{"slug":"tmp469.tmp469.opp-lat1","id":"latin:ogl-pl:tmp469.tmp469.opp-lat1","title":"Commentariorum In Osee Prophetam Libri Tres","title_source":"Commentariorum In Osee Prophetam Libri Tres","author":"Hieronymus","genre":"commentary","date":"","tradition":"latin","coverage":"not-located","coverage_claim":{"status":"not-located","text":"No English translation could be identified: a language model asked twice could not name one, though it could not rule one out either. That is not proof that none exists — translations in dissertations, recent books and other modern languages are easily missed."},"publication":{"status":"machine-draft","reviewed_by":null,"model":"deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash:floor","provider":"Baidu","generated":"2026-11-15T23:34:24Z","cost_usd":0.054814},"source":{"registry_id":"latin:ogl-pl:tmp469.tmp469.opp-lat1","work_id":"tmp469.tmp469.opp-lat1","edition":"ogl-pl","language":"","license":"Available under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License","url":"https://github.com/OpenGreekAndLatin/patrologia_latina-dev/blob/master/data/tmp469/tmp469/tmp469.tmp469.opp-lat1.xml"},"stats":{"passages":273,"english_words":72207,"coptic_letters":0,"source_letters":275141,"commentary_units":0,"commentary_kinds":0,"derived_notes":11,"ambiguities":0,"work_notes":0,"external_links":0,"timeline":0},"summary":{},"links":[{"kind":"source","label":"Open Greek and Latin Patrologia Latina","url":"https://github.com/OpenGreekAndLatin/patrologia_latina-dev/blob/master/data/tmp469/tmp469/tmp469.tmp469.opp-lat1.xml"}],"checks":{"work":"tmp469.tmp469.opp-lat1","status":"pass","blocking":[],"warnings":[],"stats":{"passages":273,"translated":273,"commentary_passages":0,"commentary_units":0,"english_words":72207,"source_letters":275141,"commentary_kinds":0},"model":"deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash:floor"},"work_notes":[],"derived_work_notes":[{"kind":"coverage","severity":"info","text":"No English translation could be identified: a language model asked twice could not name one, though it could not rule one out either. That is not proof that none exists — translations in dissertations, recent books and other modern languages are easily missed."},{"kind":"limit","severity":"caution","text":"The English is a machine draft produced passage by passage from the transcribed Latin; no human has verified it. The commentary is model-written and cites only keys the pipeline could resolve."},{"kind":"register","severity":"info","text":"Register: commentary in Latin; the English keeps the liturgical formulae and the vocatives rather than normalising them."},{"kind":"structure","severity":"info","text":"Passages: 273 narrative."},{"kind":"caution","severity":"caution","text":"7 passage(s) are fragmentary in the source; the English bridges each break and says so in the note."},{"kind":"scripture","severity":"info","text":"4 scriptural phrase match(es) noted: Hosea 11:1; Matthew 2:15; John 4:10; Psalm 118:24; Psalm 81:3."},{"kind":"source","severity":"info","text":"Source edition: ogl-pl."},{"kind":"source","severity":"info","text":"Licence: Available under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License"}],"derived_structure":{"narrative":273},"term_index":[],"citations":{},"segments":[{"i":1,"ref":"p1","source":"S. EUSEBII HIERONYMI STRIDOXEXSIS PRESBYTERI COMMENTARIORUM IN OSEAM PROPHETAM LIBRI TRES AD PAMMACHIUM.\n\nPROLOGUS.\n\nSi in explanationibus omnium prophetarum sancti Spiritus indigemus adventu, ut cujus instinctu scripti sunt, illius revelatione pandantur: et in Isaia atque Apocalypsi signatum legimus (Isa. XXIX; Apoc. V) librum, quem Scribae et Pharisaei, qui legis Litteras nosse se jactant (Joan. IX), non possunt legere, quia signatus est, nullusque inveniri potuit, nisi leo de tribu Juda, quem signavit Deus Pater, qui ejus posset reserare mysteria: quanto magis in explanatione Osee prophetae orandus est Dominus, et cum Petro dicendum: Edissere nobis parabolam istam (Matth. XIII, 36). Praesertim cum obscuritatem voluminis in fine testetur ipse, qui scripsit: Quis sapiens et intelliget ista, intelligens et cognoscet ea (Osee XIV, 10)? Quod non pro impossibili, sed pro difficili debemus accipere, juxta illud Evangelii: Quis putas est servus fidelis et prudens quem constituit Dominus super familiam suam (Matth. XXIV, 45)? Quis enim non statim in fronte libri scandalizetur, et dicat: Osee primus omnium prophetarum meretricem accipere jubetur uxorem, et non contradicit?","english":"THE THREE BOOKS OF THE COMMENTARIES OF SAINT EUSEBIUS JEROME, PRIEST, ON THE PROPHET HOSEA, ADDRESSED TO PAMMACHIUS.\n\nPROLOGUE.\n\nIf in the expositions of all the prophets we need the coming of the Holy Spirit, so that by his revelation may be opened what was written by his inspiration—and we read in Isaiah and in the Apocalypse that the book is sealed, which the scribes and Pharisees, who boast that they know the letters of the law, cannot read because it is sealed, and no one could be found to open its mysteries except the lion of the tribe of Judah, whom God the Father sealed—how much more, in the exposition of the prophet Hosea, must the Lord be entreated, and it said with Peter: Explain to us this parable. Especially since the writer himself testifies at the end of the volume to its obscurity: Who is wise and will understand these things, understanding and will know them? This we ought to take not as something impossible but as something difficult, according to that saying of the Gospel: Who do you think is the faithful and prudent servant whom the Lord has set over his household? For who would not at once be scandalized at the very opening of the book, and say: Hosea, the first of all the prophets, is commanded to take a harlot as his wife, and he does not refuse?","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":2,"ref":"p2","source":"Non saltem nolle se simulat, ut rem turpem facere videatur invitus; sed exsequitur laetus imperium, quasi optaverit, quasi multo tempore cum pudicitiae vacasse poeniteat: cum honestiora et absque peccato sanctos viros renuisse, Domino jubente 2, le gerimus. Moyses mittitur ad Pharaonem, et dux Israelitici populi constituitur: et tamen non imbecillitate, sed humilitate respondet: Provide alium quem mittas (Exod. IV, 13). Jeremias puerum esse dicit, ne peccantem arguat Jerusalem (Jerem. I). Ezechiel de omni genere leguminis ac sententis unum subcineri cium panem facere, et coquere illum in humano stercore jubetur, et ait: Nequaquam, Domine, quia nunquam immundum introivit in os meum (Ezech. IV, 14). Et Osee audiens a Domino: Accipe uxorem fornicariam (Osee I, 2), non frontem rugat, non moerorem pallore testatur, non verecundiam, mutato genarum rubore, demonstrat; sed pergit ad lupanar, et scortum ducit ad lectulum. Et non initiat illam pudicitiae matronali; sed se luxuriosum ac nepotem probat. Qui enim adhaeret meretrici, unum cum ea corpus efficitur (I Cor. VI). Haec igitur audientes quid possumus respondere nisi illud propheticum: Quis sapiens et intelliget ista, intelligens et cognoscet ea? (Osee XIV, 10.) Unde et nobis dicendum est cum David: Revela oculos meos, et considerabo mirabilia de lege tua (Psal. CXVIII, 18); ut introducat nos rex in cubiculum suum (Cant.","english":"He does not even pretend to be unwilling, so that he might seem to do a shameful thing against his will; but he carries out the command gladly, as though he had wished for it, as though he regretted having lived chastely for so long a time—although we read that holy men refused even honorable things and things without sin when the Lord commanded. Moses is sent to Pharaoh and appointed leader of the Israelite people, and yet he answers not from weakness but from humility: Send another whom you may send. Jeremiah says that he is a child, lest he rebuke Jerusalem when it sins. Ezekiel is commanded to make one barley cake from every kind of pulse and grain, and to bake it over human dung, and he says: By no means, Lord, because nothing unclean has ever entered my mouth. And Hosea, hearing from the Lord, Take a wife of fornication, does not wrinkle his brow, does not testify to grief by his pallor, does not show shame by a change in the redness of his cheeks; but he goes to the brothel and leads a harlot to his bed. And he does not initiate her into matronly chastity, but proves himself lustful and dissolute. For he who clings to a prostitute becomes one body with her. Hearing these things, then, what can we answer except that prophetic saying: Who is wise and will understand these things, understanding and will know them? Whence we too must say with David: Open my eyes, and I will consider the wondrous things of your law; that the king may bring us into his chamber.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":3,"ref":"p3","source":"I), et velamen quod ante oculos Moysi positum, fuit indectione Veteris Testamenti (Exod. XXXIV, II Cor. III) tollat a nobis. Statim enim ut locutus est Dominus: Pater in manus tuas commendo spiritum meum, et haec dicens exspiravit (Luc. XXIII, 46), velum templi scissum est, et omnia Judaeorum secreta patuerunt. Et fons qui egrediebatur de domo David, ingressus est mare solitudinis: et verus Elisaeus aquas steriles atque mortiferas sapientiae suae condivit sale, et fecit esse vitales (IV Reg. II): Maraque legis quae interpretatur amar tudo, ligno patibuli dulcorata est (Exod. XV). Intelligimus enim quis sit Judas patriarcha electus in regem, nec miratur cur ad Thamar quasi ad meretricem vir sanctus introierit (Gen. XXXVIII); quare Samson, qui interpretatur sol, Dalilam amaverit, quae transfertur in pauperem; et propter eam irrisus et mortuus adversariorum millia trucidarit (Judic. XVI); cur Salmon virum justum Booz de Raab meretrice generarit, qui Ruth Mohabitem pinna pallii sui operiens, et jacentem ad pedes (Ruth. III), ad caput Evangelii transtulerit. Quid causae sit ut cum David tot habuerit uxores, nullum alium regni sui fecerit successorem nisi eum qui de Bethsabee procreatus est (III Reg I): ut non solum meretrices, sed etiam adulterae Deo placere videantur.","english":"and let him take away from us the veil that was placed before Moses' eyes, which was a sign of the Old Testament's rejection. For immediately when the Lord spoke, \"Father, into your hands I commend my spirit,\" and having said this breathed his last, the veil of the temple was torn, and all the secrets of the Jews lay open. And the spring that flowed from the house of David entered the sea of the wilderness; and the true Elisha seasoned the barren and deadly waters with the salt of his wisdom and made them life-giving. And Mara—the law, which is interpreted as bitterness—was made sweet by the wood of the cross. For we understand who Judas the patriarch was, chosen as king, and we do not wonder why the holy man went in to Tamar as to a harlot; why Samson, which is interpreted as \"sun,\" loved Delilah, which is translated as \"poor,\" and on her account, mocked and dead, slaughtered thousands of his adversaries; why Salmon the just man begot Boaz from Rahab the harlot, who, covering Ruth the Moabite with the edge of his cloak and as she lay at his feet, brought her to the head of the Gospel. What reason there is that, although David had so many wives, he made no other successor to his kingdom except the one born of Bathsheba: so that not only harlots but even adulteresses may seem to please God.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":4,"ref":"p4","source":"Unde et in hoc ipso propheta legimus, quod junctus primum meretrici, secundo adulterae copuletur, dicente ad eum Domino: Adhuc vade, dilige mulierem dilectam amico (Osee III, 1,) sive diligentem mala, et adulteram. Haec est mulier meretrix et adultera, quae in Evangelio pedes Domini lacrymis lavit, crine detersit, et confessionis suae honoravit unguento, indignantibusque discipulis, et maxime proditore, quod non fuisset venditum, et pretium illius in alimenta pauperum distributum. Dominus respondit: Quid molesti estis mulieri? opus bonum operata est in me, pauperes enim semper habebitis vobiscum, me autem non semper habebitis (Matth. XXVI, 10, 11). Et ne putaremus leve esse quod fecerat, et nardum pisticum, id est, unguentum fidelissimum, ad aliud quid et non ad Ecclesiam esse referendum, dat nobis occasionem intelligentiae et magnae fidei, magna praemia repromittit, dicens: Amen, amen dico vobis, ubicunque praedicatum fuerit hoc Evangelium in toto mundo, dicetur quod haec fecit in memoriam ejus. Haec est meretrix de qua loquitur Dominus ad Judaeos: Amen dico vobis, meretrices et publicani praecedent vos in regno Dei (Matth. XXI, 31). Vos enim missum ad vos Filium patrisfamiliae et Dominum vineae, qui plantavit eam, suscipere noluistis.","english":"Hence we read also in this very prophet that he who was first joined to a harlot is secondly united to an adulteress, the Lord saying to him: Go yet, love a woman beloved of a friend, or loving evil, and an adulteress. This is the woman, a harlot and an adulteress, who in the Gospel washed the Lord's feet with tears, wiped them with her hair, and honored the confession of her faith with ointment, while the disciples were indignant, and especially the traitor, that it had not been sold and its price distributed for the food of the poor. The Lord answered: Why are you troublesome to the woman? She has wrought a good work in me, for the poor you will always have with you, but me you will not always have. And lest we should think that what she had done was of little account, and that the spikenard, that is, the most faithful ointment, should be referred to something else and not to the Church, he gives us an occasion of understanding and promises great rewards to great faith, saying: Amen, amen I say to you, wherever this Gospel has been preached in the whole world, it will be told what she has done in memory of her. This is the harlot of whom the Lord speaks to the Jews: Amen I say to you, harlots and publicans shall go before you into the kingdom of God. For you were unwilling to receive the Son of the father of the household and the Lord of the vineyard, who planted it, when he was sent to you.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":5,"ref":"p5","source":"Ista meretrix exploratores meos duos fortissimos juvenes, quorum alterum in circumcisionem misi, alterum ad gentes, humanitate suscepit, abscondit studio, levavit in tectum, operuit lini stipula (Jos. II). Quae caesa persecutionibus, et lota in baptismate immutat colorem, et de tetro in album vertitur. Nec mirum si in figura Domini Salvatoris, et Ecclesiae de peccatoribus congregatae, haec facta memoremus, cum ipse in hoc eodem dicat propheta Loquar ad prophetas; ego visiones multiplicavi, et in manibus prophetarum assimilatus sum (Osee XII, 10); ut quidquid prophetae jubentur operari, ad meam referatur similitudinem. Cujus uxor AEthiopissa est. contra quam Aaron et Maria, carnale sacerdotium Judaeorum, et prophetia litterae serviens mussitant et offendunt Deum (Num. XII): quae dicit in Cantico canticorum: Fusca sum et formosa, filio Jerusalem (Cant. I, 4). Alioquin ei omnia quae praecipiuntur ob causas, ut in similitudinem fiant, vere facta contendimus: ergo et Jeremias accinctus lumbari, vestimento muliebri, inter innumerabiles nationes et Assyrios atque Chaldaeos, gentes inimicissimas Judaeorum, ivit ad Euphratem, ut ibi absconderet lumbare suum, et post multa tempora reversus, invenit illud computruisse quod nulli esset usui (Jerem. XIII). Quomodo exire poterat, et ire tam longe obsessa Jerusalem, exstructis per circuitum munitionibus, fossa, vallo, atque castellis?","english":"That harlot received my two most valiant young scouts with kindness—one of whom I sent to the circumcision, the other to the Gentiles—hid them with zeal, lifted them onto the roof, and covered them with stalks of flax (Josh. 2). She who was cut down by persecutions and washed in baptism changes her color, and is turned from foul to white. Nor is it surprising if we recall these things as done in the figure of the Lord Savior and of the Church gathered from sinners, since He Himself says in this same prophet: I will speak to the prophets; I have multiplied visions, and I have been made like in the hands of the prophets (Hos. 12:10); so that whatever the prophets are commanded to do may be referred to my likeness. His wife is an Ethiopian woman, against whom Aaron and Miriam—the carnal priesthood of the Jews and the prophecy serving the letter—murmur and offend God (Num. 12); she who says in the Song of Songs: I am dark and beautiful, O daughters of Jerusalem (Song 1:4). Otherwise, if we contend that everything commanded to him was truly done for the sake of making a figure, then Jeremiah too, girded with a loincloth, a woman's garment, went among countless nations and the Assyrians and Chaldeans, races most hostile to the Jews, to the Euphrates, to hide his loincloth there, and returning after much time, he found that it had rotted and was of no use to anyone (Jer. 13). How could he have gone out and traveled so far, when Jerusalem was besieged, with fortifications built all around, a trench, a rampart, and strongholds?","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":6,"ref":"p6","source":"Qui cum semel ad Anatoth viculum suum in tertio milliario ab urbe situm voluisset exire, in porta capitur, et reductus ad principes, quasi proditor verberatus in carcerem mittitur. Si illud in typo, quia fieri non potuit: ergo et hoc in typo, quia si fiat, turpissimum est. Sed respondebis, Deo jubente, nihil turpe est: et nos dicimus, nihil Deus praecipit nisi quod honestum est, nec jubendo turpia, facit honesta quae turpia sunt. Sed quia scimus nihil Deum velle nisi quod honestum est, hoc praecepit quod honestum est. Haec in principio prolixius sum locutus, ut difficillimam primum solverem quaestionem, et obsitum in ipso exitu scopulum Dei auxilio praetergrediens, ad tuta decurrerem. Caeterum non ignoro, Pammachi charissime, a multis Ecclesiasticis praetermissam: et qui exponere sunt conati, apud Graecos reperi Apollinarem Laodicenum, qui cum in adolescentia sua breves et in hunc et in alios prophetas commenta(??)olos reliquisset, tangens magis sensus, quam explicans, rogatus est postea, ut in Osee. plenius scriberet: qui liber venit in nostras manus; sed et ipse nimia brevitate ad perfectam intelligentiam lectorem docere non potest. Origenes parvum de hoc propheta scripsit libellum, cui hunc titulum imposuit,, hoc est, quare appellatur in Osee Ephraim volens ostendere quaecunque contra eum dicuntur, ad haereticorum referenda personam.","english":"He, when he had once wished to go out to his little village of Anathoth, situated at the third milestone from the city, was seized at the gate, and led back to the princes, and, as if a traitor, was beaten and sent into prison. If that was in a type, because it could not happen, then this too is in a type, because if it happens, it is most shameful. But you will answer, With God commanding, nothing is shameful; and we say, God commands nothing except what is honorable, nor by commanding shameful things does he make honorable the things that are shameful. But because we know that God wills nothing except what is honorable, he commanded that which is honorable. I have spoken these things at greater length at the beginning, so that I might first solve the most difficult question, and, passing by with God's help the rock that blocks the very entrance, I might run down to safe ground. Otherwise I am not unaware, most dear Pammachius, that it has been passed over by many ecclesiastical writers; and those who have attempted to expound it—I have found among the Greeks Apollinaris of Laodicea, who, when in his youth he had left brief commentaries on this prophet and on others, touching the sense rather than explaining it, was later asked to write more fully on Hosea. That book has come into our hands; but even it, by its excessive brevity, cannot teach the reader to perfect understanding. Origen wrote a small book on this prophet, to which he gave this title, that is, why Ephraim is named in Hosea, wishing to show that whatever things are said against him are to be referred to the person of the heretics.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":7,"ref":"p7","source":"Et aliud volumen, quod et capite careat et fine. Pierii quoque legi tractatum longissimum, quem in exordio hujus prophetae die vigiliarum Dominicae passionis extemporali et diserto sermone profudit. Et Eusebius Caesariensis in octavo decimo libro, quaedam de Osec propheta disputat. Unde ante annoscirciter viginti duos, cum rogatu sanctae et venetabilis socrus, imo matris tuae Paula (illud enim nomen carnis, hoc spiritus est: quae monasteriorum et Scripturarum semper amore flagravit) essem Alexandriae, vidi Didymum 2, et eum frequenter audivi, virum sui temporis eruditissimum, rogavique eum, ut quod Origenes non fecerat, ipse compleret, et scriberet in Osee Commentarios qui ties libros, me petente 3, dictavit quinque quoque alios in Zachariam. Nam et in ipsum duo tantum Origenes scripsit volumina, vix tertiam partem a principio libri usque ad visionem quadrigarum edisserens. Haec dico, ut noveris quos in prophetae hujus campo habuerim praecursores: quos tamen ut simpliciter et non superbe (sicut quidam meorum amicorum semper insibilet) tuae prudentiae fatear, non in omnibus sum secutus; ut judex potius operis eorum quam interpres exsisterem, diceremque quid mihi videretur in singulis, et quid ab Hebraeorum magistris vix uno et allero acceperim.","english":"And another volume, which lacks both a beginning and an end. I have also read the very long treatise of Pierius, which he poured out in the introduction to this prophet on the eve of the Lord's passion in an extemporaneous and eloquent sermon. And Eusebius of Caesarea, in the eighteenth book, discusses certain matters concerning the prophet Hosea. Hence, about twenty-two years ago, when at the request of your holy and venerable mother-in-law—or rather, mother—Paula (for the former is a name of the flesh, the latter of the spirit; she always burned with love for monasteries and the Scriptures), I was at Alexandria, I saw Didymus and heard him frequently—a man most learned of his time—and I asked him to complete what Origen had not done and to write commentaries on Hosea, which he dictated to me at my request in three books, and five others on Zechariah. For Origen wrote only two volumes on that prophet as well, scarcely explaining the third part from the beginning of the book up to the vision of the four chariots. I say this so that you may know what forerunners I had in the field of this prophet; yet, to confess frankly and not proudly to your prudence (as some of my friends are always whispering), I have not followed them in all things, but have rather been a judge of their work than an interpreter, saying what seemed to me in each case, and what I have received from the Hebrew teachers, scarcely one or two.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":8,"ref":"p8","source":"Quorum et apud ipsos jam rara avis est, dumomnes deliciis student et pecuniis, et magis ventri quam pectoris curam gerunt, et in hoc se doctos arbitrantur, si in tabernis medicorum de cunctorumoperibus detrahant. Sed jam tempus est ut prophetae verba ponentes, ea quae scripta sunt disseramus\n\nLIBER PRIMUS.\n\n(Cap. 1.—Vers. 1.) « Verbum Domini quod fartum est ad Osee filium Beeri. » LXX similiter. Verbum Domini, quod in principio erat apud Deum Patrem, et Deus erat Verbum, factum est ad Osee filium Beeri, ut prophetam quoque Deum faceret, Salvatore dicente: Si illos dixit deos, ad quos sermo Dei factus est, et non potest solvi Scriptura: quem Pater sanctificavit et misit in mundum, vos dicitis: Quia blasphemas: quia dixi, filius Dei sum (Joan. X, 35, 36). Ut quomodo Deus deos facit, et stat in synagoga deorum, in medio autem deos dijudicat (Psal. LXXXI); et cum ipse sit verum lumen, quod illuminat omnem hominem venientem in hunc, mundum (Joan. I), ad apostolos loquitur: Vos estis lux mundi (Matth. V, 14), sic et ipse Salvator prophetam suum faciat salvatorem. Osee enim in lingua nostra, salvatorem sonat: quod nomen habuit etiam Josue filius Nun (Num. XIV), antequam ei a Deo vocabulum mutaretur.","english":"Of these men, even among themselves, it is now a rare bird, since all are devoted to pleasures and money, and take more care for the belly than for the heart, and think themselves learned in this, if in the shops of the physicians they disparage the works of all. But now it is time that, setting down the words of the prophet, we discuss what has been written.\n\nBOOK ONE.\n\n(Ch. 1—v. 1.) \"The word of the Lord that was made to Hosea the son of Beeri.\" The Septuagint likewise. The word of the Lord, which in the beginning was with God the Father, and God was the Word, was made to Hosea the son of Beeri, so that it might make the prophet also a god, the Savior saying: If he called them gods, to whom the word of God came, and the Scripture cannot be broken: whom the Father sanctified and sent into the world, you say: Because you blaspheme: because I said, I am the Son of God (John 10:35, 36). So that, just as God makes gods, and stands in the synagogue of gods, and in the midst judges the gods (Psalm 81), and since he himself is the true light, which enlightens every man coming into this world (John 1), he speaks to the apostles: You are the light of the world (Matthew 5:14), so also the Savior himself may make his prophet a savior. For Hosea in our language sounds as savior: which name Joshua the son of Nun also had (Numbers 14), before his name was changed by God.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":9,"ref":"p9","source":"Non enim (ut male in Graecis codicibus legitur et Latinis) Ause dictus est, quod nihil omnino intelligitur; sed Osee, id est salvator; et additum esi ejus nomini Dominus, ut salvator Domini diceretur. Iste ergo salvator filius est Beeri, id est, putei mei, quos puteos fodit Abrabam, Isaac et Jacob, et Allophyli eos semper conabantur obruere (Gen. XVI, XXI, XXVI,XLVI). Inter puteum et lacum, id est cisternam, hoc interest quod puteus perpetuas aquas habet, de vivo fonte manantes. Cisterna, quae refrigerat, aquas suas externas et adventitias possidet. Unde per Jeremiam prophetam loquitur Deus: Me dereliquerunt fontem aquae vivae, et foderunt sibi cisternas, quae aquas non valent continere (Jerem. II, 13). De hoc forte ad Deum Psalmista proclamat: Apud te est fons vitae, et in lumine tuo videbimus lumen (Psal. XXXV, 10). Unde quidam putant Beeri, interpretari, lumen meum; sed superior vera translatio est.","english":"For it is not \"Ause,\" as is wrongly read in the Greek and Latin manuscripts, that he is called—which means nothing at all—but Osee, that is, savior; and \"Lord\" was added to his name, so that he might be called the savior of the Lord. This savior, then, is the son of Beeri, that is, of my wells—the wells that Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob dug, and which the Philistines always tried to fill up (Gen. 16, 21, 26, 46). Between a well and a pool, that is, a cistern, there is this difference: a well has perpetual waters, flowing from a living spring. A cistern, which cools, holds waters of its own that are external and come from elsewhere. Hence God speaks through the prophet Jeremiah: They have abandoned me, the fountain of living water, and have dug for themselves cisterns, which cannot hold water (Jer. 2:13). It is perhaps of this that the Psalmist cries out to God: With you is the fountain of life, and in your light we shall see light (Ps. 35:10). Hence some think that Beeri is to be interpreted as \"my light\"; but the former translation is the true one.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[{"kind":"scripture","severity":"info","ref":"John 4:10","text":"The English carries the scriptural phrase “living water”, which matches John 4:10. The match is on the English draft; check the Coptic before quoting the verse."}]},{"i":10,"ref":"p10","source":"« In diebus Oziae, Joathan, Achaz, Ezechiae regum Juda; et in diebus Jeroboam filii regis Israel. » LXX similiter. Azarias, qui vocatur et Ozias, de stirpe David reg cavit in Jerusalem super duas tribus, quae appellabantur Juda, annis quinquaginta duobus cui successit in regnum filius ejus Joatham, qui et ipse regnavit annis sedecim; post quem filius ejus Achaz regnavit annis similiter sedecim 1. Post Achaz regnavit filius ejus Ezechias annis viginti novem, cujus anno sexto decem tribus, quae appellabantur Israel, captae sunt a Salmanasar rege Chaldaeorum, et in Medorum montibus collocatae. Ex quo perspicuum est, prophetante Osee, Isaia, et Joel, et Amos, et Abdia, et Jona et Michaea, qui ejus fuerunt, regnum decem tribuum esse Anitum, quod a primo rege Jeroboam usque ad ultimum Osee, permansit annis ducentis quinquaginta. Eo autem tempore, quo Ozias regnare coepit super Judam, super Israel regnabat Jerobuam pronepos Jehu, cui Dominus repromiserat usque ad quartam generationem sobolem illius regnaturam: eo quod percussisset duos reges impios, Juda et Israel.","english":"In the days of Uzziah, Jotham, Ahaz, and Hezekiah, kings of Judah; and in the days of Jeroboam, son of the king of Israel.\" The Septuagint reads likewise. Azariah, who is also called Uzziah, of the stock of David, reigned in Jerusalem over the two tribes which were called Judah for fifty-two years. His son Jotham succeeded him in the kingdom, and he too reigned sixteen years; after him his son Ahaz reigned likewise sixteen years. After Ahaz, his son Hezekiah reigned twenty-nine years, in whose sixth year the ten tribes, which were called Israel, were captured by Salmanasar, king of the Chaldeans, and settled in the mountains of the Medes. From this it is clear that, while Osee, Isaiah, Joel, Amos, Obadiah, Jonah, and Micah—who were his contemporaries—were prophesying, the kingdom of the ten tribes had already been ended, which from its first king Jeroboam down to the last Osee endured for two hundred and fifty years. But at the time when Uzziah began to reign over Judah, Jeroboam, the great-grandson of Jehu, was reigning over Israel, to whom the Lord had promised that his offspring would reign to the fourth generation, because he had struck down the two impious kings, Judah and Israel.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":11,"ref":"p11","source":"Hoc dicimus ut tibi breviter ostendamus, Osee prophetam, et ante captivitatem Israel, et post captivitatem ejus vaticinatum, et tam vicinam, quam praesentem, et praeteritam vidisse 3, et denuntiasse venturam, et luxisse ingruentem, et in emendationem Judae retexuisse praeterita: quod in ipso propheta juxta historiam conabimur approbare. Ozias interpretatur fortitudo Domini: Joatham, Domini consummatio, atque perfectio: Achaz, virtus: Ezechias, imperium Domini. Hi regnabant in populo Juda, cujus nomen, confessio, est. Porro in Israel qui sibi idola fecerat, et a Dei populo fuerat separatus, regnabat Jeroboam 4, qui interpretatur, id est, temporalitas, sive mora: quod mundum amaverit, et in ipso morari diu, vitam putaverit, sempiternam, nequaquam futuris, sed praesentibus delectatus.\n\n(Vers. 2.) « Principium loquendi Domini in Osee. » LXX: « Principium verbi Domini ad Osee. » Quia, ut supra diximus, et aliis prophetis praeferuntur in titulo, Ozias, Joatham, Achaz, et Ezechias, quibus regnantibus prophetaverunt: idcirco nunc dicit quod inter omnes hos primum in Osee Dominus sit locutus, et postea ad caeteros. Aliud est autem loqui Dominum in Osee, aliud ad Osee. In Osee, non ipsi loquitur Osee, sed per Osee ad alios; ad Osee vero loquens, ad ipsum significatur conferre sermonem.","english":"We say this to show you briefly that the prophet Hosea prophesied both before the captivity of Israel and after its captivity, and saw and foretold things as near, present, and past, and mourned over what was coming upon them, and wove past events into the correction of Judah—which we shall attempt to prove in this same prophet according to the historical sense. Uzziah is interpreted as \"strength of the Lord\"; Jotham, \"consummation and perfection of the Lord\"; Ahaz, \"virtue\"; Hezekiah, \"empire of the Lord.\" These reigned over the people of Judah, whose name means \"confession.\" But in Israel, which had made idols for itself and had been separated from the people of God, Jeroboam reigned, which is interpreted as \"temporality\" or \"delay,\" because he loved the world and thought that to linger long in it was eternal life, delighting not at all in things to come but in things present.\n\n(Verse 2.) \"The beginning of the Lord's speaking in Hosea.\" The Septuagint: \"The beginning of the word of the Lord to Hosea.\" Because, as we said above, Uzziah, Jotham, Ahaz, and Hezekiah are preferred to the other prophets in the title, since the prophet prophesied while they reigned, therefore he now says that among all these the Lord first spoke in Hosea, and afterward to the others. But it is one thing for the Lord to speak in Hosea, and another to speak to Hosea. In Hosea, he does not speak to Hosea himself, but through Hosea to others; but when he speaks to Hosea, it is signified that he is directing his discourse to him.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":12,"ref":"p12","source":"Alii autem non primum omnium prophetarum volunt fuisse Osee, ex eo quod dicitur: Principium loquendi Domini in Osee: sed ostendi quod haec quae sequuntur, primum ad Osee Dominus sit locutus.\n\n« Et dixit Dominus ad Osee: Vade, sume tibi uxorem fornicationum. » LXX: « Et dixit Dominus Ad Osee: Vade, tolle tibi uxorem fornicationis. » Verbum Hebraicum ZANUNIM ( )1, non fornicariam et fornicationem, ut plerique aestimant, sed multas fornicationes sonat. Ex quo ostenditur mulier ista, quam Propheta sumit in conjugem, non semel, sed frequentius fornicatam, ut quanto illa sordidior est, tanto sit Propheta patientior, qui talem uxorem duxerit. Quodque additur:\n\n« Ac filios fornicationum: quia fornicans fornicabitur terra a Domino. » LXX: « Et filios fornicationis: quia fornicans fornicabitur terra post Dominum. » subauditor: Sume tibi uxorem fornicationum, et sume ubi filios fornicationum. Utrumque potest intelligi, quod et fornicariae priores de fornicatione susceptos recipiat filios, et ipse ex meretrice generet filios, qui idcirco fornicationis appellandi sunt filii, quod sint de meretrice generati. Nec culpandus Propheta, interim ut sequamur historiam, si meretricem converterit ad pudicitiam, sed potius laudandus quod ex mala bonam fecerit. Non enim qui bonus permanet, ipse polluitur, si societur malo; sed qui malus est, in bonum vertitur, si boni exempla sectetur.","english":"But others maintain that Hosea was not the first of all the prophets, from the fact that it is said, \"The beginning of the Lord's speaking in Hosea,\" but they show that these things which follow were first spoken by the Lord to Hosea.\n\n\"And the Lord said to Hosea: Go, take to yourself a wife of fornications.\" The Septuagint: \"And the Lord said to Hosea: Go, take to yourself a wife of fornication.\" The Hebrew word ZANUNIM does not mean a fornicating woman and fornication, as most suppose, but many fornications. From this it is shown that this woman, whom the prophet takes as his wife, has fornicated not once but frequently, so that the more defiled she is, the more patient the prophet may be who has married such a wife. And what is added:\n\n\"And children of fornications: because the land will surely fornicate from the Lord.\" The Septuagint: \"And children of fornication: because the land will surely fornicate after the Lord.\" Understand: Take to yourself a wife of fornications, and take to yourself children of fornications. Both can be understood: that he receives the former children of the harlot, conceived from fornication, and that he himself begets children from a prostitute, who are for that reason called children of fornication because they were begotten from a prostitute. Nor is the prophet to be blamed, so far as we follow the historical account, if he converted a prostitute to chastity, but rather praised because he made a good woman out of a bad one. For the one who remains good is not himself polluted if he is joined to an evil person; but the one who is evil is turned to good, if he follows the examples of the good.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":13,"ref":"p13","source":"Ex quo intelligimus non prophetam perdidisse pudicitiam fornicariae copulatum; sed fornicariam assumpsisse pudicitiam quam antea non habebat: praesertim cum beatus Osee, non ob causam luxuriae, non libidinis, non propria fecerit voluntate, sed Dei paruerit imperio, ut quod in isto carnaliter legimus, in Deo factum spiritualiter probaremus. Qui suscepit Synagogam, hoc est, populum Judaeorum fornicationi et libidini servientem. Ad quam Dominus loquitur per Ezechielem: Et tu, meretriae, audi verbum Domini: Fractae enim sunt in AEgypto mammae ejus (Ezech. XXIII, 3); et volutabatur in sanguine, et fuerat polluta usque ad verticem, ut nulla pars corporis atque membrorum ejus esset, quae turpitudinis maculam non haberet. Operuit talem Dominus pallio, et suis junxit amplexibus, dedit ei mel et oleum et similam manducare, et induit eam vestibus pretiosissimis, posuit in collo ornamenta gemmarum, aures ornavit auro et lapide pretiosissimo, armillas quoque brachiis praebuit ut bonis uteretur operibus. Et nihilominus haec contempta largitate et bonitate viri, prioris immemor turpitudinis, amatores Chaldaeos et Assyrios et AEgyptios, qui magnarum sunt carnium, secuta est.","english":"From this we understand that the prophet did not lose his chastity by being joined to a harlot, but that the harlot received the chastity she did not have before; especially since blessed Hosea did this not for the sake of luxury, not from lust, not by his own will, but in obedience to God's command, so that what we read was done carnally in him, we might prove was done spiritually in God. He took up the Synagogue, that is, the people of the Jews, enslaved to fornication and lust. To her the Lord speaks through Ezekiel: \"And you, harlot, hear the word of the Lord: for her breasts were broken in Egypt\" (Ezekiel 23:3); and she wallowed in blood, and had been defiled up to the head, so that no part of her body and members was without the stain of shame. The Lord covered such a one with a cloak, and joined her to his embraces, gave her honey and oil and fine flour to eat, and clothed her in most precious garments, placed ornaments of gems on her neck, adorned her ears with gold and precious stone, and also provided bracelets for her arms, so that she might engage in good works. And nevertheless, despising the generosity and goodness of her husband, forgetful of her former shame, she followed after her lovers the Chaldeans and Assyrians and Egyptians, who are of great flesh.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":14,"ref":"p14","source":"De Salvatoris et Ecclesias typo in praefatiuncula diximus, quod sumpserit sibi uxorem fornicariam, quae prius idolis serviebat Si quis autem contentiosus, et maxime gentilium, noluerit figuraliter dictum recipere, et irriserit prophetam fornicariae copulatum, opponamus ei illud, quod solet laudare Graecia, et philosophorum scholae concinunt. Qua ratione praedicent virum eruditissimum Xenocratem, qui Polemonem luxuriosissimum juvenem inter psaltriae atque tibicines et impudicas mulieres ebrium et hedera coronatum fecit obedire sapientiae, el adolescentem turpissimum mutavit in sapientissimum philosophorum. Cur Socratem ad coelum levent, qui Phaedonem, ex cujus nomine Platonis liber est, de lupanari, ob crudelitatem et avaritiam domini, multorum libidini servientem, in Academiam transtulerit? El quidquid illi de philosophiae magistris responderint, nos ad Prophetae defensionem referimus. Haec adversum ethnicos et eos, qui ethnicorum sunt similes, dixerimus. Caeterum nostris, qui tamen volunt suscipere veritatem, illud breviter ostendamus, ex eo quod dicitur: Quia fornicans, fornicabitur terraa Domino, non tam prophetam junctum esse meretrici, quam omne hominum genus a societate Domini recessisse. Potest quoque ex co quod non. est additum.","english":"We have spoken in the preface about the type of the Savior and the Church, that he took to himself a fornicating wife, who had previously served idols. But if anyone contentious, and especially of the Gentiles, is unwilling to accept what was said figuratively, and has mocked the prophet joined to a harlot, let us set before him that which Greece is accustomed to praise and the schools of the philosophers agree upon. By what reasoning do they proclaim Xenocrates, a most learned man, who made Polemon, a most dissolute young man, drunk among harp-girls and flute-players and shameless women and crowned with ivy, obey wisdom, and changed a most shameful youth into the wisest of philosophers? Why do they raise Socrates to heaven, who transferred Phaedo—from whose name is the book of Plato—from a brothel, where he served the lust of many because of the cruelty and greed of his master, into the Academy? And whatever they answer concerning the teachers of philosophy, we refer to the defense of the prophet. We have said these things against the Gentiles and those who are like the Gentiles. But for our own people, who nevertheless wish to receive the truth, let us briefly show that from what is said—\"Because the land will surely commit fornication from the Lord\"—it is not so much that the prophet was joined to a prostitute as that the whole human race has withdrawn from fellowship with the Lord. It can also be shown from the fact that it is not added.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":15,"ref":"p15","source":"omnis terra, nunc Judaea accipi, vel proprie Samaria et Israel, id est, decem tribus, quae co tempore quo haec dicebamur, a Domino recesserant.\n\n(Vers. 5, 1.) « Et abiit, et accepit Gomer filiam Debelaim: et concepit et peperit filium. Et dixit Dominus ad cum: Voca nomen ejus Jezrael: quoniam adhuc modicum et visitabosanguinem Jezrael super domum Jehu: et quiescere faciam regnum domus Israel. » LXX: « Et abiit, et accepit Gomer filiam Debelaim: et concepit, et peperit filium. Et dixit Dominus ad eum: Voca nomen ejus Jezrael: quia adhuc modicum et ulciscar sanguinem Jezrael super domum Juda: et quiescere faciam regnum domus Israel. » Prophetae sic multa post saecula de adventu Christi et vocatione gentium pollicentur, ut praesens tempus non negligant, ne concionem ob aliud convocatam non docere de his quae instant, sed de incertis ac futuris ludere videantur. Itaque et haec Gomer filia Dehelaim, quae ab Osee uxor accipitur, et concipit ex eo, et parit ei filium nomine Jezrael, qui interpretatur semen Dei, in cujus sanguinis ultionem, regnum subvertit Jehu, sive, ut male error obtinuit, Juda, sic ad vocationem referenda est nationum, ut illi tempori congruat, sub quo filium generasse memoratur.","english":"all the earth,” now Judaea is meant, or properly Samaria and Israel, that is, the ten tribes, which at the time when these things were spoken had withdrawn from the Lord.\n\n(Vers. 5, 1.) “And he went and took Gomer the daughter of Debelaim: and she conceived and bore a son. And the Lord said to him: Call his name Jezrael: for yet a little while and I will visit the blood of Jezrael upon the house of Jehu: and I will make the kingdom of the house of Israel to cease.” The LXX: “And he went and took Gomer the daughter of Debelaim: and she conceived and bore a son. And the Lord said to him: Call his name Jezrael: for yet a little while and I will avenge the blood of Jezrael upon the house of Juda: and I will make the kingdom of the house of Israel to cease.” The prophets thus promise many things after ages concerning the coming of Christ and the calling of the Gentiles, yet not so as to neglect the present time, lest a gathering convoked for one purpose appear not to teach about the things at hand, but to play with uncertain and future things. Therefore also this Gomer, daughter of Dehelaim, who is taken by Osee as wife, and conceives from him, and bears him a son named Jezrael, which is interpreted “seed of God,” in whose blood’s avenging he overturns the kingdom of Jehu, or, as error has wrongly held, of Juda—this must be referred to the calling of the nations in such a way as to fit that time under which she is recorded to have borne a son.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":16,"ref":"p16","source":"Et ne longo tractatu lectoris aviditatem differam, duae istae mulieres quarum una vocatur Homer, et est meretrix, paritque tres liberos, primum Jezrael, secundam puellam, quae vocatur absque misericordia, et tertium masculum, qui et ipse appellatur non populas meus: et altera mulier, quae conducitur argenteis quindecim, et coro, et dimidio coro hordei, et vocatur adultera, referuntur ad Israel et ad Judam, id est, ad decem tribus quae erant in Samaria sub rege Jeroboam, qui fuit de Ephraim, et ad Judam, qui regnabat in Jerusalem de stirpe David. Hae sunt duae mulieres, quae in Zacharia upupae, sive milvi, sive herodii pennas habere dicuntur, et ire in terram Sennaar, ubi Babylon condita est. Has mulieres sub nomine duarum sororum Oola significat et Ooliba: hae in duabus virgis, quas Ezechiel in unam virgam sociat, domonstrantur. Et quia Commentarios, non lata volumina scribimus, singulis capitulis explanationes proprias in suis locis reservantes, nunc tantum de praesenti capitulo disputemus. Gomer interpretatur, id est, consummata, atque perfecta: alii, id est, loricas, significari putant. Sunt qui mensuram, sive amaritudinem suspicentur, qui recte dicerent, si GIMEL litteram non haberet. Debelaim sonat, quarum in Palaestina permagna copia est, et quas Isaias propheta ulceri Ezechiae regis jubet apponi (IV Reg. II et Isa. XXXVIII).","english":"And so that I may not keep the reader's eagerness waiting with a long treatise, these two women, of whom one is called Gomer and is a harlot and bears three children—first Jezreel, second a girl who is called \"without mercy,\" and third a male who is himself called \"not my people\"—and the other woman, who is hired for fifteen pieces of silver, and a cor and half a cor of barley, and is called an adulteress, are referred to Israel and to Judah, that is, to the ten tribes that were in Samaria under King Jeroboam, who was from Ephraim, and to Judah, who reigned in Jerusalem from the stock of David. These are the two women who in Zechariah are said to have the wings of a hoopoe, or a kite, or a heron, and to go into the land of Shinar, where Babylon was founded. These women he signifies under the name of the two sisters Oholah and Oholibah; these are shown in the two sticks that Ezekiel joins into one stick. And because we are writing commentaries, not voluminous tomes, reserving the proper explanations for each chapter in their own places, let us now dispute only about the present chapter. Gomer is interpreted as \"consummated\" and \"perfect\"; others think \"breastplates\" are meant. There are those who suspect it means \"measure\" or \"bitterness,\" who would speak correctly if it did not have the letter gimel. Debelaim means those things of which there is a very great abundance in Palestine, and which the prophet Isaiah orders to be applied to the ulcer of King Hezekiah.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":17,"ref":"p17","source":"Est autem massa pinguium caricarum, quas in morem laterum figurantes, ut diu illaesae permaneant, calcant atque compingunt. Igitur et Israel consummata in fornicatione atque perfecta filia voluptatis, quae fruentibus suavis videtur et dulcis, in typo Domini Salvatoris ab Osce uxor accipitur: et primus ex ea Dei Filius generatur, id est, Jezrael; est autem civitas metropolis decem tribuum, in qua interfictus est Naboth, ob cujus sanguinem suscitatur Jehu, qui delevit domum Achab et Jezabel. Verum quia et ipse Jehu, ultor sanguinis justi, ingressus est per vias Jeroboam filii Nabath, qui fornicari fecit Israel, et constituit vitulos aureos in Dan et in Bethel (III Reg. XII), regnum quoque ejus dicitur subvertendum: sub cujus pronepote Jeroboam prophetare coepit Osee; quo mortuo, filius ejus Zacharias successit in regnum; quem sexto mense imperii sui occidit Sellum de alia stirpe generatum (IV Reg. XV). Quam ob causam hunc dicitur: Adhuc modicum, et visitabo sanguinem Jezrael, id est, occisionem populi mei, super domum Jehu regiam, quae eo tempore praeerat Israel. Nec mirum si domus Jehu subvertatur, cum etiam regnum domus Israel, hoc est, decem tribuum post non multos annos omnino sit delendum. A Zacharia enim filio Jeroboam, cujus atavus fuit Jehu, usque ad nonum annum Osee, sub quo decem tribus ductae sunt in captivitatem, supputantur anni quadraginta et novem.","english":"Now the mass of fat figs is what they form into the likeness of bricks, treading and pressing them together so that they may remain unspoiled for a long time. Therefore Israel too, consummated in fornication and a perfected daughter of pleasure, who seems pleasant and sweet to those who enjoy her, is taken as a wife by Hosea in the type of the Lord Savior: and from her the first Son of God is begotten, that is, Jezreel; and it is the capital city of the ten tribes, in which Naboth was killed, for whose blood Jehu is raised up, who destroyed the house of Ahab and Jezebel. But because Jehu himself, the avenger of the just man's blood, entered upon the ways of Jeroboam the son of Nabath, who made Israel to fornicate, and set up golden calves in Dan and in Bethel (1 Kings 12), his kingdom too is said to be about to be overthrown: under whose great-grandson Jeroboam Hosea began to prophesy; when he died, his son Zechariah succeeded to the kingdom; whom Shallum, born of another stock, killed in the sixth month of his reign (2 Kings 15). For this reason it is said to him: Yet a little while, and I will visit the blood of Jezreel, that is, the slaughter of my people, upon the royal house of Jehu, which at that time presided over Israel. Nor is it strange if the house of Jehu is overthrown, since even the kingdom of the house of Israel, that is, of the ten tribes, is after not many years to be utterly destroyed. For from Zechariah the son of Jeroboam, whose ancestor was Jehu, up to the ninth year of Hoshea, under whom the ten tribes were led into captivity, forty-nine years are reckoned.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":18,"ref":"p18","source":"Occisoque Zacharia, qui fuit ultimus de stirpe Jehu, statim reges Assyrii ceperunt Ruben et Gad et dimidiam tribum Manasse, quae erant trans Jordanem; et deinde multas civitates Samariae, et deinde totam Nephtali, ad extremum omnes reliquas tribus. Pro Jehu in editione Vulgata legitur Juda: sed hoc mihi videtur non vitio Septuaginta interpretum, sed scriptorum inolevisse imneritia, qui ignorantes Jehu: quod magis tritum erat, scripserunt Juda. Typus autem seminis Dei, et ultio sanguinis ejus refertur ad Domini passionem, propter quam et domus Juda et regnum universi Israel dicitur subvertendum.\n\n(Vers. 5.) « Et in illa die conteram arcum Israel in valle Jezrael. » LXX similiter. Quando ultus fuero sanguinem Jezrael super domum Jeha, et regnum Israel, Assyrio vincente, delevero, tunc illa die, et in illo tempore conteram omne robur exercitus Israel in valle Jezrael. Supra diximus Jezraelem, quae nunc juxta Maximianopolim est, fuisse metropolim regni Samariae prope quam sunt campi latissimi, et vallis nimiae vastitatis, quae plus quam decem millium tenditur passibus. In hoc commisso certamine, ab Assyriis caesus est Israel, id est, decem tribus, quae ob Jeroboam de tribu Ephraim, qui primus schisma fecit in populo, appellate sunt Ephraim.","english":"And when Zechariah, who was the last of the stock of Jehu, had been slain, immediately the kings of Assyria captured Reuben and Gad and the half-tribe of Manasseh, which were across the Jordan; and then many cities of Samaria, and then all of Naphtali, and finally all the remaining tribes. In the Vulgate edition, in place of Jehu, \"Judah\" is read; but this seems to me to have crept in not through the fault of the Seventy translators, but through the inexperience of the scribes, who, not knowing Jehu, wrote \"Judah,\" which was more common. But the type of the seed of God, and the avenging of his blood, is referred to the passion of the Lord, on account of which both the house of Judah and the kingdom of all Israel is said to be overthrown.\n\n(Verse 5.) \"And in that day I will break the bow of Israel in the valley of Jezreel.\" The Seventy have it similarly. When I have avenged the blood of Jezreel upon the house of Jehu, and have destroyed the kingdom of Israel, with the Assyrian conquering, then in that day, and in that time, I will break all the strength of the army of Israel in the valley of Jezreel. We have said above that Jezreel, which is now near Maximianopolis, was the metropolis of the kingdom of Samaria, near which are very wide plains, and a valley of immense extent, which stretches for more than ten thousand paces. In this battle that was joined, Israel was cut down by the Assyrians, that is, the ten tribes, which, on account of Jeroboam of the tribe of Ephraim, who first made schism among the people, were called Ephraim.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":19,"ref":"p19","source":"Interdum propter Joseph, qui fuit pater Ephraim, vocatur Joseph: nonnunquam Samaria, quae et ipsa altera urbs fuit metropolis decem tribuum, quae postea ab Augusto Caesare appellata est Augusta, id est,, in qua ossa Joannis Baptistae condita sunt. Post divisionem ergo duarum et decem tribuum, ob maximam partem multitudinis quae Jeroboam secula est, nomen pristinum Israel remansit in decem tribubus. Et propter tribum Juda, quae regnavit in Jerusalem, aliae quae tribus appellatae sunt Juda: simulque typi veritas explicatur. Quomodo enim propter sanguinem Naboth, qui effusus est in Jezrael, deleta est domus Achab, ut Eliae vaticinium compleretur: sic propter sanguinem veri Jezrael, hoc est, seminis Dei, regnum destructum est Judaeorum. In omnibus quidem prophetis, sed praecipue in Osee, decem tribus referuntur ad haereticos, quorum multitudo maxima est: duae autem tribus quae appellantur Juda, Ecclesiae personam possident, quae sub stirpe David regnabant. Arcus igitur haereticorum, de quibus scriptum, est: Filii Ephraim intendentes, et mittentes arcum, conversi sunt in die belli (Psal. LXXVII, 9), confringetur in valle seminis Dei, de quo humilia et terrena senserunt.","english":"Sometimes, on account of Joseph, who was the father of Ephraim, it is called Joseph; sometimes Samaria, which itself was also the other capital city of the ten tribes, which was later named Augusta by Augustus Caesar, that is, in which the bones of John the Baptist were buried. After the division, therefore, of the two and ten tribes, because of the greatest part of the multitude which followed Jeroboam, the former name Israel remained with the ten tribes. And on account of the tribe of Judah, which reigned in Jerusalem, the others are called the tribe of Judah; and at the same time the truth of the type is explained. For just as on account of the blood of Naboth, which was shed in Jezreel, the house of Ahab was destroyed, so that Elijah's prophecy might be fulfilled, so on account of the blood of the true Jezreel, that is, of the seed of God, the kingdom of the Jews was destroyed. In all the prophets indeed, but especially in Hosea, the ten tribes are referred to the heretics, whose multitude is very great; but the two tribes which are called Judah hold the person of the Church, which reigned under the stock of David. Therefore the bow of the heretics, of whom it is written: The sons of Ephraim, bending and shooting the bow, were turned back in the day of battle, shall be broken in the valley of the seed of God, concerning whom they held low and earthly opinions.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":20,"ref":"p20","source":"(Vers. 6, 7.) « Et concepit adhuc, et peperit filiam, et dixit ei: Voca nomen ejus, Absque misericordia, quia non addam ultra misereri domui Israel; sed oblivione obliviscar eorum. Et domni Juda miserebor: et salvabo eos in Domino Deo suo: et non salvabo eos in gladio 3, et in arcu, et in bello, et in equis, et in equitibus. » LXX; « Et concepit adhuc, et peperit filiam, et dixit ci: Voca nomen ejus, Absque misericordia; quia nequaquam addam ultra misereri domui Israel, sed adversans adversabor eis: filiorum autem Juda miserebor, et salvabo eos in Domino Deo suo; et non salvabo eos in arcu, neque in gladio, neque in bello, neque in equis, neque in equilibus. » Postquam contritus est atque confractus arcus Israel, in valle Jezrael, et regnum decem tribuum destitutum, ita ut ducerentur in captivitatem, nequaquam jam Jezrael, id est, semen Dei, nec masculini sexus filius nascitur: sed filia, id est, femina fragilis sexus, et quae victorum pateat contumeliae, et vocatur Absque misericordia. Idcirco enim captiva ducta est, quia misericordiam Dei non habuit. Et consideranda Domini indignatio. Quod nequaquam domui Israel se dicat misereri ultra, sed eos de memoria sua aeterna oblivione delere; quia usque hodie Persarum regibus serviunt, et nunquam est eorum soluta captivitas.","english":"(verses 6–7) \"And she conceived again, and bore a daughter, and he said to her: Call her name Not-Mercy, because I will no longer add to have mercy on the house of Israel; but I will utterly forget them. And on the house of Judah I will have mercy: and I will save them in the Lord their God: and I will not save them by sword, and by bow, and by war, and by horses, and by horsemen.\" The Septuagint has: \"And she conceived again, and bore a daughter, and he said to her: Call her name Not-Mercy; because by no means will I add any more to have mercy on the house of Israel, but opposing I will oppose them: but on the sons of Judah I will have mercy, and I will save them in the Lord their God; and I will not save them by bow, nor by sword, nor by war, nor by horses, nor by horsemen.\" After the bow of Israel was crushed and broken in the valley of Jezreel, and the kingdom of the ten tribes was abandoned, so that they were led into captivity, no longer is Jezreel, that is, the seed of God, nor a son of the male sex born: but a daughter, that is, a woman of fragile sex, and one who lies open to the insults of conquerors, and she is called Not-Mercy. For she was led captive for this reason, because she did not have the mercy of God. And the indignation of the Lord must be considered: that he says he will by no means have mercy on the house of Israel any more, but will blot them out from his memory with eternal oblivion; because to this day they serve the kings of the Persians, and their captivity has never been released.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":21,"ref":"p21","source":"Domui autem Juda misericordiam pollicetur, et dicit, quia eos salvet in Domino Deo suo, vel in scipso qui loquitur: vel Pater salvet in Filio, juxta illud quod scriptum est: Pluit Dominus a Domino (Gen. XIX, 24). Salvavit eos enim quando Israel Assyriis traditus est, de manu Sennacherib, non in arcu et gladio et bello et in equitum multitudine, sed in suo robore, quando misit angelum, et percussit de exercitu Sennacherib regis Assyriorum una nocte centum octoginta quinque millia (IV Reg. XIX). Juxta typum dicimus, eos qui propter sanguinem seminis Dei vocantur Absque misericordia, et dicere ausi sunt: Sanguis ejus super nos et super filios nostros (Matth. XXVII, 23), hucusque servire Romanis. Domum autem Juda, cos videlicet ex Judaeis, qui Dominum sunt confessi, non in exercitus fortitudine, sed in Evangelii praedicatione salvatos. Quod in Israel et Juda tam juxta historiam, quam juxta typum, interpretati sumus, referamus ad haereticorum conciliabula, et ad Ecclesiam Domini Salvatoris, quod, illis absque misericordia derelictis, regnumque perdentibus, Ecclesia Dei sui virtute superarit.","english":"But to the house of Judah he promises mercy, and says that he will save them in the Lord their God—either in himself who speaks, or the Father saves in the Son, according to that which is written: \"The Lord rained from the Lord\" (Gen. 19:24). For he saved them when Israel was handed over to the Assyrians, from the hand of Sennacherib—not by bow and sword and war and the multitude of horsemen, but in his own strength, when he sent an angel and struck down from the army of Sennacherib king of the Assyrians in one night one hundred and eighty-five thousand (4 Kings 19). According to the type, we say that those who because of the blood of the seed of God are called Not-Mercy, and dared to say: \"His blood be upon us and upon our children\" (Matt. 27:23), have served the Romans up to this point. But the house of Judah—namely those from the Jews who confessed the Lord—he saves not in the strength of an army, but in the preaching of the Gospel. What we have interpreted in Israel and Judah both according to history and according to the type, let us refer to the assemblies of heretics and to the Church of the Lord Savior: that, with those left without mercy and losing the kingdom, the Church has prevailed by the power of her God.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":22,"ref":"p22","source":"(Vers. 8, 9.) « Et ablactavit eam quae erat absque misericordia: et concepit, et peperit filium, et dixit: Voca nomen ejus, Non populus meus: quia vos non populus meus; et ego non ero vester. » LXX similiter. Qui vocabatur semen Dei versus in feminam et propter imbecillitatem virium, offensamque Dei, ductus in captivitatem, quia Domini misericordiam non habebat, nequaquam ablactatus dicitur, sed ablactata: viri enim jam robur amiserat. Qui ablactatur, recedit a matre, parentis lacte non vescitur, alimentis sustentatur externis. Ita et Israel projectus a Domino, et captivitatis circumdatus angustiis, atque in Babylone cibis sustentatus immundis, vocatur non populus Dei, et aeterna gentis alienas feritur sententia, ut dicatur non populus urens, et abjiciatur in perpetuum. Quod recte intelligere possumus, et in omni populo Judaeorum, qui propter offensam seminis Dei captivitati traditus, regnum perdidit, et provinciam, appellaturque non populus Dei: et in persona haereticorum.","english":"(Verses 8, 9.) \"And she weaned her who was without mercy: and she conceived, and bore a son, and said: Call his name, Not my people: because you are not my people; and I will not be yours.\" The Septuagint has it similarly. He who was called the seed of God, having been turned into a woman and, because of the weakness of his strength and the offense of God, led into captivity, since he did not have the mercy of the Lord, is by no means said to have been weaned—but \"she was weaned\"; for he had already lost the strength of a man. He who is weaned withdraws from his mother, does not feed on his parent's milk, but is sustained by external nourishment. So too Israel, cast off by the Lord and surrounded by the straits of captivity, and sustained in Babylon on unclean foods, is called not the people of God, and is struck by the eternal sentence of a foreign nation, so that he is called not a people, and is cast away forever. We can rightly understand this both in the whole people of the Jews, who because of the offense against the seed of God were handed over to captivity, lost the kingdom and the province, and are called not the people of God: and in the person of heretics.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":23,"ref":"p23","source":"Si quis autem contentiosus interpres noluerit recipere ista, quae diximus, sed meretricem nomine Gomer filiam Debelaim, primum, et tertium masculos, secundam, quae media est, feminam intellexerit procreasse, hoc volens Scriptura sonare quod legitur, respondeat quomodo in Ezechiel illud exponat, ubi jubetur a Domino portare iniquitates domus Israel, id est, decem tribuum, et trecentis nonaginta diebus in uno latere sinistro dormire perpetuo, licet in LXX centum et nonaginta scripti sunt, et dormire ita ut nunquam evigilet, nec mutet latus, nisi forte sopore satiatus paululum aperuerit oculos ad sumendum sordidissimum cibum subcinericii panis, qui de frumento, et hordeo, et faba, et lente, et milio coctus sit in humano stercore. Hoc enim rerum natura non patitur, ut quisquam hominum per trecentos nonaginta dies in uno semper latere dormiat. Et rursus, inquit: Suscipies iniquitates domus Juda, et diebus quadraginta dormies in latere dextro. Hi autem dies pro annis supputantur, quibus Israel et Juda obsidione et captivitate longissima detinentur 1, ita ut vincti et immobiles, de altero in alterum latus se versare non possint.","english":"But if some contentious interpreter refuses to accept what we have said, and understands that the harlot named Gomer, daughter of Debelaim, bore the first and third as males, and the second, which is in the middle, as a female, wishing the Scripture to mean what is read, let him answer how he explains that passage in Ezekiel, where it is commanded by the Lord to bear the iniquities of the house of Israel, that is, of the ten tribes, and to sleep continually for three hundred and ninety days on one left side—although in the Septuagint one hundred and ninety are written—and to sleep so as never to wake, nor to change side, unless perhaps, satiated with sleep, he opens his eyes a little to take the most filthy food of a barley cake baked under ashes, which is cooked from wheat, and barley, and beans, and lentils, and millet in human dung. For the nature of things does not allow that any man should sleep for three hundred and ninety days always on one side. And again, he says: You shall take up the iniquities of the house of Judah, and for forty days you shall sleep on the right side. But these days are reckoned as years, during which Israel and Judah are held in siege and a very long captivity, so that, bound and immovable, they cannot turn themselves from one side to the other.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":24,"ref":"p24","source":"Si illa et caetera his similia, quae in Scripturis sanctis legimus, facta non potuerit approbare, sed aliud quid significare contenderit: ergo et meretrix ista mulier, et alia adultera mulier, quae aut prophetae jungebantur, aut servabantur a propheta, non turpem stupri conjunctionem, sed sacramenta indicant futurorum·\n\n(Vers. 10.) « Et erit numerus filiorum Israel quasi arena maris, quae sine mensura est, et non numerabitur. Et erit in loco ubi dicetur eis: Non populus meus vos; dicetur eis, filii Dei viventis. Et congregabuntur filii Juda, et filii Israel pariter: et ponent sibimet caput unum, et ascendent de terra: quia magnus est dies Jezrael. » LXX: « Et erit numerus filiorum Israel sicut arena maris, quae non mensurabitur, nec numerari potest. Et erit in loco ubi dictum est eis: Non populus meus vos: vocabuntur filii Dei viventis. Et congregabuntur filii Juda et filii Israel simul: et ponent sibi principatum unum, et ascendent de terra, quoniam magnus est dies Jezrael. » Legimus abjectionem decem tribuum, et non mensurabilem Israel, nec ultra populum Dei, indignatione perpetua condemnatum. Nunc discimus quomodo filii Juda et filii Israel pariter congregentur, et ponant sibi caput unum sive principatum, et ascendant de terra, et in loco ubi prius dicebatur, Non populus meus, appellentur filii Dei viventis, et hoc fieri, quia magnus sit dies Jezrael.","english":"If she could not prove that those other things like these, which we read in the Holy Scriptures, were done, but contended that they signify something else, then both this harlot woman and the other adulterous woman, who were either joined to prophets or kept by a prophet, indicate not a shameful union of fornication, but the mysteries of things to come.\n\n(Verse 10.) \"And the number of the children of Israel shall be like the sand of the sea, which is without measure and shall not be numbered. And it shall be in the place where it is said to them: You are not my people; it shall be said to them, children of the living God. And the children of Judah and the children of Israel shall be gathered together: and they shall appoint for themselves one head, and they shall go up from the land: because great is the day of Jezreel.\" The Septuagint: \"And the number of the children of Israel shall be like the sand of the sea, which shall not be measured, nor can it be counted. And it shall be in the place where it was said to them: You are not my people: they shall be called children of the living God. And the children of Judah and the children of Israel shall be gathered together at once: and they shall appoint for themselves one rule, and they shall go up from the land, since great is the day of Jezreel.\" We have read of the casting off of the ten tribes, and of Israel as not to be measured, and as no longer the people of God, condemned by perpetual indignation. Now we learn how the children of Judah and the children of Israel are gathered together at once, and appoint for themselves one head or one rule, and go up from the land, and in the place where it was previously said, \"You are not my people,\" are called children of the living God, and that this happens because great is the day of Jezreel.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":25,"ref":"p25","source":"Ambigenti et in varias sententias fluctuanti illud occurrit Pauli apostoli ad Romanos scribentis: Quod si volens Deus ostendere iram, et notam facere potentiam suam, sustinuit in multa patientia vasa irae apta in interitum, ut ostenderet divitias gloriae suae in vasa misericordiae, quae praeparavit in gloriam, quos et vocavit nos non solum ex Judaeis, sed etiam ex gentibus: sicut in Osee dicit. Vocavi non plebem meam, plebem meam, et non misericordiam consecutam, misericordiam consecutam. Et erit in loco ubi dictum est eis: Non plebs mea vos, ibi vocabuntur filii Dei vivi. Isaias autem clamat pro Israel: Si fuerit numerus filiorum Israel tanquam arena maris. reliquiae salva fient. Verbum enim consummans et brevians in aequitate: quia verbum breviatum faciet Dominus super terram. Et sicut praedixit (Isaias I, 9): Nisi Dominus Sabaoth reliquisset nobis semen, sicut Sodoma facti essemus, et sicut Gomorra similes fuissemus. Quid ergo dicemus: Quod gentes quas non sectabantur justitiam apprehenderunt justitiam? justitiam autem quas ex fide est: Israel vero sectans legem justitiae, in legem justitiae non pervenit (Rom. IX, 22, seqq.·).","english":"To one who is in doubt and wavering between various opinions, that passage of the apostle Paul writing to the Romans comes to mind: But if God, willing to show his wrath and to make known his power, endured with much patience vessels of wrath fitted for destruction, that he might show the riches of his glory upon vessels of mercy, which he prepared for glory, whom he also called, us not only from the Jews but also from the Gentiles: as he says in Hosea, I will call them my people who were not my people, and her who had not obtained mercy, her who obtained mercy. And it shall be in the place where it was said to them, You are not my people, there they shall be called sons of the living God. But Isaiah cries out for Israel: If the number of the children of Israel be as the sand of the sea, the remnant shall be saved. For he is finishing the word and cutting it short in righteousness: because the Lord will make a short word upon the earth. And as he foretold: Unless the Lord of hosts had left us a seed, we would have become as Sodom, and would have been like Gomorrah. What then shall we say: that the Gentiles, who did not follow after righteousness, have apprehended righteousness? But the righteousness which is of faith: whereas Israel, following after the law of righteousness, did not attain to the law of righteousness.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":26,"ref":"p26","source":"Igitur beatus apostolus Osee prophetae assumens testimonium, et exponens illud super vocatione gentium, et eorum fide qui ex Judaeis credere voluerunt, omnem nobis difficultatem interpretationis abscidit, asserens Christi temporibus esse completum, ut scilicet in Israel eligantur duodecim tribus, hoc est, omnis populus Judaeorum, et in Juda hi qui ex gentibus Jesum Dominum confitentur. Si quis autem alienus a fide Christi, et non recipiens auctoritatem novi Testamenti, sed de numero circumcisionis, responderit filios Juda et filios Israel duas tribus sonare et decem, de quibus crebro diximus, et in hoc dantes manus, nihil fidei nostrae nocere monstrabimus. Sed postquam fuerit numerus filiorum Israel quasi arena maris in toto orbe dispersus, et omnem supputationem vicerit populi multitudo, tunc habebit licentiam Israel, qui hodie quoque captivus est, et qui prius dicebatur absque misericordia, et non populus meus, cum duabus tribubus, id est, Juda et Benjamin, quarum magna pars in Christum credidit, inire concordiam, ut corporibus separatos jungat fides, et unum sibi caput ponant et principem, de quo scripsit Ezechiel: Et princeps unus in medio corum, David servus meus, et resuscitabuntur quasi ab inferis mortui (Ezech. XXXIV, 24), Juda scilicet et Israel qui in infidelitate mortui erant. Et haec omnia fient, quia magnus est dies seminis Dei, qui interpretatur Christus.","english":"Therefore the blessed apostle, taking up the testimony of the prophet Hosea and expounding it concerning the calling of the Gentiles and the faith of those who from the Jews wished to believe, has cut away from us every difficulty of interpretation, asserting that it was fulfilled in the times of Christ—namely, that in Israel the twelve tribes should be chosen, that is, the whole people of the Jews, and in Judah those from the Gentiles who confess Jesus as Lord. But if anyone, a stranger to the faith of Christ and not receiving the authority of the New Testament, but from the number of the circumcision, should reply that the sons of Judah and the sons of Israel signify two tribes and ten, of which we have often spoken, and in this giving their assent, we shall show that it does no harm to our faith. But after the number of the sons of Israel has been scattered like the sand of the sea throughout the whole world, and the multitude of the people has surpassed every reckoning, then Israel, who even today is captive, and who was formerly called \"without mercy\" and \"not my people,\" shall have leave to enter into concord with the two tribes, that is, Judah and Benjamin, a great part of whom have believed in Christ, so that faith may join together those separated in body, and they may set over themselves one head and prince, of whom Ezekiel wrote: And there shall be one prince in the midst of them, David my servant, and they shall be raised up as dead men from hell (Ezek. 34:24)—namely, Judah and Israel, who were dead in unbelief. And all these things shall come to pass, because great is the day of the seed of God, which is interpreted as Christ.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":27,"ref":"p27","source":"Ex quo perspicuum est, ideo in typo Naboth Jezraelitis sanguinem praecessisse, ut veritas compleretur in Christo. In hoc enim et non in illo magnus est dies Jezrael, de quo dicitur. Haec est dies quam fecit Dominus: exsultemus et laetemur in ea (Psal. CXVII, 24). Interpretationis tertiae quam suscepimus, Israel in haereticis, Juda in Ecclesiae hominibus exponendis, hic sensus est: Ut postquam Dominus in claritate sua venerit regnaturus, hi qui ante vocabantur, non populus ejus, vocentur filii Dei viventis; cum Judae, i I est, Ecclesiae Dei fuerint copulati, et unum caput Christum habuerint, et ascenderint de terra, id est, de terrenis sensibus et humilitate litterae, et susceperint magnum diem seminis Dei. Pro, id est, absque misericordia, in quibusdam fertur exemplaribus,, id est, non dilecta 2. Sed veriora sunt exemplaria, quae habent, absque misericordia; maxime quia at distinctionem Israelis, cui non miseretur, infert Deus: Domui autem Juda miserebor.","english":"From this it is clear that the blood of Naboth came beforehand among the Jezreelites in a type so that the truth might be fulfilled in Christ. For in this, and not in that, is the day of Jezreel great, of which it is said: This is the day which the Lord has made: let us exult and rejoice in it. The sense of the third interpretation, which we have undertaken—expounding Israel as the heretics and Judah as the men of the Church—is this: that after the Lord has come in His glory to reign, those who were formerly called \"not My people\" may be called sons of the living God, when they have been joined to Judah, that is, to the Church of God, and have one head, Christ, and have ascended from the earth, that is, from earthly senses and the lowliness of the letter, and have received the great day of the seed of God. For \"without mercy,\" in which certain copies read \"not beloved.\" But the more authentic copies are those which have \"without mercy,\" especially because, in distinction from Israel, on whom He does not have mercy, God adds: But on the house of Judah I will have mercy.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[{"kind":"scripture","severity":"info","ref":"Psalm 118:24","text":"The English carries the scriptural phrase “this is the day which the lord has made”, which matches Psalm 118:24. The match is on the English draft; check the Coptic before quoting the verse."}]},{"i":28,"ref":"p28","source":"(Cap. II. Vers. 1.) « Dicite fratribus vestris, populus meus, et sorori vestrae, misericordiam consecuta, » LXX: « Dicite fratri vestro, populus meus, et sorori vestrae, misericordiam consecuta. » Quia magnus est dies Jezrael, in quo Judas et Israel unum habebunt principem, et nequaquam dicetur Israeli, non populus meus, sed econtrario vocabuntur filii Dei viventis: idcirco, o homines tribus Juda, nolite desperate decem tribuum salutem, sed eas quotidie el sermone et volo et litteris ad poenitentiam provocate, quia frater vester appellantur et soror: frater, ex co quod dicitur, populus meus: soror, ex co quod appellamur, misericordiam consecuta. Aliter: Qui in Christum creditis, et estis tam ex Judaeis quam ex gentibus, dicite fractis ramis, et priori populo, qui projectus est: populus meus, quia, frater tuus est, et misericordiam consecuta, quia soror tua est. Cum enim intraverit plenitudo gentium, tunc omnis Israel salvus fiet (Rom. XI, 25)· Hoc idem nobis praecipitur, ne haereticos penitus desperemus, sed provocemus ad poenitentiam, et iliorum salutem germanitatis optemus affectu.","english":"(Ch. 2, v. 1.) «Say to your brothers, My people, and to your sister, She who has obtained mercy,» The LXX has: «Say to your brother, My people, and to your sister, She who has obtained mercy.» Because great is the day of Jezreel, in which Judah and Israel shall have one prince, and it shall no longer be said to Israel, Not my people, but on the contrary they shall be called sons of the living God: therefore, O men of the tribe of Judah, do not despair of the salvation of the ten tribes, but provoke them daily both by word and by wish and by letters to repentance, because your brother is called and your sister: brother, from the fact that it is said, My people; sister, from the fact that she is called, She who has obtained mercy. Otherwise: You who believe in Christ, and are both from the Jews and from the Gentiles, say to the broken branches, and to the former people who have been cast off: My people, because he is your brother, and She who has obtained mercy, because she is your sister. For when the fullness of the Gentiles has come in, then all Israel shall be saved (Rom. 11:25). The same is commanded to us, that we should not utterly despair of heretics, but provoke them to repentance, and desire their salvation with the affection of brotherhood.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":29,"ref":"p29","source":"(Vers. 2, 3.) « Judicate matrem vestram, judicate, quoniam ipsa non uxor mea, et ego non vir ejus: auferat fornicationes suas a facie sua, et adulteria sua de medio uberum suorum: ne forte exspoliem eam nudam, et statuam eam secundum diem nativitatis suae, » LXX: « Judicamini cum matre vestra, judicamini, quia haec non uxor mea, et ego non vir ejus, et auferam fornicationem ejus a facie mea, et adulteria ejus de medio uberum illius: ut exspoliem eam nudam, et restituam eam juxta diem nativitatis suae. » Hucusque ad Israel populum, hoc est, decem tribus sermo directus est. Nunc alterum caput incipit, et praecipitur filiis, id est, populo, ut ineant judicium adversum matrem suam, quae cos genuit, quae de meretrice uxor effecta, mores pristinos non reliquit; et rursum fornicata est cum ataatoribus suis. Et vide clementiam viri. Jam repudiata est, jam abjecta est, jam et loculus est: Haec non uxor mea, et ego non vir ejus: tamen praecipit filiis, ut nequaquam ad uxorem patris quam ille dimisit 1, sed ad matrem suam loquantur quae eos genuit. Loquantur autem ad poenitentiam provocantes, ut auferat fornicationes a facie sua, et adulteria sua de medio uberum suorum. Fornicaria est, quae cum pluribus copulatur. Adultera, quae unum virum deserens, alteri jungitur.","english":"(Verses 2, 3.) «Judge your mother, judge her, for she is not my wife, and I am not her husband: let her put away her fornications from her face, and her adulteries from the midst of her breasts: lest perhaps I strip her naked, and set her as in the day of her birth.» The LXX has: «Contend with your mother, contend, for she is not my wife, and I am not her husband, and I will take away her fornication from my face, and her adulteries from the midst of her breasts: that I may strip her naked, and restore her as in the day of her birth.» Up to this point the discourse was directed to the people of Israel, that is, the ten tribes. Now another chapter begins, and the command is given to the children, that is, to the people, that they enter into judgment against their mother, who bore them, who, having been made a wife from a harlot, did not abandon her former ways, and again played the harlot with her lovers. And see the clemency of the husband. She has already been repudiated, already cast off, and he has already said: She is not my wife, and I am not her husband; yet he commands the children to speak not to their father's wife, whom he has dismissed, but to their own mother who bore them. Let them speak, moreover, provoking her to repentance, that she put away her fornications from her face, and her adulteries from the midst of her breasts. A harlot is she who is joined to many; an adulteress, she who, forsaking one husband, is joined to another.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":30,"ref":"p30","source":"Quorum utrumque est Synagoga, quae si permanserit in fornicatione et adulterio, auferet ab ca Deus vestem et ornamenta quie dederat. De quibus scribit Ezechiel: In die quando nata es, non ligaverunt mamillas tuas, et sale non es salita: et transivi per te, et inveni te nudam, et deturpatam, et conspersam in sanguine (Ezech. XVI, 4, 5). Et post paululum Indui te byssino et subtilibus, et ornamenta circumposui tibi, et dedi armillas circa manus tuas, et monile circa collum tuum. (Ibid. 19, 11.) Haec tunc ei dedit maritus largissimus, quando invenit illam in AEgypto idololatriae libidine constupratam et divaricantem omnibus pedes suos. Et nunc comminatur, si ad virum suum noluerit reverti, ita eam futuram absque Deo et viro 2, sicut prius in AEgypto fuerat. Ne semper triplici explanatione tendamus volumina, hoc raro admonuisse sufficiat, quae dicta sunt convenire et Judaeis negantibus Christum, et haereticis fidem Domini relinquentibus; quorum fornicatio proprie inter ubera est, et in artificio idolorum et variorum dogmatum corde versatur, qui revertentur ad diem nativitatis suae, ut si non egerint poenitentiam, ethnicis comparentur.","english":"Both of these things belong to the Synagogue, which, if she persists in fornication and adultery, God will take away from her the garment and ornaments that he had given her. Of these things Ezekiel writes: «In the day when you were born, they did not bind your breasts, and you were not salted with salt: and I passed by you, and found you naked and defiled, and sprinkled in blood» (Ezek. 16:4, 5). And a little later: «I clothed you with fine linen and with delicate things, and I placed ornaments around you, and I gave bracelets around your hands, and a necklace around your neck» (Ibid. 19, 11). These things her most generous husband gave her then, when he found her in Egypt defiled by the lust of idolatry and spreading her feet for all. And now he threatens that, if she is unwilling to return to her husband, she will be thus without God and without a husband, just as she had been before in Egypt. Lest we stretch out our volumes always with a threefold explanation, let it suffice to have warned of this rarely, that the things which have been said apply both to the Jews who deny Christ and to the heretics who abandon the faith of the Lord; whose fornication is properly between the breasts, and is turned over in the heart in the contrivance of idols and of various doctrines, who will return to the day of their birth, so that if they have not done penance, they may be compared to the Gentiles.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":31,"ref":"p31","source":"« Et ponam eam quasi solitudinem, et statuam eam velut terram inviam, et interficiam eam siti » LXX: « Et ponam eam ut desertum, et statuam eam sicut terram sine aqua, el occidam illam in siti. » Si noluerit ad meliora converti, faciam illi quod feci in solitudine, ut ducti in captivitatem cadant in terra aliena, patientes sitim omnium bonorum, et ad patriam suam redire non valeant. Vel certe audiant in Evangelio: Re· linquitur vobis domus vestra deserta (Matth. XXIII, 38). Et mittet ci Dominus non famem panis, nec sitim aquae; sed famem audiendi verbum Domini (Amos VIII). De quo et Isaias loquitur: Erunt sicut paradisus aquam non habens (Isa. I, 30). Haeretici qui abjecti sunt a Domino, si non redierint ad pristinam domum, sic omnium rerum patientur penuriam, ut etiam quod falsum habere videntur, redigatur ad nihilum.\n\n(Vers.","english":"And I will make her like a wilderness, and I will set her as a waterless land, and I will kill her with thirst. The Septuagint reads: «And I will make her like a desert, and I will set her like a land without water, and I will kill her in thirst.» If she is unwilling to turn to better things, I will do to her what I did in the wilderness, so that those led into captivity may fall in a foreign land, enduring thirst for all good things, and be unable to return to their own country. Or at any rate let them hear in the Gospel: Your house is left to you desolate (Matthew 23:38). And the Lord will send upon them not a famine of bread, nor a thirst for water, but a famine of hearing the word of the Lord (Amos 8). Of which Isaiah also speaks: They shall be like a paradise without water (Isaiah 1:30). The heretics who have been cast off by the Lord, if they do not return to their former house, will suffer such a lack of all things that even what they seem to possess falsely will be reduced to nothing.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":32,"ref":"p32","source":"4, 5.) « Et filiorum illius non miserebor, quoniam filii fornicationum sunt, quia fornicata est mater eorum: confusa est quae concepit eos, quia dixit: Vadam post amatores meos, qui dant panes mihi, et aquas meas, lanam meam, et linum meum, et oleum meum, et polum meam, » LXX: « Et filiorum ejus non miserebor: quoniam filii fornicationis sunt, quia fornicata est mater eorum: confusa est quae peperit eos, dixit enim: Vadam post amatores meos, qui dant mihi panes meos et aquam meam, et vestimenta mea, et linteamina mea, et oleum meum, et omnia quae mihi necessaria sunt. » Hoc plus faciam ei cui dixi. Non uxor mea, et ego non vir tuus, et ponam eam quasi solitudinem, et faciam eam velut terram inviam. Quando enim de AEgypto eduxi eam, interfectis parentibus, filii eorum terram repromissionis ingressi sunt. Nunc autem fornicariae matris liberi peribunt cum matre meretrice, quoniam filii fornicationis sunt, et mali ex malis geniti. Quibus in Evangelio dicitur: Generatio viperarum (Matth. III, 7): quae in tantam venit impudentiam, ut audiret per Jeremiam: Facies meretricis facta est tibi: impudorata es tu (Jerem. III, 3). An non est hoc durae frontis et meretriciae, impudentiae, ut in suo scelere glorietur, ei dicat: Sequar amatores meos; vadam ad idola quae mihi et ad victum et ad vestitum necessaria praebuerunt.","english":"(4:5) «And I will not have pity on her children, because they are children of fornication, for their mother has played the harlot: she who conceived them is put to shame, because she said: I will go after my lovers, who give me bread, and my waters, my wool, and my linen, and my oil, and my purple.» The Septuagint reads: «And I will not have pity on her children, because they are children of fornication, for their mother has played the harlot: she who bore them is put to shame, for she said: I will go after my lovers, who give me my bread and my water, and my garments, and my linens, and my oil, and all things that are necessary for me.» This I will do more to her to whom I said, You are not my wife, and I am not your husband, and I will set her as a wilderness, and I will make her like a pathless land. For when I led her out of Egypt, their parents having been killed, their children entered the land of promise. But now the children of the harlot mother will perish with the harlot mother, because they are children of fornication, and evil born from evil. To whom it is said in the Gospel: Generation of vipers (Matthew 3:7): which has come to such shamelessness that she heard through Jeremiah: You have the face of a harlot: you have become shameless (Jeremiah 3:3). Or is this not the mark of a hard brow and harlot's impudence, that she should glory in her own crime, and say: I will follow my lovers; I will go to the idols which have provided me with what is necessary both for food and for clothing.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":33,"ref":"p33","source":"Omnia quae propheticus sermo describit, spiritualiter a Domino accepere Judaei. Et quia Dei Filium negaverunt, eligentes sibi Barabbam latrocinii et seditionis auctorem, et crucifigentes Filium Dei (Joan. XIX). Propterea usque hodie sequuntur daemones, et Dei beneficia ad illos referunt, qui cultorum suorum animas perdiderunt. Panes et aquas habent et haeretici, quorum panis luctus est, et aquae eorum coenosae, quae suffocant et interficiunt baptizatos. Habent et lanam de scabidis ovibus, et linum in nigredine perseverans, oleumque, de quo Propheta dicit Oleum peccatoris non impinguet caput meum (Psal. CXL, 5), et potum aquarum AEgypti, de quibus clamat Jeremia: Quid tibi et viae AEgypti, ut bibas aquam Geon (Jerem. II, 18)? Et: Quid tibi et viae Assyriorum ut bibas aquas fluminum? Breviter cuncta percurrimus, ut ad reliqua transeamus.","english":"Everything that the prophetic word describes, the Jews received spiritually from the Lord. And because they denied the Son of God, choosing for themselves Barabbas, the author of robbery and sedition, and crucifying the Son of God (John XIX), therefore to this day they follow demons, and they refer God's benefits to those who have destroyed the souls of their worshippers. Heretics too have breads and waters, whose bread is mourning, and whose waters are muddy, which suffocate and kill those baptized. They have also wool from scabby sheep, and linen persisting in blackness, and oil, of which the Prophet says: The oil of the sinner shall not fatten my head (Psalm CXL, 5), and a drink of the waters of Egypt, of which Jeremiah cries out: What have you to do with the way of Egypt, that you should drink the water of Geon (Jeremiah II, 18)? And: What have you to do with the ways of the Assyrians, that you should drink the waters of the rivers? We have briefly run through all things, so that we may pass on to the rest.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":34,"ref":"p34","source":"(Vers. 6, 7.) « Propter hoc ecce ego sepiam viam tuam spinis, et sepiam eam maceria, et semitas suas non inveniet, et sequetur amatores suos, et non apprehendet eos, et quaeret eos et non inveniet, et dicet: Vadam et revertar ad virum meum priorem, quia bene mihi erat tunc, magis quam nunc. » LXX: « Propterea ecce ego sepiam viam ejus in sudibus, et obstruam vias illius: et semitam suam non inveniet. Et persequetur amatores suos, et non apprehendet illos, et quaeret eos, et non inveniet; et dicet: Vadam et revertar ad virum meum priorem, quia melius mihi erat tunc, quam nunc est: » Dixerat meretrix: Vadam post amatores meos, qui omnium rerum mihi abundantiam praebuerunt. Respondit Dominus: Ego sepium viam tuam spinis, sive sudibus, ne possis ire quo desideras, et interponam maceriam, sive murum et semitas tuas quas crebro triveras pede, non invenies, ne apprehendas eos quos tanto studio sequebaris, ut rerum necessitate compulsa revertaris ad virum tuum, et dicas illud de Evangelio: Quanti mercenarii in domo patris mei abundant panibus, ego autem hic fame pereo. Surgam et ibo ad patrem meum et dicam illi: Pater, peccavi in coelum et coram te, et jam non sum dignus vocari filius tuus, fac me sicut unum de mercenariis tuis.","english":"(Verses 6–7.) “Therefore behold, I will hedge your way with thorns, and I will hedge it with a wall, and she will not find her paths, and she will follow after her lovers, and she will not overtake them, and she will seek them and will not find them, and she will say: I will go and return to my former husband, for it was well with me then, more than now.” The Septuagint: “Therefore behold, I will hedge her way with stakes, and I will block up her paths: and she will not find her path. And she will pursue her lovers, and she will not overtake them, and she will seek them, and she will not find them; and she will say: I will go and return to my former husband, for it was better with me then, than it is now.” The harlot had said: I will go after my lovers, who provided me an abundance of all things. The Lord answered: I will hedge your way with thorns, or with stakes, so that you cannot go where you desire, and I will place a wall, or a barrier, in between, and you will not find your paths, which you had worn smooth with your frequent foot, so that you may not overtake those whom you were pursuing with such zeal, so that, compelled by necessity, you may return to your husband and say that word from the Gospel: How many hired servants in my father’s house abound in bread, but I am perishing here with hunger. I will rise and go to my father and say to him: Father, I have sinned against heaven and before you, and I am no longer worthy to be called your son; make me as one of your hired servants.