus est, sed secundum animam et carnem suam passibilem. Accepit enim formam servi, ut tanquam homo pateretur. Habebat enim et animam et carnem, quia totum hominem liberare venerat, non amittendo vitam, sed donando vitam. Ut autem similitudinem demus, unde celerius, quod dicimus, advertatis; sicut verbi gratia quando Stephanus martyr, et Phocas, vel aliquis alius passus est, et occisus, et sepultus, caro eorum sola occisa et sepulta est; animae autem eorum neque occidi, neque sepeliri potuere, et tamen rectissime dicimus: Mortuus est Stephanus, vel Phocas, vel quicumque alius pro nomine Christi, ita, quando passus, et occisus, et sepultus est Dei Unigenitus, caro utique ejus sola occisa et sepulta est; anima autem, et multo magis Divinitas ejus occidi non potuit, et ideo securi dicimus, mortuum pro nobis esse et sepultum unicum Dei Filium, id est, Deum Dei unigenitum.","english":"I received flesh from you, so that I might die for you; receive from me the life-giving Spirit, so that you may live with me. In the end, I died from what is yours; live from what is mine.\n\nTherefore, brothers, when you hear: He was born of the Spirit from the Virgin Mary, he suffered, he was scourged, he received blows; when you hear: Christ suffered these things, do not think that the Word, that which was in the beginning with God, could have suffered anything of this kind in its own nature and in its own substance. But can we say that the Word of God, the only-begotten God, did not suffer for us? He suffered, but according to his soul and his passible flesh. For he took the form of a servant, so that he might suffer as a man. For he had both a soul and flesh, because he came to set free the whole man, not by losing his life, but by giving his life. But so that we may give a comparison, from which you may more quickly grasp what we are saying—just as, for example, when the martyr Stephen, or Phocas, or some other suffered, and was killed, and was buried, only their flesh was killed and buried; but their souls could neither be killed nor buried, and yet we most rightly say: Stephen died, or Phocas, or whoever else, for the name of Christ—so, when the only-begotten of God suffered, and was killed, and was buried, only his flesh was certainly killed and buried; but his soul, and much more his Divinity, could not be killed, and therefore we say with confidence that the only Son of God, that is, the only-begotten God of God, died and was buried for us.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":32,"ref":"p32","source":"Unde utique veraciter, non mendaciter dixit ipse Christus Dominus, qui est sine mendacio veritas: Sic enim dilexit Deus mundum, ut Unigenitum suum daret, ut omnis, qui credit in illum, non pereat, sed habeat vitam aeternam (Joan. III, 16). Et Apostolus similiter de Deo Patre dicit: Qui Filio proprio non pepercit, sed pro nobis omnibus tradidit eum (Rom. viii, 32). Vultis autem noscere, quid est Christus? Nolite attendere carnem solam, quae jacuit in sepulcro, nolite attendere animam solam, de qua dixit: Tristis est anima mea usque ad mortem, nolite attendere Verbum solum, quia, Deus erat Verbum, sed attendite, quia Christus totus Verbum, et anima, et caro est.\n\nNihil autem animae Christi subtrahatis. Haeretici enim Apollinaristae dixerunt, quia mentem non habuit, id est, intelligentiam non habuit anima illa, sed Verbum illi pro mente, et pro intelligentia erat. Hoc ait Apollinaris. Ariani autem dicunt: Nec qualemcumque animam habuit. Vos ergo fideliter tenete, quia prorsus Verbum, et anima, et caro est totus Christus. Et quando auditis: Tristis est anima mea, animam humanam intelligite, non belluinam. Anima enim sine intellectu anima pecoris est, non anima humana. Si non venit liberare mentem, non habuit mentem. Ergo unus Christus, Verbum, et anima, et caro. Quid homo? Anima et caro. Quid Christus? Verbum et homo, ac per hoc, Verbum, et anima, et caro, Christus unus.","english":"Hence Christ the Lord, who is truth without falsehood, truly and not falsely said: For God so loved the world that he gave his only-begotten Son, so that everyone who believes in him may not perish but have eternal life (John 3:16). And the Apostle likewise says of God the Father: He who did not spare his own Son, but handed him over for us all (Rom 8:32). But do you wish to know what Christ is? Do not attend to the flesh alone, which lay in the tomb; do not attend to the soul alone, of which he said: My soul is sorrowful even unto death; do not attend to the Word alone, because the Word was God, but attend to this: that the whole Christ is Word, and soul, and flesh.\n\nBut do not subtract anything from the soul of Christ. For the Apollinarist heretics said that it did not have a mind, that is, that that soul did not have intelligence, but the Word was in place of a mind and intelligence for it. So said Apollinaris. The Arians, however, say: It did not have a soul of any kind. You, therefore, hold faithfully that the whole Christ is altogether Word, and soul, and flesh. And when you hear: My soul is sorrowful, understand a human soul, not a beast's. For a soul without intellect is the soul of a beast, not a human soul. If he did not come to free the mind, he did not have a mind. Therefore one Christ: Word, and soul, and flesh. What is a man? Soul and flesh. What is Christ? Word and man, and therefore Word, and soul, and flesh: one Christ.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":33,"ref":"p33","source":"Hominem quando caedis pugnis, quid ejus percutis? Animam, an carnem? Confiteris, quia carnem. Et tamen clamat anima: quid me percutis, quid me caedis? Numquid, si dicas animae: Quis te tetigit? Ego carnem ferio, non te; nonne, quicumque te audierint haec dicentem, irridebunt, et insipientem vel insanum te judicabunt? Sic ergo, qui carnem Verbi Dei flagellaverunt, vel alapis caeciderunt, non possunt dicere: nos carnem flagellavimus, vel exalapavimus, non Verbum, vel animam Christi. Totum enim Christum, id est, Verbum, et animam, et carnem flagellaverunt, vel alapis caeciderunt. Et cum utique neque animam, neque ipsam Divinitatem ejus, quae vera vita est, in cruce occidere potuerunt, totum tamen Christum in corde suo, et in mala voluntate sua inficere delectati sunt. Quicumque enim persequitur aliquem, ut eum occidat, sic eum vult extingui totum, sicut extinguitur totum lumen lucernae in terram collisae, ut penitus non luceat, cum eam sibi quisque malefactor viderit impedire. Quod in homine fieri nullo modo potest, id est, ut totus extinguatur, qui unam utique substantiam habet mortalem, alteram immortalem. Nulla enim in illo mortalis est, nisi caro.","english":"When you strike a man with your fists, what part of him are you hitting? The soul, or the flesh? You admit it is the flesh. And yet the soul cries out: Why do you strike me, why do you beat me? If you were to say to the soul, Who touched you? I am striking the flesh, not you—will not everyone who hears you say this mock you and judge you foolish or insane? So then, those who scourged the flesh of the Word of God, or struck it with blows, cannot say: We scourged the flesh, or struck it with blows, not the Word, or the soul of Christ. For they scourged the whole Christ—that is, the Word, and the soul, and the flesh—or struck him with blows. And although they could certainly kill neither his soul nor his very Divinity, which is true life, on the cross, yet they took delight in defiling the whole Christ in their heart and in their evil will. For whoever persecutes someone in order to kill him wishes him to be extinguished wholly, just as a whole lamp's light is extinguished when it is dashed to the ground, so that it gives no light at all, since some evildoer has seen it standing in his way. But this can in no way be done in a man—that is, that he be wholly extinguished, since he has one substance that is mortal and another that is immortal. For nothing in him is mortal except the flesh.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":34,"ref":"p34","source":"Unigenitus autem Dei Christus multo magis totus extingui non potuit, cum eum se Judaei extinguere putaverunt, qui in tribus substantiis suis, id est, una, aeterna, atque divina, et in duabus temporalibus, id est, humanis unam solam habuit mortalem, id est, carnem suam. Animam autem et maxime Divinitatem suam sine dubio immortalem habuit. Et ideo sua parvi temporis morte nos de nostra morte aeterna redimere solus potuit, qui non tantummodo caro, et anima humana fuit, sed Deus et anima, et caro, unus Dei Unigenitus fuit. Qui enim Descendit usque in inferiores partes terrae, ipse est, et qui ascendit super omnes coelos (Ephes. iv, 10), quod homo solus facere non posset.\n\nSecuri ergo exultemus, et laetemur, charissimi fratres, quia ille nos sua morte redemit, qui etiam occisus de hostibus triumphavit. Occisus enim mortem occidit, et in aeternum nos de manu ejus liberavit, Ascendensque in altum captivam duxit captivitatem (Ibid.), atque hom(??)nibus misso Spiritu sancto dona sua dedit, qui etiam jacens in sepulcro credentem latronem in paradisum introducere potuit.","english":"But the only-begotten Christ of God could by no means be wholly extinguished, much less so, when the Jews thought they were extinguishing him—he who in his three substances, that is, the one eternal and divine, and the two temporal, that is, human, had only one that was mortal, namely his flesh. But his soul, and above all his divinity, he undoubtedly had as immortal. And therefore by his death, which lasted but a short time, he alone was able to redeem us from our eternal death—he who was not only flesh and a human soul, but God and soul and flesh, the one only-begotten of God. For he who descended into the lower parts of the earth is the same who also ascended above all the heavens, which a mere man could not do.\n\nTherefore let us exult securely and rejoice, most beloved brothers, because he has redeemed us by his death, who even when slain triumphed over his enemies. For being slain, he slew death, and forever freed us from its hand, and ascending on high he led captivity captive, and having sent the Holy Spirit to men, he gave his gifts—he who, even lying in the tomb, was able to bring the believing thief into paradise.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":35,"ref":"p35","source":"SERMO VI.\n\nItem de Sacramento altaris ad infantes.\n\nSYNOPSIS.\n\nI. Corpus dominicum et in altari est, et nos illud sumus. II. Eucharistia symbolum unitatis. III. Liturgiae eucharisticae expositio.\n\nHoc, quod videtis, charissimi, in mensa Domini, panis est, et vinum; sed iste panis, et hoc vinum accedente verbo fit corpus, et sanguis Verbi. Ille enim Dominus, qui In principio erat Verbum, et Verbum erat apud Deum, et Deus erat Verbum (Joan, i, 1), propter misericordiam suam, qua non contempsit, quod creavit ad imaginem suam. Verbum caro factum est, et habitavit in nobis (Ibid. 14), sicut scitis, quia et ipsum Verbum assumpsit hominem, id est, animam et carnem hominis, et homo factus est, manens Deus. Propter hoc, quia et passus est pro nobis, commendavit nobis in isto Sacramento corpus, et sanguinem suum, quod etiam fecit et nos ipsos. Nam et nos corpus ipsius facti sumus, et per misericordiam ipsius quod accipimus, nos sumus. Recordamini, quod fuit aliquando creatura ista in agro, quomodo eam terra peperit, pluvia nutrivit, ad spicam perduxit, deinde labor humanus ad aream comportavit, trituravit, ventilavit, recondidit, protulit, moluit, conspersit, coxit, et vix aliquando ad panem perduxit. Recordamini et vos. Non fuistis, et creati estis, ad aream dominicam comportati estis, laboribus boum, id est, annuntiantium Evangelium, triturati estis.","english":"SERMON VI.\n\nAgain, on the Sacrament of the altar, to infants.\n\nSYNOPSIS.\n\nI. The Lord's body is both on the altar, and we ourselves are it. II. The Eucharist is a symbol of unity. III. An exposition of the eucharistic liturgy.\n\nThis which you see, dearest ones, on the table of the Lord is bread and wine; but this bread and this wine, when the word comes to them, become the body and blood of the Word. For that Lord, who In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and God was the Word (John 1:1), out of his mercy, by which he did not despise what he created after his own image—The Word was made flesh, and dwelt among us (ibid. 14), as you know—because the Word himself also took up a man, that is, the soul and flesh of a man, and became a man, remaining God. For this reason, because he also suffered for us, he commended to us in this Sacrament his body and his blood, which he also made us ourselves. For we too have been made his body, and through his mercy we are what we receive. Remember what that creature once was in the field, how the earth brought it forth, the rain nourished it, brought it to the ear, and then human labor carried it to the threshing floor, threshed it, winnowed it, stored it, brought it out, ground it, mixed it, baked it, and at last with difficulty brought it to bread. Remember yourselves as well. You were not, and you were created, you were carried to the Lord's threshing floor, you were threshed by the labors of oxen, that is, of those who proclaim the Gospel.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":36,"ref":"p36","source":"Quando Catechumeni differebamini, in horreo servabamini. Nomina vestra dedistis, coepistis moli jejuniis, exorcismis. Postea ad aquam venistis, et conspersi estis, et unum facti estis. Accedente fervore Spiritus sancti cocti estis, et panis dominicus facti estis.\n\nEcce, quod accepistis. Quomodo ergo unum videtis esse, quod factum est, sic unum estote et vos, diligendo vos, tenendo unam fidem, unam spem, individuam charitatem. Haeretici quando hoc accipiunt, testimonium contra se accipiunt quia illi quaerunt divisionem, cum panis iste indicet unitatem. Sic et vinum in multis acinis fuit, et modo in unum est. Unum est in suavitate calicis, sed post pressuram torcularis. Et vos post illa jejunia, post labores, post humilitatem, et contritionem jam in nomine Christi tanquam ad calicem Domini venistis, et ibi vos estis ad mensam, ibi vos estis in calice. Nobiscum hoc estis; simul enim hoc sumus, simul bibimus, quia simul vivimus. Audituri estis, quod etiam hesterno die audistis, sed hodie vobis exponitur, quod audistis, et quod respondistis, aut forte, cum responderetur, tacuistis, sed, quid respondendum esset, hodie didicistis.","english":"When you were catechumens, you were being kept back, stored in the granary. You gave in your names, you began to be ground by fastings and exorcisms. Afterwards you came to the water, and you were sprinkled, and you were made one. With the heat of the Holy Spirit coming upon you, you were baked, and you were made the Lord's bread.\n\nBehold what you have received. Therefore, just as you see that what has been made is one, so be one yourselves also, by loving one another, by holding one faith, one hope, an undivided charity. When heretics receive this, they receive a testimony against themselves, because they seek division, whereas this bread indicates unity. So too the wine was in many grapes, and now it is in one. It is one in the sweetness of the cup, but only after the pressure of the winepress. And you, after those fastings, after labors, after humility and contrition, have now come in the name of Christ as it were to the Lord's cup, and there you are at the table, there you are in the cup. You are this with us; for together we are this, together we drink, because together we live. You are about to hear what you also heard yesterday, but today what you heard is being expounded to you, and what you answered—or perhaps, when the answer was being given, you kept silent—but what ought to have been answered, you have learned today.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":37,"ref":"p37","source":"Post salutationem, quam nostis, id est: Dominus vobiscum, audistis: Sursum cor. Tota vita Christianorum verorum sursum cor, non Christianorum nomine solo, sed Christianorum re ipsa, et veritate tota vita sursum cor. Quid est Sursum cor? Spes in Deo, non in te. Tu enim deorsum. Deus sursum est. Si spem habes in te, cor deorsum est, non est sursum. Ideo, cum audieritis a Sacerdote: Sursum cor! respondetis: Habemus ad Dominum. Laborate, ut verum respondeatis. Quia apud acta Dei respondetis, sic sit, quomodo dicitis. Non lingua sonet, et conscientia neget, et, quia hoc ipsum, ut sursum habeatis cor, Deus vobis donat, non vires vestrae, ideo sequitur, cum dixeritis, habere vos sursum cor ad Dominum, sequitur Sacerdos et dicit: Domino Deo nostro gratias agamus. Unde gratias agamus? Quia sursum cor habemus, et nisi ille illud levasset, in terra jaceremus. Et inde jam, quae aguntur in precibus sanctis, quas audituri estis, ut accedente verbo fiat corpus et sanguis Christi. Nam tolle verbum, panis est, et vinum. Adde verbum, et jam aliud est. Et ipsum aliud quid est? Corpus Christi et sanguis Christi. Tolle ergo verbum, panis est, et vinum. Adde verbum, et fiet Sacramentum. Ad hoc dicitis: Amen. Amen dicere subscribere est. Amen latine interpretatur Verum. Deinde dicitur dominica Oratio, quam jam accepistis, et reddidistis. Quare ante dicitur, quam accipiatur Corpus et Sanguis Christi?","english":"After the greeting, which you know, that is: The Lord be with you, you have heard: Lift up your heart. The whole life of true Christians is \"lift up your heart\"—not of those who are Christians in name only, but of Christians in reality and truth: their whole life is \"lift up your heart.\" What is \"Lift up your heart\"? Your hope in God, not in yourself. For you are below; God is above. If you place your hope in yourself, your heart is below, it is not lifted up. Therefore, when you hear from the priest: Lift up your heart! you answer: We have it to the Lord. Strive to answer truly. For you are answering in the deeds of God; let it be as you say. Let not the tongue sound it while the conscience denies it. And because it is God who grants you this very thing—that you have your heart lifted up—and not your own strength, therefore it follows, when you have said that you have your heart lifted up to the Lord, the priest continues and says: Let us give thanks to the Lord our God. For what do we give thanks? Because we have our heart lifted up; and unless he had raised it, we would lie on the ground. And from there now come the things that are done in the holy prayers, which you are about to hear, so that by the coming of the word it may become the body and blood of Christ. For take away the word, and it is bread and wine. Add the word, and it is now something else. And what is that something else? The body of Christ and the blood of Christ. Take away the word, then, and it is bread and wine. Add the word, and it will become a sacrament. To this you say: Amen. To say Amen is to subscribe. Amen, in Latin, is interpreted as True. Then the Lord's Prayer is said, which you have already received and have rendered back. Why is it said before the body and blood of Christ are received?","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":38,"ref":"p38","source":"Quia, sicut est humana fragilitas, si forte aliquid, quod non decebat, cogitatio nostra concepit; si aliquid lingua, quod non oportebat, effudit; si aliquid oculus, quod non decebat, aspexit; si aliquid auris blandius, quod non oportebat, audivit; si forte aliqua talia contracta sunt de hujus mundi tentatione, et vitae humanae fragilitate, tergitur dominica Oratione, ubi dicitur: Dimitte nobis debita nostra (Matth. vi, 12); ut securi accedamus, ne, quod accipimus, in judicium nobis manducemus, et bibamus. Post hoc dicitur; Pax vobiscum. Magnum sacramentum osculum pacis. Sic osculare, ut diligas. Ne sis Judas. Judas traditor Christum ore osculabatur, corde insidiabatur. Sed forte inimicum animum habet contra te aliquis, et non potes cum convincere, cogeris tolerare. Noli ei malum pro malo in corde tuo reddere. Ille odit, tu ama, et securus oscularis. Audistis pauca, sed magna. Non vilescant paucitate, sed chara sint pondere. Simul etiam onerandi non estis, ut ea, quae dicta sunt, teneatis.","english":"For, as human frailty is, if perhaps our thought has conceived something that was not fitting, if the tongue has poured out something that ought not to be, if the eye has looked upon something that was not fitting, if the ear has heard something too flattering that ought not to be, if perhaps such things have been contracted from the temptation of this world and the frailty of human life, it is wiped away by the Lord's Prayer, where it is said: Forgive us our debts (Matthew 6:12); so that we may come forward securely, lest what we receive we eat and drink to our judgment. After this it is said: Peace be with you. A great sacrament is the kiss of peace. Kiss in such a way that you love. Do not be a Judas. Judas the traitor kissed Christ with his mouth, plotted in his heart. But perhaps someone has a hostile mind against you, and you cannot convict him, and you are forced to tolerate him. Do not return evil for evil to him in your heart. He hates; you love, and you kiss securely. You have heard few things, but great things. Let them not become cheap through their fewness, but let them be dear through their weight. At the same time, you are not to be burdened further, so that you may hold fast to what has been said.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":39,"ref":"p39","source":"SERMO VII.\n\nDe Paschale.\n\nSYNOPSIS.\n\nI. Quis agat Pascha, et quomodo agendum II. Alleluia divitum, pauperum, afflictorum. III. Deus agit, ut Pater; Diabolus, ut Mango.\n\nDies Paschae nos celebrare omnibus notum est, quibus diebus Alleluia cantamus. Quapropter, fratres, sollicite attendendum est, ut, quod visibiliter celebramus, in animo teneamus. Pascha enim nos celebrare dicimus. Pascha hebraeus sermo est, quod interpretatur Transitus; graece autem Paschin pati, latine Pascha pascere, ut dici solet: Pascam amicos. Pascha qui celebrant, nisi qui a morte peccatorum suorum transeunt ad vitam justorum? Sicut Apostolus dicit: Transivimus de morte ad vitam, quia diligimus fratres (I Joan. iii, 14). Pascha quis agit, nisi qui credit Christo passo in terra, ut cum illo regnet in coelo? Pascha quis agit, nisi qui pascit in pauperibus Christum? Ipse enim de pauperibus ait: Quicumque uni ex minimis meis aliquid boni fecerit, mihi fecit (Matth. xxv, 40). Christus sedet in coelo, et indiget in terra. Patrem interpellat pro nobis, et hic panem petit a nobis. Ergo, Domini fratres, si volumus agere Pascha salubriter, transeamus, patiamur, pascamus Transeamus a peccatis ad justitiam, patiamur pro Christo, pascamus in pauperibus Christum. Convivia honeste celebremus, ut cum Abraham in regno Dei coelesti convivio perfruamur. Cantemus ergo Deo alleluia, quod latine sonat: Laudemus eum, qui est.","english":"SERMON VII.\n\nOn the Pasch.\n\nSYNOPSIS.\n\nI. Who should celebrate the Pasch, and how it should be celebrated. II. The Alleluia of the rich, of the poor, of the afflicted. III. God acts as Father; the Devil as a Deceiver.\n\nIt is known to all of us, on the days when we sing Alleluia, that we are celebrating the days of the Pasch. Wherefore, brothers, careful attention must be paid, so that what we celebrate visibly, we may hold in our mind. For we say that we are celebrating the Pasch. Pasch is a Hebrew word, which is interpreted as Passing Over; in Greek, however, Paschin means to suffer, in Latin Pascha means to feed, as it is commonly said: I shall feed my friends. Who celebrate the Pasch, except those who pass over from the death of their sins to the life of the righteous? As the Apostle says: We have passed from death to life, because we love the brothers (1 John 3:14). Who celebrates the Pasch, except the one who believes in Christ who suffered on earth, so that he may reign with him in heaven? Who celebrates the Pasch, except the one who feeds Christ in the poor? For he himself says concerning the poor: Whoever has done something good to one of my least ones, has done it to me (Matthew 25:40). Christ sits in heaven, and is in need on earth. He intercedes with the Father for us, and here he asks bread from us. Therefore, brothers of the Lord, if we wish to celebrate the Pasch profitably, let us pass over, let us suffer, let us feed. Let us pass over from sins to righteousness, let us suffer for Christ, let us feed Christ in the poor. Let us celebrate our banquets honorably, so that with Abraham we may enjoy the heavenly banquet in the kingdom of God. Let us therefore sing Alleluia to God, which in Latin sounds: Let us praise him who is.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":40,"ref":"p40","source":"Laudemus eum et in prosperis, et in adversis, in prosperitatibus divitiarum non extollamur, et in flagello damnorum non infirmemur. Dicamus alleluia cum Job, qui dixit: Dominus dedit, Dominus abstulit. Sicut Domino placuit, sic et factum est. Sit nomen Domini benedictum (Job i, 21). Benedicamus ergo Dominum in omni tempore. Semper alleluia cantamus, si ad sonum linguae nostrae moventur ad operationem justitiae membra nostra, si hoc, quod sonat in ore cantantis, lucet in moribus viventis.\n\nAudite, quomodo cantare jussi sunt alleluia divites et pauperes. Praecipe, ait Apostolus, divitibus hujus saeculi, non superbe sapere, neque sperare in incerto divitiarum, sed in Deo vivo, qui dat nobis omnia abundanter ad fruendum. Divites sint in operibus bonis, facile tribuant, communicent, thesaurizent sibi in futurum, ut apprehendant veram vitam (1 Tim. vi, 17, 18). Quod pauperes cantent, Tebias docet: Fili, ne timeas, quoniam pauperem vitam gerimus. Exuberabunt tibi multa bona, si timueris Dominum Deum tuum, et, quae placent in conspectu ejus, feceris (Tob. iv, 3), Dilectissima membra Corporis Christi, expectemus Caput nostrum venturum de coelo, cui cohaerentes immobiles permanebimus, ut, cujus passionem celebramus in terra, cum ipso regnemus in coelo. Disciplinam ejus sustineamus, ut corrigamur, quia, sicut filios, ita nos aggreditur Deus.","english":"Let us praise him both in prosperity and in adversity; in the prosperity of riches let us not be puffed up, and under the scourge of losses let us not grow weak. Let us say Alleluia with Job, who said: The Lord gave, the Lord has taken away. As it pleased the Lord, so it has been done. Blessed be the name of the Lord (Job 1:21). Let us therefore bless the Lord at all times. Let us always sing Alleluia, if at the sound of our tongue our members are moved to the doing of justice, if what sounds in the mouth of the one singing shines forth in the conduct of the one living.\n\nHear how the rich and the poor are bidden to sing Alleluia. Command, says the Apostle, the rich of this world not to be high-minded, nor to hope in the uncertainty of riches, but in the living God, who gives us all things abundantly to enjoy. Let them be rich in good works, give readily, share, lay up treasure for themselves for the future, that they may lay hold of true life (1 Tim. 6:17-18). That the poor should sing, Tobit teaches: Son, do not fear, for we lead a poor life. Many good things will abound for you, if you fear the Lord your God and do what is pleasing in his sight (Tob. 4:3). Most beloved members of the Body of Christ, let us await our Head, who is to come from heaven, to whom cleaving we shall remain immovable, so that, whose passion we celebrate on earth, we may reign with him in heaven. Let us endure his discipline, that we may be corrected, for God deals with us as with sons.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":41,"ref":"p41","source":"Quis est enim, ait Apostolus, cui non det disciplinam pater ejus (Hebr. xii, 7). Si separatis vos a disciplina Dei, ergo nothi, et non filii estis. Toleremus flagellum patris, ne incurramus severitatem judicis.\n\nDeus et diabolus pater et mango Deus u(??), pater, flagellat, et corrigit, et assumit; mango blanditur, seducit, et Vendit. Pater fert flagellum, et mango fert saccellum. Si concurreris sub alas flagellantis, liberaberis ab iniquitate vendentis. Vide, a quo, ubi reponaris, in regno coelorum, an in saccello gehennarum. Si regnum Dei concupiscis, in solutione libertatis laetaberis; si vero saccellum, colligationem servitutis accipies, et ligatus manibus pedibusque dicetur de te: Tollite et millite illum in tenebras exteriores. Ibi erit fletus et stridor dentium (Matth. xxii, 13) Clamatur ad nos fortiter. Qui habet aures audiendi, audiat, quid Spiritus dicat ecclesiis (Apoc. iii, 22).","english":"For, says the Apostle, what son is there whom his father does not discipline? If you separate yourselves from God's discipline, then you are not true sons but bastards. Let us endure the father's scourge, lest we fall under the judge's severity.\n\nGod and the devil are both fathers, but God is a father and the devil a peddler. God scourges, corrects, and takes us up; the peddler flatters, seduces, and sells. The father bears the scourge, and the peddler bears the purse. If you run beneath the wings of the one who scourges, you will be freed from the one who sells. See from whom, and where, you are to be stored away—in the kingdom of heaven, or in the purse of hells. If you desire the kingdom of God, you will rejoice in the release of freedom; but if you desire the purse, you will receive the binding of slavery, and, bound hand and foot, it will be said of you: Take him and cast him into the outer darkness. There will be weeping and gnashing of teeth. It is cried out to us mightily. Let anyone who has ears to hear hear what the Spirit says to the churches.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":42,"ref":"p42","source":"SERMO VIII.\n\nIn octava Paschalis ad infantes.\n\nSYNOPSIS.\n\nI. Vis, et effectus Baptismi, et Spes in eo reposita.\n\nII. Baptismus extra unitatem Ecclesiae? non prodest.\n\nIII. Contra Schismaticos Baptismo gloriantes.\n\nIV. Cohortatio ad recens baptizatos.\n\nSermo mihi est ad vos, modo nati Infantes, parvuli in Christo, nova proles Ecclesiae, gratia Patris, foecunditas Matris, germen pium, examen novellum, flos nostri honoris, et fructus laboris, gaudium et corona mea, omnes, qui statis in Domino, Apostolicis verbis vos alloquor. Ecce nox praecessit; dies autem appropinquavit. Abjicite opera tenebrarum, et induite vos arma lucis. Sicut in die, honeste ambulate. Non in comessationibus et ebrietatibus, non in cubilibus et impudicitiis, non in contentione et aemulatione, sed induite Dominum Jesum Christum, et carnis providentiam ne feceritis in concupiscentiis (Rom xiii, 12-14), ut et vitam induatis, quam Sacramento induistis,. Quotquot enim in Christo baptizati estis, Christum induistis. Non est Judaeus, et Graecus; non est servus, neque liber; non est masculus, aut femina; omnes enim vos unum estis in Christo Jesu (Gelat. iii, 27, 28). Hoc habet ipsa vis Sacramenti. Sacramentum enim est vitae novae, quae in hoc tempore incipit a remissione praeteritorum omnium peccatorum, perficietur autem in resurrectione mortuorum.","english":"SERMON VIII.\n\nOn the Octave of Easter, to the infants.\n\nSYNOPSIS.\n\nI. The power and effect of Baptism, and the hope placed in it.\n\nII. Baptism outside the unity of the Church? It does not profit.\n\nIII. Against the schismatics who glory in Baptism.\n\nIV. An exhortation to the newly baptized.\n\nMy sermon is addressed to you, infants just now born, little ones in Christ, a new offspring of the Church, the fruitfulness of the Father, the fertility of the Mother, a pious shoot, a new swarm, the flower of our honor and the fruit of our labor, my joy and my crown—all you who stand in the Lord, I address you with the Apostle's words. Behold, the night has passed; the day has drawn near. Cast off the works of darkness, and put on the armor of light. Walk honestly, as in the day. Not in reveling and drunkenness, not in chambering and impurity, not in strife and jealousy, but put on the Lord Jesus Christ, and make no provision for the flesh in its desires (Rom 13:12-14), so that you may also put on the life that you have put on in the Sacrament. For as many of you as have been baptized in Christ have put on Christ. There is no Jew and Greek; there is no slave or free; there is no male or female; for you are all one in Christ Jesus (Gal 3:27-28). This is what the very power of the Sacrament holds. For it is the Sacrament of a new life, which in this present time begins with the remission of all past sins, but will be perfected in the resurrection of the dead.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":43,"ref":"p43","source":"Consepulti enim estis Christo per baptismum in morte, ut, quomodo surrexit Christus a mortuis, sic et vos in novitate vitae ambuletis (Rom. vi. 4). Ambulatis autem nunc per fidem, quandiu in hoc mortali corpore peregrinamini a Domino, sed via vobis certa ipse, ad quem tenditis, factus est Christus Jesus secundum hominem, quod pro nobis fieri dignatus est. Servavit enim multam dulcedinem timentibus se, aperturus et perfecturus eam sperantibus in se, cum id, quod nunc in spe accepimus etiam in re acceperimus. Filii enim Dei sumus, et nondum apparuit, quod erimus. Scimus, quia, cum apparuerit, similes ei erimus, quoniam videbimus eum sicuti est (1 Joan. iii, 2). Hoc etiam in Evangelio ipse promisit. Qui diligit me, inquit, mandata mea custodit. Et qui diligit me, diligetur a Patre meo, et ego diligam illum, et ostendam me ipsum illi (Joan. xiv, 21). Utique videbant eum, quibus loquebatur, sed in forma servi, qua major est Pater, non in forma Dei, qua a qualis est Patri. Hanc ostendebat timentibus, illam servabat sperantibus. In hac peregrinantibus apparebat, ad illam cohabitaturos vocabat. Hanc eis ambulantibus substernebat, illam pervenientibus promittebat.","english":"For you were buried with Christ through baptism into death, so that, just as Christ rose from the dead, so you too might walk in newness of life (Rom. 6:4). But now you walk by faith, as long as in this mortal body you are away from the Lord, but the way for you has been made certain by Christ Jesus himself, to whom you are hastening, according to his humanity, which he deigned to become for our sake. For he has kept much sweetness for those who fear him, and he will reveal and perfect it for those who hope in him, when what we have now received in hope we shall also receive in reality. For we are children of God, and it has not yet appeared what we shall be. We know that when he appears we shall be like him, because we shall see him as he is (1 John 3:2). This too he himself promised in the Gospel. He who loves me, he says, keeps my commandments. And he who loves me will be loved by my Father, and I will love him and will show myself to him (John 14:21). Certainly those to whom he was speaking saw him, but in the form of a servant, in which the Father is greater, not in the form of God, in which he is equal to the Father. The former he was showing to those who fear him, the latter he was keeping for those who hope. In the former he appeared to those on pilgrimage, to the latter he was calling those who would dwell with him. The former he spread beneath them as they walked, the latter he promised to them when they arrived.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":44,"ref":"p44","source":"Has ergo promissiones habentes, charissimi, mundemus nos ab omni coinquinatione carnis, et spiritus perficientes sanctificationem in timore Dei (2 Cor. vii, 1). Obsecro vos, ut digne ambuletis vocatione, qua vocati estis, cum omni humilitate animi, et mansuetudine, sufferentes invicem in dilectione, studentes observare unitatem spiritus in vinculo pacis (Ephes. iv, 1-3). Qualis enim res est, unde tale pignus accepimus. Sed sunt quidam, qui Christum solo Sacramento induerunt, quo in fide vel moribus nudi sunt. Nam et multi haeretici ipsum habent Sacramentum baptismatis, sed non ipsum fructum salutis, nec vinculum pacis: Habentes, sicut ait Apostolus, formam pietatis, virtutem autem ejus negantes (2 Tim. iii, 5), vel signati a desertoribus, vel ipsi etiam desertores signum boni regis in damnabili carne portantes, qui nobis dicunt: Si fideles non sumus, baptismum nobis quare non datis? Si autem jam fideles sumus, quid nos quaeritis? Quasi non legant, Simonem magum et accepisse baptismum, et tamen a Petro audisse: Non est tibi pars neque sors in hac fide (Act. viii, 21). Ecce quia fieri potest, ut aliquis habeat baptismum Christi, et non habeat fidem, vel dilectionem Christi; habeat sanctitatis Sacramentum, nec computetur in sorte sanctorum. Neque interest, quantum ad ipsum solum pertinet Sacramentum, si ibi quisque accipiat baptismum Christi, ubi non est unitas Christi.","english":"Having therefore these promises, dearly beloved, let us cleanse ourselves from all defilement of flesh and spirit, perfecting sanctification in the fear of God (2 Cor. 7:1). I beseech you to walk worthily of the calling by which you were called, with all humility of mind and gentleness, bearing with one another in love, being careful to keep the unity of the Spirit in the bond of peace (Eph. 4:1-3). For what a thing it is, from which we have received such a pledge. But there are some who have put on Christ by the sacrament alone, while in faith or in morals they are naked. For many heretics also have the very sacrament of baptism, but not the very fruit of salvation, nor the bond of peace: having, as the Apostle says, the form of godliness but denying its power (2 Tim. 3:5), either marked by deserters, or themselves also deserters bearing the sign of the good King in their condemned flesh, who say to us: If we are not faithful, why do you not give us baptism? But if we are already faithful, why do you seek us? As if they did not read that Simon Magus both received baptism and yet heard from Peter: You have no part nor lot in this faith (Acts 8:21). Behold, because it can happen that someone has the baptism of Christ and does not have the faith or the love of Christ; he has the sacrament of holiness, yet is not counted in the lot of the saints. Nor does it matter, as far as the sacrament itself alone is concerned, whether anyone receives the baptism of Christ where the unity of Christ is not.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":45,"ref":"p45","source":"Nam et baptizatus in Ecclesia, si fuerit desertor Ecclesiae, sanctitate vitae carebit, Sacramenti signaculo non carebit. Nam utique exeuntem non potuisse amittere demonstratur, quod redeunti non redditur. Sicut desertor militiae caret legitima societate, non caret regio charactere. Qui, si et alterum eodem signo ipse signaverit, non faciet consortem vitae, sed comitem poenae. Si autem ad legitimam ordinatamque militiam et ille redeat, et ille veniat, placata regia severitate et illi ignoscitur, quod recessit, et ipse suscipitur, qui accessit. In ambobus (??)ulpa corrigitur, ambobus poena remittitur, ambobus pax datur, in nullo, quod signatum est, iteratur.\n\nJam ergo nobis non dicant: Quid nobis dabitis, si jam baptismum habemus? Sic enim nesciunt, quid loquantur, ut nec saltem legere velint, quod sancta Scriptura testatur, in ipsa intus Ecclesia, hoc est, in communione membrorum Christi, multos in Samaria baptizatos non accepisse Spiritum sanctum, sed in solo baptismo fuisse, donec ad eos de Jerusalem venirent Apostoli (Act. viii); contra autem Cornelium, et eos, qui cum illo erant, meruisse accipere Spiritum sanctum, antequam acciperent baptismi Sacramentum (Id. x). Ita Deus docuit, aliud esse signum salutis, aliud ipsam salutem, aliud formam pietatis, aliud virtutem pietatis. Quid nobis, inquiunt, dabitis, si jam baptismum habemus?","english":"For even one baptized in the Church, if he becomes a deserter of the Church, will lack holiness of life, but will not lack the seal of the Sacrament. For it is certainly shown that one departing could not have lost what is not given back to him on returning. Just as a deserter of military service lacks the lawful fellowship, but does not lack the royal mark. If he himself has also marked another with the same sign, he will not make him a sharer of life, but a companion of punishment. But if both that one returns to lawful and ordered service, and this one comes, with the royal severity appeased, both is he forgiven who departed, and he is received who approached. In both the fault is corrected, to both the punishment is remitted, to both peace is given, in no one is what has been signed repeated.\n\nNow therefore let them not say to us: What will you give us, if we already have baptism? For they do not know what they are saying, such that they do not even wish to read what the holy Scripture testifies, that within the Church itself, that is, in the communion of the members of Christ, many baptized in Samaria did not receive the Holy Spirit, but were in baptism alone, until the Apostles came to them from Jerusalem (Acts 8); on the other hand, that Cornelius and those who were with him merited to receive the Holy Spirit before they received the Sacrament of baptism (Ibid. 10). Thus God taught that one thing is the sign of salvation, another is salvation itself; one thing is the form of godliness, another the power of godliness. What, they say, will you give us, if we already have baptism?","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":46,"ref":"p46","source":"O sacrilegam vanitatem, ita nihil putare esse Christi Ecclesiam, quam non habent, ut nihil se accipere arbitrentur, si ejus communioni socientur! Dicat eis Amos propheta: Vae eis, qui nihil faciunt Sion (Amos vi, 1)! Quid accepturus sum, inquit, si jam baptismum habeo? Accepturus es Ecclesiam, quam non habes; accepturus es unitatem, quam non habes; accepturus es pacem, quam non habes. Aut si ista nihil tibi videntur, pugna, desertor, contra Imperatorem tuum dicentem: Qui mecum non colligit spargit (Luc. xi, 23). Pugna contra Apostolum ejus, imovero et ibi contra ipsum, qui per eum loquebatur, dicentem: Sustinentes invicem in dilectione, studentes servare unitatem spiritus in vinculo pacis (Ephes. iv, 3). Numera, quae dixit: Sustinentiam, dilectionem, unitatem, spiritum, pacem. Spiritus illic operator omnium, qui nominatus est, quem tu non habes. Numquid sustinuisti, qui de Ecclesia recessisti? Quem dilexisti, quando membra Christi deseruisti? Quae tibi est unitas in sacrilega praecisione? Quae pax in nefaria dissensione? Absit a nobis, ut nihil sint ista, sed nihil es tu ipse sine istis. Haec si accipere in Ecclesia contemnis, baptismum quidem potes habere, sed ad majus supplicium habes, quidquid non cum istis habes. Bapismus enim Christi, qui cum istis suffragator esset salutis tuae, sine istis testis est iniquitatis tuae.","english":"O sacrilegious vanity, to think that the Church of Christ is nothing, because they do not have it, so that they believe they receive nothing if they are joined to its communion! Let the prophet Amos say to them: Woe to those who make nothing of Zion (Amos 6:1)! \"What am I going to receive,\" he says, \"if I already have baptism?\" You are going to receive the Church, which you do not have; you are going to receive the unity, which you do not have; you are going to receive the peace, which you do not have. Or if these things seem as nothing to you, fight, deserter, against your Emperor who says: He who does not gather with me scatters (Luke 11:23). Fight against his Apostle—or rather, there too against himself, who was speaking through him—who says: Bearing with one another in love, being eager to preserve the unity of the Spirit in the bond of peace (Ephesians 4:3). Count what he said: forbearance, love, unity, spirit, peace. The Spirit is there, the worker of all things, who has been named, whom you do not have. Did you bear with others, you who have withdrawn from the Church? Whom did you love, when you deserted the members of Christ? What unity is there for you in sacrilegious cutting off? What peace in wicked dissension? Far be it from us that these things be nothing, but you yourself are nothing without them. If you disdain to receive these things in the Church, you can indeed have baptism, but you have it for a greater punishment, whatever you have without these things. For the baptism of Christ, which with these things would be a helper of your salvation, without these things is a witness of your iniquity.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":47,"ref":"p47","source":"Vos autem, filii sancti, membra catholica, baptismum non alium, sed aliud accepistis. Accepistis enim non ad poenam, sed ad vitam, non ad perniciem, sed ad salutem, non ad damnationem, sed ad honorem. Simul enim accepistis et unitatem spiritus in vinculo pacis, si tamen et vos, quod opto, quod spero, quod exhortor ac deprecor, et, quod accepistis, integrum custodiatis, et proficiendo ad majora veniatis. Hodie dies octavus est nativitatis vestrae. Hodie completur in vobis signaculum fidei, quod apud antiquos patres in circumcisione carnis fiebat octavo die carnalis nativitatis. Figurabatur enim expoliatio mortalitatis in eo membro humano, per quod moriturus nascitur homo. Unde et ipse Dominus mortalitate carnis resurgendo se expolians, et non quidem aliud, sed tamen ultra non moriturum corpus exsuscitans dominicum diem in sua resurrectione signavit, qui post diem passionis ejus tertius, in numero autem dierum post sabbatum octavus est, idemque primus. Unde et vos nondum re, sed certa jam spe, quia et hujus rei sacramentum habebitis, et pignus Spiritus accepistis, Si consurrexistis cum Christo, quae sursum sunt sapite, ubi Christus est in dextera Dei sedens, quae sursum sunt quaerite, non quae super terram. Mortui enim estis, et vita vestra abscondita est cum Christo in Deo. Cum Christus apparuerit vita vestra, tunc et vos apparebitis cum ipso in gloria (Coloss. iii, 1, 4).","english":"But you, holy children, catholic members, have received not another baptism, but a different one. For you have received it not unto punishment, but unto life; not unto destruction, but unto salvation; not unto damnation, but unto honor. For at the same time you have also received the unity of the Spirit in the bond of peace, if only you also—as I desire, as I hope, as I exhort and entreat—keep whole what you have received, and by advancing come to greater things. Today is the eighth day of your birth. Today is completed in you the seal of faith, which among the ancient fathers was wrought in the circumcision of the flesh on the eighth day of carnal birth. For the stripping away of mortality was prefigured in that human member through which man is born to die. Whence also the Lord himself, by rising again stripping himself of the mortality of the flesh, and raising up his own body—not indeed another, but one that would nevertheless die no more—marked the Lord's day in his resurrection, which is the third after the day of his passion, but in the number of days after the sabbath is the eighth, and the same is the first. Whence you also, not yet in reality but already in sure hope—since you will also have the sacrament of this thing, and have received the pledge of the Spirit—if you have risen with Christ, savor the things that are above, where Christ is seated at the right hand of God; seek the things that are above, not the things that are on the earth. For you have died, and your life is hidden with Christ in God. When Christ, your life, shall appear, then you also shall appear with him in glory.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":48,"ref":"p48","source":"SERMO IX.\n\nDe Psalmi cxvii. vers. I. Confitemini Domino, etc..\n\nSYNOPSIS.\n\nI. Quid sit confiteri Domino. II. Quomodo, et quare confitendum Bonitati divinae. III. Quantum differat Confessio facienda Homini Judici, et facienda Deo.\n\nIV. Exhortatio ad confitenda Deo peccata.\n\nConfitemini Domino quoniam bonus; quoniam in saeculum misericordia ejus (Psal. cxvii, 1). Quod nos voce Psalmi Spiritus sanctus hortatus est, cui ore uno, et corde uno respondebamus: Alleluia, quod latine interpretatur: Laudate Dominum, hoc vos et per nostram vocem idem Spiritus sanctus exhortatur. Confitemini, inquit, Domino, quoniam bonus est; quoniam in saeculum misericordia ejus. Sive dona illius laudando cantetis, sive peccata vestra gemendo fundatis, Confitemini Domino, quoniam bonus est; quoniam in saeculum misericordia ejus. Neque enim sola commemoratio peccatorum nostrorum, sed etiam Domini nostri laudatio confessio dicitur, quia et si unum horum faciamus, non sine altero facimus. Nam et iniquitatem nostram cum spe misericordiae ipsius accusamus, et ipsius misericordiam cum iniquitatis nostrae recordatione laudamus. Confiteamur ergo Domino, Quoniam bonus est, quoniam in saeculum misericordia ejus. Videtur nonnullis mala esse quaedam creatura, quia imperitorum sensus offendit, sed falsum est. Fecit enim Deus omnia bona valde, Quoniam bonus est.","english":"SERMON IX.\n\nOn Psalm 117 [118], verse 1: \"Give thanks to the Lord,\" etc.\n\nSYNOPSIS.\n\nI. What it means to give thanks to the Lord. II. How, and why, thanks must be given to the divine Goodness. III. How greatly the confession to be made to a human judge differs from that to be made to God.\n\nIV. An exhortation to confess sins to God.\n\n\"Give thanks to the Lord, for he is good; for his mercy endures forever\" (Ps. 117 [118]:1). What the Holy Spirit urged us to do through the voice of the Psalm, to which we were responding with one mouth and one heart—\"Alleluia,\" which in Latin is interpreted \"Praise the Lord\"—this same Holy Spirit exhorts you also through our voice. \"Give thanks,\" it says, \"to the Lord, for he is good; for his mercy endures forever.\" Whether you sing his gifts in praise, or pour out your sins in groaning, \"Give thanks to the Lord, for he is good; for his mercy endures forever.\" For not only the remembrance of our sins, but also the praise of our Lord, is called confession, because even if we do one of these, we do not do it without the other. For we both accuse our iniquity with hope in his mercy, and we praise his mercy together with the remembrance of our iniquity. Let us therefore give thanks to the Lord, \"for he is good, for his mercy endures forever.\" To some it seems that certain creatures are evil, because they offend the senses of the unlearned, but this is false. For God made all things very good, \"for he is good.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":49,"ref":"p49","source":"Videtur nonnullis injustus Deus, quia plerumque fideles ejus multa dura et aspera in hac temporali vita patiuntur; sed;, quibus hoc videtur, falluntur. Flagellat enim omnem filium, non quem rejicit, sed Quem recipit, quoniam in saeculun misericordia ejus (Hebr. xii, 6).\n\nConfiteamur ergo Domino, Quoniam bonus est, quoniam in saeculum misericordia ejus. Dicamus Domino Deo nostro: Admiranda sunt opera tua; omnia enim in sapientia fecisti (Psal. ciii, 24). Justa sunt judicia tua; propter iniquitatem enim erudisti hominem (Tob. iii, 2). Priusquam humiliarer, ego deliqui (Psal. cxviii, 67). Dicamus haec in confessione, quia, si quaedam supplicio nostrae mortalitatis adversa sunt, ille tamen bonum facit, Quoniam bonus est. Et si temporalibus doloribus et laboribus emendamur, Non in finem irascetur, neque in aeternum indignabitur, quoniam in saeculum misericordia ejus (Psal. cii, 9). Quid tam bonum, quam Deus noster? Blasphemant homines, nec solum non humiliantur, sed etiam superbiunt in sceleribus suis, et Facit ille solem suum oriri super bonos et malos, et pluit super justos et injustos (Matth. v, 45). Quid tam misericors, quam Deus noster? Perseverant homines in flagitiis et facinoribus suis, et ille eos ad conversionem vocare non cessat. Quid tam bonum, quam Deus noster, a quo et in pressura solatia tanta percipimus?","english":"To some it seems that God is unjust, because for the most part his faithful people endure many hard and bitter things in this temporal life; but those to whom this seems so are mistaken. For he scourges every son, not one whom he rejects, but one whom he receives, since his mercy endures forever (Heb. xii, 6).\n\nLet us therefore give thanks to the Lord, for he is good, for his mercy endures forever. Let us say to the Lord our God: Your works are wonderful; for you have made all things in wisdom (Ps. ciii, 24). Your judgments are just; for you have instructed man because of iniquity (Tob. iii, 2). Before I was humbled, I transgressed (Ps. cxviii, 67). Let us say these things in confession, because, if certain things are adverse through the punishment of our mortality, he nonetheless does good, for he is good. And if we are corrected by temporal pains and labors, he will not be angry to the end, nor will he be indignant forever, for his mercy endures forever (Ps. cii, 9). What is so good as our God? Men blaspheme, and not only are they not humbled, but they even grow proud in their crimes, and he makes his sun rise on the good and the evil, and rains on the just and the unjust (Matt. v, 45). What is so merciful as our God? Men persevere in their shameful deeds and crimes, and he does not cease to call them to conversion. What is so good as our God, from whom even in distress we receive such great consolations?","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":50,"ref":"p50","source":"Quid tam misericors quam Deus noster, cujus et futuram sententiam mutati mutamus? Confiteamur Domino, Quoniam bonus, quoniam in saeculum misericordia ejus. Non omnium rerum laudes confessiones sunt, sed laudes Domini Dei nostri. Si enim verissime dictum est: Quam bonus Deus Israel rectis corde (Psal. lxxii, 1), malus utique videtur perversis corde. Quis autem hominum nisi ex perverso fit rectus, ut tanquam convictus laudare incipiat, quod antea reprehendebat, et mirari, quod antea contemnebat, confitens Domino, quoniam sibi jam recto bonus est, qui perverso videbatur malus? Et quoniam sua malitia perversus erat, ipsius autem gratia correctus est, simul oportet confiteatur, Quoniam in saeculum misericordia ejus. Nos mali, bonus ille. Nos ab ipso boni, a nobis mali. Bonus ille nobis bonis, bonus ille nobis malis. Nos saevientes in nos, ille misericors cors erga nos. Vocat, ut convertamur; expectat, donec convertamur; ignoscit, si convertamur; coronat, si non avertamur.","english":"What is so merciful as our God, by whose changed sentence we too, changed, are changed? Let us confess to the Lord, For he is good, for his mercy endures forever. Not all praises of things are confessions, but the praises of the Lord our God. For if it has been most truly said, How good is God to Israel, to those upright in heart (Ps. 72:1), then surely he seems evil to the perverse in heart. But who among men is made upright except from being perverse, so that, as if convicted, he begins to praise what he formerly reproved, and to marvel at what he formerly despised, confessing to the Lord that he is good to him now that he is upright, who seemed evil to him when he was perverse? And because he was perverse by his own malice, but was corrected by his grace, he must at the same time confess, For his mercy endures forever. We are evil, he is good. We are good from him, evil from ourselves. He is good to us when we are good, good to us when we are evil. We rage against ourselves, he is merciful in heart toward us. He calls, that we may be converted; he waits until we are converted; he forgives if we are converted; he crowns us if we do not turn away.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":51,"ref":"p51","source":"Confiteamur ergo Domino, Quoniam bonus est, quoniam in saeculum misericordia ejus. Confessio etiam peccatorum timenda semper hominibus visa est, sed apud hominem judicem. Non saepissime flagellis et quibusdam verberibus, ungulis quoque et ignibus agitur, ut eruatur ore confessio, et aliquando prius cedunt membra tormentis, ut corporis compago solvatur, quam doloribus animus, ut secretum facinoris propaletur. Instant carnifices, crebrescunt omnia genera tormentorum; sed frustra laniando puniuntur viscera, cum clauditur negando conscientia. Cur au tem in tantis cruciatibus homo metuit confiteri, nisi quia confessi solent puniri? Qui confessus fuerit homini, punitur. Deo qui confessus fuerit, liberatur Nec mirum. Quaerit homo ab homine, quod ille, qui quaerit, ignorat; Deus autem, qui monet ut confiteamur, novit quod confiteri nolebamus, nec tunc discit, quando confessi fuerimus. Quanto ergo magis confitentes a sempiterna morte liberat, qui nostris iniquitatibus, quas et antequam confiteremur, noverat, a temporali morte parcebat.","english":"Let us therefore confess to the Lord, For he is good, for his mercy endures forever. Confession of sins, too, has always seemed something to be feared by men—but before a human judge. Very often it is by scourges and certain beatings, by claws as well, and by fire, that it is brought about that confession be wrung from the mouth; and sometimes the limbs give way to the torments before the mind gives way to the pains, so that the secret of the crime may be brought to light. The executioners press on, every kind of torment multiplies; but in vain are the fleshly parts torn and punished, when the conscience is shut fast by denial. But why, then, amid such great tortures, does a man fear to confess, except that those who confess are wont to be punished? He who has confessed to a man is punished; he who has confessed to God is set free. Nor is this strange. A man seeks from a man what the one who seeks does not know; but God, who urges us to confess, knows what we were unwilling to confess, nor does he then learn it when we have confessed. How much more, then, does he free those who confess from everlasting death, who spared them from temporal death on account of our iniquities, which he knew even before we confessed them.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":52,"ref":"p52","source":"Dicis fortasse: Quid a me quaerit Deus, ut confitear, quod ipse jam novit? Nam homo, ab homine cum hoc quaerit, ignorat. Quid putas, nisi quia Deus vult, a te ut peccatum tuum cognoscendo p(??) niatur, et ab illo ignoscendo solvatur? Nam quomodo illum cupis ignoscere, quod tu non vis agnoscere? Audi Psalmum, et, si evigilas, adverte vocem tuam, ubi est. Peccatum, inquit, meum cognovi, et facinus meum non operui. Dixi: Proloquar adversum me delictum meum Domino, et tu dimisisti impietatem cordis mei (Psal. xxxi, 5). Audi in alio Psalmo: Quoniam iniquitatem meum ego agnosco, et delictum meum ante me est semper (Id. i, 5). Non itaque hujusmodi impudenter dicebat Deo: Averte faciem tuam a peccatis meis(Ibid. 11). Tunc enim ab hominis peccato faciem Deus dignatur avertere, cum homo ipse a peccato suo faciem suam minime curat avertere, ut in Dei auribus dicat: Peccatum meum ante me est semper. Nec ideo dicitur Deo: Averte faciem tuam, quia non cognoscit, sed quia ignoscit. Si ergo propterea times, homo, confiteri homini judici, quia malus est, aut quia severitatem legis implere compellitur, securus confitere Domino, Quoniam bonus est, quoniam in saeculum misericordia ejus.","english":"Perhaps you say: What does God seek from me, that I should confess what he already knows? For when a man seeks this from a man, he does not know it. What do you think it is, except that God wishes your sin to be exposed by your acknowledging it, and to be loosed by his forgiving it? For how do you desire him to forgive what you do not wish to acknowledge? Hear the Psalm, and, if you are awake, notice where your voice is. My sin, it says, I have acknowledged, and my wrongdoing I have not hidden. I said: I will speak out against myself my offense to the Lord, and you forgave the impiety of my heart (Ps. 31:5). Hear in another Psalm: For I acknowledge my iniquity, and my offense is always before me (Ps. 51:5). It was not, then, in this manner that he was shamelessly saying to God: Turn away your face from my sins (ibid. 11). For then does God deign to turn his face from a man's sin, when the man himself takes no care to turn his own face away from his sin, so as to say in God's ears: My sin is always before me. Nor is it therefore said to God: Turn away your face, because he does not know, but because he forgives. If, then, O man, you fear to confess to a human judge because he is wicked, or because he is compelled to fulfill the severity of the law, confess securely to the Lord, For he is good, for his mercy endures forever.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":53,"ref":"p53","source":"SERMO X.\n\nDe Psalmi cxlix, vers. 1. Cantate Domino canticum novum, etc..\n\nSYNOPSIS.\n\nI. Canticum duplex: vetus et novum. II. Quae sanctorum Ecclesia in terris. III. Quae vera Sion, et quae ejus conditio. IV. In Christo fides et spes felicitatis nostrae.\n\nVenerunt dies, ut cantemus Alleluia. Adeste animo, fratres, ad percipiendum quae Dominus suggerit ad exhortationem nostram, et nutriendam charitatem, qua nobis inhaerere Deo bonum est. Adeste animo, Cantatores boni, filii laudis et gloriae sempiternae veri et incorrupti Dei; adeste intenti, et laudate Deum; hoc est enim Alleluia. Sed laudate Deum non solum in voce, sed et in intellectu, et in opere bono, et sicut nos exhortatus est Psalmus, cantemus Domino canticum novum. Sic enim coepit: Cantate Domino canticum novum (Psal. cxlix, 1). Vetus homo vetus canticum. Novus homo novum canticum. Vetus Testamentum vetus canticum. Novum Testamentum novum canticum. In Veteri Testamento promissiones sunt terrenae, In Novo Testamento promissiones sunt caelestes. Quisquis terrena diligit, et terrenis incubat delectationibus, vetus canticum cantat. Qui vult cantare canticum novum, diligat aeterna. Ipsa dilectio nova est, quia nunquam veterascit, innovat amantem. Itaque, fratres, commendamus vobis, ut Deum diligatis; imo ipse commendat omnibus nobis.","english":"SERMON X.\n\nOn Psalm 149, verse 1. Sing to the Lord a new song, etc.\n\nSYNOPSIS.\n\nI. The twofold song: old and new. II. What the Church of the saints is on earth. III. What the true Sion is, and what its condition is. IV. In Christ are the faith and hope of our happiness.\n\nThe days have come for us to sing Alleluia. Be present in mind, brothers, to receive what the Lord suggests for our exhortation, and to nourish the charity by which it is good for us to cling to God. Be present in mind, good singers, children of praise and of eternal glory of the true and incorrupt God; be present, attentive, and praise God; for this is Alleluia. But praise God not only in voice, but also in understanding, and in good work, and as the Psalm has exhorted us, let us sing to the Lord a new song. For so it began: Sing to the Lord a new song (Ps. 149:1). The old man, an old song. The new man, a new song. The Old Testament, an old song. The New Testament, a new song. In the Old Testament the promises are earthly; in the New Testament the promises are heavenly. Whoever loves earthly things and broods over earthly delights sings the old song. Whoever wishes to sing the new song, let him love eternal things. That love itself is new, because it never grows old; it renews the one who loves. And so, brothers, we commend this to you, that you love God; rather, he himself commends it to all of us.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":54,"ref":"p54","source":"Bono enim nostro illum diligimus, non bono ipsius, quia malo nostro eum non diligimus, non malo ipsius. Non enim minus habebit Deus Divinitatem, si homo in illo non habuerit Charitatem. Nos crescimus ex Deo, non ille ex nobis, et tamen tantum nos dilexit prior, antequam eum diligeremus, ut Filium suum unicum mitteret mori pro nobis. Qui fecit nos, factus est inter nos. Quomodo nos ipse fecit? Omnia per ipsum facta sunt, et sine ipso factum est nihil (Joan. i, 3), Quomodo factus est inter nos? Et Verbum caro factum est, et habitavit in nobis (Psal. cxlix. 14).\n\nErgo, fratres, si ante amare pigebat, saltem nunc redamare non pigeat. Foedos nos amavit, quia peccatores amavit. Etenim Christus, ait Apostolus, pro impiis mortuus est (Rom. v, 16). Qui donavit impiis mortem suam, quid servat justis, nisi vitam suam? Videte denique, ubi, vel a quibus canticum istud novum Domino cantetur. Cum diceret enim: Cantate Domino canticum novum, subnexuit, et ait: Laus ejus in Ecclesia Sanctorum (Psal. cxlix, 1), et potest esse in terra Ecclesia Sanctorum? Dicit enim Propheta: Quia contaminata est terra in sanguine, et adulteria, et homicidia effusa sunt super terram (Ezech. ix; et Osee. iv, 2). Quomodo ergo videbitur Ecclesia Sanctorum haberi posse in terris? Apostolus docet dicens, quia in terris ambulantes conversationem habemus in caelis (Philipp. iii, 20).","english":"For we love him for our own good, not for his own good, because we do not love him for our own evil, not for his own evil. For God will not have less Divinity if man has no Charity in him. We grow from God, not he from us, and yet he loved us so much first, before we loved him, that he sent his only Son to die for us. He who made us was made among us. How did he himself make us? All things were made through him, and without him was made nothing (John 1:3). How was he made among us? And the Word was made flesh, and dwelt among us (Psalm 149:14).\n\nTherefore, brothers, if before it shamed us to love, at least now let it not shame us to love in return. He loved us when we were foul, because he loved us as sinners. For Christ, says the Apostle, died for the ungodly (Romans 5:16). He who gave his death to the ungodly, what does he keep for the just, if not his life? Finally, see where, or by whom, this new song is sung to the Lord. For when he said, Sing to the Lord a new song, he added and said, His praise in the Church of the Saints (Psalm 149:1), and can there be a Church of the Saints on earth? For the Prophet says: Because the earth is polluted in blood, and adulteries and murders have been poured out upon the earth (Ezekiel 9; and Hosea 4:2). How then will it be seen that a Church of the Saints can be held on earth? The Apostle teaches, saying, that we who walk on earth have our conversation in heaven (Philippians 3:20).","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":55,"ref":"p55","source":"Sic ergo efficitur, ut in terris positi coelestem Ecclesiam faciant Sancti. Laetetur, inquit, Israel in eo, qui fecit eum (Psal. cxlix, 2). Israel, id est, justi et sancti laetentur in Domino, injusti autem laetentur in saeculo. Finito saeculo finitur injustorum exultatio, quia permanente Domino permanebit justorum exultatio. Ergo si pertinemus ad Israel, et si volumus esse Israel, non laetemur in his, quae facta sunt, sed in eo, qui fecit. Sit spes nostra Deus noster. Qui fecit haec omnia, melior est omnibus. Quid est Israel? Videns Deum. Quomodo sumus Israel, si nondum videmus? Est quaedam visio hujus temporis, erit alia visio futuri temporis. Visio, quae modo est, per fidem est; visio, quae futura est, per speciem erit. Si credimus, videmus; si amamus, videmus. Quid videmus? Deum. Ubi est ipse Deus? Interroga apostolum Joannem. Deus, inquit, charitas est (1 Joan. iv, et 16). Quisquis habet charitatem, ut quid illum mittimus longe, ut videat Deum? Conscientiam suam attendat, et ibi videt Deum. Si charitas ibi non habitat, non ibi habitat Deus. Si autem charitas ibi inhabitat, Deus ibi inhabitat. Vult illum videre sedentem in coelo, habeat charitatem, et in illo habitat.","english":"Thus it comes about that, placed on earth, the saints make a heavenly Church. Let Israel, he says, rejoice in him who made him (Ps. 149:2). Let Israel—that is, the just and the holy—rejoice in the Lord; but let the unjust rejoice in the world. When the world is ended, the exultation of the unjust is ended, because while the Lord remains, the exultation of the just will remain. Therefore, if we belong to Israel, and if we wish to be Israel, let us not rejoice in the things that were made, but in him who made them. Let our hope be our God. He who made all these things is better than all things. What is Israel? One who sees God. How are we Israel, if we do not yet see? There is a certain vision of this time, and there will be another vision of the time to come. The vision that now is, is through faith; the vision that is to come will be through sight. If we believe, we see; if we love, we see. What do we see? God. Where is God himself? Ask the apostle John. God, he says, is love (1 John 4:8, 16). Whoever has love—why do we send him far away to see God? Let him attend to his own conscience, and there he sees God. If love does not dwell there, God does not dwell there. But if love dwells there, God dwells there. He wants to see him sitting in heaven; let him have love, and he dwells in him.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":56,"ref":"p56","source":"Sed. Et filii Sion exultent in Rege suo (Psal. cxlix, 2). Qui illi sint, operae pretium est noscere. Sion Specula interpretatur; specula vero est locus excelsus et editus, de quo longe prospicitur, quod venturum est. Si ergo et nos vitam nostram altius a terra, et longe sublimius ab humanis vitiis collocaverimus per virtutem fidei, recte Sion Filii appellabimur. Rex autem Sion sine dubio ille est, qui dicit: Ego autem constitutus sum rex ab eo, super Sion montem sanctum ejus (Psal. ii, 6). Quae Sion, ipsa et Jerusalem, sed Sion vera, et Jerusalem vera, non illa quae bello cecidit, quae nobis in mysterio posita est, sed illa, quae est in coelis: Jerusalem, quae est mater nostra (Galat, iv, 26). Ipsa nos. genuit, ipsa nos nutrivit, ex parte peregrina in saeculo, ex magna parte commanens in coelo. Ex parte, qua commanet in coelo, beatitudo est Angelorum; ex parte, qua peregrinatur in hoc saeculo, spes est justorum. De illa dictum est: Gloria in excelsis Deo; de hac dictum est: Et in terra pax hominibus bonae voluntatis (Luc. ii, 14). Qui ergo in hac vita gemunt, et desiderant illam patriam, currant, non pedibus corporis, sed affectibus cordis. Non quaerant naves, sed pennas charitatis apprehendant. Quae sunt duae alae charitatis? Dilectio Dei, et dilectio proximi. Peregrinamur enim, dicit Apostolus: Quandiu sumus in corpore, peregrinamur a Domino (2 Cor. v, 6).","english":"But. And let the sons of Sion exult in their King (Ps. 149:2). It is worth knowing who these are. Sion is interpreted as Watchtower; and a watchtower is a high and elevated place, from which one looks far ahead to what is to come. If, then, we too have placed our life higher above the earth and far more sublimely above human vices through the power of faith, we shall rightly be called sons of Sion. But the King of Sion is without doubt the one who says: But I have been established as king by him, upon his holy mountain Sion (Ps. 2:6). This Sion is the same as Jerusalem—but the true Sion and the true Jerusalem, not that one which fell in war, which was set before us as a mystery, but that one which is in heaven: Jerusalem, which is our mother (Gal. 4:26). She bore us, she nourished us, in part a stranger in the world, in great part dwelling in heaven. In the part in which she dwells in heaven, she is the blessedness of the angels; in the part in which she is a stranger in this world, she is the hope of the just. Of her it was said: Glory to God in the highest; of this one it was said: And on earth peace to men of good will (Luke 2:14). Therefore let those who groan in this life and long for that homeland run—not with the feet of the body, but with the affections of the heart. Let them not seek ships, but let them take hold of the wings of charity. What are the two wings of charity? The love of God and the love of neighbor. For we are strangers, says the Apostle: As long as we are in the body, we are strangers from the Lord (2 Cor. 5:6).","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[{"kind":"scripture","severity":"info","ref":"Luke 2:14","text":"The English carries the scriptural phrase “glory to god in the highest”, which matches Luke 2:14. The match is on the English draft; check the Coptic before quoting the verse."}]},{"i":57,"ref":"p57","source":"Sed venerunt ad nos litterae de patria nostra admonentes reversionem nostram Ipsae nobis leguntur, cum divinae Scripturae nobis recitantur. Beati, qui ibi sunt! Nullis jam cupiditatibus sauciantur, nullis iniquitatibus vel propriis, vel alienis cruciantur, quorum non est negotium, nisi laudare Deum. Non arant, non seminant. Opera enim sunt ista necessitatis; ibi necessitas non est. Non furantur, non depraedantur. Opera enim sunt ista iniquitatis; ibi iniquitas non est. Non frangunt panem esurienti, non vestiunt nudum, non suscipiunt peregrinum, non sepeliunt mortuum. Opera enim sum ista misericordiae; ibi nulla miseria est, in qua fiat misericordia.\n\nO beati! Putamus, erimus et nos sic? Eia suspiremus, de suspirio gemamus, et quid sumus, et illud, ubi sumus. Et ubi sumus? In saeculo vano et transitorio. Et quid sumus? Mortales, projecti, abjecti, et sicut quidam dixit Sanctus: Terra et cinis (Gen. xviii, 27). Sed qui promisit nobis immortalitatem, et aeternitatem, omnipotens est. Si ad nos attendamus, quid sumus? Si ad illum, Deus est, omnipotens est. Non est facturus Angelum ex homine, qui fecit hominem ex nihilo? Aut vere pro minimo habet Deus hominem, propter quem mori voluit Unicum suum? Attendamus indicium dilectionis, et promissionis, unde tales arrhas accepimus. Tenemus mortem Christi, tenemus sanguinem Christi.","english":"But letters have come to us from our homeland, reminding us of our return. They are read to us when the divine Scriptures are read to us. Blessed are those who are there! They are no longer wounded by any desires, no longer tormented by any iniquities, whether their own or others'; they have no business except to praise God. They do not plow, they do not sow. For these are works of necessity; there necessity is not. They do not steal, they do not plunder. For these are works of iniquity; there iniquity is not. They do not break bread for the hungry, they do not clothe the naked, they do not welcome the stranger, they do not bury the dead. For these are works of mercy; there is no misery there in which mercy may be shown.\n\nO blessed ones! Do we think that we too will be so? Come, let us sigh, let us groan from our sighing, both at what we are and at that place where we are. And where are we? In a vain and transitory world. And what are we? Mortals, cast down, cast away, and as a certain saint said: Earth and ashes (Gen. 18:27). But he who promised us immortality and eternity is almighty. If we look to ourselves, what are we? If we look to him, he is God, he is almighty. Will he not make an angel out of a man, who made man out of nothing? Or does God truly regard man as of little account, the man for whom he willed his Only-begotten to die? Let us attend to the token of his love and of his promise, from which we have received such pledges. We hold the death of Christ, we hold the blood of Christ.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":58,"ref":"p58","source":"Erigat se ergo et humana fragilitas, non desperet, non se avertat. Qui promisit, Deus est, et venit, ut promitteret. Apparuit hominibus, venit suscipere mortem nostram, promittere vitam suam. Ita enim voluit Deus infirmitatem humanam de sua promissione esse securam, ut non solum diceret, sed et scriberet. Credentibus dixit, dubitantibus cavit, et ecce omnia tenentur in quodam Chirographo, in sancta Scriptura. Venit ergo ad regionem peregrinationis nostrae accipere, quod hic abundat: opprobria, flagella, contumelias, spineam coronam, crucem, mortem Haec abundant in regione nostra. Attulit commercia, venit, attulit nobis de illa regione bona, et in regione nostra pertulit mala. Promisit nobis tamen, quod ibi futuri sumus, unde venit, et ait: Pater, volo, ut ubi ego sum, et ipsi sint mecum (Joan. xvii, 24). Tanta praecessit dilectio, quia, ubi nos eramus, fuit nobiscum; ubi ipse est, erimus cum illo. Tenete ergo Christum, fratres, tenete fidem, tenete viam. Ipsa vos perducet ad id, quod videre modo non potestis. In illo enim capite apparuit, quod speretur in membris. In illo fundamento demonstratum est, quod in nostra aedificetur fide, ut postea perficiatur in spe.","english":"Let human frailty therefore lift itself up; let it not despair, let it not turn away. He who made the promise is God, and he came in order to make the promise. He appeared to men; he came to take up our death and to promise his life. For God so willed that human weakness should be made secure by his promise that he not only spoke it but also wrote it. He spoke to those who believe, he took care for those who doubt, and behold, all things are held in a kind of handwriting, in the holy Scripture. He came therefore to the region of our pilgrimage to receive what abounds here: reproaches, scourges, insults, a crown of thorns, the cross, death. These things abound in our region. He brought trade; he came, he brought us good things from that region, and in our region he endured evils. Yet he promised us that we shall be there, whence he came, and he said: Father, I will that where I am, they also may be with me (John 17:24). So great a love went before us, because where we were, he was with us; where he is, we shall be with him. Hold fast therefore to Christ, brothers, hold fast to the faith, hold fast to the way. It will lead you to that which you cannot now see. For in that head there appeared what is to be hoped for in the members. In that foundation there was shown what is to be built up in our faith, so that afterward it may be perfected in hope.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":59,"ref":"p59","source":"SERMO XI.\n\nIn Natali Joannis Baptistae.\n\nSYNOPSIS.\n\nI. Quis, et cui, et quam lucernam paraverit. II. Joannis Baptistae modestia. III. Joannis Baptistae dignitas.\n\nIV. Mysterium Trinitatis, et Patris, Filiique coaeternitas. V. In Christi Baptismo manifestata Trinitas.\n\nVI. Quinam sint occulti inimici Christi. VII. Quinam sint aperti inimici Christi. VIII. Anacephalaeosis et Adhortatio.\n\nLoquimur Charitati Vestrae in domo Dei, quod praesens Psalmus admonuit. Quis est, qui dicat: Paravi lucernam Christo meo. Inimicos ejus induam confusione; super ipsum autem florebit sanctificatio mea (Psal. cxxxi, 17, 18); et quae illa lucerna sit, quam paravit Christo suo, et qui sint inimici Christi ejus, quos per illam lucernam induit confusione, et quae sanctificatio ejus, qui paravit lucernam Christo suo, quae florebit super Christum ejus. In his enim omnibus verbis illud tantum videtur planum, et apertum, quod hic ait: Christo meo. Non enim aliud intelligendum est, quam Christus Dominus et Salvator noster. Perscrutantes itaque, quantum largitur Deus, altitudinem sensus hujus, invenimus hoc Deum Patrem dicere. Deus ergo Pater, id est, persona Dei Patris per Prophetam loquitur: Paravi lucernam Christo meo. Filium autem Dei eumdem esse et Christum Dei, non est exponendum Christianis. Inventa itaque loquentis persona videamus, quae sit lucerna a Deo Patre Christo Filio praeparata.","english":"SERMON XI.\n\nOn the Birthday of John the Baptist.\n\nSYNOPSIS.\n\nI. Who prepared the lamp, and for whom, and what kind of lamp. II. The modesty of John the Baptist. III. The dignity of John the Baptist.\n\nIV. The mystery of the Trinity, and the coeternity of the Father and the Son. V. The Trinity manifested in Christ's Baptism.\n\nVI. Who are the hidden enemies of Christ. VII. Who are the open enemies of Christ. VIII. Recapitulation and Exhortation.\n\nWe speak to your Charity in the house of God, as the present Psalm has admonished. Who is it that says: I have prepared a lamp for my Christ. I will clothe his enemies with confusion; but upon him my sanctification shall flourish (Ps. 131:17, 18); and what that lamp is which he prepared for his Christ, and who are the enemies of his Christ whom through that lamp he clothes with confusion, and what his sanctification is—he who prepared a lamp for his Christ, which shall flourish upon his Christ. For in all these words only that seems plain and open which he says here: for my Christ. For nothing else is to be understood than Christ our Lord and Savior. Searching therefore, as far as God grants, into the depth of the meaning of this, we find that God the Father says this. God the Father, then, that is, the person of God the Father, speaks through the Prophet: I have prepared a lamp for my Christ. But that the Son of God is the same as the Christ of God is not something to be expounded to Christians. Having therefore found the person of the speaker, let us see what the lamp is that was prepared by God the Father for Christ the Son.