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":35,"ref":"p35","source":"Ex quo intelligimus quod providentia Dei saepe nobis accidant mala, ne habeamus ea quae cupimus, et variis oppressi calamitatibus hujus saeculi ac miseriis, ad Dei servitutem redire cogamur. Amatores autem Jerusalem et gentis Judaeae, secundum historiam illius temporis, Assyrios atque Chaldaeos et AEgyptios nationesque caeteras intelligamus, cum quorum idolis fornicata est, a quibus bellorum tempore, et prementibus malis frustra speravit auxilium. Hos amatores juxta intelligentiam spiritualem sequuntur haeretici, a quibus saepe deserti, malorum pondere ad sinum matris Ecclesiae revertuntur. Per omnia enim flagella atque tormenta eruditur Israel.\n\n(Vers. 8.) « Et haec nescivit, quia ego dedi ei frumentum et vinum, et oleum, et argentum multiplicavi ei et aurum, quae fecerunt Baal. » LXX: « Et ipsa nescivit quia ego dedi ei frumentum, et vinum, et oleum, et argentum multiplicavi ei: haec autem argentea et aurea fecit ipsi Baal. » Ad superiora respondit, dixerat enim: Vadam post amatores meos, qui dant panes mihi, et aquas meas, lanam, et linum, et oleum, et potum meum, quae universa susceperat, ut in Dei cultum verteret. Illa vero panem et vinum, qui confirmat, et quod laetificat cor hominis (Psal. CIII), et oleum quod illuminat omnem hominem venientem in hunc mundum (Joan.","english":"From this we understand that by God's providence evils often befall us, lest we possess what we desire, and that, oppressed by the various calamities and miseries of this world, we may be compelled to return to the service of God. But the lovers of Jerusalem and of the people of Judea, according to the history of that time, let us understand as the Assyrians and Chaldeans and Egyptians and the other nations, with whose idols she committed fornication, and from whom in time of war and under pressing evils she hoped for help in vain. These lovers, according to the spiritual understanding, the heretics follow, by whom they are often deserted, and under the weight of evils they return to the bosom of mother Church. For through all scourges and torments Israel is instructed.\n\n(Verse 8.) “And she did not know that I gave her grain and wine, and multiplied oil and silver for her, and gold, which they made for Baal.” The Septuagint: “And she herself did not know that I gave her grain, and wine, and oil, and multiplied silver for her: but these silver and gold things she made for Baal himself.” He answers the preceding, for she had said: I will go after my lovers, who give me my bread, and my waters, wool, and flax, and oil, and my drink, all of which she had received, that she might turn them to the worship of God. But she turned the bread and the wine, which confirms and which gladdens the heart of man (Psalm 103), and the oil which enlightens every man coming into this world (John","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":36,"ref":"p36","source":"(??)), et argentum de quo saepe diximus Eloquia Domini, eloquia casta, argentum igne examinatum, probatum terrae, purgatum septuplum (Psal. XI, 7). Et aurum de quo legimus: Si dormiatis inter medios cleros, pennae columbae deargentatae, et posteriora dorsi ejus in virore auri (Psal. LXVII, 14), vertit in idola, et fecit Baal, quod interpretatur superior et devoratio: dum aut majora se putat habere dogmata quam Ecclesia, aut in ipsa falsae opinionis scientia devoratur. Quod autem juxta litteram, auro et argento et cunctis opibus abundaverit Jerusalem, et fecerit idola Baal daemoni Sidoniorum, sive, ut quidam rectius arbitrantur Babylonio, ex quo et Bel dicitur, Ezechiel plenius in suo ponit volumine, et omnis prophetarum narrat chorus.\n\n(Vers. 9.) « Idcirco revertar et sumam frumentum meum in tempore suo, et vinum meum, in tempore suo, et liberabo lanam meam, et linum meum quae operiebant ignominiam ejus. » LXX.: « Propterea revertar el tollam triticum meum in tempore suo, et vinum meum in tempore suo, et auferam vestimenta mea, et linteamina mea, ne operiant ignominiam ejus. » Gravior poena est, quando in tempore messis et vindemiae speratae fruges auferuntur et vinum, et quodammodo tentae tolluntur e manibus.","english":"and the silver, of which we have often said, \"The words of the Lord are pure words, silver tried in the fire, proved in the earth, purified seven times\" (Ps. XI, 7). And the gold, of which we read: \"If you sleep among the midst of the lots, the wings of the dove are silvered, and the hinder parts of her back in the greenness of gold\" (Ps. LXVII, 14), he turned into idols, and made Baal, which is interpreted as \"superior\" and \"devouring\": either while he thinks he possesses greater doctrines than the Church, or is devoured in the very knowledge of a false opinion. But that according to the letter Jerusalem abounded in gold and silver and all riches, and made idols of Baal, the god of the Sidonians, or, as some more correctly judge, of the Babylonian, from whom also Bel is named, Ezekiel sets forth more fully in his volume, and the whole chorus of the prophets relates.\n\n(Verse 9.) \"Therefore I will return and take away my grain in its time, and my wine in its time, and I will deliver up my wool and my flax which covered her shame.\" The Septuagint: \"Therefore I will return and take away my wheat in its time, and my wine in its time, and I will take away my garments and my linen, lest they cover her shame.\" It is a graver punishment when, at the time of harvest and vintage, the hoped-for fruits are taken away, and the wine, and, so to speak, the stretched-out things are snatched from their hands.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":37,"ref":"p37","source":"Sin autem in tempore areae et praeli et torcularis, quando sterilitatem, praeteritam novis frugibus terra fecundat, omnium rerum penuria est, quid de reliquo anni tempore, quando vetera conservantur, aestimare debemus? Liberatur autem lana et linum, sive vestes et linteamina, ne ultra ignominiam operiant meretricis: ut scilicet Dei nudetur auxilio: et omnium ab eo angelorum tutela discedat. Unde et Apostolus liberari dicit creaturam a servitute corruptionis in libertatem gloriae filiorum Dei (Rom. VIII). Multi accepere aurum et argentum sapientiae et eloquentiae, de quibus facerent candelabrum septem lucernarum ex auro purissimo, et mensam propositionis auream, et propitiatorium, et Cherubim auri splendore radiantia, et bases columnarum argenteas, et triticum sermonis Dei, et vinum gaudium Spiritus sancti: vestimenta quoque et linteamina quibus credentes vestirentur in Christo: quae universa venerunt in idololatriae cultum, varia errorum dogmata componentes, et decepti alios deceperunt. Quae omnia auferet Deus, ut qui ex copia datorem non senserant, sentiant ex penuria.","english":"But if in the time of the threshing floor and the press and the winepress, when the earth replenishes past barrenness with new fruits, there is a scarcity of all things, what should we think of the rest of the year, when old things are stored up? But the wool and the linen are taken away, whether garments and linens, so that they no longer cover the shame of the harlot—that is, so that she may be stripped of God's help and the protection of all the angels may depart from her. Whence also the Apostle says that the creation is freed from the slavery of corruption into the freedom of the glory of the children of God (Rom. VIII). Many have received the gold and silver of wisdom and eloquence, from which they might make the lampstand of seven lamps of purest gold, and the golden table of showbread, and the mercy seat, and the Cherubim radiant with the splendor of gold, and the silver bases of the columns, and the wheat of the word of God, and the wine, the joy of the Holy Spirit; also the garments and linens with which believers were to be clothed in Christ. All these things came into the worship of idolatry, as they composed various doctrines of errors, and being deceived they deceived others. All these things God will take away, so that those who did not perceive the giver from the abundance may perceive him from the scarcity.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":38,"ref":"p38","source":".(Vers. 10, 11, et 12.) « Et nunc revelabo stultitiam ejus in oculis amatorum ejus; et vir non eruet eam de manu mea, et cessare faciam omne gaudium ejus, solemnitatem ejus, neomeniam ejus, Sabbatum ejus, et omnia festa tempora ejus: et corrumpam vineam ejus, et ficum ejus, de quibus dixit: Mercedes hae meae sunt, quas dederunt mihi amatores mei: et ponam eam in saltum, et comedet eam bestia agri. » LXX: « Et nunc revelabo immunditiam ejus in conspectu amatorum illius: et nullus eruet eam de manu mea; et avertam omnes laetitias ejus, solemnitates illius, et neomenias, et Sabbata, et cunctas festivitates illius, et disperdam vineam ejus, et ficus illius, quae dixit: Mercedes meae istae sunt, quas dederunt mihi amatores mei: et ponam cam in testimonium, et comedent eam bestiae agri. » Quod sequitur: Volatilia coeli et reptilia terrae 2,: obelo praenotandum est. Pro saltu quoque, quod Hebraice dicitur JAR ( ) unde CARIATH JARIM ( ), interpretatur villa silvarum, LXX trantulerunt testimonium, RES et DALETH litterarum falsi similitudine. Si enim pro RES DALETH legatur, testimonium dicitur; ita duntaxat, ut JOD littera non praecedat. Liberatis ergo veste et linteamine, ne operirent ultra ignominiam fornicariae, omnis turpitudo Jerusalem, sive stultitia, per quam operata est turpitudinem, revelabitur in conspectu amatorum ejus, ut quam velatam desiderabant, apertam contemnant.","english":"(Verses 10, 11, and 12.) \"And now I will reveal her folly in the eyes of her lovers; and no man shall rescue her from my hand, and I will make all her joy to cease, her solemnity, her new moon, her Sabbath, and all her festival times: and I will corrupt her vine and her fig tree, of which she said: These are my wages, which my lovers gave me: and I will make her a forest, and the beast of the field shall devour her.\" The Septuagint: \"And now I will reveal her uncleanness in the sight of her lovers: and no one shall rescue her from my hand; and I will turn away all her gladnesses, her solemnities, and her new moons, and her Sabbaths, and all her festivities, and I will destroy her vine and her fig trees, which she said: These are my wages, which my lovers gave me: and I will make her a testimony, and the beasts of the field shall devour her.\" What follows: \"the birds of heaven and the reptiles of the earth,\" must be marked with an obelus. Also, for \"forest,\" which in Hebrew is called JAR, whence KARIATH JARIM, which is interpreted \"village of forests,\" the Septuagint translated \"testimony,\" by the false similarity of the letters RES and DALETH. For if DALETH is read in place of RES, it means \"testimony\"; only provided the letter JOD does not precede. Therefore, having been stripped of her garment and linen, so that they no longer cover the shame of the harlot, all the foulness of Jerusalem, or her folly, by which she wrought foulness, will be revealed in the sight of her lovers, so that what they desired when it was veiled, they may despise when it is laid bare.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":39,"ref":"p39","source":"Cumque tradita fuerit amatoribus suis Assyriis, sive daemonibus, quibus et ipsa et Assyrii serviunt, nullus, inquit, eam de manu mea poterit eripere, probata imbecillitate daemoniaca, quod quos rebus omnibus abundantes receperant, oppressos malis liberare non possunt. Tradita autem Babyloniae servituti, nequaquam tres solemnitates Paschae et Pentecostes et Tabernaculorum celebrare poterit. Non neomeniae, id est Kalendarum, non Sabbati exercere laetitiam, nec omnes festivitates quas uno nomine comprehendit. Vinca quoque et ficus et rerum omnium abundantia corrumpetur: In vinea laetitiam, in ficu suavitatem et dulcedinem intellige, quae auferuntur gravissimae servitutis malis: et auferentur idcirco, quia non a Deo sibi donata quasi conjugi; sed ab amatoribus suis quasi meretrici pro libidinis mercedibus arbitrata est. Tunc nequaquam habebit arbores pomiferas, sed omnia vertentur in saltum. Et quia semel metaphoram a silvis ceperat, finit in reliquo, ut hostes a quibus devoranda sunt omnia, bestias nuncupet. Haec et juxta historiam et juxta tropologiam infelix Judaea perpessa est, cujus omnis turpitudo in oculis gentium revelata est, ct nullus eam eruere potuit de manibus Dei. Cessaverunt universae caeremoniae, in luctum est versa festivitas: omnia quae sibi putabat dari a daemonibus, nunc ob offensam Dei ablata cognoscit.","english":"And when she has been handed over to her lovers, the Assyrians—or to the demons, whom both she and the Assyrians serve—no one, he says, will be able to snatch her from my hand, since the weakness of the demons has been proven: those whom they received when they abounded in all things, they cannot free when they are oppressed by evils. But having been handed over to Babylonian servitude, she will by no means be able to celebrate the three solemnities of Passover, Pentecost, and Tabernacles. Nor will she be able to practice the joy of the new moon, that is, of the Kalends, nor of the Sabbath, nor of all the festivals which he comprehends under one name. Her vineyard too and her fig tree and the abundance of all things will be corrupted: understand the joy in the vineyard, the sweetness and pleasantness in the fig tree, which are taken away by the evils of the most grievous servitude; and they are taken away for this reason, because she did not reckon them as given to her by God as to a wife, but by her lovers as to a harlot in payment for her lust. Then she will by no means have fruit-bearing trees, but all things will be turned into a forest. And because he had once taken up the metaphor from the woods, he finishes in what remains by calling the enemies, by whom all things are to be devoured, beasts. These things, both according to history and according to tropology, unhappy Judaea suffered, whose every shame was revealed in the eyes of the nations, and no one was able to tear her from the hands of God. All the ceremonies ceased, her festivity was turned into mourning: all the things which she thought were given to her by the demons, she now knows have been taken away because of her offense against God.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":40,"ref":"p40","source":"Devoraverunt eam primum Assyrii atque Chaldaei, Medi et Persae atque Macedones, ad extremum saevissima laceravit bestia, Romanorum imperium, cujus in Daniele nomen tacetur, ut major formido his qui devorandi sunt, augeatur. Quae de Judaea diximus, refer ad haereticos, qui prima fronte doctrinam et scientiam promittentes, egressi de Ecclesia deseruntur a Deo, et omnis eorum ignominia in conspectu amatorum ponitur, quos prius deceperant, et traditi bestiis quas Propheta declinat. dicens: Ne tradas bestiis animam confitentem tibi (Psal. LXXIII 19), earum morsibus derelinquentur.\n\n(Vers. 13.) « Et visitabo super eam dies Baalim, quibus accendebat incensum, et ornabatur inaure sua, et monili suo: et ibat post amatores suos: et mei obliviscebatur, dicit Dominus, » LXX: « Et ulciscar super eam dies Baalim, in quibus immolabat eis: et circumdabat sibi inaures suas, et monilia: et ibat post amatores suos: mei autem oblita est, dicit Dominus. » Servat personam meretricis, quae auro ornatur et gemmis, ut placeat amatoribus suis, et quidquid pulchritudinis non habet per naturam, arte conquirit. Has inaures, qui bus aures ejus doctrina Dei fuerant adornatae, et has margaritas quae ex collo pretiosae pendebant, ita ut sponsus ad eam diceret et maritus: Collum tuum sicut monilia (Cant. I, 9), misit aute porcorum pedes, et dedit sanctum canibus (Matth. VII).","english":"The Assyrians and Chaldeans first devoured her, then the Medes and Persians and Macedonians, and finally the most savage beast of all, the Roman empire, whose name is passed over in Daniel, so that the dread may be greater for those who are to be devoured. What we have said of Judea, apply to the heretics, who at first sight promise doctrine and knowledge, but having gone out from the Church are forsaken by God, and all their shame is set before the eyes of the lovers whom they had first deceived, and they are handed over to the beasts which the Prophet shuns, saying: Do not give to the beasts a soul that confesses to you (Ps. 73:19), and they will be abandoned to their bites.\n\n(Verse 13.) \"And I will visit upon her the days of the Baalim, in which she burned incense, and adorned herself with her earring and her necklace, and went after her lovers, and forgot me, says the Lord,\" The Septuagint: \"And I will take vengeance upon her for the days of the Baalim, in which she sacrificed to them, and put around herself her earrings and necklaces, and went after her lovers; but me she forgot, says the Lord.\" He keeps the character of the harlot, who is adorned with gold and gems to please her lovers, and whatever beauty she does not possess by nature she procures by art. These earrings, with which her ears had been adorned by the teaching of God, and these pearls which hung precious from her neck, so that the bridegroom and husband said to her: Your neck is like necklaces (Song 1:9), she sent after the feet of pigs, and gave what is holy to the dogs (Matt. 7).","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":41,"ref":"p41","source":"Et impletum est quod in Proverbiis legimus: Sicut inauris aurea in naribus suis: ita mulieri pessimae pulchritudo (Prov. XXV, 12). Haec autem universa faciebat, ut sequeretur amatores suos, et relinqueret virum. Tantumque fuit desiderium voluptatis ac libidinis, ut omnem memoriam amiserit maritalem, et oblita sit fuisse se conjugem. Quamobrem in ipsis solemnitatibus quibus incendebat thura daemonibus, visitabitur in plagis, et corripietur in poenis. Baal, numero singulari, Baalim pluraliter, eadem idola nominantur genere masculino. Ubicunque enim in fine Hebraici sermonis in syllabam legimus, numero plurali est, genere masculino: ubi autem OTH, numero plurali, genere feminino. Ergo Seraphim et Cherubim plurali intelligimus numero, genere masculino. Sabaoth autem quod interpretatur militarium, vel exercituum, vel virtutum, numero plurali, genere feminino. Itaque et Baalim masculino genere, numero sunt plurali: licet quidam male et legant genere feminino. Quomodo autem decipiant haeretici amatores suos, et componantur eloquii venustate, structuraque verborum, ut mendacia simulent veritatem, et conjugalem pudicitiam derelinquant, et incendant Baalim, id est, idolis, quae de suo corde finxerunt, quotidie cernimus.","english":"And what we read in Proverbs is fulfilled: As a golden earring in a pig's snout, so is beauty in a most wicked woman (Prov. 25:12). But she did all these things in order to follow after her lovers and forsake her husband. And so great was her desire for pleasure and lust that she lost all memory of her marriage and forgot that she had been a wife. Therefore, on the very solemnities at which she burned incense to demons, she will be visited with plagues and rebuked with punishments. Baal in the singular number, Baalim in the plural, are the same idols, named in the masculine gender. For wherever at the end of a Hebrew word we read the syllable -im, it is plural number, masculine gender; but where -oth, it is plural number, feminine gender. Therefore Seraphim and Cherubim we understand as plural number, masculine gender. But Sabaoth, which is interpreted as of soldiers, or of armies, or of powers, is plural number, feminine gender. And so Baalim too is masculine gender and plural number, although some read it wrongly as feminine gender. But how heretics deceive their lovers, and are adorned with elegance of speech and structure of words, so that they counterfeit truth with lies, and abandon conjugal chastity, and burn incense to Baalim, that is, to the idols which they have fashioned from their own heart, we see daily.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":42,"ref":"p42","source":"Non enim habent curam rusticae simplicitatis, quae meretricia ornamenta non quaerit; sed artificis elegantisque mendacii, ut amatoribus suis diabolis et daemoniis placeant·\n\n(Vers. 14.) « Propter hoc ecce ego lactabo eam: et ducam eam in solitudinem, et loquar ad cor ejus. Et dabo ei vinitores ejus, ex eodem loco, et vallem Achor ad aperiendam spem 3. » LXX: « Ideo ecce ego seducam eam, et ponam illam quasi desertum; et loquar ad cor ejus, et dabo ei possessiones suas inde, et vallem Achor et aperiendam intelligentiam ejus. » Pro eo quod nos diximus, ad aperiendam spem, et LXX verterunt, ad aperiendum intelligentiam ejus, interpretatus est Symmachus, id est, in ostium spei, Theodotion, id est, aperire patientiam, vel, exspectationem ejus.","english":"For they have no care for rustic simplicity, which does not seek a harlot's ornaments, but for the artifice of elegant falsehood, so that they may please their lovers, the devils and demons.\n\n(Verse 14.) \"Therefore, behold, I will allure her, and lead her into the wilderness, and speak to her heart. And I will give her her vineyards from that same place, and the valley of Achor to open hope.\" The Septuagint: \"Therefore, behold, I will seduce her, and I will set her as a desert; and I will speak to her heart, and I will give her her possessions from there, and the valley of Achor, and to open her understanding.\" For what we have said, \"to open hope,\" and the Septuagint translated, \"to open her understanding,\" Symmachus rendered as \"into the door of hope,\" Theodotion as \"to open her patience,\" or \"her expectation.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":43,"ref":"p43","source":"Postquam revelata fuerit ignominia Jerusalem, sive Judaeae meretricis in oculis amatorum ejus, et cessaverit universa solemnitas, vineam et ficum vel siccitas vel grando corruperit, et redacta in silvas atque infructuosas arbores, a bestiis fuerit devorata, et reddiderit ei Dominus cruciatus atque tormenta; quia daemonibus Baalim thura succenderat, et nequaquam se ultra de cineribus a favillis putaverit posse consurgere, tunc, hoc est, in adventu Christi Filii sui, aperiet spem salutis, et dabit locum poenitentiae, et blandietur ei; hoc enim significat, lactabo eam; ut post poenarum magnitudinem, dolores pristinos repromissione mitiget prosperorum. Et ducam eam, inquit, in solitudinem, id est educam ex malis, sicut et prius de AEgyptiaca eduxeram servitute; et loquar ad cor ejus verba mollia, verba consolatoria, ut tristitiam gaudio, temperem, juxta idioma Scripturarum; quibus verbis et Sichem locutus est ad cor Dinae (Gen. XXXIV), et Joseph in AEgypto fratribus suis tristibus atque metuentibus (Gen. XLV,) ut moeror gaudio mutaretur. Quod sequitur.","english":"After the ignominy of Jerusalem, or of the harlot Judea, has been revealed in the eyes of her lovers, and all her solemnity has ceased, and drought or hail has ruined her vine and fig tree, and she has been reduced to woods and unfruitful trees, and has been devoured by beasts, and the Lord has rendered to her tortures and torments—because she had burned incense to the demons of the Baalim, and had by no means thought that she could rise again from the ashes and embers—then, that is, at the coming of Christ his Son, he will open the hope of salvation, and give room for repentance, and speak soothingly to her; for this is what \"I will allure her\" means: that after the magnitude of her punishments, he may soften her former sorrows by the promise of prosperity. And I will lead her, he says, into the wilderness, that is, I will lead her out from evils, just as I had previously led her out from Egyptian slavery; and I will speak to her heart gentle words, words of consolation, so that I may temper sorrow with joy, according to the idiom of the Scriptures; with which words Sichem also spoke to the heart of Dinah (Gen. 34), and Joseph in Egypt to his brothers, who were sorrowful and afraid (Gen. 45), so that mourning might be changed into joy. What follows.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":44,"ref":"p44","source":"(Vers. 15.) « Et dabo ci vinitores ejus, ex eodem loco. » Quia blanditias et solitudinem in praeteritae historiae exeuntium de AEgypto similitudine praemiserat 1, in qua Moyses et Aaron de eadem gente Judaeorum principes exstiterunt, etiam nunc pollicetur, quod vinitores ejus de eodem loco daturus sit. Vineam intelligi Israel, omnis et veteris Instrumenti et novi Scriptura testatur: Vinea Domini Sabaoth, domus Israel est (Isa. V, 7): Et: Vineam ex AEgypto transtulisti (Psal. LXXIX, 9) Et in Evangelio (Matth. XXI), Paterfamilias locavit vineam suam, fructusque non recepit. Et interfecto filio suo, novissime locavit eam aliis vinitoribus. Hoc igitur prophetalis sermo promittit, quod principes hujus vineae exeuntes de gentibus et de captivitate hostium, sive vitiorum, de ipso sint genere Judaeorum, id est apostoli; et locus tumultus, vallisque turbarum, hoc enim interpretatur Achor, mutetur in ostium spei, sive ad aperiendam spem atque patientiam, quod idcirco supplicia et tormenta perpessa sit, ut per haec ad prospera perveniret. Quod autem vallis Achor, in qua interfectus est Achan ob furtum eorum 2, quae Deo fuerant consecrata, conturbatio et tumultus interpretetur; non ut quidam putant, id est perversitas, ipse Jesus interpretatur loquens ad Achan: Quia turbasti nos, conturbet te Dominus in die hac (Josue VII, 23).","english":"(Verse 15.) \"And I will give her vinedressers from that same place.\" Because he had previously promised blandishments and solitude in the likeness of the past history of those departing from Egypt, in which Moses and Aaron stood forth as princes of the Jewish people from that same nation, even now he promises that he will give her vinedressers from that same place. That the vineyard is to be understood as Israel, the Scripture of both the Old and the New Testament testifies: The vineyard of the Lord of hosts is the house of Israel (Isa. 5:7); and: You brought a vineyard out of Egypt (Ps. 79:9); and in the Gospel (Matt. 21), the householder leased his vineyard and did not receive the fruit. And after his son was killed, he finally leased it to other vinedressers. Therefore the prophetic discourse promises this: that the princes of this vineyard, going forth from the nations and from the captivity of enemies, or of vices, will be from the very race of the Jews, that is, the apostles; and that the place of tumult, and the valley of crowds—for this is what Achor means—will be changed into a door of hope, or for opening hope and patience, because she endured punishments and torments for this reason, that through these she might arrive at prosperity. But that the valley of Achor, in which Achan was killed for the theft of those things which had been consecrated to God, is interpreted as confusion and tumult—not, as some think, perversity—is shown by Jesus himself speaking to Achan: Because you have troubled us, may the Lord trouble you on this day (Josh. 7:23).","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":45,"ref":"p45","source":"Unde appellatus est locus illo EMEC ACHOR ( ), id est, vallis conturbationis. Simulque et in hoc intelligimus, quae in principio terrae sanctae, juxta Jericho, quando de solitudine egressus est populus, propter fluenta Jordanis, in prima Israelis victoria, moeror in gaudium commutatus sit. Ibique aperta est spes, ubi fuerat desperatio; ut, punitis his qui peccavere in Christo, et commisere sacrilegium, salventur ex eis qui blasphemantes Judeos fuerint detestati, et quantum in se est interfecerint. Haec circumcisio et nostri Judaizantes ad mille annorum regnum referunt, quae et in principio per apostolos vinitores et credentium multa millia ex Israel videmus esse completa, et compleri quotidie in his qui credere voluerint. Quodque nos diximus: Lactabo eam, et LXX interpretati sunt: Seducam cam ad Antichristi tempus referunt; ut qui Christi uon receperint veritatem, illius recipiant mendacium, et postea, Christo adveniente, salventur.","english":"Whence that place was called EMEC ACHOR, that is, the valley of disturbance. And at the same time we understand in this what happened at the beginning of the holy land, near Jericho, when the people came out of the wilderness, because of the waters of the Jordan, in Israel's first victory: mourning was turned into joy. And there hope was opened where there had been despair; so that, with those punished who sinned against Christ and committed sacrilege, some of those who detested the blaspheming Jews and, as far as in them lay, killed them, might be saved. This circumcision our Judaizers also refer to the thousand-year reign, which we see was fulfilled at the beginning through the apostles as vinedressers, and many thousands of believers from Israel, and is fulfilled daily in those who have wished to believe. And what we said, \"I will allure her,\" and the Seventy interpreted as \"I will seduce her,\" they refer to the time of Antichrist; so that those who did not receive the truth of Christ may receive his lie, and afterward, when Christ comes, may be saved.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":46,"ref":"p46","source":"« Et canet ibi juxta dies juventutis suae, et juxta dies ascensionis suae de terra AEgypti. » LXX: « Et humiliabitur juxta dies infantiae suae, et juxta dies ascensionis de terra AEgypti. » In eo ubi nos posuimus, canet, et LXX transtulerunt, humiliabitur, in Hebraico scriptum est ANATHA ( ), quod Symmachus interpretatus est affligetur, Theodotion respondebit, Aquila obediet, id est,: nos ab Hebraeo magis accipimus, id est, praecinet: ut quia semel jactationem et eductionem in solitudinem, et vinitores ex eodem loco, et vallem Achor, posuerat, et totam historiam exeuntium de AEgypto et pergentium ad terram sanctam brevi sermone perstringens, etiam nunc historiae similitudinem conservaret. Ut quomodo eo in tempore, quando egrediebantur de terra AEgypti, submerso Pharaone in mari Rubro, arripuit Maria tympanum, et praecinens caeteris, exsultavit et dixit: Cantemus Domino, gloriose enim magnificatus est; equum et ascensorem dejecit in mare (Exod. XV, 1): sic nunc quoque secundum dies juventutis suae, sive adolescentiae suae, quando egressa est de terra AEgypti, canat atque laetetur, et regnum Christi ac suam salutem inter Ecclesias choros concinat. Et animadverte quia quando eximus de AEgypto, et ad meliora transimus, dicamur ascendere: quia Jerusalem in montibus sita est, de qua qui in Jericho descendere voluerat, vulneratus est (Luc. X).","english":"And she shall sing there according to the days of her youth, and according to the days of her ascent from the land of Egypt. The Septuagint: And she shall be humbled according to the days of her infancy, and according to the days of her ascent from the land of Egypt. Where we have rendered canet, and the Septuagint has translated humiliabitur, in Hebrew is written ANATHA, which Symmachus interpreted as affligetur, Theodotion as respondebit, Aquila as obediet, that is, we take it rather from the Hebrew, that is, she shall sing beforehand: so that, since he had once set forth the tossing and the leading out into the wilderness, and the vinedressers from that same place, and the valley of Achor, and, summing up in a brief discourse the whole history of those going out from Egypt and journeying to the holy land, he would even now preserve the likeness of that history. So that, just as at that time, when they were going out from the land of Egypt, with Pharaoh submerged in the Red Sea, Miriam took up a timbrel, and singing before the others, exulted and said: Let us sing to the Lord, for he is gloriously magnified; horse and rider he has cast into the sea: so now too, according to the days of her youth, or of her adolescence, when she went out from the land of Egypt, let her sing and rejoice, and chant in the choirs of the Churches the kingdom of Christ and her own salvation. And observe that when we go out from Egypt and pass over to better things, we are said to ascend: because Jerusalem is situated on the mountains, from which he who wished to descend to Jericho was wounded.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":47,"ref":"p47","source":"Ad eos autem qui AEgypti id est, saeculi hujus quaerunt auxilia dicitur. Vae qui descendunt in AEgyptum propter auxilium (Isa. XXXI. 1). Interpretatio Aquilae et Theodotionis, e quibus alter posuit, id est, audiet, alter, id est respondebit, nobiscum facit, quod praecinentibus aliis, alii respondeant concinentes. Humiliabitur autem et affigetur, quod LXX et Symmachus transtulerunt, non convenit tempori laetitiae, nisi forte imitabitur Paulum, qui postquam vocatus est apostolus, plangit antiqua peccata, et se dicit indignum vocatione apostoli, quia persecutus sit Ecclesiam Dei (I Cor. XV): ut humiliatio et afflictio in conscientia praeteriti vulneris, non in dolore malorum praesentium accipiatur.\n\n(Vers. et 17.) « Et erit in die illa, ait Dominus, vocabit me vir meus, et non vocabit me ultra Baalim: et auferam nomina Baalim de ore ejus, et non recordabitur ultra nominis eorum. » LXX similiter. Primum omni Asiae regnasse Ninum. Beli filium, omnes et Graecae et Barbarae narrant historiae: qui apud Assyrios Ninum sui nominis condidit civitatem, quam Hebraei vocant Niniven. Hujus uxor Semiramis, de qua multa et miranda referuntur, muros Babylonis exstruxit: de qua insignis poeta testatur (Ovid. Metam. IV, 58) dicens:","english":"But to those who seek the aid of Egypt, that is, of this world, it is said: Woe to those who go down to Egypt for help. The interpretation of Aquila and Theodotion, of which the one rendered it, that is, she shall hear, the other, that is, she shall answer, agrees with us, because while some sing beforehand, others respond in harmony. But she shall be humbled and afflicted, which the Septuagint and Symmachus translated, does not fit a time of joy, unless perhaps she imitates Paul, who after he was called as an apostle laments his former sins and says that he is unworthy of the calling of an apostle, because he persecuted the Church of God, so that the humbling and affliction may be understood as in the conscience of a past wound, not in grief over present evils.\n\n(Verses 16 and 17.) And it shall be in that day, says the Lord, that she shall call me My husband, and shall no longer call me Baalim: and I will take away the names of Baalim out of her mouth, and she shall remember their names no more. The Septuagint similarly. That Ninus, son of Belus, first reigned over all Asia, all Greek and barbarian histories relate; he founded in Assyria a city of his own name, which the Hebrews call Nineveh. His wife Semiramis, of whom many and wondrous things are reported, built the walls of Babylon; of whom the distinguished poet testifies, saying:","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":48,"ref":"p48","source":"Quam dicitur olim Coctilibus muris cinxisse Semiramis urbem.\n\nHic adversus Zoroastrem magnum, regem Bactrianorum, forti certamine dimicavit: et in tantam pervenit gloriam, ut patrem suum Belum referret in Deum, qui Hebraice dicitur BEL ( ), et in multis prophetis, maximeque in Daniele juxta Theodotionem, sub idolo Babylonis, hoc appellatur nomine. Hunc Sidonii et Phoenices appellant DAAL ( ): eadem enim inter BETH et LAMED litteras consonantes, AIN vocalis littera ponitur, quae juxta linguae illius proprietatem nunc Deel, nunc Baal legitur. Unde et Dido Sidonia regii generis, cum AEneam suscepisset hospitio, hac patera Jovi vina delibat qua Belus et omnes a Belo soliti3. Didicimus exordium daemonis, imo hominis in daemonem consecrati: omnia enim idola ex mortuorum errore creverunt. Audiamus caetera: Lingua Hebraea et Syra BAAL interpretatur id est, habens, Si voluerimus dicere, habens me, dicamus BAALI: et apud utramque gentem uxores viros suos vocant Baali, id est vir meus, quod intelligitur, habens me: et est sensus, qui me habet in conjugio. Eadem Hebraeorum lingua vocatur vir is ( ): unde et uxor quae de viro sumpta est, in Genesi appellatur ISSA Gen.II, 23) quasi a viro; virago.","english":"Which is said to have once girded the city of Semiramis with baked-brick walls.\n\nHere he fought with great strength against Zoroaster, king of the Bactrians, and reached such glory that he made his father Belus a god, who in Hebrew is called BEL, and in many prophets, and especially in Daniel according to Theodotion, is called by this name in reference to the idol of Babylon. The Sidonians and Phoenicians call him DAAL; for between the consonants BETH and LAMED, the vowel letter AIN is placed, which according to the peculiarity of that language is read now Deel, now Baal. Whence also Dido of Sidon, of royal lineage, when she had received Aeneas as a guest, poured out wine to Jupiter with that bowl from which Belus and all descended from Belus were accustomed to make libation. We have learned the origin of the demon, or rather of the man consecrated into a demon; for all idols have grown from the error concerning the dead. Let us hear the rest: in the Hebrew and Syriac tongue BAAL is interpreted as \"having,\" that is, \"he who has.\" If we wish to say \"he who has me,\" we say BAALI; and among either people wives call their husbands Baali, that is, \"my husband,\" which is understood as \"he who has me\"; and the sense is, \"he who has me in marriage.\" In the same Hebrew tongue a man is called IS; whence also the wife, who was taken from the man, is called in Genesis ISSA, as it were from the man; virago.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":49,"ref":"p49","source":"Quod ergo Dominus, hoc est, cum utroque sermone, ISSI et BAALI appelletur vir meus, sive maritus meus, tantum odi idolorum nomina, ut etiam quod bene dici potest, propter ambiguitatem et verbi similitudinem, nequaquam velim dici, sed appellari me ISSI, magis quam BAALI; ne dum aliud loquitur, alterius recordetur, et virum nominans, idolum cogitet. Ignosce obscuritati, quae tribus nascitur modis; aut rerum difficultate, aut magistri imperitia, aut discentis nimia tarditate. Neque enim Hebraeum prophetam edisserens, oratoriis debeo declamatiunculis ludere, et in narrationibus atque epilogis Asiatico more cantare, sed auxilio orationum tuarum, et incredibili discendi studio, aperire quae clausa sunt. Denique Aquila diligens et curiosus interpres; Vocabit, inquit, me vir meus, et non vocabit me ultra habens me, id est, BAAL.\n\n(Vers 18.) « Et percutiam eis foedus in die illa cum bestia agri, et cum volucre coeli, et cum reptili terrae et arcum, et gladium, et bellum conteram de terra: et dormire eos faciam fiducialiter. » LXX: « Et disponam eis testamentum in dic ilia cum bestiis agri, et cum volatilibus coeli, et cum reptilibus terrae: et arcum, et gladium, et bellum conteram de terra: et habitare eos faciam in spe.","english":"Therefore what the Lord means—that is, with either word, ISSI and BAAL, He is called my man, or my husband—is that I so greatly hate the names of idols that even what can be said rightly, on account of ambiguity and the similarity of the word, I would by no means wish to be said, but rather that I be called ISSI than BAAL; lest while one thing is spoken, another be recalled, and in naming a husband, she think of an idol. Pardon the obscurity, which arises in three ways: either from the difficulty of the subject, or from the ignorance of the teacher, or from the excessive slowness of the learner. For in expounding a Hebrew prophet, I ought not to play with rhetorical declamations and, in the Asiatic manner, sing in narratives and epilogues, but with the help of your prayers and an incredible zeal for learning, to open what is closed. Finally Aquila, a diligent and careful translator, says: \"He will call me my man, and will no longer call me one having me,\" that is, BAAL.\n\n(Verse 18.) \"And I will strike a covenant for them in that day with the beast of the field, and with the bird of heaven, and with the creeping thing of the earth, and the bow, and the sword, and war I will break from the earth: and I will make them sleep confidently.\" The Septuagint: \"And I will establish a testament for them in that day with the beasts of the field, and with the birds of heaven, and with the creeping things of the earth: and the bow, and the sword, and war I will break from the earth: and I will make them dwell in hope.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":50,"ref":"p50","source":"» Quando omnia religionis adversae vocabula fuerint ablata de populo Dominum conficte, et vocaverit me, inquit, vir meus, et nequaquam Baali, id est, idolum meum, tunc percutiam eis foedus atque concordiam cum bestiis agri, et volucribus coeli, et reptilibus terrae. De hoc tempore et Isaias loquitur: Habitabit lupus cum agno; et pardus cum haedo accubabit. Vitulus, et leo, et ovis simul morabuntur, et puer parvulus minabit eos. Vitulus et ursus pascentur, et simul requiescent catuli eorum: et leo quasi bos comedet paleas (Isa. XI, 6, 7); nequaquam carnem sanguinemque desiderans, sed mundis atque simplicibus vescens cibis. Quando Petro, ut Cornelium susciperet ex nationibus (Act. X, 11), revelatum, jussumque est ut comederet omnes bestias, et nihil immundum esse cognosceret, quod cum gratiarum actione perciperetur: super quibus audit postea; Quod Deus mundavit, tu ne commune dixeris (Ibid. 15). Ergo in adventu Domini Salvatoris, post resurrectionis ejus triumphos, et ascensum ad Patrem, duo parietes angulari lapide copulati sunt ab eo, qui fecit utrumque [Al. utraque unum. (Ephes. II, 14). Et vocavit eam quae dicebatur, Absque misericordia, misericordiam consecutam; et eum qui dicebatur Non populus meus, populum suum; pacatisque omnibus, arcus et gladius conteretur ac bellum. Non enim erunt necessaria instrumenta pugnantium, cum qui pugnent, defuerint.","english":"When all the terms of the opposing religion have been taken away from the people confessing the Lord, and she has called me, he says, my husband, and no longer Baali, that is, my idol, then I will strike a covenant and concord for them with the beasts of the field, and the birds of the sky, and the creeping things of the earth. About this time Isaiah also speaks: The wolf will dwell with the lamb, and the leopard will lie down with the goat. The calf, and the lion, and the sheep will stay together, and a little boy will drive them. The calf and the bear will graze, and their young will rest together; and the lion will eat straw like an ox; no longer desiring flesh and blood, but feeding on clean and simple foods. When it was revealed to Peter, so that he might receive Cornelius from the nations, and he was commanded to eat all beasts, and to know that nothing is unclean which is received with thanksgiving—concerning which he later hears: What God has made clean, do not call common. Therefore at the coming of the Lord Savior, after the triumphs of his resurrection and his ascension to the Father, the two walls were joined by the cornerstone by him who made both one. And she who was called Without Mercy he called having obtained mercy; and him who was called Not my people, his people; and with all things pacified, the bow and the sword will be crushed, and war. For the instruments of those fighting will not be necessary, when those who fight are lacking.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[{"kind":"lacuna","severity":"caution","text":"The source is fragmentary here: the edition marks a break or an editorial bracket, and the English carries across it. Treat the bridge as supplied, not translated."}]},{"i":51,"ref":"p51","source":"Jungetur Israel gentibus, et implebitur illud Deuteronomii; Laetamini gentes cum populo ejus (Deut. XXIII, 43). Notus enim in Judaea Deus, in Israel magnum nomen ejus. Et factus est in pace locus ejus, et habitatio ejus in Sion (Psal. LXXV, 2, 3). hoc est in Ecclesia, in qua confregit potentias arcuum, scutum, gladium et bellum; quibus fractis atque contritis, dormient credentes fiducialiter, et sub uno pastore requiescent, sive sperabunt, in his quae oculus non vidit, et auris non audivit, et in cor hominis non ascenderunt, quae praeparavit Deus diligentibus se (I Cor. I).\n\n(Vers. 19.) « Et sponsabo te mihi in sempiternum; et sponsabo te mihi in justitia, et judicio, et in misericordia, et in miserationibus; et sponsabo te mihi in fide; et scies quia ego Dominus. » LXX similiter. O quanta clementia Dei! meretrix quae cum multis amatoribus fornicata est, et ob crimen bestiis tradita, postquam revertitur ad virum, nequaquam reconciliari ei dicitur, sed despondi. Et vide quid sit inter Dei conjunctionem et hominum; homo cum uxorem acceperit, de virgine mulierem facit, id est, non virginem; Deus etiam meretricibus copulatus, eas mutat in virgines, juxta illud quod adulterae dicitur per Jeremiam; Non ut dominum me invocasti, aut patrem, aut principem virginitatis tuae (Jerem. III, 4).","english":"Israel will be joined to the Gentiles, and that saying of Deuteronomy will be fulfilled: Rejoice, you Gentiles, with his people. For God is known in Judaea, his name is great in Israel. And his place has been made in peace, and his dwelling in Sion, that is, in the Church, in which he has broken the powers of bows, the shield, the sword, and war; once these are broken and crushed, believers will sleep in confidence, and will rest under one shepherd, or will hope, in those things which the eye has not seen, nor the ear heard, nor have entered into the heart of man, which God has prepared for those who love him.\n\n(Verse 19.) \"And I will betroth you to me forever; and I will betroth you to me in justice, and judgment, and in mercy, and in compassions; and I will betroth you to me in faith; and you shall know that I am the Lord.\" The Septuagint reads similarly. O how great is God's clemency! A harlot who has fornicated with many lovers, and on account of her crime has been handed over to the beasts, after she returns to her husband, is no longer said to be reconciled to him, but betrothed. And see what a difference there is between God's union and that of men: when a man takes a wife, he makes a woman out of a virgin, that is, no longer a virgin; God, even when joined to harlots, changes them into virgins, according to that which is said to the adulteress through Jeremiah: Did you not call me Lord, or father, or prince of your virginity?","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":52,"ref":"p52","source":"Unde et Apostolus post fornicationem et idolorum cultum credentibus Corinthiis loquitur; Despondi enim vos uni viro virginem castam exhibere Christo (II Cor. XI, 2). Quaerimus cur tertio desponsionis nomen repetierit. Primo enim ait: Sponsabo te mihi in sempiternum. Secundo: Sponsabo te mihi in justitia et judicio, et in misericordia et miserationibus. Nec hoc fine contentus jungit et tertium: Sponsabo te mihi in fide, et scies quia ego Dominus. Primo despondit eam in Abraham, sive in AEgypto, ut uxorem habeat sempiternam. Secundo in monte Sinai, dans ei pro sponsalibus Legis justitiam atque judicium, et junctam Legi misericordiam, ut quando peccaverit, tradatur captivitati, cum egerit poenitentiam, revocetur in patriam, et misericordiam consequatur. De his sponsalibus in diversis locis Psalmista decantat: Misericordiam et judicium cantabo tibi. Domine (Psal. CII. 2). Et: Misericordia et veritas obviaverunt sibi, et justitia et pax deosculatae sunt se (Psal. LXXXIV, 11). Quos duos calices in septuagesimo quarto psalmo legimus: Calix in manu Domini ini meri plenus misto, et inclinavit ex hoc in illum; de justitiae calice in calicem misericordiae, et rursum de calice misericordiae in calicem justitiae. Si iniquitates, inquit, observaveris, Domine, Domine, quis sustinebit? Quia apud te propitiatio est (Psal. CXXIX, 3, 4).","english":"Hence the Apostle also says to the Corinthians who believed after fornication and the worship of idols: I have espoused you to one husband, to present you as a chaste virgin to Christ. We ask why he repeated the word of espousal a third time. For first he says: I will espouse you to me forever. Second: I will espouse you to me in righteousness and judgment, and in mercy and compassion. Nor content with this end, he adds a third: I will espouse you to me in faith, and you shall know that I am the Lord. First he espoused her in Abraham, or in Egypt, that he might have her as an everlasting wife. Second on Mount Sinai, giving her for a dowry the righteousness and judgment of the Law, and mercy joined to the Law, so that when she has sinned, she may be handed over to captivity, and when she has done penance, she may be recalled to her homeland and obtain mercy. Of these espousals the Psalmist sings in various places: I will sing of mercy and judgment to you, O Lord. And: Mercy and truth have met each other, and righteousness and peace have kissed. These two cups we read of in the seventy-fourth psalm: A cup in the hand of the Lord, full of pure mixed wine, and he has inclined it from this to that; from the cup of righteousness to the cup of mercy, and again from the cup of mercy to the cup of righteousness. If you, he says, O Lord, should observe iniquities, O Lord, who shall endure it? Because with you there is propitiation.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":53,"ref":"p53","source":"Ista igitur meretrix, quae primum voto sponsi in aeternos fuerat juncta complexus, ut nunquam a vinculo recederet maritali, quia recessit et in AEgypto fornicata est, rursum per Legem assumitur: quam quia praeteriit, prophetis quasi sponsi sodalibus, qui ad se missi fuerant, interfectis, novissime venit Dei Filius, Dominus Jesus: quo crucifixo, et a mortuis resurgente, desponsatur nequaquam in Legis justitia, sed in fide et gratia Evangelii, ut cum cognoverit Unigenitum, cognoscat et Patrem. Dicit enim ipse ad Philippum; Tanto tempore vobiscum sum, et non cognovistis me? Philippe, qui videt me, videt et Patrem meum; quomodo tu dicis, ostende nobis Patrem? non credis quia ego in, Patre, et Pater in me est (Joan. XIV, 10, 11). Qui in fide fuerit desponsatus et crediderit Evangelio, statim sciet quia ipse sit Deus, credens in eum quem prius negaverat.","english":"This harlot, therefore, who had first been joined to the bridegroom's embrace by a vow of eternal union, so that she might never withdraw from the marriage bond, because she withdrew and played the harlot in Egypt, is taken up again through the Law; and because she passed it by, killing the prophets as the bridegroom's companions who had been sent to her, last of all came the Son of God, the Lord Jesus; when he had been crucified and had risen from the dead, she is betrothed no longer in the righteousness of the Law, but in the faith and grace of the Gospel, so that when she has come to know the Only-Begotten, she may know the Father as well. For he himself says to Philip: Have I been with you so long, and you have not known me? Philip, he who sees me sees my Father also; how can you say, Show us the Father? Do you not believe that I am in the Father, and the Father in me? Whoever has been betrothed in faith and has believed the Gospel will immediately know that he himself is God, believing in him whom he had previously denied.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":54,"ref":"p54","source":"(Vers. seqq.) « Et erit in die illa: Exaudiam, dicit Dominus: exaudiam coelos, et illi exaudient terram, et terra exaudiet triticum et vinum et oleum, et haec exaudient Jezrael, et seminabo eam mihi in terra, et miserebor ejus quae fuit absque misericordia, et dicam non populo meo, populus meus es tu: et ipse dicet, Deus meus es tu. » LXX: « Et erit in die illa, dicit Dominus: Exaudiam coelum et coelum exaudiet terram, et terra exaudiet frumentum, vinum, et oleum, et haec exaudiant Jezrael, et seminabo cam mihi super terram, et miserebor ejus quae fuit absque misericordia 2, et dicam non populo meo, populus meus es tu: et ipse dicet. Dominus Deus meus es tu. » In die illa et in illo tempore, quando te mihi in fide despondero, et cognoveris quod ego sim Dominus, exaudiam coelos, qui enarrant gloriam Dei (Psal. XVIII), et coeli exaudient terram, ut eam coelesti pluvia irrigent, et terra, de qua orta est veritas (Psal. LXXXIV), et in cujus agrum paterfamilias egreditur, ut seminet semen suum (Matth. XIII) exaudiet triticum et vinum et oleum, de quibus supra diximus, et haec omnia exaudient Jezrael, id est, semen Dei, ut intelligatur omnium rerum abundantia atque fertilitas ob Dei semen, qui [Al. quod) Christus est, condonari, quod Dei semen seminatur in terra, ut multiplices fructus afferat, centenarium, sexagenarium, et tricenarium (Ibid. 8).","english":"And it shall come to pass in that day, says the Lord: I will hear the heavens, and they shall hear the earth, and the earth shall hear the grain and the wine and the oil, and these shall hear Jezreel, and I will sow her for myself in the earth, and I will have mercy on her who was without mercy, and I will say to those who were not my people, You are my people: and he shall say, You are my God. The Septuagint: And it shall come to pass in that day, says the Lord: I will hear the heaven, and the heaven shall hear the earth, and the earth shall hear the grain, the wine, and the oil, and these shall hear Jezreel, and I will sow her for myself upon the earth, and I will have mercy on her who was without mercy, and I will say to those who were not my people, You are my people: and he shall say, Lord, you are my God. In that day and at that time, when I have betrothed you to myself in faith, and you have known that I am the Lord, I will hear the heavens, which declare the glory of God, and the heavens shall hear the earth, so as to water it with heavenly rain, and the earth, from which truth has sprung and into whose field the father of the household goes out to sow his seed, shall hear the grain and the wine and the oil, of which we have spoken above, and all these shall hear Jezreel, that is, the seed of God, so that it may be understood that the abundance and fertility of all things are granted on account of the seed of God, who is Christ, because the seed of God is sown in the earth, so that it may bring forth manifold fruits: a hundredfold, sixtyfold, and thirtyfold.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[{"kind":"lacuna","severity":"caution","text":"The source is fragmentary here: the edition marks a break or an editorial bracket, and the English carries across it. Treat the bridge as supplied, not translated."}]},{"i":55,"ref":"p55","source":"Et illa meretrix, qua: Deo fuerat copulata, et tres ediderat liberos, duos masculos, et unam feminam; primum Jezrael, secundam, absque misericordia; tertium, non populus meus, videat propter semen Dei mutata esse rerum vocabula, et in Christi fide consecutam misericordiam, quae absque misericordia erat, et vocatum populum Dei, qui prius, non populus vocabatur. Ex quo prospicimus posse universa quae dicta sunt referri et ad decem tribus quae Israel vocantur, et sub nomine meretricis tres liberos ediderunt, et ad omnem gentem Judaici nominis. Dc exauditione coeli et torrae, et frumenti, vini, et olei, et Jezrael, hoc quidam sentiunt, quia postquam Christus advenerit, omnia suo currant ordine et utilitati hominum cuncta deserviat creatura, ut ab initio condita est. Quae, omnia Judaei et nostri Judaizantes post Antichristum in fine mundi corporaliter praestolantur.","english":"And that harlot who had been joined to God and had borne three children, two males and one female—the first Jezreel, the second Without Mercy, the third Not My People—is to see that on account of the seed of God the names of things have been changed, and that she who was Without Mercy has obtained mercy in the faith of Christ, and that she who was previously called Not My People has been called the people of God. From this we perceive that all the things which have been said can be referred both to the ten tribes who are called Israel and who under the name of the harlot bore three children, and to the whole nation of the Jewish name. Concerning the hearkening of heaven and earth, and of grain, wine, and oil, and Jezreel, some hold this view: that after Christ has come, all things run in their own order and every creature serves the utility of men, as it was created from the beginning. All these things the Jews and our Judaizers await bodily after the Antichrist at the end of the world.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":56,"ref":"p56","source":"(CAP. Vers. 1.) «·Et dixit Dominus ad me: Adhuc vade, dilige mulierem dilectam amico et adulteram, sicut diligit Dominus filios Israel, et Ipsi respectant ad deos alienos, et diligunt vinacia uvarum. » LXX: « Et dixit Dominus ad me; Adhuc vade et dilige mulierem diligentem mala et adulteram, sicut diligit Dominus filios Israel: et ipsi respiciunt ad deos alienos, et amant coctiones `cum vinaciis. » Priori mulieri in typum decem tribuum, vel totius Judaici populi fornicantis, propheta conjungitur, et abjectos filios atque cruciatos tandem recepit in salutem: hic jubetur ut adhuc diligat adulteram mulierem. Quando dicitur, adhuc, ostendit quia prius amaverit fornicariam: quae adultera, vel diligat illa mala, vel diligatur ab amico vel proximo: RE ( ) enim verbum Hebraicum, vel malum legitur, vel amicus. Et ne putemus dilectionem prophetae in adulteram, aliud quid significare quam Dei dilectionem in filios Israel, intulit: sicut diligit Dominus filios Israel.","english":"And the Lord said to me: Go yet again, love a woman beloved of her friend and an adulteress, just as the Lord loves the children of Israel, and they look to strange gods, and love the dregs of grapes. The Septuagint: And the Lord said to me: Go yet again and love a woman who loves evil and is an adulteress, just as the Lord loves the children of Israel; and they look to strange gods, and love mixtures with the dregs. To the former woman, as a type of the ten tribes, or of the whole Jewish people playing the harlot, the prophet is joined, and the cast-off and tormented children he at last receives into salvation; here he is commanded to love yet again an adulterous woman. When it is said, yet again, it shows that he had loved a harlot before: which adulteress either loves those evil things, or is loved by a friend or a neighbor; for the Hebrew word RE is read either as evil or as friend. And lest we think that the prophet's love for an adulteress signifies anything other than God's love for the children of Israel, he added: just as the Lord loves the children of Israel.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":57,"ref":"p57","source":"Ergo quia propheta diligit adulteram, et tamen non ei matrimonio copulatur, nec fornicatione conjungitur, sed tantum diligit delinquentem, typus Dei est, qui filios Israel pessimos diligit, qui cum diligamur a Domino, ad deos alienos idolaque respiciunt, et diligunt vinacia uvarum, quae vina non habent, et pristinam gratiam perdiderunt, sicut daemones qui lapsi de propria dignitate, et nihil antiquae gratiae possidentes, aridi sunt, et veteri siccitate marcentes. Unde pro vinaciis, quod Hebraice dicitur, ASISE ( ) Aquila interpretatus est, id est, vetera. Symmachus, id est, steriles: et non solum vinacia sunt, sed et vetera vinacia, ut antiqua delicta testentur. Et notandum quia haec adultera praesens tempus significet Judaeorum, qui absque Deo et notitia Scripturarum et gratia Spiritus sancti diligantur a Domino, qui omnium exspectat salutem, et aperit januam poenitentibus, et nihilominus illi res inutiles amant, traditiones hominum et somnia diligentes, et nequaquam uvas habeant et vinum et plena musto torcularia, sed vetera vinacia quae projecta sunt. Pio pemmatibus quae LXX transtulerunt, et comeduntur cum uvis passis, sive vinaciis, placentas Latine possumus dicere, vel erustula, quae idolis offeruntur, et Graece appellantur. Filii autem Israel in praesenti loco duodecim vocantur tribus; supra vero decem quae erant in Samaria, et possidebant metropolim, Jezrael.","english":"Therefore, because the prophet loves an adulteress, and yet is not joined to her in marriage, nor united in fornication, but only loves the one who sins, he is a type of God, who loves the wicked sons of Israel, who, though we are loved by the Lord, look to strange gods and idols, and love the dregs of grapes, which have no wine and have lost their former grace, like the demons who, having fallen from their own dignity and possessing nothing of their ancient grace, are dry and withering in old dryness. Hence, in place of \"dregs of grapes,\" which in Hebrew is called ASISE, Aquila translated as \"old things,\" Symmachus as \"barren things\"; and they are not only dregs of grapes, but old dregs of grapes, so as to testify to ancient sins. And it must be noted that this adulteress signifies the present time of the Jews, who, without God and without knowledge of the Scriptures and without the grace of the Holy Spirit, are loved by the Lord, who awaits the salvation of all and opens the door to the penitent, and nevertheless they love useless things, loving the traditions of men and dreams, and by no means have grapes and wine and winepresses full of must, but old dregs of grapes which have been cast out. By \"pemmatibus,\" which the Septuagint translated, and which are eaten with raisins or dregs of grapes, we can say in Latin \"cakes,\" or \"crustula,\" which are offered to idols, and in Greek are called. But the sons of Israel in the present passage are called the twelve tribes; above, however, the ten which were in Samaria and possessed the metropolis, Jezreel.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":58,"ref":"p58","source":"(Vers. 2.) « Et fodi eam mihi quindecim argenteis, et coro hordei, et dimidio coro hordei, et dixi ad eam. » LXX: « Et conduxi eam mihi quindecim argenteis, et gomor hordie, et nebel vini, et dixi adeam. » Pro gomor in Hebraico scriptum est OMER ( ) guod omnes interpretes, absque LXX, corum interpretati sunt, sermone Graeco et pro nebel vini, in Hebraico legitur LETHECH SEORIM ( ) 1, quod caeteri interpretes hordie transtulerunt, id est, medium partem cori, quae facit quindecim medios. Quodque jungitur in editione Vulgata: Neque eris alteri viro; alteri in Hebraico non habetur, sed simpliciter, Non eris viro. Si enim ponatur alteri, subauditur quod a suo habeatur viro. Quando antem absolute dicitur, Non eris viro, intelligimus quod nulli jungatur omnino, et absque coitu maritali sit. Mensuram autem cori in Ezechiel legimus (Ezech. XLV), et in Evangelio (Luc. XVI). Fodit itaque eam sibi, id est adulteram, sive conduxit quindecim argenteis. Quando dicit, fodi, ostendit vineam, quae a Domino plantata est, et in multis locis ponitur Scripturarum, significans populum Judaeorum. Sin autem legerimus, conduxi, adulterae pretium est, non ut cum propheta dormiat, sed ut contenta mercede sua, adulterare desistat, nec passim caeteris copuletur.","english":"And I dug her for myself with fifteen pieces of silver, and a cor of barley, and half a cor of barley, and I said to her. The Septuagint: And I hired her for myself with fifteen pieces of silver, and a gomor of barley, and a nebel of wine, and I said to her. Instead of gomor, in Hebrew is written OMER, which all the interpreters except the Septuagint translated as cor, in the Greek language; and instead of nebel of wine, in Hebrew is read LETHECH SEORIM, which the other interpreters rendered as barley, that is, half a cor, which makes fifteen measures. And what is joined in the Vulgate edition: Nor shall you be for another man; another is not had in Hebrew, but simply, You shall not be for a man. For if another is placed, it is understood that she is held by her own man. But when it is said absolutely, You shall not be for a man, we understand that she is joined to no one at all, and is without marital intercourse. Moreover, we read the measure of a cor in Ezekiel, and in the Gospel. Thus he dug her for himself, that is, the adulteress, or hired her for fifteen pieces of silver. When he says, I dug, he shows the vineyard, which was planted by the Lord, and is set down in many places of the Scriptures, signifying the people of the Jews. But if we read, I hired, it is the price of the adulteress, not that she may sleep with the prophet, but that, content with her wage, she may cease to commit adultery, nor be joined indiscriminately to others.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":59,"ref":"p59","source":"Foditur etiam, sive conducitur coro hordei, et dimidio coro hordei, id est, quadraginta et quinque modiis, et hac mercede suscepta, audivit a Domino:\n\n(Vers. 3.) « Dies multos exspectabis me: non fornicaberis, et non eris viro; sed et ego exspectabo te. » LXX: « Dies multos sedebis mihi: et non fornicaberis, nec eris alteri viro, et ego tibi. » Hoc est, nec aliis amatoribus turpiter te prostitues, nec mihi, viro a quo conducta es, legitime conjungeris. Ac ne putes factam tibi injuriam, quia dixi exspectabis me, par pari referam, Et ego exspectabo te. Quinta decima die illucescente mensis Nisan percussa sunt AEgyptiorum primogenita, et Israelis de AEgypto eductus est populus, ac in servitutem Dei mercede conductus (Exod. XII). Denique pro primogenitis Israel quae plagam non sensere communem, quinos argenti accipe siclos (Num. III), qui in templi donaria conferuntur. Plerique nostrorum quindecim, ad hebdomadam legis, et ogdoadem referunt Evangelli, id est, sabbatum, et diem resurrectionis, quo exercetur circumcisio spiritualis. Sed quomodo adultera mulier quae hordeo pascitur, et a viro aliena est, utrumque in mercedem accipiat Testamentum, explanare non possunt. Quadragesimo quinto die ad montem Sina pervenit populus, statimque altero die ut sanctificentur a coitu feminarum per triduum, et se praeparent, ad accipiendam legem Dei, edicitur (Exod. XIX).","english":"She is dug for, or hired, with a cor of barley and half a cor of barley, that is, forty-five modii, and having received this wage, she heard from the Lord:\n\n(Verse 3.) \"For many days you shall wait for me: you shall not commit fornication, and you shall not be for a man; but I also will wait for you.\" The Septuagint: \"For many days you shall sit for me: and you shall not commit fornication, nor shall you be for another man, and I for you.\" That is, you shall neither shamefully prostitute yourself to other lovers, nor shall you be legitimately joined to me, the man by whom you were hired. And lest you think an injury has been done to you because I said \"you shall wait for me,\" I will return like for like: \"And I will wait for you.\" On the fifteenth day, as the month of Nisan was dawning, the firstborn of the Egyptians were struck, and the people of Israel was led out of Egypt, and was hired into the service of God for a wage (Exod. 12). Finally, in place of the firstborn of Israel, who did not feel the common plague, take five shekels of silver apiece (Num. 3), which are contributed to the temple's offerings. Most of our writers refer the fifteen to the week of the law and the ogdoad of the Gospel, that is, the sabbath and the day of resurrection, on which spiritual circumcision is performed. But how the adulterous woman who feeds on barley and is estranged from her husband may receive both Testaments as her wage, they cannot explain. On the forty-fifth day the people came to Mount Sinai, and immediately on the next day it is proclaimed that they should be sanctified from intercourse with women for three days, and prepare themselves to receive the law of God (Exod. 19).","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":60,"ref":"p60","source":"Transactis tribus diebus quinquagesimo die Moyses ascendit in montem, et decalogum suscepit. Sedet itaque populus Judaeorum qui quondam quindecim argenteis, et quadraginta quinque hordei modiis est conductus, post adventum Domini Salvatoris, et viri sui exspectat adventum. Quodque dicit: Non fornicaberis, et non eris viro, hoc ostendit quod interim modo idolis non serviat, nec tamen habeat Deum; sed et amatoribus et viro spoliata sit. Et quia virum non habet, non vescitur cibo hominum, frumento et legumine, sed hordeo irrationabilium jumentorum, ruminans vilitatem litterae, quae interficit, et non habens spiritum vivificantem. Unde et in lege mulier, quae a marito accusatur adulterii, in potione, id est convictionis, quando arguitur in peccato, farinam accipit hordei (Num. V); quae enim imitata est equos et mulos, quibus non est intelligentia (Psal. XXX), equorum atque mulorum sustentatur alimentis. Pro dimidio coro hordei, nebel vini Septuaginta transtulerunt, quod penitus in Hebraico non habetur. Et possumus dicere, in nebel vini, hoc est mensura plena atque perfecta, inebriatam adulteram, et plenis afflictam esse suppliciis. Unde et Jeremias calicem meri propinat gentibus et Jerusalem (Jerem. XV). Vir quoque sedet, imo exspectat adulterae poenitentiam, ut postquam plenitudo gentium subintraverit (Rom.","english":"When three days had passed, on the fiftieth day Moses ascended the mountain and received the Decalogue. And so the people of the Jews, who were once hired for fifteen pieces of silver and forty-five modii of barley, sits after the coming of the Lord and Savior, and awaits the coming of her husband. And what he says—\"You shall not commit fornication, and you shall not be for a husband\"—shows that in the meantime she does not serve idols, and yet does not have God; but she has been stripped both of her lovers and of her husband. And because she does not have a husband, she does not feed on the food of men—grain and pulse—but on the barley of irrational beasts of burden, chewing over the worthlessness of the letter, which kills, and not having the Spirit who gives life. Hence also in the law the woman who is accused of adultery by her husband, in the drink, that is, of conviction, when she is convicted in sin, receives barley flour (Num. 5); for she who has imitated horses and mules, which have no understanding (Ps. 30), is sustained by the food of horses and mules. For \"half a cor of barley,\" the Seventy translated as \"a nebel of wine,\" which is not found at all in the Hebrew. And we can say that in the nebel of wine, that is, a full and perfect measure, the adulteress has been made drunk and afflicted with full punishments. Hence also Jeremiah serves the cup of unmixed wine to the nations and to Jerusalem (Jer. 15). The husband also sits, or rather awaits the penitence of the adulteress, so that after the fullness of the Gentiles has come in (Rom.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":61,"ref":"p61","source":"XI) et novissimus crediderit Israel, ita ut qui fuerat caput, vertatur in caudam (Deut. XXVIII), et cauda vertatur in caput, tunc fiat unus grex et unus pastor.\n\n(Vers. 4, 5.) « Quia dies multos sedebunt filii Israel sine rege, et sine principe, et sine sacrificio, et sine altari, et sine ephod, et sine theraphim. Et post haec revertentur filii Israel et quaerent Dominum Deum suum et David regem suum: et pavebunt ad Dominum et ad bonum ejus in novissimo dierum. » LXX: « Quia diebus multis sedebunt filii Israel sine rege, sine principe, sine sacrificio, sine altari, sine sacerdotio, sine manifestationibus (quae Graece dicuntur ). Et post haec revertentur filii Israel, et quaerent Dominum Deum suum et David regem suum: et stupebunt ad Dominum, et super bonis ejus in novissimo die. » Pro ephod et theraphim Septuaginta, id est, sacerdotium, et, id est, manifestationes interpretati sunt. Sciendum autem, ut crebro diximus, ephod significare indumentum sacerdotale, quod in Exodo et Levitico a LXX dicitur, id est superhumerale ab Aquila, id est, superindumentum. Theraphim autem proprie appellant, id est, figurae et simulacra, quae nos possumus in praesenti duntaxat loco Cherubim et Seraphim sive alia quae in templi ornamenta fieri jussa sunt, dicere.","english":"11) and Israel will believe last, so that what had been the head is turned into the tail (Deut. 28), and the tail is turned into the head, then there will be one flock and one shepherd.\n\n(Ver. 4, 5.) \"Because for many days the sons of Israel will sit without a king, and without a prince, and without sacrifice, and without an altar, and without ephod, and without teraphim. And after these things the sons of Israel will return and seek the Lord their God and David their king: and they will fear the Lord and his goodness in the last of days.\" The Septuagint: \"Because for many days the sons of Israel will sit without a king, without a prince, without sacrifice, without an altar, without priesthood, without manifestations (which in Greek are called ). And after these things the sons of Israel will return, and seek the Lord their God and David their king: and they will be amazed at the Lord, and at his good things in the last day.\" For ephod and teraphim the Seventy interpreted as priesthood, and, that is, manifestations. But it must be known, as we have often said, that ephod signifies the priestly garment, which in Exodus and Leviticus is called by the LXX , that is, superhumerale by Aquila, that is, an outer garment. But teraphim they properly call , that is, figures and images, which we can, at least in the present passage, call Cherubim and Seraphim or other things that were commanded to be made for the ornaments of the temple.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":62,"ref":"p62","source":"Verum quia Septuaginta interpretati sunt, pro quibus Aquili transtulit; et haec ipsa sunt in, id est, in Rationali, hoc intelligimus, quia in pectore et corde pontificis et, id est, veritas esse debeat atque doctrina: ut non solum sciat rectam fidem, sed et quod noverit, possit ore proferre. Quod et apostolus Paulus scribit ad Titum, docens qualis episcopus ordinandus sit: Oportet enim episcopum sine crimine esse tanquam Dei dispensatorem: non superbum, non iracundum, non vinolentum, non percussorem, non turpis lucri cupidum: sed hospitalem, benignum, sobrium, justum, sanctum, continentem, amplectentem eum, qui secundum sanam doctrinam est, fidelem sermonem, ut potens sit exhortari in doctrina sana, et eos qui contradicunt arguere (Tit. I, 7–9). Ephod ac theraphim et in Judicum libro legimus (Judic. XVII et XVIII), quae sibi fecerat Levites, qui postea cum sexcentis de tribu Dan armatis profectus est. Post passionem Domini Salvatoris usque in praesentem diem, paulo minus quadringentesimus annus expletur, et quantum temporis resideat usque ad diem judicii, nec angeli noverunt, nec Filius. Qui ideo ignorare se dicit, quia nobis non expedit discere |Al. scire]. Hi sunt ergo multi dies, quibus infelix Synagoga et mulier adultera hordeo pascitur, et sedet contracta, quia cum Christo stare non potest. Sine rege, de quo locutus est Pater: Suscitavi regem cum justitia (Isa. XLV, 13).","english":"But because the Seventy interpreted, in place of which Aquila translated; and these same things are in, that is, in the Rational, we understand this, because in the breast and heart of the priest and, that is, truth and doctrine ought to be: so that he may not only know the right faith, but also be able to utter with his mouth what he knows. Which the apostle Paul also writes to Titus, teaching what sort of bishop ought to be ordained: For a bishop ought to be without crime as a steward of God: not proud, not irascible, not given to wine, not a striker, not greedy of filthy lucre: but hospitable, benign, sober, just, holy, continent, embracing him who is according to sound doctrine, a faithful word, so that he may be able to exhort in sound doctrine, and to convict those who contradict (Tit. 1:7–9). We also read of the ephod and the teraphim in the book of Judges (Judg. 17 and 18), which the Levite had made for himself, who afterwards set out with six hundred armed men from the tribe of Dan. After the passion of the Lord Savior, up to the present day, a little less than the four hundredth year is completed, and how much time remains until the day of judgment, neither the angels know, nor the Son. Who therefore says that he does not know, because it is not expedient for us to learn. These, then, are the many days in which the unhappy Synagogue and the adulterous woman feed on barley, and she sits contracted, because she cannot stand with Christ. Without a king, of whom the Father spoke: I have raised up a king with justice (Isa. 45:13).","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":63,"ref":"p63","source":"Et ipse dicit in Psalmo. Ego autem constitutus sum rex ab eo super Sion montem sanctum ejus (Psal. II, 6). Sine principe, vel ipso Domino Salvatore, vel certe pontifice, de quo scriptum est: Principi populi tui non maledices (Exod. XXII). Et sine sacrificio, et sine altari. Subverso enim templo, et incensa Jerusalem, nec sacrificium, nec sacerdotium Judaica gens exercere potest. Et sine ephod et sine theraphim, id est, instrumentis sacerdotalis habitus. De hoc rege et Jacob ita benedictione Judae patriarchae loquitur: Non deficiet princeps ex Juda, neque dux de femoribus ejus, donec veniat cui repositum est; et ipse erit exspectatio gentium (Gen. XLIX, 10). Ergo postquam defecit princeps ex Juda, et dux de femoribus ejus, et Herodes alienigena et proselytus suscepit imperium, intelligimus venisse cui regnum repositum est, et ipse erat exspectatio gentium. Haec est caecitas quae ex parte accidit Israeli, ut sub. intraret plenitudo gentium, et tunc omnis Israel salvus fieret (Rom. XI): et multo post tempore revertentur, et quaerent Dominum Deum suum, et David regem suum, qui de David stirpe generatus est, et interpretatur fortis manu. Ipse enim solvit captivitatem populi sui, et dedit vinctis remissionem. Cumque eum viderint filii Israel, qui a suis fratribus denegatus est, in Patris et sua majestate regnantem, pavebunt, et stupebunt ad Dominum et ad bonum ejus.","english":"And he himself says in the Psalm: But I have been established as king by him over Zion, his holy mountain. Without a prince, either the Lord Savior himself, or certainly the high priest, of whom it is written: You shall not curse the prince of your people. And without sacrifice, and without altar. For with the temple overthrown and Jerusalem burned, the Jewish people can exercise neither sacrifice nor priesthood. And without ephod and without teraphim, that is, the instruments of the priestly garment. Concerning this king, Jacob also speaks thus in the blessing of Judah the patriarch: The prince shall not fail from Judah, nor the leader from his thighs, until he comes to whom it has been reserved; and he himself will be the expectation of the nations. Therefore, after the prince failed from Judah, and the leader from his thighs, and Herod, a foreigner and a proselyte, took up the empire, we understand that he has come to whom the kingdom was reserved, and he himself was the expectation of the nations. This is the blindness which happened in part to Israel, so that the fullness of the nations might enter in, and then all Israel would be saved: and after a long time they will return, and seek the Lord their God, and David their king, who was begotten from the stock of David, and is interpreted as strong in hand. For he himself loosed the captivity of his people, and gave release to the bound. And when the sons of Israel see him, who was denied by his own brothers, reigning in the majesty of the Father and his own, they will be afraid, and will be astonished at the Lord and at his goodness.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":64,"ref":"p64","source":"Qui bonus filius, de bono natus est patre, sive ad bona Domini, de quibus sanctus loquitur: Credo videre bona Domini in terra viventium (Psal. XXVI, 13): haec enim quam incolimus peccatores, terra est mortuorum. Praesens capitulum, alii Judaeorum super Babylonica captivitate interpretantur, quando septuaginta annis desolatum est templum, et altare et victimae ac sacerdotium non fuerunt, et postea sub Zorobabel in sedes pristinas sunt reversi. Alii, ut nos, in futurum tempus differunt, et quae sit causa tam grandis offensae, ut tanto tempore relicti sint, maxime cum idola non colant, praeter interfectionem Salvatoris, aliam non valent invenire.\n\n(Cap. IV.—Vers. 1, 2.) « Audite verbum Domini, filii Israel; quia judicium Domino cum habitatoribus terrae: non est enim veritas, et non est misericordia, et non est scientia Dei in terra. Maledictum, et mendacium, et homicidium, et furtum, et adulterium inundaverunt: et sanguis sanguinem tetigit. » LXX: « Audite verbum Domini, filii Israel; quia judicium Domino ad habitatores terrae, quia non est veritas, neque misericordia, neque scientia Dei super terram. Maledictio, et mendacium, et homicidium, et furtum, et adulterium effusum est super terram, et sanguinem sanguini miscuerunt.","english":"He who is a good son was born of a good father, or [the phrase refers] to the good things of the Lord, of which the saint speaks: I believe that I shall see the good things of the Lord in the land of the living. For this land which we sinners inhabit is a land of the dead. Some of the Jews interpret the present chapter as concerning the Babylonian captivity, when for seventy years the temple was desolate, and there was no altar, no victims, and no priesthood, and afterward under Zerubbabel they returned to their former seats. Others, like us, defer it to a future time, and as for what the cause of so great an offense might be, such that they were abandoned for so long a time—especially since they do not worship idols—they are unable to find any other than the killing of the Savior.\n\n(Cap. IV.—Vers. 1, 2.) Hear the word of the Lord, you children of Israel; for the Lord has a judgment with the inhabitants of the land: for there is no truth, and there is no mercy, and there is no knowledge of God in the land. Cursing, and lying, and murder, and theft, and adultery have overflowed: and blood has touched blood. The Septuagint: Hear the word of the Lord, you children of Israel; for the Lord has a judgment against the inhabitants of the land, for there is no truth, nor mercy, nor knowledge of God upon the earth. Cursing, and lying, and murder, and theft, and adultery have been poured out upon the earth, and they have mixed blood with blood.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":65,"ref":"p65","source":"» A principio prophetae usque ad hunc locum sub meretricis descriptione et adulterae, quarum post gravissimas poenas et relictionem longissimam, postea fit in pristinum, vel in meliorem statum restitutio, decem tribuum, vel duarum, et in commune omnium peccata numerantur. Nunc rursum ad Israel, id est, decem tribus sermo convertitur, exponens non frustra iratum Deum tam gravia comminari et inferre supplicia: ne forsitan non ex judicii veritate, sed ex potentia Dei injuste videatur in eos qui non peccaverunt, lata sententia 1. Audite, inquit Propheta, verbum Domini, o filii Israel: quia vult Dominus cum suo populo judicari et exponere causas indignationis suae. Non est veritas, et non est misericordia, et non est scientia Dei in terra. Nec veritas enim absque misericordia sustineri potest, et misericordia absque veritate efficit negligentes: unde alterum miscetur alteri, quae qui non habuerit, consequenter et Dei notitiam non habebit. Sed e contrario pro veritate mendacium, et pro misericordia maledictum, homicidium, furtum, adulterium. Non dixit, est; sed ut delictorum abundantiam demonstraret, intulit, inundaverunt (Al. redundaverunt): et pro scientia Dei, quae non est in terra, sanguis sanguinem tetigit, sive sanguinem sanguini miscuerunt, ut augerent peccata peccatis, et novis vetera cumularent.","english":"From the beginning of the prophet up to this point, under the description of the harlot and the adulteress—after their most severe punishments and a very long rejection, there is afterward a restoration to their former, or to a better, state—the sins of the ten tribes, or of the two, and in common of all, are enumerated. Now again the discourse is turned to Israel, that is, the ten tribes, showing that God was not angry without cause in threatening and inflicting such grave punishments: lest perhaps the sentence pronounced against those who did not sin might seem to proceed not from the truth of judgment but from the power of God unjustly. Hear, says the Prophet, the word of the Lord, O children of Israel: for the Lord wishes to be judged with his people and to set forth the causes of his indignation. There is no truth, and there is no mercy, and there is no knowledge of God in the land. For neither can truth be sustained without mercy, and mercy without truth makes men negligent; whence the one is mingled with the other, and he who does not have them will consequently not have the knowledge of God either. But on the contrary, instead of truth there is lying, and instead of mercy, cursing, murder, theft, adultery. He did not say, \"it is\"; but to demonstrate the abundance of offenses, he added, \"they have overflowed\" (or, \"they have abounded\"): and instead of the knowledge of God, which is not in the land, blood has touched blood, or they have mingled blood with blood, so as to increase sins with sins and heap up old ones with new.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":66,"ref":"p66","source":"Recte autem qui habitatores terrae sunt et non incolae, ad judicium provocantur: quia a facie Aquilonis exardescunt mala super habitatores terra (Jerem. VI). Et in Apocalypsi Joannis: Vae, vae, vae dicitur super habitatores terrae (Apoc. VI). Qui autem potest cum propheta dicere: Advena sum apud te, et peregrinus, sicut omnes patres mei (Psal. XXXVIII, 13), et pertransit mundum istum quasi incola et peregrinus, veritatem sequitur et misericordiam, et scientiam Dei, ne inundatione maledicti atque mendacii, homicidii, et furti, et adulterii et sanguinis opprimatur.\n\n(Vers. 3.) « Propter hoc lugebit terra et infirmabitur omnis qui habitat in ea: in bestia agri et in volucre coeli sed et pisces maris congregabuntur. » LXX: « lugebit terra, et minuetur cum omnibus qui habitant cam, cum bestiis agri, cum serpentibus terrae 2, et cum volatilibus coeli, et pisces maris deficient. « Quia non est veritas, et non est misericordia, et non est scientia Dei super terram, sed e regione male dictum, et mendacium, et homicidium, et furtum, et adulterium inundaverunt, et sanguis sanguinem tetigit: idcirco lugebit terra cum habitatoribus suis, et infirmabitur, ut non habeat bestias agri, et volucres coeli, et pisces maris deficient.","english":"But rightly are those who are inhabitants of the earth and not sojourners called to judgment, because from the face of the North evils blaze up against the inhabitants of the earth (Jeremiah 6). And in the Apocalypse of John: Woe, woe, woe is pronounced upon the inhabitants of the earth (Apocalypse 6). But he who can say with the prophet: I am a stranger with you, and a sojourner, as all my fathers were (Psalm 38:13), and passes through this world as a sojourner and stranger, follows truth and mercy and the knowledge of God, lest he be overwhelmed by the flood of cursing and lying, murder and theft and adultery and blood.\n\n(Verse 3.) \"Therefore shall the land mourn, and every one that dwells in it shall be weakened: with the beast of the field and with the bird of heaven, and even the fishes of the sea shall be gathered together.\" The Septuagint: \"The land shall mourn, and shall be diminished with all who dwell in it, with the beasts of the field, with the serpents of the earth, and with the birds of heaven, and the fishes of the sea shall fail.\" Because there is no truth, and there is no mercy, and there is no knowledge of God upon the earth, but on the contrary cursing, and lying, and murder, and theft, and adultery have overflowed, and blood has touched blood: therefore the land shall mourn with its inhabitants, and shall be weakened, so that it may not have the beasts of the field, and the birds of heaven, and the fishes of the sea shall fail.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":67,"ref":"p67","source":"Cum enim captivitas decem tribuum venerit, habitatore sublato, bestiae quoque et volucres coeli et pisces maris deficient; iramque Domini etiam muta elementa sentient. Hoc qui non credit accidisse populo Israel, cernat Illyricum, cernat Thracias, Macedoniam atque Pannonias, omnemque terram, quae a Propontide et Bosphoro usque ad Alpes Julias tenditur, et probabit cum hominibus et animantia cuncta deficere, quae in usus hominum a Creatore prius alebantur. Sin autem voluerimus, ut quidam putant, feros homines bestias interpretari, et volucres coeli eos, qui elevantur in superbiam, et omnia humana contemnunt, et pisces maris, qui irrationabiles sunt, et ita bruti, ut nihil omnino sapiant, et aerem liberum coelumque non videant: hoc non tam irati quam clementis est Domini, ut quae mala sunt, auferantur de terra.\n\n(Vers. 4, 5.) « Verumtamen unusquisque non judicet. et non arguatur vir: populus enim tuus sicut hi qui contradicunt sacerdoti, et corrues hodie, et corruet etiam propheta tecum. » LXX: « Ut nullus neque judicetur, neque arguatur quisquam: populus autem meus quasi sacerdos, cui contradicetur, et infirmabitur per diem, et infirmabitur etiam propheta tecum. » Secundum Septuaginta interpretes, hoc quod posuimus, ut nullus neque judicetur, neque arguetur quisquam, superiori capitulo coaptandum est: sed nos Hebraeos sequimur.","english":"For when the captivity of the ten tribes has come, with the inhabitant removed, the beasts also and the birds of the air and the fish of the sea will fail; and even the mute elements will feel the wrath of the Lord. Whoever does not believe that this happened to the people of Israel, let him look at Illyricum, let him look at Thrace, Macedonia, and Pannonia, and the whole land that stretches from the Propontis and the Bosphorus all the way to the Julian Alps, and he will prove that along with men all living creatures also failed, which had previously been nourished by the Creator for the use of men. But if we wish, as some think, to interpret fierce men as beasts, and the birds of the air as those who are lifted up in pride and despise all human things, and the fish of the sea as those who are irrational and so brutish that they understand nothing at all and do not see the free air and sky, this is the work not so much of an angry Lord as of a merciful one, that the things which are evil be taken away from the earth.\n\n(Verses 4, 5.) \"Nevertheless let no one judge, and let no man be accused: for your people are like those who contradict the priest, and you will fall today, and the prophet also will fall with you.\" The Septuagint: \"That no one may either be judged, nor may anyone be accused: but my people are like a priest who is contradicted, and he will be weakened through the day, and the prophet also will be weakened with you.\" According to the Septuagint interpreters, what we have set down, that no one may either be judged, nor may anyone be accused, must be fitted to the preceding chapter; but we follow the Hebrews.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":68,"ref":"p68","source":"Provocati ad judicium Dei, filii Israel, qui habitabant in terra ut causas Dominicae indignationis audirent, et praeterita peccata cognoscerent, propter quae hostibus traderentur, nunc quia in sceleribus perseverant, et impudenti Deum fronte contemnunt, audiunt: Non necesse est ut veniatis ad judicium, ut in vestris flagitiis arguamini; quia tantae estis impudentiae, ut nec convicti quidem, pudorem habeatis et verecundiam; sed contradicatis mihi, quasi si discipulus magistro sacerdoti plebecula contradicat, quae non habet sacerdotii dignitatem. Et quia tales estis, ideo hodie corruetis, id est, ducemini in captivitatem, et perdetis regnum Israel. Quod dicit, hodie, aut praesens tempus significat, aut non fraude et insidiis, sed clara in captivitatem luce ducemini, tantaque erit vestri infirmitas, ut etiam prophetae, qui vobis solebant prophetare mendacium, vobiscum corruant, et sentiant captivitatem. Hic prophetas aut pseudoprophetas debemus accipere, aut certe omnem gratiam prophetalem. Quamdiu enim non sunt captae decem tribus, habuerunt et Eliam prophetam et Elisaeum, et caeteros filios prophetarum, qui prophetaverunt in Samaria. Unde et Amos propheta qui de tribu Juda erat, et de viculo Thecue, cogitur redire ad patriam suam, ne in alieno regno et Samaria prophetaret.","english":"Having been summoned to the judgment of God, the sons of Israel who dwelt in the land, so that they might hear the causes of the Lord's indignation and acknowledge their past sins, on account of which they were to be handed over to their enemies, now, because they persevere in their crimes and with shameless brow despise God, hear: There is no need for you to come to judgment, to be convicted in your shameful deeds; for you are of such great impudence that not even when convicted do you feel shame and modesty, but you contradict me, as if a disciple should contradict his teacher, a common rabble its priest, a rabble that does not possess the dignity of the priesthood. And because you are such, therefore today you will fall, that is, you will be led into captivity, and you will lose the kingdom of Israel. What he says, today, either signifies the present time, or that you will be led into captivity not by deceit and ambush, but in broad daylight, and your weakness will be so great that even the prophets, who used to prophesy lies to you, will fall with you and experience captivity. Here we must understand either prophets or false prophets, or certainly every prophetic grace. For as long as the ten tribes were not captured, they had both Elijah as a prophet and Elisha, and the other sons of the prophets, who prophesied in Samaria. Whence also the prophet Amos, who was from the tribe of Judah and from the village of Tekoa, is compelled to return to his own country, lest he prophesy in a foreign kingdom and in Samaria.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":69,"ref":"p69","source":"(Vers. 6.) « Nocte tacere feci matrem tuam, conticuit populus meus, eo quod non habuerit scientiam: quia tu scientiam repulisti, repellam te et ego, ne sacerdotio fungaris mihi: et oblita es legis Dei tui, obliviscar filiorum tuorum et ego. » LXX: « Nocti assimilavi matrem tuam, et assimilatus est populus meus quasi non habens scientiam: quia tu scientiam repulisti, et ego repellam te, ne sacerdotio fungaris mihi: oblita es legis Dei tui, et ego obliviscar filiorum tuorum. » Non quod alia mater sit, et alii filii, matrem vocat et filios; sed quomodo Dominus loquens ad populum Judaeorum dicebat: Jerusalem, Jerusalem, quae occidis prophetas, et lapidas eos qui ad te missi sunt, quoties volui congregare filios tuos, sicut gallina congregat pullos suos sub alas suas, et noluisti (Matth. XXIII, 37)! Non quod alia Jerusalem, et alius populus ejus: neque enim absque populo ad caementa urbis et ligna et lapides loquebatur. Sic mater vocatur populi frequentia et omnis turba nationis Hebraeae, ad quam loquitur: filii autem, vel singuli ex populo, vel per oppida villasque dispersi. In nocte ergo ac tenebris captivitatis et moeroris et prementis angustiae traditur Israel, et populus ejus aeterno silentio conticescit; quia non habuit legis scientiam, nec Dei praecepta servavit, recepitque quod fecerat.","english":"(Verse 6.) \"In the night I made your mother be silent, my people has fallen silent, because it did not have knowledge: because you have rejected knowledge, I also will reject you, so that you may not serve me in the priesthood: and you have forgotten the law of your God, I also will forget your sons.