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":60,"ref":"p60","source":"Dominus ipse dicit de Joanne Baptista: Ille erat lucerna ardens et lucens, et vos voluistis exultare ad horam in lumine ejus (Joan. v, 35). Lucernam ergo dixit Joannem accensam de fonte luminis, ut testimonium perhiberet veritati. In hac enim caecitate jacebant homines, et in hac oculi interioris infirmitate, ut Sol justitiae per lucernam quaereretur. Nam si quis haberet mundum oculum cordis, eum ipsum prius intueretur, nec ad ejus testimonium lucernam quaereret. Cum enim de illa lucerna dixisset: Voluistis exultare ad horam in lunine ejus; ego autem, inquit, habeo testimonium majus, quam Joannem (Joan. v, 36). Lucerna ergo infirmis in nocte accensa est. Et quomodo illam accendit? Pater Christo Filio suo de Joanne dicit: Ecce mitto Angelum meum ante te, qui praeparabit viam ante faciem tuam (Malach. iii, 1, et Matth. xi, 10). Paravit lucernam Christo suo (Psal. cxxxi, 17).","english":"The Lord himself says concerning John the Baptist: He was a burning and shining lamp, and you were willing to rejoice for an hour in his light (John 5:35). He called John a lamp kindled from the fountain of light, that he might bear witness to the truth. For men lay in this blindness, and in this weakness of the inner eye, so that the Sun of righteousness had to be sought through a lamp. For if anyone had a clean eye of the heart, he would behold that Sun himself first, and would not seek a lamp for his testimony. For when he had said of that lamp: You were willing to rejoice for an hour in his light; he says, But I have a testimony greater than John (John 5:36). The lamp, then, was kindled for the weak in the night. And how did he kindle it? The Father says to Christ his Son concerning John: Behold, I send my Angel before you, who will prepare the way before your face (Malachi 3:1, and Matthew 11:10). He prepared a lamp for his Christ (Psalm 131:17).","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":61,"ref":"p61","source":"Quomodo inimicos ejus per ipsam lucernam induit confusione? Ac prius videte, quod diximus, de fonte luminis accensam lucernam. Ipse Joannes te statur: Nos autem, inquit, de plenitudine ejus accepimus (Joan. i, 46). Erat autem Joannes tanta excellentia praecellens, ut non ante Christum missus, sed ipse Christus putaretur. Ille autem, si lucerna esset extincta, et nidore superbiae fumida, quando ad eum missum est a Judaeis, dictumque illi: Tu quis es (Ibid. 19)? Tu es Christus? An Elias? An Propheta? diceret: Ego sum. Invenerat enim occasionem jactantiae suae, ultro honorem falsum errore hominum deferente. Numquid hoc persuadere laborabat, quod priores dicebant, qui interrogabant? Sed missus est humilis ad parandam viam excelso. Inde amicus Sponsi, quia servus cognitor Domini. Et ait: Ego sum vox clamantis in eremo: Parate viam Domino, Rectas facite semitas ejus (Matth. III, 3). Ego non sum Christus, nec Elias, nec Propheta. Et illi: Quis ergo es? Et quid dixit? Ego sum vox clamantis in deserto: Parate viam Domino. Jam enim ista praedixerat Isaias (Isai. xl, 3). De quo autem praedixerit, ibi intelligitur. Legistis, inquit, hoc in Isaia, et forte lectum ignorastis, unde sit dictum. Ego sum, de quo est dictum. Quantum autem se abjicit, qui tantum erigebatur, ut Christus putaretur, quantum se abjicit, videte.","english":"How did he clothe his enemies with confusion through that very lamp? But first consider what we said, that the lamp was kindled from the fountain of light. John himself testifies to you: Of his fullness, he says, we have all received (John 1:16). Now John was so far excelling in excellence that he was not only sent before Christ, but was himself thought to be Christ. But if that lamp had been extinguished and smoking with the stench of pride, when the Jews sent to him and it was said to him, Who are you (John 1:19)? Are you the Christ? Or Elijah? Or the Prophet? he would have said, I am he. For he would have found an occasion for his own boasting, since men's error was freely offering him false honor. Was he not striving to persuade them of this, as those who questioned him were already saying beforehand? But he was sent humbly to prepare the way for the exalted one. Hence he is the friend of the Bridegroom, because he is the servant who knows his Lord. And he said: I am the voice of one crying in the wilderness: Prepare the way of the Lord, make straight his paths (Matthew 3:3). I am not the Christ, nor Elijah, nor the Prophet. And they said: Who then are you? And what did he say? I am the voice of one crying in the wilderness: Prepare the way of the Lord. For Isaiah had already foretold this (Isaiah 40:3). But it is understood there of whom he foretold it. You have read this, he says, in Isaiah, and perhaps you read it without knowing where it was said. I am he of whom it was said. But see how much he casts himself down, he who was raised so high that he was thought to be Christ; see how much he casts himself down.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":62,"ref":"p62","source":"Ego quidem, inquit, baptizo vos in aqua; qui autem post me venit, major me est (Luc. III, 16). Et aliquanto posset me major dici. Majorem se illum dicit. Dic, quanto majorem? Cujus non sum, inquit, dignus corrigiam calceamenti solvere (Ibid.).\n\nJam hinc intelligite dispensationem, quare Joannes ante Christum praemissus est. Videtis, quanto sit minor, quantoque illum fateatur esse majorem, ut dicat indignum se solvere corrigiam calceamenti ejus. Quantus est iste, qui se dicit indignum solvere corrigiam calceamenti hujus? Quantus est? Ubi quaerimus? Si ab ipso Joanne quaeramus, quantus sit Joannes, non invenimus; humiliat enim se, et nihil de se, vel veraciter, jactanter loquitur. Quantus ergo sit Joannes, qui non est dignus corrigiam calceamenti solvere ejus, qui homo putabatur, a quo audituri sumus? Ipsum Dominum interrogemus, et dicamus ei: Domine, perhibuit de te Joannes magnum testimonium, et cum ejus magna excellentia inter homines appareret, ut Christus esse putaretur, quaesitumque ab eo esset, quis esset, dixit non se esse Christum, dixit venturum esse majorem se, et tanto majorem, ut non sit dignus corrigiam solvere calceamenti ejus. Tanquam lucerna fidelis locuta est de excellenti lumine tuo. Hoc de te Joannes. Videamus, quis sit, qui de te ista, quantus sit ille, qui se ita humiliavit tibi, teque tanto ampliorem se confessus est. Quis est? Ille de te ista.","english":"He says, “I indeed baptize you in water; but he who comes after me is mightier than I.” And to some extent he could be called greater than I. He says that he is greater than himself. Tell us, how much greater? “The latchet of whose sandal,” he says, “I am not worthy to loose.” Now from this understand the dispensation, why John was sent before Christ. You see how much lesser he is, and how much he confesses that he is greater, so as to say that he is unworthy to loose the latchet of his sandal. How great is this one who says that he is unworthy to loose the latchet of this one’s sandal? How great is he? Where do we seek? If we ask John himself how great John is, we do not find out; for he humbles himself, and says nothing about himself either truly or boastfully. How great, then, is John, who is not worthy to loose the latchet of his sandal—of him who was thought to be a man, from whom we are about to hear? Let us question the Lord himself, and say to him: Lord, John bore great testimony concerning you, and when his great excellence appeared among men, so that he was thought to be the Christ, and it was asked of him who he was, he said that he was not the Christ; he said that one was to come who was greater than himself, and so much greater that he was not worthy to loose the latchet of his sandal. As a faithful lamp he spoke of your excellent light. This is what John said concerning you. Let us see who he is who says these things concerning you, how great he is who so humbled himself before you, and confessed that you are so much greater than himself. Who is he? The one of whom you have said these things.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":63,"ref":"p63","source":"Tu de illo dic nobis aliquid. Audi vocem Domini de Joanne. In natis mulierum nemo exurrexit major Joanne Baptista (Matth. xi, 11). Sed quid ait? Qui autem minor est, in regno coelorum major est illo. Se ipsum dicit; non enim arrogans est Deus, cum commendat magnitudinem suam. Quid est: Qui minor est? Qui posterior aetate, major majestate. Posterior enim natus Joanne est Dominus Christus, sed in eo, quod factus est propter nos, non in eo, per quod facti sumus. Ille, qui post Joannem natus est, audi a Patre: non ante Joannem, non ante David, non ante Abraham, sed Ante luciferum genui te (Psal. cix, 5) Si ergo accommodatum est aliquid infirmitati nostrae, ut diem lucerna praecederet, et creditum est lucernae de die, quanto magis credendum est diei de lucerna, quia In natis mulierum nemo exurrexit major Joanne Baptista. Homo igitur, quo nemo major natus erat, cum dicit se indignum solvere corrigiam calceamenti cujusdam, quid est ille, cujus non est dignus solvere corrigiam calceamenti homo, quo nemo major erat? Si jam Joannes tantus homo, ut amplior non possit esse homo, quidquid illo majus, amplius est, quam homo. Si jam Joannes tantus homo, ut major illo nullus sit homo, qui major illo est, amplius est, quam homo. Et qui amplius est, quam homo, tamen propter hominem homo, merito super cum floret sanctificatio Patris.","english":"Tell us something about him. Hear the voice of the Lord concerning John. Among those born of women, none has arisen greater than John the Baptist. But what does he say? \"Yet the one who is lesser in the kingdom of heaven is greater than he.\" He is speaking of himself; for God is not arrogant when he commends his own greatness. What is \"the one who is lesser\"? Lesser in age, greater in majesty. For the Lord Christ was born later than John, but in that which he became for our sake, not in that through which we were made. He who was born after John—hear from the Father: not before John, not before David, not before Abraham, but \"Before the morning star I begot you.\" If, therefore, something was accommodated to our weakness, so that the lamp should precede the day, and the lamp was believed concerning the day, how much more should the day be believed concerning the lamp, because among those born of women none has arisen greater than John the Baptist. A man, then, than whom no one greater had been born, when he says that he is unworthy to untie the strap of someone's sandal—what is he, the strap of whose sandal a man than whom no one was greater is not worthy to untie? If John is already so great a man that no man can be greater, whatever is greater than he is more than a man. If John is already so great a man that no man is greater than he, the one who is greater than he is more than a man. And he who is more than a man, yet for man's sake a man, rightly does the sanctification of the Father flourish upon him.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":64,"ref":"p64","source":"Super eum enim Spiritus sanctus in specie columbae descendit. Flos sanctitatis in specie columbae, in forma simplici atque innocenti tunc demonstratus est plenius ipsi Joanni, ut impleretur: Et super ipsum florebit sanctificatio mea. Ego, inquit, non noveram eum, sed qui me misit baptizare in aqua, ipse mihi dixit: Super quem rideris Spiritum descendentem sicut columbam, et manentem super eum, ipse est, qui baptizat in Spiritu sancto. Et ego, inquit, quod vidi, testimonium perhibeo, quia ipse est electus Dei (Joan. i, 33, 34). De quo testimonium perhibet? Super quem vidit florere sanctificationem Patris. Unde vidit descendentem Spiritum sanctum? Non enim a Filio aliquando recessit Spiritus sanctus, aut aliquando Filius a Spiritu, aut aliquando Filius a Patre, aut Pater a Filio, aut Spiritus a Filio et Patre. Sed aliter ista intelliguntur mente purgata, aliter oculis demonstrantur. Nullo tempore praecedit Pater Filium, nullo tempore sequitur Filius Patrem, nullo tempore, quia ibi nullum tempus. Pater et Filius et Spiritus sanctus, creator temporum, unus Deus. Ibi ergo non est, ut dicas: Prior est Pater, posterior Filius. Ex quo Pater, ex illo Filius. Quaere: Ex quo Pater? Superas cogitatione terram, caelum, Angelos, visibilia, invisibilia, universam creaturam, et quaeris: Ex quo coepit Pater? Non sic quaeruntur aeterna. Noli quaerere ex quo, nisi quod incipit.","english":"For the Holy Spirit descended upon him in the likeness of a dove. The flower of holiness in the likeness of a dove, in simple and innocent form, was then shown more fully to John himself, so that what was written might be fulfilled: And my sanctification shall flourish upon him. He says, I did not know him, but the one who sent me to baptize in water, he said to me: The one upon whom you see the Spirit descending like a dove and remaining upon him, he is the one who baptizes in the Holy Spirit. And I, he says, bear witness to what I have seen, that he is the chosen one of God (John 1:33-34). Of whom does he bear witness? Of the one upon whom he saw the sanctification of the Father flourish. How did he see the Holy Spirit descend? For the Holy Spirit never at any time departed from the Son, nor the Son at any time from the Spirit, nor the Son at any time from the Father, nor the Father from the Son, nor the Spirit from the Son and the Father. But these things are understood in one way by the purified mind, and shown in another way to the eyes. At no time does the Father precede the Son, at no time does the Son follow the Father, at no time—because there is no time there. The Father and the Son and the Holy Spirit, the creator of times, one God. There, then, it is not the case that you may say: The Father is prior, the Son is later. From the one who is Father, from him is the Son. Ask: From what does the Father derive? Surpass in thought the earth, the heaven, the angels, things visible, things invisible, the whole creation, and you ask: From what did the Father begin? Eternal things are not asked about in this way. Do not ask \"from what,\" except of that which begins.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":65,"ref":"p65","source":"Noli quaerere ex quo, a quo incipit, quidquid coepit, et quod a nullo incipit, quia non incipit. Sicut autem non incipit Pater, non incipit Filius, sed est Filius splendor Patris. Sic splendor ignis, ex quo ignis, et splendor Patris, ex quo Pater. Ex quo autem Pater? Ab aeterno in aeternum. Ergo et splendor Patris ab aeterno in aeternum, et tamen, quia splendor illius, Filius illius, et sic non coepit tempore, ut genitus sit a Patre? Quis hoc videat? Lima cor, excute pulverem, dilue maculam. Quidquid interiorem perturbat intuitum, curetur, et sanetur, et apparebit, quod dicitur, et creditur, antequam videatur.\n\nModo, tamen credimus, fratres. Quid credimus? Patrem et Filium et Spiritum sanctum nullo tempore se praecedere. Cum ergo Pater et Filius et Spiritus sanctus nullo tempore se praecedant, non tamen potui nominare Patrem et Filium et Spiritum sanctum, nisi ista nomina tempora tenerent, et temporibus suis tenerentur. Non est prior Pater, et posterior Filius, et tamen ego non potui dicere, nisi unum prius, et alium posterius, et sua tempora omnes syllabae tenuerunt, et secunda syllaba in verbis meis sonare non potuit, nisi cum prima transisset. Peracta sunt tempora in syllabis meis, cum ea dicerem, quae non habent tempora. Sic ergo, fratres mei, cum illa Trinitas sensibiliter ostenderetur huic carni, in fluvio apparuit omnis Trinitas, ubi baptizatus est Dominus a Joanne.","english":"Do not ask from what source, by what source, anything that has a beginning begins, and that which begins from no source does not begin. But just as the Father does not begin, the Son does not begin, yet the Son is the splendor of the Father. As the splendor of fire is from fire, so the splendor of the Father is from the Father. But from what source is the Father? From eternity to eternity. Therefore the splendor of the Father is also from eternity to eternity, and yet, because it is his splendor, it is his Son, and so he did not begin in time, in that he was begotten of the Father? Who can see this? File down the heart, shake off the dust, wash away the stain. Whatever disturbs the inner gaze, let it be cured and healed, and there will appear what is spoken and believed before it is seen.\n\nNow, however, brothers, we believe. What do we believe? That the Father and the Son and the Holy Spirit do not precede one another in any time. Therefore, since the Father and the Son and the Holy Spirit do not precede one another in any time, nevertheless I could not name the Father and the Son and the Holy Spirit unless those names held times and were held by their times. The Father is not prior and the Son later, and yet I could not say it except one first and the other later, and all the syllables held their own times, and the second syllable could not sound in my words unless the first had passed. Times were completed in my syllables when I spoke those things which have no times. So then, my brothers, when that Trinity was shown to the senses to this flesh, the whole Trinity appeared in the river, where the Lord was baptized by John.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":66,"ref":"p66","source":"Baptizatus est enim, ascendit a baptismo, descendit columba, et sonuit vox de coelo: Hic est Filius meus dilectus, in quo bene complacui (Matth. iii, 17). Filius in homine, Spiritus, in columba, Pater in voce. Res indiscreta discrete monstrata est; si tamen dicenda est res, sed potius rerum omnium causa, si tamen causa. Quid enim dicimus, cum de Deo dicimus? Et tamen, dicimus, et dici se sinit, qui non est, velut cogitatur; dici autem non potest, nec quo modo cogitatur. Sed quantum ad homines, fratres, ecce per columbam apparuit, et impletum est: Super ipsum autem florebit sanctificatio mea. Florebit enim dictum est: clare apparebit. Nihil enim in arbore flore clarius, nihil lucidius. Age jam. Pervenimus ad ultima verba Hypopsalmatis: Super ipsum autem florebit sanctificatio mea (Psal. cxxxi, 18). Recordor me praetermisisse, qui sint inimici, qui confusi sunt per lucernam.","english":"For he was baptized, he came up from the baptism, the dove descended, and a voice sounded from heaven: This is my beloved Son, in whom I am well pleased (Matthew 3:17). The Son in the man, the Spirit in the dove, the Father in the voice. The undivided reality was shown in divided signs; if indeed it is to be called a reality, but rather the cause of all things, if indeed a cause. For what do we say when we speak of God? And yet we speak, and he who is not, as he is thought of, allows himself to be spoken of; but he cannot be spoken of, nor in the manner in which he is thought of. But as far as it concerns men, brothers, behold he appeared through the dove, and it was fulfilled: Over him my sanctification shall flourish. For \"shall flourish\" was said [meaning]: it shall appear clearly. For nothing in a tree is brighter than a flower, nothing more luminous. Come now. We have reached the final words of the Hypopsalma: Over him my sanctification shall flourish (Psalm 131:18). I recall that I passed over who those enemies are, who were put to shame by the lamp.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":67,"ref":"p67","source":"Paravi lucernam Christo meo, Pater dixit de Filio suo. Quam lucernam? Joannem. Interroga ipsum Filium. Ille erat lucerna ardens et lucens. Inimicos ejus induam confusione. Inimici Christi aperti qui, nisi Judaei? Habet enim occultos inimicos Christus. Omnes inique atque impie viventes inimici sunt Christi, etsi signentur nomine ejus, etsi vocentur Christiani. Quibus enim dicturus est: Non novi vos, et dicunt illi: Domine, in nomine tuo manducavimus et bibimus, in nomine tuo virtutes multas fecimus (Luc. xiii, 26, et Matth. vii, 22, 23). Quid manducavimus et bibimus in nomine tuo? Non enim escas suas pro magno jactabant, et inde se ad Christum pertinere dicebant. Est esca quaedam, quae manducatur et bibitur, et Christus est Et ab inimicis Christus manducatur et bibitur. Norunt Fideles Agnum immaculatum, quo vescuntur, atque utinam sic vescantur, ut non sint poenae debitores! Sicut enim dicit Apostolus: Quicumque manducat et bibit indigne, judicium, sibi manducat et bibit (1 Cor. xi, 29). Ergo inimici Christi sunt, qui malunt inique vivere, quam illi obtemperare, et cum dicitur venturus judicare vivos et mortuos, timent ne veniat. Si illis liceret, facerent ne veniret. Quia non potuerunt facere ut non veniret, facerent ne rediret. Jam Judaei hoc voluerunt facere, ne rediret.","english":"I have prepared a lamp for my Christ, the Father said concerning his Son. Which lamp? John. Ask the Son himself. He was a lamp burning and shining. I will clothe his enemies in confusion. Who are Christ's open enemies but the Jews? For Christ has hidden enemies too. All who live wickedly and impiously are enemies of Christ, even if they are marked with his name, even if they are called Christians. For to whom will he say, I do not know you, when they say to him, Lord, we ate and drank in your name, we did many mighty works in your name (Luke 13:26; Matthew 7:22-23). What did we eat and drink in your name? For they were not boasting of their own foods as something great, and on that basis claiming to belong to Christ. There is a certain food that is eaten and drunk, and it is Christ. And Christ is eaten and drunk even by his enemies. The faithful know the spotless Lamb on which they feed, and would that they so feed as not to be debtors to punishment! For as the Apostle says: Whoever eats and drinks unworthily, eats and drinks judgment to himself (1 Corinthians 11:29). Therefore they are enemies of Christ who prefer to live wickedly rather than obey him, and when it is said that he will come to judge the living and the dead, they fear lest he come. If it were permitted them, they would act so that he would not come. Because they could not bring it about that he not come, they would act so that he not return. The Jews already wished to do this, that he not return.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":68,"ref":"p68","source":"Missus est enim filius ad malos illos colonos, ad malos conductores nolentes reddere mercedem, et lapidantes servos missos ad se. Tunc dixit paterfamilias, dominus vineae: Mittam filium meum (Luc. xx, 13). Forsitan vel ipsum reverebuntur. Illi autem cogitaverunt dicentes: Hic est haeres. Venite, occidamus eum, et nostra erit haereditas (Ibid. 14)! Non potuerunt facere, ne veniret a patre, et conati sunt facere, ne rediret ad patrem. Sed cui hoc? Videbant quidem et contemnebant mortalem, sed in eo non potuerunt occidere nisi mortem. In morte Christi mors mortua est. Ille resurgens ascendit ad Patrem et venturus est. Quid timetis? Amate, et securi eritis. Nonne nos oramus: Adveniat regnum tuum (Matth. vi, 10). Ergo, fratres, oramus, et timemus, ne exaudiamur?\n\nSed isti, ut dicere coeperam, occulti sunt inimici. De illis apertis loquamur, qui aperte inviderunt, saevierunt, tenuerunt, flagellaverunt, illuserunt, crucifixerunt, occiderunt, sepultum custodierunt. Videamus, quomodo induti sunt confusione per illam lucernam. Cum miracula viderent in Domino iidem inimici: Dic nobis, inquiunt, in qua potestate ista facis (Luc. 20, 2)? Inimico animo interrogaverunt, ut, si ille fateretur potestatem suam, quasi blasphemandi reum tenerent.","english":"For the son was sent to those wicked tenants, to those wicked stewards who refused to pay the rent and stoned the servants sent to them. Then the father of the household, the lord of the vineyard, said: I will send my son (Luke 20:13). Perhaps they will at least reverence him. But they thought among themselves, saying: This is the heir. Come, let us kill him, and the inheritance will be ours (ibid. 14)! They could not bring it about that he should not come from the Father, and they tried to bring it about that he should not return to the Father. But to whom did this happen? They saw him indeed and despised him as mortal, but in him they could kill nothing but death. In the death of Christ, death died. He, rising again, ascended to the Father and is to come. What do you fear? Love, and you will be secure. Do we not pray: Thy kingdom come (Matt. 6:10)? Therefore, brothers, do we pray and yet fear lest we be heard?\n\nBut these, as I had begun to say, are hidden enemies. Let us speak of those open enemies, who openly envied, raged, seized, scourged, mocked, crucified, killed, and guarded the buried body. Let us see how they were clothed in confusion by that lamp. When those same enemies saw miracles in the Lord, they said: Tell us, by what authority do you do these things (Luke 20:2)? They asked with hostile intent, so that, if he confessed his authority, they might hold him guilty as one who blasphemed.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":69,"ref":"p69","source":"Sed, quomodo ille fecit de nummo, quando volebant calumniari ei, si diceret: Reddatur tributum Caesari, quasi maledixisset genti Judaeorum, quam fecisset subditam et tributariam; si autem dixisset: Non reddatur, criminarentur eum apud Caesaris amicos et ministros, quod prohiberet reddi; ille autem: Ostendite, ait, mihi nummum; cujus habet imaginem, et superscriptionem? Responderunt: Caesaris. Reddite ergo Caesari, quae Caesaris sunt, et quae Dei sunt, Deo (Matth. xxii, 19-21). Hoc est dicere: Si Caesar quaerit imaginem suam in nummo, Deus non quaerit imaginem suam in homine? Sic et hic inimici calumniatores In corde et corde locuti sunt mala (Psal. xi, 3). Semel enim dixissent in corde, nisi, qui talia loquerentur, duplex cor haberent, et, unde paulo ante dictum est, cor combinatum, non simplex. Videte enim, quantum interest. De servis Dei multis dictum est, qui habebant unum cor: Erat, inquit, illis anima una, et cor unum (Act. iv, 32) in Deum. Multi simplices habent unum cor, unus dolosus duo corda. Ergo, quia illi loquebantur in corde et corde: Dic nobis, in qua potestate ista facis? id est, si dixeris, honoramus; ei dixeris, veneramur; si dixeris, exoramus, videtur hoc sonare de alio corde; de alio autem (nam duplex ibi erat) si dixeris, calumniamur; si dixeris, inveniemus, quod teneamus; si dixeris, inveniemus, quod accusemus. Tales inimici. Sed confundantur de lucerna.","english":"But how did he deal with the coin, when they wanted to slander him—if he said, \"Render tribute to Caesar,\" as though he had cursed the Jewish people, whom he had made subject and tributary; but if he said, \"Do not render it,\" they would accuse him before Caesar's friends and ministers of forbidding the payment. He, however, said: \"Show me a coin; whose image and inscription does it have?\" They answered: \"Caesar's.\" \"Render therefore to Caesar the things that are Caesar's, and to God the things that are God's\" (Matt 22:19-21). That is to say: If Caesar seeks his image on a coin, does God not seek his image in man? So here too the enemies and slanderers spoke evil with a heart and a heart (Ps 11:3). For they would have said it once in their heart, unless those who spoke such things had a double heart, and—as was said a little earlier—a heart joined together, not single. For see how much difference there is. Of many servants of God it is said that they had one heart: \"They had,\" it says, \"one soul and one heart\" (Acts 4:32) toward God. Many single-hearted people have one heart; one deceitful man has two hearts. Therefore, because they were speaking with a heart and a heart: \"Tell us, by what authority do you do these things?\" That is, if you say it, we honor you; if you say it, we revere you; if you say it, we entreat you—this seems to sound from one heart; but from the other (for there was a double one there): if you say it, we slander you; if you say it, we will find something to hold against you; if you say it, we will find something to accuse you of. Such are enemies. But let them be confounded by the lamp.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":70,"ref":"p70","source":"Modo illos videbitis confundi. Et bene, quia tempus agimus lucernarium, confundantur inimici Christi per lucernam, quam paravit Christo suo Pater. Ille enim lucerna erat ardens, ipse Dominus ait. Quid ergo istis respondit dicentibus: Dic nobis, in qua potestate ista facis? interrogabo et ego unum sermonem. Dicite mihi: Joannis baptismus unde est? De coelo, an ex hominibus? Illi autem perturbati apud se: Si dixerimus: De coelo, dicturus est nobis: Quare non credidistis ei? Id est, ut quid me interrogatis, in qua potestate ista facio, quando de me ille perhibuit testimonium, quem vos interrogastis? Ergo si dixerimus: De coelo, dicet nobis: Quare non credidistis ei? Si dixerimus: Ex hominibus, timemus populum; omnes enim Joannem tanquam prophetam habebant (Matth. xxi, 24-27), hac timentes populum, hac timentes veritatem, hinc timidi, hinc invidi, ubique caeci responderunt: Nescimus. Prolata est lucerna, fugerunt tenebrae. Etenim, quamvis praesentes essent corpore, fugerunt corde dicendo se nescire quod sciebant. Indicium fugae cordis timor. Timebant a populo lapidari, si dicerent ex hominibus baptismum Joannis; timebant a Christo convinci, si dicerent de coelo baptismum Joannis. Fugerunt confusi. Nominato ergo Joanne timuerunt, conturbati tacuerunt. Et ille: Nec ego dicam vobis, in qua potestate ista facio.","english":"In a moment you will see them confounded. And rightly so, for we are observing the hour of the lamp—let the enemies of Christ be confounded by the lamp that the Father prepared for his Christ. For that lamp was burning, as the Lord himself says. So what did he answer those who said: Tell us, by what authority do you do these things? I will ask you one question. Tell me: the baptism of John, where was it from? From heaven, or from men? But they, disturbed among themselves: If we say, From heaven, he will say to us: Why then did you not believe him? That is, why do you question me about the authority by which I do these things, when he bore testimony about me, and you questioned him? Therefore if we say, From heaven, he will say to us: Why did you not believe him? If we say, From men, we fear the people; for all held John as a prophet (Mt 21:24-27)—fearing the people on one side, fearing the truth on the other, timid here, envious there, blind everywhere, they answered: We do not know. The lamp was brought out, and the darkness fled. For although they were present in body, they fled in heart by saying they did not know what they knew. The proof of the heart's flight was fear. They were afraid of being stoned by the people if they said John's baptism was from men; they were afraid of being convicted by Christ if they said John's baptism was from heaven. They fled in confusion. So when John was named, they were afraid and, troubled, fell silent. And he said: Neither will I tell you by what authority I do these things.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":71,"ref":"p71","source":"Parata est ergo lucerna Christo Domino nostro Joannes Baptista. Inimici ejus calumniosi interrogatores prolato lucernae lumine confusi recesserunt. impletum est: Inimicos ejus induam confusione. Nos autem, fratres, et per Joannem Baptistam praecursorem agnoscentes Dominum, imo et per ipsius Domini testimonium, de quo ait: Habeo testimonium majus Joanne, credentes in Christum efficiamur corpus capitis ipsius, ut unus Christus sit caput et corpus, et in omnibus nobis unum factis implebitur: Super ipsum autem florebit sanctificatio mea.\n\nSERMO XII.\n\nIn vigiliis Apostolorum Petri et Pauli.\n\nSYNOPSIS.\n\nI. Petrus a Domino de dilectione ter interrogatus.\n\nII. Contra eos, qui gregem Domini dividunt. III. Contra Donatistas gregem Domini Africa concludentes. IV. Donatistae magis caeci quam Judaei. V. Dehortatio a Schismate.\n\nOmnia. quae modo leguntur de sancto Evangelio, post resurrectionem Domini gesta et dicta sunt. Audivimus ergo Dominum Jesum Christum interrogantem Apostolum Petrum, interrogantem autem utrum diligeret eum (Joan. xxi). Interrogabat ergo Dominus servum, magister discipulum, creator hominem, redemptor liberatum, firmitas trepidum, praescius ignarum, et ubi se faciebat interrogantem, ibi ostendebat docentem. Non enim aliquid Christus nesciret, quod Petrus in corde gestaret. Interrogat semel. Respondet ille; nec sufficit.","english":"Therefore the lamp was prepared for Christ our Lord: John the Baptist. His enemies, the slanderous interrogators, when the light of the lamp was brought forth, withdrew confounded. It was fulfilled: I will clothe my enemies with confusion. But we, brothers, recognizing the Lord both through John the Baptist his forerunner, and indeed through the testimony of the Lord himself, of whom he said: I have a testimony greater than John, let us believe in Christ and become the body of our head, so that there may be one Christ, head and body, and, having become one in all of us, there will be fulfilled: But upon him my sanctification will flourish.\n\nSERMON XII.\n\nOn the vigil of the Apostles Peter and Paul.\n\nSYNOPSIS.\n\nI. Peter is asked three times by the Lord about his love.\n\nII. Against those who divide the Lord's flock. III. Against the Donatists, who confine the Lord's flock to Africa. IV. The Donatists are blinder than the Jews. V. A dissuasion from schism.\n\nAll that is now read from the holy Gospel was done and said after the resurrection of the Lord. We have therefore heard the Lord Jesus Christ questioning the Apostle Peter—questioning him as to whether he loved him (John xxi). The Lord therefore questioned the servant, the master the disciple, the creator the man, the redeemer the one set free, firmness the trembling one, the foreknowing the ignorant one; and where he made himself the questioner, there he showed himself the teacher. For Christ did not fail to know anything that Peter was carrying in his heart. He asks once. He answers; and it is not enough.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":72,"ref":"p72","source":"Interrogat iterum; nec aliud, sed hoc, quod interrogaverat, hoc idem etiam ille respondet. Tertio repetitur interrogatio, tertio respondet dilectio. Ille enim ter interrogabatur propter amorem, qui ter negaverat per timorem. Cum Dominus moreretur, timuit, timuit, et negavit; resurgens autem Dominus amorem inseruit, timorem fugavit. Quid enim jam timeret Petrus? Nam, quando negavit, utique ideo negavit, quia mori timuit. Resurgente Domino quid timeret, in quo mortem mortuam reperiret? Certe ille nempe ipse interrogabat vivus, qui sepultus est mortuus. Ille aderat, qui in ligno pependerat. Quando judicabatur Dominus noster Jesus Christus a Judaeis, tunc Petrus interrogatus, et, quod pejus est, a muliere, et, quod est dedecorosius, ab ancilla, timuit, et negavit. Sub ancilla trepidavit, sub Domino fortiter stetit. Confitenti autem amorem suum semel, et iterum, et tertio oves suas commendavit. Diligis me? inquit. Domine, tu scis quia amo te. Et ille; Pasce agnos meos (Ibid. 16). Hoc semel, hoc iterum, hoc tertio; tanquam non esset, ubi ostenderet Petrus amorem suum in Christum, nisi esset pastor fidelis sub Principe omnium pastorum. Amos me? Amo (Ibid. 17). Et quid mihi praestiturus es amans me? Quid mihi collaturus es homo creatori tuo? Quid collaturus es de amore tuo redemptus redemptori tuo, ut multum, miles regi tuo? Quid es collaturus? H(??)c solum exigo.","english":"He asks again; and he answers nothing else, but the very thing he had been asked, this same thing he answers. A third time the question is repeated, a third time he answers with love. For he was asked three times about love, who had denied three times through fear. When the Lord was dying, he feared, he feared, and he denied; but the Lord rising again implanted love, put fear to flight. For what would Peter now fear? For when he denied, he certainly denied for this reason, because he feared to die. With the Lord rising again, what would he fear, in whom he would find death dead? Surely that same one was questioning him alive, who had been buried dead. He was present, who had hung on the wood. When our Lord Jesus Christ was being judged by the Jews, then Peter was questioned, and—what is worse—by a woman, and—what is more shameful—by a maidservant, he feared, and he denied. He trembled before a maidservant; he stood bravely before the Lord. But to him confessing his love once, and again, and a third time, he commended his sheep. Do you love me? he says. Lord, you know that I love you. And he: Feed my lambs. This once, this again, this a third time; as if there were no other way for Peter to show his love for Christ, unless he were a faithful shepherd under the Prince of all shepherds. Do you love me? I love you. And what will you bestow on me by loving me? What will you, a man, confer on your Creator? What will you, redeemed, confer on your Redeemer from your love—how much, a soldier on your King? What are you going to confer? This alone I require.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":73,"ref":"p73","source":"Pasce oves meas (Ibid.).\n\nVidete tamen, fratres, propter homines servos malos, qui de grege Domini peculia sibi fecerunt, et quod non emerant, diviserunt. Extiterunt enim quidam servi infideles, diviserunt gregem Christi, et de grege ipsius quodam modo furtis suis peculia sibi fecerunt, et audis eos dicere: Oves meae sunt illae. Quid quaeris ad oves meas? Non te inveniam ad oves meas. Si et nos dicamus meas, et illi dicant suas, perdidit Christus oves suas. Ponite vobis ante oculos Principem pastorum. Dominum gregis sui stantem, et discernentem, et dijudicantem inter servos suos. Tu quid dicis? Oves meae sunt istae. Et tu quid dicis? Istae sunt oves meae. Quas ego emi, ubi sunt? Servi mali! oves vestras dicitis, et, quod emi, vobis vindicatis, cum vos, si non emerem, periretis? Nos, absit ut dicamus vos oves nostras! Non est ista vox catholica, non est germana, non est Petri, quia est contra Petram. Oves estis, sed illius, qui emit et nos, et vos. Unum Dominum habemus. Pastor est, sed non conductus. Suas pascit, et, quod nemo facit de ovibus, et pretium dedit, et instrumentum confecit. Quaere pretium. Sanguis ipsius est. Quaere instrumentum. Evangelium est, quod modo, cum recitaretur, audistis. Quid dixit Petro? Amas me? Amo. Pasce oves meas. Numquid tuas? Vultis noscere, cui dicat tuas? Audite in Libro sancto, qui vocatur Canticum Canticorum.","english":"Feed my sheep (Ibid.).\n\nBut see to it, brothers, on account of wicked servants among men, who have made a private possession for themselves out of the Lord's flock, and what they had not bought, they divided. For certain unfaithful servants have arisen, they divided Christ's flock, and from his own flock in a certain manner by their thefts they made a private possession for themselves, and you hear them say: Those sheep are mine. What do you seek at my sheep? I will not find you at my sheep. If both we say \"mine\" and they say \"theirs,\" Christ has lost his sheep. Set before your eyes the Prince of shepherds, the Lord of his flock, standing and discerning and judging between his servants. What do you say? Those sheep are mine. And what do you say? These are my sheep. Those whom I bought, where are they? Wicked servants! You call them your sheep, and what I bought, you claim for yourselves, when you, if I had not bought you, would perish? We—far be it from us to call you our sheep! That is not the catholic voice, it is not the genuine one, it is not Peter's, because it is against the Rock. You are sheep, but of him who bought both us and you. We have one Lord. He is a shepherd, but not a hired one. He feeds his own, and—what no one does for sheep—he both paid the price and prepared the instrument. Seek the price. It is his blood. Seek the instrument. It is the Gospel, which you have just heard when it was read. What did he say to Peter? Do you love me? I love. Feed my sheep. Surely not yours? Do you wish to know to whom he says \"yours\"? Listen in the holy Book, which is called the Song of Songs.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":74,"ref":"p74","source":"Leguntur ibi sancta Amatoria: Sponsus et Sponsa, Christus et Ecclesia. Et ille totus Liber quasi Carmen est Nuptiarum, quomodo dicunt Epithalamium, sed cubilis sancti, cubilis casti. In sole enim posuit tabernaculum suum, hoc est, in luce, in publico, ubi pateret, et non lateret, Et ipse tanquam sponsus processit de thalamo suo (Psal. xviii, 6). Accepit enim conjugem, humanam carnem. Thalamus ejus erat uterus virginalis. Illic sibi conjunxit Ecclesiam, ut impleretur, quod ante praedictum est: Et erunt duo in carne una (Gen. ii, 21, et Matth. xix, 5).\n\nLoquebantur ergo inter se amantes isti, Christus et Ecclesia. Ait illi Ecclesia: Annuntia mihi, quem dilexit anima mea, ubi pascis, ubi cubas in meridie? Quare volo, et annunties mihi, Ubi pascis, ubi cubas in meridie? Ne forte fiam sicut operta super greges sodalium tuorum. Ideo, inquit, volo, ut annunties mihi, Ubi pascis, ubi cubas in meridie, ut quando ad te venio, non errem, Ne forte quasi operta fiam super greges soladium tuorum (Cant, i. 6), id est, irruam in greges non tuos, sed sodalium tuorum, Velut operta. Quid est aliud Operta, nisi quasi latens et ignorata? Solent Donatistae in his verbis dicere sensum suum, non sensum Scripturarum. Hoc enim solent dicere: Africa meridies est, meridies mundi Africa est; ideo Ecclesia interrogat Dominum, Ubi pascis, ubi cubas?","english":"There the holy love songs are read: the Bridegroom and the Bride, Christ and the Church. And that whole book is, as it were, a song of marriage, what they call an epithalamium, but of a holy bridal chamber, a chaste bridal chamber. For he has set his tabernacle in the sun, that is, in the light, in public, where it might be open and not hidden, and he himself went forth as a bridegroom from his chamber (Ps. 18:6). For he took a wife, human flesh. His bridal chamber was the virginal womb. There he joined the Church to himself, that what was foretold might be fulfilled: And the two shall be one flesh (Gen. 2:21; Matt. 19:5).\n\nSo these lovers spoke to one another, Christ and the Church. The Church says to him: Tell me, you whom my soul has loved, where you pasture, where you lie down at midday? Why do I wish that you tell me, where you pasture, where you lie down at midday? Lest perhaps I become like one covered over upon the flocks of your companions. Therefore, she says, I wish that you tell me, where you pasture, where you lie down at midday, so that when I come to you I may not wander, lest perhaps I become as one covered over upon the flocks of your companions (Song 1:6), that is, lest I rush in upon flocks that are not yours but your companions', as one covered over. What else is covered over but, as it were, hidden and unknown? The Donatists are accustomed in these words to state their own meaning, not the meaning of the Scriptures. For this is what they usually say: Africa is the midday, Africa is the midday of the world; therefore the Church asks the Lord, where you pasture, where you lie down?","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":75,"ref":"p75","source":"et respondet ille, In meridie; quasi: Noli me quaerere, nisi in Africa. Lege, et intellige, Mens haeretica, Speculum tibi proponitur modo. Hic te inveni. Intellige, quia adhuc Sponsa interrogat. Quare facis jam respondentem Sponsum? Vel foemininum genus agnosce. Ubi pascis, ubi cubas in meridie? Ne forte fiam sicut operta. Operta, puto, foemina est, non masculus. Ergo, o Domine, sit meridies Africa. Sic intelligatur, quomodo ipsi intelligunt. Africa est meridies. Hic facta est pars Donatistae. Hic magna divisio, et serra dissensionis ducta est per gregem Christi. Ideo interrogat velut Ecclesia transmarina, ubi non est facta ista divisio: Annuntia mihi, quem dilexit anima mea, ubi pascis, ubi cubas in meridie? Audio enim ibi dici partem Donati, alios Catholicos, alios Donatistas. Mihi annuntia, ubi pascis, ne veniam, et errem ibi. Quaero nuntium, ubi timeo incertum. Annuntia mihi, ubi pascis, ubi cubas in meridie? Quare volo ut annunties mihi? Ne forte fiam sicut operta, quia parti Donati quasi operta sum, quasi ignorata sum. Ibi praedicor, et illos latet.","english":"And he answers, \"At midday\"; that is, as if to say: Do not seek me except in Africa. Read, and understand, O heretical Mind: a Mirror is set before you now. Here I have found you. Understand that the Bride is still asking. Why do you make the Bridegroom answer already? Or rather, recognize the feminine gender. \"Where you feed, where you lie down at midday?\" Lest perhaps I become like one covered. One covered, I think, is a woman, not a male. Therefore, O Lord, let Africa be the midday. Let it be understood as they themselves understand it. Africa is the midday. Here the party of Donatus was made. Here there is a great division, and the saw of dissension has been drawn through the flock of Christ. Therefore she asks, as the Church from across the sea, where that division was not made: Tell me, whom my soul has loved, where you feed, where you lie down at midday? For I hear that there the party of Donatus is spoken of, some Catholics, some Donatists. Tell me where you feed, lest I come and go astray there. I seek a messenger, where I fear what is uncertain. Tell me where you feed, where you lie down at midday? Why do I want you to tell me? Lest perhaps I become like one covered, because I am, as it were, covered by the party of Donatus, as it were, unknown. There I am preached, and it lies hidden from them.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":76,"ref":"p76","source":"Haec dicunt Scripturae: Erit in novissimis temporibus manifestus mons Domini paratus in cacumine montium, et exaltabitur super colles, et venient ad eum universae gentes (Isai. ii, 2). Mons dicitur, et parti Donati opertus est mons. Qui offendit in lapidem, ignoscendum est illi. Qui offendit in montem, quales oculos habet? Fratres mei! Excusabiliores sunt Judaei. Judaei enim in lapidem offenderunt, Haeretici in montem offendunt. Quomodo offenderunt Judaei in lapidem? Quia adhuc Christus, quando patiebatur, parvulus erat, et dictum est: Offenderunt in lapidem offensionis (Rom. ix, 32). Daniel autem sanctus vidit visum, et scripsit, quod vidit, et ait vidisse se lapidem praecisum De monte sine manibus (Dan. ii, 34). Christus est de gente Judaeorum veniens. Erat enim et ille mons, quia regnum habet. Quid est Sine manibus? Sine opere humano lapis praecisus, quia masculinum opus non accessit ad Virginem, ut nasceretur sine opere humano. Lapis praecisus De monte sine manibus, et confregit statuam, in qua significabantur regna terrarum. Et quid dictum est? Iste est lapis, in quem offenderunt Judaei, Offenderunt in lapidem offensionis. Quis est mons, in quem offenderunt haeretici? Audi ipsum Danielem. Et crevit lapis ille, ait, et factus est mons magnus, ita ut impleret universam faciem terrae (Ibid. 35).","english":"The Scriptures say these things: In the last times the mountain of the Lord will be manifest, prepared on the summit of the mountains, and it will be exalted above the hills, and all nations will come to it (Isa. 2:2). It is called a mountain, and the mountain is hidden from the party of Donatus. He who stumbles against the stone must be forgiven. He who stumbles against the mountain—what kind of eyes does he have? My brothers! The Jews are more excusable. For the Jews stumbled against the stone; the heretics stumble against the mountain. How did the Jews stumble against the stone? Because Christ, while he was still suffering, was as yet small, and it was said: They stumbled against the stone of stumbling (Rom. 9:32). But the holy Daniel saw a vision and wrote what he saw, and said that he had seen a stone cut from the mountain without hands (Dan. 2:34). Christ is he who comes from the people of the Jews. For that was also a mountain, because it has a kingdom. What is \"without hands\"? The stone was cut without human work, because no male work came to the Virgin, so that he might be born without human work. The stone was cut from the mountain without hands, and it shattered the statue, in which the kingdoms of the earth were signified. And what was said? This is the stone against which the Jews stumbled: They stumbled against the stone of stumbling. Who is the mountain against which the heretics stumbled? Hear Daniel himself. And that stone, he says, grew and became a great mountain, so that it filled the whole face of the earth (Dan. 2:35).","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":77,"ref":"p77","source":"Merito Psalmus Christo Domino resurgenti ait: Exaltare super coelos, Deus, et super omnem terram gloria tua. Quid est Super omnem terram gloria tua? Super omnem terram Ecclesia tua, super omnem terram sponsa tua. Et tamen dicit: Annuntia mihi, quem dilexit anima mea! Jam ubique sum, jam omnes terras teneo, et Afris Operta sum. Ergo annuntia mihi, ne forte fiam sicut operta super greges, non ovium tuarum, sed sodalium tuorum. Sodales enim fecerunt schismata. Qui sunt sodales? Qui ad mensam Domini accesserunt, de quibus dicit alio loco Psalmus: Qui edebat panes meos (Psal, cvii, 6); de quibus dicit: Si inimicus exprobrasset mihi, sustinuissem utique, et, si is, q(??) oderat me, super me magna locutus fuisset, absconderem me utique ab eo (Id. xl, 10). Tu vero, homo unanimis, dux meus, et notus meus, qui simul mecum dulces capiebas cibos, in domo Domini ambulavimus cum consensu (Id. liv, 13-15). Aliquando cum consensu, modo cum dissensu, quia sine sensu. Hi sunt sodales, quos timebat illa, ne in illos incideret. Timeo, inquit, ne errem; timeo, ne quasi Operta irruam in greges sodalium tuorum, ne errando peream; ne baptismum, quem accepi, iterando totum perdam.","english":"Rightly does the Psalm say to Christ the Lord rising again: Be exalted above the heavens, O God, and your glory above all the earth. What is “your glory above all the earth”? Your Church above all the earth, your bride above all the earth. And yet she says: Tell me, whom my soul has loved! I am already everywhere, I already hold all lands, and I am hidden from the Africans. Therefore tell me, lest perhaps I become like one hidden among the flocks—not of your sheep, but of your companions. For companions have made schisms. Who are the companions? Those who came to the table of the Lord, of whom the Psalm says in another place: He who ate my bread; of whom it says: If an enemy had reproached me, I would surely have borne it, and if he who hated me had spoken great things against me, I would surely have hidden myself from him. But you, a man of one mind, my guide and my acquaintance, who together with me took sweet food, we walked in the house of the Lord with consent. At one time with consent, now with dissent, because without sense. These are the companions whom she feared, lest she fall among them. I fear, she says, lest I go astray; I fear lest, as one hidden, I rush in among the flocks of your companions, lest by going astray I perish; lest by repeating the baptism which I have received, I destroy the whole.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":78,"ref":"p78","source":"Audistis sollicitudinem Sponsae, audite responsum Sponsi. Cum hoc dictum esset a Sponsa, continuo Sponsus: Nisi cognoveris temetipsam, o pulchra inter mulieres (Cant. i, 7). Catholica, pulchra inter haereses! Nisi cognoveris temetipsam, nisi attenderis ibi te nosse, ubi me didicisti, nisi Scripturas meas praeposueris humanis rumoribus, nisi te cognoveris, quia ubique es; nisi te cognoveris, quia tu designata es, ubi dictum est; Postula a me, et dabo tibi gentes haereditatem tuam (Psal. ii, 8); nisi ergo cognoveris te met ipsam, quid? Exi tu! Nisi cognoveris, exi! Malum verbum, luctuosum verbum: Exi! Avertat Deus a nobis! Videte, de quibus dictum est: Ex nobis exierunt, sed non erant ex nobis (1 Joan. ii, 19). Malo servo dicitur: Exi, quia Servus non manet in domo in aeternum, filius manet in aeternum (Joan. viii, 35). Vultis videre, quia malo servo dicitur: Exi? Bono servo quid dicitur? Intra in gaudium Domini tui (Matth. xxv. 21). Ergo unusquisque, qui audit, unusquisque, qui membrum est Sponsae ejus, timeat quod dicitur; Nisi cognoveris temetipsam, o pulchra inter mulieres, exi tu in vestigiis gregum (Cant. i, 7). Quid est In vestigiis gregum. Per errores hominum, non in voce Pastoris. Nos, fratres, non exeamus In vestigiis gregum? Habemus vestigia Pastoris, quae sequendo non erramus.","english":"You have heard the bride’s anxiety; hear the bridegroom’s answer. When this had been said by the bride, the bridegroom immediately says: If you do not know yourself, O fair among women. Catholic, fair among heresies! If you do not know yourself, if you have not paid attention to knowing yourself there where you learned me, if you have not preferred my Scriptures to human rumors, if you do not know yourself, that you are everywhere; if you do not know yourself, that you are the one designated where it is said: Ask of me, and I will give you the nations as your inheritance; if, then, you do not know yourself, what? Go out! If you do not know, go out! A harsh word, a mournful word: Go out! May God avert it from us! See concerning whom it is said: They went out from us, but they were not of us. To the wicked servant it is said: Go out, because the servant does not remain in the house forever; the son remains forever. Do you wish to see that it is said to the wicked servant: Go out? What is said to the good servant? Enter into the joy of your lord. Therefore let each one who hears, each one who is a member of his bride, fear what is said: If you do not know yourself, O fair among women, go out in the footsteps of the flocks. What is “in the footsteps of the flocks”? Through the errors of men, not in the voice of the Shepherd. Brothers, let us not go out in the footsteps of the flocks. We have the footsteps of the Shepherd; by following them we do not go astray.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":79,"ref":"p79","source":"Christus pro nobis passus est, relinquens nobis exemplum, ut sequamur vestigia ejus (1 Petr. ii, 21). Ergo, nisi cognoveris temetipsam, exi tu in vestigiis gregum, et pasce haedos tuos (Cant, i, 7). Et Hoedos, et tuos. Nostis oves ad dexteram, hoedos ad sinistram. Et pasce hoedos tuos. Quare Hoedos tuos? Quia exis, pascis, sicut Donatus, Hoedos tuos. Si autem non exis, pascis, sicut Petrus, Oves meas (Joan. xxi, 17).\n\nSERMO XIII.\n\nIn Natali Laurentii martyris.\n\nSYNOPSIS.\n\nI. Laus S. Laurentii, et quomodo agenda Festa martyrum. II. Martyrum exemplum stimulus ad bene vivendum, et vigilandum contra diabolum. III. Nos potius Abrahae filii, quam Judaei. IV. Contra eos, qui Martyrum Memorias intemperantia profanant. V. Afflictis Pauli exemplum proponitur. VI. Charitas materna in Paulo, et magis in divina Sapientia. VII. Bona opera parit necessitas. VIII. Vita isthaec perpetua pugna est cum morte. IX. Bona vitae aeternae captum nostrum excedunt. X. Mutuum Orationis suffragium commendatur.","english":"Christ suffered for us, leaving us an example, that we should follow his footsteps (1 Pet. 2:21). Therefore, unless you know yourself, go out in the footsteps of the flocks, and feed your kids (Cant. 1:7). Both the kids, and your own. You know the sheep on the right, the kids on the left. And feed your kids. Why your kids? Because you go out, you feed, like Donatus, your kids. But if you do not go out, you feed, like Peter, my sheep (John 21:17).\n\nSERMON XIII.\n\nOn the Birthday of Laurence the Martyr.\n\nSYNOPSIS.\n\nI. The praise of St. Laurence, and how the feasts of the martyrs are to be observed. II. The example of the martyrs as a spur to living well, and to watching against the devil. III. We are rather the sons of Abraham than the Jews. IV. Against those who profane the memorials of the martyrs by intemperance. V. The example of Paul is set before the afflicted. VI. Maternal charity in Paul, and more so in the divine Wisdom. VII. Necessity gives birth to good works. VIII. This life is a perpetual struggle with death. IX. The goods of eternal life exceed our grasp. X. Mutual support of prayer is commended.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":80,"ref":"p80","source":"Propter fastidium auditoris sermo subtrahendus fuit, sed propter obsequium Martyris exhibendus. Ita ergo adjuvante Domino moderabitur, ut nec onerosus sit, nec forte diminutus, quantum sufficientiae satis est. Illuxit dies Romae solemnissimus, qui magna frequentia populi celebratur. Adjungimur nos, quamvis absentes corpore, praesentes tamen spiritu fratribus nostris in uno corpore sub uno capite. Neque enim, ubi sepulcrum corporis ejus est, ibi tantum memoria meriti ejus. Devotio ubique debetur. Caro uno loco ponitur, sed spiritus victor cum illo est, qui ubique est. Erat beatus Laurentius in corpore, sicut accepimus, adolescens, vir gravis in animo, quem multum commendabat aetas viridior, corona immarcescibilior. Erat autem diaconus, officio inferior episcopo, corona aequatus Apostolo. Haec autem solemnitas omnium Martyrum gloriosorum ad hoc instituta est in Ecclesia, ut ad imitationem, qui non viderunt patientes, adducantur fide, commemorentur solemnitate. Excideret enim fortasse de cordibus hominum, quod non anniversariis ordo repeteret. Et non omnium martyrum ubique possunt esse ferventes solemnitates, nam quotidie non deessent. Non enim vel unus dies inveniri in anni cursu potest, quo non per diversa Martyres coronati sunt. Sed ferventiores solemnitates, si continuae essent, afferrent fastidium; intervalla autem renovant affectum.","english":"Because of the hearer's distaste the sermon had to be shortened, but because of the honor due the Martyr it had to be delivered. So then, with the Lord's help, it will be moderated in such a way that it is neither burdensome nor perhaps unduly diminished, as much as is enough for sufficiency. The most solemn day has dawned at Rome, which is celebrated with a great crowd of people. We are joined, though absent in body, yet present in spirit, to our brothers in one body under one head. For it is not only where the sepulcher of his body is that the memory of his merit is. Devotion is owed everywhere. The flesh is laid in one place, but the victorious spirit is with him who is everywhere. Blessed Laurence was, as we have received, a young man in body, a man grave in soul, whom his greener age commended much, and his crown more unfading. He was moreover a deacon, inferior to the bishop in office, equaled to the Apostle in crown. But this solemnity of all the glorious Martyrs was instituted in the Church for this purpose, that those who did not see them suffering might be led to imitation by faith, and might be reminded by the solemnity. For it might perhaps slip from the hearts of men, because the order of anniversaries would not repeat it. And the fervent solemnities of all the martyrs cannot be everywhere, for daily they would not be lacking. For not even one day can be found in the course of the year on which martyrs have not been crowned in various places. But more fervent solemnities, if they were continuous, would bring distaste; intervals, however, renew affection.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":81,"ref":"p81","source":"Nos tantum audiamus quod jussum est, attendamus quod promissum est. In cujuslibet Martyris solemnitate ita praeparemus cor nostrum festivitati ejus, ut non separemur ab imitatione ejus.\n\nHomo enim erat, et nos homines sumus. A quo ille factus est, ab ipso et nos. Quo pretio emptus est, ipso et nos. Non debet itaque homo Christianus dicere: Quare ergo? Imo non debet dicere: Ego non. Sed: Quare et ego non? Audistis beatum Cyprianum martyrum et exemplum et tubam: In persecutione, inquit, militia, in pace conscientia coronatur. Nemo ergo sibi putet deesse tempus. Non semper adest tempus passionis, semper autem est devotionis. Nec se quisquam infirmum putet, ubi Deus vires operatur, ne, cum sibi timet, de ipso operatore desperet. Propterea id exemplis Martyrum omnes aetates Deus esse voluit, et utrumque sexum. Coronati sunt senes, coronati sunt juvenes, coronati adolescentes, coronati pueri, coronati viri, coronatae foeminae. Et in foeminis omnis aetas coronata est, nec dixit foemina: Impar sum sexu ad devincendum diabolum. Attendit magis hostem dejiciendum, a quo dejecta est, et expugnandum fide, cui consenserat seductione. Numquid et feminae de suis viribus praesumpserunt? Omni enim homini dictum est: Quid enim habes, quod non accepisti (1 Cor. iv, 7)? Gloria ergo Martyrum gloria Christi praecedentis Martyres, implentis Martyres, coronantis Martyres.","english":"Let us only hear what has been commanded, let us attend to what has been promised. On the solemnity of any Martyr, let us so prepare our heart for his festivity that we are not separated from his imitation.\n\nFor he was a man, and we are men. By the one who made him, we too were made. At the price by which he was bought, we too were bought. A Christian man, therefore, ought not to say: Why then? Indeed he ought not to say: Not I. But: Why not I too? You have heard blessed Cyprian, both an example and a trumpet of the martyrs: In persecution, he says, it is warfare; in peace, the conscience is crowned. Let no one therefore think that time is lacking to him. The time of passion is not always present, but the time of devotion always is. Nor let anyone think himself weak where God works strength, lest, while he fears for himself, he despair of the very one who works. For this reason God willed that all ages and both sexes be [represented] by the examples of the Martyrs. Old men have been crowned, young men have been crowned, youths have been crowned, boys have been crowned, men have been crowned, women have been crowned. And in women every age has been crowned, nor did a woman say: I am unequal in sex to conquering the devil. She considered rather the enemy to be cast down, by whom she had been cast down, and to be conquered by faith, to whom she had consented by seduction. Did women, then, also presume on their own strength? For to every man it has been said: What do you have that you did not receive (1 Cor. 4:7)? The glory of the Martyrs, therefore, is the glory of Christ going before the Martyrs, filling the Martyrs, crowning the Martyrs.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":82,"ref":"p82","source":"Verumtamen, quamvis alio sit tempore pax, alio persecutio, deest alicui tempori occulta? Nunquam deest. Leo ille draco, nec semper saevit, nec semper insidiatur, sed semper persequitur. Quando saevitia est aperta, non sunt occultae insidiae. Quando occultae sunt insidiae, non est aperta saevitia. Id est, quando ut leo rugit, non ut draco serpit. Quando ut draco serpit, non ut leo rugit; tamen, quia aut leo est, aut draco, semper persequitur. Quando tacet fremitus, insidias cave. Quando insidiae produntur, in fremitu leonem devita. Et leo autem, et draco devitatur, si semper cor in Christo servetur. Quidquid in hac vita metuendum est, transiturum est. In alia vero vita, et quod amandum est, non transit, et quod timendum est, non transit.\n\nCerte modo in Evangelio Dominus alloquebatur Judaeos, et dicebat eis: Vae vobis, Scribae, et Pharisaei! quia extruitis monumenta Prophetarum, et dicitis: Si essemus tempore patrum nostrorum, non consentiremus eis in necem Prophetarum. Certe testimonium perhibetis, quia filii estis eorum, qui occiderunt Prophetas. Et vos implebitis mensuram patrum vestrorum. Cum enim dixissent: Si essemus tempore patrum nostrorum, non consentiremus eis in necem Prophetarum (Matth. xxiii, 29, 32), confirmaverunt se filios esse illorum.","english":"Yet, although at one time there is peace and at another persecution, is any time without hidden danger? Never. That lion, that dragon, neither always rages nor always lies in wait, but always persecutes. When his savagery is open, his snares are not hidden. When his snares are hidden, his savagery is not open. That is, when he roars as a lion, he does not creep as a dragon. When he creeps as a dragon, he does not roar as a lion; yet, because he is either a lion or a dragon, he always persecutes. When his roaring is silent, beware of his snares. When his snares are exposed, avoid the lion in his roaring. But both the lion and the dragon are avoided if the heart is always kept in Christ. Whatever in this life is to be feared will pass away. In the other life, however, both what is to be loved does not pass away, and what is to be feared does not pass away.\n\nCertainly just now in the Gospel the Lord was addressing the Jews, and he said to them: Woe to you, Scribes and Pharisees! because you build up the monuments of the Prophets, and you say: If we had been in the time of our fathers, we would not have consented with them to the slaughter of the Prophets. Certainly you bear witness that you are the sons of those who killed the Prophets. And you will fill up the measure of your fathers. For when they had said: If we had been in the time of our fathers, we would not have consented with them to the slaughter of the Prophets (Matt. 23:29, 32), they confirmed that they were the sons of those men.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":83,"ref":"p83","source":"Nos autem, si rectum iter tenemus, non dicimus patres nostros, qui occiderunt Prophetas, sed patres nostros dicimus, qui occisi sunt a patribus illorum. Sicut enim degenerat quisque moribus, sic filius fit moribus. Quia utique, fratres, filii Abrahae dicti sumus, Abrahae nec faciem novimus, nec de genere ejus stirpem carnis ducimus. Quomodo ergo ejus filii? Non in carne, sed in fide. Credidit enim Abraham Deo, et deputatum est illi ad justitiam (Gen. xv, 6). Si ergo justus Abraham, quia credidit, omnes post Abraham imitantes fidem Abraham facti sunt filii Abraham. Judaei ex carne nati degeneraverunt, nos ex alienigenis orti imitando assecuti sumus, quod illi degenerando perdiderunt. Absit ergo, ut pater illorum Abraham, quamvis de carne venerunt Abraham. Patres illorum illi fuerunt, de quibus et ipsi confessi sunt. Si essemus, inquiunt, tempore patrum nostrorum, non eis consentiremus in necem Prophetarum. Quomodo dicis, te non fuisse consensurum eis, quos patres tuos dicis? Si patres erant, filius es. Si filius es, consensurus eras. Si autem consensurus non eras, filius non es. Si filius non es, non sunt illi patres. Dominus ergo ex hoc eos convincit facturos, quod illi fecerunt, quia patres suos eos esse nominaverunt. Certe, inquit, testimonium ipsi perhibetis vobis, quia filii estis eorum, qui occiderunt Prophetas, quia dixistis eos patres vestros.","english":"But we, if we hold to the right path, do not call our fathers those who killed the Prophets, but we call our fathers those who were killed by their fathers. For just as each person degenerates in his conduct, so he becomes a son in his conduct. Because, brothers, we are certainly called sons of Abraham, yet we have not known Abraham's face, nor do we draw the stock of his flesh from his lineage. How then are we his sons? Not in the flesh, but in faith. For Abraham believed God, and it was reckoned to him as righteousness (Gen. 15:6). If therefore Abraham is righteous because he believed, all after Abraham who imitate Abraham's faith have become sons of Abraham. The Jews, born of the flesh, degenerated; we, sprung from foreigners, have attained by imitation what they lost by degenerating. Far be it, then, that Abraham should be their father, although they came from Abraham's flesh. Their fathers were those of whom they themselves also confessed. If we had been, they say, in the time of our fathers, we would not have consented with them to the slaughter of the Prophets. How do you say that you would not have consented with those whom you call your fathers? If they were fathers, you are a son. If you are a son, you would have consented. But if you would not have consented, you are not a son. If you are not a son, they are not fathers. The Lord therefore convicts them by this, that they would do what those did, because they named them as their fathers. Surely, he says, you yourselves bear testimony to yourselves, that you are sons of those who killed the Prophets, because you said that they were your fathers.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":84,"ref":"p84","source":"Et vos implebitis mensuram patrum vestrorum.\n\nEt nunc consideremus, qui sint filii occisorum, et qui sint filii occidentium. Et videtis multos currere ad Memorias Martyrum, benedicere calices suos de Memoriis Martyrum, redire saturatos de Memoriis Martyrum, et tamen discute illos, et invenies inter persecutores Martyrum. Per ipsos enim tumultus, seditiones, saltationes omnis luxuriae, quas odit Deus, et modo, quia illos jam coronatos lapidibus non possunt, calicibus persequuntur. Qui erant, et quorum filii erant, quorum saltationes recenti, et prope hesterna Memoria de loco sancti Martyris Cypriani prohibitae sunt? Certe saltabant ibi, et gaudebant ibi, et solemnitatem ipsam, quasi gauderent, magnis votis expectabant, et ad eum diem semper venire cupiebant. Inter quos numerandi sunt? Inter persecutores Martyrum, an inter filios Martyrum? Apparuerunt, quando prohibiti in seditionem tumuerunt. Filii laudant, persecutores saltant. Filii hymnos dicunt, illi convivia producunt. Non ergo interest, quomodo honorare videantur. Tales enim sunt, qui honorant, quales illi fuerunt, qui dixerunt: Si essemus illis temporibus, non consentiremus patribus nostris in necem Martyrum, aut in necem Prophetarum. Consentite modo fidei Martyrum, et credimus, qui non eratis consensuri interfectoribus Martyrum. Martyres unde coronati sunt?","english":"And you will fill up the measure of your fathers.\n\nAnd now let us consider who are the sons of the slain, and who are the sons of the slayers. And you see many running to the Memorials of the Martyrs, blessing their cups at the Memorials of the Martyrs, returning filled from the Memorials of the Martyrs, and yet examine them, and you will find them among the persecutors of the Martyrs. For through those very uproars, seditions, and dances of every luxury, which God hates, even now, because they cannot stone those who are already crowned, they persecute them with cups. Who were they, and whose sons were they, whose dances were forbidden at the recent and almost yesterday's Memorial of the holy Martyr Cyprian? Surely they were dancing there, and rejoicing there, and they were awaiting that very solemnity with great vows, as if they would rejoice, and they always desired to come to that day. Among whom are they to be counted? Among the persecutors of the Martyrs, or among the sons of the Martyrs? They showed themselves when, having been forbidden, they swelled up into sedition. The sons praise, the persecutors dance. The sons sing hymns, those others prolong their banquets. It does not matter, then, how they seem to honor. For those who honor are such as those were who said: If we had been in those times, we would not have consented with our fathers to the killing of the Martyrs, or to the killing of the Prophets. Consent now to the faith of the Martyrs, and we believe that you would not have been consenting to the killers of the Martyrs. From what were the Martyrs crowned?","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":85,"ref":"p85","source":"Credo, viam Dei ambulando, tolerando, inimicos etiam suos diligendo, pro eis obsecrando. Haec est corona Martyrum, hoc meritum Martyrum. Amas, imitaris, laudas, filius es Martyris. Vitam fers contrariam, referes et tunc manum contrariam.\n\nProinde, dilectissimi, quoniam persecutio, sicut dixi, nunquam deest, et diabolus aut insidiatur, aut saevit, semper parati esse debemus corde fixo in Domino, et, quantum possumus, inter istas molestias, tribulationes, tentationes orare nos fortitudinem a Domino, quoniam per nos ipsi parvi et nulli sumus. Quid de nobis dicamus? Paulum Apostolum, cum legeretur, audistis. Sicut abundant, inquit, passiones Christi in nobis, sic abundat per Christum et consolatio nostra (2 Cor. i, 5). Sicut in Psalmo dicitur: Secundum multitudinem dolorum meorum in corde meo, exhortationes tuae, Domine, jucundaverunt animam meam (Psal. xciii, 19). Quomodo hoc dictum est in Psalmo: Secundum multitudinem dolorum meorum in corde meo, ita exhortationes tuae jucundant animam meam, sic dictum est ab Apostolo: Sicut abundant passiones Christi in nobis, sic abundat per Christum consolatio nostra. Deficeremus, cum adesset persecutio, si deesset consolator. Et quia vires ipsae vel tolerandi, vel quaedam relaxatio vivendi ad tempus propter necessarium ministerium non erant ab ipsis, videte quid dixerit.","english":"I believe, by walking in the way of God, by enduring, by loving even their enemies, by entreating for them. This is the crown of the Martyrs, this is the merit of the Martyrs. You love, you imitate, you praise, you are a son of the Martyr. You lead a contrary life, and you will then bring back a contrary hand.\n\nAccordingly, most beloved, since persecution, as I have said, is never lacking, and the devil either lies in ambush or rages, we ought always to be ready with our heart fixed in the Lord, and, as much as we can, amid these troubles, tribulations, and temptations, to pray to the Lord for strength, since of ourselves we are small and nothing. What shall we say of ourselves? You heard the Apostle Paul when he was read. As, he says, the sufferings of Christ abound in us, so through Christ our consolation also abounds (2 Cor. 1:5). As it is said in the Psalm: According to the multitude of my sorrows in my heart, your exhortations, O Lord, have gladdened my soul (Ps. 93:19). Just as it was said in the Psalm: According to the multitude of my sorrows in my heart, so your exhortations gladden my soul, so it was said by the Apostle: As the sufferings of Christ abound in us, so through Christ our consolation abounds. We would fail when persecution came, if the consoler were absent. And because the very strength either of enduring, or a certain relaxation of living for a time on account of the necessary ministry, was not from themselves, see what he said.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":86,"ref":"p86","source":"Notum vobis facio, fratres, de tribulatione nostra, quae facta est in Asia, quia supra modum et ultra vires gravati sumus (1 Cor, i, 8). Tribulatio illa transcendit vires humanas, numquid et auxilia divina? Supra modum, inquit, et ultra vires gravati sumus. Quantum ultra vires? Vide, quia de animi viribus dicit: Ita, ut taederet nos etiam vivere. Quomodo affectus erat Apostolus multitudine pressuram, ut, quem charitas vivere instigabat, taedium a vita prohiberet! Quomodo eum charitas vivere cogebat, charitas illa, de qua alio loco dicit: Permanere autem in carne necessarium propter vos (Philipp. i, 24). Ecce tanta increverat persecutio, et tanta tribulatio, ut taederet eum etiam vivere. Ecce timor et tremor venerunt super eum, et contexerunt eum tenebrae; sicut audistis, cum diceretur in Psalmo. Vox enim corporis Christi est, vox membrorum Christi. Vis ibi agnoscere vocem tuam? Esto membrum Christi. Timor, inquit, et tremor cecidit super me, et contexerunt me tenebrae. Et dixi: Quis dabit mihi pennas sicut columbae et volabo, et requiescam (Psal. liv, 6, 7)! Nonne hoc videtur dixisse Apostolus, cum ait: Ita, ut taederet nos etiam vivere? Quodam modo taedium passus est a visco carnis, quando volare volebat ad Christum. Abundantia tribulationum infestabat viam, sed non intercludebat.","english":"I make known to you, brothers, concerning our tribulation which happened in Asia, that we were burdened beyond measure and beyond our strength. Did that tribulation surpass human strength, but not also divine aid? Beyond measure, he says, and beyond our strength we were burdened. How far beyond our strength? See that he speaks of the strength of the soul: So that we even grew weary of living. How was the Apostle affected by the multitude of pressing troubles, so that charity, which urged him to live, was checked by weariness of life? How did charity compel him to live—that charity of which he says in another place: But to remain in the flesh is necessary for your sake. Behold, such great persecution had grown, and such great tribulation, that he even grew weary of living. Behold, fear and trembling came upon him, and darkness covered him, as you heard when it was said in the Psalm. For it is the voice of the body of Christ, the voice of the members of Christ. Do you wish to recognize your voice there? Be a member of Christ. Fear, he says, and trembling fell upon me, and darkness covered me. And I said: Who will give me wings like a dove, and I will fly and be at rest! Does not the Apostle seem to have said this, when he said: So that we even grew weary of living? In a certain way he suffered weariness from the birdlime of the flesh, when he wished to fly to Christ. The abundance of tribulations beset the way, but did not block it.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":87,"ref":"p87","source":"Taedebat vivere, sed hoc non in illa aeterna vita, de qua dicit: Mihi vivere Christus est, et mori lucrum (Philipp. i, 21). Sed quia ex charitate hic tenebatur, quid sequitur? Si autem vivere in carne ne hic mihi fructus operis est, et quid eligam, ignoro. Compellor autem duobus concupiscentiam habens dissolvi, et cum Chri- (??)o esse. Quis dabit mihi pennas sicut columbae? Manere autem in carne necessarium propter vos (Ibid. 22- 24). Cesserat susurrantibus pullis suis, tegebat passis alis, fovebat pullos, sicut ipse ait: Factus sum parvulus in medio vestrum, tanquam nutrix fovens filios suos (1 Thess. ii, 7).\n\nEt videte, fratres; modo lectum est in Evangelio: Quoties volui congregare filios tuos, tanquam gallina pullos suos, et noluisti (Matth. xxiii, 37). Attendite gallinam, attendite et alias aves, quae in nostris oculis nidificant. Ova fovent, pullos nutriunt. Nullam videbitis infirmari cum filiis. Videte gallinae habitum, quando pullos alit, quemadmodum mutatur vox ejus, et in quamdam raucedinem frangitur. Pen- (??) ipsae non collectae et alacres, sed hispidae et languidae, ita ut si videas avem aliam, cujus nidum ignores, non agnoscas, an ova habeat, vel pullos. Gallinam autem cum videris, etiamsi ova ejus non videas, nec pullos ejus videas, ex ipsa voce, et habitu corporis intelligas matrem. Quid ergo fecit mater nostra Sapientia?","english":"It wearied him to live, but not in that eternal life of which he says: To me to live is Christ, and to die is gain. But because he was held here by charity, what follows? But if to live in the flesh, this is to me the fruit of my labor, and what I shall choose I know not. For I am constrained by two things, having a desire to be dissolved and to be with Christ. Who will give me wings like a dove? But to remain in the flesh is necessary for your sake. He had yielded to his chirping chicks, he covered them with outstretched wings, he cherished his chicks, as he himself says: I became a little one in the midst of you, as a nurse cherishing her children.\n\nAnd see, brothers; it has just been read in the Gospel: How often would I have gathered your children together, as a hen gathers her chicks under her wings, and you would not. Consider the hen, consider also other birds, which nest before our eyes. They warm their eggs, they feed their chicks. You will see none of them weakened along with her children. See the appearance of the hen when she feeds her chicks, how her voice is changed, and is broken into a kind of hoarseness. Her feathers themselves are not sleek and brisk, but ruffled and drooping, so that if you were to see another bird whose nest you do not know, you would not recognize whether she has eggs or chicks. But when you see a hen, even if you do not see her eggs, nor see her chicks, from her very voice and the bearing of her body you understand that she is a mother. What then did our mother Wisdom do?","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":88,"ref":"p88","source":"In carne infirmata est, ut pullos colligeret, ut generaret, ut foveret; sed infirmum Dei fortius est hominibus. Sub has alas infirmitatis carnis suae, sed sub occultam potentiam Divinitatis suae colligere volebat filios Jerusalem. Hoc Apostolum suum docuerat, quia hoc in illo ipse faciebat. Hoc enim ait ipse Apostolus: Vultis experimentum accipere ejus, qui in me loquitur, Christi (2 Cor. xiii, 3)? Et passiones Christi dicit in se abundasse, non passiones suas, sed passiones Christi. Erat enim im corpore Christi, et erat membrum Christi, et quidquid cum pullis fovendis agebatur in Apostolo, et in membro suo, caput agebat. Hic ergo Apostolus attendens infirmitatem pullorum suorum affectu et desiderio, ut columba, volare cupiebat, sed charitate filiorum, ut gallina, remanebat. Ipsi, inquit, in nobismetipsis responsum mortis habuimus, ut non fidentes in nobis simus, sed in Deo, qui suscitat mortuos, qui de tantis mortibus eruit nos, et eruet, in quem speramus, quoniam et adhuc eruet (Id. i, 9, 10). Eruit, et eruet quid ait? Servat vitam istam nostram vobis. De multis enim mortibus eruit, ne opprimeretur a persecutoribus, ne citius quam pullis opus erat, coronaretur, secundum illud, quod ait: Manere autem in carne necessarium propter vos. Sed hoc confidens, novi, quia manebo, et permanebo omnibus vobis ad profectum vestrum, et gaudium fidei (Philipp. i, 24, 25).","english":"In the flesh he was made weak, so that he might gather the chicks, beget them, and cherish them; but the weakness of God is stronger than men. Under these wings of the weakness of his flesh—but under the hidden power of his divinity—he wished to gather the children of Jerusalem. This he had taught his Apostle, because he himself was doing this in him. For the Apostle himself says: Do you seek a proof of him who speaks in me, Christ? And he says that the sufferings of Christ abounded in him—not his own sufferings, but the sufferings of Christ. For he was in the body of Christ, and was a member of Christ, and whatever was done in the Apostle for the cherishing of the chicks, in him as in his own member, the head was doing. Here, then, the Apostle, attending to the weakness of his chicks with affection and desire, longed to fly like a dove, but for the sake of charity toward his children he remained, like a hen. He says: We ourselves had in ourselves the sentence of death, so that we should not trust in ourselves, but in God, who raises the dead, who delivered us from so many deaths, and will deliver us, in whom we hope, since he will yet deliver us. He delivered, and will deliver—what does he say? He preserves this our life for you. For from many deaths he delivered him, lest he be overwhelmed by persecutors, lest he be crowned sooner than was needful for the chicks, according to that which he says: But to remain in the flesh is necessary for your sake. But confident of this, I know that I shall remain and continue with you all for your progress and joy of faith.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":89,"ref":"p89","source":"Cupiditas ad alium rapiebat, necessitas alibi retinebat. Dissolvi, inquit, et esse cum Christo multo magis optimum (Ibid. 23). Istud non dixit Necessarium, sed optimum. Quod est enim optimum, per se appetitur, quod necessarium, ex necessitate assumitur; inde necessarium nominatur.\n\nNecessariae rei necessitas nomen imposuit. Proinde nunc nobis necessarius cibus est iste, quo utimur; ad sustentandam temporalem vitam necessarius cibus est; ille autem optimus cibus virtutis, et sapientiae, panis vivus, semper efficiens, nunquam deficiens. Ille optimus est, iste necessarius est. Proinde cum transierit ista necessitas famis, et sustentandi mortalis corporis, non erit iste cibus jam necessarius. Quid enim ait Apostolus? Esca ventri, et venter escis; Deus autem et hunc et has evacuabit (1 Cor. vi, 13). Quando autem evacuabit? Quando corpus hoc animale resurgens fit spirituale. Ibi enim nulla erit indigentia, et non ibi erunt opera necessitatis. Omnia enim ista, fratres, et bona, quae hic dicuntur, opera, et ea ipsa opera, quae monemur ut faciamus quotidie, necessitatis opera sunt. Quid tam bonum, quid tam praeclarum, quid tam laudabile Christiano, quam frangere panem esurienti? Egenum sine tecto inducere in domum? Videre nudum, et vestire? Videre mortuum, et sepelire? Videre litigantem, et concordare? Videre infirmum, et visitare, aut curare? Omnia haec laudabilia opera sunt.","english":"Desire was dragging us toward one thing, necessity was holding us back in another. \"To depart,\" he says, \"and to be with Christ is far better\" (Ibid. 23). He did not call that \"necessary,\" but \"best.\" For what is best is sought for its own sake; what is necessary is taken up out of necessity—hence it is called necessary.\n\nNecessity has imposed its name on a necessary thing. Accordingly, the food we now use is necessary to us; it is necessary food for sustaining this temporal life. But that other food of virtue and wisdom, the living bread, always effectual, never failing—that is the best. That is best; this is necessary. Therefore, when this necessity of hunger and of sustaining the mortal body has passed away, this food will no longer be necessary. For what does the Apostle say? \"Food is for the belly, and the belly for foods; but God will do away with both this and these\" (1 Cor. 6:13). But when will he do away with them? When this animal body, rising again, becomes spiritual. For there there will be no want, and the works of necessity will not be there. For all these things, brothers—even the good works that are spoken of here, and those very works that we are admonished to do daily—are works of necessity. What is so good, what so excellent, what so praiseworthy for a Christian as to break bread for the hungry? To bring the destitute without shelter into one's house? To see the naked and clothe them? To see the dead and bury them? To see people quarreling and reconcile them? To see the sick and visit or care for them? All these are praiseworthy works.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":90,"ref":"p90","source":"Attendite et videte, quia necessitas ea peperit. Frangis enim panem, quia vides esurientem. Si nemo esuriret, cui frangeres panem? Tolle necessitatem alterius miseriae, non erit opus tua misericordia. Sed tamen per haec opera, quae necessitas genuit, pervenimus ad illam vitam ubi necessitas non erit, quomodo per navem ad patriam. In patria semper mansuro, nunquam peregrinaturo navis opus non erit; sed illa navis, quae ibi opus non erit, illuc ipsa perducit. Cum perventum fuerit, ista non erunt, sed nisi hic adimpleantur, illuc perveniri non potest. Estote itaque alacres in bonis operibus necessitatis, ut sitis beati in perfruitione illius aeternitatis, ubi jam necessitas moritur, quia mater omnium necessitatum mors ipsa morietur. Oportet enim corruptibile hoc induere incorruptionem, et mortale hoc induere immortalitatem. Quando dicetur morti: Ubi est, mors, victoria tua? ubi est, mors, aculeus tuus (1 Cor. xv, 53-55)? absumptae morti, et devictae dicetur: Quia novissima inimica destruetur mors (Ibid. 26).","english":"Pay attention and see that necessity gave birth to these works. For you break bread because you see someone hungry. If no one were hungry, for whom would you break bread? Remove the misery of another's necessity, and your mercy will have no work to do. But nevertheless, through these works, which necessity has generated, we come to that life where there will be no necessity, just as by a ship we come to our homeland. For one who will always remain in the homeland and will never be a stranger there, the work of a ship will not be needed; but that ship, which will not be needed there, itself brings us there. When we have arrived, these things will not be, but unless they are fulfilled here, one cannot arrive there. Therefore be eager in the good works of necessity, so that you may be blessed in the enjoyment of that eternity, where necessity now dies, because death itself, the mother of all necessities, will die. For this corruptible must put on incorruption, and this mortal must put on immortality. When it is said to death: Where is your victory, O death? Where is your sting, O death? (1 Cor 15:53-55) — to death, consumed and conquered, it will be said: Because the last enemy, death, will be destroyed (Ibid. 26).","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":91,"ref":"p91","source":"Modo autem omnibus necessitatis operibus cum morte pugnatur. Defectus enim omnis ad mortem trahit, et sustentatio omnis a morte revocat, et ita mutabile est corpus, ut quodam modo aliae mortes aliis mortibus pellantur. Quidquid assumitur, ubi diu perseverari non potest, quodam modo inchoatio mortis est. Jam videte istam vitam. Si quidquid assumitur, ubi permaneri diutius non potest; ubi, si diutius permanseris, moreris, inchoatio mortis est, et tamen, nisi assumatur, alia mors non pellitur. Verbi gratia, non manducat. Si manducaverit, et digerit, reficitur. Cum non manducat, assumit jejunium, ut mortem, quam factura erat crapula, repellat a se. Nisi assumpserit abstinentiam et jejunium, non a se illud repellet. Rursus in hoc jejunio, quod assumpsit, ut mortem crapulae repelleret, si perseverare in illo voluerit, aliam mortem famis timebit. Sicut ergo assumpsit jejunium, ut mortem crapulae devitaret, sic assumpturus est cibum, ut mortem jejunii devitet. Quidquid enim horum assumpseris, si in eo perseveras, deficies. Ambulando fatigatus eras, si permanseris in ambulando, fatigatione ipsa deficies, et morieris. Ut ergo non deficias ambulando, requiescis sedendo. Perdura in sedendo, et inde morieris. Somnus te gravis oppresserat; evigilandum est, ne moriaris. Vigilando morieris, nisi rursus dormieris.","english":"But now, in all the works of necessity, we struggle with death. For every lack drags toward death, and every sustenance calls back from death, and the body is so changeable that in a certain way one death is driven out by other deaths. Whatever is taken in, since one cannot remain in it for long, is in a certain way the beginning of death. Now consider this life. If whatever is taken in cannot remain longer—where, if you remain longer, you die—it is the beginning of death, and yet unless it is taken in, another death is not driven out. For example, a man does not eat. If he has eaten and digests, he is refreshed. When he does not eat, he takes up fasting, so as to drive from himself the death that gluttony would have caused. Unless he has taken up abstinence and fasting, he will not drive that from himself. Again, in this fasting that he has taken up to drive out the death of gluttony, if he wishes to persevere in it, he will fear another death, of hunger. Therefore, just as he took up fasting to avoid the death of gluttony, so he must take up food to avoid the death of fasting. For whatever of these you have taken up, if you persevere in it, you will fail. You were tired from walking; if you persist in walking, you will fail from that very fatigue and die. Therefore, so that you do not fail by walking, you rest by sitting. Persist in sitting, and from there you will die. Sleep had weighed heavily upon you; you must wake, lest you die. By staying awake you will die, unless you sleep again.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":92,"ref":"p92","source":"Da mihi, quod assumas in adjutorium in malum, quod gravabat, pellendum, ubi securus ita sis, ut in eo perseverare velis. Quidquid assumpseris, hoc ipsum timendum erit. Ergo in omni mobilitate et mutabilitate defectionum, et adjutoriorum cum morte pugnatur. Cum autem corruptibile hoc induerit incorruptionem, et mortale hoc induerit immortalitatem, dicetur morti: Ubi est, mors, contentio tua? ubi est, mors, aculeus tuus? Videbimus, laudabimus, permanebimus. Nulla erit ibi indigentia, nullum adjutorium requiretur. Non invenis mendicum, cui panem frangas; aut peregrinum, quem in domum recipias. Non invenis sitientem, cui calicem porrigas; nec nudum, quem cooperias; nec aegrotum, quem visites; nec litigantem, quem concordes; nec mortuum, quem sepelias. Omnes cibo justi(??) et potu sapientiae saginantur, omnes immortalitate vestiti sunt, omnes in patria sua aeterna vivunt. Omnium sanitas ipsa aeternitas est, aeterna sanitas, aeterna concordia. Nemo litigat, nemo judicem quaerit, nemo arbitrum compositionis, nemo sententiam ultionis. Nulla aegritudo, nulla mors.","english":"Give me what you may take up as a help for driving out the evil that was weighing upon us, where you may be so secure that you wish to remain in it. Whatever you have taken up, this very thing will have to be feared. Therefore, in all the mobility and mutability of failings and of helps, there is struggle with death. But when this corruptible has put on incorruption, and this mortal has put on immortality, it will be said to death: Where is your contention, O death? Where is your sting, O death? We shall see, we shall praise, we shall remain. There will be no want there, no help will be required. You do not find a beggar whose bread you may break, or a stranger whom you may receive into your house. You do not find a thirsty person to whom you may offer a cup, nor a naked person whom you may clothe, nor a sick person whom you may visit, nor a quarreler whom you may reconcile, nor a dead person whom you may bury. All are fattened with the food of righteousness and the drink of wisdom, all are clothed with immortality, all live forever in their own homeland. The health of all is eternity itself, eternal health, eternal concord. No one quarrels, no one seeks a judge, no one an arbiter of settlement, no one a sentence of vengeance. No sickness, no death.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":93,"ref":"p93","source":"Haec dicere potuimus, quae ibi non erunt; quae vero ibi erunt, quis dicat? Quod nec oculus vidit, nec auris audivit, nec in cor hominis ascendit (1 Cor. ii, 9). Recte ergo Apostolus: Non sunt condignae passiones hujus temporis ad superventuram gloriam, quae revelabitur in nobis (Rom. viii, 18). Quidquid; passus fueris o Christianae, scito nihil esse ad id, quod accepturus es. Certe hoc fide retinemus, de corde tuo hoc non recedat. Non potes hoc capere, ei videre, quid eris, quale ergo erit quod ab eo, qui capturus est, capi non potest? Utique nos erimus, quod erimus, et capere non possumus, quod erimus. Supergreditur omnem infirmitatem nostram, supergreditur omnem cogitationem nostram, supergreditur omnem intellectum nostrum, et tamen nos erimus. Dilectissimi, ait Joannes, filii Dei sumus; utique jam adoptione, fide, pignore. Pignus accepimus, fratres, Spiritum sanctum. Quando fallit, qui tale pignus dedit? Filii Dei, inquit, sumus, et nondum apparuit, quid erimus. Scimus, inquit, quia cum apparuerit, similes ei erimus, quoniam videbimus eum, sicuti est. Dixit: Nondum apparuit, et id, quod Nondum apparuit, non dixit. Nondum apparuit, quod erimus. Diceret: Illud erimus, et tales erimus! Quidquid dicaret, cui diceret? Non audeo dicere: Quis diceret? sed certe: Cui diceret?","english":"We have been able to say these things, which will not be there; but the things that will be there, who could speak of them? What eye has not seen, nor ear heard, nor has it entered into the heart of man (1 Cor. 2:9). Rightly, then, the Apostle says: The sufferings of this present time are not worthy to be compared with the glory that is to come, which will be revealed in us (Rom. 8:18). Whatever you have suffered, O Christian, know that it is nothing compared to what you are to receive. Let us hold this firmly by faith; let it not depart from your heart. You cannot grasp this, nor see what you will be; so what will that be which cannot be grasped by him who is to grasp it? Surely we shall be what we shall be, and we cannot grasp what we shall be. It surpasses all our weakness, it surpasses all our thought, it surpasses all our understanding, and yet we shall be. Beloved, says John, we are the sons of God; surely already by adoption, by faith, by the pledge. We have received the pledge, brothers—the Holy Spirit. When does he deceive, who gave such a pledge? We are, he says, the sons of God, and it has not yet appeared what we shall be. We know, he says, that when it has appeared, we shall be like him, because we shall see him as he is. He said: It has not yet appeared, and what it is that has not yet appeared, he did not say. It has not yet appeared what we shall be. He would say: We shall be that, and we shall be such! Whatever he might say, to whom would he say it? I do not dare to say: Who would say it? but certainly: To whom would he say it?","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":94,"ref":"p94","source":"Et forte enim erat, qui diceret, quia ipse est, qui in Christi pectore recumbebat, et de ejus pectore in illo convivio sapientiam bibebat, qua sapientia saginatus eructavit: In principio erat Verbum (Joan. i, 1). Ergo hoc dixit: Scimus, quia, cum apparuerit, quod erimus, similes ei erimus, quoniam videbimus eum, sicuti est. Cui similes? Utique ei, cujus filii sumus. Dilectissimi, ait. filii Dei sumus, et nondum apparuit, quod erimus. Scimus quia, cum apparuerit, similes ei erimus, cujus filii sumus. Quoniam videbimus eum, sicuti est (1 Joan. iii, 2). Jam modo, si vis esse, cui similis eris, si vis nosse, cui similis eris, attende ipsum, si potes. Nondum potes. Ergo nescis, cui similis eris, propterea nescis, quantum similis eris. Nesciendo ergo adhuc, quod est ille, nescis, quod eris et tu.\n\nHoc ergo meditantes, charissimi, semper expectemus gaudium nostrum sempiternum, et semper oremus fortitudinem in laboribus et tentationibus temporalibus, sive nos pro vobis, sive vos pro nobis. Ne putetis enim, fratres, nostras orationes esse vobis necessarias, et vestras orationes nobis non esse necessarias. Invicem nobis necessariae sunt orationes pro invicem, quia ipsae orationes pro invicem charitate conflantur, et hoc sacrificium tanquam de ara pietatis suavissime fragrat Domino.","english":"And perhaps there was one who would say that it is he who reclined on Christ's breast, and from his breast at that banquet drank the wisdom by which, fattened with that wisdom, he belched forth: In the beginning was the Word (John 1:1). So he said this: We know that, when he shall appear, we shall be like him, for we shall see him as he is. Like whom? Surely like him whose sons we are. Beloved, he says, we are the sons of God, and it has not yet appeared what we shall be. We know that, when he shall appear, we shall be like him, whose sons we are. For we shall see him as he is (1 John 3:2). Even now, if you wish to be what you will be like, if you wish to know whom you will be like, attend to him, if you can. You cannot yet. Therefore you do not know whom you will be like; and for that reason you do not know how like him you will be. By not yet knowing what he is, you do not know what you yourself will be.\n\nTherefore, most beloved, meditating on these things, let us always await our everlasting joy, and let us always pray for strength in our temporal labors and temptations, whether we pray for you or you for us. For do not think, brothers, that our prayers are necessary for you and that your prayers are not necessary for us. Prayers for one another are necessary for us to each other, because these very prayers for one another are kindled by charity, and this sacrifice, as it were from the altar of devotion, gives off a most sweet fragrance to the Lord.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":95,"ref":"p95","source":"Si enim Apostoli dicebant, ut oraretur pro illis, quanto magis nos longe impares, sed utcumque vestigia eorum sequi cupientes, et quantum assequamur, nec scire valentes, nec dicere audentes. Illi ergo tales Viri orari pro se volebant ab Ecclesia, et dicebant: Quia gloria vestra sumus, sicut et vos nostra in diem Domini nostri Jesu Christi (11 Cor. i. 14). Invicem pro se orabant ante diem Domini nostri Jesu Christi, gloria in die, infirmitas ante diem. Oretur in infirmitate, ut gaudeatur in gloria. Etenim diversis temporibus illuc tamen uno tempore omnes perventuri sumus. Hinc exeundi diversa sunt tempora; illic accipiendi unum tempus est. Semel enim et simul congregabimur, ut accipiamus, quod diversis temporibus et credidimus, et desideramus. Quemadmodum operarii illi in vinea alii ducti sunt hora prima, alii hora tertia, alii sexta, alii nona, alii decima (Matth. xx). Diversis temporibus vocati sunt, sed uno tempore merces omnibus persolvitur. Conversi ad Dominum, etc.","english":"For if the Apostles said that prayer should be made for them, how much more we, who are far unequal to them, but who in whatever way desire to follow their footsteps, and, as far as we may attain, are neither able to know nor daring to say. Those men, therefore, being such as they were, wished the Church to pray for them, and said: Because we are your glory, as you also are ours, in the day of our Lord Jesus Christ (2 Cor 1:14). They prayed for one another before the day of our Lord Jesus Christ—glory in the day, weakness before the day. Let prayer be made in weakness, that there may be rejoicing in glory. For though we are called at different times, yet all of us will arrive there at one time. Hence the times of departing from here are different; there the time of receiving is one. For once and together we shall be gathered, to receive what at different times we both believed and desired. Just as those laborers in the vineyard—some were hired at the first hour, others at the third, others at the sixth, others at the ninth, others at the eleventh (Mt 20). At different times they were called, but at one time the wages are paid to all. Having turned to the Lord, etc.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":96,"ref":"p96","source":"SERMO XIV.\n\nIn Natali Cypriani Martyris.\n\nSYNOPSIS.\n\nI. S. Cypriani Laus in Domino. II. Quibuscum confligendum Christiano. III. Contra Spectacula Paganorum. IV. Contra Superbiam. V. Cypriani laus repetita.\n\nSangta solemnitas beatissimi Martyris, quae nos in nomine Domini congregavit, de meritis et gloria tanti Martyris exigit aliquid digne dici. Virtutibus enim ejus et gloriae posset forte humana lingua sufficere, si se voluisset ipse laudare. Verumtamen et nos devotione magis quam facultate laudemus eum, imo Dominum laudemus in eo, Dominum in illo, et illum in Domino. Quid enim esset in Domino, vox Martyrum de Psalmo modo, cum legeretur, audita est: Auxilium nostrum in nomine Domini (Psal. cxxiii, 8). Si auxilium omnium nostrum in nomine Domini, quanto magis Martyrum. Ubi major pugna, ibi majus auxilium necessarium est. Duo sunt enim, quae faciunt Christianorum angustam viam: voluptatis abjectio, et tolerantia passionis. Vincis, quicumque confligis, si viceris, quod libet, et terret. Vincis, inquam, Christiane, quicumque confligis, si viceris, quod libet, et terret. Aliud, quod libet; aliud, quod terret. Sed nunc de Martyrum agitur gloria. Facile est Martyrum solemnia celebrare; difficile est Martyrum passiones imitari.","english":"SERMON XIV.\n\nOn the Birthday of Cyprian the Martyr.\n\nSYNOPSIS.\n\nI. The praise of St. Cyprian in the Lord. II. With whom a Christian must struggle. III. Against the spectacles of the pagans. IV. Against pride. V. The praise of Cyprian repeated.\n\nThe holy solemnity of the most blessed Martyr, which has gathered us in the name of the Lord, demands that something worthy be said of the merits and glory of so great a Martyr. For human tongue could perhaps suffice for his virtues and glory, if he had wished to praise himself. Yet let us praise him with devotion rather than with ability—rather, let us praise the Lord in him, the Lord in that man, and him in the Lord. For what would there be in the Lord? The voice of the Martyrs from the Psalm has just now been heard, when it was read: Our help is in the name of the Lord (Ps. 123:8). If the help of us all is in the name of the Lord, how much more the help of the Martyrs. Where the battle is greater, there the greater help is necessary. For there are two things that make the narrow way of Christians: the casting off of pleasure, and the enduring of suffering. You conquer, whoever you are who struggle, if you conquer what pleases and what terrifies. You conquer, I say, O Christian, whoever you are who struggle, if you conquer what pleases and what terrifies. One thing is what pleases; another is what terrifies. But now the glory of the Martyrs is at issue. It is easy to celebrate the solemnities of the Martyrs; it is difficult to imitate the sufferings of the Martyrs.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":97,"ref":"p97","source":"Angustam, ut dicere coeperam, et arctam Christianorum viam duae res faciunt: contemptus voluptatis, et tolerantia passionis. Quisquis ergo confligit, sciat se cum toto mundo confligere, et confligens cum toto mundo, haec duo vincat, et vincit mundum. Vincat, quidquid blanditur; vincat, quidquid minatur. Voluptas enim falsa est, poena transitoria. Si vis intrare per angustam portam, claude portas cupiditatis et timoris. His enim tentat ille tentator ad evertendam animam. Janua cupiditatis promittendo tentat; janua timoris minando tentat. Est, quod cupias, ut ista non cupias. Est, quod timeas, ut ista non timeas, Non auferatur cupiditas, sed mutetur. Timor non extinguatur, sed in aliud transferatur. Quid cupiebas? Quid mundo blandienti cedebas? Quid cupiebas? Voluptatem carnis, concupiscentiam oculorum, ambitionem saeculi. Nescio, quis istorum trium capitum est carnis infernus. Sed audi apostolum Joannem, qui super pectus Domini discumbebat, et hoc in Evangelio eructabat, quod in convivio Christi bibebat, audi eum dicentem: Nolite diligere mundum, neque ea, quae sunt in mundo. Si quis dilexerit mundum, non est charitas Patris in illo, quoniam omnia, quae in mundo sunt, concupiscentia carnis est, et concupiscentia oculorum, et ambitio saeculi (1 Joan. ii, 15, 16). Dicitur ergo mundus hoc coelum et terra. Non ipsum mundum vituperat, qui dicit: Nolite diligere mundum.","english":"As I began to say, two things make the Christian way narrow and strait: contempt for pleasure and endurance of suffering. Whoever therefore struggles should know that he struggles with the whole world, and struggling with the whole world, let him conquer these two things, and he conquers the world. Let him conquer whatever flatters; let him conquer whatever threatens. For pleasure is false, and pain is transitory. If you wish to enter through the narrow gate, close the gates of desire and of fear. For by these the tempter tries to overthrow the soul. By the gate of desire he tempts by promising; by the gate of fear he tempts by threatening. There is something you should desire, so that you do not desire these things. There is something you should fear, so that you do not fear these things. Let not desire be taken away, but changed. Let not fear be extinguished, but transferred to something else. What were you desiring? To what were you yielding when the world flattered you? What were you desiring? The pleasure of the flesh, the lust of the eyes, the ambition of the world. I do not know which of these three heads is the hell of the flesh. But hear the apostle John, who reclined on the breast of the Lord, and belched forth in the Gospel what he drank at the banquet of Christ—hear him saying: Do not love the world, nor the things that are in the world. If anyone has loved the world, the love of the Father is not in him, because all that is in the world is the lust of the flesh, and the lust of the eyes, and the ambition of the world (1 John 2:15-16). This heaven and earth, then, is called the world. He does not find fault with the world itself, who says: Do not love the world.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":98,"ref":"p98","source":"Qui enim istum vituperat, artificem mundi vituperat. Audiat mundum bis uno loco nominatum sub diversis significationibus. De Domino Christo dictum est: In hoc mundo erat, et mundus per eum factus est, et mundus eum non cognovit. Mundus per eum factus est (Joan. i, 10). Auxilium nostrum in nomine Domini, qui fecit coelum et terram (Psal. cxxiii, 8). Mundus per eum factus est. Levavi oculos meos in montes, unde veniet auxilium mihi (Id. cxx, 1, 2). Auxilium meum a Domino, qui fecit coelum et terram. Iste mundus a Deo factus est: Et mundus cum non cognovit. Dilector mundi, amator operis, contemptor artificis, amor tuus migret. Rumpe funes a creatura, alliga ad creatorem. Muta amorem, muta timorem. Non enim faciunt bonos et malos mores, nisi boni vel mali amores. Magnus iste vir, dicet aliquis, bonus est, magnus est. Unde? quaeso. Multa novit. Quid diligat quaero, non quid sciat. Nolite ergo diligere mundum, neque ea, quae sunt in mundo. Si quis dilexerit mundum, non est charitas Patris in illo, quoniam omnia, quae in mundo sunt, (utique in dilectoribus mundi; ea, quae sunt in dilectoribus mundi) concupiscentia carnis est, et concupiscentia oculorum, et ambitio saecuti. In concupiscentia carnis voluptas est. In concupiscentia oculorum curiositas est. In ambitione saeculi superbia est. Qui tria ista vincit, non ei remanet omnino in cupiditate, quod vincat.","english":"For whoever criticizes this world criticizes its maker. Let him hear the world named twice in one place under different meanings. It was said of the Lord Christ: He was in this world, and the world was made through him, and the world did not know him. The world was made through him (John 1:10). Our help is in the name of the Lord, who made heaven and earth (Psalm 123:8). The world was made through him. I lifted up my eyes to the mountains, from where my help will come (Psalm 120:1–2). My help is from the Lord, who made heaven and earth. This world was made by God: and the world did not know him. Lover of the world, lover of the work, despiser of the craftsman, let your love migrate. Break your cords from the creature, bind them to the Creator. Change your love, change your fear. For nothing makes morals good or bad except good or bad loves. \"This man is great,\" someone will say, \"he is good, he is great.\" From what? I ask. He knows many things. I ask what he loves, not what he knows. Therefore do not love the world, nor the things that are in the world. If anyone has loved the world, the love of the Father is not in him, since all things that are in the world (certainly in the lovers of the world; the things that are in the lovers of the world) are the concupiscence of the flesh, and the concupiscence of the eyes, and the ambition of the age. In the concupiscence of the flesh is pleasure. In the concupiscence of the eyes is curiosity. In the ambition of the age is pride. For the one who conquers these three, nothing at all remains in his desire for him to conquer.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":99,"ref":"p99","source":"Multi rami, sed triplex radix. Quanta mala habet, quanta mala facit carnalis voluptatis appetitio! Inde adulteria, fornicationes, inde luxuria, inde ebrietas. Quidquid titillat sensus illicite, et mentem penetrat suavitate pestifera, addicit carni mentem, deturbat exercitatorem, subit servienti imperantem. Et quid poterit homo facere rectum in se ipso perversus?\n\nQuae mala facit turpis curiositas, concupiscentia vana oculorum, aviditas nugacium spectaculorum, insania stadiorum, nullo praemio consequente conflictus certaminum! Certant aurigae aliquo praemio, litigant pro aurigis populi aliquo praemio. Sed delectat auriga, delectat venator, delectat scenicus. Itane honestum delectat turpitudo? Muta etiam cupiditatem spectaculorum. Exhibet Ecclesia menti tuae honorabiliora et veneranda spectacula. Modo legebatur Passio beati Cypriani. Aure audiebamus, mente spectabamus, certantem videbamus, periclitanti quodam modo timebamus, sed Dei adjutorium sperabamus. Denique vultis nosse cito, quid intersit inter spectacula nostra et theatrica? Nos, quantum in nobis viget sana mens, Martyres, quos spectamus, cupimus imitari. Nos, inquam, sanctos Martyres, quos certantes spectamus, cupimus imitari. Honeste spectator! in theatris cum spectas, insanis, si audes imitari quem diligis. Ecce ego specto Cyprianum, amo Cyprianum. Si irasceris, maledic mihi, et dic: Talis sis!","english":"Many branches, but a threefold root. How many evils carnal desire has, how many evils it does! From it come adulteries, fornications, from it luxury, from it drunkenness. Whatever unlawfully titillates the senses and penetrates the mind with pestilential sweetness, enslaves the mind to the flesh, throws down the trainer, and the servant rises up to command the one who commands. And what can a man do rightly in himself when he is perverse?\n\nWhat evils does base curiosity do, the vain lust of the eyes, the greed for trifling shows, the madness for the games, when no prize follows from the contest of the struggles! Charioteers compete for some prize, the crowds quarrel on behalf of the charioteers for some prize. But the charioteer delights, the hunter delights, the stage-player delights. Does baseness then delight as something honorable? Change even your desire for shows. The Church presents to your mind more honorable and venerable shows. Just now the Passion of the blessed Cyprian was being read. With our ears we were hearing, with our mind we were watching, we were seeing him contending, we were in some way fearing for him in his danger, but we were hoping in God's help. Finally, do you wish to know quickly what the difference is between our shows and the theatrical ones? We, insofar as a sound mind is strong in us, desire to imitate the Martyrs whom we watch. We, I say, desire to imitate the holy Martyrs whom we watch contending. Honorable spectator! in the theaters, when you watch, you are mad if you dare to imitate the one you love. Behold, I watch Cyprian, I love Cyprian. If you are angry, curse me, and say: May you be such a one!","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":100,"ref":"p100","source":"specto, delector, quantum valeo, lacertis mentis amplector. Video certatorem, audio victorem. Irascere, ut dixi, et dic mihi: Talis sis! Vide, si non amplector; vide, si non opto; vide, si non cupio; vide, si non indignum me possum dicere; refugere tamen avertique non possum. Specta tu, delectare tu, ama tu. Noli irasci, si dixero: Talis sis! Sed parco, non dico. Agnosce amicum. Spectacula muta mecum. Tales amemus, quos imitari, quantum valemus, optemus. Sed infamis est ille, qui spectatur; qui spectat, honestus est. Cesset cupiditas emptoris, et nulla erit turpitudo venalis. Infamiam spectando confirmas. Quid provocas, quod accusas? Miror, si amati tui non te aspergit infamia. Sed non te aspergat, immaculata maneat honestas, si potest, spectatrix libidinum, emptrix turpium voluptatum. Audeo prohibere spectacula? Audeo prohibere? Audeo plane. Dat mihi fiduciam locus iste, et qui me constituit in isto loco. Potuit sanctus Martyr saevientes sustinere Paganos, ego non audeam audientes instruere Christianos? Ego metuam tacitas offensiones, cum ille contempserit apertos furores? Dicam prorsus. Certe redarguar in cordibus audientium, si falsa dico. Optime facit, omnino optime facit antiqua disciplina Romana, quae omne genus Histrionum infami loco deputavit. Non illis ullus honor in Curia, non saltem in plebeia tribuitur. Undique ab honestis remoti, et honesti venales praepositi.","english":"I look, I take delight, as far as I am able I embrace with the arms of the mind. I see the combatant, I hear the victor. Be angry, as I said, and tell me: May you be such a one! See whether I do not embrace it; see whether I do not choose it; see whether I do not desire it; see whether I cannot call myself unworthy of it; yet I cannot flee from it or turn away. You look, you take delight, you love. Do not be angry if I say: May you be such a one! But I spare you, I do not say it. Recognize a friend. Let the shows be silent with me. Let us love such men as we wish, as far as we are able, to imitate. But that man who is watched is infamous; the one who watches is honorable. Let the buyer's desire cease, and there will be no shameful thing for sale. You confirm the infamy by watching. Why do you provoke what you accuse? I wonder if the one you love does not spatter you with infamy. But let it not spatter you; let your honor remain unstained, if it can—you who are a spectator of lusts, a buyer of shameful pleasures. Do I dare to forbid the shows? Do I dare to forbid them? I dare, plainly. This place gives me confidence, and He who established me in this place. The holy Martyr was able to endure raging pagans; shall I not dare to instruct listening Christians? Shall I fear silent offenses, when he despised open furies? I shall say it outright. Surely I will be refuted in the hearts of my hearers, if I say false things. Ancient Roman discipline does altogether well, entirely well, which assigned every kind of stage-player to an infamous place. No honor is granted them in the senate-house, not even among the common people. Removed on all sides from honorable men, and honorable men are set over things for sale.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":101,"ref":"p101","source":"Quid a te propter dignitatem Decurii removisti, et propter voluptatem tibi in theatro posuisti? Consonet dignitati tuae voluptas tua. Et ipsi miseri addicti sunt spectantium cupiditatibus, spectantium insanientibus voluptatibus. Remove ista omnia, et liberantur. Misericordiam in illos facit, qui spectare noluerit.\n\nDicta sint haec de concupiscentia oculorum. Ambitio saeculi quantum mali habet! Ibi omnis superbia. Et quid est pejus superbia? Sententiam Domini audi. Deus superbis resistit; humilibus autem dat gratiam (Jacobi iv, 6). Ergo et ambitio saeculi maligna est. Dicet aliquis: Sine illa non possunt esse saeculi Potestates. Prorsus possunt. Nescio, quis auctor ipsorum ait; Suam quisque culpam auctores ad negotia transferunt. Prorsus possunt. Rector est in potestate constitutus. Erigat, et rexit. Sed humana mens pergit in elationem. Frenetur elatio. Hominem se esse cognoscat, qui de homine judicat. Dispar est dignitas, sed communis est ipsa fragilitas. Hoc qui pie, sancteque cogitat, et habet potestatem, et non pergit in elationem. Vicit ista omnia Cyprianus. Quid enim non vicit, qui vitam ipsam omnibus tentationibus redundantem contempsit. Mortem illi minatus est judex; ille confessus est Christum, paratus mori pro Christo. Ubi mors venerit, nulla remanebit ambitio, nulla curiositas oculorum, nulla appetitio sordidarum et carnalium voluptatum.","english":"Why have you removed yourself from it because of the dignity of the Decurionate, and set yourself in the theater because of pleasure? Let your pleasure be in harmony with your dignity. Even those wretched people are enslaved to the desires of the spectators, to the frenzied pleasures of the spectators. Remove all these things, and they are set free. He shows mercy to them who has refused to watch.\n\nLet these things be said concerning the concupiscence of the eyes. How much evil does the ambition of the world possess! There is all pride. And what is worse than pride? Hear the sentence of the Lord. God resists the proud, but gives grace to the humble (James 4:6). Therefore the ambition of the world is also wicked. Someone will say: Without it, the Powers of the world cannot exist. Indeed they can. I do not know who the author of their own words said: Each one transfers his own guilt to his affairs. Indeed they can. A ruler has been established in power. Let him rise up, and he has ruled. But the human mind presses on into elation. Let elation be curbed. Let him who judges concerning man recognize that he is a man. Dignity is unequal, but the frailty itself is common. He who thinks this piously and holily both has power and does not press on into elation. Cyprian conquered all these things. For what did he not conquer, who despised life itself, overflowing with all temptations? The judge threatened him with death; he confessed Christ, ready to die for Christ. When death has come, no ambition will remain, no curiosity of the eyes, no appetite for sordid and carnal pleasures.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":102,"ref":"p102","source":"Una vita contempta omnia superantur.\n\nBeatus ergo Cyprianus laudetur in Domino, quia omnia ista vicit. Quando hos posset, si non adjuvisset Dominus? Quando vinceret, si non spectator, qui coronam parabat vincenti, subministraret vires laboranti? Gaudet plane et ipse, gaudet pro nobis, non pro se, quando in Domino laudatur. Mitis enim est valde, et scriptum est: In Domino laudabitur anima mea. Audiant mites, et laetentur (Psal. xxxi, 3). Mitis erat. In Domino vult animam suam laudari, In Domino laudetur anima ejus. Honoretur etiam corpus ejus. Quia Pretiosa in conspectu Domini mors Sanctorum ejus (Id, lxxii, 1). Sancte celebretur, tanquam a Christianis celebretur. Non enim aram constituimus, tanquam Deo, Cypriano, sed Deo vero aram fecimus Cyprianum.\n\nSERMO XV.\n\nItem in Natali Cypriani Martyris.\n\nSYNOPSIS.\n\nI. Gaudium de religiosa populi frequentia, et victoria Martyrum. II. Delusa Persecutorum a Martyribus consilia. III. Ecclesia Persecutorum victrix. IV. Persecutorum, ut Christi, ita Cypriani multi conversi.","english":"One contemptible life overcomes all things.\n\nTherefore let blessed Cyprian be praised in the Lord, because he conquered all these things. When could he have done so, had the Lord not helped him? When would he have conquered, had not the spectator, who was preparing a crown for the victor, supplied strength to the one laboring? He rejoices plainly, he rejoices for us, not for himself, when he is praised in the Lord. For he is very meek, and it is written: In the Lord my soul shall be praised. Let the meek hear, and rejoice (Ps. 31:3). He was meek. He wishes his soul to be praised in the Lord; let his soul be praised in the Lord. Let his body also be honored. Because Precious in the sight of the Lord is the death of his saints (Id, 72:1). Let him be celebrated as a saint, as he is celebrated by Christians. For we have not set up an altar to Cyprian as to a god, but we have made Cyprian an altar to the true God.\n\nSERMON XV.\n\nLikewise on the birthday of the Martyr Cyprian.\n\nSYNOPSIS.\n\nI. Joy over the religious gathering of the people, and the victory of the Martyrs. II. The plans of the Persecutors foiled by the Martyrs. III. The Church the conqueror of the Persecutors. IV. Many of the Persecutors converted, as to Christ, so to Cyprian.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":103,"ref":"p103","source":"Psalmum cantavimus: Benedictus Dominus, qui non dedit nos in venationem dentibus eorum (Psal. cxxiii, 6). Donis Dei debita gratulatio. Benedictus Dominus, qui non dedit in venationem dentibus eorum. Vox est certe gratulationis, et digna gratulatio. Et quando tantis donis divinis humana sufficit gratulatio? Quando in isto loco beatissimus Martyr sacrum sanguinem fudit, nescio utrum tanta hic fuerit turba furentium, quanta nunc est multitudo laudantium. Iterum dico; delectat enim me, populum videre in domo Domini religiosissime in hunc locum convenientem, et tempora temporibus comparare. Unde iterum dico, et repeto, et vestris sensibus, quanta possum, devotione commendo: Quando in isto loco beatissimus Martyr sacrum sanguinem fudit, nescio utrum tanta hic fuerit turba furentium, quanta nunc est multitudo laudantium. Sed, etsi fuit, fuit Benedictus Dominus, qui non dedit nos in venationem dentibus eorum. » Quando occidebant, se vicisse credebant. Vincebantur a morientibus, et gaudebant, si vincebantur. Utique furebant. Abscessit ergo turba furentium, successit multitudo laudantium: Dicat, dicat multitudo laudantium: Benedictus Dominus, qui non dedit nos in venationem dentibus eorum. Dentibus quorum?","english":"We sang the psalm: Blessed is the Lord, who has not given us as prey to their teeth. Thanksgiving is owed for the gifts of God. Blessed is the Lord, who has not given us as prey to their teeth. This is surely a voice of thanksgiving, and a thanksgiving that is fitting. And when does human thanksgiving ever suffice for such great divine gifts? When the most blessed Martyr shed his sacred blood in this place, I do not know whether there was here as great a crowd of raging men as there is now a multitude of those who praise. I say it again, for it delights me to see the people in the house of the Lord gathering most religiously in this place, and to compare times with times. Therefore I say it again, and repeat it, and commend it to your minds with all the devotion I can: When the most blessed Martyr shed his sacred blood in this place, I do not know whether there was here as great a crowd of raging men as there is now a multitude of those who praise. But even if there was, there was the Blessed Lord, who has not given us as prey to their teeth. When they were killing, they believed they had conquered. They were being conquered by those who were dying, and they rejoiced if they were being conquered. Surely they were raging. So the crowd of raging men departed, and there succeeded a multitude of those who praise. Let the multitude of those who praise say, let it say: Blessed is the Lord, who has not given us as prey to their teeth. To whose teeth?","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":104,"ref":"p104","source":"Dentibus inimicorum, dentibus impiorum, dentibus persecutorum Jerusalem, dentibus Babyloniae, dentibus civitatis inimicae, dentibus turbae in sceleribus insanientis, dentibus turbae Dominum persequentis, creatorem deserentis, ad creaturam se convertentis, manu facta colentis, eum a quo facta est, contemnentis. Benedictus Dominus, qui non dedit nos in venationem dentibus eorum.\n\nVox Martyrum est. Eorum profecto vox est, qui pro Christi nomine occidi, quam negando Christum vivere maluerunt. Si ergo illi occidere voluerunt, isti occisi sunt, fecerunt, quod voluerunt illi, passi sunt isti, quomodo: Benedictus Dominus, qui non dedit nos in venationem dentibus eorum? Qualis gratulatio est: Benedictus Dominus, qui non dedit vas in venationem dentibus eorum? Quia persecutores non occidere, sed devorare voluerunt, id est, in corpus suum transferre. Pagani erant, impii erant, daemonum et idolorum cultores erant. Hoc nos facere volebant, quando devorare cupiebant. Intendite, quid cibo faciamus, quando manducamus. Quid utique facimus, nisi in corpus nostrum transferimus? Erat corpus impiorum, devoraverunt eos, qui eis ad impia consenserunt. In eorum corpus procul dubio transierunt. Martyres ergo illi instantibus, ut Christus negaretur, et idolum adoraretur, restiterunt constanter, idolum spreverunt, Christum confessi sunt, in corpus eorum consentiendo non transierunt.","english":"By the teeth of enemies, the teeth of the wicked, the teeth of the persecutors of Jerusalem, the teeth of Babylon, the teeth of the hostile city, the teeth of the crowd raging in crimes, the teeth of the crowd persecuting the Lord, forsaking the Creator, turning to the creature, worshiping what is made by hand, despising him by whom it was made. Blessed is the Lord, who has not given us as prey to their teeth.\n\nIt is the voice of the martyrs. Truly it is the voice of those who preferred to be killed for the name of Christ rather than to live by denying Christ. If, then, those men wished to kill, and these were killed, those did what they wished, these suffered it, how is it that they say: Blessed is the Lord, who has not given us as prey to their teeth? What kind of rejoicing is this: Blessed is the Lord, who has not given us as prey to their teeth? Because the persecutors did not wish to kill but to devour, that is, to transfer them into their own body. They were pagans, they were wicked, they were worshipers of demons and idols. This is what they wanted us to do, when they desired to devour. Consider what we do to food when we eat. What indeed do we do but transfer it into our body? The body of the wicked was their own; they devoured those who consented with them to impious things. Without doubt they passed over into their body. Therefore those martyrs, when they were pressed to deny Christ and to adore an idol, stood firm, despised the idol, confessed Christ, and by not consenting did not pass over into their body.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":105,"ref":"p105","source":"Dicant, dicant, gloriose dicant, feliciter dicant, veraciter dicant: Benedictus Dominus, qui non dedit nos in venationem dentibus eorum. Retia perfidia est, retia impietas est, retia Christi negatio est. Extenta sunt retia. Audis venantes. Si vis cavere venantes, contemne terrentes. Nostis, quid faciunt venatores. Ex alia parte tendunt retia, ab alia parte terrent feras, quas cogunt in retia. Malum times, quo terreris? Pejus est, quo fugis. Ergo Martyres sancti videntes, ubi venatores tetenderunt retia (ad hoc enim mortem persecutor minabatur, ut Salvator negaretur) passi sunt, sed patiendo non sunt capti. Quali sagina praedae, quali pinguedine venationis Babylon impia pasceretur, si a Cypriano episcopo Dominus negaretur. Quali sagina, quali venatione, quam optima praeda Babylon impia pasceretur, si a Cypriano episcopo, doctore gentium, frustratore idolorum, proditore daemoniorum, lucratore Paganorum, confirmatore Christianorum, inflammatore Martyrum. Si ergo a tali et tanto Viro Dominus negaretur, quali venatione Babylon impia laetaretur! « Benedictus Dominus, qui non dedit nos in venationem dentibus eorum. Saevierunt, persecuti fuerunt, torserunt, incluserunt, alligaverunt, percusserunt, incenderunt, bestiis subrepserunt. Non est Christus negatus, Confessor Domini est coronatus. Illi saevitiam perdiderunt, gloriam Martyres invenerunt.","english":"Let them say, let them say it gloriously, let them say it joyfully, let them say it truthfully: Blessed is the Lord, who has not given us over as prey to their teeth. The nets are treachery, the nets are impiety, the nets are the denial of Christ. The nets have been spread out. You hear the hunters. If you wish to beware of the hunters, despise the things that frighten you. You know what hunters do. On one side they stretch out the nets, on the other side they frighten the wild beasts, which they drive into the nets. Do you fear the evil by which you are frightened? Worse is that by which you flee. Therefore the holy martyrs, seeing where the hunters had spread their nets (for to this end the persecutor threatened death, that the Savior might be denied), suffered, but by suffering they were not captured. With what fattening of prey, with what richness of the hunt would impious Babylon be fed, if the Lord were denied by Cyprian the bishop. With what fattening, with what a hunt, with what choice prey would impious Babylon be fed, if the Lord were denied by Cyprian the bishop, teacher of the nations, frustrator of idols, betrayer of demons, gainer of the pagans, strengthener of Christians, inflamer of martyrs. If therefore the Lord were denied by such and so great a man, with what a hunt would impious Babylon rejoice! Blessed is the Lord, who has not given us over as prey to their teeth. They raged, they persecuted, they tortured, they shut us in, they bound us, they struck us, they burned us, they crept up on us with beasts. Christ was not denied, the Confessor of the Lord is crowned. They lost their savagery, the martyrs found glory.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":106,"ref":"p106","source":"Benedictus Dominus, dicat populus christianus, dicat omnino, decet, ut dicat: Benedictus Dominus, qui non dedit nos in venationem dentibus eorum. Modo, dicat, hic locus impletur populo confitentium, impletur populo unum verum Deum adorantium. Dicat: hic locus; tunc enim seges ista seminabatur, quando ille locus sanguine Martyris rigabatur. Noli mirari, Terra, fertilitatem tuam, si rigata es, ut hoc pullulares.\n\nErgo Benedictus Dominus, qui non dedit nos in venationem dentibus eorum. Quibus enim viribus nos erepti sumus de dentibus impiorum? Nihil nobis arrogamus, non hoc nostrae potestati tribuimus. Benedictus Dominus, qui non dedit nos in venationem dentibus eorum. Quid enim eramus, quando terrebamur infirmi a fortibus, humiles a sublimibus, egentes a divitibus, indigentes ab abundantibus? Quid eramus, nisi Auxilium nostrum esset in nomine Domini ejus, qui fecit coelum et terram (Psal. cxxiii, 8)? Exulta, exulta, Jerusalem, exulta et tu non data in dentes venantium. Exulta et tu. Habes et tu dentes. Dentes tui, sicut grex detonsarum. Habes et tu dentes, o sancta Jerusalem, Civitas Dei, Ecclesia Christi, habes et tu dentes. Tibi dicitur in Cantico Canticorum: Dentes tui, sicut grex detonsarum ascendens de lavacro, quae omnes geminos creant, et sterilis non est in illis (Cant. iv, 2, et vi, 5). Bene, bene, quod non timuisti dentes Babyloniae.","english":"Blessed is the Lord, let the Christian people say, let them say it altogether, it is fitting that they say: Blessed is the Lord, who has not given us over as prey to their teeth. Now, let them say it, this place is being filled with a people of those who confess, filled with a people adoring the one true God. Let them say: this place; for then that seed was being sown, when that place was being watered by the blood of the Martyr. Do not marvel, O earth, at your fertility, if you have been watered, so that you might sprout this.\n\nTherefore Blessed is the Lord, who has not given us over as prey to their teeth. For by what strength have we been snatched from the teeth of the impious? We claim nothing for ourselves, we do not attribute this to our own power. Blessed is the Lord, who has not given us over as prey to their teeth. For what were we, when the weak were being terrified by the strong, the lowly by the exalted, the needy by the rich, the destitute by the abundant? What were we, unless our help were in the name of the Lord, of him who made heaven and earth? Exult, exult, Jerusalem, exult, you too who have not been given over to the teeth of the hunters. Exult, you too. You too have teeth. Your teeth are like the flock of the shorn. You too have teeth, O holy Jerusalem, City of God, Church of Christ, you too have teeth. To you it is said in the Song of Songs: Your teeth are like a flock of shorn ewes ascending from the washing, which all bear twins, and there is no barren one among them. Well, well, that you did not fear the teeth of Babylon.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":107,"ref":"p107","source":"Dentes Babyloniae potestates saeculi fuerunt, dentes Babyloniae doctores illicitorum sacrorum fuerunt. His dentibus data non es. Agnosce dentes tuos. Fac tu, quod illi facere voluerunt. Converte te. Et tu habes dantes. « Dentes tui, sicut grex detonsarum. Quid est Detonsarum? Sarcinas saeculares ponentium. Quid est Detonsarum? Ponentium vellere, tanquam onera sarcinae saecularis. Illi erant dentes tui, de quibus scriptum est in Actibus Apostolorum, quia vendiderunt omnia sua, et pretia rerum suarum ante pedes Apostolorum posuerunt, ut distribueretur unicuique, sicut opus erat (Act. iv, 35). Percepisti vellere detonsarum tuarum. Ascendit grex ille de lavacro Baptismatis sancti. Omnes pepererunt, quia duo praecepta charitatis impleverunt. Meministis, recordati estis, tanquam instructi acclamastis, cum duo praecepta charitatis commemorarem; quae autem essent, non dixi, et tamen indicium cordis vestri voce suscepi. Agnovistis. Dicam tamen propter eos, qui ad Ecclesiam rarius accedunt. Dominus dicit, Magister veracissimus dicit, Princeps Martyrum dicit: Diliges Dominum Deum tuum in toto corde tuo, et in tota anima tua, et in tota mente tua, et diliges proximum tuum tanquam te ipsum. In his duobus praeceptis tota Lex pendet et Prophetae (Matth. xxii, 37-40). Dentes ergo tui in Deo vicerunt, quia tales geminos pepererunt.","english":"The teeth of Babylon were the powers of the world; the teeth of Babylon were the teachers of unlawful rites. You were not given over to these teeth. Recognize your own teeth. Do what they wished to do. Turn yourself. You too have teeth that give. \"Your teeth are like a flock of shorn ewes.\" What is \"of shorn ewes\"? Of those laying down worldly burdens. What is \"of shorn ewes\"? Of those laying down their fleece, as it were the loads of a worldly burden. Those were your teeth, of whom it is written in the Acts of the Apostles that they sold all that they had and laid the prices of their possessions at the feet of the Apostles, so that it might be distributed to each as there was need (Acts 4:35). You have received the fleece of your shorn ewes. That flock came up from the bath of holy Baptism. All have given birth, because they have fulfilled the two commandments of charity. You remember, you have recalled it, as though instructed you shouted aloud when I mentioned the two commandments of charity; but what they were, I did not say, and yet I received the testimony of your heart by your voice. You have recognized them. Yet I shall say it for the sake of those who come to the Church more rarely. The Lord says, the most truthful Teacher says, the Prince of the Martyrs says: You shall love the Lord your God with your whole heart, and with your whole soul, and with your whole mind, and you shall love your neighbor as yourself. On these two commandments hang the whole Law and the Prophets (Matt. 22:37-40). Therefore your teeth have conquered in God, because as such they have given birth to twins.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":108,"ref":"p108","source":"Tibi dicitur habenti tales dentes, tibi dicitur, o Ecclesia, in figura beatissimi Petri: Surge, macta et manduca (Act. x, 13). Surge. Petro dictum est, quando vas submissum de coelo in figura animalium omnis generis portabat, esurienti Petro, id est, avidae Ecclesiae, Surge, quid esuris? Surge, cibus tibi paratus est. Dentes habes; Macta et manduca. Occide, quod sunt; fac, quod es. Occide quod sunt, verte in quod es. Bene audisti tales dentes habens, bene mactasti, bene manducasti. Ipsos judices, quos non timuisti, ad te attraxisti; ipsas saeculi potestates, quas non timuisti, in te convertisti; saevientes sprevisti; honorantes fecisti. Impletum est, quod Domino tuo promissum est: Et adorabunt eum omnes reges terrae, omnes gentes servient illi (Psal. lxxi, 11).\n\nHaec persecutores non credebant, quando saeviebant. Quam multi ex ipsis persecutoribus, qui viderunt beatissimum Cyprianum fundentem sanguinem, genua flectentem, cervicem percussori praebentem, hic viderunt, hic spectaverunt, hic de tanto spectaculo exultaverunt, hic, hic morienti insultaverunt. Quam multi ex eis, quod non dubito, postea crediderunt. Non dubitandum, sine dubitatione credendum est. Judaei Christi interfectores, qui pendente illo caput agitaverunt insultantes, et in illo verba, quae voluerunt, dixerunt exultantes, postea in ipsum Dominum, quem crucifixerunt, crediderunt.","english":"To you who have such teeth, to you, O Church, it is said in the figure of the most blessed Peter: Rise, kill and eat (Acts 10:13). Rise. It was said to Peter, when a vessel let down from heaven was carrying in figure animals of every kind, to Peter as he hungered, that is, to the Church as she hungered: Rise, what are you hungering for? Rise, food has been prepared for you. You have teeth; Kill and eat. Kill what they are; make what you are. Kill what they are, turn them into what you are. You have heard well, having such teeth; you have killed well, you have eaten well. Those very judges whom you did not fear, you have drawn to yourself; those very powers of the world whom you did not fear, you have converted into yourself; those raging you have despised; those honoring you have made. What was promised to your Lord has been fulfilled: And all the kings of the earth shall adore him, all nations shall serve him (Ps. 71:11).\n\nThe persecutors did not believe this when they were raging. How many of those very persecutors who saw the most blessed Cyprian pouring out his blood, bending his knees, offering his neck to the executioner—here they saw, here they watched, here they exulted over so great a spectacle, here, here they insulted him as he died. How many of them, I do not doubt, afterward believed. It is not to be doubted; it is to be believed without doubt. The Jews, the killers of Christ, who, while he hung, shook their heads in insult, and spoke over him the words they wished, exulting—afterward they believed in the very Lord whom they crucified.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":109,"ref":"p109","source":"Haec enim poterat vacare vox Medici in cruce pendentis, et medicamentum sanitatis phreniticis de suo sanguine facientis? Non poterat ergo vacare, et inanis esse vox illa: Pater, ignosce illis, quia nesciunt quid faciunt (Luc. xxiii. 34). Non plane vacavit. Erat ibi multitudo eorum, propter quos haec vox de ore resonuit Veritatis. Nam postea facto miraculo, adveniente de coelo Spiritu sancto, cum linguis omnium gentium Apostoli loquerentur, stupentes repentinum miraculum, subito compuncti, ad eum, quem oceiderunt, conversi sanguinem, quem saevientes fuderunt, credentes biberunt. Hoc plane et de beato Cypriano Christi sancto Martyre nullo modo est dubitandum, quod plurimi eorum, qui occisum impie spectaverunt, in ejus Dominum crediderunt, et forte etiam ipsi imitando pro Christi nomine sanguinem fuderunt. Postremo de illis incertum sit. De illis, qui tunc huic loco affuerunt, qui percussum in isto loco sanctum Cyprianum viderunt, incertum sit, utrum crediderint. Certe isti omnes, aut pene omnes, quorum voces audio exultantium, filii sunt insultantium.","english":"Could that voice of the Physician hanging on the cross have been idle, and of one making the medicine of health for the delirious from his own blood? That voice, then, could not have been idle and empty: Father, forgive them, for they know not what they do (Luke 23:34). It was plainly not idle. There was there a multitude of those on whose account this voice resounded from the mouth of Truth. For afterward, when the miracle had been done and the Holy Spirit had come from heaven, when the Apostles were speaking in the tongues of all nations, those who were astonished at the sudden miracle, suddenly pricked to the heart, turned to him whom they had killed, and believing they drank the blood which in their savagery they had shed. This plainly must in no way be doubted concerning the blessed Cyprian, holy martyr of Christ, that very many of those who impiously watched him being killed believed in his Lord, and perhaps even themselves by imitation shed their blood for the name of Christ. Finally, concerning those others let it be uncertain. Concerning those who were then present at this place, who saw the holy Cyprian struck down in this place, let it be uncertain whether they believed. Certainly all these, or nearly all, whose voices I hear of those exulting, are sons of those insulting.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":110,"ref":"p110","source":"SERMO XVI.\n\nIn Natali Martyrum Scillitanorum.\n\nSYNOPSIS.\n\nI. Exemplo Martyrum Christus nec propter superflua, nec propter necessaria mundi bona negandus. II. Amor proximi unde, et qualis. III. Salus et Amicus, duo necessaria, quomodo respicienda. IV. Certamen Martyris cum Persecutore de superfluis. V. Certamen Martyris cum Persecutore de necessariis. VI. Quibus modis negetur Christus. VII. Constantiae merces in coelo.\n\nMartyres sancti, testes Dei, ne vivendo morerentur, moriendo vivere maluerunt, ne timendo mortem negarent vitam, amando vitam contempserunt vitam. Ut negaretur Christus, vitam promittebat inimicus, sed non qualem Christus. Credentes ergo, quod a Salvatore promittebatur, riserunt, quod persecutor comminabatur. Fratres, quando Solemnis Martyrum celebramus, exempla nobis proposita noverimus, quae imitando assequamur. Non enim istam faciendo frequentiam, augemus Martyrum gloriam. Illorum corona populis nota est Angelorum. Nos, quod passi sunt, cum legeretur, audire potuimus. Quod autem acceperunt, Nec oculus vidit, nec auris audivit (1 Cor. II, 9). Bona mundi hujus alia sunt superflua, alia necessaria. Hinc paululum, ut loquamur, attendite, et distinguamus, si possumus, quae sint bona hujus mundi superflua, quae necessaria, ut videatis, non esse negandum Christum nec propter superflua, nec propter necessaria. Superflua mundi hujus quis enumerat?","english":"SERMON XVI.\n\nOn the Birthday of the Scillitan Martyrs.\n\nSYNOPSIS.\n\nI. By the example of the Martyrs, Christ is not to be denied for the sake of the superfluous goods of the world, nor for the sake of the necessary. II. Whence love of neighbor comes, and what kind it is. III. Salvation and a Friend, two necessary things, how they are to be regarded. IV. The Martyr's contest with the Persecutor over superfluous things. V. The Martyr's contest with the Persecutor over necessary things. VI. In what ways Christ is denied. VII. The reward of constancy in heaven.\n\nHoly Martyrs, witnesses of God, lest by living they should die, preferred to live by dying; lest by fearing death they should deny life, by loving life they despised life. To make Christ be denied, the enemy promised life, but not such a life as Christ promises. Believing, therefore, what was promised by the Savior, they laughed at what the persecutor threatened. Brothers, when we celebrate the solemnity of the Martyrs, let us know the examples set before us, that by imitating them we may attain to them. For it is not by making this crowd of attendance that we increase the glory of the Martyrs. Their crown is known to the peoples of the Angels. What they suffered, we have been able to hear while it was read. But what they received, Eye has not seen, nor ear heard (1 Cor. 2:9). The goods of this world are some superfluous, some necessary. Attend here a little, that we may speak, and let us distinguish, if we can, which are the superfluous goods of this world, which the necessary, so that you may see that Christ is not to be denied either for superfluous things or for necessary things. Who can enumerate the superfluous things of this world?","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":111,"ref":"p111","source":"Si ea commemorare voluerimus, magnas moras faciemus. Dicamus ergo necessaria. Quaecumque alia erunt, haec erunt superflua. Necessaria sunt in hoc mundo duo ista; Salus et Amicus. Ista sunt, quae magni pendere, quae non debemus contemnere. Salus, et Amicus naturalia bona sunt. Fecit Deus hominem, ut esset et viveret. Salus est. Sed, ne solus esset, Amicitia quaesita est. Incipit ergo Amicitia a conjuge et filiis, et progreditur usque ad alienos. Sed, si consideremus, unum nos habuisse patrem, et unam matrem, quis erit alienus? Omni homini proximus est omnis homo. Interroga naturam. Ignotus est? Homo est. Inimicus est? Homo est. Hostis est? Homo est. Amicus est? Maneat amicus. Inimicus est? Fiat amicus.\n\nAd haec duo in hoc mundo necessaria, Salutem, et Amicum, venit peregrina sapientia. Invenit omnes stultos, errantes, superflua colentes, temporalia diligentes, aeterna nescientes. Haec Sapientia stultis amica non fuit. Cum ergo stultis amica non esset, et a stultis longe esset; assumpsit proximum nostrum, et facta est proxima nostra. Hoc mysterium Christi est. Quid tam longe, quam stultitia a sapientia? Quid tam proximum, quam homo, et homo? Quid tam longinquum, inquam, quam a stultitia sapientia? Ergo suscepit hominem sapientia, et facta est homini proxima per id, quod erat proximum.","english":"If we wished to commemorate those things, we would cause great delays. Let us therefore say what is necessary. Whatever other things there will be, these will be superfluous. These two things are necessary in this world: Safety and a Friend. These are what we ought to value greatly, what we ought not to despise. Safety and a Friend are natural goods. God made man so that he might exist and live. That is Safety. But lest he be alone, Friendship was sought. Friendship therefore begins with a spouse and children, and advances even to strangers. But if we consider that we all had one father and one mother, who will be a stranger? Every man is a neighbor to every man. Ask nature. Is he unknown? He is a man. Is he an enemy? He is a man. Is he a foe? He is a man. Is he a friend? Let him remain a friend. Is he an enemy? Let him become a friend.\n\nTo these two things necessary in this world, Safety and a Friend, came a wisdom from abroad. It found all men foolish, wandering, cultivating superfluous things, loving temporal things, ignorant of eternal things. This Wisdom was not a friend to fools. Since therefore it was not a friend to fools, and was far from fools, it took up our neighbor and became our neighbor. This is the mystery of Christ. What is so far off as folly from wisdom? What is so near as man and man? What, I say, is so far off as wisdom from folly? Therefore Wisdom took up man and became near to man through that which was near.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":112,"ref":"p112","source":"Et ecce, quoniam dixit homini ipsa sapientia: Ecce pietas est sapientia; ad sapientiam vero hominis pertinet colere Deum, quia hoc est pietas, data sunt nobis duo praecepta: Diliges Dominum Deum tuum ex toto corde tuo, et ex tota anima tua, et ex tota mente tua. Alterum: Diliges proximum tuum tanquam te ipsum (Luc. x, 27). Et ille, qui hoc audivit, ait: Et quis est mihi proximus (Ibid. 29). Putabat dicturum Dominum: Pater tuus, et mater tua, conjux tua, filii tui, fratres tui, sorores tuae. Non hoc respondit, sed qui volebat commendare omnem hominem omni homini proximum, instituit narrationem. Homo, inquit, quidam. Quis quidam? Tamen homo. Homo quidam. Quis ergo homo? Quidam, sed tamen homo. Descendebat de Jerusalem in Jericho et incidit in latrones (Luc. x, 30). Ipsi dicuntur in latrones, qui et insequuntur nos. Vulneratus, spoliatus, semivivus, in via relictus a transeuntibus, a sacerdote, a levita contemptus est, a Samaritano autem transeunte animadversus est. Accessum est ad eum, inspecta cura, levatus est in jumentum, perductus ad stabulum, jussum est curam ei adhiberi, sumptus impensus est. Interrogatur, qui interrogaverat: Quis erat huic semivivo proximus? Quia duo contempserant, et contempserant proximi, accessit extraneus Iste enim homo Jerosolymitanus proximos habebat sacerdotes, et levitas, Samaritanos alienigenas.","english":"And behold, since Wisdom itself said to man: Behold, godliness is wisdom; but it belongs to man's wisdom to worship God, because this is godliness, two commandments have been given to us: You shall love the Lord your God with your whole heart, and with your whole soul, and with your whole mind. The second: You shall love your neighbor as yourself (Luke 10:27). And he who heard this said: And who is my neighbor (ibid. 29). He thought the Lord would say: Your father and your mother, your wife, your sons, your brothers, your sisters. He did not answer this, but he who wished to commend every man as neighbor to every man set forth a narrative. A certain man, he says. Who, a certain man? Nevertheless a man. A certain man. Who then is the man? A certain one, but nevertheless a man. He was going down from Jerusalem to Jericho and fell among robbers (Luke 10:30). Those are said to fall among robbers who also pursue us. Wounded, stripped, half-dead, left on the road, he was despised by those passing by, by the priest, by the Levite, but was noticed by the Samaritan passing by. Approach was made to him, care was examined, he was lifted onto the beast, led to the inn, orders were given that care be given him, expense was paid out. He is asked, who had asked: Who was neighbor to this half-dead man? Because two had despised him, and had despised him though neighbors, a stranger came near. For this man, a Jerusalemite, had as neighbors priests and Levites, and Samaritans as foreigners.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":113,"ref":"p113","source":"Transierunt proximi, et extraneus factus est proximus. Quis ergo erat huic homini proximus? Dic tu, qui interrogaveras dicens: Quis est mihi proximus? Jam responde, quod verum est. Interrogaverat superbia. Loquatur natura. Quid ergo ait? Credo, qui cum illo fecit misericordiam. Et Dominus ad illum: Vade, et tu fac similiter (Ibid. 37).\n\nRedeamus ad causam. Jam tria videmus: Salutem, Amicum, Sapientiam. Sed Salus et Amicus etiam de hoc mundo; aliunde Sapientia. Propter Salutem victus et tegumentum, et, si mala valetudo occurrerit, medicina. Salvis autem salvus loquens Apostolus ait: Est autem quaestus magnus pietas cum sufficientia. Nihil, inquit, intulimus in hunc mundum, sed neque auferre aliquid possumus. Victum et tegumentum habentes his contenti simus. Ista sunt necessaria propter salutem. Quae autem propter superflua Nam qui volunt, inquit, divites fieri (propter superflua utique) incidunt in tentationem, et laqueum, et desideria multa stulta et noxia, quae mergunt hominem in interitum et perditionem. Ubi ergo Salus? Ergo propter Salutem Victum, et tegumentum habentes his contenti simus (1 Tim. vi. 6, 9). Propter Amicum quid? Quid tibi amplius potuit dici, quam: Diliges proximum tuum tanquam te ipsum? Ergo Salus tibi, Salus sit et amico tuo. Propter tegumentum amici: Qui habet duas tunicas communicet cum non habente.","english":"The neighbors passed by, and the stranger became the neighbor. Who, then, was neighbor to this man? Answer, you who had asked, saying: Who is my neighbor? Now answer what is true. Pride had asked; let nature speak. What then does he say? I believe the one who showed mercy to him. And the Lord said to him: Go, and do likewise.\n\nLet us return to the matter at hand. Now we see three things: Health, a Friend, Wisdom. But Health and a Friend belong even to this world; Wisdom comes from elsewhere. For the sake of Health there is food and clothing, and, if poor health comes upon us, medicine. But the Apostle, speaking to those who are safe, says: Godliness with sufficiency is great gain. He says: We brought nothing into this world, but neither can we carry anything out. Having food and clothing, let us be content with these. These things are necessary for the sake of health. But what of the things that are for the sake of superfluities? For those who wish, he says, to become rich—certainly for the sake of superfluities—fall into temptation, and a snare, and many foolish and harmful desires, which drown a man in destruction and perdition. Where, then, is Health? Therefore, for the sake of Health, having food and clothing, let us be content with these. For the sake of a Friend, what? What more could be said to you than: You shall love your neighbor as yourself? Therefore, as health is for you, so let health be for your friend. For the sake of clothing for a friend: Let the one who has two tunics share with the one who has none.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":114,"ref":"p114","source":"Propter victum amici: Et, qui habet escas, similiter faciat (Luc. iii, 11). Pasceris, pascis; vestiris, vestis. Ista de hoc mundo; aliunde autem, quod est sapientia, discis et doces.\n\nConstituite jam vobis ante oculos agonem Martyrum. Venit inimicus, cogit Christum negare. Sed adhuc blandientem inducamus, non saevientem. Promittit divitias et honores. Superflua sunt. Qui talibus donis tentantur, ut Christum negent, nondum accesserunt ad agonem, nondum certamen invenerunt, nondum hostem antiquissimum vera pugna provocaverunt. Contempsit autem, cui talia promittebantur, Vir fidelis, et ait: Ego propter divitias negabo Christum? Ego propter divitias negabo divitias? Ego propter aurum negabo thesaurum? Nempe ille est: Qui propter nos pauper factus est, cum dives esset, ut ejus paupertate nos ditaremur (2 Cor. viii. 9)? Nempe ille est, de quo item ait Apostolus: In quo sunt omnes thesauri sapientiae et scientiae absconditi (Coloss. ii. 3)? Attendis, quod promittis, quia non potes videre, quod tollere conaris. Ego fide video, quod mihi vis auferre, tu oculis carnis, quod vis dare. Meliora sunt, quae cordis oculos intuetur, quam quae oculus carnis videt. Quae enim videntur, temporalia sunt, quae autem non videntur, aeterna. Contemno ergo dona tua, inquit fidelis anima, quia temporalia sunt, superflua sunt, caduca sunt, volatica sunt, plena sunt periculis, plena tentationibus.","english":"For the sake of a friend's sustenance: And let him who has food do likewise (Luke 3:11). You are fed, feed; you are clothed, clothe. These things are from this world; but from elsewhere comes what is wisdom, which you learn and teach.\n\nNow set before your eyes the contest of the Martyrs. The enemy comes, he compels one to deny Christ. But let us bring him in still flattering, not raging. He promises riches and honors. They are superfluous. Those who are tempted by such gifts to deny Christ have not yet come to the contest, have not yet found the struggle, have not yet provoked the most ancient enemy to true battle. But the faithful man, to whom such things were promised, despised them, and said: Shall I deny Christ for the sake of riches? Shall I deny riches for the sake of riches? Shall I deny the treasure for the sake of gold? Is he not indeed the one who for our sake became poor, though he was rich, so that by his poverty we might be made rich (2 Cor 8:9)? Is he not indeed the one of whom the Apostle also says: In whom are hidden all the treasures of wisdom and knowledge (Col 2:3)? You attend to what you promise, because you cannot see what you are trying to take away. I see by faith what you wish to snatch from me; you see with the eyes of the flesh what you wish to give. Better are the things that the eyes of the heart behold than the things that the eye of the flesh sees. For the things that are seen are temporal, but the things that are not seen are eternal. I despise your gifts, says the faithful soul, because they are temporal, they are superfluous, they are fleeting, they are transitory, they are full of dangers, full of temptations.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":115,"ref":"p115","source":"Nemo haec habet, quando vult, perdit et quando non vult. Contemptus est promissor; accedit alius, id est, persecutor. Contemptus est blandiens; esse incipit saeviens. Contemptus est coluber; in leonem conversus est. Non vis, inquit, accipere a me divitias ampliores? Si Christum non negaveris, auferam, quas habes. Adhuc in superflua mea saevis. Sicut novacula acuta fecisti dolum (Psal. li, 4). Capillos radis, cutem non praecidis. Aufer etiam ista mihi. Imo, quoniam videbas, quod pauperibus exinde dabam, hospites suscipiebam, quod monuerat Paulus, faciebam. Praecipe, inquit, divitibus hujus saculi, praecipe, non superbe sapere, neque sperare in incerto divitiarum, sed in Deo vivo, qui praestat nobis omnia abundanter ad fruendum. Bene faciant, divites sint in operibus bonis, facile tribuant, communicent, thesaurizent sibi fundamentum bonum in futurum, ut apprehendant veram vitam (1 Tim. vi, 17-19). Haec mihi auferens, ista opera facturus non sum. Numquid apud Deum ideo minor ero, quia volo, et non possum? An usque adeo surdus sum adversus vocem Angelorum: Pax in terra hominibus bonae voluntatis (Luc. ii, 14)? Tolle ergo superflua mea. Nihil intulimus in hunc mundum, sed neque auferre aliquid possumus. Victum et tegumentum habentes eo contenti simus (1 Tim. vi. 8).","english":"No one has these things when he wants them, and he loses them even when he does not want to. The promiser was despised; another comes, that is, the persecutor. The flatterer was despised; he begins to be a raging persecutor. The serpent was despised; he has been turned into a lion. \"Do you not wish,\" he says, \"to receive from me greater riches? If you do not deny Christ, I will take away the things you have.\" You are still raging against my superfluities. \"You have made deceit like a sharp razor\" (Ps. 51:4). You shave off the hair, you do not cut the skin. Take away these things from me as well. Nay rather, because you saw that I was giving from them to the poor and receiving strangers, I was doing what Paul had admonished. \"Command,\" he says, \"the rich of this world, command them not to be proud, nor to hope in the uncertainty of riches, but in the living God, who provides us all things abundantly to enjoy. Let them do good, let them be rich in good works, let them give readily, let them share, let them store up for themselves a good foundation for the future, so that they may lay hold of true life\" (1 Tim. 6:17-19). By taking these things from me, I will not do those works. Shall I therefore be less in God's sight because I want to and cannot? Or am I so deaf to the voice of the angels: \"Peace on earth to men of good will\" (Luke 2:14)? Take away, then, my superfluities. \"We brought nothing into this world, but neither can we take anything out.\" Having food and clothing, let us be content with these (1 Tim. 6:8).","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":116,"ref":"p116","source":"Sed ait persecutor: Tollo victum, tollo tegumentum. Accessum est ad certamen. Ferventius saeviebat inimicus. Transita sunt superflua, perventum est ad necessaria. Ne discedas a me, quoniam tribulatio proxima est (Psal. xxi, 11, 12)! Nihil tam proximum animae suae, quam caro sua. Fames, et sites, et aestus in carne sentis. Ibi te volo videre. Martyr bone! Testis Dei! Vide, inquit, vide! Quis nos separabit a charitate Christi? Quid est, quod minaris? Tollo victum, tollo tegumentum. Tribulatio? an angustia? an fames? an nudit(??)s (Rom. viii, 35)? Minetur ex altera parte; Tollo amicum, occido charissimos tuos ante oculos tuos, conjugem et filios trucidabo! Occidis, occidis: Non negent, et non occidis. Quid est, quia non me terres de me, terres me de meis? Si non negaverint, meos non occidis; si negaverint, alienos occidis. Adhuc addat persecutor, et saeviat, et dicat: Si tuos non curas, te huic luci auferam. Huic luci? Numquid aeternae luci? Cui luci me auferes? Quam communem habeo et tecum? Non est magna, quam vides et tu. Ego pro hoc lumine non negabo lumen. Erat lumen verum (Joan. 1, 9). Novi, cui dicam: Quoniam apud te fons vitae, et in lumine tuo videbimus l(??) (Psal. xxxv, 10). Tolle vitam, tolle lumen. Habebo vitam, habebo lumen. Habebo vitam, ubi te non patiar interfectorem, habebo lumen, quod mihi, non dicam tu, sed nec ulla nox possit auferre.","english":"But the persecutor says: I take away your food, I take away your covering. We have come to the contest. The enemy raged more fiercely. The superfluous things have been passed over; we have come to the necessary things. Do not depart from me, for tribulation is near (Ps. 21:11-12)! Nothing is so near to a man's soul as his own flesh. You feel hunger and thirst and heat in the flesh. There I want to see you. Good martyr! Witness of God! See, he says, see! Who shall separate us from the love of Christ? What is it that you threaten? I take away your food, I take away your covering. Is it tribulation? or distress? or famine? or nakedness (Rom. 8:35)? Let him threaten from the other side: I take away your friend, I kill your dearest ones before your eyes, I will slaughter your wife and children! You kill, you kill: let them not deny, and you do not kill. What is this, that you do not terrify me concerning myself, but terrify me concerning my own? If they do not deny, you do not kill my own; if they deny, you kill those who are not mine. Let the persecutor add yet more, and rage, and say: If you do not care for your own, I will take you from this light. From this light? Not from the eternal light? From what light will you take me? What light do I share in common with you? The light you see, you also see; it is not great. I will not deny the light for the sake of this light. There was the true light (John 1:9). I know to whom I shall say: For with you is the fountain of life, and in your light we shall see light (Ps. 35:10). Take away life, take away light. I shall have life, I shall have light. I shall have life where I shall not endure you as a killer; I shall have light which, I will not say you, but not even any night can take from me.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":117,"ref":"p117","source":"Vicit Martyr, an aliquid aliud est, ubi majus certamen spectare debeamus? Non minatur mortem; saevit in salutem, exarat ungulis, excruciat tormentis, urit flammis, admovet bestias; et hic vincitur. Quare vincitur? Quia in his omnibus supervincimus per eum, qui dilexit nos (Rom. viii, 37).\n\nErgo, fratres mei, non negetur Christus propter superflua, non negetur propter necessaria. Nullus ipso est magis necessarius. Necessaria dicebam: Salutem et Amicum. Peccas propter Salutem, et negas Christum. Amando Salutem non habebis Salutem. Peccas propter Amicum tuum, et, ne illum offendas, negas Christum. Heu me miserum! Aliquando erubescendo negatur. Non saevit persecutor, non expoliat depraedator, non incumbit tortor; tantum ne displiceas amico tuo, negas Dominum tuum. Video, quid tibi abstulerit amicus, ostende, quid dabit. Quid dabit? Ipsas amicitias, per quas pecces, per quas involvaris, per quas inimicus Dei efficiaris. Iste tibi amicus non esset, si tu tibi esses. Sed quoniam ipse inimicus es tibi, amicum putas inimicum tibi. Unde autem ipse inimicus es tibi? Quia amas iniquitatem. Qui autem amat iniquitatem, odit animam suam (Psal. x, 6). Sed non negatur Christus ut amico impio et perverso placeatur, non negatur, sed ab impio vituperatur, ab impio accusatur, et a fideli erubescendo non defenditur, deseritur, tacetur, non praedicatur.","english":"The Martyr has conquered—or is there something else, where we ought to look upon a greater contest? He does not threaten death; he rages against salvation, he scrapes with nails, he tortures with torments, he burns with flames, he brings up beasts; and here he is conquered. Why is he conquered? Because in all these things we super-conquer through him who loved us (Rom 8:37).\n\nTherefore, my brothers, let not Christ be denied for the sake of superfluous things, let him not be denied for the sake of necessary things. Nothing is more necessary than he. I was saying necessary things: Salvation and a Friend. You sin for the sake of Salvation, and you deny Christ. By loving Salvation you will not have Salvation. You sin for the sake of your Friend, and, lest you offend him, you deny Christ. Woe is me, miserable! Sometimes he is denied by blushing. The persecutor does not rage, the plunderer does not despoil, the torturer does not press upon you; only so that you may not displease your friend, you deny your Lord. I see what your friend has taken from you; show what he will give. What will he give? The very friendships through which you sin, through which you are entangled, through which you are made an enemy of God. That man would not be your friend, if you were your own. But since you are yourself your own enemy, you think a friend to be an enemy to you. But whence are you yourself an enemy to yourself? Because you love iniquity. But he who loves iniquity hates his own soul (Ps 10:6). But Christ is not denied so that an impious and perverse friend may be pleased; he is not denied, but he is reviled by the impious, he is accused by the impious, and by the faithful, through blushing, he is not defended, he is deserted, he is kept silent, he is not preached.