\" The Septuagint: \"I likened your mother to night, and my people has become like one not having knowledge: because you have rejected knowledge, I also will reject you, so that you may not serve me in the priesthood: you have forgotten the law of your God, and I will forget your sons.\" Not that there is one mother and another set of sons—he calls her mother and them sons; but just as the Lord, speaking to the people of the Jews, said: Jerusalem, Jerusalem, you who kill the prophets and stone those who are sent to you, how often I wished to gather your sons, as a hen gathers her chicks under her wings, and you were unwilling! Not that there is one Jerusalem and another people of hers; for he was not speaking to the stones and timbers and wood of the city apart from the people. Thus the multitude of the people and the whole crowd of the Hebrew nation is called the mother, to whom he speaks; but the sons are either individuals from the people, or those scattered through towns and villages. In the night, therefore, and in the darkness of captivity and grief and pressing distress, Israel is handed over, and his people falls silent with eternal silence; because it did not have knowledge of the law, nor did it keep God's commandments, and it received what it had done.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":70,"ref":"p70","source":"Ipsa enim Dei repulit legem, et ideo sacerdotium perdidit in aeternum, colens vitulos aureos in Dan et Bethel: et quia oblita est legis Dei, et penitus AEgyptiis se idolis mancipavit, idcirco et Dominus obliviscetur filiorum ejus, tradens eos aeternae captivitati: Qui enim ignorat ignorabitur (I Cor. XIV, 38), et in Psalmis legimus: Nescierunt, neque intellexerunt, in tenebris ambulant (Psal. LXXXI, 5). Omnia quae dicuntur ad decem tribus, referre possumus ad haereticos, qui reliquerunt regnum David et Jerusalem, id est Christum et Ecclesiam: et ideo aeterna nocte cooperti sunt, nec habent scientiam Dei, et repelluntur a Domino ne sacerdotio fungantur ei. et filiorum quos genuerint nunquam meminit, quia filii alieni facti suut ei.\n\n(Vers. seqq.) « Secundum multitudinem eorum, sic peccaverunt mihi: gloriam eorum in ignominiam commutabo, peccata populi mei comedent, et ad iniquitatem eorum sublevabunt animas eorum, et erit sicut populus, sic sacerdos, et visitabo super eum vias ejus, et cogitationes illius reddam ei. » LXX: « Secundum multitudinem eorum, sic peccaverunt mihi, gloriam eorum in ignominiam ponam: peccata populi mei comedent, et in iniquitatibus eorum accipient alii animas eorum, et erit sicut populus, sic et sacerdos, et ulciscar super eum vias ejus, et cogitationes illius reddam ei.","english":"For she herself rejected the law of God, and therefore lost the priesthood forever, worshipping the golden calves in Dan and Bethel; and because she forgot the law of God, and wholly enslaved herself to the idols of Egypt, therefore the Lord also will forget her children, handing them over to eternal captivity. For \"he who is ignorant will be ignored\" (I Cor. 14:38), and in the Psalms we read: \"They have not known, nor understood, they walk in darkness\" (Ps. 81:5). All that is said to the ten tribes we can refer to the heretics, who have abandoned the kingdom of David and Jerusalem, that is, Christ and the Church; and therefore they are covered by eternal night, and they do not have the knowledge of God, and they are driven away by the Lord so that they may not serve him in the priesthood. And the children whom they have begotten he never remembers, because they have become foreign sons to him.\n\n(Verses following.) \"According to the multitude of them, so have they sinned against me: I will change their glory into ignominy. They shall eat the sins of my people, and they shall lift up their souls to their iniquity, and it shall be as the people, so the priest, and I will visit upon him his ways, and I will repay him his thoughts.\" The Septuagint: \"According to the multitude of them, so have they sinned against me: I will set their glory in ignominy. They shall eat the sins of my people, and in their iniquities others shall receive their souls, and it shall be as the people, so also the priest, and I will avenge upon him his ways, and I will repay him his thoughts.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":71,"ref":"p71","source":"» Quot homines habuit Israel, tot aras exstruxit daemonibus, in quorum victimis peccavit mihi. Propterea gloriam eorum, in qua gloriabantur sibi, et Deo idola praeferebant, in ignominiam commutabo, ut et sacerdotes capiantur et populi. Siquidem sacerdotes peccata populi mei comedunt, de quibus scriptum est: Qui devorant plebem meam, sicut escam panis (Psal. XIII, 4). Et idcirco peccata populi mei comedunt, consentientes sceleribus delinquentium: quia cum eos peccare perspexerint, non solum non arguunt, sed laudant, atque sustollunt, et beatos praedicant. De quibus et Isaias loquitur: Populus meus, qui beatos vos dicunt, seducunt vos, et semitas pedum vestrorum supplantant (Isa. III, 12). De his et per Psalmistam clamat: Quoniam laudatur peccator in desideriis animae suae, et iniquus benedicitur (Psal. IX, 24). Unde aequaliter populus et sacerdos indignantis Dei sententiam sustinebunt; quia non solum opera eorum visitabit, quae appellantur vioe, in quibus ingrediuntur; sed et cogitationes, quibus ut talia facerent, tractaverunt. Non solum enim opus, sed et cogitatio mali operis poenas luet. De haereticis facilis intelligentia est, quod quanto plures fuerint, tanto magis delinquunt Deo, et glorientur in populis: et idcirco decipiant infelices, ut peccata populi comedant, et per dulces sermones devorent domus viduarum (Luc. XX).","english":"As many men as Israel had, so many altars did she build to demons, and in their victims she sinned against me. Therefore I will turn their glory, in which they gloried and preferred idols to God, into ignominy, so that both the priests and the peoples may be taken captive. Indeed, the priests eat the sins of my people, of whom it is written: Who devour my people as food of bread. And therefore they eat the sins of my people, consenting to the crimes of the transgressors: because when they have seen them sin, they not only do not rebuke them, but even praise them, and extol them, and proclaim them blessed. Of these Isaiah also speaks: My people, those who call you blessed, deceive you, and overturn the paths of your feet. Of these too he cries out through the Psalmist: For the sinner is praised in the desires of his soul, and the wicked man is blessed. Hence both people and priest shall alike endure the sentence of an indignant God; because he will visit not only their works, which are called their ways, in which they walk, but also their thoughts, which they devised so as to do such things. For not only the deed, but even the thought of an evil deed shall pay the penalty. Concerning heretics the understanding is easy: that the more numerous they are, the more they sin against God, and glory among the peoples; and therefore they deceive the wretched, so that they may eat the sins of the people, and through sweet speeches devour the houses of widows.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":72,"ref":"p72","source":"Cum enim viderint aliquos delinquentes aiunt: Nihil aliud quaerit Deus nisi fidei veritatem, quam si custodieritis, non curat quid agatis. Haec enim dicentes, in iniquitatibus eorum sublevant animas eorum, ut non solum non agant poenitentiam, nec humilientur, sed gaudeant in sceleribus suis, et erecta cervice gradiantur. Unde et populus et sacerdos, et hi qui docti sunt, et hi qui docuerunt, pari judicio constringentur.\n\n(Vers. seqq.) « Et comedent, et non saturabuntur: et fornicati sunt, et non cessaverant: quoniam Dominum reliquerunt in non custodiendo: fornicatio, et vinum, et ebrietas aufert cor. Populus meus in ligno suo interrogavit: et baculus ejus annuntiavit ei. Spiritus enim fornicationum decepit eos, et fornicati sunt a Deo suo. » LXX: « Et comedent, et non implebuntur: fornicati sunt, et non dirigentur: quia Dominum reliquerunt, ut non custodirent: fornicationem et vinum, et ebrietatem suscepit cor populi mei: in auguriis interrogabant: et in virgis suis annuntiabant ei: quoniam spiritu fornicationis seducti sunt et fornicati sunt a Deo suo. » Voluptas insatiabilis, est, et quanto magis capitur, tanto plus utentibus se famem creat. Econtrario beati esurientes et sitientes justitiam, quoniam ipsi saturabuntur (Matth. V). Sicut justitia saturat, sic iniquitas substantiam non habens, vana comedentes fraude deludit, et uteros devorantium vacuos derelinquit.","english":"For when they have seen some committing sins, they say: God seeks nothing other than the truth of faith; if you have kept this, he does not care what you do. For saying these things, they lift up their souls in their iniquities, so that they not only do not repent nor humble themselves, but rejoice in their crimes and walk with head held high. Hence both the people and the priest, both those who have been taught and those who have taught, will be bound by an equal judgment.\n\n(Verses following.) \"And they shall eat, and not be satisfied: and they have committed fornication, and have not ceased: because they have forsaken the Lord in not keeping: fornication, and wine, and drunkenness take away the heart. My people have inquired of their wood: and their staff has announced to them. For the spirit of fornications has deceived them, and they have committed fornication from their God.\" The Septuagint: \"And they shall eat, and not be filled: they have committed fornication, and shall not be directed: because they have forsaken the Lord, so as not to keep: fornication and wine, and drunkenness has taken hold of the heart of my people: they were inquiring in auguries: and in their rods they were announcing to him: because they have been seduced by the spirit of fornication and have committed fornication from their God.\" Pleasure is insatiable, and the more it is taken in, the more it creates hunger for those who use it. On the contrary, blessed are those who hunger and thirst for righteousness, for they shall be satisfied (Matthew 5). Just as righteousness satisfies, so iniquity, having no substance, deludes those who eat it with vain deceit, and leaves the bellies of those who devour it empty.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":73,"ref":"p73","source":"Fornicati sunt, et non cessaverunt. Vires in fornicatione deficiunt, et fornicandi desiderium non quiescit. Fornicatae sunt et decem tribus cum idolis Jeroboam filii Nabaoth: et reliquerunt Dominum Deum suum, non custodiendo quae jusserat, dicens: Dominum Deum tuum adorabis, et ipsi soli servies (Deut. VI, 13), autem legendum: Fornicatio et vinum et ebrietas aufert cor. Sicut enim vinum et ebrietas eum qui biberit, mentis suae impotem facit: ita et fornicatio ac voluptas pervertit sensum, animumque debilitat: et de rationali homine, brutum efficit animal, ut ganeas et lupanaria et libidinum lustra sectetur. Cumque ita cor loco suo motum fuerit, ligna et lapides deos putat, et adorat opera manuum suarum. Unde et propheta quasi stupens et mirabundus eloquitur: Populus meus qui quondam meo vocabatur nomine, lignum interrogavit et virgas: quod genus divinationis Graeci vocant. Unde in Ezechiel legimus, quod virgas suas miscuerit Nabuchodonosor contra Ammon et Jerusalem, et exierit virga contra Jerusalem (Ezech. XXV): causaque hujus amentiae fornicationis est spiritus, qui decepit eos, ut fornicarentur a Deo suo. Fornicationem autem idololatriam nominat 3, juxta illud quod in Jeremia legimus: Et moechabantur in ligno et lapide, et dixi: Postquam fornicati sunt cum his omnibus, revertere ad me, et non est reversa in toto corde, sed in mendacio (Jerem. III, 9, 10).","english":"They have committed fornication, and they have not ceased. Their strength fails in fornication, and the desire to fornicate does not rest. The ten tribes also committed fornication with the idols of Jeroboam son of Naboth, and they abandoned the Lord their God by not keeping what he had commanded, saying: You shall adore the Lord your God, and him alone shall you serve; but there is also to be read: Fornication and wine and drunkenness take away the heart. For just as wine and drunkenness make the one who has drunk it powerless over his mind, so also fornication and pleasure pervert the understanding and weaken the soul, and from a rational man make a brute animal, so that he pursues brothels and whorehouses and the haunts of lusts. And when the heart has thus been moved from its place, it thinks wood and stones to be gods, and adores the works of its own hands. Hence the prophet also speaks as if stunned and marveling: My people, who once were called by my name, asked a piece of wood and rods—a kind of divination that the Greeks call by a particular name. Hence we read in Ezekiel that Nebuchadnezzar mixed his rods against Ammon and Jerusalem, and the rod went out against Jerusalem; and the cause of this madness of fornication is the spirit that deceived them, so that they fornicated from their God. But he calls idolatry fornication, according to what we read in Jeremiah: And they committed adultery with wood and stone, and I said: After they have fornicated with all these, return to me, and she did not return with her whole heart, but in falsehood.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":74,"ref":"p74","source":"Et rursum: Me dereliquisti et dixisti: Vadam super omnem collem excelsum, et diffundar in fornicatione mea subter omni ligno frondoso (Jerem. II, 20). Et in Psalmo dicitur: Perdidisti omnes qui fornicantur abs te (Psal. LXXII, 27). Principium enim fornicationis, idolorum inventio. Nunquam haeretici suo errore satiantur, nec cessant a fornicationis turpitudine, et quotidie non custodiendo Legem et Scripturas sanctas, Dominum derelinquunt, insaniunt et inebriantur, et, perdito mentis judicio, adorant idola, quae de suo corde finxerunt, fornicationisque spiritu possidentur.\n\n(Vers. 13.) « Super capita montium sacrificabant, et super colles accendebant thymiama: subtus quercum et populum et terebinthum, quia bona erat umbra ejus. » LXX: « Super verticem montium sacrificabant et super colles immolabant: subter quercum et populum et nemorosas arbores, quia bonum erat umbraculum. » In Lege praeceptum est ut non sacrificetur Domino, nisi in loco quem elegerit Dominus Deus: et juxta altare lucus et arbores non plantentur, ne scilicet passiva et voluptuosa religio austeritatem unius et verae religionis evertat. Econtrario Israel sacrificabat in montibus, et in collibus adolebat incensum, excelsa terrae diligens loca, quia excelsum reliquerat Deum, et umbram quaerens perdiderat veritatem.","english":"And again: You have forsaken me and said: I will go up upon every high hill, and I will pour myself out in my fornication under every leafy tree. And in the Psalm it is said: You have destroyed all who commit fornication apart from you. For the beginning of fornication is the invention of idols. Never are heretics satisfied by their error, nor do they cease from the shamefulness of fornication, and daily, by not keeping the Law and the holy Scriptures, they forsake the Lord, they rave and become drunk, and, having lost the judgment of the mind, they adore idols, which they have fashioned from their own heart, and they are possessed by the spirit of fornication.\n\n(Verse 13.) They sacrificed upon the heads of the mountains, and upon the hills they burned incense: under the oak and the poplar and the terebinth, because its shade was good. The Septuagint: They sacrificed upon the top of the mountains and upon the hills they offered sacrifice: under the oak and the poplar and the leafy trees, because the shade was good. In the Law it is commanded that sacrifice not be offered to the Lord except in the place which the Lord God has chosen: and that a grove and trees not be planted next to the altar, lest, to be sure, a passive and voluptuous religion overturn the austerity of the one and true religion. On the contrary, Israel sacrificed on the mountains, and on the hills burned incense, loving the high places of the earth, because they had forsaken the God who is on high, and seeking the shadow they had lost the truth.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":75,"ref":"p75","source":"Hoc est quod legimus de singulis regibus: Verumtamen excelsa non abstulit: adhuc populus immolabat et sacrificabat in excelsis (III Reg. XXII, 44), quod Hebraice appellatur BAMA ( ). Haeretici sublimitatem sibi dogmatum repromittunt, et sacrificant subter quercum et populum et terebinthum, infructuosas arbores, ficum et vineam non habentes, sub quibus Sanctus requiescere dicitur. Assumunt autem sibi interdum terebmthum 4, quae juxta Isaiam folia non habet (Isa. VI), ut Abrahae imitari videantur exemplum.\n\n(Vers. 14.) « Ideo fornicabuntur filiae vestrae, et sponsae vestrae adulterae erunt. Non visitabo super filias vestras cum fuerint fornicatae, et super sponsas vestras cum adulteraverint: quoniam ipsi cum meretricibus conversabantur, et cum effeminatis sacrificabant, et populus non intelligens vapulabit. » LXX: « Propterea fornicabuntur filiae vestrae, et sponsae vestrae moechabuntur, et non visitabo super filias vestras cum fuerint fornicatae, et super sponsas vestras cum adulteraverint: quoniam ipsi cum meretricibus miscebantur: et cum initiatis immolabant, et populus non intelligens adhaerebat meretrici. » Verbum CADESOTH ( ), quod Aquila, Symmachus, Septuaginta, Theodotion interpretati sunt, nos effeminatos vertimus, ut sensum verbi nostrorum auribus panderemus.","english":"This is what we read concerning individual kings: Nevertheless he did not take away the high places; the people still sacrificed and offered incense on the high places, which in Hebrew is called BAMA. Heretics promise themselves a sublimity of doctrines, and they sacrifice under the oak and the poplar and the terebinth, fruitless trees, not having the fig and the vine, under which the Holy One is said to rest. They sometimes, moreover, adopt the terebinth for themselves, which according to Isaiah has no leaves, so that they may seem to imitate the example of Abraham.\n\n(Verse 14.) Therefore your daughters shall commit fornication, and your brides shall be adulteresses. I will not visit your daughters when they have committed fornication, nor your brides when they have committed adultery: because they themselves consorted with harlots, and sacrificed with the effeminate, and the people who do not understand shall be beaten. The Septuagint: Therefore your daughters shall commit fornication, and your brides shall commit adultery, and I will not visit your daughters when they have committed fornication, nor your brides when they have committed adultery: because they themselves mingled with harlots, and sacrificed with the initiated, and the people who do not understand clung to a harlot. The word CADESOTH, which Aquila, Symmachus, the Septuagint, and Theodotion translated, we have rendered as \"effeminate,\" so that we might lay open the meaning of the word to the ears of our readers.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":76,"ref":"p76","source":"Hi sunt quos hodie Romae, matri, non deorum, sed daemoniorum servientes, Gallos vocant, eo quod de hac gente Romani truncatos libidine, in honorem Atys (quem eunuchum dea meretrix fecerat) sacerdotes illius manciparint. Propterea autem Gallorum gentis homines effeminantur, ut qui urbem Romanam ceperant, hac feriantur ignominia. Istiusmodi idololatria erat in Israel, colentibus maxime feminis Beelphegor ob obscoeni magnitudinem, quem nos Priapum possumus appellare. Unde et Asa rex tulit excelsa de populo, et hujuscemodi sacerdotes, et matrem de augusto deposuit imperio, sicut Scriptura testatur, dicens: Et fecit Asa rectum ante conspectum Domini, sicut David pater ejus, et abstulit effeminatos de terra, purgavitque omnes sordes idolorum, quae fecerant patres ejus. Insuper et Maacham matrem suam amovit, ne esset princeps in sacris Priapi, et in luco ejus quem consecraverat: subvertitque specum ejus, et confregit simulacrum turpissimum, et combussit in torrente Cedron. Excelsa autem non abstulit: verumtamen cor Asa perfectum erat coram Deo cunctis diebus suis (III Reg. xv. seqq.). Sciendum autem quod in praesenti CADESOTH, meretrices, 4, id est sacerdotes, Priapo mancipatas vocet.","english":"These are the ones whom today at Rome they call Galli, serving not the mother of gods but of demons, because from this people the Romans, mutilated by lust, consecrated priests to the honor of Attis (whom the whore goddess had made a eunuch). And for this reason men of the Gallic race are effeminated, so that those who had captured the city of Rome are struck with this disgrace. Idolatry of this kind existed in Israel, especially among the women worshipping Beelphegor on account of the magnitude of his obscenity, whom we can call Priapus. Hence also King Asa removed the high places from the people, and priests of this sort, and deposed his mother from the lofty authority, as Scripture testifies, saying: And Asa did what was right before the sight of the Lord, as David his father, and he removed the effeminate from the land, and purged all the filth of the idols which his fathers had made. Moreover he also removed Maachah his mother, lest she be a leader in the sacred rites of Priapus, and in his grove which she had consecrated: and he overturned her shrine, and broke the most shameful image, and burned it in the torrent Cedron. But the high places he did not remove: nevertheless the heart of Asa was perfect before God all his days (III Kings xv and following). But it must be known that in the present passage he calls CADESOTH, prostitutes, that is, priests handed over to Priapus.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":77,"ref":"p77","source":"In aliis autem locis viros exsectos libidine, CADESIM ( ) legimus, Isaia dicente, Et illusores dominabuntur eorum, pro quo ia Hebraeo scriptum est: Et CADESIM dominabuntur eorum, quod nos in effeminatos vertimus. Aquila autem interpretans, id est mutatos, hoc ostendere voluit, quod suam naturam mutaverint, et de viris facti sint feminae. Symmachus proprie meretrices appellavit. Septuaginta, id est consecratos, et initiatos, ut cultores idolorum ostenderent: Theodotion,, id est a populo separatos, qui sibi videbantur a vulgo aliquid plus habere. De verbo breviter disseruimus, nunc ad sensum capituli revertamur. Grandis offensa est postquam peccaveris, iram Domini non mereri. Fornicatus fuerat Israel a Domino Deo suo, et spiritu fornicationis seductus: ideo fornicantur et filiae ejus et sponsae, et absque ulla vindicta in suo scelere relinquuntur, ut quod filii et uxor vero parenti fecerant et marito, hoc In liberis suis et uxoribus sentiant, et ex proprio dolore intelligant dolorem Dei, qui in tantum iratus est, ut nequaquam percutiat delinquentes. Quod et Apostolus ad Romanos scribens, mystico sermone testatur: Dicentes enim se esse sapientes, stulti facti sunt, et mutaverunt gloriam incorruptibilis Dei in similitudinem imaginis corruptibilis hominis, et volucrum, et quadrupedum et serpentum (Rom. I, 22, 23).","english":"But in other places we read of men emasculated by lust, CADESIM, with Isaiah saying, \"And the mockers shall rule over them,\" for which in the Hebrew it is written: \"And CADESIM shall rule over them,\" which we have rendered as \"effeminate.\" Aquila, however, translating as \"changed,\" wished to show that they had changed their nature and from men had become women. Symmachus properly called them \"harlots.\" The Seventy, that is, \"consecrated\" and \"initiated,\" to show them as worshippers of idols. Theodotion, that is, \"separated from the people,\" who seemed to themselves to have something more than the common crowd. We have discussed the word briefly; now let us return to the sense of the chapter. It is a great offense that after you have sinned, you do not deserve the wrath of the Lord. Israel had fornicated from the Lord its God, and been seduced by a spirit of fornication; therefore both its daughters and its brides also fornicate, and are left in their crime without any vengeance, so that what the sons and wife had done to their true parent and husband, they may feel in their own children and wives, and from their own grief may understand the grief of God, who is angry to such an extent that he does not strike the transgressors at all. The Apostle also, writing to the Romans, testifies this in mystical speech: \"For professing themselves to be wise, they became fools, and they changed the glory of the incorruptible God into the likeness of the image of corruptible man, and of birds, and of four-footed beasts, and of serpents.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":78,"ref":"p78","source":"Et quia cum idolis fuerant fornicati, tali feriuntur sententia: Propter quod tradidit illos Deus in desideria cordis corum, in immunditiam, ut contumeliis afficiant corpora sua in semetipsis, qui commutaverunt veritatem Dei in mendacium, et coluerunt et servierunt creaturae, potius quam Creatori, qui est benedictus in saecula. Amen (Ibid. 24, 25). Ut autem sciamus visitationem quasi vulneratorum et languentium ideo inferri a Deo, ut veluti cauterio et amarissimis potionibus recipiant sanitatem, et morbis careant, per prophetam loquentem audiamus Dominum: Visitabo in Virga iniquitates eorum, et in verberibus peccata eorum: misericordiam autem meam non dispergam ab eo (Psal. LXXXVIII, 33, 34). Qui igitur amatur, corripitur: qui negligitur, suis peccatis dimittitur. Tantusque fuit numerus fornicatorum Israel 7, ut cesset ultio, desperans emendationem. Quid enim turpius quam viros meretricum cultui copulari, et cum effeminatis immolare hostias libidinis suae? Quod autem jungit: Populus non intelligens vapulabit, pro quo Septuaginta transtulerunt: Et populus non intelligens adhaerebat meretrici·8, hoc significat quod vapulet in captivitate, et diversis afficiatur plagis, ut per dolorem recipiat disciplinam. De haereticis facilis intelligentia est, quod filii eorum fornicentur, et sponsae, id est, animae, quas in errore genuerunt, et suis dogmatibus desponsarunt.","english":"And because they had committed fornication with idols, they are struck with this sentence: For this cause God gave them up to the desires of their heart, to uncleanness, so that they might afflict their own bodies with contumely among themselves, who changed the truth of God into a lie, and worshipped and served the creature rather than the Creator, who is blessed forever. Amen. But so that we may know that the visitation, as it were, of the wounded and the sick is brought in by God for this reason, that as if by cautery and most bitter potions they may receive health and be free of diseases, let us hear the Lord speaking through the prophet: I will visit their iniquities with a rod, and their sins with stripes; but my mercy I will not take away from him. Whoever therefore is loved is corrected; whoever is neglected is left to his own sins. And so great was the number of the fornicators of Israel that the vengeance ceased, despairing of their amendment. For what is more shameful than for men to be joined to the worship of a harlot, and with the effeminate to sacrifice victims of their own lust? But what he adds: The people that does not understand shall be beaten, for which the Seventy translated: And the people that did not understand clung to the harlot, this signifies that it is beaten in captivity and afflicted with various plagues, so that through pain it may receive discipline. Concerning heretics the understanding is easy, that their sons commit fornication, and their brides, that is, the souls whom they begot in error and betrothed to their own doctrines.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":79,"ref":"p79","source":"Istiusmodi indigni sunt correptione Dei: quoniam omnis eorum cultus fornicatio est, et turpes turpibus commiscentur, et propterea vapulabunt, ut aliquando per plagas intelligant quem requirant Deum. Quando videris peccatorem divitiis affluere, jactare se potentia, sanitate gaudere, delectari conjuge, corona circumdari liberorum, et impleri illud quod scriptum est: In labore hominum non sunt, et cum hominibus non flagellabuntur (Psal. LXXII, 5), dicito in illo comminationem Prophetae esse cumpletam: Non visitabo super filias vestras cum fuerint fornicatae, et super sponsas vestras cum adulterate· rint.\n\n(Vers. 15, 16.) « Si fornicaris tu, Israel, non delinquat saltem Juda, et nolite ingredi in Galgala, et ne ascenderitis in Bethaven, neque juraveritis, vivit Dominus, quoniam sicut vacca lasciviens declinavit Israel. Nunc pascet cos Dominus quasi agnum in latitudine. » LXX: « Tu autem, Israel, ne ignores, et Juda, nolite ingredi in Galgala, ne ascendatis in domum, et ne juretis, vivit Dominus: quoniam sicut vacca asylo percussa insanivit Israel. Nunc pascet eos Dominus sicut agnum in spatioso. » Pro domo in quibusdam exemplaribus, et maxime in Theodotione legitur domus iniquitatis, quod Aquila et Symmachus interpretati sunt domum, id est inutilem, quae nihil prosit, et alio verbo idolum nuncupetur.","english":"Men of this sort are unworthy of God's rebuke, since all their worship is fornication, and the foul are mingled with the foul, and for this reason they will be beaten, so that at some time through their wounds they may understand which God they should seek. When you see a sinner abounding in riches, boasting of power, rejoicing in health, delighting in a wife, surrounded by a crown of children, and that which is written being fulfilled: They are not in the labor of men, and they will not be scourged with men, say that in him the Prophet's threat has been fulfilled: I will not visit your daughters when they have committed fornication, nor your brides when they have committed adultery.\n\n(Verses 15, 16.) If you commit fornication, Israel, at least let Judah not sin, and do not enter into Gilgal, and do not go up to Beth-aven, and do not swear, The Lord lives, for like a wanton cow Israel has turned aside. Now the Lord will feed them like a lamb in a broad place. The Septuagint: But you, Israel, do not be ignorant, and you, Judah, do not enter into Gilgal, and do not go up to the house, and do not swear, The Lord lives, for like a cow struck in the sanctuary Israel has gone mad. Now the Lord will feed them like a lamb in a spacious place. For house, in certain copies, and especially in Theodotion, is read house of iniquity, which Aquila and Symmachus translated as house, that is, useless, which profits nothing, and is called by another word, idol.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":80,"ref":"p80","source":"Est autem Bethel: et quae prius vocabatur domus Dei, postquam vituli in ea positi sunt, appellata est Bethaven, id est, domus inutilis, et domus idoli, quod nos ut in Hebraeo legitur expressimus. Videtur autem mihi idcirco et populus Israel in solitudine fecisse sibi caput vituli, quod coleret, et Jeroboam filius Nabath vitulos aureos fabricatus, ut quod in AEgypto didicerant et, qui sub figura boum coluntur, esse deos, hoc in sua superstitione servarent. Dicamus sensum capituli: Si semel, o Israel, errore deceptus es, et te cum meretricibus miscuisti, ita ut quicunque impleret manum vel suam vel regis, offerendo et dando ei munera, sacerdos fieret excelsorum: saltem tu, Juda, qui possides Jerusalem, et habes ex Lege Levitas, et exerces templi caeremonias, non debes sororis quondam tuae Oollae in fornicatione exempla sectari, et cum ea idola colore 1. Non ingrediaris Galgala, de qua in hoc eodem propheta legimus: Omnis malitia eorum in Galgalis (Osee IX, 15), in qua Saul unctus est in regem: in qua exiens populus de deserto, primum castrametatus, secunda circumcisione purgatus est. Ex quo tempore religionis adversae, in loco celebri error inolevit. Et ne ascendas in Bethaven, id est, quae quondam vocabatur Bethel, quia postquam aurei ibi vituli positi sunt a Jeroboam filio Nabath, non domus Dei appellatur, sed domus idoli.","english":"But Bethel—which was previously called the house of God—after the calves were placed in it, was called Bethaven, that is, \"house of uselessness,\" and \"house of an idol,\" which we have expressed as it is read in Hebrew. It seems to me that for this reason both the people of Israel in the wilderness made for themselves a calf's head to worship, and Jeroboam son of Nabath fashioned golden calves, so that what they had learned in Egypt—that those who are worshiped under the figure of oxen are gods—they might preserve in their own superstition. Let us state the meaning of the chapter: If once, O Israel, you have been deceived by error and have mingled yourself with harlots, so that whoever filled his own hand or the king's, by offering and giving him gifts, became a priest of the high places—at least you, Judah, who possess Jerusalem and have Levites from the Law and perform the ceremonies of the temple, ought not to follow the examples of your sister Oholah in fornication and worship idols with her. Do not enter Gilgal, of which we read in this same prophet: All their malice is in Gilgal, where Saul was anointed king, where the people coming out of the wilderness first encamped and were purified by a second circumcision. From that time, in that famous place, the error of an opposing religion grew strong. And do not ascend to Bethaven, that is, what was once called Bethel, because after the golden calves were placed there by Jeroboam son of Nabath, it is not called the house of God but the house of an idol.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":81,"ref":"p81","source":"Pro qua miror cur Septuaginta domum interpretati sunt: nisi forte errore consueto pro IOD littera media, quae ALEPHet NUN litteris ex utraque parte vallatur, VAV, quae sola differt magnitudine, putaverunt. Neque juraveritis, vivit Dominus. Nolo enim per os vestrum nominis mei fieri mentionem, quod idolorum recordatione pollutum est. Sicut enim vacca lasciviens et abjiciens jugum: ita Israel, id est, decem tribus, declinavit a Domini servitute. Pro lasciviente vacca, Septuaginta transtulerunt, quae oestro asyloque percussa sit, quem vulgo tabanum vocant. De quo et Virgilius in tertio Georgicorum libro refert: Quia ergo insanivit Israel, et percussus fornicationis spiritu, incredibili furore bacchatus est, ideo non multo post tempore, sed dum propheto, dum spiritus bos regit artus, pascet eos Dominus quasi agnum in latitudine. Quia metaphoram a vacca lasciviente, sive oestro ceperat, servat in reliquis, ut captivitatem iu Assyrios, et in latissimam Medorum terram dispersionem populi Israel quasi in campo latissimo et in spatiosa terra gregis et agnorum pasturam vocet. Super haereticis prona intelligentia est, ad quos, vel de quibus dicitur: Si semel fornicaris, haeretice, saltem tu, ecclesiastice, ne delinquas, nec ingrediaris in Galgalam, haereticorum conciliabula, ubi peccata omnium revelantur et instar porcorum volutantur in coeno.","english":"For this reason I am surprised why the Seventy interpreted it as \"house,\" unless perhaps by their customary error they thought that in place of the middle letter IOD—which is hedged on both sides by the letters ALEPH and NUN—there stood VAV, which differs only in size. And do not swear, \"As the Lord lives.\" For I do not wish my name to be mentioned by your mouth, since it has been polluted by the remembrance of idols. For just as a heifer that is wanton and throws off the yoke, so Israel, that is, the ten tribes, turned away from the service of the Lord. For the wanton heifer, the Seventy translated \"she who is struck by the gadfly and the breeze,\" which in common speech is called the tabanus. About this Virgil also relates in the third book of the Georgics. Therefore, because Israel went mad and, struck by the spirit of fornication, raged with incredible frenzy, therefore not long afterward—but while the prophet speaks, while the spirit governs the limbs of the ox—the Lord will feed them like a lamb in a broad place. Because he had taken up the metaphor from the wanton heifer, or from the gadfly, he preserves it in the rest, so that he calls the captivity in Assyria and the dispersion of the people of Israel into the very broad land of the Medes, as it were, a pasture of flocks and lambs in a very wide plain and in a spacious land. The understanding is readily applied to heretics, to whom, or of whom, it is said: If you have once fornicated, heretic, at least you, churchman, do not go astray, and do not enter into Gilgal, the assemblies of heretics, where the sins of all are revealed and, like pigs, they wallow in the mire.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":82,"ref":"p82","source":"Ne te ascendere putes ad superbas et arrogantes falsorum dogmatum fictiones. Non est enim ibi domus Dei, sed domus idoli. Nec juraveris per nomen Christi, cujus majestatem miscendo idolis polluisti. Sicut enim vacca percussa asilo, percussi sunt haeretici ardentibus diaboli saginis, et legis notitiam reliquerunt: ideo pascentur in lata et in spatiosa via, quae ducit ad mortem, et patientia Domini bonique pastoris eos nutriet ad interitum.\n\nCui nomen asilo, Romanum est: oestrum Graii venere vocantes. Asper acerba sonans: quo lota exterrita silvis\\ Diffugiunt armenta: furit mugitibus aether Concussus, silvaeque et sicci ripa Tanagri.\n\n(Vers. seqq.) « Particeps idolorum Ephraim, dimitte cum, separatum est convivium eorum: fornicatione fornicati sunt: dilexerunt afferre ignominiam protectores ejus, ligavit spiritus eum in alis suis; et confundentur a sacrificiis suis. » LXX: « Particeps idolorum Ephraim posuit sibi scandala, provocavit Chananaeos, fornicantes fornicati sunt, dilexerunt ignominiam ex fremitu ejus; turbo spiritus sibilabit in alis ejus et confundentur ex altaribus suis. » Ephraim, de qua tribu Jeroboam filius Nabath, qui primus aureos vituios in Bethel Danque constituit, rex est decem tribuum.","english":"Do not think that you ascend to the proud and arrogant fictions of false dogmas. For the house of God is not there, but the house of an idol. Nor should you swear by the name of Christ, whose majesty you have defiled by mixing it with idols. For just as a cow struck by the gadfly, so heretics are struck by the burning enticements of the devil, and they have abandoned the knowledge of the law; therefore they will graze on the broad and spacious way that leads to death, and the patience of the Lord and of the good shepherd will nourish them unto destruction.\n\nWhose name is asilus in Roman, the Greeks call it oestrus. Harsh, sounding shrilly: terrified by which, the herds scattered from the woods; the sky is maddened, shaken by bellowings, and the woods and the dry bank of the Tanager.\n\n(And the following verses.) \"Ephraim is a partaker of idols, let him alone, their banquet is separated: they have committed fornication: his protectors have loved to bring disgrace, the spirit has bound him in his wings; and they shall be confounded by their sacrifices.\" The Seventy: \"Ephraim is a partaker of idols, he has set stumbling blocks for himself, he has provoked the Canaanites, committing fornication they have committed fornication, they have loved disgrace from his roaring; the whirlwind of the spirit shall whistle in his wings and they shall be confounded by their altars.\" Ephraim, from which tribe was Jeroboam son of Nabath, who first set up the golden calves in Bethel and Dan, king of the ten tribes.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":83,"ref":"p83","source":"O igitur Juda, cui supra dixi, si fornicatur Israel, non delinquat saltem Juda, audi consilium meum, prophetae verba non spernas; quia Ephraim semel idolorum amicus et particeps est, dimitte eum, ne sequaris impietatem ejus, cujus cultus et religio et cibus a tuo convivio separatus est. Illi enim semel idolis serviunt, et daemonibus immolant, et quotidie fornicantur, et diligunt fornicationem suam: imo principes et protectores ejus, id est, reges dilexerunt ignominiam afferre populo, id est, vitio principum, infelix populus suscepit cultum idolorum, quorum immundus spiritus ligavit Israelem in alis suis et eum libere volitare non patitur. Confundentur igitur in sacrificiis suis, et ignominiam principum in sua confusione suscipient. Symmachus pro eo quod nos interpretati sumus, ligavit spiritus eum in alis suis, hoc modo vertit in Graecum, velut si quis liget ventum in alis venti, ut scilicet et principes et populum, imo et daemones et Israelem, vanos vanis, inanibus inanes asserat copulatos. Ventus enim et spiritus apud Hebraeos uno verbo appellantur RUA ( ). Id quod Septuaginta transtulerunt [Al. posuerunt) provocavit Chananoeos, in Hebraico non habetur: tamen sic interpretari potest, ut dicamus tantum studium habuisse Israelem in idolorum cultu, ut non imitatus sit Chananaeos, id est ethnicos; sed ad imitationem sui eos provocarit erroris.","english":"Therefore, O Judah, to whom I said above, if Israel fornicates, let Judah at least not sin, hear my counsel, do not spurn the words of the prophet; because Ephraim is once for all a friend and partaker of idols, let him go, lest you follow his impiety, whose worship and religion and food are separated from your banquet. For they serve idols once for all, and sacrifice to demons, and fornicate daily, and love their fornication: indeed its princes and protectors, that is, the kings, loved to bring disgrace upon the people, that is, by the vice of the princes the wretched people took up the worship of idols, whose unclean spirit bound Israel in its wings and does not allow him to fly freely. Therefore they will be confounded in their sacrifices, and they will receive the disgrace of the princes in their own confusion. Symmachus, for what we have translated as \"the spirit bound him in its wings,\" rendered into Greek in this way, as if someone should bind the wind in the wings of the wind, so that he asserts that both princes and people, indeed even demons and Israel, vain things joined to vain things, empty things to empty things. For wind and spirit are called by one word among the Hebrews, RUA. That which the Septuagint translated as \"it provoked the Canaanites\" is not found in the Hebrew: yet it can be interpreted in such a way that we say Israel had such zeal in the worship of idols that it did not imitate the Canaanites, that is, the gentiles, but provoked them to imitate its own error.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[{"kind":"lacuna","severity":"caution","text":"The source is fragmentary here: the edition marks a break or an editorial bracket, and the English carries across it. Treat the bridge as supplied, not translated."}]},{"i":84,"ref":"p84","source":"Hoc ipsum et ad haereticos referri potest, et dicitur ad Judam, id est ad virum ecclesiasticum, quia Ephraim qui interpretatur, falsam sibi doctrinae ubertatem, et frugifera dogmata promittit, et semel amicus est daemonum, dimitte eum atque contemne: praesertim cum sacrificia eorum a tuis sint sacrificiis separata. Hoc est enim quod dicit separatum est convivium eorum, semel fornicati sunt, et principes eorum infelicem populum deceperunt; et pro Dei cultu imbuerunt eos ignominia idolorum, et ligavit cos diaboli spiritus in alis suis, qui circumferuntur omni vento doctrinae; et stabili in Ecclesia pede permanere non possunt. Qui vere in suis sacrificiis confundentur, quia panis eorum panis lucius est. Quodque dicitur, provocavit Chananaeos, eodem sensu referri potest ad haereticos, quod tam spurca plerique haereticorum et nefanda confinxerint, habeantque immunda sacrificia, ut idololatria inferior sit. Vel certe quia Chananaeus interpretatur negotiator, sive est translator, omnos qui domum Patris faciunt domum negotiationis (Joan. II), et lucra quaerunt de populis, et Ecclesiae veritatem transferunt in mendacium, Chananaei appellandi sunt.","english":"This can also be referred to the heretics, and it is said to Judah, that is, to the ecclesiastical man, because Ephraim, which is interpreted as promising himself a false abundance of doctrine and fruitful dogmas, is once for all a friend of demons: dismiss him and despise him, especially since their sacrifices are separated from your sacrifices. For this is what it says: their banquet is separated; they have fornicated once for all, and their leaders have deceived the wretched people, and instead of the worship of God they have imbued them with the ignominy of idols, and the spirit of the devil has bound them in his wings, who are carried about by every wind of doctrine, and cannot remain with a firm foot in the Church. They will truly be confounded in their sacrifices, because their bread is the bread of mourning. And what is said, he provoked the Canaanites, can be referred in the same sense to the heretics, because many of the heretics have devised such foul and abominable things, and hold such unclean sacrifices, that idolatry is inferior to them. Or certainly, because Canaanite is interpreted as merchant, or is a trader, all who make the house of the Father a house of business (John 2), and seek profit from the peoples, and change the truth of the Church into a lie, are to be called Canaanites.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":85,"ref":"p85","source":"(Cap. V. Vers. 1, 2.) « Audite haec, sacerdotes, et attendite, domus Israel, et domus regis, auribus auscultate, quia vobis judicium est: quoniam laqueus facti estis speculationi, et rete expansum super Thabor, et victimas declinastis in profundum. » LXX: « Audite haec, sacerdotes, et attendite, domus Israel, et domus regis, auribus percipite, ad vos enim est judicium, quia laqueus facti estis speculationi, et sicut rete expansum super Itabyrium, quod qui capiunt, venationem confixerunt. » Sacerdotes decem tribuum ad judicium vocantur, et reges, non quod sacerdotes sint de tribu Levi, sed quod sacerdotes vocentur a populo. Unde et sacerdotes Baal, et prophetae quadringenti quinquaginta quos interfecit Elias (III Reg. XVIII), et postea Jehu filius Namsi (IV Reg. IX, X), praesente Jonadab filio Rechab, appellati sunt sacerdotes; sed et Israel, id est populus, vocatur ad judicium, et nullus excipitur, ut et sacerdotes et populus et reges, qui induxerant populum, et constituerant sacerdotes, simul audiant quid fecerint, et cur tradantur inimicis. Speculatores, inquit, vos posui, et principes in populo, et in excelso dignitatis culmine constitui, ut populum regeretis errantem. Vos autem facti estis laqueus, et non tam speculatores et principes, quam venatores appellandi. Expanditis enim rete super montem Thabor, quem Septuaginta transtulerunt (mss.","english":"Hear this, you priests, and attend, house of Israel, and house of the king, listen with your ears, for judgment is for you: because you have become a snare for the watchtower, and a net spread out over Tabor, and you have turned the sacrifices into the depths. The Septuagint: Hear this, you priests, and attend, house of Israel, and house of the king, perceive with your ears, for judgment is for you, because you have become a snare for the watchtower, and like a net spread out over Itabyrium, which those who catch have fixed for the hunt. The priests of the ten tribes are summoned to judgment, and the kings, not because they are priests from the tribe of Levi, but because they are called priests by the people. Hence also the priests of Baal, and the four hundred and fifty prophets whom Elijah killed (1 Kings 18), and afterward Jehu son of Nimshi (2 Kings 9, 10), in the presence of Jonadab son of Rechab, are called priests; but Israel also, that is, the people, is summoned to judgment, and no one is excepted, so that both priests and people and kings, who had led the people and appointed priests, may hear together what they have done, and why they are handed over to their enemies. I appointed you, he says, as watchmen and leaders among the people, and set you on the lofty height of dignity, that you might guide the erring people. But you have become a snare, and are to be called not so much watchmen and leaders as hunters. For you spread out a net over Mount Tabor, which the Septuagint translated (manuscripts","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":86,"ref":"p86","source":"Itabyrium), hanc habentes consuetudinem, ut Hebraea nomina Graeco sermone declinent, sicut Edom, hoc est, Esau, et Seir, semper Idumaeam interpretantur. Est autem Thabor mons in Galilaea, situs in campestribus, rotundus atque sublimis, et ex omni parte finitur aequaliter. De hoc monte et in psalmo legimus: Thabor et Hermon in nomine luo exsultabunt (Psal. LXXXVIII, 13). Hunc montem et in Jeremia Septuaginta Itabyrium transtulerunt (Jerem. XLVI) in quo aves laqueis capi solent. Et victimas, inquit, declinastis in profundum, ut nullus ageret poenitentiam, nec occisus elevaret caput. Prohibuerunt et reges et sacerdotes ire populum ad templum Jerusalem: idcirco in profundum victimas declinasse dicuntur. Juxta tropologiam, accusatur populus ne se alienum arbitretur a crimine, si inductus sit a regibus et a sacerdotibus, quos haereticorum principes intelligimus. Ipsi quoque principes accusantur, quod quasi laqueus, ceperint populum, et positi speculatores in Ecclesia, eos duxerint in errorem. Et in monte Thabor excelso atque pulcherrimo, qui interpretatur veniens lumen, insidias posuerunt, ut deceptos quosque pertraherent in profundum, et immolarent daemonibus, et in barathrum victimas declinarent, ne aliquando resipiscerent, ne domum Dei Ecclesiam suspirarent.","english":"Itabyrium), having this custom, that they decline Hebrew names in Greek speech, just as Edom, that is, Esau, and Seir, they always translate as Idumaea. Now Thabor is a mountain in Galilee, situated in the plains, round and lofty, and bounded equally on every side. About this mountain we also read in the psalm: Thabor and Hermon shall rejoice in your name. This mountain the Septuagint also translated as Itabyrium in Jeremiah, on which birds are accustomed to be caught in snares. And victims, he says, you have turned aside into the depth, so that no one might repent, nor the slain lift up his head. Both kings and priests forbade the people to go to the temple in Jerusalem; therefore they are said to have turned victims aside into the depth. According to tropology, the people are accused lest they consider themselves free from the crime, if they were led on by kings and priests, whom we understand as the leaders of heretics. Those leaders themselves are also accused, because like a snare they captured the people, and stationed as watchmen in the Church, they led them into error. And on Mount Thabor, lofty and most beautiful, which is interpreted as \"coming light,\" they set ambushes, so that they might drag all the deceived into the depth, and sacrifice to demons, and turn victims aside into the abyss, lest they ever come to their senses, lest they long for the house of God, the Church.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":87,"ref":"p87","source":"Quidam Thabor interpretari putant lacum, id est cisternam, et praesenti sensui convenire, quod haeretici foderint lacum, et inciderint in foveam quam fecerunt (Psal. LVI).\n\n(Vers. 3, 4.) « Et ego eruditor omnium eorum, et ego scio Ephraim, et Israel non est absconditus a me: quia nunc fornicatus est Ephraim, contaminatus est Israel: non dabunt cogitationes suas, ut revertantur ad Deum suum, quia spiritus fornicationum in medio eorum, et Dominum non cognoverunt. » LXX: « Ego enim magister vester: ego cognovi Ephraim, et Israel non recessit a me, quia nunc fornicatus est Ephraim, commaculatus est Israel: non dederunt cogitationes suas ut reverterentur ad Dominum Deum suum, quia spiritus fornicationis est in eis: Dominum autem non cognoverunt. » O sacerdotes et reges, qui meum populum decepistis; et tu, popule, qui deceptus es, tam graviter deliquistis, ut non solum occideritis victimas, sed et in profundum eas miseritis inferni: nolite arbitrari magnitudine sceleris vos a me penitus recessisse. Ego sum magister vester, imo eruditor, qui emendare cupiam, non punire; et salvare, non perdere. Ego, inquit, scio Ephraim, in est Jeroboam, a quo seductus est populus, et omnes reges qui eum et dignitate et scelere sunt secuti, et Israel non est absconditus a me, id est, decem tribuum populus, quia, fornicante rege contaminatus est Israel.","english":"Some think that Thabor is interpreted as a lake, that is, a cistern, and that this fits the present sense, because the heretics dug a lake, and fell into the pit which they made (Psalm 56).\n\n(Verses 3, 4.) \"And I am the instructor of all of them, and I know Ephraim, and Israel is not hidden from me: because now Ephraim has fornicated, Israel is contaminated: they will not give their thoughts, that they may return to their God, because the spirit of fornications is in their midst, and they have not known the Lord.\" The Septuagint: \"For I am your teacher: I have known Ephraim, and Israel has not withdrawn from me, because now Ephraim has fornicated, Israel is defiled: they have not given their thoughts that they might return to the Lord their God, because the spirit of fornication is in them: but they have not known the Lord.\" O priests and kings, who have deceived my people; and you, people, who have been deceived, you have sinned so gravely that you not only killed the victims, but even cast them into the depth of hell: do not suppose that by the magnitude of your crime you have wholly withdrawn from me. I am your teacher, or rather instructor, who wishes to correct, not to punish; and to save, not to destroy. I, he says, know Ephraim, that is, Jeroboam, by whom the people was seduced, and all the kings who followed him both in dignity and in crime, and Israel is not hidden from me, that is, the people of the ten tribes, because, with the king fornicating, Israel has been contaminated.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":88,"ref":"p88","source":"Rex primo coepit a Dei cultu fornicari, vitulos aureos cupiens adorare, et volens secutus est populus, paremque impietatem pari studio compleverunt (III Reg. XII). Denique non revertentur ad Dominum, quia quod voluerant invenerunt, et spiritus fornicationis qui juxta Apostolum operatur in filiis diffidentiae (Ephes. II), possidet eorum corda captiva, et idcirco illo regnante, Dominum nescierunt, imo obliti sunt Creatoris sui. Unde et principes dogmatum perversorum et populum Dominus non ignorat: non quod ejus notitia digni sint, sed quia nihil eum lateat eorum quae occulte faciunt, quorum alii deceperunt, alii sunt decepti. Nec dabunt cogitationes suas ut agant poenitentiam, qui semper in perditione proficiunt. Spiritus enim fornicationis quo fornicati sunt in Ecclesia, et a vero matrimonio recesserunt, versatur in medio eorum.: ideo Dominum non cognoverunt. (Vers. 5.) « Et respondebit arrogantia Israel in facie ejus, et Israel et Ephraim ruent in iniquitate sua, ruet etiam Juda cum eis. » LXX: Et humiliabitur injuria Israel in faciem ejus: et Israel et Ephraim infirmabuntur in iniquitatibus suis, infirmabitur etiam Judas cum eis. Verbum GAON ( ) Septuaginta et Symmachus interpretantur injuriam. Aquila et Theodotion superbiam.","english":"The king first began to fornicate from the worship of God, desiring to adore the golden calves, and the people willingly followed, and they completed equal impiety with equal zeal (1 Kings 12). Finally, they will not return to the Lord, because they have found what they wanted, and the spirit of fornication which, according to the Apostle, works in the sons of disobedience (Ephesians 2), holds their hearts captive, and therefore, while that king reigned, they did not know the Lord—indeed, they forgot their Creator. Hence the Lord does not ignore both the leaders of perverse doctrines and the people: not that they are worthy of his knowledge, but because nothing escapes him of the things they do in secret, of whom some have deceived, others have been deceived. Nor will they give their thoughts to do penance, who always advance in perdition. For the spirit of fornication by which they fornicated in the Church and withdrew from true marriage dwells in their midst; therefore they have not known the Lord. (Verse 5.) \"And the arrogance of Israel will answer to his face, and Israel and Ephraim will rush into their iniquity, and Judah also will rush with them.\" The Septuagint: And the injury of Israel will be humbled before his face: and Israel and Ephraim will be weakened in their iniquities, and Judah also will be weakened with them. The word GAON the Septuagint and Symmachus interpret as injury. Aquila and Theodotion as pride.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":89,"ref":"p89","source":"Quidquid igitur fecit Israel, vel superbe agens contra Dominum, velin injuriam Creatoris idola venerans, respondebit in facie ejus ut non abeat impunitus, sed humilietur ejus contumelia, et populus et reges in iniquitate sua pariter corruant, sive infirmentur, ut qui fortes erant in scelere, infirmi ad Dominum redire cogantur. Et hoc non solum eveniet Israeli et Ephraim, id est decem tribubus et regibus earum, ut ducantur in captivitatem; sed etiam Judas, id est duae tribus quae regnabant in Jerusalem, sequentur vestigia captivorum, ut quorum imitantur scelera, imitentur et poenam. Haeretici matrem habent iniquitatis suae superbiam, dum semper altiora scire se jactitant, et in Ecclesiae contumeliam debacchantur. Sed infirmabitur arrogantia eorum, et populus ac magistri pariter corruent: Judas quoque qui videtur esse in domo Dei, et in Ecclesia, non mente sed corpore commoratur: et eumdem habet cum haereticis in errore sententiam; frustra nomen ecclesiasticum repromittit, quia et ipse cura haereticis puniendus est. Manifesta transcurrimus, ut in obscurioribus immoremur.","english":"Whatever therefore Israel did, whether acting proudly against the Lord, or venerating idols to the injury of the Creator, he will answer to his face, so that he does not go unpunished, but his contumely is humbled, and the people and the kings fall together in their iniquity, or are weakened, so that those who were strong in wickedness are compelled, weak, to return to the Lord. And this will happen not only to Israel and Ephraim, that is, the ten tribes and their kings, so that they are led into captivity; but Judas also, that is, the two tribes that reigned in Jerusalem, will follow in the footsteps of the captives, so that those whose crimes they imitate, they may imitate also their punishment. Heretics have as the mother of their iniquity pride, while they always boast that they know higher things, and rage against the Church in contumely. But their arrogance will be weakened, and the people and the teachers will fall together: Judas also, who seems to be in the house of God, and in the Church, dwells not in mind but in body: and he holds the same opinion in error as the heretics; in vain does he promise himself the name of ecclesiastical, because he too must be punished along with the heretics. We have run through the manifest things, so that we may linger on the more obscure.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":90,"ref":"p90","source":"(Vers. 6, 7.) « In gregibus suis et in armentis suis vadent ad quaerendum Dominum, et non invenient; ablatus est ab eis: in Domino praevaricati sunt, quia filios alienos genuerunt, nunc devorabit eos mensis cum partibus suis, » LXX: « Cum ovibus et vitulis ibunt et quaerent Dominum et non invenient eum, declinavit ab illis, quia Dominum reliquerunt: quia filios alienos genuerunt sibi, nunc devorabit cos rubigo, et cleros eorum. » Non solum Israel et Ephraim ibunt cum gregibus et armentis ad Dominum requirendum, sed etiam Judas, dequo supra scriptum est: Ruet etiam Juda, cum eis, hoc habentes omnes certamen, ut quem praevaricationibus offenderant, hostiis placare nitantur; et non invenient quem requirunt, quia a recedentibus et ipse discessit. Praesertim cum et alibi loquatur: Numquid manducabo carnes taurorum aut sanguinem hircorum bibam (Psal. XLIX, 13)? Et iterum: Non accipiam de domo tua vitulos, neque de gregibus tuis hircos (Ibid. 9). Et in Isaia: Holocausta arietum, et adipem agnorum, et sanguinem hircorum atque taurorum noto (Isa. I, 11). Praevaricati sunt enim in Domino; quia fornicantes cum idolis, non Deo filios genuerunt, sed daemonibus. Alii putant hoc significari quod in Esdra mulio post (I Esdrae X) tempore dicitur, quando uxores alienigenas assumpserunt, creantes ex eis liberos, et postea repudiare compulsi sunt.","english":"In their flocks and in their herds they will go to seek the Lord, and they will not find him; he has been taken away from them: they have transgressed against the Lord, because they have begotten alien sons; now a month will devour them with their portions. The Septuagint: With sheep and calves they will go and seek the Lord and will not find him; he has turned away from them, because they have forsaken the Lord; because they have begotten alien sons for themselves, now rust will devour them, and their lots. Not only will Israel and Ephraim go with their flocks and herds to seek the Lord, but also Judah, of whom it was written above: Judah also will fall with them, all having this same struggle, that the one whom they had offended by their transgressions they may strive to appease with sacrifices; and they will not find the one whom they seek, because he too has departed from those who were departing. Especially since he says elsewhere: Will I eat the flesh of bulls or drink the blood of goats? And again: I will not take calves from your house, nor goats from your flocks. And in Isaiah: I do not know the burnt offerings of rams, and the fat of lambs, and the blood of goats and bulls. For they have transgressed against the Lord, because, fornicating with idols, they begot sons not for God but for demons. Others think this signifies what is said in Ezra much later, when they took foreign wives, begetting children from them, and afterward were compelled to put them away.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":91,"ref":"p91","source":"Sed hic melius est alienos filios accipere, qui in idolorum errore generati sunt, sive quos ducentes per ignem, idolis consecrarunt. Quia igitur hoc fecerunt, non multo post tempore, non annorum spatiis infinitis, et, ut solitus eram prius, longe post futura praedicere; sed nunc et in praesentiarum adveniet Assyrius, atque Chaldaeus, et devorabunt eos cum partibus, sive cleris suis, id est cum possessionibus quas in divisione terrae ad mensuram funiculi susceperunt. Pro co quod nos diximus, devorabit eos mensis Septuaginta rubiginem transtulerunt: cum utique rubigo, id est, HASIL appelletur, ut ipsi quoque dixerunt in propheta Joel: Reliquias bruchi comedet rubigo (Joel. I, 4), id est, HASIL. Mensis autem HODES dicitur: denique Aquila neomenias, id est, kalendas interpretatus est: Symmachus et Theodotion mensem; et est sensus, per singulos menses hostis adveniet, et cuncta vastabit. Legamus Regum et Paralipomenon libros, et inveniemus sub rege Phasee, qui regnabat decem tribubus, venisse Teglatupbalasar regem Assyriorum, et magnam partem populi Samariae in Assyrios transtulisse, quo tempore apud Graecos secundus annus primae Olympiadis fuit; et apud Latinos (necdum Roma condita) Albae vicesimo anno Amulius imperabat, quem postea Romulus regno pepulit.","english":"But here it is better to understand the alien sons as those who were begotten in the error of idolatry, or those whom, leading them through fire, they consecrated to idols. Because therefore they did this, not after a long time, not after infinite spans of years, and, as I had formerly been accustomed, to foretell things far in the future; but now and in the present the Assyrian will come, and the Chaldean, and they will devour them with their parts, or their lots, that is, with the possessions which they received in the division of the land by the measure of the cord. For what we have said, \"a month will devour them,\" the Seventy have rendered as \"rust\": although certainly rust, that is, hasil, is so called, as they themselves also said in the prophet Joel: \"The residue of the locust the rust shall eat\" (Joel 1:4), that is, hasil. But a month is called hodes; indeed Aquila translated it as \"new moons,\" that is, the kalends; Symmachus and Theodotion as \"month\"; and the sense is, through each month the enemy will come, and will lay everything waste. Let us read the books of Kings and Chronicles, and we will find that under King Pekah, who reigned over the ten tribes, Tiglath-pileser king of the Assyrians came, and transferred a great part of the people of Samaria into Assyria, at which time among the Greeks was the second year of the first Olympiad; and among the Latins (when Rome was not yet founded) Amulius was reigning in the twentieth year of Alba, whom afterward Romulus drove from the kingdom.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":92,"ref":"p92","source":"Haeretici suspicantur quod in sacrificiorum multitudine placent Deum; et ecclesiastici, quod faciendo eleemosynas, redimant peccata, in quibus permanent: cum omne sacrificium praeterita scelera deleat, non praesentia; ideo non inveniunt Dominum, qui aufertur a talibus, el procul recedit. Isti vere | Al, vero] praevaricati sunt in Deum, et alienos filios nen Christo, sed diabolo procrearunt: ideo omni tempore maledicta sunt opera eorum, et cuncta quae faciunt, cruenti coloris rubigo populatur, quia sanguini et interfectioni proxima sunt. Rubigo autem proprie descendere dicitur in rore nocturno, ac lactantia in spicis frumenta maculare colore minii, vel sinopidis, et congrue juxta vastat cleros haereticorum, de quibus dicitur. Cleri eorum non proderunt cis (Jerem. XII, 13, secundum LXX).\n\nLIBER SECUNDUS.\n\nQui saepe navigat, aliquando patitur tempestatem; qui viam frequenter ingreditur, aut sustinet latronum impetus, aut certe metuit, omnique in arte, tam gloria quam obtrectatio, secundis adversisque ventis oritur, dum aut amici plus merito laudant, ant inimici plus justo detrahunt; rarumque invenias qui in utramque partem non favore, aut odio, sed rerum aequitate ducatur. Quod mihi in Scripturarum explanatione sudanti accidere video.","english":"The heretics suspect that God is pleased by a multitude of sacrifices; and churchmen, that by giving alms they redeem the sins in which they persist: whereas every sacrifice wipes away past crimes, not present ones; therefore they do not find the Lord, who is taken away from such people, and withdraws far off. These men truly have transgressed against God, and have begotten alien sons not for Christ but for the devil: therefore at all times their works are accursed, and all that they do the rust of a bloody color lays waste, because they are close to blood and slaughter. But rust is properly said to descend in the night dew, and to stain the milk-bearing grain in the ears with the color of vermilion, or of sinopis; and fittingly it lays waste the clergy of the heretics, of whom it is said: Their clergy shall not profit them (Jeremiah 12:13, according to the Septuagint).\n\nBOOK TWO.\n\nHe who sails often sometimes endures a storm; he who frequently enters upon the road either sustains the attacks of robbers, or at least fears them; and in every art, glory as well as disparagement arises from favorable and adverse winds, while either friends praise more than is deserved, or enemies disparage more than is just; and rarely will you find one who in either direction is led not by favor or hatred, but by the equity of things. This I see happening to me as I labor over the explanation of the Scriptures.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":93,"ref":"p93","source":"Alii enim quasi parva contemnunt, et quidquid dixerimus, contracta nare despiciunt; alii odio nominis nostri, non res, sed personas considerant: magisque aliorum silentium, quam nostrum studium probant. Sunt qui audacter nos facere asserant, quod arripuimus opus, quod nullus ante nos Latinorum tentare ausus est. Quidam in eo se disertos arbitrantur et doctos, si alieno operi detrahant, et non quid ipsi possint, sed quid nos non possimus dijudicent. Tu autem, Pammachi, qui nos facere praecepisti hoc, necesse est ut fautor sis imperii tui, et Amalionios ac Rabirios nostri temporis, qui de Graecis bonis, Latina faciunt non bona; et homines eloquentissimos ipsi elingues transferunt, evangelico calces pede; hydramque et scorpium juxta fabulas poetarum, aduras cauterio, solea conteras; et Scylleos canes ac mortifera carmina sirenarum surda aure pertranseas; ut pariter audire et nosse valeamus quid vaticinetur Osee propheta, in cujus explanationem secundum dictabimus librum. Cumque tuo laeter adminiculo, et in prima urbe terrarum, primum et nobilitato et religione habere mo gaudeam defensorem, tamen magis optarem illud inibi contingere, quod Titus Livius scribit de Catone, cujus gloriae neque profuit quisquam laudando, nec vituperando nocuit 3, cum utrumque summis praediti fecerint ingeniis. Significat autem M Ciceronem et C.","english":"For some, as it were, belittle it as insignificant, and whatever we may say they disdain with a wrinkled nose; others, from hatred of our name, consider not the matter but the persons, and approve the silence of others more than our diligence. There are those who boldly assert that we are doing what we have undertaken, a work that no Latin before us dared to attempt. Some think themselves eloquent and learned in this, if they disparage another's work, and judge not what they themselves can do, but what we cannot do. But you, Pammachius, who commanded us to do this, must needs be a patron of your own command, and the Amalionii and Rabirii of our time, who from good Greek make not-good Latin, and themselves tongue-tied translate men of the greatest eloquence, trample under the evangelical heel; and the hydra and the scorpion, according to the fables of the poets, burn with the cautery, crush with the sole; and the Scyllaean dogs and the deadly songs of the Sirens pass by with a deaf ear; so that together we may be able to hear and to know what Hosea the prophet foretells, in whose exposition we shall dictate the second book. And though I rejoice in your support, and in the first city of the world I rejoice to have as a defender the first man, both ennobled and distinguished in religion, yet I would rather that there should happen in that place what Titus Livius writes of Cato, to whose glory no one profited by praising, nor harmed by disparaging, since both were done by men endowed with the highest talents. He means moreover Marcus Cicero and Gaius.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":94,"ref":"p94","source":"Caesarem, quorum alter laudes, alter vituperationes supradicti scripsit viri. Dum enim vivimus et in vase fragili continemur, videntur amicorum prodesse studia, et nocere aemulorum opprobria. Postquam autem reversa fuerit terra in terram suam, et tam nos qui scribimus, quam eos qui de nobis judicant, pallida mors subtraxerit, et alia venerit generatio, primisque cadentibus foliis virens silva succreverit, tunc sine nominum dignitate, sola judicantur ingenia: nec considerat qui lecturus est, cujus; sed quale sit quod lecturus est, sive ille episcopus, sive sit laicus, imperator et dominus, miles et servus; aut purpura et sericio, aut vilissimo panno jaceat: non honorum diversitate, sed operum merito judicabitur.\n\n(Vers. 8, 9.) « Clangite buccina in Gabaa, tuba in Rama: ululate in Bethaven post tergum tuum Benjamin: Ephraim in desolatione erit in die correptionis, in tribubus Israel ostendi fidem. » LXX: « Clangite tuba super colles, sonate super excelsa, praedicate in domo: mente excidit Benjamin, Ephraim in desolatione factus est in diebus correptionis, in tribubus Israel ostendi fidelia. » Ephraim et Israel et Juda menses singuli, sive rubigo cum suis partibus devorabunt. Quamobrem praecipio vobis qui auditis, ut non voce sublimi, sed clara buccina concrepetis: claro enim auditu opus est, ut omnes audiant qui in circuitu sunt.","english":"Caesar, of whom the one wrote praises, the other censures, of the aforementioned man. For as long as we live and are contained in a fragile vessel, the studies of friends seem to profit, and the reproaches of rivals to harm. But after the earth has returned to its own earth, and pale death has withdrawn both us who write and those who judge concerning us, and another generation has come, and with the first leaves falling a green forest has grown up in their place, then without the dignity of names, only talents are judged: nor does he who is about to read consider whose the work is, but of what sort it is that he is about to read, whether that man be a bishop or a layman, emperor and lord, soldier and slave; whether he lies in purple and silk, or in the vilest cloth: he will be judged not by the diversity of honors, but by the merit of his works.\n\n(Verses 8, 9.) « Blow the trumpet in Gabaa, the horn in Rama: howl in Bethaven after your back, Benjamin: Ephraim shall be in desolation in the day of rebuke, among the tribes of Israel I have shown faith. » The Septuagint: « Blow the trumpet upon the hills, sound upon the heights, preach in the house: Benjamin has fallen from mind, Ephraim has become a desolation in the days of rebuke, among the tribes of Israel I have shown faithful things. » Ephraim and Israel and Juda shall devour the months one by one, or the mildew with its parts. Wherefore I charge you who hear, that you may sound forth not with a lofty voice, but with a clear trumpet: for clear hearing is needed, that all who are round about may hear.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[{"kind":"scripture","severity":"info","ref":"Psalm 81:3","text":"The English carries the scriptural phrase “blow the trumpet”, which matches Psalm 81:3. The match is on the English draft; check the Coptic before quoting the verse."}]},{"i":95,"ref":"p95","source":"Clangite buccina in Gabaa, cujus etymologiam in colles Septusginta transtulerunt: et tuba in Rama, quae interpretatur excelsa: istae autem duae sunt in tribu Benjamin, vicinae sibi mutuo civitates, id est Gabaa, in qua natus est Saul; et Rama, quae est juxta Gabaa, in septimo lapide a Hierosolymis sita; et quam rex Israel occupare conatus est, ut exitum et introitum clauderet tribui Judae. In Gabaa itaque et in Rama clara buccina et tuba personate; quorum buccina pastoralis est, et cornu recurvo efficitur; unde et proprie Hebraice SOPHAR ( ), Graece appellatur, Tuba autem de aere efficitur, vel argento, qua [quae] in bellis et solemnitatibus concrepabant. Super Bethaven, quae quondam vocabatur Bethel, et est in tribu Ephraim, in qua vitulus aureus erat, non clangore et sonitu, sed ululatu opus est: quia vicina captivitas est. Ei pulchre dixit quod Bethaven post tergum sit Benjamin: ubi enim tribus finitur Benjamin, haud procul in tribu Ephraim, haec urbs condita est. Idcirco autem dico atque praecipio: Clangite buccina in Gabaa, et tuba in Rama, et ululate in Bethaven; quia domus regia Ephraim, sive ipse Ephraim, hoc est imperium Israel, jam in desolatione erit; et instat vicina captivitas. In die correptionis atque supplicii decem tribuum Israel, ostendi mea fidelia verba, quae per prophetas comminatus sum: ut quod sermone praedixeram, opere comprobarem.","english":"Sound the trumpet in Gibeah, whose etymology the Seventy translated as \"hills\"; and the horn in Ramah, which is interpreted as \"high places.\" These two are in the tribe of Benjamin, cities near to each other, that is, Gibeah, in which Saul was born, and Ramah, which is next to Gibeah, situated seven miles from Jerusalem; and which the king of Israel attempted to occupy, so as to block the going out and coming in of the tribe of Judah. In Gibeah therefore and in Ramah, sound the clear trumpet and horn; of which the trumpet is pastoral, and is made from a curved horn; whence also in Hebrew it is properly called SOPHAR, in Greek salpinx. The horn, however, is made of bronze or silver, which they used to blare in wars and solemnities. Over Beth-aven, which was formerly called Bethel, and is in the tribe of Ephraim, in which was the golden calf, there is need not of blaring and sound, but of wailing, because captivity is near. And well did he say that Beth-aven is behind the back of Benjamin; for where the tribe of Benjamin ends, not far off in the tribe of Ephraim, this city was founded. Therefore I say and command: Sound the trumpet in Gibeah, and the horn in Ramah, and wail in Beth-aven; because the royal house of Ephraim, or Ephraim himself, that is, the empire of Israel, will already be in desolation, and captivity is near at hand. On the day of rebuke and punishment of the ten tribes of Israel, I showed my faithful words, which I threatened through the prophets, so that what I had foretold in speech, I might confirm by deed.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[{"kind":"lacuna","severity":"caution","text":"The source is fragmentary here: the edition marks a break or an editorial bracket, and the English carries across it. Treat the bridge as supplied, not translated."}]},{"i":96,"ref":"p96","source":"Quidam Bethaven juxta Septuaginta qui dixerunt domus, civitatem solis, interpretati sunt; et Solem justitiae Christum dicentes, urbem illius Ecclesiam esse voluerunt. Quod mihi displicet: neque enim domus idoli, quam Aquila interpretatus est domum inutilem, juxta tropologiam ad Ecclesiam referri potest. Sed hoc dicamus, quod haeretici qui in Gabaa et Rama, excelsam sibi scientiam pollicentur, jubeantur ululare in domo idoli; et non sint ante faciem Benjamin, qui interpretatur filius dexterae: sed post tergum ejus, ubi oculos non habet. Omnis enim Ephraim jactantia, quae interpretatur ubertas, brevi in desolatione erit, et cum judicii, inquit, dies et tempus correptionis advenerit, verba mea non esse inania rebus ostendam. Pro eo quod nos transtulimus post tergum tuum Benjamin, Septuaginta verterunt, mente motus est Benjamin: semper, id est mentis excessum, Benjamin, viro ecclesiastico coaptantes. Unde et in sexagesimo septimo psalmo (V. 28)dicitur: Ibi Benjamin adolescentulus in mentis excessu. Et in benedictionibus Jacob, sub persona Benjamin, de qua tribu Paulus apostolus fuit, scriptum legimus: Benjamin lupus rapax: mana comedet praedam et ad vesperam dabit escam (Gen. XLIX, 27). Qui enim in principio persequebatur Ecclesiam, postea in loto orbe Evangelii credentibus alimenta largitus est.","english":"Certain interpreters, following the Septuagint, which rendered it \"house,\" have translated Bethaven as \"city of the sun,\" and saying that the Sun of righteousness is Christ, they wished its city to be the Church. This does not please me, for the house of an idol, which Aquila translated as \"useless house,\" cannot be referred to the Church according to tropology. But let us say this: that heretics who in Gibeah and Ramah promise themselves lofty knowledge are commanded to howl in the house of an idol, and are not before the face of Benjamin, which is interpreted as \"son of the right hand,\" but behind his back, where he has no eyes. For all the boasting of Ephraim, which is interpreted as \"fruitfulness,\" will shortly be in desolation, and when, he says, the day of judgment and the time of rebuke has come, I will show by events that my words are not empty. For what we have translated as \"behind your back, Benjamin,\" the Septuagint rendered as \"Benjamin is moved in mind,\" that is, always applying the ecstasy of mind, Benjamin, to the ecclesiastical man. Whence also in the sixty-seventh psalm it is said: There Benjamin the young man in ecstasy of mind. And in the blessings of Jacob, under the person of Benjamin, from whose tribe the apostle Paul was, we read it written: Benjamin is a ravenous wolf: in the morning he shall devour the prey, and in the evening he shall give food. For he who at first persecuted the Church, afterward throughout the whole world lavished nourishment on those who believed the Gospel.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":97,"ref":"p97","source":"Unde et Saul qui de tribu Benjamin fuit, in mentis excessu, lota die usque ad vesperum vaticinatus est inter prophetarum chorum (I Reg. X).\n\n(Vers. 10.) « Facti sunt principes Juda quasi assumentes terminum; super eos effundam quasi aquam iram meam. » LXX:« Facti sunt principes Juda quasi transferentes terminos: super eos effundam sicut aquam impetum meum. » Ductis Ephraim et Israel in captivitatem, et redacta terra eorum in solitudinem, principes Juda qui flere debuerant, et suum populum cohortari ut recederent ab idololatria, ne et ipsi similia sustinerent, coeperunt gaudere atque laetari, quod pateret sibi terra eorum ad possidendum latius: et facti sunt quasi assumentes terminos Israel, transeuntes fines suos; et in locis quondam eorum regnum suum et possessionem dilatare cupientes. Quamobrem dicit Dominus: Et super ipsos principes Juda venient Babylonii; et ita eos quasi aquae impetus occupabunt: non suis viribus, sed indignatione mea. Dicit quoque et ad principes Juda, hoc est Ecclesiae, quod non debeant exsultare; et haereticorum perditionem suam salutem aestimare: sed potius plangere, quod illi perierint. Unde et apostolus Paulus docet ecclesiasticos viros, ne glorientur super fractione Judaicorum ramorum, sed potius timeant ne et ipsi frangantur (Rom. XI). Et in alio loco: Quis, ait, scandalizatur, et ego non uror (II Cor. XI, 29)?","english":"Whence also Saul, who was of the tribe of Benjamin, in an ecstasy of mind, prophesied all day until evening among the company of the prophets (1 Kings 10).\n\n(Verse 10.) \"The princes of Judah have become like those who remove a boundary; upon them I will pour out my wrath like water.\" The Septuagint: \"The princes of Judah have become like those who transfer boundaries; upon them I will pour out my impulse like water.\" When Ephraim and Israel had been led into captivity, and their land had been reduced to solitude, the princes of Judah, who ought to have wept and to have exhorted their own people to withdraw from idolatry, lest they too suffer similar things, began to rejoice and be glad that their land lay open for them to possess more widely; and they became like those who remove the boundaries of Israel, crossing their own limits, and desiring to extend their kingdom and possession in the places that had once been theirs. Wherefore the Lord says: Even upon those princes of Judah the Babylonians will come, and thus they will seize them like the rush of waters—not by their own strength, but by my indignation. He says also to the princes of Judah, that is, of the Church, that they ought not to exult, and to reckon the destruction of heretics as their own salvation, but rather to lament that those have perished. Whence also the apostle Paul teaches ecclesiastical men not to boast over the breaking off of the Jewish branches, but rather to fear lest they themselves also be broken off (Romans 11). And in another place: Who, he says, is scandalized, and I do not burn (2 Corinthians 11:29)?","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":98,"ref":"p98","source":"Alioquin super tales principes qui in aliorum miseriis gloriantur, et idcirco se star putant, si alii corruant, effundet Dominus quasi aquam iram suam. Pro ira Septuaginta, id est impetum, transtulerunt; et putant quidam pro benedictione accipiendum, juxta illud quod alibi legimus: Fluminis impetus laetificat civitatem Dei (Psal. XLV, 5.) Sed rectius (ut omnes praeter Septuaginta transtulerunt) ira accipienda est: praesertim cum nomen nomini] effusionis et irae conveniat, dicente Propheta ad Dominum: Effunde super eos irani tuam, et furor irae tuae comprehendat eos (Psal. LXVIII, 25). Transferunt principes Juda terminos quos posuerunt patres eorum, quando immutant mendacio veritatem; et aliud praedicant quam ab apostolis acceperunt.\n\n(Vers. 11.) « Calumniam patiens est Ephraim, fractus judicio, quoniam coepit abire post sordem. » LXX: « Oppressit Ephraim adversarium suum, conculcavit judicium, quia coepit abire post vana. » Si impius est Ephraim, et propter impietatem suam erit in desolationem, quomodo nunc dicitur: Calumniam patiens Ephraim fractus judicio? Qui enim calumniam patitur, et frangitur, judicium ejus inique opprimitur, maxime cum causa justa ponatur, quare sit traditus captivitati. Sequitur enim: Quoniam coepit abire post sordem, hoc est, post idola quae sordibus comparantur.","english":"Otherwise, against such princes who glory in the miseries of others, and for that reason think themselves to stand if others fall, the Lord will pour out his wrath like water. For \"wrath,\" the Seventy translated \"impetus,\" that is, a rushing; and some think it should be taken as a blessing, according to what we read elsewhere: The rushing of a river gladdens the city of God (Psalm 45:5). But more correctly (as all besides the Seventy have translated) it should be taken as \"wrath,\" especially since the meaning of the word \"pouring out\" agrees with \"wrath,\" as the Prophet says to the Lord: Pour out your wrath upon them, and let the fury of your wrath overtake them (Psalm 68:25). The princes of Judah transgress the boundaries which their fathers set, when they change truth into a lie and preach something other than what they received from the apostles.\n\n(Verse 11.) \"Ephraim is suffering calumny, broken in judgment, because he has begun to go after filth.\" The Seventy: \"Ephraim has oppressed his adversary, trampled judgment underfoot, because he has begun to go after vain things.\" If Ephraim is impious, and because of his impiety will be brought to desolation, how is it now said: \"Ephraim is suffering calumny, broken in judgment\"? For he who suffers calumny and is broken, his judgment is unjustly oppressed, especially when a just cause is set forth as to why he was handed over to captivity. For it follows: Because he has begun to go after filth, that is, after idols, which are compared to filth.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":99,"ref":"p99","source":"Quod ergo dicit, hoc est: opprimitur Ephraim ab Assyriis, primum a Phul, deinde a Teglathphalasar (IV Reg. XV), postea a Salmanasar; non quod illi justi fuerint, qui eum oppresserunt, et idcirco traditus eis sit; sed quod qui quondam fuerunt populus meus, me eos deserente traduntur ad poenas, et in hoc videtur esse calumnia, non Deo, qui justam infert sententiam; sed his qui tormenta sustinent, dum pejoribus se adversariis conceduntur. Redditque causam Dominus, idcirco eos in hac parte calumniam sustinere, et tradi pejoribus, et erga illos judicium non servari; quia coepit Ephraim, id est Jeroboam, abire post idola, et Deum derelinquere; ipse enim aureos fabricatus est vitulos. Secundum Septuaginta interpretationem, oppressit Ephraim, id est Jeroboam, adversarium suum Roboam, id est tribum Juda, et in eo oppressit; quia deserta Jerusalem et templo, AEgyptiarum sordium simulacra sectatus sit. De haereticis manifestus est sensus quod falsis sophismatibus suis et arte dialectica saepe opprimant ecclesiasticos: sed cum hoc fecerint, non munditiam verae fidei, sed sordes sequuntur mendacii, qui traditi diabolo et angelis ejus, videntur sibi calumniam pali, et in se fractam esse judicii veritatem. Taliter vastatur Israel; et omnes labores ejus Assyrio vincente populantur: Deumque perdidit praesulem, et idcirco fractus judicio est, quia secutus est idola.","english":"What he says, then, is this: Ephraim is oppressed by the Assyrians, first by Pul, then by Tiglath-pileser (2 Kings 15), and afterward by Shalmaneser; not because those who oppressed him were righteous, and he was therefore handed over to them, but because those who were once my people, when I abandon them, are handed over to punishment. And in this there seems to be a grievance, not against God, who brings a just sentence, but against those who endure torments, in that they are yielded up to worse adversaries. And the Lord gives the reason why they suffer this grievance in this regard, and are handed over to worse men, and judgment is not preserved toward them: because Ephraim, that is, Jeroboam, began to go after idols and to forsake God; for he himself fashioned the golden calves. According to the interpretation of the Seventy, Ephraim, that is, Jeroboam, oppressed his adversary Rehoboam, that is, the tribe of Judah, and in this he oppressed him, because, having abandoned Jerusalem and the temple, he pursued the images of Egyptian filth. Concerning heretics the meaning is clear: that by their false sophisms and dialectical art they often oppress churchmen; but when they have done this, they follow not the purity of the true faith but the filth of falsehood, and being handed over to the devil and his angels, they think they suffer a grievance and that the truth of judgment has been broken against them. In this way Israel is laid waste; and all his labors are plundered as the Assyrian conquers; and he has lost God as his protector, and is therefore broken by judgment, because he followed idols.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":100,"ref":"p100","source":"(Vers. 12.) « Et ego quasi tinea Ephraim, et quasi putredo domui Juda. » LXX: « Et ego quasi conturbatio Ephraim, et quasi stimulus domui Juda. » as lingua Hebraica ( ) tinea dicitur, RE GOB ( ) putredo et caries; quorum alterum vestes, alterum ligna consumit: pro quibus LXX,, id est tumultum, vel conturbationem, et stimulum transtulerunt. Et notandum quod tinea referatur ad Ephraim, et putredo ad domum Juda. Quomodo igitur tinea vestimenta consumit, et putredo vel caries ligna, quod utrumque longo fit tempore: ita Deus et decem tribubus, et postea tribubus duabus longo tempore dans locum poenitentiae, et eos provocans ad salutem, thesaurizantes sibi iram in die irae, quasi tinea efficitur et putredo, non quod Deus linea sit vel putredo, aut conturbatio vel stimulus, sed quod sustinentibus poenas haec universa videatur. Primus igitur consumptus, est Ephraim et Israel, deinde secuta est et domus Juda: non ipse Juda, sed domus ejus: alioquin reservabatur de genere Juda cui repositum fuit: Et ipse erat exspectatio gentium. Punitis autem haereticis, qui intelliguntur Ephraim, etiam Judas, scilicet hi qui cum Ecclesia permanent, et haereticorum vel erroribus vel vitiis continentur, simili sententiae subjacebunt.","english":"(Verse 12.) And I am like a moth to Ephraim, and like rot to the house of Judah. The Septuagint: And I am like a disturbance to Ephraim, and like a goad to the house of Judah. In the Hebrew tongue, tinea is the word for moth, and putredo and caries for rot; of these the one consumes garments, the other wood. For these the Septuagint translators rendered as disturbance, or confusion, and goad. And it must be noted that the moth refers to Ephraim, and the rot to the house of Judah. Therefore, just as the moth consumes garments, and the rot or caries consumes wood, each of which happens over a long time, so God, giving the ten tribes, and afterward the two tribes, room for repentance over a long time, and provoking them to salvation, while they store up wrath for themselves for the day of wrath, becomes like a moth and rot—not that God is a moth or rot, or a disturbance or a goad, but that to those enduring punishments all these things seem so. First, therefore, Ephraim and Israel were consumed, then the house of Judah followed as well—not Judah himself, but his house; otherwise one of the line of Judah would have been preserved, for whom it was reserved: And he himself was the expectation of the nations. But when heretics, who are understood as Ephraim, have been punished, even Judas—that is, those who remain with the Church and are held fast by the errors or vices of heretics—will be subject to a similar sentence.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":101,"ref":"p101","source":"(Vers. 13.) « Et vidit Ephraim languorem suum et Judas vinculum suum, et abiit Ephraim ad Assur; et misit ad regem ultorem, et ipse non poterit sanare vos, nec solvere poterit a vobis vinculum. » LXX: « Et vidit Ephraim infirmitatem suam, et Judas dolorem suum, et abiit Ephraim ad Assyrios, et misit legatos ad regem Jarib, et ipse non potuit liberare vos, nec cessare faciet a vobis dolorem. » Legatos non habetur in Hebraeo. Et ubi Septuaginta posuerunt iarib, nos, juxta Symmachum, ultorem vertimus: nam Aquila et Theodotion, judicem interpretati sunt. Quod autem JARIB ( ) ultorem significet et judicem, nomen Gedeonis ostendit (Judic. VI), quem cum cultores Baal expeterent ad supplicium, eo quod lucum Baal arasque evenisset, respondit pater, ulciscatur se Baal, aut judicet eum Baal, et appel latus est, inquit, Ierobaal, id est, ulciscatur se Baal. Intelligens itaque Ephraim infirmitatem suam, et Judas vinculum suum, quo cum decem tribubus peccato fuerat colligatus, non a Deo qui solvere poterat, sed a rege Assyriorum quaesivit auxilium. Legimus, quod sub rege Manahen, qui decem tribubus praefuit (IV Reg. XV), Israel Assyriis dona transmiserit; et Judas sub rege Achaz, praesidium flagitarit Teglathphalasar regis Assyriorum, qui eos adversante Deo liberare non putuerunt, nec captivitatis vinculum solvere.","english":"(Verse 13.) And Ephraim saw his sickness, and Judah his bond, and Ephraim went to Assur; and he sent to the avenging king, and he himself will not be able to heal you, nor will he be able to loose the bond from you. The Septuagint: And Ephraim saw his infirmity, and Judah his grief, and Ephraim went to the Assyrians, and sent envoys to king Jarib, and he himself could not deliver you, nor will he cause the grief to cease from you. \"Envoys\" is not found in the Hebrew. And where the Septuagint put iarib, we, following Symmachus, have translated \"avenger\"; for Aquila and Theodotion rendered it \"judge.\" But that JARIB signifies both \"avenger\" and \"judge,\" the name of Gideon shows (Judges 6), whom when the worshippers of Baal demanded for punishment, because he had overthrown the grove and altars of Baal, his father answered, \"Let Baal avenge himself, or let Baal judge him,\" and he was called, it says, Jerobaal, that is, \"Let Baal avenge himself.\" Understanding therefore his infirmity, Ephraim, and Judah his bond, by which he had been bound in sin with the ten tribes, sought help not from God, who was able to loose it, but from the king of the Assyrians. We read that under king Menahem, who was over the ten tribes (4 Kings 15), Israel sent gifts to the Assyrians; and Judah under king Ahaz requested the protection of Tiglath-pileser king of the Assyrians, who, with God opposing them, were unable to deliver them, nor to loose the bond of captivity.