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":118,"ref":"p118","source":"Saevit lingua blasphemantis, et nulla est laudantis. Quanta mala committuntur quasi pro necessariis, pro victu, pro tegumento, pro salute, pro amico, et omnia ista, quae appetuntur, magis pereunt! Si vero praesentia contempseris, dabit tibi Deus aeterna. Contemne salutem, habebis immortalitatem. Contemne mortem, habebis vitam. Contemne honorem, habebis coronam. Contemne amicum hominem, habebis amicum Deum. Sed illic, ubi amicum habebis Deum, sine amico proximo non eris. Ibi tecum amici, erunt, quorum facta et confessiones paulo ante legebantur.\n\nAudivimus Viros fortiter agentes, viriliter confitentes. Audivimus et Foeminas non tanquam foeminas tenentes Christum, oblitas sexum. Ibi erit cum istis illa amicitia, ubi nulla erit carnis concupiscentia, et sola erit cum amicis ad fruendum sapientia. Ecce quid perdimus, si ea hic amaverimus, et Christum negaverimus! Proximus ibi nos non terret, si moriatur. Nullus ibi luctus, ubi aeterna vita erit, nec illud necessarium est; Victum et tegumentum habentes his contenti simus. Vestis nostra immortalitas erit, cibus iste charitas erit, vita aeterna erit, nec opera ibi bona, quae ab his appellantur, faciemus. Ad ea non perveniemus, si hic ea non fecerimus. Non tibi dicetur: Frange esurienti panem tuum (Isai. lviii, 7), ubi fames non erit. Non tibi dicetur: Suscipe hospitio, ubi nullum invenies peregrinum.","english":"The tongue of the blasphemer rages, and there is no tongue of one praising. How many evils are committed as if for necessities—for food, for clothing, for safety, for a friend—and all those things that are sought after perish all the more! But if you have despised present things, God will give you eternal things. Despise safety, and you will have immortality. Despise death, and you will have life. Despise honor, and you will have a crown. Despise a human friend, and you will have God as a friend. But there, where you will have God as a friend, you will not be without a neighbor as a friend. There your friends will be with you, whose deeds and confessions were read a little earlier.\n\nWe have heard men acting bravely, confessing manfully. We have also heard women holding fast to Christ not as women, forgetful of their sex. There that friendship will be with these, where there will be no concupiscence of the flesh, and there will be wisdom alone with friends to be enjoyed. Behold what we lose if we have loved these things here and have denied Christ! There a neighbor does not terrify us if he dies. There is no mourning there, where there will be eternal life, nor is that necessary; having food and clothing, let us be content with these. Our clothing will be immortality, that food will be charity, it will be eternal life, nor will we do good works there—the ones that are called good by these people. We will not arrive at those things if we have not done them here. It will not be said to you: Break your bread for the hungry (Isaiah 58:7), where there will be no hunger. It will not be said to you: Receive into hospitality, where you will find no stranger.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":119,"ref":"p119","source":"Non tibi dicetur: Libera oppressum, ubi nullus inimicus erit. Non tibi dicetur: Concorda litigiosum, ubi pax aeterna erit. Videte, fratres mei, quomodo hic toleretur quaerendo. Ibi eam habebimus, ubi perire non possumus. Salutem quaeris? Contemne, et habebis. Negas Christum timendo offendere amicitias hominum. Confitere Christum, et amica tibi erit civitas Angelorum, civitas Patriarcharum, civitas Prophetarum, civitas Apostolorum, civitas omnium Martyrum, civitas omnium bonorum Fidelium. Christus ipse Fundavit eam in aeternum (Psal. xlvii, 9).\n\nSERMO XVII.\n\nIn solemnitate SS. Machabaeorum.\n\nSYNOPSIS.\n\nI. Effata Evangelica ad omnes aetates pertinent. II. Expositio Parabolae de Turris fabrica, et de duobus Regibus. III. Adolescens dives cum Christo congressus. IV. Post Apostolos et Judaei conversi, et deinceps multi Christiani rebus suis renuntiarunt. V. Quomodo probanda Christo fides vel in quotidianis. VI. Ad probandam fidem excitare debent Promissa. VII. Machabaeorum. Certamen collatum profanis Spectaculis. VIII. Dehortatio a profanis Spectaculis. IX. Dehortatio continuata.","english":"It will not be said to you: \"Free the oppressed,\" where there will be no enemy. It will not be said to you: \"Be at peace with the quarrelsome,\" where there will be eternal peace. See, my brothers, how it is tolerated here by seeking. There we shall have it, where we cannot perish. Do you seek safety? Despise it, and you shall have it. You deny Christ by fearing to offend the friendships of men. Confess Christ, and the city of the Angels will be a friend to you, the city of the Patriarchs, the city of the Prophets, the city of the Apostles, the city of all the Martyrs, the city of all the good Faithful. Christ himself has founded it forever (Ps. 47:9).\n\nSERMON XVII.\n\nOn the solemnity of the Holy Maccabees.\n\nSYNOPSIS.\n\nI. The words of the Gospel pertain to all ages. II. Exposition of the Parable of the building of the Tower, and of the two Kings. III. The rich young man's meeting with Christ. IV. After the Apostles, both Jews were converted, and thereafter many Christians renounced their possessions. V. How faith is to be proven to Christ, even in daily matters. VI. The Promises ought to stir us to prove our faith. VII. Of the Maccabees. Their contest compared with profane Spectacles. VIII. A dissuasion from profane Spectacles. IX. The dissuasion continued.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":120,"ref":"p120","source":"Evangelium, et verbum Dei vivum, medullas animae penetrans, et cardinem cordis inquirens salubriter profertur omnibus nobis, nec quemquam palpat, si se homo non palpet. Ecce propositum est nobis velut speculum, in quo nos omnes aspiciamus, et, si quid de facie nostra forsitan maculosum occurrerit aspectibus nostris, cura sollicita detergamus, ne rursus inspecto speculo erubescamus. Turba enim Dominum sequebatur, sicut, Evangelium cum legeretur, audivimus, et conversus locutus est ad eos, qui eum sequebantur. Nam, si ea, quae dixit, solis illis duodecim Apostolis loqueretur, poterat unusquisque nostrum dicere: Illis dixit, non nobis. Aliud videtur pertinere ad pastores, aliud ad greges. Sequentibus tui bis dixit, ergo et nobis omnibus, et vobis omnibus dixit. Non, quia tunc nondum eramus, ideo nobis non esse dictum putare debemus. In illum enim et nos credimus, quem illi viderunt, illum nos fide tenemus, quem illi oculis conspexerunt. Neque enim oculis carnalibus videre Christum, magnum fuit. Si hoc magnum fuisset, Judaeorum gens prima salutem invenisset. Certe enim et illi viderunt, et tamen contempserunt, et tamen visum et contemptum insuper occiderunt. Nos autem certe non vidimus, et tamen credimus, et tamen, quem oculis non conspeximus, corde suscepimus. Unde dixit cuidam suo, qui tunc erat inter duodecim: Quia vidisti, credidisti. Beati, qui non vident, et credunt (Joan.","english":"The Gospel, and the living word of God, piercing the marrow of the soul and searching out the hinge of the heart, is wholesomely set forth to all of us, and it flatters no one, if a man does not flatter himself. Behold, a kind of mirror has been set before us, in which we may all look at ourselves, and if perhaps anything blemished on our face meets our gaze, let us wipe it away with careful concern, lest when the mirror is looked into again we blush. For a crowd was following the Lord, as we heard when the Gospel was read, and turning, he spoke to those who were following him. For if he were speaking what he said to those twelve Apostles alone, each one of us could say: \"He said it to them, not to us.\" One thing seems to pertain to shepherds, another to flocks. He spoke to those following him; therefore he spoke both to us all and to you all. We ought not to think that because we were not yet there then, it was therefore not said to us. For we too believe in him whom they saw; we hold by faith him whom they beheld with their eyes. For it was not a great thing to see Christ with bodily eyes. If this had been great, the Jewish people would have found salvation first. For certainly they too saw, and yet they despised him, and yet they even killed the one they had seen and despised. But we certainly did not see, and yet we believe, and yet him whom we have not beheld with our eyes we have received in our heart. Therefore he said to a certain one of his own, who was then among the twelve: \"Because you have seen, you have believed. Blessed are those who do not see, and believe\" (John).","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":121,"ref":"p121","source":"xx, 29). Si enim modo praesens esset in carne Dominus et Salvator noster Jesus Christus, et stans taceret, quid nobis prodesset? Si autem loquendo profuit, et modo loquitur, cum Evangelium recitatur. Verumtamen et praesentia sua multa praestat, ut Deus Ubi autem non est Deus, aut quando absens est Deus? Tu noli esse absens a Deo, et tecum est Deus. Maxime, quia ipse promisit, et promissum ejus conscriptum quodam modo chirographum detinemus. Ecce ego v(??)biscum sum usque in consummationem saeculi (Matth. xxvii, 20). Sed nos praevidebat, nobis promittebat.\n\nRedeamus ergo, et audiamus quid dixit, et, sicut dixi, inspiciamus nos, et, quidquid nobis deesse invenerimus, ad formam pulchritudinis, quae placet oculis ejus, tota diligentia excolamus. Et, quia nos non sufficimus, illum in adjutorium invocemus. Reformet, qui formavit, recreet, qui creavit, ut perfectos recondat, qui condidit. Hoc ergo dixit: Quis est homo, qui vult turrim aedificare, et non sedens primum computat, si habet sumptus, unde perficiat? Ne forte incipiat aedificare, et non impleat, et transeuntes homines dicant: Ecce homo, qui coepit aedificare, et non potuit perficere. Aut quis est iterum Rex, qui vadit gerere contra alium Regem bellum, et non prius considerat, utrum sit idoneus cum decem millibus occurrere illi, qui habet viginti millia?","english":"If the Lord and Savior Jesus Christ were present in the flesh now and stood silent, what would it profit us? But if he profited us by speaking, he speaks even now when the Gospel is read. Yet his presence also bestows many things, as God. But where is God not? Or when is God absent? Do not be absent from God, and God is with you. Especially since he himself promised it, and we hold his promise written down, as it were, in a kind of handwriting: Behold, I am with you even to the consummation of the age. But he was foreseeing us, he was promising to us.\n\nLet us therefore return and hear what he said, and, as I said, let us examine ourselves, and whatever we find lacking in us, let us cultivate with all diligence according to the form of beauty that is pleasing to his eyes. And because we are not sufficient of ourselves, let us call upon him for help. Let him reform, who formed; let him recreate, who created; that he may store up the perfect, who established. This, then, is what he said: Who is the man who wishes to build a tower, and does not first sit down and count whether he has the means to finish it? Lest perhaps he begin to build and not complete it, and passersby say: Behold the man who began to build and could not finish. Or again, who is the king who goes to wage war against another king, and does not first consider whether he is able with ten thousand to meet the one who has twenty thousand?","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":122,"ref":"p122","source":"Alioquin, cum adhuc ille longe est, mittit legatos quaerens pacem, Et ad istas duas similitudines conclusit ita: Sic, qui non renuntiat omnibus, quae sunt ejus, non potest esse meus discipulus (Luc. xiv, 33). Si soli illi Discipuli vocarentur, nobis non esset dictum. Quia vero, sicut Scriptura testatur, omnes Christiani discipuli Christi sunt: Unus est enim, inquit, vester magister Christus (Matth, xxiii, 10), ille solus Christi se neget esse discipulum, qui Christum negat magistrum. Neque enim, quia de superiore isto loco loquimur vobis, ideo magistri vestri sumus. Ille est enim omnium magister, cujus cathedra est super omnes coelos, sub illo in unam scholam convenimus, et vos et nos condiscipuli sumus; sed monemus vos, quomodo solent majores scholae. Turris, et sumptus, fides, et patientia. Turris fides, patientia sumptus sunt. Si quis impatiens fuerit ad toleranda mala mundi hujus, defecit sumptibus. Rex malus cum viginti millibus diabolus est, rex cum decem millibus Christianus est. Simplum contra duplum, veritas contra falsitatem, quia simplicitas contra duplicitatem. Esto simplici corde. Noli esse hypocrita, aliud ostentans, aliud agens, et vincis eum duplicem, qui transfigurat se velut Angelum lucis. Unde isti ubi illi sumptus? Ubi perfecta illa simplicitas, et omnino stabilis, atque inconcussissime perseverans In eo, quod sequitur, quod durum videtur.","english":"Otherwise, while he is still far off, he sends envoys seeking peace. And he concluded with these two parables thus: So, whoever does not renounce all that is his cannot be my disciple (Luke 14:33). If only those disciples were called such, it would not have been said to us. But since, as Scripture testifies, all Christians are disciples of Christ—for One is your master, Christ, he says (Matthew 23:10)—only the one who denies Christ as master denies himself to be a disciple of Christ. Nor, because we speak to you from this higher place, are we therefore your masters. For he is the master of all, whose throne is above all the heavens; under him we have come together into one school, and both you and we are fellow disciples; but we admonish you, as older students in a school are wont to do. The tower and the expenses: faith and patience. The tower is faith, the expenses are patience. If anyone is impatient in enduring the evils of this world, he has failed in the expenses. The evil king with twenty thousand is the devil; the Christian is a king with ten thousand. The single against the double, truth against falsehood, because simplicity is against duplicity. Be of a simple heart. Do not be a hypocrite, showing one thing and doing another, and you conquer him who is double, who transforms himself as if into an angel of light. Hence, where are those expenses of his? Where is that perfect simplicity, and wholly stable, and most unshakenly persevering in what follows, which seems hard?","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":123,"ref":"p123","source":"Hoc est, quod dixi, quia sermo Dei neminem palpat. Sic, inquit, qui non renuntiat omnibus, quae sunt ejus, non potest meus esse discipulus. Multi hoc fecerunt, et se ipsos examinaverunt, antequam tempus persecutionis urgeret, et renuntiaverunt omnibus, quae sunt mundi, et secuti sunt Christum. Inde fuerunt Apostoli, qui (??) xerunt: Ecce nos dimisimus omnia, et secuti sumus te (Luc. xviii, 28). Nec ipsi magnum aliquid dimiserunt, quia omnes pauperes fuerunt, sed magnas prorsus dimisisse judicantur facultates, qui vicerunt omnes cupiditates.\n\nDenique Discipuli tunc dixerunt hoc Domino, quando dives ille tristis abscessit, qui consilium vitae aeternae, sicut petierat a Magistro veracissimo, audivit. Ipse enim venit ad Dominum dives quidam adolescens, et ait illi: Magister bone. Quid boni faciam, ut vitam aeternam consequar (Matth. xix, 16)? Credo inter delicias affluentissimas divitiarum suarum pungebatur stimulo futurae mortis, et contabescebat, et, quia nihil eorum, quae possidebat, ad inferos secum portare poterat, sciebat, et inter magnas carnis copias inops anima gemebat. Dicebat, ut existimandum est, apud semetipsum circumfusus affluentia divitiarum suarum: Bona sunt, pulchra sunt, deliciosa sunt, dulcia sunt; sed una hora illa novissima quando venerit, cuncta relinquenda sunt. Nihil eorum hinc auferendum est.","english":"This is what I said, that the word of God flatters no one. Thus, he says, whoever does not renounce all that are his cannot be my disciple. Many have done this, and have examined themselves before the time of persecution pressed hard, and have renounced all things that are of the world, and have followed Christ. From these were the Apostles, who said: Behold, we have left all things and have followed you (Luke 18:28). Nor did they themselves leave behind anything great, since they were all poor, but they are judged to have left behind truly great wealth, who overcame all desires.\n\nFinally, the disciples said this to the Lord then, when that rich man went away sorrowful, who heard the counsel of eternal life, just as he had asked of the most truthful Master. For a certain rich young man came to the Lord and said to him: Good Master, what good shall I do that I may obtain eternal life (Matthew 19:16)? I believe that amid the most abundant delights of his riches he was pricked by the sting of future death, and was wasting away, and because he knew that he could carry nothing of what he possessed with him to the underworld, even amid great abundance of the flesh his soul groaned in want. He was saying, as must be supposed, within himself, surrounded by the affluence of his riches: They are good, they are beautiful, they are delightful, they are sweet; but when that last hour comes, all must be left behind. Nothing of them is to be taken from here.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":124,"ref":"p124","source":"Restat vita et sola conscientia, restat post corpus anima: vita, et sola conscientia. Quae, si erit, non jam vita, sed mors altera, pejorque dicenda est. Nihil enim pejus illa morte, ubi mors non moritur. Hoc ille quia inter suas delicias cogitabat, habens tanta bona venit ad Dominum. Dicebat enim sibi: Post ista tanta bona si habuero et vitam aeternam, quid me felicius? Unde ergo sollicitus erat, interrogavit, et ait: Magister bone, quid faciam, ut vitam aeternam consequar? Respondit ei Dominus primo: Quid me interrogas de bono? Nemo bonus, nisi unus Deus (Matth. xix, 17). Hoc est dicere: Non te facit beatum, nisi unus Deus. Quae habent divites, bona sunt enim; sed illa bona non faciunt bonos. Nam, si illa bona fecissent bonos, tanto esset quisque melior, quanto esset his abundantior. Cum vero videamus multos quanto copiosiores, tanto pejores, sine dubio alia sunt quaerenda bona, quae faciunt bonos. Ipsa enim sunt, quae non possunt haberi a malis: justitia, pietas, temperantia, religio, charitas, Dei cultus, ipse postremo Deus. Ad illum bonum concurrere debemus. Illum, nisi his contemptis, non assequemur.","english":"What remains is life and conscience alone; what remains after the body is the soul—life, and conscience alone. And this, if it shall be [life], must now be called not life but a second death, and a worse one. For nothing is worse than that death, where death does not die. Because that man was thinking of this among his delights, having such great goods, he came to the Lord. For he was saying to himself: After such great goods, if I have eternal life too, what will be happier than I? Therefore, being anxious about this, he asked and said: Good Teacher, what shall I do to obtain eternal life? The Lord answered him first: Why do you ask me about what is good? No one is good except the one God (Matt. 19:17). That is to say: Nothing makes you blessed except the one God. The things that the rich possess are goods, for they are goods; but those goods do not make people good. For if those goods made people good, each person would be better the more abundantly he had them. But since we see that many are worse the more abundantly they have them, without doubt other goods must be sought, which make people good. For these are the things that cannot be possessed by the wicked: justice, piety, temperance, religion, charity, the worship of God, and finally God himself. We ought to run together to that good. We shall not attain it unless we have despised these things.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":125,"ref":"p125","source":"Ego vos palpem, quando Evangelium nec vos, nec nos palpat? Exhortor ergo Charitatem Vestram, fratres, sicut dicit Apostolus: Tempus breve est. Reliquum est, inquit, ut, et qui habent uxores, tanquam non habentes sint, et, qui flent, tanquam non flentes, et, qui gaudent, tanquam non gaudentes, et, qui emunt, tanquam non ementes, et, qui utuntur hoc mundo, tanquam non utentes (1 Cor, vii, 29-31). Dimiserunt ergo Apostoli tunc ea, quae habebant, et ideo Petrus dixit: Ecce nos dimisimus omnia. Quid dimisisti, Petre? Unam naviculam, et unum rete? Responderet mihi: Totum mundum dimisi, qui mihi nihil dimisi. Omnium paupertas, id est, omnium pauperum, parvas habet facultates, sed magnas habet cupiditates. Non attendit Deus, quid habeat, sed quid velit. Voluntas judicatur, quae ab illo, qui non videtur, invisibiliter perscrutatur. Ergo omnia dimiserunt, et prorsus totum mundum dimiserunt, quia quidquid sperabant in hoc mundo amputaverunt, et eum, a quo factus est mundus, secuti sunt, ejus promissis crediderunt, et postea multi hoc fecerunt. Et mirum est, fratres mei, qui hoc fecit? Ipsi hoc fecerunt, qui Dominum occiderunt. Ibi in Jerusalem, cum Dominus ascendisset in coelum, et post decem dies misso Spiritu sancto impleret promissum, impleti Spiritu sancto Discipuli linguis omnium gentium locuti sunt (Act. II).","english":"Am I to stroke you, when the Gospel strokes neither you nor us? I exhort therefore your Charity, brothers, as the Apostle says: The time is short. It remains, he says, that those who have wives be as though they had none, and those who weep as though they wept not, and those who rejoice as though they rejoiced not, and those who buy as though they bought not, and those who use this world as though they used it not (1 Cor 7:29-31). The Apostles therefore then gave up what they had, and so Peter said: Behold, we have left all things. What did you leave, Peter? One little boat and one net? He would answer me: I left the whole world, who left nothing for myself. The poverty of all, that is, of all the poor, has small means but great desires. God does not attend to what a man has, but to what he wills. The will is judged, which by him who is not seen is invisibly searched out. Therefore they left all things, and plainly they left the whole world, because whatever they hoped for in this world they cut off, and they followed him by whom the world was made, they believed his promises, and afterward many did this. And it is a wonder, my brothers, who did this? They did this who killed the Lord. There in Jerusalem, when the Lord had ascended into heaven, and after ten days, the Holy Spirit having been sent, he fulfilled his promise, the Disciples, filled with the Holy Spirit, spoke in the tongues of all nations (Acts 2).","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":126,"ref":"p126","source":"Tunc audientes multi Judaei, qui erant in Jerosolymis, et expavescentes donum gratiae Salvatoris, cum mirarentur, et stupentes ambigerent inter se, unde illud esset, acceperunt responsum ab Apostolis, quod ille hoc praestiterit Spiritu suo, quem ipsi occiderunt, et consilium salutis quaesierunt. Desperaverant enim et non arbitrabantur posse sibi donari tantum scelus, qui Dominum universae creaturae occiderunt. Et acceperunt consolationem ab Apostolis. Promissa venia, promissa impunitate crediderunt, et omnia, quae habebant, vendentes, pretia rerum suarum ad pedes Apostolorum posuerunt, quanto plus territi, tanto magis boni. Major timor extorsit delicias. Fecerunt hoc illi, qui Dominum occiderunt; fecerunt postea multi, et faciunt multi. Novimus, exempla conspicimus, in multis consolamur, in multis delectamur, quia verbum Dei non vacat in eis, qui fideliter audiunt. Sed aliqui non fecerunt, et veniente persecutione probati sunt? Quia utebantur mundo Tanquam non utentes. Non plebeii solum, non quicumque opifices, non pauperes, non egeni, non mediocres, sed multi etiam magni divites, senatores, clarissimae etiam foeminae veniente persecutione omnibus suis renuntiaverunt, ut turrim perficerent, et simplicitate fortitudinis atque pietatis duplicem ac fallacem diabolum vincerent.","english":"Then many Jews who were in Jerusalem, hearing this and dreading the gift of the Savior's grace, while they marveled and, astonished, debated among themselves whence this could be, received an answer from the Apostles: that he had accomplished this by his own Spirit, whom they themselves had killed; and they sought the counsel of salvation. For they had despaired and did not think that so great a crime could be granted to them, who had killed the Lord of all creation. And they received consolation from the Apostles. With pardon promised, with impunity promised, they believed, and selling all that they had, they laid the prices of their possessions at the feet of the Apostles—the more terrified they were, the more good they became. Greater fear wrung out their pleasures. Those who had killed the Lord did this; many did it afterward, and many do it now. We know it, we behold the examples, we are consoled in many, we are delighted in many, because the word of God is not void in those who hear faithfully. But some did not do it, and when persecution came were they proven? Because they were using the world as though not using it. Not only common people, not only any craftsmen, not the poor, not the needy, not those of modest means, but many even of the great and rich, senators, and even most distinguished women, when persecution came renounced all their possessions, so that they might finish the tower, and by the simplicity of fortitude and piety might overcome the twofold and deceitful devil.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":127,"ref":"p127","source":"Exhortans ergo ad martyrium Dominus Christus omnibus dixit: Sic, qui non renuntiat omnibus, quae sunt ejus, non potest esse meus discipulus. Interrogo ergo te, o anima christiana! Si tibi dicam, quod dictum est diviti: Vade, vende et tu omnia tua, et habebis thesaurum in coelo, et veni, sequere Christum (Matth. xix, 2), forte et tu tristis abscedes? Sic enim et ille juvenis tristis abscessit. Tamen ista verba non potest audire nisi Christianus. Numquid, quando lectum est Evangelium, potuisti tibi contra salutem tuam aures claudere? Audisti: Qui non renuntiat omnibus, quae sunt ejus, non potest meus esse discipulus. Cogita apud te ipsum: Fidelis factus es, baptizatus es, credidisti. Facultates tuas non dimisisti, sed fidem tuam interrogo. Quomodo credidisti? Ecce venit periculum fidei. Dicitur tibi: Si persistis, tollo, quod habes. Animum tuum interrogo. Si dicis in animo tuo: Tollat, quod habeo, fidem non dimitto! et tenes, et renuntiasti. Quia tenes, non teneris. Non est enim malum tenere. Teneri est malum. Sed deest persecutio, et non est, quomodo probes, quod Domino promisisti? Negotia quotidiana probant homines. Quid si enim aliquando, nescio, quis te ad falsum testimonium vocet, et sit potens, qui possit timeri pro tempore, et, si fuerit comminatus, pro tempore possit nocere, et persuadeat tibi dicere falsum testimonium?","english":"Therefore Christ the Lord, exhorting all to martyrdom, said: So, whoever does not renounce all that is his cannot be my disciple. I ask you, then, O Christian soul! If I say to you what was said to the rich man: Go, sell all that is yours, and you will have treasure in heaven, and come, follow Christ, perhaps you too will go away sad? For so that young man also went away sad. Yet these words can be heard by none but a Christian. When the Gospel was read, could you close your ears against your own salvation? You heard: Whoever does not renounce all that is his cannot be my disciple. Consider within yourself: You have been made faithful, you have been baptized, you have believed. You have not given up your possessions, but I ask about your faith. How did you believe? Behold, the trial of faith has come. It is said to you: If you persist, I will take away what you have. I ask your soul. If you say in your soul: Let him take away what I have, I do not give up the faith! then you both hold and have renounced. Because you hold, you are not held. For it is not evil to hold. To be held is evil. But persecution is lacking, and there is no way for you to prove what you promised the Lord. Daily affairs test people. What if sometime, I know not who, someone calls you to bear false witness, and he is powerful, one who can be feared for a time, and if he has threatened, can harm for a time, and persuades you to speak false witness?","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":128,"ref":"p128","source":"Non tibi dicit: Nega Christum: ad hoc te enim tu praeparabas. Alio modo subrepsit duplex ille, ad quod non meditabaris, quod tibi non proponebas. Dic, inquit, falsum testimonium. Si non dixeris, faciam hoc, et illud. Minatur proscriptionem, minatur mortem. Ibi te proba, ibi te attende. Dicis falsum testimonium? Dimisisti Christum, quia ipse dixit: Ego sum veritas (Joan. xiv, 6). Falsum testimonium dixisti, contra veritatem fecisti, ergo Christum dimisisti. Et quid tibi ille facturus erat minando proscriptionem? Inopem redditurum? Quid tibi deesset, cum quo Deus esset? Sed plus minabatur. Quid est ipsum plus? Occisurum te minabatur. Carnem. Numquid animam? Quid ille minabatur, attendis. Quid tu facias, non attendis? Ille carnem occidere comminatur. Os autem, quod mentitur, occidit animam (Sap. i, 11). Duo estis, inimicus, et tu; tamen et ille homo, ut tu. Ambo corruptibiles secundum carnem, ambo immortales secundum animam, ambo pro tempore transituri, et in hac terra hospites et peregrini. Minatur ille mortem, nesciens, utrum ante moriatur, quam impleat, quod minatur; sed tamen puta, quia et, quod minatur, impleat; discutio vos, videamus, quis sit tibi pejor inimicus, utrum ille, an tu. Profert ille machaeram ad occidendam carnem tuam, profers tu falsam linguam ad trucidandam animam tuam. Quis gladius percussit? Quis pejus occidit? Quis interius penetravit?","english":"He does not say to you: Deny Christ—for that is what you were preparing yourself for. In another way that double foe crept in, at a point you had not meditated on, that you had not set before yourself. Say, he says, false testimony. If you will not, I will do this and that. He threatens proscription, he threatens death. There prove yourself, there attend to yourself. Do you give false testimony? You have let Christ go, because he himself said: I am the truth (John 14:6). You have given false testimony, you have acted against the truth, therefore you have let Christ go. And what was he going to do to you by threatening proscription? Make you poor? What would you lack, with whom God would be? But he threatened something more. What is that \"more\"? He threatened to kill you. Your flesh. Surely not your soul? You attend to what he threatens; do you not attend to what you are to do? He threatens to kill your flesh. But the mouth that lies kills the soul (Wisdom 1:11). There are two of you, the enemy and you; yet he too is a man, as you are. Both corruptible according to the flesh, both immortal according to the soul, both to pass away in time, and on this earth guests and strangers. He threatens death, not knowing whether he will die before he carries out what he threatens; but suppose that he does carry out what he threatens. I examine you both; let us see who is the worse enemy to you, he or you. He brings forth a sword to kill your flesh; you bring forth a lying tongue to slaughter your soul. Whose sword struck? Who killed more grievously? Who pierced more deeply?","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":129,"ref":"p129","source":"Ille usque ad ossa, ille usque ad viscera, tu usque ad cor. Nihil tibi integrum dimisisti, quando cor tuum perdidisti. Os, quod mentitur, occidit, dixit, non carnem, sed Animam.\n\nTalia sunt quotidiana tentamenta hominum. Quando ventum fuerit ad iniquitatem, ut aut facias iniquitatem, aut patiaris ea, quae voluerit Deus pati pro tempore, ibi jam attende duplicem illum, ibi jam attende sumptus turris illius. Sed cogitando deficis. Invoca eum, qui jussit. Adjuvet jussa sua in te, et reddet tibi promissa sua ex se. Quid enim nobis promittit Deus? Fratres mei! Quid dicam, ut desideremus illud? Quid dicam? Aurum est? Argentum est? Praedia sunt? Honores sunt? Quidquid novimus in terra, est? Vile est. Quod oculus non vidit, nec auris audivit, nec in cor hominis ascendit, quae praeparavit Deus diligentibus se (1 Cor. ii, 9). Breviter dico, non promissa sua, sed se. Major est omnibus, qui fecit omnia. Pulchrior est omnibus, qui formavit omnia. Potentior est omnibus, qui virtutem dedit omnibus. Quidquid ergo amamus in terra, in comparatione. Dei nihil est. Parum est: Nihil est, quod amamus, et nos ipsi nihil sumus. Ipse amator in comparatione rei, quae amanda est, vilescere sibi debet. Ipsa est illa charitas, quae jubetur, Ex toto corde, ex tota anima, et ex tota mente. Sed adjunxit, et ait: Diliges proximum tuum, tanquam te ipsum.","english":"That one reaches even to the bones, even to the inward parts; you reach only to the heart. You have left nothing of yourself whole, since you have lost your heart. The mouth that lies, he said, kills—not the flesh, but the soul.\n\nSuch are the daily temptations of men. When it comes to iniquity—that you must either do iniquity, or endure for a time those things which God wills you to endure—there attend already to that double foe, there attend already to the cost of that tower. But you faint in the thinking. Call upon him who gave the command. Let him help his own commands in you, and he will render to you his own promises from himself. For what does God promise us? My brothers! What shall I say, that we may desire it? What shall I say? Is it gold? Is it silver? Are they estates? Are they honors? Whatever we know on earth—is it that? It is vile. What the eye has not seen, nor the ear heard, nor has it entered into the heart of man, which God has prepared for those who love him (1 Cor. 2:9). I say it briefly: not his promises, but himself. He is greater than all, who made all things. He is fairer than all, who formed all things. He is mightier than all, who gave power to all. Whatever, then, we love on earth, in comparison with God is nothing. It is too little to say: it is nothing, what we love, and we ourselves are nothing. The lover himself, in comparison with the thing that is to be loved, ought to become vile in his own eyes. This is that charity which is commanded: with the whole heart, with the whole soul, and with the whole mind. But he added, and said: You shall love your neighbor as yourself.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":130,"ref":"p130","source":"In his duobus praeceptis tota Lex pendet et Prophetae (Matth. xxii, 37-40), ut, cum tu dilexeris Dominum, scias quia tunc te diligis, si diligis Dominum. Si vero Deum non diligis, nec te ipsum diligis. Cum ergo te didiceris diligere diligendo Deum, rape proximum ad Deum, ut simul fruaris bono, et tanto bono, quod Deus est.\n\nModo spectavimus magnum certamen septem Fratrum et Matris illorum. Quale certamen, fratres mei, si noverunt mentes nostrae spectare? Comparate huic sancto spectaculo voluptates et delicias theatrorum. Ibi oculi inquinantur; hic corda mundantur. Hic laudabilis est spectator, si fuerit imitator; ibi autem et spectator turpis est, et imitator infamis. Denique amo Martyres, specto Martyres. Quando leguntur Passiones Martyrum, specto. Dic mihi: Talis sis, et laudasti. Tu specta Mimum, specta Pantomimum; dicam tibi: Talis sis, et noli irasci. Si autem dico tibi: Talis sis, et irasceris, faciunt te reum non verba mea, sed iracundia tua. Irascendo judicas de te ipso. Ecce quod amas, quod esse formidas. Opportune de spectaculo sanctorum Machabaeorum, quorum victoriae memoriam hodie celebramus, de spectaculis theatricis admonenda visa est Charitas Vestra. O fratres Bullenses, circumquaque prope omnibus civitatibus vicinis vestri lascivia pietas obmutuit. Non erubescitis, quia apud vos solos remansit turpitudo venalis?","english":"On these two commandments hang all the Law and the Prophets (Matt. 22:37-40), so that, when you have loved the Lord, you may know that then you love yourself, if you love the Lord. But if you do not love God, neither do you love yourself. Therefore, when you have learned to love yourself by loving God, draw your neighbor to God, so that together you may enjoy the good—and so great a good—which is God.\n\nJust now we have watched the great contest of the seven brothers and their mother. What a contest, my brothers, if our minds know how to watch it! Compare with this holy spectacle the pleasures and delights of the theaters. There the eyes are defiled; here the hearts are cleansed. Here the spectator is praiseworthy if he has been an imitator; there, however, both the spectator is shameful and the imitator infamous. In short, I love the Martyrs, I watch the Martyrs. When the Passions of the Martyrs are read, I watch. Tell me: be such a one, and you have praised it. You watch the mime, you watch the pantomime; I will say to you: be such a one, and do not be angry. But if I say to you: be such a one, and you are angry, it is not my words that make you guilty, but your own anger. By being angry you pass judgment on yourself. Behold what you love, what you dread to be. Fittingly, concerning the spectacle of the holy Maccabees, whose victory we celebrate today in memory, Your Charity has seemed to be reminded about theatrical spectacles. O brothers of Bulla, round about, in almost all the neighboring cities, your wantonness has silenced piety. Are you not ashamed that among you alone the shameful thing for sale has remained?","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":131,"ref":"p131","source":"An delectat vos, inter frumentum, vinum, oleum, animalia, pecora, et quaecumque in Romanis, vel nundinis venundantur, etiam turpitudinem emere, et vendere? Et fortassis ad talia commercia huc veniant peregrini, et dicitur: Quid quaeris? Mimos, Meretrices? Bullae habes. Gloriam putatis? Nescio, an sit major infamia. Omnino, fratres mei, ex dolore dico, vicinitas aliarum civitatum condemnat vos in conspectu hominum, et in judicio Dei. Quisquis vult malum imitari, vos proponit. Ad Hipponem nostram, ubi jam talia pene defecerunt, turpes istae Personae de vestra Civitate ducuntur. Sed forte dicitis: Nos Carthagini similes sumus. Quomodo apud Carthaginem est plebs sancta et religiosa, sic tanta turba est in magna civitate, ut se excusent omnes de aliis. Pagani faciunt, Judaei faciunt: potest dici Carthagine. Hic, quicumque faciunt, Christiani faciunt. Cum magno dolore vobis haec dicimus. Utinam aliquando vestra correctione vulnus cordis nostri sanetur! Dicimus Charitati Vestrae: Novimus in nomine Dei Civitatem et vestram, et vicinas vobis, quanta est hic multitudo, quantus populus. Potestis nisi noti omnes ei, qui vobis dispensator est constitutus Verbi, et Sacramenti? Quis excusat ab hac turpitudine? Ecce Ludi sunt. Non eant Christiani, et videamus, si non tanta erit solitudo, ut sibi erubescat ipsa turpitudo.","english":"Does it please you, amid grain, wine, oil, animals, cattle, and whatever is sold in the Roman markets or fairs, to buy and sell shamefulness as well? And perhaps foreigners come here for such commerce, and it is said: What are you looking for? Mimes, prostitutes? You have trifles. Do you think this is glory? I do not know whether it is a greater infamy. Altogether, my brothers, I speak from grief: the proximity of other cities condemns you in the sight of men and in the judgment of God. Whoever wishes to imitate evil sets you before him. At our Hippo, where such things have now nearly ceased, these shameful persons are brought from your city. But perhaps you say: We are like Carthage. Just as at Carthage there is a holy and religious people, so in a great city there is such a crowd that all excuse themselves by others. Pagans do it, Jews do it: one can say it is Carthage. Here, whoever does it, Christians do it. With great grief we say these things to you. Would that at some time your correction might heal the wound of our heart! We say to Your Charity: We know, in the name of God, both your city and those neighboring you, how great is the multitude here, how great the people. Can they be unknown to him who has been appointed to you as dispenser of the Word and the Sacrament? Who excuses himself from this shamefulness? Behold, there are the games. Let Christians not go, and let us see whether there will not be such a solitude that shamefulness itself will be ashamed.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":132,"ref":"p132","source":"Videamus, si non ipsae personae turpes aut ad Dominum convertentur, et liberabuntur, aut, si in sua turpitudine permanebunt, de ista Civitate migrabunt. Hoc vobis praestate vos, Christiani. Theatra nolite intrare.\n\nVIII. Sed paucos vos video. Ecce veniet dies Passionis Christi, ecce veniet Pascha, et ista spatia multitudinem vestram non capient. Ergo ipsi haec loca implebunt, qui modo Theatra implestis? Vel comparate loca, et contundite pectora? Dicitis fortasse: Bene vos ab istis abstinetis, qui Clerici estis, qui Episcopi estis, non autem nos Laici. Itane vero haec vox justa vobis videtur? Quid enim sumus nos, si peritis vos? Aliud est, quod sumus propter nos; aliud, quod sumus propter vos. Christiani sumus propter nos, Clerici et Episcopi non nisi propter vos. Apostolus non Clericis, non Episcopis et Presbyteris loquebatur, quando dicebat: Vos autem estis membra Christi. Plebibus dicebat, Fidelibus dicebat, Christianis dicebat: Vos autem estis membra Christi. Attendite, in quo corpore membra estis; attendite, sub quo capite in una corporis compage vivatis. Videte unum Spiritum, quem ab illo accepistis. Ipsa replico verba Apostoli: Tollens ergo membra Christi faciam membra meretricis(1 Cor. vi, 15)? Et Christiani nostri non solum diligunt, sed etiam instituunt meretrices?","english":"Let us see whether these shameful persons themselves will either be converted to the Lord and set free, or, if they persist in their shamefulness, will depart from this City. This, you Christians, grant to yourselves: do not enter the theaters.\n\nVIII. But I see few of you. Behold, the day of Christ's Passion will come, behold, Easter will come, and these spaces will not hold your multitude. Will those then fill these places who have just now filled the theaters? Or will you compare places, and beat your breasts? Perhaps you say: You do well to abstain from these things, you who are clerics, who are bishops, but not we laity. Is this voice of yours really seen as just? For what are we, if you perish? It is one thing that we are for ourselves; another that we are for you. We are Christians for ourselves, clerics and bishops only for you. The Apostle was not speaking to clerics, not to bishops and presbyters, when he said: But you are members of Christ. He was speaking to the people, he was speaking to the faithful, he was speaking to Christians: But you are members of Christ. Attend to the body in which you are members; attend to the head under which you live in the one compact body. See the one Spirit whom you have received from him. I repeat the very words of the Apostle: Taking therefore the members of Christ, shall I make them members of a harlot? And our Christians not only love harlots, but even set them up?","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":133,"ref":"p133","source":"Non solum diligunt eas, quae erant, sed instituunt eas, quae non erant, quasi non et ipsae animas habeant, quasi non et pro ipsis effusus est sanguis Christi, quasi non dictum sit: Meretrices et Publicani praecedunt vos in regnum coelorum (Matth. xxi, 51)? Cum ergo debeamus ipsas lucrari, cum illis perire eligitur, et hoc a Christianis fit! Nolo dicere, et a Fidelibus. Catechumenus forte contemnit se. Catechumenus, inquit, sum. Catechumenus es? Catechumenus. Alia frons tua accepit Christi signum, et aliam tollis ad Theatrum? Ire vis? Muta frontem, et vade? Ergo frontem, quam non potes mutare, noli perdere? Nomen Dei super te invocatur, Christus super te invocatur, Deus super te invocatur, signum crucis Christi tibi in fronte depingitur, atque fingitur. Omnes exhortor, omnes alloquor. Videbitis, quam honestiores eritis in nomine Domini nostri Jesu Christi.","english":"They not only love those who were such, but they establish those who were not, as though these too had no souls, as though the blood of Christ had not been poured out for them as well, as though it had not been said: The harlots and the publicans go before you into the kingdom of heaven (Matthew 21:31). Since, then, we ought to gain them, it is chosen to perish with them—and this is done by Christians! I do not wish to say, and by the faithful. Perhaps a catechumen despises himself. \"I am a catechumen,\" he says. You are a catechumen? A catechumen. Has your forehead received the sign of Christ, and do you lift another to the theater? Do you wish to go? Change your forehead, and go? Therefore the forehead, which you cannot change, do not destroy? The name of God is invoked over you, Christ is invoked over you, God is invoked over you, the sign of the cross of Christ is painted and fashioned upon your forehead. I exhort all, I address all. You will see how much more honorable you will be in the name of our Lord Jesus Christ.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":134,"ref":"p134","source":"Audeo dicere: Vicinam civitatem vestram imitamini? Vicinam civitatem Simitu imitamini? Nihil aliud vobis dico. Apertius vobis dico in nomine Domini Jesu Christi. Nemo ibi intrat in Theatrum. Nullus ibi turpis remansit. Legatus ibi voluit agere hujusmodi turpitudines. Nullus principalis, nullus plebeius intravit. Nullus Judaeus intravit. Ipsi honesti non sunt? Illa Civitas non est? Illa Colonia non est tanto honestior, quanto istis rebus inanior? Haec vobis non diceremus, si bona de vobis audiremus. Si autem tacuerimus, timeo, ne pariter judicemur. Voluit ergo Deus, fratres mei, ut transirem hac. Frater meus tenuit me, jussit, rogavit, compulit, ut verbum vobis facerem. Unde facerem, nisi unde plus timeo? Unde facerem, nisi unde plus doleo? Nescitis me et nos omnes gravissimam rationem reddituros Deo de laudibus vestris? Putatis, quod istae laudes honorent nos? Onerant, non honorant. Valde gravis de illis laudibus ratio redditur. Valde timeo, ne dicat nobis Christus in judicio suo: Mali servi, laudes populi mei libenter accipiebatis, et mortem ipsorum eis tacebatis. Praestabit autem Dominus Deus noster, ut de caetero bona de vobis audiamus, et in illius miseratione consolemur de vestra correptione. Tanto enim erit majus gaudium, quanto magna modo tristitia.","english":"Do I dare say it: Imitate the neighboring city of yours? Imitate the neighboring city of Simitu? I tell you nothing else. I speak to you more openly in the name of the Lord Jesus Christ. No one there enters the theater. No one there has remained shameful. A legate there wished to carry on shameful practices of this kind. No leading man, no commoner entered. No Jew entered. Are they themselves not honorable? Is that not a city? Is that colony not all the more honorable the more empty it is of these things? We would not be saying these things to you if we were hearing good things about you. But if we keep silent, I fear that we may be judged along with you. Therefore, my brothers, God willed that I pass this way. My brother held me back, ordered, asked, compelled me to give you a word. From what should I speak, if not from what I fear more? From what should I speak, if not from what I grieve over more? Do you not know that I and all of us will give a most serious account to God for your praises? Do you think that these praises honor us? They burden us, they do not honor us. A very heavy account is rendered for those praises. I greatly fear that Christ may say to us in his judgment: Wicked servants, you gladly accepted the praises of my people, and you kept silent to them about their death. But our Lord God will grant that henceforth we may hear good things about you, and in his mercy be consoled over your correction. For the joy will be as much greater as the sorrow is now great.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":135,"ref":"p135","source":"SERMO XVIII.\n\nIn Natali Quadrati Martyris.\n\nSYNOPSIS.\n\nI. Triplex ambulantium ad Deum genus. II. Pauli exemplum ambulantibus propositum. III. Aliud perfectus viator, aliud perfectus perventor, in Exemplo S. Quadrati. IV. Justitiae nunc saltem tantum dandum, quantum antea immunditiae. V. Imo plus dandum justitiae, quam immunditiae. VI. Idque deposito omni respectu humano. VII. Et praecipue erga Paganos Christianis insultantes.\n\nPraestitit Dominus Deus noster, cui gratias simul agimus, ut videremus vos, et videremur a vobis. Et si hoc est, unde Impletum est gaudio os nostrum, et lingua nostra exultatione (Psal. cxxv, 2), quia vidimus invicem in carne mortali, quale erit gaudium nostrum, quando ibi nos videbimus, ubi nihil de nobis invicem timeamus? Apostolus dicit: Spe gaudentes (Rom. xii, 12) Gaudium ergo nostrum, quod nunc est, in spe est, nondum in re. Spes autem, quae videtur, non est, ait spes. Quod enim videt quis, quid sperat? Si autem, quod non videmus, speramus, per patientiam expectamus (Rom. viii, 24, 25). Si autem peregrinantes comites ad invicem gaudent in via, quale gaudium consequenter in patria? In hac via Martyres certaverunt, et certando ambulaverunt, ambulando non haeserunt. Ambulant enim, qui amant. Non enim ad Deum passibus, sed affectibus currimus. Via ergo nostra ambulantes quaerit.","english":"SERMON XVIII.\n\nOn the Birthday of Quadratus the Martyr.\n\nSYNOPSIS.\n\nI. The threefold kind of those who walk to God. II. The example of Paul set before those who walk. III. One thing is the perfect wayfarer, another the perfect arriver, in the example of St. Quadratus. IV. That to righteousness there must now at least be given as much as was formerly given to uncleanness. V. Nay, more must be given to righteousness than to uncleanness. VI. And that with every human respect laid aside. VII. And especially toward the pagans who insult Christians.\n\nOur Lord God has granted, to whom we give thanks at the same time, that we should see you, and be seen by you. And if this is the reason that our mouth was filled with joy, and our tongue with exultation, because we have seen one another in mortal flesh, what will our joy be, when we shall see one another there, where we shall fear nothing for one another? The Apostle says: Rejoicing in hope. Our joy, therefore, which is now, is in hope, not yet in reality. But hope that is seen is not hope, says hope. For what a man sees, why does he hope for it? But if we hope for what we do not see, we wait for it with patience. But if companions on a journey rejoice in one another on the way, what joy follows in the fatherland? On this way the martyrs strove, and by striving they walked, by walking they did not falter. For they walk who love. For we run to God not with steps but with affections. Therefore our way seeks those who walk.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":136,"ref":"p136","source":"Tria sunt hominum genera, quae odit Deus: Remanentem, retro redeuntem, aberrantem. Ab his tribus generibus malis Domino adjuvante vindicetur, et defendatur gressus noster. Jam vero, cum ambulantes sumus, alius tardius ambulat, alius celerius; ambo tamen ambulant. Excitandi sunt ergo remanentes, retro redeuntes revocandi sunt, errantes in viam ducendi, tardi exhortandi, celeres imitandi. Qui non proficit, remansit in via. Qui forte a meliore proposito declinat ad id, quod deterius reliquerat, reversus est retro. Qui fidem deserit, a via aberravit. Cum tardis sit nobis, sed a celerioribus ratio, cum ambulantibus tamen.\n\nQuis est, qui non proficit? Qui se putaverit esse sapientem, qui dixerit: Sufficit mihi, quod sum; qui non attendit eum, qui dixit: Quae retro oblitus, in ea quae ante sunt extentus, secundum intentionem sequor ad palmam supernae vocationis Dei in Christo Jesu (Philipp. iii, 13, 14). Currentem se dixit; sequentem se dixit. Non remansit, non retro respexit, absit ut erraverit, qui viam ipsam docebat, qui et tenebat, et ostendebat. Celeritatem autem ejus ut imitaremur, ait: Imitatores mei estote, sicut et ego Christi (1 Cor. iv, 6). Arbitramur ergo nos, fratres charissimi, in via vobiscum ambulare. Si tardi sumus, praevenite nos. Non invidemus, quaerimus quos sequamur. Si autem nos existimatis celeriter ingredi, currite nobiscum.","english":"There are three kinds of people whom God hates: the one who remains behind, the one who turns back, and the one who wanders astray. From these three evil kinds, with the Lord's help, let our steps be delivered and defended. Now indeed, since we are walking, one walks more slowly, another more quickly; yet both are walking. Therefore those who remain behind must be stirred up, those turning back must be recalled, those wandering must be led into the way, the slow must be exhorted, the swift must be imitated. He who does not make progress has remained in the way. He who perhaps declines from a better purpose to what he had left behind as worse has turned back. He who abandons the faith has wandered from the way. We must be with the slow, but we must take our reckoning from the swifter—yet with those who are walking.\n\nWho is he who does not make progress? The one who has thought himself wise, who has said: It is enough for me that I am what I am; who does not attend to him who said: Forgetting what lies behind, stretching out to what lies ahead, I press on according to my purpose toward the prize of God's heavenly calling in Christ Jesus (Philippians 3:13-14). He called himself one who runs; he called himself one who follows. He did not remain behind, he did not look back—far be it that he should have wandered, who was teaching the way itself, who both held it and showed it. But that we might imitate his swiftness, he said: Be imitators of me, as I also am of Christ (1 Corinthians 4:6). We reckon, therefore, dearest brothers, that we are walking in the way with you. If we are slow, go before us. We do not envy; we seek those whom we may follow. But if you judge that we walk swiftly, run with us.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":137,"ref":"p137","source":"Unum est ad quod omnes festinamus, et qui tardius, et qui celerius ambulamus. Hoc ait ipse Apostolus. Unum autem, quae retro oblitus, in ea quae ante sunt extentus, secundum intentionem sequor ad palmam supernae vocationis Dei in Christo Jesu. Ordo verborum est: Unum autem sequor. Ut autem hoc diceret, supra quid dixit? Fratres, ego me ipsum non arbitror apprehendisse (Philipp. iii, 13). Ecce, qui non remanet, qui non se arbitratur apprehendisse. Ecce, qui non vult peregrinari; ecce, qui non haeret in via, ecce, qui gaudebit in patria. Ego, inquit, Quis ego? Qui plus omnibus illis laboravi (1 Cor. xv, 10); Et tamen, ubi ait: Plus omnibus illis laboravi, non dixit: Ego me non arbitror apprehendisse. Bene ibi Ego, ubi humilitatis locus est, non elationis. Ego, inquit, quantum ad me attinet, non me arbitror apprehendisse. Hoc ipse. Ubi autem ait: Plus omnibus illis laboravi, sequitur: Non ego autem, sed gratia Dei mecum. Numquid Dei gratia non apprehendit? Merito ibi Ego. Non apprehendere enim nostrae infirmitatis est, apprehendere adjutorii est gratiae divinae, non infirmitatis humanae. Quis ergo est, qui ostendat nobis? quis est, qui doceat nos? quis est, qui digne insinuet nobis, quomodo verum sit, quod tamen sine dubitatione verum est, non esse in nobis nostrum, nisi peccatum? Hoc noverit pietas, hoc in se accuset infirmitas, hoc sanari appetit charitas!","english":"There is one thing toward which we all hurry, both those who walk more slowly and those who walk more quickly. The Apostle himself says this: \"But one thing, forgetting what lies behind, stretching out to what lies ahead, according to my purpose I press on toward the prize of the upward calling of God in Christ Jesus.\" The order of the words is: \"But one thing I press on.\" Yet in order to say this, what did he say above? \"Brothers, I do not consider that I myself have apprehended\" (Philippians 3:13). Behold the one who does not remain behind, who does not consider that he has apprehended. Behold the one who does not wish to wander abroad; behold the one who does not cling to the way; behold the one who will rejoice in the homeland. \"I,\" he says—who, I? \"I labored more than all of them\" (1 Corinthians 15:10). And yet, when he said, \"I labored more than all of them,\" he did not say, \"I do not consider that I myself have apprehended.\" Rightly is \"I\" there, where there is a place for humility, not for elation. \"I,\" he says, \"as far as it concerns me, do not consider that I have apprehended.\" This is what he himself says. But where he said, \"I labored more than all of them,\" there follows: \"Yet not I, but the grace of God with me.\" Did the grace of God not apprehend? Rightly is \"I\" there. For not to apprehend belongs to our weakness; to apprehend belongs to the help of divine grace, not to human weakness. Who, then, is there to show us? Who is there to teach us? Who is there to set before us worthily how it is true—which is nevertheless true without doubt—that nothing in us is our own except sin? Let piety know this, let weakness accuse itself of this, let charity desire to be healed of this!","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":138,"ref":"p138","source":"Non, quia jam acceperim, ait, aut jam perfectus sim (Philipp. iii, 12). Et tunc subjecit: Fratres, ego me ipsum non arbitror or apprehendisse, et cum exhortaretur currendum, et, Ad ea, quae ante sunt, cor extendendum, Quotquot cutem perfecti, ait, hoc sapiamus (Philipp. iii, 15). Supra dixerat: Non quia jam acceperim, aut jam perfectus sim; et postea dicit: Quotquot autem perfecti, hoc sapiamus. Et ipsum tam magnum Apostolum dixeras esse imperfectum; modo jam plures perfectos invenis, et dicis: Quotquot autem perfecti, hoc sapiamus. Est ergo perfectio et perfectio.\n\nEst perfectus viator, qui nondum perfectus est perventor. Perfectus viator bene accedit, bene ambulat, viam tenet, sed tamen viator, nondum apprehendit. Nam utique, si ambulat, et in via ambulat, alioque ambulat, et ad aliquid pervenire conatur. Quo ergo pervenire conabatur Apostolus, nondum apprehenderat. Et hortatur perfectos, ut sciant se nondum esse perfectos, scirent imperfectionem suam. Perfectio viatoris est, scire nondum se pervenisse ad id, quo tendit. Novit enim, quantum transgressus est, quantum illi remaneat. Sciamus ergo nos non esse perfectos, quotquot sumus perfecti, ne remaneamus imperfecti Quid dicemus, fratres? Nonne perfectus Martyr Quadratus? Quid quadrato perfectius? Paria sunt latera, undique aequalis est forma, quacumque verterit, statio est, non ruina.","english":"Not \"because I have already received,\" he says, \"or am already perfect.\" And then he added: \"Brothers, I do not consider that I have apprehended,\" and when he urged that we must run and stretch out to what lies ahead, \"As many of us as are perfect,\" he says, \"let us think this.\" Above he had said: \"Not because I have already received, or am already perfect\"; and afterward he says: \"But as many of us as are perfect, let us think this.\" And you had said that this Apostle, so great, was imperfect; now you find many perfect, and you say: \"But as many of us as are perfect, let us think this.\" There is therefore a perfection, and a perfection.\n\nThe traveler is perfect who is not yet perfect as one who has arrived. The perfect traveler walks well, advances well, keeps the road, but is still a traveler, has not yet apprehended. For surely, if he walks, he walks on the road, and he walks toward something else, and he strives to reach something. Therefore what the Apostle was striving to reach, he had not yet apprehended. And he exhorts the perfect to know that they are not yet perfect, to know their own imperfection. It is the perfection of the traveler to know that he has not yet arrived at that toward which he tends. For he knows how far he has passed beyond, how much remains for him. Let us know, then, that we are not perfect—as many of us as are perfect—lest we remain imperfect. What shall we say, brothers? Is not the Martyr Quadratus perfect? What is more perfect than a square? Its sides are equal, its form is uniform on every side; wherever it turns, there is standing, not ruin.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":139,"ref":"p139","source":"O nomen pulchrum demonstrans figuram, et indicans rem futuram. Jam Quadratus et antea vocabatur, et nondum coronabatur. Nondum in tentatione apparuerat, per quam esset ille quadratus, et tamen, quando vocabatur, praenuntiabatur praedestinatus ante mundi constitutionem, et ut hoc vocaretur, hoc in illo compatitur, ut impleretur, et tamen ambulabat, et tamen adhuc in via erat, et quandiu erat in hoc corpore, totum timebatur, et ne remaneret, et ne retro rediret, et ne exorbitaret. Nunc vero cucurrit, viam finivit, in solido stetit, coaedificatus est ab artifice arcae dominicae, quae in figura jussa est aedificari de lignis quadratis (Exod, xxvii, 1). Modo jam nullam tentationem timet. Audivit vocatorem, audivit illum et ille invocatorem, secutus est salvatorem, portat habitatorem. Contempsit mundum blandientem, vicit terrentem, evasit furentem. Magna est, fratres, Martyrum gloria, prima in Ecclesia. Quaecumque sunt aliae, sequentes sunt. Non enim frustra dictum est quibusdam: Nondum usque ad sanguinem adversus peccatum certastis (Hebr. xii, 4). Quando tolerat, quando sustinet mundum saevientem, qui spernere non potest blandientem?","english":"O beautiful name that shows forth the figure and announces the thing to come! Already he was called Quadratus, and even before, and he was not yet crowned. He had not yet appeared in trial, through which he would be that \"square,\" and yet, when he was called, he was being foretold as predestined before the foundation of the world, and that he should be called this—this too is brought about in him, that it might be fulfilled. And yet he was walking, and yet he was still on the way, and as long as he was in this body, everything was feared for him: lest he remain, lest he turn back, lest he stray from the path. But now he has run his course, he has finished the way, he has stood on solid ground, he has been built together by the craftsman of the Lord's ark, which was commanded in figure to be built of squared timbers (Exod. xxvii, 1). Now at last he fears no trial. He heard the one who called, and he in turn heard him as his invoker; he followed the Savior, he bears the Indweller. He despised the world when it flattered, he conquered it when it terrified, he escaped it when it raged. Great, brothers, is the glory of the martyrs, the first in the Church. Whatever other glories there are, they follow after. For it was not in vain that it was said to certain ones: You have not yet resisted unto blood against sin (Heb. xii, 4). When does he endure, when does he withstand the raging world—he who cannot despise it when it flatters?","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":140,"ref":"p140","source":"Ait idem Apostolus: Humanum dico propter infirmitatem carnis vestrae. Sicut exhibuistis membra vestra deservire immunditiae ad iniquitatem, sic nunc exhibete membra vestra deservire justitiae; in sanctifica· tionem (Rom. vi, 19). Magnum est valde, quod videtur hortatus. Metiatur se unusquisque in his verbis Apostoli. Non adulatorie palpet se, appendat se, et dicat sibi verum. Quid a me expectat audire? Ipse sibi dicat. Ego disposui speculum proponere, ubi se quisque attendat. Non sum ego speculi fulgor, qui faciem suam intuenti renuntiet. Facies enim illas dico modo, quas habemus intus. Ipsas per aurem convenire possum, videre non possum. Speculum sane propono. Attendat se unusquisque, et renuntiet sibi. Ipsa verba Apostoli, quae commemoravi, indicem speculi accipite. Humanum dico propter infirmitatem carnis vestrae. Sicut exhibuistis membra vestra deservire immunditiae ad iniquitatem, sic nunc exhibete membra vestra deservire justitiae in sanctificationem. Quid est Sic? Sicut illud, ita et istud. Quando exhibebas membra tua arma iniquitatis peccato ad immunditiam, delectabat te? Interrogo. Attende, responde. Delectabat te? Audio respondentem, etiam tacentem. Non enim faceres, nisi delectaret. Sicut ergo exhibuisti membra tua deservire immunditiae ad iniquitatem, et cum delectatione ista fecisti, ita delectet te aliquando justitia. Nolo, timore facias, dicit tibi Deus.","english":"The same Apostle says: \"I speak after the manner of men because of the infirmity of your flesh. As you have yielded your members to serve uncleanness unto iniquity, so now yield your members to serve justice unto sanctification\" (Rom. 6:19). What he seems to exhort is something very great. Let each one measure himself by these words of the Apostle. Let him not flatter himself with adulation; let him weigh himself and tell himself the truth. What does he expect to hear from me? Let him say it to himself. I have arranged to set before you a mirror, in which each one may look upon himself. I am not the brightness of the mirror, to report back to the one looking into it what his face is like. For I mean those faces we have within. Those I can reach through the ear; I cannot see them. I do set before you a mirror indeed. Let each one attend to himself and report to himself. Take the very words of the Apostle, which I have recalled, as the pointer of the mirror. \"I speak after the manner of men because of the infirmity of your flesh. As you have yielded your members to serve uncleanness unto iniquity, so now yield your members to serve justice unto sanctification.\" What does \"so\" mean? As that was, so let this be. When you yielded your members as weapons of iniquity unto sin, unto uncleanness, did it delight you? I ask. Attend, answer. Did it delight you? I hear one answering, even when he is silent. For you would not do it unless it delighted you. Therefore, just as you yielded your members to serve uncleanness unto iniquity, and did these things with delight, so let justice delight you at last. I do not want you to do it out of fear, God says to you.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":141,"ref":"p141","source":"Numquid enim illud timore faciebas? Sic, inquit, sic. Sicut exhibuistis membra vestra deservire immunditiae ad iniquitatem, sic nunc exhibete membra vestra deservire justitiae ad sanctificationem. Ad justitiam timore compelleris, ad immunditiam amore currebas. Quid pulchrius sapientia? Rogo vos. Digna est vel sic amari, quomodo amata est immunditia. Quando currebas ad immunditiam, prohibebaris, et ibas. Patrem offendebas, et currebas. Paratus eras exhaeredari, et ab illius pravitate non separari. Quid dicturus es? Hoc a te exigit justitia, quod de te habuit immunditia. Audistis Evangelium: Non veni pacem mittere in terram, sed gladium (Matth. x, 31). Dixit se separaturum filios a parentibus. Ergo attende illam machaeram. Forte vis Deo servire, et pater prohibet? Quando immunditiam diligebas, etiam patre prohibente currebas. Modo te prohibet justitia amatorem suum. Invenisti et hic patrem prohibentem. Exere libertatem tuam, qui exeruisti tunc cupiditatem tuam. Paratus eras tunc exhaeredari, et ab illius immunditiae pravitate non separari. Paratus esto exhaeredari, et a justitiae pulchritudine non separari. Magnum est, sed justum est. Quis est, qui audeat dicere: Sed plus debuit amari immunditia, quam justitia? Interim justitia gradum tibi facit.","english":"Was it fear, then, that made you do that? So, he says, so. As you have yielded your members to serve uncleanness unto iniquity, so now yield your members to serve justice unto sanctification. You are compelled to justice by fear; you were running to uncleanness by love. What is more beautiful than wisdom? I ask you. It is worthy to be loved even in this way, as uncleanness was loved. When you were running to uncleanness, you were forbidden, and you went. You were offending your father, and you were running. You were ready to be disinherited, and not to be separated from its depravity. What will you say? Justice demands from you what uncleanness had from you. You have heard the Gospel: I did not come to send peace on earth, but a sword. He said he would separate sons from parents. Therefore attend to that sword. Perhaps you wish to serve God, and your father forbids it? When you loved uncleanness, you ran even with your father forbidding. Now justice forbids you, its lover. You have found a father forbidding here too. Draw forth your freedom, you who then drew forth your desire. You were then ready to be disinherited, and not to be separated from the depravity of that uncleanness. Be ready to be disinherited, and not to be separated from the beauty of justice. It is a great thing, but it is just. Who is there who would dare to say: But uncleanness ought to have been loved more than justice? Meanwhile justice makes a step for you.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":142,"ref":"p142","source":"Certe, inquit, dissimilis sum; certe plurimum distat inter illius immunditiae tenebras, et lucem meam, inter illam pravitatem et pulchritudinem meam, inter illius decus et decus meum. Certe plurimum distat. Interim gradum pono. Sic volo. Nam plus debeo, plus omnino debeo. Quantum di(??)o, tantum debeo. Sed Humanum dico, humanum differo quare divinum differo? Humanum dico propter infirmitatem carnis vestrae. Ideo Sic; quia parco adhuc infirmitati. Ideo Sicut exhibuistis membra vestra deservire immunditiae ad iniquitatem, sic nunc plus quidem debetis, sed saltem sic ambulate, ad hoc pervenite, sed et hinc transite. Interim Humanum dico, sed sicut illud, ita et hoc.\n\nNumquid Quadratus sic? Non plane sic, sed plus, et digne plus. Attendite enim illas immunditias, et videte, quid de vobis plus exigat pietas et charitas, et justitiae pulchritudo, et sanctificationis dulcedo. Quid de vobis plus exigat, attendite. Amator immunditiae facta sua mala sciri non vult; timet, ne inde damnetur, timet inde carcerem, timet judicem, timet carnificem. Uxoris alienae pudicitiam appetit, maritum fallit, tenebras quaerit, conscium perhorrescit, judicem metuit, timet sciri, quia timet inde puniri.","english":"Certainly,\" he says, \"I am different; certainly there is the greatest distance between the darkness of that uncleanness and my light, between that depravity and my beauty, between that glory of his and my glory. Certainly there is the greatest distance. For the meantime I set a step. So I will it. For I owe more, I altogether owe more. As much as I say, so much I owe. But I speak after the manner of men, I defer after the manner of men—why do I defer what is divine? I speak after the manner of men because of the infirmity of your flesh. Therefore 'so'; because I still spare your infirmity. Therefore 'as you have yielded your members to serve uncleanness unto iniquity, so now' you indeed owe more, but at least 'so walk,' come to this, but also pass beyond this. In the meantime I speak after the manner of men, but as that was, so also is this.\n\nIs Quadratus so? Not plainly so, but more, and worthily more. For attend to those uncleannesses, and see what godliness and charity, and the beauty of justice, and the sweetness of sanctification require of you more. Attend to what they require of you more. The lover of uncleanness does not wish his evil deeds to be known; he fears lest he be condemned for them, he fears the prison for them, he fears the judge, he fears the executioner. He covets the chastity of another's wife, he deceives the husband, he seeks the darkness, he dreads a confidant, he fears the judge, he fears to be known, because he fears to be punished for it.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":143,"ref":"p143","source":"Jam vero illud, quod sibi exigit plus pulchritudo justitiae quod interim distulit Apostolus, cum diceret: Humanum dico propter infirmitatem carnis vestrae, audi hoc a Domino: Quod dico vobis in tenebris, hoc est, in occulto: Dicite in luce, et quod in aure auditis, super tecta praedicate (Matth. x, 27). Numquid praedicat super tectum adulter flagitium suum? Sed quare ille non solum non praedicat super tectum, sed quaerit occultari tecto? Quare hoc ille? Quia tunc usque potuit amor immundi tiae; timet enim detegi, timet puniri. Hi vero amatores illius invisibilis pulchritudinis, amatores illius decoris, ubi est ille Speciosus forma prae filiis hominum (Psal. xliv, 3), amatores ergo illius pulchritudinis unde non timent praedicare super tecta, quod in aure audierunt? Quaere, unde timeat ille, ne cognoscatur et puniatur; quaere, unde iste non timeat, ipse Dominus secutus adjunxit. Cum enim dixisset: Quae dico vobis in tenebris, dicite in lumine, et quod in aure a (??)di(??)is, super tecta praedicate, Nolite, inquit, timere eos, qui corpus occidunt (Matth. x, 28). Ut, quae auditis in tenebris, in lumine dicatis; ut, quod in aure auditis, super tecta praedicetis: Nolite timere eos, qui corpus occidunt. Timeat adulter eos, qui corpus occidunt. Cum enim adulter ille perdiderit corpus, voluptatum perdit officinam. Ille timeat perdere corpus, qui vivit ex corpore.","english":"Now indeed, that which the beauty of righteousness demands for itself, and which the Apostle for a time deferred when he said, \"I speak after the manner of men because of the infirmity of your flesh,\" hear this from the Lord: \"What I tell you in darkness,\" that is, in secret, \"speak in the light; and what you hear in the ear, preach upon the housetops\" (Matthew 10:27). Does the adulterer preach his shame upon the housetop? But why does he not only fail to preach upon the housetop, but even seek to be hidden by the roof? Why does he do this? Because the love of uncleanness prevailed in him up to that point; for he fears to be exposed, he fears to be punished. But these lovers of that invisible beauty, lovers of that comeliness—where is that one who is \"fair in form above the sons of men\" (Psalm 44:3)—lovers, then, of that beauty, why do they not fear to preach upon the housetops what they heard in the ear? Ask whence that man fears lest he be known and punished; ask whence this man does not fear—the Lord himself added the reason that follows. For when he had said, \"What I tell you in darkness, speak in the light; and what you hear in the ear, preach upon the housetops,\" he said, \"Do not fear those who kill the body\" (Matthew 10:28). So that you may speak in the light what you hear in darkness, so that you may preach upon the housetops what you hear in the ear: \"Do not fear those who kill the body.\" Let the adulterer fear those who kill the body. For when that adulterer has lost the body, he loses the workshop of his pleasures. Let that man fear to lose the body, who lives by the body.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":144,"ref":"p144","source":"Totum enim, quod concupiscit, per corpus operatur; ideo in illo voluptas non sufficit, inardescit cupiditate, quoadusque perveniat ad corporis immundissimam voluptatem. Tu autem, Homo Dei! si habes oculos cordis, unde videas pulchritudinem charitatis, unde videas pulchritudinem pietatis; si habes oculos cordis, vide, unde fruaris amata tua. Ut enim ea fruaris, non membra corporis quaeris. Timeat perimi corpus amator sordidae voluptatis, sed Pax in terra in hominibus bonae voluntatis (Luc. ii, 14)!\n\nQuam longe es ab hoc amore, o Christiane! Utinam usque ad illum humanum pervenias, et cum delectatione bene facias, sicut ante cum delectatione peccabas. Si enim cum delectatione bene facis, si cum delectatione in Christum credis, si cum delectatione sapientia ejus pro tua capacitate perfruaris, si cum delectatione praeceptum audis et facis, coepit in te esse illud Humanum propter infirmitatem tuam. Jam coepisti habere bonum datum, sed necdum implesti Quadratum. Sed sicut dixi, si pervenisti, accede; adhuc via est. Noli remanere. Est adhuc, quod facias. Noli timere, et abscondere facta tua bona timendo. Reprehensores, exagitatores quid tibi dicunt? Magnus tu Apostolus! de coelo tibi pendent pedes. Unde venis? Et times dicere: De Ecclesia; ne dicatur tibi: Non te pudet, Barbate, ire, quo eunt viduae, et aniculae? Ne audias, times dicere: In Ecclesia fui.","english":"For everything that it desires, it works through the body; and so in that [desire] pleasure is not enough—it burns with craving until it arrives at the most impure pleasure of the body. But you, Man of God, if you have the eyes of the heart, by which you may see the beauty of charity, by which you may see the beauty of piety—if you have the eyes of the heart, see where you may enjoy your beloved. For in order to enjoy her, you do not seek the members of the body. Let the lover of filthy pleasure fear that his body be destroyed, but \"Peace on earth among men of good will\" (Luke 2:14)!\n\nHow far you are from this love, O Christian! Would that you might arrive at that human [love], and do good with delight, as before you used to sin with delight. For if you do good with delight, if you believe in Christ with delight, if you enjoy his wisdom with delight according to your capacity, if you hear and keep the commandment with delight, that Human [love] has begun to be in you because of your weakness. You have already begun to have the good Gift, but you have not yet completed the Square. But as I said, if you have arrived, draw near; there is still a way. Do not remain. There is still something for you to do. Do not be afraid, and do not hide your good deeds by fearing. What do your critics, your mockers, say to you? \"You are a great Apostle! Your feet hang down from heaven. Where do you come from?\" And do you fear to say, \"From the Church,\" lest it be said to you, \"Are you not ashamed, Barbatus, to go where the widows and little old women go?\" Lest you hear this, you fear to say, \"I have been in the Church.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":145,"ref":"p145","source":"Quomodo ferres persecutorem, qui horrescis insultatorem? Et certe tempus est pacis; illi erubescere debuerunt. Erubescunt tam multi, qui accesserunt, et non erubescunt tam pauci, qui remanserunt. Et hi accesserunt, quo? Illi autem remanserunt, ubi? Accesserunt hi ad lucem pacis; remanserunt illi in tenebris confusionis. Non erubescitis glorianda erubescere? Non erubescunt illi pudenda, et vos erubescitis glorianda? Et ubi est, quod audistis: Accedite ad eum, et illuminamini, et vultus vestri non erubescent (Psal. xxxiii, 6).\n\nHaec dixi, fratres mei, quoniam scio, et plurimum doleo, timeri linguas paucorum paganorum non saevientium, sed tantum insultantium, et teneri animos credere volentium, cum non acquiescunt in exhortationibus Christianorum. Et quid plura? Aut quid ego dicturus sum? Vides exagitari, nescio, quem paganum, ne fiat Christianus, et tu Christianus taces, pro magno habes, quia tibi parcit, id est, quia tibi non insultat. Quando illum deterret, dicis in corde tuo: Deo gratias! Nihil mihi dixit. Fugis non carne, sed mente. Ibi stas, et fugis. Times, ne in te lingua maledica convertatur, et non subvenis ei, quem debes Christo lucrifacere. Non subvenis, taces, ut dixi, non carne, sed mente fugis, mercenarius es, vides lupum venientem, et fugis (Joan. x, 12) Et quid plus ego dicturus sum? Modo audivimus omnes. Dominus terreat. Qui amandus est, ipse metuendus.","english":"How would you endure a persecutor, you who shudder at an insulter? And surely it is a time of peace; they ought to have blushed for shame. So many who have come forward blush for shame, and so few who have remained do not blush. And these have come forward—to what? But those have remained—where? These have come forward to the light of peace; those have remained in the darkness of confusion. Do you not blush to be ashamed of what is glorious? Do those not blush for what is shameful, and do you blush for what is glorious? And where is that which you have heard: Come to him, and be enlightened, and your faces shall not be put to shame (Ps. 33:6).\n\nI have said these things, my brothers, because I know, and I grieve exceedingly, that the tongues of a few pagans are feared—not raging, but merely insulting—and that the minds of those who wish to believe are held back, since they do not acquiesce in the exhortations of Christians. And what more? Or what am I to say? You see some pagan or other, I know not whom, being stirred up so that he does not become a Christian, and you, a Christian, keep silent; you count it a great thing that he spares you—that is, that he does not insult you. When he is deterred, you say in your heart: Thanks be to God! He said nothing to me. You flee, not in the flesh, but in the mind. There you stand, and there you flee. You fear lest a slanderous tongue be turned against you, and you do not come to the aid of him whom you ought to win for Christ. You do not come to the aid; you keep silent; as I said, you flee not in the flesh but in the mind; you are a hireling; you see the wolf coming, and you flee (John 10:12). And what more am I to say? We have all just heard. Let the Lord strike fear. He who is to be loved is himself to be feared.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":146,"ref":"p146","source":"Qui me, inquit, confessus fuerit coram hominibus. (Et videte, quando ista dicebat? Quando mundus non credebat, sed fremebat). Qui me confusus fuerit coram hominibus, confundam eum coram Patre meo, qui in coelis est. Qui autem me confessus fuerit coram hominibus, confitebor illum et ego coram Patre meo, qui in coetis est (Matth. x, 32, 33). Vis negari a Christo, an vis confiteri a Christo? Longe habebis insultatorem, quando tui Christum inveneris negatorem. Veniet, quod pollicetur. Qui tanta exhibuit, de solo die judicii fallax invenietur? Absit. Habeant illi perfidiam suam, imo vero et ipsi careant perfidia sua, sed proponite vos illis ad confessionem imitandos, non ad silentium superandos. Illi enim, si invenerint Christianos fortiores infirmorum defensores assertione fidei, libertate confitendi, prudentia docendi, charitate instruendi, silebunt, credite. Quod enim dicant, non habent. Vox inanis est. Cymbalum tinniens (1 Cor. xiii, 1), quod destitit in templis ipsorum, remansit in ore ipsorum.","english":"He who confesses me, he says, before men. (And see, when was he saying these things? When the world did not believe, but raged.) Whoever is ashamed of me before men, I will be ashamed of him before my Father, who is in heaven. But whoever confesses me before men, I too will confess him before my Father, who is in heaven (Matt. 10:32-33). Do you wish to be denied by Christ, or do you wish to be confessed by Christ? You will have an insulter far off, when you have found Christ as a denier of you. What he promises will come. Will he who displayed such great things be found deceitful concerning the day of judgment alone? Far be it. Let those have their faithlessness—no, rather let even they be rid of their faithlessness—but set yourselves before them to be imitated in confession, not to be overcome in silence. For if they find Christians stronger, defenders of the weak by the assertion of faith, by freedom of confessing, by prudence in teaching, by charity in instructing, they will be silent, believe me. For they do not have what they might say. Their voice is empty. A clanging cymbal (1 Cor. 13:1), which ceased in their temples, has remained in their mouth.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":147,"ref":"p147","source":"SERMO XIX.\n\nDe verbis Apostoli i Cor. xii, vers. 31. Supereminentem vobis viam demonstro, etc..\n\nSYNOPSIS.\n\nI. Charitas major omnibus donis, quae etiam haberi possunt absque ea. II. Prophetia sine Charitate in Saul, et ejus Satellitio. III. Prophetia sine Charitate in Caipha. IV. Fides sine Charitate in daemonibus. V. Charitatis mutuae exemplum in membris corporis humani. VI. In membris dignitas diversa, sed magis respicienda sanitas. VII. Donatistae, membra aegra, praecisi. VIII. Damnatio Crispini, et anterior Donatistarum in causa Caeciliani et Majorini. IX. Ab Ecclesia praecisis patet reditus. X. Ecclesia toto orbe diffusa catholica est, vera est. XI. Donum lingua rum primis credentibus datum significabat, Ecclesiam futuram. XII. Hortatur Donatistas ad reditum.\n\nBonum est loqui de Charitate eis, qui diligunt eam, qua bene diligitur, quidquid diligitur. Est enim secundum Apostolum in Charitate supereminentissima via. Modo legebatur. Audivimus. Supereminentem, inquit, vobis viam demonstro (1 Cor. xii, 31). Deinde narravit multa dona, et ea quidem praeclara, nec parvi facienda; nihil tamen ea dixit prodesse hominibus, qui non habuerint Charitatem. In quibus donis commemoravit: Linguis loqui hominum et Angelorum, habere omnem Prophetiam, omnem scientiam, omnem fidem, ita ut montes transferat, distribuere omnia sua pauperibus, tradere corpus suum, ut ardeat (1 Cor. xiii, 1-3).","english":"SERMON XIX.\n\nOn the words of the Apostle, 1 Cor. 12:31: I show you a more excellent way, etc.\n\nSYNOPSIS.\n\nI. Charity is greater than all gifts, which gifts can even be possessed without it. II. Prophecy without charity in Saul, and in his satellite. III. Prophecy without charity in Caiaphas. IV. Faith without charity in demons. V. The example of mutual charity in the members of the human body. VI. In the members there is diverse dignity, but health is to be regarded more. VII. The Donatists, diseased members, cut off. VIII. The condemnation of Crispinus, and the earlier case of the Donatists concerning Caecilianus and Majorinus. IX. To those cut off from the Church the way back lies open. X. The Church spread throughout the whole world is catholic, is true. XI. The gift of tongues given to the first believers signified the Church that was to be. XII. He exhorts the Donatists to return.\n\nIt is good to speak of charity to those who love it, by which whatever is loved is loved well. For according to the Apostle, in charity is the most excellent way. It was just read. We have heard. A more excellent way, he says, I show to you (1 Cor. 12:31). Then he recounted many gifts, and these indeed splendid, nor to be made little of; yet he said that they profit nothing to men who have not charity. Among these gifts he mentioned: to speak with the tongues of men and of angels, to have all prophecy, all knowledge, all faith, so as to remove mountains, to distribute all one's goods to the poor, to deliver one's body to be burned (1 Cor. 13:1-3).","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":148,"ref":"p148","source":"Haec omnia magna atque divina sunt; sed si in fundamento Charitatis collocentur, et de radice Charitatis exsurgant. Fuisse autem es his donis multa in multis, qui non habuerunt Charitatem, non auderemus dicere, nisi doceremur exemplis non quorumlibet hominum, et undecumque petitorum, sed de ipsis sanctis Scripturis, quibus quisquis non habuerit fidem, non potest habere Charitatem. Sed inter praecipua, quae dicta sunt, magnum ibi apparet vel Prophetia, vel Fides. Quid ergo de caeteris? Si Prophetiam quisquis habens nihil ei prodest, si non habuerit Charitatem, et Fidem quisquis habens non potest pervenire ad regnum Dei, nisi habuerit Charitatem, quid de caeteris loquamur? Vel linguis loqui, quid est ad Prophetiam, et Fidem? Vel distribuere omnia sua pauperibus, quid est ad Prophetiam, et tradere corpus suum, ut ardeat? Plerumque hoc faciunt temerarii praecipites. Ergo illa ibi duo magna sunt, de quibus vere mirandum est, si invenire potuerimus aliquem hominem habere Prophetiam, et non habere Charitatem, (??)ut habere Fidem, et non habere Charitatem.","english":"All these things are great and divine; but only if they are placed on the foundation of Charity, and rise from the root of Charity. That many of these gifts were present in many people who did not have Charity, we would not dare to say, unless we were taught by examples not of any random persons, sought from whatever source, but from the holy Scriptures themselves, without faith in which no one can have Charity. But among the principal things that have been mentioned, Prophecy or Faith appears great there. What then of the rest? If anyone having Prophecy profits nothing by it if he has not Charity, and anyone having Faith cannot reach the kingdom of God unless he has Charity, what are we to say of the rest? Or to speak in tongues, what is that compared to Prophecy and Faith? Or to distribute all one's goods to the poor, what is that compared to Prophecy, and to deliver one's body to be burned? For the most part reckless and precipitate people do this. Therefore those two there are great, concerning which it is truly to be wondered at if we could find some man having Prophecy and not having Charity, or having Faith and not having Charity.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":149,"ref":"p149","source":"De Prophetia exemplum nobis dat Regnorum liber. Saul persecutor erat sancti David (1 Reg. xix). Cum eum persequeretur, et mitteret satellites, qui eum arriperent ad poenas, illi, qui missi erant, ut adducerent David occidendum, invenerunt eum inter Prophetas, ubi erat et Samuel sanctus Annae sterilis filius, quem concipiendum a Domino petierat, a Domino acceperat, et natum Domino dederat. Eo ergo tempore erat Samuel, quo tempore erat David, praestantissimus ille Prophetarum, nam ab ipso unctus est David. Cum itaque persecutionem a Saule pateretur, confugit ad Samuelem, sicut modo verbi gratia, qui forte foris aliquam persecutionem patitur, confugit ad Ecclesiam. Ergo eo confugerat, ubi erat non solus Samuel praestantissimus omnium Prophetarum, sed etiam multi caeteri Prophetae. Inter illos, cum essent prophetantes, venerunt missi a Saule, qui cum, sicut dixi, ad mortem arriperent. Insiluit in illos Spiritus Dei, et coeperunt prophetare, qui venerant hominem sanctum et justum Dei ad gladium adducere, et eruere de medio Prophetarum. Repente impleti Spiritu Dei Prophetae facti sunt. Fuerit hoc fortasse istorum innocentia; non enim sponte ad illum arripiendum venerant, sed a Rege suo missi erant. Et forte venerant quidem ad eum locum, ubi erat David, sed non erant facturi, quod jusserat Saul. Forte et ipsi remansuri erant. Nam et hodie contingunt haec.","english":"The book of Kings gives us an example concerning prophecy. Saul was a persecutor of holy David (1 Kings 19). When he was persecuting him and sending attendants to seize him for punishment, those who had been sent to lead David away to be killed found him among the prophets, where Samuel also was, the holy son of the barren Anna, whom she had asked of the Lord to conceive, had received from the Lord, and had given to the Lord when he was born. At that time, then, Samuel was alive, at the time when David also was alive, that most eminent of the prophets, for David was anointed by him. And so, when he was suffering persecution from Saul, he fled to Samuel, just as today, for example, someone who perhaps suffers some persecution abroad flees to the Church. He had therefore fled to where not only Samuel, the most eminent of all the prophets, was, but also many other prophets. While they were prophesying among them, those sent by Saul came, who, as I said, were seizing him for death. The Spirit of God rushed upon them, and those who had come to lead a holy and righteous man of God to the sword and to tear him away from the midst of the prophets began to prophesy. Suddenly filled with the Spirit of God, they became prophets. Perhaps this was due to the innocence of these men; for they had not come of their own accord to seize him, but had been sent by their king. And perhaps they had indeed come to the place where David was, but were not going to do what Saul had ordered. Perhaps they too were going to remain. For even today these things happen.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":150,"ref":"p150","source":"Mittitur aliquando apparitor a magna Potestate rapere aliquem de Ecclesia. Non audet facere contra Deum, et ne et ipse incurrat gladium, remanet ibi, ubi missus erat, ut raperet. Dixerit ergo aliquis admirans, quod Prophetae isti repente facti sunt, quia innocentes fuerunt, testimonium illis innocentiae ipsa Prophetia perhibuit. Venerunt missi, sed facturi non erant, quod jusserat malus ille. Credamus hoc de istis. Missi sunt alii. Et in ipsos insiluit Spiritus Dei, et ipsi prophetare coeperunt. Et hos cum illis innocentiae merito numeremus. Missi sunt tertii. Hoc et ipsis factum est. Fuerint omnes innocentes. Cum tardarent, et non fieret, quod Saul praeceperat, venit et ipse. Numquid et ipse innocens? Numquid et ipse missus ab aliqua potestate, et non perversus propria voluntate? Et in illo tamen insiluit Spiritus Dei, et prophetare coepit. Ecce Saul prophetat habens Prophetiam, sed non habens Charitatem. Factum est Vas quoddam, quod ab Spiritu tangeretur, non quod ab Spiritu mundaretur.","english":"At times an officer is sent by a great Power to seize someone from the Church. He does not dare to act against God, and lest he himself fall under the sword, he remains there where he had been sent to seize. Someone, then, may say in wonder that these prophets were suddenly made such because they were innocent: prophecy itself bore witness to their innocence. The messengers came, but they were not going to do what that wicked man had ordered. Let us believe this about them. Others were sent. And the Spirit of God leaped upon them too, and they themselves began to prophesy. Let us count these too among the innocent by merit. A third group was sent. This happened to them as well. Let them all have been innocent. When they delayed and what Saul had commanded was not done, he came himself. Was he too innocent? Was he too sent by some power, and not rather perverted by his own will? And yet the Spirit of God leaped upon him too, and he began to prophesy. Behold, Saul prophesies, having Prophecy but not having Charity. He became a certain vessel that was touched by the Spirit, not one that was cleansed by the Spirit.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":151,"ref":"p151","source":"Tangit enim aliqua corda ad prophetandum Spiritus Dei, nec tamen mundat. Et si tangit, et non mundat, forte inquinatur ipse Spiritus? Divinae enim substantiae est, omnia contingere, nusquam inquinari. Nec miremini, si lux ista, quae de coelo funditur, omnia ubique sparsa immunda contingit, nusquam de immundo fuscatur. Nec ista sola, quae de coelo, sed etiam illa, quae de lucerna mittitur, contingit, quacumque duxeris lumen, et fortasse, quisquis per cloacam transeat, ipse, si tetigerit, polluitur; si autem fert lucernam, splendor lucernae supra omnia transit, nusquam maculam contrahit. Si hoc potuit Deus donare corporalibus luminibus, ipse lumen verum, et aeternum, et incommutabile potest alicubi coinquinari? Aut potest alicubi deesse lux Dei, de qua dictum est: Attingit a fine usque ad finem fortiter, et disponit omnia suaviter (1 Sap. viii, 1)? Tangit ergo quod vult, et mundat quod vult. Non quodcumque tetigerit, mundat, sed, quod mundaverit, tangit. Saulem itaque persecutorem Dei Spiritus non mundavit, sed tamen ad prophetandum tetigit. Caiphas princeps Sacerdotum Christi persecutor erat, et tamen Prophetiam locutus est, quando ait: Expedit ut unus homo moriatur, et non tota gens pereat (Joan, xi, 50). Secutus Evangelista exposuit Prophetiam, et ait: Hoc autem non a se dixit, sed, cum esset Pontifex, prophetavit (Ibid. 51). Prophetavit Caiphas, prophetavit Saul.","english":"For the Spirit of God touches certain hearts for the purpose of prophesying, and yet does not cleanse them. And if it touches and does not cleanse, is the Spirit itself perhaps defiled? For it belongs to the divine substance to touch all things and to be defiled nowhere. And do not marvel if that light which is poured out from heaven touches all things scattered everywhere, unclean things, and is nowhere darkened by the unclean. Nor does this apply only to the light that comes from heaven, but also to that which is sent from a lamp: wherever you carry the light, and perhaps whoever passes through a sewer is himself defiled if he touches it; but if he carries a lamp, the brightness of the lamp passes over all things and contracts no stain anywhere. If God could grant this to bodily lights, can the true light itself, eternal and unchangeable, be defiled anywhere? Or can the light of God be absent anywhere, of which it is said: She reaches from end to end mightily, and orders all things sweetly (Wis 8:1)? It touches, therefore, what it wills, and cleanses what it wills. It does not cleanse whatever it has touched, but it touches what it has cleansed. And so the Spirit of God did not cleanse Saul, the persecutor of God, but nevertheless touched him to prophesy. Caiaphas, the chief of the priests, was a persecutor of Christ, and yet he spoke prophecy when he said: It is expedient that one man die, and that the whole nation not perish (Jn 11:50). The Evangelist who followed explained the prophecy and said: This he did not say of himself, but, since he was the high priest, he prophesied (Jn 11:51). Caiaphas prophesied, Saul prophesied.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":152,"ref":"p152","source":"Habebant Prophetiam, sed Charitatem non habebant. Numquid Charitatem habuit Caiphas, qui persequebatur Filium Dei, quem ad nos Charitas duxit? Numquid Charitatem habebat Saul, qui persequebatur eum, per cujus manum fuerat ab hostibus liberatus? Non solum invidus, sed et ingratus. Ergo probavimus posse esse in aliquo Prophetiam, et non esse Charitatem. Istis autem Prophetia prodesse non potest, secundum Apostolum. Si Charitatem, inquit, non habeam, nihil sum (1 Cor. xiii, 2). Non ait: Nihil est Prophetia, aut nihil est Fides; sed nihil sum ego, si non habuero Charitatem. Habens magna nihil est, quamvis magna habeat, nihil est. Ipsa enim magna, quae habet, non habet ad adjutorium, sed habet ad judicium. Non magna habere magnum est, sed bene uti magnis magnum est. Non autem utitur bene, qui non habet Charitatem. Etenim non utitur bene aliqua re, nisi voluntas bona. Voluntas bona esse non potest, ubi Charitas non est.","english":"They had prophecy, but they did not have charity. Did Caiaphas have charity, who persecuted the Son of God, whom charity led to us? Did Saul have charity, who persecuted him by whose hand he had been freed from his enemies? He was not only envious, but also ungrateful. Therefore we have proved that prophecy can be in someone, and charity not be. But for such people prophecy cannot be of benefit, according to the Apostle. If I do not have charity, he says, I am nothing (1 Cor. 13:2). He did not say: Prophecy is nothing, or Faith is nothing; but I am nothing, if I do not have charity. One who has great things is nothing, although he has great things, he is nothing. For the very great things that he has, he does not have as a help, but he has them as a judgment. It is not great to have great things, but it is great to use great things well. But one who does not have charity does not use them well. For he does not use anything well, unless the will is good. The will cannot be good where charity is not.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":153,"ref":"p153","source":"Quid de Fide? Invenimus aliquem habere et Fidem, et non habere Charitatem? Multi sunt, qui credunt, et non amant. Nec enumerandi sunt homines. Daemones invenimus credidisse quod credimus, et non amare quod amamus. Nam, cum argueret apostolus Jacobus eos, qui sibi putabant sufficere, ut crederent, et nolebant bene vivere, quod non fit, nisi de Charitate; bona enim vita ad Charitatem pertinet, nec potest habens Charitatem male vivere, quia hoc ipsum bene vivere nihil est aliud, quam impleri Charitate. Cum ergo quidam jactarent se, quod credidissent in Deum, et nollent bene vivere, atque congruenter tantae Fidei, quam perceperant, daemonibus eos comparavit dicens: Tu, inquit, dicis, quia unus est Deus. Bene credis; sed et daemones credunt et contremiscunt (Jacob. ii, 19). Si ergo tantummodo credis, et non diligis, adhuc cum daemonibus tibi commune est. Petrus dixit: Tu es Filius Dei; et dictum est illi: Beatus es, Simon Bar-Jona, quia non revelavit tibi caro et sanguis, sed Pater meus, qui in coelis est (Matth. xvi, 16, 17). Invenimus et daemones dixisse: Quid nobis et tibi est, Fili Dei (Id. viii, 29)? Filium Dei confitentur Apostoli, Filium Dei confitentur et daemones. Confessio videtur par, dilectio dispar. Illi credunt, et amant, illi credunt et timent. Amor expectat praemium, timor poenam. Ergo invenimus posse quemquam habere etiam Fidem, et non habere Charitatem.","english":"What about faith? Do we find someone who has both faith and not charity? There are many who believe and do not love. Nor should we bother to count up individual people. We find that the demons have believed what we believe, and do not love what we love. For when the apostle James was rebuking those who thought it was enough for them to believe, and were unwilling to live well—which does not happen except through charity; for a good life belongs to charity, and one who has charity cannot live badly, because this very thing, to live well, is nothing other than to be filled with charity—when, then, certain people were boasting that they had believed in God, and were unwilling to live well and in a manner worthy of such great faith as they had received, he compared them to demons, saying: You say that God is one. You believe well; but even the demons believe and tremble (James 2:19). If, therefore, you only believe and do not love, this is still something you have in common with the demons. Peter said: You are the Son of God; and it was said to him: Blessed are you, Simon Bar-Jona, because flesh and blood did not reveal it to you, but my Father who is in heaven (Matthew 16:16-17). We find that the demons also said: What have we to do with you, Son of God (Matthew 8:29)? The apostles confess the Son of God; the demons also confess the Son of God. The confession seems equal, the love is different. The former believe and love; the latter believe and fear. Love awaits a reward, fear a punishment. Therefore we find that someone can have even faith and not have charity.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":154,"ref":"p154","source":"Nemo ergo se jactet de quocumque Ecclesiae dono, si forte eminet in Ecclesia aliquo attributo sibi dono, sed videat utrum habeat Charitatem. Nam locutus est idem apostolus Paulus, et enumeravit multa dona Dei (1 Cor. xii), in membris Christi, quae est Ecclesia, et ait dona propria quibusque Membris esse attributa, nec posse fieri ut omnes habeant unum donum. Nec quisquam tamen sine dono remanebit. Apostolus ait Prophetas, Doctores, Interpretatores, linguis locutores, habentes virtutes sanitatum, habentes adjutoria, gubernationes, genera linguarum. Dicta sunt haec, et alia videmus in aliis, alia in aliis. Non ergo doleat aliquis, non sibi esse concessum quod videt alii concessum. Habeat Charitatem, non invideat habenti, et cum illo habet, quod non habet. Quidquid enim habuerit frater meus, si non invidero, et amavero, meum est. In me non habeo, sed in illo habeo. Non esset meum, si in uno corpore, et sub uno Capite non essemus.","english":"Let no one therefore boast of any gift of the Church, if perhaps he stands out in the Church by some gift attributed to him, but let him see whether he has charity. For the same apostle Paul spoke, and he enumerated many gifts of God (1 Cor 12) in the members of Christ, which is the Church, and he said that proper gifts are attributed to each of the members, and that it cannot happen that all have one gift. And yet no one will remain without a gift. The apostle said: prophets, teachers, interpreters, speakers in tongues, those having powers of healings, those having helps, governments, kinds of tongues. These things have been said, and we see other things in others, other things in still others. Therefore let no one grieve that what he sees granted to another has not been granted to himself. Let him have charity, let him not envy the one who has it, and with him he has what he does not have. For whatever my brother has, if I do not envy him and I love him, it is mine. I do not have it in myself, but I have it in him. It would not be mine, if we were not in one body and under one Head.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":155,"ref":"p155","source":"Sinistra manus verbi gratia in corpore habet annulum, et dextra non habet. Numquid illa sine ornamento remansit? Respice singulas manus, et videbis unam habere, aliam non habere. Respice compagem corporis, cui haerent ambae manus, et vide eam, quae non habet, in illa habere, quae habet. Oculi vident, qua eatur; pedes eunt, quo oculi prospiciunt. Nec pedes possunt videre, nec oculi ambulare. Sed respondet tibi pes: Habeo et ego lumen, sed non in me, sed in oculo. Non enim oculus sibi videt, et mihi non videt. Dicunt et oculi: Et nos ambulamus, non in nobis, sed in pedibus. Non enim pedes se ipsos portant, et nos non portant. Singula ergo membra singulis et propriis officiis distributa peragunt, quod imperat animus. Omnia tamen in uno corpore constituta et unitatem tenentia nec arrogant sibi, quod altera membra habent, si forte illa membra non habent, nec putant esse a se alienum, quod in uno corpore similiter habent. Denique, fratres, si alicui membro corporis molestiarum aliquid accidat, quae membra suum auxilium denegabunt? Quid tam extremum videtur in homine, quam pes? Et in ipso pede quid tam extremum, quam planta? Et in ipsa planta quid tam extremum, quam ipsa cutis, unde terra calcatur? Ita tamen hoc extremum universi corporis compage detinetur, ut, si in ipso loco spina calcetur, ad auxilium spinae eruendae omnia membra concurrant.","english":"For example, the left hand in the body has a ring, and the right hand does not. Did the latter remain without ornament? Look at each hand, and you will see that one has it and the other does not. Look at the structure of the body, to which both hands are attached, and see that the hand which does not have it has it in the hand which does. The eyes see where one should go; the feet go where the eyes look ahead. Neither can the feet see, nor can the eyes walk. But the foot answers you: I too have light, but not in myself, but in the eye. For the eye does not see for itself and not see for me. The eyes also say: We too walk, not in ourselves, but in the feet. For the feet do not carry themselves and not carry us. Each member, then, distributed among its own particular functions, carries out what the soul commands. Yet all, established in one body and holding unity, do not arrogate to themselves what other members have, if perhaps they do not have those things themselves, nor do they think alien to themselves what they similarly have in one body. Finally, brothers, if some trouble befalls any member of the body, which members will deny it their help? What seems so lowly in a man as the foot? And in the foot itself, what is so lowly as the sole? And in the sole itself, what is so lowly as the very skin by which the earth is trodden? Yet this lowliest part is so held together by the structure of the whole body that, if a thorn is stepped on in that very spot, all the members run together to help pull out the thorn.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":156,"ref":"p156","source":"Continuo complicantur poplites, curvatur spinae non illa, quae haesit, sed quae totum dorsum continet, sedetur, ut spina eruatur; jam sedere, ut hoc fiat, totius corporis est. Quam exiguus locus in molestia est! Tantillus locus est, quantum spina pungere potuit, et tamen illius extremi, et exigui loci molestia (??) toto corpore non relinquitur. Caetera membra nihil dolent, et in illo uno loco omnia dolent. Ipse inde Apostolus dedit Charitatis exemplum, exhortans nos, ut ita nos diligamus invicem, quemadmodum se in corpore diligunt membra. Si patiatur, inquit, unum membrum, compatiuntur et alia membra, et si glorificatur unum membrum, congaudent omnia membra. Vos estis corpus Christi et membra (1 Cor. xii 26). Si se diligunt membra, quae habent caput in terra, quomodo se debent membra diligere, quorum caput in coelo est. Certe nec ipsa se diligunt, si a suo capite deseruntur. Cum vero illud caput ita sit caput, et ita exaltatum sit, et ita in coelo ad dextram Patris collocatum, ut tamen laboret in terra, non in se, sed in membris suis, ita ut dicat in fine: Esurivi, sitivi, hospes fui; quando ei dicetur; Quando te vidimus esurientem, et sitientem? et tanquam respondeat: Ego caput in coelo eram, sed in terra membra sitiebant, denique ait: Cum uni ex minimis meis fecistis, mihi fecistis, rursusque non facientibus: Cum uni ex minimis meis non fecistis, neque mihi fecistis (Matth.","english":"Immediately the knees are bent, that spine is curved—not the one that was injured, but the one that holds the whole back—and the patient is seated so that the spine may be extracted; now, for this to be done, it takes the whole body to sit. How small a place is involved in the trouble! The place is as tiny as the point where the spine could pierce, and yet the distress of that outermost and tiny place is not left to the whole body. The other members feel no pain, and in that one place all feel pain. The Apostle himself gave from this an example of charity, exhorting us to love one another as the members love themselves in the body. If one member suffers, he says, the other members suffer with it, and if one member is glorified, all the members rejoice together. You are the body of Christ and members (1 Cor. 12:26). If the members love one another—members whose head is on earth—how ought the members to love one another whose head is in heaven? Surely they do not even love themselves if they are forsaken by their head. But since that head is so truly the head, and is so exalted, and is so placed in heaven at the right hand of the Father, that it nevertheless labors on earth—not in itself, but in its members—so that it says at the end: I was hungry, I was thirsty, I was a stranger; when it will be said to him: When did we see you hungry and thirsty? and as if he were answering: I, the head, was in heaven, but on earth my members were thirsty—finally he says: When you did it to one of the least of mine, you did it to me, and again to those who did not do it: When you did not do it to one of the least of mine, neither did you do it to me (Matt.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":157,"ref":"p157","source":"xxv, 35-45), huic capiti non nisi per Charitatem connectimur.\n\nSic enim, fratres, singula membra in officiis suis videmus agere opus proprium, ut oculus videat, non autem operetur; manus autem operetur, non tamen videat; auris audiat, nec videat, nec operetur; lingua loquatur, nec audiat, nec videat, et cum sint singula suis officiis distincta atque discreta, una tamen compage corporis colligata habent aliquid commune in omnibus. Officia diversa sunt, sanitas una est. Hoc est ergo in membris Christi Charitas, quod est in membris corporis sanitas. Meliori loco positus est oculus, in eminenti, et tanquam ad consilium in arce constitutus, unde prospiciat, unde videat, unde ostendat. Honor magnus in oculis, et loco, et sensu ardentiore, et agilitate, et vi quadam, quam caetera membra non habent. Proinde plerumque homines per oculos suos jurant, quam per quodlibet alterum membrum. Nemo alicui dixit: Sic te diligo quomodo aures meas, et est aurium sensus oculis suppar, et proximus. Quid de caeteris dicam? Quotidie dicunt homines: Sic te diligo tanquam oculos meos. Et Apostolus significans majorem in oculis habere dilectionem, quam in caeteris membris, cum se dilectum ab Ecclesia Dei diceret, ait; Testimonium enim vobis perhibeo, quia, si fieri posset, oculos vestros eruissetis, et dedissetis mihi (Galat. iv, 15).","english":"We are joined to this head only through Charity. For thus, brothers, we see each individual member performing its own proper work in its offices: the eye sees but does not act; the hand acts but does not see; the ear hears, but neither sees nor acts; the tongue speaks, but neither hears nor sees; and though each is distinguished and separated by its own offices, yet being bound together in the one frame of the body they have something in common in all. The offices are diverse; the health is one. What health is in the members of the body, then, Charity is in the members of Christ. The eye is placed in a better position, on high, and as it were set in the citadel for counsel, from where it looks forth, from where it sees, from where it points out. Great is the honor of the eyes, both in place and in a keener sense, and in quickness, and in a certain power that the other members do not have. Hence for the most part men swear by their eyes rather than by any other member. No one has said to another: I love you as my ears—and yet the sense of hearing is nearly equal and next to the eyes. What shall I say of the rest? Daily men say: I love you as my eyes. And the Apostle, signifying that he had a greater love in the eyes than in the other members, when he said that he was loved by the Church of God, says: For I bear you witness that, if it were possible, you would have plucked out your eyes and given them to me (Galatians 4:15).","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":158,"ref":"p158","source":"Nihil ergo in corpore sublimius oculis et honoratius, et nihil in corpore extremius fortasse, quam digitus minimus pedis. Cum ita sint, expedit tamen in corpore digitum esse, et sanum esse, quam oculum esse, et in perturbatione lippire. Sanitas enim, quae communis est omnibus membris, pretiosior est officiis singulorum. Ita vides in Ecclesia hominem parvum aliquod donum habentem, et tamen habentem Charitatem; alterum eminentem forte in Ecclesia aliquo majore dono, et tamen non habentem Charitatem. Ille sit extremus digitus, ille sit oculus. Ille magis pertinet ad corporis compaginem, qui potuit obtinere sanitatem. Denique molestum est corpori caetero, quidquid aegrotant in corpore, et datur quidem ab omnibus membris opera, ut sanetur, quod aegrotum est, et plerumque sanatur. Si autem sanatum non fuerit, et tantam putredinem conceperit, quae sanari non possit, ita consulitur omnibus membris, ut de corporis compage perdatur.","english":"Nothing, then, in the body is higher or more honorable than the eyes, and perhaps nothing in the body is more lowly than the smallest toe. Since this is so, it is nevertheless better to be a toe in the body and to be healthy than to be an eye and to be bleary-eyed in disorder. For health, which is common to all the members, is more precious than the functions of individuals. So you see in the Church a man having some small gift, and yet having Charity; another perhaps eminent in the Church with some greater gift, and yet not having Charity. Let that one be the lowest toe, let this one be the eye. He belongs more to the compacting of the body who has been able to obtain health. Finally, whatever is sick in the body is troublesome to the rest of the body, and work is indeed given by all the members so that what is sick may be healed, and for the most part it is healed. But if it has not been healed, and has conceived such rot that it cannot be healed, provision is made for all the members that it be lost from the compacting of the body.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":159,"ref":"p159","source":"Fuerit ergo, nescio quis, Donatus, quasi oculus in corpore, fuerit; ita non scimus, qualis fuerit, sed prorsus talis fuerit, qualis dicitur, quid illi profuit excellentia honoris et gloriae? Tenere non potuit sanitatem, quia non habuit Charitatem. Denique in isti putrefacti sunt, ut necessario praeciderentur, et quod se habere aliquos dicunt, vermes putredinis sunt. Praecisi vermes sunt, nec sanitatem possunt admittere. Etenim tandiu membrum admittit sanitatem, quandiu est de corpore non praecisum. De caeteris enim sanis manat sanitas ad vulneris locum; cum autem fuerit praecisum membrum, ubi vulnus est, qua, et unde ad illud sanitas veniat, non invenitur. Ideo et sarmentis praecisis comparantur, et concurrit cum apostolica lectione evangelica lectio. Et ibi enim Dominus, ut maneamus in illo, non nobis maxime commendavit nisi Charitatem: Ego sum, inquit, vitis, vos estis sarmenta, Pater meus est agricola, Sarmentum omne, quod in me dat fructum, purgat illud, ut magis fructum afferat; quod autem in me non dat fructum, praecidet illud (Joan. xv, 1, 2). Fructus de ipsa Charitate, quia non venit fructus nisi de radice. Dicit autem Apostolus: Ut in Charitate radicati et fundati (Ephes. iii, 17). Ibi est ergo radix, unde omnis fructus exurgit.","english":"It may have been, then, some Donatus or other, as it were an eye in the body; so be it. We do not know what sort he was, but assuredly he was such as he is said to have been—what did the excellence of his honor and glory profit him? He could not hold fast to health, because he did not have Charity. Finally, in these they have rotted, so that they had necessarily to be cut off, and what they say they have as some members are worms of rottenness. Cut-off worms they are, and they cannot admit health. For a member admits health for as long as it has not been cut off from the body. For from the other healthy members health flows to the place of the wound; but when a member has been cut off, where the wound is, by what way and from what source health may come to it is not found. Therefore they are also compared to cut-off branches, and the reading of the Gospel concurs with the reading of the Apostle. For there too the Lord, so that we may remain in him, commended nothing to us more especially than Charity: I am, he says, the vine, you are the branches, my Father is the farmer; every branch that bears fruit in me, he prunes it, that it may bear more fruit; but what does not bear fruit in me, he will cut off (Jn 15:1-2). The fruit is from Charity itself, because fruit does not come except from the root. But the Apostle says: That in Charity you may be rooted and founded (Eph 3:17). There, then, is the root from which every fruit arises.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":160,"ref":"p160","source":"Qui coepit dissentire a radice, quamvis videatur aliquantum manere, aut praecisus est latenter, aut aperte etiam praecidendus; fructum enim afferre nullo pacto potest. Illi erant aliquando in unitate. Praecisi sunt. Unde praecisi sunt? Ab unitate. Sed vos estis, inquiunt, praecisi. Quid facimus! Ego dico: Vos estis praecisi. Vos dicitis: Vos estis praecisi. Judicet Deus. Distulimus itaque quaestionem, et ad judicium Dei misimus? Non plane. In multis rebus facimus hoc, ubi nondum apparet sententia Dei. Ubi autem apparet, utamur, non differamus. Scripturam profero, et video, quis unde praecisus sit. Si enim Scriptura testimonium perhibuit Parti Donati, alicui Ecclesiae in terrarum aliqua parte constitutae, sicut in parte Africae constituta est Pars Donati, dicant nos praecisos, et dicant se esse radicatos. Si autem Scriptura testimonium non perhibet nisi Ecclesiae, toto orbe diffusae, quid quaerimus litis nostrae judicem hominem? Deum habemus. Nondum praesidet in judicio, jam praesidet in Evangelio.","english":"Whoever began to dissent from the root, although he may seem to remain for a little while, has either been cut off secretly or is still to be cut off openly; for he can in no way bear fruit. They were once in unity. They have been cut off. From what have they been cut off? From unity. But they say: It is you who have been cut off. What are we to do? I say: It is you who have been cut off. You say: It is you who have been cut off. Let God judge. Have we therefore postponed the question and referred it to God's judgment? Not at all. In many matters we do this, where God's sentence does not yet appear. But where it does appear, let us use it; let us not postpone it. I bring forward Scripture, and I see who has been cut off from what. For if Scripture gave testimony to the party of Donatus, to some church established in some part of the world—just as the party of Donatus is established in a part of Africa—let them say that we have been cut off, and let them say that they are rooted. But if Scripture gives testimony only to the Church spread throughout the whole world, why do we seek a man as judge of our dispute? We have God. He does not yet preside in judgment, but he already presides in the Gospel.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":161,"ref":"p161","source":"Judicatus est modo Crispinus haereticus. Sed quid ait? Numquid evangelica sententia superatus sum? Inde se asserens victum non esse, quia Proconsul contra illum judicavit, non Christus. Si ergo judicium hominis parvi pendit, quare a Proconsule ad Imperatorem appellavit? Ipsius Proconsulis judicium ipse flagitavit, ipse dixit: Audi me. Non sum haereticus. Cujus judicium flagitasti ejus judicium displicet tibi? Quare? Quia contra te judicavit? Si pro te judicaret, bene judicaret. Quia contra te judicavit, male judicavit. Antequam judicaret, bonus judex erat, cui dixisti: Non sum haereticus. Audi me. Sed judicavit Proconsul, inquit, secundum leges Imperatorum, non secundum leges Evangelii. Ita fecerit, secundum leges Imperatorum Proconsul judicaverit. Si ergo male contra te judicant Imperatores, quare a Proconsule ad eorum judicium provocasti? Jam crant leges Imperatorum contra te, an nondum erant? Si nondum erant, non secundum ipsas Proconsul judicavit. Si jam erant, numquid pro te Imperatores contra leges suas judicaturi sunt? Deinde quaero abs te: Ipsae leges Imperatorum quae sunt contra te? Quid factum est? doce me! Manifestum est enim, et non negatur, multas Imperatorum leges esse adversus ipsos. Unde hoc contigit? Unde hoc factum est? Nos forte persecuti sumus, et multa mala Imperatoribus de vobis diximus? Hoc quidem dicunt his, quos miseros decipiunt imperitos.","english":"Crispinus the heretic has just now been judged. But what does he say? Was I overcome by the gospel's sentence? Hence he asserts that he was not defeated, because the Proconsul judged against him, not Christ. If, then, he makes little of a man's judgment, why did he appeal from the Proconsul to the Emperor? He himself demanded the judgment of that very Proconsul; he himself said: Hear me. I am not a heretic. Do you find displeasing the judgment of the one whose judgment you demanded? Why? Because he judged against you? If he had judged for you, he would have judged well. Because he judged against you, he judged badly. Before he judged, he was a good judge, to whom you said: I am not a heretic. Hear me. But the Proconsul judged, he says, according to the laws of the Emperors, not according to the laws of the Gospel. Let him do so; the Proconsul judged according to the laws of the Emperors. If, then, the Emperors judge badly against you, why did you appeal from the Proconsul to their judgment? Were the Emperors' laws already against you, or not yet? If they were not yet, the Proconsul did not judge according to them. If they already were, will the Emperors judge for you against their own laws? Then I ask you: What are those very laws of the Emperors that are against you? What was done? Teach me! For it is manifest, and it is not denied, that many laws of the Emperors are against them. How did this happen? How was this brought about? Did we perhaps persecute them, and say many evil things to the Emperors about you? This indeed they say to those whom they wretchedly deceive, being themselves inexperienced.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":162,"ref":"p162","source":"Causam enim, quemadmodum illo tempore gesta est, penitus occultant eis, quos decipere volunt. Sed, quantumlibet occultent, eruitur, patescit, publicatur, in notitiam profertur etiam invitorum, et recusantium. Claudentes oculos, ac nolentes lucem videre ipsa lux feriat. Non eis liceat dissimulare manifesta! Non eis liceat averti a patentibus! Non eis liceat aperta operire! Urgeam eos manifesta veritate. Vos Imperatoris judicium flagitastis. Mentimini! inquit. Extant chartae publicae. Ipsi Donatistae de Parte Majorini, qui prior ordinatus est, contra Caecilianum adierunt Proconsulem tunc Anullinum, et detulerunt libellos accusatorios de nomine Caeciliani, et in aluta signatos, dicentes, sed adversus Caecilianum crimina quae illo libello scripsissent, et rogantes, ut ipsam accusationem eorum mitteret ad comitatum Imperatori. Extat relatio Anullini Proconsulis scribentis ad Imperatorem Constantinum: quod homines de Parte Majorini venerint ad illum cum libellis de accusatione Caeciliani, rogantes ut eosdem libellos mitteret Imperatori, et se dicit fecisse, quod illi rogaverunt. Scripsit Imperator ad Meltiadem episcopum et Marcum, transferens ad illos causam ecclesiasticam, et removens a se.","english":"For they hide completely from those whom they wish to deceive the case as it was conducted at that time. But however much they hide it, it is dug out, laid bare, made public, brought to notice even against the unwilling and those who refuse. Let the light itself strike those who close their eyes and are unwilling to see the light. Let it not be permitted them to ignore what is manifest! Let it not be permitted them to turn away from what lies open! Let it not be permitted them to cover over what is open! Let me press them with the manifest truth. You demanded the Emperor's judgment. You lie! he says. The public records are extant. The Donatists themselves, from the party of Majorinus, who was ordained first, approached the Proconsul Anullinus at that time against Caecilian, and brought accusatory petitions in the name of Caecilian, and sealed in a leather bag, saying—but the charges which they had written in that petition were against Caecilian—and asking that he send their very accusation to the Emperor's court. There is extant the report of Anullinus the Proconsul, writing to the Emperor Constantine: that men from the party of Majorinus came to him with petitions concerning the accusation of Caecilian, asking that he send those same petitions to the Emperor, and he says that he did what they asked. The Emperor wrote to Bishop Miltiades and to Marcus, transferring the ecclesiastical case to them and removing it from himself.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":163,"ref":"p163","source":"In eisdem litteris scribit Imperator: misisse se chartas missas ab Anullino, et in ipsis litteris ignorat, quae illae chartae sint, sed in relatione Anullini cognoscitur, quae hodie publicis codicibus continentur. Deinde scribit idem Constantinus ad Anullinum, ut partes Romam dirigat ad episcopale judicium. Refert etiam Anullinus in extremo: misisse se partes. Vos ergo istis ad Imperatorem, vos causam Ecclesiae ad humanam potestatem detulistis. Ille melior, quam vos. Vos enim ad Imperatorem deferebatis, ille ad Episcopos. Dicta est causa in episcopali judicio illis primo accusantibus. Prolata est sententia pro Caeciliano. Illi non contenti judicio ecclesiastico murmurare coeperunt, rursus eumdem Imperatorem adierunt, post episcopale judicium quaerentes imperiale judicium. Dedit alterum ecclesiasticum apud A(??)elatum. Ab ipso etiam judicio illi ad ipsum imperatorem appellaverunt. Victus importunitate eorum voluit et ipse causam suscipere, atque cognoscere. Suscepit, cognovit, Caecilianum innocentissimum judicavit, etiam omnes jussiones Imperatorum contra illos. Quid mirum? Cujus judicium flagitasti, ejus sententiam recusare audes? Quare ad illum voluisti deferre judicium? Habebas Ecclesiam in Africa, non habebas in toto orbe terrarum? Sed quo ibant, unde se jam ipsi praeciderant? Illi jam in Ecclesia non haerebant, sed Imperator ibi haerebat, ad quem judicium referebatur.","english":"In the same letters the Emperor writes that he had sent the documents sent by Anullinus, and in those same letters he does not know what those documents are, but from Anullinus's report it is known what is contained today in the public records. Then the same Constantine writes to Anullinus that he should direct the parties to Rome for an episcopal judgment. Anullinus also reports at the end that he has sent the parties. You, therefore, brought these matters to the Emperor; you brought the cause of the Church before human power. He was better than you. For you were bringing it to the Emperor; he was bringing it to the bishops. The case was argued in the episcopal judgment, with them as the accusers first. The sentence was pronounced in favor of Caecilian. They, not content with the ecclesiastical judgment, began to murmur, and again approached the same Emperor, seeking an imperial judgment after the episcopal judgment. He gave another ecclesiastical judgment before Aelatus. From that judgment too they appealed to the Emperor himself. Overcome by their importunity, he too wished to take up the case and to hear it. He took it up, heard it, judged Caecilian most innocent, and also all the commands of the Emperors against them. What wonder? Do you dare to reject the sentence of him whose judgment you demanded? Why did you wish to bring the judgment before him? Did you have the Church in Africa, but not have it in the whole world? But where were they going, from where they had already cut themselves off? They were no longer clinging to the Church, but the Emperor was clinging there, to whom the judgment was being referred.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":164,"ref":"p164","source":"Proinde ille mansuetissime Episcopos voluit judicare, et illis postea cessit, ut etiam ipse judicaret. Inde sunt leges adversus vos; videte, si non contra vos. Primo vos ipsi fuistis, vos primi accusatores, vos extremi appellatores, vos novissimi murmuratores. Numquid tamen, inquit, ex Evangelio superatus sum? Ex eo judicio superatus es, quod tu ipse delegisti.\n\nSed non recusamus evangelicam sententiam. Plane, etsi non diceret, nos legeremus, nos erueremus, nos ostenderemus. Recitetur Evangelium? Videamus, ubi esse dicit Ecclesiam Dominus Jesus Christus. Illi certe et aures nostrae, et corda patere debent. Ipsum audiamus. Dicat nobis, Ecclesia ubi sit. Si in Africa esse dixerit Ecclesiam suam, omnes confluamus in Partem Donati. Si in toto terrarum orbe dixerit Ecclesiam suam, redeant ad corpus membra praecisa, non enim sic fracti sunt rami, ut denuo inseri non possint. Habes apostolum Paulum dicentem. Sed dicis: Fracti sunt rami, ut ego inserar. Bene. Propter incredulitatem fracti sunt; tu autem fide stas. Noli altum sapere, sed time. Nam, si Deus naturalibus ramis non pepercit, neque tibi parcet (Rom. xi, 19-21). Fracti enim erant Judaei, tanquam rami naturales, et insertae erant Gentes, tanquam oleaster in olivam. Ex his insertis ramis, et ex hoc inserto oleastro omnes sumus participes olivae.","english":"Accordingly, he in his great gentleness wished the bishops to judge, and afterwards yielded to them, so that he himself also judged. Hence come the laws against you; see whether they are not against you. You were the first, you were the first accusers, you the last appellants, you the latest murmurers. Yet, he says, was I not overcome by the Gospel? By that judgment you were overcome, which you yourself chose.\n\nBut we do not refuse the Gospel's sentence. Clearly, even if he had not said it, we would read it, we would dig it out, we would show it. Shall the Gospel be read? Let us see where the Lord Jesus Christ says his Church is. To him certainly both our ears and our hearts ought to lie open. Let us hear him. Let him tell us where the Church is. If he says that his Church is in Africa, let us all flock to the party of Donatus. If he says that his Church is in the whole world, let the cut-off members return to the body, for the branches have not been broken so that they cannot be grafted in again. You have the apostle Paul saying it. But you say: The branches were broken off so that I might be grafted in. Well said. They were broken off for their unbelief; but you stand by faith. Do not be wise in high things, but fear. For if God did not spare the natural branches, neither will he spare you (Rom. 11:19-21). For the Jews were broken off like natural branches, and the Gentiles were grafted in like a wild olive into the olive tree. From these grafted branches, and from this grafted wild olive, we are all partakers of the olive tree.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":165,"ref":"p165","source":"Sed, sicut minatus erat Apostolus superbientibus ramis oleastri, tales isti facti sunt superbiendo, ut cum illis naturaralibus ante amputatis, et ipsi superbia praecidi mererentur. Sed quid ait Apostolus? Et illi, inquit, si non permanserint in infidelitate, inserentur (Rom. xi, 23), et tu, si non permanseris in fide, excideris is. Nemo ergo in vite superbiat, nemo praeter vitem desperet. Si superbis in vite, observa, ne praecidaris. Si praeter vitem positi sunt, non desperent, audeant inseri. Non enim manu sua inserendi sunt. Ait enim: Potens est Deus iterum inserere illos (Ibid.). Non dicant; Unde fieri potest, res praecisa, ramus fractus ut denuo inseratur? Recte dicis fieri non posse, si interroges humanam fucultatem, non, si interroges divinam majestatem. Quid enim? Quod jam factum est a Domino, facere potest aliquis agricolarum? Oleastrum tulit, et in olivam inseruit, et oleaster in olivam insertus non baccas amaras, sed olivam dedit. Faciat hoc modo aliquis; inserat oleastrum in olivam, videbit nihil procedere, nisi baccas olea· stri. Potens ergo fuit Deus non olivam in oleastro, sed oleastrum inserere in oliva, et oleastrum facere participem pinguedinis olivae, ut exuta amaritudine pinguedine indueretur, et non erit potens te praecisum per superbiam inserere per humilitatem?","english":"But, just as the Apostle had threatened the proud branches of the wild olive, these men have become such by their pride, that when those natural branches had first been cut off, they too deserved to be cut off by pride. But what does the Apostle say? And they, he says, if they do not continue in unbelief, shall be grafted in (Rom. 11:23), and you, if you do not continue in faith, will be cut off. Let no one therefore be proud in the vine, let no one despair outside the vine. If you are proud in the vine, take care that you not be cut off. If they are placed outside the vine, let them not despair; let them dare to be grafted in. For they are not to be grafted in by their own hand. For he says: God is able to graft them in again (ibid.). Let them not say: How can it happen, that a thing cut off, a branch broken, be grafted in anew? You say rightly that it cannot be done, if you ask human ability, not if you ask divine majesty. For what? Can any of the farmers do what has already been done by the Lord? He took a wild olive, and grafted it into the olive, and the wild olive grafted into the olive yielded not bitter berries, but olives. Let someone do it in this way; let him graft a wild olive into an olive, he will see that nothing comes of it but the berries of the wild olive. God, then, was able to graft not the olive into the wild olive, but the wild olive into the olive, and to make the wild olive a partaker of the fatness of the olive, so that, its bitterness put off, it might be clothed with fatness; and will he not be able to graft you, cut off through pride, in through humility?","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":166,"ref":"p166","source":"Bene, inquit, hortaris me, sed prius meo ostende praecisum, ne forte te ipsum hortari debeas, ut ad me venias, non me, ut in te inserar. Audeo dicere: Audi me, et tamen timeo dicere: Audi me. Timeo enim, ne contemnat hominem. Imo hortor, ut contemnat hominem. Si enim contemneret hominem, non esset de Parte Donati. Homo enim fuit Donatus. Ergo, si nostra verba dicimus, contemnamur; si Christi verba dicimus, ille audiatur, qui non gratis auditur, et non gratis contemnitur. Auditur enim ad praemium, non auditur ad supplicium. Ipsum audiamus. Ipse Dominus dicat nobis.\n\nEcclesiam innumerabilibus locis ostendit, sed tamen commemorem unum aliquod. Post resurrectionem, nostis, fratres, ostendit se Discipulis suis, cicatrices demonstravit, palpandum praebuit, non solum videndum. Illi autem tenentes, et palpantes, et agnoscentes, adhuc tamen prae gaudio haesitabant, sicut Evangelium nos docet, cui oportet credere, cui nefas est non credere. Dominus autem adhuc haesitantibus prae gaudio, et dubitantibus intulit firmitatem de Scripturis, et ait: Haec dicebam vobis, cum adhuc essem vobiscum, quia oportet impleri omnia, quae scripta sunt in Lege et Prophetis, et Psalmis de me.","english":"You do well, he says, to exhort me, but first show me one cut off from my own body, lest perhaps you ought rather to exhort yourself to come to me, rather than me to be grafted into you. I dare to say: Hear me—and yet I fear to say: Hear me. For I fear that he may despise a man. No, rather I exhort him to despise a man. For if he despised a man, he would not be of the party of Donatus. For Donatus was a man. Therefore, if we speak our own words, let us be despised; if we speak Christ's words, let him be heard, who is not heard without reward, and not despised without penalty. For he is heard unto a reward, not heard unto a punishment. Let us hear him. Let the Lord himself speak to us.\n\nHe has shown the Church in countless places, but let me nevertheless mention some one. After the resurrection, you know, brothers, he showed himself to his disciples, he displayed his scars, he offered himself to be touched, not only to be seen. But they, holding him and touching him and recognizing him, were still hesitating for joy, as the Gospel teaches us, which we ought to believe, which it is a sin not to believe. But the Lord, to those still hesitating for joy and doubting, brought firmness from the Scriptures, and said: These are the words I spoke to you while I was still with you, that all things must be fulfilled which are written in the Law and the Prophets and the Psalms concerning me.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":167,"ref":"p167","source":"Tunc aperuit illis sensum, ut intelligerent Scripturas, et dixit eis: Quia sic oportebat Christum pati, et resurgere tertia die, et praedicari in nomine ejus paenitentiam, et remissionem peccatorum per omnes gentes incipientibus ab Jerusalem (Luc. xxiv. 44, 47) Ibi tu non es. Ibi ego sum. Quid expectas hominem, qui de te judicet de tribunali? Audi Christum de Evangelio. Per omnes gentes, inquit, incipientibus ab Jerusalem. Tu ibi es? Communicas omnibus gentibus? Communicas ei Ecclesiae, quae diffusa est per omnes gentes incipiens ab Jerusalem? Si communicas, ibi es, in vite es, praecisus non es. Ipsa est enim vitis, quae crevit, et implevit totum orbem terrarum, corpus Christi, Ecclesia Christi, cujus caput in coelo. Si autem non communicas, nisi Afris, et de Africa, quo potueris, clanculo mittis, qui consolentur peregrinos, non te invenis in Parte remansisse, a Toto praecisum esse? Quid dixisti in judicio Proconsulis? Catholicus sum. Vox est ipsius. De Gestis recitatur. Catholicus Totum tene. Holon enim Totum est, et inde appellata est Ecclesia catholica, quia per Totum est. Numquid Catamerica dicta est, et non Catholica? Meros enim pars est, Holon totum est. De graeco verbo dicta est Catholica, secundum totum. Ergo communicas Universo? Non, inquit. Ergo in parte es, quomodo Catholicus es? Multum interest inter Totum, et Partem. Unde accipit nomen Catholica?","english":"Then he opened their understanding, that they might understand the Scriptures, and said to them: Thus it was necessary for Christ to suffer, and to rise again on the third day, and that repentance and remission of sins should be preached in his name among all nations, beginning from Jerusalem. There you are not. There I am. Why do you wait for a man to judge you from a tribunal? Hear Christ from the Gospel. Among all nations, he says, beginning from Jerusalem. Are you there? Do you communicate with all nations? Do you communicate with that Church which is spread through all nations, beginning from Jerusalem? If you communicate, you are there, you are in the vine, you are not cut off. For that is the vine which grew and filled the whole world—the body of Christ, the Church of Christ, whose head is in heaven. But if you do not communicate except with Africans, and from Africa, wherever you can, you secretly send men to console the exiles, do you not find that you have remained in the Part, cut off from the Whole? What did you say in the proconsul's court? \"I am Catholic.\" It is his own voice. It is recited from the Acts. \"Catholic\"—hold the Whole. For holon means Whole, and from this the Church is called catholic, because it is through the Whole. Was it called \"Catamerica,\" and not \"Catholic\"? For meros is part, holon is whole. From the Greek word it is called \"Catholic,\" according to the whole. Therefore do you communicate with the Universe? No, he says. Therefore you are in a part—how are you Catholic? There is a great difference between the Whole and a Part. From where does it take the name \"Catholic\"?","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":168,"ref":"p168","source":"Tu enim accepisti nomen de Parte Donati, Catholica nomen accepit ab universo orbe terrarum. Sed nos dicimus in universo esse, et Deus forte non dicit? Evangelium commemoravi, ex Evangelio recitavi. Per omnes gentes, inquit, incipientibus ab Jerusalem. Non inde venit ad Africam? Si enim coepit ab Jerusalem, implendo omnia venit ad te, non siccando. Quis est, qui dicat: Ductus est rivus de fonte, ut veniret ad me, siccavit in via, et pervenit ad me? Si in via siccavit, ad te qua pervenit? Utique implendo omnia pervenit ad te. In grate rive, quare fontem blasphemas? Nisi manaret, non implereris. Sed timeo, ne tu siccaveris. Etenim omnis rivus a fonte praecisus siccet, necesse est. De siccitate aspera loquuntur adversus Ecclesiam; lenia loquerentur, si rigarentur. Catholicus sum. Quid est Catholicus? Homo de Numidia? Interroga saltem Graecos. Non est utique Catholicus verbum Punicum, sed verbum Graecum. Interpretem quaere. Merito erras in lingua, qui non consentis omnibus linguis.","english":"For you have taken your name from the party of Donatus; the Catholic Church has taken her name from the whole world. But we say that she is in the whole world—and does God perhaps not say so? I have cited the Gospel, I have read from the Gospel: \"Through all nations,\" it says, \"beginning from Jerusalem.\" Did it not come from there to Africa? For if it began from Jerusalem, it came to you by filling all things, not by drying up. Who is there to say: \"The stream was led from the fountain so that it might come to me, it dried up along the way, and so it reached me\"? If it dried up along the way, how did it reach you? Surely it reached you by filling all things. In gratitude for the stream, why do you blaspheme the fountain? Unless it flowed, you would not be filled. But I fear that you are the one who has dried up. For every stream cut off from its fountain must necessarily dry up. It is out of barren dryness that they speak harshly against the Church; they would speak gently if they were watered. I am a Catholic. What is a Catholic? A man from Numidia? At least ask the Greeks. \"Catholic\" is certainly not a Punic word, but a Greek word. Seek an interpreter. You are rightly mistaken in language, you who do not agree with all languages.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":169,"ref":"p169","source":"Spiritus quando venit de coelo, et implevit eos, qui in Christum crediderant, omnibus linguis locuti sunt, et hoc erat signum illo tempore accepisse Spiritum sanctum, si quis linguis omnium loqueretur (Act. ii, et xix). Numquid modo fidelibus non datur Spiritus sanctus? Absit ut hoc credamus, alioquin spem non habebimus. Et illi utique fatentur dari fidelibus Spiritum sanctum, et nos hoc dicimus, hoc credimus, hoc maxime, et in sola Ecclesia catholica fieri assequamur. Sed illi sint Catholici, illic datur Spiritus sanctus. Nos simus Catholici, hic datur Spiritus sanctus; modo, quid intersit, non quaeramus, qui sint Catholici; manifestum est, quia datur Spiritus sanctus. Quare modo linguis omnium non loquuntur, qui Spiritum sanctum accipiunt, nisi, quia tunc in paucis figurabatur, quod postea in omnibus ostenderetur? Quid enim pronuntiavit Spiritus sanctus commonens corda eorum, quos tunc impleverat, et docens eos linguas omnes? Vix discit homo duas aut tres, aut per magistros, aut per regiones, in quibus versatur aliqua consuetudine, ut multum tres, aut quatuor linguas. Omnibus linguis loquebantur, qui impleti a sancto Spiritu erant, verum et locuti repente, non paulatim discentes. Quid ergo tunc ostendebat Spiritus? Dic mihi, quare modo hoc non facit, nisi quia aliquid significando faciebat? Quid significabat, nisi Evangelium per omnes linguas futurum? Audeo dicere.","english":"When the Spirit came from heaven and filled those who had believed in Christ, they spoke in all languages, and this was the sign at that time of having received the Holy Spirit, if anyone spoke in the languages of all (Acts 2 and 19). Is the Holy Spirit not given to the faithful now? Far be it from us to believe this; otherwise we would have no hope. And they certainly admit that the Holy Spirit is given to the faithful, and we say this, we believe this, and we strive most of all that it be done in the Catholic Church alone. But let them be Catholics—there the Holy Spirit is given. Let us be Catholics—here the Holy Spirit is given. For now let us not ask what the difference is, who are the Catholics; it is manifest, because the Holy Spirit is given. Why then do those who receive the Holy Spirit not now speak in all languages, unless because what was then figured in a few was afterward to be shown forth in all? For what did the Holy Spirit declare, admonishing the hearts of those whom he had then filled and teaching them all languages? A man scarcely learns two or three, either through teachers or through the regions in which he is engaged by some custom, so that at most he learns three or four languages. All languages were spoken by those who had been filled with the Holy Spirit—and indeed they spoke suddenly, not learning little by little. What, then, was the Spirit showing at that time? Tell me, why does he not do this now, unless because he was doing it to signify something? What was he signifying, except that the Gospel would be throughout all languages? I dare to say it.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":170,"ref":"p170","source":"Et modo loquitur Ecclesia omnibus linguis. In omnibus enim linguis clamat Evangelium, et quod modo dicebam de membris, hoc dico et de linguis. Et quomodo dicit oculus: Mihi ambulat pes, sic et pes dicit: Mihi videt oculus, sic et ego dico: Lingua mea est graeca, lingua mea est hebraea, lingua mea est syra. Omnes enim una fides tenet, omnes enim una charitatis compago concludit. Quod per Dominum demonstratum est, hoc per Prophetas ante praedictum est. In omnem terram exivit sonus eorum, et in fines orbis terrae verba eorum (Psal. xviii, 5). Ecce quousque crevit Ecclesia, quae appellatur a Toto, Catholica. Et vide, quia omnes linguae ierunt per omnes terras. Non sunt loquelae, neque sermones, quorum non audiantur voces eorum (Ibid. 4).\n\nHanc ergo Ecclesiam teneo, tu illam non tenes. Si ergo praecisus es, agnosce, unde praecisus es. Redi, et inserere, ne arescas, et in ignem mittaris. Loquuntur Prophetae, loquuntur Apostoli, loquitur Dominus de Ecclesia toto orbe diffusa. Contra te dicunt omnes isti sententiam. A Proconsule ad imperiale judicium. Ab Evangelio quo? An forte ad Donatum? Donatus judicabit contra Christum? An Donatum judicat Christus? Quid tibi dicturus est Donatus? Ego Christum meum praedicavi de Africa. Quid dicturus? An: Me pro Christo opposui, et: Ego Christo successi? Hoc restat, ut dicat, quia a corpore praecidere ausus est homines, quia Christo successit.","english":"And now the Church speaks in all languages. For the Gospel cries out in all languages, and what I was just saying about the members, I say also about the tongues. And just as the eye says, \"The foot walks for me,\" so too the foot says, \"The eye sees for me,\" so I also say: My tongue is Greek, my tongue is Hebrew, my tongue is Syriac. For one faith holds all together, one bond of charity encloses all. What was shown through the Lord was foretold beforehand through the Prophets. Their sound has gone out into all the earth, and their words to the ends of the world (Ps. 18:5). Behold how far the Church has grown, which is called \"Catholic\" from the whole. And see, because all languages have gone through all lands. There are no speeches nor words whose voices are not heard (Ibid. 4).\n\nThis Church, then, I hold; you do not hold it. If therefore you have been cut off, acknowledge from where you have been cut off. Return, and be grafted in, lest you wither and be cast into the fire. The Prophets speak, the Apostles speak, the Lord speaks concerning the Church spread throughout the whole world. Against you all these pronounce sentence. From the proconsul to the imperial judgment. From the Gospel—to whom? Or perhaps to Donatus? Will Donatus judge against Christ? Or does Christ judge Donatus? What will Donatus say to you? \"I preached my Christ from Africa.\" What will he say? Or: \"I set myself against Christ for Christ's sake,\" and: \"I succeeded Christ\"? This remains, that he say that he dared to cut men off from the body, because he succeeded Christ.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":171,"ref":"p171","source":"Ecce Christi sententia, ecce Evangelia. Per omnes gentes, inquit, incipiens ab Jerusalem. Coepit ab Jerusalem. Ibi venit Spiritus sanctus, ibi erant Apostoli, quando in illos supervenit, inde coepit Evangelium praedicari, inde diffundi per omnes gentes, inde postea venit in Africam. Quo postea venit? Ipsos deseruit? Imo non deseruit, si nolint. Nam et nos Afri sumus. Utique Evangelium, quod venit in Africam, manet hic in Catholicis Afris, quo modo in omnibus gentibus manet. Nam et per omnes gentes sicut Haeretici, alii ibi, alii hic, et non sunt nati Afri, qui sunt in illis gentibus. De vite praecisi sunt. Catholica enim novit omnes, ipsi se non noverunt. Etenim vitis, unde sarmenta praecisa sunt, novit omnia sarmenta, et, quae in se manent, et quae de se praecisa sunt. Etenim ubique diffusa est Ecclesia catholica. Illa sarmenta, ubi praecisa sunt, ibi remanserunt, ad alias partes, et alias partes pervenire non potuerunt. Illa autem ubique diffusa ubique tenet suos, ubique plangit praecisos. Clamat ad omnes, ut revertantur, et inserantur. Clamor ejus non auditur, sed tamen ubera Charitatis manare non quiescunt. Sollicita est pro praecisis, clamat in Africa ad Donatistas, clamat in Oriente adversus Arianos, adversus Photinianos, adversus alios, atque alios. Quia enim ubique diffusa est, ubique invenit, contra quos clamet, quia in illa erant, et de illa praecisa sunt.","english":"Behold the sentence of Christ, behold the Gospels. Through all nations, he says, beginning from Jerusalem. It began from Jerusalem. There the Holy Spirit came, there were the Apostles, when he came upon them, from there the Gospel began to be preached, from there to be spread through all nations, from there afterward it came into Africa. Where did it come afterward? Did it abandon them? No, it did not abandon them, if they are unwilling. For we too are Africans. Certainly the Gospel that came into Africa remains here among Catholic Africans, just as it remains among all nations. For even through all nations, as the heretics are—some there, some here—and those who are in those nations were not born Africans. They have been cut off from the vine. For the Catholic Church knows all, but they do not know themselves. For the vine, from which the branches were cut off, knows all the branches, both those that remain in it and those that were cut off from it. For the Catholic Church is spread everywhere. Those branches, where they were cut off, remained there; they could not reach other parts, and other parts. But she, spread everywhere, holds her own everywhere, laments the cut-off everywhere. She cries out to all, that they may return and be grafted in. Her cry is not heard, but nevertheless the breasts of Charity do not cease to flow. She is anxious for the cut-off; she cries out in Africa against the Donatists, she cries out in the East against the Arians, against the Photinians, against others and others. For since she is spread everywhere, everywhere she finds those against whom she may cry out, because they were in her and were cut off from her.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":172,"ref":"p172","source":"Sarmenta coeperunt infructuosa esse, et praecisa sunt. Si non permaneant in infidelitate rursus inserentur. Haec audite, fratres, cum timore, ne superbiatis; cum Charitate, ut etiam pro illis oretis. Conversi ad Dominum, etc.\n\nSERMO XX.\n\nDe verbis Psalmi xxxviii, vers. 1-5. Dixi: Custodiam vias meas, etc..\n\nSYNOPSIS.\n\nI. Sollicitudo de profectu quotidiano, et inde divini auxilii imploratio. II. Usus Linguae tam necessarius, quam periculosus. III. Lingua regitur ab animo. IV. Lingua dolosa Judaeorum confusa. V. Linguae bonus usus in muliere adultera. VI. Adultera confessio nobis instructio. VII. Quomodo agendum cum conviciatore. VIII. Conviciatoribus ignoscendum, et pro eis orandum. IX. Inquiritur in finem hominis. X. Finis hominis Christus est. XI Fide et operibus hic finis attingitur. XII. Scopus tentationum, et quomodo in iis versandum. XIII. Dictorum repetitio.","english":"The unfruitful branches began to be, and were cut off. If they do not remain in unbelief, they will be grafted in again. Hear these things, brothers, with fear, lest you become proud; with love, that you may also pray for them. Turned to the Lord, etc.\n\nSERMON XX.\n\nOn the words of Psalm 38, verses 1-5. I said: I will guard my ways, etc.\n\nSYNOPSIS.\n\nI. Solicitude for daily progress, and thence the imploring of divine aid. II. The use of the tongue, as necessary as it is dangerous. III. The tongue is ruled by the mind. IV. The deceitful tongue of the Jews confounded. V. The good use of the tongue in the adulterous woman. VI. The adulteress's confession is an instruction for us. VII. How one must deal with a reviler. VIII. Revilers must be forgiven, and prayed for. IX. Inquiry is made into the end of man. X. The end of man is Christ. XI. By faith and works this end is attained. XII. The aim of temptations, and how one must conduct oneself in them. XIII. Repetition of the sayings.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":173,"ref":"p173","source":"Christianorum est, quotidie in Deum proficere, et de Deo, vel de donis ejus semper gaudere. Peregrinationis enim nostrae tempus brevissimum est, et patria nostra sine tempore est. Inter aeternitatem enim et tempus multum distat. Hic conquiritur pietas, illic requiescitur, Inde quotidianis diebus. quasi boni negotiatores, noverimus, quid profecerimus Non tantum enim studiosi esse debemus in audiendo, sed vigilantes in operando. Haec schola, in qua Deus solus magister est, bonos quaerit discipulos, non fugitivos, sed studiosos. Apostolus dicit: Studio non pigri, spiritu ferventes, spe gaudentes (Rom. xii, 11). In hac ergo schola, fratres, quotidie discimus. Aliud discimus in praeceptis, aliud in exemplis, aliud in sacramentis. Sunt ista medicamenta vulnerum nostrorum, et fomenta studiorum nostrorum. Modo respondimus: Exaudi orationem meam, et precem meam, Domine! Inaurire, hoc est: Auribus percipe lacrymas meas (Psal. xxxviii, 13). Quid putas, iste petiturus est, qui primo s(??)bimet Deum cupit propitium esse? Quid ab illo expetiturus est? Videamus, discamus. Forte divitias petiturus, forte in hac vita aliquam felicitatem? Dicat ergo nobis, quid petiturus est, qui primo Deum deprecatur. Vidit enim, quod ex se habere non potuit, sed a Deo habere potuit. Audierat emm: Petite, et accipietis (Joan. xvi, 24). Noverat ergo, quid esset petiturus, qui primo Deum rogavit.","english":"It is the mark of Christians to advance daily toward God and always to rejoice in God and in his gifts. For the time of our pilgrimage is very brief, and our homeland is without time. For there is a great distance between eternity and time. Here godliness is sought, there rest is found. Hence, like good merchants, let us know from day to day what we have gained. For we ought not only to be eager in hearing, but watchful in working. This school, in which God alone is the teacher, seeks good disciples—not runaways, but eager ones. The Apostle says: Not slothful in zeal, fervent in spirit, rejoicing in hope (Rom 12:11). In this school, then, brothers, we learn daily. We learn one thing in precepts, another in examples, another in sacraments. These are the medicines for our wounds and the encouragements of our studies. Just now we have responded: Hear my prayer and my supplication, O Lord! To give ear means: With your ears perceive my tears (Ps 38:13). What do you think—is this man about to ask for something, he who first desires that God be favorable to him? What is he going to seek from him? Let us see, let us learn. Perhaps he is about to ask for riches, perhaps for some happiness in this life? So let him tell us what he is about to ask for, he who first entreats God. For he saw what he could not have from himself, but could have from God. He had heard: Ask, and you shall receive (Jn 16:24). He knew, then, what he was about to ask for, he who first asked God.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":174,"ref":"p174","source":"Ergo Exaudi, Deus, orationem meam! Et quasi interrogatus: Quid vis, quid pulsas, quid clamas, quid interpellas? Audiam. Quid vis? Quid volo? ait. Audi voluntatem meam, et perfice opera tua. Quae est voluntas mea? Dixi; Custodiam vias meas, ut non delinquam in lingua mea (Psal, xxxviii, 1). Arduam rem iste disponit, sed non dubitat, quoniam primo Dominum deprecatus est. Noverat enim magisterium Pauli: Non ego, sed gratia Dei mecum (1 Cor. xv, 10).\n\nDixi ergo: Custodiam vias meas. Quas vias? Terrenas. Numquid per linguam ambulamus in terra? Aut pedibus nostris in terra ambulamus, aut pedibus alienis. Aut animalibus vehimur, aut pedibus nostris imus. Quid est ergo? Quam iste viam quaerit? Ne delinquat in lingua sua. Magna doctrina, videte, fratres. Numquid enim, quemadmodum una hora possumus cibum accipere, et refecti recedere, sic possumus momento uno loqui etiam, et silere? Quemadmodum enim habemus oculos ad vivendum, aures ad audiendum, caeterosque sensus ad percipiendum, sic iterum linguam ad loquendum. Est nobis magna necessitas linguae. Aut aliquid auditurus es, ut respondeas, aut aliquid dicturus es, ut doceas. Numquid oculo dicturus, et non lingua? Et si aure auditurus es, lingua responsurus es. Quid facimus de tam utili membro?","english":"Therefore hear, O God, my prayer! And as if he were asked: What do you want, why do you knock, why do you cry out, why do you plead? I will listen. What do you want? What do I want? he says. Hear my will, and accomplish your works. What is my will? I have said: I will keep my ways, that I may not sin with my tongue (Ps. 38:1). This man undertakes a difficult matter, but he does not doubt, because he first prayed to the Lord. For he knew the teaching of Paul: Not I, but the grace of God with me (1 Cor. 15:10).\n\nI have said, therefore: I will keep my ways. Which ways? Earthly ones. Do we walk on the earth by means of the tongue? Or do we walk on the earth with our own feet, or with another's feet? Either we ride on animals, or we go on our own feet. What then is this? What way is this man seeking? That he not sin with his tongue. A great teaching—see, brothers. For can we, in the way we can take food in one hour and, refreshed, depart, likewise in a single moment both speak and be silent? For just as we have eyes for living, ears for hearing, and the other senses for perceiving, so again we have the tongue for speaking. We have a great need of the tongue. Either you are going to hear something, so that you may respond, or you are going to say something, so that you may teach. Will you speak to the eye, and not with the tongue? And if you are going to hear with the ear, you will respond with the tongue. What are we to do about so useful a member?","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":175,"ref":"p175","source":"Inde Deum rogamus, inde satisfacimus, inde laudes dicimus, inde una voce concinentes Deo cantamus, inde quotidianis diebus aut misericordes efficimur, cum aliis loquimur, aut consilia damus. Quid facimus nunc? Ipsa lingua nostra vobis ministerium exhibet. Quid facimus, ut non delinquamus in lingua, maxime cum dictum sit: Mors et vita in manibus linguae (Prov. xviii, 21). Et iterum dictum sit: Multos vidi cadentes per casum gladii, sed non sic, quomodo qui ceciderunt per linguam (Eccli. xxviii, 22)? Iterum dictum est: Et lingua in membris nostris constituitur, quae maculat totum corpus nostrum (Jacob. iii, 6). Inde iterum idem Dominus: Docuerunt linguam suam loqui mendacium (Jerem. ix, 5). O docuerunt! Facit enim consuetudinem loqui mendacium. Etiam, si non vis, illa loquitur mendacium. Quemadmodum enim, si rotam volvas semel (Jacob. iii, 6), jam, ut manu impuleris, illa ipsa figura et rotunditate, vel ipso instabili, et quasi naturali cursu currit, sic et lingua nostra, opus est ut non doceatur loqui mendacium; jam enim ultro sponte currit ad id, ad quod facilius potest moveri. Aliud habes in corde, aliud illa aliquando volvit ex more. Quid facturus es? Quae, videtis, fratres! quae statera cordis facienda est, ut lingua aliquid proferat! Neque enim sponte movetur. Intus est, qui movet.","english":"From this we ask God, from this we give satisfaction, from this we speak praises, from this we sing to God with one voice in harmony, from this on our daily rounds we either become merciful when we speak with others or give counsel. What are we doing now? Our very tongue is performing a service for you. What are we doing, that we may not sin with the tongue, especially since it has been said: Death and life are in the hands of the tongue (Prov. 18:21). And again it has been said: I have seen many falling by the fall of the sword, but not as those who have fallen by the tongue (Sir. 28:22)? Again it has been said: And the tongue is set among our members, which stains our whole body (James 3:6). Hence again the same Lord: They have taught their tongue to speak a lie (Jer. 9:5). O, they have taught it! For it creates a habit of speaking a lie. Indeed, even if you do not wish it, it speaks a lie. For just as, if you turn a wheel once (James 3:6), then, as soon as you have pushed it with your hand, it runs by that very shape and roundness, or by that very instability and, as it were, natural course, so too our tongue—there is need that it not be taught to speak a lie; for already of its own accord it runs toward that to which it can more easily be moved. You have one thing in your heart, and at times it rolls out another from habit. What are you going to do? What—you see, brothers!—what scales of the heart must be made, so that the tongue may bring forth something! For it is not moved of its own accord. There is one within who moves it.