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":102,"ref":"p102","source":"Possumus vinculum, pro quo in Hebraeo scriptum est MEZUR ( ), et Aquila interpretatus est sive id est, colligationem sive conjurationem, et ad illud tempus referre, quando Basin et Phasee Alius Romeliae multa de tribu Juda hominum millia vastaverunt (Ibid. XVI), quod frustra Judas adversus reges duos non Dei, sed Assyriorum auxilium flagitarit. Quidam, juxta tropologiam Ephraim et Judam, ad haereticos et ad viros ecclesiasticos referunt, eo quod et illi et Judas peccatorum vinculis colligati, juxta illud quod scriptum est: Funibus peccatorum suorum unus· quisque constringitur (Prov. V, 22), miserint ad Assur et ad regem ultorem, id est, diabolum de quo legimus: Ut destruas inimicum et ultorem (Psal. VIII, 3). Et quia non verum vel auxiliatorem vel judicem deprecati sunt, idcirco permanere eos fecit in dolore languoris et vinculis delictorum. Legi in cujusdam commentariis regem Jarib, Christum interpretari. Et quia sequitur: Ipse non poterit sanare vos, hoc argumento usus est, quod haereticos vel ecclesiasticos peccatores Christus sanare non possit in tempore judicii, ubi nulla est misericordia, juxta illud quod scriptum est: In inferno autem quit confitebitur tibi (Psal. VI, 6)? Et quod sanare vel liberare non possit, nequaquam sua imbecillitate, sed corum merito, qui sero auxilium postularint.","english":"We can take the bond, for which in Hebrew is written MEZUR, and which Aquila translated as either a binding or a conspiracy, and refer it to that time when Pekah and Rezin of the house of Remaliah laid waste many thousands of men from the tribe of Judah, because Judah in vain sought the help of the two kings, not of God, but of the Assyrians. Some, by way of tropology, refer Ephraim and Judah to heretics and to ecclesiastical men, in that both they and Judah, bound by the chains of sins, according to what is written: Each one is bound by the ropes of his own sins, sent to Assur and to the avenging king, that is, the devil, of whom we read: That you may destroy the enemy and the avenger. And because they did not entreat the true helper or judge, therefore he made them remain in the pain of their sickness and in the bonds of their sins. I have read in someone's commentaries that the king Jarib is interpreted as Christ. And because it follows: He himself will not be able to heal you, he used this argument, that Christ cannot heal heretics or ecclesiastical sinners in the time of judgment, where there is no mercy, according to what is written: But in hell who will confess to you? And that he cannot heal or free them is by no means due to his weakness, but to the merit of those who sought help too late.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":103,"ref":"p103","source":"Quomodo et Dominus dicitur signa in patria sua facere non potuisse, et causam cur non potuerit, exponit: quia, inquit, non credebant in eum. Haec ille dixerit; nos in malam partem regem interpretemur ultorem. Pro eo quod nos exposuimus Iarib, id est, ultorem: alii male legunt IARIM per MEM litteram, quod transfertur in silvas: unde et CARIATU IARIM, interpretatur villa silvarum.\n\n(Vers. 14.) « Quoniam ego quasi leaena (Vulg. leaena) Ephraim, et quasi catulus leonis domui Juda. » LXX: « Quia ego sum quasi panther Ephraim, et quasi leo ia domo Juda. » Iliis euntibus ad Assur, et mittentibus ad regem vindicem, vel ultorem, qui eos sanare non poterit; nec solvere vinculum colligatum, ostendam quod me adversante omne hominum auxilium vanum sit: ero enim quasi Icaena Ephraim, et quasi catulus leonis domui Juda. Pro leaena, quod Hebraice dicitur SOHEL ( ), Septuaginta interpretati sint pantherem, quae Graece similiter dicitur et Latine, et tam nomen bestiae quam omnis bestia accipi potest: ut quidquid saevum in bestiis est, hoc in Dei indignatione cognoscas. Nihil panthere velocius, nihil leone fortius: in panthere velox per Assyrios regat Samariae significatur interitus; et in leone fortissimum contra Jerusalem et Judam aliquanto post tempore regnum ostenditur Chaldaeorum. Et quia leaenam sive pantherem, et leonem se esse dixerat, metaphoram servat, et dicit:","english":"Just as the Lord also is said not to have been able to perform signs in his own country, and he sets forth the reason why he could not: because, he says, they did not believe in him. Let him have said this; let us interpret the king in a bad sense as an avenger. For what we have rendered as Iarib, that is, avenger, others read incorrectly as IARIM with the letter MEM, which is translated as forests; whence also CARIATU IARIM is interpreted as village of forests.\n\n(Verse 14.) \"For I am like a lioness to Ephraim, and like a lion's cub to the house of Judah.\" The Septuagint: \"For I am like a panther to Ephraim, and like a lion in the house of Judah.\" To those going to Assyria, and sending to the king as protector, or avenger, who will not be able to heal them, nor to loose the bond that is bound, I will show that with me opposing, every human aid is vain: for I will be like a lioness to Ephraim, and like a lion's cub to the house of Judah. For \"lioness,\" which in Hebrew is called SOHEL, the Seventy interpreted as \"panther,\" which in Greek is said similarly and in Latin, and both the name of the beast and every beast can be understood: so that whatever is savage among beasts, you may recognize this in the indignation of God. Nothing is swifter than a panther, nothing stronger than a lion: in the panther, the swift destruction of Samaria through the Assyrians is signified; and in the lion, the most strong kingdom of the Chaldeans against Jerusalem and Judah after some time is shown. And because he had said that he was a lioness or panther, and a lion, he preserves the metaphor, and says:","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":104,"ref":"p104","source":"(Vers. 15.) « Ego eco capiam et vadam, et tollam, et non est qui eruat: vadens revertar ad locum meum donec deficiatis et quaeratis faciem meam. » LXX: « Et ego rapiam, et vadam et tollam, et non erit qui eruat: ibo et revertar in locum meum donec dispereant et quaerant faciem meam. » Quaeritur si capiente, et tollente, et tenente Deo, nullus de manibus ejus potest eripere, juxta illud quod scriptum est: Nemo potest rapere de manu Patris mei (Joan. X, 29), quomodo Judas de manu Dei pro· ditione sit raptus? Ad quod breviter respondebimus, nullum posse rapere de manu Dei; posse autem eum, qui tenetur, propria voluntate de manu Dei excidere. Quodque sequitur: Vadens rever tar ad locum meum, locum Dei, magnificentiam et majestatem ejus debemus accipere: ut nequaquam pro dispensatione descendat ad homines, irascatur, misereatur, obliviscatur, fiat quasi panther, venatur in leonem, mutetur in bestias: sed res spernat humanas, et permittat eos quos antea protegebat hostibus subjacere, ut tabescant, et deficiant, et intereant, et postea quaerant faciem Domini, et dicant: Illumina faciem tuam et salvi erimus (Psal. LXXIX, 4). Et: Ostende nobis, Domine, misericordiam tuam, et salutare tuum da nobis (Psal. LXXXIV, 8).","english":"(Verse 15.) “I myself will seize and go, I will take away, and there is none who can rescue: going, I will return to my place until you fail and seek my face.” The Septuagint: “And I will snatch away, and go and take away, and there will be none who can rescue: I will go and return to my place until they perish and seek my face.” The question is raised: if God seizes, takes away, and holds, no one can snatch from his hands, according to what is written: No one can snatch from the hand of my Father (John 10:29)—how then was Judas snatched from the hand of God by betrayal? To this we shall briefly answer that no one can snatch from the hand of God; but he who is held can by his own will fall away from the hand of God. And what follows: Going, I will return to my place—by “the place of God” we must understand his magnificence and majesty: so that he no longer descends to men in the economy of salvation, is angry, shows mercy, forgets, becomes like a panther, hunts as a lion, is changed into beasts; but he spurns human affairs and permits those whom he previously protected to lie subject to their enemies, so that they may waste away, fail, and perish, and afterward seek the face of the Lord and say: Shine forth your face and we shall be saved (Psalm 79:4). And: Show us, Lord, your mercy, and grant us your salvation (Psalm 84:8).","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":105,"ref":"p105","source":"Haereticis quoque et Ecclesiae negligenti, Deus in pantherem vertitur et leonem; et tollet ab his praedam quam Ecclesiae ante rapuerunt: ut capti salventur qui liberi perierant; et nequaquam habitabit in conciliabulis perversorum, sed revertetur ad locum suum, de quo dicit: Ego in Patre, et Pater in me (Joan. XIV, 10), eleos spernet atque despiciet, donec deficiant in impietate, et quaerant eum per poenitentiam a quo fuerant derelicti. Alii locum Dei coelum putant; quo offensus Deus ab his qui in terra habitant revertatur, et eos faciet disperire, qui clementissimum Dominum magnitudine peccaturum in ferarum sibi rabiem converterunt.\n\n(Cap. VI.—Vers. 1, 2.) « In tribulatione sua mane consurgent ad me: venite et revertamur ad Dominum, quia ipse cepit, et sanabit nos: percutiet et curabit nos; vivificabit nos post duos dies, et in die tertio suscitabit, et vivemus in conspectu ejus: sciemus sequemurque, ut cognoscamus Dominum.","english":"To heretics also and to the negligent Church, God is turned into a panther and a lion; and he will take away from them the prey they had previously seized from the Church, so that those who were free and perished may be captured and saved; and he will by no means dwell in the assemblies of the perverse, but will return to his place, of which he says: I am in the Father, and the Father in me, he will spurn and despise mercy, until they fail in impiety and seek him through repentance, by whom they had been abandoned. Others think the place of God is heaven, to which God, offended, returns from those who dwell on earth, and will cause those to perish who by the magnitude of their sins turned the most merciful Lord into a rage of wild beasts against themselves.\n\n(Chapter 6—Verses 1, 2.) In their tribulation they will rise early to me: come and let us return to the Lord, for he himself has seized, and he will heal us: he will strike and cure us; he will give us life after two days, and on the third day he will raise us up, and we shall live in his sight: we shall know and follow, that we may know the Lord.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":106,"ref":"p106","source":"» LXX: « In tribulatione sua mane vigilabunt ad me, dicentes: Eamus et revertamur ad Dominum Deum nostrum: quia ipse verberabit, et sanabit nos: percutiet, et curabit nos: sanos nos faciet post dies duos: in tertio resurgemus et vivemus coram eo, et sciemus, et persequemur, ut cognoscamus Dominum, » Ideo Deus tradidit Ephraim et Judam captivitati, et nullus est qui de manu ejus possit eripere, et revelletur ad locum suum donec deficiant, et quaerant factem ejus, ut quem propitium praesentemque non senserant, iratum et absentem requirant, et in tribulatione sua, orto cis lumine poenitentiae, mane consurgant ad eum. juxta illud quod in Isaia legimus: In tribulatione, Domini recordatus sum (Isa. XXVI, sec. LXX). Et in primo graduum psalmo: Ad Dominum cum tribularer clamavi, et exaudivit me (Psal. CXIX, 1). Cumque ad Dominum mane surrexerint, quid loquentur? Venite et revertamur ad Dominum. Non sunt propria salute contenti, sed se mutuo provocant, ut revertantur ad Dominum quem reliquerant, quem propter peccata deseruerant, a quo fuerant derelicti. Quia ipse cepit, et sanabit nos: qui supra dixerat: Ego ego capiam et vadam 1, percutiet, et curabit nos.","english":"The Septuagint: In their tribulation they will rise early to me, saying: Come and let us return to the Lord our God: for he himself will strike, and he will heal us: he will wound, and he will cure us: he will make us whole after two days: on the third we shall rise and live before him, and we shall know, and we shall pursue, that we may know the Lord. Therefore God handed Ephraim and Judah over to captivity, and there is no one who can snatch them from his hand, and he will be torn away to his place until they fail and seek his face, so that him whom they had not perceived as favorable and present, they may seek when angry and absent, and in their tribulation, with the light of repentance having risen upon them, they may rise early to him. According to that which we read in Isaiah: In tribulation I remembered the Lord. And in the first of the gradual psalms: To the Lord when I was in tribulation I cried, and he heard me. And when they have risen early to the Lord, what will they say? Come and let us return to the Lord. They are not content with their own salvation, but they provoke one another, that they may return to the Lord whom they had abandoned, whom they had deserted because of sins, by whom they had been forsaken. For he himself will take hold, and he will heal us: he who had said above: I, I will take hold and go, he will strike, and he will cure us.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":107,"ref":"p107","source":"Pro eo quod diximus, curabit, omnes similiter transtulerunt, proprie autem appellantur linteola quae inseruntur vulneribus, ut putridas carnes comedant, et extrahant purulentias: artisque medicorum est grandia vulnera longo sanare tempore, et per dolorem reddere sanitatem. Percutit ergo Dominus, et curat nos; quia quem diligit Dominus corripit, et castigat omnem filium quem recipit (Hebr. XII); et non solum curat, sed vivificat post dies duos et die tertio resurgens ab inferis, omne hominum secum suscitat genus. Cumque percussos curaverit, et curatos vivificaverit, et vivificatos suscitaverit, tunc vivemus in conspectu ejus, qui, illo absente, mortui jacebamus. Vivemus autem in conspectu ejus; sciemus eum, et omni studio sectabimur, ut cognoscamus Dominum, quo tertia die resurgente, resurreximus. His sermonibus explicatur illud quod saepe jam admonuimus, et Israelem et Judam, id est, decem et duas tribus, tunc unum habituras esse pastorem et regem David, cum crediderint in Dominum resurgentem: frustraque Judaei mille annorum sibi somnia pollicentur cum salus uuiversorum die tertio repromissa sit, qua Dominus ab inferis resurrexit. Hebraei diem secundum in adventu Christi sui interpretantur, et diem tertium in judicio, quando salvandi sunt. Quod ut concedamus, respondeant nobis, quae sit dies prima, hoc est, primus Salvatoris adventus.","english":"For the word we have rendered \"he will cure,\" all have translated similarly, but properly the term denotes the small linen dressings that are inserted into wounds, so that they may consume the putrid flesh and draw out the pus; and it is the art of physicians to heal large wounds over a long period of time, and to restore health through pain. The Lord therefore strikes and cures us, because whom the Lord loves he chastises, and he scourges every son whom he receives (Hebr. XII); and he not only cures, but gives life after two days, and on the third day, rising from the dead, raises up with himself the whole race of mankind. And when he has cured those who were struck, and given life to those who were cured, and raised up those who were given life, then we shall live in his sight, who, when he was absent, lay dead. But we shall live in his sight; we shall know him, and pursue him with all zeal, that we may know the Lord, by whose resurrection on the third day we have risen. By these words is explained what we have often already noted, that both Israel and Judah, that is, the ten and two tribes, will then have one shepherd and king, David, when they have believed in the Lord who rises again: and in vain do the Jews promise themselves the dreams of a thousand years, since the salvation of all is promised for the third day, on which the Lord rose from the dead. The Hebrews interpret the second day as the coming of their Christ, and the third day as the judgment, when they are to be saved. But granting them this, let them answer us: what is the first day, that is, the first coming of the Savior?","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":108,"ref":"p108","source":"Et cum respondere non potuerint, inferamus primum diem esse juxta quod ipsi volunt, in humilitate Salvatoris adventum, secundum in gloria, tertium in habitu judicantis. Qui autem secundum tertiumque suscipiunt, primum se perdidisse testantur: quia secundus et tertius sine primo non potest appellari.\n\n(Vers. 3.) « Quasi diluculum praeparatus est egressus ejus, et veniet quasi imber nobis temporaneus et serotinus terrae. » LXX: « Quasi mane paratum inveniemus eum, et veniet nobis quasi pluvia temporanea et serotina terrae. » Venite, inquit, et revertamur ad Dominam, quia ipse qui cepit, et sanabit nos, percutiet et curabit nos, et vivificabit nos, post dies duos, et die tertio suscitabit nos, ipse et non alius, quasi mane et aurora paratus est nobis. De quo et vicesimi primi psalmi titulus est: Pro assumptione matutina: licet in Hebraeo scriptum sit: Pro cervo matutino: co quod, interfecta morte, et tortuoso antiquoque serpente, cupiat ad montana conscendere, et ipse, tenebris dissipatis, oritur nobis sol justitiae, ut nostram illuminet caecitatem. Et pulchre, praeparatus est, inquit, egressus ejus. De quo juxta tropologiam in octavo decimo psalmo legimus: Et ipse tanquam sponsus egreditur de thalamo suo (Psal. XVIII, 6). Qui non solum mane vocatur, et aurora, et diluculum: sed veniet nobis quasi imber temporaneus et serotinus terrae.","english":"And since they have not been able to respond, let us introduce the first day, according to what they themselves want, as the coming of the Savior in humility, the second in glory, the third in the manner of a judge. But those who accept the second and the third testify that they have lost the first, because the second and the third cannot be named without the first.\n\n(Verse 3.) \"His going forth is prepared as the dawn, and he will come to us like the timely and late rain upon the earth.\" The Septuagint: \"As the morning we shall find him prepared, and he will come to us like the timely and late rain upon the earth.\" Come, he says, and let us return to the Lord, for he who has begun will also heal us, he will strike and cure us, and he will give us life after two days, and on the third day he will raise us up, he himself and no other, is prepared for us like the morning and the dawn. Of him also is the title of the twenty-first psalm: For the morning assumption, although in Hebrew it is written: For the morning deer, because, with death destroyed and the crooked ancient serpent slain, he desires to ascend to the mountains, and he himself, with the darkness scattered, rises for us as the sun of justice, to illuminate our blindness. And beautifully, he says, his going forth is prepared. Of him, according to tropology, we read in the eighteenth psalm: And he himself goes forth like a bridegroom from his chamber. Who is called not only morning, and dawn, and daybreak, but will come to us like the timely and late rain upon the earth.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":109,"ref":"p109","source":"Nos Christum recipimus temporaneum, quando fidei in nobis jacta sunt fundamenta, et suscipiemus eum imbrem serotinum, quando maturis segetibus, fruges capiemus aeternas, et in dominica horrea recondemur. Ergo Judaei, qui temporaneas pluvias non receperunt, et absque pluviis jecere semen, segetum fructus in ultimo tempore non recipient. Haec est pluvia de qua Dominus pollicetur dicens: Dabo vobis pluviam temporaneam et serotinam (Deut. XI, 14). Juxta allegoriam, datur pluvia temporanea, quando ex parte cognoscimus: datur pluvia serotina, quando venit quod perfectum est. Semperque Dominus mane surgentibus paratus est, qui possunt dicere, Consurgam diluculo (Psal. LVI. 9). Et: Deus, Deus meus, ad te de luce vigilo. Sitivit in te anima mea (Psal. LXII, 1, 2).\n\n(Vers. 4, 5.) « Quid faciam tibi, Ephraim? quid faciam libi, Juda? misericordia vestra, quasi nubes matutina, et quasi ros mane pertransiens: propter hoc dolavi In prophetis, et occidi eos in verbis oris mei, et judicia tua quasi lux egredientur, » LXX: « Quid faciam tibi, Ephraim? quid faciam tibi, Juda? misericordia autem vestra quasi nubes matutina, et quasi ros mane pertransiens: propterea succidi prophetas vestros, occidi eos in verbis oris mei, et judicium tuum quasi lux egredietur. » Quando dicit; Quid faciam tibi(??) Ephraim? quid faciam libi, Juda?","english":"We receive Christ as the early rain, when the foundations of faith have been laid in us, and we shall receive him as the late rain, when with ripe crops we shall gather eternal fruits and be stored away in the Lord's barns. Therefore the Jews, who have not received the early rains and have cast their seed without rains, will not receive the fruits of their crops in the last time. This is the rain of which the Lord promises, saying: I will give you the early and the late rain (Deut. 11:14). According to the allegory, the early rain is given when we know in part; the late rain is given when that which is perfect comes. And the Lord is always ready for those who rise at dawn, who can say, I will rise at daybreak (Ps. 56:9). And: O God, my God, I watch for you from the light. My soul has thirsted for you (Ps. 62:1, 2).\n\n(Verses 4, 5.) \"What shall I do to you, Ephraim? What shall I do to you, Judah? Your mercy is like a morning cloud, and like the dew that passes away in the morning: therefore I have hewn them by the prophets, and I have slain them by the words of my mouth, and your judgments shall go forth like the light,\" The Septuagint: \"What shall I do to you, Ephraim? What shall I do to you, Judah? But your mercy is like a morning cloud, and like the dew that passes away in the morning: therefore I have cut down your prophets, I have slain them by the words of my mouth, and your judgment shall go forth like the light.\" When he says: What shall I do to you, Ephraim? What shall I do to you, Judah?","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":110,"ref":"p110","source":"parentis in perditos filios monstrat affectum, juxta illud quod in Isaia legimus: Quid est quod ultra debui facere Vineae mece et non feci ei (Isa. V, 4)? Et in Michaea: Popule meus, quid feci tibi, aut quid molestus fui tibi? Responde mihi; quin eduxi te de terra AEgypti, de domo servientium liberavi te, et misi ante faciem tuam Moysen, et Aaron, et Mariam (Mich. VI, 3, 4). Quid igitur faciam tibi, Ephraim, quid faciam tibi, Juda? misericordia vestra, qua vobis semper misertus sum, quasi nubes matutina pertransiit, et quasi ros mane consurgens, qui, orto sole, siccatur. Jam enim captivitas prope est, jam vos cerno duci in Assyrios et in Babylonios catenatos; dolavi vos in prophetis, et verbis terribilibus comminatus sum, scalpellum, ignes et cauteria protuli, ut qui clementem contemnebatis, timeatis offensum, et occidi negligentes in verbis oris mei, ut ante peccatores verborum terrore punirem, quam captivitas immineret. Et haec universa feci, ut judicii, quo te judicaturus sum, veritas appareret, nullusque dubitaret vos juste quae patimini fuisse perpessos. Pro eo quod est, dolavi in prophetis, Septuaginta transtulerunt, succidi prophetas vestros, ipsos pseudoprophetas occisos a Domino intelligentes: ut qui causa erroris fuerant, prospera promittentes, interfecti verterentur in occasionem salutis.","english":"He shows the affection of a parent toward his ruined sons, according to what we read in Isaiah: What is there that I ought to have done more for my vineyard, and I have not done it? And in Micah: My people, what have I done to you, or in what have I troubled you? Answer me; indeed I brought you out of the land of Egypt, from the house of bondage I freed you, and I sent before your face Moses, and Aaron, and Miriam. What therefore shall I do to you, Ephraim, what shall I do to you, Judah? Your mercy, by which I have always shown mercy to you, has passed by like a morning cloud, and like the dew rising at dawn, which, when the sun has risen, is dried up. For now captivity is near, now I see you being led in chains into Assyria and into Babylon; I have hewn you by the prophets, and I have threatened you with terrible words, I have brought forth the scalpel, fires, and cauteries, so that you who despised the merciful one might fear him when offended, and I have slain those who were negligent in the words of my mouth, so that I might punish sinners by the terror of words before the captivity should threaten. And all these things I have done, so that the truth of the judgment by which I am about to judge you might appear, and no one might doubt that you have justly suffered the things you endure. For what is, I have hewn by the prophets, the Seventy translated as, I have cut down your prophets, understanding those false prophets themselves as slain by the Lord: so that those who had been the cause of error, promising prosperity, being killed might be turned into an occasion of salvation.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":111,"ref":"p111","source":"Et est sensus: Ne diceretis, prophetis credidimus, etiam ipsos interfeci: ut omnis vobis peccandi tolleretur occasio. Legimus in Regum volumine quadringentos quinquaginta prophetas Baalim interfectos sub Elia (III Reg. XVII), et aliam innumerabilem multitudinem sub Jehu (IV Reg. X), qui subvertit domum Achab. Haec eadem et ad haereticos, et ad verum Judam, qui similia perpessurus est, dicta sentimus, quod provocet eos Dominus ad misericordiam, et reverti cupiat ad salutem. Sed illi delicias hujus saeculi et refrigeria quasi nubem et rorem, qui cito transeat, consectentur, quibus in Evangelio dicitur: Stulte, hac nocte repetunt animam tuam a te: quae autem parasti cujus erunt (Luc. XII, 20)? Et dives ille purpuratus, qui ante januas suas jacentem Lazarum contemnebat (Luc. XVI), omne quod fruitus est, instar nubis ac roris transisse cognovit. Semper autem prophetas haereticorum interficit Deus: dum aeterna cis supplicia comminatur, et aufert de vera vita, et morti scelerum derelinquit. Nos autem nubem diligamus illam, quae perpetua est, et quae a mundi hujus ardore nos protegit, cui sedens Dominus venit in AEgyptum, et omnia AEgyptiorum simulacra confregit. Amemus illum rorem, de quo Moyses loquitur: Descendant sicut ros verba mea (Deut. XXXII, 2). Et de quo Isaias dicit: Resurgent mortui, et resuscitabuntur qui in sepulcris sunt: ros enim qui a te est, sanitas eorum est (Isa.","english":"And the meaning is: Do not say, We believed the prophets, and they themselves we also killed, so that every occasion of sinning might be taken from you. We read in the volume of Kings that four hundred and fifty prophets of Baal were killed under Elijah (1 Kings 17), and another countless multitude under Jehu (2 Kings 10), who overthrew the house of Ahab. We understand these same things as said both to heretics and to the true Judah, who is to suffer similar things, because the Lord calls them to mercy and desires them to return to salvation. But they pursue the delights of this world and its refreshments like a cloud and dew that quickly passes away, to whom it is said in the Gospel: Fool, this night they will demand your soul from you; and the things you have prepared, whose will they be (Luke 12:20)? And that rich man clothed in purple, who despised Lazarus lying before his gates (Luke 16), recognized that everything he enjoyed had passed away like a cloud and dew. But God always kills the prophets of heretics, while he threatens them with eternal punishments, and takes them away from true life, and abandons them to the death of their crimes. But let us love that cloud which is perpetual, and which protects us from the heat of this world, upon which the Lord sitting came into Egypt, and shattered all the idols of the Egyptians. Let us love that dew, of which Moses speaks: Let my words descend like dew (Deuteronomy 32:2). And of which Isaiah says: The dead shall rise, and those who are in the tombs shall be raised up; for the dew that is from you is their healing (Isaiah","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":112,"ref":"p112","source":"XXVI, 19, sec. LXX). Sunt qui prophetas interfectos vere sanctos aestiment, eo quod causa populi peccatoris diam prophetae occisi sint, et hostibus traditi.\n\n(Vers. 6, 7.) « Quia misericordiam volui, et non sacrificium: et scientiam Dei plus quam holocausta; ipsi autem sicut Adam transgressi sunt pactum: ibi praevaricati sum in me. » LXX: « Quia misericordiam volo, et non sacrificium, scientiam Dei magis quam holocausta; ipsi vero sunt sicut homo praeteriens testamentum. » Quod sequitur in Septuaginta: Ibi contempsit me Calaad civitas, quas operatur vana, et reliqua, sequenti capitulo coaptanda sunt; nos quod proposuimus, disseramus: Dolavi eos in prophetis, occidi in verbis oris mei, gravia comminatus sum, ut misererer poenitentium, ut lapsis atque surgentibus porrigerem manum. Neque enim sacrificiis delector et victimis, et holocaustorum multitudine. Victimae meae et holocausta, salus credentium, et conversio peccatorum est. Ipsi autem imitati sunt Adam, ut quod ille in paradiso fecerat, pactum meum legemque praeteriens, isti in terra facerent. Et ibi, hoc est in paradiso, omnes praevaricati sunt in me, in similitudinem praevaricationis Adam. Non enim mirum si quod in parente praecessit, etiam in filiis condemnetur.","english":"XXVI, 19, according to the LXX). There are those who consider the prophets who were killed to have been truly holy, on the ground that the prophets were slain for the sake of a sinful people and handed over to their enemies.\n\n(On verses 6 and 7.) \"For I desired mercy, and not sacrifice: and the knowledge of God more than burnt offerings; but they, like Adam, have transgressed the covenant: there they have dealt treacherously against me.\" The LXX: \"For I desire mercy, and not sacrifice, the knowledge of God more than burnt offerings; but they themselves are like a man passing over a testament.\" What follows in the Septuagint: There Gilead, a city that works vanity, has despised me, and the rest, must be fitted to the following chapter; let us discuss what we have set before us: I hewed them by the prophets, I killed them by the words of my mouth, I threatened grievous things, so that I might show mercy to the penitent, so that I might extend my hand to the fallen and those rising again. For I take no delight in sacrifices and victims and a multitude of burnt offerings. My victims and burnt offerings are the salvation of believers and the conversion of sinners. But they themselves have imitated Adam, so that what he had done in paradise, transgressing my covenant and law, these should do on earth. And there, that is, in paradise, all have dealt treacherously against me, in the likeness of Adam's transgression. For it is no wonder if what came first in the parent is also condemned in the children.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":113,"ref":"p113","source":"Quotidie Deus et eos qui extra Ecclesiam sunt, et qui peccant in Ecclesia commorantes, provocat ad poenitentiam, et dicit eis: Misericordiam volo, et non sacrificium, et scientiam Dei plus quam holocausta. Illi vero offerunt panem sacrilegum, et dant eleemosynas, et sectari videntur humilitatem: quae ego. si vere fiant, holocausta interpretor. Cum autem scientiam Dei reliquerint, frustra, truncato capite fidei, caetera membra habere se jactant, praevaricati sunt enim pactum Dei in Ecclesia, sicut Adam praevaricatus est in paradiso; et imitatores se antiqui parentis ostendunt, ut quomodo ille de paradiso, sic et isti ejiciantur de Ecclesia.\n\n(Vers. 8.) « Galaad civitas operantium idolum, supplantata sanguine, et quasi fauces virorum latronum (sive viri latronis), utrumque enim legi potest 3. » LXX: « Ibi contempsit me Galaad, civitas quae operatur vana, et conturbat aquam, et fortitudo tua viri piratae. » Legimus in Ramoth Galaad unctum esse in regem Jehu (IV Reg. IX), qui sanguinem sanguini miscuit, et Achab subvertit domum, et ante solis ortum acervos capitum filiorum ejus jussit statui; in hac urbe trans Jordanem in possessione tribus Gad, idolum consecratum est: quae habitabatur a sacerdotibus, nam et ipsa fugitivorum civitas fuit.","english":"Every day God calls to repentance both those who are outside the Church and those who remain in the Church but sin, and he says to them: I desire mercy, and not sacrifice, and knowledge of God more than holocausts. But they offer sacrilegious bread, and give alms, and seem to pursue humility—which, if they were truly done, I interpret as holocausts. Yet when they have abandoned the knowledge of God, in vain, with the head of faith cut off, do they boast that they possess the other members; for they have transgressed the covenant of God in the Church, just as Adam transgressed in paradise; and they show themselves imitators of their ancient parent, so that just as he was cast out of paradise, so too these may be cast out of the Church.\n\n(Ver. 8.) \"Gilead is a city of those who work an idol, supplanted with blood, and like the jaws of robbers (or of a robber), for either can be read.\" The LXX: \"There Gilead despised me, a city that works vain things, and troubles the water, and your strength is that of a pirate.\" We read in Ramoth Gilead that Jehu was anointed king (2 Kings 9), who mixed blood with blood, and overthrew the house of Ahab, and before sunrise ordered piles of the heads of his sons to be set up; in this city beyond the Jordan, in the possession of the tribe of Gad, an idol was consecrated; and it was inhabited by priests, for it was itself also a city of fugitives.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":114,"ref":"p114","source":"Quanto igitur celebrior et majoris auctoritatis, quia in partem sacerdolum fuerat delegata, tanto trans Jordanem habitanti Israel principium idololatriae, et malorum omnium fuit, ut qui primi peccaverant, primi ab Assyriis caperentur. Et quoniam ipsa provincia plena est latrociniorum, comparat eos latronibus, ut quomodo illi viatoribus, sic sacerdotes simplicitati populi insidiati sunt. Porro secundum tropologiam, Galaad interpretatur transmigratio testimonii; et contemnit Deum, dum testimonia Scripturarum ad perversa depravat dogmata, et omnia opera illius vana sunt, conturbatque Ecclesiae aquas, et de purissimis fontibus coenosos et sordidos rivos facit, qui maculent potius quam mundent baptizatos. Omnisque fortitudo hujus urbis, quasi viri piratae est, dum imitatur diabolum, qui in hujus saeculi mari, in quo naves pertranseunt, insidiatur his qui ad portum pervenire contendunt. Denique Symmachus manifestius interpretatus est, dicens: Et fauces tuae quasi viri insidiatoris. De istiusmodi piratis in Job legimus: Non est dilatio piratis (Job XXV, 3, sec. LXX). Quamvis enim in praesenti saeculo se jactare videantur, et conturbare aquas, et operari vana, et exercere piraticam, tamen non est mora poenarum, quae eos velociter comprehendent.","english":"Therefore, by how much more celebrated and of greater authority it was, because it had been delegated to a portion of the priests, by so much was it the beginning of idolatry and of all evils for Israel dwelling beyond the Jordan, so that those who had sinned first were the first to be captured by the Assyrians. And because that province itself is full of robberies, he compares them to robbers, so that just as those lay in wait for travelers, so the priests lay in wait for the simplicity of the people. Furthermore, according to tropology, Gilead is interpreted as the transmigration of testimony; and it despises God, while it perverts the testimonies of the Scriptures into depraved doctrines, and all its works are vain, and it troubles the waters of the Church, and from the purest fountains it makes muddy and filthy streams, which defile rather than cleanse the baptized. And all the strength of this city is like that of pirate men, while it imitates the devil, who on the sea of this world, on which ships pass by, lies in wait for those who strive to reach the harbor. Finally, Symmachus translated more clearly, saying: And your jaws are like those of a man lying in wait. About pirates of this sort we read in Job: There is no delay for pirates. For although in the present age they seem to boast themselves, and to trouble the waters, and to work vain things, and to practice piracy, nevertheless there is no delay of punishments, which will swiftly seize them.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":115,"ref":"p115","source":"(Vers. 9.) « Particeps sacerdotum in via interficientium pergentes de Sichem: quia scelus operati sunt. » LXX:« Absconderunt sacerdotes viam Domini 2, interfecerunt Sicima: quia iniquitatem operati sunt. » Symmachus hoc locum ita interpretatus est: Societas sacerdotum in via interficie bant Sichem: Theodotion hoc modo: Absconderunt sacerdotes viam, interficiebant in dorso: Aquila, Participatio sacerdotum in via occidebant humeros: quorum cum intelligentiam juxta historiam quaereremus ab Hebraeo, ita nobis expositum est: Sacerdotes Bethel, imo fanatici Bethaven, temporibus Paschae et Pentecostes, et Scenopegiae, quando per Sichem, quae hodie Neapolis appellatur, eundum erat Jerosolymam, ubi solum licebat victimas immolare, ponebant in itinere latrones, qui insidiarentur pergentibus, ut magis vitulos aureos in Dan et in Bethaven, quam in Jerosolymis et in templo adorarent Deum. Quod autem dicit: Participatio et societas sacerdotum, conjurationem corum significat, et in malam partem consensum. Sin autem legerimus, ut nos interpretati sumus: particeps sacerdotum, ad Galaad, inquit, referendum est, quae operatur idolum: est et supplantata sanguine, quod sacerdotum impietatem secuta sit, et latrociniis vacet ac sanguini. Hoc illi dixerint: Nos autem dicamus intercludere haereticos viam, ne de Sichem, id est, de bonis operibus pergamus in Jerusalem, id est, in Ecclesiam.","english":"(Verse 9.) \"Partaker with priests on the way of those who kill travelers from Shechem: because they have wrought wickedness.\" The Septuagint: \"The priests hid the way of the Lord, they killed Shechem: because they have wrought iniquity.\" Symmachus interpreted this passage thus: \"A company of priests on the way were killing Shechem.\" Theodotion in this manner: \"The priests hid the way, they were killing on the ridge.\" Aquila: \"A sharing of priests on the way were killing the shoulders.\" When we sought the meaning of these according to history from the Hebrew, it was explained to us thus: The priests of Bethel, or rather the fanatics of Beth-aven, in the times of Passover and Pentecost and Tabernacles, when one had to travel through Shechem, which today is called Neapolis, to Jerusalem, where alone it was permitted to sacrifice victims, placed robbers on the route, who would lie in wait for travelers, so that they might worship God before the golden calves in Dan and in Beth-aven, rather than in Jerusalem and in the temple. But what he says: \"A sharing and company of priests,\" signifies their conspiracy and agreement for an evil purpose. If, however, we read as we have translated: \"partaker with priests,\" he says this must be referred to Galaad, which works an idol: it is also supplanted by blood, because it has followed the impiety of the priests and is free for robberies and bloodshed. Let them have said this: but let us say that heretics block the way, so that we may not travel from Shechem, that is, from good works, to Jerusalem, that is, to the Church.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":116,"ref":"p116","source":"Isti sunt quasi fauces virorum latronum, et interficiunt eos, qui per hujus saeculi viam ad veritatem pergere cupiunt. Sichem interpretatur 2, id est, humeri: in humeris opus intelligimus, et omnes falsi sacerdotes abscondunt viam, et occidunt homines malis operibus, ne perveniant Jerusalem. Quod autem humerus opus significet illud ostendit: Da cor tuum in humerum tuum (Gen. XLIX, 15), hoc est, quae intelligis, verto in opera. Et de Issachar legimus, quod supposuerit humerum suum ad laborandum, et vir agricola sit.\n\n(Vers. 10, 11.) « In domo Israel vidi horrendum, ibi fornicationes Ephraim, contaminatus est Israel; sed et, Juda, pone messem tibi, cum convertero captivitatem populi mei. » LXX: « In domo Israel vidi horribilia, ibi fornicationem Ephraim, contaminatus est Israel et Juda; incipe vindemiam tuam cum convertero captivitatem populi mei. » De hoc scelere ct horrore terribili est Jeremias locutus: Obstupuit coelum super hoc, et exhorruit terra vehementer (Jerem. II). Quid enim horribilius, quam decem tribus ad idolorum cultum repente transgressas? Unde ad metropolim earum dicitur: Auter vitulum tuum, Samaria, in qua primus fornicatus est Ephraim, id est, Jeroboam de tribu Ephraim, et illo fornicante, contaminatus Israel est, populus videlicet Samariae, qui magna ex parte commune Israelis nomen obtinuit.","english":"These are like the jaws of robbers, and they kill those who desire to travel along the way of this world toward the truth. Shechem is interpreted as \"shoulders,\" that is, in the shoulders we understand work, and all false priests hide the way and kill men by evil works, lest they arrive at Jerusalem. But that \"shoulder\" signifies work, that passage shows: \"Give your heart to your shoulder\" (Gen. 49:15), that is, what you understand, turn into works. And concerning Issachar we read that he put his shoulder to laboring, and was a man, a farmer.\n\n(Verses 10, 11.) \"In the house of Israel I have seen a horrible thing: there the fornications of Ephraim, Israel is contaminated; but also, Judah, set a harvest for yourself, when I turn back the captivity of my people.\" The Septuagint: \"In the house of Israel I have seen horrible things: there the fornication of Ephraim, Israel is contaminated, and Judah; begin your vintage, when I turn back the captivity of my people.\" Concerning this crime and terrible horror Jeremiah spoke: \"The heaven was astonished at this, and the earth shuddered greatly\" (Jer. 2). For what is more horrible than that the ten tribes suddenly transgressed to the worship of idols? Whence it is said to their metropolis: \"Take away your calf, Samaria,\" in which Ephraim first fornicated, that is, Jeroboam of the tribe of Ephraim, and while he fornicated, Israel was contaminated—namely the people of Samaria, which for the most part obtained the common name of Israel.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":117,"ref":"p117","source":"Unde et ad Judam sermo convertitur: Tu quoque Juda, pone messem tibi; et est sensus: Non te putes esse securum, quod Israel captivus abducitur; tu quoque praepara tibi segetes, ut metantur; non multo enim post tempore duceris captivus in Babylonem, et messionis tuae tempus adveniet. Cumque te Chaldaei messuerint, convertam rursum captivitatem populi mei, et sub Cyro rege Persarum, et Artaxerxe reducam populum meum. Et nota quam significanter Judae captivitas. et regressio pariter prophetetur; de Israel autem, hoc est, de decem tribubus, et nunc tacitum est, et si quando prosperum quid dicitur, in Christi differtur adventum. In domo autem haereticorum quotidie videmus horrenda: fornicantibus primum magistris, et populo qui ab eis inducitur sordidato Judae quoque, hoc est Ecclesiae, praecipitur, ut e ipse propter peccata paret sibi messem, sive vindemiam, cum judicii tempus advenerit. Sed huic ignoscitur, et veniam Dominus pollicetur, quia quem diligit corripi:, et castigat omnem filium quem recipit (Hebr. XII), ut probatum et purgatus condat in thesauros suos. Quidam hoc quod dixitur, Juda, incipe vindemiam tuam, sive, pone messem tibi, ad bonam partem referunt, ut punito Israel, iste operum suorum fructus recipiat juxta iilud quod scriptum est: Qui seminant in lacrymis, in gaudio metent (Psal. CXXV, 6). Nobis superior sensus magis placet.","english":"Hence the address is also turned to Judah: You too, Judah, set a harvest for yourself; and the meaning is: Do not think yourself secure because Israel is led away captive; you too, prepare crops for yourself, so that they may be reaped; for not long afterward you will be led captive into Babylon, and the time of your reaping will come. And when the Chaldeans have reaped you, I will again restore the captivity of my people, and under Cyrus king of the Persians and Artaxerxes I will bring my people back. And note how significantly the captivity of Judah and the return are prophesied together; but concerning Israel, that is, the ten tribes, it is now passed over in silence, and if anything prosperous is ever said, it is deferred to the coming of Christ. In the house of heretics, moreover, we see horrible things daily: with the teachers first fornicating, and the people who are led by them defiled, it is commanded to Judah also, that is, to the Church, that she herself, on account of sins, prepare a harvest for herself, or a vintage, when the time of judgment has come. But she is pardoned, and the Lord promises forgiveness, because whom he loves he rebukes, and he chastises every son whom he receives, so that, tested and purified, he may store him in his treasuries. Some refer what is said, Judah, begin your vintage, or, set a harvest for yourself, to a good sense, so that with Israel punished, this one may receive the fruit of his works, according to what is written: Those who sow in tears will reap in joy. The former meaning pleases us more.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":118,"ref":"p118","source":"(Cap. VII.—Vers. 1.) « Cum sanare vellem Israel, revelata est iniquitas Ephraim, et malitia Samariae: quia operati sunt mendacium, et fur ingressus est, spolians latrunculus foris 5. » LXX similiter. Multa saepe Israel idololatriae accepit vulnera, et maxime illud, quando in eremo vituli conflaverunt caput, atque dixerunt: Isti sunt dii tui, Israel, qui te eduxerunt de terra AEgypti (Exod. XXXII, 8). Unde ego qui malo poenitentiam peccatoris, quam mortem (Ezech. XVIII, XXXIII), et postea loquor in Evangelio: Non indigent sani medico, sed hi qui male habent (Luc. V, 31), vulnera populi mei sanare conatus sum. Et cum haec omni arte tractarem, ut miserabilis populus curaretur, subito exstitit Jeroboam de tribu Ephraim, qui vitulos aureos faceret, et malitia Samariae revelata est, sequentis regem impium: operati sunt enim et rex et populus mendacium, hoc est, idolum. Sicut enim contrarium est simulacrum Deo, ita mendacium veritati. Ipse autem rex instar furis ingressus est ad populum Israel, et quasi latrunculus infelicem plebem Dei exspoliavit auxilio. Et est sensus: Cum vellem vetera populi mei peccata delere, propter antiquam idololatriam, Ephraim et Samaria nova idola repererunt.","english":"(Cap. 7.—Ver. 1.) “When I would have healed Israel, the iniquity of Ephraim was revealed, and the malice of Samaria: because they wrought a lie, and the thief entered in, the robber spoiling outside.” The Septuagint similarly. Israel often received many wounds of idolatry, and especially that one, when in the wilderness they melted down the calf as their head, and said: These are your gods, Israel, who brought you out of the land of Egypt (Exod. 32:8). Whence I, who prefer the repentance of a sinner to his death (Ezek. 18, 33), and afterward speak in the Gospel: Those who are well do not need a physician, but those who are sick (Luke 5:31), have attempted to heal the wounds of my people. And when I was treating these with every skill, so that the wretched people might be cured, suddenly Jeroboam arose from the tribe of Ephraim, to make golden calves, and the malice of Samaria was revealed, of the one following an impious king: for both the king and the people wrought a lie, that is, an idol. For just as a graven image is contrary to God, so a lie is contrary to truth. But the king himself entered in like a thief to the people of Israel, and like a robber he despoiled the unhappy people of God of help. And the meaning is: When I wished to blot out the old sins of my people, on account of their ancient idolatry, Ephraim and Samaria devised new idols.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":119,"ref":"p119","source":"Sed et hoc dici potest, quod Domino Salvatore post effusionem sanguinis sui, et Ecclesiam suam tam de Judaeis quam de gentibus congregatam, volente populi peccata sanare, et eos ad poenitentiam reducere; subito Ephraim, qui ubertatem falsorum dogmatum repromittunt, et populus Samariae qui se dicit Dei praecepta servare, surrexerunt et operati sunt idolum falsorum dogmatum, et per illos ingressus est fur et latro diabolus in Ecclesiam: sive ipsa doctrina haereticorum ingressa est, quasi fur et latrunculus, de quibus Salvator dicit in Evangelio: Omnes qui venerunt ante me, fures fuerunt et latrones (Joan. X, 8). Fures insidiantur, et occulta fraude decipiunt: latrones audacter aliena diripiunt. Qui enim furantur, nocte furantur et in tenebris. Unde significanter ait, quod fur ingressus clam sit, et latrunculus exspoliet foris. Non enim possunt exspoliare veste Christi quos docuerunt, nisi eos de Ecclesia foras eduxerint, et in perversa doctrinarum suarum via fecerint ambulare. Fures et latrones qui venerunt ante Dominum, non Moysen et prophetas qui semper Salvatoris ore laudantur, sed pseudoprophetas debemus accipere, et postea haereticos, qui non missi sunt a Domino, sed sua voluntate venerunt.","english":"But this too can be said: that when the Lord Savior, after the shedding of his blood, willed to heal the sins of the people and to bring them back to repentance—the Church having been gathered both from the Jews and from the Gentiles—suddenly Ephraim, who promise the richness of false doctrines, and the people of Samaria, who claim to keep God's commandments, rose up and wrought an idol of false doctrines, and through them the thief and robber, the devil, entered into the Church; or the very doctrine of the heretics entered in like a thief and a brigand, of whom the Savior says in the Gospel: All who came before me were thieves and robbers (John 10:8). Thieves lie in ambush and deceive by hidden fraud; robbers boldly plunder what belongs to others. For those who steal, steal by night and in darkness. Hence he says significantly that the thief entered in secretly, and the brigand plunders outside. For they cannot strip of Christ's garment those whom they have taught, unless they have led them out of the Church and made them walk in the perverse way of their doctrines. By the thieves and robbers who came before the Lord, we must understand not Moses and the prophets, who are always praised by the Savior's mouth, but the false prophets, and afterward the heretics, who were not sent by the Lord but came by their own will.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":120,"ref":"p120","source":"(Vers. 2.) « Et ne forte dicant in cordibus suis, omnis malitiae eorum me recordatum: nunc circumdederunt eos adinventiones suae: coram facie mea factae sunt. » LXX: « Ut concinant quasi canentes in cordibus suis, omnes malitias eorum recordatus sum: nunc circumdederunt eos cogitationes suae, contra faciem meam factae sunt. » Ne forsitan, inquit, dicant in cordibus suis: vetera nobis Deus peccata restituit, et patrum delicta persolvimus: illi comederunt uvam acerbam, et dentes filiorum obstupuerunt (Jerem. XXXI); idcirco quae nunc et in praesentiarum, me vidente, fecerant, et quotidie faciunt, sequenti sermone narrabo, et ostendam illis adinventiones suas, sive cogitationes quibus mala studiosissime consectati sunt, et quae me praesente gesserunt, non timentes faciem meam. Quod autem in Septuaginta legimus, ut concinant quasi canentes in cordibus suis, ad illud referendum est, quod ideo fur ingressus, sive latrunculus exspoliaverit foris, ne in pristinis divitiis et vestibus permanentes, repellerent furis latronisque consensum; sed cum spoliati fuerint, concinant cum eis, et uno corde efficiantur (dist. 4, de Poenit., cap. Cum ita): idcirco recipient quae fecerunt, et omnes cogitationes eorum vel opera meum non merebuntur aspectum.","english":"(Verse 2.) \"And lest perhaps they say in their hearts, I have remembered all their malice: now their own inventions have surrounded them: they have been made before my face.\" The Septuagint: \"That they may sing together as it were singing in their hearts, I have remembered all their malice: now their own thoughts have surrounded them: they have been made against my face.\" Lest perhaps, he says, they say in their hearts: God has restored to us old sins, and we are paying for the offenses of our fathers: the fathers ate a sour grape, and the teeth of the children were numbed (Jeremiah 31); therefore what they have now done and are doing at present, while I see, and do daily, I will narrate in the following discourse, and I will show them their own inventions, or the thoughts by which they have most eagerly pursued evil, and which they have carried out in my presence, not fearing my face. But what we read in the Septuagint, \"that they may sing together as it were singing in their hearts,\" must be referred to this: that the thief who entered, or the little robber, has despoiled them outside, so that, not remaining in their former riches and garments, they might repel the consent of the thief and robber; but when they have been despoiled, they may sing together with them, and be made one heart (dist. 4, de Poenit., cap. Cum ita): therefore they will receive what they have done, and all their thoughts or works will not merit my regard.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":121,"ref":"p121","source":"Haeretici quoque non possunt vetera contra Deum peccata causari; cum quotidie antiquis operibus novam addant impietatem, et cum perditis pereant, suisque ligentur erroribus, et cum Deum se coelare putent, oculos ejus vitare non valeant.\n\n(Vers. 3.) « In malitia sua laetificaverunt regem, et in mendaciis suis principes. » LXX: « In malitiis suis laetificaverunt reges, et in mendaciis suis principes. » Exponit quae coram facie ejus fecerunt: In malitiis suis laetificaverunt regem Jeroboam, et in mendaciis suis principes qui sub Jeroboam populo praefuerant. Haeretici quoque in malitia operum suorum laetificaverunt regem diabolum, et in mendaciis dogmatum perversorum principes, haud dubium quin mundi hujus, quorum falsam sapientiam destruit Deus. Possumus regem apud haereticos dicere, qui primus haeresim repent, et principes eos qui praepositi haereticorum populis, falsum sibi vindicant sacerdotium. Et simul notandum, quod in peccatis nostris gaudeant contrariae fortitudines et rectores ac principes tenebrarum istarum.","english":"Heretics too cannot plead as an excuse the ancient sins committed against God, since daily they add new impiety to old works, and perish with the lost, and are bound by their own errors; and though they think they hide themselves from God, they are unable to avoid His eyes.\n\n(Verse 3.) \"In their malice they have made the king glad, and in their lies the princes.\" The Septuagint: \"In their malices they have made the kings glad, and in their lies the princes.\" He explains what they did before His face: in their malices they made King Jeroboam glad, and in their lies the princes who had charge of the people under Jeroboam. Heretics too, in the malice of their works, have made the devil their king glad, and in the lies of their perverse doctrines the princes—undoubtedly of this world—whose false wisdom God destroys. We can call \"king\" among the heretics the one who first introduced the heresy, and \"princes\" those who, set over the peoples of the heretics, claim for themselves a false priesthood. And at the same time it must be noted that in our sins the opposing powers rejoice, and the rulers and princes of these darknesses.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":122,"ref":"p122","source":"(Vers. 4.) « Omnes adulterantes quasi clibanus succensus a coquente: quievit paululum civitas a commixtione fermenti, donec fermentaretur totum. » LXX: « Omnes adulterantes quasi clibanus ardens sid coquendum in deustionem flammae a commixtione fermenti, donec fermentaretur totum. « Qui in malitia sua laetificaverunt regem, et in mendaciis suis principes, omnes adulteri sunt, et instar clibani ab Jeroboam idololatriae igne succensi, ut panem coquerent impietatis, qui cum erroris in animas eorum misisset incendium, quasi caminus et clibanus primo igne succensus, paululum conquievit, ut non vim faceret populo, sed suae eum dimitteret voluntati, donec fermentaretur omne mendacium: quidquid enim necessitate fit, cito solvitur: quod voluntate arripitur, perseverat. Ideo et hic quia translationem a clibano sumpserat, qui ad coquendos panes succenditur, servat in reliquis, ut in commixtione fermenti totius populi monstret assensum, quo scilicet et rex et populus pari in idololatria ardore corruerint. Haereticorum corda diaboli igne succensa, ut in eis panes coquantur Antichristi, nemo ambigit, qui idcirco primum quiescunt in Ecclesia, et loquuntur occulte, et omnia pacifica repromittunt 1, ut cancer paulatim serpat in populos, et fermentum doctrinae eorum (quod et Dominus intelligens loquitur, Cavete a fermento Pharisaeorum (Matth.","english":"(Verse 4.) \"All adulterers are like an oven heated by a baker: the city rested a little from the mixture of leaven, until the whole was leavened.\" The Septuagint: \"All adulterers are like an oven burning for baking, for the burning of flame from the mixture of leaven, until the whole was leavened.\" Those who in their malice have made the king glad, and in their lies the princes, are all adulterers, and like an oven kindled by Jeroboam with the fire of idolatry, so as to bake the bread of impiety. When he had cast the fire of error into their souls, like a furnace and an oven first kindled with fire, he rested a little, so as not to do violence to the people but to leave them to their own will, until every lie was leavened. For whatever is done by necessity is quickly dissolved; what is seized upon by will perseveres. Therefore here too, because he had taken up the metaphor of an oven, which is kindled for baking bread, he keeps it in what follows, so that in the mixture of leaven he may show the consent of the whole people—namely, that both king and people fell together in an equal ardor for idolatry. No one doubts that the hearts of heretics are kindled by the fire of the devil, so that the bread of Antichrist may be baked in them. For this reason they first rest quietly in the Church, and speak in secret, and promise everything peaceful, so that the cancer may creep gradually among the peoples, and the leaven of their doctrine—which the Lord also, understanding it, speaks of: \"Beware of the leaven of the Pharisees\" (Matthew","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":123,"ref":"p123","source":"XVI, 6) cum intumuerit in cordibus deceptorum, tunc in apertam porumpunt insaniam, et impletur in cis quod a Joanne apostolo dicitur: Ex nobis exierunt, sed non fuerunt ex nobis: si enim fuissent ex nobis, mansissent utique nobiscum (I Joan. II, 19).\n\n(Vers. seq.) « Dies regis nostri: coeperunt principes furere a vino: extendit manum suam cum illusoribus, qui applicuerunt quasi clibanum cor suum cum insidiaretur eis. Tota nocte dormivit coquens eos, mane ipse succensus quasi ignis flammae: omnes calefacti sunt quasi clibanus, et devoraverunt judices suos, omnes reges eorum ceciderunt, non est qui clamet ad me ex (Vulg. in) eis. » LXX: « Dies regum vestrorum. Coeperunt principes furere a vino: extendit manum suam cum pestilentibus, quia succensa sunt quasi clibanus corda eorum, cum praecipitarentur tota nocte. Ephraim somno repletus est: mane factum est, incensus est quasi ignis flammae. Omnes calefacti sunt quasi clibanus ignis ardens, et ignis devoravit judices suos. Omnes reges eorum ceciderunt: non est in eis qui invocet (??). » Obscurus locus et attento lectoris sensu indigens, ut primum historiam cognoscamus.","english":"16, 6) when it has swelled in the hearts of the deceived, then they burst forth into open madness, and there is fulfilled in them what is said by John the apostle: \"They went out from us, but they were not of us; for if they had been of us, they would surely have remained with us\" (1 John 2:19).\n\n(Following verse.) \"The day of our king: the princes began to rage from wine: he stretched out his hand with mockers, who applied their heart like an oven while they lay in wait for him. All night the baker slept, warming them; in the morning he himself was kindled like a flame of fire: all were heated like an oven, and they devoured their judges, all their kings fell, there is none among them who cries to me.\" The Septuagint: \"The day of your kings. The princes began to rage from wine: he stretched out his hand with the pestilent, because their hearts were kindled like an oven, when they were cast down all night. Ephraim was filled with sleep: morning came, he was kindled like a flame of fire. All were heated like an oven of burning fire, and fire devoured their judges. All their kings fell: there is none among them who calls upon (??).\" The passage is obscure and requires the attentive understanding of the reader, so that we may first learn the history.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":124,"ref":"p124","source":"Paulum Israel et Samariae civitas conquievit, recepto in se erroris ardore, donec lota massa fermento similis fieret, et cresceret atque erumperet, ac populus intumescens clamaret ad fores Jeroboam regis, et diceret: Hic est dies Jeroboam regis nostri, hic est festus dies quem nobis constituit imperator noster, hunc celebramus, hunc canimus, in hoc exsultamus et ludimus, in hoc vitulos aureos adoramus. Clamante populo, principes non irati sunt, ut quidum putant; sed et ipsi coeperunt furere a vino, et intelligentiam suae mentis amittere, oblivisci Dei, et in idolorum ligna impingere. Quod cum rex cerneret, clamare scilicet populum et dicere, dies iste regis nostri est, et principes quasi temulentos et fanaticos, nescire quid dicerent, extendit manum suam illusoribus, populavit assensum his qui ei vanis laudibus illudebant. Qui illusores, cum insidiaretur eis rex suus, et eos a Deo suo abduceret, praebuerunt ei quasi clibanum cor suum, ut cos succenderet et idololatriae flammis ardere faceret. Idcirco enim assensus est populo, quia intellexit omni eos ad errorem mente conversos.","english":"A little while the city of Israel and Samaria was at rest, having received into itself the heat of error, until the whole mass became like leaven, and grew and burst forth, and the people, swelling up, cried out at the gates of Jeroboam the king, and said: This is the day of Jeroboam our king, this is the festal day which our commander has appointed for us; this we celebrate, this we sing, in this we exult and play, in this we adore the golden calves. While the people cried out, the princes were not angered, as some think; but they too began to rage from wine, and to lose the understanding of their mind, to forget God, and to stumble against stocks of idols. When the king saw this—namely, that the people were crying out and saying, This is the day of our king—and that the princes, as if drunken and frenzied, did not know what they were saying, he stretched out his hand to the mockers, he laid waste the assent of those who were mocking him with empty praises. These mockers, when their king lay in wait for them and led them away from their God, offered him their heart like an oven, so that he might kindle them and make them burn with the flames of idolatry. For this reason he assented to the people, because he understood that they were wholly turned in mind to error.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":125,"ref":"p125","source":"Quodque sequitur: Tota nocte dormivit coquens eos, mane ipse succensus est quasi ignis flammae, hoc significat: postquam misit ignem in clibanum cordis eorum, et vidit cos furere, et nullum esse qui suae resisteret voluntati, lota nocte dormivit, id est, securus fuit: versatus in tenebris est, dum illi coquerentur et impietatis panem efficerent. Unde postea surrexit mane, et scelerum suorum flammam aperta ostendit insania, ut nequaquam per insidias, sed impudenter a Dei cultu ad idolorum caeremonias transilirent. Quid plura? omnes quasi clibanus, idololatriae igne calefacti sunt, et devoraverunt judices suos, ut etiam qui bonus esse potuerat per naturam, et religionis Domini recordari, videns et principes et populum vitulis subditos, et illos putare deos, etiam ipse a scelere devoraretur. Denique omnes reges ceciderunt Israel, et ambulaverunt in viis Jeroboam filii Nabath, qui peccare fecit Israel, et nullus inventus est qui, desertis idolis, reverteretur ad Deum. Haec juxta Hebraeorum traditionem audacter magis quam scienter locuti sumus, fidem dictorum auctoribus relinquentes.","english":"And what follows: All night he slept, baking them; in the morning he himself was kindled like a flame of fire—this signifies: after he sent fire into the oven of their heart, and saw them raging, and that there was no one to resist his will, he slept all night, that is, he was secure; he occupied himself in darkness, while they were being baked and were making the bread of impiety. Whence afterward he rose in the morning, and by open madness showed forth the flame of his crimes, so that they might leap over, no longer by ambush but shamelessly, from the worship of God to the ceremonies of idols. What more? All were heated like an oven by the fire of idolatry, and they devoured their judges, so that even one who could have been good by nature, and mindful of the religion of the Lord, seeing both the princes and the people subject to calves, and thinking them gods, might himself also be devoured by crime. Finally all the kings of Israel fell, and they walked in the ways of Jeroboam son of Nabath, who made Israel sin, and no one was found who, having abandoned the idols, would return to God. These things, according to the tradition of the Hebrews, we have spoken with boldness rather than knowledge, leaving the credibility of the statements to their authors.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":126,"ref":"p126","source":"Nunc ad spiritualem intelligentiam transeamus: Infelices populi, qui a rege diabolo, et ab ejus principibus seducuntur: sive qui ab haerescos principe, et ejus ducibus solemnitates alias susceperunt, relinquentes Ecclesiam, et veritatem conculcantes fidei, solent clamare et dicere: Haec est dies regis nostri: verbi gratia, Valentini, Marcionis, Arii, atque Eunomii. Quod audientes qui eis praepositi sunt, non inebriantur vino, ne leve putetur esse peccatum; sed insaniunt ex vino, de quo Moyses scripsit in Cantico Deuteronomii: Furor draconum vinum eorum, et furor aspidum insanabilis (Deut. XXXII, 33): hi enim comedunt cibos impietatis, et vino iniquitatis inebriantur. De quo dicit et Apostolus: Nolite inebriari vino, in quo est luxuria (Ephes. V, 18). Et in Proverbiis legimus: Principes vinum non bibant: ne obliviscantur sapientiae, et recta judicare non possint (Prov. XXXI, 4, 5). Unde deceptis et populis et ducibus, princeps extendit manum suam vel illusoribus et pestilentibus, quales erant filii Heli, et de quibus in primo psalmo legimus: In cathedra pestilentium non sedit (Psal. I, 1); de quo dicitur: Ejice pestilentem de consilio, et egredietur cum eo contentio (Prov. XXII, 10): quorum succensa sunt corda, ut allidant quos deceperint. Hoc enim juxta Septuaginta significant cataractae, quae non sursum levant, sed allidunt deorsum.","english":"Now let us pass over to the spiritual understanding. Unhappy peoples, who are led astray by the devil as their king and by his princes—or who, led astray by the prince of heresy and his leaders, have taken up other solemnities, forsaking the Church and trampling underfoot the truth of the faith—are accustomed to cry out and say: This is the day of our king: for example, of Valentinus, Marcion, Arius, and Eunomius. And those set over them, hearing this, are not merely drunk with wine, lest the sin be thought trivial; rather they rave from the wine of which Moses wrote in the Song of Deuteronomy: The fury of dragons is their wine, and the incurable fury of asps. For these eat the foods of impiety and are intoxicated with the wine of iniquity. Of this the Apostle also says: Be not drunk with wine, in which is debauchery. And in Proverbs we read: Princes should not drink wine, lest they forget wisdom and be unable to judge rightly. Hence, with both peoples and leaders deceived, the prince stretches out his hand—or rather, the mockers and the pestilent, such as were the sons of Eli, and of whom we read in the first psalm: He did not sit in the chair of pestilence; of whom it is said: Cast out the pestilent man from the council, and contention will go out with him—their hearts have been set ablaze, that they may dash to pieces those whom they have deceived. For according to the Septuagint, this is what the cataracts signify: they do not lift upward, but dash downward.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":127,"ref":"p127","source":"Quodque dicit: Tota nocte Ephraim in somno repletus est, ostendit haereticos dormientes lucem solis justitiae non videre. Qui enim dormiunt, nocte dormiunt, quia oppressus est sensus eorum. Et de his in Psalmis legimus: Dormierunt somnum suum. et nihil invenerunt (Psal. LXXV, 6). Horum corda calefiunt variis perturbationibus: ira, amore, avaritia; et devorant judices suos, vel si quid possunt in animo habere virtutum, vel sensus quibus mala discernunt a bonis. Sive hoc dicendum quod duces haereticorum a suis populis devorentur, ut quorum domos devorant turpis lucri gratia, ipsi eorum devorentur assensu. Omnes haereticorum principes ceciderunt: quamvis clamet ad Dominum, nullus est qui invocet nomen ejus: Omnis enim qui invocaverit nomen Domini, salvus erit (Rom. X. 13). Moyses et Aaron in sacerdotibus ejus, et Samuel inter eos qui invocant nomen ejus: invocabant Dominum, et ipse exaudiebat illos (Psal. XCVIII, 6). qui haereticorum reges et principes non exaudit, quia non est inter cos qui clamet ad Dominum.","english":"And what he says: Ephraim has been filled with sleep all night, shows that heretics, sleeping, do not see the light of the sun of righteousness. For those who sleep, sleep at night, because their understanding has been weighed down. And concerning these we read in the Psalms: They slept their sleep, and found nothing. Their hearts grow warm with various disturbances: anger, love, greed; and they devour their judges, or whatever power of virtues they can hold in their mind, or the senses by which they distinguish evil from good. Or this must be said: that the leaders of the heretics are devoured by their own peoples, so that those whose houses they devour for the sake of shameful gain are themselves devoured by their people's assent. All the princes of the heretics have fallen; although he cries out to the Lord, there is no one who calls upon his name: For everyone who calls upon the name of the Lord will be saved. Moses and Aaron among his priests, and Samuel among those who call upon his name: they called upon the Lord, and he himself heard them—he who does not hear the kings and princes of the heretics, because there is no one among them who cries out to the Lord.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":128,"ref":"p128","source":"(Vers. 8–10.) « Ephraim in populis ipse commiscebatur, Ephraim factus est subcinericius panis 1, qui non reversatur: comederunt alieni robur ejus, et ipse nescivit: sed et cani effusi sunt in eo, et ipse ignoravit; et humiliabitur superbia Israel in facie ejus; nec reversi sunt ad Dominum Deum suum, et non quaesierunt eum in omnibus his. » LXX: « Ephraim populis suis commiscebatur: Ephraim factus est subcinericius. qui non reversatur: comederunt alieni fortitudinem ejus, ipse vero nescivit, et cani effloruerunt ei, et ipse ignovit: et humiliabitur contumelia Israel in facie ejus, et non sunt reversi ad Dominum Deum suum, et non quaesierunt eum in omnibus his. » Factum est regnum decem tribuum, sicut omnium nationum, quia recesserunt a Domino: et sicut subcinericius panis, qui non reversatur, hoc est, non agit poenitentiam, comederunt Assyrii atque Chaldaei fortitudinem ejus, et quidquid virium habere poterat, devoraverunt. Tantaeque vecordiae fuit, ut devoratum esse se nesciret: aut certe ignoraret causam propter quam fuisset devorantibus traditus: denique usque ad senectutem, id est, usque ad ultimam captivitatem, in coepto errore permansit. Unde humiliabitur superbia Israel non multo post tempore, sed nunc et in praesenti: hoc est enim quod dicit, in facie ejus: humiliabitur autem, quia se erexerat et non in Deo, sed in multitudine confidebat exercitus.","english":"Ephraim mixed himself among the peoples; Ephraim has become a bread baked under ashes, which is not turned over: foreigners have eaten his strength, and he himself did not know; moreover, gray hairs also have been poured out upon him, and he himself did not know; and the pride of Israel will be humbled before his face; and they have not returned to the Lord their God, and they have not sought him in all these things. The Septuagint: Ephraim mixed himself among his peoples: Ephraim has become a bread baked under ashes, which is not turned over: foreigners have eaten his strength, but he himself did not know, and gray hairs have blossomed forth for him, and he himself did not know: and the disgrace of Israel will be humbled before his face, and they have not returned to the Lord their God, and they have not sought him in all these things. The kingdom of the ten tribes became like that of all the nations, because they withdrew from the Lord: and like a bread baked under ashes, which is not turned over, that is, does not do penance, the Assyrians and Chaldeans ate his strength, and whatever vigor he could have, they devoured. And he was of such great folly that he did not know he had been devoured: or at least he did not know the reason for which he had been handed over to those devouring him: finally, even to old age, that is, to the final captivity, he remained in the error he had begun. Whence the pride of Israel will be humbled not a long time afterward, but now and in the present: for this is what he says, before his face: but it will be humbled, because he had raised himself up and trusted not in God, but in the multitude of his army.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":129,"ref":"p129","source":"Et quia superbis Deus resistit, humilibus autem dat gratiam (Jac. IV); pro superbia, id est, GAON ( ) more suo Septuaginta, id est, injuriam, transtulerunt. Et quia supra dixerat: Ephraim factus est subcinericius panis qui non reversatur, et videbatur ambiguum, nec satis sonare quid diceret, nunc ponit manifestius: Non sunt reversi ad Dominum Deum suum, et non quaesierunt eum in omnibus his. Quod si fuissent reversi ad Dominum Deum suum, audissent utique per Jeremiam loquentem Deum, Revertimini ad me, et ego revertar ad vos. Et cum tanta fecerint, non quaesierunt eum, quem suo vitio perdiderunt. Cum autem debeat Ephraim 2, ut ad sensum alium transeamus, docere populos, et ad similitudinem sui trahere, ipse populis commiscetur, et similis eorum efficitur, juxta quod supra dictum est: Erit sicut populus, sic sacerdos. Sive Ephraim populis et gentibus commiscetur, ut omnes haeretici nihil differant ab errore gentilium. Et qui quondam fuit princeps in Ecclesia, factus est subcinericius panis, ex omni parte immundo cinere et ignium ardore circumdatus, ut non reverteretur ad Dominum, sed in coepto permaneret errore.","english":"And because God resists the proud, but gives grace to the humble, for pride—that is, GAON—the Septuagint, according to their custom, translated as injury. And because he had said above: Ephraim has become a bread baked under ashes, which is not turned over, and it seemed ambiguous, nor did it sufficiently sound forth what he meant, now he states it more plainly: They have not returned to the Lord their God, and they have not sought him in all these things. But if they had returned to the Lord their God, they would certainly have heard God speaking through Jeremiah: Return to me, and I will return to you. And although they had done so many things, they did not seek him, whom they had lost by their own fault. But whereas Ephraim ought, to pass over to another meaning, to teach the peoples and draw them to likeness of himself, he himself is mixed in among the peoples and becomes like them, according to what was said above: The people will be like the priest. Or else Ephraim is mixed in among peoples and nations, so that all heretics differ in no way from the error of the gentiles. And he who was once a leader in the Church has become a bread baked under ashes, surrounded on every side by unclean ash and the heat of fires, so that he would not return to the Lord, but would remain in the error he had begun.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":130,"ref":"p130","source":"Comederunt daemones robur ejus: isti sunt enim alieni et hostes omnium Christianorum, et ipse nescivit, adversarios amicos putans, et devoratores suos arbitrans esse convivas: sed et cani effusi sunt in eo, imo effloruerunt, id est, multo erravit tempore; et nihilominus ignoravit senectutem et vetustatem suam, de qua scriptum est: Quod veteratur et senescit, prope exterminium est (Hebr. VIII, 13). Et si ad justum virum, et ad ecclesiasticum dicitur: Cani hominis sapientia ejus (Sap. IV, 8): quare non dicatur ad iniquum, et ad haereticum: Cani hominis stultitia ejus? De hac senectute Daniel dicebat ad presbyterum: Inveterate dierum malorum (Dan. XIII, 52). Unde et in libro Pastoris (si cui tamen placet illius recipere lectionem) Hermae primum videtur Ecclesia cano capite, deinde adolescentula, et sponsa crinibus adornata. Cumque humilietur superbia haereticorum, sive contumelia, quam quotidie faciunt ecclesiasticis viris, non revertentur ad Dominum; sed in omnibus his nequaquam requirunt eum: quia calefacti sunt quasi clibanus, et non quaesierunt eum: devoraverunt judices eorum, et reges pariter conciderunt, nec est qui clamet ad Dominum. Quae universa perpessi sunt, ut Dominum quaererent, quem quaerere noluerunt.","english":"The demons have devoured his strength: for these are the aliens and enemies of all Christians, and he himself did not know it, thinking adversaries to be friends and reckoning his devourers to be his dinner guests. But also his gray hairs have been poured out upon him—indeed, have blossomed forth—that is, he wandered astray for a long time; and nevertheless he did not recognize his old age and his decay, of which it is written: That which grows old and ages is near to destruction (Heb. 8:13). And if it is said of the just man and the churchman: The gray hairs of a man are his wisdom (Wis. 4:8), why should it not be said of the wicked man and the heretic: The gray hairs of a man are his folly? Of this old age Daniel spoke to the elder: You who are grown old in evil days (Dan. 13:52). Whence also in the book of the Shepherd—if, that is, anyone is pleased to accept the reading of that work—the Church first appears to Hermas with gray hair, then as a young woman, and as a bride adorned with tresses. And although the pride of heretics is humbled, or the insult which they daily offer to churchmen, they will not return to the Lord; but in all these things they by no means seek him: because they have been heated like an oven, and they have not sought him; they have devoured their judges, and their kings have fallen together, and there is no one who cries out to the Lord. All of which they have suffered so that they might seek the Lord, whom they were unwilling to seek.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":131,"ref":"p131","source":"(Vers. 11, 12.) « Et factus est Ephraim quasi columba seducta non habens cor. AEgyptum invocabant, ad Assyrios abierunt: et cum profecti fuerint extendam super eos rete meum, quasi volucrem coeli detraham eos, caedam illos secundum auditionem coetus eorum. » LXX: « Et erat Ephraim quasi columba incipiens non habens cor. AEgyptum invocavit, et in Assyrios abierunt sicut ibunt. Mittam super eos rete meum, ut volatilia coeli detraham illos, corripiam eos in auditu tribulationis eorum. » Praecepit Dominus in Evangelio (Matth. X) ut simus simplices quasi columbae, et astuti quasi serpentes, ut imitantes simplicitatem columbarum, et serpentis astutiam, nec aliis nocere possimus, nec ab aliis patiamur insidias, sed simplicitate et prudentia exhibeamus hominem temperatum: quia prudentia absque bonitate, malitia est: et simplicitas absque ratione, stultitia nominatur. Factus est ergo Ephraim quasi columba seducta, quod Hebraice PHOTHA ( ): ab Aquila et Symmacho,, vel dicitur, id est, lactata, sive decepta: et a Septuaginta insipiens, sive insensata: enim utrumque exprimere potest. Et pulchre columba seducta, sive insipiens appellatur, quia est columba et sapiens, quae dicit in Psalmis: Quis dabit mihi pennas sicut columbae, et volabo et requiescam (Psal. LIV, 7)? Cujus pennae deargentatae sunt, et posteriora dorsi ejus in virore auri.","english":"And Ephraim has become like a deceived dove, having no heart. They called upon Egypt, they went to the Assyrians: and when they have set out, I will spread my net over them, I will bring them down like a bird of the sky, I will strike them according to the hearing of their assembly. The Septuagint: And Ephraim was like a dove beginning, having no heart. It called upon Egypt, and they went to the Assyrians as they will go. I will send my net over them, that I may bring them down like the birds of the sky, I will reprove them at the hearing of their tribulation. The Lord commanded in the Gospel that we be simple as doves and cunning as serpents, so that, imitating the simplicity of doves and the cunning of the serpent, we may neither be able to harm others nor suffer plots from others, but by simplicity and prudence may present a well-tempered man: because prudence without goodness is malice, and simplicity without reason is called folly. Ephraim therefore became like a deceived dove, which in Hebrew is PHOTHA: by Aquila and Symmachus it is rendered as, that is, enticed or deceived; and by the Septuagint as foolish or senseless: for it can express both. And fittingly is it called a deceived or foolish dove, because there is also a dove that is wise, which says in the Psalms: Who will give me wings like a dove, and I will fly away and rest? Whose wings are silvered, and whose back is in the greenness of gold.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":132,"ref":"p132","source":"Ephraim autem columba insipiens, et non habens cor, intantum brutae mentis ostenditur, ut AEgyptum invocans, ad Assyrios perrexerit. Qui enim deprecatus AEgyptiorum auxilium est, ab Assyriis captivus abducitur. Baculus arundineus AEgyptus, cui qui innixus fuerit, statim conteret eum, et fractus atque contritus manum transforat incumbentis. Et ut ostenderet Deus, quod commutantes loca, oculos ejus vitare non possumus, et semper Dei regimur potestate: Cum inquit, profecti fuerint in Assyrios, etiam ibi extendam rete meum, et si exaltati fuerint ut volucres, inde detraham illos. Detraham illos autem non in perditionem, sed ut caedam quasi filios: et caedam non in poenarum magnitudine, sed in timore, ut audientes ventura supplicia, solis terroribus emendentur. Quaeritur cur Ephraim non aliis avibus, sed columbae comparatus sit. Aves caeterae pullos suos etiam cum periculo vitae suae protegere festinant, et cum ad nidum suum accipitrem, colubrum, corvum, sive cornicem accedere viderint, huc illucque volitant, et immittunt se morsu, et unguibus lacerant, et dolorem parentis querula voce testantur; sola columba ablatos pullos non dolet, non requirit: et ideo huic recte comparatur Ephraim, quod vastatum per partes populum non sentiat, sed negligens sit salutis suae.","english":"But Ephraim is a foolish dove, and having no heart, to such an extent is he shown to be of brutish mind, that calling upon Egypt, he has gone to the Assyrians. For he who has implored the aid of the Egyptians is led away captive by the Assyrians. Egypt is a staff of reed, which, when anyone has leaned upon it, immediately breaks it, and being broken and crushed, pierces the hand of the one leaning on it. And to show that we, by changing places, cannot avoid his eyes, and are always governed by God's power: When, he says, they have set out to the Assyrians, even there I will spread my net, and if they have been lifted up like birds, from there I will bring them down. But I will bring them down not to destruction, but that I may strike them as sons: and I will strike them not in the magnitude of punishments, but in fear, so that hearing of the coming torments, they may be corrected by terrors alone. It is asked why Ephraim is compared not to other birds, but to a dove. Other birds hasten to protect their young even at the risk of their own lives, and when they see a hawk, a snake, a crow, or a raven approaching their nest, they fly hither and thither, and hurl themselves with bites, and tear with claws, and testify to a parent's grief with a plaintive voice; the dove alone does not grieve for young taken away, does not seek them: and therefore Ephraim is rightly compared to it, because he does not feel the people laid waste in parts, but is negligent of his own salvation.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":133,"ref":"p133","source":"Quodque dicit, caedam eos secundum auditionem coetus corum, hoc significare potest: sicut juncto consilio omnes idola fabricati sunt: ita me irato omnes pariter vastabuntur. Magistros contrariorum dogmatum, qui Christum reliquere sapientiam, et de Ecclesia sunt egressi, recte insipientem et excordem columbam possumus dicere, qui terrena desiderantes, Assyriis traditi sunt et cum profecti fuerint de Ecclesia, expandit Dominus super eos rete suum, testimoniis Scripturarum, et artifici sapientiae sermone contextum, ut elevantes se contra sapientiam Dei, et instar avis ad excelsa volitantes, ad humilia detrahat, et corripiat eos comminatione, et auditione poenarum, ut correcti non pareant in aeternum.\n\n(Vers. 13.) « Vae eis, quoniam recesserunt a me: vastabuntur, quia praevaricati sunt in me. Ego redemi eos, et ipsi locuti sunt contra me mendacia, et non clamaverunt ad me in corde suo, sed ululabant in cubilibus suis. » LXX: « Vae eis, quoniam recesserunt a me: manifesti sunt quoniam impie egerunt in me: ego vero redemi eos: ipsi vero locuti sunt contra me mendacium, et non clamaverunt ad me corda eorum, sed ululabant in cubilibus suis.","english":"And what he says, I will slay them according to the hearing of their assembly, can mean this: just as with united counsel they all fashioned idols for themselves, so with me angered they all alike will be laid waste. The teachers of contrary dogmas, who have abandoned Christ, the wisdom, and have gone out from the Church, we can rightly call a foolish and heartless dove, who, desiring earthly things, have been handed over to the Assyrians; and when they have departed from the Church, the Lord spreads his net over them, woven from the testimonies of the Scriptures and the crafty speech of wisdom, so that those who raise themselves against the wisdom of God and, like a bird, fly toward the heights, he may drag down to the lowly, and rebuke them with threats and with the hearing of punishments, so that, corrected, they may not appear forever.\n\n(Verse 13.) \"Woe to them, for they have withdrawn from me: they will be laid waste, because they have transgressed against me. I redeemed them, but they spoke lies against me, and they did not cry out to me in their heart, but they howled in their beds.\" The Septuagint: \"Woe to them, for they have withdrawn from me: they are exposed, for they have acted impiously against me: but I redeemed them: yet they spoke a lie against me, and their hearts did not cry out to me, but they howled in their beds.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":134,"ref":"p134","source":"» Me extendente rete meum, ut eos comprehenderem, et quasi vo lucrem coeli de superbia deponerem, et caederem in auditu angustiae, illi recesserunt et resilierunt a me, hoc enim significat, quod Septuaginta transtulerunt: et propterea vastabuntur, quia praevaricati sunt in me. Pro eo quod nos diximus, vastabuntur, et in Hebraeo scriptum est SOD LAEM ( ). id est, vastatio eis: Symmachus, interitum: Theodotio, miseriam interpretati sunt. Porro in editione Vulgata dupliciter legimus; quidam enim codices habent,, hoc est, manifesti sunt: alii, hoc est, meticulosi, sive miseri sunt. Vastabuntur igitur et miseri erunt, et semper timentes ac formidantes, quia praevaricatis sunt in Deum, adorantes vitulos aureos, et relinquentes eum qui redemit eos de AEgyptia servitute, et eduxit in excelso brachio. Ipsi vero loculi sunt contra Dominum mendacia, dicentes de idolis: Hi sunt dii tui, Israel, qui te eduxerunt de terra AEgypti (Exod. XXXII, 4), et non clamaverunt ad Dominum in corde suo, sed in idololatriae fornicationibus volutabantur. Sive quia daemonum cultum sequitur libido et luxuria, qui colebant daemones, consequenter instar porcorum in caeno libidinum versabantur. Et pulchre cantica idolis servientium, non carmina in Deum, sed ululatum appellat.","english":"While I spread my net to capture them and, as it were, to bring down the bird of the sky from its pride and to strike them at the hearing of distress, they withdrew and recoiled from me—for this is what the Seventy translated: and therefore they will be laid waste, because they have transgressed against me. In place of what we said, they will be laid waste, and in Hebrew it is written SOD LAEM, that is, devastation to them; Symmachus rendered it destruction, Theodotion misery. Moreover, in the Vulgate edition we read it in two ways; for some codices have, that is, they are manifest; others, that is, they are fearful, or wretched. They will therefore be laid waste and will be wretched, and always fearing and dreading, because they have transgressed against God, worshiping golden calves and forsaking him who redeemed them from Egyptian slavery and led them out with an exalted arm. But they themselves are little chests of lies against the Lord, saying of the idols: These are your gods, Israel, who led you out of the land of Egypt, and they did not cry out to the Lord in their heart, but wallowed in the fornications of idolatry. Or because lust and luxury follow the worship of demons, those who worshiped demons consequently rolled about like pigs in the mire of desires. And beautifully he calls the songs of those serving idols, not songs to God, but a howling.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":135,"ref":"p135","source":"Super haereticis facilis interpretatio est, quod vae habeant sempiternum, quia recesserunt a Deo, et miseri sunt, quia reliquerunt Creatorem suum qui redemit cos sanguine sanguine suo: et ipsi loquuntur contra cum mendacia, impia falsitatis dogmata componentes, et non clamant in cordibus suis, sed ululant semper in conciliabulis, quae pulchre cubilia appellat, et ferarum lustra. Istiusmodi non possunt dicere: Lavabo per singulas noctes lectum meum, lacrymis meis stratum meum rigabo (Psal. VI, 7): sed volutantur in sordibus Libidinum, vacant stupris, et quidquid loquuntur et putaverint se in laudem Dei dicere, ululatus luporum et baccharum insanientium sonitus est. Raro haereticus diligit castitatem, et quicumque amare pudicitiam se simulant, ut Manichaeus, et Marcion, et Arius 2, et Tatianus, et instauratores veteris haereseos, venenato ore mella promittunt. Caeterum juxta Apostolum, quae secrete agunt, turpe est dicere (Ephes. V).","english":"The interpretation concerning heretics is easy: that they have an eternal woe, because they have withdrawn from God, and they are wretched because they have forsaken their Creator who redeemed them by his own blood; and they speak lies against him, composing impious dogmas of falsehood, and they do not cry out in their hearts, but always howl in their conventicles, which he aptly calls lairs and dens of wild beasts. Such people cannot say: Every night I will wash my bed, I will water my couch with my tears (Psalm 6:7); but they wallow in the filth of lusts, they are free for debaucheries, and whatever they say and think they are saying in praise of God is the howling of wolves and the din of raving bacchants. A heretic rarely loves chastity, and whoever pretends to love modesty, like Manichaeus, and Marcion, and Arius, and Tatian, and the restorers of the old heresy, promise honey with a poisoned mouth. But according to the Apostle, it is shameful even to speak of what they do in secret (Ephesians 5).","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":136,"ref":"p136","source":"(Vers. seq.) « Super triticum et vinum ruminabant: recesserunt a me, et ego erudivi et confortavi brachia eorum: et in me cogitaverunt malitiam; reversi sunt, ut essent absque jugo: facti sunt quasi arcus dolosus: cadent in gladio principes eorum, a furore linguae suae: ista subsannatio eorum in terra AEgypti. » LXX: « Super tritico et vino dissecabantur: eruditi sunt in me, ct ego confortavi brachia eorum, et contra me cogitaverunt mala: conversi sunt in nihilum, facti sunt quasi arcus intentus, cadent in gladio principes eorum propter imperitiam linguae eorum; sic est subsannatio eorum in terra AEgypti. » Propter abundantiam, inquit, rerum omnium corruerunt. Quod etiam Ezechiel in Sodomis et Gomorrhis factum esse commemorat (Ezech. XIX), ut nihil aliud nisi cibos et luxuriam ruminarent: pro quo Septuaginta transtulerunt, super frumento et vino dissecabantur, in exemplum prophetarum Baal, qui praesente Elia, concisione membrorum pluvias precabantur (III Reg. XVIII). Simulque ut ostenderet eos jumentorum similes, non dixit, comedebant, sed ruminabant: et ideo recesserunt a Domino qui dicit: ego eos erudivi, ego fortitudinem praebui, et contra me suas erexere cervices; non quod aliquid possint facere et nocere Creatori suo: sed quod solum facere potuerunt, cogitaverunt mala contra me.","english":"And on the next verse: \"They were ruminating over wheat and wine: they have withdrawn from me, and I trained and strengthened their arms: and they devised evil against me; they turned back, so as to be without yoke: they became like a deceitful bow: their princes shall fall by the sword, because of the fury of their tongue: this is their mockery in the land of Egypt.\" The Septuagint: \"Over wheat and wine they were divided: they were trained in me, and I strengthened their arms, and against me they devised evils: they turned back to nothing, they became like a bow drawn taut, their princes shall fall by the sword because of the ignorance of their tongue; thus is their mockery in the land of Egypt.