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":176,"ref":"p176","source":"Est enim quaedam vis, quae se, et caetera ministeria sua movet. Opus est, ut bonus sit ille, qui regit, et quamlibet malam consuetudinem adjutus per gratiam vincit. Bonus sit minister, et quiescit ministerium. Miles habet arma, sed si non ferierit, nihil faciunt arma. Sic et lingua in membris nostris arma animae nostrae sunt. De ipsa dictum est: Inquietum malum (Jacob. iii. 8). O inquietum! Quis fecit istud malum, nisi inquietus? Tu noli esse inquietus, et non est hoc malum. Tu noli agitare, et non est, quae se agitet. Neque enim animus est, ut moveatur; Corpus est enim. Jacet. Noli movere, et non movetur. Vide autem, quomodo moves. Ipsa est illa, de qua multi fraudibus studentes, et avaritiae servientes, cum coeperint de negotiis aliquid agere, ejiciunt membrum factum ad laudem Dei, et ibi blasphemant Deum, et dicunt: Per Christum! tantum emi, tantum vendo. Quando interrogavi te: Jura mihi, quantum vendis? Ego te interrogavi: quantum vendis? Decem follibus vendo, viginti follibus. Per Christum juras? Per oculos tuos jura, per filios tuos jura, et ipsa hora contremiscit conscientia. O impietas linguae! Creatorem contempsisti, creaturam custodisti. O inquietum malum, plena veneni mortiferi! In ipsa benedicimus Deum, et Patrem. Deum propter naturam, Patrem propter gratiam. Et in ipsa maledicimus hominem, qui factus est ad imaginem Dei (Jacob. iii, 8, 9).","english":"For there is a certain power that moves itself and its other ministries. It is necessary that the one who rules be good, and that he conquer any evil habit whatsoever, aided by grace. Let the minister be good, and the ministry is at rest. A soldier has weapons, but if he does not strike, the weapons do nothing. So too the tongue in our members is the weapon of our soul. Of it it was said: An restless evil (Jas 3:8). O restless one! Who made this evil, except the restless one? Do not be restless, and this evil is not. Do not agitate, and there is nothing that agitates itself. For it is not the mind that is moved; for it is the body. It lies still. Do not move it, and it is not moved. But see how you move. This is that very thing, about which many, eager for frauds and enslaved to avarice, when they have begun to conduct some business, cast out the member made for the praise of God, and there blaspheme God, and say: By Christ! I bought for so much, I sell for so much. When I asked you: Swear to me, for how much do you sell? I asked you: for how much do you sell? I sell for ten bags, for twenty bags. Do you swear by Christ? Swear by your eyes, swear by your children, and at that very moment the conscience trembles. O the impiety of the tongue! You despised the Creator, you guarded the creature. O restless evil, full of deadly poison! With it we bless God, even the Father. God on account of nature, the Father on account of grace. And with it we curse the man who was made in the image of God (Jas 3:8-9).","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":177,"ref":"p177","source":"Attendite, fratres, quid portetis! Ecce dico, quid portemus. Et ego enim vobiscum homo sum. Sed recurramus.\n\nExaudi, Deus, orationem meam. Inde sunt illi Judaei, quos modo in Evangelio legimus. Utique lingua illos perduxit ad mortem. Modo enim in Evangelio audivimus. Adduxerunt, inquit, Judaei quamdam mulierem licet meretricem ad Dominum, tentantes illum, ei dicentes: Magister, haec mulier modo comprehensa est in adulterio (Joan. viii, 4). In lege Moysis scriptum est, ut quaecumque fuerit in adulterio comprehensa, lapidetur. Tu quid dicis? Hoc lingua dicebat, sed creatorem non agnoscebat. Nolebant isti orare, ut dicerent: Eripe animam meam a lingua dolosa (Psal. cxix, 2). Dolose enim accesserant, hoc enim volebant agere. Venerat enim Dominus: Non legem solvere, sed implere (Matth. v, 17), et peccata dimittere. Dixerunt ergo apud se Judaei: Si dixerit: Lapidetur! dicemus ei: Ubi est, quod peccata dimittis? Non tu es, qui dicis: Donata sunt tibi peccata tua (Id. ix, 5; Marc, ii, 5-9; Luc, v, 23)? Si dixerit: Dimittatur! dicemus: Ubi est, quod legem venisti adimplere, non solvere? Videte linguam dolosam ad Deum. Ille, qui venerat redemptor, non damnator (venerat enim redimere, quod perierat (Matth. xiii, 11) aversus est ab ipsis, quasi conspicere eos nolens. Non vacat aversio ista ab ipsis. Intelligitur aliquid in hac aversione. Quaesi diceret: Peccatricem mihi adducitis.","english":"Attend, brothers, to what you carry! Behold, I say what we carry. For I too am a man with you. But let us return.\n\nHear, O God, my prayer. From that comes those Jews whom we have just read of in the Gospel. Indeed, the tongue led them to death. For we have just heard in the Gospel. The Jews brought, it says, a certain woman, a harlot indeed, to the Lord, testing him, saying to him: Master, this woman has just been caught in adultery. In the law of Moses it is written that whoever is caught in adultery shall be stoned. What do you say? This the tongue said, but it did not acknowledge the Creator. They did not want to pray, so as to say: Deliver my soul from a deceitful tongue. For they had come deceitfully, for they wanted to do this. For the Lord had come: Not to destroy the law, but to fulfill it, and to forgive sins. The Jews therefore said among themselves: If he says, Let her be stoned! we will say to him: Where is it, that you forgive sins? Are you not the one who says: Your sins are forgiven you? If he says, Let her be released! we will say: Where is it, that you came to fulfill the law, not to destroy it? See the deceitful tongue against God. He who had come as redeemer, not as condemner (for he had come to redeem what had perished), turned away from them, as if unwilling to look at them. That turning away from them is not without purpose. Something is understood in this turning away. As if he were saying: You bring a sinful woman to me.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":178,"ref":"p178","source":"Peccatores! Si putatis, quia damnare debeo peccata, a vobis incipio. Et ipse, qui venerat donare peccata, ait: Qui se scit vestrum sine peccato esse, prior in illam lapidem mittat (Joan. viii, 7). O responsio, vel propositio! Si mittere voluissent lapidem in peccatricem, ipsa hora iterum recitaretur: In quo judicio judicaveritis, judicabitur de vobis (Matth. vii, 2). Damnastis, damnabimini. Illi tamen, etsi creatorem non agnoscebant, conscientiam suam sciebant. Ponentes invicem faciem post faciem, ut nec ipsi se propter confusionem videre vellent, a senioribus (hoc dixit Evangelista) usque ad minores omnes egressi sunt. Dixerat enim Spiritus sanctus: Omnes declinaverunt, simul inutiles facti sunt. Non est, qui faciat bonum, non est usque ad unum (Psal. xiii, 3).\n\nEt exierunt omnes. Remansit solus, et sola. Remansit creator, et creatura; remansit misera, et misericordia; remansit, qui suum reatum agnoscebat, et qui peccatum dimittebat. Nam ipsum est, quod conversus scribebat in terra. Scripsit enim in terra. Quando enim peccavit homo, dictum est ei: Terra es (Gen. iii, 19). Peccatrici ergo cum daret indulgentiam, dans scribebat in terra. Indulgentiam dabat, sed, cum daret indulgentiam, erigens faciem suam ad illam: Nemo ait, te condemnavit? Et illa non dixit: Quare? quid feci? Domine! Numquid enim rea sum? Non hoc dicit; sed ait: Nemo, Domine! Semetipsam accusavit.","english":"Sinners! If you think that I must condemn sins, I begin with you. Even he who had come to forgive sins said: Let the one among you who knows himself to be without sin be the first to throw a stone at her (John 8:7). O what a reply, or rather a challenge! If they had wished to throw a stone at the sinful woman, that very hour would be recited again: With the judgment you judge, you will be judged (Matthew 7:2). You have condemned; you will be condemned. Yet those men, even though they did not acknowledge the Creator, knew their own conscience. Setting face against face in turn, so that they did not even wish to see each other for shame, from the elders (so the Evangelist said) down to the least, they all went out. For the Holy Spirit had said: All have turned aside, together they have become useless. There is none who does good, there is not even one (Psalm 13:3).\n\nAnd they all went out. He remained alone, and she alone. The Creator remained, and the creature; the wretched woman remained, and mercy; he remained who acknowledged his own guilt, and he who forgave the sin. For this is what he was doing when he turned and wrote on the ground. For he wrote on the ground. For when man sinned, it was said to him: Earth you are (Genesis 3:19). Therefore, when he granted pardon to the sinful woman, he was writing on the ground as he gave it. He was giving pardon, but while giving pardon, lifting his face to her: Has no one, he said, condemned you? And she did not say: Why? What have I done, Lord? Am I indeed guilty? She does not say this; but she said: No one, Lord! She accused herself.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":179,"ref":"p179","source":"Probare illi non potuerunt, subduxerunt se. Sed illa confessa est cujus Dominus non reatum nesciebat, sed ejus fidem atque confessionem quaerebat. Nemo te condemnavit? At illa: Nemo, Domine! Et Nemo propter confessionem peccatorum, et Domine! propter indulgentiam meritorum. Nemo, Domine! Utrumque agnosco. Qui sis, novi. Quae sim, novi. Tibi enim confiteor. Audivi enim: Confitemini Domino, quoniam bonus est (Psal. cv, 1). Novi confessionem meam, novi misericordiam tuam. Ista dixit: Custodiam vias meas, ut non delinquam in lingua mea. Illi deliquerunt dolose agendo; ista magis se absolvit confitendo. Nemo te condemnarit? Illa inquit: Nemo. Et tacens ille iterum scribit. Bis scripsit. Hoc audiamus! Bis scripsit: semel indulgentiam dando, iterum praecepta renovando. Utrumque enim fit, cum indulgentiam accipimus. Subscripsit Imperator. Cum iterum Forma procedit, quasi iterum alia praecepta dantur. Ipsa sunt, per quae primo in Apostolo audivimus charitatem illam imperatam. Primo enim ipsam lectionem audivimus; inde hoc ipse Dominus dixit: Diliges Dominum Deum tuum de toto corde tuo, et de tota anima tua, et de tota virtute tua, et diliges proximum tibi tanquam te ipsum. In his duobus praeceptis tota Lex pendet, et Prophetae (Matth. xxii, 37-40).","english":"They could not prove their case against him; they withdrew. But she confessed—she whose Lord did not need to be told of her guilt, but was seeking her faith and her confession. \"Has no one condemned you?\" And she said: \"No one, Lord.\" \"No one\"—because of the confession of her sins; and \"Lord\"—because of the granting of forgiveness. \"No one, Lord!\" I acknowledge both. Who you are, I know. What I am, I know. For I confess to you. For I have heard: Confess to the Lord, for he is good (Ps. 105:1). I know my confession; I know your mercy. She said this: I will guard my ways, that I may not sin with my tongue. They sinned by acting deceitfully; she rather absolved herself by confessing. \"Has no one condemned you?\" She said: \"No one.\" And he, silent, writes again. He wrote twice. Let us hear this! He wrote twice: once by granting forgiveness, again by renewing the commandments. For both things happen when we receive forgiveness. The Emperor has signed beneath. When the Form comes forth again, it is as if other commandments are given again. These are the very ones through which we first heard that love commanded in the Apostle. For first we heard the reading itself; then the Lord himself said this: You shall love the Lord your God with your whole heart, and with your whole soul, and with your whole strength, and you shall love your neighbor as yourself. On these two commandments the whole Law hangs, and the Prophets (Matt. 22:37-40).","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":180,"ref":"p180","source":"Ne aliquis nostrum laboraret, duo quaedam sunt dicta: Deus et Proximus, qui te fecit, et, cum quo te fecit. Nemo tibi dixit: Dilige solem, dilige In · nam, dilige terram, et quaecumque facta sunt. In his laudandus est Deus, benedicendus est Factor. Quam magnificata sunt opera tua! dicimus. Omnia in sapientia fecisti (Psal. ciii, 24). Tua sunt. Tu fecisti omnia. Gratias tibi! Sed nos fecisti super omnia. Gratias tibi! Sumus enim imago et similitudo tua. Gratias tibi! Peccavimus. Quaesiti sumus! Gratias tibi!. Ne gleximus. Non sumus neglecti. Gratias tibi! Cum nos te contemneremus, non sumus contempti. Ne Divinitatem tuam obliti fuissemus, et te amitteremus, tu etiam nostram humanitatem suscepisti. Gratias tibi! Ubi non gratias? Dixi ergo: Custodiam vias meas, ut non delinquam in lingua mea. Illa enim mulier, cum offerretur causa adulterii, accepit indulgentiam, liberata est, onerosum nobis est, quoniam per baptismum, per confessionem, per gratiam accipiunt omnes omnium peccatorum suorum indulgentiam? Sed nemo nunc dicat: Illa accepit indulgentiam; ego adhuc Catechumenus sum. Faciam adulteria, quoniam accepturus sum indulgentiam. Pone et me unum esse, quemadmodum illa mulier confessa est, et liberata est. Deus noster bonus est, et, si peccavero, confiteor illi, et dimittet mihi. Bonitatem ipsius attendis, sed justitiam ejus considera.","english":"Lest any one of us should struggle, two things have been spoken: God and neighbor—the one who made you, and the one with whom he made you. No one has said to you: Love the sun, love the moon, love the earth, and whatever things have been made. In these God is to be praised, the Maker is to be blessed. \"How magnificent are your works!\" we say. \"You have made all things in wisdom.\" They are yours. You have made all things. Thanks be to you! But you made us above all things. Thanks be to you! For we are your image and likeness. Thanks be to you! We have sinned. We have been sought out! Thanks be to you! We have been neglected—no, we have not been neglected. Thanks be to you! When we were despising you, we were not despised. Lest we should have forgotten your Divinity and lost you, you also took up our humanity. Thanks be to you! Where are there not thanks? I said therefore: I will guard my ways, that I may not sin with my tongue. For that woman, when the charge of adultery was brought against her, received pardon and was set free—is it burdensome to us that through baptism, through confession, through grace all receive pardon of all their sins? But let no one now say: That woman received pardon; I am still a catechumen. I will commit adulteries, since I am going to receive pardon. Suppose me to be one such as that woman was: she confessed, and was set free. Our God is good, and if I have sinned, I confess to him, and he will forgive me. You consider his goodness, but consider his justice.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":181,"ref":"p181","source":"Quomodo bonitatem ad indulgentiam, sic justitiam ad poenam. Dixi ergo: Custodiam vias meas, ut non delinquam in lingua mea. Vellem scire, si in hoc tempore, quo sermonem Vestrae Charitati ministramus, nemo delinquat in lingua sua. In hoc tempore, quo hic sumus, forte nemo nostrum aliquid locutus est mali, sed forte cogitavit aliquid mali. Attendite. Dixi: Custodiam vias meas, ut non delinquam in lingua mea. Dic vere: Posui ori meo custodiam, dum consistit peccator adversus me (Psal. xxxviii, 2).\n\nAttendite. Posui ori meo custodiam, dum consistit peccator adversus me. Stat adversus te aliquis Improbus, conviciatur tibi, dicit, quae nescis. Tu pone ori tuo custodiam. Dixi: Custodiam vias meas, ut non delinquam in lingua mea. Dicat ille, tu audi, et tace. Duae enim res sunt, aut verum dicit, aut falsum. Si verum dicit, tu fecisti, ut diceret, et forte hoc misericordia est. Cum enim tu non vis audire, quod fecisti, Deus, qui curam tui gerit, per aliquem tibi dicit, quod fecisti, ut vel ipso pudore confusus aliquando ad medicinam recurras. Noli ergo rependere malum pro malo; nescis enim, qui tibi per ipsum loquatur. Ergo, si aliquid dicit, quod fecisti, agnosce te misericordiam consecutum, ut aut oblitum te putes, aut ad confusionem tuam hoc dictum esse judices. Si non fecisti, libera est conscientia. Quid quaeris? Quid irasceris de eo, quod non fecisti?","english":"Just as goodness relates to pardon, so justice relates to punishment. I said therefore: I will keep my ways, that I may not sin with my tongue. I would like to know whether in this present time, in which we minister the word to Your Charity, no one sins with his tongue. In this time in which we are here, perhaps none of us has spoken anything evil, but perhaps he has thought something evil. Pay attention. I said: I will keep my ways, that I may not sin with my tongue. Speak truly: I have set a guard on my mouth, while the sinner stands against me.\n\nPay attention. I have set a guard on my mouth, while the sinner stands against me. Some wicked man stands against you, heaps insults on you, says things you do not know. You, set a guard on your mouth. I said: I will keep my ways, that I may not sin with my tongue. Let him speak, you listen and be silent. For there are two possibilities: either he speaks the truth, or he speaks falsehood. If he speaks the truth, you have acted so that he should say it, and perhaps this is mercy. For since you do not wish to hear what you have done, God, who takes care of you, says to you through someone what you have done, so that, put to shame even by that very shame, you may at some point run back to the medicine. Do not therefore repay evil for evil; for you do not know who it is that speaks to you through him. Therefore, if he says something that you have done, acknowledge that you have received mercy, so that you may either think yourself forgotten, or judge that this was said for your confusion. If you did not do it, your conscience is free. What are you looking for? Why are you angry about what you did not do?","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":182,"ref":"p182","source":"Quid enim ait tibi: Furi Ebriose? Cito tu re· curre intus ad secreta conscientiae. Vide te intus. Judex esto, discussor tui esto. Quaere ibi. Ubi putas, posui peccata mea, quae feci? Aut, si non sunt, dic: Non feci. Si: Non feci, dicit tibi conscientia tua, dic: Gloria nostra haec est, testimonium conscientiae nostrae (2 Cor. i, 12). Dixit tibi haec conscientia tua, tace, dole illum dicentem tibi. Dic etiam tu Deo: Pater, ignosce illi, quia nescit quid dicat. Roga pro illo Deum. Dixi: Custodiam vias meas, ut non delinquam in lingua mea. Posui ori meo custodiam, dum consistit peccator adversus me. Noli enim putare, quia tunc videris sanctus, si nemo te tentet. Tunc es sanctus, quando aliquo convicio non moveris, quando doles dicentem, quando non curas quod pateris, sed tamen doles eum, a quo pateris. Ibi est omnis misericordia. Doles, quoniam et ille frater tuus est, membrum tuum est. Insanit adversum te, phreneticus est, aegrotat. Dole illum. Noli gaudere; tantummodo de conscientiae tuae securitate gaude; inde dole. Homo es enim; vide, ne et tu tenteris. Dictum est enim: Onera vestra portate, et sic adimplebitis legem Christi (Galat, vi, 2). Modo, cum dicit, tace; postea, cum quieverit, dic ei: Frater, per salutem tuam, quare mihi dixisti, quod non feci? Peccasti in me, rogo Deum pro te.","english":"For what does he say to you: “Thief, Drunkard”? Hurry, then, run back within to the secrets of your conscience. Look within yourself. Be your own judge, be your own examiner. Search there. Where do you think I have placed my sins, which I have committed? Or, if they are not there, say: “I did not commit them.” If you say, “I did not commit them,” your conscience says to you, say: “This is our glory, the testimony of our conscience” (2 Cor 1:12). If your conscience has said this to you, be silent, grieve for him who says these things to you. Say also to God: “Father, forgive him, for he does not know what he is saying.” Pray to God for him. I said: I will keep my ways, that I may not sin with my tongue. I set a guard on my mouth, while the sinner stands against me. For do not think that you then appear holy if no one tempts you. You are holy then, when you are not moved by some insult, when you grieve for the one who speaks against you, when you do not care about what you suffer, but nevertheless grieve for him by whom you suffer. There is all mercy. You grieve because he too is your brother, he is your member. He rages against you, he is mad, he is sick. Grieve for him. Do not rejoice; rejoice only in the security of your conscience; grieve from that point. For you are a man; see that you are not also tempted. For it has been said: Bear your burdens, and so you will fulfill the law of Christ (Gal 6:2). For now, when he speaks, be silent; later, when he has quieted down, say to him: “Brother, by your salvation, why did you say to me what I did not do? You have sinned against me; I pray God for you.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":183,"ref":"p183","source":"Ego tibi quidem veniam do, et rogo pro te Deum meum, cui fecisti injuriam, cum in me peccasti. Noli ulterius facere, noli superbire! Non dico: Redde illi, Deus, qui dixit mihi, quod non feci. Nolo hoc dicere. Posui ori meo custodiam, dum consistit peccator adversus me.\n\nObsurdui et humiliatus sum (hoc sequitur) et tacui a bonis (Psal. xxxviii, 3). Obsurdui. Non illum audivi dicentem. Iste animus quantum profecit, qui etiam intus in fratris errore, et conscientia? suae securitate gaudens, quod foris latretur, nescit! Qualis ista anima est, quam secura, quam gaudens! Ista est, quae dicit Deo: Ambulabam in innocentia cordis mei, in medio domus tuae (Id. c, 2). Fores effractores pulsabant, sed idonea erat domus. Obsurdui et humiliatus sum, non adversus illum superbus extiti. Et humiliatus silui a bonis; nec enim temporis erat, ut aliquid boni dixissem. Tempus est enim, ut taceas modo, posteaquam ille sinceraverit, loquere, tunc intelliget. Plerumque filii aegrotantes patres suos caeciderunt, tamen illi propter infirmitatem filiorum et vapulabant, et plorabant. Quem affectum adhibent filiis homines, ne moriantur, expectantes salutem filiorum! Sed: Non est filius meus, ais? Sed est opus Dei, imago Dei, filius Dei. Si contemnis, quia non est filius tuus, noli contemnere, quia filius Dei est, frater tuus est.","english":"I indeed give you pardon, and I beseech my God for you, whom you have wronged when you sinned against me. Do not do so any further, do not be proud! I do not say: \"Repay him, O God, who said to me what I did not do.\" I do not wish to say this. I have set a guard upon my mouth, while the sinner stands against me.\n\nI was deaf and was humbled (this follows) and I was silent from good things (Ps. 38:3). I was deaf. I did not hear him speaking. How much has this soul advanced, which even inwardly, in the error of a brother, and rejoicing in the security of its own conscience, does not know that he barks outside! What kind of soul is this, how secure, how rejoicing! This is she who says to God: I walked in the innocence of my heart, in the midst of your house (Id. 100:2). Burglars were knocking at the doors, but the house was sound. I was deaf and was humbled; I was not proud against him. And being humbled I was silent from good things; for there was no time in which I might have said something good. For it is a time for you to be silent now; after he has been healed, speak, then he will understand. Often sick sons have struck their fathers, yet they, on account of the weakness of their sons, both were beaten and wept. What affection do men show to their sons, lest they die, awaiting the salvation of their sons! But: \"He is not my son,\" you say? But he is the work of God, the image of God, the son of God. If you despise him because he is not your son, do not despise him, because he is the son of God, he is your brother.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":184,"ref":"p184","source":"Ergo Obsurdui, et humiliatus sum: Non superbivi, sed Silui a bonis, et dolor meus renovatus est, non de me, sed de ipso, quia non feci, quod dixit. Habui dolorem, sed, quia ita dixit, habui dolorem. Fratris enim mei curam gerens renovatus est in me dolor. Ista est via. Hoc enim fecit ipse Dominus Pater noster, qui etiam ipse Sponsus dictus est. Non jejunabunt filii Sponsi, ait, quousque cum ipsis est Sponsus (Luc. v, 34). Vapulavit a phreneticis filiis, occiderunt illum phrenetici filii. Rogavit pro illis. Postea sinceraverunt, agnoverunt et crediderunt, et, qui noluerunt curari per medicum, curati sunt per discipulum medici; per Petrum enim curati sunt. Cum enim illos Petrus increparet, aiunt: Quid faciemus? Ait tunc Petrus: Poenitemini, et baptizetur unusquisque vestrum in nomine Domini Jesu Christi (Act. ii, 38). Modo furebant, modo credebant. Videtis, quid facit infirmitas, et sanitas. Quando infirmi fuerunt, tolerati sunt, quando salvi facti sunt, redempti sunt. Inde et nos, fratres quotiescumque talia patimur, taceamus, quo illa teneamus: Aut verum dicit, aut falsum. Etsi non dixerit, et feci, quid? Quia non dicit, et ego feci, optandum est, ut dicat, ut ego confundar, quia feci. Ista misericordia Dei est. Si autem hoc dicit, quod non feci, gaudeam de mea securitate, doleam de fratris infirmitate. Caluit cor meum intra me (Psal.","english":"Therefore I was deaf and humbled: I was not proud, but I was silent from good things, and my sorrow was renewed—not for myself, but for him, because I did not do what he said. I had sorrow, but because he said it, I had sorrow. For bearing care for my brother, sorrow was renewed in me. This is the way. For our Lord the Father himself did this, who is also himself called the Bridegroom. The sons of the Bridegroom shall not fast, he says, as long as the Bridegroom is with them (Luke 5:34). He was beaten by frenzied sons, frenzied sons killed him. He prayed for them. Afterwards they were made whole, they recognized and believed, and those who were unwilling to be healed by the physician were healed by the physician's disciple; for they were healed through Peter. For when Peter rebuked them, they say: What shall we do? Then Peter says: Repent, and let each one of you be baptized in the name of the Lord Jesus Christ (Acts 2:38). Just now they were raging, just now they were believing. You see what infirmity does, and what health does. When they were sick, they were tolerated; when they were made whole, they were redeemed. Hence we also, brothers, as often as we suffer such things, let us be silent, so that we may hold to this: Either he speaks the truth, or a falsehood. Even if he did not say it, and I did it, what then? Because he does not say it, and I did it, it is to be desired that he say it, so that I may be put to shame, because I did it. This is the mercy of God. But if he says this, which I did not do, let me rejoice in my security, let me grieve over my brother's infirmity. My heart grew hot within me (Ps.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":185,"ref":"p185","source":"xxxviii, 4), ferbuit cor meum intra me ex dilectione, quam habeo in fratrem, sed tempus loquendi non potui modo facere. Inde ipse Paulus dicit: Non potui loqui vobis quasi spiritualibus, sed quasi carnalibus (1 Cor. iii, 1). L oculus est tamen. Quomodo locutus est? Ergo Caluit cor meum intra me, et in meditatione mea exardescit ignis. Ignis est in me charitatis. Non habeo, cui dicam, quia infirmus est. Humiliem ergo me. Erit forte aliquando tempus, ut possim aliquid loqui. Tamen Dimitte nobis debita nostra, sicut et nos dimittimus debitoribus nostris (Matth. vi, 12). Dimittam illi, quod non habeo in conscientia. Parum est, quia nihil habeo in conscientia, sed rogem illum propter conscientiam.\n\nJam iste percurrerat: Dixi: Custodiam vias meas. Ponam ori meo custodiam. Humiliatus sum, et: In meditatione mea exardescit ignis. Nescio quid, subito educit hic aliud majus, et post tot certamina, magnosque labores, audite quid dicat. Locutus sum in lingua mea (Psal. xxxviii, 5). Est enim lingua animae motus ipsius voluntatis. Quemadmodum enim lingua motus est in corpore, sic voluntas motus est in anima. Ibi est prima lingua. Inde est, inde loquitur Deo. Haec enim lingua ministerium exhibet extra positis hominibus; illa autem lingua, quae est in motu voluntatis, ministerium exhibet intus manenti in templo suo. Ipsa est vera lingua.","english":"…my heart grew hot within me from the love I have for my brother, but I could not just now make a time for speaking. Hence Paul himself says: I could not speak to you as to spiritual men, but as to carnal men (1 Cor 3:1). He is an eye nonetheless. How did he speak? Therefore, My heart grew hot within me, and in my meditation a fire was kindled. The fire of charity is in me. I have no one to whom I may speak, because he is weak. Let me humble myself, then. Perhaps there will be a time when I can say something. Nevertheless, Forgive us our debts, as we also forgive our debtors (Mt 6:12). I will forgive him what I do not have on my conscience. It is a small thing that I have nothing on my conscience; but let me entreat him for the sake of conscience.\n\nAlready this man had run through: I said: I will guard my ways. I will set a guard on my mouth. I was humbled, and: In my meditation a fire was kindled. I know not what—suddenly he brings out here something else greater, and after so many struggles and great labors, hear what he says. I spoke with my tongue (Ps 38:5). For the tongue is the movement of the will itself in the soul. For just as the tongue is a movement in the body, so the will is a movement in the soul. There is the first tongue. From there, from there it speaks to God. For this tongue renders service to men placed outside; but that tongue, which is in the movement of the will, renders service within to him who remains in his temple. That is the true tongue.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[{"kind":"lacuna","severity":"caution","text":"The source is fragmentary here: the edition marks a break or an editorial bracket, and the English carries across it. Treat the bridge as supplied, not translated."}]},{"i":186,"ref":"p186","source":"Unde dixit Dominus, eos, qui adorant eum, In spiritu et veritate (Joan. iv, 23) adorare debere. Ipsa est vera lingua. Dixi in lingua mea: Notum mihi fac. Domine, finem meum, et numerum dierum meorum, qui sit, ut sciam, quid desit mihi (Psal. xxxviii, 5, 6). Si attendit Sanctitas Vestra, intelligat primo sententiam, et sic Dominus misericordia sua, qua saepe consuevit, dabit nobis orationibus vestris, ut possimus hanc discutere, quia satis est ardua. Locutus sum lingua mea. Notum mihi fac, Domine, finem meum, et numerum dierum meorum, qui sit, ut sciam, quid desit mihi. Vi· dete, quid oret. Notum mihi fac. Domine, finem meum. Finis est, fratres, ubi tendimus, ubi permansuri sumus. Quod exivimus de domibus nostris, finis nobis fuit ad Ecclesiam veniendi. Ergo iter nostrum hic finitum est. Hinc iterum unusquisque ad domum suam finem habet redeundi. Ibi finit, ubi tendebat. Modo ergo in hac peregrinatione constituti finem habemus, ubi tendimus. Ubi ergo tendimus? Ad patriam nostram. Quae est patria nostra? Jerusalem mater piorum, mater vivorum. Illic tendimus. Finis noster ipse est. Et quia viam nesciebamus. Ipse civis civitatis ipsius fecit se viam. Nesciebamus, qua ire. Anfractus, nescio qui, spinosi, lapidosi, omnino graves erant in via. Descendit huc ipse primus, qui est ibi principalis, descendit quaerens cives civitatis illius.","english":"Hence the Lord said that those who worship him must worship in spirit and in truth (John 4:23). That is the true tongue. I said in my tongue: Make known to me, Lord, my end, and the number of my days, what it is, that I may know what is lacking to me (Ps 38:5-6). If Your Holiness pays attention, let him first understand the meaning, and thus the Lord, by his mercy, as he has often been wont to do, will grant us, through your prayers, that we may be able to discuss this, for it is quite arduous. I have spoken in my tongue. Make known to me, Lord, my end, and the number of my days, what it is, that I may know what is lacking to me. See what he prays. Make known to me, Lord, my end. The end, brothers, is where we are heading, where we are to remain. That we set out from our homes was our end of coming to the Church. So our journey here has ended. From here each one again has as his end to return to his own home. He ends there where he was heading. Now, therefore, set in this pilgrimage, we have an end where we are heading. Where, then, are we heading? To our homeland. What is our homeland? Jerusalem, the mother of the godly, the mother of the living. It is there we are heading. Our end is that very place. And because we did not know the way, he who is a citizen of that city himself made himself the way. We did not know where to go. Certain winding paths, thorny, stony, altogether hard, were on the way. He himself, who is there the chief one, came down here first; he came down seeking citizens of that city.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":187,"ref":"p187","source":"Aberravimus enim, et, cum simus cives Jerusalem, facti sumus cives Babyloniae, facti sumus filii confusionis; Babylonia enim confusio est. Descendit huc quaerens cives suos, et factus est civis noster. Non noveramus civitatem istam, provinciam istam non noveramus. Sed, quia nos ad illam non venimus, descendit hac ad cives suos, et factus est ipse civis, non consentiendo, sed suscipiendo. Descendit huc. Quomodo descendit? In forma servi. Ambulavit hic inter nos Deus Homo. Si enim tantummodo Homo fuisset, ad Deum non perduxisset. Si tantummodo Deus fuisset, hominibus conjunctus non fuisset. Sus cepit nobiscum conditionis aequalitatem, habens cum Patre Divinitatem. Suscepit nobiscum temporalitatem, habens cum Patre aeternitatem. Hic nobiscum aequalis, ibi Patri aequalis. Descendit huc civis noster, et ait: Quid hic facitis? Cives Jerusalem! Imago et similitudo Dei non est erecta, nisi in Jerusalem. Statuae Dei in hac vita non ponuntur. Laboremus, redeamus! Qua redimus? Ecce substerno me vobis, fio vobis via, ero vobis finis. Imitemini me! Notum mihi fac, Domine, finem meum! Ipsum credimus, qui est finis noster.","english":"For we have wandered astray, and, though we are citizens of Jerusalem, we have become citizens of Babylonia, we have become children of confusion; for Babylonia is confusion. He descended here seeking his own citizens, and he became our citizen. We did not know that city, we did not know that province. But because we did not come to it, he descended here to his own citizens, and he himself became a citizen, not by consenting, but by taking on. He descended here. How did he descend? In the form of a servant. Here God walked among us as Man. For if he had been only Man, he would not have led us to God. If he had been only God, he would not have been joined to men. He took on with us an equality of condition, having Divinity with the Father. He took on with us temporality, having eternity with the Father. Here equal with us, there equal with the Father. Our citizen descended here, and said: What are you doing here? Citizens of Jerusalem! The image and likeness of God is not raised up except in Jerusalem. The statues of God are not set up in this life. Let us labor, let us return! How do we return? Behold, I lay myself beneath you, I become the way for you, I will be the end for you. Imitate me! Make known to me, Lord, my end! We believe in him himself, who is our end.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":188,"ref":"p188","source":"Deus Pater nunc loquitur. Ego dico tibi, o Anima, quam ego feci, o Homo, quem ego feci, ego dico tibi: Finieras. Quid finieras? Perieras. Misi tibi, qui te quaesisset; misi tibi, qui tecum ambularet; misi tibi, qui ignovisset. Inde ambulavit pedibus, ignovit manibus. Inde, quando post resurrectionem ascendit, manus, latus, et pedes ostendit: manus, unde indulgentiam dedit peccatorum; pedes, quibus pacem annuntiavit desertorum; latus, unde cucurrit pretium redemptorum. Finis ergo legis Christus ad justitiam omni credenti (Rom. x, 4). Notum mihi fac, Domine, finem meum. Jam factus est tibi notus finis tuus. Quomodo tibi notus factus est? Finis tuus pauper fuit, finis tuus humilis fuit, finis tuus alapis caesus est, finis tuus sputis oblitus est, adversus finem tuum falsum testimonium dictum est. Posui ori meo custodiam, dum consistit peccator adversum me. Ipse factus est tibi via. Qui dicit se in Christo manere, debet, quomodo ille ambulavit, et ipse ambulare (1 Joan. ii, 6). Est via. Modo ambulemus, non timeamus, ne aberremus. Foris a via non ambulemus; dictum est enim: Circa viam scandala posuerunt mihi, et circa viam muscipulam posuerunt mihi (Psal, cxxxix, 6). Et ecce illam misericordiam. Ne in muscipulam incidisses, ipsam mi(??)ricor(??)iam habes viam. Notum mihi fac, Domine, finem meum. Ecce habes finem. Christum redemptorem imitamini.","english":"God the Father now speaks. I say to you, O soul whom I made, O man whom I made, I say to you: you had reached your end. What end had you reached? You had perished. I sent you one who would seek you; I sent you one who would walk with you; I sent you one who would forgive you. Hence he walked on feet, he forgave with hands. Hence, when after the resurrection he ascended, he showed his hands, his side, and his feet: hands, by which he gave pardon for sins; feet, with which he announced peace to the desolate; side, from which flowed the price of the redeemed. Therefore the end of the law is Christ unto righteousness for everyone who believes (Rom 10:4). Make known to me, Lord, my end. Your end has now been made known to you. How has your end been made known to you? Your end was poor, your end was humble, your end was struck with blows, your end was defiled with spittle, false testimony was spoken against your end. I set a guard over my mouth, while the sinner stands against me. He himself has become the way for you. Whoever says he abides in Christ ought, just as he walked, himself also to walk (1 John 2:6). There is a way. Let us walk now, let us not fear that we may go astray. Let us not walk outside the way; for it has been said: Around the way they have set stumbling blocks for me, and around the way they have set a trap for me (Ps 139:6). And behold that mercy. Lest you fall into the trap, you have that very mercy as the way. Make known to me, Lord, my end. Behold, you have your end. Imitate Christ the redeemer.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":189,"ref":"p189","source":"Imitatores mei estote, sicut et ego Christi (Philipp. iii, 17). Paulus quomodo imitatus est Christum? Attendite, quid dixit. In fame, et siti, in frigore et nuditate, et caetera usque: Quis scandalizatur, et ego non uror (2 Cor. xi, 27-29)? Factus sum omnia omnibus, ut omnes lucrifacerem (1 Cor, ix, 22). Posui ori meo custodiam, dum consistit peccator adversum me. Quae sunt verba Pauli, fratres. Quis nos separabit a charitate Christi? Finem attende. Quis me separabit a charitate Christi? Tribulatio, an pressura, an persecutio, an nuditas, an periculum? (Rom, viii, 35.) O amantem, o ferventem, o currentem, o pervenientem Virum! Quid patiebatur haec anima, quomodo fervebat, quomodo docebat. Quis me separabit a charitate Christi? Angustia? et caetera usque: An gladius? Quid passus est iste. Et ne aliquis putaret, quia inde superbiebat, ait: Fratres, arbitror me non apprehendisse (Philipp, iii, 13).","english":"Be imitators of me, as I also am of Christ (Philippians 3:17). How did Paul imitate Christ? Attend to what he said. In hunger and thirst, in cold and nakedness, and the rest up to: Who is scandalized, and I do not burn (2 Corinthians 11:27-29)? I became all things to all men, that I might gain all (1 Corinthians 9:22). I set a guard on my mouth, while the sinner stood against me. These are the words of Paul, brothers. Who shall separate us from the love of Christ? Attend the end. Who shall separate me from the love of Christ? Tribulation, or distress, or persecution, or nakedness, or peril (Romans 8:35)? O loving man, O fervent man, O running man, O man who has reached the goal! What was this soul enduring, how was it burning, how was it teaching. Who shall separate me from the love of Christ? Anguish? and the rest up to: Or the sword? What this man suffered! And lest anyone should think that he was proud because of this, he said: Brothers, I consider that I have not yet apprehended (Philippians 3:13).","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":190,"ref":"p190","source":"Hoc ut quid: Notum mihi fac, Domine, finem meum, et numerum dierum meorum, qui sit: Quantum hic habeo vivere. Ut quid tibi, scire diem? Ut sciam. quid desit mihi: Quid desit, sed ad aeternitatem. Modo attende Paulum. Post tantos labores dinumeratos adhuc Me, ait, non arbitror apprehendisse. Audi dicentem: Quid desit mihi. Nemo ergo dicat: Jam multum jejunavi, multum laboravi, multum donavi. Jam omnia praecepta Dei feci. Heri feci, hodie feci, et adhuc hodie erit, si aliquando fecisti. Heri semper hodie habet. Ad crastinum si veneris, hodie habebit, et ad annos decem si veneris, hodie erit. Semper tu hodie dic: Quid desit mihi. Si enim Paulus in tantis laboribus miles coelestis, si enim ille post tantam exercitationem, et post tantas revelationes, raptus usque in tertium coelum, et audivit ineffabilia verba, et tamen, ne in revelationibus extolleretur, accepit stimulum carnis, qui illum humiliaret, quis est, qui dicere valeat(??): Sufficit? Inde ergo Notum fac mihi, Domine, finem meum. Et ecce habes ante te Christum finem. Non habes jam, quod quaeras. Cum jam credidisti, jam agnovisti. Sed non in fide tantum res est, sed in fide, et opere. Utrumque necessarium est. Nam et Daemones credunt (audistis Apostolum) et contremiscunt (Jacob, ii, 19); non autem prodest illis, quia credunt. Parum est fides sola, nisi et opera conjungantur.","english":"Why is this? Make known to me, Lord, my end, and the number of my days, what it is: how much I have left to live here. Why do you want to know the day? That I may know what is lacking to me: what is lacking—but with a view to eternity. Now attend to Paul. After so many labors numbered up, he still says, I do not think I have apprehended. Hear him saying: What is lacking to me. Let no one therefore say: I have already fasted much, labored much, given much. I have already fulfilled all the commandments of God. I did so yesterday, I do so today, and there will still be a today, if ever you have done so. Yesterday always has its today. If you come to tomorrow, it will have a today, and if you come to ten years from now, it will be today. Always say today: What is lacking to me. For if Paul, a soldier of heaven, amid such great labors—if he, after such great discipline and after such great revelations, caught up even to the third heaven, and heard ineffable words, and yet, lest he be exalted by the revelations, received a thorn in the flesh to humble him—who is there who can bring himself to say: It is enough? Hence therefore, Make known to me, Lord, my end. And behold, you have Christ before you as the end. You no longer have anything to seek. Since you have already believed, you have already come to know. But the matter is not in faith alone, but in faith and works. Both are necessary. For even the demons believe (you have heard the Apostle) and tremble (James 2:19); but it does them no good that they believe. Faith alone is too little unless works also be joined to it.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":191,"ref":"p191","source":"Fides, quae per dilectionem operatur (Galat, v, 6), ait Apostolus. Notum fac mihi, Domine, finem meum, et numerum dierum meorum, qui sit. Istud non dicitur, quia, si unusquisque nostrum sciret, quando moreretur, decerneret sibi verbi gratia, ut bene viveret. Inde ipse Magister volens nos sollicitos fieri interrogatur de die, et hora, et dicit: De die illa, et hora nemo scit. Nolebat enim, ut illi scirent. Inde dixit: Neque Filius (Marc, xiii, 32). Hoc est: non vobis expedit ut sciatis; eritis enim negligentes, non solliciti. Eo magis bene vivetis, cum solliciti fueritis, non, quia nescio diem, nam Omnia, quae habet Pater, mea sunt (Joan. xvi, 15). Notum mihi fac, Domine, finem meum, et numerum dierum meorum, qui sit. Notum fac mihi istud, ut semper sim sollicitus, quia nescio, quando veniet fur ut noverim, Quid desit mihi.\n\nIbi ergo, fratres, simus cauti, ut noverimus, quid desit nobis. Tentatio Christianorum probatio Christianorum est. Nam qui tentatur, ostenditur illi, quid illi desit. Duae res sunt. Aut ostenditur illi, quid habeat, aut ostenditur illi, quid desit. Tentatus est Abraham, non, ut ostenderetur illi, quid ille habuisset, sed ut ostenderetur nobis, quid imitaremur. Tentatus est autem in filio. Quae illa tentatio fuit? Optavit filium in aetate provecta, de quo jam desperabatur.","english":"Faith, which works through love, says the Apostle. Make known to me, Lord, my end, and the number of my days, what it is. This is not said because, if each one of us knew when he would die, he would decide for himself, for example, to live well. Hence the Master himself, wishing us to be anxious, is asked about the day and the hour, and says: Of that day and hour no one knows. For he did not wish them to know. Hence he said: Nor the Son. That is: it is not expedient for you to know; for you will be negligent, not anxious. You will live well all the more when you have been anxious—not because I do not know the day, for All things that the Father has are mine. Make known to me, Lord, my end, and the number of my days, what it is. Make this known to me, that I may always be anxious, because I do not know when the thief will come, so that I may know what is lacking to me.\n\nTherefore, brothers, let us be cautious there, so that we may know what is lacking to us. The temptation of Christians is the testing of Christians. For when one is tempted, it is shown to him what is lacking to him. There are two things. Either it is shown to him what he has, or it is shown to him what is lacking. Abraham was tempted, not so that it might be shown to him what he had, but so that it might be shown to us what we should imitate. But he was tempted in his son. What was that temptation? He had longed for a son in advanced age, one concerning whom hope was already being abandoned.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":192,"ref":"p192","source":"Tamen, dum promissionem Dei audivit, non haesitavit omnino, credidit, accepit; meruit, suscepit. Natus est, nutritus est, in aetatem perductus est, lactatus est, et dictum est ei: In semine tuo benedicentur omnes gentes (Gen. xxii, 18). Noverat ille, in quo semine. Habemus enim testimonium in Evangelio. Abraham concupivit diem meum, ait, videre; et vidit, et gavisus est (Joan. viii, 56). Noverat ergo. Post illa autem omnia, quae crediderat, audivit a Deo: Abraham, offer mihi filium tuum sacrificium. Tentatus est (Gen. xxii), Quare? Non noverat Deus fidem ipsius? Sed propter nos haec ostendere dignatus est. Nobis enim dicitur: Offer mihi sacrificium saccelli tui; et dubitamus. Quod sacrificium? Date eleemosynam, et ecce vobis munda sunt omnia (Luc. xi, 41). Et iterum: Misericordiam volo, quam sacrificium (Matth. ix, et xii, 7). Da aliquid de saccello tuo, dicitur tibi, et ligas. Quid si tibi juberetur de filio tuo? Ecce de saccello tuo sic dubitas, de filio tuo quid fecisses? Ut sciam, quid desit mihi. Dicturus sum non sine dolore et pudore. Pleraeque foeminae forte volunt Deo servire, et si audaces fuerint, dicunt parentibus: Dimitte me. Virgo Dei volo esse, aut servus Dei volo esse; et audiunt: Nec salva sis, nec salvus sis. Vere non facies, quod vis. Quod ego volo, hoc facies. Quid si diceretur tibi: Occide?","english":"Nevertheless, when he heard God's promise, he did not waver at all; he believed, he received it; he was found worthy, he took it up. He was born, he was nourished, he was brought to maturity, he was fed with milk, and it was said to him: In your seed all nations shall be blessed (Gen 22:18). He knew in what seed. For we have testimony in the Gospel. Abraham, he says, longed to see my day; and he saw it, and rejoiced (Jn 8:56). He knew, therefore. But after all those things which he had believed, he heard from God: Abraham, offer me your son as a sacrifice. He was tested (Gen 22). Why? Did God not know his faith? But for our sake he deigned to show these things. For it is said to us: Offer me a sacrifice from your purse; and we hesitate. What sacrifice? Give alms, and behold, all things are clean to you (Lk 11:41). And again: I desire mercy rather than sacrifice (Mt 9 and 12:7). Give something from your purse, it is said to you, and you bind it up. What if you were commanded concerning your son? Behold, you hesitate so over your purse—what would you have done over your son? That I may know what is lacking in me. I am about to speak not without grief and shame. Many women, perhaps, wish to serve God, and if they are bold, they say to their parents: Let me go. I wish to be a virgin of God, or I wish to be a servant of God; and they hear: May you be neither safe nor saved. Truly you shall not do what you wish. What I wish, that you shall do. What if it were said to you: Kill?","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":193,"ref":"p193","source":"Vivis, vita aeterna promittitur tibi, ante te est, et resistis, et dubitas, et oppugnas? Certe Christianus es. Quare? domne? Quia Christianus sum, ideo non debeo habere nepotes? Debes habere nepotes? Scis, quantum tibi deest. Quod heri jejunasti? Canta, quod iste dixit: Notum fac mihi, Domine, finem meum, et numerum dierum meorum, qui sit, ut sciam, quid desit mihi. Praestet enim Deus, et misericordia ipsius, ut quotidie agitemur, aut tentemur, aut probemur, aut exerceamur, aut proficiamus. Tribulatio patientiam operatur, patientia probationem, probatio spem, spes vero non confundit (Rom. v, 3).\n\nErgo, fratres mei, optemus quotidie scire, qui simus, ne, cum securi sumus, postea veniat dies, et nihil inveniatur de eo, quod putabamus, et dicatur nobis: In inferno quis confitebitur tibi? (Psal. vi, 6). Ergo, fratres mei, demus operam quotidie proficiendi in Deum, non parcendo rebus caducis, quas hic sumus dimissuri. Attendamus Abrahae fidem, quia et ipse pater noster fuit, imitemur devotionem, imitemur fidem. Si in filiis nostris tentati fuerimus, non timeamus; si in saccello, non terreamur; si infirmitatibus corporis nostri aliquid fuerit ingestum, spem nostram in Deum collocemus. Christiani sumus, peregrini sumus. Nemo terreatur, patria hic non est. Qui hic vult habere patriam, et istam perdet, et ad illam non veniet.","english":"You are alive, eternal life is promised to you, it lies before you, and you resist, and you doubt, and you fight against it? Surely you are a Christian. Why? My lord? Because I am a Christian, therefore I ought not to have grandchildren? Ought you to have grandchildren? You know how much is lacking to you. What—did you fast yesterday? Sing what that man said: Make known to me, Lord, my end, and the number of my days, what it is, that I may know what is lacking to me. For may God grant it, and his mercy, that daily we may be stirred up, or tempted, or tested, or exercised, or make progress. Tribulation produces patience, patience produces proof, proof produces hope, but hope does not put to shame (Rom 5:3).\n\nTherefore, my brothers, let us desire daily to know who we are, lest, when we are secure, the day come afterward, and nothing be found of what we thought, and it be said to us: In hell who will confess to you? (Ps 6:6). Therefore, my brothers, let us take care to make progress daily toward God, not sparing the things that pass away, which we are here about to leave behind. Let us attend to the faith of Abraham, because he too was our father; let us imitate his devotion, let us imitate his faith. If we are tested in our children, let us not fear; if in our purse, let us not be terrified; if something has been brought upon us by the infirmities of our body, let us place our hope in God. We are Christians, we are pilgrims. Let no one be terrified; here is not our homeland. Whoever wishes to have a homeland here will both lose this one and will not come to that one.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":194,"ref":"p194","source":"Ut boni filii ad patriam tendamus, ut cursus noster approbetur, et perducatur. Conversi ad Dominum, etc.\n\nSERMO XXI.\n\nDe verbis Psalmi xxxii, vers. 1, Exultate, Justi, in Domino, etc..\n\nSYNOPSIS.\n\nI. Quos deceat Laus Dei. II. Non judicandum de Deo e temporali Impiorum felicitate. III. Deus a rectis corde etiam in adversis laudatur. IV. Castigatio divina paterna est. V. Usus facit divitias bonas, aut malas. VI. Exemplum Job Christianis proponitur.\n\nVII. Rectitudo cordis Job in omni tentatione. VIII.\n\nDei consilia adoranda, non discutienda. IX. Implorandus tamen in adversis.\n\nI. In Dei laude gaudere, et laudi Dei vivendo congruere, admonet nos, quod modo cantavimus. Exultate, justi, in Domino. Rectos decet laudatio (Psal. xxxii, 1). Si enim rectos decet, pravos non decet. Qui autem recti, ipsi etiam justi sunt, quibus dicitur, ut exultent in Domino; ipsos enim decet laudatio. Qui autem pravi, nisi peccatores et iniqui, qui in Domino exultare non possunt, quoniam non eos decet laudatio. Merito dicitur in alio Psalmo: Peccatori autem dixit Deus: Ut quid tu enarras justitias meas, et assumis testamentum meum per os tuum (Id. xlix, 16)? Quoniam rectos decet laudatio, et utique justificationes Domini, et testamentum Domini ibi est, ubi laus Domini. Merito et alibi dicitur: Non est speciosa laus in ore peccatoris (Eccli. xv, 9).","english":"Let us as good children press on toward the fatherland, so that our course may be approved and brought to completion. Having turned to the Lord, etc.\n\nSERMON XXI.\n\nOn the words of Psalm 32, verse 1, Rejoice, you just, in the Lord, etc.\n\nSYNOPSIS.\n\nI. Whom the praise of God befits. II. We must not judge of God from the temporal prosperity of the wicked. III. God is praised by the upright of heart even in adversity. IV. Divine chastisement is paternal. V. Use makes riches good or bad. VI. The example of Job is set before Christians.\n\nVII. The uprightness of Job's heart in every trial. VIII.\n\nThe counsels of God are to be adored, not scrutinized. IX. Yet He is to be implored in adversity.\n\nI. That we should rejoice in the praise of God, and by our living be in harmony with the praise of God, is what we have just sung admonishes us. Rejoice, you just, in the Lord. Praise befits the upright (Ps. 32:1). For if it befits the upright, it does not befit the depraved. But those who are upright are also the just, to whom it is said that they should rejoice in the Lord; for praise befits them. But who are the depraved, if not sinners and the wicked, who cannot rejoice in the Lord, since praise does not befit them. Rightly is it said in another Psalm: But to the sinner God said: Why do you recount my justices, and take up my covenant with your mouth (Ps. 49:16)? Since praise befits the upright, and certainly the justifications of the Lord and the covenant of the Lord are there where the praise of the Lord is. Rightly also is it said elsewhere: Praise is not comely in the mouth of a sinner (Sir. 15:9).","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":195,"ref":"p195","source":"Ubi enim non decet, speciosa non est, et ubi speciosa est, ibi decet.\n\nQui sint tamen recti viri proprie, ut quisque agnoscat, utrum in ore suo speciosa sit laus Dei, quaerentes Scripturas invenimus hoc modo. Psalmus quidam dicit: Quam bonus Deus Israel rectis corde. Et sequitur: Mei autem pene commoti sunt pedes, quia zelavi in peccatoribus pacem peccatorum intuens (Psal. lxxii, 1-3). Confitetur iste non quidem aversionem, et casum suum, sed tamen periculum. Non enim se cecidisse dicit, sed pedes suos nutasse, ut caderet. Hoc enim ait: Quam bonus Deus Israel rectis corde. Mei autem pene commoti sunt pedes. Cum autem se per hoc, quod est aversus, discernit a rectis corde, confitetur se aliquando non fuisse rectum corde, et ideo pene commotos pedes suos. Bonus ergo, inquit, Deus Israel rectis corde; mihi autem aliquando bonus non est visus, quia non eram rectus corde. Non est autem ausus dicere: Non est mihi Deus visus bonus; sed tamen hoc dixit. Cum enim ait: Bonus Deus Israel rectis corde; mei autem pene commoti sunt pedes, ostendit, quia propterea moti sunt pedes, quia non ei videbatur bonus. Unde autem non ei visus est bonus Deus? Paulominus effusi sunt gressus mei. Paulominus quid est? Pene effusi sunt. Unde? Quia zelavi in peccatoribus pacem peccatorum intuens. Attendi, inquit, peccatores non colentes Deum, blasphemantes Deum, irritantes Deum.","english":"For where it is not fitting, it is not beautiful, and where it is beautiful, there it is fitting.\n\nBut what men are properly called upright, so that each one may recognize whether the praise of God is beautiful in his mouth, we find by searching the Scriptures in this way. A certain psalm says: How good is God to Israel, to the upright of heart. And it follows: But my feet were almost moved, because I envied the wicked, beholding the peace of sinners (Ps. 72:1-3). This man confesses not indeed his turning away and his fall, but nevertheless his danger. For he does not say that he fell, but that his feet tottered, so that he might fall. For this he said: How good is God to Israel, to the upright of heart. But my feet were almost moved. Yet in that he distinguishes himself, by reason of his having turned away, from the upright of heart, he confesses that he was once not upright of heart, and therefore that his feet were almost moved. Good, therefore, he says, is God to Israel, to the upright of heart; but to me at one time he did not seem good, because I was not upright of heart. Yet he did not dare to say: God did not seem good to me; but nevertheless this is what he said. For when he says: Good is God to Israel, to the upright of heart; but my feet were almost moved, he shows that his feet were moved for this reason, that God did not seem good to him. But why did God not seem good to him? My steps were almost poured out. What is almost? Almost poured out. Why? Because I envied the wicked, beholding the peace of sinners. I attended, he says, to sinners who do not worship God, who blaspheme God, who provoke God.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":196,"ref":"p196","source":"Vidi, quod abundent pace, abundent felicitate, et visum est mihi, quod non recte judicet Deus blasphematoribus suis donans felicitatem. Hoc ergo cum intueretur, id est, felicitatem malorum, dixit nutasse pedes suos, ut non ei videretur bonus Deus. Sed, quia postea cognovit, sicut in ipso Psalmo dicit: Suscepi, ut cognoscerem, et addidit: Hoc labor est ante me; quare sint iniqui felices, Hoc labor est ante me, ait, donec introeam in sanctuarium Dei, et intelligam in novissima eorum (Ibid. 16, 17); quia, quibus modo iniquis ad tempus datur felicitas, servatur in novissimo poena sempiterna. hoc cum cognovisset, factus est rectus corde, et coepit laudare Deum in omnibus, et in laboribus piorum, et in ipsis felicitatibus impiorum, attendens Deum justum esse retributorem in novissimis, nunc vero dare quibusdam temporalem felicitatem, quibus servat in extremo sempiternam infelicitatem, et quosdam pios exercere in praesenti infelicitate, quibus rursus servat aeternam felicitatem, et oportere, ut mutentur vices, tamquam Divitis illius. Qui epulabatur quotidie splendide (Luc. xvi, 19), et Pauperis illius ulcerosi jacentis ad januam Divitis, et de micis, quae cadebant de mensa Divitis, saturari concupiscentis.","english":"I saw that they abound in peace, abound in felicity, and it seemed to me that God does not judge rightly when he grants felicity to those who blaspheme him. When therefore he beheld this, that is, the felicity of the wicked, he said that his feet had tottered, so that God did not seem good to him. But because afterward he came to know, as he says in that same Psalm: I took up, that I might know, and he added: This is a labor before me; why are the wicked happy, This is a labor before me, he says, until I enter into the sanctuary of God, and understand in their last end (Ibid. 16, 17); because for those wicked to whom felicity is now given for a time, eternal punishment is reserved in their last end. When he had come to know this, he was made upright of heart, and began to praise God in all things, both in the labors of the pious and in the very felicities of the impious, attending to the fact that God is a just rewarder in the last things, but now gives temporal felicity to certain ones for whom he reserves eternal infelicity at the end, and exercises certain pious ones in present infelicity, for whom again he reserves eternal felicity, and that it is fitting that their lots be exchanged, as with that Rich Man who feasted splendidly every day (Luke 16:19), and that Poor man, full of sores, lying at the Rich Man's door, and desiring to be filled from the crumbs that fell from the Rich Man's table.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":197,"ref":"p197","source":"Cum autem mortui essent ambo, ille in poena in inferno esse coepit; ille in sinu Abrahae requievit, et cum indignum videretur Diviti, et vellet sibi de modico digito Lazari stillari guttam aquae, vicissim de digito ipsius desiderans guttam, de cujus mensa ille desideravit micam, audivit ab Abraham sententiam recti Dei. Fili, inquit, memento, quia recepisti bona in vita tua, Lazarus autem mala, Nunc vero hic requiescit, tu autem torqueris (Luc. xvi, 25). In haec novissima intendit aspectum intrans in sanctuarium Dei ille, cui non videbatur bonus Deus, quia zelavit in peccatoribus pacem peccatorum intuens, et agnoscens judicium Dei verua, et justum, quod q(??)ndem modo agitur, sed occulte, futurum in fine in manifestatione, et tanquam correcto corde ex privitate propria, admota velut regula justitiae Dei, qua cor tortum corrigeretur, erupit in hanc vocem, et ait: Quam bonus Deus Israel rectis corde! Modo intelligo bonum, quia factus sum rectus corde; antea vero non mihi videbatur bonus, quia nutabant pedes mei. Zelavi enim in peccatoribus pacem peccatorum intuens.","english":"But when both had died, the one began to be in punishment in hell; the other rested in Abraham's bosom. And when he seemed unworthy to the rich man, and he wished that a drop of water be dripped to him from the least finger of Lazarus, in turn desiring a drop from his own finger—he from whose table that man had desired a crumb—he heard from Abraham the sentence of the righteous God. \"Son,\" he said, \"remember that you received good things in your life, but Lazarus evil things; now therefore he rests here, but you are tormented\" (Luke 16:25). Upon these last things he directed his gaze as he entered into the sanctuary of God—he to whom God did not seem good, because he envied the peace of sinners as he looked upon it, and recognizing the judgment of God to be true and just—which is indeed carried out now, but secretly, and will be in the end in manifestation—and as though with his heart corrected from its own perversity, with the rule of God's justice, as it were, brought near, by which the crooked heart might be corrected, he burst forth into this utterance and said: \"How good is God to Israel, to those who are right of heart!\" Now I understand the good, because I have been made right of heart; but before, he did not seem good to me, because my feet were slipping. For I envied the peace of sinners as I looked upon it.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":198,"ref":"p198","source":"Si ergo jam tibi videtur bonus Deus, et quando malis dat felicitatem, unde solebas murmurare adversus Deum, factus es rectus corde, decet te laudatio; Rectos enim decet laudatio. Si autem sis pravus, non te decet laudatio. Quare non te decet? Non erit perseverans laus, qua laudas Deum. Laudas enim Deum, quando tibi bene est; blasphemas Deum, quando tibi male est. Etenim tunc tibi placet, quando dat felicitatem; displicet autem, quando castigat. Non es rectus corde, non poteris dicere canticum illud alterius Psalmi: Benedicam Dominum in omni tempore, semper laus ejus in ore meo (Psal. xxxiii, 2). Quomodo enim Semper, si tunc, quando tibi bene est, laudas, non et quando tibi male est? Quia et ipsum; quod dicitur male tibi esse, bene est, si castigatorem patrem esse intelligas. Puer insensatus amat plerumque magistrum blandientem, odit caedentem; puer vero intelligens intelligit magistrum bonum et blandientem et caedentem. Blanditur enim, ne puer deficiat; caedit, ne pereat. Tale itaque cor cum quisquam habuerit, id est, rectum, ut non ei displiceat Deus, et quando facit quod forte illi ad tempus adversari videatur, securus laudet Deum, quia Semper laudabit, et vere illum decet laudatio, et vere fideliter cantat. Benedicam Dominum in omni tempore, semper laus ejus in ore meo. Flagellat autem omnem filium, quem recipit (Hebr. xii, 6). Quid ergo eligis?","english":"If, then, God already seems good to you, and because he gives happiness even to the wicked—the very thing that used to make you murmur against God—you have become upright of heart, praise is fitting for you; for praise is fitting for the upright. But if you are crooked, praise is not fitting for you. Why is praise not fitting for you? Because the praise with which you praise God will not be persevering. For you praise God when things go well for you; you blaspheme God when things go badly for you. Indeed, he pleases you when he gives happiness; he displeases you when he chastises. You are not upright of heart; you cannot say that song from another Psalm: I will bless the Lord at all times, his praise shall always be in my mouth (Ps. 33:2). For how can it be always, if you praise him when things go well for you, but not also when things go badly? Because even that which is said to go badly for you is well, if you understand that the one who chastises is a father. A foolish child often loves a teacher who flatters him and hates one who beats him; but an understanding child understands that a good teacher both flatters and beats. For he flatters, so that the child may not give way; he beats, so that he may not perish. Therefore, when anyone has such a heart—that is, an upright one—so that God does not displease him even when he does what may for a time seem to oppose him, let him praise God securely, because he will praise him always, and truly praise is fitting for him, and truly he sings faithfully: I will bless the Lord at all times, his praise shall always be in my mouth. For he chastises every son whom he receives (Heb. 12:6). What, then, do you choose?","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":199,"ref":"p199","source":"Flagellari, et recipi, an non tangi, et non recipi? Vide, qualis sis filius. Si haereditatem paternam appetis, flagellum non recuses. Si flagellum respuis, nega haereditatem. Quo enim te erudit, nisi ut det haereditatem? Haeres patris tui ut esses, non te increpavit, non objurgavit, non castigavit, non verberavit? Ut quid hoc? Ut ei succederes in domum quandoque ruituram, et fundum quandoque transiturum, et aurum non diutius in hoc saeculo mansurum, quam tu ipse, qui aurum possides. Etenim aut vivens amissurus es, quod habes, aut moriens relicturus. Propter istam tamen temporalem haereditatem pertulisti flagella patris tui, et murmuras ad Deum erudientem, ut det tibi regnum coelorum?\n\nCum ergo talis es, ut placeat tibi Deus, et castigans placeat tibi; aut enim est in te aliquid, quod flagello corrigatur, aut ipsa rectitudo tua in flagello probatur; cum ergo talis es, lauda; securus enim laudas. Quare securus laudas? Quia decenter laudas, quia perseveranter laudas. Non enim timeo, ne modo laudes, post paululum blasphemes. Non timeo, ne sanus laudes, et aegrotus blasphemes. Non timeo, ne de sani ore procedat laus Dei, de aegroti lingua qu(??)- tur Mathematicus, aut Sortilogus, quaeratur Praeca(??)r, et remediorum diabolicorum Alligator. Non timeo, quia jam intellexisti bonum Deum esse, et cum castigat, et scis, quia ille, qui percutit filium, novit et quando parcat.","english":"To be flogged and to be received—or not to be touched and not to be received? See what kind of son you are. If you desire your father's inheritance, do not refuse the whip. If you spurn the whip, disown the inheritance. For to what end does he instruct you, except to give you the inheritance? As a heir of your father, did he not rebuke you, not scold you, not chastise you, not beat you, so that you might be? For what purpose? So that you might succeed him in a house that will one day fall, and in an estate that will one day pass away, and in gold that will not remain in this world longer than you yourself, who possess the gold. For either while living you will lose what you have, or dying you will leave it behind. Yet for the sake of this temporal inheritance you endured your father's whippings, and you murmur against God as he instructs you, so that he may give you the kingdom of heaven?\n\nWhen, therefore, you are such that God pleases you, and he pleases you even when he chastises—for either there is something in you that is corrected by the whip, or your very uprightness is tested by the whip—when, then, you are such, praise; for you praise securely. Why do you praise securely? Because you praise fittingly, because you praise perseveringly. For I do not fear that you may praise now and blaspheme a little later. I do not fear that you may praise when healthy and blaspheme when sick. I do not fear that from the mouth of the healthy may proceed the praise of God, and from the tongue of the sick be sought the Mathematician, or the Sortilegus, or the Praecantor, and the Alligator of diabolical remedies. I do not fear, because you have already understood that God is good, even when he chastises, and you know that he who strikes the son also knows when to spare him.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":200,"ref":"p200","source":"Decebit te laudare, quia semper perseveranter laudabis, et erit semper laus Dei in ore tuo. Accipis libenter blandientem patrem, accipis libenter et flagellantem patrem. Non ad illum curris, cum blanditur, et fugis ab eo, cum flagellat. Si enim hoc feceris, eris tanquam puer, qui, cum fugeret a flagellante patre, incurrit in blandientem mangonem, et putavit eum bonum, patrem vero suum malum, et praetulit dolos blandimentorum veritati flagellorum, praeferendo autem amisit haereditatem, incurrit in conditionem. Muta tu consilium, et fac cor tuum rectum. Non enim mutatus est Deus, quia flagellat te, sed tu mutabilis es. Agit ille aliquid per commutationem, ut (??) in melius commutatus percipias haereditatem. Nam si relinquat te, et negligat te, quando tibi videtur bonus, tunc multum irascitur. Intendat Charitas Vestra, quid dicat in alio Psalmo Scriptura Dei. Irritavit Dominum peccator, Ait. Quare irritavit? Videte, ubi exclamaverit de irritato Deo. Utique ad iracundiam majorem irritavit Dominum peccator. Prae magnitudine, inquit, irae suae, non exquiret (Psal. x, 4)","english":"It will delight you to praise, because you will always praise perseveringly, and the praise of God will always be in your mouth. You gladly accept a father who caresses you; gladly accept a father who flogs you too. Do not run to him when he caresses you and flee from him when he flogs you. For if you do this, you will be like a child who, when fleeing from a father who flogs him, runs into a caressing slave-dealer, and thought him good and his own father bad, and preferred the deceits of flattery to the truth of the whip; but by preferring them he lost his inheritance and fell into slavery. Change your counsel, and make your heart upright. For God has not changed because he flogs you; it is you who are changeable. He is doing something through this change, so that you, changed for the better, may receive the inheritance. For if he abandons you and neglects you when he seems good to you, then he is greatly angry. Let Your Charity attend to what the Scripture of God says in another Psalm. The sinner, it says, has provoked the Lord. Why did he provoke him? See where it cried out concerning the provoked God. Surely the sinner has provoked the Lord to greater anger. Because of the greatness, it says, of his anger, he will not seek out.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":201,"ref":"p201","source":"Contra Job sanctus benedicens Dominum in omni tempore, in cujus ore semper erat laus ejus, cum esset dives, benedixit Dominum in divitiis suis, faciens de illis omnia opera bona, quae in Libro ejus enumerantur, frangens panem esurienti, vestiens nudum, suscipiens peregrinum, et caetera, quae sola divites de divitiis suis percipiunt, quae divites sola lucrantur. Neque enim lucrantur, aut praesumunt de lucris, quae filiis suis relinquunt. Nesciunt enim, quis post eorum mortem sit possessurus labores ipsorum. Et hanc vanitatem Scriptura dixit: Verumtatem universa vanitas omnis homo vivens. Thesaurizat et nescit cui congreget ea (Psal. xxxviii, 6, 7). Ergo lucrum totum, quod fit de divitiis, thesaurus est regni coelorum. Unde Dominus dedit consilium, non ut perdas, sed ut mutes locum auro tuo. Non enim ait tibi: Cum dederis, perdes, sed male habens in terra, in coelo ego tibi servabo. Quid times, ne perdas? In coelo ponis, custode Christo. Si locus te sollicitat, coelum erit; si custos, Christus erit. Quid times, ne perdas? Ergo eum haec de talibus faceret Job, utique operabatur, et in ipsis operibus ejus Deus laudabatur, et benedicebat Dominum in his, quae acceperat. Non enim vere, fratres, divitiae accusantur. Putatis, quando videtis divites malos, divitias esse malas? Divitiae non sunt malae, sed illi; divitiae autem dona Dei sunt.","english":"Against Job, the saint blessing the Lord at all times, in whose mouth his praise was always, when he was rich, blessed the Lord in his riches, making from them all the good works which are enumerated in his Book: breaking bread for the hungry, clothing the naked, receiving the stranger, and the rest which only the rich receive from their riches, which only the rich gain. For they do not gain, nor do they presume upon the gains, which they leave to their children. For they do not know who after their death will possess their labors. And Scripture called this vanity: Truly all things are vanity, every man living. He treasures up and does not know for whom he gathers them (Ps. 38:6, 7). Therefore the whole gain which is made from riches is a treasure of the kingdom of heaven. Whence the Lord gave counsel, not that you should lose, but that you should change the place of your gold. For he did not say to you: When you have given, you will lose; but, having it badly on earth, I will keep it for you in heaven. What do you fear, that you may lose it? You place it in heaven, with Christ as custodian. If the place troubles you, it will be heaven; if the custodian, it will be Christ. What do you fear, that you may lose it? Therefore, since Job did these things concerning such matters, he was certainly working, and in his very works God was being praised, and he was blessing the Lord in those things which he had received. For truly, brothers, riches are not accused. Do you think, when you see evil rich men, that riches are evil? Riches are not evil, but those men are; riches, however, are the gifts of God.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":202,"ref":"p202","source":"Da illas justo, et vide, quae bona inde faciat. Numquid ideo malum vinum, quia nescio quis se enebriat? Da sobrio bene utenti, et vide munus Dei. Sic da aurum homini avaro. Ut amplius faciat hoc, quod habet, quaerit committere omnia facinora. Da aurum homini justo, et vide, quemadmodum distribuat, quemadmodum impertiatur, quemadmodum, quibus potuerit, necessitatibus hominum subveniat. Non ergo divitiae, sed utens male divitiis ipse est malus. Job ergo bene usus est divitiis, sicut bene usus est Abraham. Certe enim, fratres, ille mendicus ulcerosus jacens ante januam divitis ita egens erat, ut canes lingerent ulcera ejus. Sic certe legimus, sic scriptum est, et tamen quo ablatus est? In sinum Abrahae (Luc. xvi, 22). Recense Scripturas, vide, si pauper hic fuit Abraham. Invenies illum habuisse hic multum auri, multum argenti, multum pecorum, multum mancipiorum, et praediorum. Ergo pauper levatur in sinum divitis. Si meritum illi paupertas faceret, non eum ad requiem Abraham ipse praecederet, et eum succedentem susciperet, sed quia hoc in paupere Lazaro erat, quod erat in divite Abraham, id est, humilitas, pietas. Dei cultus, Dei observantia, nec illi obfuerunt divitiae, nec huic paupertas, sed illius meritum pietas fuit. Inde in illo divite, qui male mutavit vices, non reprehenduntur divitiae ipsius, sed animus ipsius.","english":"Give them to a righteous man, and see what good he does with them. Is wine therefore evil because some man or other gets drunk on it? Give it to a sober man who uses it well, and see the gift of God. So give gold to a greedy man. To do more with what he has, he seeks to commit every kind of crime. Give gold to a righteous man, and see how he distributes it, how he shares it out, how he comes to the aid of human needs, to whomsoever he can. Therefore it is not riches, but the man who uses riches badly who is himself evil. Job, then, used his riches well, just as Abraham used his well. For certainly, brothers, that ulcerous beggar lying before the rich man's door was so needy that dogs licked his sores. So certainly we read, so it is written, and yet where was he taken? Into Abraham's bosom (Luke 16:22). Review the Scriptures, see whether Abraham was poor here. You will find that he had here much gold, much silver, much livestock, many slaves, and estates. Therefore the poor man is lifted up into the rich man's bosom. If poverty had made his merit, Abraham himself would not have gone before him into rest and received him as he followed after; but because in poor Lazarus there was what was in rich Abraham, that is, humility, piety, the worship of God, the observance of God, neither did riches harm the one nor poverty the other, but his merit was piety. Hence in that rich man, who reversed the roles for the worse, it is not his riches that are censured, but his own soul.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":203,"ref":"p203","source":"Induebatur enim purpura et bysso, et epulabatur quotidie splendide (Luc. xvi, 22). Et patiebatur ulcerosum mendicum jacere ante januam suam? et eum superbe contemnens non satiabat ejus inopiam. Quid putatis dixisse divitem fastidientem mendicum? Quid hic jacet iste! Sed merito illa lingua, quae contempsit pauperem. guttam de digito ejus desiderabat.\n\nCum ergo Job sanctus, ut dixi, haberet multas divitias, laudavit Deum, tentatus, ut probaretur; probatus, ut ostenderetur. Latebat enim non solum homines, sed et ipsum diabolum latebat, qui diligentius inspicit, quam quisquam hominum. Latebat ergo eum, quis esset Job, sed Dominum non latebat. Permisit tentatorem probator; probator autem non sibi, sed nobis, ut nobis manifestaret, quid imitari debeamus. Non enim ipsi diabolo voluit ostendere Job, sed per diabolum nobis, ut diabolo victo nos haberemus, quod imitaremur. Ergo amissis omnibus, non paulatim, sed repente, ait: Dominus dedit, Dominus abstulit. Sicut, Domino placuit, ita factum est. Sit nomen Domini benedictum. Sicut Domino placuit, ita factum est (Job. I, 21). Non potest pravum esse, quod recto placuit. Non potest malum esse, quod bono placuit· Bonus enim Deus Israel rectis corde. Rectus corde erat Job, ideo decebat eum laudatio. Dominus dedit, Dominus abstulit. Sicut Domino placuit, ita factum est. Confessus est laudans: Sit nomen Domini benedictum.","english":"For he was clothed in purple and fine linen and feasted sumptuously every day (Luke 16:22). And did he suffer the ulcerous beggar to lie before his gate? And did he, contemptuously despising him, not satisfy his need? What do you think the rich man said when he disdained the beggar? \"What is this fellow lying here!\" But deservedly that tongue which despised the poor man desired a drop from his finger.\n\nWhen therefore holy Job, as I said, had great riches, he praised God—tempted, so that he might be tested; tested, so that he might be shown forth. For he lay hidden not only from men, but he lay hidden even from the devil himself, who inspects more carefully than any man. From him, then, it lay hidden who Job was, but from the Lord he did not lie hidden. The tester permitted the tempter; but the tester did so not for his own sake, but for ours, so that he might make manifest to us what we ought to imitate. For he did not wish to show Job to the devil himself, but through the devil to us, so that, with the devil conquered, we might have something to imitate. Therefore, when all things had been lost—not gradually, but suddenly—he said: The Lord gave, the Lord has taken away. As it pleased the Lord, so it has been done. Blessed be the name of the Lord. As it pleased the Lord, so it has been done (Job 1:21). What has pleased the upright cannot be perverse. What has pleased the good cannot be evil. For God is good to Israel, to those upright in heart. Job was upright in heart; therefore praise was fitting for him. The Lord gave, the Lord has taken away. As it pleased the Lord, so it has been done. He confessed, giving praise: Blessed be the name of the Lord.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":204,"ref":"p204","source":"Dominus dedit, et Dominus abstulit. Erat copia, nunc est inopia. Apud me res mutatae sunt, ille non est mutatus. Ego aliquando dives, aliquando pauper. Ille semper dives, semper rectus, semper pater. Sit nomen Domini benedictum! Non enim benedictum erat nomen Domini in copia mea, et maledictum erit in inopia mea. Absit hoc a me. Hoc direbat Job divitiis interioribus ditatus. Totam domum amiserat, sed pectus plenum erat. Amiserat domum, aurum, impleverat pectus. Deus pro his omnibus, quae dederat, ipse aderat. Dominus dedit, Dominus abstulit. Videte, quemadmodum intelligat supereminentissimam potestatem. Ne forte Deum velis colere, o Christiane! propter regnum coelorum, et diabolum timeas propter bona terrena. Omnino penes illum est tota potestas et summa. Diabolus nocere tantum voluit, non permissus non potuit. Apud illum ergo potestas est. Caeterum, si tantum liceret diabolo, quantum vult, quis Christianorum remaneret? Quis Dei cultor in terra relinqueretur? Non videtis templa ejus cadere, simulacra confringi, sacerdotes ejus ad Deum converti? Non putatis hinc dolere, et torqueri diabolum? Si ergo pro dolore suo et potestas ei esset, quae Ecclesia in terra remaneret? Proinde cum Job sanctus per diaboli insidias omnia perdidisset, non dat et aliquam potestatem. Cum laudat Deum, non ait: Dominus dedit, diabolus abstulit; sed ait: Dominus dedit, Dominus abstulit.","english":"The Lord gave, and the Lord has taken away. There was abundance, now there is want. With me things have changed; he has not changed. I was once rich, once poor. He is always rich, always upright, always a father. Blessed be the name of the Lord! For the name of the Lord was not blessed in my abundance, and it will not be cursed in my want. Far be this from me. So spoke Job, enriched with inner riches. He had lost his whole house, but his heart was full. He had lost his house, his gold; he had filled his heart. For all these things which he had given, God himself was present in their place. The Lord gave, the Lord has taken away. See how he understands the most transcendent power. Do not perhaps wish to worship God, O Christian, for the sake of the kingdom of heaven, and fear the devil for the sake of earthly goods. Altogether in his hand is all power and the highest power. The devil only wished to harm; not permitted, he could not. In him, then, is power. Otherwise, if the devil were allowed as much as he wishes, who among Christians would remain? Who, a worshipper of God, would be left on earth? Do you not see his temples falling, his idols being shattered, his priests being converted to God? Do you not think that the devil grieves and is tormented by this? If, then, for his grief he also had power, what Church would remain on earth? Therefore when holy Job had lost everything through the devil's snares, he does not give him any power either. When he praises God, he does not say: The Lord gave, the devil has taken away; but he says: The Lord gave, the Lord has taken away.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":205,"ref":"p205","source":"Nihil sibi arroget diabolus. Et quod dives eram, Dei erat, et quod pauper sum, Dei est. Et si permissus est ut tentaret, non est permissus ut suffocaret. Suffocaret autem non gulam tenens et confringens, sed spiritum intercludens. Si forte ille tribulationis passus angustias unum verbum blasphemum ex ore emitteret, tunc exhalaret extremum suffocatus excluso a se spiritu vitae. Hoc nec in illa repentina paupertate fecit, nec in illo ultimo vulnere.\n\nNam, cum parum fuisset diabolo abstulisse omnia, quae ille possidebat, abstulit et filios, quibus ille possidebat, sola relicta uxore. Solam enim illam non abstulit, et hoc utique sciens, quid faceret. Noverat Adam per Evam deceptum. Servabat ergo suam potius adjutricem, quam mariti consolatricem. Cum ergo abstulisset illa omnia, et reliquisset unam, per quam rursus tentaret, parum ei fuit; petit etiam auferre sanitatem corporis. Et ipsam permissus est auferre, ut et in illo vulnere positus Job laudaret Deum rectus corde, in nullo varians, quem decebat laudatio. Accessit ad eum illa ad hoc relicta, et persuasit, imo suasit blasphemiam. Ait enim: Quanta mala patimur! Dic aliquid in Deum, et morere (Job II, 9): Primo Eva a diabolo quasi ad vitam invitata seducta est, et invenit mortem. Etenim diabolus ait: Non morte morieris (Gen. III, 4).","english":"Let the devil claim nothing for himself. That I was rich was God's doing, and that I am poor is God's doing. And if he was permitted to tempt, he was not permitted to suffocate. But he suffocates not by seizing and crushing the throat, but by shutting off the spirit. If perhaps that man, having endured the straits of tribulation, were to let out one blasphemous word from his mouth, then he would breathe out his last, suffocated, with the spirit of life shut out from him. This he did not do in that sudden poverty, nor in that final wound.\n\nFor when it had been too little for the devil to have taken away all the things that he possessed, he took away also the sons, through whom he possessed, with only his wife left. For her alone he did not take away, and this surely knowing what he was doing. He knew that Adam had been deceived through Eve. He was keeping, then, his own helper rather than the husband's comforter. When therefore he had taken away all those things and had left one, through whom he might tempt him again, it was too little for him; he sought also to take away the health of his body. And this too he was permitted to take away, so that even placed in that wound Job might praise God, upright in heart, wavering in nothing, whom praise befitted. She who had been left for this purpose came to him and persuaded, nay urged, blasphemy. For she says: How many evils we suffer! Say something against God, and die (Job 2:9). First Eve was seduced by the devil as though invited to life, and she found death. For the devil said: You shall not die the death (Gen. 3:4).","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":206,"ref":"p206","source":"Et putans se habituram vitam, mortem invenit, quia contra praeceptum Dei fecit, et contra praeceptum Dei viro persuasit. Modo contra: Dic aliquid in Deum, et morere! Sufficiat Evae, quia persuasit facere contra praeceptum Dei. Illa adhuc Eva. Ille jam non Adam. Illa a diabolo impleta, ille exemplo correctus. Melior Job in stercore, quam Adam in Paradiso. Ut noveritis quantum sit rectum cor habere, Job quomodo prostravit diabolum in illa inopia, in illo vulnere? Respondit enim mulieri, et ait: Tanquam una ex insipientibus mulieribus locuta es. Si bona percepimus de manu Domini, mala non sustinebimus (Job. II, 10)? Benedixit Dominum in omni tempore, semper laus ejus in ore illius Re· ctus enim erat corde, propterea illum decebat laudatio. Estote recti corde. Si vultis autem esse recti corde, non vobis displiceat in aliquo Deus. Aut enim vides causam, quare faciat, quod facit, et causam intuens non reprehendis, aut, si te causa latet, scito, quia ille facit, qui in nullo poterit displicere.","english":"And thinking that she would have life, she found death, because she acted against the commandment of God, and against the commandment of God she persuaded her husband. Now on the other side: Say something against God, and die! It should be enough for Eve that she persuaded him to act against the commandment of God. She is still Eve. He is no longer Adam. She was filled by the devil, he was corrected by her example. Better is Job on the dung-heap than Adam in Paradise. So that you may know how great a thing it is to have a right heart—how did Job overthrow the devil in that destitution, in that wound? For he answered the woman and said: You have spoken like one of the foolish women. If we have received good things from the hand of the Lord, shall we not endure evil things? He blessed the Lord at all times, his praise was always in his mouth. For he was right in heart, and therefore praise was fitting for him. Be right in heart. But if you wish to be right in heart, let not God displease you in anything. For either you see the reason why he does what he does, and seeing the reason you do not find fault; or, if the reason is hidden from you, know that he does it who can displease no one in anything.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":207,"ref":"p207","source":"Dejicit, nescio, quis domum suam, reprehenditur. Si causam noveris, fors non reprehendis hominem facientem. Utique in hac modo Basilica sumus, et angusta est, et habet aliquid parvum, et placuit Domino alteram fieri, et destruenda erit haec. Quicumque forte viderit dejicientes, cum coeperit dejici, dicet: Hic non oratum est? Hic nomen Dei non invocatum est? Quid patiuntur isti, ut dejiciant? Displicet opus, quia latet consilium. Sic ergo et Deus aliquid facit. Quare faciat, aut scis, et laudas, aut nescis, et credis, si rectus es corde. Ipse est enim rectus corde, qui et in ipsis causis, quas novit, laudat Deum, et in his, quas nescit, non dat insipientiam Deo. Injuste, et stulte reprehenderis, Homo gubernator domus tuae! ab ignaro causarum, et ignaro consiliorum tuorum, et tu audes Gubernatorem totius mundi, et Creatorem caeli et terrae reprehendere, quia flavit ventus, et aruerunt vites, aut surrexit nu bes, et fudit grandinem? Noli reprehendere. Novit ille omnia opera sua et gubernare, et numerare. Tu certe non potuisti fabricare coelum et terram, et tamen, si tibi liceret, diceres Deo: O si ego gubernarem, non facerem quod facis. Quando enim tibi displicet, nescio quid, factum a Deo, nonne velles te esse gubernatorem? Erubesce. Cui velis succedere, vide. Moriturus immortali, homo Deo. Melius est te illi cedere, quam quaerere succedere.","english":"Someone, I know not who, tears down his own house and is criticized. If you knew his reason, perhaps you would not criticize the man for doing it. After all, we are now in this basilica, and it is narrow, and it has something small about it, and it has pleased the Lord that another be built, and this one will have to be destroyed. Whoever perhaps sees those tearing it down, when it begins to be torn down, will say: Was there not prayer here? Was the name of God not invoked here? What are these men suffering, that they should tear it down? The work displeases him because the plan is hidden. So too, then, God does something. Why he does it, either you know and you praise it, or you do not know and you believe, if you are upright of heart. For he is upright of heart who both praises God in those matters which he knows, and in those which he does not know does not impute folly to God. Unjustly and foolishly would you be criticized, O man, governor of your own house!—by one ignorant of your reasons and ignorant of your plans—and do you dare to criticize the Governor of the whole world and the Creator of heaven and earth because the wind blew and the vines withered, or a cloud rose and poured down hail? Do not criticize. He knows how both to govern and to number all his works. You certainly could not have made heaven and earth, and yet, if it were permitted you, you would say to God: O if only I governed, I would not do what you do. For when something displeases you, I know not what, done by God, do you not wish that you were the governor? Be ashamed. Consider whom you wish to succeed. You who are about to die, the immortal; man, God. It is better for you to yield to him than to seek to succeed him.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":208,"ref":"p208","source":"Cede Deo, quia Deus est, etsi forte contra voluntatem tuam fecit, non est forte contra utilitatem tuam. Quanta faciunt medici contra aegrotorum voluntatem, et tamen non faciunt contra sanitatem. Et errat medicus aliquando, Deus nunquam. Si ergo committis te medico aliquando erranti, committis te humano consilio, non ut adhibeat cataplasma, quod leve est, aut emplastrum, unde tibi dolorem non faciat, sed plerumque ut urat, ut secet, ut auferat membrum tibi, et tecum natum, committis te illi, non dicis: Hic forte errat, et ego minus habebo unum digitum; permittis ut tollat unum digitum, ne forte inde totum corpus putrescat, et non permittis Deum secare, ut tollat aliquid de fructibus tuis, si forte in ipsa moderatione habeas disciplinam?\n\nErgo, fratres, estote recti corde, id est, ut in nullo vobis Deus displiceat. Non dico, ut eum non rogetis. Rogate, quantum potestis, in afflictione. Suspendit imbrem; rogandus est, sed et, si pluerit, laudandus, sed et, si non pluerit, laudandus, tamen rogandus. Non enim dicimus, ut non rogetis. Aliquando enim flectitur, et concedit rogantibus, et non vult concedere non rogantibus. Arrogans est Deus, ut non concedat, nisi roganti. Sed tunc anima parvula ad magnitudinem Dei proficiet, si ei in tribula· tione subveniat, ut nobis rogantibus et tribulatis det consolationem. Dulcescere nobis vult bono nostro, non suo.","english":"Yield to God, because he is God, even if perhaps he has acted against your will, he has not perhaps acted against your advantage. How much do doctors do against the will of the sick, and yet they do not act against their health. And a doctor sometimes errs, God never. If therefore you entrust yourself to a doctor who sometimes errs, you entrust yourself to human counsel, not that he may apply a poultice, which is a light thing, or a plaster, from which he causes you no pain, but for the most part that he may burn, that he may cut, that he may remove a limb from you, even one born with you—you entrust yourself to him, you do not say: Perhaps this man errs, and I shall have one finger the less; you permit him to take away one finger, lest perhaps from there the whole body rot—and you do not permit God to cut, that he may take away something from your fruits, if perhaps in that very moderation you may have discipline?\n\nTherefore, brothers, be upright of heart, that is, so that in nothing God may displease you. I do not say that you should not ask him. Ask, as much as you can, in affliction. He has held back the rain; he must be asked, but also, if it has rained, he must be praised, but also, if it has not rained, he must be praised, yet he must be asked. For we do not say that you should not ask. For sometimes he is moved and grants to those who ask, and he does not wish to grant to those who do not ask. God is arrogant, so as not to grant except to one who asks. But then the little soul will profit toward the greatness of God, if he comes to its aid in tribulation, so that to us asking and in tribulation he may give consolation. He wishes to become sweet to us for our good, not his own.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":209,"ref":"p209","source":"Videte enim, quid mali est, ut tibi dulcis factus sit mundus, et amarus sit Deus, qui fecit mun· dum. Nonne mutandus es, nonne corrigendus es, ut habeas rectum cor? Imo sit amarus mundus, et dulcis sit Deus. Misceat itaque Dominus Deus noster amaritudines mundo huic. Misceat plane! Hic fruere, circumfluere, abundare deliciis, oblivisci Deum delectat. Si habet aliquid amplius pecuniae, nugari inde vult, non vult inde aliquid utile facere, aliquid coele· ste comparare; perdere vult et pecuniam, et se, et caeteros, in quos impendit pecuniam. Non vultis ergo, ut receset Deus superflua, ne de putredine totum putrescat? Novit ergo, quid agat. Dimittamus illum, tantum nos curandos demus, non medico consilium praebeamus. Conversi ad Dominum, etc.\n\nSERMO XXII.\n\nDe verbis Psalmi li. vers, 10. Speravi in misericordia Dei.\n\nSYNOPSIS.\n\nI. Quamdiu debeat durare Spes nostra. II. Spes humanae longae, inanes, fallaces. III. Quaenam vera Spes nostra.","english":"See, then, what an evil it is that the world has become sweet to you and God bitter, who made the world. Do you not need to be changed, do you not need to be corrected, so that you may have a right heart? Rather, let the world be bitter and God be sweet. So let our Lord God mix bitternesses into this world. Let him mix them in, plainly! Here it pleases you to enjoy, to overflow, to abound in delights, to forget God. If he has any more money, he wants to trifle with it, he does not want to do anything useful with it, to purchase anything heavenly; he wants to lose both the money and himself and the others on whom he spends the money. Do you not want God to cut away the superfluous, lest the whole rot from the rot? He knows, then, what he is doing. Let us let him be; let us only give ourselves over to be cured, and not give the physician advice. Turned to the Lord, etc.\n\nSERMON XXII.\n\nOn the words of Psalm 51, verse 10: I have hoped in the mercy of God.\n\nSYNOPSIS.\n\nI. How long our hope ought to last. II. Human hopes are long, empty, deceitful. III. What our true hope is.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":210,"ref":"p210","source":"Primo respondeam Fratri et Collegae meo. Ego mane inquietam dixi debere esse charitatem, non pigram, sed quia hoc voluit, nos obaudiamus et illi, et Deo per illum, et vobis, et det in vobis obedientiam. Cantavimus: Speravi in misericordia Dei (Psal. LI, 10). De spe nostra pauca dicamus. Et verba quidem sermonis nostri competentem tempori finem habebunt, Spes autem ipsa, de qua sermo est, perdurare debet, et non cum sermone nostro cessare. Nos loquamur, et desinamus, illa semper clamat ad Deum. Sed et ipsa Spes (durum enim fortasse, quod dico, sed non offendet, si ostendero, quare dico, et credo, quia non offendet) sed et ipsa spes non erit sempiterna. Cum enim res venerit, Spes non erit. Tandiu quippe dicitur Spes, quandiu nondum tenetur res, dicente Apostolo: Spes autem, quae videtur, non est Spes Quod enim videt quis, quid sperat? Si autem quod non videmus, speramus, per patientiam expectamus (Rom. viii, 24. 25). Si ergo Spes, quae videtur, non est Spes, quia quod videt quis, quid sperat, et ideo vocatur Spes, quia, quod non videmus, speramus, cum venerit, quod videamus, Spes non erit, quia res erit. Nec tunc maledictum erit, esse sine Spe; modo vero cuicumque sine Spe esse, maledictum est, et opprobrium. Et vae illi, qui sine Spe modo est! Male est enim sine Spe esse, quia nondum est cum re. Tunc esse desinat Spes, quando tenebitur res.","english":"First let me answer my brother and colleague. I said in the morning that charity ought to be restless, not slothful; but because he willed this, let us obey both him and God through him, and you, and may he grant obedience in you. We have sung: I have hoped in the mercy of God (Ps. 51:10). Let us say a few things about our hope. And indeed the words of our sermon will have an end suited to the occasion, but hope itself, of which the sermon speaks, must endure and not cease with our sermon. Let us speak and fall silent; that hope always cries out to God. But even hope itself—for perhaps what I say is hard, but it will not offend, if I show why I say it, and I believe it will not offend—but even hope itself will not be everlasting. For when the reality has come, hope will not be. For hope is so called as long as the reality is not yet possessed, as the Apostle says: But hope that is seen is not hope; for what a man sees, why does he hope for it? But if we hope for what we do not see, we wait for it with patience (Rom. 8:24-25). If, then, hope that is seen is not hope, because what a man sees, why does he hope for it, and it is therefore called hope because we hope for what we do not see, when what we are to see has come, hope will not be, because the reality will be. Nor will it then be a curse to be without hope; but now, for anyone to be without hope is a curse and a reproach. And woe to him who is now without hope! For it is an evil thing to be without hope, because the reality is not yet present. Then let hope cease to be, when the reality is possessed.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":211,"ref":"p211","source":"Res autem ipsa, quae est, quae tenebitur? Quid est, quod succedet Spei? Videmus enim modo homines multa terrena sperare, et secundum saeculum. Ipsa vita nullius hominis est sine Spe, et, donec moriatur quisque non est sine Spe. Spes in pueris, ut crescant, ut erudiantur, ut aliquid noverint. Spes in adolescentibus, ut uxores ducant, ut filios generent. Spes in parentibus filiorum, ut nutriant, ut erudiant, ut grandes videant, quibus parvulis blandiebantur. Ut ipsam vitam Spei humanae potissimum nominem, quae quasi naturalior, et excusabilior, et tristior est. Sunt enim multae Spes vulgares, multum reprehensibiles; sed hanc teneamus, quae civilis et naturalis est. Ad hoc enim quisque nascitur, ut crescat, ut conjugetur, ut filios procreet, ut erudiat, etiam ut pater dicatur filiorum. Quid amplius quaerit? Et nondum est finita spes. Optat conjungere filiis suis uxores, et adhuc sperat. Et cum et hoc adeptus fuerit, optat nepotes. Et cum hos habuerit, jam ecce tertia successio est, et piger est senex dare locum pueris. Adhuc quaerit sibi quid optet, quaerit quid speret, et benevolus videtur. Utinam, inquit, vocet me puer ille avum, et audiam hoc de ore ipsius, et moriar! Crescit puer, vocat avum, et ille nondum se cognoscit avum. Utique enim, si avus est, si senex est, quare non agnoscit, migrare jam debere, ut succedant, qui nati sunt?","english":"But what is the reality itself that will be held? What is it that will succeed hope? For we see that people now hope for many earthly things, and according to the world. No one's life itself is without hope, and until each person dies he is not without hope. There is hope in children, that they may grow, that they may be educated, that they may know something. There is hope in young men, that they may take wives, that they may beget children. There is hope in the parents of children, that they may nourish them, that they may educate them, that they may see them grown, the little ones to whom they used to show affection. To name human hope by life itself, which is, as it were, more natural, and more excusable, and sadder. For there are many vulgar hopes, very reprehensible; but let us hold to this one, which is civil and natural. For to this end each person is born, that he may grow, that he may be joined in marriage, that he may beget children, that he may educate them, that he may even be called the father of children. What more does he seek? And his hope is not yet ended. He desires to join his sons to wives, and still he hopes. And when he has obtained this too, he desires grandchildren. And when he has these, behold now there is a third succession, and the old man is sluggish about giving place to the children. Still he seeks what to wish for himself, he seeks what to hope for, and he seems benevolent. \"Would that,\" he says, \"that boy would call me grandfather, and I might hear this from his own mouth, and die!\" The boy grows, he calls him grandfather, and he does not yet recognize himself as a grandfather. Surely, if he is a grandfather, if he is an old man, why does he not acknowledge that he ought now to depart, so that those who have been born may succeed him?","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":212,"ref":"p212","source":"Et cum audierit a voce parvuli honoris nomen, vult illum ipse erudire. Numquid deest, ut speret et pronepotem? Sic moritur, et sperat, et sperat aliud atque aliud, cum illud, quod sperabat, acceperit. Sed accipiendo, quod sperabat, non satiatur, inhiat in aliis. Quare venerat, quod sperabas? Certe jam, ut finias, quo pergis. Non finis extenditur. Et quantos fallit haec Spes, Spes trita! Primo non satiat, cum venerit, et quantis non venit! Quanti speraverunt uxores, et ducere non potuerunt! Quanti speraverunt, cum quibus eis bene esset, et duxerunt, a quibus cruciarentur! Quam multi optaverunt filios, et suscipere nequiverunt! Quam multi de susceptis malis gemuerunt! Sic omnia. Speravit aliquis divitias; non adeptis cruciatus est cupiditate, aut adeptis tortus timore· Et nemo est, qui sperare desinat, nullus satiatur. Tam multi falluntur, et ab spe saeculi non quiescunt.","english":"And when he has heard from the voice of a little child the name of honor, he wishes himself to instruct him. Is there any lack, that he should hope even for a great-grandson? Thus he dies, and he hopes, and he hopes now one thing, now another, when he has received what he was hoping for. But by receiving what he hoped for, he is not satisfied; he gapes after other things. Why had what you were hoping for come? Surely now, so that you may end, where are you going? The end is not extended. And how many this Hope deceives, a worn-out Hope! First, it does not satisfy when it has come, and how many it does not come to! How many hoped for wives, and could not marry! How many hoped for those with whom it would go well for them, and married those by whom they would be tormented! How many desired sons, and could not beget them! How many groaned over sons they had received, to their harm! So it is with all things. Someone hoped for riches; when he had not obtained them, he was tortured by desire, or when he had obtained them, he was racked by fear. And there is no one who ceases to hope; no one is satisfied. So many are deceived, and they do not rest from the hope of the world.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":213,"ref":"p213","source":"Sit aliquando et Spes nostra non fallax, sed satians, et aliquid tam bonum, ut amplius esse non possit. Quae est ergo res, quam speramus, quae cum venerit, cessabit Spes, quia succedet res. Quid est illud? Terra est? Non. Aliquid, quod in terra nascitur, sicut aurum, argentum, arbor, seges, aqua? Nihil horum. Aliquid, quod in aere volitet? Abhorret anima. Numquid forte coelum est, tam speciosum, ornatumque luminibus? Quid enim in his rebus visibilibus delectabilius, quid pulchrius? Neque hoc est. Et quid est? Delectant ista, pulchra sunt ista, bona sunt ista. Quaere, qui fecit. Ipse est Spes tua. Ipse est modo Spes tua, ipse erit postea res tua. Spes est credentis, res erit videntis. Dic ei: Spes mea es tu. Bene enim modo dicis: Spes mea es tu. Credis enim, nondum vides. Promittitur tibi, nondum tenes. Quandiu es in corpore, peregrinaris a Domino, in via es, nondum in patria. Ipse rector, et conditor patriae via factus est, ut te perducat. Dic ergo illi modo: Spes mea es tu. Quid postea? Portio mea in terra viventium (Psal. cxiii, 6). Quae modo Spes tua est, postea erit portio tua. Sit Spes tua in terra morientium, et erit portio tua in terra viventium. Conversi ad Dominum, etc.","english":"Let our Hope be at some time not deceptive but satisfying, and something so good that it cannot be greater. What then is the thing we hope for, which when it has come will cause hope to cease, because the thing itself will succeed it? What is that? Is it earth? No. Something that is born on earth, like gold, silver, a tree, a crop, water? None of these. Something that flies in the air? The soul recoils from it. Is it perhaps heaven, so beautiful and adorned with lights? For what among these visible things is more delightful, what more beautiful? Nor is it this. And what is it? These things delight, these things are beautiful, these things are good. Seek the one who made them. He himself is your Hope. He himself is now your Hope, he himself will afterward be your possession. Hope belongs to the one who believes; the possession will belong to the one who sees. Say to him: You are my Hope. For now you say well: You are my Hope. For you believe, you do not yet see. It is promised to you, you do not yet hold it. As long as you are in the body, you are a stranger from the Lord, you are on the way, not yet in the homeland. He himself, the ruler and founder of the homeland, became the way, so that he might lead you there. Say to him, then, now: You are my Hope. What afterward? My portion in the land of the living. What is now your Hope will afterward be your portion. Let your Hope be in the land of the dying, and it will be your portion in the land of the living. Turned to the Lord, etc.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":214,"ref":"p214","source":"SERMO XXIII.\n\nDe verbis Psalmi cxlv, vers. 1. Laudabo Dominum in vita mea, etc..\n\nSYNOPSIS.\n\nI. Dei laus producenda ultra hanc vitam. II. Nihil in hac vita diu. III. Christiano non imponat felicitas transitoria. IV. Extrema Divitis et Lazari nos erudiant.\n\nDe verbis istius Psalmi, quem modo cantavimus, donet Dominus, ut vobis loqui valeamus. Diximus enim: Laudabo Dominum in vita mea. Psallam Deo meo, quandiu vivo. (Psal. cxlv, 1). Quibus verbis hoc primo admoneamus Charitatem Vestram, ne, cum auditis, vel dicitis: Quandiu vivo, psallam Deo meo; existimetis, cum haec vita finita fuerit, finiri nobis laudem Dei. Magis enim tunc laudabimus, quando sine fine vivemus. Si enim laudamus in peregrinatione, unde transimus, quomodo laudabimus in domo, unde nunquam migrabimus? Sicut dicitur, et legitur, et canitur in alio Psalmo: Beati qui habitant in domo tua. In saecula saeculorum laudabunt te (Id. lxxxiii, 5). Ubi audis: In saecula saeculorum, finis nullus est, et vivere beata vita, ubi Deus sine dubitatione conspicitur, sine offensione amatur, sine fine laudatur. Prorsus hoc erit nostrum vivere, Deum videre, amare, laudare. Si ergo laudamus, quando credimus, quomodo laudabimus, cum viderimus. Quomodo laudabitur species, si sic laudatur fides. Dicit enim Apostolus: Quandiu enim sumus in corpore, peregrinamur a Domino. Per fidem enim ambulamus, et non per speciem (2 Cor. v, 6, 7).","english":"SERMON XXIII.\n\nOn the words of Psalm 145, verse 1: I will praise the Lord in my life, etc.\n\nSYNOPSIS.\n\nI. The praise of God is to be extended beyond this life. II. Nothing in this life is lasting. III. Transitory happiness must not impose upon the Christian. IV. The end of the rich man and of Lazarus instructs us.\n\nOn the words of this Psalm which we have just sung, may the Lord grant that we be able to speak to you. For we have said: I will praise the Lord in my life. I will sing to my God as long as I live. (Ps. 145:1). By these words let us first admonish Your Charity, that when you hear or say, \"As long as I live, I will sing to my God,\" you should not think that when this life has ended, our praise of God comes to an end. For we shall praise Him all the more then, when we shall live without end. For if we praise Him in our pilgrimage, from which we are passing through, how shall we praise Him in the home from which we shall never depart? As it is said, and read, and sung in another Psalm: Blessed are they who dwell in your house. They will praise you for ever and ever (Ps. 83:5). Where you hear \"for ever and ever,\" there is no end, and to live the blessed life, where God is seen without doubt, loved without offense, praised without end. In short, this will be our life: to see God, to love Him, to praise Him. If therefore we praise Him when we believe, how shall we praise Him when we see? How shall the sight be praised, if the faith is thus praised? For the Apostle says: For as long as we are in the body, we are away from the Lord. For we walk by faith, and not by sight (2 Cor. 5:6-7).","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":215,"ref":"p215","source":"Modo ergo per fidem, tunc per speciem. Modo credimus, quod non videmus, tunc videbimus, quod credebamus. Non confunditur, qui credit, quia verum est, quod videbit; Dominus autem noster prius in nobis aedificavit fidem, ubi, si merces fidei reddatur, non praepostere ante quaeratur.\n\nDicit aliquis: Cur ergo Psalmus dixit: Psallam Deo meo, quandiu vivo, et non dixit: Psallam Deo meo semper? Ubi enim dicitur: Quandiu vivo, quasi finis significatur, sed si non intelligatur. Si putas de hac vita dictum: Quandiu vivo, discute vitam istam, utrum sit diu. Quantumcumque hic vixeris, diu non est. Quomodo est diu, quod te non satiat? Dicit puer diu vixisse hominem, quem videt senem, sed cum pervenerit, quo ille pervenit, tunc videt, quam non fuerit diu. Prorsus sic volat aetas, ita in se momenta transcurrunt, ut videamus, nudiustertius fuisse nos pueros, heri juvenes, hodie senes. Ubi ergo putas de hac vita esse dictum: Quandiu vivo, psallam Deo meo, ideo, quia dixit: Quandiu vivo, ibi verax intellectus est, de hac vita non esse dictum, quia dixit: Quandiu. Nunquam enim diceret Veritas: Quandiu, de ista vita, ubi nihil est diu. Potuerunt hoc videre Sapientes hujus mundi, et non hoc possunt videre Christiani? Quidam Sapientum mundi eloquentissimus homo dixit: Quid est enim hoc omnino ipsum diu, in quo est aliquid extremum (Cicero, Orat. pro M. Marcello n. 28)?","english":"So now through faith, then through sight. Now we believe what we do not see; then we shall see what we were believing. He who believes is not put to shame, because what he will see is true; but our Lord first built faith in us, where, if the reward of faith is paid back, it is not sought out of order beforehand.\n\nSomeone says: Why, then, did the Psalm say, I will sing to my God as long as I live, and not say, I will sing to my God always? For where it says, As long as I live, a limit seems to be signified—but only if it is not understood. If you think that As long as I live was said of this life, examine this life, whether it is long. However long you live here, it is not long. How is it long, when it does not satisfy you? A boy says that a man has lived a long time, when he sees him old; but when the boy reaches the point the old man has reached, then he sees how it was not long. Indeed, so swiftly does age fly, so do the moments run past within it, that we see that the day before yesterday we were boys, yesterday young men, today old men. Where, then, do you think that As long as I live, I will sing to my God was said of this life? Because it said, As long as I live, the true understanding is there: it was not said of this life, because it said, As long as. For Truth would never say, As long as, of this life, where nothing is long. Could the wise men of this world see this, and Christians cannot see it? A certain most eloquent man among the wise of the world said: For what is this very thing, long, altogether, in which there is some extremity?","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":216,"ref":"p216","source":"Omnino negavit diu esse, quod ad finem quandocumque potuerit pervenire. Prorsus quandocumque, non quousque tu vixisti, si forte ad senectutem ultimam pervenisti. Unius enim hominis vita, praesertim hoc tempore, Vapor est ad modicum apparens. Hoc, quod dixi, Scriptura dixit exultantibus ho· minibus, et per superbiam multam pollentibus, et, an continuo moriantur, nescientibus. Scriptura divina dixit, et eos ita superbientes, et in vanis confidentes suae transitoriae fragilitatis admonuit. Quae est enim, inquit, vita vestra? Vapor est ad modicum apparens, deinceps exterminabitur (Jacob. iv, 15). Qui ergo se erigit in datione, confidit in vapore, extollitur in honore, et perit cum vapore. Reprimenda est ergo superbia, et quanta possumus, intentione calcanda, et intelligendum nos in hac terra mortaliter vivere, et cogitandum esse de fine, ubi non erit finis. Homo enim, si tu, ut dicere coeperam, quicumque senuisti, valde extolleris, si putas te diu vixisse, qui aliquando finiturus es, sed ipse Adam, si adhuc viveret, et non modo, sed in fine saeculi moreretur, nihil haberet diu, in quo aliquid esset extremum. Et verissime dictum est, et prudenter intellectum est, et verum esse non tantum praedicatur, sed etiam ab auditoribus agnoscitur.","english":"He absolutely denied that it is a long time, since it could reach its end at some time or other. Certainly at some time, not for as long as you have lived, if perhaps you have reached extreme old age. For the life of one man, especially at this time, is a vapor appearing for a little while. This, which I have said, Scripture said to exulting men, and to those powerful through great pride, and to those not knowing whether they will die at once. Divine Scripture said it, and admonished them thus exulting, and trusting in the vain things of their own transitory frailty. For what is, it says, your life? It is a vapor appearing for a little while, afterward it will be destroyed. Therefore he who exalts himself in giving, trusts in vapor, is lifted up in honor, and perishes with the vapor. Therefore pride must be restrained, and as much as we can, trampled down by intent, and it must be understood that we live mortally on this earth, and thought must be given to the end, where there will be no end. For man, if you, as I had begun to say, whoever you are who have grown old, are greatly exalted, if you think that you have lived a long time, you who are at some time to end, but Adam himself, if he were still living, and were to die not only now, but at the end of the world, would have nothing as a long time, in which there would be any extremity. And it has been most truly said, and wisely understood, and it is proclaimed not only to be true, but is also recognized by the hearers.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":217,"ref":"p217","source":"Referamus animum ad Psalmum, quem cantavimus, et inveniamus, quia ille non diceret: Psallam Deo meo, quandiu vivo, nisi de illa vita, ubi diu est. Si enim in ista vita ideo nihil diu, quia est aliquid extremum, non ad istam vitam desiderandam vocamur, quando Christiani efficimur. Non enim propterea Christiani efficimur, ut bene nobis sit in hac vita. Si enim propterea putaverimus nos fieri Christianos, ut hic nobis bene sit secundum vitam istam temporalem, secundum felicitatem volaticam, et vapoream, valde erramus, et nutabunt pedes nostri, videntes aliquem tanta dignitate pollere, ut emineat caeteris, cum quibus vivit, sanum esse corpore, ad senectutem decrepitam pervenire. Videt hoc Christianus pauper, ignobilis, in gemitibus quotidiano labore suspirans, et dicit forte apud semetipsum: Quid mihi prodest, quia Christianus sum factus. Numquid ideo melior sum, quam ille, qui non est? Quam ille, qui in Christum non credit? Quam ille, qui Deum meum blasphemat? Admonet eum Psalmus. Nolite fidere in principes. Quid te delectat flos foeni? Omnis caro foenum, Propheta loquitur, non solum loquitur, sed exclamat. Exclamavit illi Dominus. Exclama, inquit. Et respondit: Quid exclamabo? Omnis caro foenum, et omnis honor carnis, ut flos foeni. Foenum aruit. Flos decidit. Ergo totum periit? Absit. Verbum autem Domini manet in aeternum (Isai. xl, 6-8). Qu(??)d te delectat foenum?","english":"Let us turn our mind to the Psalm which we have sung, and let us find that he would not have said, \"I will sing to my God as long as I live,\" unless he meant that life where there is a long time. For if in this life there is nothing long, because there is always some end, then we are not called to desire this life when we become Christians. For we do not become Christians so that things may go well for us in this life. If we thought we became Christians so that things might go well for us here according to this temporal life, according to a fleeting and vaporous happiness, we are greatly mistaken, and our feet will waver when we see someone flourishing in such great dignity that he stands out above the others with whom he lives, sound in body, reaching decrepit old age. The poor Christian sees this, lowly, sighing in groans and daily labor, and perhaps says to himself: What does it profit me that I have become a Christian? Am I any better for that reason than the man who is not? Than the man who does not believe in Christ? Than the man who blasphemes my God? The Psalm admonishes him: Do not trust in princes. Why does the flower of the grass delight you? \"All flesh is grass,\" the Prophet says—not only says it, but cries it out. The Lord cried out to him: Cry out, he said. And he answered: What shall I cry out? \"All flesh is grass, and all the honor of the flesh is like the flower of the grass. The grass has withered. The flower has fallen.\" So has everything perished? Far be it. \"But the word of the Lord endures forever\" (Isa. 40:6-8). Why does the grass delight you?","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":218,"ref":"p218","source":"Ecce periit foenum. Vis non perire? Tene te ad verbum. Sic et in isto Psalmo. Attendebat enim forte Christianus pauper, humilis in Pagano forte divite ac potenti, attendebat florem foeni, et eligebat eum fortasse patronum habere magis, quam Deum. Hunc alloquitur Psalmus: Nolite fidere in principes, et in filios hominum, quibus non est salus (Psal. cxlv, 3). Ille continuo respondet: Numquid de isto dicit, cui est salus? Ecce sanus est. Hodie illum vegetum video. Ego magis assidue miser aegroto. Quid attendis ista, quae tibi placent, et quae te delectant? Non est salus. Exiet spiritus ejus, et revertetur in terram suam. Ecce tota salus, Vapor ad modicum apparens. Exiet spiritus ejus, et revertetur in terram suam. Transeant aliquot anni. Moveatur fluvius, sicut fieri solet. Per diversa transcurrens aliqua sepulcra mortuorum discerne ossa divitis ab ossibus pauperis. Exeunte spiritu suo revertitur in terram suam. Optime de spiritu ejus nihil dixit, quia et ille, cum viveret, nihil spiritualiter cogitavit. Revertetur in terram suam, secundum carnem utique, secundum corpus, ubi pollebat, ubi efferebatur, ubi te decipiebat, in cujus te carnis felicitate fallebat. Exiet spiritus ejus, et revertetur in terram suam. In illa die peribunt omnes cogitationes eorum (Ibid. 4). Cogitationes illae, quae terrenae erant: Ecce facio, ecce impleo, ecce pervenio.","english":"Behold, the hay has perished. Do you wish not to perish? Hold fast to the word. So too in this Psalm. For perhaps a poor Christian, humble, was paying attention to a rich and powerful pagan, was paying attention to the flower of the hay, and was perhaps choosing rather to have him as a patron than God. The Psalm addresses him: Put not your trust in princes, nor in the sons of men, in whom there is no salvation (Ps. 145:3). He immediately replies: Is he speaking, then, of this man, in whom there is salvation? Behold, he is well. Today I see him vigorous. I, wretched man, am sick more constantly. Why do you attend to these things which please you and delight you? There is no salvation. His spirit shall go forth, and he shall return to his own land. Behold, all his salvation, a vapor appearing for a little while. His spirit shall go forth, and he shall return to his own land. Let a few years pass. Let the river be moved, as is wont to happen. Running through various tombs of the dead, distinguish the bones of the rich man from the bones of the poor man. When his spirit goes forth, he returns to his own land. He said nothing at all about his spirit, and rightly so, because while he lived he thought nothing spiritually. He shall return to his own land—according to the flesh, certainly, according to the body, where he was strong, where he was puffed up, where he was deceiving you, in the felicity of whose flesh he was beguiling you. His spirit shall go forth, and he shall return to his own land. In that day all their thoughts shall perish (Ibid. 4)—those thoughts which were earthly: Behold, I do this; behold, I fulfill it; behold, I attain it.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":219,"ref":"p219","source":"Ecce illud emo, ecce illud acquiro, ecce ad talem et talem honorem pervenio. In illa die peribunt omnes cogitationes ejus. Si autem, quoniam Verbum Dei manet in aeternum, teneas te ad verbum, ut det tibi vitam aeternam, non solum cogitatio tua tunc non peribit, sed tunc venit. Quando illius perit, tua tunc venit. Ille enim cogitabat temporalia atque terrena, opes opibus addere, pecuniarias facultates exaggerare, nitere honoribus, tumere potentia. Ergo, quia talia cogitabat, In illa die peribunt omnes cogitationes ejus. Tu autem, si cogitabas, quia Christianus factus es, non temporalem felicitatem, sed requiem sempiternam, quando corpus tuum redierit ad terram suam, tunc invenit anima tua requiem suam.\n\nAttende Evangelium, et vide, atque inspice cogitationes duorum hominum. Erat quidem Dives, qui induebatur purpura et bysso, et epulabatur quotidie splendide (Luc. xvi, 19). Quotidie foenum, et flos foeni. Non te seducat illius felicitas, qui Induebatur purpura et bysso, et epulabatur quotidie splendide. Superbus erat, impius erat, vana cogitabat, vana concupiscebat. Quando mortuus est, in illa die perierunt cogitationes ejus. Erat autem ante januam ipsius quidam Pauper, nomine Lazarus. Tacuit nomen Divitis, et dixit nomen Pauperis. Cujus nomen ventilabatur, ipsius tacuit Deus. De cujus nomine silebatur, ipsum dixit Deus. Nolo, mireris.","english":"Behold, I buy that, behold, I acquire that, behold, I attain to such and such an honor. In that day all his thoughts shall perish. But if, because the Word of God endures forever, you hold fast to the word, so that it may give you eternal life, not only will your thought then not perish, but then it comes. When his perishes, then yours comes. For he was thinking of temporal and earthly things—to add wealth to wealth, to heap up financial resources, to shine in honors, to swell with power. Therefore, because he was thinking such things, In that day all his thoughts shall perish. But you, if you were thinking, because you have been made a Christian, not of temporal happiness but of everlasting rest—when your body has returned to its own earth, then your soul finds its own rest.\n\nAttend to the Gospel, and see, and examine the thoughts of two men. There was indeed a rich man, who was clothed in purple and fine linen, and feasted sumptuously every day (Luke 16:19). Every day hay, and the flower of hay. Let not his happiness deceive you, who was clothed in purple and fine linen, and feasted sumptuously every day. He was proud, he was impious, he thought vain things, he desired vain things. When he died, in that day his thoughts perished. But there was before his gate a certain poor man, named Lazarus. He kept silent the rich man's name, and he spoke the poor man's name. Whose name was being bandied about, God kept silent about. About whose name there was silence, God himself spoke it. I do not want you to marvel.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":220,"ref":"p220","source":"Deus, quod in Libro suo scriptum invenit, hoc recitavit. De impiis enim dictum est: Et in libro tuo non scribentur (Psal. lxviii, 29); itemque Apostolis, cum gloriarentur, quia in nomine Domini daemonia illis subjecta fuerant, ne de hac re sicut homines extollerentur, seseque jactarent, quamvis de re magna, quamvis de virtute praeclara: Nolite, inquit, in hoc gaudere, quia daemonia vobis subjecta sunt; sed gaudete, quia nomina vestra scripta sunt in coelo (Luc. x, 20). Deus enim inhabitator caeli tacuit nomen Divitis, quia scriptum non invenit in coelo; dixit tamen Pauperis, quia ibi scriptum invenit, imo ibi scribi jussit Sed videte illum Pauperem. Diximus enim de cogitationibus impii Divitis, praeclari, induentis purpuram et byssum, et epulantis quotidie splendide, quia, cum mortuus esset, perierunt omnes cogitationes ejus. Pauper autem Lazarus erat ante januam Divitis, Ulceribus plenus, et cupiebat saturari de micis, quae dejiciebantur de mensa Divitis, et nemo illi dabat. Sed et canes veniebant, et lingebant ulcera ejus (Id. xvi, 21). Ibi te volo videre, Christiane. Dicuntur enim exitus duorum istorum. Potens est quidem Deus, et in hac vita salutem dare, et egestatem auferre, et sufficientiam donare Christiano. Et tamen, si etiam hoc non esset, quid eligeres? Ut ille pauper esse, an, ut ille, dives esse? Non te fallat. Audi finem, et observa malam electionem.","english":"God recited what he found written in his book. For of the wicked it is said: And they shall not be written in your book (Ps. 68:29); and likewise to the Apostles, when they were rejoicing that demons had been subjected to them in the name of the Lord, lest they be puffed up over this matter like men and boast themselves, though it was a great matter, though it was a distinguished power: Do not, he says, rejoice in this, that demons are subjected to you; but rejoice that your names are written in heaven (Luke 10:20). For God, the inhabitant of heaven, kept silent the name of the Rich Man, because he did not find it written in heaven; yet he spoke the name of the Poor Man, because he found it written there—indeed, he commanded it to be written there. But look at that Poor Man. For we have spoken of the thoughts of the wicked Rich Man, the distinguished man, clothed in purple and fine linen and feasting sumptuously every day, that when he died all his thoughts perished. But the poor man Lazarus was at the Rich Man's gate, full of sores, and he longed to be filled with the crumbs that fell from the Rich Man's table, and no one gave to him. But even the dogs came and licked his sores (Luke 16:21). There I want you to look, Christian. For the outcomes of these two are told. God is indeed able both to give salvation in this life and to take away want and to grant sufficiency to a Christian. And yet, even if this were not so, what would you choose? To be that poor man, or to be that rich man? Do not let yourself be deceived. Hear the end, and observe the bad choice.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":221,"ref":"p221","source":"Sine dubio enim Pauper ille, quoniam pius erat, in aerumnis temporalibus constitutus finiendam quandoque illam vitam, et adipiscendam aeternam requiem cogitabat. Mortui sunt ambo, sed illius Pauperis non illa die perierunt cogitationes. Contigit enim mori inopem illum, et auferri ab Angelis in sinum Abrahae. in illa die sanatae sunt omnes cogitationes ejus. Et, quoniam Lazarus in latina lingua interpretatur Adjutus, qui in hebraea Lazarus, bene admonuit Psalmus: Beatus, cujus Deus Jacob adjutor ejus (Psal. cxlv, 5) Quando spiritus ejus exibit, et caro ejus revertetur in terram suam, non peribunt cogitationes ejus, Quia spes ejus in Domino Deo ejus. Hoc discitur in schola Christi doctoris, hoc speratur ab animo fidelis auditoris, haec est merces verissima Salvatoris.\n\nSERMO XXIV.\n\nDe verbis Evangelii Luc· xvi. vers· 19-31, Homo quidam erat dives, etc. ·","english":"Without doubt that poor man, because he was pious, when placed in temporal hardships, was thinking that this life would someday be ended and eternal rest obtained. Both died, but that poor man's thoughts did not perish on that day. For it happened that the destitute man died and was carried away by angels into Abraham's bosom. On that day all his thoughts were healed. And since Lazarus is interpreted in the Latin language as \"Helped\"—the one who is Lazarus in Hebrew—the Psalm well gave this reminder: Blessed is the man whose helper is the God of Jacob (Ps. 145:5). When his spirit departs and his flesh returns to its own earth, his thoughts shall not perish, because his hope is in the Lord his God. This is learned in the school of Christ the teacher, this is hoped for by the mind of the faithful hearer, this is the most true reward of the Savior.\n\nSERMON XXIV.\n\nOn the words of the Gospel of Luke 16:19–31, \"A certain man was rich,\" etc.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":222,"ref":"p222","source":"SYNOPSIS.\n\nI. Oraculis Propheticis de Christo, et ejus Ecclesia Judaei nondum credunt. II. Judaeorum incredulitas coarguitur exemplo divitis Epulonis· III. Dives Epulo salubre nobis exemplum, IV. Satis de futuris prae· moniti nullam excusationem habemus. V, Fides nostra confirmanda ex jam impletis, et ex promissis a Deo. VI. Dei promissa in Gente Judaeorum ex Abraham, cujus fides commendatur. VII. Dei in exolvendis promissis fidelitas, et insania Idololatrarum. VIII. Deus quaerit imaginem suam in anima, ut Caesar in nummo. IX· Quanta promissa Dei jam exoluta sint. X. Abrahae fides nobis exemplum. XI. De tolerandis adversis duplex similitudo. XII. Dei patientia nobis utendum est, et illa imitanda. XIII. Committere nos debemus Deo in adversis absque querela. XIV. Exhortatio ad patientiam.\n\nChristianorum fides, quae ab impiis et infidelibus irridetur, haec est, quia nos dicimus, esse aliam vitam post istam vitam, et esse a mortuis resurrectionem, et esse post transactum saeculum in fine judicium. Hoc cum in rebus humanis non crederetur, praedicaretur autem, et annuntiaretur a Prophetis servis Dei, et a Lege, quae per Moysen data est, et adhuc incredibile hominibus videretur, venit Dominus noster Jesus Christus, qui hoc hominibus persuaderet.","english":"SYNOPSIS\n\nI. The Jews do not yet believe the prophetic oracles concerning Christ and his Church. II. The unbelief of the Jews is refuted by the example of the rich man who feasted. III. The rich man who feasted is a salutary example for us. IV. Being sufficiently forewarned of future things, we have no excuse. V. Our faith must be confirmed both from things already fulfilled and from the promises of God. VI. God's promises in the Jewish people from Abraham, whose faith is commended. VII. God's faithfulness in fulfilling his promises, and the madness of idolaters. VIII. God seeks his image in the soul, as Caesar is sought on the coin. IX. How many promises of God have already been fulfilled. X. The faith of Abraham is an example for us. XI. A twofold comparison concerning enduring adversities. XII. We must make use of God's patience and imitate it. XIII. We must entrust ourselves to God in adversities without complaint. XIV. An exhortation to patience.\n\nThe faith of Christians, which is mocked by the impious and the unbelieving, is this: that we say there is another life after this life, and that there is a resurrection from the dead, and that after this age has passed there is a judgment at the end. Since this was not believed in human affairs, but was preached and announced by the Prophets, the servants of God, and by the Law which was given through Moses, and still seemed incredible to men, our Lord Jesus Christ came, to persuade men of this.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":223,"ref":"p223","source":"Qui cum sit Filius Dei natus de Patre invisibiliter, et ineffabiliter, coaeternus Patri, et aequalis Patri, et cum Patre unus Deus, cum sit Verbum Patris, per quod facta sunt omnia, et Consilium Patris, per quod reguntur omnia, tantam magnitudinem suam, et incomprehensibilem majestatem, ac potestatem, quae non poterat cognosci ab hominibus, deposuit ad terras accipiendo carnem, et apparendo oculis hominum. Cum ergo Deus, id est, ipsa Divinitas, in Christo non videretur, caro visa contemnebatur; ille autem interiorem suam Divinitatem miraculis approbabat. Et cum talis videretur, qui humanis oculis posset sperni, tantum faciebat, ut in ipsis operibus appareret Filius Dei. Cum ergo magna faceret, utilia praeciperet, corrigeret vitia, castigaret, virtutes doceret, sanitates etiam corporum operaretur, ut sanaret mentes infidelium, iratus populus, ubi est natus, et nutritus, et tanta ista fecit, occidit eum. Ille autem, qui nasci venerat, utique et mori venerat. Nec mortem carnis suae, quam propter exemplum demonstrandae resurrectionis acceperat, voluit esse infructuosam, sed permisit eam magis manibus impiorum, ut, cum illi nollent facere, quod jubebat, pateretur ille, quod volebat. Factum est.","english":"Since he is the Son of God, born of the Father invisibly and ineffably, coeternal with the Father and equal to the Father, and with the Father one God, since he is the Word of the Father, through whom all things were made, and the Counsel of the Father, through whom all things are governed, he laid aside his great magnitude and incomprehensible majesty and power, which could not be known by men, and came down to the earth by taking flesh and appearing to the eyes of men. Therefore, since God, that is, the very Divinity, was not seen in Christ, the flesh that was seen was despised; but he approved his inner Divinity by miracles. And since he appeared to be such a one as could be scorned by human eyes, he did such great things that in those very works the Son of God might appear. Therefore, since he did great things, taught useful things, corrected vices, chastised, taught virtues, and even worked healings of bodies, so that he might heal the minds of the unbelieving, the angry people killed him in the place where he was born and raised and did all these great things. But he who had come to be born had certainly also come to die. Nor did he wish the death of his flesh, which he had taken up for the example of demonstrating the resurrection, to be fruitless, but he rather permitted it to the hands of the wicked, so that, when they refused to do what he commanded, he might suffer what he willed. It was done.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":224,"ref":"p224","source":"Occisus est Christus, sepultus, resurrexit, ut novimus, ut testatur Evangelium, ut jam toto orbe praedicavit, et adhuc Judaei, videtis, quia nolunt credere in Christum, jam posteaquam resurrexit a mortuis, et glorificatus in oculis Discipulorum suorum ascendit in coelum, cum jam impleantur per totum orbem terrarum praeconia Prophetarum. Etenim omnes Prophetae, qui praenuntiaverunt Christum nasciturum, et moriturum, et resurrecturum, et in coelum ascensurum, praenuntiaverunt etiam Ecclesiam ejus per omnes gentes futuram. Judaei autem, si non viderunt Christum resurgentem, et ad coelum euntem, viderent saltem Ecclesiam toto orbe diffusam. quod utique cum impleretur, praedicta Prophetarum dicta implerentur.\n\nFit in illis, quod modo audivimus ex Evangelio. Ideo enim non audiunt Christum, qui a mortuis resurrexit, quia Christum in terra positum non audierunt. Hoc enim dixit Abraham illi Diviti, qui apud inferos torquebatur, et volebat aliquem mitti ad superos, ut fratribus ejus nuntiaret, quid agatur apud inferos, et antequam venirent ad loca illa tormentorum, viverent bene, agentes paenitentiam de peccatis suis, ut mererentur ire potius in sinum Abraham, non ad illa tormenta, quo Dives ille pervenit.","english":"Christ was killed, buried, and rose again, as we know, as the Gospel testifies, as he has already been preached throughout the whole world; and yet the Jews, as you see, refuse to believe in Christ, even now after he has risen from the dead and, glorified in the eyes of his disciples, has ascended into heaven, although the heralds' proclamations of the prophets are now being fulfilled throughout the whole world. For all the prophets who foretold that Christ would be born, and die, and rise again, and ascend into heaven, also foretold that his Church would exist among all nations. But the Jews, if they did not see Christ rising again and going up to heaven, would at least see the Church spread throughout the whole world; and when this was certainly being fulfilled, the words spoken beforehand by the prophets were being fulfilled.\n\nWhat we have just heard from the Gospel is happening in them. For the reason they do not hear Christ, who has risen from the dead, is that they did not hear Christ while he was placed on earth. For this is what Abraham said to that rich man who was being tormented in the underworld and wanted someone sent to the world above to announce to his brothers what is done in the underworld, and that before they came to those places of torments they should live well, repenting of their sins, so that they might deserve to go rather into Abraham's bosom, not to those torments into which that rich man came.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":225,"ref":"p225","source":"Cum ergo hoc ageret ille Dives sero misericors, qui Pauperem jacentem ante januam suam contempserat, et propterea forte superbus in illum erat, ipsa lingua ardebat, et ibi stillam aquae desiderabat, cum ergo non egisset apud superos, quod agendum illi erat, ne illuc veniret, sero coepit esse misericors pro aliis. Sed quid ait Abraham? Si Moysen et Prophetas non audiunt, neque, si quis a mortuis resurrexerit, persuadebit eis (Luc. xvi, 31). Omnino verum est, fratres. Ideo Judaeis hodie non persuadetur, ut credant in eum, qui resurrexit a mortuis, quia Moysen et Prophetas non audierunt. Nam si illos audire vellent, ibi invenirent praedictum esse, quod modo impletum est, et nolunt adhuc credere. Quod ergo de Judaeis diximus, de nobis agamus, ne cum alios attendimus, et nos in ipsam impietatem incidamus. Evangelium, charissimi, Judaeis non legitur, Moyses et Prophetae leguntur, quos nolunt audire. Quod si audire vellent, crederent in Christum, quia Moyses et Prophetae Christum venturum praedicaverunt. Non ergo nos tales simus, quando nobis legitur Evangelium, quales sunt illi, quando illis leguntur Prophetae. Apud ipsos enim, ut dixi, Evangelium non recitatur, apud nes recitatur.","english":"So then, when that rich man—merciful too late—was doing this, he who had despised the poor man lying before his gate, and for that reason was perhaps proud toward him, his very tongue was burning, and there he longed for a drop of water. Since, then, he had not done in the world above what he ought to have done, so as not to come to that place, he began too late to be merciful on behalf of others. But what does Abraham say? If they do not hear Moses and the Prophets, neither will they be persuaded if someone rises from the dead (Lk 16:31). This is entirely true, brothers. Therefore the Jews today are not persuaded to believe in him who rose from the dead, because they did not hear Moses and the Prophets. For if they were willing to hear them, they would find there foretold what has now been fulfilled, and they are still unwilling to believe. What, then, we have said about the Jews, let us apply to ourselves, lest while we attend to others, we ourselves fall into that very impiety. The Gospel, dearest ones, is not read to the Jews; Moses and the Prophets are read to them, and they are unwilling to hear them. But if they were willing to hear them, they would believe in Christ, because Moses and the Prophets proclaimed that Christ was to come. Let us not, then, be such as they are when the Prophets are read to them, when the Gospel is read to us. For among them, as I said, the Gospel is not recited; among us it is recited.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":226,"ref":"p226","source":"Ecce audistis modo ex Evangelio duas vitas: unam praesentem, alteram futuram. Praesentem habemus, futuram credimus. In praesenti sumus, ad futuram nondum pervenimus. Cum in praesenti sumus. futurae meritum comparemus; nondum enim mortui sumus. Numquid Evangelium apud inferos recitatur? Quod utique si recitaretur, frustra illud Dives audiret ret, quia jam fructuosa paenitentia esse non posset. Nobis ibi legitur, et ibi a nobis auditur, ubi dum vivimus corrigi possumus, ne ad illa tormenta veniamus. Credimus quod legitur, an non credimus? Absit ut hoc opinemur de Charitate Vestra, quia non creditis! Christiani enim estis, nec Christiani ullo modo essetis, si Evangelio Dei non crederetis. Quia ergo Christiani estis, manifestum est vos Evangelio credere. Audivimus. Modo recitatum est. Erat utique Dives superbus, utique extollens se divitiis, qui Induebatur purpura et bysso, et epulabatur quotidie splendide (Luc. xvi, 19), Jacebat autem ad januam ejus ulcerosus pauper quidam nomine Lazarus, cujus etiam ulcera canes lingebant, et cupiebat Saturari de micis, quae cadebant de mensa Divitis (Ibid, 21), et non poterat. Ecce crimen Divitis, quia utique de micis saturari cupiebat, et non poterat, cui participanda humanitas erat. Ille ergo Dives, si compateretur Pauperi ante januam suam jacenti, et vellet esse de divitiis illis misericors, illuc veniret et ipse, quo venit et ille Pauper.","english":"Behold, you have just now heard from the Gospel of the two lives: the one present, the other future. The present we have, the future we believe. We are in the present, we have not yet arrived at the future. Since we are in the present, let us acquire the merit of the future; for we have not yet died. Is the Gospel ever read aloud among the dead? If it were read there, the rich man would surely hear it in vain, because repentance could no longer be fruitful for him. It is read to us here, and here it is heard by us, where while we live we can be corrected, lest we come to those torments. Do we believe what is read, or do we not believe? Far be it from us to think this of Your Charity, that you do not believe! For you are Christians, and in no way would you be Christians if you did not believe the Gospel of God. Since, therefore, you are Christians, it is manifest that you believe the Gospel. We have heard it. It has just now been read aloud. There was that rich man, proud, exalting himself in his riches, who was clothed in purple and fine linen, and feasted sumptuously every day; and there lay at his gate a certain poor man full of sores, named Lazarus, whose sores even the dogs licked, and he longed to be filled with the crumbs that fell from the rich man's table, and he could not. Behold the crime of the rich man: that he longed to be filled with the crumbs and could not, when humanity should have been shared with him. That rich man, then, if he had pitied the poor man lying at his gate, and had wished to be merciful with those riches, would himself have come to the place where that poor man also came.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":227,"ref":"p227","source":"Non enim illum Lazarum paupertas duxit ad requiem et non humilitas, aut vero illum Divitem ab illa tanta requie divitiae retraxerunt, et non superbia et infidelitas. Nam, ut noveritis, fratres, quia apud superos Dives iste infidelis fuit, de verbis ipsius approbemus, quae dixit apud inferos. Intendite. Voluit aliquem a mortuis ire, ut nuntiaret fratribus ipsius, quid agatur apud inferos, et cum illi hoc non concederetur dicente Abraham: Habent Moysen, et Prophetas. Audiant illos. Non, pater Abraham, inquiens, sed, si quis hinc ab inferis ierit, persuadebuntur; ostendit, quia et ipse, cum esset apud superos, non credebat Moysi et Prophetis, sed aliquem surgere sibi a mortuis cupiebat. Attendite tales modo, et videte, ubi ex exemplo hujus Divitis admonemur, si fidem habetis. Quanti sunt, qui modo dicunt; Bene nobis sit, cum vivimus! Manducemus, et bibamus, et deliciis istis perfruamur! Quid est, quod nobis dicitur, quia erit postea? Quis huc inde rediit? Quis huc inde surrexit? Dicuntur haec. Hoc dicebat Dives ille, et, quod non credebat vivus, expertus est mortuus. Melius vivus fructuose corrigeretur, quam mortuus infructuose torqueretur!","english":"For it was not poverty that brought that Lazarus to rest, nor was it humility; nor indeed did his riches hold that rich man back from that great rest, but rather pride and unbelief. For, that you may know, brothers, that this rich man was an unbeliever while he was among the living, let us prove it from his own words, which he spoke in the underworld. Pay attention. He wanted someone to go from the dead to announce to his brothers what is done in the underworld, and when this was not granted him, with Abraham saying, \"They have Moses and the Prophets; let them hear them,\" he said, \"No, father Abraham, but if someone should go from here, from the underworld, they will be persuaded.\" He showed that he too, while he was among the living, did not believe Moses and the Prophets, but desired that someone rise from the dead for him. Consider such people now, and see where we are admonished by the example of this rich man, if you have faith. How many there are who now say, \"Let us enjoy ourselves while we live! Let us eat and drink, and enjoy these delights! What is this that is said to us, that there will be something afterward? Who has come back here from there? Who has risen here from there?\" These things are said. That rich man said this, and what he did not believe while alive, he experienced when dead. Better for a living man to be corrected fruitfully than for a dead man to be tormented fruitlessly!","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":228,"ref":"p228","source":"Nunc ergo mutemus verba ipsa, si quis forte in nobis est, qui haec solet dicere. Non enim ostendit Deus modo, quod nos jubet credere. Ideo illud non ostendit, ut merces sit fidei. Si enim ostendat tibi, quod meritum habes, quia credis! Non est jam credere, sed videre. Magis tibi hoc non ostendit Deus, ut credas. Imperat tibi, quod credas, servat tibi, quod videas. Sed si non credas, cum imperat fidem, speciem suam non tibi servat, sed illud tibi servatur, unde Dives ille apud inferos torquebatur. Et. cum venerit Dominus noster et Salvator Jesus Christus, qui sic annuntiatur modo venisse, ut speretur etiam esse venturus, veniet cum retributionibus fidelium, et infidelium: fidelibus praemia daturus, infideles in ignem aeternum missurus. Et dixit hoc in Evangelio. quomodo sit in fine judicaturus. Positurum se alios ad dexteram, alios ad sinistram, et discreturum omnes gentes, sicut pastor separat oves ab haedis; justos ad dexteram futuros, impios ad sinistram; justis se dicturum: Venite, benedicti Patris mei, percipite regnum, quod vobis paratum est ab initio mundi. Impiis autem et infidelibus: Ite in ignem aeternum, qui paratus est diabolo et angelis ejus (Matth. xxv, 41)! Quid tibi amplius potuit prodesse Judex, quam ut definitivam sententiam suam tibi diceret, ne in illam possis incurrere? Fratres, omnis qui minatur, non vult ferire. Nam, si subitaret, et feriret.","english":"Now therefore let us change those very words, if perhaps there is one among us who is accustomed to say these things. For God does not now show what he commands us to believe. For this reason he does not show it, so that it may be the reward of faith. For if he should show it to you, what merit do you have, because you believe? It is no longer believing, but seeing. Rather, God does not show this to you, so that you may believe. He commands you what you should believe; he reserves for you what you should see. But if you do not believe, when he commands faith, he does not reserve his appearance for you, but that is reserved for you, from which that rich man was tormented in hell. And when our Lord and Savior Jesus Christ comes—who is proclaimed now to have come in such a way that he is also hoped to be going to come—he will come with retributions for the faithful and the unfaithful: to give rewards to the faithful, to send the unfaithful into eternal fire. And he said this in the Gospel, how he will judge at the end: that he will place some at the right, others at the left, and will separate all nations, as a shepherd separates the sheep from the goats; the righteous will be at the right, the wicked at the left; to the righteous he will say: Come, blessed of my Father, receive the kingdom which has been prepared for you from the beginning of the world. But to the wicked and unfaithful: Go into eternal fire, which is prepared for the devil and his angels! What more could the Judge have done to profit you than to tell you his definitive sentence, so that you might not be able to fall into it? Brothers, everyone who threatens does not wish to strike. For if he were to strike suddenly, he would also strike.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":229,"ref":"p229","source":"Qui dicit: Observa; non vult invenire, quem feriat. Homines sibi plagas conciliant, homines sibi poenas comparant, qui tandiu dicenti Deo: Observate; nolunt credere. Et quidem errantis poena, quae hic est forte aliqua afflictio, et aliquod flagellum, aut emendatorium, aut probatorium est. Aut enim emendatur quisque pro peccatis suis, ne incidat in majores poenas non emendatus, aut probatur uniuscujusque fides, qua tolerantia, aut qua patientia sub flagello patris permaneat, non murmurans de patre castigante, et gaudens ad blandientem, sed ita gaudens ad blandientem, ut gratias agat et castiganti, quia Flagellat omnem filium, quem recipit (Hebr. xii, 6). Quanta Martyres passi sunt, quanta toleraverunt! Quas catenas, quos squallores, quos carceres, quos cruciatus, quas flammas, quas bestias, quae genera mortis! Calcaverunt omnia. Videbant enim aliquid spiritu, ut, quod videbant corpore, non curarent. Erat in illis oculus fidei, tendebatur oculus in futura, contemnebant praesentia. Cujus autem oculus de futuris extinctus est, expavescit ad praesentia, et non pervenit ad futura.","english":"He who says, \"Observe,\" does not wish to find the one he may strike. Men draw blows upon themselves, men procure punishments for themselves, who for so long refuse to believe God when he says, \"Observe.\" And indeed the punishment of the erring, which here is perhaps some affliction and some scourge, is either corrective or testing. For either each one is corrected for his sins, lest, uncorrected, he fall into greater punishments, or the faith of each is tested—with what endurance, or with what patience, he remains under the scourge of the Father, not murmuring against the Father who chastises, and rejoicing toward him who caresses—but so rejoicing toward him who caresses that he gives thanks also to him who chastises, because \"he scourges every son whom he receives\" (Heb 12:6). How much the Martyrs suffered, how much they endured! What chains, what squalor, what prisons, what tortures, what flames, what beasts, what kinds of death! They trampled all things underfoot. For they saw something in the spirit, so that they did not care for what they saw with the body. The eye of faith was in them, the eye was stretched out toward things to come, they despised things present. But whose eye has been extinguished toward things to come, he is terrified at things present, and does not arrive at things to come.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":230,"ref":"p230","source":"Est ergo fides, quae aedificatur in nobis. Modo, quicumque non vult credere, quia natus est Christus de Maria Virgine, quia passus est, quia crucifixus est, credat Judaeis, quia fuit, et occisus est, credat Evangelio, quia de Virgine natus est, et resurrexit. Est enim, unde credat. Et inimici Judaei non audent dicere: Non fuit Christus in gente nostra, aut: Non fuit iste homo, nescio quis, quem colunt Christiani. Fuit, dicunt, et parentes nostri occiderunt illum, et mortuus est, ut homo. Si ea, quae consecuta sunt mortem ipsius, invenimus dicta a Prophetis, quia in nomine ejus cursurus erat totus mundus, quia adoraturae illum erant omnes gentes, et omnes patriae gentium, quia omnes etiam reges sub jugum ipsius mittendi erant, et videmus impleta post mortem Christi, quae praedicta erant ante nativitatem Christi, quomodo nos fallimus, si caetera credere nolumus, cum videamus in nobis multa impleta? Nos enim ipsi, fratres, non soli nos, qui hic sumus Christiani, nos totus mundus sumus modo. Ante paucos annos non eramus, et mirum est, quomodo factum sit, ut, quod per tot saecula non erant, modo sint. Legimus illud in Prophetis. Ne putemus casu evenisse, invenimus praedictum esse. Hinc enim augetur fides nostra, hinc aedificatur, hinc confortatur. Nemo est, qui dicat: Subito accidit. Unde? Ecce hoc, quod nunquam fuit in terra.","english":"Faith, then, is what is built up in us. Now, whoever is unwilling to believe that Christ was born of Mary the Virgin, that he suffered, that he was crucified, let him believe the Jews, that he existed and was killed; let him believe the Gospel, that he was born of the Virgin and rose again. For he has grounds for believing. And the hostile Jews do not dare to say, \"Christ was not among our people,\" or, \"That man, whoever he was, whom the Christians worship, did not exist.\" He existed, they say, and our parents killed him, and he died as a man. If we find that the things which followed his death were spoken by the Prophets—that the whole world was to run in his name, that all nations were to worship him, and all the lands of the nations, that all kings too were to be brought under his yoke—and we see fulfilled after the death of Christ what had been foretold before the birth of Christ, how do we deceive ourselves if we are unwilling to believe the rest, when we see many things fulfilled among us? For we ourselves, brothers—not only we who are Christians here, but we are the whole world now. A few years ago we did not exist, and it is a wonder how it came about that what did not exist through so many ages now exists. We read that in the Prophets. Lest we think it happened by chance, we find that it was foretold. For from this our faith is increased, from this it is built up, from this it is strengthened. There is no one who can say, \"It happened suddenly.\" From where? Behold this, which was never on the earth.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":231,"ref":"p231","source":"Nonnunquam in Scripturis debitor in illis Deus tenebatur, sed tempore suo debitum redditurus. Unde autem debebat Deus? An ab aliquo mutuum acceperat, qui omnibus omnia insuper donat? Qui fecit, quibus donaret? Non enim vel ipsi homines, quibus aliqua donarentur, erant. Potest aliquis dicere: Meritis meis Deus concessit haec bona? Puta, concessit meritis tuis bona ista. Ut esses, cui concessit? Qui non eras, quid tibi donavit? Ut esses gratis. Non enim promerueras illud, antequam esses. Crede ei, quia et caetera gratis tibi donare dignatus est. Habemus ergo gratiam Dei, et tenebat Deum quodam modo debitorem mundus totus. Imo non tenebat, quia cautionem, quam fecerat, nesciebat. Promittendo se fecit debitorem, non mutuum accipiendo. Nam duobus modis dicitur debitor: Redde, quod accepisti, aut quod promisisti. Quia, quod promisit Deus, non potest dici: Redde; nihil enim ab homine accepit, qui totum homini dedit; restat ut debitor non sit, nisi quia polliceri dignatus est.","english":"At times in the Scriptures God was held as a debtor to them, but in his own time he would repay the debt. But from whom was God owing? Had he received a loan from anyone, he who besides gives all things to all? He who made them, to whom would he give? For not even were the very men, to whom certain things were to be given, in existence. Can someone say: \"God granted these good things to me because of my merits\"? Suppose he granted these good things to you because of your merits—so that you might exist, to whom did he grant them? What did he give to you, who were not? That you might exist was free. For you had not earned that before you existed. Believe him, because he has deigned also to give you the rest freely. We have, then, the grace of God, and the whole world was in a certain manner holding God as a debtor. No, rather it was not holding him, because it did not know the bond that he had made. By promising he made himself a debtor, not by receiving a loan. For a debtor is spoken of in two ways: \"Repay what you received,\" or \"what you promised.\" Because, as for what God promised, it cannot be said: \"Repay\"; for he received nothing from man, who gave all things to man; it remains that he is a debtor only because he deigned to promise.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":232,"ref":"p232","source":"Haec pollicitatio in Scripturis erat, haec Scripturae in una gente Judaea, quam elegit nasci de carne servi sui, fidelis sui, qui in illum credidit. Et quomodo gens illa nata est? De Abraham sene, et de Sara sterili. Ut parturiretur, ut nasceretur ipse Isaac, unde venit gens Judaeorum, miraculum fuit (Gen. xvii et xxi). Nihil de membris suis senex sperabat, nihil de sterilitate conjugis suae optare audebat. Quod omnino non computabat, Deus illi obtulit, et offerenti Deo credidit, qui a Deo optare non ausus est. Et cum credidisset, et natus ei esset filius, de quo credidit, nascituram innumeram prolem, petiit Deus ipsum filium immolari sibi (Id. xxii). Tantae autem fidei fuit Abraham, ut non dubitaret immolare unicum, de quo acceperat promissum. Numquid haesitavit, et dixit Deo: Domine, pro magno mihi concessisti Filium in senectute, pro magnis votis, pro magna laetitia, insperato mihi natus est filius. Hunc exigis, ut occidam? Nonne melius erat, ut non dares, quam ut datum auferres? Non haec dixit, sed credidit utile esse, quidquid Deum videbat velle. Haec est fides, fratres. Certe Pauper ille in sinum Abrahae sublatus est, et Dives ille ad tormenta inferorum. Ut sciatis non in culpa esse divitias, Abraham dives erat, in cujus sinu Lazarus requiescebat. Dives hic erat in terra: sicut habemus docentem Scripturam. Habebat multum auri, argenti, pecorum, familiae.","english":"This promise was in the Scriptures, the Scriptures concerning one nation, Judea, which he chose to be born from the flesh of his servant, his faithful one, who believed in him. And how was that nation born? From Abraham, an old man, and from Sarah, a barren woman. That Isaac himself should be conceived and born, from whom the nation of the Jews came, was a miracle. The old man hoped for nothing from his own members, he did not dare to wish anything from his wife's barrenness. What he did not reckon on at all, God offered to him, and he believed God when he offered it, he who had not dared to wish for it from God. And when he had believed, and a son had been born to him, concerning whom he believed that a countless offspring would be born, God asked that this very son be sacrificed to him. But Abraham was of such great faith that he did not hesitate to sacrifice his only son, concerning whom he had received the promise. Did he waver and say to God: Lord, you granted me a son in my old age as a great gift, in answer to great prayers, for great joy; a son was born to me beyond hope. Do you demand that I kill him? Would it not have been better not to give him than to take away what was given? He did not say these things, but believed that whatever he saw God will was profitable. This is faith, brothers. To be sure, that poor man was carried up into Abraham's bosom, and that rich man into the torments of hell. So that you may know that riches are not a fault: Abraham was rich, in whose bosom Lazarus rested. This man was rich on earth, as we have the Scripture teaching. He had much gold, silver, flocks, and household.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":233,"ref":"p233","source":"Dives erat, sed superbus non erat. Ut noveritis, quia in divite sola torquebatur superbia, sola torquebantur vitia, Ipsa meruerant poenam, non substantia Dei. Substantia enim Dei bona cuicumque datum fuerit. Sed bene utenti merces acquiritur, male utenti poena retribuitur. Attendite autem, quomodo habebat Abraham divitias. Numquid filiis suis servabat? Si ipsum filium jubente Deo obtulit, divitias quomodo contempsit?\n\nErgo haec Scriptura, ubi se Deus promittendo fecerat debitorem, latebat apud Judaeos. Venit Dominus noster Jesus Christus, secundum ipsam Scripturam natus, quia secundum ipsam redditus. Secundum ipsam Scripturam passus, quia in ipsa praenuntiatus passurus. Secundum ipsam Scripturam resurgens, quia in ipsa praenuntiatus resurrecturus. Secundum ipsam Scripturam ascendens in coelum, quia in ipsa praenuntiatus ascensurus. Posteaquam ascendit ignoratus a Judaeis, coepit mittere Apostolos suos ad gentes, et quodam modo excitare dormientes, et dicere? Surgite, recipite debitum, quod olim vobis promissum est! Quis est, qui excitat creditorem suum, et offert illi quod debet? Non enim gentes, quia debitorem habebant Deum, surrexerunt. Vocatae sunt, in Scripturam intendere coeperunt, et ibi invenire, quia, quod accipiebant, jam olim ipsis promissum erat.","english":"He was rich, but he was not proud. So that you may know that in the rich man only pride was tormented, only vices were tormented—these had deserved punishment, not God's substance. For God's substance is good to whomever it is given. But to one who uses it well a reward is acquired; to one who uses it badly a penalty is repaid. Attend, then, to how Abraham possessed riches. Did he perhaps keep them for his sons? If he offered his own son at God's command, how did he despise riches?\n\nTherefore this Scripture, in which God by promising had made himself a debtor, lay hidden among the Jews. Our Lord Jesus Christ came, born according to that same Scripture, because according to it he was rendered. He suffered according to that same Scripture, because in it he had been foretold as about to suffer. He rose according to that same Scripture, because in it he had been foretold as about to rise. He ascended into heaven according to that same Scripture, because in it he had been foretold as about to ascend. After he ascended, unknown to the Jews, he began to send his Apostles to the nations, and in a certain manner to rouse the sleeping and to say: Rise, receive the debt that was once promised to you! Who is it that rouses his own creditor and offers him what he owes? For the nations did not rise because they had God as a debtor. They were called; they began to attend to the Scripture, and to find there that what they were receiving had already long ago been promised to them.