\" On account of abundance, he says, of all things they collapsed. Which Ezekiel also records happened in Sodom and Gomorrah, that they ruminated on nothing else but food and luxury: for which the Septuagint translated, \"over grain and wine they were divided,\" in the example of the prophets of Baal, who in the presence of Elijah, by the cutting of their limbs, prayed for rain. And at the same time, to show that they were like beasts of burden, he did not say \"they ate,\" but \"they ruminated\": and therefore they withdrew from the Lord who says: I trained them, I provided strength, and against me they raised up their necks; not that they can do anything and harm their Creator: but what alone they were able to do, they devised evils against me.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":137,"ref":"p137","source":"Et quomodo a principio fuerunt, priusquam vocarem eos per Abraham, et postea per Moysen et Aaron, et erant absque jugo legisque notitia, et cunetis nationibus miscebantur: ita etiam nunc reversi sunt in pristinum statum: ut absque jugo et frenis deferrentur per praecipitia, et mutarentur in arcum dolosum, ut quem Deus contra adversarios intenderat, ipsi contra suum Dominum verterent, et mitterent adversus eum blasphemiarum sagittas. Unde principes eorum, qui infelicem populum deceperunt, cadent gladio propter furorem linguae suae, quod vitulos aureos deos appellare sunt ausi, ut hoc facerent in terra repromissionis, quod in AEgypto didicerant: colentes Apim AEgyptium, et omnia eorum portenta venerantes: ita enim et in solitudine, quando egressi sunt de AEgypto, Dominum subsannaverunt, dicentes: Isti sunt dii tui, Israel (Exod. XXXII, 4). Et: Utinam essemus in terra AEgypti, ubi sedebamus super ollas carnium (Exod. XVI, 3), et caetera. Super tritico et vino, et falsis mysteriis corporis et sanguinis Christi, qui dicit in Evangelio: Nisi ceciderit granum tritici in terram, et mortuum fuerit, ipsum solum manet (Joan. XII, 24): Et in alio loco: Ego sum vitis vera (Joan. XV, 1): Et: Nisi biberitis sanguinem meum (Joan. VI. 54).","english":"And just as they were from the beginning, before I called them through Abraham, and afterward through Moses and Aaron, and they were without the yoke and knowledge of the law, and were mingling with all nations: so even now they have returned to their former state: so that without yoke and bridles they were carried headlong through precipices, and were changed into a deceitful bow, so that the one whom God had aimed against adversaries, they themselves turned against their own Lord, and shot against him the arrows of blasphemies. Whence their princes, who deceived the unhappy people, will fall by the sword because of the fury of their tongue, because they dared to call golden calves gods, so as to do in the land of promise what they had learned in Egypt: worshiping the Egyptian Apis, and venerating all their portents: for thus also in the wilderness, when they came out of Egypt, they mocked the Lord, saying: These are your gods, Israel (Exod. 32:4). And: Would that we had been in the land of Egypt, where we sat over pots of meat (Exod. 16:3), and the rest. Over the wheat and wine, and the false mysteries of the body and blood of Christ, who says in the Gospel: Unless a grain of wheat falls into the earth and dies, it remains alone (John 12:24): And in another place: I am the true vine (John 15:1): And: Unless you drink my blood (John 6:54).","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":138,"ref":"p138","source":"Super hoc ergo tritico et vino haeretici conciduntur, et diversa sibi construunt tabernacula: sive praeciduntur ab Ecclesiae corpore, et legem Dei meditari, et ruminare se simulant. Sed hoc facientes recedunt a Domino qui docuit eos in Ecclesia, et dedit eis fortitudinem, qua contra adversarios dimicarent. Illi vero cogitaverunt malitiam contra Dominum, impiissimas haereses exstruentes, et reversi sunt in statum gentilium, ut essent absque Dei notitia et jugo: sive reversi sunt in nihilum, non quod desierint esse, sed quod ad comparationem ejus, qui loquitur ad Moysen: Vade, dic populo Israel: Qui est misit me (Exod. III, 14), omnes qui contra Dominum sapiunt, non esse dicantur. Juxta illud quod in Esther legimus in Septuaginta duntaxat: Ne tradas sceptrum tuum his qui non sunt (Esther XIV, 11, sec. LXX), haud dubium quin idola significet. Si enim Deus est veritas, quidquid contrarium veritati est, mendacium est, et nihil nominatur. Hoc haereticis convenit, qui instructi de Scripturis sanctis, adversum Dominum Legis et Prophetarum et Evangelii verba vertunt et sunt quasi arcus dolosus sive perversus. Dolosus arcus atque perversus est, qui percutit dirigentem, et vulnerat dominum suum. Sive facti sunt quasi arcus intentus, parati semper ad pugnam et contentiones, in subversionem audientium.","english":"On this wheat and wine, therefore, heretics are cut down and build for themselves various tabernacles: either they are cut off from the body of the Church, and pretend to meditate on and ruminate the law of God. But in doing this they depart from the Lord who taught them in the Church and gave them strength with which to fight against adversaries. They, however, devised malice against the Lord, building up most impious heresies, and have returned to the state of the Gentiles, so as to be without knowledge and yoke of God: or they have returned to nothingness, not that they have ceased to exist, but that in comparison with him who speaks to Moses—Go, tell the people of Israel: He who is has sent me (Exod. 3:14)—all who think against the Lord are said not to be. According to what we read in Esther in the Septuagint only: Do not hand over your scepter to those who are not (Esther 14:11, according to the LXX), undoubtedly signifying idols. For if God is truth, whatever is contrary to truth is a lie and is called nothing. This applies to heretics, who, instructed from the Holy Scriptures, turn the words of the Law and the Prophets and the Gospel against the Lord, and are like a deceitful or perverse bow. A deceitful and perverse bow is one that strikes the one aiming it and wounds its own master. Or they have become like a bow bent, always ready for battle and contentions, for the subversion of hearers.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":139,"ref":"p139","source":"Unde principes eorum, id est haeresiarchae, Domini mucrone feriantur, propter insaniam linguae suae, qua Dominum blasphemaverunt: hoc idem facientes in falsi nominis Ecclesia, quod faciebant eo tempore quo in AEgypto saeculi morabantur, hoc est, quando gentiles erant. Omnes enim haereticorum et gentilium quaestiones eaedem sunt, quia non Scripturarum auctoritatem, sed humanae rationis sensum sequuntur.\n\n(Cap. VIII.—Vers. seq.) « In gutture tuo sit tuba, quasi aquila super domum Domini, pro eo quod transgressi sunt foedus meum, et legem meam praevaricati sunt. Me invocabunt, Deus meus, cognovimus te Israel. Projecit Israel bonum, inimicus persequetur eum. Ipsi regnaverunt, et non ex me: principes exstiterunt, et non cognovi. Argentum suam et aurum suum fecerunt sibi idola, ut interirent. » LXX: « In sinu eorum quasi terra sicut aquila super domum Domini: pro eo quod transgressi sunt testamentum meum, et contra legem meam impie egerunt. Me invocaverunt, Deus, cognovimus te: quia Israel aversatus est bona: inimicum persecuti sunt, ex semetipsis regnaverunt, et non per me: principes exstiterunt, et non indicaverunt mihi: argentum suum et aurum suum fecerunt sibi idola, ut dispereant. » Hoc quod interpretati sumus, in gutture tuo sit tuba, pro quo in Hebraeo scriptum est, ALECHCHAC SOPHAR ( ) Aquila et Symmachus et Theodolio similiter transtulerunt.","english":"Whence their leaders, that is, the heresiarchs, are struck by the Lord's sword, because of the madness of their tongue, by which they blasphemed the Lord, doing the same thing in the church of the false name that they did at the time when they dwelt in the Egypt of this world, that is, when they were Gentiles. For all the questions of heretics and Gentiles are the same, because they follow not the authority of the Scriptures but the sense of human reason.\n\n(Cap. VIII.—Vers. seq.) \"Let the trumpet be in thy throat, as an eagle over the house of the Lord, because they have transgressed my covenant, and have violated my law. They will call upon me, My God, we have known thee, Israel. Israel hath cast off good, the enemy shall pursue him. They themselves have reigned, and not from me: they have become princes, and I have not known them. They have made for themselves idols of their silver and their gold, that they might perish.\" The Septuagint: \"In their bosom as earth, as an eagle over the house of the Lord: because they have transgressed my testament, and have acted impiously against my law. They have called upon me, O God, we have known thee: because Israel hath turned away from good things: they have persecuted the enemy, they have reigned of themselves, and not through me: they have become princes, and have not made known to me: they have made for themselves idols of their silver and their gold, that they may perish.\" That which we have translated, \"Let the trumpet be in thy throat,\" for which in Hebrew is written, ALECHCHAC SOPHAR, Aquila and Symmachus and Theodotion translated similarly.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":140,"ref":"p140","source":"Soli Septuaginta dixerunt: In sinu eorum quasi terra: quod quid significet, incertum est. Quidam enim aestimant sinum dupliciter accipi, et inferiorem partem vestimenti a genitalibus usque ad pedes: et colpum maris, id est, sinum, verbi gratia, Hadriatici, et Ionii, et Propontidis, falsosque magistros, qui blasphemiam AEgypti sunt secuti, omnia, in sinu suo libidini servientia et terrena retinere: vel certe in portu et refugio navigationis suae, nihil pretiosarum mercium, sed terrena conquirere. Nos autem sequentes veritatem Hebraicam, coeptae explanationis texamus ordinem. Praecipitur prophetae, et dicitur ad eum: in gutture tuo sit tuba, hoc est, sic exalta vocem tuam, ut tubae similis sit: ut plurimi audiant, quia plurimi peccaverunt. Cumque exaltaveris vocem tuam, hoc dicito cum clamore, quasi aquila super domum Domini, et est sensus: Veniet Nabuchodonosor cum omni exercitu suo tam raptim, tam velociter, ut aquilae imitetur volatum festinantis ad praedam: et veniet non ad alium locum, sed ad Jerusalem, in qua templum Dei situm est, ut eam destruat atque subvertat. De hac aquila et Ezechiel plenius loquitur (Ezech. XVII): magnarum alarum plumarumque et unguium, quae habet ductum intrandi in Libanum, hoc est, in templum Dei. Juxta Zachariam prophetam, in quo scriptum est: Aperi, Libane, portas tuas, et comedat ignis cedros tuas (Zach. XI, 1).","english":"Only the Septuagint said: In their bosom as it were earth: what this signifies is uncertain. For some think that \"bosom\" is taken in two ways: both the lower part of a garment from the genitals down to the feet, and the gulf of the sea, that is, a bay, for example, of the Adriatic, the Ionian, and the Propontis; and that false teachers, who have followed the blasphemy of Egypt, keep all things in their bosom that serve lust and are earthly; or certainly that in the harbor and refuge of their voyage they acquire nothing of precious cargo, but only earthly things. We, however, following the Hebrew truth, weave the order of the explanation begun. The prophet is commanded, and it is said to him: Let there be a trumpet in your throat, that is, so raise your voice that it be like a trumpet, so that very many may hear, because very many have sinned. And when you have raised your voice, say this with a shout, like an eagle over the house of the Lord; and the sense is: Nebuchadnezzar will come with all his army so swiftly, so speedily, that he imitates the flight of an eagle hastening to prey; and he will come not to another place, but to Jerusalem, in which the temple of God is situated, to destroy and overthrow it. Of this eagle Ezekiel also speaks more fully (Ezek. XVII): of great wings and feathers and talons, which has a way of entering into Lebanon, that is, into the temple of God. According to the prophet Zechariah, in whom it is written: Open, Lebanon, your gates, and let fire devour your cedars (Zech. XI, 1).","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":141,"ref":"p141","source":"Hoc autem, o propheta, quod tibi dico atque praecipio: In gutture tuo sit tuba, ut vocifereris et dicas, quasi aquila super domum Domini, regem venire Chaldaeorum, non aliam ob causam jubeo, nisi quod transgressi sunt foedus meum, et meas caeremonias reliquerunt. Unde tempore necessitatis et angustiae, quan do captivitas venerit, me invocabunt et dicent: Deus meus, cognovimus te, Israel; nos qui appellamur Israel, scimus te atque cognoscimus, et non en Jacob, qui tibi placuit, servamus antiquum, ut dicamur Israel. Quibus respondit Dominus: Quomodo vocamini Israel, cum Israel projecerit bonum, id est, Dominum Deum suum, a quo appellatus est Israel? Idcirco quia Israel projecit bonum, inimicus, hoc est, Assyrius persequetur eum, atque comprehendet: qui, me rege deserto, petierunt sibi regem, sicut et gentes reliquae, et fecerunt contra voluntatem Dei. Denique Samuel ideo eis dura regis exponit imperia, et filios eorum ac filias dicit regibus servituras, ut ad Dominum regem clementissimum convertantur (I Reg. VIII); sed illi absque voluntate Dei principes exstiterunt. Et non eis suffecit hoc scelus, nisi majori impietate facinus duplicarent, ut argentum suum et aurum quod acceperant ad divitias et ornatum in idola verterent. Ergo Saul non ex voluntate Dei, sed ex populi errore rex factus est. Et quia radicem pietatis non habuit, statim ut regnare coepit, impietate succensus est.","english":"But this, O prophet, which I say and command to you: Let there be a trumpet in your throat, that you may cry out and say, like an eagle over the house of the Lord, that the king of the Chaldeans is coming—I command this for no other reason than that they have transgressed my covenant and abandoned my ceremonies. Hence in the time of necessity and distress, when captivity comes, they will call upon me and say: My God, we have known you, Israel; we who are called Israel know you and recognize you, and it is not as Jacob, who pleased you, that we observe the ancient custom, so as to be called Israel. To whom the Lord responds: How are you called Israel, when Israel has cast off the good, that is, the Lord his God, from whom he was named Israel? Therefore because Israel has cast off the good, the enemy, that is, the Assyrian, will pursue him and seize him—they who, with me as king rejected, sought a king for themselves, just as the other nations did, and acted against the will of God. Indeed, for this reason Samuel sets before them the harsh decrees of a king, and says that their sons and daughters will serve kings, so that they may turn to the Lord, the most merciful king (1 Samuel 8); but those princes came to be without the will of God. And this crime did not suffice for them, unless they doubled the deed with greater impiety, so that the silver and gold which they had received for wealth and adornment they turned into idols. Therefore Saul was made king not by the will of God but by the error of the people. And because he did not have the root of piety, as soon as he began to reign he was set ablaze with impiety.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":142,"ref":"p142","source":"Potest hoc quod dicit: Ipsi regnaverunt, et non ex me, principes exstiterunt, et non cognovi, etiam de Jeroboam accipi filio Nabath, et de caeteris principibus, qui ei in imperio successerunt. Nec statim, quia Deus Salomoni iratus, regnum ejus dividi voluit, idcirco Israel bene suscepit regem. Debuerat enim juxta legis praecepta interrogare Dominum, an vellet hoc fieri. Nam de Salvatore dicitur: quod oporteat quidem tradi Filium hominis, sed vae illi, per quem tradendus sit.(Matth. XXVI). Diabolum qui ponere capit supra astra coeli nidum suum, aquilam saepissime legimus: Si exaltatus fueris ut aquila, inde detraham te, dicit Dominus (Abdiae 4). Oculus quoque qui irridet patrem, et despicit senectutem matris, effodietur a corvis, et devorabunt eum pulli aquilarum (Prov. XXX): per diabolum ac daemones, clarum visionis suae lumen amittens. Unde in Lege praecipitur, ut non comedamus aquilam [Levit. XI) Haec igitur aquila venit super haereticorum conciliabula, quae quondum fuerant domus Domini: et idcirco venit, quia praevaricati sunt foedus ejus, et legem Dei dereliquerunt: et sine causa invocant eum, et dicunt: Deus meus es, et cognovimus te, nos qui vocamur Israel, cernentes Deum, et vocamur nomine Christiano.","english":"That which he says: They themselves have reigned, and not from me; they have become princes, and I did not know them, can also be understood of Jeroboam son of Nabath, and of the other princes who succeeded him in rule. Nor, immediately because God, angered at Solomon, willed his kingdom to be divided, did Israel for that reason rightly receive a king. For it ought, according to the precepts of the law, to have asked the Lord whether he wished this to be done. For of the Savior it is said that the Son of man must indeed be handed over, but woe to that man through whom he is to be handed over. The devil, who sets his nest above the stars of heaven, we very often read of as an eagle: If you are exalted like an eagle, from there I will drag you down, says the Lord. Also the eye that mocks a father and despises the old age of a mother shall be dug out by ravens, and the young of eagles shall devour it: through the devil and demons, losing the clear light of its vision. Whence in the Law it is commanded that we not eat the eagle. This eagle, therefore, comes over the assemblies of heretics, which once were the house of the Lord: and it comes for this reason, because they have transgressed his covenant and abandoned the law of God: and they invoke him in vain, and say: You are my God, and we have known you, we who are called Israel, beholding God, and are called by the Christian name.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[{"kind":"lacuna","severity":"caution","text":"The source is fragmentary here: the edition marks a break or an editorial bracket, and the English carries across it. Treat the bridge as supplied, not translated."}]},{"i":143,"ref":"p143","source":"Frustra, inquit, haec faciunt, cum ipsi sibi reges constituerint, et contra meam fecerint voluntatem, et principes habeant adversarios meos, quos ego nescio, quia mei notitiam non merentur. Argentum quoque suum, et aurum, et quidquid habere poterant naturaliter, sermones ac sensus verterunt in idola, quae de suo corde finxerunt: et verterunt, non ut interirent; sed quia verterunt, ideo interierunt. Neque enim hac ratione fecerunt, ut perirent; sed quia fecerunt. idcirco perierunt.\n\n(Vers. 5, 6.) « Projectus est vitulus tuus, Samaria. Iratus est furor meus in eis: usquequo non poterunt emundari? quia ex Israel et ipse est: artifex fecit illud, et non est Deus: quoniam in aranearum telas erit vitulus Samariae. » LXX: « Projice vitulum tuum, Samaria concitatus est furor meus super eos: usquequo non poterunt emundari in Israel? et hoc artifex fecit, et non est Deus, quia seducens erat vitulus tuus, Samaria. » In eo loco, in quo nos posuimus aranearum telas, in Hebraico scriptum est SABABIM ( ), per IOD litteram penultimam: non ut quidam falso putant, SABABUM ( ). id est, per VAU, quod Septuaginta et Theodotion, interpretati sunt, id est, seducens, atque decipiens: Aquila errantibus, sive conversis; Symmachus, inconstans, vel instabile, id est,; quinta editio,, vagus et fluctuans.","english":"In vain, he says, do they do these things, since they have appointed kings for themselves, and have acted against my will, and have as princes my adversaries, whom I do not know, because they do not deserve to be known by me. Their silver also, and gold, and whatever they could naturally possess, they have turned their words and thoughts into idols, which they have fashioned from their own heart: and they turned them, not so that they might perish; but because they turned them, therefore they perished. For they did not do this for the purpose of perishing; but because they did it, therefore they perished.\n\n(Verses 5, 6.) \"Your calf, Samaria, has been cast out. My fury is enraged against them: how long will they be unable to be cleansed? For it is from Israel, and it itself is: a craftsman made it, and it is not God: for the calf of Samaria will be among spiders' webs.\" The Septuagint: \"Cast out your calf, Samaria; my fury is stirred up against them: how long will they be unable to be cleansed in Israel? And a craftsman made this, and it is not God, because your calf, Samaria, was leading astray.\" In that place where we have put \"spiders' webs,\" in Hebrew is written SABABIM, with IOD as the penultimate letter: not, as some falsely think, SABABUM, that is, with VAU, which the Septuagint and Theodotion translated as \"leading astray\" and \"deceiving\"; Aquila as \"wandering\" or \"turned aside\"; Symmachus as \"inconstant\" or \"unstable,\" that is; the fifth edition as \"wandering and fluctuating.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":144,"ref":"p144","source":"Nos ab Hebraeo didicimus SABABIM proprie nominari aranearum fila per aerem volantia, quae dum videntur intereunt, et in atomos atque in nihilum dissolvuntur. Et recte his Samariae vitulus comparatur, quem eo tempore pro pretii magnitudine, quia aureus erat, populus adorabat. Hoc quod supra dixerat: Argentum suum et aurum suum fecerunt sibi idola, ut interirent, nunc exponit manifestius: Projectus est vitulus tuus, Samaria. iratus est furor meus in eos: vel in vitulos, quia duos fecerant, vel in Samariae habitatores, qui eos adorabant. Porro quod in Septuaginta legimus: Projice vitulum tuum, Samaria, cohortatur habitatores ejus, non unius urbis, sed omnium decem tribuum, quae appellantur Samaria (alioquin in urbe Samaria vituli non erant, sed in Dan et in Bethel), ut projiciat vitulos super quos iratus est Deus, sive, id est, defricet: ut quos multo tempore coluerat, paulatim a se defricet et emundet. Illisque non audientibus, convertitur ad alios, et quasi ad tertiam personam loquitur: Usquequo non poterunt emundari? Quae ista, inquit, insania est, me dante locum poenitentiae, illos ad sanitatem nolle converti. Et quia dixerat: Projice titulum tuum, Samaria, exponit quis iste sit vitulus; quia ex Israel et ipse est: non ab aliis ait, vitulum gentibus accepistis, ut Baal et Astaroth a Sidoniis, ut Chamos a Moabitis, ut Moloch ab Ammonitis (IV Reg.","english":"We have learned from the Hebrew that SABABIM properly denotes the threads of spiders flying through the air, which perish while they are seen, and are dissolved into atoms and into nothing. And rightly is the calf of Samaria compared to these, which at that time the people worshiped in proportion to the greatness of its value, because it was golden. What he had said above: They made for themselves idols of their silver and their gold, that they might perish, he now explains more plainly: Your calf, Samaria, has been cast out. My fury is enraged against them: either against the calves, because they had made two, or against the inhabitants of Samaria, who worshiped them. Moreover, what we read in the Septuagint: Cast out your calf, Samaria, he exhorts its inhabitants—not of one city, but of all the ten tribes, which are called Samaria (otherwise the calves were not in the city of Samaria, but in Dan and in Bethel)—to cast out the calves against which God is enraged, or, that is, to rub away: so that those which it had worshiped for a long time, it may gradually rub away and cleanse from itself. And when they do not listen, he turns to others, and speaks as if to a third person: How long will they be unable to be cleansed? What madness is this, he says, that while I give room for repentance, they are unwilling to be converted to health. And because he had said: Cast out your calf, Samaria, he explains who this calf is; because it too is from Israel: not from others, he says, did you receive the calf, as the Gentiles did Baal and Astaroth from the Sidonians, as Chamos from the Moabites, as Moloch from the Ammonites (IV Kings","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":145,"ref":"p145","source":"XXIII); sed vos ipsi, et rex vester Jeroboam, quod in AEgypto didiceratis, fecistis in Israel. Aut qualis ille est deus, qui manu formatur artificis? Denique ut aranearum fila dissolvuntur in ventum, ita vitulus Samariae redigetur in nihilum. Projicit Dominus haereticorum vitulos et Samariae, qui se dicunt legis praecepta servare: qui vituli haerent humo, et operantur in terra, non spiritu, nec oculos ad coelum levant; et idcirco iratus est furor Domini super cos, et miratur quae sit tanta perversitas, ut nolint relinquere idola, quae sibi fabricati sunt, et ament sordes haereticas pro Ecclesiae munditiis. Quos vitulos non accepit Israel, qui Dominum videre se fingit a caeteris gentibus: sed de Scripturis sanctis sibi ipse conflavit intelligentiae pravitatem, et artifex est Dei sui, qui cito peribit et aranearum telas imitabitur, quae levi rumpuntur attactu.","english":"but you yourselves, and your king Jeroboam, have done in Israel what you had learned in Egypt. Or what kind of god is that which is formed by the hand of a craftsman? Finally, just as spiders' threads are dissolved into the wind, so the calf of Samaria will be reduced to nothing. The Lord casts away the calves of the heretics and of Samaria, who claim that they keep the precepts of the law: calves that cling to the ground and work in the earth, not in the spirit, nor do they lift their eyes to heaven; and therefore the fury of the Lord's wrath is kindled against them, and He marvels at what such great perversity is, that they refuse to abandon the idols they have fashioned for themselves, and love heretical filth instead of the Church's purity. These calves Israel did not accept—Israel, who pretends to see the Lord apart from the other nations—but from the Holy Scriptures he has forged for himself a perversity of understanding, and he is the craftsman of his own God, who will quickly perish and imitate the webs of spiders, which are broken by a light touch.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":146,"ref":"p146","source":"(Vers. 7.) « Quia ventum seminabunt, et turbinem metent: culmus stans, non est in eo germen, non faciet farinam: quod et si fecerit, alieni comedent eam. » LXX: « Quia corrupta vento seminaverunt, et subversio eorum suscipiet ea: manipulus non habens vires ut faciat farinam: quod et si fecerit, alieni comedent eam. » Aranearum telis, Samariae vitulum comparat: idcirco metaphoram servat in reliquis, ut quos aranearum telas dixerat, comparet vento, et turbini, culmisque non stantibus: et si steterint, farinam non habentibus; et si farinam, inquit, fecerint, ab aliis devorabitur. Et quia tam de haereticis quam de his, qui in Samaria fabricati sunt idola, communis est sensus, communiter disputandum est. Isti ventum seminant, sive quae a vento corrupta sunt semina, quae medullam non habent, quam Graeci vocant, et idcirco vacua seminantes, inania vacuaque recipiunt: imo seminantes in carne, de carne metunt corruptionem, et circumferuntur omni vento doctrinae. Cumque ventum seminaverint. metent turbines et tempestates, et primum quidem culmus, hoc est, stipula non erit ex his seminibus, nec aliquam poterunt speciem segetis habere fecundae. Quod si raro acciderit, ut Ecclesiastici quid dogmatis simile habere videantur: ipsum germen et spica farinam non faciet. In cujus farinae satis tribus mittit fermentum Evangelica mulier (Matth.","english":"(Verse 7.) \"Because they shall sow the wind, and reap the whirlwind: a standing stalk, there is no sprout in it, it shall not make flour: and even if it does, strangers shall eat it.\" The Septuagint: \"Because they have sown seeds corrupted by the wind, and their overthrow shall receive them: a sheaf having no strength to make flour: and even if it does, strangers shall eat it.\" He compares Samaria's calf to spiders' webs: therefore he preserves the metaphor in the rest, so that those whom he had called spiders' webs, he compares to wind, and whirlwind, and stalks not standing: and if they have stood, not having flour; and if they have made flour, he says, it will be devoured by others. And because the meaning is common both concerning heretics and concerning those who fashioned idols in Samaria, it must be discussed in common. These sow the wind, or seeds that have been corrupted by the wind, which have no marrow, which the Greeks call [medulla], and therefore sowing empty things, they receive empty and void things: indeed sowing in the flesh, from the flesh they reap corruption, and they are carried about by every wind of doctrine. And when they have sown the wind, they shall reap whirlwinds and tempests, and first indeed the stalk, that is, the stubble, shall not come from these seeds, nor will they be able to have any appearance of a fruitful harvest. But if it rarely happens that certain ecclesiastical [teachers] seem to hold something similar in doctrine: the sprout itself and the ear shall not make flour. Into whose measure of flour the Evangelical woman sends three leavens (Matt.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":147,"ref":"p147","source":"XIII): ut et spiritus quo sentimus, et anima qua vivimus, et corpus quo incedimus, in unum sanctum Spiritum redigantur, juxta Apostolum: In ipso vivimus, movemur et sumus (Act. XVII, 28). Quod si raro acciderit haereticis, ut farinam quoque sementis eorum faciat, de hac farina fiet subcinericius panis, qui non reversatur, et quem alieni comedent. Unde et nunc ait: Quod et si fecerit farinam, alieni comedent eam. Alienos autem illos debemus accipere, de quibus scriptum est: Filii alieni mentiti sunt mihi (Psal. XVII, 46). Et in octavo decimo psalmo: Ab occultis meis munda me, Domine, ei ab alienis parce servo tuo. Qui si justo viro non fuerint domni nati, tunc immaculatus erit, et mundabitur a delicto maximo.\n\n(Vers. 8.) « Devoratus est Israel, tunc factus est in nationibus quasi vas immundum. » Septuaginta pro immundo, inutile transtulerunt, caetera similiter 1. Immundum vas, sive inutile, Hebraei matulam vocant, qua ad suscipienda et projicienda stercora uti solemus. Huic immunditiae idololatras et haereticos comparat, qui misceatur gentibus, dum Dei non custodiunt veritatem, et facti vas in honorem, conversi sunt in vasa contumeliae. Quid enim immundius daemonico spiritu, et haereticorum dogmatibus, quae eos ethnicis miscuerunt? Talis erat Jechonias idolis mancipatus, de quo per Jeremiam loquitur Deus: Inhonoratus est Jechonias, sicut vus cujus nulla est utilitas (Jerem.","english":"that both the spirit by which we perceive, and the soul by which we live, and the body by which we walk, may be gathered into one Holy Spirit, according to the Apostle: In him we live, and move, and are. But if it rarely happens to heretics that he also makes flour of their seed, from this flour will be made a bread baked under the ashes, which is not turned over, and which strangers shall eat. Whence also now he says: And even if it has made flour, strangers shall eat it. But we ought to understand those as strangers, of whom it is written: Strangers' sons have lied to me. And in the eighteenth psalm: From my secret faults cleanse me, O Lord, and spare your servant from strangers. If these have not been born to a just man at home, then he will be immaculate, and will be cleansed from the greatest offense.\n\n(Verse 8.) \"Israel is devoured, now he has become among the nations like an unclean vessel.\" The Septuagint, instead of \"unclean,\" translated \"useless,\" and the rest similarly. The Hebrews call an unclean vessel, or a useless one, a chamber pot, which we customarily use for receiving and throwing out excrement. To this uncleanness he compares idolaters and heretics, who are mingled with the nations, while they do not keep the truth of God, and having been made a vessel for honor, they have been turned into vessels of dishonor. For what is more unclean than a demonic spirit, and the doctrines of heretics, which have mingled them with the heathen? Such was Jeconiah, handed over to idols, of whom God speaks through Jeremiah: Jeconiah is dishonored, like a vessel of which there is no use.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":148,"ref":"p148","source":"XXII, 28). Econtrario Paulus qui dicere poterat: An experimentum quaeritis ejus qui in me loquitur Christus (II Cor. XIII, 3)? appellatur vas electionis aureum et argenteum: quia habebat sapientiam, et eloquium, quo Christi Evangelium praedicabat. Quod autem dicit, devoratus est, vel absorptus, hoc significat, quod mixtus idolis et nationibus, proprium Israelis et Christiani nomen amiserit.\n\n(Vers. 9, 10.) « Quia ipsi ascenderunt ad Assur, onager solitarius sibi: Ephraim munera dederunt amatoribus, sed et cum mercede conduxerunt nationes: nunc congregabo eos, et quiescent paulisper ab onere regis et principum. » LXX: « Quia ipsi ascenderunt ad Assyrios, germinavit apud semetipsum Ephraim: munera dilexerunt: idcirco tradentur in gentibus, nunc suscipiam eos, et quiescent parvum, ut ungant reges et principes. » Devoratus est, inquit, Israel, et factus est tanquam vas inutile, sive immundum, de quo non supersit testa, in qua hauriri possit aqua, aut modicum quid igniculi. Et quia factus est vas immundum, ideo ascenderunt ad Assyrios imitantes onagrum solitarium: nequaquam ut oves pasti a Domino, sed male abutentes libertate sua, et educti in captivitatem, quos propheta plangit et dicit: Ephraim munera dederunt Assyriis, et conduxerunt mercede amatores suos, de quibus scribit Ezechiel: Omnibus meretricibus dantur mercedes: tu autem dedisti mercedes amatoribus tuis (Ezech.","english":"22:28). On the other hand, Paul, who could say: Do you seek a proof of him who speaks in me, Christ? (2 Cor. 13:3), is called a golden and silver vessel of election, because he had the wisdom and eloquence with which he preached the Gospel of Christ. But what he says, he has been devoured, or absorbed, signifies this: that, mingled with idols and nations, he has lost the name proper to an Israelite and a Christian.\n\n(On verses 9, 10.) \"Because they themselves have gone up to Assur, a wild ass solitary to himself: Ephraim gave gifts to his lovers, but even with a reward they hired nations: now I will gather them, and they shall rest a little while from the burden of the king and the princes.\" The Septuagint: \"Because they themselves have gone up to the Assyrians, Ephraim has sprouted among himself: they have loved gifts: therefore they shall be handed over among the nations, now I will receive them, and they shall rest a little, so that they may anoint kings and princes.\" Israel, he says, has been devoured, and has become like a useless vessel, or an unclean one, from which no shard remains, in which water can be drawn, or a little spark of fire. And because he has become an unclean vessel, therefore they have gone up to the Assyrians, imitating the solitary wild ass: by no means as sheep fed by the Lord, but wrongly abusing their freedom, and led out into captivity, whom the prophet laments and says: Ephraim gave gifts to the Assyrians, and hired his lovers with a reward, of whom Ezekiel writes: To all harlots gifts are given: but you gave gifts to your lovers (Ezek.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":149,"ref":"p149","source":"XVI, 33), et econtrario factum est in te. Cumque dederit dona gentibus, et mercede ad auxiliandum sibi conduxerint nationes, congregabuntur ad pugnam, et vinci pariter abducentur. Et quia amant offerre adversariis munera, ideo paulisper beneficium consequentur, ut non solvant stipendia regi et principibus, donec perveniant in Assyrios, ubi nequaquam tribula, et stipendia dabunt ut liberi; sed redigentur in ultimam servitutem. De haereticis non ambigimus, quin juxta errorem mentis suae euntes ad Assyrios, ascendere se putent, et non descendere. Unde dicitur ad eos per Isaiam: Quid factum est tibi nunc, quia ascendistis omnes in tecta vana (Isa. XXII, 1)? quorum Assyriorum princeps est sensus magnus. Unde in semetipso germinavit Ephraim, praesumptione sui aestimans se crevisse. Sive onager factus est solitarius, ut non Ecclesiae consita, sed diaboli deserta penetraret. Amavit munera pro errore suo, ipse sibi praemia repromittens, sive turpis lucri gratia omnia faciens. Vel certe dedit amatoribus suis daemonibus munera atque mercedes, et cum hoc fecerit, tradetur gentibus. Sicut enim nationes corporalia simulacra venerantur: sic isti idola deos putant, quas de suo corde finxerunt, et ideo reputabuntur in numero nationum. Sin autem, inquit, nunc, et in praesenti saeculo egerint poenitentiam, et susceperim eos, cessabunt parvum super se regem constituere et principes ejus.","english":"16:33), and the opposite has happened in you. And when he has given gifts to the nations, and the nations have hired themselves out for wages to help him, they will be gathered for battle, and will be led away conquered together. And because they love to offer gifts to their adversaries, for a little while they will obtain a benefit, so that they do not pay stipends to the king and his princes, until they arrive in Assyria, where they will no longer pay tribute and stipends as free men, but will be reduced to the utmost slavery. Concerning heretics we do not doubt that, following the error of their own mind as they go to the Assyrians, they think they are ascending and not descending. Whence it is said to them through Isaiah: What has happened to you now, that you have all gone up onto the vain roofs (Isa. 22:1)? The prince of these Assyrians is the great mind. Whence Ephraim sprouted in himself, in his presumption thinking that he had grown by his own power. Or he has become a solitary wild ass, so that he might penetrate not the planted fields of the Church but the deserts of the devil. He loved gifts in return for his error, promising rewards to himself, or doing everything for the sake of shameful gain. Or certainly he gave gifts and wages to his lovers, the demons, and when he has done this, he will be handed over to the nations. For just as the nations worship bodily idols, so these men think that the idols which they have fashioned from their own heart are gods, and therefore they will be reckoned in the number of the nations. But if, he says, now, and in the present age, they have repented, and I have received them, they will cease to set a little king over themselves and his princes.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":150,"ref":"p150","source":"Ut intelligamus parvum regem diabolum, ad distinctionem magni regis, qui societatem cum Belial habere non potest; sed statim ut receptus fuerit, de corde credentium fugat parvum regem et principes ejus. Juxta Hebraicum autem, congregabuntur in Ecclesia Dei qui fuerant antea dispersi, et mercede sibi conduxerant nationes, et quiescent ab onere regis, super quo Apostolus scissos ab Ecclesia increpat, dicens: Sine nobis regnatis: atque utinam regnetis (I Cor. IV, 8), et a principibus quos habent in synagogis diaboli constitutos.\n\n(Vers. 11) « Quia multiplicavit Ephraim altaria ad peccandum, factae sunt ei arae in delictum. » LXX: « Quia multiplicavit Ephraim altaria: in peccatum sunt ei altaria dilecta 2. » Ducti, ait, in captivitatem cessabunt paulisper ab onere regis et principis. Et hoc patientur quia Ephraim princeps eorum multiplicavit altaria, non in quibus immolaret Domino, sed in quibus peccatis peccata conjungeret: quae altaria, id est, arae vertentur ei in delictum, ut quanto plura fuerint, tanto illius scelera multiplicentur. Deinde ut supra dixerat: Quid faciam tibi, Ephraim? quid faciam tibi, Juda? velut ambigens et requirens, quo medicamine sanaret infirmum, et quibus consiliis peccantem retraheret ad salutem.","english":"So that we may understand the \"small king\" to be the devil, in distinction from the great King, who cannot have fellowship with Belial; but as soon as he has been received, he puts to flight from the heart of believers the small king and his princes. According to the Hebrew, however, those who had previously been scattered will be gathered in the Church of God, and had hired nations for themselves for wages, and they will rest from the burden of the king, concerning whom the Apostle rebukes those who have been torn away from the Church, saying: \"You reign without us: and I would that you did reign\" (1 Cor. 4:8), and from the princes whom they have established in the synagogues of the devil.\n\n(Verse 11) \"Because Ephraim has multiplied altars to sin, the altars have become for him a trespass.\" The Septuagint: \"Because Ephraim has multiplied altars: the altars beloved have become for him a sin.\" Led, he says, into captivity, they will cease for a little while from the burden of the king and the prince. And they will suffer this because Ephraim, their prince, has multiplied altars, not on which he might sacrifice to the Lord, but on which he might join sins to sins: which altars, that is, the altars, will be turned for him into a trespass, so that the more there are, the more his crimes may be multiplied. Then, as he had said above: \"What shall I do to you, Ephraim? What shall I do to you, Judah?\" as if doubting and seeking by what remedy he might heal the sick one, and by what counsels he might draw the sinner back to salvation.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":151,"ref":"p151","source":"(Vers. 12.) « Scribam ei multiplices leges meas, quae velut alienae reputatae sunt: hostias offerent, immolabunt carnes, et comedent, et Dominus non suscipiet eas » LXX: « Scribam eis multitudinem: legitima ejus in aliena reputata sunt altaria: quia si immolaverint hostias, et comederint carnes, Dominus non suscipiet eas; » quas prius dederam per Moysen. Sed quid prodest ultra alias scribere, cum contempserit eas quas ante suscepit? Annon contemptus Dei est, quando, me jubente, ut unum in Jerusalem esset altare, per omnes montes et colles idola fabricati sunt, quibus irritarent Dominum? Altaria quoque idcirco fecerunt, non ut mihi placerent; sed ut, multis hostiis immolatis, carnes carum comederent, juxta illud quod Dominus loquitur in Evangelio: Amen, amen dico vobis, quaeritis me, non quia vidistis signa, sed quia manducastis de panibus, et saturati estis (Joan. VI, 26). Omne enim studium victimarum in eo habent, ut devorent hostias, non ut per eas placeant Deo: nec suscipiet eas Dominus quas non illi, sed suo ventri immolaverunt et gutturi. Unum autem esse altare in Ecclesia, et unam fidem, et unum baptisma apostolus docet (Ephes. IV), quod haeretici deserentes, multa sibi altaria fabricati sunt, non ad placandum Deum, sed in delictorum multitudinem. Propterea leges Dei accipere non merentur, cum eas quas acceperant, ante contempserim.","english":"(Verse 12.) \"I will write for him my manifold laws, which have been reckoned as foreign: they will offer sacrifices, they will slay victims, and they will eat, and the Lord will not accept them.\" The Septuagint: \"I will write for them a multitude: his ordinances have been reckoned as foreign altars: for if they have sacrificed victims and eaten the flesh, the Lord will not accept them\" — which I had previously given through Moses. But what profit is there in writing other laws besides, when he has despised those which he received before? Is it not a contempt of God, when, at my command that there should be one altar in Jerusalem, they fashioned idols for themselves through all the mountains and hills, by which they provoked the Lord? They also made altars for this reason, not that they might please me, but that, with many victims sacrificed, they might eat their flesh, according to that which the Lord says in the Gospel: Amen, amen I say to you, you seek me, not because you saw signs, but because you ate of the loaves and were filled (John 6:26). For all their zeal for victims consists in this, that they devour the sacrifices, not that through them they may please God; nor will the Lord accept those which they sacrificed not to him, but to their own belly and gullet. But that there is one altar in the Church, and one faith, and one baptism, the Apostle teaches (Ephesians 4), which the heretics abandoning, have fashioned for themselves many altars, not to appease God, but unto a multitude of sins. Therefore they do not deserve to receive the laws of God, since they had despised beforehand those which they had received.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":152,"ref":"p152","source":"Et si quid dixerint de Scripturis, nequaquam divinis verbis, sed ethnicorum sensibus comparandum est. Isti multas immolant hostias et comedunt carnes earum, unam Christi hostiam deserentes: nec comedentes ejus carnem, cujus caro cibus credentium est. Quidquid fecerint, sacrificiorum ordinem ritumque simulantes, sive dederint eleemosynam, sive pudicitiam repromittant, sive humilitatem simulent, fictisque blanditiis simplices quosque decipiant, nihil de hujuscemodi sacrificiis Dominus suscipiet.\n\n(Vers. 13, 14.) « Nunc recordabitur iniquitates eorum, et visitabit peccata eorum: ipsi in AEgyptum convertentur, et oblitus est Israel factoris sui, et aedificavit delubra, et Judas multiplicavit urbes munitas, et mittam ignem in civitate ejus, ex devorabit aedes illius. » LXX: « Nunc recordabitur iniquitates eorum, et ulciscetur injustitias eorum: ipsi in AEgyptum conversi sunt, et oblitus est Israel eum qui fecit illum, et aedificaverunt delubra, et Judas multiplicavit urbes munitas, et emittam ignem in civitates ejus, et devorabit fundamenta ejus. » Inter, id est, iniquitatem, et peccatum, hoc interest, quod iniquitas ante legem, peccatum post legem est, et qui permanent in delictis, iniquitates eorum Dominus recordabitur, quas ante legem commiserant: peccatorum autem non recordabitur, sed faciet ultionem.","english":"And if they have said anything from the Scriptures, it is by no means to be compared with divine words, but with the thoughts of the Gentiles. These men sacrifice many victims and eat their flesh, forsaking the one sacrifice of Christ, and not eating his flesh, whose flesh is the food of believers. Whatever they do, simulating the order and rite of sacrifices—whether they give alms, or promise chastity, or feign humility, and deceive the simple by fabricated flatteries—the Lord will accept nothing of sacrifices of this kind.\n\n(Verses 13, 14.) \"Now he will remember their iniquities, and visit their sins: they themselves will turn back to Egypt, and Israel has forgotten his maker, and has built shrines, and Judah has multiplied fortified cities, and I will send fire into his city, and it will devour his houses.\" The Septuagint: \"Now he will remember their iniquities, and will avenge their injustices: they themselves have turned back to Egypt, and Israel has forgotten him who made him, and they have built shrines, and Judah has multiplied fortified cities, and I will send fire into his cities, and it will devour its foundations.\" Between iniquity, that is, and sin, there is this difference: that iniquity is before the law, sin after the law; and those who remain in offenses, the Lord will remember their iniquities, which they committed before the law; but he will not remember their sins, but will exact vengeance.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":153,"ref":"p153","source":"Ideo autem et veterum iniquitatem recordabitur, et peccata pristina visitabit: quia in AEgyptum sunt reversi, vel auxilia postulantes, vel eosdem colentes deos, in quibus prius erraverant, et. Oblitus est enim Israel factoris sui, et aedificavit delubra in excelsis, totos colles et montes, et umbrosas arbores, Baal et Astaroth, et aliis idolis consecrans, Judas quoque intelligens Israelem de Dei amore recessisse, et visitata eorum peccata esse, non est conversas ad Dominum, sed in urbium munitione confisus est, quas Dominus destructurum esse se dicit, et usque ad fundamentum illius voraturum. Illius, haud dubium 3, quin Judam (Al. Juda) significet: licet quidam fundamenta earum, id est, urbium pro illius legant. Secundum autem anagogem iniquitatis, id est, et vocantur, quas ante baptismum commisimus, et quae nobis in baptismate sunt dimissae: pecata autem quae post baptismum egimus, de quibus et in psalmo scriptum est: Beati quorum remissae sunt iniquitates, et quorum tecta sunt peccata (Psal. XXXI, 1). Quae omnia imputabuntur haereticis ut et veteres iniquitates, et nova eis peccata reddantur. Qui enim de AEgypto exierant per confessionem Christi, perfidia in AEgyptum sunt reversi. Oblitus est Israel factoris sui, et Oratore contempto, alium sibi finxit Dominum.","english":"Therefore he will both remember the iniquity of the ancients and visit their former sins: because they have returned to Egypt, either seeking aid or worshipping the same gods in which they had previously gone astray. For Israel has forgotten his Maker, and has built shrines on the high places, consecrating whole hills and mountains and shady trees to Baal and Astaroth and other idols. Judas also, understanding that Israel had withdrawn from the love of God and that their sins had been visited, did not turn back to the Lord, but trusted in the fortification of cities, which the Lord says he will destroy and devour even to their foundation. By \"their\" there is no doubt that he signifies Judas, although some read \"the foundations of them,\" that is, of the cities, instead of \"of him.\" According to anagogy, however, \"iniquities\" are those which we committed before baptism and which were forgiven us in baptism; but \"sins\" are those which we have committed after baptism, of which it is also written in the psalm: Blessed are those whose iniquities are forgiven, and whose sins are covered. All these things will be imputed to heretics, so that both their old iniquities and their new sins may be requited to them. For those who had gone out of Egypt through confession of Christ have returned to Egypt through faithlessness. Israel has forgotten his Maker, and, despising the Orator, has fashioned for himself another Lord.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":154,"ref":"p154","source":"Judas quoque, id est, vir ecclesiasticus, in malis operibus, vel in sanctarum Scripturarum interpretatione perversa, aedificavit sibi urbes munitas, non auxilio Dei, sed artifici (Al. artificis) mendacio: quas Dominus igne sui spiritus succensurum esse se dicit, et devoraturum ejus, id est, magnas et in modum turrium aedificatas domos: et fundamenta male posita subversurum, ne possint sacrilega contra Deum delubra construere. Quidam urbes a Juda munitas in bonam partem accipiunt, et illud quod huic sensui contrarium videbatur: immittam ignem in civitates ejus, et devorabit cedes illius, ita temperare nituntur, ut postquam venerit quod perfectum est, in quod ex parte est, destruatur. Quod juxta LXX interpretes legimus,: et in Assyriis immunda comederunt, in Hebraico non habetur, et idcirco obelo praenotandum est. Possumus autem dicere, quod desiderantes AEgyptum Israelitae, capti ab Assyriis, ibi immunda comederint, juxta Ezechielem, qui eos in Chaldaea idolothyta comedisse describit (Ezech. IV): et in tantum idolorum polluta sordibus, ut humano stercori comparentur. Haeretici quoque quorum principes sunt Assyrii (de quibus crebro diximus), comedunt apud eos immunda, dum illorum sordibus inquinantur.","english":"Judas also, that is, the ecclesiastical man, in evil works, or in the perverse interpretation of the Holy Scriptures, has built for himself fortified cities, not by the help of God, but by the lie of a craftsman: which cities the Lord says he will set on fire with the fire of his spirit, and will devour his, that is, great houses built in the manner of towers: and will overturn the foundations wrongly laid, so that they may not be able to construct sacrilegious shrines against God. Some take the cities fortified by Judas in a good sense, and that which seemed contrary to this meaning: I will send fire into his cities, and it will devour his slaughter, they try so to temper it, that after that which is perfect has come, that which is in part may be destroyed. What we read according to the Seventy: and among the Assyrians they ate unclean things, is not found in the Hebrew, and therefore must be marked with an obelus. But we can say that the Israelites, desiring Egypt, when captured by the Assyrians, ate unclean things there, according to Ezekiel, who describes them as having eaten things sacrificed to idols in Chaldea (Ezek. 4): and to such an extent polluted with the filth of idols, that they are compared to human dung. The heretics also, whose leaders are the Assyrians (of whom we have often spoken), eat unclean things among them, while they are defiled by their filth.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":155,"ref":"p155","source":"(Cap. IX.—Vers. 1. 2.) « Noli laetari. Israel: noli exsultare sicut populi: quia fornicatus es a Deo tuo: dilexisti mercedem super areas tritici. Area et torcular non pascet eos, et vinum mentietur eis. » LXX: « Noli gaudere, Israel, et noli laetari sicut populi: quia fornicatus es a Deo tuo: dilexisti munera super omnem aream tritici. Area et torcular non cognovit cos, et vinum mentitum est illis. » Qui a Deo recesserunt, cum in profundum venerint peccatorum, et desperaverint salutem suam, universa contemnent (Prov. XVIII). Denique et Israel recedens a lege Dei, et colens idola, ex multis gentibus unam gentem esse dicit: gaudens et gratulans quod a Dei notitia recesserit, et sit gens mixta cum caeteris; et propterea nunc corripit eos et dicit: Ne gaudeas, ne laeteris, nec putes te talem esse, ut sunt caeterae nationes. Aliter enim nesciens Deum, aliter punitur recedens a Deo, quia servus qui scit voluntatem domini sui, et non facit eam, vapulabit multum (Luc. XII). Mercedem fornicationis tuas areas multas et torcularia reputasti, ut rerum omnium abundantia fruereris: ideo area et torcular, triticum vinumque non facient, et mentietur eis torcular, sive negabit vinum suum, quo se inebriandos putabant. Legimus sub Achab rege Israel, et Elia propheta, famem gravissimam fuisse in Samaria: ita ut matres filiorum suorum cadaveribus vescerentur (IV Reg. VI).","english":"(Cap. 9.—Vers. 1, 2.) «Do not rejoice, Israel; do not exult as the peoples do: for you have played the harlot against your God: you have loved a reward upon the threshing floors of wheat. The threshing floor and the winepress shall not feed them, and the wine shall lie to them.» The Septuagint: «Do not rejoice, Israel, and do not exult as the peoples do: for you have played the harlot against your God: you have loved gifts upon every threshing floor of wheat. The threshing floor and the winepress have not known them, and the wine has lied to them.» Those who have withdrawn from God, when they have come into the depth of sins and have despaired of their salvation, will despise all things (Prov. 18). Finally, Israel too, withdrawing from the law of God and worshipping idols, is said to be one nation out of many peoples: rejoicing and exulting that it has withdrawn from the knowledge of God and has become a nation mixed with the rest; and therefore he now rebukes them and says: Do not rejoice, do not exult, and do not think that you are such as the other nations are. For one who does not know God is punished in one way, and one who withdraws from God in another, because the servant who knows the will of his master and does not do it will be beaten with many blows (Luke 12). You have reckoned your many threshing floors and winepresses to be the reward of your fornication, so that you might enjoy an abundance of all things: therefore the threshing floor and the winepress shall not produce wheat and wine, and the winepress shall lie to them, or shall deny its wine, with which they thought they would be made drunk. We read that under Ahab king of Israel, and Elijah the prophet, there was a most grievous famine in Samaria: so much so that mothers fed on the corpses of their sons (4 Kings 6).","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":156,"ref":"p156","source":"Eo tempore, juxta litteram, area et torcular non pavit eos, et vinum mentitum est eis, et in egestate tabuerunt. Dicitur et ad haereticos, ne exsultent atque laetentur, et putent se caeterarum similes nationum. Illae enim non crediderunt in Deum; isti vero sub nomine Dei idola colunt, et fornicantur a Deo suo: et plures sibi areas, et torcularia infinita multiplicant, et comedunt triticum, de quo efficitur panis luctus, et bibunt vinum Sodomorum, quod cum aspidum felle calcatur. Et quia sibi plura torcularia, et multas areas praepararunt: idcirco de vera et de una area, et de torculari quod calcavit Dominus Jesus, non vescentur, et non bibent: sed quodcunque se habere putaverint, mendacio depravabitur.\n\n(Vers. et 4.) « Non habitabunt in terra Domini. Reversus est Ephraim in AEgyptum, et in Assyriis pollutum comedit: Non libabunt Domino vinum, et non placebunt ei sacrificia eorum, quasi panis lugentium, omnes qui comedunt illum, contaminabuntur, quia panis eorum, animae ipsorum, non intrabunt in domum Domini. » LXX: « Non habitaverunt in terra Domini, habitavit Ephraim in AEgypto, et in Assyriis immundum comedit: non libaverunt Domino vinum, nec placuerunt ei sacrificia eorum: quasi panis luctus ejus: omnes qui manducaverint ea, contaminabuntur; quia panes animarum eorum non intrabunt in domum Domini.","english":"At that time, according to the letter, the threshing floor and the winepress did not feed them, and the wine lied to them, and they wasted away in want. It is said also to heretics, that they should not exult and rejoice, and think themselves like the other nations. For those did not believe in God; but these under the name of God worship idols, and play the harlot away from their God: and they multiply for themselves more threshing floors, and countless winepresses, and eat the wheat from which is made the bread of mourning, and drink the wine of Sodom, which is trodden with the gall of asps. And because they have prepared for themselves more winepresses and many threshing floors: therefore from the true and one threshing floor, and from the winepress which the Lord Jesus trod, they shall not eat, and shall not drink: but whatever they think they have, will be corrupted by falsehood.\n\n(Vers. 3 and 4.) «They shall not dwell in the land of the Lord. Ephraim has returned to Egypt, and among the Assyrians eats what is polluted: They shall not pour wine to the Lord, and their sacrifices shall not please him, like the bread of mourners, all who eat it shall be contaminated, because their bread is for their own souls, they shall not enter into the house of the Lord.» The Septuagint: «They did not dwell in the land of the Lord, Ephraim dwelt in Egypt, and among the Assyrians ate what is unclean: they did not pour wine to the Lord, nor did their sacrifices please him: like the bread of his mourning: all who eat them shall be contaminated; because the loaves of their souls shall not enter into the house of the Lord.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":157,"ref":"p157","source":"» Non solum arca, et torcular non pavit eos, et vinum mentitum est in terra Israel, quando per triennium, et mensessex cuncta perierunt 5, sed et ipsi habitatores recedent de terra Domini, et ducentur in terram alienam, ne habitent in terra sancta quam suis fornicationibus polluerunt. Reversus est, inquit, Ephraim in AEgyptum, et in Assyriis pollutum comedit. De hoc loco quidam supra addiderunt: et\n\nin Assyriis pollutum comedit, quod in Hebraico non habetur, de quo jam diximus. Cum autem fuerint in Chaldea absque templo et absque altari, non libabunt Domino vinum, sed daemonibus, et non placebunt ei, qui libant diis alienis, et qui in captivitate retinentur atque in Assyriis idolothyta comedunt, et quasi panes lugentium sunt. Non est enim licitum de sacrificiis comedere lugentium, et si comederit, immundum fiet quod licite oblatum est. Lugentium coenas Graeci vocant, nos parentalia possumus dicere, ab eo quod parentibus mortuis immolentur. Et non solum qui obtulerit, sed etiam qui comederit de hujuscemodi cibis immundus erit: panis enim eorum, hoc est cibus quem offerunt, non intrabit in domum Domini, quae destructa est, quae Babylonio igne succensa est; sed erit animae eorum. Et est sensus, suae gulae, et suae provident voluptati; caeterum mihi non placent polluta.","english":"Not only did the ark and the winepress not feed them, and the wine lied in the land of Israel, when for three years and six months all things perished, but also the inhabitants themselves will depart from the land of the Lord and be led into a foreign land, so that they may not dwell in the holy land which they defiled with their fornications. Ephraim, he says, has returned to Egypt, and among the Assyrians he has eaten what is polluted. Concerning this passage, some have added above: and among the Assyrians he has eaten what is polluted, which is not found in the Hebrew, about which we have already spoken. But when they have been in Chaldea without a temple and without an altar, they will not pour out wine to the Lord, but to demons, and they will not please him—those who pour libations to alien gods, and who are held in captivity and among the Assyrians eat things sacrificed to idols, and are like the bread of mourners. For it is not lawful to eat of the sacrifices of mourners, and if one eats, what was lawfully offered will become unclean. The Greeks call these the dinners of mourners; we can call them parentalia, from the fact that they are sacrificed to dead parents. And not only the one who offers, but also the one who eats of foods of this kind will be unclean: for their bread, that is, the food which they offer, will not enter into the house of the Lord, which has been destroyed, which has been set on fire by Babylonian flame; but it will be for their soul. And the sense is: for their own gullet and their own pleasure of appetite; otherwise, polluted things do not please me.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":158,"ref":"p158","source":"Non habitabunt in terra domini, qui ab ecclesia recesserunt, et reversi sunt mente in AEgyptum, et Assyriorum, id est, daemonum comedunt sacrificia: nec libant Domino vinum quo inebriati sunt in luxuriam, et non placent ei nec illa quae offerunt, nec ipsi qui offerunt. Sacrificia haereticorum panis luctus est et lacrymarum: omnia enim quae faciunt vertentur in fletum. Nec audire poterunt: Beati lugentes, quoniam ipsi consolabuntur (Matth. V, 5); sed e contrario audient: Vae ridentibus, quia ipsi lugebunt (Luc. VI. 25). Quidquid offerunt non Deo, sed mortuis offerunt: his videlicet qui sceleratas haereses confinxerunt; et quicunque de eorum comederit victimis, contaminabitur. Caeci in foveam ducentur a caecis. Quidquid fecerint deliciarum causa faciunt, ut populum decipiant, ut domos devorent viduarum. Panem luctus possumus dicere, verba mortifera, quibus iniquitatem loquuntur contra Dominum: qui panis non ingreditur in domum Dei: haereticorum enim conciliabula, non domus Dei appellantur, sed speluncae latronum.","english":"They will not dwell in the land of the Lord, those who have withdrawn from the church and have turned back in mind to Egypt, and eat the sacrifices of the Assyrians, that is, of demons; nor do they pour a libation to the Lord of the wine with which they have become drunk unto debauchery, and neither the things they offer nor they themselves who offer are pleasing to him. The sacrifices of heretics are the bread of mourning and of tears; for all things they do will be turned into weeping. Nor will they be able to hear: Blessed are they that mourn, for they shall be comforted; but on the contrary they will hear: Woe to them that laugh, for they shall mourn. Whatever they offer, they offer not to God but to the dead: namely to those who devised wicked heresies; and whoever eats of their victims will be contaminated. The blind will be led into the pit by the blind. Whatever they do, they do for the sake of pleasure, that they may deceive the people, that they may devour the houses of widows. We can call the bread of mourning the death-bearing words with which they speak iniquity against the Lord; which bread does not enter into the house of God: for the assemblies of heretics are not called the house of God, but dens of robbers.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":159,"ref":"p159","source":"(Vers. 5. et 6.) « Quid facietis in die solemni, in die festivitatis Domini? Ecce enim profecti sunt a vastitate: AEgyptus congregabit eos, Memphis sepeliet eos, desiderabile argentum eorum urtica haereditabit, lappa in tabernaculis eorum. » LXX: « Quid facietis in die conventus, et in die solemnitatis Domini? Ideo ecce ibunt de miseria AEgypti, et suscipiet eos Memphis, et sepeliet eos Machmas, argentum eorum interitus possidebit, spinae in tabernaculis eorum. » Cum venerit, inquit, dies captivitatis ct saevissimus hostis ingruerit, quae mea solemnitas est? quam ego placabilem habeo hostiam? quia me de meis hostibus vindicat, et injuriae ponit modum, et flagellat impios filios. Quid igitur facietis in die festivitatis Domini? Respondete. Illisque tacentibus, sibi ipse respondet, imo quae facturi sint, divinis oculis intuetur: Ecce, inquit, miseria et vastitate prementibus, et Assyrio atque Chaldaeo captos ligare cupientibus, ad AEgyptum confugerunt. Ibi Memphis sepeliet eos, quae eo tempore erat metropolis AEgypti, antequam Alexandria, quae prius appellabatur NO ( ) ab Alexandro Macedone et magnitudinem urbis et nomen acciperet. Quod autem in Septuaginta dicit, sepeliet eos Machmas, in Hebraeo non habetur; sed MAMAD ( ) quod appellatur desiderabile.","english":"(Verses 5 and 6.) “What will you do on the day of solemnity, on the day of the Lord’s festivity? For behold, they have departed from devastation: Egypt will gather them, Memphis will bury them, the nettle will inherit their desirable silver, the burdock will be in their tents.” The Septuagint: “What will you do on the day of assembly, and on the day of the Lord’s solemnity? Therefore behold, they will go out from the misery of Egypt, and Memphis will receive them, and Machmas will bury them, destruction will possess their silver, thorns will be in their tents.” When the day of captivity has come, he says, and the most savage enemy has pressed in, what solemnity of mine is there? What acceptable victim do I have? For he avenges me on my enemies, and sets a limit to injury, and scourges impious sons. What then will you do on the day of the Lord’s festivity? Answer. And while they are silent, he answers himself—rather, what they are going to do he beholds with divine eyes: Behold, he says, with misery and devastation pressing, and with the Assyrian and Chaldean desiring to bind the captives, they have fled to Egypt. There Memphis will bury them, which at that time was the metropolis of Egypt, before Alexandria, which was formerly called No, received both the size of a city and its name from Alexander of Macedon. But what the Septuagint says, “Machmas will bury them,” is not found in the Hebrew; but Mamad, which is called “desirable.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":160,"ref":"p160","source":"Ex quo perspicuum est, falsos eos esse similitudine litterarum DALETH ( ) et CHAPH( ); et pro Mamad, quod omnes desiderabile transtulerunt, putasse Machmas AEgypti civitatem esse. Possumus hoc quod dicitur: Ecce enim profecti sunt a vastitate, AEgyptus congrebabit eos, Memphis sepeliet eos, et de tribu Juda accipere: quando, interfecto Godolia ab Ismaele, quem Nabuchodonosor terrae proposuerat, reliquiae populi cum Jeremia propheta ad AEgyptum transfugerunt, et ibi persequentibus postea Chaldaeis, vel captae sunt, vel sepultae (IV Reg. XXV). Desiderabile autem argentum eorum, quod urtica possedit, villas et omnia ornamenta villarum intelligemus, quae pretio emuntur argenti. Quodque sequitur lappa in tabernaculis eorum, longam significat vastitatem, ut ubi quondam domus eorum erant, ibi lappae et urticae nascantur ac spinae. Dicitur et ad haereticos: Cum dies solemnis advenerit, quid facturi estis? Pro die solemni, Aquila interpretatus est tempus.","english":"From this it is clear that they are false, by the similarity of the letters DALETH and CHAPH; and that instead of Mamad, which all have translated as \"desirable,\" they thought Machmas was a city of Egypt. But what is said here—\"For behold, they have departed from devastation, Egypt will gather them, Memphis will bury them\"—we can understand as concerning the tribe of Judah: when, after Gedaliah had been killed by Ishmael, whom Nebuchadnezzar had appointed over the land, the remnants of the people fled with the prophet Jeremiah to Egypt, and there, when the Chaldeans later pursued them, they were either captured or buried (2 Kings 25). But \"their desirable silver,\" which the nettle possessed, we will understand as the estates and all the ornaments of estates, which are bought at the price of silver. And what follows—\"the burdock in their tabernacles\"—signifies a long devastation, so that where their houses once were, there burdocks and nettles and thorns may grow. It is also said to heretics: \"When the day of solemnity has come, what will you do?\" Instead of \"day of solemnity,\" Aquila translated it as \"time.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":161,"ref":"p161","source":"Ex quo manifestum est, non festum diem sonare, sed tempus retributionis: statim enim sequitur: Venerunt dies ultionis, venerunt dies retributionis tuae; Ecce vastati estis a multis hostibus: Assyrii vos Chaldaeique jugularunt, fugistis ad saeculum, et caeteris estis nationibus comparati: ibi vos Memphis sepeliet, quod interpretatur ex ore; et est sensus: juxta vestras blasphemias recipietis, et quod locuti estis, in suppliciis sentietis: desiderabilia, hoc est, dogmata quae vobis artifici composueratis eloquio, quod interpretatur argentum, possidet urtica, quae vos aeterno ardore consumet: et erit lappa vel spina in tabernaculis vestris, spinae quippe orientur in manibus eorum, qui inebriati sunt calice Babylonio (Jerem. LI). Et in Evangelio legimus, turpes cogitationes et curas hujus mundi, et inhaerentia vitia, spinas appellari, quae surgentia in herbis frumenta suffocent (Matth. XIII). (Vers. 7.) « Venerunt dies visitationis, venerunt dies retributionis: scitote 2, Israel, stultum prophetam, insanum virum spiritualem propter multitudinem iniquitatis tuae, et multitudinem amentiae. » LXX: « Venerunt dies ultionis, venerunt dies retributionis tuae, et affligetur Israel sicut propheta insaniens, homo qui habebat spiritum, propter multitudinem iniquitatum tuarum, multiplicata est amentia tua.","english":"From this it is clear that it does not signify a feast day, but a time of retribution; for immediately there follows: The days of vengeance have come, the days of your retribution have come. Behold, you have been laid waste by many enemies: the Assyrians and Chaldeans have slaughtered you, you have fled to the world, and you have been made like the other nations: there Memphis will bury you, which is interpreted as \"from the mouth\"; and the sense is: in accordance with your blasphemies you will receive, and what you have spoken, you will feel in your punishments: the desirable things, that is, the doctrines which you had composed for yourselves with artificial eloquence, which is interpreted as \"silver,\" the nettle possesses, which will consume you with eternal burning: and there will be a burdock or thorn in your tents, for thorns will spring up in the hands of those who have been intoxicated with the Babylonian cup (Jeremiah 51). And in the Gospel we read that shameful thoughts and the cares of this world, and the vices that cling to us, are called thorns, which springing up choke the grain growing among the plants (Matthew 13). (Verse 7.) \"The days of visitation have come, the days of retribution have come: know, Israel, the foolish prophet, the mad spiritual man, because of the multitude of your iniquity, and the multitude of your madness.\" The Septuagint: \"The days of vengeance have come, the days of your retribution have come, and Israel will be afflicted like a mad prophet, a man who had the spirit, because of the multitude of your iniquities, your madness has been multiplied.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":162,"ref":"p162","source":"» Et in hoc loco error est solitus: ubi enim nos interpretati sumus, scitote, Israel, hoc est, Israelitae, et Hebraeo legitur JADAU ( ), Septuaginta transtulerunt et affligetur: JOD litteram VAU putantes, et pro DALETH legentes RES: quorum alterum scientiam, alterum afflictionem, vel malitiam sonat. Venerunt igitur dies visitationis, de quibus supra (vers. 5) dixerat: Quid facietis in die solemni, et in die festivitatis Domini? Venerunt dies retributionis. O Israel, nunc tua verba cognosce, qui prophetam tibi vere dicentem, et prophetantem Spiritu sancto, stultum et insanum vocabas, juxta illud quod in Ramoth Galaad principes locuti sunt ad Jehu: Quid venit ad te iste vesanus (IV Reg. IX, 11)? Igitur propter multitudinem iniquitatum tuarum, quibus in scelere diu debacchatus es, non prophetam meum, sed te insanum esse cognosce, qui ad hoc laborasti, ut mea verba calcares. Pro amentia, Aquila vertit, quam nos vel iracundiam vel memoriam doloris, in Latino possumus dicere. Diem ultionis et retributionis, quidam interpretantur diem judicii, quando affligetur Israel, qui nunc Deum se videre jactat, et non sancto Spiritu regitur, sed daemoniaco in partes varias circumfertur, nesciens quid loquatur: dicens Dei Filium creaturam, sanctum Spiritum Deum negans.","english":"And in this place too there is a customary error: for where we have translated, Know, Israel, that is, Israelites, and in Hebrew it is read JADAU, the Septuagint translated it as and he shall be afflicted, taking the letter JOD for VAU, and reading RES for DALETH: of which the one sounds forth knowledge, the other affliction or malice. The days of visitation have therefore come, of which he had said above: What will you do on the solemn day, and on the day of the feast of the Lord? The days of retribution have come. O Israel, now recognize your own words, you who called the prophet, truly speaking to you and prophesying by the Holy Spirit, a fool and a madman, according to that which the princes spoke at Ramoth Gilead to Jehu: What has this madman come to you for? Therefore, because of the multitude of your iniquities, in which you have long raged in wickedness, recognize that it is not my prophet but you who are mad, you who have labored for this end, that you might trample my words underfoot. For amentia, Aquila rendered it as which we can say in Latin either as wrath or as remembrance of grief. The day of vengeance and retribution some interpret as the day of judgment, when Israel shall be afflicted, who now boasts that it sees God, and is not governed by the Holy Spirit, but is carried about by a demon into various factions, not knowing what it says: saying that the Son of God is a creature, denying that the Holy Spirit is God.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":163,"ref":"p163","source":"Et rursum alium Deum bonum, alium mundi asserens creatorem: quorum vesania multiplex est, quia et iniquitates fuere quamplurimae. Quem nos stultum prophetam diximus, septuaginta pseudoprophetam interpretati sunt. Et ne eadem saepe repetentes, videamur lectoris prudentiae diffidere. breviter admonemus, quidquid de Israel et de Ephraim in hoc propheta dicitur, ad haereticos esse referendum, qui vere insanientes, contra Deum loquuntur mendacia.\n\n(Vers. et 9.) « Speculator Ephraim cum Deo meo: propheta laqueus ruinae super omnes vias ejus: insania in domo Dei ejus, profunde peccaverunt: sicut in diebus Gabaa, recordabitur iniquitates eorum, et visitabit peccata eorum. » LXX: « Speculator Ephraim cum Deo propheta: laqueus tortuosus super omnes vias ejus, insaniam in domo Dei confinxerunt: corrupti sunt secundum dies collis: recordabitur iniquitates eorum, ulciscetur super peccata eorum. » Idcirco Deus principes dedit, ut populum corriperent delinquentem, et ad rectum iter retraherent: unde et ad Ezechiel loquitur: Speculatorem te dedi domui Israel (Ezech. XXXVIII, 7). Ergo Jeroboam quasi speculator datus in populo est, et quasi propheta cum Deo meo, hoc est, cum Deo, qui haec Osee loquitur.","english":"And again, asserting that there is another God who is good, and another who is the creator of the world—whose madness is manifold, because their iniquities were also very many. The one whom we have called a foolish prophet, the Seventy translated as a false prophet. And lest, by often repeating the same things, we seem to distrust the reader's prudence, we briefly warn that whatever is said concerning Israel and Ephraim in this prophet must be referred to the heretics, who, truly raving, speak lies against God.\n\n(Verse 8 and 9.) \"The watchman of Ephraim was with my God: the prophet is a snare of ruin upon all his ways: madness in the house of his God, they have sinned deeply: as in the days of Gabaa, he will remember their iniquities, and will visit their sins.\" The Septuagint: \"The watchman of Ephraim with God, a prophet: a twisted snare upon all his ways, they have contrived madness in the house of God: they are corrupted according to the days of the hill: he will remember their iniquities, he will avenge upon their sins.\" Therefore God gave princes, that they might rebuke the people when they sin, and draw them back to the right path: whence also he speaks to Ezekiel: I have given you as a watchman to the house of Israel (Ezekiel 38:7). Therefore Jeroboam was given as a watchman among the people, and as a prophet with my God, that is, with God, who speaks these things through Hosea.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":164,"ref":"p164","source":"At illa juxta id quod supra scriptum est: Laqueus facti estis speculationi, et rete expansum super Thabor, et victimas declinastis in profundum, etiam nunc populi Israel laqueus appellatur, eo quod omnes in laqueo ejus corruant, maxime cum insaniam in domo Dei posuerit, sive confinxerit, id est, in Bethel vitolum aureum fecerit, hoc enim interpretatur domus Dei: et tam profunde in scelere peccaverit, sicque in impietatis barathrum sit demersus, ut vincat scelus, quod quondam gestum est in Gabaa, quando uxorem levitae revertentis dc Bethleem illicito necavere concubitu (Judic. XIX). Possumus dies Gabaa et illud tempus accipere, quando pro Deo elegerunt sibi regem de urbe Gabaa, id est, Saul. Et multo nunc eos dicit majora peccasse, eligendo Jeroboam et adorando idola, quam co tempore, quo elegerunt Saul: hic enim schismati etiam idololatria copulata est: ibi vero Dei cultus permansit in populo. Ideo recordabitur iniquitates eorum, qui nunc per patientiam putatur oblitus, et visitabit peccuta eorum, et vulnera, quae longo tempore computruerunt. Veteres scrutans historias, invenire non possum scidisse Ecclesiam, et de domo Domini populus seduxisse, praeter eos qui sacerdotes a Deo positi fuerant et prophetae, id est speculatores.","english":"But that [people], according to what was written above: You have become a snare for the watchtower, and a net spread over Tabor, and you have turned aside victims into the deep — even now the people of Israel is called a snare, because all fall into its snare, especially since it has placed — or devised — madness in the house of God, that is, in Bethel made a golden calf; for this is the meaning of \"house of God.\" And it has sinned so deeply in wickedness, and has been so submerged in the abyss of impiety, that its crime surpasses what was once committed in Gibeah, when they unlawfully killed the wife of the Levite returning from Bethlehem through illicit intercourse (Judges 19). We can take the \"days of Gibeah\" as that time when, in place of God, they chose for themselves a king from the city of Gibeah, that is, Saul. And he says that they have now sinned much more greatly by choosing Jeroboam and worshiping idols than at that time when they chose Saul; for here idolatry was joined even to schism, whereas there the worship of God remained among the people. Therefore he will remember their iniquities, which he now seems to have forgotten through patience, and he will visit their sins and the wounds that have festered for a long time. Searching the ancient histories, I cannot find that anyone tore the Church apart and seduced the people from the house of the Lord, except those who had been appointed by God as priests and prophets, that is, watchmen.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":165,"ref":"p165","source":"Isti ergo vertuntur in laqueum tortuosum, in omnibus locis ponentes scandalum, ut quicunque per vias illorum ingressus fuerit, corruat, et in Christo stare non possit, variisque abducatur erroribus, et semitis tortuosis ad praecipitia deferatur. Hi sunt speculatores Ephraim, qui insaniam in domo Domini confinxerunt, hoc est, in Ecclesia, sive in Scripturis sanctis, perverse eas interpretantes, vel certe in unoquoque credentium, qui domus Dei rectissime nominatur. Propterca corrupti sunt, et interierunt juxta dies collis, quando iniquitatem in excelsos loculi sunt, et ascenderunt in tecta vana. Recordabitur Deus iniquitatis eorum, per quam inique gesserunt in proximum, educentes eum de Ecclesia, et visitabit peccata eorum, quibus in suas animas peccaverunt. Hoc est quod in psalmo legimus: Juxta semitam scandalum posuerunt mihi (Psal. CXXXIX, 6). Nisi enim quis Del viderit semitam, id est, Christi nomen audierit, non ingredietur per eum. Idcirco et haeretici sub nomine Christi juxta semitam ponunt laqueos, ut qui in Christo calcare se credit, de quo legimus, quod ipse sit via, calcet et in eorum laqueis, qui insaniam in domo Dei confinxerunt.","english":"These, therefore, are turned into a twisted snare, placing a stumbling block in every place, so that whoever enters by their ways may fall and be unable to stand in Christ, and may be led away by various errors and carried down to precipices along twisted paths. These are the watchmen of Ephraim, who devised madness in the house of the Lord, that is, in the Church, or in the Holy Scriptures, interpreting them perversely, or certainly in each one of the believers, who is most rightly called the house of God. Therefore they have been corrupted and have perished according to the days of the hill, when they set iniquity on high and climbed onto empty roofs. God will remember their iniquity, by which they acted wickedly against their neighbor, leading him out of the Church, and he will visit their sins, by which they sinned against their own souls. This is what we read in the psalm: Along the path they have set a stumbling block for me (Ps. 139:6). For unless one has seen the path of God, that is, has heard the name of Christ, he will not enter through him. Therefore heretics too, under the name of Christ, set snares along the path, so that one who believes he is walking in Christ, of whom we read that he himself is the way, may also walk into their snares, who have devised madness in the house of God.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":166,"ref":"p166","source":"(Vers. 10, 11.) « Quasi uvas in deserto inveni Israel, quasi prima poma ficulneae in cacumine ejus, vidi patres eorum, ipsi autem intraverunt ad Beelphegor, et alienati sunt in confusionem, et facti sunt abominabiles, sicut ea quae dilexerunt. » LXX: « Sicut uvam in deserto inveni Israel, et sicut ficum in arbore ficus temporanea vidi patres eorum, ipsi autem ingressi sunt Beelphegor, et abalienati sunt in confusionem, et facti sunt abominabiles sicut dilecti. » Pro quo in aliis exemplaribus legimus: et facti sunt dilecti, quasi abominabiles, quod magis congruit veritati. Cum omnis orbis esset desertus, et Dei notitiam non haberet, inveni, ait, populum Israel quasi uvam in solitudine, et quomodo cum invenerit. dicit: Sicut prima poma ficulneae, in cacumine ejus vidi patres eorum. Ergo in Abraham, in Isaac, et Jacob inventus est populus. Et nota proprietatem, parentes videntur, populus invenitur et in utroque vinea est, cl ficulnea, sub quibus requiescere dicitur qui confidit in Domino. Ipsi autem educti de AEgypto, fornicati sunt cum Madianitis (Num. XXV), et ingressi sunt ad Beelphegor idolum Moabitarum, quem nos Priapum possumus appellare. Denique interpretatur Beelphegor idolum tentiginis, habens in ore, id est. in summitate, pellem 1; ut turpitudinem membri virilis ostenderet.","english":"(Vers. 10, 11.) «Like grapes in the desert I found Israel, like the first fruits of the fig tree on its top, I saw their fathers, but they themselves entered in to Beelphegor, and were estranged into confusion, and became abominable, like the things which they loved.» The Septuagint: «Like a grape in the desert I found Israel, and like a fig on the fig tree I saw their fathers as an early fig, but they themselves entered in to Beelphegor, and were alienated into confusion, and became abominable like their beloved.» In place of which, in other copies we read: and they became beloved, like abominable things, which agrees more with the truth. When the whole world was desert, and did not have knowledge of God, I found, he says, the people of Israel like a grape in the wilderness, and how he found them he says: Like the first fruits of the fig tree, on its top I saw their fathers. Therefore in Abraham, in Isaac, and Jacob the people was found. And note the propriety: the parents are seen, the people is found, and in both there is a vine and a fig tree, under which he is said to rest who trusts in the Lord. But they themselves, having been led out of Egypt, fornicated with the Midianites (Num. 25), and entered in to Beelphegor, the idol of the Moabites, whom we can call Priapus. Finally Beelphegor is interpreted as the idol of tentigo, having in its mouth, that is, on its top, a skin, so that it might display the shamefulness of the male member.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":167,"ref":"p167","source":"Et quia intraverunt ad Beelphegor, idcirco abalienati sunt a Deo, confusioni suae, id est, idolo mancipati, ut propter quod recesserant a Deo, illud colerent, secundum quod scriptum est: A quo enim quis superatur, hujus et servus est (II Petr. II, 19), et sicut gulae servientes, habent ventrem Deum (Philipp. III): ita qui libidini deserviunt, habet Deum Beelphegor. Et facti sunt, inquit, abominabiles, sicut ea quae dilexerunt, juxta illud quod scriptum esi in Psalmis: Similes illis fiant qui faciunt ea, et omnes qui confidunt in eis (Psal. CXXXIV, 18), ut non solum idololatrae, sed idola nuncupentur. Dicente autem Domino in passione sua: Torcular calcavi solus, et de gentibus non est vir mecum (Isa. LXIII, 3). Et in psalmo: Salvum me fac. Domine, quoniam defecit sanctus (Psal. XI, 1). Cum omnis mundus teneretur in peccato et gentes ignorarent Deum, et Israel repulisset quem ante cognoverat, primum in apostolis, et in apostolicis viris, invenit Dominus Israel populum Christianum, et sensu videntem Deum et dulcissimis eorum satiatus est fructibus, uva et ficu, quae si in deserto inveniantur, et necdum maturo tempore, ob raritatem majoris sunt gratiae. Ipsi autem, hoc est, Israel, qui sibi Christianum nomen assumunt (neque enim de patribus intelligendum est), intraverunt ad idolum Beelphegor, quod habet in ore pellem.","english":"And because they entered in to Beelphegor, therefore they were estranged from God, enslaved to their own confusion, that is, to an idol, so that by the very thing for which they had departed from God, they might worship it, according to what is written: For by whatever a man is overcome, of that same is he also the servant (2 Peter 2:19), and just as those who serve gluttony have their belly as their god (Philippians 3), so he who is enslaved to lust has Beelphegor as his god. And they became, he says, abominable, like the things which they loved, according to what is written in the Psalms: Let those who make them become like them, and all who trust in them (Psalm 134:18), so that they are called not only idolaters but idols. But when the Lord says in his passion: I have trodden the winepress alone, and of the nations there is no man with me (Isaiah 63:3). And in the psalm: Save me, O Lord, for the holy one has failed (Psalm 11:1). Since the whole world was held in sin and the nations did not know God, and Israel had rejected him whom it had previously known, first in the apostles and in apostolic men the Lord found the Christian people as Israel, both seeing God in understanding and satisfied with their sweetest fruits, the grape and the fig, which if they are found in the desert, and not yet in the ripe season, are of greater grace because of their rarity. But they themselves, that is, Israel, who assume for themselves the Christian name (for it is not to be understood of the fathers), have entered in to the idol Beelphegor, which has a skin in its mouth.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":168,"ref":"p168","source":"Quidquid enim loquitur haereticus, mortiferum est, et a vivente Dei sermone sejunctum. Sive intraverunt ad libidinem: difficile est enim haereticum reperire, qui diligat castitatem, non quod eam praeferre desistat in labiis, sed quod non servet in conscientia, aliud loquens, et aliud faciens; unde et abalienati sunt a Deo, et habent gloriam in confusionem suam, et facti sunt abominabiles, qui prius diligebantur in patribus. Si autem voluerimus legere, facti sunt abominabiles, sicut dilecti, quod tamen in Hebraico non habetur: dicemus ita factos esse gentiles, qui sunt abominabiles, quomodo et haereticos qui prius diligebantur in patribus, hoc est, ut et hi, et illi pariter abominabiles sint, et culpae rei.\n\n(Vers. 12.) « Ephraim quasi avis avolavit: gloria eorum a partu, et ab utero, et a conceptu: quod et si enutrierint filios suos, absque liberis eos faciam in hominibus. Sed et vae eis cum recessero ab eis. Ephraim, ut vidi, Tyrus erat fundata in pulchritudine: et Ephraim educet ad interfectorem filios suos. » LXX: « Ephraim quasi avis avolavit: gloria eorum in partu. et in parturitionibus et conceptu: quia etiam si enutrierint filios suos, sine filiis erunt in hominibus: quia et vae eis est: caro mea ex eis. Ephraim, sicut vidi, in captionem praebuit filios suos: et Ephraim, ut educeret ad interfectionem filios suos. » Multum in hoc loco inter se discordant interpretes.","english":"For whatever a heretic says is deadly and severed from the living word of God. Or they entered in to lust—for it is difficult to find a heretic who loves chastity, not that he ceases to profess it with his lips, but that he does not keep it in his conscience, saying one thing and doing another. Hence they are also estranged from God, and they have their glory in their confusion, and they have become abominable, who were previously loved in the fathers. But if we wish to read, \"They became abominable, like the beloved,\" which however is not found in the Hebrew, we shall say that the Gentiles became such—they who are abominable—just as also the heretics who were previously loved in the fathers, that is, so that both these and those alike may be abominable and guilty.\n\n(Verse 12.) \"Ephraim has flown away like a bird: their glory is from birth, and from the womb, and from conception: for even if they have brought up their sons, I will make them childless among men. But also woe to them when I have departed from them. Ephraim, as I saw, was Tyre founded in beauty: and Ephraim will bring out his sons to the slayer.\" The Septuagint: \"Ephraim has flown away like a bird: their glory is in birth and in parturitions and conception: because even if they have brought up their sons, they will be without sons among men: because woe is also to them: my flesh is from them. Ephraim, as I saw, offered his sons as a prey: and Ephraim, to bring out his sons to slaughter.\" In this passage the interpreters disagree greatly among themselves.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":169,"ref":"p169","source":"In co enim loco, in quo nos diximus, vae eis cum recessero ab eis, Septuaginta et Theodotion transtulerunt, vae eis, caro mea ex eis: quaerensque causam cur sit tanta varietas, hanc mihi videor reperisse: Caro mea, lingua Hebraea dicitur BASARI ( ): rursum si dicamus, recessio mea, sive, declinatio mea, dicitur BASORI ( ). Septuaginta igitur et Theodotion pro co, quod est recessio mea, et declinatio mea, verterunt, caro mea. Rursum ubi nos posuimus: Ephraim, ut vidi, Tyrus erat, Septuaginta interpretati sunt,, id est, venationem, sive capturam: Aquila et Symmachus et Theodotion, petram durissimam, id est, silicem, quae lingua Hebraica appellatur SUR ( ); quod si legamus SOR, Tyrus dicitur. Putantes autem Septuaginta interpretes ob litterarum similitudinem RES et DALETH, non esse RES, sed DALETH, legerunt SUD, id est, venationem, sive capturam, unde et BETHSAIDA (iTPXm) domus dicitur venatorum. Diversitatem interpretum diximus: revertamur ad sensum. Ephraim, id est, decem tribus, quasi avis avolavit in captivitatem, et de suo recessit loco. Avem autem appellavit, ut velocem in Babylonem transitum demonstraret. Sin autem legerimus, Quasi avis avolavit gloria eorum, hoc dicimus, quod Dei ab eis recesserit et avolaverit auxilium.","english":"For in that place where we said, \"Woe to them when I depart from them,\" the Seventy and Theodotion translated, \"Woe to them, my flesh is from them.\" And seeking the reason why there is such variation, I think I have found this: \"My flesh\" in the Hebrew tongue is called BASARI. Again, if we say \"my departure\" or \"my turning aside,\" it is called BASORI. The Seventy, therefore, and Theodotion, instead of \"my departure\" and \"my turning aside,\" translated \"my flesh.\" Again, where we have set down, \"Ephraim, as I saw, was Tyre,\" the Seventy translated it as \"hunting\" or \"capture\"; Aquila and Symmachus and Theodotion as \"hardest rock,\" that is, flint, which in the Hebrew tongue is called SUR. But if we read SOR, it means Tyre. The Seventy interpreters, however, thinking because of the similarity of the letters RES and DALETH that it was not RES but DALETH, read SUD, that is, \"hunting\" or \"capture,\" whence also BETHSAIDA is called \"house of hunters.\" We have spoken of the diversity of interpreters; let us return to the sense. Ephraim, that is, the ten tribes, flew away like a bird into captivity, and departed from its own place. But he called it a bird to demonstrate the swift passage into Babylon. If, however, we read, \"Like a bird their glory flew away,\" we say this: that the help of God departed and flew away from them.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":170,"ref":"p170","source":"Quodque sequitur, a partu, et ab utero, et a conceptu, dupliciter intelligi potest, ut gloria quae avolavit ab Ephraim, etiam a partu, et ab utero, et a conceptu eorum recedat, hoc est, deserat filios eorum, et posteros derelinquat. Aut certe dicimus, omnem gloriam Israel habuit in multitudine, et in eo se majorem arbitratus est Juda fratre suo, quia ipse decem tribubus, ille duabus praefuit. Unde Dominus loquitur, quod etiam si enutrierint filios, et liberorum multitudinem congregaverint, tradentur neci: et nunc eis verum incumbat vae, cum ab eis recesserit Deus. Et consequenter exponit, qualis quondam, fuerit Ephraim, qui tunc desertus est: tam pulcher, inquit, erat, et sic Dei vallabatur auxilio, ut Tyrus quae mari cingitur, vel certe, ut scopulus durissimus, qui fixus in terra, omnes contemnit procellas, et de turbinibus ventisque non curat. Ipse autem, id est, Ephraim, sive Tyrus, quae erat fundata in maris pulchritudine, educet ad captivitatem filios suos. Multi hoc capitulum ad Azaelis tempora referunt, qui obsedit Samariam, et longo tempore afflixit fame, ut levius arbitrarentur obsessi gladio perire, quam inedia (IV Reg. VI, VII, et VIII).","english":"And what follows, \"from the birth, and from the womb, and from the conception,\" can be understood in two ways: either that the glory which flew away from Ephraim also departs from their birth, and from their womb, and from their conception, that is, that it forsakes their sons and abandons their descendants. Or certainly we say that Israel had all its glory in multitude, and in this it considered itself greater than its brother Judah, because the former presided over ten tribes, the latter over two. Whence the Lord says that even if they raise sons and gather a multitude of children, they will be handed over to death; and now a true woe presses upon them, since God has withdrawn from them. And consequently he explains what Ephraim, who was then deserted, had once been: so beautiful, he says, was he, and so fortified by God's help, like Tyre which is girded by the sea, or certainly like a hardest rock, which, fixed in the earth, despises all storms and cares nothing for whirlwinds and winds. But he himself, that is, Ephraim, or Tyre, which was founded in the beauty of the sea, will lead his sons out into captivity. Many refer this chapter to the times of Hazael, who besieged Samaria and afflicted it with famine for a long time, so that the besieged thought it lighter to perish by the sword than by starvation (2 Kings 6, 7, and 8).","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":171,"ref":"p171","source":"Nos autem dicamus juxta tropologiam, Ephraim, id est, haereticos, quasi avem de Ecclesia recessisse, et omnem habere gloriam in partu, ct in utero, ct in conceptu, si multos genuerint filios, quos Dominus comminatur, etiamsi enutriti fuerint, ct puniendos, non ab alio quolibet, sed ab ipso Domino, quoniam filios fornicationis generarint, et verum illis sit vae, cum Deus recesserit ab eis. Simulque replicat qualis fuerit Ephraim: quando, inquit, in Ecclesia erat, ita saeculi hujus tentationibus, quasi Tyrus maris fluctibus tundebatur, et tamen nihil adversi poterat sustinere, quia habebat fundamentum Christi, super quo aedificata domus, everti non potest (Matth. VII). Nunc autem filios suos educit ad interfectorem: hoc est, ad diabolum. Et pulchre dixit, educit, id est, de Ecclesia facit exire foras. Possumus filios Ephraim, cogitationes pessimas dicere, et contraria dogmata veritati, qua interficit Dominus spiritu oris sui, ct eos tales liberos hahere non patitur, et aeterno interitui derelinquit. Quod autem in Septuaginta legimus, Caro mea ex eis: Ephraim, quomodo vidi, in venationem praebuit filios suos, ita intelligimus: Si Christus caput est corporis, id est, Ecclesiae, omnes nos Christi et Ecclesiae membra sumus. Qui ergo de Ecclesia recesserit, Christi corpus lacerat: igitur et Ephraim caro fuit et membrum Domini Salvatoris.","english":"But let us say according to tropology that Ephraim, that is, heretics, has withdrawn like a bird from the Church, and has all its glory in birth, and in the womb, and in conception, if they have begotten many sons, whom the Lord threatens, even if they have been brought up, are also to be punished, not by any other, but by the Lord himself, because they have begotten sons of fornication, and woe will truly be theirs when God has withdrawn from them. And at the same time he unfolds what sort of thing Ephraim was: when, he says, it was in the Church, it was beaten by the temptations of this world like Tyre by the waves of the sea, and yet it could endure nothing adverse, because it had the foundation of Christ, upon which a house built cannot be overturned (Matthew 7). But now it brings forth its sons to the killer: that is, to the devil. And well did he say, brings forth, that is, makes them go out from the Church. We can call the sons of Ephraim evil thoughts and doctrines contrary to the truth, which the Lord kills by the spirit of his mouth, and he does not allow such men to have children, and abandons them to eternal destruction. But what we read in the Septuagint, My flesh is from them: Ephraim, as I saw, offered its sons for hunting, we understand thus: If Christ is the head of the body, that is, of the Church, we are all members of Christ and the Church. Whoever therefore has withdrawn from the Church lacerates the body of Christ: therefore Ephraim too was flesh and a member of the Lord Savior.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":172,"ref":"p172","source":"Sed in venationem praebuit filios suos, in venationem autem eorum, de quibus scriptum est: Anima nostra sicut passer erepta est de laqueo venantium (Psal. CXXIII, 7). Et eduxit de Ecclesia liberos suos, ad occisionem, sive ad vulnerandum: ut vulnerentur ab his qui mittunt ardentes sagittas, ut percutiant pariter et exurant.\n\n(Vers. 14.) « Da eis, Domine: quid dabis eis? da eis vulvam sine filiis, et ubera arentia. » LXX similiter 1.Si his quae Deus pro benedictione donavit, male abutamur, et in contrarium quam ab eo data sunt convertuntur, expedit ut auferantur a nobis. Denique lingua data est ad laudandum Dominum Deum, et quae bona sunt eloquenda: Si quis ea abutatur in blasphemiam, contra hunc Psalmista Dominum deprecatur: Muta fiant labia dolosa, quae loquuntur adversus justum iniquitatem in superbia et in abusione (Psal. XXX, 19). Et in alio loco: Disperdat Dominus universa labia dolosa, et linguam magniloquam (Psal. XI, 4). Quia igitur Ephraim gloriabatur in utero, et in conceptu, et in partu, et in populorum multitudine, Propheta Dominum deprecatur, et dicit: Da eis, Domine. Sibique ipse respondit: Quid dabis eis? et statim infert: Da eis vulvam sterilem, et ubera arentia, ne habeant causas superbiae, ut in quo sibi gloriari solent, in eo confundantur.","english":"But he handed over his sons to the hunt, to the hunt of those of whom it is written: Our soul has been snatched like a sparrow from the snare of the hunters. And he led his children out of the Church, to slaughter, or to being wounded: that they may be wounded by those who send burning arrows, so as to strike and scorch at the same time.\n\n(Verse 14.) \"Give them, Lord: what will you give them? Give them a womb without sons, and dry breasts.\" The Septuagint similarly. If we misuse the things that God has given for a blessing, and they are turned to the opposite of what they were given for, it is expedient that they be taken away from us. Finally, the tongue was given for praising the Lord God, and for uttering the things that are good. If anyone misuses it for blasphemy, the Psalmist entreats the Lord against such a one: Let deceitful lips be made mute, which speak iniquity against the righteous in pride and in abuse. And in another place: May the Lord destroy all deceitful lips, and the tongue that speaks great things. Since, therefore, Ephraim gloried in the womb, and in conception, and in birth, and in the multitude of peoples, the Prophet entreats the Lord and says: Give them, Lord. And he himself answers himself: What will you give them? And immediately he adds: Give them a barren womb and dry breasts, lest they have grounds for pride, so that in that in which they are accustomed to glory, in that they may be confounded.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":173,"ref":"p173","source":"Quod et de magistris contrariorum dogmatum intelligi posse, perspicuum est, qui in populorum multitudine gloriantur, et in iis liberis quos nutrierint in interitum, ut educerent eos de Ecclesia et inducerent ad interfectorem. Tot enim diabolus jugulat, quot haeretici in errore genuerint filios. De istiusmodi anima dicitur: Beata sterilis immaculata, quae non cognovit cubile in peccato (Sap. III, 13). Beatus est enim vir Ecclesiasticus, qui comparatione haeretici in errore filios non procrearit. Et in alio loco legimus: Melius est filios non habere cum virtute. Ex iniquo enim concubitu semen peribit (Sap. LV et III, sec. LXX): et cum longi fuerint temporis, reputabuntur in nihilum et ignobilis in novissimis erit senectus eorum: fecunda enim impiorum multitudo ad nihilum est utilis; neque enim aestimare debemus, quod vulvam sterilem, et ubera arentia corporaliter deprecatus sit.","english":"That this can also be understood of the teachers of contrary dogmas is clear, who glory in the multitude of peoples, and in those children whom they have nourished for destruction, so as to lead them out of the Church and bring them in to the slayer. For the devil slaughters as many as the heretics have begotten as sons in error. Of such a soul it is said: Blessed is the barren woman who is undefiled, who has not known a bed in sin. For blessed is the ecclesiastical man who, in comparison with the heretic, has not procreated sons in error. And in another place we read: It is better not to have sons with virtue. For from an iniquitous union the seed will perish: and when they have lasted a long time, they will be reckoned as nothing, and their old age will be ignoble in the last days; for the fruitful multitude of the impious is useful for nothing; nor should we think that he prayed in a bodily sense for a barren womb and dry breasts.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":174,"ref":"p174","source":"(Vers. 15.) « Omnes nequitiae corum in Galgal: quia ibi exosos habui eos. » LXX similiter 1. In Galgal Saul unctus in regem est, Samuele iram Dei populo nuntiante (I Reg. X). Ibi, inquit, exosos habui eos, et sibi regem hominem postulantes, a meo imperio recesserunt. Sive quia Galgala idololatria locus est, ubi omnia scelera commiserunt. Verum quia Galgala interpretatur revelatio, aut id est, volutabra, omnes malitias haereticorum dicit eo tempore revelandas, cum eis dederit Deus vulvam sterilem, et ubera arentia, et viderint ignominiam suam. Et qui se jactabant per superbiam, quod ad excelsa conscenderint, devolventur in terram, sive ad inferos pertrahentur. Vere haeretici odio Dei digni sunt, qui loquuntur contra Dominum mendacium, de quibus dicit in consequentibus:\n\n« Propter malitiam adinventionum eorum de domo mea ejiciam eos. Non addam ut diligam eos: omnes principes eorum recedentes, sive inobedientes. » Quod ct Septuaginta similiter 2. Et de haereticis quidem non est dubium, quin de domo Dei ejecti sint, et non addat ut diligat eos, quandiu in errore permanserint, omnesque principes eorum recedentes a Deo sunt, sive inobedientes, ut Valentinus, Marcion, ct caeteri. Possumus principes haereticorum daemones dicere, qui vere a Deo recesserunt, et appellantur principes, juxta quod Dominus loquitur in Evangelio: Veniet princeps hujus mundi, et inveniet in me nihil (Joan.","english":"(Verse 15.) \"All their wickedness is in Galgal: for there I hated them.\" The Septuagint similarly. In Galgal Saul was anointed king, while Samuel announced the wrath of God to the people (1 Kings 10). There, he says, I hated them, and they, demanding a human king for themselves, departed from my command. Or because Galgala is a place of idolatry, where they committed all crimes. But since Galgala is interpreted as revelation, or else rolling-places, he says that all the wickednesses of heretics will be revealed at that time, when God has given them a barren womb and dry breasts, and they have seen their own shame. And those who boasted in their pride that they had climbed to the heights will be rolled down to the earth, or dragged down to the underworld. Truly heretics are worthy of God's hatred, who speak a lie against the Lord, of whom he says in what follows:\n\n\"Because of the wickedness of their devices I will cast them out of my house. I will not continue to love them: all their princes are departing, or disobedient.\" Which the Septuagint likewise. And concerning heretics there is indeed no doubt that they have been cast out of the house of God, and that he will not continue to love them as long as they remain in error, and all their princes are departing from God, or disobedient, such as Valentinus, Marcion, and the rest. We can call the demons the princes of heretics, who truly departed from God, and are called princes, according to what the Lord says in the Gospel: The prince of this world will come, and will find nothing in me (John","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":175,"ref":"p175","source":"XIV, 30). Et Apostolus adversus potestates, principatus ct rectores tenebrarum istarum pugnare nos dicit (Ephes. VI). Queritur autem juxta historiam, quomodo de domo sua ejecerit eos, id est, decem tribus, cum in domo Dei non fuerint? Sed domum Dei, vel terram sanctam appellabimus, in quam introducti sunt vel falsum nomen Israelis, vel quod ad eos quasi ad populum Dei mittebantur prophetae. Quod autem non addat, ut diligat eos, et omnes reges Israel a Deo fuerint recedentes, perspicuum est: usque hodie enim permanent in captivitate. Alii hoc quod scriptum est, de dumo mea ejiciam eos, ad regnum Juda referri arbitrantur, quod et ipsi ducendi sint in captivitatem Sed quomodo eis poterit adaptari, non addat ut diligam eos, cum postea Hierosolymam sint reducti: et omnes principes eorum sint recedentes, cum legerimus David, Asa, Josaphat, Ezechiam, et Josiam reges fuisse justos? Unde ad Christi tempora transeundum est, quod in adventa ejus ejecti sint de domo Dei, et nequaquam salventur ut Israel, sed ut populus Christianus. Unde et Dominus fecit sibi flagellum de funiculis, et ejecit eos de templo: quia domum Patris ejus fecerant domum negotiationis (Joan. II).","english":"(14:30). And the Apostle says that we fight against the powers, principalities, and rulers of these darknesses (Eph. 6). But according to the historical sense it is asked how he cast them out of his house, that is, the ten tribes, when they were not in the house of God? But we shall call the house of God even the holy land, into which they were brought, either the false name of Israel, or because the prophets were sent to them as to the people of God. But that he does not add, \"that I might love them,\" and that all the kings of Israel were departing from God, is clear: for to this day they remain in captivity. Others think that what is written, \"I will cast them out of my house,\" refers to the kingdom of Judah, because they too are to be led into captivity. But how can it be applied to them, \"that I might not love them,\" when afterwards they were brought back to Jerusalem: and that all their princes were departing, when we read that David, Asa, Jehoshaphat, Hezekiah, and Josiah were righteous kings? Whence we must pass over to the times of Christ, because at his coming they were cast out of the house of God, and are no longer saved as Israel, but as the Christian people. Whence also the Lord made for himself a whip of cords, and cast them out of the temple: because they had made his Father's house a house of commerce (John 2).","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":176,"ref":"p176","source":"(Vers. et 17.) « Percussus est Ephraim: radix eorum exsiccata est: fructum nequaquam facient: quod et si genuerint, interficiam amantissima uteri eorum. Abjiciet eos Deus meus 4, quia non audierunt eum: et erunt vagi in nationibus. » LXX: « Doluit Ephraim radices suas: arefactus est, fructum nequaquam affert: quia et si genuerint, interficiam desiderabilia uteri eoram. Repellet eos Deus, quia non audierunt eum: et erunt vagi in nationibus. » Metaphoram sumit ab arbore, cujus si radices aruerint, fructum afferre non poterit, et si paululum fecerit, statim in ipso flore siccabitur. Dicit autem de Ephraim, cujus radix aruit, quia Deum, in quo fundatus erat, perdidit, sive patres suos Abrabam, Isaac, et Jacob, in quibus radicem miserat, habere non meruit: et propterea fructum justitiae non facit; quod et si fecerit, Interficiam, inquit, amantissime uteri ejus, juxta id quod supra dixerat: Si enutrierint filios suos, absque liberis eos facium in hominibus: unde et abjecit eos Deus, et fecit ire captivos. Et erunt vagi in nationibus. Possumus hoc ipsum et de omnibus Judaeis dicere quorum quia principes a Deo recesserunt, commoventes populum, ut eum ad mortem expeterent: propterea ejecit eos de domo sua, et non addet, ut ultra diligat eos. Percussit radicem eorum et exsiccavit, et fructum ultra non facient: quod et si fecerint, et visi fuerint Scripturam sanctam.","english":"(Verses 16 and 17.) \"Ephraim is struck: their root is dried up: they shall bear no fruit: and even if they beget, I will kill the most beloved of their womb. My God will cast them out, because they have not heard him: and they shall be wanderers among the nations.\" The Septuagint: \"Ephraim has grieved its roots: it is dried up, it bears no fruit: for even if they beget, I will kill the desirable ones of their womb. God will repel them, because they have not heard him: and they shall be wanderers among the nations.\" He takes up a metaphor from a tree, whose roots, if they have dried up, it will not be able to bear fruit, and if it has produced a little, it will immediately wither in the very blossom. But he speaks of Ephraim, whose root has dried up, because it has lost God, in whom it was founded, or it did not deserve to have its fathers Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob, in whom it had sent down a root: and for that reason it does not produce the fruit of justice; and even if it has done so, I will kill, he says, the most beloved of its womb, according to what he had said above: If they have brought up their sons, I will make them childless among men: whence God has also cast them out, and made them go captive. And they shall be wanderers among the nations. We can say this same thing also about all the Jews, because their leaders withdrew from God, stirring up the people to demand him for death: for that reason he cast them out of his house, and he will not add, to love them further. He struck their root and dried it up, and they shall bear fruit no more: and even if they have done so, and have seemed to be Scripture.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":177,"ref":"p177","source":"Legemque meditari, et quasi amantissimos filios aliquid scientiae atque doctrinae de suo corde protulerint, adversante Domino, succidetur. Abjecit enim eos Deus omnium prophetarum, quia non audierunt eum; et vagi erunt in nationibus, non habentes altare, non sedem, non civitatem propriam. Unde ct David loquitur in Psalmo: Ne occidas eos. ne quando obliviscantur populi mei: disperge illos in virtute tua (Psal. LVIII, 12). Et in alio loco: Secundum multitudinem impietatum eorum expelle eos, quoniam irritaverunt te, Domine (Psal. V, 11, 12). De hac arbore etiam in Evangelio legimus: Jam securis ad radices arborum posita est. Omnis arbor quoe non facit fructum bonum, excidetur et in ignem mittetur (Matth. III, 10). Haereticos fructus facere non posse virtutum, quia Dominum perdiderunt, super quo juxta Apostolum radicati esse debuerant et fundati (Ephes. III), nemo dubitet: quod et si fecerint, et aliquos uteri sui fecunditate generarint, Domino adversante, morientur. Sive quia fructus eorum sunt universa quae fingunt, et de suo corde generant, arefient et peribunt: et erit cunctis perspicuum, siccam radicem fruges afferre non posse. Isti abjicientur, imo abjecti sunt a Deo; quia non audierunt eum dicentem: Ne transferas terminos quos posuerunt patres tui (Prov. XXII, 28).","english":"And to meditate on the law, and as if they were most loving sons they had brought forth something of knowledge and doctrine from their own heart, with the Lord opposing, it shall be cut down. For God has cast them off, [away from] all the prophets, because they did not hear him; and they shall be wanderers among the nations, having no altar, no seat, no city of their own. Whence also David speaks in the Psalm: Do not kill them, lest at some time they forget my people: scatter them in your power. And in another place: According to the multitude of their impieties, drive them out, because they have provoked you, O Lord. Concerning this tree we also read in the Gospel: Already the axe is laid to the roots of the trees. Every tree that does not bear good fruit will be cut down and thrown into the fire. Let no one doubt that heretics cannot bear the fruits of the virtues, because they have lost the Lord, upon whom according to the Apostle they ought to have been rooted and founded: and even if they have done so, and have begotten some by the fruitfulness of their womb, with the Lord opposing, they shall die. Or because their fruits are all the things they invent and generate from their own heart, they shall wither and perish: and it will be clear to all that a dry root cannot bring forth crops. These shall be cast off, or rather have been cast off by God; because they did not hear him saying: Do not move the boundaries which your fathers set.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":178,"ref":"p178","source":"Et idcirco vagi erunt in nationibus, nunc ad has, nunc ad illas sententias transeuntes: dum non eis placet, quod semel repererint, sed semper vetera mutant novis, et ethnicorum imitantur errores.\n\n(Cap. X.—Vers. 1.) « Vitis frondosa Israel: fructus adaequatus est ei: secundum multitudinem fructus sui multiplicavit altaria: juxta ubertatem terrae suae exuberavit simulacris. » LXX: « Vitis frondosa Israel, fructus abundans in ea; secundum multitudinem fructuum suorum multiplicavit altum: juxta bona terrae eorum aedificabunt titulos. » Pro vite frondosa, Aquila interpretatus est,, quam nos aquosam, vel 1, possumus dicere, eo quod vini perdat saporem; Symmachus 2, quae tota in frondibus creverit. Vites quae putatae a vinitore non fueriut, in flagella frondesque luxuriant, et humorem quem debuerant in vina mutare, vana frondium et foliorum ambitione disperdunt: istiusmodi vitis damnosa est agricolis. Talis fuit Israel, crescens in multitudine populorum, et non reddens fructus agricolae Deo debitos.","english":"And therefore they will be wanderers among the nations, passing now to these opinions, now to those: since what they have once found does not please them, but they always exchange old things for new, and imitate the errors of the Gentiles.\n\n(Cap. 10.—Vers. 1.) \"Israel is a leafy vine: its fruit has been made equal to it: according to the multitude of its fruit it multiplied altars: according to the richness of its land it abounded in idols.\" The LXX: \"Israel is a leafy vine, fruit abounding in it; according to the multitude of its fruits it multiplied the high place: according to the goods of their land they will build titles.\" For \"leafy vine,\" Aquila translated , which we can call \"watery,\" or 1, because it loses the savor of wine; Symmachus 2, \"which has grown entirely in leaves.\" Vines that have not been pruned by the vintner run wild into shoots and foliage, and the moisture that they ought to have turned into wine they waste in the vain display of shoots and leaves: a vine of this sort is ruinous to farmers. Such was Israel, growing in the multitude of peoples, and not rendering to God the farmer the fruits it owed.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":179,"ref":"p179","source":"Dicamus et aliter: Vitis frondosa, sive juxta Septuaginta, id est, bonas habeus propagines, et flagella fructifera, multos botros attulit, et uvarum fecunditas ramorum magnitudinem coaequavit; sed haec quae prius talis erat antequam offenderet Deum, postea abundantium fructuum vertit in offensae multitudinem: ut quanto plures haberet populos, tanto plura aedificaret altaria, et abundantiam terrae numero vinceret idolorum. Pro simulacris, Septuaginta verterunt, quas nos statuas vel titulos appellamus, qui proprie daemonum sunt, aut hominum mortuorum, Ita et haeretici dum essent in Ecclesia plantati, et crescerent in domo Dei, vocabantur vinea Sorec, et afferebant uberrimos fructus: postea vero quanto plures facti sunt, tanto sibi multiplicaverunt altaria, ut pro uno altari quod verum est, plures erroris sui aras exstruerent, et juxta ubertatem terrae suae exuberaverunt simulacris. Haereticorum terra fecunda est, qui a Deo acumen sensus et ingenii percipientes, ut bona naturae in Dei cultum verterent, fecerunt sibi ex his idola. Nullus enim potest haeresim struere, nisi qui ardentis ingenii est, et habet dona naturae: quae a Deo artifice sunt creata. Talis fuit Valentinus, talis Marcion, quos doctissimos legimus. Talis Bardesanes, cujus etiam philosophi admirantur ingenium.","english":"Let us also say it in another way: The leafy vine, or according to the Septuagint, that is, one having good shoots and fruitful branches, brought forth many clusters, and the fruitfulness of the grapes equaled the size of the branches; but this vine, which was previously of such a kind before it offended God, afterward turned the abundance of its fruits into a multitude of offenses: so that the more peoples it had, the more altars it built, and by the number of its idols it surpassed the abundance of its land. For \"simulacra,\" the Septuagint rendered as what we call statues or inscriptions, which properly belong to demons or to dead men. So too the heretics, while they were planted in the Church and grew in the house of God, were called the vineyard of Sorec and brought forth most abundant fruits; but afterward, the more numerous they became, the more they multiplied altars for themselves, so that in place of the one true altar they erected many altars of their own error, and according to the fertility of their land they abounded in idols. The land of heretics is fertile: receiving from God sharpness of sense and talent, so that they might turn the goods of nature to the worship of God, they made idols for themselves out of these. For no one can construct a heresy unless he is of ardent talent and has the gifts of nature, which were created by God the artificer. Such was Valentinus, such was Marcion, whom we read to have been most learned. Such was Bardesanes, whose talent even the philosophers admire.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":180,"ref":"p180","source":"Isti ergo terrae suae bona verterunt in titulos mortuorum, quia omnis doctrina eorum non ad viventes refertur, sed ad mortuos, tam eos quos colunt, quam illos quos decipiunt.\n\n(Vers. 2.) « Divisum est cor eorum: nunc interibunt: ipse confringet simulacra eorum: depopulabitur aras eorum. » LXX: « Diviserunt corda sua: nunc peribunt: ipse suffodiet altaria eorum: affligentur tituli eorum. » Tradunt Hebraei hujuscemodi fabulam, suspicionem suam Scripturarum auctoritate confirmantes: Quamdiu et reges et populi pariter vitulos aureos adorabant, et habebant in impietate consensum, non venit captivitas. Extremus rex decem tribuum fuit Osee, de quo scriptum est (IV Reg.XVII), quod fecerit quidem malum Osce in conspectu Domini, sed non sicut reges Israel, qui fuerunt ante cum, cujus nono anno Salmanasar, rex Assyriorum, cepit populum Israel, et eduxit cos in Assyrios, et habitare fecit juxta flamen Gozan in civitatibus Medorum. Quaeritur ergo quare sub pessimis regibus capti non fuerint·3, sed sub co qui coeperat ex parte aliqua ad meliora converti? Ad quod haec inferunt: excusabat se primum populus, et dicebat, Regum paremus imperiis, nec possumus eorum resistere tyrannidi: edimus vitulos quos adorare compellimur.","english":"These men, therefore, turned the goods of their land into monuments of the dead, because all their teaching is referred not to the living but to the dead—both those whom they worship and those whom they deceive.\n\n(Verse 2.) \"Their heart is divided: now they shall perish: he himself will shatter their images: he will lay waste their altars.\" The Septuagint: \"They divided their hearts: now they shall perish: he himself will undermine their altars: their monuments shall be afflicted.\" The Hebrews hand down a tale of this sort, confirming their suspicion by the authority of the Scriptures: As long as both kings and peoples alike were worshiping the golden calves, and held consensus in impiety, the captivity did not come. The last king of the ten tribes was Hoshea, of whom it is written (2 Kings 17) that Hoshea indeed did evil in the sight of the Lord, but not like the kings of Israel who were before him; in whose ninth year Shalmaneser, king of the Assyrians, captured the people of Israel, and led them away into Assyria, and made them dwell beside the river Gozan in the cities of the Medes. It is asked, therefore, why they were not captured under the worst kings, but under him who had begun in some part to turn to better things? To this they bring forward the following: at first the people excused themselves and said, \"We obey the commands of kings, and we cannot resist their tyranny: we eat the calves which we are compelled to worship.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":181,"ref":"p181","source":"In diebus autem Osce ab eodem rege praeceptum est, ne tanto studio vituli colerentur, sed qui vellet iret in Jerusalem, et in templo sacrificaret Deo; huic, aiunt, sententiae populus contradixit. Et hoc est, quod nunc dicit: divisum est cor eorum, hoc est, regis et populi, nulla excusatione remanente, nunc interibunt, et tradentur aeternae captivitati; statim enim ut populus dissensit a rege, venit interitus. Quodque sequitur: ipse confringet simulacra eorum, de Deo dicit: arasque depopulabitur, non quia Dens ipse propria hoc fecerit manu, sed quod per hostes voluntas ejus expleta sit. Haereticorum inter se corda divisa, et contrariis repugnare sententiis, etiam ipsi non negant, dum diversa sentiunt. Unde disperdentur, et confringet sive suffodiet Dominus simulacra vel altaria eorum, quae de suo corde finxerunt, et vastabit titulos, quibus singuli suis appellantur nominibus, et vocaverunt nomina sua super terras suas, et nequaquam Christi Ecclesiae, sed illius vel illius esse dicantur.","english":"In the days of Hosea, however, it was commanded by that same king that the calves should not be worshiped with such zeal, but that whoever wished should go up to Jerusalem and sacrifice to God in the temple. To this decree, they say, the people objected. And this is what he now says: Their heart is divided—that is, the heart of the king and of the people—with no excuse remaining; now they will perish and be handed over to eternal captivity, for as soon as the people disagreed with the king, destruction came. And what follows: He himself will shatter their images, is said of God; and he will lay waste their altars—not because God himself did this with his own hand, but because through enemies his will was fulfilled. That the hearts of heretics are divided among themselves and that they struggle against contrary opinions, even they themselves do not deny, since they hold differing views. Hence they will be scattered, and the Lord will shatter or undermine their images or altars, which they have fashioned from their own heart, and he will lay waste the titles by which individuals are called by their own names; and they have called their names upon their lands, so that they are said to belong not to the Church of Christ but to this one or that one.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":182,"ref":"p182","source":"(Vers. et 4.) « Quia nunc dicent, Non est rex nobis: non enim timemus Dominum, et rex quid faciet nobis? Loquimini verba visionis inutilis, et ferietis foedus, et germinabit quasi amaritudo judicium super sulcos agri. » LXX: « Propterea nunc dicent. Non est rex nobis, quia non timuimus Dominum, rex autem quid faciet nobis? Loquens verba, occasiones mendaces: disponet testamentum, orietur sicut gramen judicium super desertum agri. » Postquam confregerit Deus simulacra Israel, et depopulatus fuerit aras, vel statuas eorum, et extrema captivitas venerit, dicent: Non est rex nobis. Et ne in longum tempus potent sententiam protelari, addidit: Nunc dicent, quando vastabuntur, quando sentient Osee regem ultimum a se esse sublatum: ideo rex ablatus a nobis est, quia non timuimus Dominum verum regem; homo enim rex prodesse quid poterat? Dicite quid vultis, errores veteres suspirate, pollicemini vobis prospera, quae vertentur in contraria, foedus ferietis, nequaquam cum Deo, sed eum mendacio. Et post foedus, quod Septuaginta interpretati sunt testamentum, germinabit vobis, non seges fecunda frumenti, non saltem jumentorum cibus, hordeum, non legumina varia, non vites quae fructus suos in musta desudant, non poma arbores germinabunt, quae humorem terrae in varios mutant sapores; sed orietur vobis amaritudo, imo amaritudinis judicium, sive, quam Latine in gramen vertimus.","english":"(Verses 3 and 4.) \"Because now they shall say, We have no king: for we do not fear the Lord, and what shall a king do for us? Speak words of useless vision, and you shall strike a covenant, and judgment shall spring up like bitterness upon the furrows of the field.\" The Septuagint: \"Therefore now they shall say, We have no king, because we have not feared the Lord, but what shall a king do for us? Speaking words, lying occasions: he shall arrange a testament, judgment shall rise like grass upon the desert of the field.\" After God has shattered the idols of Israel, and laid waste their altars or statues, and the final captivity has come, they shall say: We have no king. And lest they think the sentence can be prolonged for a long time, he added: Now they shall say, when they are being laid waste, when they perceive that Hosea, the last king, has been taken away from them: therefore the king has been taken away from us, because we did not fear the Lord, the true king; for what could a man who is king profit? Say what you will, sigh over your old errors, promise yourselves prosperous things, which will turn into the opposite, you shall strike a covenant, not at all with God, but with falsehood. And after the covenant, which the Seventy interpreted as testament, there shall spring up for you, not a fertile crop of grain, not even the fodder of beasts, barley, not various legumes, not vines that sweat out their fruits into must, not trees that shall bring forth fruits, which change the moisture of the earth into various flavors; but bitterness shall rise for you, indeed the judgment of bitterness, or, which we have rendered in Latin as grass.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":183,"ref":"p183","source":"Est enim genus herbae calamo simile, quae per singula genicula fruticem sursum et radicem mittit deorsum, rursusque ipsi frutices et virgulta alterius herbae seminaria sunt, atque ita in brevi tempore si non imis radicibus effodiatur, totos agros veprium similes facit. Denique etiam si sicca ejus aliqua pars, dummodo geniculum habeat, super cultam tetram ceciderit, omnia replet gramine. Haec diximus juxta LXX interpretes, caeterum in Hebraico ROS ( ) scriptum habet, quod in amaritudinem vertitur, hoc est, amaritudinis judicium, de quo et Dominos loquitur in Evangelio: In judicium ego in mundum istum veni (Joan. IX, 39): et de aliis scriptum est, quod recipiant amplius judicium (Marc. XII, 40). Discipuli quoque contrariorum dogmatum, cum eorum fuerint contrita mendacia, et arae lucique subversi, sero dicent: Non habemus reges qui nobis prius imperaverant, quibus decipientibus, Dominum non timuimus; quid enim nobis profuit illos sequi, quorum in necessitate non sentimus auxilium? Haec loquentur quaerentes aliquam excusationem, ut non per se sed per doctores pessimos errasse videantur. Unde et LXX. verba eorum, excusationes falsas transtulerunt, quas propheta devitat, dicens: Ne declines cor meum in verba malitiae, ad excusandas excusationes in peccatis (Psal. CXL, 4).","english":"For there is a kind of herb similar to a reed, which through each of its joints sends a shoot upward and a root downward, and again these shoots and sprouts are the seeds of another herb, and thus in a short time, if it is not dug out by its lowest roots, it makes whole fields resemble brambles. Finally, even if some dry part of it, provided it has a joint, falls upon cultivated ground, it fills everything with grass. We have said these things according to the Seventy interpreters; but in the Hebrew it is written ROS, which is turned into bitterness, that is, the judgment of bitterness, of which the Lord also speaks in the Gospel: I came into this world for judgment (John 9:39); and of others it is written that they shall receive greater judgment (Mark 12:40). The disciples also of contrary doctrines, when their lies have been crushed and their altars and groves overthrown, will say too late: We have no kings who previously ruled over us; by whose deceiving we did not fear the Lord; for what did it profit us to follow them, whose help we do not feel in our necessity? These things they will say, seeking some excuse, so that they may seem to have erred not through themselves but through the worst teachers. Whence also the Seventy translated their words as false excuses, which the prophet avoids, saying: Incline not my heart to words of malice, to making excuses for sins (Psalm 141:4).","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":184,"ref":"p184","source":"Libenter vitiis nostris applaudimus, et superati voluptatibus, obtendimus carnis infirmitatem, aut dura majorum imperia: unde verba et visiones haereticorum inutiles erunt Et ferient foedus, nequaquam cum Deo, sed cum amaritudine, quae cum dies judicii advenerit, germinabit super sulcos agri eorum, ut qui seminaverunt in gaudio, metant in lacrymis: qui riserunt, fleant: qui habuerunt consolationem, lugeant.\n\nLIBER TERTIUS.\n\n109-110 Non ignoro, Pammachi, difficillimum me duodecim prophetarum opus cudere, certe interpretatum Latinis, ct quod magis temeritatem nostram possit arguere, quam scientiam prodere. Sed quia tibi hortanti, imo imperanti, negare nihil possumus, et pro offerentium viribus in gazophylacium Dei, multorum divitias duo mulieris pauperis aera superarunt (Luc. XXI): quidquid possumus, primum Deo, deinde tibi, qui Dei es, solvimus: illiusque semper versiculi recordamur: Pollio et ipse facit nova carmina. Cumque apertum fautorem pro jure amicitiae esse te gaudeam, tacitum eruditionis tuae judicium pertimesco; magisque te laudantem, quam adversarios detrahentes metuo. Illis enim aemulatio detrahit fidem, et non tam judices quam accusatores vocandi sunt.","english":"We willingly applaud our own vices, and, overcome by pleasures, we put forward the weakness of the flesh, or the harsh commands of our elders; whence the words and visions of heretics will be useless, and they will strike a covenant, not at all with God, but with bitterness, which, when the day of judgment comes, will sprout upon the furrows of their field, so that those who sowed in joy may reap in tears: those who laughed may weep: those who had consolation may mourn.\n\nBOOK THREE.\n\n109–110 I am not unaware, Pammachius, that it is a most difficult task for me to forge a work on the twelve prophets, certainly to render it into Latin, and—what may more rightly convict our rashness than display our knowledge. But since, at your urging—nay, your commanding—we can deny you nothing, and in the treasury of God, according to the means of those who offer, the two mites of the poor widow surpassed the riches of many (Luke 21): whatever we can, we pay first to God, then to you, who are God's: and we always remember that verse: Pollio himself too makes new songs. And while I rejoice that you are an open patron by the right of friendship, I dread the silent judgment of your learning; and I fear you more when you praise than adversaries when they disparage. For envy robs them of credibility, and they are to be called not so much judges as accusers.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":185,"ref":"p185","source":"Tu autem qui diligis, nequaquam personarum, sed rerum promis sententiam: quanquam et amor recipiat errorem, pulchrumque sil illud 1, quod Tullius magis ad sensum, quam ad verbum interpretatus est,, id est, amantium caeca judicia sunt; attamen in istam partem peto magis ut labaris, non odio, sed amore 2. Tertium in Osee prophetam dictamus librum, et ad vaccas Bethaven usque pervenimus: nobisque interpretationis vela pandentibus, tu debes propheticum illud dicere: A quatuor ventis coeli veni, spiritus, ut celeri cursu varios insidiantium scopulos transeuntes, merces Dominicas, ex omni parte saeviente naufragio, ad portus tutissimos perferamus.\n\n(Vers. et 6.) « Vaccas Bethaven coluerunt habitatores Samariae, quia luxit super eum populus ejus: et aeditui ejus super eum exsultaverunt in gloria ejus, quia migravit ab eo. Siquidem et ipse in Assur delatus est, munus regi ultori, confusio Ephraim capiet: confundetur Israel in voluntate sua. » LXX: « Apud vitulum domus morabuntur qui habitant in Samaria: quia luxit populus ejus super cum. Et sicut irritaverunt illum, gaudebunt super gloria ejus: quia translata est ab eo. et ipsum in Assyrios ligantes, tulerunt munera regi Jarib in domo. Ephraim suscipiet confusionem: confundetur Israel in consilio suo. » Quae sit Bethaven, pro qua LXX transtulerunt, domum, et qui sit rex Jarib. qui interpretatur ultor, supra plenius disputavimus.","english":"But you who love, give judgment not at all by persons, but by things; although even love may admit error, and that saying of Tully may be fine, which he interpreted according to sense rather than word, that is, the judgments of lovers are blind; yet I ask that you slip into that side more out of love than out of hatred. We dictate the third book on the prophet Hosea, and we have come as far as the cows of Bethaven; and as we spread the sails of interpretation, you ought to say that prophetic word: Come, spirit, from the four winds of heaven, so that passing with swift course the various rocks of those lying in wait, we may carry the Lord's wages, with shipwreck raging on every side, to the safest harbors.\n\n(Verses 5 and 6.) \"The inhabitants of Samaria have worshipped the cows of Bethaven, because its people have mourned over it: and its temple-keepers have exulted over it in its glory, because it has departed from it. Indeed it too has been carried off to Assur, a gift to the avenging king; confusion will seize Ephraim: Israel will be confounded in its own will.\" The Septuagint: \"They who dwell in Samaria will linger at the calf of the house: because its people have mourned over it. And as they provoked him, they will rejoice over its glory: because it has been transferred from it. And binding it, they carried it to the Assyrians, gifts to king Jarib in the house. Ephraim will receive confusion: Israel will be confounded in its own counsel.\" What Bethaven is, for which the Septuagint translated \"house,\" and who king Jarib is, which is interpreted \"avenger,\" we have discussed more fully above.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":186,"ref":"p186","source":"In Bethaven igitur, id est, Bethel, vaccas aureas coluerunt habitatores Samariae, quas cum irrisione non vitulos sexus masculini, sed vaccas· id est, feminas appellavit: ut videlicet Israel non solum deos vitulos, sed deas vaccas coleret. Et ut ostenderet vaccas Bethaven, unum in Bethel vitulum sentiendum, non intulit, luxit super eis populus, sed, super eo, id est, vitulo aureo. Si autem luxit populas, quare aeditui ejus super eo exsultaverunt? Tradunt Hebraei vitulos aureos a sacerdotibus furto esse sublatos et pro his aeneos et deauratos repositos. Cum igitur lugeret populus tempore necessitatis et angustiae, etiam vitulos aureos inter munera caetera Assyriis regibus et maxime regi Sennacherib ab Israel rege esse directos, exsultabant aeditui, quod fraus eorum nequaquam posset argui vel deprehendi. Et hoc est quod ait, aeditui ejus, id est, vituli, super eo exsultaverunt in gloria populi, hoc est, in vitulo, quem habebant pro gloria; quia migrasset ab eo, lid est, a populo, et translatus esset ad Assyrios. Et ut sciamus, inquiunt, hoc esse quod dicitur, perspicue sequens versus ostendit: Siquidem ipse in Assur delatus est, munus regi ultori. Statimque sequitur: Confusio Ephraim capiet, et confundetur Israel in voluntate sua, sive, in consitio suo.","english":"In Bethaven, therefore, that is, in Bethel, the inhabitants of Samaria worshiped golden cows, which he called, with mockery, not calves of the male sex but cows, that is, females, so that Israel might evidently worship not only god-calves but goddess-cows. And to show that the cows of Bethaven are to be understood as one calf in Bethel, he did not say, the people mourned over them, but, over it, that is, over the golden calf. But if the people mourned, why did its temple-keepers exult over it? The Hebrews report that the golden calves were stolen by the priests and that bronze gilded ones were put in their place. So when the people grieved in a time of need and distress, and the golden calves had also been sent by the king of Israel to the Assyrian kings among other gifts, and especially to King Sennacherib, the temple-keepers exulted because their fraud could by no means be exposed or detected. And this is what he says: its temple-keepers, that is, the calf's, exulted over it in the glory of the people, that is, in the calf, which they had as their glory, because it had departed from it, that is, from the people, and had been transferred to the Assyrians. And so that we may know, they say, that this is what is meant, the following verse clearly shows: For it itself has been carried off to Assur, a gift to the avenging king. And immediately follows: Confusion will seize Ephraim, and Israel will be confounded in its will, or, in its counsel.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":187,"ref":"p187","source":"Deprehensa enim fraus deauratorum vitulorum regi Israel litteris indicatur, et unde se placere aestimaverant, inde vel maxime confunduntur, et offendunt eos quibus munera miserant, aestimantes non furto sacerdotum, sed fraude regum atque consilio hoc esse perfectum. Legimus in Regum volumine, regem Israel Manahen regi Assyriorum Phul mille argenti talenta misisse, ut esset manus ejus cum eo, id est, ut ei praeberet auxilium, inter quae nonnulli arbitrantur etiam vitulos aureos esse directos 5. Pro Jarib in praesenti loco Symmachus interpretatus est 6, id est praesuli et defensori. Juxta spiritalem intelligentiam laborandum est, quomodo omnia haereticis coaptemus. Vaccas Bethaven, sive domus, quod interpretatur labor, coluerunt haeretici, qui se in custodia mandatorum Dei, hoc est, Samaria habitare jactabant, dicque judicii quando germinabit quasi amaritudo judicium super sulcos agri, lugebit populus super cum, hoc est super vitulum, et super dogma perversum, quod putabat Deum. Sed et aeditui, non dixit, exsultabant, sed exsultaverunt, ad praeteritum tempus referens super gloria sua, qua quondam gloriosa confixerant, eo quod migrasset populus a Deo, sive quod ipsa gloria Dei migrasset a populo, a quo fuerat derelicta.","english":"For the fraud of the gilded calves, once detected, is reported to the king of Israel by letter, and from the very source where they had thought they pleased, there they are most of all confounded, and they offend those to whom they had sent gifts, reckoning that this was accomplished not by the theft of priests but by the fraud and counsel of kings. We read in the volume of Kings that Manahen, king of Israel, sent a thousand talents of silver to Phul, king of the Assyrians, so that his hand might be with him, that is, so that he might furnish him aid; among these, some think that golden calves were also sent. In place of Jarib in the present passage, Symmachus translated it as \"to the president and defender.\" According to the spiritual understanding, we must labor to fit all these things to heretics. The cows of Bethaven, or of the house, which is interpreted as \"labor,\" were worshiped by heretics, who boasted that they dwelt in Samaria, that is, in the custody of God's commandments, and on the day of judgment, when judgment shall spring up like bitterness upon the furrows of the field, the people shall mourn over it, that is, over the calf, and over the perverse dogma that it thought to be God. But also the temple-keepers—he did not say \"were exulting,\" but \"exulted,\" referring to past time—over their glory, with which they had once been gloriously pierced, because the people had departed from God, or because the very glory of God had departed from the people by whom it had been forsaken.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":188,"ref":"p188","source":"Quidquid autem loquuntur haeretici, et pulchro sermone componunt, mittunt munera regi suo diabolo, ad illum cuncta referentes, unde confusio eos capiet in aeternum, et confundentur in voluntatibus suis. Quidam et supra et in praesenti loco in commentariis suis scriptum reliquit, regem Jarib, id est, ultorem, Christum intelligendum. Quod nobis omnino displicet. Impium enim est quod juxta, historiam intelligitur de rege Assyrio, juxta tropologiam ad Christum referri.\n\n(Vers. et 8.) « Transire fecit Samaria regem suum quasi spumam super faciem aquae, et disperdentur excelsa idoli, peccatum Israel. » LXX: « Pro jecit Samaria regem suum sicut cremium super fa tiem aquae, et auferentur arae, peccata Israel. » Pro spuma, quam LXX et Theodotio, id est, cremium, transtulerunt' aridas, scilicet herbas siccaque virgulta, quae camino et incendio praeparantur, Symmachus posuit volens ostendere ferventis ollae superiores aquas, et in spumam bullasque assurgentes, quas Graeci; vocant. Sicut igitur spuma, quae super aquam est, cito dissolvitur: sic regnum decem tribuum velociter finietur, et peribunt excelsa, id est, BA- MOTH ( ), de quibus scriptum est: Verumtamen adhuc populus immolabat el adolebat in excelsis (III Reg. XXII, 44). Ipsa autem excelsa sunt, sive AVEN ( ), id est, idoli, quod interpretatur inutile, quod idolum et inutile peccatum est Israel.","english":"But whatever heretics say, and compose with beautiful speech, they send gifts to their king, the devil, referring everything to him, whence confusion will seize them forever, and they will be confounded in their own desires. Someone has left it written both above and in the present passage in his commentaries that the king Jarib, that is, the avenger, is to be understood as Christ. This is entirely displeasing to us. For it is impious that what is understood according to history concerning the king of Assyria should be referred to Christ according to tropology.\n\n(Verses 7 and 8.) \"He has made Samaria's king pass away like foam upon the face of the water, and the high places of the idol shall be destroyed, the sin of Israel.\" The Septuagint: \"Samaria has cast off her king like dry stubble upon the face of the water, and the altars shall be taken away, the sins of Israel.\" For \"foam,\" which the Septuagint and Theodotion translated as \"dry stubble,\" that is, dry grasses and withered shoots, which are prepared for the furnace and the fire, Symmachus rendered, wishing to show the upper waters of a boiling pot and the bubbles rising into foam, which the Greeks call. Just as, therefore, foam that is upon the water is quickly dissolved, so the kingdom of the ten tribes will swiftly come to an end, and the high places will perish, that is, BAMOTH, concerning which it is written: \"Nevertheless the people still sacrificed and burned incense in the high places\" (3 Kings 22:44). Moreover these high places are, or AVEN, that is, of the idol, which is interpreted as \"useless,\" which idol and useless thing is the sin of Israel.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":189,"ref":"p189","source":"Dissipato autem idolo et excelsis ejus\n\n(Vers. 9.) « Lappa et tribulus ascendet super aras eorum, et dicent montibus, Operite nos, et collibus, Cadite super nos. » LXX: « Spinae et tribuli ascendent super altaria eorum, et dicent montibus, Operite nos, et collibus, Cadite super nos. » Signum ultimae solitudinis, ut ne parietes quidem et extrema aedificiorum vestigia relinquantur. Eo tempore, dicent montibus, Operite vos, et collibus. Cadite super nos. Quod Dominus in ultimo tempore captivitatis Judaicae dicit esse complendam. Quidquid ergo nunc contra decem tribus, sive contra omnem dicitur Israel, sciamus etiam ad totum populum posse transferri, ut quando Romani ceperint Jerusalem, et subverterint templum, sive cum judicii dies venerit, ut alii suspicantur, dicant magno horrore metuentes, montibus, operite nos, et collibus, cadite super nos, mori magis optantes quam cernere quae afferunt mortem. Sed et spiritalis nequitiae Samaria, quae se a populo Dei diviserat, fecit regem suum transire velociter, sermonem videlicet haereticorum, atque doctrinam quasi spumam, sive cremium super faciem aquae, quorum aliud dum videtur, repente dissolvitur, aliud facile est tollere de aquarum summitatibus, et in ignem mittere. Tales sunt haeretici spumantibus verbis tumentes, et arsura praecipta Christi baptismati ac sermonibus illius commiscentes.","english":"But when the idol and its high places have been scattered\n\n(Verse 9.) \"The burdock and the thistle shall come up over their altars, and they shall say to the mountains, Cover us, and to the hills, Fall upon us.\" The Septuagint: \"Thorns and thistles shall come up over their altars, and they shall say to the mountains, Cover us, and to the hills, Fall upon us.\" It is a sign of utter desolation, that not even the walls and the last traces of buildings are left. At that time, they shall say to the mountains, Cover us, and to the hills, Fall upon us. Which the Lord says is to be fulfilled in the last time of the Jewish captivity. Whatever therefore is now said against the ten tribes, or against all Israel, let us know that it can also be transferred to the whole people, so that when the Romans have captured Jerusalem and overthrown the temple, or when the day of judgment has come, as others suspect, they may say in great horror and fear, to the mountains, Cover us, and to the hills, Fall upon us, choosing rather to die than to behold the things that bring death. But also the Samaria of spiritual wickedness, which had divided itself from the people of God, made its king pass by swiftly—that is, the speech of heretics—and its doctrine like foam, or scum upon the face of the water, of which one part, while it is seen, is suddenly dissolved, and the other is easily lifted from the surface of the waters and thrown into the fire. Such are the heretics, swelling with foaming words, and mingling things destined to burn with the baptism of Christ and his words.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":190,"ref":"p190","source":"Quae omnia pertransibunt, et verba magnifica in quibus laboraverunt, quod inter· prelatur, illico dispergentur, in quibus peccavit Israel: tantaque erit solitudo doctrinae pessimae, ut spinae et tribuli ascendant super aras eorum. Spinas et tribulos ibi nasci, ubi agrorum nulla cultura est, omnibus patet. Istae spinae sunt, quae suffocant sementem, et crescere non sinunt quae nascuntur in manu temulenti, quas pro uva fecit Israel. Dominus enim exspectavit ut faceret uvas, et fecit spinas, sive labruscam habentem uvae similitudinem, et amaro gustu vescentium ora torquentem. Ideo cum Judicii tempus advenerit, et fuerint cuncta subversa, dicent montibus, quos prius excelsos putabant, et magistris quondam suis, operite nos; collibusque, cadite super nos. Sed quia in montibus posuit, operite nos, et in collibus, cadite, sacratius aliquid explanandum est. Montibus, id est, sanctis qui veram habent et non fictam altitudinem, dicent: operite nos: Beati enim quorum opertae sunt iniquitates (Psal. XXXI, 1); et collibus qui non habent altitudinem naturalem, quos dudum putabant habere aliquid summitatis, loquentur, cadite supernos: montes enim operient, et colles cadent: haec autem fient prae pavore et incredibili formidine, per quam et montes et colles humiliabuntur.","english":"All these things will pass away, and the magnificent words in which they labored, which is brought out in between, will be scattered at once, in which Israel sinned; and so great will be the desolation of the worst doctrine that thorns and thistles will come up over their altars. That thorns and thistles grow there where there is no cultivation of the fields is clear to all. These are the thorns that choke the seed and do not allow what is born in the hand of the drunkard to grow, which Israel made instead of grapes. For the Lord expected that it would produce grapes, and it produced thorns, or the wild vine that has the likeness of a grape and twists the mouths of those tasting it with its bitter flavor. Therefore when the time of judgment has come and all things have been overthrown, they will say to the mountains, which they previously thought lofty, and to their former teachers, Cover us; and to the hills, Fall upon us. But because he placed Cover us with the mountains, and Fall with the hills, something more sacred must be explained. To the mountains, that is, to the saints who have true and not feigned loftiness, they will say: Cover us: for blessed are those whose iniquities are covered; and to the hills that do not have natural loftiness, which they once thought had some height, they will speak, Fall upon us: for the mountains will cover, and the hills will fall: but these things will happen from fear and incredible dread, through which both the mountains and the hills will be brought low.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":191,"ref":"p191","source":"(Vers. 9, 10.) « Ex diebus Gabaa peccavit Israel: ibi steterunt. Non comprehendet eos in Gabaa pralium super filios iniquitatis. Juxta desiderium meum corripiam cos: congregabuntur super eos populi, cum corripientur super duas iniquitates suas. » LXX: « Ex quo colles sunt, peccavit Israel: ibi steterunt, non comprehendit cos in colle bellum super filios iniquitatis: venit ut corriperet eos, et congregabuntur super illos populi, quando correpti fuerint in duabus iniquitatibus suis. » Ex eo die quo uxorem Levitae turpiter atque crudeliter interfecit Benjamin in urbe Gabaa, peccavit mihi omnis Israel (Judic. XX), non quia ultus est injuriam, et scelus sanguine vindicavit, sed quia dolore maritali prosilivit ad pugnam, et sacrilegium in Deum suum noluit vindicare: eo quod in domo Michae ephod et therapim quae pro idolis adorabantur, neglexerint 3. Hic igitur stetit Israel, ibi suum repressit gradum, ne ultra ambularet in viis Domini. Idcirco non eos comprehendet propter Gabaa praelium, sive captivitas, sicut ipsi putant: ibi enim bene fecerunt ut persequerentur filios iniquitatis; sed corripiam, inquit, eos atque erudiam tota animi mei voluntate, et congregabo adversus illos populorum multitudinem, quia duas fecerunt iniquitates, vindicando hominem, et Dei sui injuriam negligendo.","english":"From the days of Gibeah Israel has sinned: there they stood. Battle shall not overtake them in Gibeah against the sons of iniquity. According to my desire I will chastise them: peoples shall be gathered together against them, when they are chastised for their two iniquities. The Septuagint: From the time that the hills are, Israel has sinned: there they stood, war did not overtake them on the hill against the sons of iniquity: he came to chastise them, and peoples shall be gathered together against them, when they have been chastised for their two iniquities. From that day on which Benjamin shamefully and cruelly killed the wife of the Levite in the city of Gibeah, all Israel sinned against me (Judges 20), not because he avenged the wrong and punished the crime with blood, but because with marital grief he rushed out to battle, and was unwilling to avenge the sacrilege against his God: in that in the house of Micah they neglected the ephod and teraphim which were adored as idols. Here therefore Israel stood, here he checked his step, lest he walk further in the ways of the Lord. Therefore battle shall not overtake them on account of Gibeah, or captivity, as they themselves think: for there they did well to pursue the sons of iniquity; but I will chastise, he says, and instruct them with the whole will of my mind, and I will gather against them a multitude of peoples, because they have committed two iniquities, by avenging a man, and by neglecting the wrong done to their God.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":192,"ref":"p192","source":"Sive duas iniquitates, quia primum peccaverunt in idolis Michae, secundo in vitulis Jeroboam; vel certe duos vitulos Samariae in Dan et Bethel, possumus duas iniquitates appellare, de quibus et Jeremias loquitur: Duo pessima fecit populus meus; dereliquerunt me fontem aqua vivae, et foderunt sibi lacus contritos, qui non possunt aquas continere (Jerem. II, 13). Haec duae iniquitates contra duo Decalogi erupere praecepta, in quibus dicitur: Ego Dominus Deus tuus: non erunt tibi dii alii absque me (Exod. IX, 3). Septuaginta Gabaa, colles interpretati sunt. A diebus ergo collium peccavit Israel, quando montes Ecclesiae dereliquit, et ad colles. sive clivos descendit haereticos; doctiorem se putans quam Ecclesia est, et sublimius aliquid reperisse: ibi steterunt, hoc est, in errore perseveraverunt. Quodque sequitur, Non comprehendet eos in colle praelium, quidam sic interpretati sunt; quia genuerunt filios iniquitatis, et de Ecclesia recedentes, coeperunt esse in collibus, cum persecutio advenerit, non eos comprehendet praelium, diabolo suos impugnare nolente. Alii ita: Quoniam ex diebus collium peccavit Israel, et ibi stetit et ultra ambulare non potuit, nonne oportet eum in collibus a praelio comprehendi? Nonne debent pugnare adversus eum viri ecclesiastici, ut illos destruant super filios iniquitatis? qui si fuerint compre hensi et superati, ultra generare non poterunt.","english":"Or we can call the two iniquities those of which Jeremiah also speaks: because they sinned first in the idols of Micah, and second in the calves of Jeroboam; or certainly the two calves of Samaria at Dan and Bethel: My people have done two evil things; they have forsaken me, the fountain of living water, and have dug for themselves broken cisterns, which cannot hold water. These two iniquities burst forth against the two precepts of the Decalogue, in which it is said: I am the Lord your God: you shall not have other gods besides me. The Seventy interpreted Gibeah as hills. From the days, therefore, of the hills Israel sinned, when it forsook the mountains of the Church and descended to the hills, or the slopes, of heretics, thinking itself more learned than the Church is, and that it had found something more sublime: there they stood, that is, they persevered in error. And what follows, Battle shall not overtake them on the hill, some have interpreted thus: because they begot sons of iniquity, and departing from the Church they began to be on the hills; when persecution comes, battle shall not overtake them, since the devil is unwilling to attack his own. Others thus: Since from the days of the hills Israel sinned, and there stood and could no longer walk, should it not be overtaken by battle on the hills? Should not ecclesiastical men fight against it, to destroy those upon the sons of iniquity? who, if they have been overtaken and overcome, will no longer be able to beget.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":193,"ref":"p193","source":"Simulque Dominus pollicetur, quod corripiat cos atque erudiat, ut cum superati fuerint magistri, congregentur adversus eos discipuli sui, quos ante deceperant, et videant correptionem propter duas iniquitates, quia et Ecclesiam fontem Domini reliquerunt, et foderunt sibi lacus contritos, speluncas scilicet haereticorum, qui non possunt aquas, id est, doctrinam Salvatoris et sacramentum baptismi continere.\n\n(Vers. 11.) « Ephraim vitula docta diligere trituram: et ego transivi super pulchritudinem colli ejus, et ascendam super Ephraim; arabit Judas; confringet sibi sulcos Jacob. » LXX: « Ephraim vitula (sive vacca; etenim quod Hebraice dicitur EGLA ( ), id est, et, utrumque significat), Ephraim ergo vitula edocta diligere contentionem: ego autem veniam super pulchritudinem colli ejus; superponam Ephraim, et leticebo Judam: roborabitur sibi Jacob. » Locus iste, imo omnia quae hoc capitulum sequuntur, magnis obscuritatibus involuta sunt. Unde et nos qui explanare conamur, et prudens simul lector attendat, ut si non veritatem, quod difficillimum est, saltem suspicionem verisimilium investigare valeamus. Hanc habet consuetudinem sermo divinus, ut per tropologiam et metaphoram historiae exprimat veritatem.","english":"At the same time the Lord promises that he will rebuke and instruct them, so that when their teachers have been overcome, their own disciples, whom they had previously deceived, may be gathered against them, and may see the rebuke on account of the two iniquities, because they both abandoned the Church, the fountain of the Lord, and dug for themselves broken cisterns, that is, the caves of heretics, which cannot hold the waters, that is, the doctrine of the Savior and the sacrament of baptism.\n\n(Verse 11.) Ephraim is a trained heifer that loves to thresh: and I passed over the beauty of her neck, and I will mount upon Ephraim; Judah shall plow; Jacob shall break up furrows for himself. The Septuagint: Ephraim is a heifer (or a cow; for what is said in Hebrew as Eglah, that is, and, signifies both), Ephraim therefore is a heifer taught to love contention: but I will come upon the beauty of her neck; I will set Ephraim above, and I will make Judah rejoice: Jacob shall be strengthened for himself. This passage, indeed all that follow in this chapter, are wrapped in great obscurities. Therefore both we who attempt to explain, and the prudent reader alike should attend, so that if we cannot attain the truth, which is most difficult, we may at least investigate a suspicion of what is plausible. The divine word has this custom, that through tropology and metaphor of history it expresses the truth.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":194,"ref":"p194","source":"Igitur Ephraim similis est vaccae vel vitulae, quae a juventute sua didicit aream terere, et ferreos orbes super acervos segetum trahere, ut paleae a tritico separentur i et non solum didicit, verum nimia consuetudine coepit amare, quod docta est. Et ego, inquit, transivi super pulchritudinem colli ejus. Verbum Hebraicum ABARTHI ), id est, transivi, maxime quando a Deo dicitur, semper plagas et adversa significat. Denique et exterminator in AEgypto transisse memoratur. Quia ergo Ephraim vacca vel vitula diligit aream terere, ego, inquit, transivi super pulchritudinem colli ejus, et tumentes cervicum toros jugo imposito edomui. Quid memorem legis jugum? ipse ascendi super eam, et me ita laborante, Judas, hoc est, duae tribus coeperunt arva scindere vomere, et in sulcos terram reclinare. Portante autem jugum Ephraim, et arante Juda. confregit sibi sulcos Jacob. Hic Jacob ad distinctionem Israel et Judae, duodecim tribus intelligamus: quod coeperint aratris glebas frangere, terramque comminuere: ut emollita recipiat sementem, et fecunda post modicum seges pullulet. Pro tritura, vel area, contentionem Septuaginta transtulerunt, et est sensus: Quia Ephraim non vult legis recipere jugum, ego transibo et ascendam super pulchritudinem colli ejus: ut discat contentiosa vacca atque lasciviens laborare, quod non vult.","english":"Therefore Ephraim is like a cow or a heifer that from its youth has learned to thresh the floor and to drag iron rollers over heaps of grain, so that the chaff may be separated from the wheat; and not only has it learned this, but by excessive habit it has begun to love what it was taught. And I, he says, passed over the beauty of its neck. The Hebrew word ABARTHI, that is, I passed over, especially when it is spoken by God, always signifies plagues and adversities. Finally, the destroyer in Egypt is also recorded to have passed over. Since, therefore, Ephraim, a cow or a heifer, loves to thresh the floor, I, he says, passed over the beauty of its neck, and by imposing the yoke I subdued the swelling muscles of its neck. Why should I mention the yoke of the law? I myself mounted upon her, and while I labored thus, Judah, that is, the two tribes, began to cut the fields with the plowshare and to lay the earth back into furrows. But while Ephraim carried the yoke and Judah plowed, Jacob broke its own furrows. Here let us understand Jacob, in distinction from Israel and Judah, as the twelve tribes: that they began to break the clods with plows and to crumble the earth, so that once softened it might receive the seed, and after a little while a fruitful harvest might sprout. For threshing, or the floor, the Seventy translated as contention, and the sense is: Because Ephraim does not wish to receive the yoke of the law, I will pass over and ascend upon the beauty of its neck, so that the contentious and wanton cow may learn to labor, which it does not wish to do.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":195,"ref":"p195","source":"Judas autem arabit sponte sua: quia habet templum, et moratur in lege, ut lota certatim duodecim tribus arva praeparent ad serendum. Quodque sequitur juxta eosdem Septuaginta: Superponam Ephraim: et retice' o Judam, roborabitur sibi Jacob, hic esse sensus potest: Ephraim qui contentiosus est et non vult legis onera portare, imponam captivitatem. Judam autem parumper relinquam, et nihil loquar de eo: quicunque autem tam de Ephraim, quam de Juda mea praecepta servaverit, roborabitur sibi et vocabitur Jacob. Secundum hoc dici potest, quod Ephraim qui eruditus fuit in lege Dei, ut tereret aream Scripturarum, et meditaretur in ea die ac node, coepit diligere contentionem et jugum legis abjicere, et contendere contra ecclesiasticos in subversionem audientium. Unde Dominus elevatam cervicem et sibi sublimia promittentem, vel jugo premet, vel ipse transiens calcabit pedibus suis, et ascendet super eum, ut sciat se habere Dominum. Judas autem, hoc est, ecclesiasticus arabit, in coepto opere perseverans. Sive: Retinebo, inquit, Judam. Non enim sani indigent med co, sed qui mule habent (Luc. V, 31).","english":"But Judah will plow of his own accord, because he has the temple and abides in the law, so that the twelve tribes, having been washed, may prepare the fields for sowing in rivalry with one another. And what follows according to the same Septuagint: I will place Ephraim upon him, and I will hold back Judah, Jacob will be strengthened for himself — this can be the meaning: Ephraim, who is contentious and does not wish to bear the burdens of the law, I will impose captivity upon him. But Judah I will leave for a little while, and I will say nothing about him. But whoever, whether from Ephraim or from Judah, has kept my commandments, he will be strengthened for himself and will be called Jacob. According to this it can be said that Ephraim, who was instructed in the law of God so as to thresh the floor of the Scriptures and to meditate on it day and night, began to love contention and to cast off the yoke of the law, and to contend against churchmen for the subversion of hearers. Whence the Lord, when he has raised up his neck and promised himself lofty things, will either press him down with a yoke, or he himself, passing by, will trample him with his feet and ascend over him, so that he may know that he has the Lord. But Judah, that is, the churchman, will plow, persevering in the work he has begun. Or: I will retain Judah, he says. For those who are healthy do not need a physician, but those who are sick (Luke 5:31).","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":196,"ref":"p196","source":"Jacob vero qui interpretatur supplantator, et quotidie supplantat vitia atque peccata, et accipit primitiva fratris sui, et haeres paternae possessionis est, et dormit in Bethel, quod interpretatur domus Dei, sulcos glebasque confringet, ut molli sinu jactatam sementem terra suscipiat, et faciat centum modios hordei, sive, ut habetur in Hebraeo, centuplum. Neque enim credendum est quod patriarcha Isaac hordeo studuerit, et non frumento. Usque hodie vir ecclesiasticus Jacob glebas historiae et litterae duritiam confringit in partes, et spiritaliter dividit, ut possint fruges reddere spiritales. Quod quidem et Dominum fecisse legimus, ut quinque legis panes, quos integros populus comedere non poterat, in frusta concerperet: ut per apostolorum manus vescendos credentibus daret (Luc. IX). Quod autem dicit juxta Septuaginta, roborabitur sibi Jacob, ostendit sibi omnem laborantem laborare, ut fructus capiat sempiternos.","english":"But Jacob, whose name is interpreted as supplanter, and who daily supplants vices and sins, and receives his brother's firstborn rights, and is heir of his father's possession, and sleeps in Bethel, which is interpreted as house of God, will break the furrows and clods, so that the earth may receive the seed cast into its soft bosom, and may produce a hundred measures of barley, or, as it stands in the Hebrew, a hundredfold. For it is not to be believed that the patriarch Isaac devoted himself to barley and not to wheat. To this day the ecclesiastical man Jacob breaks the clods of history and the hardness of the letter into parts, and divides them spiritually, so that they may be able to yield spiritual fruits. We read that the Lord also did this, so that the five loaves of the law, which the people could not eat whole, he tore into pieces, so that through the hands of the apostles he might give them to the believers to eat (Luke 9). But what he says according to the Septuagint, Jacob will be strengthened for himself, shows that everyone who labors labors for himself, so that he may receive eternal fruits.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":197,"ref":"p197","source":"(Vers. 12.) « Seminate vobis in justitia, metite in ore misericordiae. Innovate vobis novale: tempus autem requirendi Dominum, cum venerit qui docebit vos justitiam. » LXX: « Seminale vobis in justitia, vindemiate fructum vitae: illuminate vobis lumen scientiae, quoniam est tempus: quaerite Dominum, donec veniant fruges justitiae vobis. » Servat ab agricolis semel coeptam translationem. Dixerat Ephraim vitulam edoctam trituram areae amare ac diligere, et se ascendisse super collum ejus, et arasse Judam, et confregisse sulcos sive glebas Jacob. Nunc praecipit ut seminent sibi per poenitentiam, el seminent in justitia, id est, in lege, metantque in misericordia, id est, in gratia Evangelii. Ibi enim: Oculum pro oculo, dentem pro dente (Exod. XXI, 24): hic legimus: Qui te percusserit in dexteram maxillam, praebe ei et alteram (Matth. V, 39). Cumque seminaveritis in justitia, et messueritis in misericordia, innovate vobis laeta novalia. Redditque causas cur seminent, cur metant, cur innovent lacta novalia. Tempus, inquit, requirendi Dominum est, cum venerit, Christus atque Salvator, qui docebit vos justitiam, quam nunc speratis in lege: Finis enim legis Christus est ad justitiam omni operanti bonum (Rom. X, 4).","english":"(Verse 12.) \"Sow for yourselves in righteousness, reap in the mouth of mercy. Break up for yourselves fresh ground: but it is time to seek the Lord, when he who will teach you righteousness shall come.\" The Septuagint: \"Sow for yourselves in righteousness, gather the fruit of life: enlighten for yourselves the light of knowledge, for it is time: seek the Lord, until the fruits of righteousness come to you.\" He preserves the metaphor once begun from the farmers. He had said that Ephraim loved and cherished the trained heifer that treads the threshing floor, and that he had ascended upon her neck, and had plowed Judah, and had broken the furrows or clods of Jacob. Now he instructs that they sow for themselves through repentance, and sow in righteousness, that is, in the law, and reap in mercy, that is, in the grace of the Gospel. For there: An eye for an eye, a tooth for a tooth (Exod. 21:24): here we read: Whoever strikes you on the right cheek, offer him the other as well (Matt. 5:39). And when you have sown in righteousness, and reaped in mercy, break up for yourselves joyful fresh ground. And he gives the reasons why they should sow, why they should reap, why they should break up joyful fresh ground. It is time, he says, to seek the Lord, when Christ and Savior shall come, who will teach you the righteousness which you now hope for in the law: For Christ is the end of the law unto righteousness for everyone who does good (Rom. 10:4).","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":198,"ref":"p198","source":"Pro eo quod nos diximus, metite in ore misericordiae, Septuaginta transtulerunt, vindemiate fructum vitae: magisque semini convenit messio, quam vindemia: fructus autem vitae ipse est, qui et lignum vitae. Et pro eo quod nos posuimus, innovate vobis novale, illi verterunt, illuminate vobis lumen scientiae, ut ex operibus atque mandatis legis notitiam habere mereamur, juxta illud quod in quodam libro legimus: Desiderasti sapientiam: serva mandata, et Dominus dabit eam tibi (Eccli. I, 33). Qui enim mandata in opera verterit, seminat in justitia, et metet et ea fructus vitae. Unde et alibi legimus: Mandatum Domini lucidum illuminans oculos [Psal. XVIII. 9). Et Isaias ad Dominum dicit: Lux praecepta tua super terram. Et in alio loco: A mandatis tuis intellexi (Psal. CXVIII, 104). His quoque, qui ab Ecclesia separati sum, et falsum sibi Christianorum nomen assumunt, praecipitur ut agant poenitentiam, et utrumque recipiant Testamentum: in Veteri justitiam seminent, in Novo metant misericordiam: et illuminent sibi lumen scientiae, sive innovent sibi novalia, et requirant Dominum, qui docere eos potest veram justitiam, falsosque magistros destruant, a quibus non discunt justitiam, sed iniquitatem.","english":"Instead of what we rendered as \"reap in the mouth of mercy,\" the Septuagint translated \"gather the fruit of life\"; and harvest fits the seed better than vintage does. But the fruit of life is the very one who is also the tree of life. And instead of what we set down as \"break up for yourselves fresh ground,\" they rendered \"illuminate for yourselves the light of knowledge,\" so that from the works and commandments of the law we may deserve to have knowledge, according to what we read in a certain book: \"You have desired wisdom: keep the commandments, and the Lord will give it to you\" (Sirach 1:33). For he who turns the commandments into works sows in righteousness, and will reap from them the fruits of life. Hence we also read elsewhere: \"The commandment of the Lord is bright, enlightening the eyes\" (Psalm 18:9). And Isaiah says to the Lord: \"Your precepts are a light upon the earth.\" And in another place: \"From your commandments I gained understanding\" (Psalm 118:104). To those also who are separated from the Church and assume for themselves the false name of Christians, it is commanded that they do penance and receive both Testaments: in the Old, to sow righteousness; in the New, to reap mercy; and to illuminate for themselves the light of knowledge, or to break up for themselves fresh ground, and to seek the Lord, who can teach them true righteousness, and to destroy the false teachers, from whom they do not learn righteousness but iniquity.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[{"kind":"lacuna","severity":"caution","text":"The source is fragmentary here: the edition marks a break or an editorial bracket, and the English carries across it. Treat the bridge as supplied, not translated."}]},{"i":199,"ref":"p199","source":"(Vers. 13.) « Arastis impietatem, iniquitatem messuistis: comedistis frugem mendacii, » LXX: « Quid reticetis impietates, et iniquitates ejus vindemiastis; comedistis fructum mendacem, » Cogor contra voluntatem meam saepius de Hebraeae linguae proprietatibus disputare: neque enim rhetorum more sententias repetimus, verba construimus, et audientes vel legentes in laudes nostras declamationibus suscitamus: sed quae obscura sunt, maxime alienae linguae hominibus explanare nitimur. Supra ubi nos interpretati sumus, arabit Judas, in Hebraico legitur JEROS ( ) per JOD primam litteram, quam Septuaginta VAU ( ) putantes, interpretati sunt, et tacebo. Nunc quoque in Hebraeo scriptum est ARASTHEM, ( ) quod nos vertimus, arastis: pro quo Septuaginta transtulerunt, quid reticetis: simili errore quo supra, silentium pro aratione interpretantes. Est autem sensus iste dictorum: Super collum vitulae Ephraim contentiosae amantisque trituram ego transivi, et ego ascendi, ut arante Juda, et confringente sulcos, Jacob tereret aream, et solis ferret calorem. Monuique eos ut seminarent in justitia, et meterent in misericordia, et facerent sibi novalia: tempusque requirendi Dominum illud esse cognoscerent, quo venturus est qui docebit nos justitiam.","english":"(Verse 13.) \"You have plowed impiety, you have reaped iniquity: you have eaten the fruit of lying,\" the Septuagint: \"Why are you silent, you have gathered the impieties and iniquities of him; you have eaten a lying fruit.\" I am compelled, against my will, to dispute rather often about the peculiarities of the Hebrew language; for I do not, in the manner of rhetoricians, repeat opinions, construct words, and rouse hearers or readers to praise me with declamations; but what is obscure, especially for men of another language, I strive to explain. Above, where we translated \"Judas shall plow,\" in the Hebrew it is read as JEROS through the first letter JOD, which the Septuagint, thinking it was VAU, translated as \"and I shall be silent.\" Now too in the Hebrew it is written ARASTHEM, which we rendered \"you have plowed\"; for which the Septuagint translated \"why are you silent,\" by a similar error to the one above, interpreting silence instead of plowing. But this is the sense of the words: Upon the neck of the contentious calf of Ephraim that loves threshing, I passed over, and I ascended, so that with Judas plowing and breaking the furrows, Jacob might tread the threshing floor and bear the heat of the sun. And I warned them to sow in justice, and reap in mercy, and make for themselves new ground; and to recognize that this was the time to seek the Lord, when he is to come who will teach us justice.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":200,"ref":"p200","source":"Me haec jubente, et volente de laetis novalibus fructus justitiae ac misericordiae accipere, araverunt impietatem, qua egerunt impie contra Dominum, relinquentes Creatorem, et colentes idola, et messuerunt iniquitatem, de malo semine malas fruges recipientes, de quibus fecerunt non solum panem subcinericium, sed fraudulentum atque mendacem, qui vana spe deciperet comedentem. Istiusmodi sunt haeretici, qui arant sermone composito, et protegunt vel tacent impietatem: ne impietas esse videatur, sed credatur pietas. Unde quia dixerunt in corde suo, Non est Deus (Psal. XIII), corrupti sunt et abominabiles facti sunt, et messuerunt, sive vindemiaverunt iniquitates. Quomodo enim radix omnium malorum est avaritia (I Tim. VI): sic peccatorum scelerumque cunctorum radix est impietas, quam qui araverit sive seminaverit, metet iniquitates. Qui igitur araverunt impietatem, et messuerunt iniquitates, comederunt fructum mendacii: omnia quae falsa sunt deceptis populis praedicantes, ut non quaerant panem verum, qui de coelo descendit: sed panem mendacii, qui suffocat et interficit devorantes.","english":"At my command and will, that they should receive from the glad new fields the fruits of justice and mercy, they plowed impiety, by which they acted impiously against the Lord, forsaking the Creator and worshiping idols, and they reaped iniquity, receiving evil fruits from evil seed, from which they made not only bread baked under ashes, but fraudulent and lying bread, which would deceive the one eating it with vain hope. Of this sort are the heretics, who plow with composed speech and protect or keep silent about impiety, lest it appear to be impiety but be believed to be piety. Hence, because they said in their heart, There is no God, they are corrupted and have become abominable, and they reaped, or gathered as vintage, iniquities. For just as the root of all evils is avarice, so the root of all sins and crimes is impiety; whoever has plowed or sown it will reap iniquities. Therefore those who plowed impiety and reaped iniquities ate the fruit of lying, preaching all things that are false to deceived peoples, so that they might not seek the true bread, which came down from heaven, but the bread of lying, which chokes and kills those who devour it.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":201,"ref":"p201","source":"(Vers. et 15.) « Quia confisus es in viis tuis: in multitudine fortium tuorum consurget tumultus in populo tuo, et omnes munitiones tuae vastabuntur: sicut vastatus est Salmana a domo ejus, qui vindicavit Baal in die praelii, matre super filios ali si, sic fecit vobis Bethel a facie malitiae nequitiarum vestrarum. » LXX: « Quia sperasti in curribus tuis, in multitudine fortitudinis tuae, consurget perditio in populo tuo, et omnia murata tua abibunt; sicut principes Salmana de domo Jerobaal in diebus belli, matrem super filios alliserunt, sic faciam vobis, domus Israel. a facie malitiarum vestrarum. » Ideo comedistis frugem mendacii, et in cunctis quae proposuistis, spes vos vana decepit; quia confisus es, o Ephraim, in viis idololatriae tuae: hae sunt enim viae tuae, et in multitudine fortium tuorum, non in Deo habens spem, sed in exercitus robore. Itaque consurget tumultus in populo tuo, quod Hebraice dicitur, SAON ( ), id est, sonitus et fremitus ululantis exercitus, quibus clamantibus, omnes munitiones tuae vastabuntur, et ea quae munita arbitrabaris et tuta, patebunt hostibus, et sic vastabuntur, quomodo vastatus est atque contritus Salmana princeps Madianitarum, qui interfectus est a domo Jerobaal (Judic. VIII).","english":"(Verses 14–15.) \"Because you have trusted in your ways: in the multitude of your mighty men a tumult shall rise up in your people, and all your fortifications shall be laid waste: just as Salmana was laid waste by his own house, who avenged Baal in the day of battle, the mother dashed upon her sons; so Bethel has done to you because of the malice of your wickedness.\" The Septuagint reads: \"Because you have hoped in your chariots, in the multitude of your strength, destruction shall rise up in your people, and all your walled cities shall pass away; just as the princes of Salmana from the house of Jerobaal in the days of war dashed the mother upon the sons, so I will do to you, house of Israel, because of your wickednesses.\" Therefore you have eaten the fruit of falsehood, and in all the things you have proposed, empty hope has deceived you; because you have trusted, O Ephraim, in the ways of your idolatry—for these are your ways—and in the multitude of your mighty men, placing your hope not in God but in the strength of your army. And so a tumult shall rise up in your people, which in Hebrew is called SAON, that is, the noise and roaring of a howling army; and when they cry out, all your fortifications shall be laid waste, and the things you thought fortified and safe shall lie open to the enemy, and shall be laid waste just as Salmana, the prince of the Midianites, was laid waste and crushed, who was killed by the house of Jerobaal (Judges 8).","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":202,"ref":"p202","source":"Haud dubium quin Gedeonem significet, qui ex eo quod destruxit fanum Baal, lucumque succidit, et ille se vindicare non potuit, cognomentum Jerobaal sortitus est, id est, ulciscatur se Baal; ut quomodo Salmana interfecit filios coram matribus suis, ipsis quoque matribus deinceps interfectis; sic et filii, tui. o Ephraim, te praesente interficiantur, qui et ipse trucidandus es. Quaerimus, ubi scriptum sit, quod Salmana matrem super filiis occiderit: legimus in Judicum libro loquente Gedeone ad principem Madian: Quomodo absque liberis fecit gladius tuus multas matres, ita sine filiis erit inter mulieres mater tua (Judic. VIII). Sicut igitur vastatus est Salmana ab Jerobaal, quem male quidam arbittantur Jeroboam filium Nabath, qui decem tribubus praefuit, et vastatus est. ut in Hebraeo continetur, ab ARBEL id ipsum significante, quod et Jerobaal, sed breviori disertiorique sermone: sic fecit vobis, o Israel, a facie malitiarum vestrarum Bethel, in qua vitulum aureum posuistis, et estis venerati AEgyptios deos. Pro Bethel, quod interpretatur domus Dei, LXX transtulerunt domus Israel, quod in Hebraeo penitus non habetur. Evasimus utcunque de confragosis locis: nunc in altum vela tendentes, allegoriae pelagus transeamus.","english":"There is no doubt that he signifies Gideon, who from the fact that he destroyed the shrine of Baal and cut down the sacred grove, and Baal could not avenge himself, received the surname Jerobaal, that is, \"let Baal avenge himself\"; so that just as Salmana killed sons in the presence of their mothers, with the mothers themselves afterward also killed, so also your sons, O Ephraim, shall be killed in your presence, you who yourself must also be slaughtered. We ask where it is written that Salmana killed a mother over her sons: we read in the book of Judges, when Gideon speaks to the prince of Midian: \"Just as your sword made many mothers childless, so your mother shall be without sons among women\" (Judg. 8). Therefore just as Salmana was laid waste by Jerobaal—whom some wrongly think to be Jeroboam son of Nabath, who presided over the ten tribes—and he was laid waste, as is contained in the Hebrew, by ARBEL, which signifies the same thing as Jerobaal, but in a shorter and more distinct expression: so he did to you, O Israel, from the face of your wickednesses, Bethel, in which you set up the golden calf, and you have worshiped the gods of Egypt. For Bethel, which is interpreted \"house of God,\" the Seventy translated as \"house of Israel,\" which is not found in the Hebrew at all. We have somehow escaped from the rugged places: now, spreading our sails for the deep, let us cross the sea of allegory.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":203,"ref":"p203","source":"Quia confisus es, o Ephraim, in viis, sive, in curribus tuis, de quibus scriptum est, Hi in curribus et hi in equis: nos autem in nomine Domini Dei nostri magnificabimur (Psal. XIX, 8): et confisus es in multitudine fortium tuorum, quos libi falsa scientia roborasti: ideo consurget tumultus et sonitus in populo tuo. Quidquid enim loquuntur haeretici, non habent vocem sententias explicantem, sed tumultum clamo, remque et sonitum. Et omnes munitiones taae, sive quae murata sunt, vastabuntur (non enim testimoniis Scripturarum, sed arte dialectica, et argumentis philosophorum munita sunt atque constructa), sicut vastatus est quondam Salmana a Gedeone, matre super filiis interfecta. Cujus historiae et octogesimus secundus psalmus meminit: ubi inter caeteros duces Madian etiam Salmana fuisse commemorat, dicens: Fac eis, Domine, haud dubium quin eos significet qui contra Dominum inierunt pactum sive testamentum, sicut Madian et Sisarae (Psal. LXXXII, 10). Et post reliqua: Pone, inquit, principes eorum sicut Oreb et Zeb, et Sebee et Salmana, omnes principes eorum qui dixerant: Haeredilate possidemus sanctuarium Dei (Ibid. 12, 13). Et in boc eodem psalmo duces haereticorum describuntur, qui altare Dei sibi vindicare conati sunt.","english":"Because you have trusted, O Ephraim, in your ways, or in your chariots, of which it is written, Some in chariots and some in horses: but we will be magnified in the name of the Lord our God: and you have trusted in the multitude of your strong men, whom you have strengthened for yourself by false knowledge: therefore an uproar and a noise shall arise among your people. For whatever heretics say, they do not have a voice that sets forth clear meanings, but a clamor, a noise, and a din. And all your fortifications, or those that are walled, shall be laid waste (for they are fortified and built not by the testimonies of the Scriptures, but by dialectical skill and the arguments of philosophers), just as Salmana was once laid waste by Gideon, after the mother had been killed over her sons. The eighty-second psalm also mentions this history, where it recalls that Salmana was among the other leaders of Midian, saying: Do to them, O Lord—there is no doubt that he signifies those who entered into a pact or covenant against the Lord—as to Midian and Sisera. And after other things it says: Make their princes like Oreb and Zeb, and Zebee and Salmana, all their princes who said: Let us possess the sanctuary of God as an inheritance. And in this same psalm the leaders of the heretics are described, who have attempted to claim the altar of God for themselves.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":204,"ref":"p204","source":"Quodque sequitur: Sicut fecit vobis, Bethel, a facie malitiae nequitiarum vestrarum, proprie haereticorum principibus coaptatur, quod eis fecerit Bethel quam ipsi vocant Bethel, hoc est, domum Dei, et falsam Ecclesiam; ut sit sensus: Sic vobis faciet Ecclesia vestra quam vocatis domum Dei: caeterum ex quo a vobis. tenetur, appellanda est Bethaven, id est, domus idoli, propter multitudinem malitiarum vestrarum.\n\n(Cap. XI.—Vers. et 2.) « Sicut mane transiit 3, pertransit rex Israel: quia puer Israel, et dilexi eum, et ex AEgypto vocavi filium meum: vocaverunt eos: sic abierunt a facie eorum Baalim immolabant, et simula, ris sacrifi abant. » LXX: « Mane projecti sum, projectus est rex Israel quia parvutus Israel, et ego dilexi eum, et ex AEgypto vocavi filios suos. Sicut vocavi eos, ita abierunt a facie mea ipsi: Baalim immolabant, et sculptilibus adolebant 1. » Diversis figuris eumdem explicat sensum. Qui supra dixerat, Transire fecit Samaria regem suum quasi spumam super faciem aquae, eo quod spuma et bullae in aquarum summitatibus natantes celeriter dissolvantur: nunc eamdem rem sub alia ponit similitudine. Sicut enim ortus aurorae et diluculum et principium diei quod appellatur mane, inter noctis solisque viciniam transit celeriter, ita ut finiatur mox et clarescat dies: sic rex Israel, id est, decem tribuum velociter transiet.","english":"And what follows: As he did to you, Bethel, from the face of the malice of your wickednesses, is properly applied to the leaders of heretics, because Bethel—which they themselves call Bethel, that is, the house of God, and the false Church—has done this to them; so that the sense is: Thus your Church, which you call the house of God, will do to you; but from the time it is held by you, it should be called Bethaven, that is, the house of an idol, on account of the multitude of your wickednesses.