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":234,"ref":"p234","source":"Acceperunt Christum promissum, et exhibitum, acceperunt gratiam Dei, Spiritum sanctum promissum, et exhibitum, acceperunt ipsam Ecclesiam per omnes gentes, dispersam, promissam, et exhibitam. Idola, quae colebant gentes, promiserat Deus se eversurum. Legitur in Scripturis; ibi illud invenis (Isai. ii, 18; Ezech. vi, 6; et Mich. i, 7). Videtis quemadmodum hoc temporibus nostris fecit Deus, quod ante tot millia annorum promisit. Etenim converterant se homines ab eo, a quo facti erant, ad illud, quod ipsi fecerant. Et cum sit semper melior, qui facit, quam illud, quod facit, ideo melior est Deus non solum homine, quem fecit, sed omnibus Angelis, Virtutibus, Potestatibus, Sedibus, Thronis, Dominationibus, quia omnia ipse condidit (Ephes. i, 21; et Coloss. i, 16), ut sit inferius, quidquid facit homo, quam est ipse homo. Ad tantam dementiam ducti erant homines, ut adorarent idolum, qui damnare deberent. Si adorarent fabrum, qui fecerat idolum, manifestum est, fratres, quia faber melior, quam idolum, quod fecit. Et cum detestandi essent homines, si fabrum adorarent, ipsum idolum adorant, quod factum est fabro. Detestandi essent adorando fabrum, sed meliores essent, quam qui adorant idolum. Si ergo damnantur meliores, quomodo plango pejores?","english":"They received Christ promised and manifested; they received the grace of God, the Holy Spirit promised and manifested; they received the Church herself, scattered through all nations, promised and manifested. God had promised that he would overturn the idols that the nations worshiped. It is read in the Scriptures; there you find it (Isa. 2:18; Ezek. 6:6; and Mic. 1:7). You see how in our times God has done what he promised so many thousands of years beforehand. For men had turned away from him by whom they were made, to that which they themselves had made. And since the one who makes is always better than that which he makes, God is therefore better not only than man, whom he made, but than all Angels, Virtues, Powers, Seats, Thrones, Dominations, because he himself created all things (Eph. 1:21; and Col. 1:16), so that whatever man makes is lower than man himself is. Men had been led to such great madness as to adore an idol, which they ought to condemn. If they adored the craftsman who had made the idol, it is clear, brothers, that the craftsman is better than the idol he made. And although men would be detestable if they adored the craftsman, they adore the idol itself, which was made by the craftsman. They would be detestable for adoring the craftsman, but they would be better than those who adore an idol. If, then, the better are condemned, how do I bewail the worse?","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":235,"ref":"p235","source":"Si vero adorantem fabrum damnandum esse dixi, qui dimittit fabrum, et adorat idolum, qui utique meliorem dimisit, ad inferiorem se contulit, quomodo damnandus est? Sed quem meliorem primo dimisit? Deum a quo ipse factus est. Imaginem Dei quaerit. In se habet. Non enim potuit facere faber imaginem Dei, sed Deus potuit facere imaginem sibi. Non fecit autem aliud tibi, sed te ipsum fecit ad imaginem suam· Adorando autem imaginem hominis, quam fecit faber, conteris imaginem Dei, quam tibi impressit Deus. Ideo, cum te vocat, ut redeas, reddere tibi vult illam imaginem, qua tu ipse cupiditate terrena quodam modo confricando perdidisti, et obsoletasti.\n\nInde est, fratres, quod imaginem suam a nobis quaerit Deus. Hoc commemorat Judaeos illos, quando illi obtulerunt nummum. Primo enim tentare illum voluerunt, cum dicerent: Domine, licet tributum dare Caesari (Matth, xxii, 17)? ut, si diceret ille: Licet; calumniarentur illi, quia in maledicto vellet esse Israel, quem volebat esse tributarium, ut subjugatus esset Regi, ut daret tributa. Si autem diceret: Non licet reddere tributa; calumniarentur illi, quia contra Caesarem praeciperet, et auctor esset, ut non redderent tributum suum, quod debebant, quia subjugati erant. Vidit tentantes, tanquam veritas falsitatem, et convicit breviter mendacium ex ore mentientium.","english":"But if I said that the craftsman who worships is to be condemned, how is the man to be condemned who dismisses the craftsman and worships the idol—the man who has in fact dismissed the better and betaken himself to the worse? But whom did he first dismiss, the better one? God, by whom he himself was made. He seeks the image of God. He has it in himself. For the craftsman could not make the image of God, but God could make an image for himself. Yet he did not make something else for you, but he made you yourself in his own image. But by worshiping the image of a man, which the craftsman made, you trample underfoot the image of God, which God impressed upon you. Therefore, when he calls you to return, he wishes to restore to you that image which you yourself have lost and worn away by a kind of rubbing of earthly desire.\n\nThis is why, brothers, God seeks his image from us. He recalls this in the case of those Jews, when they brought him a coin. For first they wished to test him, when they said: Lord, is it lawful to give tribute to Caesar? so that, if he should say, It is lawful, they might slander him, because he wished to be under a curse—Israel, which he wished to be tributary, so that it might be subject to the king and pay tribute. But if he should say, It is not lawful to pay tribute, they might slander him, because he would be commanding against Caesar and would be the author of their not paying their tribute, which they owed, since they were subject. He saw those testing him, truth as it were confronting falsehood, and briefly convicted the lie from the mouth of those who were lying.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":236,"ref":"p236","source":"Non enim dixit in illos sententiam, ex ore suo, sed fecit, ut illi in se dicerent sententiam, quia scriptum est: Ex ore tuo justificaberis, et ex ore tuo damnaberis (Id. xii, 37). Quid me, inquit, tentatis? Hypocritae, ostendite mihi nummum. Ostenderunt. Cujus ait, habet imaginem, et inscriptionem? Responderunt: Caesaris. Et ille: Reddite ergo Caesari, quod Caesaris est, et Deo, quod Dei est (Id. xxii, 18-21). Sicut Caesar quaerit imaginem suam in nummo tuo, sic quaerit Deus imaginem suam in animo tuo. Redde Caesari, ait, quae Caesaris sunt. Quid a te quaerit Caesar? Imaginem suam. Quid a te quaerit Deus? Imaginem suam. Sed Caesaris in nummo est. Dei imago in te est. Si quando nummum perdis, plangis quia imaginem Caesaris perdidisti. Quando adoras idolum, non plangis, quia injuriam facis in te imagini Dei?\n\nTenete ergo, fratres, pollicitationem Domini Dei nostri, et numerate jam ex illo numero pollicitationum suarum, quanta reddidit. Christus nondum erat natus. In Scriptura erat promissus. Reddidit illum. Natus est. Nondum erat passus, nondum resurrexerat. Et hoc reddidit. Passus, crucifixus, resurrexit. Passio ipsius praemium nostrum est. Sanguis ipsius redemptio nostra est. Ascendit in coelum, sicut promiserat. Et hoc reddidit. Misit Evangelium per omnes terras.","english":"For he did not pronounce sentence against them from his own mouth, but brought it about that they pronounced sentence against themselves, because it is written: Out of your own mouth you will be justified, and out of your own mouth you will be condemned (Id. xii, 37). Why, he says, do you test me, hypocrites? Show me a coin. They showed him one. Whose, he says, does it have the image and inscription? They answered: Caesar's. And he said: Render therefore to Caesar what is Caesar's, and to God what is God's (Id. xxii, 18-21). Just as Caesar seeks his image on your coin, so God seeks his image in your soul. Render to Caesar, he says, what is Caesar's. What does Caesar seek from you? His image. What does God seek from you? His image. But Caesar's is on the coin. God's image is in you. If at some point you lose a coin, you lament because you have lost the image of Caesar. When you worship an idol, do you not lament, because you do injury to the image of God within yourself?\n\nHold fast, then, brothers, to the promise of the Lord our God, and count now, from that number of his promises, how many he has fulfilled. Christ had not yet been born. He had been promised in Scripture. He fulfilled it. He was born. He had not yet suffered, had not yet risen. And this too he fulfilled. He suffered, was crucified, rose again. His passion is our reward. His blood is our redemption. He ascended into heaven, as he had promised. And this too he fulfilled. He sent the Gospel through all the lands.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":237,"ref":"p237","source":"Ideo quatuor Evangelia esse voluit, ut significaretur quaternario numero totus orbis terrarum, ab Oriente et Occidente, ab Aquilone et Meridiano. Ideo duodecim Discipulos habere voluit, ut terni quodam modo per quatuor distributi videantur, quia in Trinitate vocatus est mundus, in Patre, et Filio, et Spiritu sancto. Reddidit hoc. Misit Evangelium, sicut praedixit. Quam speciosi pedes evangelizantium eorum, qui annuntiant pacem, evangelizantium bona (Rom. x, 15)! Sicut praedixit: Non sunt sermones, neque verba, quorum non audiantur voces eorum. Per omnem terram exivit sonus eorum, et in fines orbis terrae verba eorum (Psal. xviii, 4, 5). Quomodo dixit, sic misit. Evangelium per omnes terras scribitur. Etiam Ecclesia persecutionem primo passa est. Reddidit, quia et Martyres promiserat. Recita cautionem: Pretiosa in conspectu Domini mors justorum ejus (Psal. cxv, 15). Reddidit etiam Martyres, quia et ipsos promiserat. Quid postea reddendum erat? Adorabunt in conspectu ejus omnes reges terrae (Id. lxxi, 11). Crediderunt et reges, qui primo persequendo Martyres fecerant. Videmus ergo et modo reges credidisse. Reddidit etiam, quod promiserat, ut jubentibus regibus idola frangerentur, quibus primo jubentibus Christiani occidebantur. Abstulit etiam idola, quia promiserat: Et in idolis nationum non erit respectus (Sap. xiv, 1).","english":"Therefore he willed that there be four Gospels, so that by the number four the whole world might be signified, from East and West, from North and South. Therefore he willed that there be twelve Disciples, so that in a certain manner they might be seen distributed three by three through four, because the world has been called in the Trinity, in the Father, and the Son, and the Holy Spirit. This he fulfilled. He sent the Gospel, just as he foretold. How beautiful are the feet of those who bring good news, who proclaim peace, who bring good news of good things (Rom 10:15)! As he foretold: There are no speeches, nor words, whose voices are not heard. Through all the earth their sound has gone forth, and to the ends of the world their words (Ps 18:4-5). As he said, so he sent. The Gospel is written through all lands. The Church also first suffered persecution. He fulfilled it, because he had also promised Martyrs. Read the guarantee: Precious in the sight of the Lord is the death of his saints (Ps 115:15). He also fulfilled the Martyrs, because he had promised them as well. What was to be fulfilled afterwards? All the kings of the earth will adore in his sight (Ps 71:11). Kings also believed, who at first by persecuting had made Martyrs. We see therefore that even now kings have believed. He also fulfilled what he had promised, that at the command of kings idols would be broken, at whose command Christians were first killed. He also took away idols, because he had promised: And among the idols of the nations there will be no regard (Wis 14:1).","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":238,"ref":"p238","source":"Cum tanta ergo reddiderit, fratres, quare non illi credimus? Minus idoneus debitor est Deus? Si omnino nihil adhuc nobis reddidisset, idoneum debitorem tenebamus, qui fecit coelum et terram. Non enim pauper futurus erat, ut non haberet, unde redderet, aut fallit, cum ipse sit Veritas, aut tanta potestas est Deus, cui possit succedi, ut non habeat tempus reddendi?\n\nJustum est, fratres, ut credatur Deo, antequam aliquid reddat, quia utilibet mentiri non potest, fallere non potest. Deus est. Sic illi crediderunt Patres nostri. Abraham sic illi credidit. Ecce vere laudanda fides, et praedicanda. Nihil ab illo acceperat, et credidit promittenti. Nos nondum credimus, qui tanta jam accepimus. Numquid poterat illi dicere Abraham: Credam, quia illud mihi promisisti, et reddidisti? A primo jussu credidit, nihil tale aliud acceperat. Exi de terra tua, dictum est illi, et de cognatione tua, et vade in terram, quam tibi dabo (Gen. xii, 1). Et credidit statim, et non dedit illi ipsam terram, sed semini illius illam servavit, et semini ipsius promisit quid? In semine tuo benedicentur omnes gentes (Gen, xxii, 18). Semen ipsius Christus, quia de Abraham Isaac, de Isaac Jacob, de Jacob duodecim, de duodecim populus Judaeorum, de populo Judaeorum Virgo Maria, de Virgine Maria Dominus noster Jesus Christus.","english":"Since he has therefore rendered such great things, brothers, why do we not believe him? Is God a less suitable debtor? If he had as yet rendered absolutely nothing to us, we held him to be a suitable debtor, who made heaven and earth. For he was not going to be poor, so as not to have the means to repay; nor does he deceive, since he himself is the Truth; nor is God of such great power that he can be succeeded, so as not to have time to repay?\n\nIt is just, brothers, that God be believed before he renders anything, because he cannot lie in any way, he cannot deceive. He is God. Thus our Fathers believed him. Thus Abraham believed him. Behold a faith truly to be praised and to be proclaimed. He had received nothing from him, and he believed him when he promised. We do not yet believe, who have already received such great things. Could Abraham say to him: I will believe, because you promised me that and you rendered it? From the first command he believed; he had received nothing else of that kind. Leave your land, it was said to him, and your kindred, and go to the land which I will give you (Gen. 12:1). And he believed at once, and he did not give him that land itself, but he kept it for his seed, and to his seed he promised what? In your seed all nations will be blessed (Gen. 22:18). His seed is Christ, because from Abraham came Isaac, from Isaac Jacob, from Jacob the twelve, from the twelve the people of the Jews, from the people of the Jews the Virgin Mary, from the Virgin Mary our Lord Jesus Christ.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":239,"ref":"p239","source":"Et factus est semen Abraham Dominus noster Jesus Christus, et quod promissum erat Abrahae, invenimus impletum in nobis. In semine tuo, inquit, benedicentur omnes gentes. Credidit hoc, antequam aliquid vidisset. Credidit, et non vidit quod promittebatur. Nos autem videmus quod illi promissum est. Et quidquid illi promittebatur, futurum erat. Quid enim nondum reddidit Deus? Labores in saeculo isto futuros denuntiavit, et sanctos suos, et fideles suos futuros in laboribus, et fructum allaturos cum tolerantia (Luc, viii, 15). Praenuntiavit, et videmus. Ipsis laboribus atterimur. Qui nondum labores praenuntiati sunt? Neque enim putetis, fratres, quia, quod videtis atteri res humanas modo, non est scriptum in Scriptura Dei. Totum scriptum est, et tolerantia indicta est Christianis, et magis futura bona, quia venerunt mala, quae praedicta ventura erant. Nam si non venirent, quae dicta erant, etiam de bonis nobis fidem auferrent, sed ideo venerunt ante mala, ut credamus futura bona.","english":"And our Lord Jesus Christ has become the seed of Abraham, and what was promised to Abraham we find fulfilled in us. In your seed, he says, all nations shall be blessed. He believed this before he had seen anything. He believed, and he did not see what was being promised. But we see what was promised to him. And whatever was promised to him was still to come. For what has God not yet rendered? He announced labors that were to come in this world, and that his holy ones and his faithful ones would be in labors and would bring forth fruit with patience (Luke 8:15). He foretold it, and we see it. We are worn down by these very labors. What labors have not yet been foretold? For do not think, brothers, that because you see human affairs being worn down now, it is not written in the Scripture of God. It is all written, and patience has been declared to Christians, and the good things are all the more to come because the evils have come which were foretold as going to come. For if the things that were said had not come, they would even take away our faith concerning the good things; but for this reason the evils came beforehand, so that we may believe in the good things to come.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":240,"ref":"p240","source":"Modo mundus sic est, quomodo et torcular in pressuris est. Sed si amurca es, per cloacas vadis; si oleum, in gemellario manes. Nam necesse est, pressurae sint. Attendite amurcam, attendite oleum. Pressura fit aliquando in mundo, verbi gratia: fames, bellum, inopia, egestas, mortalitas, rapina, avaritia, pressurae pauperum, labores civitatum. Sunt ista. Videmus. Et praedicta sunt futura, et videmus, quia sunt. Invenimus homines inter istas pressuras murmurare, et dicere: Ecce temporibus christianis quanta mala sunt! Ante tempora christiana quanta bona abundabant! Non erant tanta mala ista. De pressura amurca exit. Per cloacas currit. Os ipsius propterea nigrum est, quia blasphemat. Non splendet. Oleum relucet. Invenis autem alium hominem de pressura ipsa, et de ipsa tritura, quae illum trivit. Numquid non ipsa tritura est, quae illum trivit? Audistis vocem amurcae, audite vocem olei. Deo gratias! Benedictum nomen tuum! Ista omnia mala, quibus nos conteris, praedicta erant. Securi sumus, quia ventura sunt et bona. Quando nos, et mali simul emendamur, fit voluntas tua. Te novimus Patrem promittentem, te novimus Patrem flagellantem. Erudi nos, et redde haereditatem, quam in fine promisisti. Benedicimus sanctum nomen tuum, quia nusquam fuisti mendax. Omnia, quemadmodum praedixisti, sic exhibuisti. In his laudibus de ipsa pressura emanantibus oleum currit in gemellario.","english":"The world now is as it is, just as the winepress is in its pressures. But if you are the dregs, you go down through the drains; if you are the oil, you remain in the storehouse. For it is necessary that there be pressures. Consider the dregs, consider the oil. Pressure comes upon the world at times—for example: famine, war, want, destitution, pestilence, plunder, greed, the oppressions of the poor, the labors of cities. These things are. We see them. And they were foretold as going to happen, and we see them, because they are. We find men murmuring amid these pressures, and saying: Behold, in Christian times how many evils there are! Before Christian times how many good things abounded! These evils were not so great. Out of the pressure the dregs come forth. It runs through the drains. Its mouth is therefore black, because it blasphemes. It does not shine. The oil gleams. But you find another man [coming] out of that very pressure, and out of that very threshing which threshed him. Is it not that very threshing which threshed him? You have heard the voice of the dregs; hear the voice of the oil. Thanks be to God! Blessed be your name! All these evils, with which you crush us, were foretold. We are secure, because the good things also are going to come. When we and the wicked alike are corrected, your will is done. We know you as the Father who promises, we know you as the Father who scourges. Instruct us, and restore the inheritance which you promised at the end. We bless your holy name, because you have never been false. All things, just as you foretold, so you have brought forth. In these praises flowing out from that very pressure, the oil runs into the storehouse.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":241,"ref":"p241","source":"Tamen quia torcular est totus iste mundus, unde etiam dicitur alia similitudo. Sicut in fornace probatur aurum et argentum, sic probat justos tentatio tribulationis; et de fornace aurificis similitudo ponitur. In angusto cacabo tres res sunt: Ignis, aurum, et palea. Et ibi vides imaginem totius mundi. Est ibi palea, est ibi aurum, est ibi ignis. Palea comburitur, ignis ardet, aurum probatur. Sic et in isto toto mundo sunt justi, sunt impii, est tribulatio. Mundus tanquam fornax est aurificis, justi tanquam aurum, impii tanquam palea, tribulatio sicut ignis. Numquid aurum purgaretur, nisi palea ureretur? Fit, quod impii ad cineres rediguntur. Cum enim blasphemant, et murmurant contra Deum, cinis efficiuntur. Ibi aurum purgatum justi, qui tolerabiliter ferunt omnes molestias mundi, et in suis tribulationibus laudant Deum, ut aurum purgatum, rediguntur in thesauros Dei. Habet enim Deus thesauros, quo mittat aurum purgatum; habet etiam loca sordida, quo mittat cinerem paleae. De isto mundo totum exigit. Tu vide, quid sis. Nam necesse est, ut veniat ignis. Si aurum te invenerit, sordes tollet; si paleam te invenerit, comburet, et ad cinerem perducet. Elige tibi, quid sis. Nam non potes dicere: Sine igne ero. Jam in fornace es aurificis, quo necesse est, veniat ignis. Magis te ibi esse necesse est, quia sine igne esse non poteris.","english":"Nevertheless, because this whole world is a winepress, another comparison is also given. As gold and silver are tested in a furnace, so the trial of tribulation tests the just; and the comparison is drawn from the goldsmith's furnace. In a narrow crucible there are three things: fire, gold, and chaff. And there you see an image of the whole world. There is chaff there, there is gold there, there is fire there. The chaff is burned, the fire blazes, the gold is tested. So also in this whole world there are the just, there are the impious, there is tribulation. The world is like the goldsmith's furnace, the just like gold, the impious like chaff, tribulation like fire. Would the gold be purified unless the chaff were burned? It comes about that the impious are reduced to ashes. For when they blaspheme and murmur against God, they are made ashes. There the just are gold purified, who bear all the troubles of the world with patience and in their tribulations praise God, so that, like purified gold, they are brought into the treasuries of God. For God has treasuries into which he may send purified gold; he also has filthy places into which he may send the ashes of chaff. From this world he demands an accounting of everything. See to it what you are. For it is necessary that the fire come. If it finds you gold, it will take away the dross; if it finds you chaff, it will burn you and reduce you to ashes. Choose for yourself what you are. For you cannot say: I will be without fire. You are already in the goldsmith's furnace, into which the fire must necessarily come. You must be there all the more, because you cannot be without fire.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":242,"ref":"p242","source":"XII Quare ergo non credimus, fratres, et venturum finem saeculi, et diem judicii, ut ibi recipiat unusquisque nostrum ea, quae gessit in corpore, sive bonum, sive malum? Quando videmus tot res promissas, exhibitas, et datas, quare non nobis eligimus, cum vivimus, illud, ubi semper vivamus? Puta, quia negligentes fuimus, hodie simus diligentes. Negligentes non debemus semper esse. Crastinus dies, nescis, quid sit. Dei patientia id agere nos admonet, ut et nos, et vitam nostram, si mala fuerit, corrigamus, et, cum tempus est, meliora eligamus. An putatis, quia Deus dormit, et non videt facientes mala? Sed forte patientiam nos docet, et patientiam prior exhibet. Invenit autem hominem forte profecisse, et non facere, quod faciebat, id est, malum. P(??)titur iste aliquem malitiosum, et vult, ut tollat illum Deus, et murmurat adversus Deum, quia retinet inimicum ipsius fortem, et male facientem, et non illum tollit. Oblitus est, quia in ipsum patienter egit, et si prius agere vellet severiter, non esset qui loqueretur. Severitatem exigis Dei? Quia tu transisti, transeat et alter. Non enim, quia tu jam transisti, praecidisti pontem misericordiae Dei. Adhuc est, qui transeat. Fecit te bonum, cum esses malus, vult et alium, ut sit et ipse bonus ex malo, sicut tu ex malo factus es bonus. Sic omnes veniunt ordinibus suis. Sed alii nolunt venire, alii veniunt.","english":"XII Why then, brothers, do we not believe that the end of the world is coming, and the day of judgment, so that there each one of us may receive what he did in the body, whether good or evil? When we see so many things promised, fulfilled, and given, why do we not choose for ourselves, while we live, that place where we may always live? Suppose we have been negligent; let us be diligent today. We ought not always to be negligent. You do not know what tomorrow may be. God's patience admonishes us to do this, so that we may correct both ourselves and our life, if it has been evil, and, while there is time, choose better things. Or do you think that God sleeps and does not see those who do evil? But perhaps he teaches us patience, and shows patience first himself. Yet he finds that a man has perhaps made progress and no longer does what he used to do, that is, evil. This man endures someone malicious, and wants God to take him away, and murmurs against God because he keeps his enemy alive and strong, doing evil, and does not take him away. He has forgotten that God dealt patiently with him too, and if he had wished to act severely first, there would be no one to speak. Do you demand severity from God? Because you have passed over, let another also pass over. For it is not because you have already passed over that you have cut off the bridge of God's mercy. There is still someone to pass over. He made you good when you were evil; he wants another also to be good out of evil, just as you were made good out of evil. Thus all come in their own order. But some do not want to come; others come.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":243,"ref":"p243","source":"Talibus enim dicit Apostolus: Tu autem secundum duritiam cordis tui, et cor impoenitens thesaurizas tibi iram in die irae, et revelationis justi judicii Dei, qui reddet unicuique secundum opera sua (Rom. ii, 5). Deinde si malus vult perseverare in malo non est socius tuus, sed erit probator tuus. Etenim, si malus est, et tu bonus, tolerando malum probaris bonus. Tu accipies coronam probationis tuae; ille autem habebit poenam in malo perseverationis suae. Deus autem, quid agat, patienter expectemus bonam ejus patientiam, paternam ejus disciplinam. Pater est, benignus est, misericors est. Magis si dimiserit nos fluere, tunc male irascitur nobis.\n\nAttendite enim, fratres, et videte Amphitheatra ista, quae modo cadunt. Luxuria illa aedificavit. Putatis, quia illa pietas aedificavit? Non illa aedificavit nisi luxuria hominum impiorum. Non vultis, ut aliquando cadat, quod luxuria aedificavit, et surgat, quod pietas aedificat? Permisit enim Deus, quando ista aedificabantur, ut quandoque cognoscerent homines mala sua, quae faciebant. Sed quia noluerunt cognoscere, venit Dominus Jesus Christus, coepit illis mala sua praedicare, coepit evertere, quod pro magno habebant, et dicunt; Mala sunt tempora christiana. Quare? Quia evertitur tibi, ubi moriebaris. Sed. Abundabant, inquiunt, omnia bona, quando ista fiebant. Utique sic, ut bona de illis fierent.","english":"For the Apostle says to such people: But you, according to the hardness of your heart and your impenitent heart, are storing up for yourself wrath on the day of wrath and of the revelation of the just judgment of God, who will repay each one according to his works (Rom 2:5). Then, if a wicked man wishes to persevere in wickedness, he is not your companion, but he will be your tester. For indeed, if he is wicked and you are good, by tolerating the wicked man you are proven good. You will receive the crown of your testing; but he will have the punishment of his perseverance in wickedness. But let us patiently await what God may do—his good patience, his fatherly discipline. He is a Father, he is kind, he is merciful. Rather, if he lets us drift along, then he is angrily displeased with us.\n\nFor attend, brothers, and see those amphitheaters, which are now falling down. That luxury built them. Do you think that piety built them? Nothing but the luxury of impious men built them. Do you not want what luxury built to fall at some point, and what piety builds to rise? For God permitted, when those things were being built, that at some point men might recognize the evils they were doing. But because they refused to recognize them, the Lord Jesus Christ came, began to preach their evils to them, began to overturn what they held in great esteem, and they say: The Christian times are evil. Why? Because what is being overturned for you is where you were dying. But, they say, all good things abounded when those things were being done. Indeed, so it was—that good things might be made from them.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":244,"ref":"p244","source":"Si ergo nosti, quia dedit tibi Deus aliquando abundantiam, et male usus es, et ad perditionem usus es, vide, quia abundantia illa fecit te fluere, et perdere animam tuam. Nonne venit severus pater, et coepit dicere: Indisciplinatus est puer iste. Commisi illi hoc, aut illud. Quomodo illud perdidit, et illud. Si nos semen terrae, nisi bona fuerit, non damus, ne semen intereat, quomodo vultis, ut Deus nobis indisciplinatis, et negligentibus vitam nostram det abundantiam suam ad male utendum, et non vultis, ut praecidat Deus defluxus hominum? Fratres mei, medicus est, et membrum putre novit praecidere, ne putrescant inde et alia loca. Unus, inquit, digitus inde praeciditur; quia melius est, ut unus digitus minus sit, quam totum corpus putrescat. Si hoc homo medicus per artem suam facit, si ars medicinae aliquam partem membrorum tollit, ne omnia putrescant, quare Deus, quidquid novit putre esse, non secet in hominibus, ut perveniant ad salutem?","english":"If, then, you know that God at some time gave you abundance, and you used it badly, and you used it for destruction, see that that abundance made you flow away and lose your soul. Did not the severe father come and begin to say: This boy is undisciplined. I entrusted this to him, or that. How did he lose that, and that? If we do not give seed to the earth unless it is good, lest the seed perish, how do you wish that God should give his abundance to us who are undisciplined and negligent of our life, for us to use badly, and you do not wish that God should cut off the outflows of men? My brothers, he is a physician, and he knows how to cut off a rotten limb, lest other parts also rot from it. One finger, he says, is cut off from there, because it is better that one finger be missing than that the whole body rot. If the human physician does this through his art, if the art of medicine removes some part of the members lest all rot, why should God not cut away whatever he knows to be rotten in men, so that they may come to salvation?","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":245,"ref":"p245","source":"Nolite ergo, fratres, taediari ad Deum flagellantem, ne dimittat vos, et in aeternum pereatis, sed magis rogemus illum, ut moderetur ipsas plagas, et sic temperet, ne sub ipsis deficiamus, et rogemus, ut emendet cum salute, metiatur, et reddat postea, quod promisit sanctis suis. Videte, quid dixit Scriptura: Irritavit Dominum peccator. Secundum magnitudinem irae suae non exquiret (Psal, x, 4). Quid est: Pro magnitudine irae suae non exquiret? Quia multum irascitur, Non exquiret, id est, dimittet illos perire. Si ergo multum irascitur, quando non exquirit, etiam multum misericors est, quando exercet. Tunc autem exercet, quando flagellat, quando cor nostrum affigit ad se. Teneamus ergo salutare ejus, et non fugiamus flagellum ipsius, Hoc nos docet, hoc monet, in hoc nos aedificat. Ipse filius ipsius, qui ad hoc venit, ut consoletur nos, quid boni hic pertulit? Dicite mihi. Certe Filius Dei est, Verbum Dei est, per quod facta sunt omnia. Quid boni hic pertulit? Non ipse est, qui, cum daemonia ejiceret, tales contumelias audiebat, ut diceretur illi: Daemonium habes (Joan. vii, 20)? Filio Dei, qui daemones ejiciebat, Judaei dicebant: Daemonium habes. Jam meliores daemones, qui confitebantur Filium Dei, quam illi (Luc. iv, 41) Nam et illi confitebantur, et illi non confitebantur. Tanta autem erat potentia illius, et tanta magnitudo, et tanta patientia, ut omnia toleraret.","english":"Do not, therefore, brothers, be wearied by God as he scourges, lest he abandon you and you perish forever, but rather let us ask him to moderate those very blows and so temper them that we not fail beneath them, and let us ask him to correct us with our salvation, to measure them, and afterward to restore what he promised to his saints. See what the Scripture said: The sinner has provoked the Lord. According to the greatness of his anger he will not search it out (Ps. 10:4). What is this: According to the greatness of his anger he will not search it out? Because he is greatly angered, he will not search it out, that is, he will let them perish. If, then, he is greatly angered when he does not search it out, he is also greatly merciful when he exercises it. But he exercises it when he scourges, when he afflicts our heart toward himself. Let us therefore hold fast to his salvation, and let us not flee his scourge. This he teaches us, this he admonishes, in this he builds us up. His own Son, who came for this purpose, that he might console us—what good did he endure here? Tell me. Surely he is the Son of God, he is the Word of God, through whom all things were made. What good did he endure here? Is he not the one who, when he was casting out demons, heard such insults that it was said to him: You have a demon (John 7:20)? To the Son of God, who was casting out demons, the Jews said: You have a demon. Now the demons were better, who confessed the Son of God, than those men (Luke 4:41). For the former confessed, and the latter did not confess. So great, moreover, was his power, and so great his greatness, and so great his patience, that he endured all things.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":246,"ref":"p246","source":"Flagellatus est, contumelias audivit, alapas accepit, consputus est in faciem, spinis coronatus est, irrisus est, delusus est, ad extremum ligno suspensus interfectus est, postea sepultus est. Filius Dei tanta hic pertulit. Si Magister, quanto magis Discipulus. Si ille, qui nos creavit, quanto magis nos creatura illius. Qui, ut nobis exemplum daret, patientiam nobis dimisit. Quare nos deficimus in ipsa patientia, quasi caput nostrum perdiderimus, quod nos praecessit ad coelum? Ideo enim caput nostrum praecessit ad coelum, tanquam dicens: Ecce qua. Venite, per molestias, per patientiam. Haec est via, quam vobis tradidi. Sed quo ducit via, qua me videtis ascendere? In coelum. Qui non vult hac ire, non vult illuc pervenire. Qui vult ad me pervenire, per viam veniat, quam monstravi. Et non potestis pervenire, nisi per viam molestiarum, dolorum, tribulationum, angustiarum. Sic pervenies ad requiem, quae tibi non tollitur. Si autem vis istam requiem, quae est ad tempus, et recedere a via Christi, observa tormenta Divitis illius, qui apud inferos torquebatur, quia et ipse requiem praesentem desideravit, et poenas sempiternas invenit. Fratres charissimi, eligite potius duriora, quae sine fine requiem habebunt in aeternum. Conversi ad Dominum, etc.","english":"He was scourged, he heard insults, he received blows, he was spat upon in the face, he was crowned with thorns, he was mocked, he was derided, and at last he was hanged on a tree and killed, and afterward buried. The Son of God endured such great things here. If the Master, how much more the disciple. If he who created us, how much more we, his creatures. He, in order to give us an example, left patience to us. Why then do we fail in that very patience, as though we had lost our head, which went before us to heaven? For this reason our head went before us to heaven, as if saying: Behold, where. Come, through troubles, through patience. This is the way that I have handed down to you. But where does the way lead, along which you see me ascending? To heaven. Whoever does not wish to go by this way does not wish to arrive there. Whoever wishes to come to me, let him come by the way that I have shown. And you cannot arrive except through the way of troubles, sorrows, tribulations, and distresses. Thus you will arrive at the rest that will not be taken from you. But if you want that rest which is for a time, and to withdraw from the way of Christ, observe the torments of that rich man who was tortured in hell, because he too desired present rest, and found everlasting punishments. Dearest brothers, choose rather the harder things, which will have rest without end for eternity. Turned to the Lord, etc.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":247,"ref":"p247","source":"SERMO XXV.\n\nDe verbis Evangelii Matth. xii, vers 41-50. Ecce plus quam Jonas Hic, etc\n\nSYNOPSIS.\n\nI. Judoei deteriores Ninivitis, et Regina Saba. II. Quomodo hominis a spiritu immundo liberati novis - sima fiant pejora prioribus. III. Parentes a Christo docentur, non impedire filios in bono opere. IV. Cum Christus nascendo utrumque sexum honoraverit docetur officium Prolium. V. Refelluntur Manichaei asserentes Christum non habuisse Matrem. VI. Concluditur contra Manichaeos Christum habuisse matrem. VII, Unde Mariae Virginis excellentia. VIII. Quomodo Christianus fieri possit mater Christi.\n\nEa, quae de sancto Evangelio recitata sunt, fra· tres charissimi, si omnia pertractare cupiamus, vix tempus sufficit singulis, quanto magis non sufficit omnibus. Jonam prophetam, qui dejectus in mare belluae marinae utero exceptus est, et die tertia vivus emovitus, figuram gessisse Salvatoris, qui passus est, et die tertia resurrexit, ipse Salvator ostendit. Accusatus est populus Judaeorum in comparatione Ninivitarum, quoniam Ninivitae, ad quos missus est redarguendos Jonas propheta, agendo paenitentiam iram Dei placaverunt, et misericordiam meruerunt. Et ecce, inquit, plus quam Jonas hic (Matth, xii, 41), volens intelligi se ipsum Dominus Christus. Audierunt illi servum, et vias suas correxerunt; audierunt isti Dominum, et non solum se non correxerunt, sed insuper illum occiderunt.","english":"SERMON XXV.\n\nOn the words of the Gospel of Matthew 12:41-50. Behold, something greater than Jonah is here, etc.\n\nSYNOPSIS.\n\nI. The Jews are worse than the Ninevites, and than the Queen of Sheba. II. How a man freed from an unclean spirit becomes worse than before. III. Parents are taught by Christ not to hinder their children in a good work. IV. Since Christ by his birth honored both sexes, the duty of children is taught. V. The Manichaeans are refuted who assert that Christ did not have a mother. VI. It is concluded against the Manichaeans that Christ had a mother. VII. Whence is the excellence of Mary the Virgin. VIII. How a Christian can become the mother of Christ.\n\nIf we wish to treat fully all the things that have been read from the holy Gospel, dearest brothers, time scarcely suffices for each one individually, and how much less does it suffice for all of them together. That the prophet Jonah, who was cast into the sea and received into the belly of a sea monster, and on the third day came forth alive, bore the figure of the Savior, who suffered and rose again on the third day—the Savior himself shows. The people of the Jews are accused in comparison with the Ninevites, because the Ninevites, to whom the prophet Jonah was sent to rebuke them, by doing penance appeased the wrath of God and merited mercy. And behold, he says, something greater than Jonah is here (Matthew 12:41), the Lord Christ wishing to be understood as himself. They heard a servant and corrected their ways; these heard the Lord and not only did not correct themselves, but even killed him.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":248,"ref":"p248","source":"Regina Austri exurget, inquit, in judicio cum generatione hac, et condemnabit eam. Venit enim a finibus terrae audire sapientiam Salomonis, et ecce plus quam Salomon hic (Ibid. 42). Non fuit magnum Christo plus esse quam Jonas, plus esse quam Salomon. Ille enim Dominus, illi servi erant. Sed tamen quales sunt, qui praesentem Dominum contempserunt, quando alienigenae servos ejus audierunt?\n\nDeinde sequitur: Cum autem spiritus immundus exierit ab homine, ambulat per loca arida quaerens requiem, et non invenit. Tunc dicit: Revertar in domum meam, unde exivi. Et veniens invenit eam vacantem, scopis mundatam, et ornatam, Tunc vadit, et assumit secum alios septem spiritus nequiores se, et inhabitantes habitant in ea, et fiunt novissima hominis illius pejora prioribus Sic erit generationi huic pessimae(Matth. x(??). 43). Hoc ut intelligatur, si congruenter exponatur, multum sermo immorabitur. Breviter tamen attingam, quantum Dominus donat, ne vos ab hujus rei intellectu jejunos dimittam. Quando fit in Sacramentis remissio peccatorum, mundatur domus, sed habitator est necessarius Spiritus sanctus. Spiritus autem sanctus non habitat nisi humiles corde. Deus enim dicit: Super quem requiescet Spiritus meus? et respondet proposito: Super humilem, et quietum, et trementem verba mea (Isai, lxvi, 2).","english":"The Queen of the South, he says, will rise in judgment with this generation and will condemn it. For she came from the ends of the earth to hear the wisdom of Solomon, and behold, something greater than Solomon is here (Ibid. 42). It was no great thing for Christ to be greater than Jonah, greater than Solomon. For he was the Lord, and they were servants. But yet what sort of people are those who despised the Lord present, when foreigners listened to his servants?\n\nThen it follows: But when the unclean spirit has gone out of a man, he walks through dry places seeking rest, and finds none. Then he says: I will return to my house from which I went out. And coming, he finds it empty, swept with brooms, and adorned. Then he goes and takes with him seven other spirits more wicked than himself, and dwelling there they dwell in it, and the last state of that man becomes worse than the first. So will it be for this most wicked generation (Matthew 12:43). For this to be understood, if it is expounded fittingly, the sermon will linger long. Yet I shall touch on it briefly, as far as the Lord grants, lest I send you away fasting from the understanding of this matter. When remission of sins takes place in the sacraments, the house is cleansed, but the Holy Spirit is needed as its inhabitant. But the Holy Spirit does not dwell except in the humble of heart. For God says: On whom will my Spirit rest? and he answers as proposed: On the humble and quiet man, and the one who trembles at my words (Isaiah 66:2).","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":249,"ref":"p249","source":"Ille ergo cum fuerit habitator, implet, regit, agit, frenat a malis, ad bona excitat, suavem facit justitiam, ut homo bene faciat amore recti, non timore supplicii. Hoc, quod dixi, agere per semetipsum homo minus idoneus est; sanctum autem Spiritum si habuerit habitatorem, ipsum in omnibus bonis etiam invenit et adjutorem. Superbi autem quidam, peccatis sibi remissis, si praesumpserunt ad bene vivendum de solo libero humanae voluntatis arbitrio, ipsa superbia a se excludunt Spiritum sanctum, et remanet domus quasi mundata a peccatis, sed inanis omnibus bonis. Dimissa sunt peccata tua, caruisti malis, sed non te nisi Spiritus sanctus implebit bonis. Hunc repellit superbia. Praesumis de te, dimittit te. Confidis tibi, donaris tibi. Sed illa cupiditas, qua malus eras, repulsa ab homine, hoc est, a mente tua, quando remissa sunt peccata tua, vagatur per deserta quaerens requiem, et non inveniens requiem redit ad domum illa cupiditas, invenit mundatam. Adducit secum alios spiritus septem nequiores se, et erunt pejora hominis illius novissima, quam erant prima. Septem alios adducit secum. Quid est, Alios septem? Ergo et ipse immundus spiritus septenarius est? Quid est hoc? Per septem universitas significatur. Totus ierat, totus venit, et utinam solus veniret. Quid est: Adducit secum alios septem? Quos non habebat, quando erat malus, habebit alios falso bonus.","english":"When he has become the inhabitant, therefore, he fills, rules, moves, restrains from evils, stirs to good things, makes righteousness sweet, so that a man does good out of love for what is right, not out of fear of punishment. What I have said—to do this by himself—a man is less fit for; but if he has the Holy Spirit as an inhabitant, he finds him in all good things and as a helper too. But certain proud persons, when their sins have been forgiven them, if they have presumed to live well on the sole free choice of human will, by that very pride shut the Holy Spirit out from themselves, and the house remains, as it were, cleansed from sins, but empty of all good things. Your sins have been forgiven; you have been deprived of evils, but only the Holy Spirit will fill you with good things. Pride repels him. You presume on yourself; he abandons you. You trust in yourself; you are given over to yourself. But that desire by which you were evil, having been driven out from the man—that is, from your mind—when your sins were forgiven, wanders through the deserts seeking rest, and not finding rest, that desire returns to the house and finds it cleansed. It brings with it other spirits, seven more wicked than itself, and the last state of that man will be worse than the first. It brings with it seven others. What is this, \"seven others\"? Is the unclean spirit himself then sevenfold? What is this? By seven the whole is signified. The whole had gone away, the whole has come, and would that he came alone. What is this: \"It brings with it seven others\"? Those it did not have when it was evil, it will have as others when falsely good.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":250,"ref":"p250","source":"Intendite, ut, si possum, quantum adjuvor, explanem quod dico. Spiritus sanctus operatione septenaria commendatur, ut sit in nobis Spiritus sapientiae et intellectus, consilii et fortitudinis, scientioe, et pietatis, et timoris Dei (Isai. xi, 2, 3). Huic septenario bono constitue a contrario septenarium malum: spiritum stultitiae et erroris, spiritum temeritatis, et ignaviae, spiritum ignorantiae, et impietatis, et spiritum superbiae contra timorem Dei. Isti sunt septem nequam. Qui sunt Alii septem nequiores? Alii septem nequiores in hypocrisi inveniuntur. Unus malus spiritus stultitiae, alter pejor simulatio sapientiae. Spiritus malus spiritus erroris, alter pejor simulatio veritatis. Spiritus malus spiritus temeritatis, alter pejor simulatio consilii. Spiritus malus spiritus ignaviae, alter pejor simulatio fortitudinis. Spiritus malus spiritus ignorantiae, alter pejor simulatio scientiae. Spiritus malus spiritus impietatis, alter pejor simulatio pietatis. Spiritus malus spiritus elationis, alter pejor simulatio timoris. Septem non ferebantur, quis ferat quatuordecim? Necesse est ergo, ut, cum malitiae fuerit addita simulatio veritatis, sint pejora hominis novissima, quam erant prima.","english":"Attend, so that, if I can, insofar as I am helped, I may explain what I am saying. The Holy Spirit is commended by a sevenfold operation, so that there may be in us the Spirit of wisdom and understanding, of counsel and fortitude, of knowledge, and of piety, and of the fear of God (Isa. 11:2–3). Over against this sevenfold good, set a sevenfold evil: the spirit of folly and error, the spirit of recklessness, and of cowardice, the spirit of ignorance, and of impiety, and the spirit of pride against the fear of God. These are the seven wicked ones. Who are the other seven more wicked? The other seven more wicked are found in hypocrisy. One evil spirit is that of folly; the other, worse, is the simulation of wisdom. The evil spirit is the spirit of error; the other, worse, is the simulation of truth. The evil spirit is the spirit of recklessness; the other, worse, is the simulation of counsel. The evil spirit is the spirit of cowardice; the other, worse, is the simulation of fortitude. The evil spirit is the spirit of ignorance; the other, worse, is the simulation of knowledge. The evil spirit is the spirit of impiety; the other, worse, is the simulation of piety. The evil spirit is the spirit of elation; the other, worse, is the simulation of fear. Seven were not borne; who shall bear fourteen? It is necessary, therefore, that when the simulation of truth has been added to malice, a man's last state be worse than his first.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":251,"ref":"p251","source":"Hoec eo loquente ad turbas (Evangelium sequor) mater ejus, et fratres ejus stabant foris volentes loqui cum illo. Nuntiavit ei quidam dicens: Ecce mater tua(??) et fratres tui foris sunt, loqui tecum volunt. Et ille: Quae mihi mater est, aut qui fratres? et extendens manum super Discipulos suos ait: Hi sunt mater mea, et fratres mei. Et quicumque fecerit voluntatem Patris mei, qui in caelis est, ipse mihi frater, soror, et mater est (Matth, xii, 50). Hinc solum vellem loqui, sed, quia superiora nolui praeterire, non parvam partem temporis, quantum sentio, consumpsi. Hoc enim, quod modo proposui, multos habet sinus, nodosque quaestionis, quomodo pie Dominus Christus contempserit matrem, non qualemcumque matrem, sed quanto magis Virginem matrem, tanto magis talem matrem, cui sic attulit foecunditatem, ut non adimeret integritatem, matrem Virginem concipientem, Virginem parientem, Virginem perpetuo permanentem. Talem matrem ille contempsit, ne operi, quod agebat, maternus se inseret, eumque impediret affectus. Quid enim agebat? Populis loquebatur, veteres homines destruebat, novos aedificabat, animas liberabat, vinctos solvebat, caecas mentes illuminabat, bonum opus faciebat, in bono opere actu et sermone fervebat. Inter haec nuntiatus illi est carnalis affectus. Audistis quid responderit, ut quid ego repetam? Audiant matres, ne impediant carnali affectu bona opera filiorum.","english":"While he was saying this to the crowds (I am following the Gospel), his mother and his brothers stood outside, wanting to speak with him. Someone announced to him, saying: Behold, your mother and your brothers are outside; they want to speak with you. And he said: Who is my mother, or who are my brothers? And stretching out his hand over his disciples, he said: These are my mother and my brothers. And whoever does the will of my Father who is in heaven, he is my brother, sister, and mother (Matthew 12:50). On this point alone I would like to speak, but because I did not wish to pass over the earlier matters, I have used up, as I feel, no small part of my time. For this very matter that I have just proposed has many folds and knots of question: how the Lord Christ piously disregarded his mother—not just any mother, but the more a virgin mother, the more such a mother, to whom he brought fruitfulness in such a way that he did not take away her integrity: a mother virgin conceiving, virgin giving birth, virgin remaining forever. Such a mother he disregarded, lest maternal affection insert itself into the work he was doing and hinder him. For what was he doing? He was speaking to the peoples, destroying old men, building new ones, freeing souls, loosing the bound, enlightening blind minds, doing a good work; in that good work he was fervent in deed and word. Amid these things, carnal affection was announced to him. You have heard what he answered—why should I repeat it? Let mothers hear, that they not hinder the good works of their sons by carnal affection.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":252,"ref":"p252","source":"Si enim voluerint impedire, et agentibus sic irruerint, ut saltem interpolent, quod differri non oportet, contemnentur a filiis. Audeo dicere: Contemnentur, pietate contemnentur. Et quando erit filio suo bono operi mente intento, et ideo matrem venientem contemnenti, quando erit irata mulier, sive maritata, sive vidua, quando contempta est Virgo Maria? Sed dictura es mihi: Ergo filium meum Christo comparas? Nec illum Christo comparo, nec te Mariae. Non ergo Dominus Christus maternum damnavit affectum, sed contemnendae matris pro opere Dei magnum in se ipso demonstravit exemplum. Et in loquendo doctor erat, et in contemnendo doctor erat, et ideo dignatus est contemnere matrem, ut pro Dei opere te contemnere doceret et patrem.\n\nNon enim poterat Dominus Christus homo fieri sine matre, qui potuit sine patre. Si oportebat, imo quia oportebat, ut homo fieret propter hominem, qui fecit hominem, considerate et recolite, unde ipsum primum hominem fecit. Primus homo factus est sine patre, sine matre. Quod potuit primo humanis instruendis rebus aptare, non potuit postea tale aliquid ad reparandas res humanas sibi coaptare? Difficile erat Sapientiae. Dei, Verbo Dei, Virtuti Dei, unigenito Filio Dei, difficile erat, quem sibi coaptaret, facere hominem, undecumque voluisset? Angeli se homines hominibus praebuerunt.","english":"For if they wish to hinder, and have rushed in upon those who are doing so, so that they at least interrupt what ought not to be delayed, they will be despised by their children. I dare to say: They will be despised, they will be despised by filial piety. And when will a good son, with his mind intent on a good work, and therefore despising his mother as she comes, when will a woman be angry, whether married or widowed, when Mary the Virgin has been despised? But you will say to me: So you compare my son with Christ? I do not compare him with Christ, nor you with Mary. Therefore the Lord Christ did not condemn a mother's affection, but by despising his mother for the sake of God's work he showed in himself a great example of a mother to be despised. And in speaking he was a teacher, and in despising he was a teacher, and therefore he deigned to despise his mother, so as to teach you to despise mother and father for the sake of God's work.\n\nFor the Lord Christ could not become man without a mother, who could become man without a father. If it was fitting—indeed, because it was fitting—that he become man for the sake of man, who made man, consider and recall from what source he made the first man himself. The first man was made without a father, without a mother. What he was able to arrange for the first instruction of human affairs, could he not afterward adapt some such thing to himself for the restoration of human affairs? Was it difficult for the Wisdom of God, the Word of God, the Power of God, the only-begotten Son of God, to make a man from whatever source he wished, whom he might adapt to himself? Angels presented themselves to men as men.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":253,"ref":"p253","source":"Abraham sanctos Angelos pavit, et tanquam homines invitavit, nec tantum vidit; sed et tetigit; nam pedes lavit (Gen. xviii). Numquid illa, quasi per phantasmata ludicra, ab Angelis facta sunt? Si ergo potuit Angelus humanam speciem, cum voluit, veram exhibere, non potuit Dominus Angelorum, undecumque vellet, quem susciperet, verum hominem facere? Sed noluit hominem habere patrem, ne per concupiscentiam carnalem veniret ad homines, voluit tamen matrem, ut matrem haberet inter homines, quam pro Dei opere contemnendo doceret homines. Voluit sexum virilem suscipere in se, et muliebrem sexum honorare dignatus est in matre. Etenim antiquitus et foemina peccaverat, et viro peccatum propinaverat (Id. iii). Utrumque conjugium diaboli fraude deceptum est. Si veniret Christus vir non cum foeminei sexus commendatione, desperarent de se foeminae, maxime, quia per illam lapsus est homo. Utrumque honoravit, utrumque commendavit, utrumque suscepit. De foemina natus est. Nolite desperare, viri. Vir esse dignatus est Christus. Nolite desperare, foeminae. De foemina nasci dignatus est Christus. Ad salutem Christi sexus uterque concurrat. Veniat masculus, veniat femina. In fide nec masculus est, nec femina (Galat, iii, 28). Docet ergo te Christus contemnere parentes tuos, amare parentes tuos. Tunc enim ordinate et pie amas parentes, quando Deo non prae parentes.","english":"Abraham fed holy angels and invited them as though they were men, and not only saw them but even touched them; for he washed their feet (Gen. 18). Were those things done by the angels as though by some playful phantasms? If, therefore, an angel could, when he wished, display a true human form, could not the Lord of angels, from whatever source he wished, make the true man whom he took up? But he did not wish to have a human father, lest he come to men through carnal concupiscence; yet he wished to have a mother, so that he might have a mother among men, and by teaching men to despise the work of God, teach them. He wished to take up the male sex in himself, and he deigned to honor the female sex in his mother. For in ancient times the woman had sinned, and had handed the sin on to the man (Ibid. 3). Both were deceived by the devil's fraud in that union. If Christ had come as a man without the commendation of the female sex, women would have despaired of themselves, especially because man fell through her. He honored both, he commended both, he took up both. He was born of a woman. Do not despair, men: Christ deigned to be a man. Do not despair, women: Christ deigned to be born of a woman. Let both sexes come together for the salvation of Christ. Let the male come, let the female come. In faith there is neither male nor female (Gal. 3:28). Christ therefore teaches you to despise your parents, and to love your parents. For then you love your parents in an ordered and pious way, when you do not set them before God.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":254,"ref":"p254","source":"Qui amat (Domini verba sunt) qui amat patrem aut matrem plus quam me, non est me dignus (Matth. x, 57). His verbis quasi videtur admonuisse, ne amares. Imo, si attendas, admonuit, ut amares. Potuit enim dicere: Qui amat patrem aut matrem, non est me dignus. Non hoc dixit, ne loqueretur contra legem, quam dedit. Ipse enim legem illam per Moysen famulum suum dedit, ubi scriptum est: Honora patrem tuum, et matrem tuam (Exod. xx, 12; et Dent, v, 16). Non contrariam legem promulgavit, sed illam commendavit, et ordinem te docuit, non pietatem subvertit. Qui amat patrem aut matrem, sed plus quam me. Amet ergo, sed non plus quam me. Deus Deus est, homo homo est. Ama parentes, obsequere parentibus, honora parentes; sed, si te Deus ad aliquid amplius vocat, ubi possit impedimento esse parentalis affectus, serva ordinem, noli evertere charitatem.","english":"He who loves (these are the Lord's words) he who loves father or mother more than me is not worthy of me (Matt. 10:37). By these words he seems, as it were, to have warned against loving. No—if you attend closely, he warned that you should love. For he could have said: He who loves father or mother is not worthy of me. He did not say this, lest he speak against the law that he himself gave. For he himself gave that law through Moses his servant, where it is written: Honor your father and your mother (Exod. 20:12; Deut. 5:16). He did not promulgate a contrary law, but commended that one, and taught you order, not overturned piety. He who loves father or mother—but more than me. So let him love them, but not more than me. God is God, man is man. Love your parents, obey your parents, honor your parents; but if God calls you to something greater, where parental affection could be an obstacle, keep the order, do not overturn charity.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":255,"ref":"p255","source":"In tanta veritate doctrinae Domini et Salvatoris nostri Jesu Christi quis credat calumniam quaesivisse Manichaeos, qua conarentur asserere Dominum Jesum Christum non habuisse ullam matrem? Hoc enim sapiunt, imo desipiunt, quod Dominus Jesus non habuerit hominem matrem, contra Evangelium, contra lucem ipsius veritatis. Et, unde argumententur, attendite. Ecce, inquiunt, ipse dicit. Quid dicit? Quae est mater mea, aut qui sunt fratres mei (Matth. xii, 48)? I, se, inquiunt, negat, et tu ei vis imponere, quod negat. Ipse dicit: Quoe est mater mea, aut qui sunt fratres mei? et tu dicis: Habet matrem. O stulte, o contentiose, o merito odiose! responde mihi, unde scias dixisse Dominum: Quoe est mater mea, aut qui sunt fratres mei? Tu negas Christum habuisse (??)matrem, et quod intendis, per hoc docere conaris, quia dixit: Quae est mater mea, aut qui sunt fratres mei? Si alius existat, et dicat hoc Dominum Christum non omnino dixisse, unde convinces? Responde, si potes, ad hominem negantem, quod hoc dixerit Christus. Unde convinces, inde convinceris. Numquid enim, hoc se dixisse, in aurem tibi Christus ipse indicavit? Responde, ut ore tuo convincaris. Responde ut, hoc Christum dixisse, convincas. Novi, quod dicturus est Codicem sumam, Evangelium aperiam, verba ejus recitabo scripta in sancto Evangelio. Bene. bene.","english":"In such great truth of the teaching of our Lord and Savior Jesus Christ, who would believe that the Manichaeans sought a false accusation by which they might try to assert that the Lord Jesus Christ did not have any mother? For this is what they think—or rather, what they are foolish enough to think—that the Lord Jesus did not have a human mother, against the Gospel, against the light of truth itself. And attend to the basis on which they argue. “Behold,” they say, “he himself says it.” What does he say? “Who is my mother, or who are my brothers?” (Matt. 12:48). “Go,” they say, “he denies it himself, and you want to impose on him what he denies.” He himself says: “Who is my mother, or who are my brothers?” and you say: “He has a mother.” O foolish one, O contentious one, O rightly hateful one! Answer me: how do you know that the Lord said, “Who is my mother, or who are my brothers?” You deny that Christ had a mother, and what you intend, you try to teach by this, because he said: “Who is my mother, or who are my brothers?” If another comes forward and says that the Lord Christ did not say this at all, how will you convict him? Answer, if you can, the man who denies that Christ said this. By the very means you use to convict, you are convicted. For did Christ himself whisper into your ear that he said this? Answer, so that you may be convicted out of your own mouth. Answer, so that you may prove that Christ said this. I know what he is going to say: “I will take up the Codex, I will open the Gospel, I will recite his words written in the holy Gospel.” Good. Good.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":256,"ref":"p256","source":"Ipso Evangelio tenebo te cum ipso, Evangelio alligabo te de ipso Evangelio suffocabo te. In ipso Evangelio recita, quod pro te, putas. Aperi, lege. Quoe est mater mea? Quare hoc dixit, supra leges. Nuntiavit ei quidam: Ecce mater tua, et fratres tui foris stant (Matth. xii. 47). Nondum premo, nondum teneo, nondum suffoco. Adhuc potes dicere: Ille quidem falsus nuntius fuit, non verum dixit, mendacia suggessit. Propterea Dominus falsum nuntium refutavit. Post nuntium quippe ejus respondit: Quoe est mater mea? Quasi diceret: Tu dicis: Foris stat mater tua. Ego dico: Quae est mater mea? Cui vis, inquit, credamus? Nuntio suggerenti, an, quod nuntiaverat, Christo respuenti. Audi ergo. Adhuc interrogo te. Tantum Evangelium tene. Noli mihi codicem projicere post te. Tene, da auctoritatem Evangelio, quam nisi dederis, non erit unde probes Dominum dixisse: Quoe est mater mea? Cum vero auctoritatem dignam tribueris Evangelio, vide quid interrogem. Paulo ante interrogaveram, unde scires utrum dixerit Christus: Quoe est mater mea? Quid praecesserat? Nuntius quidam dixerat Christo. Mater tua foris stat. Antequam hoc diceret nuntius, vel, ut hoc diceret nuntius, quid praecessit? Cogo, ut legas. Video te jam timere, ne legas. Respondit Dominus, et dixit. Quis dixit? Non dico, quis dixit: Quoe est mater mea? respondebis enim: Dominus dixit. Respondit Dominus, quis dixit?","english":"By that very Gospel I will hold you, with that very Gospel I will bind you, by that very Gospel I will choke you. Read in that very Gospel what you think was done for you. Open it, read. “Who is my mother?” Why did he say this? Read the passages above. Someone announced to him: “Behold, your mother and your brothers are standing outside” (Matt. 12:47). I am not yet pressing you, not yet holding you, not yet choking you. You can still say: “That messenger was false, he did not speak the truth, he suggested lies. Therefore the Lord refuted the false message.” For after his message he answered: “Who is my mother?” As if to say: “You say, ‘Your mother is standing outside.’ I say, ‘Who is my mother?’” To whom, he says, do you want us to give credence? To the messenger who suggested it, or to Christ who rejected what had been announced? Hear then. I am still questioning you. Just hold on to the Gospel. Do not throw the book away from you behind your back. Hold it, give authority to the Gospel; unless you give it, there will be no means by which you can prove that the Lord said: “Who is my mother?” But when you have given worthy authority to the Gospel, see what I am asking. A little earlier I had asked how you know whether Christ said: “Who is my mother?” What had come before? A certain messenger had said to Christ: “Your mother is standing outside.” Before the messenger said this—or, in order that the messenger might say this—what came before? I compel you to read. I see that you are now afraid to read. The Lord answered and said. Who said it? I am not saying who said: “Who is my mother?”—for you will answer: “The Lord said it.” The Lord answered; who said it?","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":257,"ref":"p257","source":"Responsurus es: Evangelista dixit. Evangelista iste verum dixit, an falsum? Dicturus es, quod verum dixit, aut falsum.·Respondit Dominus, et ait illi, quod Evangelista dixit, verum dixit, an falsum? Si dicturus es falsum dixisse Evangelistam, Dominum respondisse, unde scis: Quoe est mater mea? Dominum dixisse? Si autem propterea convincis: Quoe est mater mea? Dominum dixisse, quia hoc eum dixit Evangelista dixisse, non convincis hoc Dominum dixisse, nisi credideris Evangelistae. Jam si credis Evangelistae, quia nihil dicis, si non credideris Evangelistae, lege superius quid dixerit ipse Evangelista.\n\nQuandiu tibi moras facio! Quandiu te suspendo! Beneficium est, ut cito vincaris. Attende, inspice, lege. Video te nolle. Da co(??)icem. Ego lego: Hoec eo loquente ad turbas. Quis hoc dicit? Evangelista, cui si non credis, nihil Christus dixit. Si nihil Christus dixit. Quoe est mater mea? Christus non dixit. Si autem, Quae est mater mea? Christus dixit, verum est quod Evangelista scripsit. Vide, quid ante dixit. Haec eo loquente ad turbas, mater ejus et fratres foris stabant, volentes loqui cum eo. Nondum aliquid nuntius ille nuntiavit, quem potes dicere fuisse mentitum. Quid nuntiaverit vide, quid Evangelista praemiserit attende. Haec Domino loquente ad turbas, mater ejus, et fratres ejus foris stabant. Quis hoc dicit? Evangelista, cui credis. Dominum dixisse: Quae est mater mea?","english":"You are going to answer: The Evangelist said it. Did that Evangelist tell the truth, or a lie? You are going to say whether he told the truth or a lie. The Lord answered and said to him—did the Evangelist tell the truth or a lie? If you are going to say that the Evangelist told a lie, how do you know that the Lord answered, \"Who is my mother?\" If, however, you prove that the Lord said \"Who is my mother?\" because the Evangelist said that he said it, you do not prove that the Lord said it unless you believe the Evangelist. So then, if you believe the Evangelist—for you say nothing if you do not believe the Evangelist—read above what that same Evangelist said.\n\nHow long do I keep you waiting! How long do I hold you in suspense! It is a kindness that you be conquered quickly. Pay attention, look, read. I see you are unwilling. Give me the book. I read: \"While he was speaking these things to the crowds.\" Who says this? The Evangelist. If you do not believe him, Christ said nothing. If Christ said nothing, Christ did not say \"Who is my mother?\" But if Christ said \"Who is my mother?\" then what the Evangelist wrote is true. See what he said before. \"While he was speaking these things to the crowds, his mother and his brothers were standing outside, wanting to speak with him.\" The messenger had not yet announced anything—the one whom you can claim lied. See what he announced; pay attention to what the Evangelist set down beforehand. \"While the Lord was speaking these things to the crowds, his mother and his brothers were standing outside.\" Who says this? The Evangelist, whom you believe. That the Lord said, \"Who is my mother?","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":258,"ref":"p258","source":"Sed si haec dicta non credis, ut illa, Dominus ergo non dixit: Quae est mater mea? Sed vere Dominus dixit: Quae est mater mea? Crede ergo ei qui dixit, Dominum dixisse: Quae est mater mea? Qui enim dixit. Dominum dixisse: Quae est mater mea? ipse dixit: Haec eo loquente, foris stabat mater ejus. Quare ergo negavit matrem suam? Absit! Intellige. Non negavit, sed aliquid, quod faciebat, matri praeposuit. Postrema sola causa est quaerere, quare Dominus dixerit: Quoe est mater mea? Prima causa est videre, quod habuerit, de quo diceret: Quoe est mater mea? Habuit, foris stabat, loqui cum eo volebat. Dic mihi, unde scis? Evangelista dicit, cui si non credidero, nihil Dominus dicit. Ergo habuit matrem; sed quid est: Quoe est mater mea? Ad ista, quae ego facio, Quoe est mater mea? Si dicas alicui periclitanti, et patrem habenti: Liberet te pater tuus; quem scit ille non esse idoneum liberando filio suo, nonne respondet tibi summa pietate, integra veritate: Quid est pater meus? Ad hoc quod volo, ad hoc quod mihi nunc opus esse sentio, quid est pater meus? Ad illud ergo, quod agebat Christus, quod vinctos solvebat, caecas mentes illuminabat, interiores homines aedificabat, templum spirituale sibi fabricabat, quae est mater ejus? Sed si putas ideo Christum non habuisse matrem in terra, quia dixit: Quoe est mater mea?","english":"But if you do not believe these words, as you do those, then the Lord did not say: Who is my mother? But truly the Lord did say: Who is my mother? Believe, then, the one who said that the Lord said: Who is my mother? For the one who said that the Lord said: Who is my mother? is the same one who said: While he was saying this, his mother was standing outside. Why, then, did he deny his mother? Far be it! Understand. He did not deny her, but he placed something he was doing before his mother. The last point alone is the reason to ask why the Lord said: Who is my mother? The first point is to see that he had someone about whom he could say: Who is my mother? He had her; she was standing outside; she wanted to speak with him. Tell me, how do you know? The Evangelist says it; and if I do not believe him, the Lord says nothing. Therefore he had a mother; but what is this: Who is my mother? In relation to these things that I am doing, who is my mother? If you were to say to someone in danger who has a father: Let your father deliver you—a father whom that person knows is not fit to deliver his son—will he not answer you with the greatest piety and complete truth: What is my father to me? For this that I want, for this that I now feel I need, what is my father to me? In relation, then, to what Christ was doing—what he was doing in loosing the bound, enlightening blind minds, building up the inner man, fashioning for himself a spiritual temple—who is his mother? But if you think that Christ therefore did not have a mother on earth because he said: Who is my mother?","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":259,"ref":"p259","source":"nec Discipuli ejus habuerunt patres in terra, quia dixit eis ipse Dominus: Ne vobis dicatis patrem in terra. Domini verba sunt: Ne vobis dicatis patrem; unus est enim Pater vester Deus (Id, xxiii, 9). Non patres non habebant, sed ubi venturum est ad regenerationem, quaeratur pater regenerationis, non damnetur pater generationis, sed ei praeponatur pater regenerationis.\n\nEcce illud magis attendite, charissimi fratres mei, illud magis attendite, obsecro vos, quod ait Dominus Christus extendens manum super Discipulos suos: Hoec est mater mea, et fratres mei. Et qui fecerit voluntatem Patris mei, qui me misit, ipse mihi et frater, et soror, et mater est. Numquid non fecit voluntatem Patris Virgo Maria, quae fide credidit, fide concepit, electa est, de qua nobis salus inter homines nasceretur, creata est a Christo, antequam in illa Christus crearetur? Fecit, fecit plane voluntatem Patris sancta Maria, et ideo plus est Mariae, discipulam fuisse Christi, quam matrem fuisse Christi. Plus est felicius discipulam fuisse Christi, quam matrem fuisse Christi. Ideo Maria beata erat, quia, et antequam pareret, magistrum in utero portavit. Vide, si non est, quod dico. Transeunte Domino cum turbis sequentibus, et miracula faciente divina, ait quaedam mulier: Felix venter, qui te portavit. Beatus venter, qui te portu vit. Et Dominus, ut non felicitas in carne quaereretur, quid respondit?","english":"Nor did his disciples have fathers on earth, because the Lord himself said to them: Do not call anyone on earth your father. These are the Lord's words: Do not call anyone your father; for one is your Father, God. They did not lack fathers, but where one must come to regeneration, the father of regeneration is to be sought; the father of generation is not to be condemned, but the father of regeneration is to be preferred to him.\n\nLook, my dearest brothers, attend more closely to this, attend more closely, I beg you, to what the Lord Christ said, stretching out his hand over his disciples: This is my mother and my brothers. And whoever does the will of my Father who sent me, he is to me both brother and sister and mother. Did not the Virgin Mary do the will of the Father, who believed by faith, conceived by faith, was chosen, from whom salvation would be born for us among men, and was created by Christ before Christ was created in her? She did, she plainly did the will of the Father, holy Mary, and therefore it is more for Mary to have been a disciple of Christ than to have been the mother of Christ. It is more and more blessed to have been a disciple of Christ than to have been the mother of Christ. Therefore Mary was blessed because, even before she gave birth, she carried the teacher in her womb. See whether what I say is not so. As the Lord was passing by with crowds following him and performing divine miracles, a certain woman said: Blessed is the womb that bore you. Blessed is the womb that bore you. And the Lord, so that blessedness might not be sought in the flesh, what did he answer?","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":260,"ref":"p260","source":"Imo beati, qui audiunt verbum Dei, et custodiunt (Luc. xi, 27, 28). Inde ergo et Maria beata, quia audivit verbum Dei, et custodivit. Plus mente custodivit veritatem, quam utero carnem. Veritas Christus, caro Christus. Veritas Christus in mente Mariae, caro Christus in ventre Mariae. Plus est, quod est in mente, quam quod portatur in ventre. Sancta Maria, beata Maria, sed melior est Ecclesia, quam Virgo Maria. Quare? Quia Maria portio est Ecclesiae, sanctum membrum excellens membrum, supereminens membrum, sed tamen totius corporis membrum. Si totius corporis, plus est profecto corpus, quam membrum. Caput Dominus, et totus Christus caput et corpus. Quid dicam? Divinum caput habemus, Deum caput habemus.\n\nErgo, charissimi, vos attendite. Et vos membra Christi estis, et vos corpus Christi estis. Attendite, quomodo sitis, quod ait: Ecce mater mea, et fratres mei. Quomodo eritis mater Christi? Et Quicumque · que audit, et quicumque facit voluntatem Patris mei, qui in caelis est, ipse meus frater, et soror, et mater est (Matth. xii, 49, 50). Puta, Fratres intelligo, Sorores intelligo; una est enim haereditas, et ideo Christi misericordia, qui, cum esset unicus, noluit esse solus, voluit nos esse Patri haeredes, sibi cohaeredes. Talis est enim illa haereditas, quae cohaeredum multitudine angusta esse non possit.","english":"Rather, blessed are those who hear the word of God and keep it (Luke 11:27, 28). Hence, therefore, Mary too is blessed, because she heard the word of God and kept it. She kept the truth in her mind more than she kept the flesh in her womb. The truth is Christ, the flesh is Christ. The truth is Christ in Mary's mind, the flesh is Christ in Mary's womb. What is in the mind is greater than what is carried in the womb. Holy Mary, blessed Mary, but the Church is better than the Virgin Mary. Why? Because Mary is a portion of the Church, a holy member, an excellent member, a preeminent member, but still a member of the whole body. If she is of the whole body, then surely the body is greater than the member. The Lord is the head, and the whole Christ is head and body. What shall I say? We have a divine head, we have God as our head.\n\nTherefore, dearly beloved, pay attention. You too are members of Christ, and you too are the body of Christ. Pay attention to how you may be what he said: Behold my mother and my brothers. How will you be the mother of Christ? And whoever hears, and whoever does the will of my Father who is in heaven, he is my brother, and sister, and mother (Matthew 12:49, 50). Consider: I understand brothers, I understand sisters; for there is one inheritance, and therefore it is by the mercy of Christ, who, though he was the only Son, did not wish to be alone, but wished us to be heirs of the Father, co-heirs with himself. For such is that inheritance that it cannot be made narrow by a multitude of co-heirs.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":261,"ref":"p261","source":"Intelligo ergo fratres nos esse Christi, sorores Christi esse sanctas et fideles foeminas; matres Christi quomodo possumus intelligere? Quid igitur? Audemus nos dicere matres Christi? Imo audemus nos dicere matres Christi. Dixi enim vos fratres ejus omnes, et matrem suam non(??) auderem? Sed multo minus audeo, quod Christus dixit, negare. Eia, charissimi, intendite, quomodo sit Ecclesia, quod manifestum est, conjux Christi, quod difficilius intelligitur, sed tamen verum est, mater Christi. In ipsius typo Maria Virgo praecessit. Unde, rogo vos, Maria mater est Christi, nisi quia peperit membra Christi? Vos, quibus loquor, membra estis Christi. Quis vos peperit? Audio vocem cordis vestri: Mater Ecclesia. Mater ista sancta, honorata, Mariae similis et parit, et virgo est. Quia parit, per vos probo. Ex illa nati estis, et Christum parit: nam membra Christi estis. Probavi parientem, probabo virginem. Non me deserit divinum testimonium, non me deserit. Procede ad populum, beate Paule. Esto testis assertionis meae. Exclama, et dic, quod volo dicere. Sponsavi vos uni viro virginem castam exhibere. Christo (2 Cor. xi, 2). Ubi est ista virginitas? U(??) timetur corruptio? Ipse dicat, qui virginem dixit. Sponsavicos uni viro virginem castam exhibere Christo.","english":"I understand, then, brothers, that we are Christ's, and that holy and faithful women are Christ's sisters; but how can we understand that we are mothers of Christ? What then? Do we dare to say that we are mothers of Christ? Indeed, we dare to say that we are mothers of Christ. For I have said that you are all his brothers, and would I not dare to call his mother? But far less do I dare to deny what Christ has said. Come now, dearest ones, attend to how the Church is—which is manifest—the spouse of Christ, and—which is harder to understand, yet nevertheless true—the mother of Christ. In her figure the Virgin Mary went before. Whence, I ask you, is Mary the mother of Christ, except that she gave birth to the members of Christ? You to whom I speak are the members of Christ. Who gave birth to you? I hear the voice of your heart: Mother Church. This holy, honored mother, like Mary, both gives birth and is a virgin. That she gives birth, I prove through you. You were born from her, and she gives birth to Christ, for you are the members of Christ. I have proved the one giving birth; I will prove the virgin. The divine testimony does not fail me, it does not fail me. Come forward before the people, blessed Paul. Be a witness to my assertion. Cry out and say what I wish to say: I betrothed you to one husband, to present you as a chaste virgin to Christ (2 Cor 11:2). Where is that virginity? Is corruption feared? Let him speak who called her a virgin. I betrothed you to one husband, to present you as a chaste virgin to Christ.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":262,"ref":"p262","source":"Timeo autem, inquit, ne sicut serpens Evam seduxit versutia sua, sic et vestrae mentes, inquit, corrumpantur a castitate, quae est in Christo. Tenete in mentibus virginitatem mentis. Virginitas fidei catholicae integritas tas. Ubi corrupta est Eva sermone serpentis, ibi debet esse virgo Ecclesia dono Omnipotentis. Ergo in mente pariant membra Christi, sicut Maria in ventre Virgo peperit Christum, et sic eritis matres Christi. Non est longe a vobis, non est praeter vos, non abhorret a vobis. Fuistis filii, estote et matres. Filii matris, quando baptizati estis, tunc membra Christi nata estis. Adducite ad lavacrum baptismatis, quos potestis, ut sicut filii fuistis, quando nati estis, sic etiam ducendo ad nascendum matres Christi esse possitis.","english":"But I fear, he says, lest as the serpent seduced Eve by his cunning, so too, he says, your minds may be corrupted from the chastity that is in Christ. Hold in your minds the virginity of the mind. The virginity of the catholic faith is its integrity. Where Eve was corrupted by the serpent's speech, there the Church ought to be a virgin by the gift of the Almighty. Therefore let them give birth to Christ's members in the mind, just as Mary as a virgin gave birth to Christ in her womb, and so you will be mothers of Christ. It is not far from you, it is not outside you, it does not shrink from you. You were sons; be mothers too. Sons of a mother, when you were baptized, then you were born as Christ's members. Bring to the bath of baptism as many as you can, so that just as you were sons when you were born, so too by leading others to be born you may be able to be mothers of Christ.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]}]}