\n\n(Cap. XI.—Vers. 1 and 2.) \"As the morning passed, the king of Israel passed away: for Israel was a child, and I loved him, and out of Egypt I called my son: they called them: so they went away from their face; they sacrificed to Baalim, and offered sacrifice to graven images.\" The Septuagint: \"In the morning I was cast out, the king of Israel was cast out, because Israel was a little child, and I loved him, and out of Egypt I called his sons. As I called them, so they went away from my face: they sacrificed to Baalim, and burned incense to graven images.\" He explains the same meaning by different figures. He who above had said, He made Samaria's king pass away like foam upon the face of the water, because foam and bubbles floating on the surface of waters are quickly dissolved: now he sets forth the same thing under another similitude. For just as the rising of the dawn and the daybreak and the beginning of the day, which is called morning, passes quickly between the neighborhood of night and the sun, so that the day is soon ended and becomes bright: so the king of Israel, that is, of the ten tribes, will quickly pass away.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[{"kind":"scripture","severity":"info","ref":"Hosea 11:1; Matthew 2:15","text":"The English carries the scriptural phrase “out of egypt i called my son”, which matches Hosea 11:1; Matthew 2:15. The match is on the English draft; check the Coptic before quoting the verse."}]},{"i":205,"ref":"p205","source":"Exponitque beneficia quae in ipsum contulerit Deus. Dum, inquit, esset puer et parvulus, et captus in AEgypto teneretur, in tantum eum dilexi, ut mitterem servum meum, Moysen, et ex AEgypto vocarem filium meum, de quo dixi in alio loco: Filius primogenitus meus Israel (Exod. IV, 22). Et quia Israel singulariter quidem dicitur, sed pluraliter intelligitur: quomodo et populus et Ephraim et Judas: siquidem in numero singulari multus est numerus, qui hoc numero continetur, veteris recordatur historiae, quod vocaverit quidem eos per Moysen et Aaron, qui vocaverunt eos, ut egrederentur de AEgypto: ipsi vero vocati ab eis recesserunt a facie eorum, vertentes ei terga, et mentis duritiam gestu corporis indicantes. Nec eis suffecit vocantes contemnere, nisi immolarent Baal et sculptilibus suis, sive simulacris adderent incensum. Adorasse eos Baal primum sub Achab rege Israel legimus, qui Sidonii regis filiam Jezabel duxit uxorem, et Babylonium ac Phoenicis idolum transtulit in Samariam. Ergo distantia peccata temporibus, uno sermone conjungit: quomodo primum vocati sint de AEgypto et appellati filii, deinde in solitudine recesserint a Deo, Beelphegor magis colentes, quam Deum, et postea in terra sancta Baalim et Astaroth, et caeteris idolis servierint.","english":"And he sets forth the benefits that God conferred upon him. While, he says, he was a boy and a little child, and was held captive in Egypt, I loved him to such a degree that I sent my servant Moses, and called my son out of Egypt, of whom I said in another place: Israel is my firstborn son. And because Israel is spoken of in the singular, but is understood in the plural—just as also the people, and Ephraim, and Judah—since in the singular number there is a great multitude contained within that number, he recalls the ancient history: that he called them indeed through Moses and Aaron, who called them to go out from Egypt; but they, when called by them, drew back from their face, turning their backs on him and indicating the hardness of their mind by the gesture of their body. Nor did it suffice for them to despise those who called them, unless they also sacrificed to Baal and offered incense to their graven images, or rather to their idols. We read that they first worshiped Baal under Ahab king of Israel, who took as wife Jezebel the daughter of the king of Sidon, and brought the idol of Babylon and Phoenicia into Samaria. Therefore he joins together in one discourse sins separated by their times: how they were first called out of Egypt and named sons, then in the wilderness drew back from God, worshiping Beelphegor rather than God, and afterward in the holy land served the Baals and Ashtaroth and the other idols.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":206,"ref":"p206","source":"Et transire haereticos instar diluculi, et regem eorum diabolum, vel haeresiarcham intelligimus quos in infantia (quando crediderunt in Ecclesia, et erant parvuli, et Christi nomine censebantur) dilexit eos Deus, et vocavit illos de tribulatione et tenebris AEgypti. Vocavit autem per apostolos et doctores Ecclesiae. Cumque a meis, inquit, ducibus sint vocali, recesserunt a facie eorum, et adoraverunt Beelphegor, hoc est, suis vitiis et libidini servierunt, et postea immolabant Baalim et simulacris, quae sibi confinxerunt. Singuli enim haereticorum habent deos suos, et quodcunque simulaverint, quasi sculptile colunt atque conflatile. Pro eo quod cos diximus, Ex AEgypto vocavi filium meum, Septuaginta transtulerunt: Ex AEgypto vocavi filios ejus, quod in Hebraico non habetur; nullique dubium est, Matthaeum de hoc loco sumpsisse testimonium (Matth. II, 15), juxta Hebraicam veritatem. Ergo qui detrahunt nostrae translationi, dent Scripturam de qua evangelista hoc testimonium sumpserit, et interpretatus sit in Domino Salvatore, quando de AEgypto reductus est in terram Israel. Et cum invenire non quiverint, desinant rugare frontem, adducere supercilium, crispare nares, digitis concrepare.","english":"And we understand the heretics to pass by like the dawn, and their king the devil, or the heresiarch, whom in their infancy—when they believed in the Church, and were little ones, and were reckoned under the name of Christ—God loved, and called them out of the tribulation and darkness of Egypt. But he called them through the apostles and teachers of the Church. And though, he says, they were called by my leaders, they departed from before them, and adored Beelphegor, that is, they served their own vices and lust, and afterward sacrificed to the Baalim and the idols that they fashioned for themselves. For each of the heretics has his own gods, and whatever they have feigned, they worship as a graven and molten image. In place of what we have said, Out of Egypt I called my son, the Seventy translated, Out of Egypt I called his sons, which is not found in the Hebrew; and no one doubts that Matthew took his testimony from this passage according to the Hebrew truth. Therefore let those who disparage our translation give the Scripture from which the evangelist took this testimony and interpreted it in the Lord Savior, when he was brought back from Egypt into the land of Israel. And when they cannot find it, let them stop wrinkling their brow, raising their eyebrow, curling their nose, and snapping their fingers.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":207,"ref":"p207","source":"Hunc locum in septimo volumine Julianus Augustus quod adversum nos, id est, Christianos evomuit, calumniatur, et dicit: Quod de Israel scriptum est, Matthaeus evangelista ad Christum transtulit, ut simplicitati eorum qui de gentibus crediderant, illuderet. Cui nos breviter respondebimus: primum Matthaeum Evangelium Hebraeis litteris edidisse 3, quod non poterant legere nisi hi qui ex Hebraeis erant. Ergo non propterca fecit, ut illuderet ethnicis. Sin autem Hebraeis illudere voluit, aut stultus, aut imperitus fuit: stultus, si apertum finxit mendacium; imperitus, si non intellexit, de quo haec dicerentur. Stultitiam ipsum volumen excusat, quod prudenter ordinateque compositum est; imperitum non possumus dicere, quem ex aliis testimoniis Scripturarum scientiam legis habuisse cognoscimus. Superest ut illud dicamus, quod ea quae praecedunt in aliis, juxta veritatem et adimpletionem referantur ad Christum: quod Apostolum in duobus montibus Sina et Sion, et in Sara et Agar fecisse cognovimus. Neque enim non est Sina mons, et non est Sion: non fuit Sara, et non fuit Agar; quia haec Apostolus Paulus ad duo retulit Testamenta (Galat. IV).","english":"Julian Augustus, in the seventh volume which he spewed out against us, that is, against the Christians, slanders this passage and says: What was written of Israel, the evangelist Matthew transferred to Christ, so as to mock the simplicity of those who had believed from among the Gentiles. To him we shall briefly respond: first, that Matthew published his Gospel in Hebrew letters, which none could read except those who were of the Hebrews. Therefore he did not do this in order to mock the Gentiles. But if he wished to mock the Hebrews, he was either foolish or ignorant: foolish, if he fabricated an open falsehood; ignorant, if he did not understand of whom these things were spoken. His very volume excuses him from foolishness, since it was composed prudently and in order; and we cannot call him ignorant, whom we know from other testimonies of the Scriptures to have had knowledge of the law. It remains for us to say that the things which precede in others are, according to truth and fulfillment, referred to Christ: which we know the Apostle did in the two mountains Sinai and Sion, and in Sarah and Hagar. For Sinai is not not a mountain, and Sion is not not a mountain; Sarah was not not, and Hagar was not not; because the Apostle Paul referred these to the two Testaments (Gal. 4).","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":208,"ref":"p208","source":"Sic igitur hoc quod scriptum est: Parvulus Israel, et dilexi eum, et ex AEgypto vocavi filium meum, dicitur quidem de populo Israel, qui vocatur ex AEgypto, qui diligitur, qui eo tempore post errorem idololatriae quasi infans et parvulus est vocatus: sed perfecte refertur ad Christum. Nam et Isaac in typo Christi fuit quod futurae mortis ligna sibi ipse portaverit (Gen. XXIII), et Jacob quia Liam dolentem oculos, et Rachel pulchram habuerit uxorem (Gen. XXIX). In Lia quae major erat, caecitatem intelligimus Synagogae: in Rachel pulchritudinem Ecclesiae: et tamen qui ex parte typi fuerunt Domini Salvatoris, non omnia quae fecisse narrantur, in typo ejus fecisse credendi sunt. Typus enim partem indicat: quod si totum praecedat in typo, jam non est typus, sed historiae veritas appellanda est. Haec breviter ut in Commentariis diximus: nunc ad reliqua recurramus.","english":"Thus, then, what is written: Israel is a little child, and I have loved him, and out of Egypt I have called my son, is indeed said of the people of Israel, who are called out of Egypt, who are loved, who at that time after the error of idolatry were called as it were an infant and a little child: but it is perfectly referred to Christ. For both Isaac was a type of Christ in that he himself carried the wood for his coming death (Gen. 22), and Jacob because he had as wife Leah, who had sore eyes, and Rachel, who was beautiful (Gen. 29). In Leah, who was the elder, we understand the blindness of the Synagogue; in Rachel, the beauty of the Church: and yet those who were in part types of the Lord Savior are not to be believed to have done in type of him everything that is narrated of them. For a type indicates a part: but if the whole precedes in a type, it is no longer a type, but must be called the truth of history. These things we have said briefly, as in a Commentary: now let us return to the rest.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":209,"ref":"p209","source":"(Vers. 3, 4.) « Et ego quasi nutritius Ephraim, portabam eos in brachiis meis, et nescierunt quod curarem eos. In funiculis Adam traham eos, in vinculis charitatis. Et ero eis quasi exaltans jugum super maxillas eorum, et declinavi ad cum ut vesceretur. » LXX: « Et ego colligavi Ephraim, suscepi eum super brachium meum; et non cognoverunt ut sanarem illos in corruptione hominum: extendi eos in vinculis charitatis meae. Et ero illis, quasi dans alapas homo super maxillas ejus: et respiciam ad eum praevalens ei. » Multum inter se Hebraicum et Septuaginta interpretum editio dissonant. Tentemus igitur juxta Hebraeos historiam; juxta LXX, texere. Qui supra dixerat: Puer Israel et dilexi eum, et ex AEgypto vocavi filium meum; et postea intulit quod perpetraverit nefas, Baalim immolabant, et simulacris sacrificabant, nunc narrat quo Israel amore dilexerit, secundum illud quod in Deuteronomio legitur: Portavit te Dominus tuus, ut solet homo gestare parvulum filium suum, in omni via, per quam ambulasti, donec venires ad locum istum (Deut. I, 31). Et in alio loco: Expandit alas suas et assumpsit eum, atque portavit in humeris suis (Deut. XXXII, 11). Ego, inquit, qui pater eram, nutritius factus sum, et parvulum meum in ulnis meis ipse portabam, ne laederetur in solitudine, et ne vel aestu vel tenebris terreretur, in die nubes eram, in nocte ignis columna (Exod.","english":"(Verses 3, 4.) “And I was like a foster father to Ephraim, carrying them in my arms, and they did not know that I was caring for them. In the cords of Adam I will draw them, in the bonds of love. And I will be to them like one lifting a yoke from their jaws, and I bent down to him so that he might eat.” The Septuagint: “And I bound Ephraim, I took him up on my arm; and they did not know that I would heal them in the corruption of men: I stretched them out in the bonds of my love. And I will be to them like a man giving blows on his jaw: and I will look upon him, prevailing over him.” The Hebrew and the edition of the Seventy interpreters differ greatly from each other. Let us therefore attempt to weave the history according to the Hebrews; according to the Septuagint. He who had said above: Israel is a child and I loved him, and out of Egypt I called my son; and afterward added what wickedness they committed, they sacrificed to the Baals, and offered sacrifice to idols, now declares with what love he loved Israel, according to what is read in Deuteronomy: Your Lord carried you, as a man is accustomed to carry his little son, on every road by which you walked, until you came to this place (Deut. 1:31). And in another place: He spread out his wings and took him up, and carried him on his shoulders (Deut. 32:11). I, he says, who was a father, became a foster father, and I myself carried my little one in my arms, lest he be harmed in the wilderness, and lest he be terrified either by heat or by darkness; in the day I was a cloud, in the night a pillar of fire (Exod.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":210,"ref":"p210","source":"XIII): ut quos protexeram, meo illustrarem et sanarem lumine, cumque peccassent, et fecissent sibi vituli caput, dedi locum poenitentiae, et ignoraverunt quod curarem eos, vulnus idololatriae quadraginta annorum spatio obducerem, et pristinae redderem sanitati. Curavi autem eos propter funiculos et vincula charitatis, quibus mihi Abraham, Isaac et Jacob astrinxeram. Pro Adam enim Aquila et Symmachus et Septuaginta et Theodotio, homines transtulerunt; ut dicerent: In funiculis hominum traham eos, in vinculis charitatis. Quodque sequitur: Ero eis quasi exaltans jugum, pro quo interpretatus est Symmachus: Et putaverunt quod imponerem jugum super maxillam eorum, dupliciter accipitur: aut abstuli ab eis jugum cunctarum per circuitum nationum: ant legem meam quasi gravissimum jugi pondus arbitrati sunt. Et dedi eis escam manna in deserto (Exod. XVI), quo vescerentur; hoc est enim, quod ait, declinavi ad eum, ut vesceretur: pro quo interpretatus est Symmachus, et declinavi ad eum cibos. Non quod Deus ad cum declinaverit, sed quod cibum mannae ad eum fecerit declinare. Aliter: In tantum dilexi eos, et tam clemens pas or fui, ut morbidam ovem humeris meis ipse portarem (Luc.","english":"so that those whom I had protected I might enlighten and heal with my light; and when they had sinned and made for themselves the head of a calf, I gave them room for repentance, and they did not know that I was caring for them, that I was covering over the wound of idolatry in the span of forty years and restoring them to their former health. But I cared for them because of the cords and bonds of love, by which I had bound Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob to myself. For in place of Adam, Aquila and Symmachus and the Seventy and Theodotion translated “men,” so as to say: “In the cords of men I will draw them, in the bonds of love.” And what follows: “I will be to them like one lifting up the yoke,” for which Symmachus rendered: “And they thought that I was placing a yoke upon their jaw,” is understood in two ways: either I took away from them the yoke of all the nations round about, or they considered my law to be like the heaviest weight of a yoke. And I gave them manna for food in the desert, with which they might eat; for this is what he says: “I inclined to him, that he might eat,” for which Symmachus rendered: “And I inclined foods to him.” Not that God inclined to him, but that he made the food of manna incline to him. Otherwise: I so loved them, and was so merciful a father, that I myself carried the sick sheep on my shoulders.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":211,"ref":"p211","source":"XV): ipsi vero ignoraverunt quod mea illos passione curarem: et qui amator sum omnium hominum, traherem cos ad credendum in vinculis charitatis, juxta illud quod in Evangelio scriptum est: Nemo venit ad me, nisi Pater qui misit me traxerit eum (Joan. VI, 44). Et arbitrati sunt jugum meum leve, esse gravissimum: et declinavi ad eos deserens regna coelorum, ut cum eis vescerer 2, assumpta forma hominis, sive dedi eis esum corporis mei: ipse et cibus et conviva. Transeamus ad intelligentiam spiritualem, juxta Septuaginta duntaxat interpretes: ne si utrumque et secundum historiam, et secundum voluerimus exponere, tendamus libri magnitudinem. Illis immolantibus Baalim quae de suo corde finxerunt, et me vocante, fugientibus a facie mea (ita enim in Septuaginta continetur), ego clementissimus Dominus ligabam pedes Ephraim, ne a me longius fugerent: hoc enim significat. Ligabam autem testimoniis Scripturarum, et disputatione magistrorum Ecclesiae, ut ligatos per patientiam suis brachiis contineret, non intelligentes quod patientia Dei salutis eorum esset occasio. Unde in corruptione hominum, videlicet magistrorum, qui eos deceperant contractos perfidiae frigore, extendi calorem fidei, et quasi repugnantes vinculis meae dilectionis astrinxi.","english":"They themselves, however, did not know that I was healing them by my passion; and I, who am the lover of all men, was drawing them to believe in the bonds of love, according to what is written in the Gospel: No one comes to me unless the Father who sent me draws him (John 6:44). And they thought my yoke, which is light, to be most heavy; and I stooped down to them, forsaking the kingdoms of heaven, so that I might eat with them, having taken the form of a man, or rather I gave them my body to eat: himself both the food and the guest. Let us pass on to the spiritual understanding, following only the Seventy interpreters, lest, if we wish to expound both according to history and according to allegory, we stretch out the length of the book. While they were sacrificing to the Baalim which they fashioned from their own heart, and while I was calling, they were fleeing from my face (for so it is contained in the Septuagint), I, the most merciful Lord, was binding the feet of Ephraim, lest they flee farther from me: for this is what it means. I was binding them, moreover, by the testimonies of the Scriptures and by the disputation of the teachers of the Church, so that, bound, he might hold them in his arms through patience, they not understanding that the patience of God was the occasion of their salvation. Hence, in the corruption of men—that is, of the teachers who had deceived them—contracted by the cold of faithlessness, I extended the warmth of faith, and as it were bound them, resisting, with the chains of my love.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":212,"ref":"p212","source":"Et quia non sua sponte currebant, sed vincti funibus trahebantur, paululum maxillas eorum alapis verberavi, non puniens, sed corrigens et emendans. Judex lacerat carnes, torquet funiculis, flagellis atque ignibus cruciat. Qui autem pater est, lascivientem filium palma percutit manus. Et pulchre non dixit, ero eos alapis verberans, sed quasi homo maxillas manu percutiens. Percutit autem Deus filios aberrantes comminatione poenarum, evangelica lectione, et testimoniis prophetarum. Cumque sic percusserit in maxilla, ut haereticorum panem atque doctrinam excutiat de ore polluto, tunc respicit ad eum, dicente sibi filio verberato. Respice in me, et miserere mei (Psal. LXXXV, 16). Et iterum: Respice et exaudi me, Domine Deus meus (Psal. XII, 4). Cumque eo respexerit, praevalebit, sive proderit eis, Id est, superabit adversarios, et de fugitivis servos faciet Sive dabit eis verum et dulcem cibum, qui prius haereticorum mendacia ct cibos amarissimos devorabant.","english":"And because they were not running of their own accord, but were being dragged bound with ropes, I struck their jaws lightly with blows, not punishing but correcting and amending. A judge lacerates the flesh, tortures with cords, torments with whips and fires. But he who is a father strikes the hand of a wanton son with his palm. And fittingly he did not say, I will be striking them with blows, but as a man striking the jaws with his hand. For God strikes his erring sons with the threat of punishments, with the reading of the Gospel, and with the testimonies of the prophets. And when he has thus struck them on the jaw, so as to knock the bread and doctrine of heretics from their polluted mouth, then he looks upon him, when the son who has been struck says to him: Look upon me, and have mercy on me. And again: Look upon me and hear me, O Lord my God. And when he has looked upon him, he shall prevail, or it shall profit them, that is, he shall overcome their adversaries, and from fugitives he shall make them servants; or he shall give them true and sweet food, who previously were devouring the lies and most bitter foods of heretics.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":213,"ref":"p213","source":"(Vers. 5, et 7.) « Non revertetur in terram AEgypti, et Assur ipse rex ejus, quoniam noluerunt converti. Coepit gladius in civitatibus ejus, et consumet electos ejus, et comedet capita eorum, et populus meus pendebat ad restitum meum. Jugum autem imponetur cis simul, quod non auferetur. » LXX: « Habitabit Ephraim in AEgypto, et Assur ipse rex ejus, quia noluit converti. Et infirmatus est gladius in civitat bus ejus, et requievit in manibus illius, et comedent de cogitationibus suis; et populus ejus suspensus est ex incolatu suo, et Deus super pretiosa ejus irascetur, cl non exaltabit eum. » Quando dicit, non revertetur in terram AEgypti, ostendit quod reverti cupiat, sed ire non possit. Reverti autem cupiebat Israel ab AEgyptiis auxilium efflagitans; sed possessus est ab Assyrio, qui cepit eum, et dominatus est illius jure victoris, et hoc passus est, quia converti noluit, nec agere poenitentiam. Vel certe dicamus, quod reversus sit in terram AEgypti, quando AEgyptios in terra sancta adoravit deos, vel illo sensu accipiendum, quo supra dictum est, AEgyptum invocabant, ad Assyrios abierunt. Coepit itaque gladius in civitatibus ejus, sive irruet, ut interpretatus est Aquila, aut vulnerabit, ut Symmachus transtulit. Et vide quantum sit miseriarum.","english":"(Verses 5 and 7.) \"He shall not return into the land of Egypt, and Assur himself shall be his king, because they refused to be converted. The sword has begun in his cities, and it shall consume his chosen men, and shall devour their heads, and my people hung upon my rope. And a yoke shall be imposed upon them together, which shall not be taken away.\" The Septuagint: \"Ephraim shall dwell in Egypt, and Assur himself shall be his king, because he refused to be converted. And the sword was weakened in his cities, and it rested in his hands, and they shall eat of their own thoughts; and his people is hung from its sojourning, and God shall be angry over his precious things, and he shall not exalt him.\" When he says, \"He shall not return into the land of Egypt,\" he shows that he desires to return, but cannot go. For Israel desired to return, urgently seeking help from the Egyptians; but he was seized by the Assyrian, who captured him and ruled over him by the right of a victor, and he suffered this because he refused to be converted, nor to do penance. Or certainly let us say that he did return into the land of Egypt, when he worshiped the gods of the Egyptians in the holy land, or it must be understood in that sense in which it was said above, they called upon Egypt, they went over to the Assyrians. Thus \"the sword has begun in his cities,\" or \"it shall rush in,\" as Aquila interpreted, or \"it shall wound,\" as Symmachus translated. And see how great are the miseries.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":214,"ref":"p214","source":"ut non agri vel possessiones ac rura vastentur; sed medias civitates hostis introeat, et consumat electos ejus, sive brachia illius, ut interpretatus est Symmachus, quod Hebraice dicitur BADDAU ( ). Cumque consumpserit gladius electos, et principes, sive robur exercitus, et devoraverit vel capita vel consilia eorum, ut non possint aliquod invenire praesidium, tunc plebs miserabilis quae ad me reveni noluit, meum ad se reditum praestolabitur. Et sero aget poenitentiam, hostibus cuncta vastantibus. Itaque quia peccata grandia grandibus sunt punienda suppliciis, imponent eis qui derelicti fuerint de populo (rege eorum ac principibus Assyrio mucrone truncatis) jugum gravissimum servitutis, et imponent pariter quod non auferetur juxta litteram, nisi spiritualiter tollatur in Christo. Juxta Septuaginta habitabit Ephraim in AEgypto, terram sanctam se habere dicens, et Ecclesiam Domini Salvatoris; sed vitiis atque peccatis et perversitate fidei semper in AEgypto commoratus est. Quia igitur habitavit in AEgypto, sensus magnus Assyrius erit rex ejus. noluit enim reverti ad Ecclesiam.","english":"so that fields or possessions and country places may not be laid waste; but the enemy may enter the midst of the cities, and consume its chosen men, or its arms, as Symmachus translated it, which in Hebrew is called BADDAU. And when the sword has consumed the chosen men and the princes, or the strength of the army, and has devoured either their heads or their counsels, so that they cannot find any protection, then the wretched people who refused to return to me will await my return to them. And they will repent too late, while the enemies lay everything waste. Therefore, because great sins must be punished with great torments, those who are left of the people (their king and princes having been cut down by the Assyrian sword) will impose on them the heaviest yoke of slavery, and they will impose equally what will not be taken away according to the letter, unless it is taken away spiritually in Christ. According to the Septuagint, Ephraim will dwell in Egypt, claiming to possess the holy land and the Church of the Lord Savior; but in vices and sins and perversity of faith he has always sojourned in Egypt. Therefore, because he dwelt in Egypt, the great Assyrian meaning will be his king. For he refused to return to the Church.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":215,"ref":"p215","source":"et virtute perdita, id est, Christo, qui est Dei virus et Dei sapientia, semper in languore versatus est, et infirmus fuit, cunctis daemonibus ac perturbationibus subjacens: idcirco gladius, hoc est, scientia spiritualis, vel sermo ecclesiastici viri, vastans atque debellans seni per versabitur in urbibus ejus, quas impie exstruxit contra Dominum, et ipse gladius requiescet in manibus ejus, ut occisus ab alio, alium non possit occidere, nec contra adversarium levare manum. Denique recipient, et vorabunt secundum consilia sua. Infelix autem populus et vulgus indoctum suspirabit antiquam patriam, et captum se esse sentiet, sive pendebit in incolatu suo, nesciens quid agat, et quo vertatur ignorans. Deus vero super pretiosa corum, aurum videlicet et argentum quae acceperant ab eo, de quibus saepe diximus, irascetur, et nequaquam liberabit cum qui suo vitio corruit. Hoc juxta LXX; cumdem autem sensum et Hebraico coaptabimus.","english":"and with virtue lost, that is, with Christ, who is the power of God and the wisdom of God, it has always been in languor and has been weak, subject to all demons and disturbances; therefore the sword, that is, spiritual knowledge, or the speech of an ecclesiastical man, laying waste and fighting, will turn against the old man in his cities, which he impiously built against the Lord, and the sword itself will rest in his hands, so that, killed by another, he cannot kill another, nor raise his hand against an adversary. Finally they will receive and devour according to their own counsels. But the unhappy people and the untaught crowd will sigh for their ancient homeland, and will feel that they have been captured, or will hang in suspense in their sojourning, not knowing what to do, and ignorant of where to turn. But God will be angry over their precious things, namely gold and silver which they had received from him, of which we have often spoken, and he will by no means free the one who has fallen by his own fault. This is according to the Septuagint; but we will fit the same meaning to the Hebrew as well.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":216,"ref":"p216","source":"(Vers. et 9) « Quomodo dabo te. Ephraim, protegam te, Israel? quomodo dabo te sicut Adama, ponam te ut Seboim? Conversum est in me cor meum, pariter conturbata est poenitudo mea. Non faciam furorem irae meae, non convertar, ut disperdam Ephraim, quoniam Deus ego sum et non homo: in medio tui sanctus, et non ingrediar civitatem. » LXX, « Quid faciam tibi, Ephraim, protegam te, Israel? Quid faciam tibi? sicut Adama ponam te, et sicut Seboim: conversum est cor meum in ipso 2, simul conturbata est poenitudo mea. Non faciam juxta iram furoris mei. Non derelinquam ut deleatur Ephraim, quoniam Deus ego sum, et non homo, inte sanctus, et non ingrediar civitatem. » In eo loco ubi nos et LXX interpretati sumus, protegam te, Israel? in Hebraico scriptum est AMAGGENACH ( ), quod Aquila transtulit,, id est scuto circumdabo te. Quod cum in bonam partem putaremus intelligi, et significare protectionem, ex editione Symmachi contrarius nobis sensus subjicitur dicentis,, id est tradam te. Ex translatione quoque Theodotionis non prospera, sed adversa demonstrantur,, quod significat, nudabo te, et auferam a, hoc est, scutum, quo te ante protexeram, et hic sensus magis convenit Domino comminanti.","english":"(Ver. 8 and 9) «How shall I give you up, Ephraim, protect you, Israel? How shall I give you up like Admah, set you like Zeboiim? My heart is turned within me, my repentance is troubled together. I will not do the fury of my wrath, I will not turn to destroy Ephraim, since I am God and not man: the Holy One in your midst, and I will not enter the city.» The Septuagint: «What shall I do to you, Ephraim, protect you, Israel? What shall I do to you? Like Admah I will set you, and like Zeboiim: my heart is turned within him, my repentance is troubled together. I will not do according to the wrath of my fury. I will not forsake so that Ephraim be destroyed, since I am God and not man, the Holy One in your midst, and I will not enter the city.» In that place where we and the Septuagint have translated, protect you, Israel? in Hebrew is written AMAGGENACH, which Aquila translated as, that is, I will surround you with a shield. Since we thought this was to be understood in a good sense, and to signify protection, from the edition of Symmachus the opposite sense is suggested to us, saying, that is, I will hand you over. From the translation of Theodotion also, not prosperous but adverse things are shown, which signifies, I will lay you bare, and I will take away from you, that is, the shield with which I had previously protected you, and this sense fits better with the Lord threatening.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":217,"ref":"p217","source":"Quod igitur dicit, hoc est: quoniam noluerunt converti, et Assur factus est rex eorum, devorabit gladius et urbes et prin cipes et populum, et imponetur eis jugum, quod non auferetur ab eis; et quia videbatur dura sententia, nequaquam eis locum poenitentiae derelinquens, nunc Deus parentis ad Israel loquitur affectu, Quid tibi faciam, Ephraim? quomodo te meo auxilio denudabo? quid tibi faciam? qua te arte corripiam? quo potero sanare medicamine? Sicut Adama et Seboim ponam te, quae duae sunt quinque urbium, sicut in Genesi legimus, Sodoma et Gomorrha, Adama, et Seboim et Bale, quoe est Segor, et Syro sermone Zoara dicitur. Ponam itaque et vertam te in solitudinem, et delebo usque ad cineres ac favillas, sicut delevi Adama et Seboim. Cumque duram, imo crudelem sententiam protulisset, rursum parentis affectu misericordia vincitur, et austeritatem judicii pietate mitigat patris. Dicit enim: Conversum est in me cor meum: pariter conturbata est poenitudo mea. Statim ut loculus sum, me Ephraim et Israel sicut Adama Seboimque positurum, mea commota sunt viscera. Poenituit me meum quondam populum delere in perpetuum: idcirco non faciam secundum furorem iracundiae meae, nec de mea clementia commutabor, ut disperdam Ephraim: non enim percutio ut perdam in perpetuum, sed ut emendem. Crudelitas mea poenitentiae et pietatis occasio est: Deus enim ego sum, et non homo.","english":"What he therefore says is this: because they were unwilling to be converted, and Assur became their king, the sword will devour both their cities and their princes and their people, and a yoke will be placed upon them that will not be taken away from them; and because the sentence seemed harsh, leaving them no place for repentance at all, now God speaks to Israel with the affection of a parent: What shall I do to you, Ephraim? How shall I strip you of my help? What shall I do to you? By what means shall I correct you? With what medicine shall I be able to heal you? I will set you like Adama and Seboim, which are two of the five cities, as we read in Genesis—Sodom and Gomorrah, Adama, and Seboim, and Bale, which is Segor, and in the Syriac tongue is called Zoara. I will therefore set you and turn you into a wilderness, and I will destroy you utterly, down to ashes and embers, as I destroyed Adama and Seboim. And when he had brought forth a harsh, indeed cruel sentence, he is again overcome by mercy with the affection of a parent, and tempers the severity of judgment with a father's tenderness. For he says: My heart is turned within me: my repentance is troubled together. As soon as I spoke that I would set Ephraim and Israel like Adama and Seboim, my inward parts were moved. I repented of having once destroyed my people forever; therefore I will not act according to the fury of my anger, nor will I change from my clemency so as to destroy Ephraim: for I do not strike to destroy forever, but to correct. My cruelty is the occasion of repentance and tenderness: for I am God, and not man.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":218,"ref":"p218","source":"Homo ad hoc punit ut perdat, Deus ad hoc corripit ut emendet. In medio tui sanctus. et non ingrediar civitatem, hoc est, non sum unus de his, qui in urbibus habitant, qui humanis legibus vivunt, qui crudelitatem arbitrantur justitiam, quibus jus summum summa malitia est; mea antem lex meaque justitia est salvare correctos. Possumus et aliter dicere: quia primus Cain parricida exstruxit civitatem in nomine filii sui Enoch, in hujuscemodi urbem Dominus non ingreditur, quae ex scelere et sanguine et parricidio fabricata est. Sin autem voluerimus legere, quomodo dabo te. Ephraim, protegam te, Israel? sic intelligendum est: Quid libi faciam? num protectione dignus es qui lauta fecisti? Notandum quoque quod ubi contra Judam dicitur, id est, populum Dei, non Adama ponitur et Seboim, sed Sodoma et Gomorrha. Legimus enim in Isaia: Audite legem Dei, principes Sodomorum: attendite verbum Domini, populus Gomorrhae (Isa. I, 10). In Evangelio quoque civitas, quae et apostolos non receperit, excutientibus eis pulverem pedum suorum, dicitur de ea, quod in die judicii tolerabilius erit terrae Sodomorum et Gomorrhae, quam civitati ili·(Matth. X). Et ad Jerusalem prophetalis sermo dirigitur: Justi· ficata est Sodoma ex te (Ezech. XVI).","english":"Man punishes for the purpose of destroying, God corrects for the purpose of amending. In the midst of thee is the Holy One, and I will not enter into the city — that is, I am not one of those who dwell in cities, who live by human laws, who consider cruelty to be justice, for whom the highest right is the highest malice; but my law and my justice is to save those who have been corrected. We can also say otherwise: because Cain, the first parricide, built a city in the name of his son Enoch, the Lord does not enter into a city of this kind, which was constructed from crime and blood and parricide. But if we wish to read, How shall I give thee up, Ephraim? shall I protect thee, Israel? it must be understood thus: What shall I do for thee? Are you worthy of protection, you who have done splendid things? It must also be noted that where it is said against Judah, that is, the people of God, Adama and Zeboim are not set down, but Sodom and Gomorrah. For we read in Isaiah: Hear the law of God, ye princes of Sodom: attend to the word of the Lord, ye people of Gomorrah. In the Gospel too, concerning a city that has not received the apostles, when they shake off the dust of their feet, it is said of it that on the day of judgment it will be more tolerable for the land of Sodom and Gomorrah than for that city. And to Jerusalem the prophetic word is directed: Sodom is justified by thee.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":219,"ref":"p219","source":"Datur ergo nobis suspicio, quod Sodoma et Gomorrha principes fuerint in peccato, et Adama et Seboim earum exempta sectatae sint, quod potentes potenter tormenta patiantur (Sap. VI), et servus qui scit voluntatem Domini sui, et non facit eam, vapulet multis (Luc. XII). Unde et ecclesiastici viri, si iisdem quibus haeretici sceleribus continentur, nequaquam Adamae Seboim, quae inferiores sunt; sed Sodomae et Gomorrhae, quae majorum criminum esse dicuntur, cruciatibus subjacebunt. Ad haereticos quoque deceptumque ab eis populum loquitur Dominus, quod nisi egerit poenitentiam, ponantur sicut Adama et Seboim, ut nullam spem habeant salutis. Rursum ut clementissimus pater dicit se suam mutare sententiam, et poenitere quod talia sit locutus, ut illos quoque ad conversionem et ad poenitentiam provocet: Non faciam, inquit, in furore meo, non disperdam Ephraim. Quantum, inquit, in me est, quantum ego cupio, si errorem veritate correxerit, si me magis amaverit quam principes haereseos, Deus enim ego sum, et non homo, lapsis manum porrigam, errantes ad salutem vocabo. Et quia sanctus sum, propterea non ingrediar civitatem, id est, conciliabula et urbes haereticorum.","english":"A suspicion is therefore given to us that Sodom and Gomorrah were the leaders in sin, and that Admah and Zeboiim, taken from them, followed them, because the powerful shall suffer torments powerfully (Wisdom 6), and the servant who knows the will of his lord and does not do it shall be beaten with many stripes (Luke 12). Whence also ecclesiastical men, if they are held by the same crimes as the heretics, will by no means be subject to the torments of Admah and Zeboiim, which are the lesser, but of Sodom and Gomorrah, which are said to be of greater crimes. To the heretics also and to the people deceived by them the Lord speaks, that unless it does penance, they shall be set like Admah and Zeboiim, so that they may have no hope of salvation. Again, as a most merciful father he says that he changes his sentence, and repents that he has spoken such things, so as to provoke them also to conversion and to penance: I will not do it, he says, in my fury, I will not destroy Ephraim. As much, he says, as is in me, as much as I desire, if he corrects his error by the truth, if he loves me more than the leaders of heresy — for I am God, and not man — I will extend my hand to the fallen, I will call the erring to salvation. And because I am holy, therefore I will not enter the city, that is, the assemblies and cities of the heretics.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":220,"ref":"p220","source":"Foras exeuntes de urbibus suis, libenter recipio; in civitates eorum non ingrediar, Hoc quod dixit, non ingrediar civitatem, et juxta LXX sequitur; post Dominum ambulabo, quidam sic interpretati sunt, ut dicerent Domino populum respondisse, et esse sensum: Quia conversum est cor tuum in te, et non secundum peccata nostra fecisti nobis; sed imitaris clementiam tuam, et nostra delicta non punis, et polliceris te sanctum et clementem in nostri medio versaturum; idcirco et ego malorum hominum non ingrediar civitatem, nec ero de numero peccatorum; sed ambulabo post Dominum Deum meum, Hebraei autem ex persona Dei ita edisserunt: Non te derelinquam: non ibo ad aliam gentem: nec ingrediar alteram civitatem.\n\n(Vers. et 11.) « Post Dominum ambulabunt: quasi leo rugiet: quia ipse rugiet: et formidabunt filii maris, et volabunt quasi avis ex AEgypto, et quasi columba de terra Assyriorum: et collocabo eos in domibus suis, dicit Dominus. » LXX: « Post Dominum ambulabo: sicut leo rugiet; quia ipse rugiet, et formidabunt filii aquarum, et volabunt quasi avis ex AEgypto, et quasi columba de terra Assyriorum: et collocabo eos in domibus suis, dicit Dominus. » Domino prospera pollicente, populus convertetur ad eum: et ambulabit post Dominum; quia Dominus rugiet quasi Ico. De quo et Amos propheta commemorat: Dominus de Sion rugiet, et de Jerusalem dabit vocem suam (Amos I, 2).","english":"Going forth from their cities, I gladly receive them; I will not enter their cities. What he said, \"I will not enter the city,\" and according to the Septuagint it follows: \"I will walk after the Lord\" — some have interpreted it thus, saying that the people responded to the Lord, and the sense is: Because your heart has been turned within you, and you have not dealt with us according to our sins; but you imitate your clemency, and you do not punish our offenses, and you promise that you will dwell as holy and merciful in our midst; therefore I also will not enter the city of wicked men, nor will I be among the number of sinners; but I will walk after the Lord my God. The Hebrews, however, expound it from the person of God thus: I will not forsake you; I will not go to another nation; nor will I enter another city.\n\n(Verses 10 and 11.) \"They will walk after the Lord: he will roar like a lion: because he himself will roar: and the sons of the sea will be afraid, and they will fly like a bird from Egypt, and like a dove from the land of the Assyrians: and I will place them in their own houses, says the Lord.\" The Septuagint: \"I will walk after the Lord: he will roar like a lion; because he himself will roar, and the sons of the waters will be afraid, and they will fly like a bird from Egypt, and like a dove from the land of the Assyrians: and I will place them in their own houses, says the Lord.\" With the Lord promising prosperity, the people will be converted to him: and will walk after the Lord; because the Lord will roar like a lion. Of which the prophet Amos also makes mention: The Lord will roar from Zion, and from Jerusalem he will give his voice (Amos 1:2).","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":221,"ref":"p221","source":"Rugiet autem quando dicit: Sicut Adama. ponam te in Seboim 2. Cumque ille rugierit, tunc formidabunt filii maris, sive aquarum, ut LXX transtulerunt. Etenim verbum MAIM ( ), quod per tres litteras scribitur MEM, JOD, MEM: si legatur MAIM, aquas significat: si MEJAM, de mari intelligitur. Haec Hebraei ad adventum Christi referunt, quem sperant esse venturum. Nos jam transacta convincimus; quia et de AEgypto, et de Assyriis, hoc ost ab Oriente et Occidente, et ab Aquilone et a Meridie venerunt, et quotidie veniunt qui discumbant cum Abrabam, Isaac et Jacob (Matth. VIII). Filios autem maris, sive aquarum, eos possumus appellare, qui sagena Domini comprehensi sunt, et abstracti de mari hujus saeculi (Matth. XIII, 47). Cumque capti fuerint de morte ad vitam, collocabuntur in domibus suis: quae horrea vocat Evangelium (Matth. XIII), in quibus electa et a paleis separata frumenta conduntur. Natura leonum esse dicitur, ut cum infremuerint et rugierint, omnia animalia contremiscant, et fixo gradu se movere non possint: tantus pavor est et lania formido. Itaque et Dominus cum instar leonis rugierit et intonuerit, ac dederit vocem suam, cunctae aves et universa volatilia perhorrescent: et ibunt ad nidos, id est, ad domos suas in quibus Dominus habitabit eum eis. Dicamus et aliter; Cum verus leo infremuerit, falsus leo qui est juxta apostolum Petrum, a Iversarius noster (I Petr.","english":"But he will roar when he says: Like Adama I will place you in Seboim. And when he has roared, then the sons of the sea, or of the waters, as the Septuagint translated, will be terrified. For the word MAIM, which is written with three letters, MEM, JOD, MEM: if it is read MAIM, it signifies waters; if MEJAM, it is understood of the sea. The Hebrews refer these things to the coming of Christ, whom they hope is to come. We have proved them already fulfilled; because both from Egypt and from the Assyrians, that is from the East and the West, and from the North and the South, they have come, and daily come, who recline with Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob (Matthew 8). But the sons of the sea, or of the waters, we can call those who have been caught by the Lord's net, and drawn out from the sea of this world (Matthew 13:47). And when they have been captured from death to life, they will be placed in their own houses: which the Gospel calls barns (Matthew 13), in which the chosen grain, separated from the chaff, is stored. It is said to be the nature of lions that when they have roared and roared, all animals tremble, and cannot move a fixed step: so great is the fear and so great the dread. And so when the Lord has roared and thundered like a lion, and given forth his voice, all the birds and every flying creature will shudder: and they will go to their nests, that is, to their own houses in which the Lord will dwell with them. Let us say it also in another way: When the true lion has roared, the false lion, who according to the apostle Peter is our adversary (1 Peter","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":222,"ref":"p222","source":"V), illico conticescet, et urine dogma perversum os suum aperire non poterit: quique ante ab eo capti fuerant, rugitu leonis soluti et comminatione terribili, sequentur Dominum Deum suum. Tunc timebunt filii maris, sive aquarum, qui in amaritudine et salsis baereticorum aquis fuerant procreati; et assumptis pennis, volabunt quasi aves ex AEgypto, et quasi columba Assyriorum, et dicent: Quis dabit mihi pennas sicut columbae, et volabo et requiescam (Psal. LIV, 7)? ut qui apud haereticos laboraverant, requiescant in Ecclesia, et habitent in domibus suis, de quibus fuerant errore seducti. AEgyptum, id est, MESRAIM ( ) tribulationem interpretari, et angustiam novimus: Assyrios quoque, dirigentes, sive, ut melius arbitramur, arguentes. Ab his ergo liberabuntur haeretici, cum habitare coeperint in domibus suis, et malis parentibus dixerint: Relinquetur vobis domus vestra deserta (Matth. XXIII, 38).","english":"he will immediately fall silent, and the perverse dogma of his mouth will not be able to open its mouth; and those who had previously been captured by him, released by the lion's roar and the terrible threat, will follow the Lord their God. Then the sons of the sea, or of the waters, who had been begotten in the bitterness and salt waters of heretics, will be afraid; and having taken up wings, they will fly like birds from Egypt, and like the dove of the Assyrians, and they will say: Who will give me wings like a dove, and I will fly and rest? so that those who had labored among heretics may rest in the Church, and dwell in their own houses, from which they had been led astray by error. We know that Egypt, that is, MESRAIM, is interpreted as tribulation and distress; and the Assyrians likewise as \"directing,\" or, as we consider better, \"accusing.\" From these, therefore, heretics will be freed, when they begin to dwell in their own houses and say to their evil parents: Your house will be left desolate to you.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":223,"ref":"p223","source":"(Vers. 12.) « Circumdedit me in negatione sua Ephraim: et in dolo domus Israel: Judas amem testis descendit cum Deo et cum sanctis fidelis. » LXX: « Circumdedit me in mendacio Ephraim: et in impietate domus Israel et Juda; nunc cognovit cos Deus: et populus sanctus vocabitur Dei. » Tradunt Hebraei hujuscemodi fabulam: In exitu Israel ex AEgypto, quando ex alia parte mons, ex alia Rubrum mare, et ex alia Pharaonis cingebat exercitus, et inclusus populas tenebatur, caeteris tribubus desperantibus salutem, et aut reverti in AEgyptum, aut bellare cupientibus, solus Juda fideliter ingressus est mare, unde et regnum meruit accipere, et hoc esse quod nunc dicatur: Judas testis sermonum Dei, et astipulator ac vindex descendit cum Deo in mare, et inter sanctos fuit fidelissimus, ut verbis jubentis crederet Dei. Hoc illi dicunt. Nos coeptae explanationis sequamur ordinem, quod circumdederit Ephraim regia tribus et domus Israel, populus qui tribui regiae serviebat, et circumdederit eum in negatione sive mendacio, dum Dominum negant, et idola confitentur. Judas autem, hoc est, duae tribus, quae habebant Templum, Legem, Prophetas, et servabant praecepta legalia, erant testes gradientesque cum Deo et cum sanctis fideles. Sanctos possumus dicere, vel angelos, vel patriarchas ac prophetas, et caeteros qui Dei imperio serviebant.","english":"(Verse 12.) \"Ephraim has surrounded me with his denial, and the house of Israel with deceit; but Judah has gone down as a witness with God, and with the saints is faithful.\" The Septuagint: \"Ephraim has surrounded me with falsehood, and the house of Israel with impiety, and Judah; now God has known them, and the people shall be called holy to God.\" The Hebrews hand down a story of this kind: At the departure of Israel from Egypt, when on one side the mountain, on another the Red Sea, and on another Pharaoh's army was enclosing them, and the people were held shut in, while the remaining tribes despaired of safety and wished either to return to Egypt or to fight, Judah alone faithfully entered the sea, and hence also merited to receive the kingdom; and this is what is now said: Judah, a witness of the words of God, and a supporter and avenger, went down with God into the sea, and among the saints was most faithful, so as to believe the words of God who commanded. That is what they say. Let us follow the order of the explanation we have begun: that Ephraim, the royal tribe, and the house of Israel, the people that served the royal tribe, surrounded him, and surrounded him in denial or falsehood, while they deny the Lord and confess idols. But Judah, that is, the two tribes, which had the Temple, the Law, the Prophets, and observed the precepts of the Law, were witnesses and, walking with God, were faithful with the saints. By \"saints\" we can understand either angels, or patriarchs and prophets, and the rest who served the command of God.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":224,"ref":"p224","source":"Ad comparationem enim illius temporis quo haec dicebantur, aberrante penitus Ephraim, et decepto in idolorum cultu Israel, solus Juda remanserat, qui in Dei cultu et testimoniis versaretur, et posset descendere cum eo, sive fortis esse cum forte: RAD ( ) enim et descensionem et fortitudinem significat; pro quo Aquila transtulit 2. Juxta circumdant haeretici Dominum in. mendacio, imo in negatione. Quidquid enim loquuntur, negatio, imo mendacium est: et circumdant eum in dolo, sive in impietate domus Israel; dum universa quae simulant, artifici sermone componunt, et impietatem loquuntur contra Dominum. Judas autem, hoc est, vir ecclesiasticus, non superbit, non inflatur tumore haeretico, sed humiliatur cum Deo, et cum sanctorum choro fidelis est et robustus: dum aedificat domum suam super petram, quae nulla tempestate quatiatur (Matth. VII). LXX multo aliter transtulerunt: quod et Ephraim et domus Israel et Judas circumdederint Deum in mendacio et in impietate, et tantae clementiae sit Deus ut non ab eis abscindat spem salutis; sed cognoscat illos, et paratus sit vocare populum sanctum et populum Dei, qui nunc impietate perversus est. Juxta tropologiam quoque, velle Deum et haereticos salvari, et ecclesiasticos peccatores, et omnes suo vocabulo nuncupari.","english":"For in comparison with that time when these things were being said, when Ephraim had utterly wandered away and Israel had been deceived into the worship of idols, Judah alone remained, who was occupied in the worship and testimonies of God, and could descend with him, or be strong with the strong; for RAD signifies both descent and strength, for which Aquila translated it as 2. According to this, heretics surround the Lord in falsehood, indeed in denial. For whatever they speak is denial, indeed falsehood; and they surround him in deceit, or in the impiety of the house of Israel, while they compose with cunning speech all that they feign, and speak impiety against the Lord. But Judah, that is, the ecclesiastical man, does not pride himself, is not puffed up with heretical swelling, but humbles himself with God, and with the choir of the saints is faithful and strong, while he builds his house upon rock, which is shaken by no storm (Matthew 7). The Septuagint translated it much differently: that both Ephraim and the house of Israel and Judah surrounded God in falsehood and in impiety, and God is of such great clemency that he does not cut off from them the hope of salvation, but acknowledges them, and is prepared to call a holy people and a people of God, which is now perverted by impiety. According to tropology as well, God wills that both heretics and ecclesiastical sinners be saved, and that all be called by his name.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":225,"ref":"p225","source":"Qui autem vere sanctus est, non circumdat Deum in mendacio, sed in veritate, Psalmista dicente: Potent es, Domine: et veritas tua in circuitu tuo (Psal. LXXXVIII, 9).\n\n(Cap. XII.—Vers. 1.) « Ephraim pascit ventum, et sequitur aestum; tota die mendacium et vastitatem multiplicat: et foedus cum Assyriis iniit: et oleum in AEgyptum ferebat. » LXX: « Ephraim autem pessimus spiritus, prosecutus est aestum: tota die inania et vana multiplicavit, et testamentum cum Assyriis pepigit, et oleum in AEgypto mercabatur. » Sacra narrat historia, Manahen regem Israel, pace facta cum Assur, ab AEgyptiis auxilium postulasse (IV Reg. XV), et hoc est quod nunc dicitur, Ephraim pascere ventos, id est, spe vana se decipere, sequique 3, hoc est, aestum, et ire ad Meridiem, nihilque aliud agere tota die nisi sibi illudere. Et dum huc illucque discurrat, vastitatem et eversionem suis urbibus praeparare. Annon est vastitas atque mendacium, pepigisse foedus cum Assyriis, et oleum tulisse in AEgyptum? a parte totum, quod videlicet munera AEgyptiis miserit. Licet quidam arbitrentur quod nequaquam in AEgypto oleum gignitur; sed pretiosissimum missum esse ab Ephraim, cujus terra Samaria olei fertilissima est. Porro secundum tropologiam omnes haeretici pessimo daemonum spiritu continentur, de quo et in Apostolo scriptum est: Adversus spiritualia nequitiae in coelestibus (Ephes. VI, 12).","english":"But he who is truly holy does not surround God with falsehood, but with truth, as the Psalmist says: \"You are powerful, O Lord, and your truth is round about you\" (Ps. 88:9).\n\n(Ch. 12.—Ver. 1.) \"Ephraim feeds on wind, and follows after the east wind; all day long he multiplies falsehood and devastation: and he made a covenant with the Assyrians: and he carried oil into Egypt.\" The Septuagint: \"But Ephraim is a most wicked spirit, he has followed after the east wind: all day long he has multiplied empty and vain things, and he made a covenant with the Assyrians, and he was trading oil in Egypt.\" Sacred history relates that Manahen, king of Israel, after making peace with Assur, sought aid from the Egyptians (4 Kings 15), and this is what is now said, that Ephraim feeds on winds, that is, deceives himself with vain hope, and follows after the east wind, that is, the heat, and goes to the South, and does nothing else all day long but mock himself. And while he runs about hither and thither, he prepares devastation and overthrow for his own cities. Is it not devastation and falsehood to have made a covenant with the Assyrians, and to have carried oil into Egypt? By a part for the whole, namely that he sent gifts to the Egyptians. Although some think that oil is by no means produced in Egypt; but that a most precious oil was sent by Ephraim, whose land of Samaria is most fertile in oil. Furthermore, according to tropology, all heretics are held by the most wicked spirit of demons, of which it is also written in the Apostle: \"Against the spiritual forces of wickedness in the heavenly places\" (Eph. 6:12).","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":226,"ref":"p226","source":"Et immundus spiritus cum exierit ab homine, et requiem non invenerit, septem alios spiritus nequiores se sibi copulat, et ad pristinam revertitur domum (Luc. XI). Spiritu igitur pessimo sequuntur, id est, ariditatem, sive ventum urentem, qui contrarius floribus est, et germinantia cuncta disperdit, tota die inania vacuaque sectatur, nec proprio errore contentus est, sed multos discipulos, imo comites suae vanitatis errorisque multiplicat. Foedus quoque facit cum Assyriis, quorum princeps est sensus magnus, ut quaecunque finxerit, sapienter simulasse videatur, ea sapientia quae destruitur a Deo, quam et Apostolus praecipit declinandam, dicens: Videte, ne quis vos depraedetur per philosophiam et inanem seductionem, secandum traditionem hominum, secundum elementa mundi (Coloss. II, 8). Sed et oleum fert in AEgyptum, sive mercatur AEgypti sapientiam, ecclesiasticis cupiens miscere dogmatibus oleum unctionis, quo ungebantur prophetae ac sacerdotes, quo ungebantur et reges. Hoc oleum habent et sancti, de quibus dicitur: Filii tui sicut novellae olivarum in circuitu mensae tuae (Psal. CXXVII, 3). Et bona oliva in qua oleaster noster insertus est. Quamvis autem conentur haeretici veritati miscere mendacium, oleum aquis et caeteris humentibus atque liquentibus rebus non potest copulari. Semper veritas supra est, deorsumque mendacium.","english":"And when the unclean spirit has gone out from a man and has found no rest, it joins to itself seven other spirits more wicked than itself, and returns to its former house (Luke 11). Therefore they follow a most wicked spirit, that is, dryness, or a burning wind, which is contrary to flowers and destroys all things that sprout, and all day long pursues empty and vain things, and is not content with its own error, but multiplies many disciples, or rather companions, of its vanity and error. It also makes a covenant with the Assyrians, whose prince is the great intellect, so that whatever it has fashioned, it may seem to have wisely feigned, by that wisdom which is destroyed by God, which the Apostle also bids us avoid, saying: See that no one despoils you through philosophy and empty seduction, according to the tradition of men, according to the elements of the world (Col. 2:8). But it also carries oil into Egypt, or trades in the wisdom of Egypt, desiring to mix with ecclesiastical doctrines the oil of anointing, with which prophets and priests were anointed, with which kings also were anointed. This oil the saints also have, of whom it is said: Your sons are like young shoots of olive trees around your table (Ps. 127:3). And the good olive tree into which our wild olive has been grafted. But although heretics strive to mix falsehood with truth, oil cannot be joined to waters and the other moist and liquid things. Truth is always above, and falsehood below.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":227,"ref":"p227","source":"Omnes aliae species, id est haereses, quae non habent, ut diximus, oleum veritatis, possunt sibi misceri, et de pluribus unum effici corpus. Sed harum oleum quod defertur in AEgyptum, et de terra sancta ad Pharaonis regna descendit, detestatur propheta, dicens: Oleum peccatoris non impinguet caput meum (Psal. CXL, 5).\n\n(Vers. 2, et seqq.) « Judicium ergo Domini cum Juda: et visitatio super Jacob: juxta vias ejus, etjuxta adinventiones ejus reddet ei. In utero supplantavit fratrem suum: et in fortitudine sua directus est cum angelo, et invaluit ad angelum, et confortatus est: flevit, et rogavit eum, in Bethel invenit eum, et ibi locutus est nobiscum, et Dominus Deus exercituum, Dominus memoriale ejus, et tu ad Deum tuum converteris: misericordiam et judicium custodi, et spera in Deo tuo semper. » LXX: « Et judicium Domino cum Juda, ut ulciscatur Jacob, juxta vias ejus, et juxta adinventiones ejus reddet ei. In utero supplantavit fratrem suum, et in labore suo praevaluit Deo, et confortatus est cum angelo, et potuit: fleverunt et deprecati sunt me: in domo invenerunt me, et ibi dictum est ad eos: Dominus autem Deus omnipotens erit memoriale ejus, et tu in Deo tuo converteris, misericordiam et judicium custodi: et appropinqua Deo tuo semper.","english":"All other species, that is, heresies, which do not have, as we have said, the oil of truth, can mingle with one another and out of many become one body. But their oil, which is carried down to Egypt and descends from the holy land to the kingdoms of Pharaoh, the prophet detests, saying: The oil of the sinner shall not anoint my head (Ps. 140:5).\n\n(Ver. 2 and following.) «Therefore the Lord has a judgment with Judah: and visitation upon Jacob: according to his ways, and according to his devices, he will render to him. In the womb he supplanted his brother: and in his strength he was directed with the angel, and he prevailed with the angel, and was strengthened: he wept, and entreated him, in Bethel he found him, and there he spoke with us, and the Lord God of hosts, the Lord is his memorial, and thou shalt turn to thy God: keep mercy and judgment, and hope in thy God always.» The Septuagint: «And the Lord has a judgment with Judah, that he may avenge Jacob, according to his ways, and according to his devices he will render to him. In the womb he supplanted his brother, and in his labor he prevailed with God, and was strengthened with the angel, and prevailed: they wept and entreated me: in the house they found me, and there it was said to them: But the Lord God almighty shall be his memorial, and thou shalt turn in thy God, keep mercy and judgment: and draw near to thy God always.»","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":228,"ref":"p228","source":"« Ephraim semel pascente ventos, et sequente mendacium, qui in tantam venit amentiam, ut inter duas gentes adversarias dubius fluctuaret, faciens pacem cum Assyriis, et oleum portans in AEgyptum, nunc mihi omne judicium est cum Juda, et visitatio super Jacob. Visitationem autem vocat flagella atque supplicia, ut qui Ephraim reddidit, quod merebatur, Judae quoque, qui de Jacob ortus est semine, reddat juxta vias et juxta adinventiones suas, qui non tantum fortuito errore deceptus est, et humana concidit fragilitate, sed inquisivit et adinvenit in quibus peccaret et rueret. Exponit autem quanta bona Judas, hoc est, Jacob acceperit, et in patre filius nominatur, veterisque recordatur historiae, ut et Dei misericordia erga Jacob, et illius contra Dominum duritia cognoscatur. Dum adhuc esset in utero Rebeccae, supplantavit fratrem suum Esau (Gen. XXV), non utique fortitudine propria, qui sentire non poterat; sed misericordia Dei, qui cognoscit et diligit eos, quos praedestinavit. Et non solum in utero supplantavit fratrem suum; sed in fortitudine quoque directus est cum angelo, quando ad torrentem Jacob adversum angelum tota nocte pugnavit (Gen. XXXII). Et quia directus est cum angelo, propterea, quod Hebraice dicitur ISAR ( ) hoc est, dirigentis, sive directi, nomen accepit. Et invaluit, inquit, adversum angelum; et ejus benedictione quem vicerat, confortatus est.","english":"Ephraim once feeding on the winds and following a lie, who came to such madness that he wavered uncertain between two hostile nations, making peace with the Assyrians and carrying oil to Egypt, now has every judgment of mine with Judah, and visitation upon Jacob. But he calls visitation scourges and punishments, so that he who rendered to Ephraim what he deserved may also render to Judah, who sprang from the seed of Jacob, according to his ways and according to his own devices, who was not only deceived by chance error and fell by human frailty, but sought out and devised the things in which he might sin and fall. He sets forth, moreover, how many good things Judah, that is, Jacob, received, and in the father the son is named, and he recalls the old history, so that both God's mercy toward Jacob and his hardness against the Lord may be known. While he was still in Rebecca's womb, he supplanted his brother Esau (Gen. 25), not, to be sure, by his own strength, since he could not yet perceive, but by the mercy of God, who knows and loves those whom he predestined. And not only in the womb did he supplant his brother; but in strength he was also made upright with the angel, when at the torrent Jacob wrestled against the angel the whole night through (Gen. 32). And because he was made upright with the angel, therefore, from what in Hebrew is called ISAR, that is, of the one directing or of the one directed, he received the name. And he prevailed, he says, against the angel; and by the blessing of him whom he had conquered, he was strengthened.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":229,"ref":"p229","source":"Flevit quoque, et rogavit eum, id est, angelum dicens: Non te dimittam, nisi mihi benedixeris (Ibid. 26). Cumque patris matrisque consilio in Mesopotamiam fugeret, invenit eumdem angelum in Bethel, qui locutus est ad eum, locutus est nobiscum, id est in patre locutus et filiis est, et in Jacob dilexit et Judam: ex quo tempore usque ad praesens nominis ejus quod illi ab angelo et a Deo impositum est, memoria perseverat. Cum haec se habeant ita, et tu, o Juda, imitare parentem tuum, plora et roga Dominum exercituum, et ad eum convertere. Custodi et misericordiam et judicium, et cum utrumque feceris, spera in Deo tuo semper, bonis operibus ad majora proficiens. Pro eo quod in Hebraico habet, Flevit et rogavit eum: in Bethel invenit eum, et ibi locutus est nobiscum, legimus in editione Vulgata: Fleverunt et rogaverunt me, in domo invenerunt me, et ibi dictum est ad eos; interpretatur dolor. Si quis igitur flet, et agit poenitentiam, et Dominum deprecatur, inveniet eum in dolore cordis sui, et cum eum invocaverit, sibi audiet respondentem.","english":"He wept also and entreated him, that is, the angel, saying: I will not let you go unless you bless me. And when by the counsel of his father and mother he fled into Mesopotamia, he found the same angel in Bethel, who spoke to him, spoke with us, that is, in the father he spoke also to the sons, and in Jacob he loved Judah; from that time until the present the memory of his name, which was imposed on him by the angel and by God, endures. Since these things are so, do you also, O Judah, imitate your forefather, weep and entreat the Lord of hosts, and turn to him. Keep both mercy and judgment, and when you have done both, hope in your God always, advancing to greater things by good works. In place of what the Hebrew has, He wept and entreated him: in Bethel he found him, and there he spoke with us, we read in the Vulgate edition: They wept and entreated me, in the house they found me, and there it was said to them; it is interpreted as grief. If anyone therefore weeps, and does penance, and entreats the Lord, he will find him in the grief of his heart, and when he has called upon him, he will hear him answering him.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":230,"ref":"p230","source":"Possumus Judam ecclesiasticum virum intelligere, qui a Domino corripitur, quod non sit pristinorum in se beneficiorum ejus memor, sed quotidie peccatis peccata consociet, et exponit quae sint ipsa beneficia: Cum te, inquit, nascentem in fide Ecclesia parturiret, supplantasti Judaeum sive gentilem fratrem tuum, et ejus accepisti primogenita, et in fortitudine tua directus es cum angelo, vel vincens adversarias fortitudines, vel roboratus benedictionibus angeli, qui ipse est Deus, et invaluisti per figuram contra angelum, ut invalesceres contra homines, et confortatus es. Cumque esses victoriam consecutus, flevisti, et rogasti angelum Domini, et peccatorum veterum recordatus, invenisti eum in Bethel, hoc est, in domo Dei, quae est Ecclesia, sive in domo, doloris et lacrymarum et poenitentiae. Et ut sciremus quis esset iste Judas, ibi, inquit, locutus est nobiscum, hoc est, nobis Christianis, et ex eo tempore usque in praesentem diem, Christi censemur nomine, et ipso dirigente corrigimur. O itaque, vir ecclesiastice, qui appellaris Judas, et confitens, convertere quotidie per poenitentiam ad Dominum tuum, et si forte peccaveris, imitare prophetam dicentem: Laboravi in gemitu meo, lavabo per singulas noctes lectum meum, lacrymis meis stratum meum rigabo (Psal. VI, 7).","english":"We can understand Judah as an ecclesiastical man, who is rebuked by the Lord because he is not mindful within himself of His former benefits, but daily joins sins to sins, and He sets forth what those benefits are: When, He says, the Church in travail brought you forth as one being born in faith, you supplanted your Jewish or Gentile brother, and you received his firstborn rights, and in your strength you were directed with the angel, either conquering the opposing powers, or strengthened by the blessings of the angel, who is Himself God, and you prevailed in figure against the angel, so that you might prevail against men, and you were strengthened. And when you had obtained victory, you wept and entreated the angel of the Lord, and, mindful of former sins, you found Him in Bethel, that is, in the house of God, which is the Church, or in the house of grief and tears and penitence. And so that we might know who this Judah was, there, He says, He spoke with us, that is, with us Christians, and from that time even to the present day we are reckoned under the name of Christ, and under His direction we are corrected. Therefore, O ecclesiastical man, who are called Judah, and confessing, turn daily through penitence to your Lord, and if perhaps you have sinned, imitate the prophet saying: I have labored in my groaning, I will wash my bed every night, I will water my couch with my tears (Ps. 6:7).","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":231,"ref":"p231","source":"Nec hoc dixisse sufficiat, sed Dei serva mandata, fac in alios misericordiam, ut et ipse misericordiam consequaris. Judicium verum judica, ut in quo judicaveris, judicetur de te. Et spera in Deo tuo semper, sive appropinqua Deo tuo jugiter, ut omni tempore in virtute proficiens, appropinques Deo tuo.\n\n(Vers. 7, 8.) « Chanaan in manu ejus statera dolosa, calumniam dilexit, et dixit Ephraim: Verumtamen dives effectus sum, inveni idolum mihi, omnes labores mei non invenient mihi iniquitatem quam peccavi. » LXX.: « Chanaan in manu ejus statera iniquitatis, opprimere per potentiam dilexit, et dixit Ephraim: Verumtamen dives effectus sum, inveni requiem mihi, omnes labores ejus non invenientur ei, propter iniquitates in quibus peccavit. » Monuerat Judam ut converteretur ad Dominum Deum suum, et misericordiam servaret atque judicium, et speraret in Domino semper, sive appropinquaret ei jugiter. Nunc ad Ephraim, hoc est, ad decem tribus sermo convertitur, quem vocat Chanaan, juxta illud quod loquitur Daniel ad presbyterum, qui utique erat de semine Juda: Semen Chanaan, et non Juda, species decepit te (Dan. XIII, 56). Et in Ezechiel ad Jerusalem dictum legimus: Pater tuus Amorrhaeus, et mater tua Cethaea (Ezech. XVI, 3). Et in Isaia dicitur ad tribum Juda: Audite verbum Domini, principes Sodomorum: percipite auribus legem Domini nostri, populus Gomorrhae (Isa. I, 10).","english":"Nor should it be enough to have said this, but keep God's commandments, show mercy to others, so that you yourself may obtain mercy. Judge true judgment, so that by the judgment with which you judge, you may be judged. And hope in your God always, or draw near to your God continually, so that advancing in virtue at all times, you may draw near to your God.\n\n(Verse 7, 8.) «Chanaan in his hand a deceitful balance, he loved calumny, and Ephraim said: Yet truly I have become rich, I have found an idol for myself, all my labors will not find in me the iniquity that I have sinned.» The Septuagint: «Chanaan in his hand a balance of iniquity, he loved to oppress by power, and Ephraim said: Yet truly I have become rich, I have found rest for myself, all his labors will not be found for him, because of the iniquities in which he sinned.» He had admonished Judah to turn to the Lord his God, and to keep mercy and judgment, and to hope in the Lord always, or to draw near to him continually. Now the discourse is turned to Ephraim, that is, to the ten tribes, whom he calls Chanaan, according to that which Daniel speaks to the elder, who was certainly of the seed of Judah: Seed of Chanaan, and not of Judah, beauty has deceived you (Dan. 13:56). And in Ezekiel we read it said to Jerusalem: Your father was an Amorite, and your mother a Hittite (Ezek. 16:3). And in Isaiah it is said to the tribe of Judah: Hear the word of the Lord, you princes of Sodom: give ear to the law of our God, you people of Gomorrah (Isa. 1:10).","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":232,"ref":"p232","source":"In Zachariae quoque extremo versiculo legimus: Et non erit Chananaeus ultra in domo Domini (Zach. XIV, 21). Dicit autem Chanaan, hoc est, Ephraim, habere in manu sua stateram dolosam, sive iniquam, jubente Scriptura, AEqua sint tibi pondera (Levit. XIX); et non solum habere stateram iniquam ac dolosam, sed dilige calumniam, et opprimere homines per potentiam. Et ne putaremus Chanaan alium quempiam sentiendum, ponit manifestius qui sit iste Chanaan Dixit Ephraim: Verumtamen dives effectus sum; et est sensus: Non referi unde possideam, dummodo possideam. Hoc morbo laborant plurimi, de quibus scriptum est: Divitiae congregatae inique evomentur (Job XX, 15). Redemptio enim animae viri, propriae divitiae (Prov. XIII, 8). Unde praecipitur, ut faciamus nobis amicos de iniquo mammona, qui nos possint recipere in aeterna tabernacula (Luc. XVI). Ephraim autem qui gloriatur et dicit: Verumtamen dives effectus sum; inveni idolum mihi, sive, hoc est, AVEN ( ), quod non prosit possidenti, casso labore sudavit. Sicut autem gulosi et luxuriosi venter deus est. ita et avarus adorat auri idolum, et dicit in corde suo: inveni quod quaerebam: sed audiet: Stulte, hac nocte rapietur anima tua a te: quae autem praeparasti, cujus erunt (Luc. XII, 20)?","english":"In the final verse of Zechariah as well we read: And there will no longer be a Canaanite in the house of the Lord. But he says that Canaan, that is, Ephraim, has in his hand a deceitful scale, or an unjust one, since Scripture commands, Let your weights be equal; and not only has an unjust and deceitful scale, but loves calumny, and oppresses men through power. And lest we think that Canaan should be understood as someone else, he sets forth more clearly who this Canaan is: Ephraim said: Yet I have become rich; and the sense is: It does not matter from where I possess, so long as I possess. Very many labor under this disease, of whom it is written: Wealth gathered unjustly will be vomited up. For the redemption of a man's soul is his own wealth. Whence it is commanded that we make for ourselves friends from the unjust mammon, who can receive us into eternal tabernacles. But Ephraim, who boasts and says: Yet I have become rich; I have found an idol for myself, or, that is, AVEN, which does not profit the one who possesses it, has sweated in vain labor. For just as for the gluttonous and luxurious the belly is their god, so too the covetous man adores the idol of gold, and says in his heart: I have found what I was seeking; but he will hear: Fool, this night your soul will be taken from you: and the things you have prepared, whose will they be?","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":233,"ref":"p233","source":"Cumque semel oculos ejus divitiarum, non dicam fulgor, sed caecitas occuparit, loquitur: Omnes labores mei non invenient iniquitatem meam, in qua peccavi. Et est sensus: quidquid peccavero, si habuero divitias ab his, qui meo indigent auxilio, mihi non poterit imputari, secundum illud quod scriptum est: Et qui iniqua gerit, benedicitur (Psal. IX): divitam enim amici multi. Unde et ad haereticos hoc ipsum refertur. Chanaan quippe interpretari potest, quasi moventes. Et nota quod dixerit, quasi moventes, non moventes. Moventes sunt, eos quos deceperint, quasi moventes, illos quos tentaverint. Sed quia fundati sunt super petram (Matth. VII), nullo possunt turbine concuti, nec pedum suorum mutare vestigium. In istiusmodi Chanaan manu, hoc est, operibus, statera dolosa est et iniqua; quidquid enim haereticus loquitur. Dei justitiam non habet, et plenum est doli et fraudium; unde et calumniam diligunt, dum deprimunt innocentes, sive opprimunt eos per po tentiam. Opprimitur pauper ecclesiasticus verbositate et argutiis haereticorum, qui postquam aliquos deceperint, solent dicere: Divites facti sumus, habemus plurimam multitudinem; discipulorum turba nos sequitur; invenimus idolum vel refrigerium nobis. Idcirco enim vel maxime haereses componuntur, ut devorent domos viduarum, quae semper discunt, et nunquam ad scientiam perveniunt veritatis (II Tim. III).","english":"And once the blindness—I will not say the splendor—of riches has seized his eyes, he says: All my labors will not find my iniquity, in which I have sinned. And the sense is: whatever I have sinned, if I have riches from those who need my help, it cannot be imputed to me, according to what is written: And he who does iniquity is blessed (Psalm 9); for a rich man has many friends. Whence this same thing is also referred to heretics. For Chanaan can be interpreted as \"those who move.\" And note that he said \"as it were moving,\" not \"moving.\" Those who move are those whom they have deceived; as it were moving, those whom they have tempted. But because they are founded upon rock (Matthew 7), they can be shaken by no storm, nor change the trace of their feet. In the hand, that is, in the works, of such a Chanaan there is a deceitful and unjust scale; for whatever a heretic speaks does not have the justice of God, and is full of guile and frauds; whence they also love calumny, while they press down the innocent, or oppress them through power. The poor churchman is oppressed by the wordiness and subtleties of heretics, who after they have deceived some are accustomed to say: We have become rich, we have a very great multitude; a crowd of disciples follows us; we have found an idol or a refreshment for ourselves. For this reason especially are heresies composed, that they may devour the houses of widows, who always learn and never arrive at the knowledge of the truth (2 Timothy 3).","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":234,"ref":"p234","source":"Et pulchre, inveni, ait, idolum mihi. Omnia enim haereticorum figmenta idola sunt et simulacra gentilium: nec multum differunt in impietate, licet in nomine discrepare videantur. Solentque dicere, Quidquid fecero, quidquid egero, mihi non poterit imputari: habeo enim divitias meas, argumenta philosophorum, habeo populi multitudinem, quam qui aspexerit, me peccare non arbitrabitur.\n\n(Vers. et 10.) « Et ego Dominus Deus tuus qui eduxi te de terra AEgypti, adhuc sedere te faciam in tabernaculis sicut in diebus festivitatis, et locutus sum super prophetas, et ego visionem multiplicavi, et in manu prophetarum assimilatus sum. » LXX: « Ego autem Dominus Deus tuus eduxi te de terra AEgypti: adhuc habitare te faciam in tabernaculis, sicut in diebus solemnitatis, et loquar ad prophetas, et ego visiones multiplicavi, et in manibus prophetarum assimilatus sum. » Tu quidem tanta peccasti, ut laetareris in scelere, et multitudinem peccatorum putares esse divitias, et diceres: Dives effectus sum, inveni idolum mihi: omnes labores mei peccata mea invenire non poterunt. Ego autem Dominus Deus tuus qui te eduxi de terra AEgypti, quando serviebas Pharaoni, et aedificabas de luto et paleis civitates (Exod V.): adhuc tribuo tibi locum poenitentiae, et magnitudine promissorum hortor, ut ad me redeas, adhuc enim sedere te faciam in diebus festivitatis.","english":"And well does he say, I have found an idol for myself. For all the figments of heretics are idols and images of the Gentiles; nor do they differ much in impiety, though they seem to differ in name. And they are accustomed to say: Whatever I shall have done, whatever I shall have accomplished, cannot be imputed to me; for I have my riches, the arguments of philosophers; I have a multitude of people, which whoever looks upon will not think that I sin.\n\n(Verses 9 and 10.) \"And I am the Lord your God who brought you out of the land of Egypt; I will yet make you dwell in tabernacles as in the days of a festival, and I have spoken to the prophets, and I have multiplied vision, and I have been likened in the hand of the prophets.\" The Septuagint: \"But I am the Lord your God; I brought you out of the land of Egypt; I will yet make you dwell in tabernacles, as in the days of solemnity, and I will speak to the prophets, and I have multiplied visions, and I have been likened in the hands of the prophets.\" You indeed have sinned so greatly that you rejoiced in wickedness, and thought a multitude of sins to be riches, and said: I have become rich, I have found an idol for myself; all my labors will not be able to find out my sins. But I am the Lord your God who brought you out of the land of Egypt, when you served Pharaoh and built cities of mud and straw (Exodus 5): I still grant you a place of repentance, and by the greatness of my promises I exhort you to return to me, for I will yet make you dwell in the days of a festival.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":235,"ref":"p235","source":"Diem festivitatis, Scenopegiam vocat, septimo mense, quintadecima die mensis, quando de AEgypto egressi sunt filii Israel. Sicut, inquit, in eo tempore te de AEgypto liberavi, et habitasti in tabernaculis ad terram sanctam, et ad locum templi ire festinans: sic etiam nunc educam te de tribulatione et angustiis, et imminente captivitate, si tamen feceris quoe praecepi. Ego enim sura qui per omnes prophetas et varia genera visionum assimilatus sum hominibus et te ad poenitentiam provocavi. An non est humanae similitudinis, quando Moyses in altum extollens manus orat, ut Jesus vincat Amalec (Exod. XVII), et crucis in eo sacramenta monstrentur? Nonne in manibus prophetarum assimilatur Deus, quando Jonas tribus diebus ac noctibus in profundo est, ut Dominum significet die tertia ab inferis resurgentem? Multiplicatas autem visiones in omnibus prophetis legimus, quando Ezechiel Dominum cernit in aurigae modum sedentem super Cherubim (Ezech. X). Et Isaias, Vidi, inquit, Dominum sedentem super thronum excelsum et elevatum, et duo Seraphim in circuitu ejus clamantia ad invicem, Sanctus, sanctus, sanctus Dominus Deus Sabaoth (Isa. VI, 1, 2). Et Abacue stabat in specula sua, ut cornua videret in manibus Salvatoris, in quibus abscondita est fortitudo ejus (Habac. III). Unde et Psalmista conclamat: Audiam quid loquatur in me Dominus Deus (Psal. LXXXIV, 9).","english":"He calls the day of the festival the Scenopegia, in the seventh month, on the fifteenth day of the month, when the children of Israel went out of Egypt. As, he says, at that time I freed you from Egypt, and you dwelt in tents on the way to the holy land, and hastening to go to the place of the temple: so even now I will lead you out of tribulation and straits, and from imminent captivity, if only you do what I have commanded. For I am he who through all the prophets and various kinds of visions was made like men and provoked you to repentance. Is it not of human likeness, when Moses, lifting up his hands on high, prays that Joshua may overcome Amalek (Exod. XVII), and the sacraments of the cross are shown in him? Is not God made like in the hands of the prophets, when Jonah is three days and nights in the deep, to signify the Lord rising from the dead on the third day? But we read of multiplied visions in all the prophets, when Ezekiel beholds the Lord sitting in the manner of a charioteer upon the Cherubim (Ezech. X). And Isaiah says, I saw the Lord sitting upon a throne high and lifted up, and two Seraphim round about him crying to one another, Holy, holy, holy is the Lord God of hosts (Isa. VI, 1, 2). And Habakkuk stood upon his watch, to see the horns in the hands of the Savior, in which his strength is hidden (Habac. III). Whence also the Psalmist cries out: I will hear what the Lord God speaks in me (Psal. LXXXIV, 9).","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":236,"ref":"p236","source":"Ut autem sciamus omnem prophetiam in Scripturis sanctis appellari visionem: Et omnis, inquit, populus videbat vocem Domini (Exod. XX, 18): unde et prophetae ante dicebantur videntes. Ad cos quoque qui ab haereticis seducti sunt, dicitur ut revertantur ad Dominum, qui mavult poenitentiam peccatoris, quam mortem (Ezech. XVIII): ipsum enim esse qui eos eduxerit de terra AEgypti, id est, de tenebris et errore gentilium. Et ne forsitan peccati memores tardius revertantur: adhuc, inquit, sedere vos faciam in tabernaculis, sicut in diebus festivitatis: ut quod facit baptisma, hoc faciat poenitentia, et habitent in tabernaculis Salvatoris, hoc est, in Ecclesiis, de quibus dicitur: Plantati in domo Domini, in atriis domus Dei nostri florebunt (Psal. XCI, 14). Et ne putent haeresiarchas et principes erroris sui, Dei loculos spiritu: Ego sum, inquit, qui locutus sum ad prophetas, et non ad magistros vestros: et ego visiones multiplicavi, et in manu prophetarum meorum qui sunt in Ecclesia constituti, assimilatus sum.","english":"But so that we may know that every prophecy in the Holy Scriptures is called a vision: And all the people, it says, saw the voice of the Lord: whence also the prophets were formerly called seers. To those also who have been seduced by heretics, it is said that they should return to the Lord, who prefers the repentance of a sinner to his death: for it is he himself who led them out of the land of Egypt, that is, out of the darkness and error of the Gentiles. And lest perhaps, mindful of their sin, they return too late: I will yet, he says, make you dwell in tabernacles, as in the days of the festival: so that what baptism does, repentance may do, and they may dwell in the tabernacles of the Savior, that is, in the Churches, of which it is said: Planted in the house of the Lord, they shall flourish in the courts of the house of our God. And lest they think that the heresiarchs and leaders of their error are the treasuries of God in spirit: I am he, he says, who spoke to the prophets, and not to your teachers: and I multiplied visions, and was likened in the hand of my prophets who are established in the Church.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":237,"ref":"p237","source":"(Vers. 11.) « Si Galaad idolum, ergo frustra erant in Galgal bobus immolantes; nam et altaria eorum quasi acervi super sulcos agri. » LXX: « Si non Galaad est, ergo falsi erant in Galgala principes immolantes, et altaria corum quasi testudines super desertum agri. » Pro eo quod nos transtulimus, bobus, qui Hebraice appellantur SURIM ( ), LXX interpretati sunt, principes, qui vocantur SARIM ( ), verbi similitudine atque ambiguitate decepti. Rursum ubi nos posuimus, acervos, qui Hebraice appellantur GALLIM ( ) et proprie significant, hoc est, ex arena tumulos congregatos, qui maxime in deserto, et in littoribus flante vento, vel augentur, vel minuuntur, LXX transtulerunt. testudines ( ): pro quibus Symmachus, acervos lapidum interpretatus est, Theodotio colles. Et revera si respicias, habent similitudinem magnarum testudinum in deserto agro, vel in ripis atque littoribus paululum humo eminentium. Quod ergo dicit, hoc est, Si in Galaad, de qua scriptum est: Galaad civitas operantium idelum, supplantata sanguine, falsi sunt dii et perversa religio, et est trans Jordanem ubi duae tribus habitant, Ruben et Gad, et dimidia tribus Manasse, ergo et Galgal de qua in hoc eodem propheta legimus: Omnis malitia eorum in Galgala, quae est post tergum Bethaven; quicunque idola colunt, non boves diis immolant, sed bobus offerunt sacrificia, imitantes errorem Samariae.","english":"(Verse 11.) \"If Gilead is an idol, therefore they were sacrificing to cattle in Galgal in vain; for even their altars are like heaps upon the furrows of the field.\" The Septuagint: \"If Gilead is not, therefore the princes were false in Galgala, sacrificing, and their altars like tortoises upon the desert of the field.\" For that which we translated as \"to cattle,\" which in Hebrew are called SURIM, the Septuagint rendered as \"princes,\" which are called SARIM, deceived by the similarity and ambiguity of the word. Again, where we placed \"heaps,\" which in Hebrew are called GALLIM and properly signify this, that is, mounds gathered from sand, which especially in the desert and on shores when the wind blows are either increased or diminished, the Septuagint translated as \"tortoises\"; for which Symmachus rendered \"heaps of stones,\" Theodotion \"hills.\" And indeed, if you look, they have a resemblance to great tortoises in a desert field, or on banks and shores slightly raised above the ground. What he says, therefore, is this: If in Gilead, of which it is written: \"Gilead is a city of workers of idol, supplanted with blood,\" the gods are false and the religion perverse, and it is across the Jordan where two tribes dwell, Reuben and Gad, and the half tribe of Manasseh, therefore also Galgal, of which we read in this same prophet: \"All their malice is in Galgala, which is behind Bethaven\"; whoever worships idols does not sacrifice oxen to the gods, but offers sacrifices to cattle, imitating the error of Samaria.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":238,"ref":"p238","source":"Eo enim tempore quo haec prophetabantur, Galaad in regno decem tribuum erat: et Galgal sub imperio duarum tribuum, quae appellabantur Juda. Ergo et decem tribus et duae pari idololatriae errore deceptae sunt, et altaria eorum sicut acervi et tumuli de lapidibus congregati, sive de arenis. Cumque et illi et hi. in captivitatem fuerint abducti, arae quondam eorum absque cultoribus testudinum vel tumulorum habebunt similitudinem. Quia vero Galaad interpretatur, translatio testimonii, et Galgal, volutabrum, hoc dicere possumus, quod principes haereticorum testimonia veritatis transferant in mendacium, et quidquid colunt, idolum sit, et sacrificia eorum habeant similitudinem vel acervorum de lapidibus congregatorum, vel testudinum. Quomodo enim [ ], et acervi hinc atque illinc de lapidibus et sabulo congregantur: ita et haeretici de sapientia saeculari et argutiis hominum, fraude atque mendacio simulacra componunt. Et cum hoc fecerint, tardis gressibus in uno moventur loco, et totum orbem occupare non possunt. Testudo tardigrada et onerata, imo oppressa pondere suo, non tam ambulat quam movetur, haereticorum gravissima peccata significans, qui suis in coeno et volutabro luti erroribus immolant, adorantes opera manuum suarum, et instar boum cuncta pro terrenis frugibus laborantes.","english":"For at the time when these things were being prophesied, Gilead was in the kingdom of the ten tribes, and Galgal under the rule of the two tribes which were called Judah. Therefore both the ten tribes and the two were deceived by an equal error of idolatry, and their altars were like heaps and mounds gathered from stones, or from sand. And when both those and these had been led away into captivity, their altars, once without worshippers, will have the likeness of tortoises or mounds. But since Gilead is interpreted as \"translation of testimony,\" and Galgal as \"rolling-place,\" we can say this: that the leaders of heretics transfer the testimonies of truth into falsehood, and whatever they worship is an idol, and their sacrifices have the likeness either of heaps gathered from stones or of tortoises. For just as [ ], and heaps are gathered on this side and that from stones and sand, so too heretics compose idols from worldly wisdom and the subtleties of men, from fraud and falsehood. And when they have done this, with slow steps they move in one place, and cannot occupy the whole world. The tortoise, slow-paced and burdened, indeed oppressed by its own weight, does not so much walk as move, signifying the very grave sins of heretics, who sacrifice to their errors in the mire and the rolling-place of mud, adoring the works of their own hands, and laboring like oxen for all things for earthly fruits.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[{"kind":"lacuna","severity":"caution","text":"The source is fragmentary here: the edition marks a break or an editorial bracket, and the English carries across it. Treat the bridge as supplied, not translated."}]},{"i":239,"ref":"p239","source":"(Vers. et 13.) « Fugit Jacob in regionem Syriae, et servivit Israel in uxore, et in uxore servavit. In propheta autem eduxit Dominus Israel de AEgypto, et in propheta servatus est. » LXX: « Et recessit Jacob in campum Syriae, et servivit Israel in uxore, et in uxore custodivit, et in propheta eduxit Dominus Israel de AEgypto, et in propheta servatus est. » Videtur absque ratione et ordine prophetali post idolum Galaad et Galgal et altaria acervis lapidum similia, subito historiam Geneseos de Jacob voluisse narrare: quod slatim solvit, qui supra de Jacob legisse se meminit: In utero supplantavit fratrem suum, et in fortitudine sua directus est cum angelo, et invaluit ad angelum, et confortatus est: flevit et rogavit eum; in Bethel invenit eum, et ibi locutus est nobiscum. Iste igitur Jacob non frustra ab angelo confortatus est; sed quia tota nocte pugnavit, et vicit adversarium, ut ex hoc fratrem disceret non timere, cujus metu in Syriam fugeret ad Laban avunculum suum (Gen. XXVII), et servivit in uxore Rachel septem annis, et pro Lia oves soceri Laban, eodem annorum spatio custodivit. Et quia semel Jacob dixerat Israel, patrem filiosque conjungit, et sequentis recordatur historiae, quando in propheta Moyse eduxit Dominus Israel de AEgypto et duodecim tribus, quae generatae sunt de Israel, propheta educente, servatae sunt.","english":"(Verses 12 and 13.) \"Jacob fled into the region of Syria, and Israel served for a wife, and for a wife he kept watch. But by a prophet the Lord brought Israel out of Egypt, and by a prophet he was preserved.\" The Septuagint: \"And Jacob departed into the plain of Syria, and Israel served for a wife, and for a wife he kept watch, and by a prophet the Lord brought Israel out of Egypt, and by a prophet he was preserved.\" It seems without reason and prophetic order that after the idol of Gilead and Galgal and altars like heaps of stones, he should suddenly wish to narrate the history of Genesis concerning Jacob. But he immediately resolves this, who remembers that he read above concerning Jacob: \"In the womb he supplanted his brother, and in his strength he was directed with the angel, and he prevailed with the angel, and was strengthened; he wept and entreated him; in Bethel he found him, and there he spoke with us.\" This Jacob, therefore, was not strengthened by the angel in vain, but because he wrestled all night and conquered his adversary, so that from this he might learn not to fear his brother, for fear of whom he fled into Syria to Laban his uncle (Gen. 27), and served seven years for Rachel as a wife, and for Leah he kept watch over the sheep of his father-in-law Laban for the same span of years. And because Jacob had once been called Israel, he joins the father and the sons, and recalls the following history, when by the prophet Moses the Lord brought Israel out of Egypt, and the twelve tribes, which were begotten from Israel, were preserved by the prophet leading them.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":240,"ref":"p240","source":"Non errabit qui supplantatorem Jacob, et Israel videntem Deum, in typo Domini dixerit praecessisse., et Rachel primum sterilem atque formosam, quam plurimum dilexit Jacob, significare Ecclesiam; Liam autem lippientibus oculis atque fetosam, Synagogae sacramenta monstrare, et quod ipse credentium populum eduxerit de tenebris hujus saeculi, et ad dulcissima Jordanis, id est, baptismi fluenta pervenerit.\n\n(Vers. 14.) « Ad iracundiam me provocavit Ephraim in amaritudinibus suis, et sanguis ejus super cum veniet, et opprobrium illius restituet ei Dominus suus, » LXX similiter 1. Cum ergo Ephraim tanta praestiterim, ut nudum et exulem et solum, divitem dominumque reducerem, et multorum filiorum parentem, deseruit me Ephraim, imo ad iracundiam provocavit; et amaritudine sua amarum fecit esse qui dulcis sum: unde sanguis ejus super eum veniet, id est, ipse erit causa mortis suae, secundum id quod David loquitur ad eum, qui Saulis nuntiavit interitum, et a se regem Israel caesum esse memorabat: Sanguis tuus super caput tuum (II Reg. I, 16). Non mea sententia, sed Saulis sanguine tuus sanguis effundetur. Quodque sequitur: Et opprobrium ejus restituet ei Dominus, illi sensui congruit quem Nathan loquitur ad David: Quia blasphemare fecisti inimicos nomen Domini, propter hanc rem (II Reg.","english":"He will not err who says that Jacob the supplanter, and Israel the one who sees God, prefigured the Lord, and that Rachel, at first barren and beautiful, whom Jacob loved exceedingly, signifies the Church; but Leah, with weak eyes and fruitful, displays the mysteries of the Synagogue, and that he himself led the people of believers out of the darkness of this world, and came to the sweetest waters of the Jordan, that is, the streams of baptism.\n\n(Verse 14.) \"Ephraim provoked me to anger in his bitterness, and his blood shall come upon him, and his Lord shall repay him his reproach,\" the Septuagint similarly. Since therefore I bestowed such great things on Ephraim, that I brought back the naked, exiled, and solitary man as rich and a lord, and the parent of many sons, Ephraim deserted me—nay rather, provoked me to anger; and by his bitterness he made bitter the one who is sweet. Whence his blood shall come upon him, that is, he himself will be the cause of his own death, according to what David says to him who announced Saul's destruction and recalled that the king of Israel had been slain by him: Your blood be upon your head (2 Samuel 1:16). Not by my sentence, but by Saul's blood shall your blood be shed. And what follows: And his Lord shall repay him his reproach, agrees with that sense which Nathan speaks to David: Because you have caused the enemies to blaspheme the name of the Lord, on account of this matter (2 Samuel","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":241,"ref":"p241","source":"XII, 14), hoc est, propter hoc peccatum quo interfecisti Uriam, ipsa blasphemia atque opprobrium, quo per te Dominus blasphematus est, vertetur in caput tuum. Semper haeretici ad iracundiam provocant clementem Dominum, et eum qui mavult poenitentiam peccatoris, quam mortem, duritia cordis sui punire compellunt, et sanguis eorum, quo et suum et multorum effuderunt sanguinem, veniet super caput eorum, et opprobria quibus Dominum blasphemaverunt, restituet eis Dominus suus, non quod eorum Dominus sit, sed quia quondam Dominus eorum fuit.\n\n(Cap. XIII.—Vers. 1, 2.) « Loquente Ephraim horror invasit Israel et deliquit in Baal, et mortuus est, et nunc addiderunt ad peccandum: feceruntque sibi conflatile de argento suo quasi similitudinem idolorum: factura artificum lotum est, his ipsi dicunt: Immolate homines, vitulos adorantes. » LXX: « Juxta verbum Ephraim justificationes accepit ipse in Israel, et posuit ad (Al. absque ad) Baal, et mortuus est, et nunc apposuit ut peccaret, et fecerunt sibi conflatile ex auro et argento suo, secundum imaginem idolorum, opera artificum completa; his ipsi dicunt. Immolate homines, vituli enim defecerunt. » Pro eo quod LXX interpretati sunt, immolate homines, vituli enim.","english":"For this sin by which you killed Uriah, the blasphemy itself and the reproach by which the Lord was blasphemed through you will be turned back upon your own head. Heretics always provoke the merciful Lord to anger, and by the hardness of their heart they compel him who prefers the repentance of a sinner to his death to punish them; and their blood, which they have shed both their own and that of many, will come upon their own head, and the reproaches with which they blasphemed the Lord, their own Lord will repay to them—not that he is their Lord, but because he once was their Lord.\n\n(Cap. 13.—Vers. 1, 2.) When Ephraim spoke, horror seized Israel, and he sinned in Baal and died, and now they have added to their sinning: they made for themselves a molten image from their silver, like the likeness of idols: the work of craftsmen is wholly consumed; to these they themselves say: Sacrifice men, worshiping calves. The Septuagint: According to the word of Ephraim he received justifications, he himself in Israel, and he set it beside Baal, and he died, and now he has added to sin, and they made for themselves a molten image from their gold and silver, according to the image of idols, the works of craftsmen complete; to these they themselves say: Sacrifice men, for the calves have failed. In place of what the Septuagint translated, Sacrifice men, for the calves.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":242,"ref":"p242","source":"defecerunt; et nos vertimus, immolate homines, vitulos adorantes, Symmachus interpretatus est immolate, homines vitulos adorent; ut sit sensus; Immolate, hoc est, sacrificate idolis, et hucusque distinctio sequatur: rationale animal, homines, adorent vitulos, mula animantia. Loquente ergo Ephraim, id est, Jeroboam filio Nabath de tribu Ephraim, horror invasit Israel, id est, decem tribus. Pro horrore qui Hebraice dicitur RATHATH ( ), quem Symmachus et Theodotio tremorem interpretati sunt; nescio quid volentes,, id est, justificationes, LXX transtulerunt. Et tantus Israelem horror invasit, ut delinqueret et offenderet Deum in Baal et moreretur perdens eum qui dicit: Ege sum vita (Joan. XIV, 6). Anima enim quae peccaverit, ipsa morietur (Ezech. XVIII). Et Apostolus: Vidua, inquit, quae in deliciis est, vivens mortua est(I Tim. V, 6). Et non solum mortuus est in Baal, sed addidit peccata peccatis, ut ex argento quod Dominus dederat, idola fabricaretur, opera manuum hominum. Quibus ipsi dicunt, id est, sacerdotes et principes qui populum bona docere debuerant: Immolate homines, vitulos adorantes: quod quidem et in Psalmis dicitur: Immolaverunt filios suos, et filias suas daemoniis (Psal. CV, 37). Pro eo quod juxta Symmachum et Theodotionem vertimus, adorantes, Aquila interpretatus est, id est deosculantes.","english":"they failed; and we have translated, \"Sacrifice men, worshipping calves,\" while Symmachus rendered it, \"Sacrifice, let men worship calves\"; so that the sense is: Sacrifice, that is, offer sacrifice to idols, and let the distinction follow thus far: a rational animal, men, let them worship calves, brute animals. Therefore, when Ephraim spoke, that is, Jeroboam son of Nabath of the tribe of Ephraim, horror seized Israel, that is, the ten tribes. For \"horror,\" which in Hebrew is called RATHATH, and which Symmachus and Theodotion translated as \"trembling,\" the Septuagint rendered as \"I know not what they will,\" that is, \"justifications.\" And so great a horror seized Israel that it sinned and offended God in Baal and died, destroying him who says: \"I am the life\" (John 14:6). For the soul that has sinned, it shall die (Ezekiel 18). And the Apostle says: \"The widow who lives in pleasures is dead while she lives\" (1 Timothy 5:6). And it did not only die in Baal, but it added sins to sins, so that from the silver which the Lord had given, it fashioned idols, the works of men's hands. To these they themselves say, that is, the priests and princes who ought to have taught the people good things: \"Sacrifice men, worshipping calves\"—which indeed is also said in the Psalms: \"They sacrificed their sons and their daughters to demons\" (Psalm 105:37). For what we translated, following Symmachus and Theodotion, as \"worshipping,\" Aquila rendered as \"kissing.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":243,"ref":"p243","source":"Qui enim adorant, solent deosculari manum suam: quod Job fecisse se negat, dicens: Si osculatus sum manum meam apponens ori meo, et hoc mihi ad iniquitatem maximam reputetur (Job XXXI, 27, 28). Sin autem, ut quidam volunt, daemones loquuntur ad populum: Immolate homines, vituli enim defecerunt, ostenditur ingluvies eorum qui sanguine victimarum aluntur, et holocaustorum fumo: quod deficientibus hostiis, homines sibi cupiant immolari, quorum non solum interitu, sed et cruore laetantur. Loquentibus autem haereticis, imo principibus haereticorum, id est, Ephraim, horror et tremor invasit infelicem populum; et deliquit in idol, quae de suo corde confinxit, et mortuus est cum populo quem seduxit. Et non sufficit corruisse, nisi linguam quam ad canendum Deum acceperat, vertat in imagines idolorum, et artifici eloquio simile veritati dogma componat, quod nihil est aliud, nisi excogitatio pravitatis humanae. Praecipiuntque discipulis suis, ut et ipsi immolent homines, hoc est, furentur de Ecclesia Dei, et introducant ad haereticos, et occidant quos deceperint. Quodque sequitur, Vituli enim defecerant, hunc habet sensum; Nolite quaerere quos seducatis de gentibus, qui vocantur bruta animalia; sed cos rapite, eos immolate, qui in Ecclesia constituti, Christi censentur nomine, et homines appel· lantur","english":"For those who adore are accustomed to kiss their own hand, which Job denies that he did, saying: If I have kissed my hand, putting it to my mouth, and let this be reckoned to me as the greatest iniquity. But if, as some hold, the demons speak to the people: Sacrifice men, for the calves have failed, the gluttony of those who feed on the blood of victims and the smoke of burnt offerings is shown: that, when the sacrifices fail, they desire men to be sacrificed to them, taking delight not only in their destruction but also in their blood. But when the heretics speak, or rather the leaders of the heretics, that is, Ephraim, horror and trembling seized the wretched people; and it sinned against the idol which it fashioned from its own heart, and it died with the people whom it seduced. And it is not enough to have fallen, unless it turns the tongue which it had received to sing to God into images of idols, and by cunning eloquence composes a doctrine resembling the truth, which is nothing other than the devising of human depravity. And they command their disciples that they too should sacrifice men, that is, steal from the Church of God, and lead them over to the heretics, and kill those whom they have deceived. And what follows, For the calves had failed, has this sense: Do not seek whom you may seduce from the nations, who are called brute animals; but seize these, sacrifice these, who, established in the Church, are reckoned under the name of Christ, and are called men","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":244,"ref":"p244","source":"(Vers. 3.) « Idcirco erunt quasi nubes matutina, et sicut ros matutinus pertransiens (Vulg. praeteriens], sicut pulvis turbine raptus ex area, et sicut fumus de fumario. » LXX similiter: hoc solum quod in ultimo est immutantes: Et sicut vapor de locustis, sive de lacrymis, quia in plerisque codicibus, in aliis positum reperimus. Quia, inquit, homines pro vitulis immolaverunt, et adoraverunt vitulos: idcirco erunt quasi nubes matutina, et sicut ros mane pertransiens, sicut pulvis turbine raptus ex area, et sicut fumus de fumario. Quae omnia videntur ad tempus, et subito dilabuntur, juxta illud quod dixerat: Transire fecit Samaria regem suum quasi spumam super faciem aquae. Et iterum: Sicut mane transit, pertransit rex Israel. Et nubem quidem aut rorem transire velociter, et pulverem ex area, et fumum de fumario, nemo ambigit, juxta illud quod scriptum est: Sicut deficit fumus, deficiant (Psal. LXVII, 3). Quaerimus autem quare LXX pro fumario, quod Theodotio transtulit (editi legunt ), locustas interpretati sunt? Apud Hebraeos locusta et fumarium, iisdem scribitur litteris ALEPH, RES, BETH, HE. Quod si legatur ARBE ( ), locusta dicitur; si OROBRA, fumarium: pro quo Aquila, Symmachus foramen interpretati sunt. Cataractam autem proprie vocat foramen in pariete fabricatum, per quod fumus egreditur.","english":"(Verse 3.) \"Therefore they shall be like a morning cloud, and like the morning dew that passes away, like dust caught up by a whirlwind from the threshing floor, and like smoke from a chimney.\" The Septuagint similarly, changing only that which is at the end: \"And like vapor from locusts,\" or \"from tears,\" because in most codices we find it set down in some, in others differently. Because, he says, men sacrificed for calves and adored calves, therefore they shall be like a morning cloud, and like the dew of morning that passes away, like dust caught up by a whirlwind from the threshing floor, and like smoke from a chimney. All these things appear for a time and suddenly slip away, according to that which he had said: He has made Samaria's king pass away like foam upon the face of the water. And again: As the morning passes, the king of Israel passes away. And that a cloud or dew passes quickly, and dust from the threshing floor, and smoke from a chimney, no one doubts, according to that which is written: As smoke fails, let them fail. But we ask why the Septuagint, for \"chimney,\" which Theodotion translated (the editions read ), interpreted as \"locusts\"? Among the Hebrews, \"locust\" and \"chimney\" are written with the same letters: ALEPH, RES, BETH, HE. For if it is read ARBE, it means \"locust\"; if OROBRA, \"chimney,\" for which Aquila and Symmachus translated \"opening.\" But properly he calls a \"cataract\" the opening made in a wall, through which smoke goes out.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":245,"ref":"p245","source":"Si quis autem contentiosus et nolens recipere Hebraicam veritatem, locustae sensum quaesierit, audiat Ephraim, id est, vapori sive aurae et spiritui comparari: qui ita tenuis de ore locustae egreditur, ut non sentiatur; quod si e contrario objecerit, quare non aliis, quae minora sunt, periturum Ephraim assimilaverit: verbi gratia pulici, qui omnia membra habet, caput, oculos, pedes, ventrem, et caetera: quae licet oculis non videamus, tamen sensu intelligimus; intantum ut os pulicis ac dentes non videntes oculis, morsibus sentiamus: respondendum est ei, quod ideo vapori locustae, sive aurae tenuissimae, periturorum gloria comparata sit: quia locusta noxia est, et sic inimica mortalibus, ut famem faciat, et segetum culta populetur: intantum ut arbores quoque et vineas decorticet: quod plenius in Joel propheta legimus (Joel. I et II). Et huic locustae et nubi matutinae et rori et pulveri haeretici comparantur, de quibus et in Epistola Catholica dicitur: Hi sunt nubes sine aquis (Judae 12). Habent enim speciem prophetarum, et nubium apostolicarum, ad quas Dei veritas pervenit: sed non habent aquas, id est, gratiam Spiritus sancti, dicente Domino in Evangelio: Qui credit in me (sicut dicit Scriptura), flumina de ventre ejus fluent aquae vivae. Hoc au· tem, inquit, dixit de spiritu quem accepturi erant credentes in eum (Joan. VII, 38, 39).","english":"If anyone, however, is contentious and unwilling to accept the Hebrew truth, and seeks the meaning of the locust, let him hear that Ephraim is compared to a vapor or a breeze and a breath: which issues so faintly from the mouth of the locust that it is not perceived. But if, on the contrary, he objects, why did he not liken perishing Ephraim to other things that are smaller: for example, to a flea, which has all its members—head, eyes, feet, belly, and the rest—which, although we do not see them with our eyes, we nevertheless understand by sense, to such an extent that, not seeing the mouth and teeth of a flea with our eyes, we feel them by their bites: it must be answered that the glory of those who are to perish was for this reason compared to the vapor of a locust, or to a most tenuous breeze: because the locust is harmful, and so hostile to mortals that it causes famine and lays waste the cultivated fields of grain, to such an extent that it even strips the bark from trees and vines, as we read more fully in the prophet Joel (Joel 1 and 2). And to this locust, and to the morning cloud, and to the dew, and to the dust, heretics are compared, of whom it is also said in the Catholic Epistle: These are clouds without water (Jude 12). For they have the appearance of prophets, and of apostolic clouds, to which the truth of God has come; but they do not have the waters, that is, the grace of the Holy Spirit, the Lord saying in the Gospel: Whoever believes in me (as the Scripture says), from his belly shall flow rivers of living water. This, he says, he spoke of the Spirit whom those who believed in him were to receive (John 7:38-39).","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":246,"ref":"p246","source":"De lacrymis autem, quae sermone Graeco habent aliquam similitudinem locustarum,, manifestus error est, quibusdam pro locustis lacrymas aestimantibus.\n\n(Vers. 4.) « Ego autem Dominus Deus tuus qui eduxi te de terra AEgypti. » Pro quo in LXX legitur: « Ego autem Dominus Deus tuus: firmans coelum, et creans terram: cujus manus creavit omnem militiam coeli, et non ostendi ea libi, ut ambulares post ea. Et ego eduxi te de terra AEgypti. » Quae quoniam et in Hebraico non habentur, et a nullo vertuntur interpretum, in antiqua quoque editione LXX non leguntur, obelo praenotanda sunt: praesertim cum sensus eorum perspicuus sit. Unde ad reliqua transeamus, cum his quae sequuntur jungentes superius capitulum.\n\n(Vers. 5, 6.) « Ego autem Dominus Deus tuus qui eduxi te de terra AEgypti, et Deum absque me nescies: et salvator non est praeter me: ego cognovi te in deserto, in terra solitudinis: juxta pascua sua adimpleti sunt et saturati sunt: et elevaverunt cor suum et obliti sunt mei. » LXX: « Ego autem Dominus Deus tuus, et ego eduxi te de terra AEgypti: et Deum praeter me non cognosces, et salvator non est absque me. Ego pascebam te in solitudine, in terra inhabitabili, secundum pascua sua: et repleti sunt in saturitate, et elevata sunt corda eorum: idcirco obliti sunt mei.","english":"But concerning tears, which in the Greek language have some similarity to locusts, the error is manifest, since certain people reckon tears instead of locusts.\n\n(Verse 4.) «But I am the Lord your God, who brought you out of the land of Egypt.» In place of this, the Septuagint reads: «But I am the Lord your God: establishing heaven and creating the earth, whose hand created all the host of heaven, and I did not show them to you, so that you might walk after them. And I brought you out of the land of Egypt.» Since these things are neither found in the Hebrew, nor translated by any of the interpreters, and are not read in the old edition of the Septuagint either, they must be marked with an obelus, especially since their meaning is clear. Hence let us pass on to the rest, joining the preceding chapter with what follows.\n\n(Verses 5, 6.) «But I am the Lord your God, who brought you out of the land of Egypt, and you shall know no God besides me: and there is no savior apart from me: I knew you in the desert, in a land of solitude: according to their pastures they were filled and satisfied: and they lifted up their heart and forgot me.» The Septuagint: «But I am the Lord your God, and I brought you out of the land of Egypt: and you shall not know a God besides me, and there is no savior apart from me. I fed you in the wilderness, in an uninhabitable land, according to their pastures: and they were filled in their fullness, and their hearts were lifted up: therefore they forgot me.»","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":247,"ref":"p247","source":"» Qui supra dixerat: Fugit Jacob in regionem Syrae: et servivit Israel in uxore, et in uxore servavit; in propheta eduxit Dominus Deus Israel de AEgypto, et in propheta servatus est: etiam nunc quid eis praestiterit, refert: Ego Dominus Deus tuus, qui te eduxi de terra AEgypti, qui tibi mandavi per Moysen: Attende, ne forte comedas et satureris, et obliviscaris Dei tui, qui eduxi te de terra AEgypti: non est enim alius Deus praeter me, et qui possit salvare, nullus est alius. Ego qui conditor omnium sum, cognovi, sive pavi te in deserto et in terra inhabitabili, ubi rerum omnium penuria, ubi nullae aquae: dedi tibi manna de coelo, et aquarum fontes produxi de petra durissima. Qui juxta illud, quod alibi scriptum est: Incrassatus est, impinguatus, dilatatus et recalcitravit dilectus (Deut. XXXII, 15): nunc quoque comederunt et saturati sunt, et elevaverunt cor suum, et obliti sunt ejus, cujus beneficiorum memores esse debebant. Neque enim per tantam eremi vastitatem, ubi non solum fruges et arbores vineaeque, sed nec herba quidem gignitur, et nullae aquae ardorem temperant solis, quadraginta annis poterat Israel ad terram pervenire Jordanis, nisi Dominus omnia praestitisset.","english":"He who had said above: «Jacob fled into the region of Syria, and Israel served for a wife, and for a wife he kept watch; by a prophet the Lord God of Israel brought him out of Egypt, and by a prophet he was preserved» — even now he recounts what he has bestowed upon them: «I am the Lord your God, who brought you out of the land of Egypt, who commanded you through Moses: Take heed, lest perhaps you eat and be filled, and forget your God, who brought you out of the land of Egypt; for there is no other God besides me, and there is no other who can save. I, who am the creator of all things, have known, or rather have fed you in the desert and in an uninhabitable land, where there is a scarcity of all things, where there are no waters: I gave you manna from heaven, and I brought forth fountains of waters from the hardest rock.» These, according to that which is written elsewhere: «The beloved grew fat, grew thick, grew wide, and kicked» — now too they have eaten and been filled, and have lifted up their heart, and have forgotten him, whose benefits they ought to have remembered. For through so great a vastness of wilderness, where not only crops and trees and vineyards, but not even grass is produced, and no waters temper the heat of the sun, Israel could not have reached the land of the Jordan in forty years, unless the Lord had provided all things.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":248,"ref":"p248","source":"Haereticos quoque eduxit Dominus de terra AEgypti, de domo servitutis, et de camino ferreo: qui primo serviebant regi Pharaoni et ducibus ejus: praecepitque eis in Ecclesia, ut alium nescirent Deum, nisi eum qui creator est omnium, et novit salvare quos fecit. Ipse cognovit eos et pavit in terra solitudinis; ita ut possint dicere: Dominus pascit me, et nihil mihi deerit: in loco pascuae ibi me collocavit: super aquam refectionis educavit me (Psal. XXII, 1, 2). Deditque eis angelorum panem manna de coelo, quod in AEgypto nunquam comederant, et aquas de sequenti eos petra. Petra autem, juxta Apostolum, Christus est (I Cor. X): qui comederunt et impleti sunt, et cibos Domini non tulerunt. Quibus idem Apostolus loquitur: Jam saturati estis, et jam divites facti estis: sine nobis regnatis, atque utinam regnetis, ut et nos regnemus vobiscum (I Cor. IV, 8). Comederunt enim in sanctis Scripturis panem qui de coelo descendit, et cum David dixerunt: Incerta et occulta sapientiae tuae manifestasti mihi (Psal. L, 8). Impletique et saturati elevaverunt contra Creatorem cor suum: et alterum sibi finxerunt deum, quidquid biberant et comederant, suis meritis, non Dei misericodiae deputantes. Idcirco obliti sunt Dei, qui praeceperat eis, ut legis verba religarent inter oculos et in manibus, atque in fimbriis palliorum, ne unquam obliviscerentur Dei sui.","english":"The Lord also led the heretics out of the land of Egypt, out of the house of bondage, and out of the iron furnace, who at first served king Pharaoh and his leaders; and he commanded them in the Church that they should know no other God than him who is the creator of all things, and who knows how to save those whom he made. He himself knew them and fed them in the land of the wilderness, so that they could say: The Lord feeds me, and nothing shall be lacking to me; in a place of pasture there he set me; beside the water of refreshment he brought me up. And he gave them the bread of angels, manna from heaven, which they had never eaten in Egypt, and waters from the rock that followed them. But the rock, according to the Apostle, is Christ; those who ate and were filled did not endure the Lord's foods. To these the same Apostle speaks: Already you are filled, already you have become rich; you reign without us, and would that you did reign, so that we too might reign with you. For they ate in the holy Scriptures the bread that came down from heaven, and with David they said: You have made known to me the uncertain and hidden things of your wisdom. And being filled and satisfied, they raised their heart against the Creator, and fashioned for themselves another god, attributing whatever they had drunk and eaten to their own merits, not to God's mercy. Therefore they forgot God, who had commanded them to bind the words of the law between their eyes and on their hands, and on the fringes of their cloaks, lest they should ever forget their God.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":249,"ref":"p249","source":"(Vers. 7, 8.) « Et ego ero eis quasi leaena, sicut pardus in via Assyriorum: occurram eis quasi ursa raptis catulis: et disrumpam interiora jecoris eorum: et consumam eos ibi quasi leo: bestia agri scindet eos. » LXX: « Et ero eis quasi panther, et sicut pardus in via Assyriorum; occurram eis sicut ursa indigens cibo, et disrumpam interiora cordis eorum, et devorabunt eos ibi catuli silvarum, bestiae agri disrumpent eos. » Illi adimpleti sunt et saturati: elevaverunt corda sua, et obliti sunt mei. Ego autem, inquit, ero eis quasi leaena, sive panther, de quo supra plenius diximus: et sicut pardus in via Assyriorum, quando ducentur captivi ab Assyriis: et occurram illis quasi ursa raptis catulis, sive indigens cibo: et disrumpam eorum universa vitalia. Aiunt qui de bestiarum scripsere naturis, inter omnes feras nihil esse ursa saevius cum perdiderit catulos, vel indiguerit cibis; et non solum pantherae, pardi, et ursae ferociam comminatur, sed leonis quoque et omnium bestiarum, quas gignuntur in saltibus: et in haec omnia dicit se esse vertendum, quando ierint ad Assyrios: ne cum ibi dura fuerint perpessi, non potentiae et indignationi Domini, sed hostium fortitudini assignent miserias suas.","english":"And I will be to them like a lioness, like a leopard in the way of the Assyrians: I will meet them like a bear robbed of her cubs: and I will break the inner parts of their liver: and I will consume them there like a lion: the beast of the field shall tear them. The Septuagint: And I will be to them like a panther, and like a leopard in the way of the Assyrians; I will meet them like a bear lacking food, and I will break the inner parts of their heart, and the cubs of the forests shall devour them there, the beasts of the field shall tear them. They were filled and satisfied: they lifted up their hearts, and forgot me. But I, he says, will be to them like a lioness, or a panther, about which we have spoken more fully above: and like a leopard in the way of the Assyrians, when they shall be led captive by the Assyrians: and I will meet them like a bear robbed of her cubs, or lacking food: and I will break all their vital parts. Those who have written about the natures of beasts say that among all wild beasts nothing is more savage than a bear when it has lost its cubs, or lacks food; and he threatens not only the ferocity of the panther, the leopard, and the bear, but also of the lion and of all the beasts that are born in the woodlands: and into all these he says that he will turn himself, when they shall go to the Assyrians: lest, when they have suffered harsh things there, they should attribute their miseries not to the power and indignation of the Lord, but to the strength of their enemies.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":250,"ref":"p250","source":"Simulque consideremus, quod qui in Evangelio credentibus loquitur: Venite ad me omnes qui laboratis et onerati estis, et ego reficiam vos: ju gum enim meum suave est et onus meum leve (Matth. XI, 28, 29), nunc per Prophetam incredulis, et nolentibus agere poenitentiam, panther, pardus, ursa et leo efficitur: non solum Israelitis, quia propter idololatriam in Medorum urbibus sive montibus collocati sunt: sed etiam haereticis; quia propter mentis superbiam, et falsorum dogmatum vanitatem, obliti sunt Dei sui, finxerunt idola 1, et secuti sunt deos alienos.\n\n(Vers. 9, et 11.) « Perditio tua, Israel, tantummodo in me auxilium tuum. Ubi est rex tuus? maxime nunc te salvum faciat in omnibus urbibus tuis; et judices tui, de quibus dixisti: Da mihi regem et principes: dabo tibi regem in furore meo, et auferam in indignatione mea. » LXX: « Corruptioni tuae, Israel, quis auxiliabitur? ubi est rex tuus iste? et salvum te faciat in cunctis urbibus tuis; judicet te de quo dixisti: Da mihi regem et principem, et dedi tibi regem et principem, et dedi libi regem in ira mea, et habui in furore meo. » Pro eo quod LXX interpretati sunt habui, omnes abstuli transtulerunt. Infelix Israel et dignus maledictione perpetua, qui in tantum impietatis descendit profundum, ut solius Dei salvetur misericordia.","english":"At the same time let us consider that he who in the Gospel speaks to believers, Come to me, all you who labor and are burdened, and I will refresh you; for my yoke is sweet and my burden light, now through the Prophet becomes a panther, a leopard, a bear, and a lion to unbelievers and to those unwilling to do penance: not only to the Israelites, because on account of idolatry they were settled in the cities or mountains of the Medes, but also to heretics, because on account of the pride of their mind and the vanity of false doctrines they have forgotten their God, fashioned idols, and followed strange gods.\n\n(Verses 9 and 11.) Your destruction, Israel, only in me is your help. Where is your king? Let him now save you in all your cities; and your judges, of whom you said: Give me a king and princes: I will give you a king in my fury, and I will take him away in my indignation. The Septuagint: To your corruption, Israel, who will help? Where is your king? Let him save you in all your cities; let him judge you, of whom you said: Give me a king and a prince, and I gave you a king and a prince, and I gave you a king in my wrath, and I held him in my fury. In place of what the Septuagint translated as I held, all have rendered I took away. Unhappy Israel and worthy of perpetual malediction, which has descended to such a depth of impiety that it is saved only by the mercy of God alone.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":251,"ref":"p251","source":"Potest autem in Hebraeo et hoc sensu legi: Dispereas, Israel, quia nihil libi reliquum est nisi ut mea solum clementia conserveris. In LXX autem alter est sensus: Corruptioni tuae, Israel, quis auxiliabitur? id est, captivitati tuae et ultimae servituti quis ferre poterit auxilium eorum, quos tibi praesules aestimasti? Ubi est rex tuus, de quo dicebas ad Samuel: Constitue super nos regem, ut judicet nos: sicut et gentes habent caeterae (I Reg. VIII, 5)? Cumque ille contradiceret, respondebas: Nequaquam, sed rex erit nobis, et erimus etiam nos sicut et gemes omnes, et judicabit nos rex noster, et egredictur ante nos, et pugnabit pro nobis. De quo ergo tibi promiseras, quod tua bella bellaret, nunc in necessitate subveniat, et universas urbes tuas liberet de servitute. Ubi sunt judices tui? ubi reges? Tu enim dixisti: Da mihi regem et principes: itaque dedi tibi Saulem regem in furore meo; in tantum ut in diebus messis pluviam demonstrarem contra naturam Judaeae provinciae· Et abstuli, inquit, in indignatione mea regem, videlicet Sedeciam: ut quem cum furore dederam, tollerem cum indignatione. Alii arbitrantur datum in furore regem Jeroboam filium Nabath, et ablatum in indignatione Osee ultimum regem decem tribuum. Hoc quod exposuimus, Dedi tibi regem et abstuli regem in indignatione mea, Hebraei ad futurum tempus referunt.","english":"But in the Hebrew this can also be read in this sense: May you perish, Israel, because nothing is left for you except that you be preserved by my mercy alone. In the Septuagint, however, the sense is different: To your corruption, Israel, who will bring help? that is, to your captivity and final servitude, who will be able to bring help from those whom you esteemed as your leaders? Where is your king, of whom you said to Samuel: Appoint a king over us to judge us, just as the other nations have (1 Samuel 8:5)? And when he objected, you answered: By no means, but a king shall be ours, and we too shall be like all the nations, and our king shall judge us, and shall go out before us, and shall fight for us. Let him therefore, whom you had promised yourself would fight your battles, now come to your aid in your necessity, and free all your cities from servitude. Where are your judges? Where are your kings? For you said: Give me a king and princes: and so I gave you Saul as king in my wrath; to such an extent that in the days of harvest I showed rain contrary to the nature of the province of Judea. And I took away, he says, in my indignation the king, namely Zedekiah: so that whom I had given in wrath, I might take away in indignation. Others think that the king given in wrath was Jeroboam son of Nabath, and the one taken away in indignation was Hoshea, the last king of the ten tribes. This that we have expounded, I gave you a king and I took away a king in my indignation, the Hebrews refer to a future time.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":252,"ref":"p252","source":"Eo, inquit, tempore quo dicebas: Da mihi regem et principes; ego tibi respondebam per Samuelem, quod daturus tibi essem in furore meo, et ablaturus in indignatione mea. Perditus est omnis haereticus et corruptioni traditus; qui enim corrupit templum Dei, corrumpet illum Dominus: et in nullo alio habet auxilium, nisi in sola misericordia Dei, quam poenitudine consequitur. Hujus rex et judices diabolus est et daemones, sive omnes principes dogmatum perversorum, qui eos tempore necessitatis et angustiae liberare non poterunt, qui dati sunt in furore, et auferentur in indignatione: non quod Dominus tales eos voluerit habere reges: alioquin non auferret quos sponte dederat, sed quod dimiserit eos voluntatibus suis: ut comedentes et incrassatis carnibus, nausearent, et evomerent per nares suas, et odisse inciperent eos, quos tanto studio sequebantur.","english":"At that time, he says, when you were saying: Give me a king and princes, I was answering you through Samuel, that I would give them to you in my fury, and take them away in my indignation. Every heretic has been destroyed and handed over to corruption; for whoever has corrupted the temple of God, the Lord will corrupt him; and he has help in nothing else except in the mercy of God alone, which he obtains through repentance. His king and judges are the devil and the demons, or all the leaders of perverse doctrines, who will not be able to free them in the time of necessity and distress, who were given in fury and will be taken away in indignation: not that the Lord willed them to have such kings—otherwise he would not take away those whom he had given willingly—but that he let them go according to their own wills: so that, eating and growing fat on flesh, they might feel nausea and vomit through their nostrils, and begin to hate those whom they had followed with such zeal.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":253,"ref":"p253","source":"(Vers. et 13.) « Colligata est iniquitas Ephraim; absconditum peccatum ejus; dolores parturientis venient ei, ipse filius non sapiens; nunc enim non stabit in contritione filiorum. » LXX: « Congregatio iniquitatis Ephraim: absconditum est peccatum ejus; dolores quasi parturientis venient ei; iste est filius tuus sapiens: quia nunc non sustinebit in contritione filiorum. » Quomodo si ligetur quid in saeculo, conservatur, et non perit ei cui ligatum est: sic omnis iniquitas qua in Deum peccavit Ephraim, colligata est ei, et abscondita quasi in marsupio reservatur. Denique cum dies ultionis advenerit, et extrema captivitas, dolores quasi parturientis venient ei, sive apprehendent illum. Mulier parturiens multo antequam pariat, ex eo tempore quo concupit, scit se esse parituram, et exspectat quotidie extrema tormenta cruciatusque venturos. Ita et Ephraim illius insipiens, de quo supra dixerat: Ephraim columba insipiens, non habens cor in contritione filiorum et populi sui. Cum dies parturitionis et captivitatis advenerit, aut stare aut sufferre non poterit. Pro insipiente filio in LXX per ironiam legitur: Iste filius sapiens, hoc est, quem sapientem putabas, ut e contrario intelligatur insipiens.","english":"(Verses 12 and 13.) \"The iniquity of Ephraim is bound up; his sin is hidden; the pangs of a woman in labor will come upon him; he is an unwise son; for now he will not stand in the breaking of his sons.\" The Septuagint: \"The gathering of the iniquity of Ephraim: his sin is hidden; pangs like those of a woman in labor will come upon him; this is your wise son: because now he will not endure in the breaking of his sons.\" Just as if something is bound in the world, it is preserved, and it does not perish for the one to whom it is bound: so every iniquity by which Ephraim sinned against God is bound up for him, and hidden as if reserved in a purse. Finally, when the day of vengeance comes, and the final captivity, pangs like those of a woman in labor will come upon him, or will seize him. A woman in labor, long before she gives birth, from the time she conceives, knows that she will give birth, and daily expects the final torments and agonies that are to come. So too that unwise Ephraim, of whom he had said above: Ephraim is a foolish dove, not having a heart, in the breaking of his sons and his people. When the day of childbirth and captivity comes, he will be able neither to stand nor to endure. In place of \"unwise son,\" in the Septuagint it is read by way of irony: \"This is your wise son,\" that is, the one you thought wise, so that by contrast he is understood to be unwise.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":254,"ref":"p254","source":"Omnibus autem haereticis iniquitas colligata est, quam in excelso locuti sunt: et absconditum est peccatum eorum, dum se putant venena sui cordis abscondere et habere secreta: quae cum dies parturitionis advenerit, dolore ejulationibusque pandentur. Iste Ephraim filius insipiens est, quia Dei sapientiam dereliquit, de quo in Jeremia scriptum est: Novissimum ejus erit insipiens (Jerem. XVII), et in contritione filiorum suorum quos interfecit, quos jugulavit, Dei iram sustinere non poterit.\n\n(Vers. 14.) « De manu mortis liberabo eos: de morte redimam eos. Ero mors tua, o mors: ero morsus tuus, inferne. Consolatio abscondita est ab oculis meis: quia ipse inter fratres dividet LXX: « De manu inferni liberabo eos, de morte redimam illos: ubi est causa tua, mors? ubi est aculeus tuus, inferne? consolatio abscondita est ab oculis meis: quia ipse inter fratres dividet, » Secundum utramque intelligentiam Ephraim, hoc est, et decem tribuum, et haereticorum, qui sustinere non poterunt in contritione filiorum suorum, cum dolores quasi parturientis advenerint, Dominus pollicetur de manu mortis se eos liberaturum, et de morte redempturum. Manum autem mortis appellat opera quibus interficit, juxta illud quod scriptum est: In manu linguae mors et vita (Prov. XVIII, 21).","english":"But for all heretics their iniquity is bound up, which they have spoken on high; and their sin is hidden, while they think to conceal the poisons of their heart and to keep them secret: when the day of travail comes, these will be laid bare with pain and wailings. That Ephraim is an unwise son, because he has forsaken the wisdom of God, of whom it is written in Jeremiah: His last end shall be unwise (Jeremiah 17), and in the breaking of his sons whom he killed, whom he slaughtered, he will not be able to endure the wrath of God.\n\n(Verse 14.) \"I will deliver them from the hand of death: I will redeem them from death. I will be your death, O death: I will be your sting, O hell. Consolation is hidden from my eyes: because he himself will divide among the brothers.\" The Septuagint: \"I will deliver them from the hand of hell, I will redeem them from death: where is your cause, O death? where is your sting, O hell? Consolation is hidden from my eyes: because he himself will divide among the brothers.\" According to either understanding of Ephraim, that is, both of the ten tribes and of the heretics, who will not be able to endure in the breaking of their sons, when pains like those of a woman in labor come upon them, the Lord promises that he will deliver them from the hand of death and redeem them from death. But he calls the works by which death kills the hand of death, according to that which is written: In the hand of the tongue are death and life (Proverbs 18:21).","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":255,"ref":"p255","source":"Liberavit autem omnes Dominus, et redemit in passione crucis et effusione sanguinis sui, quando anima ejus descendit in infernum, et caro ejus non vidit corruptionem, et ad ipsam mortem atque infernum loculus est: Ero mors tua, o mors. Idcirco enim mortuus sum, ut tu mea morte moriaris. Ero morsus tuus, inferne, qui omnes tuis faucibus devorabas. Vidensque mortis duram necessitatem, et quod nullus sit hominum qui vivat et non videat mortem (Psal. LXXXVIII), clementissimus pater sententiae recordatur antiquae, quia in Adam omnes morimur (I Cor. XV). Sive propheta intelligens fragilitatem suam, et conditionem carnis humanae: Consolatio, ait, abscondita est ab oculis meis, et est sensus: Non valeo consolari, quidquid mente concepero, dolorem meum non potest mitigare, cernentis, charissima inter se nomina morte sejungi: ipse enim infernus inter fratres dividit. Quidquid igitur separat fratres, infernus est appellandus; et maxime mulier meretrix, quae vocans insipientem ad se, dicit in opibus prudentiae: Panes occultos libenter attingite, et aquae furtivae dulcedinem bibite: et nescit insipiens, quoniam terrigenae apud eam pereunt, et in profundum inferni incurrunt. Quidquid enim non licet, magis desideratur, et quod raritate dulce est, assiduitate in amaritudinem vertitur.","english":"But the Lord freed and redeemed all in the passion of the cross and the shedding of his blood, when his soul descended into hell and his flesh did not see corruption, and he spoke to death and hell itself: I will be your death, O death. For I died for this reason, that you might die by my death. I will be your sting, O hell, who were devouring all with your jaws. And seeing the harsh necessity of death, and that there is no man who lives and does not see death (Psalm 88), the most merciful Father remembers the ancient sentence, that in Adam we all die (1 Corinthians 15). Or the prophet, understanding his own frailty and the condition of human flesh: Consolation, he says, is hidden from my eyes, and the sense is: I cannot be consoled; whatever I conceive in my mind cannot mitigate my grief, as I see names most dear to one another separated by death; for hell itself divides brothers. Whatever therefore separates brothers is to be called hell; and especially the harlot woman, who calling the foolish man to herself, says in the riches of her prudence: Touch hidden breads willingly, and drink the sweetness of stolen waters: and the fool does not know that the earth-born perish with her, and rush into the depth of hell. For whatever is not lawful is more desired, and what is sweet in its rarity is turned to bitterness by its constancy.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":256,"ref":"p256","source":"Et mel distillat de labiis mulieris meretricis, quae ad tempus impinguat fauces insipientis, novissime autem amarius felle invenitur, et acutius magis quam gladius utrinque acutus (Prov. V). Quicunque terrigena est, et de coelo non nascitur, interficitur ejus amplexibus, et ligatur institis lectulorum, et insipientiae pedes deducunt eos, qui utuntur ea, cum morte ad inferos. Inter mortem autem et inferos, hoc interest: mors est, qua anima separatur a cor pore; infernus, locus in quo animae recluduntur. sive in refrigerio sive in poenis, pro qualitate meritorum. Hoc diximus, ut ostenderemus, id mortem facere, quod meretricem mulierem. Mors enim dividit fratres, hoc et mulier facit. In fratribus, omnem intellige charitatem, quod et mater dividatur a filia, et pater a filio, et frater a fratre. Quod autem aliud sit mors, et aliud infernus, et Psalmista demonstrat, dicens: Non est in morte qui memor sit tui: in inferno autem quis confitebitur tibi (Psal. VI, 6)? Et in alio loco: Veniat mors super eos, et descendant in infernum viventes (Psal. LIV, 16). Pro eo quod nos interpretati sumus: Ero mors tua, o mors: ero morsus tuus, inferne, LXX transtulerunt: Ubi est causa tua, o mors? ubi est stimulus tuus, inferne? Pro quo Apostolus posuit: Absorpta est mors in contentione: ubi est, mors, contentio tua? Ubi est, mors, aculeus tuus (I Cor. XV, 54, 55)?","english":"And the lips of the harlot woman distill honey, which for a time fattens the jaws of the fool, but in the end is found more bitter than gall, and sharper than a sword sharpened on both sides (Prov. 5). Whoever is earth-born and is not born from heaven is slain by her embraces and bound by the cords of her bed, and the feet of folly lead those who enjoy her down to the underworld with death. But between death and the underworld there is this difference: death is that by which the soul is separated from the body; the underworld is the place in which souls are confined, whether in refreshment or in punishments, according to the quality of their merits. We have said this to show that death does what the harlot woman does. For death divides brothers, and the woman does this too. In brothers, understand all charity, in that both a mother is divided from a daughter, and a father from a son, and a brother from a brother. But that death is one thing and the underworld another, the Psalmist also demonstrates, saying: There is no one in death who remembers you: but in the underworld who will confess to you (Ps. 6:6)? And in another place: Let death come upon them, and let them go down alive into the underworld (Ps. 55:16). In place of what we have translated: I will be your death, O death: I will be your sting, O underworld, the Septuagint rendered: Where is your cause, O death? Where is your sting, O underworld? For which the Apostle put: Death is swallowed up in contention: where is your contention, O death? Where is your sting, O death (1 Cor. 15:54-55)?","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":257,"ref":"p257","source":"Et exponens virtutem testimonii intulit: Aculeus autem mortis peccatum est, virtus vero peccati lex; Deo autem gratias, qui dedit nobis victoriam per Dominum nostrum Jesum Christum (Ibid. 56, 57). Itaque quod ille in resurrectionem interpretatus est Domini, nos aliter interpretari nec possumus, nec audemus. Potest mors et infernus et diabolus accipi, qui Christi morte jugulatus est, de quo et Isaias loquitur: Devoravit mors invalescens (Isa. XXV, 8, sec. LXX). Et postea sequitur: Abstulit Dominus omnem lacrymam ab omni facie. Duos autem fratres inter se morte divisos, juxta historiam illius temporis, quidam Israel et Judam intelligunt: ut quod tunc figurabatur in parte, nunc sentiatur in toto, et cum omni humano genere Israel et Judas liberandus sit et redimendus. In eo loco, in quo LXX transtulerunt. Ubi est causa tua? et nos diximus, ero mors tua: Symmachus interpretatus est, ero plaga tua: quinta","english":"And expounding the power of the testimony, he added: But the sting of death is sin, and the power of sin is the law; but thanks be to God, who has given us the victory through our Lord Jesus Christ (Ibid. 56, 57). Therefore what he interpreted as referring to the resurrection of the Lord, we can neither interpret otherwise nor dare to. Death and hell and the devil can be understood, who was slain by the death of Christ, of whom Isaiah also speaks: Devouring death has prevailed (Isa. 25:8, according to the LXX). And afterward it follows: The Lord has taken away every tear from every face. But the two brothers divided from each other by death, according to the history of that time, some understand as Israel and Judah: so that what was then prefigured in part may now be perceived in whole, and together with all the human race Israel and Judah are to be liberated and redeemed. In that place where the LXX translated, Where is your cause? and we have said, I will be your death: Symmachus translated, I will be your plague: the fifth","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":258,"ref":"p258","source":"editio et Aquila: Ubi sunt sermones tui? quod Hebraice scribitur DABARACH ( ): legentes DABAR, hoc est, verbum pro DEBER, quod interpretatur mors: juxta illud quod in Isaia legimus: Mortem misit Dominus in Jacob, et venit in Israel (Isa. IX, 8), hoc est, deber, pro quo nos interpretati sumus: Verbum misit Dominus in Jacob, et venit in Israel, id esi, dabar. Pro aculeo quoque, quem nos morsum transtulimus, Symmachus, id est occursum, Theodotion et quinta editio, plagam, et conclusionem interpretati sunt.\n\n(Vers. 15.) « Adducet urentem ventum Dominus de deserto ascendentem, et siccabit venas ejus, et desolabit fontem ejus, et ipse diripiet thesaurum omnis vasis desiderabilis. » LXX: « Adducet urentem ventum Dominus de deserto super cos, et siccabit venas ejus, desolabit fontes illius; iste arefaciet terram ejus, et omnia vasa desiderabilia. » Legi in cujusdam Commentariis, ventum urentem quem adducet Dominus de deserto, illum esse qui percusserit domum Job in quatuor angulis et fecerit eam super filios ruere convivantes (Job. I), et unum esse de his ventis, quos in Evangelio legimus flare et venire cum turbine, pluviis atque fluminibus, ut subvertant domum, quae super petram aedificata est, sive super arenas (Matth. VII).","english":"The edition and Aquila: Where are your words? What is written in Hebrew as DABARACH: those reading DABAR, that is, \"word,\" instead of DEBER, which is translated as \"death,\" according to what we read in Isaiah: The Lord sent death into Jacob, and it came into Israel (Isa. 9:8), that is, deber, for which we have translated: The Lord sent his word into Jacob, and it came into Israel, that is, dabar. For \"sting\" also, which we have rendered as \"bite,\" Symmachus translated as \"encounter,\" while Theodotion and the fifth edition translated as \"blow\" and \"conclusion.\"\n\n(Verse 15.) \"The Lord will bring a burning wind rising from the desert, and it will dry up his veins, and lay waste his spring, and it will plunder the treasure of every desirable vessel.\" The Septuagint: \"The Lord will bring a burning wind from the desert upon them, and it will dry up his veins, lay waste his springs; that one will dry up his land, and all desirable vessels.\" I have read in someone's Commentary that the burning wind which the Lord will bring from the desert is the one that struck Job's house at its four corners and made it fall upon his sons as they were feasting (Job 1), and that it is one of those winds which we read in the Gospel blow and come with a whirlwind, rains, and floods, to overthrow the house that is built upon rock, or upon sand (Matt. 7).","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":259,"ref":"p259","source":"Quod nequaquam mihi videtur: neque enim in Job scriptum est, quod ventum de deserto Dominus adduxerit; sed nomen Domini tacitum est, ut ventus de solitudine, qui contra sanctum virum sua venerat voluntate, contraria possit accipi fortitudo, et venti qui domorum fundamenta subvertunt, utique ad bonam partem non poterunt referri. Superest ut ventum urentem quem adducet Dominus de deserto ascendentem, illum intelligamus, de quo et in Habacuc legimus: Deus ab Austro veniet, et sanctus de monte Pharan (Habac. III, 3): qui utique in solitudine et in meridie situs est. Et in Cantico legimus: Ubi pascis, ubi cubas in meridie (Cant. I, 6)? Hunc itaque ventum urentem, qui siccet venas mortis, et fontes ejus arefaciat, adducet Dominus de deserto ascendentem: de deserto autem humani generis, in quo et diabolus quaerens requiem, invenire non potuit. Sive desertum intelligimus sanctae Mariae uterum virginalem, quod absque semine humano nullo frutice pullulaverit: sed virga simplex atque purissima et unione fecunda ediderit eum florem qui dicit in Cantico canticorum: Ego flos campi et lilium convallium (Cant. II, 1). Et pulchre tam in Isaia, quam in praesenti loco, flos ascendens ct ventus ascendens dicitur: quia de humilitate carnis ad excelsa conscendit, et nos secum duxit ad Patrem, dicens in Evangelio: Cum exaltatus fuero, omnia traham ad me (Joan. XII, 32).","english":"This by no means seems so to me; for it is not written in Job that the Lord brought a wind from the desert, but the name of the Lord is left unspoken, so that the wind from the wilderness, which had come against the holy man by its own will, can be understood as a contrary power, and the winds that overturn the foundations of houses certainly cannot be referred to a good part. It remains that we understand the burning wind which the Lord will bring, rising from the desert, as that of which we also read in Habakkuk: God will come from the South, and the Holy One from Mount Paran (Hab. 3:3); which is certainly situated in the wilderness and in the south. And in the Canticle we read: Where do you pasture, where do you lie down at midday (Cant. 1:6)? This burning wind, therefore, which dries up the veins of death and parches its fountains, the Lord will bring, rising from the desert: from the desert, moreover, of the human race, in which even the devil, seeking rest, could not find it. Or we understand the desert as the virginal womb of holy Mary, which without human seed put forth no shoot, but as a simple and most pure rod, fruitful in its union, brought forth that flower which says in the Canticle of Canticles: I am the flower of the field and the lily of the valleys (Cant. 2:1). And fittingly, both in Isaiah and in the present passage, it is called a flower ascending and a wind ascending: because from the lowliness of the flesh he ascended to the heights, and drew us with himself to the Father, saying in the Gospel: When I am lifted up, I will draw all things to myself (John 12:32).","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":260,"ref":"p260","source":"Ipse quasi radix ascendet de terra inhabitabili, et nequaquam mors in eum, sed ipse morti superveniet, neque enim mors in eo ullam suae potestatis viam reperit, et hoc est, quod in Proverbiis dicitur: Impossibile est super petram serpentis invenire vestigia (Prov. XXX, 19). Et ipse, loquitur in Evangelio: Ecce veniet princeps mundi hujus, et inveniet in me nihil (Joan. XIV, 30). Iste siccabit venas mortis, et desolabit fontes ejus. Venae mortis et fontes et aculeus, peccata ab Apostolo nominantur: quibus arefactis, mors quoque ipsa siccabitur. Quodque sequitur: Ipse diripiet thesaurum omnis vasis desiderabilis, dupliciter accipitur, sive quod desiderabilia sunt his, qui in morte habitant, sive vasa desiderabilia quae in thesauro retinebantur inferni, sanctos intelligimus quos alligatos forte Dominus eripuit et tulit de inferis, et quasi vasa pretiosissima secum perduxit in paradisum. Pro thesauro, LXX, terram transtulerunt: terra haud dubium quin mortem significet. Et in Psalmis legimus: Credo videre bona Domini in terra viventium (Psal. XXVI, 13). Et juxta Evangelium: Mites possidebunt terram (Matth. V, 4). E contrario debemus accipere terram inferni non esse terram viventium, sed mortuorum, quae diripitur atque vastatur, quando morte Christi vinctae apud inferos animae liberantur.","english":"He himself will ascend like a root from an uninhabitable land, and death will by no means be in him, but he himself will come upon death; for death found in him no path of its own power. And this is what is said in Proverbs: It is impossible to find the traces of a serpent upon a rock (Prov. 30:19). And he himself speaks in the Gospel: Behold, the prince of this world will come, and he will find nothing in me (John 14:30). He will dry up the veins of death and lay waste its fountains. The veins of death and its fountains and its sting are called sins by the Apostle; when these are dried up, death itself will also be dried up. And what follows: He himself will plunder the treasure of every desirable vessel, is understood in two ways: either that they are desirable to those who dwell in death, or that the desirable vessels which were kept in the treasure of hell we understand to be the saints, whom the Lord perhaps rescued, bound as they were, and took from hell, and led with him into paradise as most precious vessels. For \"treasure,\" the Septuagint translated \"land\"; land undoubtedly signifies death. And in the Psalms we read: I believe I shall see the good things of the Lord in the land of the living (Ps. 27:13). And according to the Gospel: The meek shall possess the land (Matt. 5:4). On the contrary, we must understand that the land of hell is not the land of the living but of the dead, which is plundered and laid waste when, by the death of Christ, the souls bound in hell are set free.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":261,"ref":"p261","source":"Secundum tropologiam in eisdem (de quibus supra diximus) Commentariis legimus ventum urentem, diabolum intelligi et singulos haeresiarchas. Quod nobis displicet. Neque enim diabolus venas mortis fontesque erroris siccare potest, cum ipse fons et initium mortuorum sit. Itaque sermo Ecclesiasticus, urens intelligendus est ventus, qui omnia haereticorum dogmata arefaciat et perducat ad nihilum, et diripiat eos atque dispergat, qui haereticorum doctrina in morte fuerant congregati.\n\n(Cap. XIV.—Vers. 1.) « Percat Samaria, quoniam ad amaritudinem concitavit Deum suum: in gladio pereant; parvuli eorum elidantur, et foetae ejus discindantur. » LXX: « Disperdetur Samaria, quoniam restitit Deo suo: in gladio corruent, et lactentes eorum elidentur ad petram 6, et habentes in utero disrumpentur. » Saepe diximus decem tribus appellari Samariam a metropoli Samaria, quae ex nomino Augusti nunc vocatur Augusta, id est, Sebaste. Cur autem Samaria dicta sit civitas, in Regum volumine legimus. Imperat igitur Propheta, et, ut verius dicam, optativo modo loquitur, ut Samaria pereat. Cui cum Deus tanta praepararit bona, illa contra Deum faciat, et magis daemonum simulacra sectetur.","english":"According to tropology, in the same Commentaries (of which we spoke above) we read that the burning wind is understood as the devil and the individual heresiarchs. This displeases us. For the devil cannot dry up the veins of death and the fountains of error, since he himself is the fount and origin of the dead. And so the Ecclesiastical discourse must be understood as the burning wind, which dries up all the dogmas of heretics and brings them to nothing, and plunders and scatters those who had been gathered in death by heretical doctrine.\n\n(Cap. XIV.—Vers. 1.) «Let Samaria perish, because she provoked her God to bitterness: let them perish by the sword; let their little ones be dashed in pieces, and let her pregnant women be ripped open.» The LXX: «Samaria shall be destroyed, because she resisted her God: they shall fall by the sword, and their sucklings shall be dashed against the rock, and those having [children] in the womb shall be burst asunder.» We have often said that the ten tribes are called Samaria from the metropolis Samaria, which from the name of Augustus is now called Augusta, that is, Sebaste. But why the city was called Samaria, we read in the volume of Kings. The Prophet therefore commands, and, to speak more truly, speaks in the optative mode, that Samaria may perish. Though God had prepared so many good things for her, she acts against God, and rather follows after the idols of demons.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":262,"ref":"p262","source":"Symmachus autem non dixit pereat, sed, id est, aget poenitentiam, suique eam poenitebit erroris, quod dulcissimum Deum in amaritudinem verterit, ita ut bellatores ejus in gladio pereant, parvuli et lactentes elidantur ad terram, et fetae ejus atque praegnantes disrumpantur in mortem. Quae omnia ei accidisse credendum est tempore captivitatis et angustiae, quando suam patriam perdiderunt, et qui evasere gladium, in servitutem perpetuam sunt abducti. De haereticis facilis intelligentia est, quod vocentur Samaria, eo quod Dei praecepta servare se jactent, non quod custodes sint legis ejus; sed quod hoc esse se dicant, in similitudinem schismatis Novatianorum, qui et ipsi, id est mundos, se vocant, cum sint ominum immundissimi, negantes poenitentiam, per quam peccata mundantur, juxta illud quod scriptum est: Lavabis me, et super nivem dealbabor (Psal. L, 9). Et in Isaia: Lavamini, mundi estote (Isa. I, 16). Lavacrum autem non baptismum vocat, sed omnem paenitudinem, quae sordes abluit peccatorum. Pereat igitur hujuscemodi Samaria: quia quidquid loquitur, repugnat Deo suo, et clementiam ejus vertit in crudelitatem, usque adeo, ut qui viri sunt apud illam et ad malitiae aetatem venere perfectam, spirituali mucrone truncentur; Qui autem parvuli atque lactentes, elidantur ad petram. De quibus et in Psalmo legimus: Beatus qui tenebit et allidet parvulos suos ad petram (Psal.","english":"Symmachus, however, did not say \"let her perish,\" but, that is, she will repent and regret her error, because she turned the most sweet God into bitterness, so that her warriors perish by the sword, her little ones and infants are dashed to the ground, and her pregnant women and those with child are burst asunder unto death. All these things must be believed to have happened to her in the time of captivity and distress, when they lost their own country, and those who escaped the sword were led away into perpetual slavery. Concerning heretics the understanding is easy: that they are called Samaria because they boast that they keep God's commandments, not because they are keepers of His law, but because they say they are such, in the likeness of the schism of the Novatians, who also call themselves clean, that is, pure, though they are the most unclean of all, denying repentance, through which sins are cleansed, according to what is written: You shall wash me, and I shall be made whiter than snow. And in Isaiah: Wash yourselves, be clean. But he calls \"washing\" not baptism, but every repentance that washes away the filth of sins. Let Samaria of this kind, therefore, perish: because whatever she speaks is opposed to her God, and turns His clemency into cruelty, to such an extent that those who are men among her and have come to the perfect age of malice are cut down by the spiritual sword; but those who are little ones and infants are dashed against the rock. Of these we also read in the Psalm: Blessed is he who shall hold and dash his little ones against the rock.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":263,"ref":"p263","source":"CXXXVI, 5). Fetae quoque ejus atque praegnantes quae de malo semine conceperunt, ideo disrumpentur, ne pessimos liberos faciant. Tale quid et in Evangelio nobis subjicitur: Voe praegnantibus et nutrientibus in diebus illis (Luc. XXI, 23): diebus videlicet tribulationis et angustiae. Interficiuntur autem et bellatores Samariae gladio, et lactentes eliduntur, et praegnantes disrumpuntur: ut, pereunte male semine, zizaniisque ejus exustis, solum remaneat triticum, quod in Domini horrea recondatur.\n\n(Vers. 2, et 4.) « Convertere, Israel, ad Dominum Deum tuum, quoniam corruisti in iniquitate tua, tollite vobiscum verba, et convertimini ad Dominum; dicite ei: Omnem aufer iniquitatem, et accipe bonum, et reddemus vitulos labiorum nostrorum. Assur non salvabit nos, super equum non ascendemus, nec dicemus ultra: Dii nostri opera manuum nostrarum, quia ejus qui in te est misereberis pupilli. » LXX: « Convertere, Israel, ad Dominum Deum tuum, quia infirmatus es in iniquitatibus tuis: sumite vobiscum sermones, et revertimini ad Dominum, dicite ei ut non tollatis iniquitatem, sed assumatis bona, et reddemus fructum labiorum nostrorum. Assur non salvabit nos, super equum non ascendemus, nequaquam ultra dicemus: Dii nostri, in operibus manuum nostrarum: qui in te est miserebitur pupilli.","english":"136, 5). Her pregnant women too, and those who have conceived from evil seed, will therefore be ripped open, so that they may not produce utterly wicked children. Something of this kind is also suggested to us in the Gospel: Woe to those who are pregnant and to those who are nursing in those days (Luke 21:23)—that is, in days of tribulation and distress. And the warriors of Samaria are killed by the sword, and infants are dashed to pieces, and pregnant women are ripped open, so that, with the evil seed perishing and its tares burned up, only the wheat may remain, to be stored in the Lord's barns.\n\n(Verses 2 and 4.) Return, Israel, to the Lord your God, for you have fallen by your iniquity; take words with you, and return to the Lord; say to him: Take away all iniquity, and accept what is good, and we will render the calves of our lips. Assur will not save us, we will not mount upon a horse, nor will we say any more: Our gods are the works of our hands, because you will have mercy on the orphan who is in you. The Septuagint: Return, Israel, to the Lord your God, for you have been weakened by your iniquities; take words with you, and return to the Lord, say to him that you should not take away iniquity, but should assume good things, and we will render the fruit of our lips. Assur will not save us, we will not mount upon a horse, we will no longer say: Our gods, in the works of our hands; he who is in you will have mercy on the orphan.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":264,"ref":"p264","source":"» Pereunte Samaria, et viris ejus et parvulis et praegnantibus occisis, elisis atque discissis, totus Israel ad poenitentiam provocatur, ut qui infirmatus est, sive corruit in iniquitatibus suis, revertatur ad medicum et recipiat sanitatem, vel stare incipiat qui corruerat; doceturque quomodo debeat agere poenitentiam: Tollite inquit, vobiscum verba, id est, preces, et delictorum confessionem, et convertimini ad Dominum tam verbis quam operibus; et dicite ei: Omnem aufer iniquitatem, nihil languoris in nobis et ruinae pristinae derelinquas, ne rursum mali seminis pullulent rediviva plantaria; et accipe, inquit, bonum: nisi enim tuleris mala nostra, bonum tibi quod offeramus, habere non possumus, juxta illud quod alibi scriptum est: Declina a malo, et fac bonum (Psal. XXXVI, 27), et reddemus, ait, vitulos labiorum nostrorum. Pro vitulis qui Hebraice appellantur PHARIM ( ), fructum Septuaginta transtulerunt qui dicitur PHERI ( ), falsi sermonis similitudine. Vituli autem labiorum, laudes in Deo sunt et gratiarum actio: Sacrificium enim Deo spiritus contribulatas (Psal. L, 19). Igitur illo jam tempore carnalibus victimis reprobatis, placabilis Deo hostia est pura confessio.","english":"With Samaria perishing, and its men, little ones, and pregnant women killed, crushed, and torn apart, all Israel is provoked to repentance, so that those who have grown weak, or have fallen in their iniquities, may return to the physician and receive health, or those who had fallen may begin to stand; and it is taught how one ought to practice repentance: Take with you, it says, words, that is, prayers and confession of sins, and be converted to the Lord in both words and deeds; and say to him: Take away all iniquity, leave nothing of sickness or former ruin in us, lest the revived shoots of evil seed sprout again; and receive, it says, what is good: for unless you take away our evils, we cannot have the good that we may offer you, according to what is written elsewhere: Turn away from evil, and do good (Psalm 36:27), and we will render, it says, the calves of our lips. In place of the calves, which in Hebrew are called PHARIM, the Seventy translated fruit, which is called PHERI, by a similarity of false wording. But the calves of the lips are praises in God and thanksgiving: for Sacrifice to God is a troubled spirit (Psalm 50:19). Therefore, since carnal victims were already rejected at that time, the sacrifice pleasing to God is pure confession.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":265,"ref":"p265","source":"Qui reddituros se esse dicunt labiorum vitulos, et Dei laudes perpeti voce cantaturos, etiam illud repromittunt quod nequaquam in Assyriis spem habeant, nec super equos AEgyptios, quia fallax equus ad salutem (Psal. XXXII), et ultra non adorent opera manuum suarum, vitulos aureos, quos in Dan Bethelque conflaverunt, et idcirco inquiunt: Nequaquam operi manuum nostrarum dicemus: Dii nostri; quia tu ejus qui in te est pupilli misereberis, hoc est, populi Israel, de quo dixeras: Filius primogenitus meus Israel (Exod. IV, 22). Et: Filios genui et exaltavi, ipsi autem me spreverunt (Isa. I, 2). Et in alio loco: Filii alieni mentiti sunt mihi (Psal. XVII, 46). Pupillus autem vocatur, quia Deum perdidit patrem. Quidam autem pupillum exposuit eum qui a malo patre recesserit diabolo, et idcirco Dei misericordia sublevetur. Ad omne quoque dogma perversum quotidie propheta loquitur, et sectatores ejus ad poenitentiam provocat, dicens: Convertimini ad Dominum Deum vestrum, qui corruistis, sive elangulstis, Domini perdita sanitate: tollite vobiscum verba, veram, fidei confessionem, et dicite: Aufer iniquitatem quae in nostro corde versatur, et accipe bonum fidei: Quia corde creditur ad justitiam, ore autem confessio fit ad salutem (Rom. X, 10).","english":"Those who say they will render the calves of their lips, and will sing the praises of God with a voice that endures, also promise that they will by no means have hope in the Assyrians, nor in Egyptian horses, because a horse is a deceptive thing for salvation, and that they will no longer adore the works of their own hands, the golden calves which they cast in Dan and Bethel, and therefore they say: We will no longer say to the work of our hands: You are our gods; because you will have mercy on him who is an orphan in you, that is, on the people of Israel, of whom you had said: Israel is my firstborn son. And: I have begotten sons and exalted them, but they have despised me. And in another place: Foreign sons have lied to me. But he is called an orphan because he has lost God as father. Some, however, have interpreted the orphan as him who has departed from the evil father, the devil, and is therefore raised up by God's mercy. To every perverse doctrine, too, the prophet speaks daily, and provokes its followers to repentance, saying: Be converted to the Lord your God, you who have fallen, or have been strangled, having lost the health of the Lord: take with you words, the true confession of faith, and say: Take away the iniquity that turns about in our heart, and receive the good of faith: Because with the heart one believes unto justice, but with the mouth confession is made unto salvation.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":266,"ref":"p266","source":"Vituli et victimae, sive fructus labiorum, sunt in Patrem et Filium et Spiritum sanctum, et in passionem et resurrectionem Domini credere: quam qui obtulerit ei, nequaquam sperabit in rege Assyrio, de quo crebro diximus. Nec ascendet super equum quem praecipit Dominus nequaquam, multiplicandum (Deut. XVII), quem habens Pharao, cum suo est demersus equitatu (Exod. XIV). Omnis enim haereticus ascendit equos per superbiam, quos in errore suo ipse generavit. Et nequaquam ultra dicent operibus manuum suarum, quae ipsi artifici eloquio confinxerunt: Dii nostri. Gulosi venter deus est, avarus colit mammona, haereticus dogma quod finxit; qui universa haec deseruerit, id est, Assur et equum et opera manuum suarum, revertetur ad Dominum, et placabit patrem suum a quo fuerat abjectus.\n\n(Vers. seqq.) « Sanabo contritiones eorum, diligam eos spontanee, quia aversus est furor meus ab eo: ero quasi ros. Israel germinabit quasi lilium, et erumpet radix ejus ut Libani; ibunt rami ejus, et erit quasi oliva gloria ejus, et odor ejus ut Libani. Convertentur sedentes in umbra ejus, vivent tritico, et germinabunt quasi vinea. Memoriale ejus sicut vinum Libani. Ephraim, quid mihi ultra idola: ego exaudiam et dirigam eum; ego ut abietem virentem, ex me fructus tuus inventus est. » LXX: « Sanabo habitatores eorum; diligam eos manifeste, quia aversa est ira mea ab eis.","english":"The calves and the victims, or the fruit of the lips, consist in believing in the Father and the Son and the Holy Spirit, and in the passion and resurrection of the Lord. Whoever offers this to him will by no means hope in the king of Assyria, of whom we have spoken often. Nor will he mount the horse which the Lord forbids to be multiplied in any way (Deut. 17), which Pharaoh, possessing it, was drowned with his cavalry (Exod. 14). For every heretic mounts horses through pride, which he himself has begotten in his error. And they will no longer say to the works of their hands, which they have fashioned by their own clever eloquence: Our gods. The glutton's god is his belly, the covetous man worships mammon, the heretic worships the dogma he has fashioned. Whoever has abandoned all these things—that is, Assur and the horse and the works of his hands—will return to the Lord and will appease his father, by whom he had been cast off.\n\n(Vers. seqq.) \"I will heal their contritions, I will love them freely, because my fury has turned away from him: I will be like the dew. Israel will blossom like a lily, and his root will burst forth like Lebanon; his branches will go forth, and his glory will be like the olive, and his fragrance like Lebanon. Those sitting in his shadow will return, they will live on wheat, and they will bud like a vine. His memorial will be like the wine of Lebanon. Ephraim, what have I to do any more with idols: I will hear and direct him; I am like a green fir tree, from me your fruit has been found.\" The Septuagint: \"I will heal their inhabitants; I will love them openly, because my wrath has turned away from them.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":267,"ref":"p267","source":"Ero quasi ros: Israel florebit ut lilium, et mittet radices suas quasi Libanus: ibunt rami ejus, et erit quasi oliva fructifera, et odor illius quasi Libani, convertentur et sedebunt sub umbra ejus: bibent et inebriabuntur frumento, et efflorebit ut vinea memoriale ejus quasi vinum Libani Ephraim: Quid ei ultra et idolis? ego humiliavi eum, et ego confortabo ilium, ego sicut juniperus condensa: ex me fructus tuus inventus est. » Conversis ad poenitentiam, et instar pupilli patrem quem reliquerant cognoscentibus, respondit Deus: Sanabo contritiones, vel habitacula eorum in quibus fuerant vulnerati, sive confracti, vel in quibus tam male habitaverant. diligam eos spontanee; quod LXX transtulerunt 3, perspicue atque aperte, vel absque ulla dubitatione. Diligit autem Dominus diligentes se, de quibus et in alio loco ait: Ego diligentes me diligo (Prov. VIII, 17). Qui enim prius irascebar eis propter peccata quae fecerant: nunc miserebor propter clementiam meam. Et ero eis quasi ros; ut fornacem Babylonicam, et caminum aestuantis incendii meo rore restinguam, qui et per Isaac patriarcham ad Jacob servum meum loculus sum: De rore coeli erit habitaculum tuum.","english":"I will be like the dew: Israel will blossom like a lily, and will send out its roots like Lebanon; his branches will go forth, and he will be like a fruitful olive tree, and his fragrance like that of Lebanon. They will return and sit under his shadow; they will drink and be intoxicated with grain, and his memorial will blossom like a vine, like the wine of Lebanon. Ephraim: What has he to do further with idols? I have humbled him, and I will strengthen him; I am like a dense juniper tree: from me your fruit has been found. To those converted to repentance, and recognizing as a father the one whom they had abandoned, like an orphan, God has answered: I will heal their contritions, or their dwellings in which they had been wounded, or broken, or in which they had dwelt so badly. I will love them freely, which the Septuagint translated as \"3,\" plainly and openly, or without any doubt. But the Lord loves those who love him, of whom he also says in another place: I love those who love me (Prov. 8:17). For I who previously was angry with them because of the sins they had committed: now I will have mercy because of my clemency. And I will be to them like the dew; so that I may extinguish the Babylonian furnace and the furnace of burning fire with my dew, I who also spoke through Isaac the patriarch to Jacob my servant: Your dwelling will be from the dew of heaven.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":268,"ref":"p268","source":"Quomodo enim Dominus fit credentibus lumen, via, veritas, panis, vinea, ignis, pastor, agnus, janua, vermis, etc.: sic qui indigemus illius misericordia, et peccatorum febribus aestuamus, in rorem nobis vertitur, ad quem dicit Isaias: Ros enim qui a te est, sanitas eorum est (Isa. XXXVI, sec. LXX). Et in Deuteronomii Cantico Moyses loquitur: Descendant sicut ros verba mea (Deut. XXXII, 2). Cum autem nos Dominus suo rore resperserit, et siccitatem pectoris nostri suis pluviis irrigarit, germinabimus, imo florebimus ut lilium, imitantes Dominum Salvatorem, qui dicit in Cantico canticorum: Ego flos campi et lilium convallium (Cant. II, 1), et loquitur ad sponsam suam, quae non habet rugam neque maculam: Sicut lilium in medio spinarum, sic proxima mea in medio filiarum (Ibid. 2). Cumque creverimus in Domino, mittemus radices nostras sicut arbores Libani, quae quantum in auras consurgunt vertice, tantum radicem in ima demergunt, ut nulla tempestate quatiantur, sed stabili mole consistant. Harum arborum rami huc illucque tenduntur, ut veniant volatilia coeli et habitent in eis. Et ne forsitan putaremus, quia dixerat, erumpet radix ejus, sive emittet radices suas quasi Libanus, de cedris eum loqui et infructuosis arboribus, sanctum virum et conversum ad Dominum, olivae frugiferae comparat, qui dicit in alio loco: Ego autem sicut oliva fructifera in domo Dei (Psal. LI, 10).","english":"For just as the Lord becomes for believers light, way, truth, bread, vine, fire, shepherd, lamb, door, worm, and so on, so for us who need his mercy and burn with the fevers of sins, he is turned into dew for us, to whom Isaiah says: For the dew that is from you is their healing. And in the Canticle of Deuteronomy Moses speaks: Let my words descend like dew. But when the Lord has sprinkled us with his dew and irrigated the dryness of our heart with his rains, we shall sprout, indeed we shall blossom like a lily, imitating the Lord Savior, who says in the Canticle of Canticles: I am the flower of the field and the lily of the valleys, and speaks to his bride, who has neither wrinkle nor blemish: Like a lily among thorns, so is my neighbor among the daughters. And when we have grown in the Lord, we shall send out our roots like the trees of Lebanon, which, as much as they rise on high toward the breezes with their top, so much do they plunge their root into the depths, so that they may not be shaken by any storm, but stand firm with unshaken mass. The branches of these trees are stretched this way and that, so that the birds of heaven may come and dwell in them. And lest perhaps we should think that, because he had said, his root will burst forth, or he will send out his roots like Lebanon, he was speaking of cedars and unfruitful trees, he compares the holy man, converted to the Lord, to a fruitful olive tree, who says in another place: But I am like a fruitful olive tree in the house of God.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":269,"ref":"p269","source":"Cujus fructum quinque sibi sapientes virgines paraverunt (Matth. X), ex quo vulnerum mitigatur tumor, languentis membra requiescunt, in tenebris lumen accenditur, unguntur in agone certantes. Haec oliva habebit odorem quasi Libani, vel thuris, quod genus est thymiamatis: apud Graecos et Hebraeos et mons appellatur, et thus, vel certe montis Libani, qui fertilissimus et virens, densissimis arborum comis protegitur, ita ut possit oliva dicere: Christi bonus odor sumus (II Cor. II, 15). Qui autem conversi fuerint ad Dominum, accipient conversionis suae praemium, ut sedeant in umbra ejus et dicant: Sub umbra ejus requievi et sedi, et fructus ejus dulcis est in ore meo (Cant. II, 3). Cumque sederint in umbra illius, vivent qui prius mortui fuerant, sive juxta Septuaginta, bibent et inebriabuntur tritico, hoc est, rerum omnium abundantia. Quod autem hic ebrietas non eversionem mentis, sed copiam rerum omnium significet, versiculus ille declarat, dicens: Visitasti terram et inebriasti eam (Psal. LXIV, 10). Et Joseph convivium, in quo inebriasse dicitur fratres suos (Gen. XLIII). Et Dominus loquens ad apostolos: Comedite, amici mei, et bibite, et inebriamini, fratres (Cant. V, 1). Sive quia Dominus noster ipse est frumentum et vinea, quicunque crediderit in eo, inebriari dicitur. Denique sequitur: Et florebit quasi vinea memortale ejus sicut vinum Libani.","english":"Its fruit the five wise virgins prepared for themselves, from which the swelling of wounds is soothed, the limbs of the languishing find rest, light is kindled in darkness, and those contending in the contest are anointed. This olive shall have a fragrance like that of Lebanon, or of frankincense, which is a kind of incense; among the Greeks and Hebrews both the mountain and the incense are called thus, or certainly it is the fragrance of Mount Lebanon, which, most fertile and verdant, is covered with the densest foliage of trees, so that the olive can say: We are the good odor of Christ. But those who have been converted to the Lord shall receive the reward of their conversion, so that they may sit in his shadow and say: I have rested and sat in his shadow, and his fruit is sweet in my mouth. And when they have sat in his shadow, those who had previously been dead shall live, or according to the Septuagint, they shall drink and be intoxicated with grain, that is, with an abundance of all things. But that intoxication here signifies not an overturning of the mind, but an abundance of all things, that verse declares, saying: You have visited the earth and intoxicated it. And the banquet of Joseph, at which he is said to have intoxicated his brothers. And the Lord speaking to the apostles: Eat, my friends, and drink, and be intoxicated, brothers. Or because our Lord himself is the grain and the vine, whoever has believed in him is said to be intoxicated. Finally it follows: And his memorial shall blossom like a vine, like the wine of Lebanon.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":270,"ref":"p270","source":"Vinum autem Libani possumus appellare mistum et conditum thymiamate, ut odorem suavissimum habeat, vel vinum Libani quod Domino libatur in templo, de quo in Zacharia sub Libani vocabulo legimus: Aperi 1, Libane, portas tuas(Zacch. XI, 1). Cum ergo tanta rerum abundantia sit futura, o Ephraim omnis, qui agis poenitentiam, et qui meus esse coepisti, dimitte idola, simulacra contemne: ego enim sum qui humiliavi te, et ego exaltabo te, sive ego exaudiam et dirigam, et facium eum quasi abietem virentem, ut de illo juxta Hebraeos dicatur in Psalmo: Abies domus ejus (Psal. CIII, 17). Aut certe ego, ero juniperus condensa, ut sub mea umbra requiescat. De, id est, juniperis, juxta Septuaginta interpretes, Salomon januas templi fecisse memoratur, quia Christus, per quem ad Patrem accedimus, hanc habet naturam, ut semper floreat, semper novos afferat fructus, et nunquam deponat virorem suum. Haec juniperus sub umbra sua quiescentibus, ne mundi hujus ardore feriantur, et percutiat aestus caput eorum, sicut quondam percussit et Jonae (Jon. IV), dat fruges, et non solum dormientibus requiem et sedentibus; sed et saturitatem vescentibus praebet. Quidquid secundum interpretati sumus, in adventu Domini Salvatoris, et in conversione veri Israel, hoc tam ad haereticos et Judaeos, quam ad gentes et ad omne dogma perversum referri potest: ut cum egerint poenitentiam, veniam consequantur.","english":"But the wine of Lebanon we can call mixed and seasoned with incense, so that it has a most sweet odor, or the wine of Lebanon which is poured out to the Lord in the temple, of which we read in Zechariah under the name of Lebanon: Open, O Lebanon, your gates. Since therefore there will be such abundance of things, O Ephraim, everyone who does penance, and who has begun to be mine, dismiss idols, despise graven images: for I am he who humbled you, and I will exalt you, or I will hear and direct, and I will make him like a green fir tree, so that concerning him, according to the Hebrews, it is said in the Psalm: The fir tree is his house. Or certainly I will be a thick juniper, so that he may rest under my shade. Of junipers, that is, according to the Seventy interpreters, Solomon is recorded to have made the doors of the temple, because Christ, through whom we approach the Father, has this nature, that he always flourishes, always brings forth new fruits, and never lays aside his greenness. This juniper gives fruits to those resting under its shade, lest they be struck by the heat of this world, and the heat strike their head, as it once struck even Jonah's, and it offers not only rest to those sleeping and sitting, but also satiety to those eating. Whatever we have interpreted according to the coming of the Lord Savior, and in the conversion of the true Israel, this can be referred as much to heretics and Jews as to the Gentiles and to every perverse doctrine: so that when they have done penance, they may obtain pardon.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":271,"ref":"p271","source":"Si ergo plenitudo repromissionis adimpleta est in adventu Salvatoris, et quotidie impletur in Ecclesia, credendum est quod plenius impleatur, quando perfectione veniente, quod nunc ex parte destruetur. Notandum, quod saepe jam diximus, salutem Israelis et reversionem ad Dominum, et de captivitate redemptionem, non carnaliter accipere, ut Judaei putant, sed spiritualiter, ut verissime comprobatur.\n\n(Vers. 10.) « Quis sapiens et intelliget ista? intelligens et sciet haec? quia rectae viae Domini, et justi ambulabunt in eis, praevaricatores vero corruent in eis. » LXX: « Quis sapiens et intelliget haec, aut intelligens et cognoscet ea? quia rectae viae Domini, et justi ambulabunt in eis: qui autem impii sunt, infirmabantur in illis. » Quando dicit: Quis sapiens et intelliget haec? intelligens et cognoscet ea? obscuritatem voluminis et difficultatem explanationis ostendit: Si autem ipse qui scripsit, vel difficile, vel impossibile confitetur: quid nos facere possumus, qui lippientibus oculis et peccatorum sordibus obscuratis, clarissimum jubar solis non possumus intueri, nisi dicere illud quod scriptum est: O profundum divitiarum sapientiae et scientia Dei! quam inscrutabilia sunt judicia ejus, et investigabiles viae ejus (Rom. XI, 33)!","english":"If therefore the fullness of the promise has been fulfilled in the Savior's advent, and is fulfilled daily in the Church, it must be believed that it will be fulfilled more fully, when perfection comes and what is now in part will be destroyed. It must be noted, as we have often said already, that the salvation of Israel and their return to the Lord, and their redemption from captivity, are not to be understood carnally, as the Jews think, but spiritually, as is most truly proved.\n\n(Verse 10.) \"Who is wise and will understand these things? One who understands and will know them? For the ways of the Lord are straight, and the just will walk in them, but the transgressors will fall in them.\" The Septuagint: \"Who is wise and will understand these things, or one who understands and will know them? For the ways of the Lord are straight, and the just will walk in them; but those who are impious grew weak in them.\" When he says: Who is wise and will understand these things? one who understands and will know them? he shows the obscurity of the book and the difficulty of its explanation. But if he who wrote it confesses that it is either difficult or impossible, what can we do, who with bleary eyes and darkened by the filth of sins cannot gaze upon the brightest radiance of the sun, except to say what is written: O the depth of the riches of the wisdom and knowledge of God! how unsearchable are his judgments, and his ways past finding out (Rom. 11:33)!","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":272,"ref":"p272","source":"Quis enim potest absque Christo docente cognoscere quid significet Jezrael; quid soror ejus, non misericordiam consecuta; quid tertius frater, non populus meus; quae sit adultera, quae sine lege Dei multo sessura sit tempore; quod sit pactum cum bestiis terrae, et cum volatilibus coeli; qui sit David ad quem populus reversurus sit, cujus sit die tertia resurrectio, et egressus ejus diluculo comparetur; quae sit pluvia prima et novissima; qui sit quem propheta dicit esse venturum, qui nobis monstret justitiam, aut in cujus typo Israel educatur ex AEgypto, et portetur in brachiis, et ducatur in funiculis charitatis; qui sit qui interficiat mortem, et siccet venas ejus et fontes arefaciat, et diripiat vasa quae in thesauro condita tenebantur, et caetera quae longum est retexere? Unde quicunque sanctus et justus est, rectas vias Domini esse cognoscet. Vias autem Domini esse cognoscimus lectionem veteris et novi Testamenti, sanctarum intelligentiam Scripturarum. In his viis qui ambulat, nisi convertatur ab Dominum et ablatum ad eo fuerit velamen, quod erat ante oculos Moysi, rectum iter invenire non poterit. Sin autem dixerit cum David: Releva oculos meos, et considerabo mirabilia de lege tua (Psal.","english":"For who can know, without Christ as teacher, what Jezreel signifies; what her sister, Not-Obtained-Mercy, signifies; what the third brother, Not-My-People, signifies; who the adulteress is, who without the law of God will sit for a long time; what the covenant with the beasts of the earth and with the birds of heaven is; who the David is to whom the people will return, whose resurrection is on the third day, and whose going forth is compared to the dawn; what the early and the latter rain is; who he is whom the prophet says will come, who will show us justice, or in whose type Israel is led out of Egypt, and carried in arms, and drawn with cords of love; who he is who kills death, and dries up its veins and parches its fountains, and plunders the vessels that were kept stored in the treasury, and the rest which it would take long to unfold? Hence whoever is holy and just will know that the ways of the Lord are straight. But we know the ways of the Lord to be the reading of the Old and New Testament, the understanding of the holy Scriptures. Whoever walks in these ways, unless he is converted to the Lord and the veil that was before the eyes of Moses is taken away from him, will not be able to find the right path. But if he has said with David: Unveil my eyes, and I will consider the wonders of your law (Psal.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]},{"i":273,"ref":"p273","source":"CXVIII, 18), ambulabit in cis, et Christum inveniet: et Judaeos atque haereticos, quos vel impios Scriptura nunc nominat, offendere in eis, et infirmari atque corruere sentiet, juxta illud quod scriptum est: Ecce iste positus est in ruinam et in resurrectionem multorum in Israel (Luc. II, 34).","english":"he will walk in them and find Christ; and he will perceive that the Jews and heretics, whom Scripture now calls impious, stumble over them and are weakened and fall, according to what is written: Behold, this one is appointed for the fall and the rising of many in Israel.","structure":"narrative","commentary":[],"ambiguities":[],"confidence":"","notes":[]}]}